Rory McIlroy won the Masters, finally. The roars told the story

AUGUSTA, Ga. — A concoction of sweaty bodies and long-lens cameras was deadlocked in the upper left-hand corner of the No. 15 grandstand at Augusta National as Rory McIlroy’s 7-foot eagle putt slid underneath the cup. At that point in the day, the phoneless Masters Tournament patrons were not unfamiliar with the sound of thousands of simultaneous groans. Hearing and participating in them repeatedly, however, was not getting any easier.

A Green Jacket stood up out of his plastic bleacher seat in a frenzy.

“I can’t take much more of this,” the gentleman uttered. He bee-lined toward the steep downward staircase, his sons close behind, fumbling to button the coat that only a select group can sport on this property.

Until it actually happened, McIlroy’s chase of the career Grand Slam and the end to his 11-year major championship drought felt more like if you took the most nauseating roller coaster on earth and increased its speed tenfold. Or stuck yourself in a blender and turned it to the highest setting, making the table shake.

An opening double bogey, a water ball into Rae’s Creek with a wedge in hand, the first sudden-death playoff in the Masters since 2017 — McIlroy gave Augusta National the show it didn’t know it wanted. The patrons on site still aren’t sure that’s what they would have signed up for. Sunday was a ticketed heart attack.

“My battle today was with myself. It wasn’t with anyone else,” McIlroy said Sunday evening, a 38 Regular green jacket slung over his shoulders. “You know, at the end there, it was with Justin (Rose), but my battle today was with my mind and staying in the present.

“I’d like to say that I did a better job of it than I did. It was a struggle, but I got it over the line.”

It might have been an internal waging of the wars for McIlroy, but all of Augusta National felt it with him. They leaned with the wayward drives, hustled to catch a glimpse of the gravity-defying escape routes, and hoped — oh, did they hope — every time the putter face made contact with the golf ball it would find a hole. Just this one, Rory.

Rotation by rotation, they held their breath.

Then, a final roar that could only mean one thing: sweet, sweet relief.


In his 1975 Masters file for Sports Illustrated, the great Dan Jenkins wrote: “There is an old saying that the real Masters doesn’t begin until the back nine on Sunday.” That was 50 Masters ago. It’s still true.

This back nine of the 89th Masters began with a semblance of something that you can never trust at the place: comfort. It is almost always a mirage.

No. 10 crushed McIlroy’s Masters dreams 14 years ago as a naive 21-year-old. Sunday morning, McIlroy opened his locker to a note from Angel Cabrera, the 2009 champion who played with McIlroy that day.


Patrons surrounded Rory McIlroy all day. (Richard Heathcote / Getty Images)

The drive on No. 10 was demonless. The ensuing birdie putt to take a four-shot lead? Electrifying. Patrons surrounded the 10th green and 11th fairway 30 deep, peering through tree branches and shuffling around aimlessly to find a gap where they could see something. Anything. Amen Corner lurked. Lest they all knew, the rug was about to be ripped out from underneath the Northern Irishman.

It all happened in a blur. A bogey on No. 11 — a number that could have been a lot bigger. A par at No. 12. A 3-wood off the tee at No. 13, McIlroy playing it safe with a four-shot lead.

There’s no tighter part of the property for patrons than Amen Corner, tens of thousands pressed together to watch as McIlroy’s ball flew through the air once, then twice. He stood with a wedge in his hands from 82 yards. If he was going to screw this all up, it wasn’t going to be here, with all of Georgia to the left side of the green. Right?

McIlroy’s ball tumbled into the creek. He bent his spine in half and threw his hands onto his knees. There had been plenty of triumphant patron responses at that point in the day. Here, in Amen Corner’s final chapter, the gasps returned. They did not stop.

First, McIlroy’s red 13 came off the nearby manual leaderboard and was replaced by a somber 11. He paused, waiting an additional moment before heading over the 14th tee, almost as if he knew it was coming. Rose suddenly had his 10 switched out for an 11.

Tie score.

No Masters champion has ever won the green jacket with four double bogeys. Is that the kind of history McIlroy was going to make?

Every time it looked as though McIlroy had thrown away the golf tournament for good, he followed it with a shot, a moment, even a bounce in his step that added up to the opposite. He looked like he was in cruise control until the emergency brakes hit. The patrons’ fists in the air were coupled with sunburned faces buried in hands. More new red numbers caused a stir. McIlroy threw another dart. Birdie-par-birdie. Triumph? No. Closing bogey. There it was. All of it would come down to this. A sudden-death playoff against his Ryder Cup teammate, Rose.

Harry Diamond, McIlroy’s caddie and best friend since age 7, looked at his player as they headed to the golf cart that would bring the pair back to the 18th tee box once again.

“Well, pal, we would have taken this on Monday morning,” he said.

The jostled Augusta National audience did not agree. The anguish was becoming unbearable, borderline exhausting, but also the best Masters of the modern era. Either way, it needed to end. McIlroy needed to put himself — and everyone else — out of their misery.


Walk through the white and gold doors of the Augusta National clubhouse, up a winding staircase and through a quaint but decadent dining room, and you’ll find yourself on a porch. It overlooks the giant oak tree, the iconic rows of green and white umbrellas, and in the distance, if you crane your neck just enough, No. 18 green.

But today that view was clouded by a sea of anxious bodies. On the ground, some proposed starting a game of “telephone” to communicate the play-by-play on the green.

Up on the porch, you can rotate 180 degrees and you’re facing a row of white window panes. They lead to a 35-inch television, the only piece of modern technology in a 100-yard radius. A strange combination of Green Jacket wearers, off-duty broadcasters and confused writers gathered around to watch the playoff. Patrick Reed dipped in to order an Azalea cocktail. The incoming USGA president showed up. Everyone was too nervous to utter a word. No one did.

A sound of this force cannot be tape-delayed.  All of Augusta National felt McIlroy’s energy release after that 4-foot birdie putt dropped. And by the look of him — collapsing onto his knees and convulsing with sobs — he felt it, too.

One of the most chaotic final rounds of recent memory ended with pure emotion, a release appropriate for the sixth man to complete the career Grand Slam, and McIlroy shut down a narrative he wondered whether he’d ever escape.

“It was all relief. There wasn’t much joy in that reaction. It was all relief,” McIlroy said after the round, laughing. “And then, you know, the joy came pretty soon after that. But that was — I’ve been coming here 17 years, and it was a decade-plus of emotion that came out of me there.”

We know, Rory. We know.

(Top photo: Harry How / Getty Images)

2025 NFL Draft matchmaker: Best fits for Cam Ward, Jaxson Dart, other top QBs

Read Dane Brugler’s 2025 ‘The Beast’ NFL Draft guide.

At least beyond Cam Ward, there is no consensus on where each of this year’s crop of quarterbacks may get drafted. After Ward presumably becomes a Tennessee Titan, the rest of the group is a complete mystery. It’s just as likely Ward is the only quarterback we see on Thursday night as it is that four quarterbacks go in the first round.

Lucky for us, we’re going to cut through all that uncertainty and play quarterback matchmaker, placing all of this year’s top quarterback prospects on the teams that make the most sense. In some cases, that has more to do with what type of quarterback the team needs; in others, it’s about finding the right environment for getting the most out of a particular skill set.

Let’s get to the lovely new couples.

Cam Ward: Tennessee Titans

All signs point to Ward being the Titans’ starting quarterback next year. It’s not even worth entertaining different possibilities for either QB or team at this point. Ward is both a good fit for the core of Brian Callahan’s offense and would bring elements that Titans’ quarterbacks last season did not.

The Titans’ 2024 offense was all about maximizing play-action opportunities and attacking down the field. Ward has the arm talent and fearlessness as a thrower to excel in that environment. However, Ward also massively improved his quick-game operation in college, and he’s much more comfortable playing from spread and empty formations than Will Levis has ever been. Ward is leaps and bounds ahead of Levis (or Mason Rudolph) as a creator outside of the pocket, too.

There are going to be growing pains with Ward’s overzealous play style early on, but they will be worth it in the long run. Ward has both a floor and ceiling worthy of being the No. 1 pick in this class.

Shedeur Sanders: New Orleans Saints

Finding Sanders’ best fit was trickier than I anticipated. Kevin Stefanski’s downfield play-action offense in Cleveland is not ideal; Brian Daboll’s quicker passing attack in New York might make sense, but that offensive line is a sieve and Sanders is not athletic enough to tap into some of the best parts of Daboll’s playbook.

The idea of Sanders being Kellen Moore’s first crack at a quarterback is intriguing, though. Sanders is at his best operating spread passing concepts, especially in the underneath area. He’s a reliable short-area passer who uses the intermediate and deeper areas of the field to keep defenses honest, rather than making those his preferred areas of attack. That’s perfectly fine for a West Coast-inspired offense.

Of course, falling to ninth overall is no guarantee. The Browns or the Giants may feel the itch of desperation and draft Sanders in the top three. If Sanders does slide a little bit, however, it wouldn’t be a shock to see the Saints stop that fall.

Jaxson Dart: Seattle Seahawks

It would be stunning if the Seahawks left the first two days of the draft without a quarterback. The deal Sam Darnold signed in March is effectively a one-year contract with team options from then on out — if that doesn’t scream “a developmental quarterback is coming,” I don’t know what does.

Seattle could go in a few directions, but Dart makes sense for their new offense under Klint Kubiak, and vice versa.

Dart reminds me a lot of Jimmy Garoppolo as a passer. The two are quite similar in build, arm talent and ability on throws over the middle of the field. A majority of Dart’s best throws on film are slants, short posts and crossers. The same was true of Garoppolo at his best in San Francisco. Neither Dart nor Garoppolo is a quarterback you want reading out a full progression very often.

In theory, Kubiak’s offense plays into all of that. It’s built off the run game, which is then parlayed into a strong play-action attack. Not only does that simplify reads for the quarterback, it also demands the QB often makes tight throws over the middle of the field, which is where Dart shines.

With a year on the bench to learn the pace of the league, maybe Dart can make it work with the Seahawks.

Tyler Shough: Cleveland Browns

The Browns’ best path to a quarterback is to take the Day 2 player most ready to start immediately. For my money, that is Shough.

Outside of Ward, Shough is the most talented thrower in the class. He has a flexible yet explosive release that works well from all platforms, in and out of the pocket. Though he’s more of a straight-line thrower than someone with fantastic touch, he still gets the job done from an accuracy perspective.

Shough is a quality processor, as well. Similar to Ryan Tannehill, he can be a hair slow coming off of reads early in the down but generally doesn’t make bizarre mistakes, and he protects the ball well.

In terms of pro readiness and arm talent, Shough just makes the most sense for Kevin Stefanski’s offense right now.

Jalen Milroe: Los Angeles Rams

If Sean McVay wants to keep the offense roughly the same in an eventual post-Matthew Stafford world, Milroe is not the answer — he’s actually the furthest thing from Stafford in this draft class (aside from the two or three bizarre misfires each QB has every game).

McVay has long flirted with the idea of a mobile quarterback, though. He was eager to give John Wolford a chance at the end of the Jared Goff saga, then held onto him as the team’s backup through the 2022 season. McVay also gave Bryce Perkins a start in 2022, a game in which Perkins carried the ball 19 times for 90 yards.

Milroe will walk into the league as one of the best athletes at the position. As a passer, he’ll need at least a year to fix his footwork and adapt to the speed of coverage at the NFL level, but that’s okay. There would be no pressure on Milroe to compete with Stafford for the job.

This would be a long play. Regardless of it being a good or realistic idea, I just so badly want to see the world in which McVay gets to re-unlock the boot-action game and dabble in a quarterback-centric rushing attack.

Riley Leonard: New York Giants

Brian Daboll’s best work over the years — outside of his time with Josh Allen — was at Alabama in 2017, with Jalen Hurts, and in 2022, with Daniel Jones.

Though different quality players, Hurts and Jones can both generally be described as sturdy, athletic quarterbacks with the arm talent to push the ball down the field a little bit. Both players added something to the offense via their mobility, and Daboll took advantage.

Aside from maybe Milroe, Leonard is Daboll’s best swing at that kind of athlete. Leonard is 6-foot-4, 218 pounds with serious wheels. He’s fairly explosive in short areas and excels when he really gets to stride out, similar to Jones. He’s clearly a weapon in the designed-run game and the red zone.

Leonard still has a lot to prove as a passer, but his athletic ability and toughness gives him a floor to work with while he figures it out.

Kyle McCord: Dallas Cowboys

It’s hard to find and hold onto good backup quarterbacks — the Cowboys were lucky to draft and retain Cooper Rush for as long as that they did. Boring as he is to watch, Rush was a perfectly competent quarterback when it came to running the offense and not playing outside of his means.

With Rush now in Baltimore, the Cowboys are in search of the next guy to fill that role. McCord is their best bet.

McCord is not an overwhelming talent. His arm is just okay, and he’s not going to scare anyone on the move. Like any good NFL backup, however, McCord can run an offense efficiently and consistently. He really learned to play within himself at Syracuse, displaying good rhythm and decision-making as a thrower.

It’s unlikely he ever ascends to anything above a very good backup, but that’s quite alright for a Cowboys team shopping for that exact kind of player.

Will Howard: Pittsburgh Steelers

They have to draft somebody, right? Even under the assumption Aaron Rodgers finally drops the charade and signs, the Steelers need to make some sort of effort to secure a young quarterback.

Howard, if nothing else, fits Arthur Smith’s offense. He is not someone who should be a high-volume passer, which already leans into Smith’s run-first approach. Additionally, Howard’s best traits are his size and arm talent, which allows him to comfortably throw down the field, as well as ample athletic ability for a player his size. Smith’s entire play-action and boot menu would be open with Howard at quarterback.

It’s hard to imagine Howard developing the down-to-down accuracy and play speed to really thrive as an NFL starter, but Smith’s offense in Pittsburgh at least would give Howard a chance to hide his weaknesses and lean into his strengths.

Dillon Gabriel: Miami Dolphins

Putting the short lefty quarterback prospect as a backup to the short lefty NFL quarterback feels like a bit, but it’s not. It makes sense when you consider each player’s strengths and the dynamics of being a left-handed vs. right-handed thrower.

Firstly, pass-catchers often talk about the flight and spin of the ball being different from lefty quarterbacks — the ball rotates in the opposite direction of 99 percent of quarterbacks, so it looks different coming into a receiver’s vision.

Gabriel, like Tua Tagovailoa, also thrives with RPOs and throws over the middle. He has a flexible and explosive release, making him perfectly equipped to manage those RPOs at a high level. And he thrives on in-breaking throws, even offering more velocity than Tagovailoa does.

The Dolphins desperately need to invest in a backup quarterback somehow. Gabriel fits.

Quinn Ewers: Buffalo Bills

Not every player or team gets their ideal match in an exercise like this. Sometimes, teams have to settle for whoever is left on the dance floor.

From the Bills’ perspective, a young backup quarterback should be on the table, because Mitchell Trubisky has just one year left on his deal. It makes some sense for the Bills to get ahead of things early and get a developmental player in the pipeline.

Ewers would bring functional athleticism and arm talent for Joe Brady. He still struggles with pocket presence and touch accuracy, especially down the field, but there’s enough talent there to mold a functional backup.

(Top photo of Jaxson Dart:  Justin Ford / Getty Images)

Rating the favourites to win the 2025 Ballon d’Or: Is Raphinha now in pole position?

We’re into the defining stretch of the 2024-25 season, with trophies to be won, European spots up for grabs and relegations to be avoided. All of Europe’s domestic leagues and UEFA’s three club competitions are nearing completion, which not only prompts conversation about the end-of-year awards but the next Ballon d’Or too.

At its roots, the Ballon d’Or is a subjective award. Handed out every October to honour the best player in the game over the previous 12 months, it is decided by votes from 100 journalists, one from each of the countries in the top 100 of the FIFA world rankings. Yet, for both players and fans, it remains arguably the best way to judge and reward individual performance. Lionel Messi has the most wins, with eight, followed by Cristiano Ronaldo (five) and then Michel Platini, the late Johan Cruyff and Marco van Basten on three each.

So, with around six months to go before this year’s winner is crowned, here’s a considered analysis of those players The Athletic currently considers the main contenders. We will update these rankings regularly, so expect to see plenty of movement as individual form waxes and wanes over the rest of this season and into the next one.


1) Raphinha (Barcelona and Brazil)

Why’s he in the top 10? Raphinha leads La Liga players in goal contributions across all club competitions with 28 goals and 20 assists in his 45 games. Few could have foreseen the Brazilian having a season of this nature when he was battling relegation from the Premier League with Leeds United this time three years ago, but if Barcelona go on to complete a historic treble, few would argue against him receiving the Ballon d’Or in October.

This week Raphinha had to settle for a half-hour appearance off the bench in a 1-1 home draw against Real Betis last Saturday, with his minutes being carefully managed since he returned from international duty in South America last month. Restored to the starting XI for the visit of Borussia Dortmund in the first leg of a Champions League quarter-final on Wednesday, Raphinha scored the game’s opening goal from about two inches out before assisting both Robert Lewandowski and Lamine Yamal as Barcelona won 4-0. He is now up to a club record 19 goal contributions in the Champions League this season, matching Lionel Messi’s career-best tally from 2011-12.

Up next Barcelona return to domestic action on Saturday away at Leganes with revenge on their mind after losing 1-0 to the relegation-threatened side in December and with Raphinha on the hunt for just his third La Liga goal of 2025. That is followed by a visit to Dortmund’s Signal Iduna Park on Tuesday for what looks like a dead-rubber of a second leg.


2) Ousmane Dembele (Paris Saint-Germain and France)

Why’s he in the top 10? After displaying flashes of brilliance for years, Dembele has finally added consistency to his game this season. He has 32 goals in 41 club appearances, including 21 in 19 since the turn of the year (to go with scoring for France against Croatia last month too). Turning 28 next month, Dembele is one of the senior players in PSG’s youth-infused project under Luis Enrique, which is finally taking off, with the team in contention for a treble, including a Ligue 1 campaign where they are yet to lose after 28 of the 34 matches.

This week Dembele came off the bench for the final half-hour of PSG’s title-clinching win against Angers on Saturday before dazzling in the 3-1 defeat of visitors Aston Villa four days later in the first leg of their Champions League quarter-final. He crowned an impressive display by assisting Nuno Mendes for a potentially pivotal third goal in stoppage time.

Up next PSG have no match this weekend, so don’t play again until the return leg against Villa on Tuesday. With the home side needing to attack to claw back that two-goal deficit, Dembele should find plenty of opportunities on the counter.


Dembele underlined his Ballon d’Or credentials once more against Villa (Franck Fife/AFP via Getty Images)

3) Lamine Yamal (Barcelona and Spain)

Why’s he in the top 10? The cult of Yamal seems to grow every week as he shows off new skills while improving on those we’ve already seen. Whatever he touches seems to turn to gold. He has a record of 14 goals and 17 assists for Barcelona this season, to go with a sumptuous goal for Spain in their Nations League quarter-finals win over the Netherlands in March.

This week Yamal cut a frustrated figure last weekend against Betis, with some rarely-seen heavy touches and misplaced passes as Barca tried to break through a disciplined defence. But it was a good learning experience for him, and he proceeded to toy with Dortmund’s Ramy Bensebaini in midweek before scoring the game’s final goal with an impudent toe-poke.

Up next Yamal will be key if Barcelona are to continue their La Liga title charge at Leganes — the second leg against Dortmund a few days later is now a mere formality with that four-goal lead.


Yamal had another outstanding game in the Champions League on Wednesday (Pedro Salado/Getty Images)

4) Harry Kane (Bayern Munich and England)

Why’s he in the top 10? The Bundesliga is proving far too easy for Kane. Having scored 36 league goals in his 2023-24 debut season after a move from the Premier League’s Tottenham Hotspur, he is on 23 this time, helping put Bayern six points clear at the top with six games to go after surprisingly losing the title to Bayer Leverkusen a year ago. Vincent Kompany’s side are also in the last eight of the Champions League, where Kane has 10 goals in his 12 appearances. He also scored twice for England in their March double-header.

This week Kane scored Bayern’s go-ahead goal in a 3-1 win against Augsburg last Friday, heading home from Michael Olise’s 60th-minute cross. He struggled on Tuesday against visitors Inter in the first leg of their Champions League quarter-final, though, hitting the post in the first half from his best chance as Bayern lost 2-1.


Kane scoring against Augsburg last weekend (Sebastian Widmann/Getty Images)

Up next Kane and Co are at home on Saturday against Dortmund, who he has scored seven goals against in seven games for Spurs and now Bayern. While Der Klassiker is usually an A-list fixture, their focus will undoubtedly be more on turning the Inter tie around at San Siro on Wednesday than domestic matters.


5) Kylian Mbappe (Real Madrid and France)

Why’s he in the top 10? Mbappe is approaching the end of one of the best debut seasons ever by a Madrid forward, with 32 goals in 47 games across all competitions despite some growing pains early on. As he has found his feet, the Frenchman has overtaken Vinicius Junior and Jude Bellingham as the talisman of the team.

This week Last weekend saw a humbling for the La Liga champions as Valencia beat them at the Bernabeu for the first time in 17 years. Mbappe toiled with minimal luck against goalkeeper Giorgi Mamardashvili as Madrid fell four points behind leaders Barcelona with eight games to go. If that 2-1 defeat was a shock to the system, Tuesday brought full-fledged electrocution as Arsenal thrashed Madrid 3-0 at the Emirates Stadium in the first leg of a quarter-final to leave their hopes of back-to-back Champions League titles dangling by a thread. Mbappe missed two presentable chances in the first half before being shut out for much of the second.

Up next A trip north to Alaves, who are fighting relegation from La Liga, on Sunday could be the ideal match to either return to form or deepen the sense of crisis at Madrid. That will be followed by Wednesday’s return leg against Arsenal, a fixture which will require Mbappe to channel his inner 2021-22 Karim Benzema.


Mbappe endured a difficult night in north London on Tuesday (Justin Setterfield/Getty Images)

6) Mohamed Salah (Liverpool and Egypt)

Why’s he in the top 10? When your statistics are being compared to those of Messi and Ronaldo, it’s an indication you’re having an all-timer of a season. Salah has gone off the boil rather in the past month but still has 44 goal contributions (27 goals and 17 assists) in the Premier League alone, with Liverpool looking primed to win the title. There will be no other trophies for them in 2024-25, but this is undoubtedly one of the greatest individual seasons played out on English turf.

This week Liverpool suffered a rare league defeat on Sunday, beaten 3-2 at Fulham in a match where Salah was kept quiet for the second time in a week after the 1-0 derby win against Everton. He ended the week much more brightly, though, with confirmation of a new two-year contract.

Up next Liverpool host West Ham United on Sunday and may have a chance to extend their lead at the top of the table if Arsenal rotate players for their home match against Brentford the previous evening. Salah is due a bounce-back game having not scored a non-penalty goal in the league since February 23 and 16th-placed West Ham present the ideal opportunity for him to cut loose.


7) Alessandro Bastoni (Inter and Italy)

Why’s he in the top 10? Bastoni has been a near ever-present for treble-chasing Inter, racking up 3,193 minutes across competitions, the most by any of their outfield player. In addition to his defensive prowess, he averages the second-most pass attempts per 90 minutes (76.6) among all Serie A centre-backs this season.

This week Bastoni played only the first half away at struggling Parma last Saturday as a precaution because of a knee issue. Inter were 2-0 up at the break but conceded twice in nine minutes without him to draw the game. He then played the full 90 at Bayern in the Champions League quarter-final first leg on Tuesday, helping his team to an impressive 2-1 win.

Up next Bastoni and Inter will look to extend their three-point lead in Serie A when they entertain 15th-placed Cagliari on Saturday before the rematch with Bayern, also at San Siro, on Wednesday.


8) Robert Lewandowski (Barcelona and Poland)

Why’s he in the top 10? After facing questions over his Barcelona future at the end of last season, the 36-year-old Lewandowski has spearheaded their treble charge in this one. He is the only player in Europe’s top five leagues to get to 40 goals across all competitions and has a barely believable 123 times in 116 matches under Hansi Flick over three seasons with Bayern and now Barca.

This week Lewandowski, like his attacking partners, struggled in that 1-1 draw with Betis but came to the fore in midweek against Dortmund, another of his former clubs. He scored with a close-range header to make it 2-0, then powered home Barcelona’s third as they put one foot and a couple of toes in the Champions League semi-finals.

Up next Leganes are one of just three teams Lewandowski has faced in La Liga without scoring (although in his defence, he’s only played against them once), a record he will want to change on Saturday. A rest could do him good too, though, if Flick decides he wants him fresh for the trip to Dortmund.


Lewandowski is one of three Barcelona forwards in our top 10 currently (Lluis Gene/AFP via Getty Images)

9) Pedri (Barcelona and Spain)

Why’s he in the top 10? The front three understandably take the headlines but most of Barcelona’s good play stems from Pedri, their midfield engine. His first fully-fit season since 2019-20 has delivered one good performance after the other for Barca and Spain with excellent passes, non-stop running, defensive interventions — and the occasional goal, too.

This week Pedri was another restricted by Betis’ system but found more joy against Dortmund’s inexperienced midfield.

Up next Unlike his attacking team-mates, who might get a rest, you are almost guaranteed to see Pedri start against both Leganes and Dortmund.


10) Jude Bellingham (Real Madrid and England)

Why’s he in the top 10? Bellingham has struggled with inconsistency compared to his 2023-24 debut season with Madrid but still has 11 goals and 10 assists from midfield in 36 matches across La Liga and the Champions League. Madrid have struggled with their balance and their attack’s best moments have come when Bellingham has pulled the strings and made his signature late runs into the box.

This week Bellingham assisted Vinicius Jr’s equaliser against Valencia, and created two great openings in the first half against Arsenal before fading after the break.

Up next Alaves have been one of Bellingham’s favourite opponents — he has a goal and three assists from his three matches against them — but Madrid need him at his absolute best for the Arsenal game in midweek as they aim to conjure another Bernabeu miracle.

(Photos: Getty Images; design: Eamonn Dalton)

Masters fashion: Stretching the concept of quiet luxury underneath a giant oak tree

Follow live coverage of the final round of the 2025 Masters

AUGUSTA, Ga. — The Masters will never be cheugy.

It may be a crime of fashion to be overdone, outdated or, gasp, dressed in millenial-core for 51 weeks a year. But for this week, at Augusta National Golf Club during the Masters, the patrons come dressed for the scene they find when they step on property, and there’s something about the place that makes it all work.

The open space between the clubhouse, the first tee and the practice green at Augusta National is like the Shibuya Crossing of golf. Spectators shuffle in every which direction, creating a dizzying blur of rye green, seersucker and straw hats. The Green Jackets gather under the canopy of the legendary oak tree, schmoozing with VIP guests, while groups of done-up women meander about, greeting each other and dishing out compliments on floral dresses from the latest spring collections: “Oh I love that! Where’s it from?” Meanwhile, the golf bros walk with purpose to find their next vantage point, as spikeless golf shoes and big box brand dry-fit polos do exactly what they are supposed to do: perform.

From the old to the young, to the PGA Tour superfan and the clueless significant other, the patrons at Augusta National all have one thing in common when it comes to their varying fashion choices: They’re trying to say something.

The spectators at the Masters take full advantage of the opportunity to be, well, extra.

For the men, this effort manifests in a competition as old as time. The Country Club Logo Olympics begin at 7:00 a.m. Monday, when the patron gates open for the week’s first practice round. At the Masters, the idea of “quiet luxury” is not just a Hermés bag or a pair of Chanel ballet flats, but also needlepoint whales and acorns stitched onto canvas golf hats.

It’s impossible for a few not to catch your eye: Pine Valley on a navy polo, Seminole Golf Club on a cashmere pullover. Spot the ultra-private Ohoopee Match Club onion? Or the lesser-known but mighty crest for one of Scotland’s finest, North Berwick Golf Club? It might spark a conversation. That’s exactly what they want.

“You see these logos and you’re like, he definitely knows a member. But you’re not sure if he is a member. But if he is a member, I need him to be my friend,” says Stephen Malbon, founder of Malbon Golf, a lifestyle brand that has partnered with PGA Tour pro Jason Day to stretch player fashion past slim-fit golf pants and shades of blue.

That’s the least of it. Turn to the left or right anywhere on property and it won’t take long to find the GOAT: The Augusta National Golf Club logo. It is not to be confused with the Masters logo. These are very different things.

There’s already an exclusivity to the idea of purchasing Masters merchandise because it is only sold on site. When you get there, there are about 19 other elevations beyond what you can take home from the massive merchandise building, which contains 64 check out registers and 385 mannequins and sells everything from $400 cashmere hoodies to scented candles and gnomes. Now Augusta National has Berckmans Place and Map & Flag, two brand new and hot-ticketed hospitality venues that also sell their own apparel. The holy grail is, of course, the club’s intimate pro shop. That’s the only place one can purchase an item that is simply adorned with the coveted “ANGC.” Yes, those four letters make the difference.

“There are people flexing their Berckmans merch. And that’s different from the main merch. And the pro shop merch is different from that merch,” says Malbon. “There’s levels to it. People are showing their social or economic status by wearing this stuff.”


For men at the Masters polos and khakis are de rigueur. (Kyle Terada / USA Today Sports)

For the women of Augusta National, there’s an understanding that you dress for the female gaze. Admit it or don’t, you’re scrolling Pinterest and TikTok in the months leading up the tournament to find outfit inspiration for your Masters outfit, which, if you’re attending Thursday-Sunday, will not be seen on an Instagram feed (unless you film an “outfit check” in the parking lot.) Cell phones are prohibited from the Augusta National grounds and cameras are only allowed on practice round days. You dress to impress, though, even if the internet may not see it.

“The key to fashion at the Masters is not necessarily clothes that you’d wear to play golf. Those outfits are great for other golf tournaments. For me, the Masters is more like the Kentucky Derby of golf, minus the hat and definitely minus the heels,” says Golf Channel’s Kira K. Dixon. “If you wear a hat, it should just be a really good wide-brim hat because sun protection is key.”

“Wear something really cute that you wouldn’t normally wear, blow it out of the water. Wear the wide leg pants, wear the fun blazer, wear the fun print. This is Augusta National. Do it.”

A pop of green is the first aesthetic necessity for women at the Masters, but there are always ways to go above and beyond.

Annie Shoulders and Kylie Shemanksi stood on the ropeline of the fifth fairway at Augusta National, waiting for Jordan Spieth’s Thursday pairing to find the short grass. Shemanski’s name was stitched onto the back of her white sweater in green letters in the style of the traditional Masters caddie bibs — a creative touch. But then Shoulders turned around for the grand reveal.

She had painted her square-shaped crossbody purse by hand to look like a pimento cheese sandwich.

“I knew I was going to do this for about a month,” said Shoulders, an engineer from Little Rock, Ark., attending her second Masters. “I also made sweaters for (Shemanski’s) daughters.”


(Michael Madrid / USA Today Sports)

There’s a decadence to the women at Augusta National. Round, flat-brim straw hats and monochrome matching sets have been two popular trends in 2025. Color combinations of Masters green — also known as Pantone 342 — and Butter Yellow, the season’s hottest spring shade, have been plentiful. Adidas Sambas are the tournament’s most popular shoe, with New Balance 327s coming in as a close second. Dixon, who has received hundreds of direct messages from Masters ticket-holders asking for outfit advice, coined a term to describe the style: “Augustacore.”

The local boutiques in Augusta make it their mission to capitalize on Masters week. The Swank Company prepares inventory with the proper color schemes and accessories for patrons in need of a last-minute shopping trip. The Peppy Poppy says that Masters season is their second-most profitable time of the year, behind only Christmas.

“Masters style is always going to be the same: Something green and something stylish and comfortable to walk around in,” says Dawne Byrd, owner of the Peppy Poppy.

The fashion circus at the Masters feels like it could get old really fast, but somehow, it just never does. There’s a sense of, if you’re at Augusta National, why wouldn’t you go all out?

“When I told my sister that we were going to the Masters, her first question was ‘What are we going to wear?” says Kiara Dowdell, who was wearing a matching cardigan with her sister, Alexis Vega.


(Peter Casey / USA Today)

The players and their sponsors participate in the frenzy too, with pre-planned weekly scripting and outfit choices that they wouldn’t make at any other golf tournament. For example: Cam Smith wore a four-way stretch blazer during Wednesday’s practice round. It was the result of a drunken conversation with the man who makes said blazer.

The tournament participants are focused on the task at hand, but they’re also aware of what’s going on around them.

“When you’re walking the golf course, everyone looks like they’re having a good time. Everyone is dressed up really nice,” Day, who is known for pushing the boundaries with his on-course attire, says. “It’s kind of like a horse racing event when everyone comes out and they’re wearing some really nice clothes. They just do it right here at Augusta.”

The Masters is not just a golf tournament. It is different. So naturally, the patrons, in all sorts of ridiculous ways, are going to treat it like a one-of-a-kind opportunity. And that allure will never go out of style.

(Illustration: Demetrius Robinson / The Athletic; Photos: Andrew Redington, Richard Heathcote / Getty Images; Rob Schumacher, Kyle Terada / USA Today Sports)

Inside Mohamed Salah’s contract saga: Lawyer’s concerns, Saudi interest – and a deal that pleases everyone

In the end, the news that Mohamed Salah will remain at Liverpool was delivered with a humorous tagline.

“More in than out,” read the message across the club’s social media pages at 8am on Friday, around 36 hours after reports in the forward’s homeland of Egypt first suggested he had agreed to extend his eight-year stay at Anfield.

It was a play on words, nodding to Salah’s comments in November when his future on Merseyside felt far more tenuous. The fact that he felt “more out than in” after scoring two crucial goals in a 3-2 come-from-behind win at Southampton that day was confirmation that the process of his contract negotiations has not exactly been smooth. Though Liverpool always felt confident a successful resolution would be reached, that scenario was not inevitable.

Now, however, the deal is done.

Salah has signed a two-year extension, with no breaks or release clauses, on terms very similar to the ones that almost certainly made him the second-highest-paid player in the Premier League behind Manchester City striker Erling Haaland. While his previous contract included a basic weekly salary of £350,000 ($480,000), when bonuses and performance-related incentives were taken into account, Salah’s package was worth far more. Including external commercial endorsements, some of which also had performance-related clauses, he earned up to £1million per week.

This new contract’s lucrative nature reflects Salah’s status and his ongoing excellence, even though he’ll turn 33 in June. After scoring 243 goals in 394 games, he is set to complete a decade’s service at Anfield.

Discussions on this latest deal have been a drawn-out process, rather than there being any breakthrough ‘moment’, and have taken nearly a year. The path has not been straightforward.

The Athletic has talked to figures with intimate knowledge of those negotiations, who spoke to us on condition of anonymity to protect relationships, to understand why they took so long, how both parties approached them and what ultimately clinched an agreement.


Ramy Abbas, the Colombian lawyer who is Salah’s long-time representative, does not like discussing sensitive matters on his phone. For him, it is convenient that services such as WhatsApp are banned from receiving or making calls in the United Arab Emirates, where he lives.

Though messages are permitted, hundreds of them are usually left unread on his accounts, many from potential commercial partners looking to work with his most famous client. A note on his WhatsApp profile warns: “Voice notes ignored. If you’re late, I will leave.”

Abbas is transactional, he likes efficiency and he prefers to meet in person.

When Liverpool signed Salah in the summer of 2017, their sporting director at the time, Michael Edwards, and chief scout Dave Fallows flew to Dubai out of respect for Abbas. They wanted to show him how keen they were to sign Salah from Roma.

Having arrived in the evening when it was already dark, they headed home to England a few hours later without ever taking their jumpers off. On that return journey, the pair joked they must be the only visitors to leave the Gulf resort without experiencing any sun on their backs.

That negotiation was relatively straightforward due to Salah’s enthusiasm for a return to the Premier League, where he felt he had much to prove having barely played during a previous spell with Chelsea.

When Liverpool’s new sporting director, Richard Hughes, picked up the phone to introduce himself to Abbas in July last year, however, there was much work to do.

Hughes had inherited significant challenges at Liverpool, starting with the recruitment of a manager/head coach to succeed Jurgen Klopp, who stepped down at the end of last season after almost nine years. Following the hiring of Feyenoord coach Arne Slot to fill that vacancy, Hughes moved on to player retention: as with Salah, there was only 11 months left on the contracts of the team’s captain, Virgil van Dijk, and his deputy, Trent Alexander-Arnold, the Liverpudlian local hero.

Alexander-Arnold’s case was different to the others in that he was in his mid-twenties, and had active interest from Real Madrid. Salah and Van Dijk were in their early thirties, and while still performing at an elite level, Liverpool were conscious that their previous contracts had been agreed when both were at the peak of their powers.

The mantra from Liverpool and the club’s owners at Fenway Sports Group (FSG) was the need to ignore the question of, ‘What looks like the right decision today?’, and rather frame it as, ‘What will look like the right decision in future?’.


Virgil van Dijk was also holding contract talks (Ryan Pierse/Getty Images)

That first conversation between Hughes and Abbas was brief and casual, with the sporting director promising that he would be in touch again soon to discuss Salah’s future. Like Edwards and Fallows had years earlier, Hughes would subsequently travel to Dubai to see Abbas, going twice before the end of 2024.

The first meeting, in late September, was held in the bar of one of the city’s quieter restaurants but the discussion was again short and informal until Hughes asked Abbas whether Salah wanted to stay at Liverpool. Abbas told him that he did, but the sporting director flew back to the UK with Abbas concerned the club might not be willing to maintain his client’s level of remuneration.

Abbas was impressed by Hughes but was left asking himself whether Liverpool valued Salah quite as much as they used to. He wondered whether the lack of commitment represented a hostile act.

As far as Salah was concerned, he was operating at the same level as the best players on the planet and showing no signs of slowing up, despite a disappointing end to last season after sustaining a hamstring injury at the Africa Cup of Nations in January 2024. The goals and assists were flowing.

Salah and Abbas understood the player’s salary would be in line with what he might achieve in the future but they wanted to sustain his position as one of world football’s best-paid players.

Liverpool, for their part, maintain that a pay cut was never on the agenda and that they always wanted to keep Salah. They had no issue with Salah pushing for the best possible terms and FSG had, after all, sanctioned lucrative deals for players — including Salah — worth the investment. They were also conscious of the need to try to find common ground with Abbas before tabling a formal offer.

There was also an acknowledgement, however, that any deal could not run counter to FSG’s sustainable financial model and had to be in the best interests of the club. For Liverpool’s owners, this principle could not be sacrificed, regardless of how valuable Salah was to the team’s chances of on-pitch success.


Richard Hughes, Liverpool’s sporting director (John Powell/Liverpool FC via Getty Images)

Salah thought the best years of his career were still to come.

Until Manchester City’s Rodri won it at age 28 last year, Ballon d’Or winners over the previous decade had all been in their early to mid-thirties and he wasn’t turning 33 until June 2025. Salah believed that his goals fuelling a successful Liverpool side would allow him to follow legends such as Lionel Messi, Cristiano Ronaldo, Luka Modric and Karim Benzema in winning that award, recognising the best footballer of the previous 12 months.

Hughes had travelled to that first meeting alone but Abbas wondered about Edwards’ involvement behind the scenes. Though he now officially worked for FSG, rather than the club, it was ultimately his responsibility to manage the budgets in the organisation’s football interests. Liverpool were not in financial distress. Though the club was expected to post a loss before tax for the 2023-24 season, it remained well within the limits for profit and sustainability rules (PSR) for the following campaign.

When Salah last renewed with Liverpool in July 2022, a deal that made him the highest-paid player in the club’s history, the contract was brokered and signed off by FSG president Mike Gordon. Julian Ward had succeeded Edwards as Liverpool’s sporting director but the meatier conversations were between Gordon and Abbas. That negotiation was a slog and Abbas and Salah both felt that the player’s future lay elsewhere just three weeks before an agreement was reached.

Abbas was unsure whether a resolution would have been found had Edwards led that process. He had brokered a complex package that was realistically achievable but, on a basic level, more lucrative than the figure suggested publicly. He was proud of the deal, realising that the club and their owners had extended themselves as far as they could to keep Salah, and even allowed the prestigious Harvard Business School in the United States to turn it into a case study.


Mohamed Salah signs his previous contract in 2022, along with Ramy Abbas (facing away from camera), and club officials Jonathan Bamber and Julian Ward (Nick Taylor/Liverpool FC via Getty Images)

The revelation that FSG had authorised a record-breaking deal to keep Liverpool’s star man meant it was more difficult for any of its critics to accuse it of being tight with money but it also suited the owners to keep the figures lower. If it was known that Salah was earning considerably more than some of his team-mates, there was a danger that Liverpool’s pay structure would spiral out of control.

FSG brought Edwards back into the organisation in March last year to try to re-establish a chain of command that existed at Liverpool before it became a manager-led operation under Klopp. The owners knew how ruthless Edwards could be. Yet beyond him and Hughes, Abbas could not shake the feeling that Gordon would also still be involved when it came to the final figures, if the negotiations ever got to that stage. FSG’s money was ultimately Gordon’s, and he would be the one signing off any deal.


In a second Dubai meeting between Abbas and Hughes in October, the conversation didn’t move on very far, with the lawyer concluding the discussion was light on meaningful content. It was his view that negotiations had not even really started. Abbas’ policy had always been to let the club make the first move, allowing him to see clearly how highly they valued his client. The lack of pace or urgency worried him.

Towards the end of November, Abbas did not know how much Liverpool were willing to pay Salah or how long they wanted him to stay. Though he was told there was an offer in the making, nothing happened. He was confident Liverpool would deliver on their promise eventually, but was increasingly beginning to think it would only be done to save face, allowing the club to claim they had tried to keep Salah — even though they knew the offer made to him would be rejected.

This explains why, on November 24, after he’d scored twice in the second half to inspire that win at Southampton, the player decided to speak to journalists about his future, telling them he was disappointed not to have received a new contract offer, before making his “more out than in” comments regarding the 2025-26 season.

Nothing that Salah says publicly is done without consideration. He is rarely impulsive and little is improvised. Initially, he planned to tell UK broadcaster Sky Sports about his frustrations but in the immediate post-match interview, he was not asked about his future. Outside the stadium, as he boarded the team bus, he asked print journalists whether they were willing to ask the difficult questions.

It was unusual to hear a player as private as Salah speak so openly. Yet on this occasion, he felt as though he was able to attack the situation because Abbas only represents him. Neither the player nor the lawyer had team-mates or other clients to think of at Liverpool.

Salah would subsequently receive criticism, notably from Sky Sports pundit Jamie Carragher, a former Liverpool defender, for speaking out. A comparison was drawn with Van Dijk, but Abbas had been told that the Dutchman had already received a contract offer while his client had not. Therefore, Salah had more of a reason to go public about his concerns.

Hughes had taken the view early on in the process that he had no desire to put anything relating to the contract talks in the public domain, reasoning that doing so would only cause issues for Salah (who he wanted to focus simply on scoring goals and winning games), new coach Slot or the team as a whole.

This often meant the club being subjected to ferocious criticism, particularly on social media, for seemingly allowing talks to drift and uncertainty to foment. A fan’s banner also appeared on the Kop during a match at Anfield, nodding to Salah’s ‘bow and arrow’ goal celebration, urging FSG: “He fires a bow, now give Mo his dough!”

Yet, for Hughes, it was deemed a price worth paying, even after the Southampton game when the temptation to become drawn into a public debate may have been acute. Following that banner’s advice would have been the antithesis of FSG’s principles.


A banner on the Kop encouraging FSG to finalise Salah’s new contract (Visionhaus/Getty Images)

Abbas was open-minded about the length of any new contract, despite some claims the issue was causing a dispute. If the offer was right, Salah was willing to extend his stay at Liverpool by only one year. Yet as November turned into December, both parties were not even at the numbers stage.

It was certainly in Liverpool’s interest to ensure Salah’s deal was the last one signed among the three players approaching free agency. If he were the first and his salary remained high, the representative of every other player at the club would have a figure to work from during their own contract negotiations. It was Abbas’ view that Salah was the star player and, just as Andriy Shevchenko (a striker) had earned more money than Paolo Maldini (a defender) at Milan decades earlier, so Salah deserved the more lucrative package.

With the focus swinging from Liverpool’s table-topping surge in the Premier League to Salah’s future after his words with reporters in Southampton, champions Manchester City were the team’s next opponents at Anfield the following Sunday — December 1. Earlier in the week, Abbas had flown into London’s Heathrow Airport, taking a meeting with a sponsor in Manchester before a night back in London, where he ate at one of his favourite Japanese restaurants. He travelled north again by train, arriving in Liverpool a few hours before kick-off and heading into a hospitality suite at the stadium without anyone from the media noticing him.

Though Hughes had contacted him about Salah’s comments the previous weekend, there was no summit with the sporting director. After watching the match, which Liverpool won 2-0, with Salah scoring the late clincher, Abbas flew back the next morning to Dubai via Manchester, no closer to knowing where his client’s future lay.


Abbas had earmarked the start of February as a cut-off point for any decision. That would leave a reasonable amount of time to try to find a resolution with Liverpool, or failing that, reach an agreement somewhere else.

Foreign clubs could not officially talk to Salah until January. Abbas was planning to spend the first month of 2025 broadening his client’s options but he knew that Salah’s priority was to re-sign with Liverpool. He was enjoying playing under Slot, and admired the head coach’s sense of superiority — he did not seem to mind embracing the expectations that fall upon the club.

Previously, Klopp liked to cast himself as the underdog but Slot was the opposite: Liverpool were a global superpower who should be winning trophies. Salah respected that attitude. Whereas Klopp had regularly complained about the demanding fixture schedule, Slot seemed to relish it. There were no excuses — it was all on the manager, the staff and the players to find solutions.

By Christmas, Liverpool were leading the Premier League by four points and also top of the reformatted Champions League table. Salah was convinced this was his and the club’s season of opportunity. Abbas, by comparison, believed success did not always lead to good sporting or business decisions. Win the league and it would be a much easier argument for Liverpool to then let Salah go, as the fan pressure might not be as significant.

This potentially left a curious dynamic: could it be true that the better Salah and Liverpool did, the weaker his chances of staying at Anfield beyond the summer of 2025 became? Salah wanted to play at the highest level for as long as possible. If Liverpool ended up winning the Premier League and Champions League, then anywhere else at that point was down as far as he was concerned.

At the turn of the year, this made the Saudi Pro League a low-probability destination. Though it was a league with mind-boggling resources, Saudi Arabia was also a developing country in football terms. Salah also loved living in England, where his family privacy was respected — he has a wife and two daughters who are well settled in the county of Cheshire, just south of Liverpool — and he could focus on his career. Would that be the same if he returned to the Middle East?

In the long-term, Abbas was interested in the United States but Major League Soccer did not make any approaches. While there was press speculation that Paris Saint-Germain were another option, in early January, the French club’s president Nasser Al-Khelaifi denied he was targeting the player.

By mid-January, the player’s sponsors were getting twitchy, keen to know where Salah’s future lay. Abbas did the maths about what a move to France would mean — Salah’s endorsements would take a serious hit because Ligue 1 does not have the same global visibility as the Premier League. This contributed to Abbas being more inclined towards a longer stay in England, preferably with Liverpool. Salah would not trash his legacy by joining a rival, which ruled out both Manchester City and neighbours United.

There was some intrigue about Chelsea, where he’d played for just over a year across 2014 and early 2015 and was considered a failure as he was first loaned to Fiorentina and fellow Italians Roma, then sold to the latter in August 2016. Salah felt as though he still had something to prove at Stamford Bridge, yet any deal to go back was reliant on Chelsea abandoning a transfer strategy that focuses on signing young players. Any move to another English club was also made more complicated by the fact none of them were legally allowed to negotiate with Salah until May.


Salah feels he has unfinished business with Chelsea (Richard Heathcote/Getty Images)

By the end of January, Salah had told his family that there was a chance they would have to uproot from their Cheshire home. For Abbas, there were now two clear options: stay at Liverpool, or, somewhat reluctantly, agree a deal with the only alternative that could satisfy his financial expectations.

That meant one of the Saudi Arabian clubs, most likely reigning champions Al Hilal in the capital, Riyadh, who had wanted him for their Club World Cup campaign this summer. Though Abbas had held talks with other clubs owned by the state Public Investment Fund (PIF), he was increasingly beginning to think that the interest in his client was a charm offensive by the country’s football powers to show how highly Salah was valued.

Abbas did not have an offer in writing but the numbers the Saudis were talking about would remove any concerns about sponsors and how they would react. His contacts in Saudi Arabia told him that if Salah wanted to move there, then an offer would come, though Abbas was mindful of what might happen if it became clear first that a new deal was not happening at Liverpool. Potentially, this would leave Salah exposed and suddenly he would be in a buyers’ market.

Of more significance, however, was what was happening closer to home.

By early December, Liverpool had finally made Salah an offer. Abbas’ fears were allayed and he considered it something to work from. He was happier now with the way things were going because of the regularity of the contact with the club.

Liverpool seemed more serious but Haaland’s nine-year contract at City, announced in the middle of January, had the potential to complicate things. What was he earning? Abbas understood that any deal for Salah would be much shorter but if Haaland was setting the rate for forwards, given Salah was outscoring him and playing for a team higher up the table, his wage ought to be competitive with what City were paying the Norwegian.


By now, speculation was reaching fever pitch, something Abbas found faintly amusing.

When it was suggested by local media on Merseyside at the end of January that he was flying in for talks, Abbas posted a picture on Instagram of the view from his home in Dubai.

Halfway across the world, Salah continued to hit landmarks: after scoring his 50th European goal for Liverpool on January 21 in a Champions League game against Lille, Slot spoke about his “elite mindset”. Back in Dubai, Abbas had dinner with his wife before watching that game at their apartment. Despite making progress, he and Liverpool remained some distance away from an agreement.

After January, however, Salah did his best to divert questions about his future.

In an interview with Sky, he insisted he did not know which club he was going to be playing for after this season, suggesting that if these were his final months at Liverpool, he did not want his memories of the period attached to any wrangling related to an impending exit. Instead, the focus would be on his and the club’s attempts to bring more trophies to Anfield.

The change of tactics was also a reflection of momentum shifting, with progress being made between Hughes and Abbas. On Valentine’s Day, Abbas was in a somewhat combative mood, posting on Instagram about too many social media users craving “attention and validation” from people they’ve never met, before switching to X, where he was rather more complimentary about Liverpool’s head coach, who he said was “excellent at his job” after taking the team seven points clear at the top of the Premier League.

Slot, meanwhile, was making it clear in interviews that he wanted Salah to stay, and the determination of the player to continue with Liverpool reflected the respect the Dutchman had gained during his debut season.


Arne Slot has struck up a good relationship with Salah (Alex Livesey/Getty Images)

Outside the club, many were baffled why all this was taking so long. Internally, Liverpool were relaxed about leaving any decision about Salah as late as possible.

They knew the retention of Salah would allow Liverpool to continue as the “destination club” they had become under Klopp, but they considered it smart practice to wait, as the team had settled into a rhythm, and this time gave Hughes and other club officials more of an opportunity to be sure the player was capable of maintaining his performances at age 33 and beyond.

The deal, when it was announced just before 8am on Friday UK time, involved images of Salah sitting on a throne beneath the Anfield floodlights at night. They had been taken the previous evening, when it was easier to get him in and out of the stadium without being seen.

For Liverpool, the announcement was a vindication of the work Hughes and Edwards have done behind the scenes, and of the impression made by Slot since his arrival last summer. The club feel the same will be true of Van Dijk, whose own two-year contract extension is also nearing confirmation.

Salah’s team-mates had long expected him to commit his future to Liverpool, not just because of his contribution this season, but because of the relationship he has struck up with Slot and how positive he has been about the head coach helping to elevate his game over course of this season. They have also been struck by how Salah has embraced the responsibility that comes with being part of the club’s leadership group and the support he gives to the younger players as a role model.

When the video was released on Friday morning, Abbas was back in Dubai. In some ways, dealing with him had been simple because only he acts on Salah’s behalf, and Salah is a footballer who does not have an entourage interfering in his affairs, unlike other players of his stature.

Abbas has no emotional connection as to where Salah plays his football — for him, it is simply a case of getting the best deal for his client, and he knows Liverpool are good for business.

But Salah was desperate to stay, as were his family. In the video released by LFCTV, he spoke about how his daughter Makkah was “the happiest one in the family” when he told the family he was staying because she didn’t want to move away from her school and friends.

Despite some difficulties, the dialogue between Abbas and Hughes was respectful, helping them extend a relationship that, until this point, has worked out handsomely for everyone.

Additional reporting: James Pearce

(Top photo: Carl Recine/Getty Images; design: Eamonn Dalton)

Carlos Alcaraz’s ‘My Way’ documentary trailer and a tennis tweener trick shot from heaven

If a player hits a running trick shot to save a break point, but later gets broken off three unforced errors and a double fault, is it good tennis? For Carlos Alcaraz, definitely.

He delivered a signal example of the tension running through his documentary series, ‘My Way,’ just as Netflix released its trailer. While Alcaraz was oscillating between the sublime and the absurd on court against Daniel Altmaier at the Monte Carlo Masters in Monaco, the streaming company put out a snapshot of the series on YouTube.

It asks some fundamental questions of tennis: how much should it require of its stars? How much sacrifice should greatness take? And is there a route to greatness that does not demand everything of the player who seeks it?

Against Altmaier, Alcaraz found himself down 30-40 in his first service game of their match. The German feathered a drop shot just over the net, dragging Alcaraz forward…

He responded with a sharp, cross-court angle…

… but Altmaier read the shot and moved across the court, to send the ball deep down the line on the other side.

Alcaraz, running diagonally to his left, would have to hit a shot through his legs. The easier option was to send the ball back cross-court. Altmaier duly moved to cover that shot; Alcaraz, perhaps obviously, did not hit it.

Instead, he levered the ball down the line, sending Altmaier scrambling to his backhand corner. The German managed to hook the ball back into play, but Alcaraz was waiting to crush a backhand flat into the same corner, which Altmaier could only send into the net.

It was an example of the divine inspiration and at times otherworldly skill — and joy — that Alcaraz brings to the court, and which has carried him to the upper echelons of tennis.

“It’s beautiful to play points like that,” Alcaraz said later, watching the shot back. “I’m trying to put on a show, trying to entertain the people. A point like that… Just to reflect, how my matches are going to be.”

The rest of the match was not so much like that.

Having saved that break point, Alcaraz missed a routine first groundstroke behind his serve. He saved four more break points in the game and held his serve for 1-1. He then broke Altmaier to lead 3-2, before hitting three unforced errors and a double fault to get broken straight back in the next game.

That was the pattern of the first set, oscillating between brilliant points and routine mistakes, before Alcaraz broke again at 5-3 to take it, 6-3.

The second set was more routine, with the Spaniard ultimately triumphing 6-3, 6-1 to set up a quarterfinal against No. 12 seed Arthur Fils.


“I want to do it my way,” Alcaraz says, in the series trailer, of his goal to be the best player in the world. That ambition is intercut with opinions from Rafael Nadal and Roger Federer, who both did it their way.

“To accomplish what Novak (Djokovic), Roger or myself have done,” Nadal says, “you need to feel that the sacrifices are worth it and that they pay off.”

With 66 Grand Slam titles between the three greatest men’s players of all time, there is little argument that they paid off in achievement. What Alcaraz appears to ask is whether or not they pay off in other ways.

Alcaraz, 21, already has four Grand Slam titles. He is the youngest man to win a major on all three surfaces, and still has two more opportunities — at the 2026 and 2027 Australian Opens — to become the youngest man to win all four majors.

If he wins the title in Monaco, he will reassume the No. 2 spot in the men’s rankings, behind only his closest rival and the player with whom he shares the mantle of the best in the world: Jannik Sinner.

His style of play is so singular that both his wins and his losses can appear as if from another world.

When he loses, whether a set or a whole match, he tends to lose badly. The creativity looks like naivety and the shotmaking looks like waste — and it tends to happen against lesser-ranked players. He has 16 defeats and one retirement due to injury since the start of 2024, but only six of those defeats came against top-10 players. Two of those six came in one tournament, the 2024 ATP Tour Finals, during which he was struggling with illness. The average ranking of his opponents in the other 10 losses is 32.

He is making adjustments, mentally and technically, most notably to his serve and his backhand. He has changed the motion on the former and the racket take-back on the latter, which means mistakes sometimes flow like water but also reveals a dedication to on-the-fly improvement, one of the hardest things to do given tennis’ demanding schedule.

Alcaraz describes the challenges of that schedule in the trailer, emphasizing that he wants to be able to spend time at home, to see his family. If he also wants to dominate the sport as Djokovic, Nadal and Federer did, that time will be limited.

As the retired Nadal and Federer hint at in their roles as Netflix talking heads, it’s only possible to find out if all that was worth it in the end.

On the way, there will be tweeners.

There will be errors too.

(Top photo: Valery Hache / AFP via Getty Images)

How do you fix an NHL arena where the fans don’t cheer? ‘Play in the sandbox’

It was a small moment in the Toronto Maple Leafs season, a late-January footnote that most of the NHL hardly noticed.

But when the team captain remarked how he was disappointed in the home crowd for showing so little enthusiasm for an early-game fight, it set off plenty of commentary in the center of the hockey universe about the Leafs fan base.

Or, to be more specific, the lack of one in the seats.

“I would’ve liked a little more energy from the crowd after that (fight),” Auston Matthews said following a 5-1 loss to the Columbus Blue Jackets, during which the Leafs’ Ryan Reaves dropped the gloves with Mathieu Olivier in the first period. “I thought it was a little quiet tonight, especially after two guys like that go at it.”

“He’s just admitting what everybody knows,” TSN commentator Bryan Hayes later added. “That building on a Wednesday night in January is never loud.”

Criticism of the crowds at Scotiabank Arena is not new in Toronto, where ticket prices have long outpaced the average fan’s means.

The tepid game atmosphere was raised by many of the hundreds of Leafs faithful who responded to our ownership survey last month. It was heavily featured again when we interviewed season-ticket holders about eye-opening price increases for next year’s packages.

Part of the issue in Toronto has to do with the nature of sports attendance in general over the past 20 years. More and more tickets are bought by companies as corporate perks, to the point that sitting in the lower bowl often doubles as attending a business meeting in major markets such as Toronto, New York and Vancouver.

Swanky suites and expensive lounges near the best viewing areas help woo clientele, who then help inflate revenue beyond what anyone could have imagined in earlier eras.

And yet, even with this growing trend across all sports, many organizations have started sinking millions of dollars into improving the atmosphere in their respective arenas. What’s become known as the “event presentation industry” has grown dramatically in that span. The impact has become particularly noticeable over the last decade or so in hockey, as newer markets have pushed the envelope of what’s possible at an NHL game.

According to some in the event presentation industry, the Nashville Predators may have started it all when they erected a band stage above the Zamboni entrance at Bridgestone Arena, embracing their Music City reputation with live performances integrated into the gameday experience. Plenty of other teams have followed suit, between the Tampa Bay Lightning’s outdoor areas and Tesla coil; the Seattle Kraken’s flying fish; and how the Vegas Golden Knights have … well, there’s a lot going on at T-Mobile Arena.

The result? When you travel to non-traditional markets these days, it’s jarring how much better the arena environment can be compared to some of the most venerated hockey cities on Earth.

It’s a contrast that made me wonder about the science behind working the crowd — and whether, perhaps, the NHL’s old guard can learn something from the new.


When Las Vegas landed an NHL expansion franchise in 2016, the soon-to-be Golden Knights heavily invested in the in-game experience. But they didn’t simply airlift in “hockey people” for the roles.

President Kerry Bubolz, who came by way of the NBA’s Cleveland Cavaliers, instead hired two staffers from the WWE to build out their presentation team: Jonny Greco, who became the Golden Knights’ vice president and chief experience officer, and Andrew Abrams, who specialized in video production at the arena level.

Greco and Abrams had worked in the NHL before — Greco with the Columbus Blue Jackets and Abrams with the St. Louis Blues — but their assignment for the Golden Knights was significantly different. In Vegas, they were tasked with combining what they had learned in both hockey and wrestling; applying the lessons to a unique market; and establishing a new brand that would stand out in an old league.

“Everybody thought we’d just have, like, strippers everywhere,” Greco added. “You know, ‘Vegas — that’s what they’re gonna do!’ And it was like, well, hold on, there needs to be more thought to it than that. … Let’s honor the game and honor the traditions, but let’s also play in the sandbox a little bit. Let’s innovate.”

In the beginning, Abrams and Greco didn’t know if they had a winning product to work with, given the sorry state of most expansion rosters. Instead, the Golden Knights went on to reach the Stanley Cup Final in their first season of existence.

“The show was our No. 1 priority,” said Abrams, now the Golden Knights’ vice president and executive producer. “We had to make it good because if the team wasn’t good, we still needed people to come and have a good time, pay for the ticket and generate the revenue. Luckily for us, the team has been good.”


The Golden Knights have deployed a medieval mascot to rouse the crowd since the franchise’s inception. (Ethan Miller / Getty Images)

The Golden Knights’ initial version of innovation included deploying an actor dressed as a medieval knight to give rousing pregame speeches on the ice while carrying out a plot of a looming battle against an opponent. The team has since added more layers to its game experience, including a group of drummers who can fire up the crowd even while play is going; a “Knight Club” experience with DJs and special celebratory bottle service at the second intermission; and, as of last season, a 34-foot-wide, smoke-emitting dragon at one end of the rink.

Abrams explained that the Golden Knights have taken a lot of inspiration from theme parks, especially when it comes to the scale of some of their designs (see: dragon). And that they try to switch things up, so even season-ticket holders don’t know what they’re going to see any given night.

Even on a Wednesday in January, NHL games in Vegas are never boring.

The approach has won the Golden Knights a boatload of recognition, including the best overall production award at the 2023 IDEA conference, an Emmy Award for their Stanley Cup banner-raising ceremony that same year, and honors as the NHL’s top team for game presentation three times in the past four seasons.

Yes, some of the success is because it’s all happening in Las Vegas. But other teams around the league have taken notice, too. And not just in the Sun Belt. The Edmonton Oilers, for example, installed an area for a band — the Oilers Drum and Brass Crew — that fires up the Rogers Place crowd during games, a new twist for a Canadian market.

The push to innovate the fan experience has been so pronounced that Greco has branched out to start his own company, Shine Entertainment. He now travels the globe helping sports franchises push their crowd work to the next level, bringing some of that Golden Knights touch and encouraging teams to channel that “potential energy” into something fun and authentic for everyone in the building to experience. In one presentation that he regularly delivers, on the “ingredients of a goal moment,” Greco details the appropriate music, animation, lighting, scoreboard visuals and timing for every time a goal is scored.

More and more franchises, Greco said, are rewarding game presentation staff with executive titles and “a seat at the table,” having recognized how important the role is in building momentum with ticket holders.

“People are really realizing the power of the engagement — what I call scoreboard-proof programming,” said Greco, who before launching Shine, also worked as a senior vice president for both the Madison Square Garden Company, which owns the New York Knicks and Rangers, and the Seattle Kraken. “To be able to connect differently, to be able to have the conversations with hockey ops, but also the brand people, and then try to create something that plays and hits all the feels right, that creates home-ice advantage.”

But Greco acknowledged that the challenges for established, traditional franchises can be more pronounced than for those starting anew in, say, Vegas or Seattle.

“It’s way, way harder,” he said. “Some teams do have leaders that are very micromanaging of your show and can’t tell you why they don’t like something. But it’s like, ‘Oh, I don’t like that, don’t do that anymore,’ without maybe a rhyme or reason.”


As interesting — and successful — as the in-arena efforts of newer teams such as the Golden Knights and Kraken have been, some of it will likely never happen in more established NHL markets.

In Toronto, the Leafs have invested in advanced video projection technology, and there’s an impressive display on the ice at Scotiabank Arena before games. But they are not about to put the equivalent of a giant dragon in the corner of their rink.

One idea Greco believes could work to boost the energy level in traditional markets: soccer-like supporters’ sections. It’s already added a new wrinkle to Los Angeles Clippers games this season with “The Wall,” and it’s been tested in NHL arenas to a limited extent over the years in Nashville and Vancouver.

For the Canucks, the group is known as The Larscheiders, and starting in 2016, they worked with the team to purchase large sections of nosebleed seats to seven or eight games a season.

The Larscheiders have a 10-point code of conduct for fans who buy into the section — “No. 2: Stand the entire game and react to what happens on the ice” — and they’ve received media attention for coming up with popular chants such as “Bruce, there it is!” (in honor of former coach Bruce Boudreau) and rowdily cheering on Elias Pettersson’s first NHL goal.

The motivation behind starting the group was to inject some life into Vancouver’s Rogers Arena, which had become quiet in recent years due to so many seats being sold to corporate interests, group co-creator Carlo Bodrogi said.

“Cheering for your home team while surrounded by other fans who are with you — not on their phones or closing deals — in the same mindset, that’s something really powerful and different from other entertainment options,” Bodrogi said. “It’s a feeling of solidarity and group joy.”

The challenge with building a supporters section, he explained, involves the need for buy-in from the team, as purchasing a block of tickets where hundreds of fans can stand together isn’t possible through Ticketmaster. This season, after making the playoffs last spring and with ticket prices on the rise, the Canucks didn’t set up a section for The Larscheiders, a move that drew criticism in the market.

With the playoffs approaching and the Leafs on a first-round collision course with their long-time rival, the Ottawa Senators, it’s likely the energy will pick up organically in Toronto beginning next weekend. More tickets will find their way to die-hard fans, and the stakes of the postseason will bring more passion to a building that’s needed it at times this season.

Whether the future brings something more, however, remains an open question. At the very least, it’s one worth investing some additional time, money and thought into over the years to come.

(Top photo: Mark Blinch / NHLI via Getty Images)

Ja Morant switches to grenade gesture after NBA fined All-Star for finger-gun 3-point celebration

After the NBA fined Ja Morant $75,000 last week for making finger-gun gesture celebrations, the Memphis Grizzlies star has found a new way to commemorate a made 3-pointer.

In the Grizzlies’ 141-125 loss to the Minnesota Timberwolves on Thursday night, Morant mimicked pulling a pin, tossing a grenade and covering his ears following a made 3. It was the second straight game in which Morant had made the grenade gesture, having unveiled it Tuesday when Memphis played at Charlotte.

“That’s my celebration now until somebody else has a problem with it, and I’ll find another one,” Morant said after Thursday’s shootaround.

The NBA fined Morant $75,000 on April 4, one day after the 25-year-old mimicked shooting a gun with his fingers after a made 3 — once in the first quarter and once in the third quarter — in the Grizzlies’ win over the Miami Heat. Ahead of that matchup, the NBA notified Morant he wouldn’t be punished for his April 1 gun-related gestures while playing the Golden State Warriors.

Morant finished with a team-high 36 points and shot 5 of 13 from behind the arc against Minnesota.

Against Golden State, Morant and Buddy Hield engaged in a verbal altercation that included the gun-related hand gestures. Both players and teams received warnings from the NBA, and the league told each team the gestures were inappropriate and instructed them to stop using them, a league source told The Athletic. The argument from the teams’ side was that the gestures were not intended to be violent, according to the league source.

Despite the warning, Morant continued the gesture into the next game against Miami and received the fine one day later.

Morant, a two-time All-Star, was also suspended twice in recent seasons for gun-related incidents.

In March 2023, the NBA issued an eight-game suspension after Morant was seen brandishing a gun on Instagram Live while at a gentlemen’s club in Glendale, Colo. He also missed the first 25 games of the 2023-24 season due to suspension after he was seen holding a handgun while riding in a car on Instagram Live.

While the NBA does not have a rule against specific gestures, the league has fined players for making gun-related motions before. In 2017, then-Phoenix Suns forward Josh Jackson was fined $35,000 for gesturing toward a fan in a way that appeared to mimic pulling a trigger. In 2015, then-Miami Heat guard Gerald Green received a $25,000 penalty for making a similar gesture.

The NBA caps the fines for on-court conduct at $100,000.

(Photo: David Jensen / Getty Images)

Paralyzed in a crash, Robert Wickens kept on racing, and now he’s adding a new chapter

The crash was horrifying.

During a 2018 IndyCar race, the wheels of Robert Wickens’ car clipped those of Ryan Hunter-Reay’s car, launching Wickens airborne and into the fencing surrounding Pocono Raceway. Among the injuries Wickens suffered were a thoracic spinal fracture, a neck fracture, tibia and fibula fractures to both legs, fractures in both hands, four fractured ribs and a pulmonary contusion. He also had a spinal cord injury that left him paralyzed from the waist down.

At the time, Wickens was on the cusp of stardom in one of motorsports’ premier series. That year, he had seven top-five finishes in 14 races, finished ninth in the Indianapolis 500 and won IndyCar’s Rookie of the Year honor. Those injuries cut short a promising IndyCar career and could’ve meant Wickens’ days as a professional race car driver were over. But that thought never crossed the now 36-year-old’s mind.

“I thought I was going to make the first (IndyCar) race in March the following year,” Wickens said. “We were always talking about what (racing) would look like if I used hand controls. It was never a question; it was a question of ‘How? Where?’ I knew it was something that was possible.”

Wickens, who regained some use of his legs but lacks the full capability to use them while driving, returned to competitive racing a little over three years after the accident, using a hand-controlled throttle and braking system to control the cars. He competed in the IMSA Michelin Pilot Challenge, and in 2023, he captured the drivers’ championship.

And he isn’t done. A new chapter begins this weekend when he moves into an even higher level of racing by competing in the IMSA SportsCar Championship in a race through the streets of Long Beach, Calif. He’ll co-drive a Chevrolet Corvette fielded by DXDT Racing in the highly competitive GTD class, going against Mercedes, Ferrari, Porsche and other top-flight exotic sports cars.

Wickens will be on the grid at Long Beach due in part to an electric hand-controlled throttle and braking system, developed by Bosch and Pratt Miller, that he’s been able to utilize since returning to racing.

Without it, Wickens’ driving career would’ve likely ended in August 2018. However, the system has proven to be an equalizer, allowing him to compete on a mostly level field. And continued technological refinements by Bosch over the past few years have narrowed the performance gap between a car operated by hand controls and one operated by traditional pedals.


Robert Wickens’ custom steering wheel gives him the ability to control his Corvette race car — throttle, brakes and all — entirely by hand. (Courtesy of Chevrolet Racing)

The hand control operates like similar systems that can be installed in road cars, except this one has been more fine-tuned to allow Wickens to drive almost as if he were using the throttle and brake by foot. He can lightly tap the brake while turning and thereby carry greater speed through the corners.

“The best thing about my new system with Bosch is that the tuning can happen in the background because this is an electronic braking system,” Wickens said. “So if I want more brake sensation or less braking sensation, I can either have a button on the steering wheel that I tune out of brake pressure that I get to apply to the brakes.

“The old system that I was using when I first started, the system was a very mechanical system where there’s a bunch of linkages and levers that just pushed the able-bodied brake pedal down, but I would squeeze something with my hand up by the steering wheel. … The downfall of that is there was a lot of latency in that system and a lot of inconsistency.”

Because Wickens and fellow driver Tommy Milner must trade off driving the Corvette, Bosch had to develop a straightforward way to switch between Milner using pedals and Wickens the hand controls.

“It’s quite impressive,” Milner said. “There’s just one button that either of us has to push to put it in the mode that we want and that switches all the systems over within a second.”

Once Wickens was committed to racing again, the challenge of navigating the expense and lack of accessibility only further complicated the endeavor. Finding sufficient sponsorship is often problematic enough in racing; Wickens also had to convince a team owner to install a hand-control system in their car.

Robert Wickens


“There are people racing all over the world with disabilities,” Robert Wickens said. “I’m just fortunate that I had a platform to show my progress.” (David Rosenblum / Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

Having gone through the process himself, Wickens would like to see such features more readily available in commercially produced vehicles. Just as manufacturers use auto racing to develop technology that can be applied to passenger vehicles, Wickens wants to see the same principle applied to hand-controlled systems to make it both convenient and cost-effective.

“I kind of have naive dreams of thinking that there could be a Robert Wickens steering wheel that can just fit into every road car in the world,” he said. “I’m imagining it’s like, ‘Oh, yeah, just plug it in like a USB or something and you’re on your way.’ But I know that that’s just not how it works. …

“The reality is, right now, when I’m driving on the road and I want to make a lane change, for example, I have to consciously over-speed because when I take my hand off the throttle to put on my turn signal, I slow down, and my hand isn’t on the throttle. Then, I have to signal and put my hand back on the throttle, make the lane change, and then take my hand off the throttle to stop your signal. It’s just a lot of extra steps.”

Long Beach is the first of five events in 2025 in which Wickens will drive the DXDT Racing Corvette entry. Plans beyond this season are still being determined. He is open to securing a full-time ride in the IMSA SportsCar Championship if the opportunity arises. He’d also like to race again in the Indianapolis 500.

Wickens downplays the idea that he is an inspiration, but those who know him marvel at how he’s refused to let go of his dream of being a professional driver when he had every reason to quit. He also wants to help others facing a similar situation.

“I personally don’t feel like I’m an inspiration to anybody, but I’m always kind of humbled when people tell me that I am,” Wickens said. “After I was paralyzed and out of my medical-induced coma, I was trying to understand what life I had. I was just working hard to try getting myself and my wife the best quality of life possible.

“There are people racing all over the world with disabilities. I’m just fortunate that I had a platform to show my progress where others might not.”

(Top photo of Robert Wickens: Courtesy of Chevrolet Racing)

Paralyzed in a crash, Robert Wickens kept on racing, and now he’s adding a new chapter

The crash was horrifying.

During a 2018 IndyCar race, the wheels of Robert Wickens’ car clipped those of Ryan Hunter-Reay’s car, launching Wickens airborne and into the fencing surrounding Pocono Raceway. Among the injuries Wickens suffered were a thoracic spinal fracture, a neck fracture, tibia and fibula fractures to both legs, fractures in both hands, four fractured ribs and a pulmonary contusion. He also had a spinal cord injury that left him paralyzed from the waist down.

At the time, Wickens was on the cusp of stardom in one of motorsports’ premier series. That year, he had seven top-five finishes in 14 races, finished ninth in the Indianapolis 500 and won IndyCar’s Rookie of the Year honor. Those injuries cut short a promising IndyCar career and could’ve meant Wickens’ days as a professional race car driver were over. But that thought never crossed the now 36-year-old’s mind.

“I thought I was going to make the first (IndyCar) race in March the following year,” Wickens said. “We were always talking about what (racing) would look like if I used hand controls. It was never a question; it was a question of ‘How? Where?’ I knew it was something that was possible.”

Wickens, who regained some use of his legs but lacks the full capability to use them while driving, returned to competitive racing a little over three years after the accident, using a hand-controlled throttle and braking system to control the cars. He competed in the IMSA Michelin Pilot Challenge, and in 2023, he captured the drivers’ championship.

And he isn’t done. A new chapter begins this weekend when he moves into an even higher level of racing by competing in the IMSA SportsCar Championship in a race through the streets of Long Beach, Calif. He’ll co-drive a Chevrolet Corvette fielded by DXDT Racing in the highly competitive GTD class, going against Mercedes, Ferrari, Porsche and other top-flight exotic sports cars.

Wickens will be on the grid at Long Beach due in part to an electric hand-controlled throttle and braking system, developed by Bosch and Pratt Miller, that he’s been able to utilize since returning to racing.

Without it, Wickens’ driving career would’ve likely ended in August 2018. However, the system has proven to be an equalizer, allowing him to compete on a mostly level field. And continued technological refinements by Bosch over the past few years have narrowed the performance gap between a car operated by hand controls and one operated by traditional pedals.


Robert Wickens’ custom steering wheel gives him the ability to control his Corvette race car — throttle, brakes and all — entirely by hand. (Courtesy of Chevrolet Racing)

The hand control operates like similar systems that can be installed in road cars, except this one has been more fine-tuned to allow Wickens to drive almost as if he were using the throttle and brake by foot. He can lightly tap the brake while turning and thereby carry greater speed through the corners.

“The best thing about my new system with Bosch is that the tuning can happen in the background because this is an electronic braking system,” Wickens said. “So if I want more brake sensation or less braking sensation, I can either have a button on the steering wheel that I tune out of brake pressure that I get to apply to the brakes.

“The old system that I was using when I first started, the system was a very mechanical system where there’s a bunch of linkages and levers that just pushed the able-bodied brake pedal down, but I would squeeze something with my hand up by the steering wheel. … The downfall of that is there was a lot of latency in that system and a lot of inconsistency.”

Because Wickens and fellow driver Tommy Milner must trade off driving the Corvette, Bosch had to develop a straightforward way to switch between Milner using pedals and Wickens the hand controls.

“It’s quite impressive,” Milner said. “There’s just one button that either of us has to push to put it in the mode that we want and that switches all the systems over within a second.”

Once Wickens was committed to racing again, the challenge of navigating the expense and lack of accessibility only further complicated the endeavor. Finding sufficient sponsorship is often problematic enough in racing; Wickens also had to convince a team owner to install a hand-control system in their car.

Robert Wickens


“There are people racing all over the world with disabilities,” Robert Wickens said. “I’m just fortunate that I had a platform to show my progress.” (David Rosenblum / Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

Having gone through the process himself, Wickens would like to see such features more readily available in commercially produced vehicles. Just as manufacturers use auto racing to develop technology that can be applied to passenger vehicles, Wickens wants to see the same principle applied to hand-controlled systems to make it both convenient and cost-effective.

“I kind of have naive dreams of thinking that there could be a Robert Wickens steering wheel that can just fit into every road car in the world,” he said. “I’m imagining it’s like, ‘Oh, yeah, just plug it in like a USB or something and you’re on your way.’ But I know that that’s just not how it works. …

“The reality is, right now, when I’m driving on the road and I want to make a lane change, for example, I have to consciously over-speed because when I take my hand off the throttle to put on my turn signal, I slow down, and my hand isn’t on the throttle. Then, I have to signal and put my hand back on the throttle, make the lane change, and then take my hand off the throttle to stop your signal. It’s just a lot of extra steps.”

Long Beach is the first of five events in 2025 in which Wickens will drive the DXDT Racing Corvette entry. Plans beyond this season are still being determined. He is open to securing a full-time ride in the IMSA SportsCar Championship if the opportunity arises. He’d also like to race again in the Indianapolis 500.

Wickens downplays the idea that he is an inspiration, but those who know him marvel at how he’s refused to let go of his dream of being a professional driver when he had every reason to quit. He also wants to help others facing a similar situation.

“I personally don’t feel like I’m an inspiration to anybody, but I’m always kind of humbled when people tell me that I am,” Wickens said. “After I was paralyzed and out of my medical-induced coma, I was trying to understand what life I had. I was just working hard to try getting myself and my wife the best quality of life possible.

“There are people racing all over the world with disabilities. I’m just fortunate that I had a platform to show my progress where others might not.”

(Top photo of Robert Wickens: Courtesy of Chevrolet Racing)

MLB Power Rankings: Braves with a big drop; How about that NL West?

By Grant Brisbee, Chad Jennings and Levi Weaver

Every week,​ we​ ask a selected group of our baseball​ writers​ — local and national — to rank the teams from first to worst. Here are the collective results.

Two surprising weekends can make a big difference in football, but small samples mean less in baseball. Keep that in mind as you browse our Power Rankings a week and a half into the season.

Some of our opinions have changed, but perhaps not as much as each team’s record would suggest. The one-win Atlanta Braves are still far ahead of the middle-of-the-pack Miami Marlins, and the red-hot San Francisco Giants have our attention, but we’re not anointing them a top-five team just yet. (And before you blame our biases, note that the soulless algorithm at FanGraphs seems to agree.)

We do want to have our opinions changed, though. We want to believe in Cinderella and predict Goliath’s defeat, and so we offer this week’s Power Rankings with a “difference-maker” on each team: one player who’s having an outsized impact on either present performance or our future expectations.


Record: 9-3
Last Power Ranking: 1

Early difference-maker: Yoshinobu Yamamoto

If the Dodgers can turn Michael Conforto into an All-Star again, it won’t matter if Jon Garland comes out of retirement and makes every start for them for the rest of the season. They’ll hit their way to 160 wins. But assuming they’ll need some reliable starting pitching at some point, Yamamoto has been their best source of that so far. Now-injured Blake Snell’s 8.0 BB/9 is the second-best in the rotation so far, at least among pitchers with two starts, so this is the shakiest top spot in the power rankings the Dodgers have had in months, if not an entire year. (They were still the unanimous choice, of course.) — Grant Brisbee

GO DEEPER

Dodgers place Blake Snell on IL due to shoulder inflammation

Record: 7-2
Last Power Ranking: T-4

Early difference-maker: Jesús Luzardo

There’s a lot going right for the Phillies. Kyle Schwarber has been a monster, Zack Wheeler has been as good as ever, Edmundo Sosa has been awesome off the bench and the bullpen has picked up the slack for struggling closer Jordan Romano. But the defining moment in this strong start to the season has been taking two out of three from the Dodgers over the weekend, and that series started with Luzardo going seven scoreless innings in the opener. Two starts into his Phillies career, Luzardo is 2-0 with 19 strikeouts and a 1.50 ERA. The rest of the rotation (other than Aaron Nola) has also been excellent, but Luzardo was the team’s biggest offseason addition, and he’s had an immediate impact, including that early season statement against the defending world champs. — Chad Jennings

Record: 6-4
Last Power Ranking: 2

Early difference-maker: Aaron Judge

The Yankees are this high in our rankings for many reasons, most of them to do with their offense. Jazz Chisholm Jr. and Anthony Volpe have been the best middle-infield duo in baseball, Paul Goldschmidt has been resurgent at first base, and both Trent Grisham and Ben Rice have taken advantage of more-than-expected playing time.

But let’s not overthink this. Judge was historically great last season, and it took eight games this season for FanGraphs to declare him already a 1 WAR player (he dipped to 0.9 WAR after a hitless Game 9). A three-homer game certainly helped pad the early-season stats, but Judge has another three-hit game, he’s twice homered in back-to-back games, and he leads the league in both runs and RBIs. It’s going to be hard to match last season, but Judge is making an early run at it. — Jennings

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Trent Grisham hits 2 home runs in win over Pirates, talks overcoming difficult 2024

Record: 9-2
Last Power Ranking: 7

Early difference-maker: Jackson Merrill

Merrill is the only Padre currently with a double-digit RBI total and now, he’s one of those Padres who can pick up a restaurant tab, too. San Diego expects him to be a superstar and make up for the less-than-superstar production it might get from Xander Bogaerts and Manny Machado going forward. So far, so good, and it’s making A.J. Preller’s foresight to keep him while trading every minor leaguer and minor-league mascot in the system look even more impressive. — Brisbee

Record: 8-3
Last Power Ranking: 3

Early difference-maker: Josh Smith

The thing about the Rangers is that there are at least six guys I could nominate here. Nathan Eovaldi has pitched like an ace. Jack Leiter looks more like a blowtorch and less like a flameout. (This is absolutely a “Leiter” pun, I’ll own it.) Joc Pederson and Jake Burger have been helpful additions to the lineup. But I’m going with Smith here. His defense is good-to-great at any of the five positions he can play, and at the time of this writing, he led all Rangers position players in fWAR (0.5) and OPS (1.011). This is a team with Corey Seager, Marcus Semien and Adolis García in the lineup, in case you forgot. — Levi Weaver

Record: 5-6
Last Power Ranking: 6

Early difference-maker: Corbin Carroll

Corbin Carroll’s back? Corbin Carroll’s back. The Diamondbacks scored more runs than any other team in baseball last year, even with their young, burgeoning superstar hitting below the Mendoza Line for the first two months. Any herpetological-related optimism for this season was based on the belief that his second half was much more representative of his talent level. It probably was, and now every starting pitcher not named Zac Gallen has to make the good kind of difference if they’re going to keep up in a red-hot NL West. — Brisbee

Record: 6-5
Last Power Ranking: 8

Early difference-maker: Rafael Devers

Oftentimes, we’re using the term “difference-maker” as a shorthand for team MVP. And if we apply that logic to the Red Sox, Wilyer Abreu would be the choice. But if we’re looking for a tangible difference, consider this: Devers went 0-for-19 in the first five games of the season, and the Red Sox were 1-4. Then he had two hits in Game No. 6, stayed blistering hot through a four-hit game on Sunday — the last game we saw before voting on the Power Rankings — and the Red Sox went 5-0 in those games. When Devers wasn’t hitting, the Red Sox weren’t winning. When he started hitting, the Red Sox couldn’t lose. Seems like the definition of a difference-maker. — Jennings

Record: 7-3
Last Power Ranking: 9

Early difference-maker: Tylor Megill

Juan Soto is getting on base a ton, Pete Alonso is hitting for power and Francisco Lindor is struggling (but still delivering when it matters). The Mets are built around those things. For their team to work, those three pieces have to be clicking. So far, so good. (For the most part.) The surprising piece keeping the Mets afloat in the early going is starter Megill, who’s become especially important following injuries to Sean Manaea, Frankie Montas and Paul Blackburn. Megill made two starts and won them, including the first game of a three-game weekend sweep of the Toronto Blue Jays. He has a 0.87 ERA. — Jennings

Record: 8-2
Last Power Ranking: 15

Early difference-maker: Wilmer Flores

The Giants are off to their fastest start since 2003, when they went wire-to-wire and finished with the best record in baseball. That team had Barry Bonds in his prime, but this team has a healthy Wilmer Flores, which is roughly the same thing, at least for the first couple of weeks of the season. It was Flores’ home run that helped them come back on Opening Day, and it was his ninth-inning single on Sunday that helped keep the Giants’ winning streak going. The .900-something OPS will come down, but a return to his career numbers would be a big deal for a lineup that will need steady contributors. — Brisbee

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

‘We like fun!’: Matt Chapman, Jung Hoo Lee help Giants extend win streak to 6 games

Record: 1-8
Last Power Ranking: T-4

Early difference-maker: Spencer Strider?

Almost all of the Braves’ positive impact has come from three players: Marcell Ozuna (he can still hit), Matt Olson (ditto) and Spencer Schwellenbach (two starts, three hits, 14 strikeouts, no earned runs). But the Braves have only one win because of [gestures wildly in all directions] everything else. Austin Riley has a .468 OPS, Chris Sale has a 5.40 ERA, Jurickson Profar has an 80-game suspension, and Reynaldo López is having shoulder surgery. It’s last season all over again.

Except, very soon, the Braves could get Strider off the IL, and that’s the kind of addition that could be a turning point. Give the rotation another ace, get some hitters back on track, and the Braves could gain some momentum and remind us why they were among the favorites heading into this season. — Jennings

Record: 5-6
Last Power Ranking: 10

Early difference-maker: Charlie Morton

The Orioles’ lineup is performing more or less as expected. It has not been great with runners on base, but the lineup is loaded with well-above-average hitters (including Jackson Holliday, whose second season is off to a better start than his first). But if the lineup has been as expected, the rotation has been as feared. Failure to re-sign Corbin Burnes, plus injuries to Grayson Rodriguez and Kyle Bradish — among others — left the Orioles’ rotation vulnerable. Through the weekend, three of their starters had an ERA higher than 6.00, including Morton (9.72 ERA in two starts, both losses). This helps explain why, despite Cedric Mullins being awesome, the Orioles still have a losing record. — Jennings

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Happy New Year, Baseball! 17 Weird & Wild ways the season’s first week surprised

Record: 8-5
Last Power Ranking: 13

Early difference-maker: Kyle Tucker

As much fun as it would be to give the nod to Carson Kelly, who hit for the cycle and has some very fun small-sample early-season numbers, the clear answer here is Tucker. Dude has been everything the Cubs hoped they were getting when they traded away a prospect (Cam Smith) who this spring looked very capable of giving them a bad case of Trade Regret™.

Not yet, though. Tucker is hitting .327 (1.165 OPS) with five home runs. Enjoy it now, Cubs fans — he’s going to break a lot of brains when we hear how much he makes in free agency this winter.

(Shout out to Shota Imanaga, who’s also been very good.) — Weaver

Record: 6-4
Last Power Ranking: 16

Early difference-maker: Spencer Torkelson

I could easily go with Riley Greene here, but he was already pretty good last year. That doesn’t mean he can’t be a difference-maker, but if we truly want to highlight something new and current, Torkelson has been a different player this year, hitting .289 (.953 OPS) with a pair of homers. Last year, it wasn’t clear whether or not there would be space on the roster for Torkelson in the future. A swing change and breakthrough later, he’s been one of the Tigers’ best hitters. — Weaver

Record: 4-6
Last Power Ranking: 11

Early difference-maker: Brendan Rodgers

Does the early difference-maker have to be making his team different in a better way? If so, then it’s Rodgers, a third-overall pick who was a top-25 prospect for five years before being aggressively OK with the Rockies. There’s also a chance that he arrived in Houston and said something like, “Wait, these video rectangles — these ‘eye pads’ — can show me videos of opposing pitchers and help me break down my swing? And there are people whose entire job is to look at ‘statistics’ and ‘data’ now? Golly.” He’s now Brendan Rodgers in the 21st century, and maybe this is the year he breaks out.

If the early difference-maker can be someone making the team worse, then the answer is … well, just about everyone. The post-Tucker/Bregman era hasn’t gotten off to a scintillating start. — Brisbee

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

How Brendan Rodgers’ first Astros team flight helped him handle ‘pressure’ of being the new guy

Record: 4-7
Last Power Ranking: 12

Early difference-maker: Julio Rodríguez

Not because Rodríguez has been so good that he’s propelled the Mariners to a winning record, but because he’s had a strong-ish start to the season. If the team is going to leverage its strong rotation, it will need Rodríguez to be the perennial MVP candidate the franchise has been expecting for a couple years now. He’s making a difference by helping Mariners fans believe a rainbow might follow the 10-game season-opening downpour, and that’s about all they can ask for. Well, that and a pennant or two. — Brisbee

Record: 6-5
Last Power Ranking: 14

Early difference-maker: Andrés Giménez

Of all the guys to hit cleanup on this team, Blue Jays manager John Schneider has gone with his slick-fielding second baseman since Opening Day. Giménez came into the season with a barely above-average 101 OPS+ for his career, but he’s justified the lineup choice by coming out of the gate with the best offensive numbers on the team. Much slower starts by Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Anthony Santander help explain why the Blue Jays were only a .500 team through the weekend. Another difference-maker worth noting: If we voted for Cy Young awards after two starts, Chris Bassitt would be among the front-runners in the American League. He’s allowed one run and two walks through 12 2/3 innings. — Jennings

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Blue Jays agree on 14-year, $500 million extension

Record: 4-5
Last Power Ranking: 17

Early difference-maker: Brandon Lowe

Eight seasons in the big leagues, and Lowe has yet to finish a year with below-average offensive numbers. He came close in 2022 (103 wRC+) but has otherwise never had a season with less than a 112 OPS+ or 114 wRC+. When Lowe’s healthy, he hits, and he’s doing it again this year and that’s been enough to keep the Rays afloat in the early going. Their rotation has been predictably solid from top to bottom, and Kameron Misner has given them a spark off the bench. The rest of their lineup has been too erratic to maintain much momentum, and the Rays were swept this weekend in Texas. They have yet to lose when they’ve scored more than four runs, but they’ve scored more than four runs only three times. — Jennings

Record: 5-5
Last Power Ranking: T-21

Early difference-maker: Maikel García

By the end of the season, I have full confidence that the answer to this question will be Bobby Witt Jr.  He hasn’t been bad, but there are two others I think deserve it a bit more.

On the pitching side, Kris Bubic has been brilliant in his first two starts, going 2-0 with a 0.71 ERA, striking out 16 and walking just three in 12 2/3 innings, outpacing even Cy Young candidate Cole Ragans. As for the hitters, while Mark Canha’s numbers are a little better, García is right there, and in about twice as many plate appearances, hitting .333 (.977 OPS) with two home runs.

García has always been an anomaly to me. Compare his barrel percentage (lower 10th percentile in 2023 and 2024) with his hard-hit percentage (93rd and 65th percentile in 2023 and 2024, respectively).

So far this season, we’re seeing what happens when a blue number flips to even a pinkish shade of red. — Weaver

Record: 5-5
Last Power Ranking: 20

Early difference-maker: Freddy Peralta

For one year, in 1969, the Seattle Pilots existed. Then they moved to Milwaukee and became the Brewers, completely wrecking what would have been — given their dogged dedication to stripping out parts and somehow staying afloat — a perfect “Ship of Theseus” reference in this space. I’d love to be able to nominate the departed Corbin Burnes or Devin Williams or Willy Adames or Josh Hader or Brent Suter or manager Craig Counsell or GM David Stearns or … well, there’s a word limit. William Contreras is still around, but he’s had a slow start.

But look, it’s Fastball Freddy! Peralta has a 2.08 ERA and a 0.538 WHIP. On a team that has not pitched well, he’s been an oasis. — Weaver

Record: 3-7
Last Power Ranking: 18

Early difference-maker: One of the center fielders

The Twins have a single hitter with a batting average over .300 (Matt Wallner, .303). Their pitching fWAR leaders are Pablo López and two relievers (0.2). Do you see any “difference-makers” in their pitching or hitting leaderboards? Because I do not.

So I guess let’s go with Harrison Bader, who has been distinctly not terrible. Or maybe we want to go with vibes and point out that Byron Buxton is a difference-maker in terms of creating excitement? You can take your pick; the vitriol and fire of my youth have long since waned, and I no longer have it in me to debate about a team such as this. — Weaver

Record: 3-6
Last Power Ranking: 19

Early difference-maker: Austin Hedges

From a pure statistical standpoint, the answer is José Ramírez. Maybe the league’s most underrated superstar, Ramírez is off to another hot start for the Guardians, hitting .320/.438/.880 (1.318 OPS) through the first nine games.

But I’m going to give some love to backup catcher Hedges here. He has been the worst hitter in baseball for a very long time, but his defense and clubhouse enthusiasm have been so outsized that he keeps getting big-league jobs. So far this year? He has an OPS of 1.229. Please do not inform me that it is on the strength of one hit (a home run) in five at-bats. I know. — Weaver

Record: 4-6
Last Power Ranking: T-21

Early difference-maker: Lars Nootbaar

Lots of candidates here, including Iván Herrera, who is currently leading the National League in slugging percentage. Let’s turn the spotlight on Nootbaar, though, because he’s always been a Baseball Savant darling for his ability to stay in the strike zone and hit the snot out of the ball, but hasn’t had flashy statistics to show for it. There’s a stat called expected weighted on-base average on contact (xwOBAcon) that says Nootbaar’s offensive output should be closer to Bryce Harper’s and Fernando Tatis Jr.’s than Brandon Nimmo’s or Michael Conforto’s. Maybe this is the year it shows up in the real world. — Brisbee

Record: 4-7
Last Power Ranking: 24

Early difference-maker: Tyler Soderstrom

Soderstrom was once one of the better-hitting prospects in the game, and he was called up at a younger age than most of his peers. With a full season of above-average hitting in his age-22 season last year, he might have had a lot more buzz coming into this year. A wrist injury cost him a couple months, so that left us with about 200 plate appearances that suggested that he was on schedule and could still develop into an All-Star. A few weeks into the season, he looks like an All-Star, so don’t be surprised if he signs an extension to make sure he joins Brent Rooker and Lawrence Butler as franchise cornerstones when Sacramento’s beautiful new ballpark opens in 2029. You may say I’m a dreamer, but I’m not the only one, and I’ll believe in Las Vegas when one (1) steel girder is in place. — Brisbee

Record: 4-7
Last Power Ranking: 23

Early difference-maker: Brady Singer

We’re going for good difference-makers, right? Because I could make the argument that a few guys have made a bad difference, given that the Reds put together an impressive 35-inning scoreless streak last week.

But if we’re leaning positive here, I have two finalists. Hunter Greene has been very impressive thus far, boosting an already-nasty fastball into consistent triple digits. But I’m going with new addition Singer, who came over in the Jonathan India trade. Through two turns of the rotation, he went pitch-for-pitch with Greene. Throw in Nick Lodolo, and that’s starting to look like a pretty nasty rotation in Cincinnati. — Weaver

Record: 6-3
Last Power Ranking: 28

Early difference-maker: Kyren Paris

The Angels have won twice as many games as they’ve lost, which puts them on pace for a 108-win season. Will it last? Probably not, but they’ll always have Paris. The 2019 second-rounder was scorching hot all spring, and he somehow got even hotter for the start of the season, with a .444/.545/.889 slash line as of this writing. He’s always shown strong plate discipline in the minors, but it came with an outsized strikeout rate. Now he’s making more contact, and he’s making better contact. If your first thought was “swing change,” guess what, you’re right. He has Angels fans believing, which might be the biggest miracle of the season so far. — Brisbee

Record: 5-5
Last Power Ranking: 27

Early difference-maker: Daniel Moskos

It’s impossible to accurately judge this from afar, but here’s what the numbers show: Last season, the Marlins ranked next-to-last in staff ERA. Only the Rockies were worse. This season, the Marlins have an above-average ERA that’s nearly a run better than last season. Getting Sandy Alcantara off the IL has certainly helped, but it’s hard not to notice that the Marlins also hired Moskos this offseason to be their new pitching coach. Now, Max Meyer’s numbers are better, Anthony Bender’s numbers are better, and the Marlins have a winning record. It’s an absurdly small sample, but if you’re wondering what’s made the difference for the Marlins out of the gate, it’s their pitching. It’s only fair that the new pitching coach gets at least some of the credit. — Jennings

Record: 4-7
Last Power Ranking: T-25

Early difference-maker: Paul Skenes

I like to think of myself as a creative person and an outside-the-box thinker. I love to eschew the predictable in favor of the underappreciated or unexpected. Routine? Never heard of it. My art? Abstract. My music? Eclectic. I put mayonnaise on my hot dogs because I like it and because it makes my friends from Chicago very angry. Look who I picked for the Guardians blurb. (I stand by it.)

But no matter how much I look for a zag (Andrew McCutchen?), it’s obviously Skenes, who has a 1.46 ERA after two starts. Nobody outside Pittsburgh can even give you a half-hearted suggestion that anyone else is even close, and nobody in Pittsburgh wants to. — Weaver

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Every time Paul Skenes starts, an entire sport marvels — and also holds its breath

Record: 4-6
Last Power Ranking: T-25

Early difference-maker: Mitchell Parker

It was first-rounder MacKenzie Gore who stole the show on Opening Day, but ever since, the most reliable way for the Nationals to win a game has been to put Parker on the mound. Through their first nine games, the Nationals were 3-6, but two of those wins belonged to Parker, a 25-year-old with a 0.73 ERA in his second big-league season. Rookie of the Year candidate Dylan Crews has fallen flat out of the gate, but Parker and Gore have been good in the first two turns through the rotation. They’re going to need some help, though, to ultimately lift the Nats out of mediocrity. — Jennings

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Juan Soto spent 3 weeks with his minor-league host family. Memories endure 7 years later

Record: 2-7
Last Power Ranking: 29

Early difference-maker: Kyle Freeland

The frontrunner was Dinger, with his gleeful and only slightly demonic cavorting forever giving the franchise a chance to turn 6-year-olds into Rockies fans. Let’s throw a bone to Freeland, though, as he’s made two good starts so far. The Denver native has watched a lot of lousy baseball in his nine-year Rockies career, and very little of it was his fault. Here’s hoping for 30 more solid-to-excellent starts and some downballot Cy Young votes this year. He’s earned it. — Brisbee

Record: 2-7
Last Power Ranking: 30

Early difference-maker: Martín Pérez

The biggest difference between the 2024 White Sox and 2025 White Sox? Last year, they waited until game No. 11 to win their second game. This year? They were at .500 as late as … four games into the season, at 2-2. The reason was that their starting pitchers came out of the gate on an absolute heater, going on a 28-inning scoreless streak that extended into their fifth game. (They lost that game, and every subsequent game they have played.)

So yeah, it all imploded after that, but if we have to pick one of the guys who staved off the inevitable for almost a week, let’s go with Pérez, who pitched six no-hit innings in his first start of the year. — Weaver

(Top photo of Austin Riley: David J. Griffin / Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

Making the jump from college hoops to the NFL: ‘I was like, what? Change sports?’

CHARLOTTE, N.C. — After pouring in 19 points for Coastal Carolina in a first-round loss to Southern Miss in the Sun Belt Conference tournament on March 4, Colin Granger went back to the team hotel in Pensacola, Fla., to have dinner with his parents and discuss his future.

In football.

Granger had told Chanticleers coach Justin Gray that if Coastal went on an unexpected run in the conference tourney, it would be his sign that he would continue his basketball career overseas, where he had multiple offers from professional teams.

If not, Granger would become the first client of George Fant, the 10-year NFL veteran who was starting a business in which he identifies and trains college basketball players he believes can make the jump to the NFL — a transition Fant made in 2016 after leaving Western Kentucky.

So when the Chants were bounced in the opening round in Pensacola, Granger talked it over with his parents before calling Fant and telling him he was on board. A month later, Granger worked out for five NFL teams at a private pro day at his Atlanta-area high school. And three days after that workout, Granger signed with the Carolina Panthers as a tight end in one of the more non-traditional transactions in their history.

Because Granger did not play in college and at least four NFL seasons have elapsed since he finished high school in 2020, he was eligible for last year’s draft. That meant the Panthers or any team could sign him as a free agent this year.

Shortly after finalizing his contract with the Panthers on Monday, Granger was eating lunch in the cafeteria at Bank of America Stadium with three edge rushers on their pre-draft visits — Texas A&M’s Shemar Stewart, Boston College’s Donovan Ezeiruaku and LSU’s Bradyn Swinson. Granger told the group he’d just joined an NFL team despite not having played football since eighth grade.

“I tried to tell them the story and they just literally laughed in my face,” Granger said. “They were like, ‘Dude, come on. Like whatever, bro, just tell us what are you actually doing?’ ”

What Granger is trying to do is follow a trail blazed by Fant and other former college basketball players — including several high-profile tight ends — who carved out successful NFL careers. Fant believes Granger can make his mark in a Panthers tight end room that currently has Tommy Tremble, Ja’Tavion Sanders and Jordan Matthews at the top of the depth chart.

“Don’t be surprised if we see Colin out there playing early and often,” Fant said.

Tony Gonzalez (Cal), Antonio Gates (Kent State), Jimmy Graham (Miami) and Mo Alie-Cox (VCU) all became receiving tight ends after playing hoops in college, with Gonzalez and Gates both becoming Hall of Famers. Gates and Alie-Cox — like Granger — did not play college football.

The 6-foot-8, 240-pound Granger played football and lacrosse through eighth grade, which is when he first suited up for his middle school basketball team. Within eight months, Granger had his first basketball scholarship offer from Mount St. Mary’s.

“My freshman year of high school, I had just stopped playing football. The head football coach called me out of class every single day, and he wanted me to play football,” Granger said during a phone interview Monday.

But other than the occasional comment from a strength coach about how he might look in pads and a helmet, Granger had pretty much forgotten about football as he worked his way through five basketball seasons at three schools — Ohio University, Western Carolina and Coastal Carolina (he averaged 7.2 points, 4.4 rebounds, including 2.0 offensive rebounds last season).

And then he got a DM from Fant, who explained his background and said he was looking to work with college basketball players who projected as NFL prospects.

“I saw it was a real account, that it was a real NFL player,” Granger recalled. “But I was like, what? Change sports? I’m trying to beat freaking N.C. State tomorrow. I’m not worried about that.”


George Fant, second from right, and his team spent several weeks working with Colin Granger, middle, before he signed with the Carolina Panthers. (Courtesy of George Fant)

Fant, who played sparingly in his only football season at Western Kentucky, started his niche headhunter business with his trainer and agent. Fant started going through an online database of every Division I basketball player, scanning their heights, weights and statistics, paying particular attention to offensive rebounds. When he found guys he liked, he would look for YouTube videos and see if their athleticism might play in the NFL.

“I just saw Colin kind of pop off the screen to me. (Initially) I thought he could be a guy that could play offensive line like a Lane Johnson kind of guy,” said Fant, a free-agent offensive tackle with nine years of experience. “Once I got him to Kentucky, though, and I got to see him run around, I knew right away he was a tight end.”

Following the loss in the Sun Belt tournament, Granger returned to Coastal’s campus to pack his stuff, spent a few days at his parents’ house in Florida and then headed to Fant’s home in Bowling Green, Ky., arriving around midnight on March 10.

“He walked out in his driveway and met me,” Granger said, “and I moved into his guest room.”

The two spent 2 1/2 weeks working out in Fant’s home gym while Fant and his agent, Jeffery Whitney, organized a pro day for April 4. In between sets on the bench or during breaks in speed training, Fant would give other tips to a player who hadn’t been on a football field in nearly 10 years.

“Right away he bought in and was the kind of guy you didn’t have to tell something twice,” Fant said. “Once you were able to show it to him, he took it and learned from it right away and got better.”

Justin Gray, Granger’s coach at both Western Carolina and Coastal, predicted that Granger’s work ethic would be well received in Kentucky.

“I guarantee you as soon as he got there and they saw how hard he works and how dedicated he is and how disciplined he is, it’s like, ‘Man, this kid has a chance,’” said Gray, who just wrapped up his first season at Coastal.

“He plays as hard as he possibly can. He’s a great offensive rebounder, defensive rebounder. The ball’s in the air, he goes after it. He’s tough as nails. He eats nails for breakfast. He’s not soft, nothing about him is soft. And then he’s competitive.”

A competitive attitude is great, but Granger still had to show scouts his physical traits. The Panthers — represented by pro scout Adam Maxie — and four other teams last Friday came out to Lambert High in Suwanee, Ga., where Granger ran the 40-yard dash in 4.8 seconds and posted a 40-inch vertical leap, according to him and Fant.

Granger, who caught passes from former Georgia State quarterback Zach Gibson at the workout, was thrilled with his vertical jump but thought he’d run a faster 40.

“My 10-yard split, my 20-yard split all during training, I was running 4.7 numbers,” he said. “I only trained for three weeks. My trainer told me, ‘Dude, if I got you just for another three weeks, you’re a 4.6 guy.’ I’m fast. It’s the little bit of the mechanics that shave off those tenths of a second.”

Granger only did seven reps on the pro bench (225 pounds), but chalked that up to the difference in weight training in the two sports. “I’ve got muscle and I can put it on there,” he said. “But an Olympic lift like that, we didn’t really straight bench-press like that all the time.”

Fant was pleased with how things went. “I think the craziest part of this whole thing is we only had 2 1/2 weeks to train him,” he said. “My trainer, Jacob Davis, was able to get hands on him and do the impossible, and get him ready for a pro day in two weeks.”

Granger was scheduled to attend the Atlanta Falcons’ local day this week. Instead, he’s under contract with their division rivals, thanks in part to Fant’s ties to Carolina general manager Dan Morgan, coach Dave Canales and tight ends coach Pat McPherson from their time together in Seattle, where Fant signed as an undrafted free agent in 2016 and started 10 games as a rookie.

Fant said he appreciates the Panthers’ giving Granger a chance, and expects him to make the most of it. “He’s a big guy and he’s able to high-point the ball,” Fant said. “He’s able to catch the ball really, really naturally.”

Gray, a Charlotte native who played at Wake Forest from 2002 to 2006, believes Granger’s basketball skill set will transfer to the gridiron.

“Don’t get me wrong, I coach basketball. So I would assume ball in the air, he’s gonna jump up and get it at its highest point. He did that for us. He was really good at offensive rebounding, being able to dunk it back in. Playing with people around him wasn’t a thing,” Gray said. “But it’s a different sport, man, and it’ll take an adjustment period. But I know with his discipline and his consistency, he’ll be just fine.”

Granger, who met Chuba Hubbard on Monday while getting fitted for equipment, said the biggest adjustments will be learning an NFL playbook and getting used to the physicality.

“I’m excited to go get hit. I used to love hitting people in football. It’s a grown man’s league. I know it’s gonna hurt a little bit more now. But guess what, I’m big now and I’m only getting bigger,” he said. “I just want to go out there and pop someone or get popped, get put on my ass and just feel it. Be immersed in the game. Get that first hit out of the way and I think I’ll be fine.”

(Top photo: Scott Kinser / Cal Sport Media via AP Images)

MLB players won’t even pay to read this article: ‘You stay rich by being cheap’

In 2009, Cy Young Award winner Zack Greinke went viral after telling Yahoo Sports he was boycotting Chipotle’s guacamole.

“I mean, $1.50 is already pretty darn high. So they changed it to $1.80, and I’ll never again get guacamole,” Greinke said. “It’s not about the guacamole itself. I just don’t want to let them win.”

Fifteen years later, a (small) side of Chipotle’s guacamole is $2.65, and Greinke’s thoughts remain a common sentiment among MLB players.

“Greinke was on a kick for a while,” said Reds pitcher Scott Barlow, a former Greinke teammate. “It’s the principle.”

So what else are MLB players cheap about? Well, after The Athletic asked dozens of them the question over the past year, the answer is … pretty much everything.

“It’s that old cliche,” said Cleveland’s Steven Kwan, “You stay rich by being cheap.”

Some players took issue with the framing of the question. “I don’t like the c-word,” A’s pitcher T.J. McFarland said. “I use frugal.”

You be the judge.

Whit Merrifield, free agent: It’s funny when music is playing in the clubhouse and someone has their phone hooked up and an ad comes on. Guys will yell, “You’re a big leaguer making millions of dollars and can’t pay $11.99 for Spotify?!”

Ryan McMahon, Rockies: My wife is on her cousin’s Spotify, so I use that.

Jake Cronenworth, Padres: I don’t buy any music. It’s a pretty useless purchase. I like to drive in silence. Total silence.

Zach Neto, Angels: I use Apple Music but I’m still on my (cheaper) student account. Don’t tell Apple Music that. It’s the only app I pay for.

Hayden Birdsong, Giants: I’m not paying for any apps. I’m on my mom’s Spotify.

Tyler Glasnow, Dodgers: There’s something about (buying an app). I just don’t want to give them the $2.

Barlow: If I have a game app and it says you can upgrade for no ads, I won’t do that.

Glasnow: It’s probably worth it, too. It’s just ingrained in my brain — like, no, I’m not doing it.

Despite being division rivals last season, former Yankees pitcher Lou Trivino was on Orioles reliever Cole Irvin’s Netflix account.

Tanner Scott, Dodgers: We are definitely still on my wife’s family’s Netflix.

Evan Carter, Rangers: I’m on my wife’s parents’ Netflix and my parents’ Hulu.

McMahon: If you’ve got someone else’s log-in, you’re all set.

McFarland: Up until about two years ago I was on my family cellphone plan. And I wasn’t even paying my parents, it was free. Finally, my dad is like, “You are in the big leagues, time to get your own s—.”

Dansby Swanson, Cubs: I had that moment, too. I needed a new phone and it was a good time to switch my phone number. I was like, “All right, it’s time to get off my parents’ plan.”

Tristan Beck, Giants: That day is coming for me, too. But I’m going to try to avoid it as long as I can.


Matt Strahm, Phillies: I’m not going to just buy new clothes because I want to. I need to need clothes to buy clothes.

Joe Musgrove, Padres: You know how in elementary school you get to go back to school shopping and you get a few pairs of jeans and a couple T-shirts to last you the year? I’m still the same way.

McFarland: I’m coming in with shoes literally coming apart — the sole was coming off. My wife was like, “That’s enough.” She took them and threw them out.

Derek Law, Nationals: My wife is like, “You need to get some new shirts,” and I’m like, “Ehh, I’m good.”

Ryan Mountcastle, Orioles: I never need new clothes.

Mike Yastrzemski, Giants: I don’t buy clothes, I don’t buy shoes. I get very weirdly indecisive about things. I’ll be like, “I want this,” and then I’ll turn around 10 minutes later and be like, “Well, what’s going to change if I buy this? Nothing.” So then I’m like, “I guess I don’t need this,” and I move on.

Strahm: I’m very simple and cheap with clothes. There is black, white and gray in my closet, just plain T-shirts.

Craig Kimbrel, Braves: I’ll wear stuff out.

Kwan: Socks, undershirts, that stuff I will ride until the end.

Musgrove: I’ll wear it until I can’t wear it anymore.

Mountcastle: Until it literally has holes in it.

Kwan: I had a pillow for 10 years that my now-wife was totally disgusted by. She’s like “You can get a new one!” and I was like “Why? I don’t need a new one.” One day she took the cover off and said, “You need to look at this, it’s disgusting.” And it was. I did end up throwing it away my first year up here. It made it to the big leagues, though.


Seth Lugo, Royals: I hate paying for shipping.

Austin Riley, Braves: There was something — it was a hunting gadget, it was like $6, and the shipping was $8. And I was like, “I’ll just go buy it somewhere.”

Jesse Chavez, Braves: And a “processing fee.”… Processing? Where did that come from?

McFarland: When you use DoorDash and it’s an extra couple bucks to have someone deliver the food to you, I tell my wife, “No way, we are picking it up.”

Lugo: Go get it yourself. I’m not ordering stuff (to get delivered).

McFarland: Sure, it’s 15-20 minutes to go pick it up and you are probably spending that money on gas, but (delivery) is something I am not OK wasting money on.

Jesse Winker, Mets: I feel like Uber’s prices have gotten out of control, so if I can’t walk somewhere, I’ll rent a scooter for a fraction of the price.

Clay Holmes, Mets: I’m cheap about flights. You fly so much with the team you never even think about it, then you go to book flights in the offseason, and it’s like, “I got to pay this much to fly?”

Jameson Taillon, Cubs: I have a hard time paying for extra legroom. I can afford to fly first class or in an exit row, but I feel like I’m getting punished for being tall, so I refuse to upgrade my seat.

Triston McKenzie, Guardians: I look at first-class seats, but I don’t ever buy them.

Matt Vierling, Tigers: I still drive my car from college. It’s a 2012 Ford Escape. It broke down on the highway on me (in September).

Birdsong: I’ve got a 2015 Ford Fusion.

Paul Sewald, Guardians: I had my first car, a Toyota 4Runner, for 13 years in the big leagues, and only upgraded in 2021 because we got pregnant and needed a bigger car.

Vierling: I was driving an even older car before. (The Escape) was used when I got it; it had like 65,000 miles on it. Now it’s got like 172,000, and we are still rolling. I am going to try to ride it out for another year. I got everybody in my family saying, It’s not safe, you should get another car. And I’m just like, “Not yet. I will ride it until it dies.”

Birdsong: I was a sixth-rounder, I’ll keep it till it breaks, and it’s pretty close. It’s got 140-150,000 miles on it.

Sewald: I’ve got a Ford Expedition now. It’s not fancy. It’s pretty much a dad car.

Birdsong: Maybe I’ll get a Prius next.

Kwan: I still don’t own a car. I lease one and do some (promotional stuff) for the company, and they pay for it. That saves a lot of money.

Kyle Gibson, Orioles: When I was in college, my junior year (2009), I needed a 60-degree lob wedge. So I went to Walmart, and bought a $19.99 wedge. I still have that club, and I have yet to buy a new one because I love it. The grip is ripped badly, the shaft of the club is completely rusted out. Whenever I golf with somebody new, they see me pull it out of my bag and they go, “What are you doing?”

Yastrzemski: I have the same clubs I’ve had for four years that I got for free anyway. I called my agent because I cracked my driver face and said, “Hey, do you know anyone who can send me a driver? I don’t care what it is.” I didn’t want to buy it. … I did buy a new putter recently. It took me a year and a half to pull the trigger on it.


Chavez stayed near a lake during the All-Star break with teammate A.J. Minter and their families. There were eight people total, and they filled up a cart, mainly with fruit and vegetables. It was $600.

Chavez: I’m also a big stickler at the grocery store. … Where did this (bill) come from?

Law: Groceries are crazy.

McFarland: I will look at the store, and it’s like, “OK, if it’s 60 cents less, I am getting the generic brand.”

Emilio Pagàn, Reds: Even if it’s 40 cents cheaper.

McKenzie, Guardians: If I need medicine, I’m definitely getting Target brand ibuprofen.

Law: If the strawberries say they’re two for $7, I’m going to get two strawberries because I feel like I’m saving money. Am I? Probably not, because they made me buy two now.

Jake Diekman, free agent: The other day at self-checkout I was like, where are all the bags? And the lady said you have to buy them. It was wild. I only bought two, though.

Law: Most of the time you forget the bags that you’re supposed to bring. And it’s like, damn, I am not paying 10 cents.

Kwan: I don’t like paying for snacks. I have my little Lulu(lemon) bag and it’s like a trick-or-treat (in the clubhouse) every day. Usually it’s spilling out the brim. I’ve got free waters and these sweet Thai chili almonds I’ve been absolutely emptying out.

Winker: The price of water has gone way too high. We get so used to just being able to grab water (in the clubhouse). Then in the offseason you go buy water and you’re like, “This water is this expensive?”

Dustin May, Dodgers: I’m not saying I don’t load up (on the free waters). I definitely do.

Neto: I won’t pay for water bottles. Before I leave here, I will take a couple home with me to drink.

McFarland: The same guys walking out of here with tons of free water bottles have no problem spending $25,000 on a Rolex.

Manny Machado, Padres: I won’t spend money on a wine (at a restaurant) that they charge you 800 percent (markup) on. I’ll just go home and drink my own wine or bring my own wine.

Pagan: For the longest time, my diet included a lot of Taco Bell. Crunch Wrap Supreme is hard to beat. That helped my cheap mindset, but now I’m getting older and can’t eat that as much.

Machado: I like wine, but the value’s got to be there. I’m a value guy.

Diekman: You have to go to Costco, the No. 1 seller of wine in the world. I feel like everyone trying to save should go to Costco, grab yourself a hot dog and get some wine.

Kwan: You got to buy in bulk. I’m not playing around going to get toothpaste five or six times. I’m going to get the 10-pack and let that ride out.

Logan O’Hoppe, Angels: Don’t hate me, but even though it’s a dollar, I refuse to pay for The Athletic. Even if my name is in it, my ego gets in the way and I don’t want to pay for it.

(Editor’s note: Subscribe now for just $1/week for four weeks, Logan.)

McKenzie: I did finally subscribe. (Guardians beat writer Zack) Meisel got me to. He was like, it’s only a dollar! But I did hold out for a little bit.

O’Hoppe: I am not paying that damn dollar. It’s the principle. I will read the first paragraph before the paywall. So, I guess I’m too cheap to read this article.

The Athletic’s Katie Woo, Dennis Lin, David O’Brien and Patrick Mooney contributed to this story.

(Illustration: Dan Goldfarb / The Athletic; photo: Mitchell Leff / Getty Images)

Inside Draymond Green’s defensive mind, which seeks to ‘completely destroy’ you

The Golden State Warriors’ regular season will end on a Sunday afternoon at Chase Center in one of Draymond Green’s favorite matchups. Against the LA Clippers. It will likely have postseason implications, so Green will no doubt be intense.

But it’s not one of his favorites for the matchup against Ivica Zubac, the bruising center he’ll have to face. Or Kawhi Leonard. Or James Harden. No, Green loves the matchup because of opposing head coach Ty Lue.

“When I’m playing against his teams,” Green said, “I feel like it’s a chess match with me and him.”

It’s a window into why Green is here, at 35 years old, still playing stellar enough defensively to be worthy of Defensive Player of the Year consideration. He’s not as fast as he once was, not as explosive as when he last won the award in 2017. His body has endured, is enduring, the typical wear and tear of a career over a thousand games long.

But Green compensates with his mind. Always a high-IQ player, Green’s advanced knowledge, accrued through six NBA Finals trips and four championships, has evolved him into an algorithmic deconstructor of offenses.

He still has some tangible strengths. He’s strong. He remains spry. He also has a 7-foot-2 wingspan he wields like a weapon. It compensates for him being only 6-foot-6. Sometimes, he’ll guard people with one hand in the air, like a fly swatter.

But the activation of these tools is his special trick. It ain’t checkers. Not to Green. He doesn’t want to win matchups; he wants to disrupt whole schemes. He doesn’t see his battle with the players on the court but with the aim of what they want to accomplish.

“Every offense in the NBA is built to put (defensive) players in a rotation,” Green said. “So if I know that, and I know the rotation … if I see that y’all are doing this or y’all (are) doing this to get to that? Great. I’m going to stand right there and f— this whole play up.

“I want everything that y’all thought y’all was going to come in this game and do, I want to take all of that s— off the table. That’s why I talk to the coaches so much. … This is my little battle with the coach. I want to f— your s— up. It’s no hard feelings. I’m always bantering and talking. But I want you to know that your offensive game plan, I wanna f— it up. … Completely destroy your offensive game plan, and then I want to let you know about it.”

What goes into the monkey-wrenching of defenses? Green sat down and broke down five plays from this season that give a window into his defensive mind. Watch the videos to hear Green’s detailed explanation.


Warriors vs. Pelicans | Oct. 30 | Chase Center

Zion Williamson went 5 of 20 in this early season showdown, back when he was healthy and spry. Green frustrated him into a rough night. He explained how he did it, using this sequence as an example.

Williamson caught the pass as he was curling into the lane. But Green, after having watched Williamson score 31 points on 12-of-19 shooting the previous night against the Warriors, altered his approach: Give Williamson space.

“I want to give myself a little distance because he’s fast and powerful. You know, quick,” Green said. “But I don’t want to give too much distance to where the momentum of the bump that he’s going to deliver, it’s gon’ move me.”

Against taller players, such as Nikola Jokić and Anthony Davis, Green has to be close enough to get a good contest. Williamson is just 6-6. So Green could give him space and still contest thanks to his wingspan.

Williamson settled for the midrange jumper and missed badly. Wide left. He managed to get the ball back, but Green hunted him down with his fly swatter and challenged his shot. He calls it the deflector hand.

“It’s the deflector,” he said. “I need the deflector going. I’ve got to get this hand up because I’m not 7 feet. If my hand goes up late, it’s a wrap. I’m 6-5.”


Warriors vs. Mavericks | Nov. 12 | Chase Center

Two plays — one early in the first quarter, another late in the fourth quarter — revealed the nuance of the chess Green plays.

Then-Dallas star Luka Dončić ran a pick-and-roll with Dallas Mavericks center Daniel Gafford on the left wing. Andrew Wiggins and Trayce Jackson-Davis trapped Dončić on the sideline. Green defended Naji Marshall. But he left Marshall to go cover Gafford.

 

The rotational scheme called for Green to pass off Gafford once he got below the free-throw line. Straying too far from his man would give Dončić an easy pass to an open shooter. But Green didn’t mind that shot.

“I tag Gafford because if you don’t tag Gafford, what Luka gon’ do? He’s gon’ probe, probe, he gon’ throw it right to the front of the rim to Gafford for a lob. So I’m tagging him all the way down. But I know I have a non-shooter. I know I can get back here.”

Sticking with Gafford did two things. One, it kept Stephen Curry out of rotation. He was the low man responsible for cutting off the diving big man. Since Green discouraged the pass to Gafford, preventing the roll, Curry didn’t need to rotate and could stay tethered to Klay Thompson in the weakside corner. And then-Warrior De’Anthony Melton could stick with Kyrie Irving instead of zoning up to cover both Thompson and Irving — if Curry had to rotate.

Dončić, with his roll man covered, dribbled around Jackson-Davis and drove baseline. The double-team stayed with him, and Dončić ended up under the rim. Thompson was covered by Curry, Irving by Melton and Gafford by Green.

Dončić, being such an exceptional passer, knew his lone option — though it was behind him. He wrapped a no-look, two-hand pass from the right low block to the left wing, where Marshall was wide open.

Notice Green’s back was to Dončić, whose back was to the shooter. Yet, Green had already diagnosed what Dončić would do. The ball was barely out of Dončić’s hands when Green made his move toward Marshall on the wing.

 

So Green freelanced the defensive scheme, baited Dončić to throw the ball where he wanted, then “jumped the route” and got one of his patented blocked 3-pointers — which was relatively easy.

Green said most defenders, when they see an open player, run toward the open man with their hands up. Since defenders are trained to get a hand up on shooters, they instinctively raise their arms while closing out. But Green said that slows the defender down.

“When I see the ball passed, I take off and sprint. At the last second, I get my hand up. Before my hand goes up, I’m on a dead sprint.”

With a bead on the play, a sprinting closeout and a 7-2 wingspan, this was an easy block of Marshall’s 3-pointer.

Oddly enough, the biggest defensive play of this game happened because Green made the opposite choice with Gafford and left the Mavericks big man open on purpose.

The Warriors were down a point with 2:21 left and needed a stop. Dončić was running a pick-and-roll with then-Maverick Quentin Grimes, trying to get Curry on Dončić. Green tried baiting Dončić into passing to Gafford. Green parked at the free-throw line in the middle, negating Grimes’ roll to the basket.

Green was aware of Gafford behind him. He wanted Dončić to feed him the ball. They’ve been in this situation before.

It worked. Dončić passed behind Green to Gafford on the baseline. Green didn’t get in front of Gafford. Instead, he essentially gave Gafford the lane to the rim.

“Because I know I can get the ball on the back side,” Green said. “… If I come to him and get my body in front of him, he’s too big. He’s just going to shoo me off and just lay it here. Me getting my body in front of him at that point, I’m at a disadvantage. My advantage is to elude his body and get the ball on the other side.”


Warriors at Rockets | Dec. 11 | Toyota Center

Houston’s Alperen Şengün had Green in the paint isolated and decided to post up the smaller Warrior. The Rockets’ big man is 6-11, 235 pounds and one of the best in the NBA with his back to the basket. But Green made quick work of him in the paint. He used his hands to keep Şengün from getting into his body.

Şengün got into the low post on the left block. But Green anticipated his move and, using the baseline as a defender, angled his body to be in the way when Şengün attempted to turn back to the middle.

“He always wants to spin,” Green said. “So when he’s going left, guess where he’s going? He’s spinning back right. So now I just need to pin him that way. I can’t let you spin back to your right hand, and you’re too deep. You’re under the backboard.”

An off-balance Şengün was easy prey. Green stripped the ball, and the Warriors were off the other way.


Warriors vs. Knicks | March 15 | Chase Center

Midway through the fourth quarter, the Warriors had taken control of the game. Green started the play on New York’s Josh Hart, a non-shooter who allowed Green to play center field. When Mikal Bridges curled off a screen, Green left Hart to stop Bridges. Green knows Bridges likes to get to his midrange pullup.

“As soon as I see him coming off the screen with a little bit of space, I’m already knowing, like, ‘Oh, I need to jump up. Because if I don’t, he’s gon’ shoot that. That’s his pet shot. So I need to put this fire out right away.”

Instead of taking his midrange shot, Bridges lofted a pass to the left wing for Knicks forward OG Anunoby. Karl-Anthony Towns set a screen on Warriors forward Gui Santos, who shadowed Anunoby. Then Towns rolled out of the screen and warded off Jimmy Butler, who was on Towns.

This resulted in a clear path to the rim for Anunoby.

Bridges, after making the pass, floated to the top. But Green didn’t follow him. He abandoned Bridges, leaving him alone behind the arc.

“I don’t think he can make this pass,” Green said. “He can’t make that pass. He don’t even see it. … He got a drive to the rim. He ain’t passing. And he was playing well? Go put the fire out.”

Ever the freelancer, Green beat Moses Moody and Butler to the rotation and cut off Anunoby on the baseline. When the Knicks forward leapt toward the front of the rim for a layup, Green blocked it to complete the play.

So Green started on Hart, switched onto Bridges, then thwarted Anunoby.


Warriors vs. Bucks | March 18 | Chase Center

The Warriors were one stop away from sealing the game. Green was on Giannis Antetokounmpo.

Antetokounmpo did a dribble-handoff (DHO) with forward Kyle Kuzma into a pick-and-roll. Buddy Hield, chasing Kuzma, zipped around Giannis to stay connected to his man. He found himself behind a screen by Giannis.

But Green didn’t drop back to cover Giannis.

“My thought process here is I’m gonna be up at the level of the screen,” Green said. “Because I’ve got to take the 3 away. We’re up 11 points with 51 seconds to go. I’ve gotta take this 3 away.”

So Green immediately ate the space between him and Kuzma. For one, he wanted to speed up Kuzma. He also wanted to make the pass harder for Kuzma. And Green already knew he couldn’t let Kuzma turn the corner and have a two-man game with Giannis rolling to the basket in open space.

 

“Look where Kuz catches the ball,” Green said. “He’s in a prime trap spot. He’s got the sideline. He’s got nowhere to go. … I’ve got him dead right here. Once he turns his back, I can get out now.”

Green hustled back to Giannis. Butler had rotated over to cover for Green, but now Green sent him away. He was ready for his second effort on the defensive possession.

With Giannis catching the ball farther out, Green was in a better position to defend.

“So now I can beat (Giannis) to the spot, and I can prepare myself for the shoulder because I know the shoulder is coming,” Green said. “I can take the hit.”

Green indeed absorbed Giannis’ shoulder and impeded a shot attempt. Giannis passed to Damian Lillard in the weakside corner. Green remained connected to Giannis, who drifted to the left side. But when the ball reversed to the opposite corner, Green had to give a third effort.

He sprinted out to contest an open 3 from Taurean Prince. Green closed out well enough to make Prince pump fake and step away from Green. The change was enough to disrupt Prince, and he missed.

The play began with him blowing up their pick-and-roll plans and ended with a good contest. Ball game.

(Illustration: Demetrius Robinson / The Athletic; Photos: Jed Jacobsohn / NBAE, Elsa, Thearon W. Henderson / Getty Images)

Reader poll results – Discussing Kevin De Bruyne and the most influential midfielders of the Premier League era

“Always I have to be careful for the respect for the players that have played incredible roles, but there’s no doubt he’s one of the greatest for sure,” said Pep Guardiola of Kevin De Bruyne’s impending exit from Manchester City.

De Bruyne’s impact at City since joining from Wolfsburg in 2015 has been huge, with the Belgian scoring 106 goals in 413 appearances, contributing to 187 Premier League goals (scoring or assisting), equalling the assist record for a single season and winning 19 trophies.

While Guardiola was careful about discussing where he stands in the greatest player debate, the City coach praised his “influence in our success in the last decade”.

Which had us asking, who are the most influential midfielders of the Premier League era?

Here is a selection of our writers’ answers and explanations of why they chose them. There probably isn’t a right answer but please let us know who we’ve overlooked (sorry, Paul Scholes) and register your vote in our poll (or submit your own entry).

We’ll publish the results on Sunday.


Yaya Toure

Premier League career: Manchester City 2010-18

Quite simply, Yaya Toure played in a style different to any midfielder the Premier League had seen before. He had the physicality of a centre-back, screening of a No 6, driving ability of a No 8, and shot power of a striker, patch-worked together in one sky blue-clad body.

There was Claude Makelele, who achieved Toure’s defensive coverage but was far more limited in attack, while even Arsenal’s Patrick Vieira lacked the Ivorian’s ability to take games by the scruff of their necks. Mousa Dembele, at his best, probably comes closest.

Here was the player that straddled City’s first post-takeover steps — his goal against Stoke City won the 2011 FA Cup, the club’s first trophy in 35 years — and Pep Guardiola’s dominant sides. David Silva, as wonderful as he was, relied on the industry and guile of his deeper-lying partner.


Toure playing for Manchester City in 2018 (Mike Hewitt via Getty Images)

He is probably the figure who has most influenced the mimetic ideal of a Premier League midfielder, his frame dominating in the most physical league in the world, but his technical ability still allowing him to evade pressure and crash the box. Ask any top-flight manager to draw up the frame and skill set of their ideal midfielder, all rules of creation in their hands, and Toure would be the closest facsimile.

Jacob Whitehead


Frank Lampard

West Ham United 1995-01, Chelsea 2001-14, Manchester City 2014-15

Goals. Lampard scored 177 of them, elevating him to seventh place on the Premier League’s all-time list. To put that into context, he’s surrounded by strikers. The next-highest midfielder — Steven Gerrard — is in 23rd place. Lampard’s assists? 102. Astonishing numbers that highlight Lampard’s incredible attacking output across 22 Premier League seasons, most spent with Chelsea, where he won three Premier League titles after signing from West Ham in 2001.

Lampard’s biggest talent, by his own admission, was his work ethic and dedication. Encouraged by his father, Frank Lampard Snr, he practised relentlessly, striving to be the best that he could be every day at training, and, ultimately, he got his reward.

An elegant passer of the ball, aided by his awareness and football intelligence, Lampard mastered the art of the late run into the penalty area, where he scored goals of every description to establish himself as one of the Premier League greats.

Stuart James


Roy Keane

Nottingham Forest 1990*-93, Manchester United 1993-2005

A force of nature, a supreme competitor. Sir Alex Ferguson once said, “If I was putting Roy Keane out there to represent Manchester United on a one-on-one, we would win the Derby, the Grand National, the Boat Race and anything else.”

Keane was not just part of a dominant team at United in the 1990s and early 2000s, he was the heart and soul.


Keane was United’s on-pitch leader (Michael Steele/EMPICS via Getty Images)

He didn’t play defence-splitting passes like Gerrard, De Bruyne or Paul Scholes. He didn’t have the silky skills of Cesc Fabregas, Luka Modric or Silva. He didn’t score goals like Lampard and he didn’t have the towering presence of Vieira. But he was, in an understated way, an extraordinary footballer — not just a fearsome tackler but a swashbuckling box-to-box midfielder and who evolved into an intelligent and inspirational (if at times impetuous) captain who elevated and at times dragged his team-mates to another level.

Oliver Kay

* 1992-93 was the first Premier League season


Xabi Alonso

Liverpool 2004-09

As if it wasn’t enough to be so good that Jose Mourinho compared you to a “metronomic” Guardiola. No, Alonso could also do the audacious to sit alongside the elegantly procedural midfield demands.

He scored in a Champions League final, won the FA Cup and shared the limelight with Gerrard in his prime. But the Basque midfielder will also be remembered for one of the Premier League’s most ridiculous goals, against Newcastle United at Anfield in September 2006.

Having won the ball himself just outside the centre circle, he saw opposition ‘keeper Steve Harper off his line and duly put the ball into the net from a staggering 60 yards. It was the second-longest goal in top-flight history but remarkably, he had already gone better.

That year, he had scored from more than 70 yards near the end of an FA Cup win at Luton Town after the goalkeeper had gone up for a set piece. The complete range of passing, a penchant to put his foot in when required and capable of jaw-dropping goals — Alonso had it all.

Greg O’Keeffe


Steven Gerrard

Liverpool 1998-2015

Football has become about specialisms, players whose job description is tightly defined around one super-strength. Very few have possessed the ability to claim they are one of the best across all categories.

Vieira, Toure and Rodri all have a case, but those players were usually part of either the best or second-best team in England. Gerrard did not have that luxury in many seasons, yet he is still the best all-rounder there has been. It is why his spectacularly outsized influence on Liverpool was so captivating.

He had power, guile, range, aggression. He was Roy of the Rovers incarnate, a sheer force of nature who could transform games on his own. It is why Jose Mourinho tried to sign him for three different clubs and why Ferguson thought he was the only player who replicated Keane’s ubiquity on the pitch.

Steven Gerrard


Gerrard stayed loyal to Liverpool (AMA/Corbis via Getty Images)

That ferocious energy and desire to be everything was what Rafa Benitez refined. He added a subtlety to his game while playing just off Fernando Torres, producing sublime killer passes on tap. Late in his career, he was reinvented as a ‘quarterback’, pinging diagonals from deep with machine-like precision.

He could have been placed into any team or style and had he not stayed at his boyhood club and racked up titles elsewhere, the conversation would be a lot shorter.

Jordan Campbell


Cesc Fabregas

Arsenal 2003-11, Chelsea 2014-19

He was so good, he changed the way Arsenal played football.

Arsene Wenger’s early success in north London had been built on the pace and power of Vieira, Emmanuel Petit and Gilberto Silva, but when a scruffy 16-year-old with a dodgy mullet and a baggy shirt arrived from Barcelona, a new era began.

After Viera’s departure, Fabregas was given the keys to the Arsenal midfield and grabbed them with both hands. His passing was slick, his vision sublime, and he quickly became the poster boy for what would come to be known as ‘Wengerball’.

He was unlucky to never win the trophies his quality deserved with Arsenal, but he returned from a spell back at Barcelona to win two Premier League titles in three seasons with Chelsea.

Under Wenger, Mourinho and Antonio Conte, the styles were wildly different, but it’s a testament to how good a player he was that Fabregas’ quality always shone through.

Kaya Kaynak


Patrick Vieira

Arsenal 1996-2005, Man City 2010-11

In the Premier League, there was a time before Wenger and a time after he arrived.

And just as Thierry Henry used Wenger’s Arsenal team as a vehicle to redefine the role of a Premier League forward, so Vieira used it to transform the idea of a midfielder.

There had been outstanding box-to-box operators before him, most notably Bryan Robson at the league’s inception in the early 1990s, then Keane. But Vieira was the complete package.


Vieira was key to Wenger’s Arsenal (John Peters/Manchester United via Getty Images)

He could match any midfielder of his era for technique, skill and intelligence while having the edge on everyone else in athleticism, physical presence, stamina and mobility. He could bend games to his will through sheer force of personality and he did it all while gliding across the pitch with a grace that no supreme, 6ft 4in (193cm) athlete should be able to produce.

Steve Madeley


Kevin De Bruyne

Manchester City 2015-2025

It’s not just the relentlessness of De Bruyne’s output that City will miss, but the imagination and variety — the spark — that he consistently found, so often the man with the creative solution that other talented team-mates just couldn’t see.

There were moments of sheer genius — a deft reverse pass to find Leroy Sane in a 7-2 win against Stoke City; a free kick rolled under the wall against Cardiff City, a defence-splitting ball to drag Manchester City back into the game at Newcastle.

There were moments of repeated brilliance — those unstoppable crosses from the right, always struck with whip, venom, and deep into the areas that no opponent wanted to defend. And when all else failed, there was sheer power — searing strikes against Swansea City and Chelsea, a thumping half-volley off the bar at St James’ Park, and a surging, title-winning run into the box against Aston Villa all springing to mind.

On both feet, and with absolutely everything he had, De Bruyne brought a unique mix of brutal efficiency and eye-catching style, a hard-working midfielder with game-breaking talent to boot.

How City will adapt to life without him remains unclear; it’s the same question fans asked when Toure and Silva chose to move on, before a certain Belgian midfielder answered the call.

Leaving with six Premier League titles, five League Cups, two FA Cups and, most importantly, a Champions League to his name, the club have De Bruyne to thank for helping to deliver its finest hours.

Thom Harris


Claude Makelele

Chelsea 2003-08

There are not many football players whose role became so clearly defined that it is named after them.

Makelele arrived at Chelsea in the twilight of his career. Aged 30, Makelele had been converted from an attacking midfielder to a deep-lying, anchoring midfielder that would protect his back line and hoover up any defensive actions that came anywhere near his orbit.

However, it was not just his ability to cover ground and regain possession, but also how much his role transformed the way that Chelsea played on the ball — signalling to the Premier League that a 4-4-2 was becoming increasingly outdated.


Makelele even had a role named after him (Odd Andersen/AFP via Getty Images)

“If I have a triangle in midfield — Claude Makelele behind and two others just in front — I will always have an advantage against a pure 4-4-2 where the central midfielders are side by side,” said Mourinho as Chelsea manager. “That’s because I will always have an extra man. It starts with Makelele, who is between the lines.”

When ‘The Makelele Role’ becomes an established phrase within the game, you know you have made an impact in the Premier League.

Mark Carey


Paul Ince

Manchester United 1989*-1995, Liverpool 1997-99, Middlesbrough 1999-2002, Wolverhampton Wanderers 2003-04 (Ince played in the top flight for West Ham from 1986-89)

Ince was the start of it all. In the inaugural Premier League season (1992-93), Manchester United won their first title in 26 years. Ince played 41 of the 42 games. He made United win matches.

Next season, same again. United won the second ever Premier League season, with Ince playing 39 of 42 matches and scoring eight goals, most of them alongside new arrival Keane.

In the third Premier League season, United were beaten into second place by Blackburn Rovers and Ince’s relationship with Ferguson had soured, so he was sold to Inter Milan for £7.5million ($9.7m at current rates).

A lot was said about Ince, not least by Ferguson, who called Ince a “big-time Charlie” when the midfielder was playing for Liverpool, a comment Ferguson later regretted.

It’s true, Ince did rate himself, but justifiably so. If you supported the opposition, Ince felt unbeatable. He controlled the midfield and controlled the game, the way great Italian midfielders were able to.

He spent two seasons in Serie A before signing for Liverpool. He was past his best then, but before that, Ince was the Premier League’s stepping stone to get to Keane, Vieira and De Bruyne.

Andrew Hankinson


N’Golo Kante

Leicester City 2015-16, Chelsea 2016-23

Kante took the Makelele role and asked for large fries to go with it. He super-sized what it meant to be a ball-winning midfielder (despite his shorter height and slighter frame) and spearheaded consecutive Premier League titles with different clubs.

He arguably achieved a unique feat in being central to two successive title-winning teams. Eric Cantona did something similar with Leeds United and Manchester United in 1992 and 1993, but only joined the former from February onwards when they were already top of the table.


Kante was central to Leicester’s remarkable title (Getty Images)

It is impossible to envisage Leicester winning the title in 2016 without Kante, who did the jobs of two, even three players with his relentless interceptions and tackles. Then at Chelsea a season later, he repeated the feat, scooping up all the player-of-the-year awards along the way.

A World Cup and a Champions League would follow as Kante reimagined himself slightly further up the field. Sadly, injuries stunted his golden era, but at his best, no one in the world was better at what Kante did.

He is also the greatest bargain buy on this list, costing Leicester just £5.6m from French club Caen in 2015

Tim Spiers


David Silva

Manchester City 2010-20

There is an interesting debate to be had between Silva and De Bruyne, purely in terms of their different styles of play. Plenty of City fans will pick Silva as the best player to ever play for the club, and most Spaniards would probably side with Silva due to their different appreciation of what makes a footballer special.

De Bruyne’s game lends itself more to British sensibilities: he is all about powerful running and crash, bang, wallop goals.

Silva was the yin to De Bruyne’s yang. If De Bruyne was the icing on the cake, Silva was the cake.

He made City tick during his entire period at the club, whether it was Roberto Mancini, Manuel Pellegrini or Guardiola in charge. The latter’s game plans are all about controlling the game and Silva’s tempo-setting approach, always knowing how many touches were needed in a given moment, found an obvious home. To sound all hipster for a moment, Silva would be the thinking man’s choice.

Sam Lee


Have your say

After it was announced Kevin De Bruyne is to leave Manchester City at the end of the season, we asked a selection of our writers who the most influential midfielders of the Premier League are and then opened it up to a vote.

And you voted in the thousands. In addition to the 12 players nominated by our writers, there were votes for players including Rodri, Luka Modric, Joelinton, Mousa Dembele and Paul Scholes. Or “Paul Scholes you idiots” as one voter put it. But for all the support for the former Manchester United midfielder, it was Steven Gerrard who won the poll.

This is how readers of The Athletic voted:

28% Steven Gerrard

17% Roy Keane

14% Kevin De Bruyne

12% Patrick Vieira

8% Frank Lampard

5% Yaya Toure

4% Paul Scholes

4% N’Golo Kante

2% David Silva

2% Claude Makelele

1% Cesc Fabregas

1% Xabi Alonso

The remaining votes were shared among other players

 

(Top image: Getty Images)

Meet the MIT physicist turned Marlins coach behind the ‘torpedo’ bats used by the Yankees

NEW YORK — The New York Yankees’ bats were the story of the team’s franchise-record nine-home run day against the Milwaukee Brewers on Saturday. Then came the discussion about the actual bats used by some players in the 20-9 win.

The uniquely shaped lumber is the result of two years of research and experimentation with a former Massachusetts Institute of Technology physicist-turned-coach at the helm.

The question at its center?

“Where are you trying to hit the ball?” Aaron Leanhardt said in a phone interview Sunday morning. “Where are you trying to make contact?”

Leanhardt, 48, began his work when he was a member of the Yankees’ minor-league hitting department in 2022 and brought it to the major leagues last season when he was the team’s lead analyst, with some players, including shortstop Anthony Volpe, trying them in games. Now, as many as five Yankees will be using them in games at least early this season, according to outfielder Cody Bellinger.

The bats — with their torpedo-like shape — are custom-made to player preferences and are designed so that the densest part of the bat is where that particular hitter most often makes contact with the baseball, said Leanhardt, who became a field coordinator with the Miami Marlins in the offseason.

“Really,” he said. “It’s just about making the bat as heavy and as fat as possible in the area where you’re trying to do damage on the baseball.”


Anthony Volpe (holding a “torpedo” bat) congratulates Jazz Chisholm during the Yankees’ 20-9 win on Saturday. (Mike Stobe / Getty Images)

A Major League Baseball spokesman told The Athletic that the bats don’t break any rules. MLB Rule 3.02 states that a bat “shall be a smooth, round stick not more than 2.61 inches in diameter at the thickest part and not more than 42 inches in length. The bat shall be one piece of solid wood.” It also says that “experimental” bats can’t be used “until the manufacturer has secured approval from Major League Baseball of his design and methods of manufacture.”

Asked whether he was the inventor of the technology, Leanhardt said it was a group effort, the results coming from conversations with coaches, players, MLB and bat makers.

“Credit goes to those who take it,” Leanhardt said. “But if people want to ascribe credit to different people, then I’ll take some cut of it.”

A Yankees official, however, said Leanhardt deserves “a lot” of the credit. Retired infielder Kevin Smith, who spent parts of four seasons in the majors, also credited Leanhardt as the inventor.

Leanhardt took an unorthodox route to baseball.

He has a bachelor’s degree in electrical engineering from the University of Michigan and a Ph.D. in physics from MIT. He was a physics professor at the University of Michigan from 2007 to 2014.

Leanhardt began coaching in the Atlantic League in 2017 and coached at a Montana community college before joining the Yankees in 2018. In the majors in 2024, the club said he was its first “major league analyst” and “responsible for integrating the use of quantitative information with on-field performance and preparation.”

Why leave academia for baseball?

“I think that’s one of the cool things about sports is it’s very competitive,” he said. “Guys are willing to push the envelope. It’s just an opportunity to take my background to an area and find ways to innovate.”

Talking to players over the years revealed that their biggest concerns were twofold, Leanhardt said. They wanted to make more contact with pitches and they wanted to strike the ball more often with the bat’s “sweet spot,” or the densest area.

“They’re going to point to a location on the bat that is probably six or seven inches down from the tip of the bat,” he said. “That’s where the sweet spot typically is. It’s just through those conversations where you think to yourself, why don’t we exchange how much wood we’re putting on the tip versus how much we’re putting in the sweet spot? That’s the original concept right there. Just try to take all that excess weight and try to put it where you’re trying to hit the ball and then in exchange try to take the thinner diameter that used to be at the sweet spot and put that on the tip.”

Leanhardt said he didn’t see many drawbacks to redistributing the weight of the bat.

“The bat speed should stay the same,” he said. “Maybe the bat speed can even increase a little bit depending on how you want to redesign the bat. But ultimately you’re getting a fatter barrel, a heavier barrel at the sweet spot. So in some sense, you can have your cake and eat it here too. You can get some gains without actually making sacrifices.”

Leanhardt said he didn’t want to talk about individual players’ experiences with the new bat. Yankees designated hitter Giancarlo Stanton told reporters earlier this month that it was “probably some bat adjustments”  last season that caused the ligament tears in both of his elbows that led to his current stay on the injured list, though he didn’t place specific blame on anybody. Then he added: “I don’t know why it happened.” Leanhardt declined to comment on Stanton’s situation.

“You’d have to ask the Yankees’ medical personnel about that,” he said. “I’ll defer all those questions to the Yankees’ medical guys.”

Leanhardt said it was “the nature of our business” that it took years for a radically new bat design to come along.

“People back in the day swung very heavy bats made out of hickory and then someone had this genius idea to swing something lighter, something like ash, and that was revolutionary back in the 1920s, ’30s, ’40s kind of in that transition, and then the industry kind of stayed the course for quite some time,” he said. “Ultimately, it just takes people asking the right questions and being willing to be forward-thinking.”

He got a kick out of seeing the social media fervor the bats caused Saturday. He said that while some players began to use them last season, “the entire industry kind of caught wind of it” and “it exploded in the offseason.”

“Which is why you see it in the hands of so many guys right now,” he said. “Obviously, (Saturday’s) performance threw a whole lot of attention to it.”

It took a lot of coordination for the bats to go from the design stage to being manufactured. Leanhardt said he would “guarantee” he’s on a first-name basis with officials at MLB who oversee bat regulation and “everyone who operates the lathe for every bat manufacturer in baseball.”

“You really just are communicating with each company and trying to find the person who really knows the wood and knows how to turn the wood on a lathe. You just build a relationship with those guys and convince them that this is something that’s in their best interest to produce for their players. They want their players to be as successful as possible. Some guys buy in and it gains traction,” he said. “That’s really how it got built up.”

(Top photo of Aaron Leanhardt, right, with Marlins manager Clayton McCullough: Jasen Vinlove / Miami Marlins / Getty Images)

The Cubs are one of MLB’s top revenue machines. So why aren’t they paying for more players?

By Patrick Mooney, Ken Rosenthal and Sahadev Sharma

CHICAGO —  At first glance, the post from an X user named @Brooks_Gate seemed like something a multibillion-dollar company would ignore.

It consisted of a chart that used estimated data to illustrate the percentage of revenue spent on player payroll. Rather than sitting at the top with heavyweights like the Los Angeles Dodgers and New York Mets, the Chicago Cubs were lumped in near the bottom alongside the crosstown White Sox as well as the Pittsburgh Pirates, Tampa Bay Rays and Miami Marlins — the lightweight class.

The Wrigley Field money-making machine drove the Cubs to the third-highest revenue in Major League Baseball last year, according to sources briefed on the club’s finances. Yet even as one of the world’s most beloved ballparks hums along, a single post on social media struck a nerve with fans — and inside the executive offices.

When fans stream into Wrigley Field for Friday’s 1:20 p.m. home opener, unmistakable signs of the disparity between revenue and payroll will be visible. It’s seen in making Craig Counsell the highest-paid manager in the game and then handing him almost the same roster that got David Ross fired after the 2023 season. It’s seen in trading for Kyle Tucker after back-to-back years with 83 wins, but not going all-out to maximize his final season before becoming a free agent. It’s seen in handing the third-base job to an unproven rookie at the start of a playoffs-or-bust season, after budgetary restrictions effectively took them out of the running for Matt Chapman and Alex Bregman.

The graphic that perturbed Cubs executives was just one of many floating around in the vast expanse of social media. But it captured the growing belief that the Cubs no longer seem quite as singularly focused on winning the World Series, at least compared to the way that 1908 once hung over prior regimes.

One reason is the payroll parameters set by the Ricketts family ownership group and Crane Kenney’s business operations department. Another is the rising cost of doing business in the hypercompetitive National League. Taken together, those factors have left the club in a somewhat nebulous state, as legitimate contenders but with a margin for error that is arguably thinner than it should be.

The organization’s decision-makers dispute that notion. They believe the graphic is misleading and that they are making forward-looking financial choices, from hiring Counsell to building a scouting presence in Japan to enhancing player development.

“Talking about team revenue and payroll without including the other investments in baseball and business operations, as well as the impact of revenue sharing, does not show the whole picture,” said Kenney, a reference to the capital expenditures to maintain a team-owned ballpark that opened in 1914, and operating costs to run a popular tourist attraction.

Still, one league source referred to “the handcuffs” that Cubs president of baseball operations Jed Hoyer has dealt with while trying to build a playoff contender. A competing view, however, is that the Cubs spent roughly $100 million more than the Milwaukee Brewers last year and still finished 10 games behind that small-market team.

“The focus should not be on payroll,” Hoyer said. “Last season we went over the luxury tax and we ultimately didn’t win. That’s on me. I think we’ve built a better team this year and I’m excited for the season.”

On paper, the club remains a favorite to win the NL Central with a solid pitching staff, first-round picks all over the field and the ability to upgrade at the trade deadline. This new Cubs Way could work. But success would come despite the discrepancy highlighted by the graphic on social media. The Cubs’ spending on payroll does not appear to match their revenues.


Budget restrictions kept the Cubs from making a more competitive bid for free-agent third baseman Alex Bregman, who wound up with the Red Sox. (Maddie Malhotra / Boston Red Sox/Getty Images)

Imagine what Chicago’s lineup would look like with Chapman or Bregman hitting in the middle of the order and playing Gold Glove defense at third base. Within the past two offseasons, the Cubs had their chances to sign those All-Stars, who lingered on the free-agent market longer than expected.

Hoyer’s baseball operations department viewed each player as a sound investment and lasted into the final rounds with Scott Boras, the high-powered agent who represents both Chapman and Bregman. Those negotiations, however, went down as missed opportunities.

Matt Shaw, the unproven player tapped to play third base, might wind up being the NL’s Rookie of the Year. But the Cubs also could have bought more time for Shaw, the No. 13 pick in the 2023 draft, or upgraded in other areas to lower some of the team’s overall unpredictability.

Shaw started spring training this year understanding that Bregman was a possibility for a front office that often stays engaged on free agents deep into February or even March.

The year before, with a hole at third base, league sources said the Cubs kept Chapman on their radar but never made a formal offer due to budgetary constraints.

Chapman eventually signed a three-year, $54 million contract with the San Francisco Giants. While the Cubs started seven different players at third base last year — all no longer in the organization — Chapman posted 7.1 wins above replacement, per Baseball Reference.

“The Cubs had a lot of interest in me,” Chapman told The Athletic. “They were willing to do a one-year deal with me.

“There was just no way I could take the Cubs’ one-year deal, just for protection purposes. I was definitely considering it. I thought it would have been a good place to play. I thought they were a good team.

“Even if it was two with an opt-out after the first year, I would have really had to take a look at it. But they said with the way their money was, they could only do a one-year. I was just like, ‘That’s just too risky.’”

Boras first placed another client, Cody Bellinger, back with the Cubs before securing Chapman’s deal with the Giants. Chapman played so well in the Bay Area that he wound up signing a six-year, $151 million contract extension last September.


Matt Chapman would have made sense for the Cubs, who couldn’t make him more than a one-year offer because of budget limitations. (Ross D. Franklin / Associated Press)

Bellinger, meanwhile, had a good-but-not-great season with the Cubs, which convinced him to opt in for another year on his current deal. Rather than retain the former MVP, the Cubs traded Bellinger to the New York Yankees last December, a move that lined up with their blockbuster deal to acquire Tucker from the Houston Astros.

In a salary dump, the Cubs gave up Bellinger for Cody Poteet, a 30-year-old pitcher who got designated for assignment last week and was then traded to the Baltimore Orioles for cash considerations.

Internal frustrations resurfaced in February once the Cubs missed on another third baseman. Bregman picked the Red Sox, signing a three-year, $120 million contract that includes a substantial amount of deferred money that lowered the present-day value.

Hoyer was authorized to present Bregman and Boras a four-year deal worth $115 million, according to league sources, which paled in comparison to offers made by the Astros (six years, $156 million) and Detroit Tigers (six years, $171.5 million) as well as the opportunity in Boston.

While thanking the Ricketts family for the freedom to pursue Bregman, Hoyer also made it clear to reporters that this was deemed an exceptional case. The money earmarked for Bregman would not be automatically transferred into this year’s budget for baseball operations.

Hoyer also revealed that the Cubs were around their budget limits last year when ownership gave the approval to sign Bellinger. Their final 2024 payroll wound up ninth in the majors, according to The Associated Press, at almost $240 million, or just slightly over MLB’s luxury-tax threshold.

If Hoyer had to make a special request for Bellinger, then signing another All-Star shortly thereafter would have been out of the question. This was not lost on one of the sport’s most influential agents.

“The winning commitment barometer of a major-league team is the percentage of revenues invested in talent,” Boras said.


Ten years ago, Cubs executives were highlighted in a glowing Bloomberg Businessweek cover story that declared “a sports empire is in bloom.” The major-league club had finished in fifth place five years running, and the franchise had not captured a World Series title since Theodore Roosevelt’s presidential administration. Still, the roaring optimism proved to be accurate.

Theo Epstein, the curse-buster from Boston, had recruited Hoyer to serve as his general manager in a growing front office, and later hired star manager Joe Maddon. Big-name free agents flocked to Chicago for the money and the chance to make history.

Just as the baseball side of the organization had modernized scouting and player development systems to support an elite farm system, Cubs chairman Tom Ricketts and Kenney’s group realized the synergy of a renovated Wrigley Field, which suddenly became the new avatar for a franchise long known as the Lovable Losers.

Kenney delivered the money quote in that Bloomberg Businessweek story: “Basically, my job is fill a wheelbarrow with money, take it to Theo’s office, and dump it.”

The wheelbarrow was big enough to win the 2016 World Series and carry the NL’s highest payroll in 2019, a disappointing season that was the lone playoff miss amid five postseason appearances between 2015 and 2020. But since the fall of what they hoped would be a dynasty, the Cubs have taken a conservative approach while certain NL clubs continue to operate aggressively.

The financials for almost every MLB franchise are opaque, but The Associated Press gave a snapshot on Opening Day 2025 that ranked the Cubs 12th out of 30 clubs with a major-league payroll nearing $193 million, which put them lower than the Arizona Diamondbacks.

That total does not reflect the organization’s entire spend on baseball operations. A team source indicated the Cubs were fifth in that category last year, though the NL is becoming a different kind of arms race.

The Mets, pushed by owner Steve Cohen, and Dodgers, taking advantage of an exceptional TV deal, are both carrying major-league payrolls north of $300 million. The Philadelphia Phillies, led by managing partner John Middleton, have added more investors in recent years as the club pushed its payroll toward the $300 million level.

The Atlanta Braves followed a Wrigleyville blueprint, building The Battery Atlanta around Truist Park, and business is booming. The San Diego Padres just signed Jackson Merrill, a dynamic young center fielder, to a nine-year, $135 million contract extension, which now gives the club six players on nine-figure deals.

“Deficit spending in the National League has definitely accelerated in the past five years,” Kenney said. “This has added pressure to grow revenue in new ways and innovate beyond our comfort zone.”


Fans cheer on Shota Imanaga. Wrigley Field continues to help fuel the Cubs’ robust revenue. (Michael Reaves / Getty Images)

Forbes recently assessed the Cubs at $4.6 billion, the fourth-most valuable franchise in baseball, an astronomical increase from the $845 million purchase price of the team, Wrigley Field and a piece of a regional sports network in 2009. The Ricketts family subsequently sold equity shares to help finance the stadium renovations, but they do not view that as a sustainable strategy for signing free agents and propping up payroll.

Even as valuations soar — the Boston Celtics, an iconic NBA team, recently sold for $6.1 billion — industry sources said the franchise remains a generational asset for the Ricketts family. Navigating this next phase will be a challenge.

“The business model in baseball, it’s worked pretty well for a long time, but there’s a few things right now that are just a little out of kilter,” Ricketts said on 670 The Score during the team’s winter fan festival. “The Dodgers have a lot more resources, naturally, from smart business moves they made years ago. I don’t begrudge them any of that.

“I understand when fans say, ‘How come you don’t spend like that?’ Because they think somehow we have all these dollars that the Dodgers have or the Mets have or the Yankees have and we just keep it. Which isn’t true at all. What happens is we try to break even every year.”

Ricketts clarified his Cubs Convention comments during a recent sit-down interview with CNBC.

“Maybe using the word ‘break even’ wasn’t the way I wanted to say that,” Ricketts told CNBC. “I just want people to know that every dollar that’s spent at the ballpark goes back into putting a more competitive team on the field. Away from that, everyone knows — every Cub fan knows — that we’ve invested roughly a billion dollars into Wrigley Field itself and the neighborhood around, so it’s not a matter of us not investing. We are putting the best team on the field that we can every year.

“Fortunately, for baseball, player development is as important as how much you’re spending on free agents, so we just keep grinding and doing the blocking and tackling that build the organization from the bottom up.”


In 2020, when Hoyer took over for Epstein, the Cubs refused to label it as a rebuild. But they made no secret that there would be changes.

Hoyer dealt with the COVID-19-related budget cuts that forced his group to non-tender Kyle Schwarber and trade Yu Darvish in the middle of a pandemic. When the Cubs began to collapse months later, Hoyer made the bold move to unload Anthony Rizzo, Kris Bryant and Javier Báez in a flurry of deals at the 2021 trade deadline.

All those unpopular and unsentimental decisions eventually left the Cubs without any players remaining from their 2016 World Series team.

But what has surprised some players, agents and rivals is the cautiousness that has followed that period of transition.

“They announced what they were going to do when Jed took over,” said one executive who was granted anonymity to candidly discuss another club. “They were going to take a step back and they have. There was the assumption that once they got to a particular point they would start investing very heavily again. And they’ve probably been a little bit more methodical about it than a lot of people in the industry thought they would.”

The expectation was that Kenney’s wheelbarrow of money would come in once the front office reconstructed a stable foundation. While that has not yet happened in full force, the rival exec said, “They’re arguably the favorites in that division now. They’re still in pretty decent shape even with somewhat more modest spending.”

But big spending is the competitive advantage in a division where every other club routinely collects competitive balance draft picks to stack up more prospects. And if deficit spending, equity sales and deferred money are becoming common practices for the sport’s top teams, then the Cubs’ seeming reluctance to more assertively wield those financial tools becomes noticeable.


Jed Hoyer has yet to lead the Cubs to the postseason. In the final year of his contract, he faces pressure. (Griffin Quinn / Getty Images)

The Cubs’ pursuit of Bregman indicated that the bigger wheelbarrow has yet to arrive. Bregman passed the scouting eye test and the club’s projection model. Third base represented the only spot on the field where the Cubs did not have an established position player. Bregman’s championship experience and baseball IQ could have provided intangible benefits, and he’s close with Tucker after their time together in Houston.

After years of creating a solid major-league nucleus and restocking the farm system, this felt like the moment to strike. Instead, the Cubs whiffed and moved forward with Shaw, a top prospect and one of several talented young players who are being counted on to have breakthrough years.

Hoyer is now in the final year of his contract and under pressure. The rival official pointed to the Tucker trade, one that will be endlessly debated if the Cubs miss the playoffs this year and the Astros turn Cam Smith, the headlining prospect in that deal, into a superstar. The outcome may prove to be a referendum on the Cubs — and whether they’ll continue to face scrutiny for their spending.

“They’re going to have a test case with Kyle Tucker,” the rival executive said. “One extension probably puts all of that discussion to bed. And they have been active in a variety of these conversations. They just haven’t quite landed the player.”

Until they do, an undercurrent of frustration will run through Wrigleyville and social media, and the rumbling over time will only grow louder. Unless this is the year the Cubs win big.

(Illustration: Demetrius Robinson / The Athletic; Photo: Quinn Harris / Getty Images)

The Final Four coaches, scored and ranked: It’s Boomers vs. Millennials

One of the four head coaches left working in the men’s NCAA Tournament will win his first national championship Monday night. It could be Houston’s Kelvin Sampson in his 36th season of running a program at age 69. It could be Duke’s Jon Scheyer in his third at age 37.

Auburn’s Bruce Pearl is on the Sampson side of things — 30th year as a head coach, 65 years old. Florida’s Todd Golden is just getting going, like Scheyer — sixth year as a head coach, 39 years old. It’s difficult to compare the quality of work of careers that are decades apart in length, but that is our charge in advance of Sampson-Scheyer and Pearl-Golden matchups in Saturday’s national semifinals at the Alamodome in San Antonio.

After scoring the coaches in a variety of categories on a four-point scale and ranking them, we may have a hint at which one of them will end up winning it all. Or at least that coach will have this victory as consolation while watching one of the others cut the nets.

Longevity

It’s a worthwhile category of its own, especially considering the way Sampson and Pearl have been able to hang in and thrive in the era of (out-in-the-open) player compensation and player movement.

4: Sampson
3: Pearl
2: Golden
1: Scheyer

Achievement

Sampson is 798-353 — what a way this could be to reach 800. Like Pearl (706-267), Sampson started at a lower level (Montana Tech, Pearl at Southern Indiana) and has done nothing but win at every stop. Sampson is one of 16 coaches to lead two different schools to the Final Four. That and his run of recent dominance at Houston give him the edge. Golden has won at San Francisco and Florida, two programs that aren’t advantaged like Duke. Still, Scheyer is winning more than 80 percent of his games.

4: Sampson
3: Pearl
2: Scheyer
1: Golden


Will Kelvin Sampson pick up win No. 800 in San Antonio? (Jamie Squire / Getty Images)

Mentors

No one is topping the top reference on Scheyer’s resume, Mike Krzyzewski. Sampson learned from a good coach at Washington State, Len Stevens, and then took that program to another level. But he also credited his graduate year under Jud Heathcote at Michigan State — 1979-80, the year after the Magic Johnson-led national championship — as being formative. Pearl was a Tom Davis guy all the way, assisting him at Stanford and Iowa before striking out on his own. Golden played for Randy Bennett at Saint Mary’s and then for Pearl at the Maccabiah Games in Israel in 2009. He later joined Pearl’s staff at Auburn. So yeah, having Pearl as a mentor gives Golden the edge over Pearl.

4: Scheyer
3: Golden
2: Sampson
1: Pearl

Resources and other supporting factors

Who’s doing the most with what they’ve got? Pearl ($5.96 million in pay, by the way) is the one coach here doing unprecedented things at a place that never cared for basketball the way it does now. His is a football school all the way. Yes, that means Pearl and Golden ($3.6 million) both have that sweet SEC football money, but that also means fierce competition for NIL dollars.

Sampson ($4.6 million) has reversed a tradition-rich but moribund program, elevating to the Big 12 and continuing to thrive. Scheyer (reportedly more than $7 million, but Duke is a private school and not subject to open records laws) has a ton of pressure succeeding Krzyzewski, but also every advantage. For the record, none of these programs is believed to be at the very top of the NIL pay scale this season. Cooper Flagg, it should be noted, came in with the national marketability to make a ton of money this season off “actual NIL.”

4: Pearl
3: Sampson
2: Golden
1: Scheyer

NCAA rule following

The fact that no one cares about NCAA rules anymore does not mean no one ever cared — in particular, other coaches who actually followed said rules. Sampson got a five-year show-cause from the NCAA in 2008 for making impermissible phone calls to recruits while at Indiana, the NCAA saying he lied to investigators. That was also the crux of the Pearl case — which started with a recruit at a cookout at his house — that got him fired from Tennessee and given a three-year show cause. Auburn also got four years of probation, and Pearl a two-game suspension, in 2021 after an investigation that involved the FBI.

4: Scheyer
4: Golden
1: Sampson
0: Pearl

Basketball identity

Sampson’s is the clearest and easiest to identify. The Cougars are going to grab your offense, squeeze it, put it in a box and stomp on it, just like his Oklahoma Sooners Final Four team of 23 years ago did. He’s also developed many great point guards. Does he have enough shooters this year to finish the deal for the first time?

Pearl has always been a pressing, high-tempo, self-described “gambling” coach, but to his credit, he listened to son and associate head coach Steven Pearl this season and slowed it way down to maximize his team’s strengths.

Florida and Duke play aesthetically pleasing basketball with size and length as bullying traits. Many of Duke’s best teams over the years have leaned on ferocious man defense, but the prevailing identity is having better players and fitting scheme to their strengths. Which is what smart coaches do.

4: Sampson
3: Pearl
2: Scheyer
1: Golden

Recruiting and development

Take it all together, high school recruiting and portal adds. Golden and Scheyer have been effective in both areas. Scheyer has done a masterful job of building the right team around Flagg — which is actually more impressive than getting Flagg. Duke is going to land superstars until further notice and until whoever’s in charge screws it up.

Golden’s star, Walter Clayton Jr., was the original find of Rick Pitino. Several of his returnees from last season improved significantly. But the two Baby Boomers have long track records of excellence. Big recruits, no-name recruits into stars and portal wins. Johni Broome, the Morehead State transfer who has developed into a national player of the year candidate, tilts it slightly toward Pearl. Recency bias for the win.

4: Pearl
3: Sampson
2: Scheyer
1: Golden

Playing career

Scheyer played four years under Krzyzewski, winning the national championship in 2010 as a senior and second team All-American. Golden was a solid guard at Saint Mary’s. Sampson played for his father, John W. “Ned” Sampson, at Division II Pembroke State (now UNC Pembroke). Pearl didn’t play for Davis at Boston College. He was a student manager and got into coaching from there. Managers work hard, too.

Scheyer: 4
Golden: 3
Sampson: 2
Pearl: 1

Media darlingness

Hey, don’t laugh, this matters! It’s not about whether we like you — it’s about whether you can use us to better your cause. We’re actually very easy to use. Smart coaches know how much this can help with recruits and fans (read: potential donors) as well. Everyone here is good — these are basketball coaches, not football coaches — but Pearl is must see/must listen. You never know what may come out of his mouth. Scheyer seems genuinely interested in giving insightful and revealing answers, which means he understands that media are simply conduits to the people.

Pearl: 4
Scheyer: 3
Golden: 2
Sampson: 1

Final results

Sampson: 24
Pearl: 23
Scheyer: 23
Golden: 19

If these scores apply to the games, we’ll be talking about Houston and Auburn on Monday night, a rematch of the Tigers’ 74-69 win in November at the Toyota Center in Houston. Advantage Sampson? Maybe. But Pearl remains the only known coach in NCAA history to beat a top-five team away from home after two of his players got in a fight on the plane and forced the pilot to turn the plane around.

(Top photo of Todd Golden and Bruce Pearl: John Reed / Imagn Images)

Why tennis media is a fragmented mess, from Grand Slam broadcast rights to social media highlights

Alexandra Eala had the biggest week of her tennis career at the Miami Open in March. She beat three Grand Slam champions — Jelena Ostapenko, Madison Keys and Iga Świątek — on her way to the semifinals, where she had 2024 U.S. Open finalist Jessica Pegula on the ropes in what was ultimately a three-set defeat. Eala, 19, who has been making tennis history for the Philippines for most of her life, was the most surprising star of the tournament.

More surprising, for anyone familiar with the uneasy relationship between tennis and media, was how quickly she became a star on the women’s tennis tour’s YouTube, too. By the Monday after her incredible run, Eala was front and center for “Rally the World,” the WTA’s series of videos in which players declare how the sport lets them express their full selves, launched as part of a rebrand in late February.

“This is my stage to rally a nation,” Eala, who became the highest-ranked Filipino player in WTA history at the end of March, says.

Eala used the Miami Open’s teal and blue courts as her living room for most of that tournament, but the wider stage on which tennis broadcasts itself — across television, streaming and social media — is more often an exercise in restricted views and convoluted entry points. When world No. 3 Coco Gauff, who has as much star power on TikTok as she does on the tennis court, was asked about what she wanted the WTA to improve, she focused on user-generated content: the clips, highlights packages, memes and other media that players and fans make, separate from the official output of the tennis tours or rights holders. The WTA cannot create this itself, because then it wouldn’t be user-generated, but it can follow the outlines of what makes it so compelling.

“Obviously I’m someone who is on social media a lot. A lot more TikToks and following the trends that a lot of the other sports are doing, which I know that WTA has a plan in place … they ask for feedback and that was the main thing I noticed,” Gauff said in a news conference at Indian Wells.

The tension between official and unofficial content — and how the rights and deals are made that decide which is which — are at the center of tennis’ future.


If a tennis fan in the United States wants to watch the next Grand Slam, the French Open at Roland Garros, Paris, they have a few choices. They can buy in-person tickets; they can watch on television; they can watch on a streaming service; or they can watch highlights, either on those services or on a social media channel like YouTube.

Buying in-person tickets is expensive, even before factoring in travel to France. To watch on cable television, they will need to use a Warner Bros. Discovery network, after the company signed a 10-year, $650 million (£503.2m) deal for U.S. broadcast rights to the tournament in June 2024. In April, it announced that eight-time Grand Slam champion Andre Agassi will join as an analyst, for coverage that will air on TNT Sports and TBS. It will also stream on Max. It had previously aired across a fragmented combination of NBC, the Tennis Channel, Tennis Channel+ (its streaming service) and Peacock.

That’s for one Grand Slam. The other three are variously broadcast across ABC, ESPN and the Tennis Channel. For the next rung down, ATP and WTA 1,000 tournaments, the fan could use Tennis Channel. Or, to just watch men’s tournaments, they could subscribe to Tennis TV, the ATP-run streaming service from ATP Media. It launched as a combined service in 2009, but the WTA left the platform in 2016. The WTA has its own WTA TV platform, but it does not operate in the United States.

For highlights, the fan could use television or streaming, or they could use YouTube — through the French Open’s own channel.

This combination of platforms, subscription costs and split services is a feature, rather than a bug, because of how central broadcast media rights are to tennis’ financial ecosystem. ESPN will pay $2.04 billion (£1.58 bn) to air the U.S. Open through 2037, while Wimbledon’s broadcast deal with ABC and ESPN networks comes in at $52.5m per year as of 2024, according to SP Global. Those revenues, along with ticket sales and sponsorships, form the three pillars of how tennis tournaments make money.

At the upper echelons of tennis, media rights revenues take up more of that three-way split; moving down the pyramid of events, they take up less. For the biggest events, that means their value requires protection, which means being officious about broadcast restrictions. One of the main limitations to Gauff’s desire for more social content? Players, who create the product for which media companies pay so much, can’t even share footage of themselves.

At Wimbledon last year, the Australian player Daria Saville launched a petition against the restriction. “It pains me that Grand Slams do not currently permit players and fans to share footage and highlights from matches on their social media platforms,” she wrote. “The opportunity for us to self-promote and inspire a broader audience, particularly young and aspiring athletes, is being denied by this outdated copyright policy.”

Daria Kasatkina, the world No. 12 who recently switched allegiance from Russia to Australia, runs “What The Vlog.” It’s a YouTube channel, produced with Kasatkina’s partner, Natalia Zabiiako, which gives fans an insight into life on the tour and interviews Kasatkina’s fellow players. Kasatkina has also criticized the fact that players can’t share footage of themselves in action. “This is something I a bit don’t agree with, because it’s not like we’re streaming,” she told a couple of reporters at the Australian Open.

“It’s something that happened two weeks ago, plus, it’s me. Goddamn, it’s me playing the match. I was waiting there outside running, and now I cannot use the footage of myself.”

The Grand Slams were contacted for comment. A spokesperson for the All England Lawn Tennis Club, which organizes Wimbledon, said: “It’s important to strike a balance between encouraging fan engagement with The Championships, the players and the sport, while at the same time tackling the growing issue of illegally pirated content and protecting the contractual agreements that are in place with our rights-holding broadcasters who bring a significant amount of value into the tennis ecosystem.”

A spokesperson for the United States Tennis Association (USTA) added: “Our broadcast partnerships are vital to the growth and success of the U.S. Open and the game of tennis in many ways. Together they are the platform through which the US Open is seen by hundreds of millions of fans around the world each year. We understand the evolving universe of player and fan-shared content, and we support athletes’ desires to promote themselves. We’re constantly evaluating how we can make changes and enhancements in these areas to maximize the promotion and growth of our sport, while also ensuring that our agreements with our partners, and their copyrighted material, are protected.”


Myriad tennis players like Coco Gauff have used social media to build a connection with fans beyond the court. (Robert Prange / Getty Images)

Kasatkina said that the WTA has been more permissive about sharing match footage from its events. Marina Storti, chief executive of WTA Ventures, the tour’s commercial arm, said in an interview in February that what players can and can’t share will be a discussion point in future rights negotiations.

The WTA has also introduced “Inside the Tour,” a video series designed to emulate the popularity of player vlogs like Kasatkina’s, on its own YouTube channel.

One Grand Slam has even circumvented its own broadcast agreements in order to attract a wider audience. In January, the Australian Open showed matches for free live on its YouTube channel, but instead of the actual match footage, it used animated characters, like something from a video game. It was a hit, with the viewership increasing from 246,542 over six days for a more basic 2024 version to 1,796,338 in the same timeframe this year.


Innovation in how tennis is broadcast is not easy in a sport with an often traditionalist audience. “I think broadcasting in all sports has stayed the same,” said Farzeen Ghorashy, president at Overtime, in a video interview in February.

“What innovation has there been in broadcasting broadly? The camera angles are the same. The commentators are mostly the same. There’s more simulcasts and visual sort of things, but that doesn’t bring fans into the sport.

“I think if you’re any league that has sold your media rights and it lives on linear television, the average age of the linear television viewers is older, so therefore the fan is going to be older as well.

“So I think all the leagues and rights holders are now thinking about, how do I age down … (and) reach a new audience in a different way.”

Overtime is a media company aimed at Gen Z sports fans which focuses on the NFL and NBA, and claims to have an audience of over 100m people. The ATP Tour recently signed a content partnership to bring its clip-microphone interviews with players to tennis. These kinds of clips, which can be shared endlessly by fans across social media platforms, are a key access point for people who may know someone like Gauff, Ben Shelton, Carlos Alcaraz or Aryna Sabalenka as someone they have seen on social media doing a dance, rather than a champion tennis player.

Other sports, including Formula One, have embraced drivers’ prominence in other spaces, especially on streaming platforms like Twitch. Amazon, which owns Twitch, had a five-year deal for the U.S. Open between 2018 and 2023. It did not renew the deal, and the cross-over opportunity went away. Golf has made strides in embracing YouTube. Direct-to-consumer streaming services, like the one the Tennis Channel launched in November last year, could yet add single-match subscriptions, or one-off payments for compelling rivalries, or other introductory offers. Even a relatively modest monthly payment is not a good deal for someone who only wants to follow one player or just the odd final. But these things don’t yet exist.

Another key entry point is controversy, something which official rights holders don’t always want to lean into. At last year’s Madrid Open, a short clip of Daniil Medvedev asking if the “Illuminati” were responsible for roof closure decisions went viral. It is still up on the Tennis Channel and Tennis TV YouTube channels, but it was copyright-striked on X. These kinds of clips, like the above player interviews, are ways into tennis for fans unfamiliar with the sport and its protagonists, but more often than not rightsholders’ contracts are written so restrictively that they limit discoverability.

Fans generating these kinds of entry points meet similar obstacles. The Sabinelisickifansss YouTube account racked up 27,000 subscribers before being shut down last July for repeated copyright strikes, in which the official rightsholder for a clip makes a complaint to YouTube. The account started as a way of sharing footage of the German player and former Wimbledon finalist Sabine Lisicki, but grew into a showcase for controversial moments on the WTA Tour more widely.

It became popular with videos like “Top 10 most HATED WTA tennis players” and “Double Bounce in WTA Tennis (No Sportsmanship at all…) ( (DRAMA),” but sailed close to the wind with the amount of footage it used without actually owning any rights. After a series of complaints from Wimbledon, and previous copyright strikes from other tournaments and governing bodies, it was shut down.

The account was first set up by Jacky, 25, who lives in Hong Kong. He started it seven years ago, when he was a student. In a phone interview in February, he said he was “shocked” when the account was closed down, despite receiving several warnings. Last year, a letter sent to the European Union and signed by the Premier League, Sky and Warner Bros Discovery, among others, claimed that the total cost of piracy to sports rights holders is $28.3bn each year. That complaint was primarily about the live streaming of events on unofficial streams, rather than short clips from matches that happened, in some cases, years ago.

Jacky said that the tours’ limits on what they will post don’t serve fans’ desire for controversy. “They will not put up negative things like the worst player in history. But I think the WTA audience wants to know which player played really badly in a Grand Slam or what’s the biggest losing streak on the WTA Tour.

“This tennis YouTube is doing something official YouTube accounts cannot provide, and Grand Slam highlights are often only like two or three minutes long.”

He decided to start a new version of his YouTube account after around a month away. He said that he’s a lot more careful now about sharing footage from Grand Slams, but feels strongly that tennis fans are often underserved by the quality and quantity of highlights that is freely available from the majors. Highlights on the ATP and WTA channels are made using artificial intelligence, which can capture exciting points but often leads to a package that gives a fan absolutely no idea of how a match played out, jumping from halfway through with one player leading to the other player having match point.

They are also very short (official Grand Slam channels, most often the Australian Open, do offer longer packages and sometimes full matches) and big matches sometimes don’t get full fanfare. Last year’s Madrid Open final between Świątek and Sabalenka, widely regarded as the best match of the year and a rare final meeting for the two best women’s players in the world, got the full-match treatment…

…On Christmas Day, almost eight months after it was played.


Joint broadcast rights for the ATP and WTA Tours would simplify all of this. This is in place at the four Grand Slams, but a long-discussed commercial merger between WTA Ventures and the ATP into a new company called Tennis Ventures is yet to be finalized. The proposed merger would not come with a 50-50 revenue split between the two tours at present, with the ATP slated to receive closer to 80 percent of revenue from tournaments, media rights and sponsorships.

“Everyone sees the opportunity to align more closely the men and the women sport both commercially, but also from a marketing perspective,” Storti said, adding that talks remain ongoing. “And we know we see the opportunity to help grow the sport. I think it would benefit everyone — the players, the tournaments.”

Tennis is also not alone in reaching a sports media inflection point, as media companies try to figure out how to balance the decline in what has made them money in the past (linear broadcast and cable) and the rise of what could make them money in the future, but largely hasn’t yet (streaming.) MLB and ESPN will terminate their broadcast deal, which was supposed to run until 2028, at the end of the 2025 season. Sources briefed on ESPN’s thinking told The Athletic that ESPN, which would have paid the league $550 million for the three remaining seasons, saw that figure as too far above market value.

The sport is also still recovering from the impact of Covid-19, which was financially ruinous; the renewal of media rights deals in its wake has been vital.

In the short-term, tennis tournaments and tours can see that high-value rights deals plus intense media restrictions equals high demand for pay television and in-person tickets. But in the long-term, as streaming inevitably overtakes cable, those restrictions — which shut out fans from discovering the sport, as well as consistently watching it — could come home to roost.

If those broadcast deals decline in value, and other services don’t fill the shortfall — because their figures show there are fewer fans waiting to watch on the other side of that decline, because their routes into the sport have been closed off — tennis tournaments will suddenly find themselves at the head of a broken system.

The WTA’s increased focus on its players’ stories, and acting with speed when a new one emerges, like with Eala in Miami, is one example of a move to fight against that tide. The Australian Open’s cartoon players and the ATP’s Overtime partnership are another; so are the social media accounts of players like Gauff and Kasatkina.

It’s the friction between these on-ramps for fans and the full tournament experience that will be critical for tennis, if it really does want to “rally the world.”

(Illustration: Kelsea Petersen / The Athletic / Getty Images)

Olivia Miles’ transfer portal entrance highlights power shift in women’s basketball

The top of the 2025 WNBA Draft experienced a major shakeup when Olivia Miles entered the transfer portal. Miles was projected to be the No. 2 pick in April’s draft and likely fall no lower than third overall, but instead she has elected to extend her college career, just not at Notre Dame.

Even though the era of the pandemic bonus year has essentially ended in college basketball as eligible players had to be on rosters during the 2020-21 season, which was when the current crop of fourth-year seniors was in high school, eligibility decisions are still at play for WNBA prospects. There are still medical redshirts, which is why Miles can play for another year because she missed the 2023-24 season with a torn ACL. Furthermore, juniors who turn 22 during the year of the draft have the option to go pro or remain in school.

Miles’ decision not only represents the emerging power of player agency in the women’s basketball landscape, but it is particularly interesting strictly from a basketball consideration, as she is beloved by WNBA talent evaluators. The former Notre Dame guard was all but guaranteed to be a lottery pick, with general managers calling her the safest pick in the draft beyond UConn’s Paige Bueckers. Her massive improvement as a 3-point shooter (24.6 percent before the injury compared to 40.8 percent after) was the tipping point when combined with her already excellent facilitation as a lead guard.

In theory, Miles’ stock has nowhere to go but down if her shooting doesn’t remain consistent at this level. That indicates that when she gets picked isn’t nearly as important as how much money she can make in the process, where she goes, and how her body feels after her ACL injury.

The WNBA is currently negotiating a new collective bargaining agreement with the players’ association that could potentially triple individual salaries. Rather than lock herself into a four-year rookie contract totaling about $350,000, Miles could wait to enter the league until 2026 and possibly recoup that figure within the first two seasons. Agents have been advising college players across the country with an additional year of eligibility to stay in school and reap the financial rewards of the next CBA.

If Miles makes her transfer decision within the next week, she could also secure name, image and likeness commitments before the final hearing in the House v. NCAA lawsuit on April 7. This is the last gasp for unregulated “pay-for-play” deals with athletes before they are assessed by an NCAA clearinghouse. Given Miles’ status as a two-time All-American — the only other multi-time All-American to ever enter the portal was LSU’s Aneesah Morrow, who left DePaul — Miles will presumably be raking in cash from collectives.

It’s worth remembering that Miles’ external sponsorships will likely stay with her when she turns professional, supplementing her WNBA salary. However, collectives affiliated with a university will only be interested in her as a collegian; thus, this is her last opportunity to pull in that particular revenue stream.

Most WNBA executives didn’t cite Miles’ health as a concern in the lead-up to the draft, as she has suffered only one significant injury and appeared to be in excellent form during the 2024-25 season. However, she told The Athletic in Birmingham that she is not close to where she wants to be post-injury.

“My physical shape could be better,” Miles said. “This injury, it’s a long, long process. Even after you’re healed, getting the rest of your body to catch up. I would say I’m not even 75 percent of the way there yet.”

Taking the leap from college to the WNBA requires a certain level of confidence not only in a player’s skills, but in their body. If Miles doesn’t feel physically herself, it wouldn’t be the right time to play against grown women in a physical league. That’s a similar calculation that Azzi Fudd had to make. The redshirt junior opted out of the 2025 draft to return to the Huskies despite also being a projected first-round pick. Fudd has barely played one full healthy season at UConn and could stand to get stronger before joining the W.

Miles also has more to accomplish at the collegiate level. She ended her season in the Sweet 16, just as she has every full season at Notre Dame, which was short of what the Irish — who were ranked No. 1 in the country on Feb. 17 — had hoped for. There were always questions about the fit between Miles and another ball-dominant guard in Hannah Hidalgo. Now, Miles can find another team where she is the full-time point guard and with more returning talent. Even if Miles returned, Notre Dame was losing half its rotation (Sonia Citron, Maddy Westbeld, Liatu King and Liza Karlen) and bringing in one top-100 recruit.

Flau’jae Johnson, a draft-eligible junior, said she wanted to do more winning before leaving LSU, despite already being a national champion.

“Once you taste the national championship, you want more,” Johnson said after losing in the Elite Eight. “And I feel like that national championship I had (as a freshman), yeah, I was a big factor in it, but there were bigger factors in that. I want my own one. Where I lead the team.”

Ta’Niya Latson, who was a 2025 All-American with Miles and Johnson, has experienced enough individual accolades at Florida State. She also entered the portal instead of the WNBA draft, having hit a repeated NCAA Tournament first-weekend ceiling with the Seminoles.

There will always be a draw to playing in the NCAA Tournament, one that the WNBA can’t match, and there are only so many years when players can take part in it. All of the aforementioned athletes have been deprived of postseason experience due to injury. Miles missed two tournaments, Fudd missed one and was ill during another, and Latson was injured during her freshman postseason.

This is a situation JuJu Watkins will have to consider when she returns from her ACL injury. Rather than go pro in 2027, she could stay in college a fifth year as a medical redshirt to get back the March time she lost, depending on what USC has accomplished to that point.

Miles’ decision doesn’t exist in a vacuum. It is representative of all the financial, medical and legacy-related questions that female athletes are confronting in a time when they have more agency than ever. The balance of power is shifting, and colleges and WNBA teams are now at the mercy of the players.

(Photo: Michael Reaves / Getty Images)

From UberEats driver to NHL goalie: Inside the unlikeliest start in hockey history

Three years ago, Brandon Halverson had all but given up on his hockey dream.

He was delivering UberEats and groceries and working on a farm. He sold his truck. He borrowed money from his parents. Whatever it took to scrape out enough money for rent.

Two weeks ago, he stepped into the net with the Tampa Bay Lightning for the first time as an NHL starter — nearly 11 years after being drafted as a highly touted prospect, and more than seven years after his only other appearance in the league.

From toiling away with a last-place team in Germany’s second division, a tiny club on the verge of relegation that played on an outdoor rink in below-freezing temperatures, to begging a coach in North America’s third-rung ECHL for a training camp tryout, a final Hail-Mary shot at his dream.

Through numerous injuries, several of which required surgery, and wondering multiple times whether he had reached the end of his career. Through tough talks, and tears, and mental health struggles.

His path to that start for the Lightning might be one of the most improbable in hockey history.

“It’s been a very long road,” said Halverson, who turned 29 last weekend. “I’m just happy that after all of everything that I’ve gone through that I was able to start a game (in the NHL). That was the goal in my mind this entire time, was to get that actual start.”


Halverson was 9 when he knew he wanted to be a goalie. He grew up in a working-class family in Traverse City, Mich., where his father, Paul, — a former boxer — put in hard early morning hours as a construction worker.

When the city landed an NAHL junior team in 2005, the Halversons decided to billet players. The first to stay with them was Jeremy Kaleniecki, a 19-year-old goalie who quickly became Halverson’s idol and surrogate big brother. They played countless games of mini sticks with balls of tape in the living room when they weren’t on the ice. Kaleniecki nicknamed Halverson “Fuzz Ball” after his mess of blonde hair.

While Kaleniecki’s playing career ended after that season, leading him to become a local goalie coach, Halverson’s took off. He rapidly grew into a gangly 6-foot-4 teenager and used the athletic aggressive moves he had picked up from his much smaller billet brother to attract the attention of professional scouts.

In June 2014 Halverson was drafted by the New York Rangers with the penultimate pick of the second round — higher than current starting NHL goalies Igor Shesterkin, Ilya Sorokin and Elvis Merzlikins — despite having only 19 games of experience at the major-junior level.

Halverson’s stock continued to rise over the next two seasons; in 2014-15, he won 40 games to help the Sault St. Marie Greyhounds to the OHL’s best regular-season record before they lost in the playoffs to Connor McDavid’s powerhouse Erie Otters. He also made the United States’ world junior team in consecutive years, winning a bronze medal in early 2016 alongside the next generation of American stars in Auston Matthews, Matthew Tkachuk and Zach Werenski.

Later that year, at age 19, Halverson signed an NHL entry-level contract to join the Rangers, an Original Six franchise, with a $92,500 signing bonus. He had made it. But he wasn’t prepared for what came next.

“It was so much so soon for him,” Kaleniecki says now.

The transition to minor-league hockey is often brutal, between the punishing bus rides, packed game schedule and low pay. It’s a meat grinder of a system that leaves many young players behind, whether through cuts or demotions to even lower levels.

When Halverson turned pro in 2016, the Rangers were a perennial contender team with future Hall of Fame goalie Henrik Lundqvist leading the way. They didn’t hesitate to bring in hardened veteran goalies to challenge their kids for minutes, making for a very competitive environment in the minors.

As one of the youngest goalies in his first pro season, Halverson had some tough games early with the Hartford Wolf Pack, to the point he ended up getting sent down to the Greenville Swamp Rabbits of the ECHL for most of the next two seasons.

He struggled with the adversity and conditions, to the point that his mental health took a turn for the worse. At one point, Kaleniecki was concerned enough to hop on a plane to South Carolina to help.

“You take somebody who’s a high prospect who needs just some fostering and development,” Kalenicki said, explaining that in the ECHL goalies often don’t have a dedicated coach to work with them. “Then you compound that with adding in multiple competitors all vying for the same thing. And it kind of becomes a toxic environment. You know, toxic mentally.”


In his third season, Halverson ended up hurting his knee. He tried to play through it, rather than miss time, but he lost his spot to older, more experienced goalies.

He now realizes how much he was struggling, but he explains that he didn’t reach out to the team or league for help, believing he could tough out the challenges as he had in junior.

“I knew there was some sort of thing you can call and reach out for (help),” Halverson said, referring to a players-only phone line operated by the Professional Hockey Players’ Association, the union that represents minor-league players. “But I was just like, ‘I know what I have to do.’ Even though I’m incredibly depressed.”

By the end of his three-year, entry-level contract, Halverson had played 50 games in the AHL, 63 in the ECHL, and only 13 minutes with the Rangers as a mid-game fill-in for Lundqvist in February 2017 after another goalie forgot his passport and missed the initial call-up.


Prior to his first career start, Halverson’s only NHL appearance came as a third-period replacement for the Rangers in February 2017. (Jana Chytilova / Freestyle Photography / Getty Images)

At age 23, New York cut him loose.

Halverson’s next few years are a blur for him now. There were more injuries, including a badly broken wrist that cost him a full season. More thrilling call-ups and heartbreaking cuts. More packing up his life and moving to a new city only to once again return home to an existence of odd jobs and unpaid bills.

In 2019-20, with his ECHL club toiling in last place and the AHL seeming further away than ever, Halverson decided to leave midseason for mental health reasons. At that point, his father met with him for a heart-to-heart to discuss whether the toll was worth it.

“Are you sure you want to keep doing this?” his father asked.

“He was only saying that because he’s being a good dad,” Halverson recalled later. “Just advising me what he thinks is best. I was like, ‘Dad, it just eats away at me. It’s on my mind all the time, every single day. I’ve gotten in my car at work, all I could think about was playing in an NHL game. I don’t think my body and my mind can rest until this happens. I’m gonna keep going forward.’”

That led to nearly two years away to heal his body and mind. After separate surgeries on both his knee and wrist, Halverson tried to make money however he could, delivering UberEats meals and groceries. He also took shifts at a friend’s farm where, with one arm in a cast, he helped build a barn and tended the greenhouse.

Meanwhile, to get ice time, he started training beer-league goalies at 11 p.m. on Wednesdays — including some who were still learning to skate.

Prior to the 2022-23 season, Halverson received a tryout offer from a team in Germany’s top division. He flew overseas and the team ran some tests on his battered body. They indicated they intended to give him a contract, Halverson recalled, to the point that he turned down a competing offer from a British Elite Ice Hockey League squad.

When the German team then cut him before he had played a game, he suddenly had nowhere to go. Five thousand miles from home, Halverson broke down sobbing.

“I’ve never done that before,” he said. “It’s just always been one thing after another in my career. I never could stick it with New York. I never could stick it anywhere else. And there was always something happening, something happening. And when they told me that, my whole body just fell apart and I just wasn’t doing good.”

That was how he ended up in Bayreuth, a German city of 74,000 an hour north of Nuremberg. The pay was paltry, he couldn’t even play some games due to league rules limiting the number of import players, and the second-division team was relegated due to financial issues at the end of the 2022-23 season.

Really, it was the end of the line in pro hockey. But hockey was all he had.

“That was quite a different world for me,” Halverson said. “In my head, I’m just like, ‘This is gonna make for a great story.’ So I just kept working hard and put my head down.”


When Halverson returned home to Traverse City in summer 2023, he was desperate to find ice wherever he could. Kaleniecki helped, bringing him out to skates in Michigan. So did Jon Elkin, a well-known NHL goalie coach who had worked with Halverson in junior.

Halverson also called the Orlando Solar Bears’ Matt Carkner, one of many minor-league coaches who had cut him in the past, and said he wanted a chance to attend camp and beat out their two incumbent goalies.

He told the Solar Bears staff this would be his last attempt to play pro. It was this or retirement.

“He was the hardest worker every single day. And with his ability, his size, his work ethic in preparation, he clearly earned his opportunity to sign with us,” Orlando goalie coach Nathan Craze said, recalling how intensely Halverson dug into video sessions of Solars Bears practices and their upcoming opponents. “But the biggest thing for me was he really found the love of playing again.”

And he started to win. After a successful first few months, Halverson was called up on a tryout deal to the Syracuse Crunch, the Lightning’s AHL affiliate. A late-November shutout — his first ever at that level — got the team’s attention, earning him an AHL contract. By the end of the 2023-24 season, Halverson had posted a 7-3-3 record with a .913 save percentage for Syracuse and, more incredibly, started for the team during the AHL playoffs.


Brandon Halverson and Jeremy Kaleniecki during an on-ice session. (via Jeremy Kaleniecki)

This season, he has continued to justify the Crunch’s faith in giving him their No. 1 job, going 18-10-8 with a .913 save percentage in 37 appearances. In January, he was named an AHL All-Star. A month later, the Lightning signed him to a two-year, two-way NHL contract that guarantees him $300,000 next season.

It’s a long way from where he was even two years ago, when he couldn’t secure a league minimum $575-a-week offer in the ECHL.

Halverson credits his parents, Paul and Jennifer, and a newfound close relationship with God for helping get him here. He also knows he couldn’t have done it without his big billet brother, who watched him get his first NHL start against Utah HC last week with a lump in his throat.

Little Fuzz Ball had done it.

“To be honest, I think that’s probably the most nervous and excited I’ve been for anything in hockey in my life,” Kaleniecki said. “It’s somebody that is truly family. And you’ve seen the struggles. You’ve been a part of it with them … you know what they’ve gone through. It was hard to hold (the emotions) in. It’s just one of the coolest moments in my life in hockey.”

The game didn’t go the way Halverson wanted, as he allowed five goals in a 6-4 loss in Salt Lake City. Despite the outcome, though, Halverson’s phone blew up with congratulatory messages throughout the night. One of the texts was from Craze, who told Halverson to be proud of where he had come from, and how far he had come. “That’s something no one can ever take away from you,” he wrote. “And this is only the start.”

Halverson knows nothing is guaranteed for him with the Lightning. His start last week was to cover for backup Jonas Johansson, who was away from the team for family reasons, so he knew his NHL stay wouldn’t be a long one.

But after everything he’s been through, he feels ready for what’s next.

“I try not to think about what’s gonna happen,” Halverson said over the phone last week. “I’m here another day. Great. If I’m leaving tomorrow, great. I get to go down and get back to work and play whatever game I’m gonna be in next. So I’m just happy and thankful.”

The very next day, Halverson was reassigned to Syracuse.

His first start back? A 1-0 shutout, his fifth of the season.

(Illustration: Demetrius Robinson / The Athletic. Photos: Dave Reginek / NHLI via Getty Images, Peter Creveling / Imagn Images)

MLB Power Rankings: Rangers, Yankees on the rise; Dodgers are right where you think they are

By Tim Britton, Johnny Flores Jr. and Andy McCullough

Every week,​ we​ ask a selected group of our baseball​ writers​ — local and national — to rank the teams from first to worst. Here are the collective results, with the average rankings of our panel in parentheses.

The first weekend of the baseball season offered its usual cornucopia of familiar sights and unexpected delights. Shohei Ohtani sent a baseball soaring over the fence at Dodger Stadium; Aaron Judge sent four of his own into orbit in the Bronx. Zack Wheeler looked sharp. Paul Skenes threw hard. Matt Chapman still knows how to pick it. The Braves called up Jesse Chavez.

All of those could have been predicted. But raise your hand if you’d heard of Kameron Misner before last week. Or if you thought Rafael Devers would spend all weekend whiffing. Or if you knew the biggest story in the sport would involve something called a “torpedo bat.”

It’s the time of year when every team still can be optimistic, both about the things they expected and some that have caught them by surprise. Here’s a look at the most encouraging sign from the season’s opening weekend for all 30 teams.

GO DEEPER

MLB Preseason Power Rankings: Where is your favorite team starting the 2025 season?


Record: 6-0
Preseason Power Ranking: 1

Most encouraging sign: Uh, everything?

Roki Sasaki hasn’t been throwing strikes. Mookie Betts hasn’t been able to keep down solid food. Max Muncy hasn’t been making much contact. So far, none of it has really mattered. The Dodgers swept the first two series of the season, taking down the Tigers after downing the Cubs twice in Japan. Ohtani looks like himself. So does Freddie Freeman (although he was not in Monday’s lineup because of a tweak to his surgically-repaired ankle). Betts returned from his gnarly stomach bug to swat a walkoff homer. Michael Conforto has lengthened the lineup. The summer figures to be a delight for Dodgers fans — and a nightmare for all the clubs visiting Chavez Ravine. — Andy McCullough

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Shohei Ohtani leads MLB players in jersey sales, six Dodgers crack top 20 list

Record: 3-0
Preseason Power Ranking: 7

Most encouraging sign: Either the Yankees own magic bats or their lineup hits for enough power to make everyone believe they own magic bats

The biggest story of opening weekend was the Yankees’ use of so-called torpedo bats, which move the barrel down from the end of the bat to a spot closer to the handle. New York smashed 15 home runs in three games against the Brewers, or more long balls than the Mets had hits over the weekend.

The bats are legal, and the Yankees aren’t the only team using them. But New York’s lineup overwhelmed the Brewers so comprehensively that hitters around the league are intrigued. Of course, Judge used a boring old normal bat to slug four homers in three games. Imagine that guy with a magic bat. — Tim Britton

Record: 3-2
Preseason Power Ranking: 10

Most encouraging sign: Wyatt Langford took a step toward taking the leap

The Rangers brass believes its postseason-missing campaign in 2024 was an aberration and the championship season of 2023 should become more of the norm. Part of the reason is Langford, who was drafted No. 4 that summer. The 23-year-old outfielder held his own as a rookie last season, with 16 homers and an 111 OPS+ in 134 games. Texas believes his ceiling is much higher than that.

In the first weekend of the season, Langford’s five-hit series helped the Rangers knock off the Red Sox. If Langford approaches his potential, a Texas offense that already includes Corey Seager, Marcus Semien and Joc Pederson will be that much more intimidating. — McCullough

Record: 0-5
Preseason Power Ranking: 2

Most encouraging sign: An 0-4 start in the NL East actually portends greatness

Atlanta is just the ninth team in the last five seasons to start the year 0-4, and five of those teams have resided in the NL East. You might think, given what you know, that starting 0-4 is not optimal, and that starting 0-4 in a typically difficult division like the NL East would be especially troublesome. But it’s basically the opposite.

The other four NL East teams to start 0-4 since 2021 are:

• The 2024 Mets, who went to the NLCS
• The 2022 Phillies, who went to the World Series
• The 2021 Braves, who won the World Series
• The 2024 Marlins, who are the exception that proves the rule.

— Britton

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

MLB suspends Braves’ Jurickson Profar 80 games for PEDs

Record: 3-1
Preseason Power Ranking: 4

Most encouraging sign: Jesús Luzardo looked like his best self

While the Phillies are running it back with mostly the same lineup, their deal for Luzardo feels like it went under the radar in the winter. Filling in a fifth starter role that was problematic for long stretches of 2024 for Philadelphia, Luzardo went and struck out 11 Nationals in five innings. In short, he pitched like he did for most of the ’23 season with the Marlins, when All-Star games and Cy Young votes appeared on his horizon. If that’s the version of Luzardo the Phillies get to round out their rotation, they can be even better than the 95-win outfit they were a season ago. — Britton

Record: 2-2
Preseason Power Ranking: 3

Most encouraging sign: The offense still looks dangerous

After leading the sport in runs last season, Arizona let two crucial hitters, Christian Walker and Pederson, depart in free agency. The team asked a new addition, Josh Naylor, to replace Walker at first base, with holdover Pavin Smith taking Pederson’s at-bats as designated hitter. Naylor and Smith appeared up to the task against the Cubs over the weekend. Naylor drove in three runs and scored three more. Smith clubbed three doubles. The four home runs from Eugenio Suárez didn’t hurt, either. The Diamondbacks may not be able to overtake the Dodgers, but they can hang with anyone. — McCullough

Record: 5-0
Preseason Power Ranking: 13

Most encouraging sign: The back-end starters looked sharp

San Diego’s four-game sweep of Atlanta provided a reminder to anyone who had forgotten: No team pushed the Dodgers harder last season than the Padres. Even if San Diego did not spend to keep up with L.A. this winter, the top-end talent is still there. With Joe Musgrove out for the season and Yu Darvish on the shelf with an elbow injury, the team will need Nick Pivetta and Randy Vásquez to help keep the rotation afloat behind Dylan Cease and Michael King. Pivetta and Vásquez combined for 13 innings of scoreless baseball against Atlanta. — McCullough

Record: 1-4
Preseason Power Ranking: 6

Most encouraging sign: Kristian Campbell fit right in

In his first series in the big leagues, Campbell showed why the Red Sox maneuvered their infield around to make room for the 23-year-old (and why they appear willing to commit to a long-term contract extension for him). Of the six hits he picked up in four games against the Rangers, three were for extra bases (including his first major-league homer), and he showcased his defensive versatility by starting a game in left field. Ask Xander Bogaerts and Jackie Bradley Jr., and even Mookie Betts what it’s like to be a young, unproven player on a win-now roster in Boston. For one weekend, Campbell — the first in a long line of prospects slated to debut for the Red Sox soon — made it look easy. — Britton

Record: 2-2
Preseason Power Ranking: 5

Most encouraging sign: The rotation has a chance

It’s a tradition for teams to throw their best starter on Opening Day, followed by their second best and third best, etc. The Mets, foremost keepers of that custom as evidenced by their ridiculous record on Opening Day, decided this year to zag: In their opening series with Houston, they started pitchers who ranked fifth, sixth and seventh in the hierarchy at the start of spring training.

Sure, injuries drove that decision. But New York went with Clay Holmes, Tylor Megill and Griffin Canning against the Astros, and they actually pitched pretty well. Megill and Canning, in particular, cruised for stretches by shifting their pitch mixes and ditching those that didn’t work for them in 2024. The Mets earned some benefit of the doubt by maximizing Sean Manaea and Luis Severino last year, and they might be at it again. — Britton

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Can the Mets’ Francisco Lindor start hot this time? He’s wondering, too

Record: 3-2
Preseason Power Ranking: 9

Most encouraging sign: Adley Rutschman went yard twice

A lot of Baltimore’s limp toward the finish line in 2024 derived from Rutschman’s prolonged second-half slump: He had a .585 OPS after the break, barely cracking a .200 average and hitting all of three home runs.

He nearly matched that power total on Opening Day, when he went deep twice in Toronto. The Orioles have enough young talent to withstand an unexpectedly down season from someone, somewhere. But Rutschman and Gunnar Henderson are the driving forces of that position-player core — the duo that lifts the ceiling of this group from postseason participant to World Series challenger. — Britton

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

The Windup: An unbelievable Opening Day streak

Record: 2-2
Preseason Power Ranking: 8

Most encouraging sign: Jose Altuve is still Jose Altuve — at the plate

Altuve’s transition from second base to left field has featured plenty of hiccups. He biffed several low-stress plays in the Grapefruit League during spring training. It will still take him time to adjust to fielding near Daikin Park’s Crawford Boxes. The team may need to remove him for defensive purposes later in games, as manager Joe Espada did on Sunday. But Altuve can still hit better than almost every other person on the planet. In a season-opening series victory against the Mets, Altuve collected five hits in 11 at-bats. With Alex Bregman and Kyle Tucker gone, the lineup requires hearty contributions from Altuve more than ever. — McCullough

Record: 2-3
Preseason Power Ranking: 11

Most encouraging sign: Andrés Muñoz still has it

The 2025 Mariners looked a lot like the Mariners of recent vintage in a four-game sample against the Athletics. The rotation is strong despite the absence of George Kirby; Logan Gilbert demonstrated why he is a trendy Cy Young Award candidate with seven innings of one-run baseball on Opening Day. The lineup, of course, is less daunting. Seattle will need Muñoz, an All-Star reliever in 2024, to lock down as many save opportunities as he can. Muñoz bookended the Athletics series with crisp performances, sitting down six of the seven batters he faced. — McCullough

Record: 3-4
Preseason Power Ranking: 12

Most encouraging sign: Kyle Tucker is that guy

On Saturday, Tucker came within one triple of the cycle. The next day, his three-run homer in the eighth inning gave the Cubs a 97 percent chance of winning. That’s exactly the player that Tucker is. On any given day of the week, he gives you a strong chance to win, whether that’s with his defense, bat or speed. If the Cubs manage to get out of the 83-win cellar, it’ll be because Kyle Tucker does Kyle Tucker things for a full campaign. — Johnny Flores Jr.

Record: 3-2
Preseason Power Ranking: 18

Most encouraging sign: Is Bo Bichette back?

A series of maladies to his right leg undercut Bichette’s production from late 2023 through all of last season. (Bichette’s career OPS before his knee injury in August 2023 was .834; since his recovery it was .625 through the end of last season.) In the opening series with Baltimore, the shortstop in his platform season picked up seven hits, including two doubles, and scored four times.

When Bichette and Vlad Guerrero Jr. have both been at their best, the Blue Jays tend to win 90-plus games, as they did in 2021 and 2022. Toronto has one more shot to put it all together behind that duo this year. — Britton

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Blue Jays pitcher Max Scherzer placed on 15-day IL with thumb inflammation

Record: 3-1
Preseason Power Ranking: 20

Most encouraging sign: Justin Verlander looked closer to 40 than 45

Verlander made his Giants debut a little over a month after his 42nd birthday. It was only five innings, but Verlander subdued the Reds with his fastball. His velocity touched 96 mph. He generated six whiffs with the heater. All of this is encouraging for a club that will rely upon its arms and defense to stay within striking distance of a postseason berth. But the bigger question will come as the season progresses: Can Verlander continue to hold off Father Time? — McCullough

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Justin Verlander, Astros had ‘mutual interest’ in reunion during offseason

Record: 1-3
Preseason Power Ranking: T-16

Most encouraging sign: Spencer Torkelson might be putting it together

By this point, it’s no secret that this is something of a make-or-break season for former No. 1 overall pick Spencer Torkelson. The former Arizona State slugger largely forced his way into Detroit’s 2025 plans with a standout spring (.340/.389/.680) and picked up right where he left off to begin the season. Four hits, including one double and one homer, as well as four walks against the defending World Series champions are a major development for Torkelson. It’s the type of performance that will keep him on the roster, even as the Tigers begin to see the likes of Wenceel Perez and Matt Vierling come off the IL. — Flores 

Record: 3-1
Preseason Power Ranking: 14

Most encouraging sign: The rotation holdovers held it down over the weekend

Before Drew Rasmussen returned this week, before Shane McClanahan comes back down the line, before the Rays have all the makings of a shutdown rotation — the guys who kept them in it last year looked just fine again over the weekend. The trio of Ryan Pepiot, Zach Littell and Taj Bradley combined to allow four earned runs in 18 innings, striking out 22 and walking one. That’s the kind of ratio that plays regardless of how much smaller your new home ballpark is.

Rasmussen and McClanahan (along with Shane Baz, who came back in the second half last season) certainly raise the level of what the Rays can do this season. But the three holdovers from last year make this a dangerously deep rotation as well. — Britton

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Rays prepare for a sunny season of home-field challenges (and maybe home-field advantages)

Record: 0-4
Preseason Power Ranking: T-16

Most encouraging sign: Joe Ryan’s return from injury

In his first start since August, Ryan posted five innings of one-run ball with no walks and five strikeouts. It was an encouraging sign for the 29-year-old, who missed much of last year’s second half due to a season-ending grade 2 teres major sprain. The Twins will need these kinds of starts to make up for a lackluster winter, in which they did not make any free agent moves until well into February. Much like the Mariners out west, if the bats are going to struggle to put together hits, it’ll be on the starters to keep other teams in line and give the team just enough opportunities to make a difference. That Ryan was able to look mostly like his old self is a strong sign in that regard. — Flores 

Record: 2-2
Preseason Power Ranking: 21

Most encouraging sign: Kyle Manzardo’s bat

For what feels like years, the Guardians have been searching for another complementary hitter to pair with José Ramírez. Franmil Reyes went from hitting in the middle of their order to playing in Japan, the Josh Bell experiment didn’t work and Josh Naylor is no longer in Cleveland. It’s only three games, but Manzardo looked like the hitter that the Guardians need, slugging two homers over Cleveland’s first three games. It’s the type of stabilizing presence that could carry the Guardians into another AL Central title and perhaps even a longer postseason run. — Flores 

Record: 0-4
Preseason Power Ranking: 15

Most encouraging sign: Freddy Peralta looks like Freddy Peralta

The Yankees’ lineup may have thrashed the rest of Milwaukee’s staff, but the same can’t be said about Peralta, who turned in five innings of two-run ball on Opening Day. With news of Aaron Civale being placed on the IL, the Brewers are down to just two established starters, Peralta and Nestor Cortes. For Milwaukee to stay afloat in the NL Central until Jose Quintana, Tobias Myers and Brandon Woodruff all make their season debuts, it’ll be on Peralta to provide stability every fifth day. Five solid innings against one of baseball’s best offenses is a step in that direction. — Flores 

Record: 2-2
Preseason Power Ranking: 19

Most encouraging sign: Jonathan India at leadoff

While the Royals still feel a bit like Bobby Witt Jr. and company, the addition of India provides Kansas City with another bat to give the lineup a bit more length. If at least one of the Royals’ 5-9 hitters (10-for-56 with 11 strikeouts) can turn into a serviceable bat, the team can go from being in the bottom half leaguewide on offense to something more middle-of-the-pack. India goes a long way in helping the team get there. — Flores 

Record: 3-1
Preseason Power Ranking: 24

Most encouraging sign: Nolan Arenado might still have it

After spending what felt like the entire offseason in an awkward trade limbo, Arenado came out and reminded everyone of the player that he can still be. Over three games, he authored five hits, three of which went for extra bases. He got the curtain-call treatment from the St. Louis faithful, and the Cardinals marched to a 3-0 start, just how everyone drew it up. A return to form for Arenado could make absorbing his salary a bit more palatable for another team, or provide St. Louis with enough reason to try to make the postseason in an otherwise weak NL Central. — Flores 

Record: 2-2
Preseason Power Ranking: 23

Most encouraging sign: Nick Lodolo’s ability to battle

In his first start of 2025, Lodolo did not have his best stuff, nor did he really have any command of the strike zone. He still managed to turn in six innings of two-run ball. In particular, after throwing 57 pitches through the first three innings, Lodolo needed just 29 to complete his next three, retiring eight of nine batters. He relied on his defense to make plays behind him with the Reds suffocating 11 grounders to keep the Giants off the bases. It’s the kind of start that veteran pitchers know how to make and one that will be important for Cincinnati as Lodolo looks to take a step forward in his age-27 season. — Flores 

Record: 2-3
Preseason Power Ranking: 25

Most encouraging sign: A healthy Jeffrey Springs is a low-key beast

Springs struck out nine Mariners across six scoreless innings in his Athletics debut. He scattered three singles and walked one. He looked a lot like the pitcher who starred for Tampa Bay in 2022 before Tommy John surgery wiped him out for most of the next two seasons. The Athletics took on Springs’ salary this past winter and paired him with Luis Severino atop the rotation. The duo should help the Athletics, for the first time in a while, at least stay competitive in the American League West. — McCullough

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

As Athletics begin their Sacramento residency, a city tentatively opens its arms

Record: 1-4
Preseason Power Ranking: 22

Most encouraging sign: The starting pitching was strong

Here are the lines for Pittsburgh’s starters through the first four games:
Paul Skenes: 5 1/3 IP | 2 ER | 2 BB | 7 K
Mitch Keller: 6 IP | 1 ER | 1 BB | 4 K
Bailey Falter: 6 IP | 2 ER | 4 K
Andrew Heaney: 5 IP | 1 ER | 1 BB | 1 K

Here’s the Pirates’ record through four games: 1-3, with three losses all on walk-offs. Consider that Jared Jones is on the IL and Bubba Chandler is in Indianapolis, meaning there is room for this rotation to be even stronger. Starting pitching is half the battle, and provided the lineup can string together just enough hits, this team could end up winning a lot more games than originally anticipated. — Flores 

Record: 1-3
Preseason Power Ranking: 26

Most encouraging sign: MacKenzie Gore can do that?

Since they lowered the mound in 1969, here’s the list of pitchers with more strikeouts in an Opening Day start than the 13 Gore piled up against the Phillies:

• Randy Johnson (1993 and 1996)
• Shane Bieber (2020)

Bieber won the Cy Young that season. Johnson won it five times, though not in either of those seasons.

How good was Gore Thursday? His FIP is 1.70 — sorry, minus-1.70, which, if maintained, would be a record. Since coming over in the Juan Soto trade, the lefty has established himself as a pretty good major-league starter. Thursday suggested the leap to something more could be imminent. — Britton

Record: 3-2
Preseason Power Ranking: 28

Most encouraging sign: Clutch exists and the Marlins have it

Statistically speaking, the best chance for the Marlins to outperform expectations is to be, and this is a specifically defined term, “crazy good” in close games — 2012 Orioles good in close games. And in the first weekend, that somehow looked like a plausible blueprint.

Miami became the first team since the ’01 Tigers to win with three walk-offs in its first series. You hear ’01 Tigers and probably think of Tony Clark and Bobby Higginson. No, I mean the ’01 Tigers of Kids Gleason and Elberfeld — the 1901 Tigers, who overcame deficits of nine, one and three in the ninth inning to earn those walk-offs against the ur-Milwaukee Brewers. It’s disheartening no one on that Detroit roster earned “Clutch” as a nickname, but their mistake doesn’t have to be ours. What a game Clutch Conine had Sunday, eh? — Britton

Record: 3-1
Preseason Power Ranking: 27

Most encouraging sign: Jack Kochanowicz missed some bats

Kochanowicz, a 24-year-old right-hander, presented a puzzle for analysts last season. He stands 6-foot-7 and wields a fastball that touches the upper 90s. Yet in his rookie season, he struck out only 3.4 batters per nine innings. He has solid command, so any improvement to his whiff rate could help him level up. He made decent progress in his first outing of 2025. It was only four batters in six innings, and it occurred against the White Sox. But progress is progress is progress. — McCullough

Record: 1-3
Preseason Power Ranking: 29

Most encouraging sign: Ryan McMahon could rejuvenate his trade value…

But then again, the Rockies haven’t been very aggressive with trying to move homegrown players in recent years. McMahon is a quality defender at third base, but he’s been a slightly below-average hitter for his entire career. There is probably a team or two willing to gamble on McMahon’s upside getting out of Colorado, especially if he produces at the plate like he did in the season’s first weekend. — McCullough

Record: 2-2
Preseason Power Ranking: 30

Most encouraging sign: Chicago’s 1-2 punch

Yes, the White Sox lost two of three games to the Angels, and yes, they had a massive malfunction with their tarp that became the stuff of internet tomfoolery.

But consider this: Between Opening Day starter Sean Burke and Game 2 arm Jonathan Cannon, the duo managed to put up 11 scoreless innings, with eight strikeouts against just three walks. Now, the Angels aren’t some offensive powerhouse, and the weather was rather cold, but seeing as Chicago lost an astounding 121 games in 2024, a reliable 1-2 duo is the kind of progress that the White Sox need so that they stay away from another historically bad season. — Flores 

(Top image of Texas’ Wyatt Langford and Joc Pederson: Ron Jenkins / Getty Images)

The ex-Real Madrid striker who had not scored for 1,135 days or played in 304 – and a glorious return

Three hundred and four days is a long time for a footballer to go without playing in a game. And 1,135 days must feel like a lifetime for a striker to go without scoring.

The former Real Madrid forward Mariano Diaz ended both of those personal droughts within the first 20 minutes of a friendly between the Dominican Republic and Puerto Rico this week.

Mariano made 84 appearances for Madrid over two spells between 2016 and 2023, scoring 12 times. He then joined fellow La Liga side Sevilla in 2023 but left them last summer and has been without a club since.

He had scored his last official goal on February 15, 2022, for Madrid against Cadiz in La Liga, and his most recent appearance in any recognised competition was in a Spanish top-flight match for Sevilla against Barcelona on April 26 last year.

Now, he is back in business.

The 31-year-old has committed to the Dominican Republic national team in time for their 2026 FIFA World Cup qualifiers and this summer’s Concacaf Gold Cup in Canada and the United States, with 16 sides from North and Central America and the Caribbean competing.

So, why did the Dominican Republic want Mariano after such a long time out? And how was he able to hit the ground running on his return?


Mariano played 88 minutes in the Dominican Republic’s 2-0 win against Puerto Rico on Tuesday, at Cibao Stadium in the Dominican city of Santiago.

His goal came from a long ball over the top, which he received on his chest while running in behind the Puerto Rican defence. That touch dropped the ball onto his favoured right foot, before he fired a shot into the bottom left-hand corner.

It was a high-quality take and finish from a similar angle to his stoppage-time goal seconds after coming off the bench against Barcelona in March 2020 — his best moment in a Madrid shirt — and showed why the Dominican Republic are so excited to have him, despite his lack of club football over the past 10 months.

“It was a very beautiful feeling to return to the pitch, to score a goal again. It’s what I most like,” Mariano told the Dominican Republic football team’s official channels. “There’s a very good connection (with the rest of the team), very good chemistry, and I hope it continues like that in the next games.”

The goal was of special importance to the Dominican Republic’s Argentinian manager Marcelo Neveleff, who pushed for Mariano’s inclusion.

“I told him before (the game) that I was praying for him to score a goal, and he gave me a big hug. And then after the game, he gave me another big hug,” Neveleff, 62, tells The Athletic. “We were all rooting for him, and he knew that, even without saying words. He showed gratitude to us all, coaching staff and players. We were all really happy for him.”

The two teams had met just four days earlier in Puerto Rico and drew 2-2 without the Dominican Republic’s two most high-profile players, Mariano and Leeds United left-back Junior Firpo, who both scored in the later win in Santiago. Puerto Rico are 157th in FIFA’s world rankings (the Dominican Republic are 141st), so there will be tougher tests ahead for Mariano.


Mariano celebrates his first goal in 1,135 days (Dominican Football Federation)

It was his first appearance for the Dominican Republic — where his mother is from — since his international debut in 2013, when he featured in a friendly against Haiti. He was also eligible to play for Spain, having been born in Premia de Mar, Catalonia.

In a 2018 interview with Spanish news agency EFE, as reported by Marca, he called playing for Spain “a dream I have since I’ve been little” and added: “They (the Dominican Republic) have tried to get me to go (there), but I have the desire and the intention of playing for Spain.”

Neveleff, who was appointed in January 2023, says: “When I got here two years ago, we went over the players of Dominican heritage that played in Europe, and he was on the top of the list. We met a year ago, and then he told me that he was interested but not at the moment, when he was in Seville. But then we started talking again and it was a big-time opportunity for us as a national team to have a player of his calibre.

“He believed that we were going to be able to help him relaunch his career. And that’s why it was a win-win situation for all of us.”

Players without a club very rarely represent their countries.

Notable examples include Cristiano Ronaldo for Portugal at the 2022 World Cup after his second Manchester United exit two days into the tournament and Zinedine Zidane at the 2006 World Cup, as he had announced he would retire when his France team’s involvement ended having already played his last game at club level for Real Madrid.

Goalkeeper Guillermo Ochoa put in stellar performances for Mexico at the 2014 World Cup while he was a free agent after leaving France’s Ajaccio to earn a move to Spanish side Malaga and Hal Robson-Kanu helped Wales to the 2016 European Championship semi-finals as a free agent after his deal at Reading expired — his decisive second in the 3-1 quarter-final win against Belgium nominated for FIFA’s Puskas award for the best goal that calendar year — and was then signed by West Bromwich Albion.

But none were without a club for as long as Mariano, who endured a difficult time at Madrid.

He joined their youth system in 2011-12 from Catalan side Badalona and rose to become third-choice striker behind Karim Benzema and Alvaro Morata in 2016-17. He made the most of his limited minutes to earn an €8million ($8.7m; £6.7m at current exchange rates) move to France’s Lyon in summer 2017 and scored 21 goals in 48 games for them across all competitions the following season before Madrid then exercised a right of first refusal to bring him back in 2018.

His final five years at Madrid were characterised by a lack of playing time and it probably did not help that he took on the iconic No 7 shirt worn by Cristiano Ronaldo when he left for Juventus in the summer of 2018. Mariano finally left through the back door in 2023 and signed as a free agent with Sevilla — but failed to score in 13 appearances and has been without a club since leaving last summer after his one-year contract expired.


Mariano scores for Madrid against Barca in March 2020 (David S. Bustamante/Soccrates/Getty Images)

Dominican Republic manager Neveleff describes him as a “tough kid” who is “very strong mentally”.

“These guys are high-level athletes,” says Neveleff. “If they have the idea to come back, they cannot relax, especially (when it comes to) physical training. What is most challenging (for a player) is (going without) the competition. When you play in La Liga, the Premier League or the Championship, whichever, some of the stuff that you were resolving on the field in a split second, it might take you a bit longer to do it and when you take longer, you are already late for the action.

“He missed a couple of chances (in the Puerto Rico game). I told him if he had been in top shape and form he would not have missed. He missed a one-on-one with the goalkeeper before he scored the goal, but he knows.”

But the signs were mostly positive on Mariano’s return. He trained well before the game and played those 88 minutes to a decent level before being replaced.

“I saw him in the first day in practice and it was obvious this guy has been training all the time (despite being without a club),” says Neveleff, “so we had a conversation and I asked him, ‘Do you feel that you are ready to start?’. When he told me ‘Yes’, I believed him.”

The Dominican Republic’s goalkeeper Xavier Valdez, of MLS club Nashville FC, agrees on Mariano’s quality.

“With him as a new addition, it makes our fight for qualification to the World Cup much stronger,” the 21-year-old tells The Athletic. “He brings a lot of quality and effectiveness to the team. Everyone has received him well, and I think we can all say that we are all very excited for him to be part of the team again.”

With two games played and two to go, the Dominican Republic are third in their second-round Concacaf World Cup qualifying group, behind Guatemala and Jamaica, as they chase a historic first appearance in football’s most prestigious tournament.

The top two in each of the six groups (12 teams overall) progress to the third round, where they will be split into three groups of four. The three third-round group winners will qualify directly for next year’s World Cup, with the two best-ranked runners-up entering inter-confederation play-offs also involving teams from Asia, Africa, South America and Oceania.

Neveleff says Mariano is hoping to find himself a club before the Dominican Republic’s next matches in early June, when they visit Guatemala and host Dominica, a fellow Caribbean island nation, in those last two second-round World Cup qualifiers before the Gold Cup starts later that month.


The Dominican Republic qualified for the 2024 Olympics and are now aiming for a first World Cup appearance (Alex Grimm – FIFA/FIFA via Getty Images)

“I don’t think he will be without a team for long, but if that happens, I am going to start bugging him,” says Neveleff.

“I know it is in the middle of the season (for many leagues), but hopefully, he will get somewhere. If not, he will stay training, and I’ll see how I can help him. Maybe we can bring him over and train with a group of players here, but I believe in his quality.

“The next international window is only a few months away. I don’t think he will lose his quality from today to June, so my plan is to have him at all costs.”

The Dominican Republic have made important strides in football in recent years.

Their qualification for the Gold Cup marks the men’s team’s first major tournament, one year after the women first qualified for their equivalent competition.

The men’s side also appeared at the 2024 Olympics in France, where they were knocked out at the group stage, drawing with Egypt (0-0) and Uzbekistan (1-1) and losing 3-1 to eventual gold medallists Spain. Mariano was listed in their preliminary squad but ultimately got left out, with competing countries only allowed three players over 23 years old in their selected 18.

The country’s increased commitment to football also saw it host the Under-17 Women’s World Cup from October to November last year.

Higher standards have been set partly thanks to the successful recruitment of dual-national players playing in Europe, including Firpo, who committed his future to them in February 2024, Getafe forward Peter Gonzalez, and left-back Juan Familia-Castillo of Dutch side RKC Waalwijk.

If he can continue to score, Mariano could take the Dominican Republic closer to history — and perhaps relaunch his club career in the process.

(Top photo: Mariano celebrates scoring for Madrid in 2019; David S. Bustamante/Soccrates/Getty Images)

‘Scaremongering’ or a cause for concern? Why the F1 engine debate is intensifying ahead of 2026

There has been growing excitement within Formula One over the potential return of the V10 engines. That roaring sound is part of the sport’s history and identity.

But the calls from senior figures in the F1 paddock, including the FIA president, Mohammed Ben Sulayem, to consider returning the loud engines used most recently 20 years ago, has also raised questions.

If simpler, louder and cheaper V10 engines, running on fully sustainable fuels and resulting in smaller and lighter car designs, are introduced in the coming years, what happens in the interim? And how would that impact the imminent power unit change scheduled for 2026?

F1’s stakeholders have been working on the 2026 engine rules, maintaining the V6 hybrid basis for the power units, for years. Since their approval in the summer of 2022, the ruleset has encouraged Audi, Ford (via Red Bull), and General Motors to join the grid, as well as reversing Honda’s decision to quit, all thanks to the sport’s commitment to fully sustainable fuels and greater electrification. In the case of Audi and Red Bull, the development of their new engine programs has required significant investment and recruitment, running into the hundreds of millions of dollars.

These rules were meant to cover a five-year cycle from 2026 through to the end of 2030. But will they even happen at all?

In a select media roundtable, including The Athletic, on Sunday in Shanghai, Nikolas Tombazis, the FIA’s single-seater director who helps shape F1’s future rules, framed the discussion over the future engine regulations as hinging on two questions.

The first relates to the long-term direction of the sport and whether, in the next three or four years, F1 wants a different type of power unit. “If the answer to that is yes, (that) we want to change something, then question number two is, ‘What we do in the intervening period?’” Tombazis said. That period begins next year.

“What I want to say at the start about 2026 is that, either way, whether we stay with the current regulations or whether we do the already approved new regulations, I think Formula One would be in a good place,” Tombazis said. “I don’t want it to be seen as sort of, ‘OK, we are panicking about 2026,’ because that is far from reality.”

On Friday in China, Red Bull team principal Christian Horner claimed there were “limitations” with next year’s rules that could impact the sport’s on-track spectacle due to the “shortcomings of the split in electrification and combustion” sources with the new power unit, which leans more on the electric power in the power unit. Those “limitations” would relate to consistent performance issues across the grid, which could affect the quality of competition and racing.

But Tombazis said he and the wider FIA did not share what he called a “scaremongering” view raised about the 2026 regulations’ potential impact on racing.

“I think there will be cars racing closely with each other, able to fight each other, and using driver skill, etc,” Tombazis said. “So fundamentally, I think I don’t share the panic stories. I remind people that there were panic stories for the ’22 regulations about how the cars would be massively slow.” This was when F1 last made a major overhaul to the aerodynamic regulations, which was not on the scale of 2026 when both the car designs and power units will change.

“I’m not saying everything was perfect,” Tombazis said of the 2022 change. “There are things with the benefit of hindsight we would have done differently. But I don’t think it was that disaster.”

Any change to the plans for next year would depend on the position of all the engine manufacturers. The investment and effort already put in has led the sport to a point where it’s “10 past midnight, and Cinderella has left the building,” to quote Horner.

Although Tombazis agreed that “the train has left the station to a large extent” for 2026, he noted that talk about the ‘interim’ period was fueled by chatter in the wake of Ben Sulayem, the FIA president, calling for an evaluation of a future switch to V10s.

Tombazis added that the FIA did not wish to impose any changes that would make it impossible for a team to compete. “We won’t just go on majorities,” he said. “We are trying to build a consensus here, and if that fails, then we will stay where we are (with the existing 2026 plan).”

If F1 power unit manufacturers were to feel it’s better to shelve the ’26 engines due to potential negative impacts on the sport — if the “scaremongering” were serious and concerns were widely shared — then mechanisms do exist that could lead to the status quo with the current specification of power units being the interim solution until a possible return to V10s.

But that would lead to other major knock-on effects and issues, given that Audi and Red Bull Powertrains/Ford haven’t produced a V6 hybrid engine for the current regulations. Other existing manufacturers have shifted all development to future engines. This, again, makes the idea of changing next year’s engine plans seem unthinkable.

Horner told reporters on Sunday in China he would be “very surprised” if the existing rules continued next year. “I think all teams are all in at the moment on ’26,” Horner said. “So we’d have to understand what it was all about.” He also denied Red Bull was pushing for a delay of the new rules, saying it was “geared up and ready for ’26.”

Toto Wolff, the Mercedes team principal, didn’t give much thought to the possibility of the 2026 changes not going ahead.

“It’s all going to be good,” he told reporters, calling the change an “exciting adventure” for the F1 grid that meant it should be celebrated, not derided by already looking at what follows the upcoming change.


Mercedes team principal Toto Wolff (Fadel Senna/AFP via Getty Images)

“This is where we should put our emphasis,” Wolff said. “This is what we should cheer for, and speak about, all the goodness that is going to bring rather than looking too far forward.”

A spokesperson for Audi issued a statement noting that the upcoming rule change and power unit design was “a key factor in Audi’s decision to enter Formula One. These power unit regulations reflect the same technological advancements that drive innovation in Audi’s road cars.” The German manufacturer has established its own F1 engine program and bought the Sauber team all on the basis of these rules — which now could only last a few years.

Assuming things go ahead as planned for 2026, as most still anticipate, the winds are currently blowing toward a shorter cycle from the original five years to change the power unit formula.

The desire for a long-term game plan is shared by senior figures throughout the paddock, meaning it’ll be a talking point in the coming months. The positions of the various power unit manufacturers could be influenced by their relative competitive standings in the political battles next year. If one team has produced the best power unit and has an advantage that would be hard to overcome, it’s only natural it might seek to protect that and kick any shift in regulations as far down the road as possible — and that its rivals would try to fight back.

Given how celebrated the 2026 engine rules were when they were announced in 2022 and the credit given to them when each new major manufacturer joined the grid, ditching them early would be strange. But Tombazis felt two primary factors had caused the change in stance. First, he cited the perception from manufacturers about electrification uptake across the automotive industry given a slow down in consumer interest.

“Back in 2020, 2021, when these discussions were had, the trend was pretty decisively in the direction of electrification,” he said. “I’m not saying that’s not happening, but certainly the views of the participants have changed since then.”

He also highlighted the costs of making the power units, admitting the current designs are “way too expensive.” When the 2026 rules were announced, improved cost control was heralded as one of their benefits, but Tombazis said their expense was a consideration.

“Even if Formula One is in very good health financially, it has become important also to protect it against world economy fluctuations, and I think we need to take these protective measures while the sun is shining and not when it starts raining, ideally,” he said. “The drive to cut costs is important to consider.

“All of these things are not things we would dream of doing without trying to respect all of the participants properly.”

Wolff said Mercedes was “always open” to different engine solutions, but that F1 had to consider what fans wanted too, and whether their views might have changed amid the shift toward a younger and more diverse fanbase than in the past. For those who came to the sport through “Drive to Survive,” the sound of V6 hybrids is all they will have known.

“All of this needs to be set as questions,” Wolff said. “What are the objectives for a future regulation change in a few years? Let’s analyze that based on data and come to a conclusion that is for the best of our sport.

“Because this is the single most important denominator between the FIA, Formula One, the teams, that we want to have the greatest product for our fans.”

(Top photo: Peter Parks/AFP via Getty Images)

Ranking the best players in the NCAA men’s basketball transfer portal

More than 1,000 Division I men’s basketball players have entered the transfer portal since it opened on March 24. That’s a lot of names and faces to learn as college basketball’s roster management busy season increasingly resembles NBA free agency. This is where The Athletic’s transfer portal rankings come in.

The rankings are a living document we will continue to expand and update as more players hit the portal. Some notes to keep in mind: First, positional scarcity is taken into account. The easiest type of player to find in the portal is a scoring guard; the hardest types are versatile wings and bigs. Second, remaining eligibility matters. Players with potential to play more than one season carry more value. Finally, these rankings are essentially scheme-agnostic. Not every team runs the same offense and defense, so no two teams’ boards look the same. Take these as more of a list of transfers to watch than an official window into how much every team values every player.

With that said, here are The Athletic’s 2025 transfer portal rankings.

Loading

Try changing or resetting your filters to see more.

Ht: 6-4 Wt: 180

The maestro of Drake’s 31-win team is following Ben McCollum to Iowa, announcing that he would be joining his coach in Iowa City even before his name officially hit the portal. Stirtz is a tremendous processor who understands exactly how to play within McCollum’s scheme. He runs the show and seemingly never leaves the court (over 39 minutes per game this season). He can score from all three levels, can play on and off the ball and serves as an extension of his coach on the floor. He scored 21 points in both of Drake’s NCAA Tournament games against high-major competition. There are some athletic concerns as he moves up a level, but those are more NBA-focused than college-centric. Stirtz is a good bet to be an All-American next season and a monster building block for Iowa in the post-Fran McCaffery world. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-4 Wt: 180

The maestro of Drake’s 31-win team is following Ben McCollum to Iowa, announcing that he would be joining his coach in Iowa City even before his name officially hit the portal. Stirtz is a tremendous processor who understands exactly how to play within McCollum’s scheme. He runs the show and seemingly never leaves the court (over 39 minutes per game this season). He can score from all three levels, can play on and off the ball and serves as an extension of his coach on the floor. He scored 21 points in both of Drake’s NCAA Tournament games against high-major competition. There are some athletic concerns as he moves up a level, but those are more NBA-focused than college-centric. Stirtz is a good bet to be an All-American next season and a monster building block for Iowa in the post-Fran McCaffery world. — Sam Vecenie

Guard

Committed

Drake

Iowa Hawkeyes

Ht: 6-2 Wt: 175

Dent was one of the best point guards in college basketball this season, becoming the first player since 1997 to average at least 20 points and six assists while shooting 49 percent from the field and 40 percent from 3. He was a borderline All-American while carrying a fast-paced offense to the second round of the NCAA Tournament. He’s wildly competitive and reads the court incredibly well. Any mistake that a team makes in ball-screen defense, Dent is going to hammer it. Tag too late, he’ll hit the lob to a big. Tag too aggressively on the weak side, he’ll hit the cross-corner kick-out. If you give him too much space coming off of a screen, he’ll attack the rim or find a beautiful little floater. He’s lethal at getting to the foul line, too. Dent has every chance to be an All-American next year wherever he ends up. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-2 Wt: 175

Dent was one of the best point guards in college basketball this season, becoming the first player since 1997 to average at least 20 points and six assists while shooting 49 percent from the field and 40 percent from 3. He was a borderline All-American while carrying a fast-paced offense to the second round of the NCAA Tournament. He’s wildly competitive and reads the court incredibly well. Any mistake that a team makes in ball-screen defense, Dent is going to hammer it. Tag too late, he’ll hit the lob to a big. Tag too aggressively on the weak side, he’ll hit the cross-corner kick-out. If you give him too much space coming off of a screen, he’ll attack the rim or find a beautiful little floater. He’s lethal at getting to the foul line, too. Dent has every chance to be an All-American next year wherever he ends up. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-4 Wt: 215

Conwell proved he could be a high-major go-to guy this year at Xavier after breaking out in his one season at Indiana State. He’s one of the best scorers in the portal, able to fill it up from all three levels. The lefty shot 41.2 percent from 3, and he’s elite in catch-and-shoot, off movement and off the bounce. He’s one of those lefties who just seems hard to stop from getting to his left hand. He’s smooth and strong, so he finds a way to get to his spots. He also battles defensively and is a valuable two-way wing. He can be streaky, but when he’s on, he can really go off — proven by two 30-plus-point games this season. Conwell is arguably the best wing in the portal and should be highly coveted.
— C.J. Moore

Ht: 6-4 Wt: 215

Conwell proved he could be a high-major go-to guy this year at Xavier after breaking out in his one season at Indiana State. He’s one of the best scorers in the portal, able to fill it up from all three levels. The lefty shot 41.2 percent from 3, and he’s elite in catch-and-shoot, off movement and off the bounce. He’s one of those lefties who just seems hard to stop from getting to his left hand. He’s smooth and strong, so he finds a way to get to his spots. He also battles defensively and is a valuable two-way wing. He can be streaky, but when he’s on, he can really go off — proven by two 30-plus-point games this season. Conwell is arguably the best wing in the portal and should be highly coveted.
— C.J. Moore

Ht: 6-7 Wt: 225

DeVries played for his dad, Darian, at Drake before following him to West Virginia and now to Indiana. A two-time Missouri Valley player of the year, he’s an elite shooter off movement who can create shots from all three levels. He takes about seven 3s per game, and while he only hits them at a 37 percent clip, that’s because he takes some truly difficult ones off all sorts of intricate action within this offense. He also passes extremely well. His feet can be a bit slow on defense, a trait that could be exploited in the Big Ten. Still, expect him to be one of the best players in the league next season even coming off the wrist injury that held him out for all but eight games this year. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-7 Wt: 225

DeVries played for his dad, Darian, at Drake before following him to West Virginia and now to Indiana. A two-time Missouri Valley player of the year, he’s an elite shooter off movement who can create shots from all three levels. He takes about seven 3s per game, and while he only hits them at a 37 percent clip, that’s because he takes some truly difficult ones off all sorts of intricate action within this offense. He also passes extremely well. His feet can be a bit slow on defense, a trait that could be exploited in the Big Ten. Still, expect him to be one of the best players in the league next season even coming off the wrist injury that held him out for all but eight games this year. — Sam Vecenie

Wing

Committed

West Virginia

Indiana Hoosiers

Ht: 6-10 Wt: 230

Freeman extended a long line of great Iowa post players under Fran McCaffery, consistently getting to his spots on the block and making shots. He shot 63 percent in post-ups, per Synergy, and has a great back-to-the-basket game. But he also has some handle, allowing him to attack in straight lines before using drop steps and counters to finish. His footwork is terrific, and he had a couple of moments when he stepped away and showed some potential from 3-point range. Teams that run several post-ups will likely be the best fit here, but he would also fit in ball-screen offenses that utilize seals. But to win games that matter, his new team must surround him with high-level defenders. That end of the floor wasn’t always a strength despite his gaudy 1.8 blocks per game. — Sam Vecenie 

Ht: 6-10 Wt: 230

Freeman extended a long line of great Iowa post players under Fran McCaffery, consistently getting to his spots on the block and making shots. He shot 63 percent in post-ups, per Synergy, and has a great back-to-the-basket game. But he also has some handle, allowing him to attack in straight lines before using drop steps and counters to finish. His footwork is terrific, and he had a couple of moments when he stepped away and showed some potential from 3-point range. Teams that run several post-ups will likely be the best fit here, but he would also fit in ball-screen offenses that utilize seals. But to win games that matter, his new team must surround him with high-level defenders. That end of the floor wasn’t always a strength despite his gaudy 1.8 blocks per game. — Sam Vecenie 

Forward

Committed

Iowa

Creighton Bluejays

Ht: 6-5Wt: 210

One of the most fun breakout stars of the year in the Big Ten, Dix is a skilled, efficient gunner who makes great decisions. He shot 51 percent from the field and 77 percent from the free-throw line, but the big number here is the 42.2 percent mark on five 3-point attempts per game. He’s an all-situations shooter: off spot-ups, off movement, off relocations and off the dribble. He tops it off by being useful in ball screens as a handler and cutting sharply off the ball. He has an NBA-style off-ball game, and he’ll likely fit best in a scheme that prioritizes off-ball movement, 3-point shooting and five-out play. But he can play anywhere in the country. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-5Wt: 210

One of the most fun breakout stars of the year in the Big Ten, Dix is a skilled, efficient gunner who makes great decisions. He shot 51 percent from the field and 77 percent from the free-throw line, but the big number here is the 42.2 percent mark on five 3-point attempts per game. He’s an all-situations shooter: off spot-ups, off movement, off relocations and off the dribble. He tops it off by being useful in ball screens as a handler and cutting sharply off the ball. He has an NBA-style off-ball game, and he’ll likely fit best in a scheme that prioritizes off-ball movement, 3-point shooting and five-out play. But he can play anywhere in the country. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-5 Wt: 200

DeMary is unlike just about anyone else available. Why? He’s a big guard who can actually run an offense. Landing him gives a team a lot more flexibility in the other guys they can pursue: A big lead lets you play smaller scoring guards if you want, or go with the recent Connecticut model and switch all actions across positions one through four at a high level. DeMary had a monster close to this season, averaging 19.3 points and 3.5 per game over his final 10, and he shot it well enough from 3 all year to play both on and off the ball if needed. He’s a serious chess piece. Expect an expensive battle for his services. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-5 Wt: 200

DeMary is unlike just about anyone else available. Why? He’s a big guard who can actually run an offense. Landing him gives a team a lot more flexibility in the other guys they can pursue: A big lead lets you play smaller scoring guards if you want, or go with the recent Connecticut model and switch all actions across positions one through four at a high level. DeMary had a monster close to this season, averaging 19.3 points and 3.5 per game over his final 10, and he shot it well enough from 3 all year to play both on and off the ball if needed. He’s a serious chess piece. Expect an expensive battle for his services. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-6Wt: 225

Hopkins has had a wild career, starting at Kentucky as a consensus top-40 recruit before transferring to Providence and exploding onto the scene with a first-team All-Big East campaign in 2022-23. Hopkins tried his luck with the NBA Draft in 2023 but returned to school and tore his ACL midway through his junior season. He tried to return this season but suffered a bone bruise after three games and missed the rest of the year. At his best, Hopkins is a mismatch nightmare at the four who can slash and finish at the rim with physicality, make plays for his teammates and defend with toughness. He could turn out to be one of the best players in college hoops next season, or he could struggle with his knee and disappoint. Given the resources that you’d have to allocate to get him, Hopkins won’t be for everyone. But if he’s right, he’s a genuine program-changer. — Sam Vecenie 

Ht: 6-6Wt: 225

Hopkins has had a wild career, starting at Kentucky as a consensus top-40 recruit before transferring to Providence and exploding onto the scene with a first-team All-Big East campaign in 2022-23. Hopkins tried his luck with the NBA Draft in 2023 but returned to school and tore his ACL midway through his junior season. He tried to return this season but suffered a bone bruise after three games and missed the rest of the year. At his best, Hopkins is a mismatch nightmare at the four who can slash and finish at the rim with physicality, make plays for his teammates and defend with toughness. He could turn out to be one of the best players in college hoops next season, or he could struggle with his knee and disappoint. Given the resources that you’d have to allocate to get him, Hopkins won’t be for everyone. But if he’s right, he’s a genuine program-changer. — Sam Vecenie 

Forward

In Portal

Providence

Ht: 7-0Wt: 190

Gwath went from zero-star recruit to legitimate NBA prospect in a single season. He won both freshman of the year and defensive player of the year in the Mountain West (although he has some ball-screen and perimeter issues to work through on that end) and has a pro-style game. The numbers don’t look gaudy, but that’s because it took him time to establish himself. He is a 7-footer with legitimate handles who can attack from the perimeter in addition to shooting from 3. Gwath is still quite skinny and will need to keep filling out his frame over the next few years, but I would anticipate this ends with him playing in the NBA, and he should go to a school that will better weaponize his perimeter game and space the court around him. — Sam Vecenie 

Ht: 7-0Wt: 190

Gwath went from zero-star recruit to legitimate NBA prospect in a single season. He won both freshman of the year and defensive player of the year in the Mountain West (although he has some ball-screen and perimeter issues to work through on that end) and has a pro-style game. The numbers don’t look gaudy, but that’s because it took him time to establish himself. He is a 7-footer with legitimate handles who can attack from the perimeter in addition to shooting from 3. Gwath is still quite skinny and will need to keep filling out his frame over the next few years, but I would anticipate this ends with him playing in the NBA, and he should go to a school that will better weaponize his perimeter game and space the court around him. — Sam Vecenie 

Forward

In Portal

San Diego St

Ht: 6-7 Wt: 220

Swain certainly has one of the best potential futures of any player in the portal. He’s a genuine NBA prospect who should declare for the draft this season to at least test his stock. A tremendous defensive playmaker, Swain has incredibly long arms and is wildly reactive on the court. He averaged 1.6 steals and 0.6 blocks to go with 11 points. Offensively, teams generally played off him this year, and he made them pay at times (he had 27 points in Xavier’s Round of 64 game vs. Illinois). However, to take that next step and become one of the best college players in the country — and a legitimate NBA player — he will have to improve his shot. He made just 25 percent from 3 this season and doesn’t look all that comfortable taking them. The good news? He has some real touch around the rim and made 82 percent of his free throws, so he has a chance to take that next step. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-7 Wt: 220

Swain certainly has one of the best potential futures of any player in the portal. He’s a genuine NBA prospect who should declare for the draft this season to at least test his stock. A tremendous defensive playmaker, Swain has incredibly long arms and is wildly reactive on the court. He averaged 1.6 steals and 0.6 blocks to go with 11 points. Offensively, teams generally played off him this year, and he made them pay at times (he had 27 points in Xavier’s Round of 64 game vs. Illinois). However, to take that next step and become one of the best college players in the country — and a legitimate NBA player — he will have to improve his shot. He made just 25 percent from 3 this season and doesn’t look all that comfortable taking them. The good news? He has some real touch around the rim and made 82 percent of his free throws, so he has a chance to take that next step. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-5 Wt: 195

A former five-star recruit, Sanon is a bucket-getter through and through. He’s not overly big, but he averaged 12 points per game while shooting 42 percent from the field and 37 percent from 3 as a freshman. The numbers aren’t what they seem, however. He had a dry spell in conference play after a strong start, averaging just six points from Dec. 14 through Feb. 23 while he played through an ankle injury. He was healthy at the end of the season and averaged 19 points in his final five games. He needs to improve drastically on defense and work on making consistent reads as a driver. If he can make tough, winning plays on both ends of the court on a regular basis, he has real NBA upside after next season. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-5 Wt: 195

A former five-star recruit, Sanon is a bucket-getter through and through. He’s not overly big, but he averaged 12 points per game while shooting 42 percent from the field and 37 percent from 3 as a freshman. The numbers aren’t what they seem, however. He had a dry spell in conference play after a strong start, averaging just six points from Dec. 14 through Feb. 23 while he played through an ankle injury. He was healthy at the end of the season and averaged 19 points in his final five games. He needs to improve drastically on defense and work on making consistent reads as a driver. If he can make tough, winning plays on both ends of the court on a regular basis, he has real NBA upside after next season. — Sam Vecenie

Wing

Committed

Arizona State

St. John’s Red Storm

Ht: 6-5 Wt: 180

One of the best pop-up freshmen in the country this season, Wooley was dominant in Conference USA for Kennesaw State. Not only are the averages per game impressive, but he shot 51 percent from the field, 42 percent from 3 and 77 percent from the line. His frame still needs a bit of work, so it makes sense that he spends at least one more season in college. However, he did almost carry Kennesaw to a win over league-champion Liberty in the conference tournament, scoring 28 points, grabbing seven rebounds and dishing out five assists. He also had 25 points and 19 points against top-100 teams UC Irvine and Santa Clara. Originally from Tuscaloosa, this feels like it’ll be an all-out war between Alabama and Auburn. Wooley is good enough to play anywhere.
— Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-5 Wt: 180

One of the best pop-up freshmen in the country this season, Wooley was dominant in Conference USA for Kennesaw State. Not only are the averages per game impressive, but he shot 51 percent from the field, 42 percent from 3 and 77 percent from the line. His frame still needs a bit of work, so it makes sense that he spends at least one more season in college. However, he did almost carry Kennesaw to a win over league-champion Liberty in the conference tournament, scoring 28 points, grabbing seven rebounds and dishing out five assists. He also had 25 points and 19 points against top-100 teams UC Irvine and Santa Clara. Originally from Tuscaloosa, this feels like it’ll be an all-out war between Alabama and Auburn. Wooley is good enough to play anywhere.
— Sam Vecenie

Guard

In Portal

Kennesaw St

Ht: 6-4Wt: 200

The pitch with McKneely is simple: He’s one of the best shooters in the country, point blank. He has made 43.1 percent of his nearly seven 3-point attempts over the last two years. He makes them off movement at a high level and can find his shot from just about any situation. Where he’s really improved over the last two years, though, is how he uses the threat of that shot to attack off it, finding his way into the lane to score occasionally or to use a touch floater. He’s not a monster passer, but he sees reads well and is unselfish. He also rarely makes mistakes. Teams that run a lot of actions to free shooters should be salivating about getting McKneely into their scheme. The perfect fit here is for McKneely to be Koby Brea’s replacement at Kentucky, given that he grew up a three-hour drive away in West Virginia. — Sam Vecenie 

Ht: 6-4Wt: 200

The pitch with McKneely is simple: He’s one of the best shooters in the country, point blank. He has made 43.1 percent of his nearly seven 3-point attempts over the last two years. He makes them off movement at a high level and can find his shot from just about any situation. Where he’s really improved over the last two years, though, is how he uses the threat of that shot to attack off it, finding his way into the lane to score occasionally or to use a touch floater. He’s not a monster passer, but he sees reads well and is unselfish. He also rarely makes mistakes. Teams that run a lot of actions to free shooters should be salivating about getting McKneely into their scheme. The perfect fit here is for McKneely to be Koby Brea’s replacement at Kentucky, given that he grew up a three-hour drive away in West Virginia. — Sam Vecenie 

Ht: 6-10Wt: 230

Cofie started the season on fire and looked like a potential one-and-done player. However, he cooled off as the season progressed, looking more like a terrific first-year starter who will take some time to develop to get to the next level. He played about 20 minutes per game and is a sharp, reactive player across the board. He gets his hands up and makes defensive plays regularly and can rotate across the back line to be available on the weak side. Offensively, the jumper looks entirely workable, and he’s a serious mismatch threat with his size and ability to handle the ball. It’s hard to find fours with enough size to play the center position in college, and even with his downturn in shooting late in the year, Virginia was still 10 points per 100 possessions better with Cofie on the court than when he was off it, per CBB Analytics.
 — Sam Vecenie 

Ht: 6-10Wt: 230

Cofie started the season on fire and looked like a potential one-and-done player. However, he cooled off as the season progressed, looking more like a terrific first-year starter who will take some time to develop to get to the next level. He played about 20 minutes per game and is a sharp, reactive player across the board. He gets his hands up and makes defensive plays regularly and can rotate across the back line to be available on the weak side. Offensively, the jumper looks entirely workable, and he’s a serious mismatch threat with his size and ability to handle the ball. It’s hard to find fours with enough size to play the center position in college, and even with his downturn in shooting late in the year, Virginia was still 10 points per 100 possessions better with Cofie on the court than when he was off it, per CBB Analytics.
 — Sam Vecenie 

Ht: 6-8Wt: 190

NBA teams are keeping their eyes on Williams after a terrific freshman season at Tulane that saw him do exactly what scouts look for from low-usage wings — knock down shots and be a menace on defense. He drilled 41 percent of his five 3-point attempts per game and has a nice stroke that should continue to translate up levels. On defense, he’s active with his hands and length, averaging 1.4 steals and 1.1 blocks from the four spot. The reason he’s more of a four than a three right now is that his ball skills need to improve significantly. But he knows his role, makes good decisions and doesn’t tend to overextend himself. This is a good bet for any high-major team to take, even the ones at the highest levels.
— Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-8Wt: 190

NBA teams are keeping their eyes on Williams after a terrific freshman season at Tulane that saw him do exactly what scouts look for from low-usage wings — knock down shots and be a menace on defense. He drilled 41 percent of his five 3-point attempts per game and has a nice stroke that should continue to translate up levels. On defense, he’s active with his hands and length, averaging 1.4 steals and 1.1 blocks from the four spot. The reason he’s more of a four than a three right now is that his ball skills need to improve significantly. But he knows his role, makes good decisions and doesn’t tend to overextend himself. This is a good bet for any high-major team to take, even the ones at the highest levels.
— Sam Vecenie

Wing

Committed

Tulane

Kentucky Wildcats

Ht: 6-7 Wt: 200

Harper is this season’s mid-major breakout freshman, a 6-foot-7 wing who won both the MEAC’s player of the year and freshman of the year awards. A smooth lefty with a sweet shooting stroke and great touch, Harper still has some things to work on but has the look of a high-level, high-major recruit. He attacks aggressively off the bounce and is fearless driving to the paint. He averaged 8.4 free-throw attempts per game and does a great job of drawing contact, even though he’s not overly vertical. The worries here are that he wasn’t overly efficient at the rim and that he was an athletic/size outlier at the MEAC level. He needs to work on his strength to bounce off other wings and improve his footwork on drives. Otherwise, he’ll need to be more willing to fire from 3. He reminds me of Florida starting wing Will Richard back when Richard was at Belmont.
— Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-7 Wt: 200

Harper is this season’s mid-major breakout freshman, a 6-foot-7 wing who won both the MEAC’s player of the year and freshman of the year awards. A smooth lefty with a sweet shooting stroke and great touch, Harper still has some things to work on but has the look of a high-level, high-major recruit. He attacks aggressively off the bounce and is fearless driving to the paint. He averaged 8.4 free-throw attempts per game and does a great job of drawing contact, even though he’s not overly vertical. The worries here are that he wasn’t overly efficient at the rim and that he was an athletic/size outlier at the MEAC level. He needs to work on his strength to bounce off other wings and improve his footwork on drives. Otherwise, he’ll need to be more willing to fire from 3. He reminds me of Florida starting wing Will Richard back when Richard was at Belmont.
— Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-9Wt: 220

The Horizon League Player of the Year, Folgueiras led Robert Morris to the NCAA Tournament and helped give Alabama just about all it could handle. At 6-foot-9, Folgueiras is an incredibly gifted, skilled mismatch four. The Spanish forward has great instincts across the court for playing off the ball, with timely cuts and sharp movements to find open 3s. He can pick-and-pop, and he posted his man well at the Horizon League level. His touch is terrific, and he can put the ball on the deck to finish, too. He’s also a sharp passer who sees the court well. So, what’s the issue? He’s just not all that explosive athletically. He’s a bit in-between positions defensively at the high-major level, too. But he’s active with his hands and knows where to be, averaging 1.3 steals and 1.1 blocks per game. I’m a big believer in him translating up levels and thriving at least as a high-level starter.
— Sam Vecenie 

Ht: 6-9Wt: 220

The Horizon League Player of the Year, Folgueiras led Robert Morris to the NCAA Tournament and helped give Alabama just about all it could handle. At 6-foot-9, Folgueiras is an incredibly gifted, skilled mismatch four. The Spanish forward has great instincts across the court for playing off the ball, with timely cuts and sharp movements to find open 3s. He can pick-and-pop, and he posted his man well at the Horizon League level. His touch is terrific, and he can put the ball on the deck to finish, too. He’s also a sharp passer who sees the court well. So, what’s the issue? He’s just not all that explosive athletically. He’s a bit in-between positions defensively at the high-major level, too. But he’s active with his hands and knows where to be, averaging 1.3 steals and 1.1 blocks per game. I’m a big believer in him translating up levels and thriving at least as a high-level starter.
— Sam Vecenie 

Forward

In Portal

Robert Morris

Ht: 6-1 Wt: 180

A former five-star prospect coming out of Sweden by way of high school powerhouse Link Academy in Missouri, Cadeau never quite found his footing at North Carolina after choosing to reclassify into the 2023 recruiting class. He’s certainly a dynamic playmaker and passer, as he showed while averaging over six assists per game this season. But he could be turnover-prone and didn’t have a consistent way to score. He’s a real athlete, but he’s a bit undersized and needs to keep working on the jumper to create that threat to get defenders off-balance. He likes to drive downhill or to get out in transition to finish at the rim, but he’s inconsistent at doing that, having made only 50 percent of his attempts in the half court at the basket. There’s clear talent here, and a change of scenery may allow him to bloom. A well-spaced offense that is ball-screen dominant would fit his game best. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-1 Wt: 180

A former five-star prospect coming out of Sweden by way of high school powerhouse Link Academy in Missouri, Cadeau never quite found his footing at North Carolina after choosing to reclassify into the 2023 recruiting class. He’s certainly a dynamic playmaker and passer, as he showed while averaging over six assists per game this season. But he could be turnover-prone and didn’t have a consistent way to score. He’s a real athlete, but he’s a bit undersized and needs to keep working on the jumper to create that threat to get defenders off-balance. He likes to drive downhill or to get out in transition to finish at the rim, but he’s inconsistent at doing that, having made only 50 percent of his attempts in the half court at the basket. There’s clear talent here, and a change of scenery may allow him to bloom. A well-spaced offense that is ball-screen dominant would fit his game best. — Sam Vecenie

Guard

In Portal

North Carolina

Ht: 6-1Wt: 175

A two-time All-Mountain West pick, Thomas is one of the better floor generals available in the portal. He passes the ball extremely well and has a very attack-oriented mindset. He constantly trying to get downhill to the rim and does an amazing job of drawing fouls, averaging six per game. He also has a smooth lefty floater game and the ability to step out and drill shots from distance off the catch. But he’s also quite small, and that impacts his game in several ways. His finishing on the interior when he doesn’t draw contact isn’t great, and he isn’t always effective on defense. Still, expect Thomas to get a massive amount of money to run the show at a high-major next year, and he’ll have a real shot to be an all-conference pick as he puts up gaudy numbers.
— Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-1Wt: 175

A two-time All-Mountain West pick, Thomas is one of the better floor generals available in the portal. He passes the ball extremely well and has a very attack-oriented mindset. He constantly trying to get downhill to the rim and does an amazing job of drawing fouls, averaging six per game. He also has a smooth lefty floater game and the ability to step out and drill shots from distance off the catch. But he’s also quite small, and that impacts his game in several ways. His finishing on the interior when he doesn’t draw contact isn’t great, and he isn’t always effective on defense. Still, expect Thomas to get a massive amount of money to run the show at a high-major next year, and he’ll have a real shot to be an all-conference pick as he puts up gaudy numbers.
— Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-7Wt: 185

Freeman is a Division II prospect from Lincoln Memorial in Tennessee, the former stomping grounds of current Saint Louis coach Josh Schertz. He’s twitchy and athletic and has the look of a real NBA prospect down the road. He has significant burst and hit around 40 percent of his 3s this season. He’s 6-7, and it’s hard to find players this big, skilled and athletic. So, where does he slot in as a transfer? He’s still quite skinny, and while he has a creative handle, it feels like it can get away from him a bit too often. Going to a place like Saint Louis would make the most sense. Play in an uptempo scheme that is conducive to your athleticism and continue to grow physically in a league that is a bit more forgiving than the highest of high-majors. Having said that, he’s a prospect worth investing in if you are a high-major program.
— Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-7Wt: 185

Freeman is a Division II prospect from Lincoln Memorial in Tennessee, the former stomping grounds of current Saint Louis coach Josh Schertz. He’s twitchy and athletic and has the look of a real NBA prospect down the road. He has significant burst and hit around 40 percent of his 3s this season. He’s 6-7, and it’s hard to find players this big, skilled and athletic. So, where does he slot in as a transfer? He’s still quite skinny, and while he has a creative handle, it feels like it can get away from him a bit too often. Going to a place like Saint Louis would make the most sense. Play in an uptempo scheme that is conducive to your athleticism and continue to grow physically in a league that is a bit more forgiving than the highest of high-majors. Having said that, he’s a prospect worth investing in if you are a high-major program.
— Sam Vecenie

Wing

In Portal

Lincoln Mem.

Ht: 7-0Wt: 240

Quality bigs seem to be the most expensive asset in the portal, and Tilly will likely draw lots of attention because of his size and advanced numbers. The second-team All-WCC center has solid per-game averages, but his advanced numbers pop. He had a 117.8 offensive rating and a high free-throw rate, drawing 4.7 fouls per 40 minutes. He’s a skilled big who can score in the post and step out to make a jumper — he made 17 3s in ‘24-25. And most promisingly, he had some of his best games against Santa Clara’s best opponents: 17 points and eight boards against Saint Louis, 16 points against Stanford, 21 points against Bradley and 17 points on 7-of-9 shooting in an upset of Gonzaga. — C.J. Moore

Ht: 7-0Wt: 240

Quality bigs seem to be the most expensive asset in the portal, and Tilly will likely draw lots of attention because of his size and advanced numbers. The second-team All-WCC center has solid per-game averages, but his advanced numbers pop. He had a 117.8 offensive rating and a high free-throw rate, drawing 4.7 fouls per 40 minutes. He’s a skilled big who can score in the post and step out to make a jumper — he made 17 3s in ‘24-25. And most promisingly, he had some of his best games against Santa Clara’s best opponents: 17 points and eight boards against Saint Louis, 16 points against Stanford, 21 points against Bradley and 17 points on 7-of-9 shooting in an upset of Gonzaga. — C.J. Moore

Center

In Portal

Santa Clara

Ht: 6-3 Wt: 180

Agbim is well-traveled; his next school will be his fourth in five years after three juco seasons and a season at Wyoming. He could be the best three-level scorer in the portal: He drilled 44 percent of his six 3s per game and has real juice in the open court to lead the break, fill lanes or space to the corners. His shot is smooth and translatable to any situation, and he plays off that threat well by getting into the midrange and finding pull-ups, which he hits at about 45 percent. Give him a ball screen, and he’ll snake his way into a good look. While he doesn’t get to the rim often in halfcourt settings, he makes those at a reasonable clip for a guard and has a nice little floater package. Essentially, Agbim is a professional scorer playing in college. He’ll need to play next to a bigger distributor and defender to find the most success. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-3 Wt: 180

Agbim is well-traveled; his next school will be his fourth in five years after three juco seasons and a season at Wyoming. He could be the best three-level scorer in the portal: He drilled 44 percent of his six 3s per game and has real juice in the open court to lead the break, fill lanes or space to the corners. His shot is smooth and translatable to any situation, and he plays off that threat well by getting into the midrange and finding pull-ups, which he hits at about 45 percent. Give him a ball screen, and he’ll snake his way into a good look. While he doesn’t get to the rim often in halfcourt settings, he makes those at a reasonable clip for a guard and has a nice little floater package. Essentially, Agbim is a professional scorer playing in college. He’ll need to play next to a bigger distributor and defender to find the most success. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-3Wt: 180

Boyd is coming off an All-Mountain West season at San Diego State, where he defended at the point of attack and consistently made good decisions in an offensive structure that looked awfully archaic for long stretches. He’s not a wildly dynamic downhill driver, and he’s a good shooter (not a great one), but Boyd is extremely reliable and can be counted on to organize his team as a lead guard. I don’t know that I quite see him as an all-conference guy at the high-major level, but he can be a big part of a winning team as a starter in the right spot — as he proved when he was a starting guard as a sophomore during Florida Atlantic’s 2023 Final Four run. — Sam Vecenie 

Ht: 6-3Wt: 180

Boyd is coming off an All-Mountain West season at San Diego State, where he defended at the point of attack and consistently made good decisions in an offensive structure that looked awfully archaic for long stretches. He’s not a wildly dynamic downhill driver, and he’s a good shooter (not a great one), but Boyd is extremely reliable and can be counted on to organize his team as a lead guard. I don’t know that I quite see him as an all-conference guy at the high-major level, but he can be a big part of a winning team as a starter in the right spot — as he proved when he was a starting guard as a sophomore during Florida Atlantic’s 2023 Final Four run. — Sam Vecenie 

Guard

In Portal

San Diego St

Ht: 6-3Wt: 180

George, originally from Toronto, emerged from out of nowhere at the 2023 Peach Jam, signed that summer with Georgia Tech and has grown into one of the better point guards in the ACC. He has a slick handle and a high-level feel working out of ball screens. He can also shoot behind a screen — he made 36 of his 60 3s off the bounce, per Synergy — shimmy his way into the paint and score there, or find an open teammate. He’s one of the best passers in the portal. He has high turnover numbers (3.0 per game) and is susceptible to trying to make the home-run pass, but he has the vision, size and ability to make just about every pass. He’s not a great finisher at the basket, but in the right system with shooters around him and paired with a good pick-and-roll or pick-and-pop big, he would likely flourish. — C.J. Moore 

Ht: 6-3Wt: 180

George, originally from Toronto, emerged from out of nowhere at the 2023 Peach Jam, signed that summer with Georgia Tech and has grown into one of the better point guards in the ACC. He has a slick handle and a high-level feel working out of ball screens. He can also shoot behind a screen — he made 36 of his 60 3s off the bounce, per Synergy — shimmy his way into the paint and score there, or find an open teammate. He’s one of the best passers in the portal. He has high turnover numbers (3.0 per game) and is susceptible to trying to make the home-run pass, but he has the vision, size and ability to make just about every pass. He’s not a great finisher at the basket, but in the right system with shooters around him and paired with a good pick-and-roll or pick-and-pop big, he would likely flourish. — C.J. Moore 

Wing

In Portal

Georgia Tech

Ht: 6-8 Wt: 235

Reneau, a former top-30 recruit, has a terrific mid-post game and sharp low-post footwork. He’s about as physical a player as you’ll find down there, always trying to hunt contact to create a bit of separation for him to score with his left hand. I worry that he’s a bit undersized to be a high-major center, but that’s where his game works best on offense, unless you have a big who can step out and shoot. A league like the ACC is probably the best bet for him. Two schools to watch: Georgia because Mike White originally recruited Reneau to Florida but lost him to Indiana when he took the Bulldogs’ head coaching job, and Miami because it’s Reneau’s hometown and the assistant who led his recruitment at Florida, Erik Pastrana, just joined the Hurricanes’ staff. — Sam Vecenie 

Ht: 6-8 Wt: 235

Reneau, a former top-30 recruit, has a terrific mid-post game and sharp low-post footwork. He’s about as physical a player as you’ll find down there, always trying to hunt contact to create a bit of separation for him to score with his left hand. I worry that he’s a bit undersized to be a high-major center, but that’s where his game works best on offense, unless you have a big who can step out and shoot. A league like the ACC is probably the best bet for him. Two schools to watch: Georgia because Mike White originally recruited Reneau to Florida but lost him to Indiana when he took the Bulldogs’ head coaching job, and Miami because it’s Reneau’s hometown and the assistant who led his recruitment at Florida, Erik Pastrana, just joined the Hurricanes’ staff. — Sam Vecenie 

Ht: 6-5Wt: 190

An expected one-and-done, Bethea’s season didn’t go as planned. The former top-10 recruit showed great range beyond the 3-point line in both pull-up and catch-and-shoot situations. He’s also big enough to play both guard positions down the road, although this season I didn’t feel like his handle was quite strong enough to initiate the offense. It would help Bethea to keep getting stronger, but he’s also a willing defender, and there aren’t many big combo guards available. After Miami’s disastrous season and December coaching change, it might be as simple as getting Bethea into a competent situation that will allow him to grow. Some sharp high-major should still take a flyer on him. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-5Wt: 190

An expected one-and-done, Bethea’s season didn’t go as planned. The former top-10 recruit showed great range beyond the 3-point line in both pull-up and catch-and-shoot situations. He’s also big enough to play both guard positions down the road, although this season I didn’t feel like his handle was quite strong enough to initiate the offense. It would help Bethea to keep getting stronger, but he’s also a willing defender, and there aren’t many big combo guards available. After Miami’s disastrous season and December coaching change, it might be as simple as getting Bethea into a competent situation that will allow him to grow. Some sharp high-major should still take a flyer on him. — Sam Vecenie

Guard

In Portal

Miami (Fla.)

Ht: 6-8 Wt: 240

Teams that love to play five-out, spacing-conscious basketball will prioritize Davidson in the portal. It’s hard to find bigs who can step away and fire, and Davidson can do just that. He hit 37 percent from 3 this past year and has a really nice inside-out game as a stretch four that should translate up levels. He’s very skilled as a passer, too. With one year left, he’s a good flyer for a creative offensive coach to take. But the players around him will need to be conscious defensively to get the most out of him. I think it’s reasonable to expect an impact similar to Kentucky’s Andrew Carr. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-8 Wt: 240

Teams that love to play five-out, spacing-conscious basketball will prioritize Davidson in the portal. It’s hard to find bigs who can step away and fire, and Davidson can do just that. He hit 37 percent from 3 this past year and has a really nice inside-out game as a stretch four that should translate up levels. He’s very skilled as a passer, too. With one year left, he’s a good flyer for a creative offensive coach to take. But the players around him will need to be conscious defensively to get the most out of him. I think it’s reasonable to expect an impact similar to Kentucky’s Andrew Carr. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-10Wt: 230

The Missouri Valley has a long history of successfully sending players to the high-major level. Expect Schwieger to be next in line. He largely played the five as a two-year starter at Valpo and projects best there athletically at the high-major level. He’s also improved his frame over the last year, which should allow him to find success against physical players. He has kind of a funky load into his shot but has made about 33 percent of his 3s in college on about three attempts per game. His footwork in ball screens as a roller or a pick-and-pop player is terrific, and he also can run dribble handoffs to roll, pop or reject and get all the way to the rim himself. Defensively, there will be some athletic concerns, but don’t sleep on his timing as a shot blocker: He swatted two shots per game to lead the Missouri Valley. A team trying to play five-out would do well to give him a shot.  —Sam Vecenie 

Ht: 6-10Wt: 230

The Missouri Valley has a long history of successfully sending players to the high-major level. Expect Schwieger to be next in line. He largely played the five as a two-year starter at Valpo and projects best there athletically at the high-major level. He’s also improved his frame over the last year, which should allow him to find success against physical players. He has kind of a funky load into his shot but has made about 33 percent of his 3s in college on about three attempts per game. His footwork in ball screens as a roller or a pick-and-pop player is terrific, and he also can run dribble handoffs to roll, pop or reject and get all the way to the rim himself. Defensively, there will be some athletic concerns, but don’t sleep on his timing as a shot blocker: He swatted two shots per game to lead the Missouri Valley. A team trying to play five-out would do well to give him a shot.  —Sam Vecenie 

Forward

In Portal

Valparaiso

Ht: 6-7Wt: 215

A big Italian wing who came to Evansville by way of the NBA Academy in Australia, Pozzato is more athletic than you’d expect and plays with authority when he decides to get to the rim. He’s a sharp cutter and mover without the ball and attacks close-outs at a high-level. If you let him get downhill in a straight line, it’s a rack attack. The key for Pozzato is the jumper. He only made 32 percent of his 3s last year despite taking six per game and possessing a fluid stroke that should translate to made shots in the future. He looks like a perfect option to play off of dynamic guards at the high-major level and not be as responsible for creating offense as he was at times this season. — Sam Vecenie 

Ht: 6-7Wt: 215

A big Italian wing who came to Evansville by way of the NBA Academy in Australia, Pozzato is more athletic than you’d expect and plays with authority when he decides to get to the rim. He’s a sharp cutter and mover without the ball and attacks close-outs at a high-level. If you let him get downhill in a straight line, it’s a rack attack. The key for Pozzato is the jumper. He only made 32 percent of his 3s last year despite taking six per game and possessing a fluid stroke that should translate to made shots in the future. He looks like a perfect option to play off of dynamic guards at the high-major level and not be as responsible for creating offense as he was at times this season. — Sam Vecenie 

Ht: 6-1 Wt: 180

Rataj has a genuinely fascinating game that has prompted me to reach out to multiple coaches to get a read on where they stand on him. The German forward is a dynamic four man who can dribble, pass and shoot at 6-9. He was a serious mismatch nightmare at the WCC level this year for Oregon State, where his ability to use his frame and skill level made him an exceptionally difficult cover. He could just as easily shoot from 3, where he hit 35 percent, attack in a straight line from the 3-point line or post a smaller player. However, he’s not all that explosive, either, and that could get him into some trouble areas. He’s also quite active with his hands on defense and seems to have awesome hand-eye coordination. Rataj is a player who will fit best in a five-out offense that will give him room to operate. But fit will be important to his success. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-1 Wt: 180

Rataj has a genuinely fascinating game that has prompted me to reach out to multiple coaches to get a read on where they stand on him. The German forward is a dynamic four man who can dribble, pass and shoot at 6-9. He was a serious mismatch nightmare at the WCC level this year for Oregon State, where his ability to use his frame and skill level made him an exceptionally difficult cover. He could just as easily shoot from 3, where he hit 35 percent, attack in a straight line from the 3-point line or post a smaller player. However, he’s not all that explosive, either, and that could get him into some trouble areas. He’s also quite active with his hands on defense and seems to have awesome hand-eye coordination. Rataj is a player who will fit best in a five-out offense that will give him room to operate. But fit will be important to his success. — Sam Vecenie

Forward

In Portal

Oregon State

Ht: 6-11 Wt: 260

A massive, wide Australian big man who took some time to develop, Cluff is getting an extra year as a player who started his career at a junior college. He’s played at the high-major level before, proving that he could be a starter on an NCAA Tournament team at Washington State. He transferred down for a bigger role this year at South Dakota State and flourished. He finished second nationally in rebounding and has a soft touch on the interior. He’s not particularly vertical, but few bigs across the country do a better job of using their frame to seal off defenders to create space. That lack of vertical pop could make it a bit easier to contest him at a higher level, and I don’t think I’d expect him to average 17 again. But if you put him in an offense like Gonzaga’s, which makes a concerted effort to seal and post, he could thrive again at the highest level.
— Sam Vecenie 

Ht: 6-11 Wt: 260

A massive, wide Australian big man who took some time to develop, Cluff is getting an extra year as a player who started his career at a junior college. He’s played at the high-major level before, proving that he could be a starter on an NCAA Tournament team at Washington State. He transferred down for a bigger role this year at South Dakota State and flourished. He finished second nationally in rebounding and has a soft touch on the interior. He’s not particularly vertical, but few bigs across the country do a better job of using their frame to seal off defenders to create space. That lack of vertical pop could make it a bit easier to contest him at a higher level, and I don’t think I’d expect him to average 17 again. But if you put him in an offense like Gonzaga’s, which makes a concerted effort to seal and post, he could thrive again at the highest level.
— Sam Vecenie 

Center

In Portal

South Dakota St

Ht: 6-11Wt:270

The starting center and interior anchor on a top-10 defense this year, Jackson is a ready-made starting center at 6-11 and 270 pounds. He’s well-traveled, having gone from Washington State to Charlotte to Iowa State, and is still eligible after taking a medical redshirt at Washington State in 2021-22 to correct a genetic variation in his heart. There’s certainly some game-to-game inconsistency, and you would expect him to finish a bit better than he does at this size. He can be a bit of an adventure as a defensive rebounder, too, because his hands can be awkward and he’s not overly twitchy. But he’s a good screener, and he does a great job of creating driving lanes for his guards with seals. Defensively, he’s just a massive body on the interior who takes up space and contests. In a portal not exactly littered with huge humans, he can come in and start for a mid-tier high-major.
— Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-11Wt:270

The starting center and interior anchor on a top-10 defense this year, Jackson is a ready-made starting center at 6-11 and 270 pounds. He’s well-traveled, having gone from Washington State to Charlotte to Iowa State, and is still eligible after taking a medical redshirt at Washington State in 2021-22 to correct a genetic variation in his heart. There’s certainly some game-to-game inconsistency, and you would expect him to finish a bit better than he does at this size. He can be a bit of an adventure as a defensive rebounder, too, because his hands can be awkward and he’s not overly twitchy. But he’s a good screener, and he does a great job of creating driving lanes for his guards with seals. Defensively, he’s just a massive body on the interior who takes up space and contests. In a portal not exactly littered with huge humans, he can come in and start for a mid-tier high-major.
— Sam Vecenie

Center

In Portal

Iowa State

Ht: 6-9 Wt: 205

Davis is at his best as an athletic slasher and cutter who finds his way to the rim either by driving in a straight line, waiting in the dunker spot or cutting. If you give him even a little bit of space, he’s going to get downhill in a hurry by using his long strides to find his way to the rim. He also does a great job of playing through contact, as he drew six foul shots per game this year. He’s continued to get better every year as a shooter, too and made 30 percent of his 3s this year. That’s the swing skill here. If Davis can’t shoot, he’s probably more of a role player at the high-major level on a great team. If he gets to work on the jumper over the summer and figures things out, then he has a chance to be a significant impact player given his length and athleticism at the four at around 6-9.
— Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-9 Wt: 205

Davis is at his best as an athletic slasher and cutter who finds his way to the rim either by driving in a straight line, waiting in the dunker spot or cutting. If you give him even a little bit of space, he’s going to get downhill in a hurry by using his long strides to find his way to the rim. He also does a great job of playing through contact, as he drew six foul shots per game this year. He’s continued to get better every year as a shooter, too and made 30 percent of his 3s this year. That’s the swing skill here. If Davis can’t shoot, he’s probably more of a role player at the high-major level on a great team. If he gets to work on the jumper over the summer and figures things out, then he has a chance to be a significant impact player given his length and athleticism at the four at around 6-9.
— Sam Vecenie

Forward

In Portal

Notre Dame

Ht: 6-8Wt: 240

Hansberry is the perfect five-out center in that he understands screening angles, can pass, can pop and make a 3, and he is excellent in dribble-handoff actions. He can also play as more of a traditional big-man role and score over both shoulders. He has excellent feel for the game and knows where to be on both ends. He’s also a good rebounder, knowing where to position himself and how to use his body. The shot looks good — he made 35 3s last year — but the percentage (29.2) wasn’t ideal. Maybe that’ll improve. Where Hansberry is limited is in his length and athleticism. He can sometimes struggle to finish around the basket against length, and he’s not a rim protector. He played center for West Virginia, and he is skilled enough to slide over to the four, although guarding more athletic fours could be an issue. But in the right system that utilizes his abilities as a hub on the perimeter, he’s a really effective player. — C.J. Moore

Ht: 6-8Wt: 240

Hansberry is the perfect five-out center in that he understands screening angles, can pass, can pop and make a 3, and he is excellent in dribble-handoff actions. He can also play as more of a traditional big-man role and score over both shoulders. He has excellent feel for the game and knows where to be on both ends. He’s also a good rebounder, knowing where to position himself and how to use his body. The shot looks good — he made 35 3s last year — but the percentage (29.2) wasn’t ideal. Maybe that’ll improve. Where Hansberry is limited is in his length and athleticism. He can sometimes struggle to finish around the basket against length, and he’s not a rim protector. He played center for West Virginia, and he is skilled enough to slide over to the four, although guarding more athletic fours could be an issue. But in the right system that utilizes his abilities as a hub on the perimeter, he’s a really effective player. — C.J. Moore

Forward

In Portal

West Virginia

Ht: 6-1 Wt: 175

The SoCon Player of the Year this past season, Peterson led ETSU to a 12-6 league mark and morphed into a dominant player late in the year, averaging 11 points while shooting 45 percent from 3 in his final 12 games. He’s a fast, jittery lead guard who can be a high-volume 3-point shooter when he’s rolling. He’ll make shots off movement and tends to thrive most off the catch, drilling 46.5 percent of his catch-and-shoot 3s, per Synergy. But I don’t really think he’s a high-major lead guard, either. He’s best running off actions or relocating and finding open areas. However, he’s just a bit small for that role at the highest levels. You’ll need a big guard next to him who can help share ballhandling responsibilities. But Peterson is a good bet to be a good high-major scoring guard next year.
— C.J. Moore

Ht: 6-1 Wt: 175

The SoCon Player of the Year this past season, Peterson led ETSU to a 12-6 league mark and morphed into a dominant player late in the year, averaging 11 points while shooting 45 percent from 3 in his final 12 games. He’s a fast, jittery lead guard who can be a high-volume 3-point shooter when he’s rolling. He’ll make shots off movement and tends to thrive most off the catch, drilling 46.5 percent of his catch-and-shoot 3s, per Synergy. But I don’t really think he’s a high-major lead guard, either. He’s best running off actions or relocating and finding open areas. However, he’s just a bit small for that role at the highest levels. You’ll need a big guard next to him who can help share ballhandling responsibilities. But Peterson is a good bet to be a good high-major scoring guard next year.
— C.J. Moore

Ht: 6-6 Wt: 190

Eaglestaff is a volcano waiting to happen, a dynamic wing scorer who can fire the ball from distance as well as use the threat of that shot to score in other ways. This year alone, he dropped 40 on Alabama and had 51 points against South Dakota State in the conference tournament. He’s a ridiculously tough shot-maker when he’s on, but he also was tasked with taking some absolutely wild attempts for North Dakota this year. That ultimately dragged down his efficiency. The key for a high-major will be finding a role for Eaglestaff that allows him to take easier shots — which will be easier when pairing him with high-level shot creators. He’ll have one year at high-major to show what he’s capable of after playing for a pretty rough North Dakota team that he wasn’t able to elevate. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-6 Wt: 190

Eaglestaff is a volcano waiting to happen, a dynamic wing scorer who can fire the ball from distance as well as use the threat of that shot to score in other ways. This year alone, he dropped 40 on Alabama and had 51 points against South Dakota State in the conference tournament. He’s a ridiculously tough shot-maker when he’s on, but he also was tasked with taking some absolutely wild attempts for North Dakota this year. That ultimately dragged down his efficiency. The key for a high-major will be finding a role for Eaglestaff that allows him to take easier shots — which will be easier when pairing him with high-level shot creators. He’ll have one year at high-major to show what he’s capable of after playing for a pretty rough North Dakota team that he wasn’t able to elevate. — Sam Vecenie

Wing

In Portal

North Dakota

Ht: 6-1 Wt: 185

Wilkinson was a fun surprise for Cal, finishing among the national scoring leaders for first-year players. He has a dynamic game off the bounce, with the ability to both drive and find pull-up options. But the decision making on some of his shots was often an adventure, and he’ll need to moderate that as he moves to a winning team. It can also be a struggle to place pure scoring guards roughly his size in the lineup, given how much they can give back on defense. Still, Cal was much better when Wilkinson was on the court because of his ability to beat his man, and that’ll provide value wherever he ends up. He’s from Georgia, so don’t be surprised to see him head back east. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-1 Wt: 185

Wilkinson was a fun surprise for Cal, finishing among the national scoring leaders for first-year players. He has a dynamic game off the bounce, with the ability to both drive and find pull-up options. But the decision making on some of his shots was often an adventure, and he’ll need to moderate that as he moves to a winning team. It can also be a struggle to place pure scoring guards roughly his size in the lineup, given how much they can give back on defense. Still, Cal was much better when Wilkinson was on the court because of his ability to beat his man, and that’ll provide value wherever he ends up. He’s from Georgia, so don’t be surprised to see him head back east. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-8 Wt: 225

This one is going to be complicated. Mgbako has shown moments of brilliance, and as a former five-star with long arms and shooting potential, he will have an awful lot of suitors. But, man, there is just an awful lot of bad tape, too, where he looks completely invisible on offense because the jump shot isn’t consistent enough yet and his defensive intensity wavers. Maybe it’s as simple as Mike Woodson not being able to get through to him, but the ‘24-25 Hoosiers were a better team when Mgbako was off the court, per CBB Analytics: They gave up nearly 10 points more per 100 possessions when he played (by far the worst of the nine players to play at least 300 minutes). If a change of scenery is all that was needed, a team could reap massive dividends — or it could come away disappointed. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-8 Wt: 225

This one is going to be complicated. Mgbako has shown moments of brilliance, and as a former five-star with long arms and shooting potential, he will have an awful lot of suitors. But, man, there is just an awful lot of bad tape, too, where he looks completely invisible on offense because the jump shot isn’t consistent enough yet and his defensive intensity wavers. Maybe it’s as simple as Mike Woodson not being able to get through to him, but the ‘24-25 Hoosiers were a better team when Mgbako was off the court, per CBB Analytics: They gave up nearly 10 points more per 100 possessions when he played (by far the worst of the nine players to play at least 300 minutes). If a change of scenery is all that was needed, a team could reap massive dividends — or it could come away disappointed. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-7 Wt: 215

Sutton earned Summit League player of the year honors while leading Omaha to the NCAA Tournament, but he’s not particularly elite at any skill by high-major standards. He posted smaller players well in the Summit. He made the occasional 3 off the catch. He attacks in transition and can get downhill in a straight line. But I’m not sure I see him as a shot creator at the highest level; he only hit 27 percent from 3 last year, and his post game isn’t particularly well-developed. If you’re looking for a dynamic athlete to play in an uptempo scheme, Sutton should work. But he’ll need to find the right fit that works for him. Something like the St. John’s scheme would have potential. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-7 Wt: 215

Sutton earned Summit League player of the year honors while leading Omaha to the NCAA Tournament, but he’s not particularly elite at any skill by high-major standards. He posted smaller players well in the Summit. He made the occasional 3 off the catch. He attacks in transition and can get downhill in a straight line. But I’m not sure I see him as a shot creator at the highest level; he only hit 27 percent from 3 last year, and his post game isn’t particularly well-developed. If you’re looking for a dynamic athlete to play in an uptempo scheme, Sutton should work. But he’ll need to find the right fit that works for him. Something like the St. John’s scheme would have potential. — Sam Vecenie

Ht: 6-6 Wt: 200

Rohde was one of the most improved players in the ACC, as it took a year for him to adjust to the level after transferring from St. Thomas following his freshman year. He’s an exceptional passer, leading Virginia in assists. He’s elite in catch-and-shoot situations and also able to shoot off movement, which he did a lot in Virginia’s system, which frequently runs its shooters off screens. Rohde is not a big-time scorer, but he should be a popular target because he’s a heady player who should not be hard to incorporate into a winning system. — C.J. Moore

Ht: 6-6 Wt: 200

Rohde was one of the most improved players in the ACC, as it took a year for him to adjust to the level after transferring from St. Thomas following his freshman year. He’s an exceptional passer, leading Virginia in assists. He’s elite in catch-and-shoot situations and also able to shoot off movement, which he did a lot in Virginia’s system, which frequently runs its shooters off screens. Rohde is not a big-time scorer, but he should be a popular target because he’s a heady player who should not be hard to incorporate into a winning system. — C.J. Moore

(Illustration: Will Tullos / The Athletic; Photos: Porter Binks, Jamie Squire, Zach Bolinger, Joe Robbins / Getty Images)

Visually impaired NBA fans experience the game on a new level with haptic device

PORTLAND, Ore. — Brian Vu has been a fan of the NBA for 14 years, but he has never experienced a game like the one he attended last week in Portland.

Not only did his hometown Trail Blazers beat the Memphis Grizzlies, but also for the first time in his life, Vu said he felt involved in the game, every bit a part of the 18,491 in attendance at Moda Center.

Vu, who has low vision, didn’t see one play during the Blazers’ 115-99 win. But he felt every score, every turnover, every shot.

The 32-year-old Vu used a haptic device that allowed him to follow the action in real time through vibrations felt through his fingers. The device was unveiled this season by Seattle-based OneCourt. After three pilot trials last spring, the Trail Blazers in January became the first NBA team to offer the service to fans. Since then, Sacramento and Phoenix also have been offering the devices at games.

Using a laptop-sized device that has the outline of the basketball court, visually impaired users feel vibrations that indicate ball movement. An earpiece gives updates on the score, as well as the result of a play, whether it’s a steal, block, 3-pointer or something else.

OneCourt founder Jerred Mace likens the concept to a tactile animator, creating the illusion of movement through pixels.

“We’ve basically built this display that functions similarly to a visual screen, but instead of pixels that you see, these are pixels that you feel,” Mace said.

So while Vu couldn’t see Blazers guard Scoot Henderson, his favorite player, zip through the defense for a layup, he could feel the play through his fingertips, which were spread out over the device that rested on his legs.


Brian Vu uses the OneCourt device for the visually impaired to follow along at a live Portland Trail Blazers game. (Jason Quick / The Athletic)

Vu said his fan experience had changed exponentially.

“It’s pretty cool. I feel more independent,” Vu said. “I’m usually bugging my friend during the game, asking him, ‘What’s happening?’ So now, I can interpret the game in my head … and I don’t feel excluded.”

Vu attended the Blazers-Grizzlies game with his friend James Kim, the recipient of many of Vu’s elbow jabs and questions during games over the years. As the Blazers pulled away in the third quarter, Kim and Vu were in sync, oohing and aahing when Shaedon Sharpe dunked or Donovan Clingan rejected shots.

“Usually, he’s like, ‘Who shot that? What just happened?’ It was not that big of a deal for me, but this is definitely an upgrade,” Kim said of Vu. “He can enjoy the game without having to stop and get the details from me, so I think it’s great for him.”

Vu’s experience is exactly what Mace hoped for when he brainstormed the idea as a student at the University of Washington. Mace, 24, grew up in Spokane, Wash., with parents with disabilities. He also wore glasses so thick he was called “goggles” by classmates. He had astigmatism in his left eye — what people could see 80 feet away, he would see at only 20 feet — and although his vision improved through surgeries and by wearing a patch over the right eye, he was left with a lasting empathy and understanding for those with disabilities.

“You bundle those experiences together, and I think that just primed my heart for this work,” Mace said. “I think it’s given me a ton of perspective and appreciation for what it’s like to experience the world differently.”

During his junior year at Washington, he was surfing through social media when he discovered a video of a blind person watching a soccer match. A woman in the stands moved his hands across a board to mimic the game action.

The idea of OneCourt was born.

“The physicality of that experience stood out to me, and as someone who struggled with vision, it was such an appealing intersection for me,” Mace said.


The OneCourt staff, led by founder Jerred Mace (far right), has produced an effective way for visually impaired fans to enjoy athletic events. (Courtesy of OneCourt)

He presented his idea at the University of Washington’s 2022 Science and Technology Showcase. The idea was in its infancy, just a research poster with no physical product, but it won first place and a $2,000 prize.

The contest used tennis as the example, but Mace had broader aspirations. The key, he knew, would be linking the idea with readily available data. Beginning with the 2023-24 season, all NBA arenas were equipped with optical tracking technology, which captures player and ball movement in real time. The NBA says up to 20 tracking devices are stationed in the rafters of each arena.

Mace reached out to the Trail Blazers with the idea and, with their help, was introduced to the NBA. The league has seen value in working with Mace.

“We’ve been thrilled to work with Jerred and the team at OneCourt to use technology to help advance their mission of enabling visually impaired fans enjoy NBA games,” said Jason Bieber, the NBA’s vice president of new business ventures. “We’re especially excited to have OneCourt in the current cohort of NBA Launchpad companies so we can continue to partner and explore even more possibilities in the space.”

Within four months, Mace had access to the NBA data and began running pilot tests at the end of last season.

“The NBA is innovative when it comes to technology like this and when it comes to accessibility for their fans,” said Matthew Gardner, the Blazers’ senior director of customer insights. “They saw the good that it could do, and they were like, ‘Hey, no problem. We’ll unlock it for you.’”

Mace added: “I think (the NBA) is always looking for new applications for their data, and this happens to be a very special one. It’s not analytics on the back end. It’s not sports betting on the front end. It’s something that had the potential to change someone’s life and their entire experience and relationship with sports.”


A Blazers fan claps while a OneCourt device rests on his lap. The device creates a focused, yet intimate game-day scene for the visually impaired. (Courtesy of Portland Trail Blazers)

Vu and Kim can attest: When Vu experienced the Blazers game with the OneCourt device, it was a game changer. From their end zone seats, Vu and Kim were as locked in and vocal as anyone in the arena.

Vu couldn’t clap because it would cause his hands to lose track of the action. But his legs were in constant movement, and he joined in with the crowd chanting “DE-FENSE! DE-FENSE!”

“There was a steal, and you can feel the vibration go to the other side — really fast — and I got super excited,” Vu said. “I knew why the crowd was cheering. Before, I wouldn’t understand what was happening.”

Vu estimated he used to go to Blazers games once a year. It was exciting to hear the crowd and the sounds, but he always felt detached and behind.

“Now it’s a whole different experience,” he said. “I’ve got the best of both worlds.”

Kim could only smile as he watched Vu’s hands moving quickly across the device, his feet nervously tapping.

“He’s really into the game,” Kim said, nodding toward his friend. “He’s, like, zoning in on it.”

Gardner said several other NBA teams have called and asked him for feedback after the Blazers debuted the device on Jan. 11. He tells the teams that nearly every home game has had at least one device checked out, and offering the device is essential to the fan experience.

“Being a fan should be for everybody,” Gardner said. “This unlocks an entirely new world for our fans who are blind and have low vision. We’ve seen it across all the faces of those who have used it so far.”

Mace said his company of eight employees, five of whom work full time, is bracing for the demand as more teams inquire about the services. Portland and Sacramento have five devices that can be reserved ahead of time or checked out on the concourse, while Phoenix has 10 devices. Fans do not need to pay for the device, thanks to Ticketmaster, an NBA sponsor.

Mace says the impact expands beyond the number of people using the device.

“One might think, ‘Oh, this device just impacts five people in a stadium.’ But really, the ripple effects are incredible,” Mace said. “Now, the circle of who is going to the game — friends and family — has expanded because everyone can share the experience.”

Vu said the device was easy to use after listening to a two-minute tutorial, but he wishes the audio could include specific indications, like which player has the ball and which player is shooting. Those could be updates for the future.

For now, Vu said knowing the Blazers offer the device increases his chances of attending more games.

“Oh, 1,000 percent,” Vu said. “Instead of maybe one game a year, I could see myself going to five a year. It’s just a better experience.”

(Top photo courtesy of Portland Trail Blazers)

NFL projection model: Raiders, Commanders winning the offseason; 49ers, Cowboys slipping

The NFL offseason is well underway, and while the upcoming NFL Draft will shake things up even more, there has been no shortage of roster-altering moves. The biggest, of course, have come at quarterback. We’re still waiting for one big domino (Aaron Rodgers) to fall, but we’ve already seen huge shifts in the QB landscape. No. 1, of course, was the Seattle Seahawks trading Geno Smith to the Las Vegas Raiders before signing former Minnesota Vikings quarterback Sam Darnold to be their new signal caller.

How did those moves, and all of the others made so far this offseason, affect their teams’ outlooks for the 2025 season? It’s a bit like asking: Who have been the biggest winners and losers of the offseason so far? We’re going to attempt to answer that analytically using our NFL Projection Model.

Before we get there, it bears repeating: A lot can change. Teams have plenty of time to alter their standing in these rankings. But we wanted to examine where things are right now. How much value have some teams added? How much have some teams lost?

To measure that, my model uses a handful of advanced metrics and assigns a value to every player in the NFL. Think of that value as how much a single player affects the point spread of the expected winning percentage of a single game.

After that, I went through every transaction made this offseason and calculated the value added or lost (up through March 25). Since I’m only looking at how these moves affect each team for the 2025 season, my model does not factor in the length of the contract or money spent on contracts. It’s also important to note that this process only assesses players changing teams. Players who re-signed with their teams aren’t included because those players’ values were already included in their teams’ projections.

With that explanation out of the way, here’s a look at how many expected points each NFL team had added or lost this offseason.

Five Biggest Winners

Las Vegas Raiders

I’m not sure how any list doesn’t include the Raiders at the top, or at the very least inside the top three, after landing Smith. The Raiders roster isn’t ready to compete for a playoff spot, especially in the vaunted AFC West, but they’ve solidified the sport’s most important position with a quarterback who has proven he can give you a solid floor as a league-average QB with the ability for more. And with quarterback (presumably) locked down for the next few seasons, new coach Pete Carroll can focus on acquiring talent to fill out the rest of the roster.

New York Giants

The Giants were wise not to stop addressing the QB position after signing Jameis Winston last week. He now becomes their backup with the newly signed Russell Wilson leading the charge into 2025. Now we’ll see if they want to add a rookie to the mix in April. Beyond their solid start at QB, the Giants made some nice moves on defense by adding safety Jevon Holland and cornerback Paulson Adebo while improving the depth of their front seven. The Giants weren’t a QB away from anything significant, but they’ve quietly done a good job fortifying the roster at a position they still need to find a long-term answer for.

New England Patriots

The Patriots continued their free-agent spending spree Tuesday night, adding star wide receiver Stefon Diggs to a receiving group that needed a No. 1. After that splash signing, finishing third in these rankings might seem low. And maybe it is. It probably boils down to what you think of Harold Landry III as an edge rusher. My model thinks Landry is just fine — and that’s not a bad thing. Having average players on the roster can be good if you can put stars around them. Factor in Landry’s familiarity with new head coach Mike Vrabel, and you understand why New England made the move. Offensive tackle Morgan Moses and defensive tackle Milton Williams are the other additions my model likes, and if you think Landry will be better in this new system, you can easily make an argument for the Patriots jumping the Giants in these rankings and even threatening the Raiders for the top spot.

Indianapolis Colts

My model loved the Charvarius Ward signing, grading it as one of the most impactful moves made this offseason not involving a quarterback. While there is some risk — Ward is 28 years old — a change of scenery might be what just what the veteran cornerback needs to return to form as one of the best defensive backs in the league. Pair the Ward signing with the addition of safety Cam Bynum, and the Colts have done an excellent job of upgrading a secondary that badly needed one.

Washington Commanders

The Commanders made their splashes on the trade market rather than in free agency, and my model liked what they did. Laremy Tunsil remains one of the better left tackles in the league, and that was a position where Washington needed an upgrade. Meanwhile, wide receiver Deebo Samuel Sr. should fit into this Washington offense with his versatility, pairing well with the skill set of QB Jayden Daniels. Adding cornerback Jonathan Jones was another interesting move and one that my model liked. He’s up there in age (31) and didn’t have the greatest 2024 season, but if he bounces back in any way, watch out for the Commanders (again) this season.

Five Biggest Losers

New York Jets

The loss of Rodgers might be offset by the addition of Justin Fields, but there were still some major losses here. Davante Adams remains a very good wide receiver, despite getting up there in age; Moses is still a quality tackle; and the biggest loss, according to my projections, is D.J. Reed. Reed has been a quality cornerback for a while, and he’s going to be difficult to replace. I don’t necessarily disagree with letting these players walk, given the state of the roster and the price tags it would have taken to keep them in town, but there’s no debate the Jets lost some top talent this offseason.

San Francisco 49ers

This ranking shouldn’t come as a surprise to those tracking San Francisco’s offseason, which has seen a mass exodus of quality players. I already spoke about how much my model likes Ward, but the 49ers also lost Samuel, Jordan Mason, Aaron Banks, Dre Greenlaw, Talanoa Hufanga, Javon Hargrave, Leonard Floyd, Maliek Collins and Isaac Yiadom, among others. Maybe that’s the price of doing business after paying running back Christian McCaffrey and wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk ahead of of a new contract for quarterback Brock Purdy, but the 49ers are in the middle of a transitional period, and the state of their roster shows it.

Philadelphia Eagles

One of the byproducts of winning the Super Bowl, or just being consistently competitive in the NFL, is that players on your team earn significant raises. That’s just the way it goes. Last year, the Eagles and Chiefs were near the bottom of this list after the early part of free agency, and both reached the Super Bowl, so all hope isn’t lost in Philadelphia, especially with so much talent still on the roster. But no matter how you shake it, Philadelphia will be looking to replace a lot of snaps from this year’s championship-winning squad as Josh Sweat, Milton Williams, Brandon Graham, Darius Slay Jr., C.J. Gardner-Johnson and Isaiah Rodgers are all gone.

Dallas Cowboys

Staying in the NFC East here, the Cowboys will again be looking to primarily bolster their roster through the draft, which they’re pretty decent at, rather than free agency. The losses of DeMarcus Lawrence, Jourdan Lewis, and Chauncey Golston are daunting (though letting Lewis walk after one of his best seasons isn’t the worst decision), and the loss of Zack Martin to retirement will sting. He was certainly past his peak, but he was still a quality offensive lineman, and those are always hard to find.

Seattle Seahawks

What did you expect after they traded away their starting quarterback and a Pro Bowl-caliber wide receiver? If it’s any consolation to Seahawks fans, it’s impressive they aren’t last on this list. That’s because they replaced Smith and DK Metcalf with Darnold and Cooper Kupp to help offset those losses, while adding Lawrence to their defense. The model is skeptical Darnold can replicate his success from Minnesota, while Kupp and Lawrence are past their primes and have some injury concerns, so it’s no surprise the Seahawks still rank near the bottom.

(Photos of John Lynch, Pete Carroll and Geno Smith: Ezra Shaw and Tom Hauck / Getty Images)

The real Novak Djokovic tries to stand up in front of Serena Williams in Miami

MIAMI — After two decades of professional tennis, 99 career singles titles and 24 Grand Slam triumphs, Novak Djokovic has become a mystery — to tennis fans and to himself. Both parties are trying to answer the same question, from match to match and tournament to tournament, as his career moves towards an as-yet unknown end.

Who is the greatest player of the modern era at this moment?

Is he the player who faded two weeks ago against Botic van de Zandschulp, in his opening match at the BNP Paribas Open at Indian Wells, Calif.? Or is he the player who has plowed through his first three opponents in at the Miami Open the past five days, including Lorenzo Musetti, the world No. 16 from Italy?

Is he the player whose return of serve, one of the greatest in the sport’s history, has been a shadow of its usual self? Or is he the player who broke Musetti five times Tuesday night on his way to a 6-2, 6-2 win?

Is he the player ramping up his schedule as he approaches his 38th birthday, because it’s his last spin around the tennis globe? Or is he the player he described to the Miami crowd when he told them, “You’re going to be seeing me a few more years.”

When it comes to the subject of Novak Djokovic, Djokovic is like everyone else: always searching for the signal in the noise, searching for the data about himself and his tennis that will allow him to separate what matters from what does not. At this moment, there is both too much and not enough data to figure out who and what the Djokovic of 2025 is. All these years later, but just 14 matches into this season, he has become the sport’s international man of mystery — definitively not what he once was, and searching for the answer of what he will be.

“I do hope and wish for Novak that you saw tonight, and then at the same time, I worked hard not to have the Novak that was playing in Indian Wells,” Djokovic said in the mixed zone with reporters when his match with Musetti was over. “The continuity or consistency of the level of tennis nowadays for me is more challenging than it was years ago or 10 years ago, five years ago, and I know that.

“That’s definitely not due to lack of hours spent on the practice court and in the gym because I still keep the dedication. It’s there, but it’s just makes it a bit more challenging for me to maintain the level.”

Djokovic is living through a common misconception about what happens to elite athletes declining from their peaks. The apexes stay sharp and accessible in fleeting moments, even when they need them most: Djokovic found his on his otherworldly run to the gold medal at last year’s Paris Olympic Games. It’s the stability that erodes, the repetitions that are necessary to maintain their excellence.

Djokovic’s biggest triumph this year came at the Australian Open, where he beat Carlos Alcaraz in the quarterfinals after a series of wins that had included serious dips in his level, during which young and inexperienced opponents found ways to hurt him but could not finish him off.

Stunning as it was, the victory was also one of the strangest tennis matches in memory. Djokovic suffered a muscle tear in the first set, but somehow managed to win in four, thanks to a heady cocktail of painkillers, adrenalin and an inexplicable Alcaraz breakdown. The Spaniard succumbed to the stress of playing Djokovic, of thinking about his opponent’s tennis and his physical condition more than he was thinking of his own.

Three days later, Djokovic had to retire from his semifinal against Alexander Zverev at the end of the first set because of his muscle injury. When he arrived in Florida, he had not won a match since beating Alcaraz on that January night in Melbourne.

In Miami, he has wins against Rinky Hijikata, a 24-year-old Australian who has played 13 Grand Slam matches, just over half the number of Grand Slam titles that Djokovic has won. He then beat Camilo Ugo Carabelli, a 25-year-old Argentine who has never won a Grand Slam match.

Both matches opened with a blowout set and ended with Djokovic winning a tiebreak. It’s one of the most familiar patterns in Djokovic matches over the years, just inverted: the tight set to loosen everything up before the acceleration to victory swapped for a fast start and then an ebbing end.


Djokovic has eased through his opening matches at the Miami Open. (Geoff Burke / Imagn Images)

Then came Musetti. On paper, he looked like a legitimate threat. On the court, Djokovic picked up his head and saw Serena Williams sitting in the stands. He looked at his box and saw Andy Murray and Juan Martin Del Potro, the retired Grand Slam champions. One his coach; the other his good friend. All those big names made him a little starstruck and nervous about playing well, especially in front of Williams, the greatest female player of all time.

Musetti’s elegant all-court game suits grass, clay and slow hard courts, but he remains reasonably lost on fast ones. Against the best hard-court player in the history of the sport, he broke serve in the first game and surged to the illusion of a 2-0 lead built on making the match physical. Djokovic decided he wasn’t going to play a match like that and won the next nine games to seize control. Musetti showed about as much resistance as a swinging door.

On Wednesday night, Djokovic will face Sebastian Korda, the young and talented American of a thousand renaissances, seemingly always on the cusp of announcing himself. Korda, 24, is still trying to find his way after a couple of years of wrist injuries; he received treatment on his wrist during his round-of-16 win over Gael Monfils on Tuesday.

Djokovic won their only previous meeting, in Adelaide, Australia, two years ago. He might get some more data about their matchup and about himself Wednesday, but it’s not clear how fit Korda will be to give him what he needs. Djokovic at least has no doubts about his wants: to keep playing at the highest level in an era when even the youngest players approach the game with a level of professionalism unheard of when he was starting out.

“Fitness and recovery and just overall approach to the work, from both physical and mental side has improved so much,” he said in Miami.

“Nowadays, pretty much every player in the top 30 in the world has a full team of three and four people around them that takes care of them, their body and everything, so that that reflects on the court. That’s why the careers are extended now.”

When he embarked on his professional career, players started counting their days when they hit 30, he said. Now it’s more like 35, maybe more.

“Of course I’m in that group. I’m not going to get younger, but I still feel good about my body and about my tennis.”

That may be the data point that matters more than all the others.

(Top photo: Al Bello / Getty Images)

Viktor Hovland and the case for perfectionism

PALM HARBOR, Fla. — There was Viktor Hovland, moments after winning his first PGA Tour championship in 18 months, after storming back from three shots down with five to play to beat a top-10 player in the world for the Valspar Championship.

If there was a moment to declare himself back, to say that every swing fix and coaching change he has put himself through since the 2023 Ryder Cup was absolutely worth it because here he is with the trophy next to him, this was it.

But as much as it was clear that Hovland, the 27-year-old Norwegian flashing that easy smile, was happy, I had to ask him, “How happy are you with your swing right now?”

“Yeah, it’s still not great,” Hovland said. “… The club is just not in a great place for me coming down. It’s just not what it used to be. So I can’t really rely on my old feels anymore because the club is in a different spot and I have to change my release pattern to make that work.”

OK, well, it did work. Results over process, right? Hovland just played four straight rounds under par at the Copperhead Course, including a Sunday 67 with birdies on two difficult holes to edge Justin Thomas by a stroke. No, not so much.

“I think that is something that I’m extremely proud of that I can show up at a PGA Tour event at one of the hardest golf courses we play all year and still win with not my best stuff. … But at the same time, it makes this game a lot more stressful than I think it should be,” Hovland said.


Viktor Hovland, right, walks off the 18th tee with caddie Shay Knight. (Douglas P. DeFelice / Getty Images)

This is, at its core, who Viktor Hovland is and why he believes he’s been able to go from a relatively minor golfing country like Norway to Oklahoma State to the PGA Tour and have as much success as he has. Sunday was his seventh PGA Tour win, including a Tour Championship, and he has three top-five finishes at the majors in the last three years.

It’s not enough to be good. It’s not enough to flirt with great. He’s striving for something here, and why is that a problem?

“I find it kind of weird that we’re professional athletes and the people that are wanting to improve are somewhat looked at, ‘Oh, he’s a perfectionist, he’s out on the perimeter searching too much.’ It’s like, that’s what we do; we are here to get better, and we are here to win tournaments. So if you’re not going to try to get better, what are you doing?” Hovland said.

There’s something to be admired there. The not-so-secret truth of the PGA Tour is that the money is good enough that you don’t have to win to set up yourself and your family nicely. And for years the tour has operated in a way that if you kept your card for a few years, it was hard to lose it, perpetuating a cycle of doing just enough to keep the checks coming. Good is, in fact, the enemy of great. Men’s professional golf is no different from any other industry in that way.

No one has been able to convince Hovland to join the murky middle, even his well-meaning mother, who makes it a habit to let Viktor, at his low moments, know that a lot of other people played poorly that day too. “It never consoles me,” he said.

This was the tournament week for Hovland, who had not made a cut in 2025 and was ejected from The Players Championship with a first-round 80: While committed to the Valspar, he spent Monday in Orlando working with swing coach Grant Waite, and they found something of a swing feel. Enough that Hovland figured he might as well drive over to Tampa Bay on Tuesday, playing a late practice round. Only after those nine holes did he make the final decision to play in the tournament, but with very little, if any, expectation of contending.

Then came a first-round 70, and a 67 the next day that had him one shot off the lead. “I don’t have control over what I’m doing,” Hovland said that day. Playing in the final group Saturday, Hovland shot a 69 and ended the day in a three-way tie for the lead. “Still feels like I’m saving a lot of shots, but they’re going fairly straight, so it’s OK,” Hovland said.


Viktor Hovland leaned on his irons during the Valspar Championship. (Brennan Asplen / Getty Images)

Sunday was a stress test, then. Could Hovland manage his game, play into that swing feel and find a way to win? The answer was a testament to his work. Hovland not only avoided his biggest problem right now — a “big push fade” — on No. 16, where water runs the length of the fairway, but he also hit maybe the shot of the tournament, an approach from 187 yards out to less than 6 feet. With a birdie putt there and another on No. 17, Hovland had a two-shot cushion, enough to bogey 18 and still win.

Now the work begins again with Waite, one of the swing coaches Hovland hired and fired over the last 18 months, bringing him back this month in part because Waite is an information guy and Hovland wants all the information. All the data. Don’t hide from the problem. Lean into it and come back out the other side. Hopefully.

You win this time of year on the PGA Tour and it’s only so long until the questions inevitably come around to the Masters. There are 18 days until the first round, and Hovland believes what he did to win this week — taming tight fairways with accurate iron shots and a good week putting — will not have the same effect at Augusta National, an entirely different test of golf. That is his reality as he sees it, though Hovland sprinkled in some positive self-talk.

“I still need to be honest so I can attack the problems that I have and we can improve, but at the same time, I got to give myself some credit. And even no matter how bad it feels or how many poor shots I’m hitting, I’m still capable of shooting good scores with it. So I kind of have to keep that in the back of my head,” Hovland said.

So, is Viktor Hovland back? Yes. Just don’t ask him to confirm it.

(Top photo: Brennan Asplen / Getty Images)

Analysing Jamal Musiala’s bizarre corner goal for Germany against Italy

On average, about one in every 30 corners leads to a goal. The success rate tends to go up dramatically, however, when the goalkeeper and their entire defence are standing outside their six-yard box when a corner is taken.

That was the remarkable scene during the UEFA Nations League quarter-final in Dortmund on Sunday. Germany’s Jamal Musiala turned the ball into an empty net against an Italy team who acted like they thought the game would stop for them to hold a debrief into where everything had been going wrong for them during the first half.

Joshua Kimmich had other ideas and the combination of his brilliant quick-thinking and Musiala’s goal-hanging — allied to a ball boy who was, well, on the ball — led to Germany doubling their 1-0 lead from a highly unusual corner on 36 minutes, and making fools out of Italy in the process.


Musiala celebrates scoring in a highly unusual way (Christof Koepsel/Getty Images)

The goal evoked memories of Liverpool’s fourth against Barcelona in the Champions League semi-final second leg at Anfield in 2019, when Divock Origi swept home Trent Alexander-Arnold’s swiftly-taken corner to take the Premier League club through 4-3 on aggregate. On that occasion, though, there was a goalkeeper standing between the posts. Gianluigi Donnarumma, in contrast, went AWOL in Dortmund last night.

It wasn’t just the Italian goalkeeper who was caught out. Amazon Prime, which was showing the game live as part of a pay-per-view package, almost missed the goal completely too, with viewers only seeing exactly what had happened when a replay was eventually shown.

The bizarre chain of events started with Donnarumma producing an exceptional one-handed save to claw striker Tim Kleindienst’s twisting header behind for a corner. Italy were being outplayed at the time, trailing by a goal on the night following a Kimmich penalty and 3-1 on aggregate. In that context, it was not surprising that their players were annoyed.

As Kleindienst turned away holding his head in his hands in disbelief and disappointment, Kimmich (circled below), quickly made his way to the corner flag.

Italy wing-back Giovanni Di Lorenzo (No 22) started the inquest, pointing with his right arm and looking in the direction of his central-defender team-mate Alessandro Bastoni. With his back turned on the play, Bastoni was gesturing too as he walked towards Di Lorenzo.

Donnarumma decided to get involved as well. Wandering outside of his six-yard box with arms outstretched, the Paris Saint-Germain goalkeeper was oblivious to the presence of Musiala behind him, free as a bird in the six-yard box after following up Kleindienst’s original header.

By now, some important work had already taken place off the pitch. A steward (circled behind the goal below) was busy trying to retrieve the ball Donnarumma had tipped behind.

As the steward bent down to pick it up and motioned to throw it back, he realised a ball boy (also circled) close to the corner flag was already delivering a chest pass that had pre-assist written all over it (think Callum Hynes, the teenage Tottenham Hotspur ball boy who got a high five from their then manager Jose Mourinho after his quick-thinking led to Harry Kane scoring in the Champions League against Olympiacos in 2019).

As Musiala signalled to Kimmich to take the corner quickly, Donnarumma carried on walking and joined what was now a group of five Italians, who had congregated outside the six-yard box to dissect their problems. The only thing missing was a tactics board and a table and chairs.

Central defender Alessandro Buongiorno, who also had his back to play, was among that group, as was fellow centre-back Federico Gatti, who was busy wiping his face with his shirt. The rest of the team may as well have been covering their eyes too.

Late for the meeting, midfielder Samuele Ricci (circled below) was about to become the sixth Italy player to offer his thoughts until he saw Kimmich out of the corner of his eye and sounded the alarm. Unfortunately for Italy, it was far too late.

After placing the ball, Kimmich had spotted Musiala on his own — it was hard to miss the Bayern Munich youngster, especially when he was waving his arms about like an aircraft marshal on a runway — and the corner was launched, arcing towards the edge of the six-yard box.

Although the ball was slightly behind Musiala, forcing him to retreat a little, there was plenty of margin for error on the delivery; six yards to be exact. As Musiala shaped to swivel and strike the ball with his right foot, Donnarumma pivoted too, in a state of blind panic. Musiala’s shot was en route to the back of the net before the goalkeeper had a chance to get reacquainted with his six-yard box…

… and Germany were 2-0 up.

Italy, to their credit, staged a superb fightback to come back from three goals down to draw 3-3 on the night (losing 5-4 on aggregate). But the damage — some of it self-inflicted — was done during a chaotic first half.

“Everyone knows we struggle from set plays, but we cannot keep talking about it, or this will turn into an obsession,” Italy’s head coach, Luciano Spalletti, had told reporters a few days earlier.

And thanks to Musiala’s bizarre goal, that topic of conversation is here to stay for Italy for some time yet.

(Top photo: Alex Grimm/Getty Images)

Jamie Mulgrew, an 11th league title with Linfield and the thirst for further success

“My phone kept buzzing with messages, but I was so tired, I went straight to sleep — I hadn’t realised I’d set the record!”

For Linfield captain Jamie Mulgrew, last Tuesday night was just like any other. The 38-year-old midfielder spent the evening coaching the club’s under-18s. Once home, he watched the football, then went to bed. Yet for Mulgrew and Linfield, this was a record-breaking evening.

The televised match was between Linfield’s two closest rivals: Glentoran drew against Larne, confirming Linfield as champions for the 57th time, a world record. That success confirmed Mulgrew’s 11th league winner’s medal — setting a national record and joining an exclusive global club. It was an extraordinary achievement in the most ordinary of circumstances.

“In some ways, it was an anti-climax,” Mulgrew admits. “You would always prefer to win it on the pitch.” The title was confirmed with six matchdays remaining.

Only four active professional footballers — Dinamo Zagreb’s Arijan Ademi (13), Bayern Munich’s Thomas Muller, James Forrest of Celtic and former TNS full-back Chris Marriott (all 12) — have won more league titles than Mulgrew’s at one European club. Yet there is one key difference: Linfield have been significantly less dominant domestically than any of those clubs. Larne entered this season as back-to-back champions and, since 2013, Crusaders had won three league titles and Cliftonville two.

Mulgrew, who turns 39 in July, insists those title-less campaigns make his successes more enjoyable, highlighting the five-year gap between titles from 2012 to 2017.

“You never know if it’s going to be your last one and that makes them sweeter,” he offers. “The hunger for more never disappears.”


Mulgrew celebrates winning last season’s League Cup with his children (Published with the permission of Jamie Mulgrew)

Mulgrew began his career at Glentoran, Linfield’s primary Belfast rivals.

He made two first-team appearances, including during their 2004-05 league success. Linfield approached Mulgrew that summer, with the 19-year-old’s contract expiring, and he decided to join the club he had supported in his youth. That 2005-06 season saw Linfield complete a clean sweep of all four domestic trophies, but a recurring medial knee injury limited Mulgrew’s game time.

For successive seasons, the midfielder was involved in title-winning squads but missed the minimum appearance threshold to claim a winner’s medal.

Mulgrew, who has 26 trophies and counting at Linfield, believes his ascent to the captaincy was born of having to fight for recognition in a dressing room of serial winners. “That squad I joined was full of leaders and big personalities,” he explains. “You had to adapt to those standards. Back then, it was only 14-player matchday squads, so you constantly had that pressure of performing and working hard.”

His longevity is made more remarkable given his playing style; Mulgrew is a combative midfielder comfortable at carrying the ball, shuffling past opponents and drawing free kicks due to his low centre of gravity. While no statistical measurement is available, he is widely considered to be the Irish League’s most fouled player.

Yet he has other qualities that are arguably more important: constantly instructing team-mates on positioning, what runs to make, when to push up the pitch and when to slow a game down. He credits his leadership to his early years at the club.

“I was shaped by that pressure to win and perform, of needing to know how to train, to set an example on and off the pitch, to have the right combination between confidence and staying humble… and that hunger,” he says. “To use criticism as fuel. That is what I try to instil in my team-mates and the youngsters I coach.”


Mulgrew swaps pennants with Celtic’s Scott Brown ahead of a Champions League qualifier in 2017 (Craig Williamson – SNS GroupSNS Group via Getty Images)

One of the midfielder’s biggest tasks is helping new players integrate into a winning culture.

“The pressures at Linfield are unique — winning trophies is everything,” says Mulgrew. “I joined the club so young, that environment is all I have ever known. But others take time to adjust. It is our job to make them comfortable, but our responsibility for them is more than that — we need to win for them. If they join a winning team, that pressure lifts.”

Mulgrew will almost certainly not surpass the remarkable tally of 1,013 Linfield appearances set by his former team-mate, Noel Bailie, but he is closing in on the 800-game landmark. There has previously been interest from elsewhere. In 2011, a year after his two international appearances for Northern Ireland, Mulgrew’s Linfield contract was expiring and he attracted interest from Colombus Crew and Portland Timbers in Major League Soccer. The midfielder travelled to the United States for separate trial periods but decided against a move.

In 2021, Linfield went full-time; an upgrade from their previous semi-professional status. This was not without risk, with several of Mulgrew’s long-term team-mates deciding to move elsewhere due to personal circumstances. Yet, for Mulgrew, the opportunity to become full-time, aged 34, was too good to turn down.

His work outside football was centred on afternoons, with the new model freeing up his evenings to spend with his wife and three young children. “That decision, without doubt, has prolonged my career.”


Mulgrew fires off a shot during a UEFA Conference League play-off in 2022 (Liam McBurney/PA Images via Getty Images)

For Mulgrew and his team-mates, this season’s trophy lift will have added poignance.

In June 2024, the club’s physiotherapist, Paul Butler, passed away suddenly aged 37. Six months later, Michael Newberry — the defender who spent three and a half seasons at Linfield before joining Cliftonville last summer — died on his 27th birthday.

“What has happened in the past year is hard to come to terms with,” says Mulgrew, whose brother-in-law passed away in 2023. “We can forget how anyone, no matter how famous or successful, are just people and we all go through the same emotions.

“For us, being in a team environment and going in to train every day together is an important support network. Everyone here has helped each other. We have a really strong changing room, you can maintain the normality with the banter and the support. We genuinely enjoy spending time with each other.

“This squad has great character and resilience, too, that is borne out through our results this season but also coming through everything we have together.”

Mulgrew has already committed himself to Linfield for next season, which will take him up to his 40th birthday. “I won’t outstay my welcome,” he says. “I will know when it’s time to move aside.”

He believes he needs to listen to his body more, admitting to playing through muscular pain earlier in the campaign. That is indicative of his relentless desire to be involved but, these days, he has to compromise.

Mulgrew begins his UEFA Pro coaching licence next week and while current Linfield manager David Healy has previously said he is “keeping the seat warm for him” and often consults his captain as he “knows the club inside out”, the midfielder insists his focus is on adding to his success on the pitch.

Mulgrew adds: “I already want my 12th title.”

(Top photo: Matthew Ashton – AMA/Getty Images)

Breslow’s Red Sox front-office audit resulted in painful cuts. Will the changes bring wins?

In the 17 months since the Boston Red Sox hired Craig Breslow as chief baseball officer — their fourth leadership change within the past 10 seasons — the organization has undergone sweeping changes, particularly behind the scenes in the front office. Under Breslow’s direction, longtime employees have been fired, while others have left on their own, frustrated with the direction of the organization. The scouting department, in particular, has seen deep cuts.

Many that remain in the roughly 275-person front office paint a previously unreported picture of uncertainty and unease, though others see opportunity and optimism, particularly in the rapid revamping of the organization’s pitching infrastructure and player development methods, and in a promising big-league team. Some indicate it’s created an odd juxtaposition between those eager to initiate change and those trying to adapt to new roles under new leadership.

Breslow does not apologize for changes he believes will finally snap the organization out of a years-long stretch of mediocrity. He was hired for this purpose. The team has made the postseason once since their last World Series title in 2018 and has posted a record at or below .500 in four of the past five seasons. Red Sox ticket prices remain among the highest in baseball.

Breslow recently spoke to The Athletic about the restructuring that resulted from an internal audit conducted last year that helped reshape the front office, noting that they “tried to pick off the highest leveraged opportunities first.”

“There are times where maybe it makes sense to bulldoze through things and then kind of pick up the pieces afterward and there are times where being a little bit more intentional and patient ends in the best outcome,” he said, standing outside of Boston’s spring training complex at JetBlue Park. “I think ultimately, what we’ve been trying to instill is the idea that what is most important is what happens on the field, and we need to work backwards from that.”

Change is not new in Boston. Far from it. Just two years ago under Chaim Bloom, the Red Sox underwent a different front-office overhaul. But Bloom wasn’t around long enough to see those changes make an impact.

So, how will Breslow’s restructuring be different? After so many years of upgrading and updating the front office structure under previous leadership, is this new setup the right one? Will ownership give Breslow enough runway to see the changes through or — given that his predecessors were each fired within their first five years on the job — is he already nearing the halfway mark of his tenure in Boston?

Sources within the team acknowledge that baseball’s increasingly competitive landscape necessitated swift change. Yet too much change can create instability.

Breslow is clear that he believes it’s important to be transparent and he is mindful of the organization’s culture and staff morale. But he also has a strong vision of how the Red Sox can improve.

“Our goal is not to make everyone happy,” he said.



Craig Breslow was introduced as the Red Sox chief baseball officer on Nov. 2, 2023. (Charles Krupa / Associated Press)

Within a few months of joining the Red Sox, Breslow hired New York City-based Sportsology Group to conduct an internal audit of all baseball operations employees.

One goal was to get all of the front-office departments on the same page so that they could collaborate and communicate more effectively, ultimately benefitting the major-league team. The audit also laid out an objective evaluation method for Breslow to utilize when identifying employees who would best fit his vision for the franchise.

“The one thing I’m committed to, is doing what’s best for the organization and that requires taking a hard look at the processes that we have in place, the systems we have in place, and the people that we have in place,” Breslow told The Athletic in June amid the audit.

“Sportsology is not the decision-making group. They are not evaluating people, we are evaluating people,” he added. “They’re helping us create the frameworks that allow us to do that and certain benchmarks against which we want to evaluate and how to calibrate the information that’s coming in. But the evaluations are being done by us.”

During the audit, there was a natural undercurrent of anxiety within the organization about just what the evaluations would suggest, according to multiple employees who spoke on a condition of anonymity. After the audit was completed, there were widespread changes, not just in scouting, where people with decades of experience were let go, but in creating new department heads in research and development, and reorganizing player development and the medical department.

“The result of an audit was not some drastic kind of headcount-cutting measure,” Breslow said. “It was understanding who our people are, what type of work they’re doing, what we’re really good at, what opportunities there are to improve.”

The scouting department had the biggest turnover — and those departures created the most angst. On the amateur side, a 34-person staff last year was reduced to 22 following departures and layoffs. Four people were added in their place, increasing the amateur staff to 26. Among the most notable layoffs were longtime scouts Mark Wasinger, Paul Fryer and Willie Romay, a group with decades of collective scouting experience. Tom Kotchman, a scout for nearly 50 years, including 14 with the Red Sox, retired at the end of 2024.

Changes in the scouting world have become ubiquitous over the past decade with the evolving landscape of how the game is evaluated, particularly as advances in technology enhance — and at the same time challenge — traditional scouting methods. Breslow admitted emerging research methods have allowed teams to collect information differently and often more objectively.

“But it has not eliminated the value in the role of the scout,” he said. “I think in certain cases, we’re asking our scouts to take on slightly different responsibilities in order to ensure that we are continually positioned at the industry’s leading edge. But it isn’t that scouts are less important. It isn’t that we’re looking to diminish the voice or the role of the scout. It’s that the job of the scout has changed, and we have to provide the support for people to make sure that they’re going to do their jobs every day.”

All of the scouts who were let go had significant impacts on the club, but Romay, in particular, was directly responsible for uniting the Red Sox with key pieces of the current clubhouse, signing Triston Casas, Kutter Crawford and Roman Anthony. One employee noted that Romay being part of the cuts in the fall was “incredibly disheartening for everyone.”

“Like anything, like friends that get traded, like anyone that gets released, you never want to see that happen to someone and it’s sad,” said Anthony, whose relationship with Romay was a key reason he didn’t forgo signing with the Red Sox to play at Mississippi. “I still stay in contact with him. He still texts me and still roots for me. I understand it’s a business, and I understand that teams have to do whatever they think is right. And people may not always agree with that.”

Mike Rikard, who’d previously served as amateur scouting director and most recently as vice president of scouting, was moved to a special assistant role last fall before he left the organization in January to join the Arizona Diamondbacks as senior advisor in the scouting department. The Diamondbacks have several former Red Sox employees in their front office, including GM Mike Hazen. Rikard led the team’s drafts from 2015-19 when they selected Andrew Benintendi, Tanner Houck, Jarren Duran, Casas and Crawford. He later transitioned to VP of scouting where he helped in the evaluations of Mayer, Anthony, Campbell and Kyle Teel.

On the international side, 12 scouts were let go or reassigned to different departments with eight additions, shifting the 40-person group to 36.

Assistant general manager Eddie Romero, who had focused on the club’s international scouting and player development efforts, remained an assistant GM but with a role more centered on the big-league club in acquisitions and player development. Over the past 20 years, Romero has helped revitalize the organization’s Dominican Academy and led efforts in signing and developing players such as Xander Bogaerts, Rafael Devers, Brayan Bello and Ceddanne Rafaela.


A batting cage at the Red Sox Dominican Academy. (Jen McCaffrey / The Athletic)

On the professional scouting side, five pro scouts on an 18-person staff were fired and their spots were filled with a mix of external and internal moves, including shifting international amateur scouts Kento Matsumoto and Won-Sang Lee, based in Japan and South Korea, respectively, to the pro side.

Several inquiries about these changes were left unanswered and those who did discuss changes asked not to be identified or quoted, citing ongoing questions about their job security. Some scouts who were fired have said they’re happy with their new teams and didn’t want to discuss the matter.

The industry has taken notice of the changes to the Red Sox scouting department. In a recent Baseball America poll of more than two dozen scouts, the Red Sox ranked among the least “scout-friendly” teams.

Breslow wouldn’t address specific departures, but defended what he deemed difficult decisions in order to keep the organization at the forefront of the game, noting “that there are a number of people who have contributed to the success of this organization, and that will not change.”

“We have to evaluate where we currently are and where we think this game is headed,” he said. “In some cases, that means the set of responsibilities that our scouts take on has changed and in certain situations it hasn’t at all. We need to find the best people and put them in the right places.

“Fortunately, and in a lot of ways and as a result of a pretty comprehensive audit, we found that we do have a lot of great people here. And there are maybe people who decide that the direction that we’re going is not for them, and that’s OK. But again, all of this is rooted in trying to put the best team we possibly can on the field and give ourselves the best chance of making great decisions.”

Boston is not the only team reorganizing their scouting structure. The Chicago Cubs, a team for which Breslow previously worked, is in the midst of its own front-office changes. As teams shift more toward Driveline-type methods, others have gone a different direction. The Philadelphia Phillies scaled back “Driveline-ification” efforts of their front office in recent years. In 2022, the Red Sox hired former Phillies director of minor-league hitting Jason Ochart.

At the same time the Red Sox have cut from the scouting department, they have added to others, including research and development, which is now the second-largest department in the front office, behind only international scouting. The R&D department was reorganized under four directors — baseball sciences, baseball systems, baseball technology and baseball analytics. Early in the offseason, Breslow hired Taylor Smith, former director of predictive modeling for the Tampa Bay Rays, as an assistant general manager tasked with overseeing R&D. Mike Groopman, an assistant GM who’d previously overseen R&D, moved to a role focused on acquisitions. The new structure created a heavy emphasis on data-driven analysis and sought to streamline a growing department that had increased to 33 people, up from 30 last year.

Although R&D grew, there were departures, including Joe McDonald, a former director of analytics, who joined the New England Patriots as senior analyst of football strategy. A few analysts were moved to scouting roles. In all, there were six additional hires, including one Breslow specifically highlighted at his end-of-season presser, former Driveline employee Kyle Wasserberger, a biomechanist with an extensive background in injury prevention and rehabilitation.

The Red Sox now employ nine former Driveline employees, the most of any team in baseball, including Driveline founder Kyle Boddy, who serves as a special assistant to Breslow. Breslow said there has not been a directive to hire Driveline employees but he values the way they approach the game.

“I think people who have gone to work at Driveline have taken on a specific set of experiences that typically lends itself to a way of thinking and a curiosity and open-mindedness,” he said. “Yeah it’s data-driven decision-making, but it’s understanding and having evidence and having support for decision-making rather than just blindly working through different possibilities of outcomes and solutions. It’s doing a lot of the work beforehand, before you take a suggestion or a recommendation to a player. It’s being grounded in evidence and information.”

This analytical approach has paid dividends in many areas, particularly in developing several top position player prospects, including Anthony, Mayer and Campbell, who’ve excelled at the plate thanks to a revamped hitting philosophy implemented over the past few years on the minor-league side, a process that began under Ochart at the end of Bloom’s tenure.

It has also created tension with traditional coaching methods. The Boston Globe recently reported on a “heated conversation” Hall of Famer Jim Rice, a former hitting instructor who now serves as a special assignment instructor for the Red Sox, had with an unidentified staffer after a player approached Rice for hitting advice. Rice was told by the staffer his advice “didn’t align with the team’s approach.”

“There are little tips of the iceberg that have revealed themselves,” one employee noted about the culture of the organization.

Despite that rift and the obvious shift toward more data-driven methods, the Red Sox are not foregoing hands-on instruction. As they seek to strengthen ties between their farm system and their major-league team, another notable change was the addition of Chris Stasio, formerly the assistant farm director, who will work in a player development role on the major-league coaching staff.

Traditionally, the Red Sox player development group was solely involved in development in the minor leagues, but now, via Stasio’s new role, it will also focus on continued development at the big-league level. Stasio will be in uniform and travel with the major-league team. Stasio’s new position was part of a larger restructuring of player development that saw eight people fired and four moved to different positions, including former minor league hitting coordinator Dillon Lawson, who was promoted to big league assistant hitting coach.

There have been changes in the medical department, too. Dr. Larry Ronan, who’s been the team’s lead physician for 20 years, stepped into an advisory role this season. Dr. Peter Asnis, who’d been the team’s head orthopedist for more than a decade, was elevated to head physician, leading a staff of multiple specialized doctors. On the field, strength coach Kiyoshi Momose moved to a Boston-based strength role, rather than traveling with the club, while two strength coaches were added to their staff of roughly a dozen trainers, rehab specialists, massage therapists and physical therapists.


The vast number of changes across the Red Sox organization has empowered some employees while leaving others feeling diminished in their roles. Some understood the cutthroat nature of working in a billion-dollar industry where the bottom line is what matters most. Others saw years of loyalty and hard work wiped clean.

The Red Sox have not won in recent years and that, in turn, means change. Once again.

Breslow and his leadership team acknowledge the painful moves but remain steadfast that in a competitive industry, this type of restructuring is par for the course and that the organization is re-evaluated after every season. This was, however, a larger and deeper reorganization.

“Without a doubt, we had to make really difficult decisions,” he said. “My hope is that whether people agree with those decisions or not, they understood that we were making the best decisions that we could in order to further this goal we have of competing for World Series championships year over year.

“I don’t know that there’s a finish line,” he added. “We need to constantly evolve, track our progress, reevaluate. I think that’s what good organizations do.”

(Top photo: Charles Krupa / Associated Press)

When should Jaxson Dart be drafted? Evaluating pros and cons of the Ole Miss QB

Mississippi’s Jaxson Dart is this NFL Draft cycle’s most divisive quarterback. Some evaluators think he’s a mid-round pick, while ESPN’s Mel Kiper mocked Dart going No. 9. Kiper may have been trying to be controversial for engagement, but Dart does have an intriguing skillset and one can see how an evaluator could be drawn to him.

He’s not tall (6-foot-2), but he’s built well (225 pounds). He has good arm talent and is a legitimate big-play threat as a runner. However, he played in a simplistic spread offense and will need time to adjust to an NFL offense. In a weaker quarterback class, can Dart’s theoretical ceiling, along with his steady production, be enough to push him into the first two rounds of the draft?

The skillset

When it comes to natural throwing ability, Dart has every type of throw in his bag. He doesn’t have a rocket arm, but he has a live one, and he can complete outbreakers and move the ball downfield with ease.

He throws outbreaking routes with timing, accuracy and zip. These are defined throws on which he has a high degree of confidence before the snap that the receiver will be open. He doesn’t hesitate to make these throws if he sees off coverage and space outside.

Dart doesn’t just have a fastball. One of his best traits is his ability to throw off-speed and layer passes over defenders. The Mississippi offense is free flowing and routes aren’t precise. Receivers are looking for space and adjusting their angles. Dart does a good job of seeing what his receivers see and leading them into open spaces. Even though he’ll put touch on passes in the middle of the field, he rarely leads his receivers into big hits.

Dart’s deep accuracy is very good. Not elite, but his deep passes are pristine when he’s on. He can hit his receivers perfectly in stride down the field on deep posts and go-balls but can have stretches where he sprays the ball.

Dart has a natural ability as a creator. Sometimes, you want to see him look downfield more when he breaks the pocket (9.5 percent scramble rate) or gets pressured, but he was an effective scrambler (6.87 yards per scramble) so it’s understandable. The clip above was one of his best throws of the season. Against Duke, he was flushed out of the pocket, kept his eyes downfield, and threw a perfect deep bomb, hitting his receiver in stride.

On third-and-14, against Oklahoma, Dart broke the pocket to his right. Originally, Dart’s receiver was running a shallow across the field. As Dart broke the pocket, he threw the ball upfield instead of horizontally to lead his receiver to open space. He and his receiver were on the same page and they converted. This pass shows creativity and instincts when playing outside of structure. He won’t be able to scramble as much in the NFL, so he’ll have to look downfield more.

Dart has good size and vertical speed. Teams will have to gameplan for his ability to scramble, and he’ll be able to execute designed quarterback runs in the league. He’s twitchy in the pocket and has the strength to rip away from pass rushers. He routinely makes the first defender miss in the pocket. He’s a linear runner in the open field but has the speed to pull away from defenders.

Pocket toughness is a trait that you either have or you don’t. Rarely do quarterbacks become more willing to stand in the pocket and take hits. Dart is very willing to keep his eyes downfield and rotate into throws despite knowing he’ll take a hit. He also can generate power and maintain accuracy in muddy pockets without a big runway in front of him.

The offense

Overall, Dart’s skillset offers a lot that you can’t teach. His ceiling relative to other quarterbacks in this class is very high. However, his offense at Ole Miss doesn’t translate to the NFL. It will take time for him to learn a pro system, footwork and even how to take a snap from under center. As we’ve seen, the NFL rarely shows the necessary patience for long periods of development.

There was a free-flow feel to the Ole Miss offense. Receivers weren’t running precise timing routes, so Dart doesn’t have much experience with timing throws and syncing his feet with his progressions. Head coach Lane Kiffin is an excellent play caller and often got Dart’s first read open. There weren’t many examples of Dart getting through multiple reads on a play but that doesn’t mean he can’t eventually learn how to do it.

This third-and-14 play against Arkansas was one of the rare examples of him getting through multiple reads. Dart initially looked to his left. His slot receiver was indecisive and ran a sloppy route, showing his receivers were either undisciplined or given a lot of freedom to find open space. Dart eventually progressed to his right outside receiver and led his target to open space. You can see in the clip that Dart hops from read to read rather than hitch from read to read. Cleaning up his footwork is going to take some time.

One of the few full-field progression concepts that Ole Miss has in their offense is an air raid staple: Y-Cross. On Y-cross, Dart should be reading the fade and shoot route (bottom of the screen) simultaneously. The corner to that side was playing flat-footed and had his eyes on the shoot route. Ideally, Dart would have seen the corner’s body language and thrown the fade route. No one was deep with the corner playing the shoot route. Instead, Dart progressed to his third read but made a nice throw in the middle of the field.

Sometimes it looks like Dart determines his throws pre-snap because he often goes to the same receiver on certain concepts. For example, against Florida, early in the game, he hit his receiver on a deep post on a Mills concept (deep post with a dig route). Kiffin called the same play later in the game. This time, Florida’s defensive backs dropped deep and easily picked off the pass.

Dart has to be better against the blitz. He was sacked 9.6 percent of the time when blitzed (10 sacks overall). His numbers against the blitz are inflated by run/pass options (RPOs) counting as blitzes because defenders are moving toward the line of scrimmage to play the run. On third-and-long (7+ yards), which are true dropback situations, his EPA per dropback against the blitz is 0.05.

Here, the Duke defense showed a cover 0 blitz look with multiple defenders at the line of scrimmage. With more potential pass rushers than blockers, ideally, Dart should abort the play fake and quickly find a “hot” receiver. But he still carried out the play fake which made it easy for an unblocked defender to get to him. His slot receiver to his right found space and quickly got his eyes back to Dart but the quarterback didn’t see him.

In this clip, the defense again showed a heavy-pressure look. Ideally, Dart should look for a quick outlet and hope his receiver can break a tackle in space on third-and-long. He had a three-on-three situation to his left (bottom of the screen) but after the snap, he looked to the single receiver side but that receiver was double covered. Dart broke the pocket and found a receiver on the scramble drill, but this isn’t a reliable answer against heavy-pressure looks.

Though Dart has an intriguing skill set with a high ceiling, a sizable gap must be bridged between the offense he operated at Ole Miss and what he’ll be asked to do in the league. Ideally, Dart will get drafted to a team where he can sit, learn a playbook and clean up his footwork without live action. However, quarterbacks drafted in the first round are rarely afforded redshirt years. With Dart’s developmental gap, getting drafted in the second or third round to a team with an established starter would be the best situation. After Cam Ward, Dart could have the highest ceiling of any quarterback in the draft, and he’s only 21 years old.

(Photo: Todd Kirkland / Getty Images)

NBA free agency: Russell Westbrook, Quentin Grimes and the odd situations that loom

Get ready for a different kind of free agency this summer: Less wild, perhaps, but weirder.

At first, the 2025 NBA free-agent class doesn’t exactly overwhelm you with front-line talent. This isn’t the year for superstars holding meetings in the Hamptons while teams wait on pins and needles for franchise-altering decisions. Only one likely All-NBA selection can become a free agent this summer, and that one (the Los Angeles Lakers’ LeBron James) isn’t going anywhere. The next-best potential free agent, the Dallas Mavericks’ Kyrie Irving, turns 33 soon and just tore his ACL.

However, what the free-agent class lacks in superstar talent, it makes up for in sheer quirkiness. Between the most recent collective bargaining agreement, some existing rules that rarely came into play before and several players massively outplaying small contracts, this summer could offer some real financial puzzles for front offices.

Here’s a preview of some of the more interesting conundrums as we truck toward the offseason:

Ty Jerome’s unlikely breakout

Jerome might have the best value non-rookie contract in the league; the Cleveland Cavaliers’ breakout super sub only makes $2.56 million after signing a two-year deal with the Cavs in 2023.

The issue this summer is that the Cavs only have early Bird rights on him as a free agent because of that two-year deal. Nobody ever considered the possibility that Jerome would be so awesome that “only” being able to pay him $14 million next season would make him a potential flight risk, but here we are.

Jerome is having one of the most unlikely breakout seasons in league annals, suddenly emerging in his sixth season out of Virginia (wahoowa!) as a serious contender for both the Sixth Man of the Year and Most Improved Player awards. He’s shooting 41.8 percent from 3 and an unfathomable 55.6 percent from floater range, boasts the league’s 10th-highest steal rate among players with at least 1,000 minutes, averages nearly three assists for every turnover and has compiled a 20.1 PER for a team that’s a phenomenal 56-13.

Knowing the Cavs can only get to $14 million, if you’re a team like the Brooklyn Nets or Chicago Bulls that has some cap space this summer, is it out of the question to offer Jerome $20 million a year? He’s 27, so his next deal would pay him for his prime years.

The cap rules on paying Jerome are only half the problem for Cleveland. The other half is … what if he re-signs? Locking up Jerome at that $14 million number becomes a very expensive proposition for the Cavs, who are plunging deep into the luxury tax next year regardless because of Evan Mobley’s likely supermax extension.

Paying Jerome market-rate money on top of that would blast Cleveland way past the second-apron threshold. While it’s possible other trades could soften the blow (what would you give me for a lightly used Isaac Okoro?), it’s clear Jerome’s unlikely success has added another layer to what was already a tricky cap problem facing Cleveland.

Could he take a cheapo one-plus-one deal that would let the Cavs pay him as a Bird rights free agent a year from now? That might be the only palatable endgame from Cleveland’s side, but it’s tough to ask a guy who has never been paid to wait another year for his bag.


Ty Jerome has taken a major leap in Year 6. (Gary A. Vasquez / Imagn Images)

Russell Westbrook’s option

Westbrook is thriving in Denver, yet he and the Nuggets face a very interesting fork in the road. He has a player option for 2025-26 for $3.5 million, and he’s pretty clearly worth massively more than this, at least to the Nuggets. That’s good news for this season but bad news once we get to the summer.

Westbrook opting out feels like a no-brainer, but Denver has few mechanisms for paying him much more. The best possibility is probably to use its taxpayer midlevel exception, which would cap the Nuggets at the second apron but would allow them to pay Westbrook a projected $5.7 million in 2025-26. A two-year deal with a player option would let him opt out of that contract again in 2026 to get more jelly as an early Bird free agent.

Anything more than $5.7 million requires some serious digging. For instance, getting to the point where the Nuggets could pay Westbrook some or all of the projected $14.1 million nontaxpayer midlevel exception would require the Nuggets to shed about $10 million in other salaries to get themselves below the first apron.

That would most likely be accomplished by trading Dario Šarić (who, incredibly, was signed for more money than Westbrook last summer) and Zeke Nnaji (who is playing better of late but still owed $23 million over the next three years). The Nuggets, however, have no draft picks left to incentivize a trade, because they’ve already used so many to offload other bad contracts. They can trade their two 2032 picks after the draft, but do they really want to ditch those picks already? At what price point is it worth just trying to find their next Westbrook?

Jake LaRavia’s contract ceiling

The Sacramento Kings acquired LaRavia from the Memphis Grizzlies with a second-round pick at the trade deadline, a needed piece in a lineup that lacked size at the forward spot.

The conundrum for Kings fans is that they want a “Goldilocks” LaRavia … one who plays well but not too well. As a result of Memphis declining his fourth-year option for 2025-26 this past fall, LaRavia is limited in free agency to re-signing for that declined fourth-year salary of $5,163,127. That limit carried over in the trade; neither Memphis nor Sacramento can pay him more than this but 28 other teams can.

That puts Sacramento at a disadvantage in free agency, but the Kings have a way to get that advantage back if LaRavia doesn’t play too well. The Kings could give him a two-year deal with a second-year player option that starts at that $5.16 million figure; he could then opt out of the second year in 2026 if he has a good year and would have full Bird rights with the Kings and be able to re-sign for any amount.

Obviously, that goes out the window if somebody drops a full midlevel exception offer on him this summer, but thus far, it seems like LaRavia will thread the needle where nobody values him at that amount.

Guerschon Yabusele’s minimum

The Dancing Bear hasn’t played quite as well as Westbrook, but he’s in a similar situation: Playing well enough on a short deal for a taxed-out team that keeping him will be a bit of a pickle.

Yabusele is on a one-year minimum deal; he has non-Bird rights, and the most he can get from Philly without using exception money is a 20 percent raise on his minimum for next year, or $2.85 million. His market value seems pretty clearly more than that, although there is a glimmer of possibility that the Sixers could get him to sign a one-plus-one deal that lets him try free agency again next summer.

As with Westbrook above, the cleanest solution would be for the Sixers to re-sign Yabusele with their taxpayer midlevel exception of $5.7 million. The problem is that it would cap the Sixers at the second apron, and they might need that money for…

Quentin Grimes, superstar

One of the most bizarre situations in the league is happening in Philadelphia right now, where the Sixers are simultaneously navigating a tank job to possibly keep a top-six protected pick and a contract push from Grimes as he hits restricted free agency. A low-usage role player in his first three seasons, Grimes had stepped things up a bit in 47 games in Dallas this season, but he didn’t really blow up until he got to Philly at the trade deadline.

On a denuded Sixers roster with three injured All-Stars, Grimes has averaged 21.8 points while making shots from everywhere — he’s shooting 39.5 percent on 3s and 60.1 percent on 2s, the latter a fairly incredible figure for a 6-foot-5 guard with middling athleticism.

At some point, you figure he’ll cool off a bit, but even after regressing his shooting to the mean, the stat line is impressive. (He’s also increased his rates of rebounds, blocks, steals and assists. Dude is balling.)

What does that mean for Grimes this summer? Being a restricted free agent might limit the market, but given the Sixers’ position vis-a-vis the luxury tax and aprons, teams might also be tempted to test the Sixers’ willingness to spend by dropping a big offer sheet. It could actually tempt a rival team to spend more, in the hopes of creating such a poisonous sheet that the Sixers run away shrieking. Right now, Brooklyn is the only team in a strong position to do this, but things can change before July 1; Grimes will only be 25 this summer, so as with Jerome above, a team would be buying his theoretical prime.

That takes us to the other aspect of Grimes’ situation. Paying him something on the order of $20 million a year would take the Sixers right to the second-apron line, assuming their three players with options choose to pick them up. (Kelly Oubre, Andre Drummond and Eric Gordon have player options worth a total of $17 million; none set hearts aflame with their play in 2024-25.)

That is, unless the Sixers keep their pick, which would add several million to their cap number (the fourth pick will make $8.4 million, for instance) and tighten the screws in other places. In particular, it would seemingly be very difficult to keep both Grimes and Yabusele at their market rates with a top-six pick in the draft.

This takes us back to the tank. The Sixers are in quite a “race” with Toronto and Brooklyn for the fifth- through seventh-worst records in the league, with the three teams resorting to increasingly impressive hijinks to, um, keep up … except that Philly keeps playing Grimes. The Sixers have gone 4-17 since Feb. 4, but Grimes singlehandedly delivered one of the wins (a 44-point masterpiece against the Golden State Warriors) and nearly pulled out another when he hung 46 on the Houston Rockets in an overtime loss.

The difference between fifth and seventh might not seem like much, but it literally doubles the Sixers’ odds of keeping the pick (from 31.9 percent to 63.9 percent). If Grimes leads them to enough wins that the Sixers don’t keep the pick, there’s more money left to pay him!

Malik Beasley, shooting star

I’m not sure what the Pistons’ plans were for their non-max trove of cap space this summer (roughly $25 million), but I’m guessing “using it all to re-sign Malik Beasley” wasn’t anywhere on the list when they were mapping out scenarios last fall.

That was before Beasley basically turned into Stephen Curry from beyond the 3-point line. No, seriously. Beasley’s 16.2 3-point attempts per 100 possessions this season are second only to Curry’s 16.9, and Beasley has knocked down an incredible 41.9 percent of them.

Wait, it gets better: Beasley’s 6.8 3-point makes per 100 are the most ever for a player not named Curry — Steph has beaten it four times, but James Harden in 2018-19 is the only other player to reach 6.5 in a season of 1,500 or more minutes.

This, obviously, has made Beasley a very valuable player. Beasley signed a one-year deal worth $6 million last summer; there is no scenario where the Pistons can keep him for anything close to that. At a bare minimum, they would seemingly need to pay him the full nontaxpayer midlevel exception of $14.1 million; even if that contract didn’t require cap room, it would essentially nuke any cap-room scenarios for Detroit.

Fortunately, Detroit’s books are in a strong enough position that retaining Beasley should be fairly straightforward; the only question is deal length and player options. Would Beasley rather have a short deal with a player option to get more bread a year from now, or would he prefer the security of a longer deal?


Malik Beasley is having a season for the ages from 3. (Rick Osentoski / Imagn Images)

Moe Wagner and Orlando’s tight tax

The Magic have the full allotment of 15 players under contract for next season, have four draft picks this June and are $11 million over the projected tax line. All of that would make it seem unlikely that they would pick up Mo Wagner’s $11 million team option, especially since he’s out with a torn ACL.

However, all may not be as it appears. Wagner is a highly-valued player in Orlando, and not just because he’s the brother (and housemate!) of Magic star Franz Wagner; his injury more or less marked the turning point in the Magic’s season. (They were 18-12 at the time and 14-25 since.)

For one, the Magic have other options they can decline to get the roster down to reasonable size. Declining options on Gary Harris and little-used Cory Joseph and Caleb Houstan would put them under the projected tax (at least until the draft picks put them back over) and open enough roster breathing room to bring back Wagner. Also, because the Magic would retain Bird rights on him, a cheap one-year deal with a second-year player option could be a palatable option for both sides; he could have his “rehab year” then get paid off his work in the second half of the season when he returns.

Either way, declining the option seems like the only play for Orlando. The question is what the Magic can do to retain somebody they would prefer to keep amid a tricky cap environment and a roster that, once Paolo Banchero’s likely max extension hits in 2026, will become fairly expensive.

Lakers decline-and-sign pathway

This little trick is likely to come up in the case of several teams dancing the first-apron tightrope, most notably with the Lakers and Dorian Finney-Smith.

The idea is that L.A. can get Finney-Smith to decline his player option for $15.4 million for 2025-26 in return for re-signing on a longer deal for less money. The risk of overpaying on the back end of the deal (Finney-Smith turns 32 this summer) is offset by managing the immediate tax situation by shaving a few million off his 2025-26 cap number.

The motivation for L.A. would be to leave enough wiggle room under the first apron to either use its nontaxpayer midlevel exception to sign a real center or to trade for one. It’s a tight squeeze right now, even if the Lakers decline Shake Milton’s $3 million nonguaranteed deal. They might even consider stretching Maxi Kleber’s $11 million to generate the necessary space, especially since they’re running out of draft picks to put into trades to incentivize a deal. (I’ll also note this option exists for James as well; there is no rule requiring him to sign for the max, and he actually took a slight haircut on that amount last summer to keep L.A. below the second apron and allow it to aggregate salary in trades. That decision has worked out very well, based on recent events.)

The Minnesota Timberwolves could potentially go this route, too, with Julius Randle, who has a $31 million player option for next season with incentives that could raise the value. Locking in a lower number for Randle on a long-term deal might make it easier to keep Naz Reid in free agency and still make Minnesota’s tricky cap math work in future seasons.

And then there are the Rockets. Houston has a similar issue with Fred VanVleet, except it’s a team option instead of a player option, so the Rockets have a lot more control over the situation. VanVleet is due $44.9 million next season, one where the Rockets are likely to push into the tax. Things don’t get any easier in the future, as their talented young players need to be paid (most notably Amen Thompson in the summer of 2027), but 2025-26 is a squeeze point unless VanVleet’s cap number goes way down.

Thus, locking in VanVleet at a lower number for a longer tenure has a lot of advantages for Houston. However, there’s a case to be made that the Rockets could go the complete opposite route by opting to pay him the $44.9 million, in return for extending his contract at a much lower number in the out years. That concept trades a single year of pain in 2025-26 in return for making the salary structure more manageable in the out years when Houston’s other young players will be ready to get paid. It’s a fascinating puzzle for the Rockets with no clear answer, beyond the obvious one that Houston still very much needs to keep VanVleet one way or another.

Decline-and-sign, discount version

Finally, you may have noticed an unusual number of players this season were signed off two-way deals into two-year contracts with second-year team options.

There’s a reason for that: The teams can decline the option and, as non-Bird free agents, re-sign the player to a much longer four-year deal worth up to 20 percent over the minimum. Given the limited likelihood of a bidding war on players of this ilk (and the protection of restricted free agency, just in case), it’s a good way for teams to play their hands. This is particularly true for those teams that either don’t have access to their nontaxpayer midlevel exception or want to save it for potential use at the trade deadline.

This category includes several rookie two-way players who have since been promoted to roster deals, such as Oklahoma City’s Ajay Mitchell, Golden State’s Quinten Post, New York’s Ariel Hukporti and Philadelphia’s Justin Edwards. All are likely looking at summer “decline-and-sign” situations that end with them returning to their present teams on three- or four-year deals at or near the minimum. (One slight exception: Mitchell got $3 million out of the Thunder’s room exception money and thus can sign for a starting salary of as much as $3.6 million if the option is declined.)

(Top photo of Russell Westbrook: Katelyn Mulcahy / Getty Images)

The hecklers are targeting Rory McIlroy. His challenge is to resist golf’s unruly spectators

PONTE VEDRA BEACH, Fla. — Two thick, beefy strong boys with snug polos and holstered pistols walked, chests out, up to the area behind TPC Sawgrass’ 12th green Sunday. As they approached the hill, another security officer smiled at two of the day’s main characters.

“It’s the Bash Brothers!” the man joked.

The three of them waited behind the green in the moments before play restarted at the final round of the Players Championship after a four-hour weather delay halted what appeared to be Rory McIlroy’s runaway moment. By then, roughly two-thirds of the massive crowd understandably left, but the ones who decided to stay all day? They were there for Rory. His gallery remained full. As the van dropped off McIlroy to continue his round, the fans loudly chanted “Ro-ry! Ro-ry! Ro-ry!” They applauded as he birdied the hole to take a three-shot lead. Most of Ponte Vedra seemed to be pulling for McIlroy.

But that support was not why the Bash Brothers were there.

That nickname was earned, for all the hecklers the two police officers kicked out of the Players Championship that day. One or two officers follow every PGA Tour group all year to act as security for the game’s stars. It’s normal, making sure no unauthorized people get inside the ropes and the crowd doesn’t do anything out of line. Most days they won’t have a single issue.

But by the time McIlroy hit his approach from the 18th fairway, one of the Bash Brothers claimed to have kicked out 15 people at least. Because, for a very minuscule, annoying, yet loud minority, McIlroy is becoming a target for heckling right now. How he handles it will tell us so much.

As McIlroy approached the 18th tee Sunday, tied for the lead trying to win the tour’s marquee event, he looked around at the crowd. He scanned his head as if trying to take it all in. And that crowd rose up and roared for him.

Until one man shouted, “Hit it in the water, Rory!” The crowd groaned. It was isolated enough that McIlroy certainly heard it. No problem, as he launched an absolutely beautiful draw around the bended fairway along the water. By the end of the day, McIlroy was headed to a three-hole Monday playoff with J.J. Spaun, one he would win going away to claim his second Players.

But is it a challenge for McIlroy to tune those heckles out?

“Yeah, absolutely,” he admitted.

“But I think when you’re in business mode you’re just trying to keep your head down and stay in your own little world for the most part.”

McIlroy is not new to fame. And he’s not new to criticism. He’s one of the bigger lightning rods for discussion in the sport, and he’s heard (and historically laughed along with) every crack about his deflating losses in majors like the 2024 U.S. Open at Pinehurst.

Until a week ago.

McIlroy was playing a Tuesday practice round when he hit his tee shot on 18 into the water and a young-ish fan shouted, “Just like 2011 at Augusta!” while his buddy filmed. McIlroy hit another tee shot, and before going to his ball he walked over to the fan, grabbed the friend’s phone that was filming and walked away. It turned out the guy who yelled this was Texas golfer Luke Potter, who won the amateur tournament in town just days earlier. That only added to the bizarre nature of the incident. Security kicked Potter and his friend out, but a third party filmed the incident, posted it online and it went viral.

Seeing McIlroy react that way was surprising, and perhaps it shed light on a deeper insecurity of McIlroy. He can joke and laugh about Pinehurst. Maybe even the 2022 Open Championship or the 2023 U.S. Open. But that 2011 Masters when he led by four shots and shot a Sunday 80 to finish 10 back? That’s the big one.

That reaction is human. It is relatable.

There’s just one problem. The reaction encouraged the masses. Or at least a particular segment of it. It’s why the Bash Brothers had such a busy day. Perhaps even more interestingly, it’s why there was such a short leash to kick those people out.


Caddy Harry Diamond, left, advised a pair of security guards to throw out multiple hecklers during McIlroy’s round Sunday. (Richard Heathcote / Getty Images)

As McIlroy walked to Sawgrass’ famous island 17th green, one fan yelled “2011 Augusta, Rory!” McIlroy’s caddie, Harry Diamond, called the Bash Brothers over and the fan was taken away.

We don’t know what led to each anecdotal example, so we can’t be sure how bad each one was. We just know a good deal of them happened. The PGA Tour has in its code of conduct specific rules related to fan behavior, and it takes a firm zero-tolerance policy when it comes to things like heckling. Specifically, it makes clear you are at risk of expulsion, for “rude, vulgar or other inappropriate comments or gestures or any words or actions,” including “verbal or physical harassment of players, caddies, volunteers, officials, staff, guests and/or spectators.”

The tour doesn’t appear to have an overall fan problem. There was concern when gambling was legalized that it would lead to severe issues with spectators attempting to shout during backswings or otherwise affect results. The tour hasn’t seen that happen, other than some pleading with a player to win their bet or complaining that they lost it (which is indeed a problem but not too dramatic of one).

Most events go on with no issue, but we also live in a new era of social media where it’s common for some to revel in the chance to get a reaction and gain some attention by posting it online. That reaction is everything. And while maybe 40 years ago nobody would know it even happened, it now has the chance to go viral and be seen by the world.

That’s why Tuesday’s practice round incident was so consequential. For that minuscule minority, McIlroy provided a target. The 2011 Masters at Augusta. It’s now his exhaust port in the Death Star — hecklers know they can hit it and watch it go boom. Diamond being the one to call security over for a dumb but generally innocuous comment (“2011 Augusta, Rory!”) only confirmed it.

Because yes, the tour has its code of conduct, but it’s generally the players or their caddies who act on it. Many players ignore any stupidity, and then it goes away. McIlroy generally always had.

We’re seeing what happens when you flinch. At Torrey Pines last month, a fan told McIlroy to blame his caddie, Diamond, for a missed put. McIlroy, always quick to defend Diamond, told the fan to “shut the f—k up.”

Former U.S. Ryder Cup captain Zach Johnson got heckled by rowdy spectators at the 2024 WM Phoenix Open for the U.S. loss in Rome, and he went over and argued with them. That went viral, of course. So two months later at the Masters — the one place “patrons” are supposedly so well behaved — Johnson made a mess of the 12th hole and heard sarcastic cheers. A hot mic caught Johnson turning and yelling, “Oh, f—k off.” He’s now perhaps the most consistent target for heckling in golf.

Before that it was Bryson DeChambeau, a top target during his feud with Brooks Koepka. After a painful playoff loss to Patrick Cantlay at the 2021 BMW Championship, a fan yelled the taunt, “Great job, Brooksie!” and DeChambeau lost it. “You know what? Get the f–k out!” DeChambeau yelled.


Things were so bad once for Colin Montgomerie that Golf Digest made buttons. (Stuart Franklin / Getty Images)

It’s not all recent. Take Colin Montgomerie. Back in the early 2000s, he had become such a target for heckling in the U.S. that it got to him. They called him “Mrs. Doubtfire” and made fun of his figure. And he reacted. It bothered him so much he threatened to boycott U.S. events. So at the 2002 U.S. Open at Bethpage Black, Golf Digest made 25,000 buttons to handout reading “Be Nice To Monty.”

The point for McIlroy is that these kinds of comments will now continue. The through line on all of this is that spectators pile on when they know they can make you mad. Immaturity, alcohol and/or comedic laziness lead to a lot of generic dudes thinking they’re clever when repeating the same lines. That stinks, the same way somebody yelling “Mashed potatoes!” after a tee shot or “Get in the hole” on an approach gets old fast.

The vast majority of fans sincerely love McIlroy. Maybe that’s difficult to remember when the negativity stands out. McIlroy is playing the best overall golf in the world. He won his sixth DP World Tour championship in December. He won at Pebble Beach last month. Add in a huge Players win Sunday. This could be McIlroy’s moment.

Yet people aren’t going to suddenly change. And each ejected fan or viral video of an angry reaction only provides more fuel to the fire, and the comments will continue. The Ryder Cup is coming, in New York of all places. All the power to him if that’s how he wants to react, but the test will be how he plays in response.

Sunday, he did let Spaun come back from a three-shot deficit to force a playoff. Then again, as the fan yelled “Hit it in the water” on 18, McIlroy hit one of the prettier shots you can hit. Which response he channels more will tell us everything about his 2025.

(Top photo: Richard Heathcote / Getty Images)

In star-studded Los Angeles, it’s JuJu Watkins’ show

LOS ANGELES — USC coach Lindsay Gottlieb and her star player, JuJu Watkins, were invited to the annual Los Angeles Dodgers Foundation Blue Diamond Gala in May. In a who’s-who world of L.A. glitterati, Gottlieb was astounded by how many people flocked to Watkins. Dodgers manager Dave Roberts and owner Mark Walter wanted to meet her. Magic Johnson and his wife, Cookie, came over. A section of Los Angeles Lakers personnel were interested, too.

“Everywhere I’m turning, these fans and these people that are here go, ‘JuJu! JuJu!’” Gottlieb said. “She’s as recognizable with (her) bun (hairstyle) as any of the Dodgers and was the biggest star. I came back and I said to my staff and the administration here, this was next level. Amongst L.A., she is kind of the star amongst the stars.”

Watkins was coming off a historic first season that saw her set the NCAA record for points by a freshman and lead the Trojans to their first conference title in a decade and first Elite Eight appearance in 30 years. Her bun became famous in its own right, and a national AT&T commercial during last season’s March Madness featured NBA superstar Joel Embiid, among others, trying out the look.

Watkins had already brought USC basketball back from relative obscurity. The promise of what she can be and what that means for the program and the city is evolving in real time as the Trojans start the NCAA Tournament as a No. 1 seed, hosting the first two rounds on their home court.

The sophomore sensation and the people around her have been preparing for this possibility before she started college. Watkins signed with Klutch Sports Group as a junior in high school and has been building her brand portfolio ever since. As a Los Angeles native, it has always been part of the plan to use her influence to elevate her community — a previous partnership with Lids allowed her to design a hat that highlighted her neighborhood of Watts — and choosing to attend USC allowed her to remain in the same spotlight.

“L.A. is just a great place as far as opportunity and relationships,” Watkins said. “I feel like L.A. plays a big part in my legacy and what I do on and off the court.”

The city is drawn to Watkins. The Trojans averaged 1,037 fans at home games in 2022-23, per data from the NCAA. During Watkins’ freshman season, that number spiked to 4,279 and further increased to 5,932 during the 2024-25 regular season. In addition to former USC players, Watkins has brought out a number of celebrities to the Galen Center. Actors, musicians and other influential stars, including Sanaa Lathan, Leslie Jones, Vanessa Bryant, Flea, Snoop Dogg and Michael B. Jordan, have cheered from USC courtside seats.

In anticipation of the extra attention, the program reached out to get a sense of what was to come, contacting the Big Ten and Iowa, including former Hawkeyes head coach Lisa Bluder, before the season began.

Caitlin Clark had been the talisman for women’s basketball fans during her senior season at Iowa, drawing historic crowds and TV ratings en route to breaking multiple scoring records. The Hawkeyes’ run to back-to-back national title games culminated in the highest-rated national championship game of all time, outdoing the men’s final the next day.

When Clark turned pro alongside former LSU star Angel Reese, and with UConn star Paige Bueckers entering her final college season, Watkins became the natural heir apparent to fill the superstar vacuum, both in the Big Ten and nationally.

As a result, USC updated its security protocols, adding a wristband policy to control the specific crowds permitted to stay in the arena after games. The Big Ten helped handle pregame and postgame protocols on the road, and Bluder shared details about how to maintain privacy at hotels. Watkins’ agent, Jade-Li English, added that security is a particular topic of interest given how recognizable Watkins is in her home city — with or without her bun.


JuJu Watkins signs her autograph for one of her many bun-copying fans. (Katelyn Mulcahy / Getty Images)

When the Trojans went on the road this season for their inaugural Big Ten campaign, every school (other than Iowa, which sold out every home game) saw an uptick in attendance. The JuJu Bump produced an average attendance increase of 75 percent, punctuated by Rutgers nearly tripling its average crowd when USC visited. All around the country, moms and dads in Watkins jerseys brought their daughters wearing their hair in buns to games.

“It was hard to predict this until you’re living in it in real time,” Gottlieb said. “We all had a vision for her helping to really grow this program, but I think that the gravitational pull in the change in the fan support is really pretty remarkable.”

That Watkins’ arrival into college basketball has coincided with an overall boom for the sport has only enhanced her popularity and her opportunities. Her portfolio is extensive, with 16 current national marketing deals, including Nike, State Farm, Gatorade and Fanatics. Her image is inescapable whether walking around Los Angeles — where she has a three-building-wide Nike billboard in downtown — or turning on the television.

“We’re able to align JuJu with brands that are leaders in their respective industries and align with brands that have a natural synergy with women’s basketball,” Klutch Sports senior vice president of athlete strategy Brittany McCallum said. “All of these partners have television placements, TV broadcasts during the NCAA Tournament. So these partnerships leverage national TV visibility, allowing for JuJu to be a part of a larger cultural moment, while also amplifying the brand’s presence during one of the most watched times in women’s sports.”

Watkins said her collaboration with Funko Pop was one of her favorites, as she helped with the details of its bun and eyelashes being as close to her likeness as possible. She signed at least 30 of them during USC’s Selection Sunday party. Her ad spot with Chipotle was another standout as it included the entire Trojans roster.

But the partnership with Nike has truly opened doors for Watkins. McCallum said her 19-year-old client was over the moon and “completely caught off guard” when she learned she would be appearing in a Super Bowl commercial.

“Seeing those moments and the power behind what Nike is putting behind women’s sports right now has been really special to her and probably something that wasn’t in the cards but definitely aligns on where the women’s game is right now,” McCallum said. “And JuJu is very grateful to be a part of the movement.”

The JuJu Watkins rise doesn’t happen without her corresponding basketball success. She followed up her freshman campaign with another first-team All-American season, joining Notre Dame’s Hannah Hidalgo as the third and fourth players to earn first-team honors as freshmen and sophomores. She led USC to its first conference regular-season title in more than three decades.

With all of the added attention, the focus remains on basketball. She doesn’t do pregame interviews, preferring to stay in the zone. Gottlieb says Watkins goes hard in every rep in every practice, accepting challenges on both ends of the floor. After dealing with cramping during her freshman season, Watkins put extra emphasis on hydration this season to negate that issue.

Even though her star turn has been choreographed, and the expectation was for her to succeed, she is reaching heights that were impossible to predict.

Gottlieb joked that her own identity is now defined through Watkins. At a USA Basketball event, she was working out in the hotel gym with Dawn Staley and the family of one of the U-17 players. The young boy in the family excitedly told his dad, there’s Dawn Staley, before turning around and noticing, there’s JuJu Watkins’ coach! At the 2024 Final Four, a father asked Gottlieb for a picture with his daughter because she was a massive Watkins fan, excited to merely get a picture with someone in Watkins’ orbit. Gottlieb felt compelled to point out that she’d be the one in the picture, not JuJu.

Los Angeles Lakers head coach JJ Redick attended the regular-season finale between USC and UCLA. Afterward, he said, “JuJu Watkins is one of one, she’s incredible. First time seeing her play in person, but obviously I’ve watched her before. She lived up to the hype.”

The hype train is unprecedented at this point, Where it leads is anyone’s guess.

(Illustration: Kelsea Petersen/ The Athletic; Photos of Angel Reese, JuJu Watkins and Caitlin Clark: Harry How / Getty Images, Brian Fluharty / Getty Images, Eakin Howard / Getty Images)

The BookKeeper – Exploring Manchester City’s finances during a season of change

The Athletic has appointed Chris Weatherspoon as its first dedicated football finance writer. Chris is a chartered accountant who will be using his financial acumen as The BookKeeper to explore the money behind the game. He is starting with a series this week analysing the financial health of some of the Premier League’s biggest clubs.

You can read more about Chris and pitch him your ideas, and his first article exploring how Manchester United ended up in a financial mess.


Last summer, in the afterglow of a record fourth consecutive English league title, Manchester City didn’t feel the need to do much. As rivals strengthened and Premier League splurging continued, the reigning champions were the division’s lowest spenders. Of the £2.4billion spent by England’s top clubs, City accounted for just £23million of it.

A rebuild would be necessary but City could wait another year. Even the departure of Julian Alvarez to Atletico Madrid did little to dim sunny dispositions in the blue half of Manchester, not least as his sale brought in world football’s biggest fee of the window — £64m ($83m), potentially rising to £81m.

Then the rains came. City, imperious under Pep Guardiola for so long, imploded in the autumn and on Christmas Day, sat seventh. In the revamped Champions League, they were in danger of going out at the first hurdle (avoided, just). And so, like any rich protagonist in a rut, they went shopping.

The effects of retail therapy on mood improvement are debatable. A University of Michigan study published in late 2013 found residual sadness was reduced by shopping because it gave the shopper what the paper termed “personal control restoration”. Through the act of buying things, individuals regained some agency over their lives, so they felt less sad.

The study didn’t cover football clubs, so the question of whether control restoration might sufficiently offset the misery felt after a 5-1 defeat at one of your biggest rivals was omitted, but City’s £50m deadline-day signing of Nico Gonzalez presumably acted as a small salve to Guardiola and staff following a chastening 24 hours beforehand against Arsenal.

City spent £183m in the winter, the highest-ever mid-season spend behind Chelsea’s £275m two years ago. City were the only club to top £100m in fees, disbursing almost three times as much as next-highest spending Al Nassr of the Saudi Pro League (whose entire outlay went on coaxing Jhon Duran from Aston Villa). Domestically, City accounted for over two-fifths of the Premier League’s spend. Oh, and they also tied down the best striker on Earth to a nine-and-a-half-year contract.

So in a world of spending regulations, what did this do to their financial position? And what is the broader picture for City during a season of change in which they are also fighting legal battles with the Premier League.


How could City afford to spend so much this winter?

Other than the glaringly obvious, ‘They’re owned by an Emirati royal’ answer, City’s could splurge thanks to years of financial prosperity. There’s little fear of City’s club credit cards being declined any time soon. And as for profit and sustainability rules (PSR), unlike when UEFA first introduced financial limits in the early 2010s, City have nothing to concern themselves with. The club’s owners haven’t put money in as shares since a £23m injection in 2021, meaning City can only lose up to £15m of their own money over three years — but the club are so profitable such matters are hardly on their radar.

In the three years to the end of last season, City booked a cumulative pre-tax profit of £195.9m, a PSR position made stronger once allowable costs, such as investment infrastructure and women’s football, are deducted. Using a combination of estimates and figures disclosed in the accounts, The Athletic projects City’s PSR headroom in last season’s calculation came to around £324m.

Correspondingly, they’ll have zero trouble with compliance this year, too. City’s finances will be impacted by their exit from the Champions League and they’re likely to drop domestic prize money but this summer’s Club World Cup could cover those shortfalls anyway. Unless they posted a £287m loss this season (newsflash: they won’t), they’ll be fine on the Premier League’s PSR, even after the winter spree.


Omar Marmoush was one of City’s January signings (Neal Simpson/Sportsphoto/Allstar via Getty Images)

The £183m they spent in transfer fees will be closer to £200m once agent payments and other associated costs are included, but that’s not £200m hitting City’s books this season. Omar Marmoush, Abdukodir Khusanov, Vitor Reis and Nico were signed on four-and-a-half year deals, so only £22m of extra transfer fee costs should land in City’s 2024-25 figures after amortisation (spreading the cost of acquiring a player over the length of their contract).

This season’s accounts will also include significant sales City made in the summer. Alvarez’s move to Atletico ensured a chunky profit on sale — likely at least £45m, possibly more — and the departures of Joao Cancelo and Liam Delap generated yet more money to boost the bottom line.

City are also now subject to UEFA’s squad cost ratio rule, which seeks to limit how much clubs can spend on their football staff. European football’s governing body will only allow clubs to spend a certain amount of ‘relevant turnover’ — 90 per cent last season, 80 per cent this and 70 per cent from 2025-26 onwards — but crucially, it allows clubs to count player-sale profits towards relevant turnover. City’s headroom here will be reduced from last year, but still shouldn’t pose a problem.


What do Manchester City’s recent finances look like? 

Last season was Manchester City’s fourth consecutive year of posting a profit, and their ninth in the last 10, although the one loss-making year in 2020 comprised a hefty, Covid-19-induced £125m deficit. Even including that big loss, City have booked net pre-tax profits of £126.4m in the last decade.

City are one of English and world football’s most consistently profitable clubs. If we strip out skewing — one-off items, such as owner loan write-offs — the only Premier League club to have posted a higher net profit over their last 10 accounting periods is Liverpool (£136.2m).

City are one of only a handful of teams to have successfully rebounded from the pandemic. In the five seasons before the Covid-19 outbreak, Premier League clubs were generally profitable. Then the virus arrived and revenues stagnated or fell as wage bills and other costs kept growing.

The impact on club finances was galling: of the 80 financial results for Premier League clubs announced from 2019-20 to 2022-23, just 20 were profitable. City accounted for three of those. In 2016-17 and 2017-18, all of the Premier League’s ‘Big Six’ were profitable. Since the pandemic shutdown, the only club among that cohort to post a profit other than City was Liverpool in 2022, and that was on the low side at just £7.5m.

That’s impressive, while potentially misrepresentative. City have been a profitable club for a while but it is worth remembering what it comes on the back of: heavy losses in the years after being taken over by the Abu Dhabi United Group (ADUG) in 2008. The first six years of ADUG ownership, unrestrained by any domestic ‘financial fair play’ regulations, saw City rack up a cumulative pre-tax loss of £601m. To put that sum into context, the net loss of every other Premier League club combined in those six years was £56m lower, at £545m, albeit that does omit two years of expected losses at Portsmouth, who entered administration during that time and didn’t publish their accounts.

City investing heavily back then is old news but its impact continues to be felt today. The club’s ongoing profitability derives from their excellent navigation of the transfer market; in each of their last seven profitable years, City booked an operating loss, with that propelled into the black by chunky player sale profits. Last season, by selling Riyad Mahrez, Aymeric Laporte, Cole Palmer and a slew of other youngsters, City’s profit on player sales figure hit a club-record £139m. In the past five years alone, player sale profits stand at £436.8m.


Revenue up again – even without a treble

City’s revenue increased again last season to another club record of £715m. That was only a £2.2m increase on 2022-23, but any growth is impressive given it came on the back of their treble-winning season. That £715m was enough for City to retain their position of generating the second-highest income in world football, though enormous year-on-year growth at Real Madrid means the Spanish giants’ income now sits over £170m ahead of anyone else.

City saw minimal change across all three main revenue streams, with matchday income up five per cent to £75.6m, commercial income up one per cent to £344.7m and broadcast income falling two per cent to £294.7m. In each of the latter two categories, they lead the way domestically, though that matchday revenue figure is only the Premier League’s sixth-highest.

City view that as a significant growth area, and it’s one of the reasons the club is investing heavily in expanding the Etihad Stadium and the surrounding area. City’s gate receipts trail Manchester United by £61.5m, and Tottenham Hotspur joined United, Arsenal and Liverpool as the English clubs whose annual matchday revenues top £100m.

The regeneration project carried out at the Bernabeu drove the surging income at Real Madrid, one of several European rivals who make more money on matchdays than City. Based on the latest available figures, Bayern Munich and Barcelona (even despite having their attendances slashed while the Camp Nou is renovated) took more at the gate than City. Those ongoing works will improve the Etihad’s standing. For now, season ticket prices rose by an average of five per cent for 2024-25, continuing a theme whereby supporters have borne extra costs in nearly all of the last 10 seasons.

Falling at the quarter-final stage of last season’s Champions League hit City’s broadcast income, though £4m of that was offset by Club World Cup success in December 2023. Commercially is where they continue to excel and grow. Last season’s figure of £344.7m was the highest in England for the fourth year running.

City’s commercial income figures have been a cause of much debate in the past, and they form the basis of a hefty chunk of the 129 charges levelled at the club in their ongoing legal battle with the Premier League. They stand accused of disguising cash injections from majority owner Sheikh Mansour as sponsorship income. It’s worth noting here the gravity of those charges: City’s auditor, BDO LLP, has repeatedly signed off on the club’s accounts without issue, so any suggestion of misstating commercial income figures is to accuse City of going far beyond just breaching some industry-specific (and oft-criticised) financial rules. City deny any wrongdoing.

The club’s increase in commercial revenues since the 2008 takeover remains staggering, having risen by over 1,000 per cent. All big clubs have seen huge rises and City were starting from a particularly low base. Even so, critics point to how among Europe’s elite it was only at City and Paris Saint-Germain — the French club who also have state ties — that commercial revenues remained pandemic-proof. Among the continent’s most prominent clubs, only City and PSG have enjoyed 1,000 per cent commercial growth since 2008.

The impact of City’s commercial growth can hardly be understated. Across the past decade, they’ve booked £2.54bn in commercial revenues, a figure eclipsed domestically only by United’s £2.67bn — an advantage City are now eating into at a rate of £40m per season. Everyone else is a long way back, with Liverpool (£1.67bn) the only club within £1bn of their Mancunian rivals. That’s a huge edge to have, so it’s little wonder City’s rivals will be watching the outcome of that court case with a keen eye.


How wages compare – and the CFG disparity

City’s salary bill fell last season, down £10.3m (two per cent) to £412.6m. A reduction was unsurprising — the previous set of accounts included bonuses from the historic treble — but the expectation was the drop in 2023-24 would have been more pronounced.

Few clubs disclose how much of their wage bills are consumed by the playing squad. City are no different but there was some information released in a 2024 UEFA report that detailed the quantum of various clubs’ player wages (the relevant page of the report has since been removed from the version available on UEFA’s website — why it was removed is unknown). According to that, City spent €389m (£338m; $430m) of their 2022-23 wage bill on players. That was 80 per cent of the season’s overall bill, so applying the same proportion to 2023-24 gets us to a playing wage bill of £330m.

On the topic of UEFA documents, the governing body’s most recent ‘finance and investment landscape’ report included a notable divergence from City’s financial statements. In there, City’s wages were listed as Europe’s second-highest at €554m, only trailing PSG. Using UEFA’s exchange rate, that translates to a wage bill of £475.8m — £63.2m higher than the figure per City’s accounts. In other words, there’s a material difference between the wages reported to UEFA and those in the club’s annual accounts.

That difference is explained by UEFA’s reporting requirements. The governing body employs a ‘reporting perimeter’, which asks that clubs report any figures ‘in respect of (that club’s) football activities’, including any amounts that occur under the auspice of other legal entities. By contrast, City’s published accounts cover the club individually but none of the other active legal entities related to the club, some of which evidently contribute to football activities. City therefore report a higher wage bill to UEFA than is seen in their individual club accounts in order to appropriately record those football-related costs.

Those other entities likely sit within City Football Group (CFG), City’s parent company that oversees the multi-club structure. Where City, the club, now make continual profits, CFG as a whole is significantly loss-making; the wage bill found in the UEFA report confirms figures given by clubs to the governing body might bear little resemblance to a club’s published accounts.

City’s wages were still the highest in the Premier League (illustrated in the graphic above), as they have been in four of the last five years. Last season was also the second successive year their wage bill was above £400m, a feat only one other English club has achieved — and Chelsea’s £404m in 2023 included around £45m in managerial change costs. City are big payers, and they see positive results on the pitch as a result.

That said, it’s not like they’re over-leveraging themselves. City’s wages to revenue metric stood at 58 per cent last season, a level it has hovered around for most of the last decade. They also aren’t really close to world football’s biggest spenders but nobody is. PSG spent roughly £565m on wages in 2023-24, even without Lionel Messi or Neymar on their books. 


Pep’s net spend argument

Guardiola has been keen during the recent malaise to highlight City’s relatively low net spend. Using the last five years of club accounts, it’s easy to see where he’s coming from. Between 2020 and 2024 City spent £970.3m on new players and recouped £570.5m in sales, a net spend of £399.9m. That put them sixth in England, behind Chelsea (£833.6m from 2019 to 2023), Arsenal (£776.5m, 2020-24), Manchester United (£713.1m, 2020-24), Newcastle United (£492.2m, 2020-24) and Spurs (£468.6m, 2019-23).

There’s a reason Guardiola highlights net spend — that particular measure paints his achievements at City in an even better light — but it does not assess a club’s overall financial outlay. For one, correlation between transfer spending and on-pitch success is sketchy (wages have historically been a better barometer for how a club will perform). For two, the implication of a lower net spend is that a club has needed to rid itself of its stars and find hidden gems on the cheap — that hasn’t been the case at the Etihad. City’s £970.3m on new players was only topped by Chelsea’s largesse and, rather more narrowly, by Arsenal (£991.7m).

Where City have benefited significantly is in reaping the rewards of plans laid over a decade ago. The club’s youth facilities are world-renowned and formed a key plank of the owners’ strategy to build City into one of the best clubs on the planet. Establishing the club’s academy as one of football’s most revered is paying clear financial benefits.

In the last six years, six players — Taylor Harwood-Bellis, Romeo Lavia, James Trafford, Douglas Luiz, Gavin Bazunu and Carlos Forbs — have left City’s setup for eight-figure fees despite not playing a single minute of Premier League football in sky blue. City banked £99m in transfer fees, and that’s without considering any sell-on clauses that may soon or already have accrued from subsequent moves.

Add in the £40m received for Palmer from Chelsea, the £15m Ipswich Town paid for Delap last summer and £10.5m from Southampton for Shea Charles and you’re at over £150m for nine players with a combined Premier League career for City of scarcely more than six full games.

City’s youngsters generate big sums

Season Player Age Sold to Fee (£millions) MCFC EPL minutes

2023-24

Cole Palmer

21

Chelsea

40.0

490

2024-25

Taylor Harwood-Bellis

22

Southampton

20.0

0

2023-24

James Trafford

20

Burnley

15.0

0

2019-20

Douglas Luiz

21

Aston Villa

15.0

0

2024-25

Liam Delap

21

Ipswich Town

15.0

47

2022-23

Roméo Lavia

18

Southampton

14.0

0

2023-24

Carlos Forbs

19

Ajax

12.0

0

2022-23

Gavin Bazunu

20

Southampton

12.0

0

2023-24

Shea Charles

19

Southampton

10.5

27

153.5

564

Palmer, paradoxically, is one many people now think City were silly to sell, but it’s not as if Guardiola parted with a key player. One of City’s greatest financial successes has been their ability to generate vast sums for largely untried young players.

City’s production line is the envy of most clubs, with plenty now trying to copy them — but it needs to be acknowledged when citing net spend. While transfer fees aren’t indicative of future success (and cross-city rivals United are the poster boys for that), it still stands to reason that the costlier a squad, the better they should be. To the end of June, City’s squad cost stood at £1.11bn, the second-highest in Europe, only surpassed by Chelsea (£1.42bn). City and Guardiola, regardless of their net spend, possess one of the most expensively assembled squads in world football.


Legal case and what’s next?

Except for the Covid-19-hit 2019-20 season, Manchester City’s revenue has increased every year since 2008. That trend might be under threat this season. Having exited the Champions League before the round of 16 and with a fifth consecutive Premier League title out of the question, City’s broadcast income should fall.

Domestically, the reigning champions earned £175.9m in Premier League distributions last season, a figure they will struggle to match this time. City sit fifth, leaving them in line for a reduced merit payment of around £12m. As well, through April 28, City’s games have been selected for live TV 23 times. With only four games to play after that date, City can’t match the 28 times they were selected last season, meaning they’ll likely drop income from this pot, too (TV appearances have generally earned clubs just under £1m per game).

In Europe, they earned €122m from reaching the Champions League quarter-finals in 2023-24. That figure looks set to drop significantly, even as the new format of UEFA’s premier competition advances more wealth to clubs than ever before. City drew two and lost three of their eight league-stage games this season, having won all six of their group games last year before falling at the second knockout hurdle to Real Madrid. Even with that increased prize pot, it’s estimated City will only earn €75m from the Champions League, their lowest income from Europe in seven years.

Not that an income drop this season is a foregone conclusion. As we’ve seen, City’s commercial revenues continue to rise and rise and that broadcast drop could be offset by participation in the revamped Club World Cup. FIFA’s tournament will straddle the financial year end, but with recent reports suggesting City could earn £46m just for turning up and up to £77m if they win the whole thing, it’s clear the expanded Club World Cup could make up much of the money lost from their under-performance elsewhere.

As many await the outcome of City’s much-publicised court case with the Premier League, scrutiny of the club’s finances has continued.

For instance, that UEFA finance and investment report included a pointed note around kit and merchandising revenues, which it stated “can be viewed as a proxy for each club’s global fanbase”.

The note went on to highlight that, of the 20 clubs with the highest such revenues, City’s kit and merchandising income comprised the lowest proportion of overall income.

Though UEFA’s report did not identify whether individual club figures were presented on a net or gross basis, one person familiar with the matter, speaking anonymously to protect their position, cited the lack of like-for-like comparison between clubs as a reason for City’s lowly ranking. City outsource their merchandising operation to stichd, a licensee within the PUMA Group, and accordingly record merchandising income on a net basis. Per the source, City’s kit and merchandise ranking would be higher if all clubs’ figures were presented on a gross basis.

Javier Tebas, the outspoken president of La Liga, Spain’s top flight, was rather less subtle at last month’s Business of Football Summit. Tebas outlined his belief City hide costs in affiliated companies, and disclosed that La Liga reported the club to the European Commission in July 2023.

“What worries me is not the APTs, what worries me is the companies outside the City Football Group where the City expenses are sent,” said Tebas.

“They have a scouting company, a marketing company. That’s where they have very high expenses. They invoice City for less money. City have costs that are less than if they didn’t have this circle of companies.

“All they do is they think about how they can avoid the rules and regulations. We have reported this to the European Union with facts and figures.”

City declined to comment.

In terms of CFG, a comparison shows that City’s financials comprise a greater proportion of CFG’s income than its costs. CFG’s accounts, like City’s, are audited annually, and each has consistently been given clean bills of health.

Man City CFG Man City proportion

Revenue

£715.0m

£933.1m

76.6%

Wages

£412.6m

£664.3m

62.1%

Other external charges

£172.4m

£316.1m

54.5%

Football staff

230

917

25.1%

Admin staff

381

1,543

24.7%

Some observers pointed to City’s minimal spending last summer as evidence the club knew the looming judgement in that Premier League court case was headed toward an unsatisfactory end. This winter’s activity should have put paid to that logic. As should the fact the club continues to plough ahead with the expansion project at the Etihad. At the end of June 2024, there were £73.8m in assets under construction sitting on the club’s balance sheet, with a further £169.3m in committed infrastructure costs. In total, the project is expected to set the club back around £300m. If City are posturing to give off an air of confidence before a court verdict, it’s some pose to strike.

Such costs won’t affect the club’s PSR calculation, at least not until works are complete and the benefits and running costs start to flush through. Those costs that do land immediately — such as transfer fee amortisation and new wages, including that bumper Erling Haaland contract — still won’t take City close to a breach.

Much harder to be sure about is the financial impact of that court case. If City prevail, their financial rise will continue. If they don’t, all bets are off.

Manchester City have been one of the more fascinating clubs to follow off the field since their world was turned upside down a decade and a half ago. There’s little sign of that changing any time soon.

(Top image: Eamonn Dalton for The Athletic, images: Getty Images)

‘Can’t-miss’ Men’s NCAA Tournament games on Thursday and Friday: truTV FTW?

The NCAA Tournament’s 32-game feast across Thursday and Friday is one of the most highly anticipated TV stretches of the sports year. You should watch as many games as you can, but if you need to prioritize, here are the “can’t-miss” ones to watch, informed by full-bracket predictions from The Athletic’s Brendan Marks, C.J. Moore and Lindsay Schnell. — Dan Shanoff

THURSDAY

The best game

(7) Missouri at (10) Drake
7:35 p.m. ET, truTV

Inexplicably, the best game of the first round is shunted to truTV, which is known mostly for the perennial March query: “How do I find truTV?”

Missouri made it through the gauntlet of the SEC schedule, but Drake — led by a former DII coaching legend and a couple of up-transfers he brought with him — has the official “Team Nobody Wants To Play” label. Mizzou loves to push the pace; Drake cranks the pace down about as low as it can go. A fascinating game on every level.

CJ Moore: Drake will be a trendy upset pick, and for good reason. The Bulldogs are 3-0 against high-major teams this year, Ben McCollum is one of the best coaches in college basketball, and he has Bennett Stirtz, whom a rival Missouri Valley coach recently told me is the best guard in the country. The Tigers rely on turnovers and prefer to play fast; McCollum’s teams always control the tempo. He also hasn’t lost in the first round of an NCAA Tournament since 2018.

Making things even more complicated, the other two games in that early-evening Thursday block are outstanding: No. 13 seed Yale in an Upset Special vs. No. 4 seed Texas A&M (7:25 p.m. ET, TBS) and a Hall of Fame coaching matchup between John Calipari (No. 10 seed Arkansas) and Bill Self (No. 7 seed Kansas) at 7:10 p.m. ET on CBS. (“Multi-view” FTW!)

Blow off work for…

(4) Purdue vs. (13) High Point
12:40 p.m. ET, truTV

Another possible Upset Special! High Point will have most of America saying “Who?” But also: Who cares, upsets are amazing! If High Point keeps it close (which it can through its high-octane offense and personnel tailor-made to match up well with Purdue), this will be the game your group chat is texting about.

Brendan Marks: Purdue has lost six of its past nine games, with its interior defense being exposed. Over those last nine games? A horrid 196th nationally in adjusted efficiency, per Torvik; opponents are making 63.3 percent of their 2s during that stretch, which is second worst in all of DI. No, thank you! High Point is dancing for the first time in program history because of Alan Huss’ top-25 offense, which just so happens to be the ninth-best 2-point shooting team in the field. Smells like a mismatch. High Point is the easiest upset pick in the region.

Amazing back-to-back-to-back

(5) Clemson vs. (12) McNeese
3:15 p.m. ET, truTV
(6) BYU vs. (11) VCU
4:05 p.m. ET, TNT
(8) Gonzaga vs. (9) Georgia
4:35 p.m. ET, TBS

Settle in, because the late-afternoon window is the best string of games of the entire first round.

• Clemson checks in as the 12th-most likely team to win it all; its tournament could end Thursday afternoon against Will Wade’s fearless McNeese squad.

• BYU’s “size, depth and offensive execution” versus VCU’s “guard play and defensive prowess” (per our Bracket Big Board). If styles make fights, this is a phenomenal fight.

• Ranked No. 9 in the country by the essential KenPom, Gonzaga nonetheless got stuck with an No. 8 seed; Georgia is under pressure, as the first SEC team to play/justify the league’s record-smashing 14 NCAA spots.

Worth staying up late

(5) Michigan vs. (12) UC San Diego
10 p.m. ET, TBS

Part of the fun of these first few days of the tournament is sitting glued to the TV after midnight, catching an upset by a team few know over a school everyone knows, then enjoying the bleary-eyed feeling when the morning alarm goes off, knowing you caught a classic.

Meanwhile: Every “12-5” game is self-recommending for its potential to be an upset (or “upset,” because at this point, a No. 12 seed beating a No. 5 seed is considered normal). UC San Diego has every characteristic of the classic 12-seed (this feature on the team is your must-read); Michigan is coming off a Big Ten Tournament championship run.

Moore: Michigan-UC San Diego might be one of the most interesting matchups of the Round of 64. Michigan’s dread all season has been turnovers, and the Tritons rank second in Division I in defensive turnover rate. The only issue for UC San Diego is its small frontcourt. Michigan is huge up front with 7-footers Danny Wolf and Vladislav Goldin.

FRIDAY

The best game

(4) Maryland vs. (13) Grand Canyon
4:35 p.m. ET, TBS

Lindsay Schnell, picking Grand Canyon: This choice is nothing personal against Maryland. It’s because GCU is one of the best and most consistent mid-major programs in the country (this is the Antelopes’ fourth NCAA appearance in the past five years; they upset Saint Mary’s last year).

Blow off work for…

(5) Memphis vs. (12) Colorado St
2 p.m. ET, TBS

Moore: Colorado State, winner of 10 in a row, is one of the hottest teams in the country and has one of the best wings in the country in Nique Clifford. His matchup with PJ Haggerty will be a fun one. The Rams could end up betting favorites, and I like them because Rashaan Mbemba has the strength to match up with Memphis big man Dain Dainja.

Then stick around for…

(7) Saint Mary’s vs. (10) Vanderbilt
3:15 p.m. ET, truTV

Schnell, backing Saint Mary’s: I’ll take Saint Mary’s to beat Vanderbilt in the first round and then upset Alabama in the second round. The Gaels are a tough, talented and, most importantly, veteran squad. They’re led by one of my favorite players: crafty point guard Augustas Marciulionis.

Worth staying up late

(5) Oregon vs. (12) Liberty
10:10 p.m. ET, truTV

Moore: Oregon-Liberty is one of the few spots where I went with an upset. Like Drake, Liberty can control the pace and is one of the best 3-point shooting teams in the country. Oregon prefers to play with pace. It’s not usually a good strategy to bet against Ducks coach Dana Altman in March, but Ritchie McKay is one of the mid-major level’s best coaches, and this is the best team he’s taken to the tournament since 2019, when Liberty upset Mississippi State in the first round.

(Photo: Michael Reaves / Getty Images)

MLB wants Japan to cheer for more than the Dodgers and Ohtani. The prize could be billions

TOKYO — During the early innings of a nighttime exhibition between the Los Angeles Dodgers and Yomiuri Giants, Nori Kawana walked through the concourse of the Tokyo Dome in disbelief. As the head of Fanatics’ East Asia operation, Kawana leads MLB’s merchandising in Japan, and the day had already set his company’s sales record in Asia. He was willing to bet no other sports retailer had ever had a better day in the region, either.

Seemingly every other fan at the Dome wore national hero Shohei Ohtani’s No. 17 jersey. Some 20 minutes after Kawana stopped to talk to a reporter, Ohtani ripped a home run to right field, and the frenzy continued. Just outside the Dome, fans streamed through a 31,000-foot MLB retail store, even as it grew late on a Saturday. Fanatics and MLB clocked an average of 1,100 transactions every hour across 140 registers.

The much-anticipated centerpiece of MLB’s week in Japan, the regular-season games between the Dodgers and Cubs, were still three days away.

“The Tokyo series is going to be the biggest standalone international event in the history of Major League Baseball,” league commissioner Rob Manfred said.

If MLB has its way, the series will also serve as a beginning. The league sees a trove of fan interest and cash to be unlocked in Japan, a country long obsessed with baseball that has grown infatuated with the defending World Series champion Dodgers and their expat star, Ohtani. The mission at baseball’s central office is to broaden the appeal of the whole league here, and success would not be trivial.

“We do believe there are payoffs in the B’s: billions,” Manfred said.

Manfred expects this Opening Series will set records across the board among league special events, including in viewership and revenue, the latter pegged by Manfred at $35 million. The only comparison he sees is to the league’s annual All-Star Game, an analogy that both flatters and undersells the moment: The midsummer classic is MLB’s premier standalone event, but also never produces the kind of fervor Japan has shown this week.

To Manfred, MLB has the benefit of both years of work in Japan — the first Opening Series was 25 years ago this month — as well as the lightning-in-a-bottle stardom of Ohtani. Last season, he became the first player in MLB history to hit 50 home runs and steal 50 bases in one year.

“We have really stayed after Japan, but it takes time for something like this to grow,” Manfred said. “Ohtani is like the accelerator. I mean, every once in a while, even we need to get lucky, right?”


MLB has multiple avenues for growth, and more games abroad is an obvious starting point. National teams from MLB and Japan will participate in another World Baseball Classic, the sport’s recurring international tournament, next year. But Manfred also expects to propose “more regular activity” in Japan and Korea in future negotiations with the MLB players’ union. Japan wants to see an event like the Opening Series every three years, he said.

But the greatest windfall lies with media rights: in the telecasts of stateside MLB games in Japan, including Ohtani’s Dodgers.

“Because media unlocks everything else,” said Dodgers president Stan Kasten, who has also run an NBA and NHL team. “What the NBA learned was the importance of exposure. The NBA got their finals in 200 countries around the world on television.”

MLB’s international TV deals expire following the 2028 season, at the same time the league’s national contracts in the U.S. conclude. When negotiating the next iterations, Manfred intends to dangle the possibility of bundling both together, hoping to entice the major streaming companies that seek audiences both in the U.S. and abroad.

“The explosion in popularity in Korea and Japan is going to create an opportunity to fundamentally change the way we sell our media rights,” Manfred said. “We’ve traditionally sold them in (individual) countries, and I think in 2028 they will be sold as part of an international package that will help us drive our media revenue in general.”

A powerful advertising agency, Dentsu, has brokered MLB’s TV rights in Japan since 1990, sublicensing to major broadcasters like NHK. Another company, Eclat, sells MLB’s streaming rights in the country. Overall, MLB has 10 TV partners in Japan today.

“Particularly in a digital space, we’re going to sell the rights where we get the best deal,” Manfred said.

But ultimately, how much MLB can grow in Japan likely depends on a few questions: How well can MLB tailor itself to the Japanese customer? And is the outcome really in MLB’s hands, or does the league’s fate rest with star players and their individual teams?

“Thinking about MLB entering the Japanese market, do people watch baseball because of the MLB teams? I don’t think so,” said Mariko Sakakibara, a professor at the University of California, Los Angeles who teaches international business courses and previously served as the deputy director of Japan’s Ministry of International Trade and Industry. “People watch MLB games because those teams have familiar players, right? And so it’s player-driven.”

In the last five years, Ohtani merchandise has accounted for 57 percent of Fanatics’ sales in Japan, Kawana said. Ohtani is so ubiquitous that it makes for a game: Try to wander around Tokyo for a few minutes and not catch a glimpse of him.

He appears not only on a multi-story New Balance display near the city’s famed Shibuya Crossing, but on smaller Seiko watch ads along the moving walkways at Haneda airport — a greeting for visitors who might have just landed on a Japan Airlines plane wrapped in his image. He is on both bottles and boxes of Ito En green tea in the convenience chain Family Mart, and on the banner above one’s head when entering the store. In a taxi ride at the end of one’s day, Ohtani might recommend a mattress on the passenger’s video monitor.


In Japan, Ohtani’s face is everywhere. (Tomohiro Ohsumi / Getty Images)

MLB believes there’s a halo effect to be had from that omnipresence. But there’s a competing theory that essentially places MLB at the mercy of its individual clubs.

“If you really want to grow MLB, it’s by attracting more NPB players to a more diverse set of major-league teams,” said player agent Joel Wolfe, who represents Ohtani’s Dodgers teammates Yoshinobu Yamamoto and Roki Sasaki, both Japanese. “MLB can’t do that. It’s on the individual teams that are truly interested to take the time to research and find the right people to expand their presence individually as organizations in Japan. Because MLB has been at the forefront of the minds of NPB players and fans for decades.”

At the team level, recruitment is an uneven playing field. What the Dodgers have done in landing all three of Ohtani, Yamamoto and Sasaki would be hard to replicate. It was hardly an accident.

“We saw this day coming,” Kasten said.

Kasten rattled off all the groundwork the Dodgers laid: attempts to sign Ohtani a decade ago and again seven years ago when he landed with the Angels, then preparing for his free agency years in advance. They signed Sasaki this winter when his Japanese team made him available, but the team had been ready for that possibility for at least a couple years, separating itself from the pack.

“It was like the Powerball got to $1.5 billion and all of a sudden the entire league wanted to drive down to the corner store and buy a lottery ticket. But they soon realized that it didn’t work that way for this kid, and most Japanese players,” Wolfe said of the Sasaki sweepstakes. “There’s a handful of teams that have spent an enormous amount of time, energy and manpower building a ground game in Japan and learning about Japanese culture. The ones that just showed up out of nowhere really didn’t have much of a chance to separate themselves.”

It is inevitable that more Japanese stars will play in the U.S. But if the rate of defection spikes, complexities or even conflict could follow. The nation already has its own professional league, Nippon Professional Baseball, where all three of the Dodgers’ stars once played.

Recently, top Japanese talents have started pursuing MLB careers at a younger age, bucking an expectation that players remain in their home country for much of their prime. NPB official historian Nobby Ito said that “of course, it is not positive” to lose the best players, but added “it is not necessarily negative” either, because MLB helps expose Japanese kids to baseball and spurs NPB teams to grow.

“You don’t want to do damage,” Manfred said, “and you’ve got to be a little careful about that.”


Ohtani jerseys are everywhere in Japan. (Mary DeCicco / MLB Photos via Getty Images)

Japanese teams, often resistant to change, have some leverage. They are party to the posting agreement that allows for NPB teams to put their players up for bidding, and any party can seek revision to the agreement, or even terminate it.

“It’s good for the business for there to be players performing at a very high level in Major League Baseball because it sort of validates the quality of play in Japan, right?” Manfred said. “In a perfect world with no other consideration, we’d have every one of the best players in the world playing Major League Baseball. But the fact of the matter is we also recognize we can’t play every day in Japan, and we want a thriving domestic product in Japan.”

After a meeting with NPB commissioner Sadayuki Sakakibara on Sunday in Tokyo, Manfred said he does not expect NPB will push for change in the near future.

“Deference and humility go a long way in this country,” said Ulrike Schaede, professor of Japanese business at the University of California, San Diego. “The commissioner’s right. I would tread very carefully about this.”


While the Dodgers guard their strategies for recruiting top Japanese players, they will gladly tell other teams how to then make money off them.

MLB clubs share best off-the-field practices, and the Dodgers are piloting a program in Japan that has been successful in European soccer: a paid fan club, which is a joint venture between MLB and the team. There are different annual membership fees for four levels, starting at $45 or so and ranging up to $500. Exclusive opportunities come along, from special events to offers for bobbleheads and tickets.

“MLB hasn’t done this with an individual team before, and maybe the time will come that all teams will do that based on what we learn,” Kasten said. “Remember, Premier League and La Liga teams have hundreds of millions of signed-up fans around the world. Hundreds of millions. And so far, we don’t have any because we haven’t started those programs.”

The profits of the fan club are considered international revenue, which means they are shared equally among the 30 MLB teams. The same is true for the money MLB makes from international TV deals. It isn’t clear what percentage of the league’s overall revenue the international bucket accounts for, but “it’s a significant number that can grow significantly bigger,” Kasten said.

“It’s not a small rounding error,” he said.

Most companies trying to grow in Japan have a steep learning curve. But MLB has an advantage in that its product is already entrenched.

Baseball is Japan’s top sport. In the last few years, research revealed accounts of its arrival here in 1871, a year earlier than previously understood. Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, Jimmie Foxx and other Hall of Famers famously came to Japan on tour in 1934.

“I appreciate the fact that if you show up in Japan on day one as ‘New Company X,’ there are challenges,” Manfred said. “The relationship between American baseball and Japanese baseball, I mean hell, it goes back to Babe Ruth for God’s sake. That’s not an issue for us.”

But customers in Japan do have nuances compared to those in the U.S. — “You don’t want to come in and say, ‘we have the better way,’” Schaede said — and the league will benefit from partnerships with companies that want to grow in Japan alongside it.


Nori Kawana of Fanatics. (Evan Drellich / The Athletic)

Kawana of Fanatics noted that Japanese fans do not wear sports jerseys day to day nearly as often as their U.S. counterparts. His mission is to convince them it’s cool to do so. The company collaborated with the artist Takashi Murakami on limited-edition merchandise for the Opening Series that sold out almost within an hour.

Japanese fans also expect a high level of service, and one of Kawana’s first undertakings at Fanatics was to reduce shipping times. “We’ve got to make sure the customers are treated with care in a much more granular way than I think anywhere else,” he said.

Both Fanatics and New Balance pointed to the different tastes in graphic T-shirts fans in Japan have. Illustration can be key. Japan is “one of the most fashion-forward countries in the world,” said Evan Zeder, New Balance’s head of baseball marketing. New Balance sponsors Ohtani, but the sneaker brand had a presence in the country well before that long-term deal was struck in 2023.

Topps, which has a multi-level installation in Tokyo during the Opening Series not far from New Balance’s, has seen an explosion in sales here, but still considers the country something of a nascent market. The Fanatics-owned brand said it totaled $22.6 million last year in Japan, up from $1.5 million in 2021.

“There’s definitely demand here for high-end $10,000 boxes,” said David Leiner, Topps’ president of trading cards. “But we think ultimately, to be most successful and to really grow the market and to introduce new collectors, we’ve got to have some lower-level price points to get people to try it.”

The best way for MLB to connect in Japan might be to take up efforts that read less like marketing at all. Sakakibara of UCLA suggested MLB focus on projects that benefit Japanese baseball and the country more broadly, such as arranging more games between MLB and NPB teams, and educational and community efforts.

On Monday, Manfred and a host of retired MLB stars, including CC Sabathia and Adam Jones, visited a school in Tokyo to hold a baseball skills event.

“It hasn’t changed since I was over there,” said Trey Hillman, a consultant to NPB’s Nippon Ham Fighters who has been a manager in MLB, NPB and Korea’s top league as well. “If they know that you’re in and that it’s genuine and sincere, and you really want to build a business relationship, it’s got to start at the grassroots. They’re not as quick to make changes as we are here in the United States.”

Nothing, of course, might be more grassroots than the homegrown role model who hits home runs every other night. In 2023, Ohtani said he would donate roughly 60,000 New Balance baseball gloves across schools in Japan.

“I don’t believe there’s ever been an athlete with this much demand in baseball,” said Zeder of New Balance, which manufactured the gloves. “I think people want to connect to an athlete, and I think people want to connect to someone who has achieved the greatness that he has.”

(Illustration: Will Tullos / The Athletic; Photos: Robert Gauthier, Kiyosha Ota, Yuki Taguchi, Yuichi Yamazaki, Gene Wang, Harry How / Getty Images)

Can a new college football stadium buy a seat at the table? Inside USF’s $340 million bet

TAMPA, Fla. — In September 2021, Will Weatherford stood between green and gold balloons under a white canopy and made the proclamation that could change the trajectory of South Florida football.

After playing their first 25 years across town at the Tampa Bay Buccaneers’ stadium, the Bulls were ready for their own home. Weatherford vowed an on-campus stadium — a building that has been discussed longer than the school has existed — was finally “going to happen.”

There was, South Florida’s board of trustees chairperson confessed later, a minor technicality: Weatherford had no actual plan.

No location in mind. No idea how much it would cost. No proposal to pay for it. And no contingencies for whatever industry headwinds were brewing.

“Sometimes in life,” Weatherford said, “you just have to speak things into existence.”

Like a $340 million stadium. Or, just maybe, a program’s return to major college football after being left behind.

USF administrators say the 35,000-seat venue will transform the university and transcend fall Saturdays when it opens in 2027. But it’s also a nine-figure shot at relevance for a football program that has never won a conference title or appeared in a major bowl game.

Though some premier programs are reevaluating the facilities arms race as they prepare to pay players directly, the Bulls are charging ahead with the most expensive project in program history. The risk is that borrowing $200 million becomes an albatross around the neck of a middling mid-major program that remains a middling mid-major program while the sport’s juggernauts consolidate even more power.

The potential reward is a seat back at the table for whatever the next stage of major college football is — before it’s too late.

“We don’t just want to be in the game,” Weatherford said. “We want to be competitive in the game and win.”


USF plans to open its new stadium in 2027. (Courtesy of USF Athletics)

A stadium 70 years in the making

The first idea for a South Florida football stadium surfaced around 1957, three years before the school’s first class. County commissioners discussed zoning in the campus’ northwest corner, but university president John S. Allen didn’t want intercollegiate athletics interfering with academics. Today, buildings for continuing education and public health stand where the stadium could have been. There’s a Hooters just down the street.

Simply fielding a football team was a literal uphill challenge. The university needed a push from a Bucs legend, Hall of Famer Lee Roy Selmon, to start a Division I-AA program that debuted a dozen miles away at Tampa Bay’s NFL stadium in 1997. Players drilled on slanted fields until 2000 when Tampa’s Raymond James Stadium prepared to host Super Bowl XXXV. The NFL couldn’t let the Ravens practice on a slope, so the league helped fix it. Current athletic director Michael Kelly remembers how happy administrators were; USF got a level field and saved several thousand dollars.

Stadium ideas popped up periodically over the decades. Kelly wrote about a venue for a grad school assignment before joining the Bulls. A park committee proposed a sports complex on an island between Tampa and St. Petersburg. As Florida prepared a bid to host the 2012 Summer Olympics, officials discussed an 85,000-seat facility that could be downsized afterward for USF.

The ideas never gained traction, even as stadiums opened at comparable programs like UCF (2007), Houston (2014), Tulane (2014) and Colorado State (2017). In 1998, the Bulls’ athletic director told the St. Petersburg Times a new building “wouldn’t make any sense” because it’d be too expensive. Three weeks later, SMU broke ground on a 32,000-seat stadium that, adjusted for inflation, cost a third of USF’s proposal.

“I think everybody thought that you should (build one),” Kelly said. “But the practical realities were, there was certainly no money and not high enough on the priority list of the university at the time to make that happen.”

The university’s priorities remained academics: gaining state recognition as a preeminent school and joining the prestigious Association of American Universities (AAU). Football facilities remained lower despite the Bulls’ climb to the Big East. USF announced plans for a $22 million indoor practice facility — a practical necessity in a rainy region — under one coach (Charlie Strong), began building it under another (Jeff Scott) and opened it under a third (Alex Golesh).

The list changed in 2021 when Weatherford made his proclamation under the white canopy during the groundbreaking ceremony for the indoor facility. The former Florida statehouse speaker and Jacksonville University defensive end wondered why USF didn’t have a stadium. He never got a good reason. But he was in position to change it.

South Florida’s president left a month before Weatherford’s announcement, and Weatherford made it clear the successor would agree with his vision. Trustees made stadium progress an objective for interim president Rhea Law and one of their presidential goals after she earned the full-time job.

“I wish we would have done it a long time ago …” Weatherford said. “Just because you didn’t do it 30 years ago doesn’t mean you shouldn’t do it today.”

Even if today looks very different than it did three years ago, much less 30.

If you build it …

Though conference realignment has never been the stadium’s primary selling point, its specter has hovered in the background.

Weatherford made his proclamation as the Big 12 was on the verge of expansion; South Florida didn’t make the cut. A trustee has asked in two board meetings whether a stadium would help the Bulls get into the SEC.

When Weatherford sought final financing approval from the state, he highlighted the Bulls’ four American Athletic Conference peers — Houston, Cincinnati, SMU and rival UCF — that earned spots in the Big 12 or ACC.

“It’s no coincidence that every one of these universities also made a significant investment in their athletic facilities, either through a new stadium or making tremendous renovations to their existing one,” Weatherford said in 2023.

Though it’s no coincidence, there’s no clear cause and effect, either.

“I think it is what we would call a necessary but not sufficient condition,” said Michael Leeds, an economics professor at Temple.

Leeds has studied the impact of on-campus stadiums, and he followed Temple’s decision to stay at the Philadelphia Eagles’ venue instead of building on campus. His takeaway: Though a mid-major program probably does need an on-site stadium to move into the Power 4 …

“Building it,” Leeds said, “does not make it happen.”

But not building it might guarantee it doesn’t happen.

Though facilities are not the driving factor in realignment, they matter. To join the Mountain West as a full member, Hawaii agreed to help the state replace the inoperative Aloha Stadium by 2032.

Facilities fall under “commitment to athletics success” — one of the rebuilding Pac-12’s five expansion criteria. If there were any doubts about the commitment Colorado State and San Diego State have shown as they move from the Mountain West, they can point to the combined half a billion dollars they spent to build stadiums.

Colorado State president Amy Parsons sees them as part of a cycle. TV partners, sponsors and other schools want to associate with competitive programs that excite fan bases, play in major bowls or make the NCAA Tournament.

“And it starts with, does a school have the commitment to the program and value the program in order to compete at that level?” Parsons said.

If a school is spending nine figures on its stadium, the answer is a clear yes. Especially against these headwinds.


San Diego State opened 35,000-seat Snapdragon Stadium in 2022. (Orlando Ramirez / Imagn Images)

Skyrocketing stadium costs

When Weatherford started speaking the Bulls’ stadium into existence, San Diego State was midway through building its 35,000-seat, multipurpose stadium. Thanks in part to lower-than-expected interest rates from the pandemic, Snapdragon Stadium’s final price before opening in 2022 was $310 million.

If the Aztecs had to build it today, athletic director John David Wicker said, it would probably cost between $450 million and $500 million.

“At this point,” Wicker said, “I don’t know how feasible that would be.”

That, too, hovers in the background at South Florida.

Faculty have expressed concerns about erecting a stadium and adjoining operations center for football and the new women’s lacrosse team while classrooms had mold or leaky roofs. Citing hidden or unforeseen costs, the faculty senate’s president cast the trustees’ lone vote against the stadium budget.

A pair of 2023 memos from Florida’s Division of Bond Finance questioned “arguably ambitious” projections of ticket sales and other “historically volatile” sources. If the Bulls miss their targets and can’t handle $19.6 million in annual debt service, it warned the school risks relying on its endowment or cutting athletics’ budget.

Attendance remains a long-term question. Half of USF’s conference home games fail to draw at least 30,000 fans. And how often will teams like Alabama and Florida revisit if the SEC expands its conference schedule or starts an alliance with the Big Ten?

Doubts didn’t disappear in 2023 when trustees and the state separately approved a $340 million budget: $200 million in debt, $50 million in donations, $31 million from capital funds and the rest from sources like the sale of old broadband equipment and auxiliary parking/bookstore funds. No tax dollars are included.

Trustees still have not approved the final cost, which Weatherford said has gone up. He referred to it as a “$400 million building” in November but said recently it will be “well within what we can afford.” The project has already been postponed a year because of a backed-up supply chain — and that was before the Trump administration’s tariffs and research funding cuts added uncertainties in construction and higher education.

Those complications come as athletic departments brace for a new expense: paying players. The prospect of $20.5 million in revenue-sharing has, along with rising construction costs, reshaped the once-booming facilities arms race. Alabama, Auburn, Miami and Ole Miss have all paused or scaled back major football/basketball projects. After Maryland football moved into its new home in 2021, Mike Locksley bemoaned the timing, saying that facilities matter less in recruiting because players would “get dressed in the trash can for $25,000.”

But if the calculus was that simple, Florida wouldn’t be exploring a $1 billion upgrade to The Swamp, and Florida State wouldn’t be spending $380 million to renovate Doak Campbell Stadium and add a football operations center. The Seminoles are investing because they expect facilities to matter more again in recruiting if every school has the same de facto salary cap.

“We wanted to make sure coming out of whatever was going to happen that we were prepared to take advantage of the new age of college athletics,” Seminoles athletic director Michael Alford said.

That costs money.

The Bulls plan to max out on revenue-sharing under whatever guidelines they’re given by the conference, NCAA or courts. USF’s 2022-23 payout from the American was $8.2 million — more than $30 million less than the smallest Power 4 distribution, according to conference tax returns. To compete at the highest level possible, the Bulls are counting on help from the stadium’s new income streams: stronger ticket sales, pricier amenities, naming rights, extra events like concerts.

“You can’t share revenue,” Kelly said, “if you don’t have any.”

‘It’s still a dream’

Last fall, 38 months after Weatherford made the proclamation that could vault the Bulls back to national relevance, he stood under an even larger white canopy on a once-sloped swath of land a few hundred yards north. Green and gold streamers shot through the air as dignitaries dug golden shovels into a sand sculpture for the ceremonial groundbreaking of South Florida’s stadium.

Five months later, the ground remains unbroken.


Despite a fall groundbreaking, USF hasn’t begun construction yet. (Matt Baker / The Athletic)

Though USF planned to begin construction by the end of February, bulldozers can’t start rumbling until the guaranteed maximum price is set. The lag time isn’t expected to keep the stadium from debuting for the 2027 opener against Louisville.

From there, administrators expect it to transform the university through greater involvement from students and alumni plus rising interest from donors and prospective students. Colorado State reported its second highest enrollment last year and is on track to top it this year. Parsons said it’s impossible to quantify Canvas Stadium’s impact on those numbers, but game days are a significant recruiting tool for everyone (not just athletes).

That’s critical as schools prepare for a demographic drop in college-aged students — the so-called enrollment cliff. Increased engagement from an on-campus stadium is one way to fight it and raise a university’s academic profile.

“I won’t say that it’s a slam dunk,” said Karen Weaver, a former college coach and administrator who teaches about the intersection of higher education and athletics at Penn. “But it’s certainly a way to elevate your campus enthusiasm for athletics.”

And if that’s the goal at South Florida, Bill Sutton knows it’s feasible. He saw it firsthand.

When Sutton started working at UCF’s sport business management program, the Bulls were what the Knights aspired to be. USF was in the Big East, then a power conference, and skyrocketed to No. 2 in the nation. The War on I-4 rivalry began to turn after the Knights opened what’s now called FBC Mortgage Stadium in 2007. Sutton watched students stop wearing Florida and Florida State shirts and start supporting UCF. Fan interest and on-field success spiked, and the Knights capitalized on a perfect season and two other major bowl appearances to catapult past the Bulls and into the Big 12.

A similar leap is the dream scenario for South Florida, which is 99-117 since its week at No. 2.

“If the facility’s there, if it’s full, if the interest is there, all the things that we don’t really have right now would make the dream in play,” said Sutton, the director emeritus of USF’s Vinik Sport and Entertainment Management Program. “It’s still a dream.”

But it’s a dream that’s impossible to ignore for a program that has already been left behind once. USF is one of three ex-Big East schools that have failed to land in a power conference in football after the league splintered around 2012 and became the AAC. The other two: Temple and UConn.

The stakes are rising again. TV contracts for the Big Ten, SEC, Big 12 and College Football Playoff are all set to expire between 2030-34 as an escape hatch opens for ACC schools. If major realignment — Big Ten/SEC spin-off? Super league? — is coming, that’s the likeliest timeline. It’s why Parsons said the pressure to build a stadium would be even more immense now than when Colorado State started its push.

“There’s a risk if you build it. There’s a risk if you don’t,” Parsons said. “And I would say in this landscape today, the risk if you don’t is even higher.”

USF officials say they’re happy in the American. The Bulls proved that in the fall when they, along with Memphis, Tulane and UTSA, turned down interest from the new-look Pac-12 to stay put. 

But where they are now might not be where they want or need to be in 5-10 years, if the ACC needs a new foothold in Florida, or the Big 12 expands again, or a fault line divides the teams willing to ante into the sport’s highest level from the ones that aren’t.

“We just want to make sure we’re on the right side of it,” Weatherford said. “I don’t even know what the right side of it means yet, but we’ll know it when we see it.”

If college sports is entering a new era of paying players and, perhaps, super leagues, Kelly asks why it matters where programs were generations ago when conferences formed? In that case, South Florida has one of the nation’s largest student bodies and sits in a top-20, fast-growing market in a talent-rich state. The Bulls have been one of the conference’s most competitive in NIL and were among the nation’s first programs to put a sponsorship logo (Publix) on the field.

South Florida feels closer to the bottom of the Power 4 than the middle of the Group of 5, and the Bulls are willing to put a third of a billion dollars into a building to prove it.

“Everyone has to recognize their moment in history, I guess,” Kelly said. “There’s times that call for bold decisions. There’s times that call for true action.”

 

2025 NCAA Tournament bracket picks: Why CJ Moore has Florida topping Duke for national title

The men’s basketball selection committee had an easy job at the top of the bracket this year. The 2025 NCAA Tournament might have the best collection of No. 1 seeds in March Madness history.

By the numbers, it is the best, at least in college basketball’s advanced analytics era, which dates to 1997, when Ken Pomeroy’s eponymous website began tracking college basketball data. This year’s four No. 1 seeds — Auburn, Duke, Houston and Florida — are all above 35 in adjusted efficiency margin. (Efficiency margin is determined by points scored and allowed per 100 possessions and adjusted for schedule.) In no other year have even two teams finished above 35. The No. 1 seeds’ net ratings add up to 144.81; last year’s No. 1 seeds’ pre-tourney net ratings totaled 117.7, and remember that field had two truly dominant teams at the top in UConn and Purdue.

Two reasons for that dominance: a funneling of the best mid-major players to high-major programs via the transfer portal, and an all-time season of offensive efficiency across the country, with the teams at the top scoring at historic rates.

That’s why it’s smart to mostly steer clear of riding mid-majors too far. We will look back at last year’s tournament as an inflection point in college basketball history: No true mid-major advanced past the second round. San Diego State (Mountain West) and Gonzaga (WCC) did, but their resources are closer to high-major programs than the schools with which they share a conference. We are only two years removed from both Florida Atlantic and San Diego State reaching the Final Four, but look at what has happened to their rosters since:

• FAU’s entire rotation with eligibility remaining is elsewhere, with Alijah Martin (Florida) and Vlad Goldin (Michigan) playing key roles on two highly seeded teams.

• Stars on that San Diego State team still left in college include Lamont Butler (now at Kentucky) and Micah Parrish (Ohio State).

Studying tourney history is always a good guide to filling out your bracket, and although this is a new era, this rule should hold true: In the years with truly elite teams near the top — using analytics as the measuring stick — a No. 1 seed usually wins the title. A No. 1 seed has also won six of the last seven tournaments.

I’m almost embarrassed at how chalk I went with my picks, but I’ve been writing all year about how the top tier of college basketball was historically good, and it’s hard not to let that knowledge influence my picks. My prediction is we’ll end up with one of the chalkiest NCAA Tournaments ever. That might not make for as fun of a first weekend, but the matchups in the second weekend and at the Final Four could be epic.

South Region

• Michigan-UC San Diego might be one of the most interesting matchups of the Round of 64. Michigan’s dread all season has been turnovers, and the Tritons rank second in Division I in defensive turnover rate. The only issue for UC San Diego is its small frontcourt. Michigan is huge up front with 7-footers Danny Wolf and Vladislav Goldin. The Tritons will double the post, but Michigan is used to dealing with that, and Wolf is dangerous diving to the basket. Dusty May also has solid options for dealing with UC San Diego star Aniwaniwa Tait-Jones between Wolf and Rubin Jones. Before the bracket was released, I was pretty sure I would go with the Tritons, but the Wolverines might just have too much up front. Expect this betting line to be a small one — Michigan is ranked 25th at KenPom, UC San Diego 36th — so if you’re looking for an upset pick that makes sense in this region, this is a good spot.

• Louisville, which lost only two games in conference play, is a bit of a surprise here on the No. 8 line, but that’s how bad the ACC was this year. The Cards could struggle with Bluejays big man Ryan Kalkbrenner, but Creighton needs efficient production from Steven Ashworth, and Louisville’s Chucky Hepburn is a stopper. Whoever wins that matchup will win the game. Hepburn could also be a tough matchup for Auburn in the second round; guards who excel in pick-and-roll situations have given the Tigers some trouble. If you want to fade the No. 1 seed, which has struggled defensively lately (ranking 47th in the last three weeks, per Bart Torvik), then this is the first spot to consider the upset. I’m just not sure the Cards have the bodies up front to deal with national player of the year candidate Johni Broome.

• Yale could be a trendy upset pick after knocking off Auburn a year ago, but remember Danny Wolf was on that team and is now at Michigan. The Aggies will likely face Wolf in the second round, and although Texas A&M’s ability to apply pressure and force turnovers is worrisome, Michigan has the bodies to hang on the glass. You have to rebound to beat the Aggies, and the Wolverines will get it done.

• Iowa State was a team considered Final Four-level good in the opening months of the season, but this isn’t the same team. Keshon Gilbert, who was expected to be the Cyclones’ best player this year, is done for the season, coach T.J. Otzelberger announced Sunday. The Cyclones have good depth, but they were laboring down the stretch, losing four of their last seven. Ole Miss coach Chris Beard is familiar with the Cyclones from his time in the Big 12, and his Rebels should be able to handle some physicality after playing in the SEC. A mini-upset here, with the Rebels moving on to the Sweet 16.

• New Mexico is another upset pick I considered, but the way to beat the Lobos is with talented guards who can score off the bounce. Marquette’s Kam Jones might be better at that than anyone in America.

• Michigan State has the easiest path to the Sweet 16 of any No. 2 seed. To beat Auburn, you need guards who can get to the rim and evade Broome, who wants to turn his hips and meet you at the basket to block your shot. That’s a dangerous strategy against speedy guards like Jase Richardson and Jeremy Fears. I’m tempted to pick the Spartans or Wolverines to knock off Auburn because the Tigers have lost some of their magic these last few weeks, but a little humility might just be what Auburn needed to refocus.

West Region

• Last year the West got wacky, and it could happen again this year. Florida, Maryland and St. John’s were all teams I considered putting in the Final Four before the bracket was released, but I decided over the last few weeks to pick Florida as my champ, and I’m sticking with that pick. The Gators, much like UConn in 2024, have the hardest path, but I’m a believer in picking what you believe is the best team. That said, the thought of seeing UConn in the second round is scary, as is meeting Maryland’s Crab Five in the Sweet 16, and you could argue St. John’s/Texas Tech is the best No. 2/No. 3 seed combo in any region.

• Memphis won the AAC championship without third-leading scorer Tyrese Hunter. His unclear status makes me hesitant to pick the Tigers to go too far. The predictive metrics do not love Memphis this year (No. 51 at KenPom), and Hunter has the best plus-minus numbers on the team, per CBB Analytics. Mountain West champ Colorado State, winner of 10 in a row, is one of the hottest teams in the country and has one of the best wings in the country in Nique Clifford. His matchup with PJ Haggerty will be a fun one. The Rams could end up betting favorites, and the reason I like them is Rashaan Mbemba has the strength to match up with Memphis big man Dain Dainja.

• Drake will be a trendy upset pick, and for good reason. The Bulldogs are 3-0 against high-major teams this year, Ben McCollum is one of the best coaches in college basketball, and he has Bennett Stirtz, whom a rival Missouri Valley coach recently told me is the best guard in the country. The Tigers rely on turnovers and prefer to play fast; McCollum’s teams always control the tempo. He also hasn’t lost in the first round of an NCAA Tournament since 2018. Granted, that’s the Division II tournament, but it’s actually harder to get out of the first round in D-II because its bracket is split into eight regions by geography, meaning the bottom (No. 8) seed could be a top-20 team if you happen to be in a stacked region.

• Texas Tech could be upset-prone depending on health. Starting guard Chance McMillian and starting forward Darrion Williams sat out the Big 12 semis. I’d expect Williams to be back for the tournament, but not so sure on McMillian. I’d be tempted to put Drake in the Sweet 16, but here’s one reason to believe in Texas Tech: Coach Grant McCasland is one of McCollum’s best friends and is not going to overlook Drake. In fact, these teams played a secret scrimmage in the preseason — won by Texas Tech — so the Red Raiders already know how good Drake is. Also, JT Toppin is a difficult matchup for a smaller front line.

• Arkansas-Kansas is another matchup that took place in the preseason. The Razorbacks won that one comfortably, but it was in Fayetteville and the Jayhawks were without veteran big man Hunter Dickinson. Though this is not the typical Kansas team, it was playing better down the stretch, and Arkansas could be out of sync trying to work Boogie Fland back into the lineup from a hand injury that sidelined him for two months.

• Kansas-St. John’s is another game with a perfect storyline. Two years ago, Bill Self recruited Dickinson out of the portal, and his addition pushed out Zuby Ejiofor, who has emerged as a star for the Johnnies. Expect this game to go much like Kansas’ recent loss at Houston. Kansas turned the ball over too often against the Cougars, and it will do it again in a low-scoring game that St. John’s will win.

• The Sweet 16 in this region should be awesome. Maryland will play with Florida for about 30 minutes but eventually wear down against the deepest front line in college basketball. St. John’s is one of the few opponents that can give Texas Tech a hard time finding advantageous matchups for JT Toppin and Darrion Williams. If the Red Raiders get hot from 3, they could pull off the upset. They were the only team to beat Houston in Big 12 play, but their health is a concern.

• This sets up a regional final that will be must-watch television, with Florida star Walter Clayton facing his old coach Rick Pitino — Clayton started his career at Iona — and one of the sport’s all-time best coaches squaring off against one of its best young ones, Todd Golden. The Gators should be prepared from the three games they played against another blue-collar team with a dominant defense in Tennessee. (Florida won two of three.) St. John’s might be the defense best equipped to slow the Gators, but Florida’s 3-point shooting will be the difference.

East Region

• Oregon-Liberty is one of the few spots where I went with an upset. Like Drake, Liberty can control the pace and is one of the best 3-point shooting teams in the country. Oregon prefers to play with pace. It’s not usually a good strategy to bet against Ducks coach Dana Altman in March, but Ritchie McKay is one of the mid-major level’s best coaches, and this is the best team he’s taken to the tournament since 2019 when Liberty upset Mississippi State in the first round.

• VCU is a concerning matchup for BYU. It’s going to take a great defensive team to knock off the Cougars, and that’s what VCU is. But BYU was on a roll recently until it lost by 20 to Houston in the Big 12 semis, and I’m just going to chalk that up to the fact playing Houston is unlike playing anyone else in college basketball. Under first-year coach Kevin Young, BYU has one of the best offenses in the country and has been playing with a ton of confidence.

• Wisconsin-BYU could be one of the most entertaining games of the tournament. Both teams shoot a lot of 3s, play with beautiful ball movement and are solid but not elite on the defensive end. The Badgers are the slightly better team and worry about BYU’s ability to slow down John Tonje, but I have to pick some kind of upset, and BYU has been playing more like a top-three seed as of late. This is close to a coin flip.

• Saint Mary’s could give Alabama issues if it can control the pace, but the Gaels would need to hit double-digit 3s to keep up. They haven’t done that since Jan. 11.

• If you want to pick Duke to get upset, the Sweet 16 might be a decent spot. Duke beat Arizona by 14 in Tucson earlier this season, but the Wildcats have improved as much as anyone since November, mostly because of the emergence of Henri Veesaar. The Wildcats’ bigs are athletic enough to at least match up with Cooper Flagg, but it would take Caleb Love’s going nuclear to pull off the upset. I’m tempted but ultimately too much of a believer in this Duke team.

• Speaking of Duke, some might fade the Blue Devils because of the weak ACC they dominated. Let me remind you that Gonzaga has made the national championship game twice coming out of the West Coast Conference. If anything, the easier schedule helped Jon Scheyer find another asset. I’m not sure he would have experimented with playing freshman sharpshooter Isaiah Evans if Duke was playing in a league like the SEC.

• Duke-Alabama could be another great Elite Eight game. My worry for the Crimson Tide is Grant Nelson’s health. Nelson injured his knee against Florida in the SEC tournament semifinals, and Alabama will need him at 100 percent to knock off Duke. The Crimson Tide are another team with the size and athleticism up front to deal with the Blue Devils, but Duke wing Kon Knueppel could be a matchup problem. The size and strength of Sion James could also give Crimson Tide leading scorer Mark Sears some issues. I wouldn’t blame anyone for picking Alabama to get back to the Final Four, but Duke and Florida were the two teams I knew pre-bracket I was taking at least to the Final Four, and I’m not budging off that strategy.

Midwest Region

• Houston cannot love the idea of seeing Gonzaga, No. 9 at KenPom, in the second round. The Zags have made nine consecutive Sweet 16s and always seem to be peaking in March. But the Zags lost to Saint Mary’s twice in low-possession games, and Houston has taken its elite defense to another level.

• My buddy Seth Davis took High Point and McNeese in the Round of 64 in this region, and I was tempted to do the same. Will Wade’s Cowboys played Alabama and Mississippi State close in the nonconference, and the talent gap isn’t going to be that big against Clemson. I am going with High Point for a few reasons. High Point has one of the best offenses at the mid-major level. The Panthers, coached by former Creighton assistant Alan Huss, make 57.4 percent of their 2s, and Purdue has struggled defensively inside the arc this year without Zach Edey, ranking 350th out of 364 D-I teams in 2-point percentage defense. The health of Fletcher Loyer, who injured his elbow in the Boilermakers’ Big Ten tournament loss to Michigan, is also a concern. High Point gets by Purdue, but I’m sticking with my rule of no mid-majors past the second round.

• Illinois has been a wild ride this year. Every time I start to believe in the Illini, they give me good reason to jump off the bandwagon. But they have been much better with a healthy Tomislav Ivisic, and he was starting to play better until the loss to Maryland in the Big Ten quarterfinal. Kentucky, meanwhile, is limping into the tournament and has been injury-riddled all season. If Lamont Butler were back to his usual self, I’d maybe lean Kentucky, but it doesn’t seem like his shoulder is ever going to be the same.

• Tennessee was the one No. 2 seed I was convinced I wouldn’t pick to make the Elite Eight about a week ago, but then I watched the SEC tournament. The Vols’ offense seems to have new life with Jordan Gainey catching fire. UCLA is good enough to pull off the second-round upset. We already watched the Illini almost beat Tennessee in mid-December, when Gainey helped the Vols escape Champaign with a buzzer-beater. I wouldn’t blame someone for falling for the Illini, but I’m betting on experience.

• Houston-Tennessee is a Spider-Man meme Elite Eight matchup: old rosters, legendary coaches, great defenses and offenses that rely on shot-making guards. I just trust Houston’s guards to consistently make shots at a higher clip. This is Kelvin Sampson’s best offensive team at Houston, and Milos Uzan, who starred in the Big 12 title game, will be the difference in this one as well. But if you want to deviate from my silly chalky ways, this might be a good spot. Sampson told me Saturday he thinks the four best SEC teams might be the four best teams in the country, so maybe we should listen to him. But I’m betting on the Cougars, who will enter this tournament (mostly) healthy for the first time since 2021, a year when they made the Final Four.

(Photo of Alijah Martin: James Gilbert / Getty Images)

Remembering Greg Gumbel: Viewers relied on him from Selection Sunday to ‘One Shining Moment’

The Athletic has live coverage of the 2025 Men’s March Madness Selection Show

Ever the gentleman, Greg Gumbel reached out to offer a welcoming handshake. Ernie Johnson responded with … a fist bump?

The awkward exchange — one Johnson still describes, a decade later, as “so embarrassing” — lasted maybe two seconds. To Johnson, a TV veteran, it felt like an eternity. And yet if it had to happen, for two seconds or 20, it’s agreed that no one other than Gumbel could have handled it so smoothly.

For more than a quarter of a century, Gumbel provided calm in the most chaotic stretch of the sports calendar, gently and seamlessly guiding NCAA Tournament viewers from one thrilling upset to another marquee matchup. He kicked off March Madness each year with the Sunday selection show and ended it by tossing to “One Shining Moment.”

“With certain shows, it’s all about, ‘let’s add a bunch of bells and whistles,’” Johnson told The Athletic. “But on Selection Sunday, all you needed was Greg Gumbel and a bracket. So much goes into running that show but honestly, you could have made it a single camera shoot: Here’s Greg, here’s the bracket, go.”

The tournament is here again, the first since the legendary sportscaster died on Dec. 28 at the age of 78 of cancer. Though he missed last March for the first time since he started in 1998 for undisclosed reasons — which people now know were related to his illness — many hoped he’d be back in studio this spring.

The descriptions of Gumbel from those who knew him best and worked with him longest are flattering and varied: Kind, classy, soothing, charismatic, surprisingly funny. Above all else, unflappable.

Unless, of course, Charles Barkley was in the studio.

“When you can get Greg Gumbel to laugh,” Barkley told The Athletic, “that’s when you know you’re having a good day.”

CBS and Turner merged in 2011, bringing TNT’s “Inside the NBA” crew into NCAA Tournament coverage, letting Barkley loose on college basketball fans, and Gumbel.

“I’ll never forget at the beginning, I’m not in studio anymore, I was back calling games, so I’m watching from the gym and I’m like, ‘Oh, my gosh what is happening?!’” basketball analyst Clark Kellogg, another mainstay in the CBS studio during the NCAA Tournament, recalled while laughing. “When it became a little bit of a circus, the look on Greg’s face, you could tell he was flummoxed — but only if you’d worked with him and knew him. He was so adaptable, he handled it so well.”

Led by Gumbel — and including Johnson and Clark after he moved back to the studio in 2014 — the new group quickly found a rhythm that worked, even if it continued to involve Barkley being Barkley. One particularly memorable on-air moment: Gumbel laughing uncontrollably in response to Barkley’s bizarre story about showering in his uniform.

According to Gumbel’s daughter, Michelle, her dad loved the chaotic pace of March Madness, and the fact that no script could ever keep up with the “non-stop action.” His widow, Marcy, pointed to her husband appreciating basketball’s unpredictability and that every spring, no matter what teams were ranked, if he called their names during Selection Sunday, they would have “a chance to chase their dream.”

But Gumbel was much more than one of college hoops’ most trusted and reassuring voices. Barkley considered him the king of dad jokes. He loved the Rolling Stones with an unmatched passion, attending more than 50 of their concerts. He despised golf. “It’s a stupid game,” he’d tell anyone who would listen. “You walk around and chase a ball — that’s not a sport!” He had a “huge, special laugh,” as CBS Sports president and CEO David Berson liked to describe it, as recognizable to viewers as much as his on-camera authenticity and warmth.

He was a trailblazer and a rare talent. He was also a husband, dad and grandpa.

Suzanne Smith, CBS Sports’ first female director who worked with Gumbel on football broadcasts starting in the early 1990s, put it this way: “Greg was always the coolest guy in the room — and he never knew it.”


Gumbel’s career accomplishments included being the first Black play-by-play announcer to call a major sporting event when he did so at Super Bowl XXXV in 2001. He won three Emmys, anchored three Olympic Games across two networks and led broadcast coverage of everything from the NFL to the NBA. Not that he ever wanted to brag about it.

“He is an iconic pioneer in the space, but he was so uninterested in talking about it that you’d tend to forget it,” Kellogg said. “It was a revelation even for me, especially as a fellow Black man. I had forgotten some of the trailblazing things he’d done. And believe me, he wasn’t going to tell you.”

At CBS, Harold Bryant became the first Black executive producer to oversee sports at any of the major broadcast networks. Bryant studied how Gumbel handled being “the first” himself.

“He didn’t want to be known as the groundbreaker,” Bryant said. “He wanted to let his presence speak for itself, and I took a lot from that.

“He would just say, ‘I want to be known as the best at my craft.’ By always being the best, he showed that anybody can do this job, it’s not limited to one particular type of person. He didn’t talk about wanting to break the mold.”

Barkley said Gumbel’s talent was always clear.

“For as long as he was in the business — and to go from sport to sport, which can’t be easy — you don’t have that type of career until you’re really, really good,” he said.

Despite sitting in the No. 1 chair, Gumbel never wanted the focus on him.

Years ago after calling a Colts game, Smith, Gumbel and the CBS crew wound up at St. Elmo, the Indianapolis steak house famous for its shrimp cocktail. After the group was told the wait was two, maybe three hours, a few people nudged Gumbel and suggested he drop his name. After all, his photo hung on the celebrity wall.

“He wanted no part of it,” Smith said. Afterward, when the crew insisted he take a photo standing by the photo wall, he was mostly mortified, asking his colleagues, “What are we doing? No one cares who I am!”


Throughout sports media there are “certain broadcasters who have that big-time voice,” Smith said. “Greg Gumbel was one of them. If he was calling it, you knew it was an important, special event.”

Despite that acknowledgment from nearly everyone in sports television, Gumbel constantly deferred to his teammates.

“He did love paving the way for others,” said Berson, the CBS Sports president. “That’s a big part of why he was such a good studio host because he was always looking to tee up his colleagues and make them look good.”

Gumbel understood how to deftly transition from one topic and analyst to another, smoothly taking viewers through an entire rundown. Perhaps best of all for everyone working with him, he never appeared rattled; what viewers experienced in their living rooms is the same thing producers experienced in the production truck and on set.

This was the case no matter the situation — a highlight not working, a promo not being read correctly or Barkley needing to be corralled.

“When we go off the rails, Ernie’s used to it,” Barkley said. “We do it probably 20 times a year with him on TNT. But Greg would only see us once a year and he had to react in real time. There’s a talent to that. He never seemed flustered.”

Numerous people who worked with Gumbel spoke about his ability to crack tension on set, though it never came at someone else’s expense.

Kellogg called him “a closet comedian.” Barkley recalled Gumbel told “10 dad jokes a day, and they were just awful. You never knew if you were laughing because it was funny or because they were so nerdy.”

For as much as Gumbel’s work revolved around sports, the stories imprinted on the minds of colleagues, friends and family are about life and conversations beyond the court or field.


Greg Gumbel was a private man, but his love of the Rolling Stones and his granddaughter, Riley, were no secret. (Courtesy of the Gumbel family)

Michael Gluc worked as Gumbel’s spotter during NFL games for more than two decades. They traded family stories and holiday cards and checked in with each other throughout the offseason. Gluc still catches himself waiting for Gumbel’s regular Friday email sharing dinner plans for the next day in whatever NFL city they were headed to.

“He loved the Stones, everyone knew that, he saw them in concert multiple times. And for 24 years, I couldn’t tell him I liked the Beatles more,” Gluc confessed, laughing. “I didn’t want to disappoint him.”

At the 1992 Winter Olympics, Gumbel’s first as CBS host, he de-boarded the plane in Albertville, France, and noticed Smith struggling. On crutches after breaking her foot, she couldn’t juggle her luggage. Gumbel, who’d yet to meet Smith, rushed to help.

“There were probably 200 people getting off that plane, and this guy is a superstar at CBS, running over to help someone he doesn’t know,” Smith said.

At the 2011 Final Four in Houston, Berson shared a car with Gumbel to Reliant Stadium. Gumbel asked Berson about his interests outside of sports. They spent the entire ride trading book recommendations after discovering they preferred the same suspense authors like Vince Flynn, Harlan Coben and Sue Grafton (Gumbel also recommended John Sandford and Lee Child).

And yet there is no question that the true highlight of Gumbel’s life came in 2012 when his granddaughter Riley was born. Though Gumbel was an intensely private person — numerous people at CBS did not know he’d been diagnosed with cancer until shortly before his death — one topic he never shied from was Riley.

“The pictures and videos,” Kellogg said, “were unceasing.”

Riley’s favorite memories with her grandpa include dance-offs in the kitchen, telling knock-knock jokes and his insistence that she also get familiar with the Rolling Stones.

“He would always send me his favorite songs that he’d think I’d like, and I ended up loving each one,” Riley wrote in an email to The Athletic. “Whenever I hear one of those songs on the radio, such as ‘Brown Sugar,’ I always think of him and how he is communicating with me from above.”

A few years ago, when Riley was in the fifth grade, her school put together a morning show. When it was Riley’s turn to anchor, her parents recorded it and sent it to Grandpa for feedback.

Her next time in front of the camera, she shined.

“I remembered all the things he had taught me,” she said. “Talk slower, pronounce words with diction and always smile.”

As March Madness tips this week, Gumbel’s absence will be felt. Michelle attended her first and only Final Four with her dad in Houston in 2011, proudly “watching him do what he’s always done best.”

“I feel fortunate to have had the opportunity to grow up watching my dad all these years,” Michelle said via email. “I will greatly miss his send-offs after calling the game or hosting, saying goodnight with a heartfelt, ‘Goodbye and so long.’”

(Illustration: Demetrius Robinson / The Athletic; Photos: Kyle Terada / USA Today Network via Imagn Images)

The funniest 2025 March Madness bracket names: Picking our favorites

There’s not too much shame in a botched March Madness bracket. The NCAA Tournament is compressed chaos in single elimination, upsets are part of the game, and only one entrant can actually win it all.

What we can’t forgive is a lazy, uninspired bracket name.

The men’s and women’s tournaments give us a wealth of punnable school, player and coach names to choose from — even an arena or two. Here are this correspondent’s favorite puns and frivolities for 2025 bracket names. Give us yours in the comments below.


Men’s

Ok, Broomer — For those who see Auburn as an inevitability, go with their star, Johni Broome. These are not your postwar Tigers.

Green Flaggs — A lot of folks will swipe right on the Blue Devils if their megastar Cooper Flagg is healthy.

Lipsey’s Hustle The marathon continues for Tamin Lipsey, Iowa State and the Fightin’ Otzelbergers.

Knuck If You Buzz — Texas A&M head coach Buzz Williams has the sheer intensity and righteous passion of prime Lil Scrappy.

Let’s Get Oweh From It All — To Kentucky’s Otega Oweh: “Let’s take a boat to Bermuda, let’s take a plane to Lexington.”

Yes, UConn — For the Huskies believers.

No, UConn’t — For people who actually watched UConn this season.

Creighton for a Star to Fall — The name whispered on the wind was, in fact, “Ryan Kalkbrenner.”

Caleb Love and BasketballFor what? Our hearts, of course. And an Arizona run.

Caleb Grillz — Missouri bucket-getter Caleb Grill has his whole top diamond and the bottom row gold … we think.

Littlejohn and the Eastside Boyz — Chase Hunter and Clemson have forced their tourney seeding to Get Low. Looking to bring some hardware back to Littlejohn Coliseum.

Frankie Fidler on the Roof To life, to life, to Sparty. Tevye would’ve trusted Michigan State’s Tom Izzo in March.

Love (Ma)shackIt’s a lil’ old place where we can get together … and make Alabama really upset. Tennessee’s Jahmai Mashack had one of the coolest moments of this college season.

LJ Cryer and the Infinite Sadness A [Houston] Cougar with Butterfly Wings. Underestimate whatever that is at your own peril.

Queen’s Gambit — Maryland’s freshman center Derik Queen is the tallest, fleetest turtle we’ve ever seen.

Kameron Presents…the (Golden) Diplomats — Based on Marquette’s guard Kameron Jones. Does that make David Joplin Juelz Santana?

Silkk Da Shaka — Another great Marquette play.

Toppin My Collar — For those both appreciating Texas Tech’s resurgence (and star JT Toppin) and wishing it was 2005 again.

“What Are You Doing in My Swamp?!”— The Florida Gators would win and cover against Lord Farquaad.

Rick Pitino’s Bodega Corner — The Johnnies have taken New York by (red) storm.

Throw it Down, Big Man —For those wanting to honor the late Bill Walton.

One Shining Moment — For those wanting to honor the late Greg Gumbel.

Grant Nelson’s Mustache —  In celebration of the sport’s modern canon.

The Parentheses Preferers — Who needs brackets? Proper punctuation prevents poor performance.

Tar Heels and Glass Slippers Maybe, just maybe, there’s someone out there who has UNC making a Cinderella turn.

The Floor Slappers Federation — Yup, it’s about that time.

Women’s

Elementary, My Dear Watkins — For those who fashion JuJu Watkins and the Trojans as “A Study in Scarlet.”

JuJu Fruit — We’re sweet on JuJu and USC.

For Bueckers or Worse — Paige Bueckers is the superstar, but Sarah Strong and Azzi Fudd also balled out this year.

For Auriemma, Forever Ago — Do we think UConn’s iconic coach, Geno Auriemma, knows who or what Bon Iver is?

Place Your Betts — UCLA and Lauren Betts could certainly cash out after their inspired Big Ten tourney performance.

Dawn and On — South Carolina and Dawn Staley pursue their fourth national title of this era. We’ll take every opportunity to hear more Erykah Badu.

Boom Boom Paopao — The WNBA-bound Gamecock Te-Hina Paopao is so 3008.

The Van, The Lith, The Legend — TCU’s superstar Hailey Van Lith just put in work as the MVP of the Big 12 Tournament.

Hidalgo To Bed — Don’t sleep on Notre Dame (or Hannah Hidalgo) despite the late-season slump.

Came Out a Beast — Flau’jae Johnson is nice on the boards and in the booth.

Taylor Jones’ Block Party — Everyone’s invited. Texas is tough in the frontcourt.

Wes is Moore — A guiding mantra. NC State’s sideline strategist Wes Moore is the ACC’s Coach of the Year.

Lawson’s Creek — For those switching over to Duke (coached by Kara Lawson) after their conference tournament title. Casting recommendation: Michelle Williams as Toby Fournier.

O.K., Sooner — We brought it back one time for those rolling with Raegan Beers and Oklahoma.

(Illustration: Kelsea Petersen / The Athletic; Harry How / Getty Images, Grant Halverson / Getty Images, Kevin C. Cox / Getty Images)

Is Alexander Isak the striker who troubles Virgil van Dijk more than any other?

You could make a strong case that this year’s Carabao Cup final will see Europe’s most threatening striker come up against its strongest centre-back.

Alexander Isak has scored 22 goals in all competitions this season as he looks to surpass a career-best tally of 25, achieved in 2023-24. If he wants to add to that total on Sunday, he will likely need to get the better of Liverpool’s imperious captain, Virgil van Dijk.

But for some tightness in his groin, Isak could have got in some further practice against Van Dijk in last month’s Premier League match at Anfield — a game in which Newcastle were comfortably beaten after failing to register a single shot on target.

Even without Isak in the side that night, Van Dijk made sure to give the Sweden international the praise he deserved before their impending battle at Wembley.

“A final is always different and we’re very wary of the threat they possess,” Van Dijk said after his side’s 2-0 win on February 26. “We know Isak is definitely the most in-form striker at the moment in world football, so you know when he’s back that will give them a boost.”

On the one hand, the broad statistics help us draw a simple conclusion about the pair’s previous battles. Liverpool have won four and drawn one of the games in which Van Dijk and Isak have both started for their respective sides.

However, to say the Dutch international has had things his own way across those five games would only be telling half the story.

Isak has scored three and assisted one of the seven goals Newcastle have managed when facing Liverpool in that time. Only Arsenal’s Gabriel Martinelli and Brighton & Hove Albion’s Solly March (both five) have more combined goals and assists against Liverpool since the start of 2022-23 — with neither being centre-forwards aiming to lock horns with Liverpool’s centre-backs.

Put simply, Isak has caused Liverpool’s captain issues every time the pair have shared the same turf. So what can we expect on Sunday?


Given Isak has a tendency to drift to the left side of Newcastle’s attack, it may be that Liverpool’s Ibrahima Konate is the man who should be more aware of the 25-year-old’s threat.

Not including last season’s game, when Van Dijk was sent off — don’t worry, we’ll get to that — you can see Isak’s tendency to pull away from the Dutchman’s side in his early matches, before going toe-to-toe in his last two games against Liverpool.

There are not too many strikers who can match Van Dijk’s physical attributes in terms of pace, power, and height, and there are signs the 33-year-old plays slightly differently against Isak for that reason.

Van Dijk does not typically seek out defensive work for himself, but in each game they have played, there is a greater inclination to get touch-tight to Isak to nullify any threat before it really develops — whether that be close to his own penalty area or pushing high to follow Isak’s deeper runs.

With Isak pulling into those wider left channels in Newcastle’s attack, there are even occasions of Van Dijk being willing to drift out of position — running across his own centre-back — to follow the Sweden international rather than pass him onto a team-mate.

Such is the threat he offers that Isak has the ability to drag Van Dijk into areas he does not want to be in.

Liverpool’s captain sees it as something of an insult if he is ever asked to put the afterburners on and engage in a sprint, but he was forced to match Isak’s speed and pull across to the far touchline to engage during their most recent meeting at St James’ Park.

Not many centre-forwards go up against Van Dijk in a one-on-one battle and come out the other side with the ball at their feet, but Isak managed to pull ahead of the defender, which acted as a warning sign within the opening 15 minutes of December’s match.

Isak had clearly spooked Van Dijk with his movement and it was only 20 minutes later that he punished some uncharacteristically confused defending with an incredible finish.

Stationed between Liverpool’s centre-backs, Isak received a punched ball from Bruno Guimaraes with his left foot. Note that Newcastle’s No 14 is not in the eyeline of Van Dijk, forcing the Dutchman to swivel his body quickly when the pass is made — meaning there is a period when he is not looking at the man or ball as he looks to regain his orientation (see frame 2 below).

As the old football adage goes, when a striker can see the defender’s number, they know they have beaten them. Isak’s shot from distance is sublime, but the movement and speed of action are what turn Van Dijk inside out to create separation.

Playing on the last line is a particularly strong part of Isak’s game. He tends to start in an offside position before dropping back onside just as the opposition back line drops.

Much like an old-school No 9, Isak will place himself between the centre-backs to avoid being marked and attack the space in behind following a team-mate’s through ball. This can be seen from the two teams’ meeting in December…

… but it is a sequence that has proven lucrative for Isak against Liverpool’s back line.

In their game at Anfield last season, it was a similar sequence that featured Anthony Gordon cutting inside from the touchline before playing a purposeful slide pass behind the Liverpool defensive line. Isak barely needed to break stride as he ran between the centre-backs to finish beyond Alisson.

Earlier that season, it was an identical sequence that led to Van Dijk’s dismissal at St James’ Park. Gordon comes inside, Isak is placed between the centre-backs and a through ball enables Newcastle’s forward to race away.

If not for Van Dijk’s swipe at Isak in which he took man then ball, you would have likely seen another coolly taken finish from Isak. Had it been another, less-threatening Premier League striker, you could be confident Van Dijk would have simply ushered his man away from goal without making a challenge.

Newcastle’s injury and suspension issues mean Eddie Howe’s side will not be at full strength at Wembley — particularly down their left side — but they will provide a physical battle with their typical energy across the pitch.

Liverpool are the only ever-present Premier League side Howe has failed to beat in any competition since taking charge of Newcastle in November 2021, but any team with Isak has a fighting chance.

Crucially, if any striker could be named as Van Dijk’s kryptonite in recent years, it would be Isak.

(Top photo: Justin Setterfield/Getty Images)

Mirra Andreeva’s tennis rise looked inevitable. Then Conchita Martinez sped it up

INDIAN WELLS, Calif. — Conchita Martinez, one of the queen bees of tennis, had done just about everything there was to do in the sport.

She had won Wimbledon. She had coached Garbine Muguruza to win Wimbledon. She had won five Federation Cup titles as part of Spain’s women’s national team, going on to captain the team and then to run the entire tournament, by which time it was known as the Billie Jean King Cup. She found time to captain the men’s national team in the Davis Cup, too.

But last spring, a new type of opportunity arrived: molding a teenager with the chance to be a generational talent. Did she want to coach Mirra Andreeva, the Russian already making waves on the WTA Tour at 16?

Muguruza was in her early twenties when Martinez helped guide her to the Wimbledon title in 2017. There’s only so much a coach can do at that point. Coaching a teenager is a chance to help define their tennis for the better, perhaps forever. It’s also coaching a teenager … yikes!

Not really. A year later, Andreeva, 17, is the toast of tennis. She is the ascendant player on the WTA Tour, on a 10-match winning streak that brought her a debut WTA 1,000 title in Dubai, UAE, and took her into the top 10 of the rankings for the first time. Coco Gauff did not win one of those titles, one rung below a Grand Slam, until she was 19.

She has beaten all comers in that streak: Iga Swiatek, the world No. 2 and the dominant player in the sport the past three years, was demolished in Dubai. Andreeva beat Elena Rybakina there too, and when she played the 2022 Wimbledon champion again at Indian Wells on Tuesday night, it wasn’t even competitive. Andreeva produced a 6-1, 6-2 masterclass.

Thursday afternoon brought tighter competition against Elina Svitolina, a former world No. 2, but the same result: 7-5, 6-3 to the young Russian. Andreeva didn’t just win. She confused and beguiled an opponent 13 years her senior, moving Svitolina around the court, interspersing drop shots with power and angles in a way that teenagers rarely do. They are supposed to be one- or two-dimensional in their first years, and then develop an arsenal.

And then came Friday, a rematch with an extra-motivated Swiatek, still smarting from the loss last month in Dubai and trying to win a tournament for the first time since the French Open last year. She blasted her way into their semifinal with her usual brutal efficiency. Surely this was too tall a task for Andreeva, especially as she kept slipping behind in her service games, setting up moment after moment when Swiatek’s opponents so often crumble.

Andreeva did the opposite of that, in a flurry of those flat, cross-court and down-the-line backhands that Swiatek couldn’t touch. Or she hung in rallies until Swiatek’s impatience got the better of her and the former world No. 1 sent forehands wide and backhands into the net. Swiatek had inroads in nearly all of Andreeva’s service games, but she rarely took them to break points. Soon, she was swatting balls in anger and snapping at her coaches. Andreeva, cool and collected and courageous when it counted most, was marching into the final, having won fewer points and been under more pressure.

“I don’t know why I felt so much confidence,’ Andreeva said in her post-match news conference.

That may have something to do with the 52-year-old Spanish woman sitting in Andreeva’s box, often with a resting grin-face as she watches her latest charge. Andreeva said Wednesday that she was always smaller than her competition growing up — at 5ft 9in (175cm), she isn’t anymore — and that forced her to find ways to win without overwhelming power. She learned to use her legs, to counterpunch and to spin the ball in all directions. Those attributes propelled her during her breakout tournaments, the 2023 Madrid Open and the 2024 Australian Open, where she put top players to the sword and puzzled lost positions into winning ones.

Martinez, Andreeva said, has taken those skills to a different, more aggressive level. Now she uses her tricks on offense as well as defense.

“Conchita is helping me to not be defensive all the time, when I have a chance to step in and try to be aggressive and to go for my shots,” she said in her news conference after beating Svitolina. “It’s working pretty good.”

It is. In 2025, Andreeva is winning a lower proportion of return points than she did in 2024, according to data collated by Tennis Abstract. She’s making fewer of her first serves. But she is winning a higher proportion of points behind those serves — 69 percent vs. 64 — and her dominance ratio, which divides the percentage of return points won by the percentage of serve points lost, has increased from 1.14 to 1.22 despite her drop-off on return. She is dictating more than she is being dictated to.

Beyond the results, Martinez has evolved into an Obi-Wan Kenobi to Andreeva’s Luke Skywalker, but only sort of. Skywalker never really tried to prank Kenobi as Andreeva often does Martinez, including Wednesday afternoon, when her coach was attempting to have a quasi-serious conversation with a journalist.

Cue the goofy faces and poses about 15 feet behind said journalist, attempting to mess with Martinez’s game face. Mission accomplished. Then off went a giggling Andreeva, simultaneously embarrassed and thrilled to have one of the legends of the sport kvelling about her.

Oh, to be 17 and have it all happening for you, in ways that sometimes even Andreeva does not understand.

“I don’t know why people are supporting me this much because honestly, when I was playing in U.S., my results were not great,” she said in her post-match news conference after easing past Rybakina. Andreeva lost in the first round in her only previous appearance here last year and lost in the second round in her two U.S. Open appearances.

“People are so energetic,” she said. “It kind of lights me up.”

Once that happens, watch out. Here comes a drop shot on an angle, followed by a whistling topspin lob. Or another searing, flat backhand diving onto the knot of the singles sideline and shooting off the court. Or, and perhaps most often, there’s her forehand squash-shot slice, which converts a position of stress into one of control.

In Andreeva, Martinez has found a near perfect muse, a player who aspires to play with the creativity that Martinez had, with her own style of quiet determination and passion. Andreeva barely had a slice a year ago. Now, she can use it for defensive or offensive shots. Martinez wants her to develop a heavier forehand with more spin to make it more difficult for an opponent to get the ball back. She’s working with her to play around with different trajectories, “instead of just hitting flat from nowhere.”

She wants her to have choices and is trying to teach her how to make the good ones.

“She’s not making a lot of stupid decisions on the court,” Martinez said. “It’s about having the good choices, waiting for the right ball, to compete against any player.”


Mirra Andreeva has added attacking shots to her game in recent months. (Clive Brunskill / Getty Images)

Coach-player relationships can be overrated in tennis, a sport where there are few chances for a real tactical discussion and no timeouts. Plenty of players run through coaches like toilet paper, jettisoning them at the first patch of poor results.

There are some relationships, though, that evolve into so much more than discussions about forehands and backhands, serves and returns. Carlos Alcaraz has one of those with Juan Carlos Ferrero, Martinez’s compatriot and a former world No. 1. Ferrero has guided Alcaraz for seven years, since he was 14.

Andreeva and Martinez have some way to go to catch up with them, but they are off to a good start. They are living similar versions of the same life in different eras. Martinez was just 16 when she made the fourth round of the French Open, in her third professional tournament. The next year, she reached the quarterfinals at Roland Garros and finished the year as the world No. 7. She and her compatriot, Arantxa Sanchez Vicario, captured the imagination of the sport, a creative and passionate yin to the brutalist, machine-like yang of Steffi Graf.

Martinez knows what it’s like to be on the verge of the world discovering you, and then to make that leap from tennis being an exercise in what is fresh and fearless to a world of expectation. First, they ask, “How did you do that?” Then it becomes: “Why didn’t you do that?”

“Tennis forces you to grow up quickly but she maintains that playfulness in there, she likes to joke around,” she said. “I am very much like that too. I like to joke around. I like to bother her. She likes to bother me.”

Andreeva is a student of the game’s history. She passes evenings in bed watching old tennis matches on YouTube. She knew all about Conchita Martinez. During her first months on the tour, though, she didn’t realize that Martinez was the woman who kept smiling and nodding to her at various tournaments.

When she finally did, she couldn’t believe that Martinez knew who she was, or that she would take the time to be cordial to her. Then, after she split with her coach and Muguruza retired, Andreeva’s management team floated Martinez as a potential match.

Andreeva knew the resume. Wimbledon champion, coach of a Wimbledon champion. Good enough for her.

They had several talks to feel each other out, which was more Martinez taking the measure of this teenage girl born in Siberia, raised in Sochi, Russia, and who moved to the south of France to traipse the tennis world. She needed to make sure that Andreeva was ready to be serious, that she was hiring a coach and not a babysitter.

She quickly realized that Andreeva is mature beyond her years. She eats right, she rests, she listens to adults older and smarter than she is. She could look someone in the eye and have a serious conversation in three languages, soon to be a fourth as she picks up Spanish.

“She’s a sponge,” Martinez said.


Conchita Martinez has accelerated Andreeva’s rise to the top of tennis. (Robert Prange / Getty Images)

They tried a tournament together and Andreeva said she immediately felt comfortable with Martinez. “Super great,” is how she described their chemistry.

“She told me that it was the same for her, so thank God it’s not just me,” she said the other day in a news conference, with her trademark grin and twinkle in her eyes. “I completely trust her with everything. I think she knows everything that’s going on in my life. I don’t know if it’s good or bad, but, no, it’s just like this.”

When they first started, Martinez worried that Andreeva might not be enough of a teenager, rather than too much of one. On the practice courts in France or in Barcelona, where Martinez lives, Andreeva would hit 10 great shots in a row, miss on the 11th and drama would ensue.

Martinez told her to give herself a break, maybe focus on the 10 good ones instead of the last miss. And when she hit a great shot, she needed to learn to acknowledge it, to enjoy it and be proud of what she has accomplished.

“I always tell her, ‘Wow, amazing’,” she said. “You need to have fun with those things. Amazing drop shots, amazing angle. Wow, great, don’t take it for granted. Enjoy that.”

There has been plenty to enjoy lately. Andreeva’s ranking was hovering around 40 when Martinez came on the scene. She finished last year making the final of the Ningbo Open in China, where she lost against Daria Kasatkina from a winning position and broke down in tears at the trophy ceremony. Then she made the fourth round of the Australian Open, went 1-1 in Qatar and 6-0 in Dubai. Until very recently, she was the only teenager in the WTA top 100.

While the tennis world had long expected Andreeva’s ascendancy, the steepness and immediacy of this year’s trajectory has been a surprise. Not for Martinez. She couldn’t make much of an impact last year, because she started with Andreeva in the middle of the season, but the off-season let the Russian get the full Martinez treatment. They combined fitness and weight training with their goals to achieve a certain style of play.

Now comes the task of maintaining the work ethic that has lifted Andreeva to her lofty heights so quickly. People think getting to the top 10 is the hard part. It isn’t, Martinez said.

“It’s not getting there, it’s staying there — year after year, dealing with the pressure of defending those points and staying in a good frame of mind. And doing it all over and all over again,“ Martinez said.

She has shown few signs of doing anything else. Even after she got steamrollered in the second set against Swiatek, she told herself to run and fight for every point, to not worry how she got balls back but to get them back, however she could. When it was over, and Andreeva was 7-6(1), 1-6, 6-3 winner, Andreeva gave a nod to Martinez, a two-time finalist at Indian Wells, and a little ribbing, too.

“My coach lost in the finals,”  she said. “I’m going to try to do better than her.”

Nothing would please Martinez more.

(Top photo: Jay Calderon / The Desert Sun via Imagn Images)

NBA Awards Watch: Rookie of the Year race leaves a lot to be desired

We’re doing our NBA Awards Watch every Thursday until the end of the regular season, and each week we’ll emphasize a new award. This week, we’ve got Rookie of the Year.

Sandwiched between the class with Victor Wembanyama and the upcoming Cooper Flagg sweepstakes, this rookie class has been one we’ve known isn’t likely to deliver a future star or franchise-changer for a while. But there are still some good role players in the mix. That has made me wonder whether we’ve seen similar ROY races in the past. We’ll get into that below.

For the criteria I use for each award, check out our initial Awards Watch from this season. It explains how I, and a lot of the voting history, look at the six major individual awards. We’ll go heavy on Rookie of the Year here and give quick-hit thoughts for the other awards. All betting odds are courtesy of BetMGM.


Rookie of the Year

We haven’t had a lot of duds when it comes to the Rookie of the Year winners. By duds, I mean players who eventually ended up being mediocre or afterthought players in the NBA. Let’s take it back 40 years to 1985 when Michael Jordan won the award. In the last four decades, the worst Rookie of the Year winners are probably Chuck Person (1987), Mike Miller (2001), Tyreke Evans (2010), Michael Carter-Williams (2014) and Malcolm Brogdon (2017).

Person, however, had a 13-year career and put up 19.0 points per game in his first six seasons with Indiana. Miller had a 17-year career, averaged double-digit scoring, was named Sixth Man of the Year and won two titles with the Miami Heat. Evans had a historic start to his career, but eventually, foot and knee issues and a suspension for violating the antidrug program cut his career short. Carter-Williams was traded the year after winning Rookie of the Year, and we all knew his rookie numbers were inflated by the Trust the Process Sixers. He was quickly relegated to a supporting role and didn’t last in rotations very long after.

The example most akin to what we’re seeing in this 2024-25 rookie class is what happened with the Rookie of the Year campaign in 2016-17. That was the year a second-round pick ended up winning the award because a Philadelphia 76ers rookie simply didn’t play enough games to garner enough votes to justify taking home the trophy.

Do you see how we’re already starting to connect the dots? That was Joel Embiid’s third season in the NBA but first year on the court due to injuries. Embiid only played 31 games in that season, but he averaged 20.2 points, 7.8 rebounds, 2.1 assists and 2.5 blocks in just 25.4 minutes per game. It was the equivalent of averaging 28.7 points, 11.1 rebounds, 3.5 blocks and 3.0 assists if he played 36 minutes a night. That’s historic!

Embiid was the best rookie in the class, and it was a legitimate conversation of whether 31 games was enough to be named Rookie of the Year. Jaylen Brown and Jamal Murray were in that class, but they didn’t have significant rookie seasons. Embiid’s biggest competition was Dario Šarić, Brogdon and the concept of availability. Embiid finished third in ROY voting that season, garnering 23 of the 100 first-place votes and 177 of the 900 voting points.

Šarić received only 13 first-place votes but was on more ballots to give him 269 voting points. Brogdon ran away with the award with 64 first-place votes and 414 voting points. Brogdon was the 36th pick in the draft, and his numbers didn’t blow anybody away. He averaged 10.2 points, 4.2 assists and 2.8 rebounds in 26.4 minutes per game. He also was very efficient with 45.7/40.4/86.5 shooting splits, and he started 28 of the 75 games he played in for the Milwaukee Bucks. No offense to Brogdon, but it felt like he won by default — because he played, not because he played the best.

Fast-forward to this season, and we’ve got a similar thing happening. Jared McCain is not Embiid by any stretch, but he does look like he’s capable of being a great role player. McCain is by far the best rookie we’ve seen this season, but he’s played 23 games and is out for the season with a knee injury. He averaged 15.3 points in 25.3 minutes with a 58.9 true shooting percentage. No other rookie can really approach that level of production.

This year, once again, we might end up seeing a second-round pick take the award.

Two honorable mentions: Zaccharie Risacher, Atlanta Hawks | Kel’el Ware, Miami Heat

3. Zach Edey, Memphis Grizzlies (Last week: 3)

Edey has a pretty good case across the board for being the pick, although we’re not certain he’s even the best rookie on his own team. His numbers have been really good for most of the season. He’s averaging 9.2 points, 7.9 rebounds and 1.2 blocks in 20.9 minutes. And generally, the Grizzlies are good with him on the floor, so he’s not some rookie taking away from what a good team is trying to do. What hurts his case is he missed 15 games this season and probably needs to play at least half the game to truly get into the mix. He’s good, though. Edey has the fourth-best odds at +2200 behind Risacher (+2000).

2. Stephon Castle, San Antonio Spurs (Last week: 2)

Aside from McCain, I think Castle has shown the highest ceiling and peak during the rookie campaigns. He’s started about half the games he’s played in, and his production as a starter is really good. Castle averages 15.1 points and 4.2 assists in 29.7 minutes as a starter. Compare that with 12.1 points and 3.0 assists in 21.8 minutes coming off the bench. Castle might be peaking at the right time to take the award. Over his last 26 games, he’s averaging 17.5 points, 4.3 rebounds and 3.3 assists while making 46.8 percent of his shots in 26.7 minutes. Some of that has been boosted by Wemby being out for the season, but he’s also only started 10 of those games. The issue for Castle is twofold. 1. He wants to be a primary playmaker, and now he’s on a team with both Chris Paul and De’Aaron Fox, so he has to adjust. 2. Castle has struggled to make shots consistently this season. In the first 36 games of the season, Castle made just 38.3 percent from the field and 25.4 percent from 3.

In such a weak rookie class, Castle’s recent surge the last two months appears to be enough to take the award for a lot of voters. He’s the most recognizable name, and he has the best odds at -450 to win the award. He’s my favorite player from the class, but that doesn’t mean he should win.

1. Jaylen Wells, Memphis Grizzlies (Last week: 1)

I’m sticking with the consistency of Wells. At least for now. I’m open to Castle’s continuing his play in the final month of the campaign and ending up with the award. However, Wells deserves to get credit for remaining steady.

His numbers aren’t going to blow you away. He’s averaging 11.0 points, 3.3 rebounds and 1.7 assists. He plays 26.1 minutes per game and has started 60 of the 65 games he’s played in. Wells has been a fixture in the lineup for a really good team (something we’ll get back to in a minute). Wells is holding the second-best odds at +1000 to win Rookie of the Year and was the favorite a couple of weeks ago.

Wells’ game is less about production and more about maintaining impact on both ends. Edey does something similar for the Grizzlies, as does anybody coach Taylor Jenkins is asked to plug and play. Wells is seeing a bad shooting month, and it’s coming at the same time as Castle’s rise. If your argument is that Wells hasn’t been good enough to stave off a run like Castle’s, I don’t necessarily fault it. That kind of stuff happens in a rough rookie class without any true remarkable (healthy) candidates. But at least for now, I’m valuing the consistency of Wells, and with all things relatively equal at this point, I do believe his contributing to the better team gives him the slight edge over Castle. We’ll see whether that holds.


Most Valuable Player

5 honorable mentions: Steph Curry, Golden State Warriors | Jalen Brunson, New York Knicks | Anthony Edwards, Minnesota Timberwolves | Jayson Tatum, Boston Celtics | Alperen Şengün, Houston Rockets

5. Giannis Antetokounmpo, Milwaukee Bucks (Last week: 4)

Quick-hitter: The toughest decision for me right now is trying to decide whether Giannis or Tatum belongs here. I have been leaning toward there’s no way you can leave Tatum off the ballot, and it still might go that way in a month when it’s time to vote. As of right now, Antetokounmpo’s numbers and the necessity of his being on the court for the Bucks to be good are ahead of Tatum. But I don’t feel great about it. Ultimately, Tatum’s team success combined with his play will probably win out.

4. Donovan Mitchell, Cleveland Cavaliers (Last week: 3)

Quick-hitter: I do not see how Mitchell can be left off any ballots. He’s averaging 24-4-4 with 58.5 percent true shooting, and he’s on a historically great team. It’s mostly due to his being willing to sacrifice his own personal numbers and ego for the greater good of the team that made the Cavs greater now and should hopefully set them up for playoff success they couldn’t previously attain. That’s value and leadership.

3. LeBron James, LA Lakers (Last week: honorable mention)

Quick-hitter: This groin injury might end up removing James from the final ballot if he ends up missing more than the one to two weeks he’s expected to be out. We know he’s been great all season long on offense, but the uptick in his defensive performance is what brings him back into this MVP balloting for me. James had been a pretty bad defender the previous few seasons, and so often we’d see a wide-open dunk in the lane when the weakside help should have come from James. We’ve seen an uptick this season in his defense, but especially since the Luka Dončić acquisition. James has more energy to put toward that end of the floor, and it shows.

2. Nikola Jokić, Denver Nuggets (Last week: 2)

Quick-hitter: Check out these bars from Marcus Thompson II:

Jokić has so normalized ridiculousness as to desensitize the present community from appropriate reverence. He’ll need six MVPs and 10 championships and a five-minute highlight reel of epic moments to help those who didn’t experience him to process his elitism.

You should absolutely read Marcus talking about Big Honey here. We’ll have more about Jokić next week when we dive back fully into MVP, a month after our initial check-in.

1. Shai Gilgeous-Alexander, Oklahoma City Thunder (Last week: 1)

Quick-hitter: Something that is bothering me about fans who want to be dismissive of what Gilgeous-Alexander does is that they’re likening him to the “foul merchanting” James Harden became so infamous for. I’m not sure I can get there in terms of the logic and the reasoning for it. Gilgeous-Alexander goes about his foul-drawing in a much different way. For the most part, he drives to the hoop way more than Harden typically did. Gilgeous-Alexander has learned how to be physical on his drives, and it either creates a shot for him or creates contact that leads to fouls. The refs call it for him, but it’s not the same as Harden’s constantly flailing or bringing his arms under the hand of the defender.

This race is still completely neck and neck, and I’m excited to get into it next week.


Shai Gilgeous-Alexander and Donovan Mitchell lead two of the better teams in the NBA. (Jason Miller / Getty Images)

Defensive Player of the Year

Two honorable mentions: Jaren Jackson Jr., Memphis Grizzlies | Draymond Green, Golden State Warriors

3. Lu Dort, Oklahoma City Thunder (Last week: honorable mention)

Quick-hitter: The Thunder have the best defense in the league, by far, and with Jackson injured, it felt right to bring Dort into the mix. He’s one of the best defensive players in the league, and he should definitely be first-team All-Defense. Dort is a monster on that end.

2. Dyson Daniels, Atlanta Hawks (Last week: 2)

Quick-hitter: Daniels is averaging 3.0 steals, and no player has done that since Alvin Robertson in 1990-91. He already has 184 steals on the season. No player has reached that total since Ricky Rubio in 2013-14, when he had 191 steals. Rubio played all 82 games that season. Daniels has played 61 games and still has 16 left.

1. Evan Mobley, Cleveland Cavaliers (Last week: 1)

Quick-hitter: He’s still not the big favorite, at least not what we were seeing with Victor Wembanyama versus the field. Mobley is -250 to win with Daniels (+450) as his closest competition. That’s close to the same distance in the odds as SGA (-425) and Jokić (+300). I just can’t imagine anybody making a big enough push to unseat Mobley, as long as he stays healthy.


Sixth Man of the Year

Two honorable mentions: Naz Reid, Minnesota Timberwolves | Ty Jerome, Cleveland Cavaliers

3. De’Andre Hunter, Cleveland Cavaliers (Last week: honorable mention)

Quick-hitter: Since joining the Cavaliers, Hunter’s scoring average has gone from 19.0 a game with the Hawks to 14.3 in Cleveland. However, the efficiency is through the roof. It was already great with a 61.6 percent true shooting in Atlanta. Now he’s hitting half of his shots and half of his 3-pointers, and we’re seeing a 68.9 percent true shooting in Cleveland.

2. Malik Beasley, Detroit Pistons (Last week: 2)

Quick-hitter: If Beasley doesn’t miss another game this season, he’s going to end up having played 80 games. If he keeps this pace up with shooting 3-pointers, he’ll finish with 313 made 3-pointers. Only Stephen Curry (five times) and James Harden (once) have made more in a season.

1. Payton Pritchard, Boston Celtics (Last week: 1)

Quick-hitter: He’s averaging 14.2 points per game with 64.5 percent true shooting. The Celtics are better when he’s on the floor, and his usage rate is below 20 percent. That means he’s just hyperefficient in how he affects the game with his scoring. There were times I tried to talk myself into Beasley over him, but it’s Pritchard’s to win.


The Celtics are a better team with Payton Pritchard on the floor. (Brian Fluharty / Getty Images)

Coach of the Year

Two honorable mentions: Taylor Jenkins, Memphis Grizzlies | JJ Redick, LA Lakers

3. Mark Daigneault, Oklahoma City Thunder (Last week: honorable mention)

Quick-hitter: I know this team was great last season and the No. 1 seed, so we dismiss some of what’s happening with the success of the Thunder. However, we shouldn’t dismiss the fact they have the highest margin of victory in league history. Nobody has ever been this dominant. They lost a little recently, and they still hold this mark over the 1971-72 Lakers. I doubt Daigneault will finish in the top three in voting, but we shouldn’t ignore him.

2. J.B. Bickerstaff, Detroit Pistons (Last week: 1)

Quick-hitter: It’s kind of jarring to see the Pistons house the Washington Wizards on Tuesday night and think about where these two teams were a year ago. I mean … the Wizards were in the same place and on their way to the worst season in franchise history, something they can tie if they only win two more games or set if they win fewer than two more games. The Pistons were a complete joke, too. But this year, they are fighting for home-court advantage in the first round. They aren’t in the top six in the Eastern Conference by default. They’ve earned it. That’s mostly Bickerstaff’s coaching them properly.

1. Kenny Atkinson, Cleveland Cavaliers (Last week: 2)

Quick-hitter: An impressive outpouring of Cavs fans did not read what I wrote last week and just reacted to the ranking. With that I say, thank you for clicking! But Atkinson is back in the lead position in a tight race because the Cavs keep winning. So do the Pistons, but not like this. The Cavs became the sixth team in league history to have two 15-game win streaks in the same season, and they might win 70 games. They’re on pace to get to 69 wins, and this streak doesn’t even end when Mitchell sits.


Most Improved Player

Two honorable mentions: Dyson Daniels, Atlanta Hawks | Payton Pritchard, Boston Celtics

3. Ty Jerome, Cleveland Cavaliers (Last week: unmentioned)

Quick-hitter: Jerome went from a fringe role player, bouncing around a couple of teams in his first few seasons, to being integral on the best team in the NBA. He has become indispensable for Cleveland. That’s remarkable improvement, even though he has no chance of winning this award.

2. Cade Cunningham, Detroit Pistons (Last week: 2)

Quick-hitter: Cunningham is the favorite (-275), and I might end up voting for him by season’s end. He has made solid improvements across the board while becoming much more serious about defense and applying all of this to winning. He has a great case. I just feel like we saw a lot of the skill improvements last season.

1. Evan Mobley, Cleveland Cavaliers (Last week: 1)

Quick-hitter: Mobley probably has no chance of winning this, but I do think he’s shown the most improvement. He’s +8000 to win the award, putting him behind Cunningham, Daniels, the Denver Nuggets’ Christian Braun and the Miami Heat’s Tyler Herro on BetMGM. But look at Mobley last year, and look at him this year. The Cavs weren’t running offense through him like this, and he wasn’t defending like this. He’s shown the highest level of improvement to me.

(Illustration: Demetrius Robinson / The Athletic; photos: Matt Slocum / AP; Michael Reaves, Nathaniel S. Butler / NBAE via Getty Images; David Gonzales / Imagn Images)

Inside the women’s hockey powerhouse led by ‘Miracle on Ice’ legend Mark Johnson

MADISON, Wis. — Three hours before the Wisconsin Badgers were set to practice on a Tuesday afternoon in late January, the best coach in the history of women’s college hockey was telling a story about a deer.

“I’d like to get in the mindset of a deer,” Mark Johnson said during a coaches meeting inside the team offices at LaBahn Arena.

He talked for several minutes, trying to empathize with the deer that had jumped in front of his car — and then ran off — while Johnson was driving home from the rink a few days prior. He couldn’t quite figure out why the deer did what it did.

Johnson, 67, is always trying to see things from another perspective, whether it’s a deer on the road or the people around him.

“We’ve got these hockey players and we’re trying to figure them out,” he said.

That goal — trying to understand his players’ mindset — never leaves the foreground for Johnson and his coaching staff.

On that Tuesday, coming off a 2-2 tie against St. Cloud State — one of only three games the Badgers failed to win in regulation all season — Johnson decided not to break down video with the team. “Look ahead,” he urged them. The coaching staff planned drills with their next opponent, the University of Minnesota Duluth, in mind. And knowing it had been a long season with the most important hockey still to come, Johnson said the team would play several mini-games to end practice on a fun — yet competitive — note.

“He wants to make (practice) the best part of their day,” said Dan Koch, an associate coach at the University of Wisconsin. “If coming to the rink feels like work, or they’re getting bored, we’re not going to get anything out of it. … He has a great feel for (what the players need).”

It’s just one of the trademarks of a coach who has built one of the greatest women’s hockey programs the sport has ever seen.

In 22 years as head coach of the Badgers, Johnson has become the winningest coach in NCAA Division I women’s hockey history and the only coach to eclipse 600 wins. No program has won more than Wisconsin’s seven national championships, all celebrated with Johnson behind the bench.

And this year’s roster is one of the deepest and most skilled in the program’s history, with four players nominated for the 2025 Patty Kazmaier Award, given to the best women’s hockey player in the nation. The Badgers lost only one game in regulation this season — against the reigning champion Ohio State Buckeyes — and are coming off another WCHA conference title with a 4-3 win over the Minnesota Golden Gophers.

Now, the Badgers enter the NCAA Tournament, which begins on Thursday afternoon, as the No. 1 team in the nation — and the favorite to win another national title. Can they deliver on expectations?


The program’s rise to dominance begins with Johnson.

The son of legendary coach “Badger Bob” Johnson — who built the Wisconsin men’s hockey program and led the Pittsburgh Penguins to their first Stanley Cup — Mark grew up in Madison and is one of the all-time greatest players to ever suit up for the Badgers.

He’s well known for winning a gold medal at the 1980 Olympics and scoring two goals in the “Miracle on Ice” semifinal game against the Soviet Union. He went on to play 11 seasons in the NHL before retiring in 1992. By 1996, after a few high school coaching stints, Johnson was back in Madison as an assistant coach for the Badgers.

After six years, the head coaching job opened up. Johnson applied, but the job went to one of his former teammates, Mike Eaves, instead. Johnson had a decision to make: He could continue as an assistant for one of his friends, or he could return to the NHL to work as an assistant in the top professional league.

“I had kids at the time, and had been traded a few times in the NHL,” he said. “I didn’t want to go back to that lifestyle if I had a choice.”

As it turned out, there was an opening for the upstart Wisconsin women’s hockey program that had just played its first season in 1999. At the time, the job was considered something of a risk. If Johnson left the men’s game, would he be able to cross back over?

Johnson’s desire to keep his family in Madison and run his own program won out; he was named head coach of the women’s hockey team ahead of the 2002-03 season.

“It was this leap of faith,” he said. “Like, I’m going to take this jump and I don’t know where I’m going to land.”

At an introductory news conference, Johnson laid out his vision for the program and promised to provide stability for a team that had gone through two coaches in its first three seasons. Skeptics didn’t believe that a legendary men’s player would stick in the women’s game; they assumed Johnson would jump at the first job at a men’s program or an NHL team.

Only a few months into the job, Colorado Avalanche coach Tony Granato offered Johnson a position as an assistant, which he declined. There have been other opportunities over the years, too, but since 2002, Johnson has been all in.

Over the first few years, Johnson mostly laid the foundation of the program. He established a team-first culture and a strong, relatively simple on-ice identity.

“He’s a teacher of the game,” said Koch. “He’s somebody that feels if you can skate, pass, shoot, stick handle better than the other team, your percentages of winning are going to go up.”


Laila Edwards, who became the first Black woman to play for the U.S. women’s national team at a world championship in April 2024, said head coach Mark Johnson is “hands off, but not too hands off to a point where we’re a mess.” (Ashley Landis / AP Photo)

Johnson continued recruiting and developing the talent he had inherited, such as future Canadian Olympic defender Carla MacLeod, U.S. Olympian Molly Engstrom and Meghan Hunter, who is now an assistant GM of the Chicago Blackhawks. He also challenged the school’s administration to move the team from a community rink in the suburbs to the Kohl Center — home of the men’s hockey team — until LaBahn Arena opened in 2012.

“He just came in and provided stability,” said assistant coach Jackie Crum. “You had this startup program and this legendary Badger came in, everyone respected him, he knows hockey, and his style of coaching just fits for a female hockey player.

“He’s not a yeller, he’s not a screamer. He’s not a swearer. He’s not berating. You watch those inside the NHL documentaries and they’re all ‘bleeps’ and ‘bleeps’ and that’s not him. Nor do I think that would work for 18- to 22-year-old females.”

The Badgers made their first NCAA tournament appearance in Johnson’s third season (2004-05), and won back-to-back national titles in 2006 and 2007 — the first DI program not in the state of Minnesota to win an NCAA women’s hockey championship.

Wisconsin quickly became a destination for elite hockey players, including future Hockey Hall of Fame inductees Meghan Duggan, Hilary Knight and Brianna Decker, who all won championships with the Badgers. It helps the Badgers that so many influential alumni have passed through the halls. Young players who look up to Knight or Duggan might want to chart the same path that leads through Madison.

But if you ask the players, it all goes back to the head coach.

“(Mark has) built that program to where it is,” said Knight. “It’s a dynasty.”


If you get to a Badgers women’s hockey game an hour before puck drop, you’re already late. At least if you want one of the best seats in the house.

At LaBahn — with general admission seating — the die-hard fans arrive hours in advance to secure their favorite spot.

“Sometimes they get here before I do,” said Edwards.

After games, when players go to see their friends or family, they’ll mingle with the fans who are waiting in the concourse.

“It’s the most special thing,” said captain Casey O’Brien. “It gives you something more to play for. You want to do well for them because they invest so much in us and we kind of want to pay it back.”

The Badgers have averaged the top attendance in NCAA women’s hockey this season with around 3,500 fans per game — including a massively attended double-header with the men’s team at Wrigley Field in January. Outside of the University of Minnesota, no other program’s fan base is close.

Wisconsin has hosted the six most-attended women’s college hockey games ever, including a record 15,359 at a “Fill the Bowl” game hosted at the Kohl Center in 2017.

The fan base is just one part of the Wisconsin experience. The $34 million LaBahn Arena was built to provide professional-level facilities for its sports teams. And when it was built in 2012, it was only the second women’s hockey specific rink built in the country after Ridder Arena in Minnesota.

The Wisconsin women’s hockey facility has a big locker room, training facilities, therapy pools — hot tub, cold tub and sauna — and a team lounge, which serves as a central spot for players to hang out between class and practices. Lately, the team has gotten into watching “Deal or No Deal.”

“I don’t know why, but game shows are always on,” said O’Brien. “And we get way too into it.”

At Wisconsin, the resources match what can be expected for a Big Ten sports school that has a self-sufficient athletic department, which means it funds its operation through its own revenue rather than relying on university money. This season, the athletics budget was set at over $170 million, a record high for the department.

LaBahn is adjacent to the Kohl Center, which recently underwent around $48 million in renovations. The two buildings are connected through a series of hallways, which give players direct access to more shared facilities with the men’s hockey, basketball and volleyball teams, such as study rooms, cafeterias and a brand-new 10,000 square-foot gym.

“The facilities are second to none here,” said defender Caroline Harvey.

And then there’s the appeal of playing for a highly decorated coach whose style extends beyond his even-tempered demeanor. Wisconsin does well to recruit elite players, and Johnson allows them to shine on the ice.

“He’s hands off, but not too hands off to a point where we’re a mess,” said Edwards. “His job, as he’s taken it on, is giving us the systems, trust and confidence and just letting us go out and play.”

That coaching style has worked well for the 2024-25 Badgers roster that is full of talent up and down the lineup.

“It plays a lot into our playing style,” said Harvey. “If he was more rigid, we’d probably be holding our sticks too tight. … You’re able to expand and grow and try new things here, and you’re not punished for that or any (mistakes).”

Naturally, none of the 2024-25 Badgers were alive when Johnson was scoring big goals on the international stage. But it helps that his players know Johnson has “been there and done that” at every level. That Crum was in their shoes, playing for Johnson’s Badgers, helps players too, giving them an older sister figure who knows exactly what they’re going through. Not to mention, the trio of Crum, Koch and Johnson are in their 15th year coaching the program together.

“Everything that happens with the team, we’ve been there, we’ve done it,” said Crum. “We’ve been around the block. I know where they go on a Friday night because I was there once too.”


Edwards and Harvey were freshmen the first time they experienced winning at Wisconsin in 2023. Last season, the Badgers lost 1-0 to Ohio State in the championship game.

“We want to win it all,” said Harvey, now a junior. “We don’t want to be in the same position we were last year.”

The 2024-25 Badgers are the tournament favorites. They are four lines deep, with great defenders and solid goaltending. Five players have been named to the U.S. national team for the upcoming women’s world championships. And on Wednesday, three players (O’Brien, Harvey and Edwards) were announced as the finalists for the Patty Kazmaier.


Mark Johnson, famous for his role in the “Miracle on Ice,” could win his eighth national championship with the Badgers this month. Last year, Wisconsin lost to the Ohio State Buckeyes 1-0 in the championship game. (Mark Stewart / Milwaukee Journal Sentinel / USA Today Network)

O’Brien, Edwards, Kirsten Simms and Harvey are four of the top five scorers in the NCAA. The last time the Badgers dominated the rankings like this was the 2010-11 national championship team with Duggan, Decker and Knight going 1-2-3 in scoring.

Still, Knight calls this current roster a “super team.” And coaches will agree.

“Going off of the skill, it’s probably the deepest we’ve ever been,” said Crum.

O’Brien in particular is putting together a masterful season in her final year on campus. She has scored a nation-leading 83 points in only 38 games and is the favorite to win the Patty Kazmaier Award. Last week, she had three points in the conference championship and was named player of the tournament. She also became the all-time leading scorer in Badgers hockey history (men’s or women’s) with her 269 career points.

“She’s been good for us for a long time,” said Johnson after the WCHA Final, calling her “the best player in college hockey this year by far.”

With so much talent, the expectation for the Badgers, like most years, is to win. But Ohio State is ranked No. 2 and is building its own dynasty under head coach Nadine Muzerall, who has won two national titles in the last three years. No. 4-ranked Minnesota will have home-ice advantage as tournament host.

Some veterans on this year’s Badgers, such as Edwards and Harvey, have experienced the highs and lows of winning and losing in the final game. Others, such as O’Brien, are trying to win a third championship. And sophomores, such as Cassie Hall or Kelly Gorbatenko, will try to erase the sting of a loss.

“They’re on a mission,” said Johnson.

If the team wins, it will be Johnson’s eighth national championship and his fourth in six seasons. He said he’s still motivated by the challenge of building and coaching winning rosters, especially this year.

“The team is talented, it’s deep, but how do you keep them hungry? How do you keep them motivated?” he wondered. “Those types of challenges are why I get up and enjoy coming to the rink.”

There will come a time when Johnson won’t be at the rink to run a practice or stand behind the bench. He doesn’t know exactly when he’ll retire, but he has been considering what the next chapter of his life might look like.

Johnson and his wife, Leslie, are planning to open a therapeutic horse ranch in Verona, a suburb of Madison. The couple, who have been married for over 40 years, hope it can be a place of healing for children and families.

For now though, Johnson’s focus is on the path to winning another national championship. As the No. 1 seed, the Badgers won’t play on the opening day of the tournament on Thursday, but will await their Saturday afternoon opponent for the regional final.

With a win — against the winner of Clarkson vs. Boston University — the Badgers will head to their third straight Frozen Four, which begins March 21 in Minneapolis.

“We definitely have the group to win,” said Edwards. “But it doesn’t mean we’re going to. There’s still work to be done.”

(Illustration: Dan Goldfarb / The Athletic; Gil Talbot / NCAA Photos / Getty, Dave Kallmann / Milwaukee Journal Sentinel / USA Today Network via Imagn Images)

Bidding on Paul Skenes MLB Debut Patch card nears his 2025 salary

An 11-year-old boy from Los Angeles who pulled the Paul Skenes MLB Debut Patch card will likely sell it for more money than Skenes will make from his 2025 base salary with the Pittsburgh Pirates.

With 56 bids as of Wednesday night, the gem-mint PSA 10 graded autographed one-of-one rookie card bearing the patch Skenes wore on his jersey sleeve during his Major League debut has a high bid of $550,000 as of this writing. That would mean with the auction house’s buyer’s premium (to be donated to the Los Angeles Fire Department and Red Cross), the new owner of the card would have to pony up $660,000 for one of the most hyped cards in the hobby.

And there’s still ample time for more bids, as the auction for the card on Fanatics Collect ends March 20.

At some point, Skenes could make $44 million per season if he continues his current trajectory. For now, though, the Pittsburgh Pirates All-Star pitcher will make a base salary of $800,000 this season, via Spotrac.

The Skenes MLB Debut Patch card already carries a price tag more than four times higher than the most expensive sale of one of his other cards. The previously high mark was set by the pitcher’s one-of-a-kind 2023 Bowman Draft Chrome Prospect autographed Superfractor card (PSA 7 card grade, 10 auto grade), which sold for $123,200 through Goldin Auctions last September.

Since the beginning of 2024, there have been 29 sales of individual cards for at least $500,000 documented by Card Ladder’s database. Only six cards in that period have sold publicly for more than where the Skenes card stands as of Wednesday morning:

  • $1.37 million: 1916 M101-4 Sporting News Babe Ruth blank back rookie PSA 7 grade (Heritage)
  • $1.2 million: 2003-04 Upper Deck Exquisite Collection LeBron James rookie patch autograph numbered 18 of 23; Beckett 8.5 card grade, 10 auto grade (Goldin)
  • $1.0 million: 1955 Topps Roberto Clemente PSA 9 (Heritage)
  • $860,100: 2023-24 Panini Prizm Victor Wembanyama Nebula Choice Prizm, numbered 1 of 1, PSA 9 (Goldin)
  • $701,500: 1997 Skybox E-X 2001 Allen Iverson Essential Credentials Now, numbered 2 of 3, PSA 5 (Heritage)
  • $579,500: 1997-98 SkyBox E-X 2001 Kobe Bryant Essential Credentials Now, numbered 1 of 8, Beckett 9 (Goldin)

(Shohei Ohtani’s record card sale came in November, when his 2018 Bowman Chrome Rookie Autographs Orange Refractor numbered to 25 in a Pristine BGS 10 grade sold for $533,140.)

The Skenes MLB Debut Patch card will push the $500,000 card tally one tick higher when the auction ends next week. But how high will this card ultimately go? Here are some guesses from The Athletic’s staff:

Larry Holder

I’ve been on record saying this card could reach the $1 million price tag. Is that too low given we’re more than halfway there already? What makes me believe this could be the case is what Nick Bell, CEO of Fanatics Collect and Fanatics Live, told me just before the auction for the card opened:

“I can tell you obviously we get a lot of inbound from this, and the inbound that we’ve received for this card is not only from big collectors who typically kind of circle this sort of card, but also from a bunch of non-collectors who are really interested in this card for their first kind of major acquisition in the space.”

The interest from the non-traditional crowd could make this card more unique than the top dollar Honus Wagner or Mickey Mantle cards. Those cards may sell for more, but there’s only one Skenes Debut Patch card and the hype surrounding it may be unmatched for a modern card.

So I’m still bullish on a seven-figure sale. I’ll guess $1.1 million will be the final bid.

Caleb Mezzy

When the Skenes MLB Debut Patch landed in the hands of an 11-year-old kid who declined the offers from everyone from the Pirates and Livvy Dunne to Ken Goldin, I predicted a wholesome $2 million.

Here’s why: First, there has been a chase spurred by the Pirates’ bounty offer that Willy Wonka would applaud. Then there’s Skenes himself, who is arguably the most generational pitching talent since Stephen Strasburg, when the sports card industry was much smaller. His talent and timing are the next ingredient.

Skenes also had an interesting path coming from a college baseball powerhouse in LSU, where he transferred in as a catcher with the Air Force. His story, 100-plus MPH fastball, NL Rookie of the Year season, and All-Star game start, are another element. Then there’s the story of the 11-year old kid who pulled the card and was kept anonymous by Topps to protect his privacy.

But possibly the biggest element in this is Paul Skenes’ famous girlfriend. If he’s the face of Debut Patches, she’s the face of NIL for the NCAA. Her celebrity status has brought attention to their relationship and this card, helping to draw in eyeballs and likely bids.

Dan Uthman

Skenes has the look of a generational pitcher, and he could get even better than he’s shown in his professional career. But we’re talking about a lot of money at a time when some financial portfolios have taken a hit. I see the ceiling as $1.5 million.

Craig Custance

There’s just so much buzz about this card that I think it blows well past $1 million and ends at $1.7 million. But we’re still talking about a pitcher, which generally isn’t a premium position in collecting so I’m not ready to push it over $2 million.

Brooks Peck

I have to admit that I didn’t think that bidding on the card would be this high already, but it’s become clear that the interest in this card has transcended the usual collector circles thanks to all those factors Caleb laid out above. But how high can those elements push the bidding? Narrative aside, it’s hard to justify a seven-figure value on the card. Pitchers generally aren’t as valued as hitters in the hobby and they also carry a significant risk for long-term injury. While the MLB Debut Patch cards are incredibly unique items that are just starting to find their footing in the space, no other Debut Patch card has sold anywhere close to where the Skenes card is already at. But with all that said, you can no longer divorce the narrative from the card. It has probably become the most widely recognized and pop-culture relevant baseball card of the last 25-30 years. For that reason, I now think it’ll go over $1 million, but $2 million still seems like a bridge too far. So I’ll say it lands around $1.4 million.

The Athletic maintains full editorial independence in all our coverage. When you click or make purchases through our links, we may earn a commission.

(Top photo: Joe Sargent/MLB Photos via Getty Images)

In Sam Darnold, Seahawks got a younger, cheaper QB. It won’t matter unless they support him

The Seattle Seahawks have their Geno Smith replacement in Sam Darnold. Now they need to get him some help.

Seattle’s agreement with Darnold is a three-year, $100.5 million contract with $55 million guaranteed, according to The Athletic’s Dianna Russini.

On paper, it’s essentially the same deal Baker Mayfield signed with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers last offseason after a resurgent 2023 season. When accounting for the rise in the salary cap since then, however, Darnold’s deal looks more like an updated version of the three-year, $75 million contract Smith signed in March 2023 after his breakout season in 2022.

By average annual salary, Darnold’s contract is one of the lowest among veteran starting quarterbacks. Justin Fields’ two-year, $40 million contract with the New York Jets — also agreed to on Monday — is currently the lowest. The rankings could change depending on what happens with Aaron Rodgers and Russell Wilson.

But regardless, the Seahawks are acquiring Darnold for a bargain relative to the rest of the veteran quarterback market, and probably for $7 million to $12 million less per year than Smith’s expected extension with the Raiders.

Seattle is banking on getting the best version of Darnold, who before last season had just one season in which he threw for more than 3,000 yards and completed at least 60 percent of his passes (2019 with the Jets). At his best, Darnold is an athletic, strong-armed quarterback who can make big-time throws. There’s a reason he had the sixth-highest touchdown rate in the league at 6.4 percent, just a few points behind Joe Burrow (6.6) and well above the league average of 4.8 percent (all stats provided by TruMedia) in 2024.

Seattle saw some of Darnold’s best work up close in Minnesota’s Week 16 win at Lumen Field.

The Vikings were able to get that version of Darnold last season by giving him a capable offensive line — albeit one that struggled late in the year — a very good scheme that was heavy on play-action dropbacks, and one of the best wide receiver tandems in the league. But acquiring a younger, cheaper option at quarterback won’t matter if the Seahawks can’t give him that same level of support, starting with the offensive line.



Seattle is expected to sign former Ravens offensive lineman Josh Jones on a one-year deal worth up to $4.75 million, according to a report Monday from Ian Rapoport of NFL Network. Jones has started multiple games at guard and tackle since entering the league as a third-round pick of the Cardinals in 2020. He’s likely to be a do-it-all depth piece on the line and perhaps a replacement for swing tackle George Fant, who was released as a cap-saving measure last week.

Seattle should still actively search for more bodies up front. The first day of free agency wasn’t a busy one for veteran centers, but a couple of the best options came off the board. The Chicago Bears agreed to terms with The Athletic’s top-ranked center, Drew Dalman, on a three-year, $42 million contract that makes him the second-highest-paid center by average annual salary. Chicago entered this offseason with the same interior offensive line needs as Seattle, and the price the team paid to protect quarterback Caleb Williams speaks to how expensive it can be to upgrade the front line.

Chicago traded a 2026 fourth-round pick to Kansas City for All-Pro guard Joe Thuney, who has a 2025 base salary of $15.5 million but is due for a contract extension ahead of his age-33 season. The Bears also traded a 2025 sixth-round pick to the Rams for 28-year-old guard Jonah Jackson, who is due $17.5 million this season.

Seattle general manager John Schneider has expressed apprehension about making those sorts of commitments. He has made exceptions in the past, such as the three-year, $22.5 million deal he signed 30-year-old Gabe Jackson to after trading a fifth-round pick in 2021. The move appeased quarterback Russell Wilson, who publicly complained about his pass protection, but it was a deviation from Schneider’s typical player acquisition strategy. Jackson was useful for only the first year of the deal.

All of this ties into why the Seahawks were mostly dormant on the first day of the negotiating period. Schneider wants to take calculated risks in free agency, but that can be tough to do when Seattle is one of many teams needing interior offensive upgrades.

One of those other needy teams is Minnesota, which agreed to terms with center Ryan Kelly, The Athletic’s third-ranked center, on a two-year, $18 million contract ($9 million guaranteed). This Seahawks free-agency plan listed Kelly as a fallback option in the event the Seahawks couldn’t land Josh Myers, The Athletic’s second-ranked center. At this point in free agency, a Myers signing would be Seattle’s best path to upgrading the center spot, which is critical in Klint Kubiak’s offense.

The beginning of free agency was a good one for guards, and the next few days might produce more of the same. The following deals were agreed to on Monday, according to multiple reports:

  • Aaron Banks, Green Bay Packers — four years, $77 million
  • Patrick Mekari, Jacksonville Jaguars — three years, $37.5 million
  • James Daniels, Miami Dolphins — three years, $24 million
  • Ben Bredeson, Tampa Bay Buccaneers — three years, $22 million
  • Evan Brown, Arizona Cardinals — two years, $11.5 million

There are still multiple players available from The Athletic’s top 150 rankings, including the top-ranked guard, Will Fries, No. 14 on the list. The others are Mekhi Becton (No. 26), Teven Jenkins (No. 33), Brandon Scherff (No. 51), Kevin Zeitler (No. 58), Will Hernandez (No. 79), Shaq Mason (No. 115) and Dalton Risner (No. 147).

The structure of Darnold’s deal will reveal more about Seattle’s available cap space, but the team hasn’t otherwise made much of a dent with its other signings. Linebacker Ernest Jones IV and defensive tackle Jarran Reed have Year 1 cap hits of $5.2 and $5 million, respectively, according to Over the Cap. Seattle has the cap room to add multiple impact players up front on the second day of free agency.

If Banks’ deal is any indication, Fries is due for a major payday, although the broken leg that ended his 2024 season could limit his market somewhat. Seattle might have to sweeten its proposal with more years, guaranteed money or both to pry him away from another guard-needy team, such as Minnesota. (Update: Fries agreed to a five-year, $88 million deal with Minnesota on Tuesday, a league source told The Athletic’s Dianna Russini.)

Scherff or Zeitler would be nice backup plans who make the Seahawks better, but since they’re 33 and 35, those two former Pro Bowlers would obviously be temporary solutions.

Seattle needs to be active in the wide receiver market, too, but the offensive line should be the priority. Once that is settled, Seattle can pursue receivers such as Demarcus Robinson, Marquez Valdes-Scantling or even Cooper Kupp, who is expected to be released by the Rams (it’s worth noting the Seahawks have former Rams assistant coach Jake Peetz on staff as the passing game coordinator).

An intriguing fullback option has also emerged, as the 49ers are expected to release veteran Kyle Juszczyk, according to The Athletic’s Jeff Howe.

But Day 2 of free agency needs to be about ensuring the Seahawks have a much better run game than they’ve had in recent years, and that Darnold isn’t constantly dodging pass rushers the way he was in the wild-card loss to the Rams. That game looked like many of Seattle’s outings with Smith, who was one of the most pressured quarterbacks in the league last season.

The only way to justify swapping Smith for Darnold in the name of youth and cap savings is to reallocate those funds to the position group most responsible for helping the quarterback be at his best.

(Photo of Sam Darnold, left, and Seahawks outside linebacker Boye Mafe: Steph Chambers / Getty Images)

Manchester United announce plans for new 100,000-capacity stadium

Manchester United intend to build a 100,000-capacity new stadium rather than redevelop their existing Old Trafford home.

United announced the ambitious plans on Tuesday, with London-based architecture firm Fosters + Partners selected to lead the project.

The new-build will be situated on land surrounding Old Trafford, as part of a wider regeneration of the Trafford Wharfside area. The club said in a press release that the new stadium and regeneration project have the potential to deliver an additional £7.3billion ($9.7bn) to the local economy, create 92,000 job opportunities and build more than 17,000 new homes, as well as drive an additional 1.8 million visitors annually.

The Old Trafford regeneration task force, which was set up to review options for the stadium and regeneration project, held a final meeting on Friday before being stood down.

Digital renders of what the new stadium and surrounding area could look like were unveiled by Foster + Partners on Tuesday. These included a three-pronged stadium canopy inspired by the Red Devils trident on the club’s badge. The conceptual images and scaled models will now provide “a masterplan for more detailed feasibility, consultation, design and planning work as the project enters a new phase”, the club said.

While it was determined that the capacity of a redeveloped Old Trafford could be as high as 87,000, it was found that a new build could accommodate as many as 100,000 supporters.

A survey of United supporters last year identified that 52 per cent of fans asked were in favour of building a new stadium from scratch, while 31 per cent preferred redevelopment.

“Today marks the start of an incredibly exciting journey to the delivery of what will be the world’s greatest football stadium, at the centre of a regenerated Old Trafford,” Sir Jim Ratcliffe, the club’s co-owner, said in the release.

“Our current stadium has served us brilliantly for the past 115 years, but it has fallen behind the best arenas in world sport. By building next to the existing site, we will be able to preserve the essence of Old Trafford, while creating a truly state-of-the-art stadium that transforms the fan experience only footsteps from our historic home,” Ratcliffe said.

“Just as important is the opportunity for a new stadium to be the catalyst for social and economic renewal of the Old Trafford area, creating jobs and investment not just during the construction phase but on a lasting basis when the stadium district is complete. The government has identified infrastructure investment as a strategic priority, particularly in the north of England, and we are proud to be supporting that mission with this project of national, as well as local, significance.”

Ratcliffe expects “a five-year project rather than a 10 year” with the planned “modular build” — where structures are built elsewhere and shipped in — designed to significantly cut down the build time.


(Manchester United/Foster + Partners)

The task force delivered its options report looking into the benefits of both a new build and a redeveloped stadium earlier this year.

The report concluded that while both options will “deliver transformative benefits for the club as well as Trafford and beyond”, those benefits would be “amplified under the new build option”.

“Our long-term objective as a club is to have the world’s best football team playing in the world’s best stadium,” chief executive Omar Berrada said. “We are grateful for the feasibility work done by the Old Trafford Regeneration Task Force exploring options for the future of Old Trafford.

“We have carefully considered its findings, together with the views of thousands of fans and local residents and concluded that a new stadium is the right way forward for Manchester United and our surrounding community. We will now embark on further consultation to ensure that fans and residents continue to be heard as we move towards final decisions.”

The iconic Old Trafford (Michael Regan/Getty Images)


(Michael Regan/Getty Images)

Sir Alex Ferguson, the club’s legendary former manager and winner of 13 Premier League titles, said: “Manchester United should always strive for the best in everything it does, on and off the pitch, and that includes the stadium we play in. Old Trafford holds so many special memories for me personally, but we must be brave and seize this opportunity to build a new home, fit for the future, where new history can be made.”

Funding remains a significant question mark, with the cost of a newly-built stadium estimated at more than £2bn. As reported by The Athletic in June, United would consider selling the naming rights to their new home to help pay for the project.

“As a PLC we can’t speculate too much about the funding,” Berrada said in a briefing with reporters in London following Tuesday’s announcement. “What I will say is as a centrepiece it is a very attractive investment opportunity. We are very confident we will find a way to finance the stadium.”

Manchester United Supporters Trust (MUST) welcomed the plans but raised concerns and the need for consultation with fans as the project takes shape.

“The announcement of plans to build a brand new stadium adjacent to Old Trafford is clearly very big news for United fans. Everyone wants the biggest and the best for our club and the visuals look both stunning and exciting. But against the backdrop of uncertainty around next year’s ticket prices, continuing poor performance on the field, speculation around sales of key young players, and the recent financial results, the news probably does beg more questions than it gives clear answers,” a MUST spokesperson said.

“If they are able to produce a new stadium as stunning as the plans suggest without harming the atmosphere, without hiking ticket prices and without harming investment elsewhere, then this could be very exciting. But until the questions are answered, our optimism about plans to make Old Trafford the biggest and the best again will be restrained by caution about what the consequences for fans might be.”


‘The major question is how this will be paid for’

Analysis by Manchester United correspondent Laurie Whitwell

This outcome was trailed as soon as Ratcliffe walked through the doors at Old Trafford. Last July in Los Angeles, senior United figures talked about the possibility of a new stadium reaching 100,000 capacity and Ratcliffe’s desire was clear then.

There is certainly appeal among the fanbase for a ‘New Trafford’ — especially with the urban regeneration plan alongside — but the view is not unanimous and many people will be sad that a ground holding so many memories is being left behind.

That being said, Ferguson’s support of the project, having been cut as an ambassador, is notable given he created so many of those moments etched in the club’s consciousness.

The major question is how the build will be paid for: acquiring more debt, via sponsorship, or through cash injected by INEOS? Ticket price rises would seem inevitable in this scenario, but extreme care has to be taken not to price out fans.

(Manchester United/Foster + Partners)


(Manchester United/Foster + Partners)

The actual design of the stadium is crucial also. Old Trafford, for all its faults, has character and history. Many clubs have struggled when moving to new stadiums. Can some of the architecture be retained?

Ratcliffe hails Real Madrid’s Bernabeu and Barcelona’s Camp Nou, but both those grounds have been renovated on their original sites.

Lord Norman Foster, founder of Foster + Partners, said: “It all starts with the fans’ experience, bringing them closer than ever to the pitch and acoustically cultivating a huge roar. The stadium is contained by a vast umbrella, harvesting energy and rainwater, and sheltering a new public plaza that is twice the size of Trafalgar Square.”

Keeping supporters close to the pitch feels essential to sustain that connection to the action.

But the renders put out by United are a dramatic shift from the current stadium and will be hugely divisive. The tent on top of the ground strikes as an odd juxtaposition amid the landscape and what came before.


A naming-rights deal and more debt?

Analysis by senior football news reporter Matt Slater

“Naming-rights deals are like free money for clubs, and those who do not have them are simply leaving money on the table,” Michael Weaver, an expert on sponsorship deals who heads up the valuation advisory team at Kroll’s London office, told The Athletic. “You only have to look at the United States, where almost every stadium is named after a sponsor, to see that.

“If Manchester United sold the naming rights to Old Trafford, our analysis suggests they would earn about £15m a year but you could double that for a new stadium. A naming-rights deal for, let’s say, 10 years, would cover a significant chunk of the construction costs and enable them to borrow money for the rest at a better interest rate. I don’t understand why they would not do a naming-rights deal.”

Who or what would fit at United’s new home? Would anyone even use the new name?

These questions are harder to answer and United fans are divided — but Arsenal fans have got used to the Emirates and Manchester City fans seem to have no problem with calling their home the Etihad.

(Manchester United/Foster + Partners)


(Manchester United/Foster + Partners)

“INEOS might be a more palatable sponsor than someone else as Manchester United are already actively associated with INEOS and it would suggest that Ratcliffe’s company is fully committed and in it for the long haul,” suggests Weaver.

“Our research suggests that British fans are no longer as opposed to naming-rights deals as they were. Fans are becoming more financially literate with their clubs and they know what it takes to compete on the pitch, particularly if you are up against rivals backed by sovereign wealth funds. You have to squeeze out all of the juice.”

So, a naming-rights deal will help but what about the rest?

“It is going to be very expensive,” says Tim Williams, who was United’s group financial controller for five years until 2015. “I’m sure it will have to be funded by a mix of equity and debt. There will be no shortage of global banks and private-equity firms that want to lend United money but it will be interesting to see how much they borrow and where that debt sits.

“Debt is a very loaded term at United but it is normally better to put any stadium debt on the club’s books or a club subsidiary. Separating club and stadium rarely works in the long term.”

(Top photo: Manchester United/Foster + Partners)

SailGP Championship: From towering catamarans racing at 60mph to $12.8m in prize money. Is this F1 on the water?

Humans have sailed the oceans for centuries. But, as a spectator sport, sailing has barely made a dent in the public consciousness, outside of the Olympics at least. There’s no denying that it can often be difficult to make sense of what’s going on way out there on the water, for a start.

But the SailGP Championship has set out to prove watching sailboat racing can be thrilling, entertaining and even get you jumping off the sofa and yelling at your TV.

Every aspect of this global competition — the boats, the track, the sudden-death format — has been designed to grab attention. The aim has been to turn heads, generate excitement and engage people who have previously never shown any interest in sailing.

And now you’ll be able to follow the action with The Athletic too, as we bring our fan-first approach to global sports coverage to SailGP, taking you inside the championship and telling you everything you need to know about a competition that has been likened to Formula 1 on water.


SailGP in a nutshell

SailGP is a high-speed, close-to-shore international sailing championship consisting of 12 national teams who race identical F50 catamarans head-to-head at 13 venues around the world over a 12-month season.

For 2024-25, which runs from November to November, the competition takes the six-person teams to five continents. Three Grands Prix are held in the United States (Los Angeles, San Francisco and New York), while England, Germany, Spain, Brazil, Switzerland, France and Italy also host race weekends. The season-ending round will be in Abu Dhabi.

So far, the competition has been open, with multiple winners across the opening three Grands Prix in Dubai, New Zealand and Australia. Each race weekend, the 12 teams compete in five races, three on the Saturday and two on Sunday. The top three teams from those five then progress to a winner-takes-all final race.

The boat: Meet the F50


Team Australia competes during SailGP Sydney on February 8 (Matt King/Getty Images)

Most boats float on the surface of the water. The F50, on the other hand, is a lightweight carbon-fiber catamaran that uses intricately designed and engineered hydrofoils to launch the body of the boat above the water, massively reducing the hydrodynamic drag and attaining a level of efficiency that was once unthinkable.

The unique aspect of SailGP is that all its F50s are identical, which helps keep costs down and competition tight. The difference between winning and losing comes down to the skill and strategy of the athletes controlling them.

With the F50 ‘foiling’ above the surface of the ocean, it is capable of speeds over 60mph (100 kilometers an hour) — a pace so rapid that even the petrol-powered chase boats can’t keep up.

Once these high-tech catamarans are flying along above the water, they can travel at over three times the speed of the wind, with athletes on board experiencing G-forces of up to three times their body weight during the tight maneuvers around the congested race track. A sailor who weighs, for example, 80kg (176 pounds; 12st 8lb) will feel the weight of 240kg on their body.

Propelling F50s at breakneck speeds is potentially dangerous, which is why the sailors wear body armor and crash helmets. They are permanently tethered to a retaining line on the boat to prevent them from falling overboard.

Even with all these safety measures in place, injuries do happen from time to time.

At the SailGP Auckland event at the end of January, for example, Canada’s Billy Gooderham was injured when he was hit by a wall of water, shattering his crash helmet and causing him to be rushed to hospital. Thankfully, X-rays later revealed that nothing had been broken.


Denmark, helmed by Nicolai Sehested, nearly capsized during practice ahead of the second race day in New Zealand on January 19 (Felix Diemer for SailGP)

Who is behind SailGP?

American billionaire Larry Ellison made his fortune helping build Oracle Corporation into one of the world’s most successful software businesses. Over the decades, Ellison — fourth on Forbes’ ‘Real Time Billionaires List’ — has spent a good part of his wealth on various forms of sailboat racing.

From a near-death experience in the 600-mile Sydney Hobart Race in Australia to twice winning the America’s Cup, the world’s oldest international sporting competition, Ellison’s passion for sailing has been one of enduring enthusiasm.

New Zealand’s Russell Coutts, one of the most successful competitive sailors of all time, masterminded those two America’s Cup victories for Ellison (in Valencia, Spain, in 2010 and San Francisco three years later).

Having lost the America’s Cup in 2017, however, Coutts and Ellison turned their minds to an idea they had been kicking around for years: would it be possible to create a sailboat racing circuit that was truly commercially viable and capable of being self-sustaining without large cash injections from privately wealthy individuals?

Just over a year later, in late 2018, Coutts unveiled his grand plan — SailGP was born.

How similar (and different) is SailGP to F1?

SailGP shares some similarities with Formula 1, the pinnacle of professional motor racing.

Coutts makes no secret of his desire to emulate the commercial success of F1, to the point where he has even thrown out the traditional language of sailing. Crew members are called ‘athletes’ not sailors, the skippers are ‘drivers’ and boat speeds are measured not in nautical knots or even in miles per hour but in kilometres per hour (partly because you sometimes see them exceed that nice round number of 100km/h).


The fleet leaves the start during SailGP Auckland on January 19 (Phil Walter/Getty Images)

Whereas in F1 there are constructors’ and drivers’ championships, in SailGP there is only one title at stake. In SailGP, winning the start is important, but there is no pole position as in F1. All 12 teams are jostling for the best position on the start line until the gun fires, with the aim being to be flying above the water at full speed as the front of your F50 crosses the start line right on the ‘B’ of that bang.

Judging time and distance at high speed is no easy job — hit the start line too soon and the umpires will message to slow down until the rest of the fleet have gone past you. Some teams prefer to get in position early, although this means they have limited space and opportunity to get up to full speed before the gun fires. Others like to sit off and make a timed run towards the line from a long way back.

In F1, data is king and is guarded from rival teams. In SailGP, all the race data is shared centrally, the aim being to keep the gap between the front and the back of the fleet as short as possible. Immediately after a race weekend, you can bet other crews will be poring over all that data for the smallest clues of how to improve performance.

Both F1 and SailGP place strong limits on practice time.

For SailGP, a big reason for this is because the teams’ equipment spends so much time traversing the globe in a stack of 40ft shipping containers. But it’s also to keep a limit on costs, though the lack of practice time does make it challenging for the less-experienced crews to close the performance gap on the veteran teams from Australia, Great Britain and New Zealand.

The vagaries of the wind

The race course is never the same twice in a wind-powered sport such as SailGP. There could be a mild breeze, a storm, or sometimes no wind at all.

To adapt to various weather conditions, much like having different tires for different race conditions in F1, the F50 catamarans are equipped with three different wing sizes — 18m (59ft), 24m, and 29m — as well as interchangeable sizes of hydrofoils and rudders (the latter are used for steering).


Team Great Britain and Team New Zealand compete during SailGP Sydney on February 9 (Matt King/Getty Images)

The smallest wing is used in strong winds to maintain control, the largest gets deployed in light winds to maximize power, and the middle-sized one serves as an all-purpose option. Similarly, the size of the hydrofoils and rudders varies according to changes in the wind strength.

The size of wing teams must use in a race is decided by the race organizers and all teams must use the same ones. In lighter winds, the F50 relies on the biggest set of foils to generate the lift to break clear of the water’s surface and get up and foiling. In stronger winds, getting on the foils is much easier and the smaller set of hydrofoils creates less drag in the sea, resulting in the highest speeds.

The crew: Who does what on board?

Success in the F50s requires not only physical strength but split-second decision-making and constant communication too. Each individual’s role is vital to a team’s success.


Helmed by Martine Grael on race day 1, Brazil competes in Australia on February 8 (Felix Diemer for SailGP)

The best crews are a tight-knit bunch who implicitly understand the needs of their teammates with only minimal communication. It’s vital that everyone is in tune with the boat’s pre-agreed set moves.

There are usually six athletes on board each F50 — a strategist, a driver, a wing trimmer, a flight controller and two grinders.

  • Grinders: The engine room. Their job is to generate power for the wing trimmer to adjust the wing in and out as the wind varies.
  • Wing trimmer: Constantly adjusts the wing sail for maximum speed.
  • Flight controller: Manages the ride height of the boat above the water, aiming to avoid any costly nosedives or crashes.
  • Strategist: Reads the ever-changing wind, making tactical decisions either to attack or defend.
  • Driver: The figurehead and a team’s highest earner, steering and making the final decisions about positioning.

In light winds, race organizers might instruct teams to drop to as few as four people to make the F50s lighter. When this happens, the teams are in charge of deciding who they keep on board.

As with other forms of professional sport, the salaries can vary enormously from team to team. For many of the athletes, the prize money — across this season there is a $12.8million (£10m) prize pool up for grabs — often outweighs their basic salary, which tends to be around $50,000 per season.

How does the championship format work?

Success depends on consistency. The aim is to score well enough from the five fleet races across a weekend to earn a place in the top three who progress to the winner-takes-all final race.


Switzerland, helmed by Sebastien Schneiter, in Auckland on January 19 (Ricardo Pinto for SailGP)

Going from the more conservative points-accumulation parts of the weekend to that 10-minute sudden-death final race demands a complete switch of mindset. Some sailors are more naturally suited to a cautious, patient approach, whereas others throw caution to the wind. Neither approach is right or wrong, it’s a matter of applying the mindset that best matches the moment.

At the season finale, the three top-performing teams from across the season face off in a single, winner-takes-all showdown for the title and a $2million prize. A team can be dominant all season yet lose in the grand final — which is exactly what we saw last season in San Francisco, with Australia toppled from the top of the leaderboard as Spain swooped in to take the championship in a masterfully executed smash-and-grab.

How do you win a race?

Each race lasts a maximum of 16 minutes. The fleet launch out of a timed start and accelerate to speeds close to 100kmh as they converge on Mark 1.

Getting around Mark 1 first brings a huge advantage, so there’s enormous emphasis on winning the launch out of the start. Then, the fleet turn downwind towards the bottom of the course for a fast and furious two laps before a high-speed finish, usually positioned to give spectators on shore a grandstand view as the F50s blast across the finish line.

There are three key strategies to winning a race: finding more wind to sail your boat faster through the water, using superior techniques to travel quicker in conditions that are the same for everybody, and identifying wind shifts and angles to navigate a shorter distance around the course.

Sailing is totally powered by nature. You have to zig-zag your way around the course, searching for the best breeze and steering at the optimal angle to the wind.

Wind: the invisible power source

How do sailors see wind? It creates ripples on the surface of the water, giving clues as to where the strongest gusts are likely to be. Spotting wind shifts is even trickier — you have to look at how gusts move along the course. The shape and movement of these gusts become second nature to experienced sailors.

There’s a lot to take in at once — reading the subtleties of the wind, as well as the current on the water in tidal venues such as San Francisco — which is why SailGP attracts the best sailors in the world, many of them Olympic gold medallists and world champions from other branches of professional sailing.

Who are the teams to watch?

Australia, skippered by Tom Slingsby, are an ever-present threat. The Flying Roos won the first three seasons of SailGP before being beaten to the punch last year by Spain in the final race. Past seasons have seen New Zealand showing strong form, but the Kiwis — headed up by three-time America’s Cup winner Pete Burling — are struggling in mid-pack so far this year.

Leading the standings after the first three events are the Brits, with new driver Dylan Fletcher on an impressive learning curve in his first season at the helm of Emirates GBR. On the other hand, the United States are struggling in 11th. Taylor Canfield’s crew will be looking to turn their season around at the forthcoming events on home waters, in Los Angeles this weekend, then San Francisco on March 22-23.


Britain celebrate victory on race day 2 in Sydney in February (Andy Cheung/Getty Images)

What does the remaining 2025 calendar look like?

Los Angeles, U.S.: March 15-16

San Francisco, U.S.: March 22-23

Rio de Janeiro, Brazil: May 3-4

New York, U.S.: June 7-8

Portsmouth, UK: July 19-20

Sassnitz, Germany: August 16-17

Saint-Tropez, France: September 12-13

Geneva, Switzerland: September 20-21

Andalucia-Cadiz, Spain: October 4-5

Abu Dhabi: November 29-30

I’m convinced. How do I watch?

You can watch SailGP live or catch highlights on broadcast partners around the world, as well as through the official SailGP app and social media channels. In the United States, racing is live on CBS Sports, and in the UK, you’ll find it on TNT Sports.

(Top photo: SailGP; design: Demetrius Robinson)

NCAA Tournament Bracket Watch 2025: Teams with the most and least to gain this week

(Editor’s note: This article is part of the Bracket Central series, an inside look at the run-up to the men’s & women’s NCAA Tournaments, along with analysis and picks during the tournaments.)

Drake’s in, so we can dispense with the arguments about whether Ben McCollum’s Bulldogs would have made the field of 68 without winning the Missouri Valley tourney (they probably wouldn’t have), save follow-up discussions about the plight of the mid-major and tournament expansion for another day and simply appreciate the fact that this tournament is better with Drake in it.

Lipscomb’s in, too. And High Point. And SIU-Edwardsville. And Omaha. With the Sun Belt and Southern Conference scheduled to produce champions Monday. And on through the week we’ll go, into power conference tournaments and finishing on Selection Sunday. The teams playing for those automatic bids and the at-large hopefuls right around the bubble have the most at stake this week, of course — check for regular updates this week on Jim Root’s Bubble Watch.

But what about the stakes in safe parts of the bracket? Here are five teams that have much to gain in their conference tournaments and five that don’t.

Five that should go hard this week

Florida: I’ve got Florida as the last No. 1 seed after an enormous win at Alabama, and a No. 1 seed is worth it simply to guarantee Auburn/Duke avoidance. Though I’m not sure Florida should be worried about avoiding anyone, the way the Gators are playing.

Alabama: It’s so close between Florida and Alabama. If things go the way this bracket unfolded, it wouldn’t much matter because the No. 4 overall seed and No. 5 overall seed got shipped out West together. But it doesn’t have to unfold that way. The only clear rule is that No. 5 overall can’t be with No. 1 overall.

Tennessee: It’s so close between Alabama and Tennessee, too. These three appear to be fighting for one spot because Houston is inching toward No. 1 lock status. But it’s worth it for the Vols to be a higher No. 2 than Alabama — that’s the difference right now between starting in Lexington or Cleveland.

Wisconsin: The Badgers need to get their swagger back. Also, a No. 3 seed is still very attainable and worth pursuing.

UConn: The Huskies need to maintain momentum. And get the heck out of having to play in an 8/9 game.

Five that would be better off bailing out and resting

Auburn: Two straight losses haven’t changed the fact that this is the clear best resume in the sport. You’re outright SEC champs. Rather than beat yourself up over three days, tell everyone your bus broke down and get Johni Broome’s left ankle some rest.

Duke: The No. 1 overall seed could be attained, I suppose. But so what? Duke will be a No. 1 seed with a Raleigh-Newark path. Auburn will be a No. 1 seed with a Lexington-Atlanta path. This week is nothing but injury exposure.

Michigan State: I don’t see the Spartans cracking the top line — though they can be pushy! I also don’t see how they fall to a No. 3 seed. Another outright champ that doesn’t need the hassle.

St. John’s: A start in Providence should be assured with a No. 3 seed. So rather than go all out for a No. 2, maybe get a few thousand shots up instead?

Houston: OK, go hard for one win, just to make sure on that No. 1 seed.

We’ll be back Thursday with a new bracket, and then it’s every day until the big day.

 

First four out Next four out Last four in Last four byes

Xavier

Nebraska

Oklahoma

West Virginia

Texas

Dayton

Indiana

Utah State

Boise State

Wake Forest

Ohio State

Arkansas

Colorado State

UC Irvine

North Carolina

San Diego State

 

Multi-bid conferences

Conference Bids

SEC

13

Big Ten

10

Big 12

8

ACC

4

Big East

4

Mountain West

3

West Coast

2

The Bracket Central series is sponsored by E*Trade from Morgan Stanley.
The Athletic maintains full editorial independence. Sponsors have no control over or input into the reporting or editing process and do not review stories before publication.

(Photo of Walter Clayton Jr: Matt Pendleton / Imagn Images)

2025 MLB Franchise Rankings: Dodgers closing in on No. 1 team of past 25 years

It’s time for another round of the tested, trusted, completely objective, never-been-questioned, all-math, no-bias MLB franchise rankings.

First, a change: Rather than span the Wild-Card Era (1995 to present) as we have done previously, the franchise rankings will henceforth cover the past 25 years, a floating time frame that feels right to start this year — 25 for ’25. The scoring system we borrowed years ago from football writer Bob Sturm and tweaked to fit baseball postseason structure has not changed since last year’s edition.

Winning the World Series (WS): 9 points
Losing in the World Series (WSL): 6 points
Losing in the Championship Series (CS): 3 points
Losing in Division Series (DS): 2 points
Losing in Wild-Card Round (WC): 1 point

The scoring system also incentivizes division titles (+1 point) and penalizes prolonged losing cycles, docking teams (-1 point) each time they lose at least 90 games in consecutive seasons. Add up the point totals from 2000 to 2024 and you have the franchise rankings. It’s just simple math.

In the past, some readers have asked to inject a recency bias into the scoring system — to calculate, say, the 2024 World Series as more valuable than the 2014 or 2004 titles. But no! This exercise aims to measure sustained success (and ineptitude) over a 25-year period. Below, we have included each team’s point total and ranking from the past decade.

Tiebreaker order: World Series wins, World Series losses, Championship Series appearances, Division Series appearances, division titles

Loading

Try changing or resetting your filters to see more.

New time frame or not, the Pirates are still in the negative. Pittsburgh has been to the playoffs just three times since 1992, and advanced to the Division Series only once. It remains a tough time to be a Bucco fan. We don’t need to belabor that point. With Paul Skenes, Jared Jones, Mitch Keller and prospect Bubba Chandler, the Pirates’ rotation could keep them competitive in 2025. But a playoff run would require a series of breakouts and bouncebacks in a lineup that underwhelms on paper. This offseason, the Pirates brought back Andrew McCutchen and Adam Frazier, signed Tommy Pham and traded for now-injured Spencer Horwitz. Fans had hoped for far more than that.

Total playoff years: 13DS, 14WC, 15WC

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

8

Last decade: 0 points (MLB rank: t-26th)

Average: -.16 points per season

The Orioles have gained ground with postseason appearances in the last two years, but they’re still at the back of the pack over this 25-year span. Our scoring system is not kind to teams that rebuild — or accidentally stink for a long time? — and only one team (Kansas City) has had more consecutive 90-loss seasons since 2000 than the Orioles. But the Orioles are in a competitive mode now, with young talent up and down their lineup, from Gunnar Henderson to Adley Rutschman, Jackson Holliday, Jordan Westburg and 2024 AL Rookie of the Year runner-up Colton Cowser. The rotation is without an ace like Corbin Burnes, but there’s real talent there, and the bullpen should be exceptional.

Total playoff years: 12DS, 14CS, 16WC, 23DS, 24WC

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

8

Last decade: 4 points (MLB rank: t-20th)

Average: .12 points per season

Step aside, Buccos. Cincinnati is the only team with a negative point total (-2) over the past 10 years. But because the scope of this ranking is wider than a decade, the Reds will mostly escape ridicule here. If a genie granted Reds president of baseball operations Nick Krall one wish, he would probably inquire whether it was too much to ask for a full season of perfect health for this Reds roster. (It is.) Otherworldly numbers from Elly De La Cruz will only take a team so far if Matt McLain, Hunter Greene, TJ Friedl, Nick Lodolo and Jeimer Candelario are all hurt. For now, though, it’s a (mostly) healthy and intriguing roster.

Total playoff years: 10DS, 12DS, 13WC, 20WC

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

3

Last decade: -2 points (MLB rank: 30th)

Shifting our time frame to cover just the past 25 years eliminated two mid-1990s Mariners postseason trips included in previous rankings. Two more playoff appearances (ALCS runs in 2000 and 2001) will fall outside the 25-year window soon. So, Seattle could backslide further in this list in the next couple years. The primary reason for hope this season is that this rotation is still together. The team has made moves designed to marginally improve the lineup — adding Randy Arozarena, Victor Robles, Donovan Solano and re-signing Jorge Polanco — but after a no-splash offseason, the Mariners seem to be banking mostly upon positive regression from in-house options.

Total playoff years: 00CS, 01CS, 22DS

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

2

Last decade: 2 points (MLB rank: t-22nd)

The Rockies’ miracle run to the 2007 World Series decides our first tiebreaker decision, placing them over the Mariners (still waiting on that first World Series appearance). But Colorado is moving backward lately. Having lost 94, 103 and 101 games the past three seasons, the deductions are racking up. The Rockies are not expected to be much better in 2025, though Ezequiel Tovar, Brenton Doyle and Ryan McMahon offer quality at the top of the lineup. If nothing else, it’ll be worth tracking the progress of top-100 prospects Charlie Condon (the No. 3 pick in the 2024 draft) and Chase Dollander (the No. 9 pick in the 2023 draft) this season.

Total playoff years: 07WSL, 09DS, 17WC, 18DS

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

4

Last decade: 0 points (MLB rank: t-26th)

The lowest-ranked franchise on this list to have won a World Series in the past 25 years, the Marlins are a marvel. Since that 2003 title, Miami has turned in losing seasons in 15 of 21 years and made the playoffs just twice — once because of the 2020 expanded playoff field. Coming off a 100-loss season, the Marlins roster has worsened this offseason, having traded Jesús Luzardo and Jake Burger and added virtually no one. The lineup will likely be dreadful. But Cy Young Award winner Sandy Alcantara is healthy again, Eury Pérez is progressing in his Tommy John recovery, and the Marlins have two top-100 pitching prospects in Thomas White and Noble Meyer. The Fish have arms, at least.

Total playoff years: 03WS, 20DS, 23WC

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

4

Last decade: 1 point (MLB rank: 25th)

The Padres’ past quarter-decade has featured only one NLCS, but, boy, they sure had the smell of a World Series team in the 2024 postseason. Unfortunately for the Friars and their fans, the Dodgers exist, escaped the 2024 NLDS and are now stronger than ever. San Diego has had a relatively quiet offseason on the transaction front (not so much at the ownership level). But the top half of the lineup should be potent, the rotation has real arms and the bullpen, even after losing Tanner Scott in free agency, should be strong again. Even so, that little problem lingers: The Padres somehow still have to get past the Dodgers.

Total playoff years: 05DS, 06DS, 20DS, 22CS, 24DS

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

4

Last decade: 4 points (MLB rank: t-20th)

Kansas City ranked 29th on last year’s list, but bumping the starting point from 1995 to 2000 didn’t hurt the Royals the way it did the teams now below them. The Royals hold the distinction of most consecutive 90-loss seasons in the past 25 years, with nine. They’ve made good use of their three playoff trips, reaching two World Series and winning one. The Royals project to make further progress in the years ahead. Bobby Witt Jr. is one of the best players in baseball. The rotation has Cole Ragan’s top-tier stuff and the experience of Seth Lugo, Michael Wacha and Michael Lorenzen. The bullpen has added Hunter Harvey, Lucas Erceg and Carlos Estévez since July. The arrow is pointing up.

Total playoff years: 14WSL, 15WS, 24DS

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

9

Last decade: 10 points (MLB rank: t-14th)

The good news is the Blue Jays are one of just six franchises that have not recorded any consecutive 90-loss seasons since 2000. The bad news? The other five teams — Dodgers, Yankees, Red Sox, Cardinals and Angels (yes, Angels) — are all ranked in the top 10. The Blue Jays are in the bottom 10 primarily due to their postseason drought that stretched from 1994 to 2015. Toronto has squeezed five playoff appearances into the past decade; the last three have been wild-card sweeps. Given the state of the AL East, the Blue Jays face another uphill climb this season, which could be Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s last hurrah in Toronto. The Blue Jays made interesting additions this offseason, from Anthony Santander and Andrés Giménez to Jeff Hoffman and Max Scherzer, but none were the big swing for which fans had clamored.

Total playoff years: 15CS, 16CS, 20WC, 22WC, 23WC

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

0

Last decade: 10 points (MLB rank: t-14th)

Twenty-five years ago, the Nationals were still the Montreal Expos. If you erase the Expos years from our timeline, the Nats would have 16 total points and win a tiebreaker against the Brewers. Go ahead and tell your friends about that little loophole to get the Nationals in the top 20. Washington has been rotten since winning the 2019 World Series, which ended an eight-year run of competitiveness. The Nats are longshots to contend in the NL East in 2025. For now, the franchise is treading water. But with several young potential stars — James Wood, CJ Abrams, Dylan Crews — on the rise, the future appears bright.

Total playoff years: 12DS, 14DS, 16DS, 17DS, 19WS

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

7

Last decade: 12 points (MLB rank: t-11th)

This feels low, right? The Brewers have reached the playoffs in six of the past seven years (and were 86-76 the year they missed out). They’ve lost 90 games only once since 2004. But this is where the Brewers land because of early postseason exits — four of their past five playoff runs have ended in the Wild Card — and because they were pretty awful in the early 2000s. The team should be right back in the thick of the NL Central race this season. Their lineup, led by Jackson Chourio and William Contreras, has power and a penchant for running wild; their rotation is solid; and their bullpen, even without new Yankees closer Devin Williams, will continue to baffle batters.

Total playoff years: 08DS, 11CS, 18CS, 19WC, 20WC, 21DS, 23WC, 24WC

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

3

Last decade: 13 points (MLB rank: 13th)

The White Sox won’t finish last in everything this year, folks. Chicago set Major League Baseball’s modern loss record last season, losing 121 games to “beat” the expansion 1962 New York Mets. There’s really no reason to expect the White Sox will be better this season. They probably will be, though, given how hard it is to lose 121 times in 162 tries. The White Sox traded ace Garrett Crochet. They have not traded Luis Robert Jr. — not yet, anyway. But they’re still sitting in a decent spot in the franchise rankings. Because the 2005 White Sox were a wagon in October. And because flags fly forever.

Total playoff years: 00DS, 05WS, 08DS, 20WC, 21DS

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

2

Last decade: 2 points (MLB rank: t-22nd)

Fresh off spending their first October at home since 2018, Tampa has stocked up since last July in the most Raysian ways. They accepted reality and sold at the trade deadline, swapping veterans Jason Adam, Zach Eflin, Randy Arozarena and Isaac Paredes for 12 players, including several prospects now in the organization’s top 20. This offseason, the Rays signed quality catcher Danny Jansen, landed a short-term deal with injured shortstop Ha-Seong Kim and took a flier on Eloy Jiménez. With the rotation much healthier now, the Rays are again positioned for a playoff run — and potentially to push higher up these rankings.

Total playoff years: 08WSL, 10DS, 11DS, 13DS, 19DS, 20WSL, 21DS, 22WC, 23WC

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

8

Last decade: 14 points (MLB rank: t-8th)

The Tigers ended a decade-long postseason drought in style last year with a surprise second-half surge. Detroit was nine games under .500 in early July, sold at the trade deadline and was still .500 as late as Sept. 7. But the Tigers streaked into the playoffs and swept the Astros in the Wild Card Series before nearly closing out the Guardians in the Division Series. They added moderately this offseason, signing Gleyber Torres, Jack Flaherty and Tommy Kahnle and Alex Cobb. The roster still does not scream championship contender, but with reigning Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal and with more top-100 prospects (seven) than any other team, the Tigers certainly are capable of making noise again this season.

Total playoff years: 06WSL, 11CS, 12WSL, 13CS, 14DS, 24DS

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

6

Last decade: 0 points (MLB rank: t-26th)

Here come the big, bad Metropolitans. This franchise was something of a Cinderella story last season (though this Cinderella had the highest payroll in the land), clinching a playoff spot in a bonus-day doubleheader and then charging into the NLCS. It was their first time advancing in the postseason since 2015. And now the Mets have Juan Soto. Along with bringing back Pete Alonso, Sean Manaea, Ryne Stanek and Jesse Winker, New York traded for Jose Siri and signed Clay Holmes, Frankie Montas and A.J. Minter, among others, in free agency. There was a lot of work to be done this winter. It got done.

Total playoff years: 00WSL, 06CS, 15WSL, 16WC, 22WC, 24CS

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

1

Last decade: 12 points (MLB rank: t-11th)

These are tough times for Athletics fans, as the rebuilding franchise leaves Oakland for a short-term stay in Sacramento. Over the past 25 years, though, there was a fair share of success, as the A’s reached the playoffs 11 times. They only reached the ALCS once (they were swept by the Tigers in 2006), however, and they haven’t won a game that deep into the playoffs since 1992. The A’s don’t project to be playoff-bound this season, though with the offseason additions of Luis Severino, Jeffrey Springs and Jose Leclerc they certainly are capable of breaking their streak of three consecutive 90-loss seasons.

Total playoff years: 00DS, 01DS, 02DS, 03DS, 06CS, 12DS, 13DS, 14WC, 18WC, 19WC, 20DS

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

3

Last decade: 2 points (MLB rank: t-22nd)

It took the fifth tiebreaker (division titles) to distinguish between the Twins and A’s. Neither reached a World Series since 2000; each had one Championship Series loss, seven Division Series losses and two Wild-Card losses. That’s a lot of bites at the apple, as the saying goes, and a lot of disappointing exits. The Twins have been to the playoffs 10 times in the past 25 years, but the last nine times, they have not advanced beyond the ALDS. The Twins are still a talented bunch, but they have not substantively added to the roster in the past two offseasons. The plan is, for the most part, to run it back in 2025.

Total playoff years: 02CS, 03DS, 04DS, 06DS, 09DS, 10DS, 17WC, 19DS, 20WC, 23DS

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

4

Last decade: 9 points (MLB rank: 17th)

The Cubs haven’t won a postseason game since 2017, but a World Series ring and a couple NLCS appearances in the past 25 years are good enough for a top-half finish here. This is a crucial year for the Cubbies. If this is their only year with Kyle Tucker, they’d better make it count. They added a handful of free agents this offseason — notably Matthew Boyd, Caleb Thielbar, Justin Turner, Jon Berti, Carson Kelly and Colin Rea — but did most of their work in the trade market, acquiring Tucker, Ryan Pressly and Ryan Brazier. The Cubs still project as a fringe Wild-Card team this season, but it’s not hard to fathom them making a run at Milwaukee atop the NL Central.

Total playoff years: 03CS, 07DS, 08DS, 15CS, 16WS, 17CS, 18WC, 20WC

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

3

Last decade: 20 points (MLB rank: 6th)

The Diamondbacks have a tiebreaker over the Cubs, having appeared in two World Series since 2000. Arizona had the top run-scoring offense in the majors last season, but the pitching staff badly underperformed and the Diamondbacks were eliminated from playoff contention on the last day of the regular season. They upgraded their rotation with authority this winter, adding ace Corbin Burnes on a six-year contract. The D-Backs replaced departed free agent Christian Walker with Josh Naylor. They exercised Eugenio Suárez’s option and re-signed Randal Grichuk. There may be a dip in offensive production in 2025, but a markedly improved pitching staff could make up for that.

Total playoff years: 01WS, 02DS, 07CS, 11DS, 17DS, 23WSL

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

1

Last decade: 8 points (MLB rank: 18th)

Whittling our time frame to the past 25 years knocks out Cleveland’s great late-1990s run — two World Series appearances, an ALCS exit and two in the ALDS — but the Guardians are still knocking on the door of our top 10. In the past decade, the Guardians have the fifth-most points from our scoring system, behind only the Dodgers, Astros, Braves and Yankees. Cleveland operates with a much more small-market mindset than those four but has managed to sustain success. It is, however, the highest-ranked team in our list without a World Series title in this 25-year window. This winter, the Guardians re-signed the rehabbing Shane Bieber and brought back Carlos Santana to replace Josh Naylor at first base.

Total playoff years: 01DS, 07CS, 13WC, 16WSL, 17DS, 18DS, 20WC, 22DS, 24CS

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

1

Last decade: 21 points (MLB rank: 5th)

The Rangers disappointed last season coming off their 2023 championship, but three World Series appearances in the past 15 seasons squeak them into the top 10 via a tiebreaker advantage over the Guardians. No other top-10 franchise has had as few playoff seasons since 2000 as Texas (six); the Rangers have made those chances count. The 2025 Rangers’ results will hinge upon health and a return to career norms for a number of regulars. Joc Pederson and Jake Burger bring more thunder to the lineup. Nathan Eovaldi is back, and the bullpen has been rebuilt. “Healthy Jacob deGrom” is one of the most enticing (and fleeting) thoughts one can conjure. The Rangers have stars and young studs, but with so much injury risk baked into this roster, just hold your breath.

Total playoff years: 10WSL, 11WSL, 12WC, 15DS, 16DS, 23WS

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

2

Last decade: 14 points (MLB rank: t-8th)

That’s right! The Angels! The 2000s are doing almost all the lifting for this franchise, which is remarkable when you consider that the 2010s and 2020s were when they employed Albert Pujols, Mike Trout and Shohei Ohtani. Despite their current standing as the butt of many baseball jokes, the Angels have not had a single instance of back-to-back 90-loss seasons in the past 25 years. Yet. After avoiding that distinction as narrowly as possible in recent years, losing 89 games in 2022 and 2023, they lost 99 last season. Can the 2025 Angels avoid losing 90? Adding veterans such as Yusei Kikuchi, Kenley Jansen, Yoán Moncada, Travis d’Arnaud and Jorge Soler should help, but without Anthony Rendon and with Trout’s health always in question, the Angels still look like a team stuck in the murky middle.

Total playoff years: 02WS, 04DS, 05CS, 07DS, 08DS, 09CS, 14DS

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

0

Last decade: 0 points (MLB rank: t-26th)

The 2024 Phillies snatched the franchise’s first division title since 2011 — the tail end of their five-year reign that included two World Series appearances — but exited the postseason in the NLDS, a year after exiting in the NLCS, a year after reaching the World Series. So, yeah, getting stomped by the Mets was a downer. The Phillies did not set out to make a splash this offseason, but smart adds of Jesús Luzardo, Jordan Romano and Max Kepler could pay dividends. Navigating an NL East with three teams jockeying for playoff positioning will be hard enough. For Philadelphia, the real test awaits in October.

Total playoff years: 07DS, 08WS, 09WSL, 10CS, 11DS, 22WSL, 23CS, 24DS

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

2

Last decade: 10 points (MLB rank: t-14th)

The Giants haven’t advanced past the NLCS since 2014, but winning three World Series rings in the past 25 years is a sure way to rack up points. This Giants roster, now under the command of franchise legend Buster Posey, should be better this season with Willy Adames at shortstop, Jung Hoo Lee healthy and Justin Verlander rounding out the rotation. But in the grand scheme of the NL West, it’s still hard to feel great about the Giants compared to the Dodgers, Diamondbacks and Padres. San Francisco has averaged 80 wins the past three seasons. Given the division context, the team still feels rather 80-win-ish these days.

Total playoff years: 00DS, 02WSL, 03DS, 10WS, 12WS, 14WS, 16DS, 21DS

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

1

Last decade: 5 points (MLB rank: 19th)

The Braves may have been the biggest loser in our timeframe switch this season, dropping four spots when we cut out their 1995-99 playoff runs. Still, making the playoffs in 16 of the past 25 years is pretty impressive. The Braves have reached the postseason for seven consecutive Octobers, though they’ve advanced beyond the NLDS just twice (2020 and 2021). Atlanta lost a lot of talented ballplayers this offseason — Max Fried, Charlie Morton, Travis d’Arnaud, a couple relievers. They addressed left field by signing Jurickson Profar. If Ronald Acuña Jr., Spencer Strider and Chris Sale are healthy for most of the 2025 season, this team’s ceiling remains remarkably high.

Total playoff years: 00DS, 01CS, 02DS, 03DS, 04DS, 05DS, 10DS, 12WC, 13DS, 18DS, 19DS, 20CS, 21WS, 22DS, 23DS, 24WC

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

2

Last decade: 25 points (MLB rank: 3rd)

The Astros didn’t just lose a third baseman to the Red Sox this winter. They also lost a franchise-ranking tiebreaker! Talk about a double whammy. Houston has accrued the second-most points of any team in the past decade, just four points behind the Dodgers. But the 2025 Astros are missing many familiar faces. Alex Bregman is a Red Sox. Kyle Tucker and Ryan Pressly are Cubs. Justin Verlander is a Giant. Yusei Kikuchi is an Angel. The Astros brought in Christian Walker, Isaac Paredes and Hayden Wesneski. They still might win a wide-open AL West. But it’s going to be strange seeing Jose Altuve play left field as many of his fellow World Series-winning former teammates are now scattered across the league.

Total playoff years: 01DS, 04CS, 05WSL, 15DS, 17WS, 18CS, 19WSL, 20CS, 21WSL, 22WS, 23CS, 24WC

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

3

Last decade: 49 points (MLB rank: 2nd)

Not sure if any of you had heard of this franchise until Netflix rolled out a couple recent documentaries, but the reason these Red Sox are perched up so high in our rankings is the rings. ’04. ’07. ’13. ’18. Boston hasn’t won the AL East since 2018, and they’re not favorites to do so in 2025, but their moves this winter warranted attention. The Red Sox added a few starters (Garrett Crochet, Walker Buehler and Patrick Sandoval) and two lefty relievers (Aroldis Chapman and Justin Wilson), then took a big swing in mid-February, signing third baseman Alex Bregman away from the Astros on a short-term deal.

Total playoff years: 03CS, 04WS, 05DS, 07WS, 08CS, 09DS, 13WS, 16DS, 17DS, 18WS, 21CS

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

0

Last decade: 19 points (MLB rank: 7th)

The Cardinals have reached the playoffs in 16 of the past 25 years and advanced to at least the NLCS 10 times. But it’s been a bummer lately. The Cards were a Wild Card loser in 2020, 2021 and 2022, and they missed the playoffs entirely the past two seasons. This season is unlikely to be fruitful. St. Louis did not orchestrate a sell-off, exactly, though it was in trade talks about Nolan Arenado and Ryan Helsley. The Cardinals’ timeline for a return to World Series contention is not entirely clear, as the front office begins its transition out of the John Mozeliak era. For now, we’ll see whether they improve running it back with mostly the same roster as last season.

Total playoff years: 00CS, 01DS, 02CS, 04WSL, 05CS, 06WS, 09DS, 11WS, 12CS, 13WSL, 14CS, 15DS, 19CS, 20WC, 21WC, 22WC

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

0

Last decade: 11 points (MLB rank: 13th)

The Dodgers are the best team of the past decade by our scoring system, as their 53 points in that time are double the total of any team not named the Astros (49 points). A World Series win over the Yankees pulled Los Angeles within striking distance of our No. 1. Did they stop there? They did not! In fact, evaluators consider them the league’s most-improved team this spring. The Dodgers continue to spend (and defer) enormous sums of money. Coming off a championship, they’ve re-signed Teoscar Hernández, Clayton Kershaw, Blake Treinen and Kiké Hernández and bolstered the roster by signing Blake Snell, Roki Sasaki, Tanner Scott, Kirby Yates, Michael Conforto and Hyeseong Kim. It’s overwhelming.

Total playoff years: 04DS, 06DS, 08CS, 09CS, 13CS, 14DS, 15DS, 16CS, 17WSL, 18WSL, 19DS, 20WS, 21CS, 22DS, 23DS, 24WS

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

0

Last decade: 53 points (MLB rank: 1st)

New time frame, same champion. When these rankings still spanned the Wild-Card Era (1995 to present), the Yankees were miles ahead. Now that we’re only looking at the past 25 years, the Dodgers are closing fast. The Yankees’ 2000 World Series title will fall outside our window for next year’s ranking, so the franchise that collects more points this season will be our No. 1. Frustrated as fans have been by the Yankees over the past decade — last fall, they reached their first World Series since 2009 — the team has made the postseason in 20 of the 25 years in our exercise, four times more than any other franchise. This offseason, the Yankees lost a star, Juan Soto, and a number of contributors. They added a big-time starter (Max Fried), a closer (Devin Williams) and two former MVPs (Cody Bellinger and Paul Goldschmidt). The road is not easy in the AL East, but the Yankees, led by Aaron Judge and Gerrit Cole, remain formidable.

Total playoff years: 00WS, 01WSL, 02DS, 03WSL, 04CS, 05DS, 06DS, 07DS, 09WS, 10CS, 11DS, 12CS, 15WC, 17CS, 18DS, 19CS, 20DS, 21WC, 22CS, 24WSL

Consecutive 90-loss seasons

0

Last decade: 24 points (MLB rank: 4th)

(Top illustration: Will Tullos / The Athletic; Photos: Scott Taetsch, Ric Tapia, Lachlan Cunningham, Nick Cammett / Getty Images)

Why Canadians are stung by Wayne Gretzky’s silence

As Canada played through controversy at the 2002 Salt Lake City Olympics, its most beloved and iconic sports star grabbed a microphone and stood up for the nation. The Canadian men’s national team had just come from behind to tie the Czech Republic 3-3 in a heated round-robin match.

Wayne Gretzky, the executive director of Canada’s team, called media reports of unrest in the Canadian locker room “American propaganda.”

“I don’t think we dislike those countries as much as they dislike us,” he said. “They want to see us fail. They love beating us. … We’ve got to get that same feeling toward them.”

It was as fiery as hockey fans had seen the game’s greatest player since he’d retired a few years earlier. Canada was in pursuit of its first Olympic gold medal in men’s hockey in half a century.

“Am I hot? Yeah, I’m hot,” Gretzky said. “Because I’m tired of people taking shots at Canadian hockey. … It almost sickens my stomach to turn the TV on because I’m such a proud Canadian and such a fan of our game and very proud of all the guys in the locker room, and it makes me ill to hear some of the things that are being said about us.”

Gretzky’s emotional defense of Canada was an inspirational turning point for the star-packed Canadian team, which went on to win the gold medal on American soil.

Since Gretzky rose to fame as a teenage phenom in the 1970s and went on to rewrite almost every scoring record in the game, Canadians have viewed the Great One as a symbol of national pride.

Now, all the pride that Canadians have felt in the country’s greatest sporting export is being questioned. North of the border, that sentence was once unfathomable. But Gretzky’s allegiance to U.S. President Donald Trump — and his silence after Trump’s repeated calls to make Canada the 51st state while hammering the northern neighbor with crippling tariffs — has left many Canadians feeling deeply betrayed.

Gretzky has made headlines and newscasts across Canada. A petition to rename Gretzky Drive in Edmonton has more than 12,000 signatures.

Some of Gretzky’s defenders have called the criticisms unfair and politically motivated. But in Canada, the sentiment reaches beyond the political spectrum, into a deep, rising nationalism as the country feels backed into a corner.

For decades, Gretzky — fairly or not — has embodied a sense of patriotism that transcends sports.

Yes, Gretzky is the pride of Brantford, Ontario — the tiny boy who learned the game on a backyard rink. He came from a working-class family, which arrived in Canada by way of Ukraine. His journey toward excellence, with hard work and blue-collar spirit, felt representative of a nation.

Over the decades, Walter Gretzky, his father, was so frequently seen at small-town rinks that he became affectionately known as Canada’s hockey dad. He lived in the same house in Brantford until he died. People visited. The place felt common and familiar, an anywhere-in-Canada that became a portal to greatness.

And despite his fame, Gretzky himself always seemed to retain those small-town Canadian ideals. He was kind to fans, humble in interviews, but unapologetic in his pursuit of success and the will it took to achieve. Because of that folksy familiarity, it seemed like Gretzky’s connection to home never wavered, even at the height of his fame.

That’s how it felt, anyway.

If you grew up in Canada through the 1980s and 1990s, Gretzky was at the pinnacle of national esteem. He set untouchable records in Edmonton, and battled for Canadian glory on the ice — and then he wept after learning he was being exported to California.

In his greatness, the Canadian with the flowing blonde hockey hair made people talk about Canada. We watched him on Saturday morning cartoons, alongside Michael Jordan and Bo Jackson. We saw him in Coke and Nike commercials and referenced in Hollywood movies. He became internationally recognized in a way that no hockey player had before. Rising through a transformative era of globally connected media, Gretzky became the first Canadian to sit in the pantheon of the world’s sports legends.

So it is difficult to overstate the pride that many Canadians carry for Gretzky. But pride isn’t the only word here. There was also a sense of ownership: that Gretzky belonged to Canada.

This, of course, was never true.

Gretzky has lived in the U.S. since being traded to the Los Angeles Kings in 1988. He married an American and they raised their tightly knit, loyal and loving family south of the Canadian border. He became a naturalized U.S. citizen. The Gretzkys have had homes in California, Wyoming, Missouri and Florida.

In 2009, Gretzky was awarded with the nation’s highest civilian honor, companion of the Order of Canada. The award recognizes outstanding achievement, dedication to community and service to the nation. But to date, Gretzky has not taken part in an investiture ceremony to receive the award from Canada’s Governor General at Rideau Hall in Ottawa.

Somewhere along the way, the idea of Gretzky as Canada’s constant ambassador became mythology.

A simple reality underscores so much of the hurt and resentment Canadians feel about the mockery and threats and economic attacks coming from the U.S. president. There is a sense of knowing that this northern nation orbits its larger neighbor. There’s an unmentioned understanding that our greatest points of pride — indeed, or own sovereignty — can be swallowed by the behemoth.

Gretzky was Canada’s, until America inevitably claimed him.

Over the past decade, I’ve had several in-depth conversations with Gretzky. He was thoughtful, willing to reflect on all the joy and pain in his life. He spoke of Canada fondly, with a sincere sense of gratitude.

Gretzky did not respond to a text requesting to speak for this story.

In the past, we’ve chatted about the passion he showed at 2002 Olympics, and later about the death of his close friend and mentor Ace Bailey in the 9/11 terror attacks. We spoke about his late father, his family and his legacy in the game — for which Gretzky mostly deferred to the greatness of other players. I followed him as he crossed the field at Fenway Park during the NHL’s outdoor classic, as fans of all generations called out to him — “Wayne! Wayne! Gretzky! Gretzky!”

That aura follows Gretzky wherever he goes. For years, it seemed like that would always be the case. But now in Canada, for many people, the image of Gretzky as a revered symbol of national pride has faded. And that’s not because of his politics or where he chooses to live. It’s not even because of anything Gretzky has done himself. It’s because we know the myth was never real and that maybe it was never a fair standard to hold him to.

There was politicized criticism when images of Gretzky first emerged celebrating Trump’s election victory at Mar-a-Lago, and later when he attended the president’s inauguration. But that wasn’t what Canadians were really upset about. It was what came later, when Trump turned his focus to Canada — and Gretzky, the national hero, stayed silent.


Wayne Gretzky and his wife, Janet, attended U.S. President Donald Trump’s inauguration in January. (Kevin Lamarque / Pool / Getty Images)

Introduced as ambassador of the Canadian team inside TD Garden ahead of the 4 Nations Face-Off Final a few weeks ago — a best-on-best match between Canada and the U.S. — Gretzky walked out from the American side of the benches wearing a suit while acknowledging players from both teams. He was greeted with tepid applause and a smattering of boos. From the stands, it was hard to decipher whether the lukewarm response was directed at Gretzky or his role representing Canada. The crowd heavily favored the Americans, but about a third of the building supported the northern rivals. In calmer times, Gretzky’s entrance would have faced a passing degree of scrutiny and then would have been forgotten.

But these aren’t calm times north of the border. And when criticism swelled, fairly or not, Gretzky’s silence was interpreted as a statement.

Bobby Orr — another Canadian-born hockey icon — defended Gretzky in a letter published by the Toronto Sun, calling his Hall of Fame counterpart “one of the greatest Canadians ever.”

Gretzky has represented Canada as a player and an executive for decades, Orr wrote, criticizing “fickle” people who have turned on him for his personal beliefs.

“Wayne respects your rights and beliefs,” Orr wrote. “Why can’t you respect his?”

Janet Gretzky shared a message on Instagram thanking Orr for coming to her husband’s defense.

“I have never met anyone who is more proud to be Canadian and it has broken his heart to read and see mean comments. … He would do anything to make Canadians proud, with his love for hockey and his country.”

There hasn’t been an uproar about the silence of so many other Canadian-born celebrities who found their fame and fortune in the United States. But then, there aren’t any photos of them in a MAGA hat supporting the president who has called for the country to be annexed.

President Trump also chimed in, posting on social media that he doesn’t want Canadians to turn on Gretzky.

“He is the Greatest Canadian of them all, and I am therefore making him a ‘free agent,’ because I don’t want anyone in Canada to say anything bad about him,” Trump wrote.

“He supports Canada the way it is, as he should, even though it’s not nearly as good as it could be as part of the Greatest and Most Powerful Country in the World, the Good Ole’ U.S.A.!”

Those taunts were met with more silence from Gretzky and a stinging realization that hurts Canadians even more. In this moment of national upheaval, the Great One is on the opposite bench.

(Illustration: Demetrius Robinson / The Athletic. Photo: Saul Loeb-Pool via Imagn Images) 

NHL trade deadline winners and losers: Mikko Rantanen, Brad Marchand reshape Stanley Cup race

What the 2025 NHL trade deadline lacked in quantity, it made up for in quality. After all, it’s not often we have a prolonged drama like the Mikko Rantanen saga, which took several twists and turns before ending deep in the heart of Texas. And the Panthers’ stunning acquisition of Brad Marchand is one of the great buzzer-beaters in deadline history.

GO DEEPER

NHL trade deadline: Grading every deal completed this trade season

Now that the dust has settled — and knowing full well that the true winners and losers won’t be known until mid-June — let’s take a look at who improved the most, who took the biggest chances and who fell flat on their face on deadline day.


Winner: Florida Panthers

Imagine going up against a line with both Brad Marchand and Matthew Tkachuk on it. Good luck with that. Panthers GM Bill Zito made the most of the cap space Tkachuk’s groin injury opened up, snagging Marchand at the very last minute after adding Seth Jones earlier in the week.

Marchand might not be the 100-point player he was six years ago, but he’s still an excellent all-around player and one of the game’s all-time great pests. You can count on The Rat being showered with fake rats after a big win in South Florida at some point this spring. Both Marchand and Tkachuk are hurt right now, but both are expected back for the postseason, which is all that matters in Florida. And while Jones was overpaid as the Blackhawks’ No. 1 defenseman, he can be an outstanding No. 3 in Florida (and potential No. 2 going forward as Aaron Ekblad hits unrestricted free agency this summer), and at a more manageable $7 million cap hit with Chicago retaining $2.5 million for the next five seasons.

Winner: Mikko Rantanen

Rantanen was a member of the Carolina Hurricanes for about six weeks. He spent his first week on the road. He spent the next two weeks with Team Finland in Montreal and Boston. He had all of six home games in Raleigh. It’s entirely reasonable that he wasn’t ready to commit the next eight years of his life to a franchise and a city he barely knows. And that he was pushing for a nine-figure deal, complicating matters further.

Then Rantanen went and signed an eight-year deal with Dallas, a team for which he’s never played, a city in which he’s never lived. And for $96 million, less than Carolina reportedly offered. As if there were any doubt that teams in tax-free states had an inherent advantage over the rest of the league.

Rantanen had total control of his situation, so he must be happy with the deal or it wouldn’t have happened. While it would have been fun to see what someone like Rantanen could have gotten on the open market — players like him so rarely get to that point — he’s joining one of the best and best-run teams in the league, and he’s earning generational wealth to do so. How could you look at that as anything but a win?

Winner: Dallas Stars

Jim Nill has painted himself into something of a corner, handing $96 million to Rantanen with Tyler Seguin coming off long-term injured reserve (LTIR) and Jason Robertson, Wyatt Johnston and Thomas Harley all due significant raises in the next two years. Then there’s captain Jamie Benn, who is a pending unrestricted free agent. Whatever. He’ll get to that eventually, and given Nill’s history, he’ll surely make it all work. What matters is that this is now the Stanley Cup favorite, the best team in the NHL. Getting Rantanen — at significantly less than he’d get on the open market — is a massive coup for the Stars. The NHL’s center of gravity continues to shift south.

Loser: Carolina Hurricanes

There’s no spinning this as a positive for the Hurricanes. GM Eric Tulsky did well enough to salvage something tangible out of it — and if you go all the way back to the initial deal with Colorado, it might even be a net gain — but it’s a bad beat all the same. The Hurricanes gave up a premium talent with another year on a team-friendly contract in Martin Necas to acquire Rantanen, got 13 measly games out of him (won only seven of them), and then flipped him to Dallas for Logan Stankoven and two late first-round picks. Stankoven is an exciting young player, but will he even be at Necas’ level, let alone Rantanen’s? The fact is, this might have been Carolina’s best chance to break through in a wide-open Eastern Conference. Instead, they’re further from contention than they’ve been in years.

The Hurricanes broke from team tradition last year by getting Jake Guentzel as a rental, only to watch him leave for Tampa (another team in a tax-free state!). That apparently spooked Carolina enough that Rantanen’s ambivalence about Raleigh as a long-term home prompted this rather drastic course of action. It’s a shame. Rantanen’s production was subpar (six points in 13 games), but he was generating a massive amount of scoring chances. The goals were going to come, and Rantanen is a monster in the playoffs. Carolina could have gone for it, consequences be damned. Instead, the Hurricanes hedged and were left trying to make the best of a bad situation.

Winner: Mitch Marner

With Rantanen off the board, guess who’s the belle of the ball this summer in free agency? Get that bag, Mitch.

Winner: Colorado Avalanche

The trade deadline is typically an imperfect tool for filing holes, with teams scrambling and often settling to add something, anything, as the clock ticks down. There’s rarely a perfect fit out there for a team, and it’s even more rare for such a trade to happen. But Brock Nelson was the perfect fit for the Avalanche, giving them the second-line center they so clearly needed.

The price was high (a first-rounder and top prospect Calum Ritchie), and the Islanders can feel just as good about this deal as Colorado can. But the Avalanche can win the Stanley Cup this season. Nelson makes them that much better. Swapping Casey Mittelstadt for Charlie Coyle only helps. You won’t hear anyone complaining about the Avalanche’s lack of centers anymore.

Loser: Colorado Avalanche

Eight years, $96 million for Rantanen? That’s pretty much what the Avalanche reportedly offered him before they sent him to Carolina. There’s the tax-free aspect, obviously, but if Rantanen never wanted to leave and Colorado was willing to hit the same number, that initial trade to Carolina looks premature in hindsight.

Winner: Chicago Blackhawks

Trading Jones makes the Blackhawks worse; there’s no way around that fact. Yet again, it could get even worse before it gets better in Chicago. But Spencer Knight’s 41-save debut has Chicago fans feeling hope for the first time since the 2023 draft lottery, and it’s an undeniable victory for Kyle Davidson to only have to retain $2.5 million on Jones’ contract for the next five seasons.

With Jones forcing the issue and Chicago having no leverage, it seemed like a cap dump for futures with high retention was all the Blackhawks could hope for. Instead, they got a potential No. 1 goalie and a first-rounder, without an onerous retention. Unloading Petr Mrázek and landing a young, controllable, former first-rounder in Joe Veleno is a nice bonus that not only moves out a bad contract but averts an awkward three-goalie situation. Nice work by Davidson.

Loser: Chicago Blackhawks

Davidson, flush with cap space and desperate for a difference-maker up front, had his eye on Rantanen as an ideal linemate for Connor Bedard. Now that Rantanen is off the board, Davidson can only hope that Toronto doesn’t strike a deal with Marner — and that Marner’s up for a fixer-upper.

Winner: Tampa Bay Lightning

Some day, there will be a reckoning for Julien BriseBois and the Lightning, a day on which all their core players suddenly are tumbling down the aging curve and the cupboard is completely bare. But that day is not today.

Tampa has won 10 of its last 11 games and has muscled its way back into the true contender tier of the NHL. And when you have a chance to win, you go for it. BriseBois’ utter disregard for draft picks is almost comical at this point — Tampa has had one first-round pick in the last five drafts and has dealt away its 2025, 2026 and 2027 first-rounders (the last two with top-10 protection) — but it’s also absolutely the right attitude for a perennial contender.

Neither Yanni Gourde nor Oliver Bjorkstrand is a franchise-changing needle-mover, but the Lightning know as well as anybody that it’s those second-tier depth additions that often make the difference in the postseason.

Every hockey fan should want their team’s GM to think this way.

Loser: Buffalo Sabres

As they hurtle toward a 14th straight spring without a playoff appearance, the Sabres had to do something. And they did something. But they did something that doesn’t really change anything.

At best, swapping Dylan Cozens (and depth defenseman Dennis Gilbert) for Josh Norris (and depth defenseman Jacob Bernard-Docker) is a wash. At worst, it’s selling low on a player with a very high ceiling. That the Sabres sent a second-rounder to Ottawa for the privilege is baffling.

Instead of getting aggressive and truly remaking a talented but continually underperforming roster by dealing away the likes of Jason Zucker or even Alex Tuch, the Sabres are stuck running in place. And that place is last.

They are in the same position after the trade deadline as they were before the trade deadline — lost.

Winner: Toronto Maple Leafs

The Leafs didn’t have the splashiest deadline — at one point in the day, while chaos swirled, you wanted to poke Brad Treliving with a stick and see if he was still awake. But Scott Laughton and Brandon Carlo are sneaky good gets who make Toronto a better defensive team, first and foremost.

Laughton’s certainly an upgrade over Max Domi, who can shift to the wing. With the Flyers retaining half of Laughton’s salary, the Leafs get a reliable two-way, third-line center for two playoff runs at just a $1.5 million cap hit. And it didn’t cost them any of their top prospects or young players. Even the 2027 first-rounder is top-10 protected.

Laughton is good on the ice and great in the room. It’s not the most exciting move, but for a team that’s been done in by its lack of forward depth in previous postseasons, it’s a savvy one.

Loser: Vancouver Canucks

It sounds like there could be progress toward a Brock Boeser extension, but what are these Canucks? They’re not going for it, having traded J.T. Miller away earlier in the season and Carson Soucy to the Rangers for a third-rounder at the deadline. They’re not retooling, having held on to Boeser and Elias Pettersson. Their captain and best player is hurt, they’re on the periphery of the playoffs, and they seem to be going nowhere slowly.

Winner: San Jose Sharks

For absolutely nothing, Sharks GM Mike Grier got 50 solid games from Jake Walman, a second-round pick (from Detroit as a cap-dump sweetener last summer) and a first-round pick (from Edmonton for Walman on Thursday). Steve Yzerman could never.

Loser: Edmonton Oilers

Dallas went out and added the best player available in Rantanen and locked him up long-term. Colorado went out and added the top rental available in Nelson. Edmonton added a solid second-pair defenseman in Walman and a third-line forward in Trent Frederic. If this is an arms race, Edmonton is losing. The Oilers are the defending conference champion and were the preseason favorites to win it all. Now, they look like the fifth-best team in the West. It’s foolish to ever doubt Leon Draisaitl and Connor McDavid, but the Oilers have an uphill climb to get back to the Final.

(Illustration: Kelsea Petersen / The Athletic; Bill Wippert, Mike Stobe, Josh Lavellee / Getty Images)

NFL free agency 2025 predictions: One top target for every team

This is supposedly the NFL offseason, but if you’re feeling like you may be suffering from a case of whiplash, there’s a good reason for that.

The Super Bowl came and went on Feb. 9. Two weeks later, the NFL world descended on Indianapolis for the annual scouting combine. And next week, free agency kicks off.

Essentially, the action never stops in the NFL. As a result, multitasking is a crucial strength for general managers. By week’s end, front offices across the league will have finalized their game plan for free agency. Monday, at noon ET, the legal tampering period begins. Wednesday, the new league year begins at 4 p.m. ET.

The NFL salary cap is set at $279.2 million — a jump of roughly $24 million from last season — so every team will have some money to spend. How much varies on a case-by-case basis, and as a result, some teams will rely more heavily on the draft than free agency to fill holes, and others will go on spending sprees. Regardless, needs will be met next week. And so, we’re looking into our crystal ball and offering you one free-agent target prediction for every team.

Arizona Cardinals: Edge Haason Reddick

The 2017 Cardinals first-round pick is a free agent after a frustrating 2024, when he was traded from the Eagles to the Jets, who both declined to grant his wishes for a long-term contract extension. Now Reddick hits the open market, and his former team makes a lot of sense. The Cardinals need pass-rushing help after no player managed more than five sacks in 2024, and the team ranked 13th in this statistic. After a lengthy holdout, Reddick appeared in only 10 games for the Jets, starting two of them. But he recorded double-digit sacks in the four seasons prior and could fill a big need for Arizona.

Atlanta Falcons: Edge Khalil Mack

The Falcons ranked 31st in the league in sacks last season, with just 31. They need pass-rushing help in the worst way and would be wise to find help in this department in both free agency and the draft. Although not brimming with spending money, they need to find a way to free up some cash, and Mack — named to the Pro Bowl the last three seasons with the Chargers — would seemingly fit well.

Baltimore Ravens: FS Tre’von Moehrig

The Ravens have decisions to make with a number of their own players, including left tackle Ronnie Stanley, who is set to hit free agency. But as far as outside free agents go, they need help in their secondary, where a lack of speed and impact plays hampered their efforts. Moehrig would fill a big need at free safety after racking up 104 tackles, 10 pass breakups and two interceptions for the Raiders last season.

Buffalo Bills: WR Hollywood Brown

Easing pressure on Josh Allen is the name of the game, and the Bills need a field-stretching wideout to give their offense a greater home-run threat. Brown missed the bulk of last season with the Chiefs with injury, but now healthy again, he could provide a nice spark.

GO DEEPER

22 free agents who could help the Bills if Buffalo chooses to spend

Carolina Panthers: DT D.J. Jones

While Bryce Young displayed encouraging signs of growth, the Panthers remain a ways off from contention, and upgrading their defense is a high priority. Jones is among the most disruptive interior defensive linemen on the market, and he has ties to Panthers defensive coordinator Ejiro Evero from their time together in Denver. Jones would provide a veteran presence on a defense that is expected to feature multiple rookies next season.

Chicago Bears: C Drew Dalman

Positioning Caleb Williams for success is priority No. 1 for Ben Johnson and Ryan Poles, and based on the moves they made this week (trading for Rams lineman Jonah Jackson and Chiefs lineman Joe Thuney), supporting Williams begins with solidifying the offensive line. So look for the Bears’ new coach and fourth-year GM to work to further bolster this unit. A reliable center like Dalman would go a long way toward helping Williams find comfort in the pocket, and also would bolster a run game that can serve as a valuable security blanket for the second-year quarterback.

Cincinnati Bengals: G Brandon Scherff

Working out long-term extensions for Tee Higgins and Ja’Marr Chase are among the Bengals’ top offseason priorities. But Cincinnati also must further fortify its offensive line, especially following the cost-cutting release of guard Alex Cappa. A potential target: Scherff, the five-time Pro Bowl selection and fifth pick of the 2015 draft. After leaving Washington, Scherff battled injuries with Jacksonville. But when healthy, he’s a force in the trenches and would make life easier for Joe Burrow.

Cleveland Browns: QB Kirk Cousins

That’s IF the Falcons wind up cutting the 36-year-old Cousins now that they’re all-in on second-year pro Michael Penix Jr. Cousins makes so much sense for the Browns, who appear unlikely to have Deshaun Watson for some time because of the setback he experienced in his recovery from a torn Achilles tendon. Cousins played under Browns coach Kevin Stefanski when the latter was offensive coordinator in Minnesota and seemingly would be able to make a seamless transition to the Browns.


The Steelers declined Najee Harris’ fifth-year option. (Dale Zanine / Imagn Images)

Dallas Cowboys: RB Najee Harris

Jerry Jones committed malpractice by neglecting to address the running back position last offseason. Perhaps he has learned from his mistake and will devote resources to it now to give first-year head coach Brian Schottenheimer and quarterback Dak Prescott a better shot at success. Harris played in every game over the past four seasons for the Steelers, but Pittsburgh declined his fifth-year option. He rushed 263 times for 1,043 yards (4.0 average) and six touchdowns last season.

Denver Broncos: WR Amari Cooper

The Broncos badly want a veteran wide receiver to pair with second-year pro Bo Nix. With the Bengals taking Tee Higgins off the free-agent market by using the franchise tag on him for a second straight offseason, Cooper is among the best options available. The 30-year-old never seemed to fully settle in with Buffalo after a midseason trade, but he should fit well with Sean Payton’s offense.

Detroit Lions: Edge Azeez Ojulari

The Lions are hoping leading pass rusher Aidan Hutchinson makes a complete recovery from a fractured left tibia and fibula, but their defense could really use an impactful running mate for the fourth-year defensive end. Ojulari is a pass rusher who should come at a fairly affordable rate. He has played just one full season (an eight-sack rookie campaign in 2021), he has been used primarily in his career as a situational pass rusher and is coming off a toe injury that limited him to 11 games in 2024. Teaming Ojulari with Hutchinson could translate into a boost for Detroit.

Green Bay Packers: Edge Josh Sweat

Sweat made himself some money with his impactful performance for the Eagles in Super Bowl LIX. He’s expected to hit the open market, where he’ll draw a good bit of interest. The Packers have needed a difference-making pass rusher, and Sweat seemingly could step in and fill that void.

Houston Texans: WR Stefon Diggs

Diggs’ lone season with the Texans came to an abrupt end with a Week 8 torn ACL. He was putting up solid numbers (47 receptions for 496 yards and three touchdowns), so the Texans would do well to bring him back to help ensure continuity for C.J. Stroud. The Texans have plenty of needs and limited cap space, but Diggs would check a big box.

Indianapolis Colts: QB Daniel Jones

Jones’ time in New York ended with a late November release, and he spent the rest of 2024 learning from Kevin O’Connell while buried on the Vikings’ depth chart. Given the questions that still loom over Anthony Richardson, the Colts will look to add another quarterback, and Jones makes some sense. He will not break the bank, and after coming in and initially learning behind Richardson, the 2019 first-round pick could wind up earning playing time as an experimental starter should Richardson continue to struggle.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Aaron Rodgers to Giants? Justin Fields to Jets? QB predictions for every NFL team

Jacksonville Jaguars: G Mekhi Becton

The Jaguars have hit the reset button once again, hiring rookie head coach Liam Coen and first-year general manager James Gladstone. Getting the most out of Trevor Lawrence is the key to success, and the Jaguars know they have to upgrade the interior of their offensive line. Becton, who just helped the Eagles win the Super Bowl, would fill a key need.

Kansas City Chiefs: LT Ronnie Stanley

The Eagles made it abundantly clear in Super Bowl LIX the Chiefs need to upgrade Patrick Mahomes’ offensive line. After utilizing a patchwork line in 2024, look for Kansas City to devote resources in free agency and the draft to solidify the unit. Stanley, who has spent his entire career with the Ravens and just made his second Pro Bowl appearance, would give Mahomes a reliable blind-side protector.

L.A. Chargers: C Ryan Kelly

Like last season, general manager Joe Hortiz and coach Jim Harbaugh are expected to take a conservative approach to spending in free agency. They do, however, need to solidify the heart of their line, and Kelly — a four-time Pro Bowl selection, who has spent his entire career with the Colts — could help them do that.

L.A. Rams: WR Davante Adams

With the Rams working to trade Cooper Kupp, Sean McVay and Matthew Stafford will need another target to pair with Puka Nacua. Adams is now available after the Jets released him on Tuesday. The six-time Pro Bowl wideout still has plenty left in the tank, and McVay boasts the creativity needed to maximize Adams’ skill set.

Las Vegas Raiders: QB Russell Wilson

After a failed pursuit of Matthew Stafford, the Raiders will turn their attention to another veteran quarterback who can serve as a bridge to their future. Pete Carroll and Wilson spent 10 seasons together in Seattle, so a reunion makes a lot of sense. The Raiders could then decide whether to draft a quarterback or wait for a more robust draft class in 2026 to find Wilson’s successor.

Miami Dolphins: S Talanoa Hufanga

The Dolphins seem likely to lose Jevon Holland to free agency, so that will leave defensive coordinator Anthony Weaver in need of a difference-making safety. Hufanga has battled some injuries, but when healthy is as impactful as they come, having garnered All-Pro and Pro Bowl honors in 2022 (his last healthy season).


Sam Darnold could remain with the Vikings despite their decision not to franchise-tag him. (Mark J. Rebilas / Imagn Images)

Minnesota Vikings: QB Sam Darnold

The Vikings opted against franchise-tagging Darnold, which subjects them to the risk of losing the quarterback to free agency. But they should still do what it takes to bring him back for another season. Doing so would give them a chance to build on last season’s success rather than risk taking steps backward if J.J. McCarthy isn’t ready after missing all of last season with a torn meniscus.

New England Patriots: DT Milton Williams

The Patriots have plenty of needs as they try to surround second-year quarterback Drake Maye with a quality supporting cast. But look for defensive-minded coach Mike Vrabel to stress fortifying that side of the ball as well by adding impact players to dominate in the trenches. Williams, who just helped the Eagles win the Super Bowl, could rank among the centerpieces of the defense.

New Orleans Saints: WR Darius Slayton

Derek Carr needs another weapon and the steady Slayton, who has averaged 720 receiving yards and four touchdowns a season, with 15 yards per catch, could fit nicely as a sidekick to Chris Olave while giving new coach Kellen Moore’s offense additional firepower.

New York Giants: QB Aaron Rodgers

It’s hard to say how appealing the Giants would be to Rodgers, because they seemingly have a ways to go before they are ready to contend. But the Giants certainly need a quarterback after ending the Daniel Jones experiment last season and swinging and missing at Matthew Stafford. Could Rodgers be the answer? A young receiver like Malik Nabers does make New York a little more attractive.

New York Jets: QB Carson Wentz

The Jets have Tyrod Taylor still under contract, but look for them to bring in another midlevel veteran for competition given that they seem unlikely to have a shot at drafting a top-flight quarterback. Wentz spent last season behind Patrick Mahomes and while not a franchise savior, he could compete for bridge duty.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Seven years later, Carson Wentz’s mind still wanders

Philadelphia Eagles: Edge Baron Browning

The Eagles have some of the best interior linemen in the game, but with Josh Sweat expected to depart via free agency, they need to add more help off the edge. Howie Roseman could look to both the draft and free agency to meet needs here. Browning is a young player (26) who has a history with Vic Fangio, having played under the Eagles’ defensive coordinator when Fangio was head coach in Denver.

Pittsburgh Steelers: QB Justin Fields

The Steelers used 2024 as an experimental season at quarterback, adding both Russell Wilson and Fields. Now both will become free agents. The Steelers should bring Fields back. Is he a finished product? Not at all. But he’s only 26, showed promise and will only ascend given another year working with Arthur Smith and in a system designed specifically for his strengths. Could the Steelers give Aaron Rodgers a shot? Sure. Could they try another experimental quarterback like Daniel Jones? Sure. But the upside with Fields is far higher.

San Francisco 49ers: CB D.J. Reed

The 49ers could wind up losing Charvarius Ward to free agency, so John Lynch and Kyle Shanahan may place a high priority on addressing the secondary. Reed makes a lot of sense. He spent the last three seasons with the Jets, playing under Robert Saleh, now the 49ers defensive coordinator, and should be able to make a seamless transition while serving as the lockdown corner San Francisco needs.

Seattle Seahawks: S Jevon Holland

The Seahawks are expected to maintain their usual conservative approach in free agency, but they need a veteran presence on the back end of their defense. Holland would help fill this need, bringing both versatility and aggressive playmaking. After playing under Anthony Weaver in Miami last season, Holland would see some carryover playing in the system of Mike Macdonald, under whom Weaver coached in Baltimore.


Charvarius Ward has discussed the emotional challenges of playing in California. (Mark J. Rebilas / Imagn Images)

Tampa Bay Buccaneers: CB Charvarius Ward

The Buccaneers have a strong defensive front anchored by Vita Vea, but they really could benefit from adding a top-flight cornerback like Ward. He seems likely to depart San Francisco after a trying 2024, which included the death of his 1-year-old daughter, and could potentially benefit from a change of scenery.

Tennessee Titans: QB Marcus Mariota

Let’s face it: Will Levis is not the answer. And because they own the top pick in the draft, the Titans can fill their need for a franchise quarterback. But whether it’s Cam Ward or Shedeur Sanders, the rookie of choice could take some time to develop. The smart move: Bring back former face of the franchise Marcus Mariota (2015-19) to serve as the bridge or as a valuable veteran mentor (similar to what he did last season with Jayden Daniels) to help a young QB navigate the pro game.

Washington Commanders: Edge DeMarcus Lawrence

Edge rusher is one of the biggest needs on Washington’s defense and Lawrence can help in a big way. Lawrence, who played under Dan Quinn in Dallas from 2021 to 2023 and reached the Pro Bowl in back-to-back seasons, has averaged 7.4 sacks per season during his 11-year career. He’s coming off a season limited by a foot injury to four games, but now healthy again, Lawrence would make his presence felt in D.C.

(Illustration: Dan Goldfarb / The Athletic; photos of D.J. Reed, Josh Sweat and Russell Wilson: Nick Cammett / Diamond Images, Cooper Neill, Todd Rosenberg / Getty Images)

What teams think of the 2025 Club World Cup: Opportunity, concerns and financial benefits

The expanded Club World Cup begins in 100 days, with the 32-team tournament taking place in the United States from June 14.

It is the first time the club edition of the World Cup will mirror the national team version of the tournament. There have been worries about the additional workload on players — FIFPro and the World Leagues Association threatened legal action in May last year. There are also concerns over high ticket prices.

FIFA announced there will be $1billion (£775m) in prize money for the Club World Cup, which will be distributed among all 32 clubs. FIFA president Gianni Infantino said, “All revenue generated by the tournament will be distributed to the participating clubs and via club solidarity across the world, as FIFA will not keep a single dollar.”

So how do the clubs themselves feel about the tournament? The Athletic has approached teams and senior figures at clubs for their perspective on the competition. Fifteen of the teams involved responded to our enquiries. Unless otherwise noted, those spoken to did so under the condition of anonymity as they did not have permission to speak.

Here, we share their perspectives on the Club World Cup.


Chelsea (England)

Chelsea have been taking the tournament seriously for a long time.

The first indication was the decision to part ways last May with head coach Mauricio Pochettino because they did not want any uncertainty over the role going into the Club World Cup. Pochettino was given only a two-year deal with an option for another 12 months in 2023. His replacement, Enzo Maresca, was handed a five-year deal.

Senior players who departed on loan in the January window, including Joao Felix and Renato Veiga, have clauses that mean they can return before it begins (loan agreements normally last until June 30), giving Chelsea the strongest squad possible.

Chelsea have not agreed a front-of-shirt sponsor for this season but believe being on display in America can help their bargaining position in ongoing talks with interested parties. They also see it as a genuinely good opportunity to win some silverware.

Simon Johnson


Seattle Sounders (U.S.)

The Sounders look at the Club World Cup as a “generational” opportunity. After playing in the 2022 Club World Cup in Morocco, Seattle see this tournament as a showcase for the city, the fanbase and the club.

With a chance to play in front of their home supporters against Atletico Madrid and Paris Saint-Germain, the Sounders believe it’s a rare opportunity to showcase themselves as a marquee franchise in MLS and one of the top clubs in the Americas.

Seattle will also host several games at the 2026 World Cup, including a U.S. men’s national team group-stage game, and believe the tournaments are a chance to advertise the city’s support for soccer across the globe. In a way, it’s putting the Sounders in the shop window for potential players and new fans.

Paul Tenorio


Al Ahly (Egypt)

Al Ahly are looking forward to the tournament and want to present themselves to a wider audience, especially considering they will open the tournament against Inter Miami.

The record 12-time CAF Champions League winners want to face the best teams in the world and view the Club World Cup as an opportunity to test themselves against different opponents on the global stage — similar to the previous versions of the competition where they finished in third place on four occasions. It’s also a learning experience off the field as the tournament will allow the club to interact and connect with teams from around the world.


Al Ahly celebrate winning the CAF Champions League (Fadel Senna/AFP via Getty Images)

Participating in the Club World Cup is viewed as a crowning of Al Ahly’s domestic and continental achievements in the past couple of years.

Even if their chances of winning the whole thing are slim, they are heading to the U.S. to do their best.

Ahmed Walid


Wydad AC (Morocco)

For Wydad, the Club World Cup represents an opportunity in many ways. The first and most obvious is money: last year, 30 per cent of their revenue came from participating in the CAF Champions League, but this year they didn’t qualify, so a financial gap needed to be filled. The roughly $50million (£39m) they will earn just for participating in the Club World Cup will plug that gap and then some.

That money will, they hope, allow them to close the gap slightly with European teams on player trading. If they negotiate with a potential signing and a European team made any kind of offer, they simply couldn’t compete. With this additional income, they hope this will change. They look to the basketball arm of their club, which can attract American players because there is less of a financial disparity between them and some European clubs.

Interestingly, they could also parlay their appearance at the Club World Cup into a conversation about being part of a multi-club ownership group. To this point, European-based models, such as Red Bull or City Football Group, have mostly shown little interest in acquiring an African club for a variety of reasons — sporting, economic, organisational — but the hope is that a decent showing at this tournament might make them more attractive as a takeover target.

Nick Miller


Mamelodi Sundowns (South Africa)

When Sundowns goalkeeper Ronwen Williams was nominated for the Yashin Award at the Ballon d’Or ceremony in 2024, he told The Athletic that the Club World Cup “…can help people realise the gap isn’t quite as big as it seems”.

He wasn’t referring to non-Africans. Instead, he believes the competition can help players from his continent realise how talented they are.

To say Williams is excited about travelling to the United States is an understatement. “We can’t wait to be a part of it, to try to open doors for African football,” he said.

Sundowns have become one of the most talked-about clubs in Africa over the past decade due to investment from mining tycoon Patrice Motsepe, who is also the president of the Confederation of African Football (CAF). While the club have won nine of the last 11 South African Premiership titles, they have only lifted one CAF Champions League trophy, back in 2016.

The Club World Cup has been high on their agenda for some time, with weekly meetings centred on media engagement and ticketing.

The U.S. gives Sundowns the opportunity to globalise their brand in new markets. With a significant African diaspora in the U.S., Sundowns hope to engage new fans who can identify with the club’s story as well as the abilities of their players.

Simon Hughes


Palmeiras (Brazil)

Palmeiras are still waiting on clarity for certain elements of the tournament — like how the prize money will be distributed. But they are understanding, given it is the first edition of the tournament, and they have been impressed by how quickly FIFA have responded to their other queries.

The club view it as an important tournament both in sporting and marketing terms, given the global visibility. They are aiming to make the most of the opportunity commercially and have worked on their squad in a bid to go far in the tournament.

Mario Cortegana


Fluminense (Brazil)

Fluminense lost 4-0 against Manchester City in the final of the Club World Cup in 2023 but are animated by the opportunity to test themselves against other global heavyweights.

The club do not expect a huge surge in sponsorship income — there are strict rules governing the number of brand logos visible on shirts, for instance — but expect to reap more indirect benefits from increased international brand recognition.


Fluminense will be competing in the tournament (Buda Mendes/Getty Images)

The prospect of a showpiece match against Borussia Dortmund, plus the realistic possibility that Fluminense will progress from a fairly weak group (Sundowns and South Korean side Ulsan are their other opponents), also proved to be a big draw with transfer targets in the last Brazilian off-season.

Jack Lang


Botafogo (Brazil)

“It has been many years since Botafogo have competed on a global stage,” John Textor, the majority owner and chairman of Eagle Football Holdings Limited, Botafogo’s leading shareholder, tells The Athletic. “So the chance to play the best teams in the world, in the biggest media market in the world, is incredibly important as we try to reestablish our reputation among the world’s greatest clubs.

“Our fans are excited, too, for these very same reasons. Our club is known as ‘the most traditional’ and ‘the glorious’ based on its historic reputation as a ‘grandfather’ of Brazilian football, so they have yearned for the return of our club to a position of global prominence. We are just starting to rebuild that reputation, forgotten for many years, and this opportunity in the United States is the first step. Truth be told, our fans will expect much more. They expect us to win.

“It’s a huge story in Brazil. Four big clubs, all participating against the best in the world… it’s been many years since Brazil has seen such an opportunity.”

Matt Slater


Flamengo (Brazil)

Jose Boto, Flamengo’s director of football, told The Athletic: “Flamengo views the creation of the new Club World Cup with great enthusiasm and congratulates FIFA for this initiative, which is a milestone in the evolution of global football. Bringing together the best clubs in the world in an innovative format is a great step towards further strengthening club football and providing a unique experience for players and fans.

“For us, it is an honour and a privilege to have the opportunity to represent Brazil and South American football at this event. We are confident that the United States, with its world-class sporting infrastructure, will offer modern and optimal facilities for the competition, providing all the necessary conditions for a tournament of the highest level.

“The history of hosting major events, such as the 1994 World Cup and various editions of the Olympic Games, is a benchmark of attendance and public enthusiasm on U.S. soil. In addition, the proximity of the 2026 World Cup further reinforces the interest and growth of football in the region.

“We believe this edition of the Club World Cup will be an absolute success, both in terms of infrastructure and audience, further consolidating football as a truly global phenomenon.”

Mario Cortegana


Manchester City (England)

City are embracing the revamped format and the chance to add a new trophy to their collection.

Although more games seem to be the last thing they need this season, the money involved appeals to the more financially minded members of the hierarchy, while Guardiola’s stance is similar to his outlook on pre-season tours: he and his players will go wherever the club need them to.

Once they’re there, they’ll try to win.

Sam Lee


Real Madrid (Spain)

The board at Real Madrid are generally in favour of the Club World Cup, but president Florentino Perez, head coach Carlo Ancelotti and some players have highlighted their concerns over the calendar. They were also surprised by how late the dates were confirmed, along with venues and who they would face.

However, they issued a statement in June last year after Ancelotti expressed his doubts in an interview: “At no time has Real Madrid questioned its participation in the new Club World Cup to be organised by FIFA. Our club will play, as planned, this official competition that we face with pride to make our millions of fans around the world dream again with a new title.”


Madrid are the Champions League holders (Thomas Coex/AFP via Getty Images)

Despite their doubts, they consider the tournament to be very important for marketing and finances. If they win the final, it could be worth around €100million (£84m; $108m) to them. Madrid also have a good relationship with FIFA.

Since the pandemic, all of Real’s pre-seasons have taken place in the U.S. and it is undoubtedly the market that attracts and interests them the most.

Mario Cortegana


Bayern Munich (Germany)

Bayern are really popular in the U.S. and are looking forward to spending time directly with their fans and fan groups over there — they have offices in America, so there’s a big opportunity to show their best face in a competitive environment. Given German football’s restrictions and the staging of competitive games abroad being a non-starter, this is a rare chance to do something different.

There is some trepidation about the tournament’s popularity and a bit of bewilderment over the timing of their games — a couple of them kick off at 3am CEST, which hardly suits their domestic fans. There have already been murmurs of discontent from ultra groups in response to that scheduling as well as some of the exorbitant ticket prices being charged.

Bayern are braced for tension. Playing in front of long-distance fans is one thing, but taking competitive matches away from season ticket holders and pricing them out of attending is a new issue for German football and one that will not be resolved quietly.

Sebastian Stafford-Bloor


Paris Saint-Germain (France)

Sources close to the hierarchy at Paris Saint-Germain admit the organisation behind the Club World Cup has not been perfect, but they think it is a positive for football’s ecosystem. There is also a belief that it would be the wrong tournament to target over workload concerns. The Club World Cup already exists — it is only being revamped — and it is only going to run every four years.

There is also positivity over the deal with DAZN and the addition of new commercial partners — and the potential redistribution of money from the tournament. For PSG, the income will be significantly higher than what would be generated from a pre-season tour.

However, there are concerns over filling the stadiums in the U.S. Sources at PSG hope there will be a significant push — possibly even involving President Donald Trump — to shift tickets before the tournament kicks off. In all, it is viewed by those close to the hierarchy as a potential cherry on the cake for the season.

Mario Cortegana


Borussia Dortmund (Germany)

Financially, the Club World Cup comes at a convenient time for Dortmund. They sit 10th in the Bundesliga and only have an outside hope of playing Champions League football — and benefiting from its riches — next season. The payday FIFA is promising the participating clubs will be invaluable, then, particularly with the squad due to undergo a major rebuild in the summer

Socially, it’s an opportunity. Dortmund are among a group of clubs at the top of German football who believe that the domestic game should be doing more to grow itself and that other teams in the division should be spending more time in fertile markets, including the United States. And, given there is no hope at all of ever playing Bundesliga games outside Germany — fan power makes that impossible — this will be as close as the club gets to being able to export an authentic version of themselves.

How successful will the tournament be? The club are not sure. Kick-off times are inconvenient for German supporters and it’s unclear what kind of traction the competition will have with U.S. supporters.

One strange technical detail to add: Chelsea midfielder Carney Chukwuemeka is on loan at Dortmund, but that deal — provided it is not made permanent — will expire between the end of the Bundesliga season and the start of this tournament. He has started promisingly in Germany, with a few exciting cameos, but that may not be relevant in Dortmund by the summer.

Sebastian Stafford-Bloor


Atletico Madrid (Spain)

The Club World Cup is seen as a big opportunity — on lots of different levels.

Senior figures at Atletico were very proud to have qualified, especially qualifying ahead of Barcelona as one of the two clubs involved from La Liga, and believe it demonstrates the club is part of the European elite.


Atletico see the Club World Cup as a big opportunity (Denis Doyle/Getty Images)

Last summer’s €200million investment in new players — including €75m for Argentine World Cup winner Julian Alvarez and €42m on England international Conor Gallagher — was also made knowing that a deep squad would be required for what was going to be a very long season for Diego Simeone’s side.

Club CEO Miguel Angel Gil Marin and president Enrique Cerezo attended December’s draw in Miami and Atletico are very keen to promote the club brand in the U.S., having visited in pre-season regularly in recent summers.

Gil Marin and Cerezo will probably sell their majority stake within the next five years. Atletico are part-owned by U.S. investment manager Ares Management Corporation, which increased its share last summer. Winning a prestigious international tournament on American soil would make the club even more valuable to interested buyers.

Dermot Corrigan


Red Bull Salzburg (Austria)

The club’s individual approach might be better reflected through the prism of the Red Bull network as a whole, for whom the U.S. is a big footballing focus.

Last summer, RB Leipzig were delighted with the reception they received around their games in New York and Miami, where they played Aston Villa and Wolverhampton Wanderers and held a range of coaching seminars and activation events. It was the first time the club had toured outside Europe and given the ideological opposition and cynicism they face domestically, the U.S. sports culture — combined with Red Bull’s existing presence in MLS and across international sport — is an easier environment in which to operate.

Expect Salzburg to embrace those opportunities in much the same way. They have not had an easy season and might not be much of a factor in the tournament itself — a group with Al Hilal, Pachuca and Real Madrid looks tough — but there’s plenty of enthusiasm about exporting the brand.

Sebastian Stafford-Bloor


Inter Miami (United States)

Since signing Lionel Messi, owner Jorge Mas has spoken about the club’s ambition to become a global brand. The worldwide proliferation of pink Inter Miami jerseys is a testament to the progress made.

The Club World Cup offers a chance to put the actual soccer product on a stage for the world to see.

“It’s a difficult group that presents challenges, but I am very hopeful to compete,” Mas said last year. “A good tournament for the team would be to make it out of the group stage and compete. Our first objective is to make it out of the group stage and then compete with those who qualify to the next round.”

Messi acknowledged the value of the tournament for a league and a team that are still trying to gain respect in the eyes of the world.

“This is very important for the club, especially, to participate for the first time in a World Cup that will take place in the country and for MLS to have two teams is a wonderful thing,” Messi said in an interview with Apple Music. “Everything that’s happening creates an opportunity for MLS to keep growing in football, as a league, and for other players to have the opportunity to come and keep growing.

“Football is different from the sports they are accustomed to watching in the U.S. and it should be managed differently. It’s a different sport and this is an opportunity to change the chip, to shift, and for MLS to continue maturing.”

Paul Tenorio

(Top photo: Brennan Asplen/Getty Images)

Naomi Osaka calls Indian Wells loss to Camila Osorio the worst match she has ever played

Naomi Osaka showed that she is on the road to recovery from the abdominal injury that forced her out of the Australian Open in January, but getting sharp and match tough is going to take a little more time.

Osaka, the four-time Grand Slam champion and former world No. 1, lost to Camila Osorio of Colombia, the world No. 53, in straight sets Wednesday night (6-4, 6-4) in the first round of Indian Wells. On social media, she later described the defeat as the “worst match I’ve ever played in my life.”

Osaka, ranked 56th, and Osorio were dead even through the first eight games, but Osaka committed a flurry of errors while serving at 4-4. It gave Osorio the chance to serve out the set, and the spunky Colombian didn’t waste it.

The game was a microcosm of the match. Osaka committed errors every which way. Balls flew long and wide. Some missed by a few inches. Others missed by a few feet.

The errors were especially prevalent when Osaka was under pressure. Osaka and Patrick Mouratoglou, her coach since September, focused on that dynamic for months and seemed to have made headway as Osaka got on a roll at the start of the year.

Osaka made the finals in Auckland and was rolling against Clara Tauson when she aggravated an abdominal injury and had to retire after the first set. Osaka played some of her best tennis since her return from maternity leave at the beginning of 2024 through 2 1/2 matches at the Australian Open, including a win over Karolina Muchova, one of the world’s top players.

Then, Osaka strained the muscle again and had to retire from her third-round match with Belinda Bencic after the first set. She had dominated Bencic until the injury.

Osaka returned to California and rested. But she had two hard weeks of training ahead of Indian Wells, and Mouratoglou pronounced her ready to go. Physically, perhaps, but the tennis just wasn’t there.

“It’s crazy for me, a dream come true,” said Osorio, 23, who had never won a match in Indian Wells. Her win marked the first time a woman from Colombia has beaten a former world No. 1.

For Osaka, who won Indian Wells in 2018, the loss allows her to rest before she heads to the Miami Open, one of the events closest to her heart and near where she grew up in South Florida. After her defeat, Osaka confirmed that her body is fit, but her form just was not there.

“I don’t think I was too good on my end,” she said in her news conference.

She described a frustrating month after the Australian Open in which she was not allowed to play for a week, could not serve for another week, then was allowed to slowly begin serving but only if she slowly increased her intensity week by week so as not to reinjure her abdominal muscle.

“I did well in Australia,” she said. “It feels a little bit like stopping starting again.”

That said, even with the loss, Osaka said her start to the year feels far better than last year, when she struggled to find any consistency. Or maybe she’s getting used to the idea she will likely never have a smooth ride back to the top of the sport.

“It feels like a bump in the road,” she said. “I don’t feel like I played well at all, but I still feel like I had so many chances to be in the match.”

Required reading

(Photo: Clive Brunskill / Getty Images)

Ranking 40 years of men’s NCAA Tournament champions, from 2024 UConn to 1985 Villanova

This article is part of our Rankings & Tiers series, an evaluation across sport about the key players, front offices, teams, franchises and much more.

What better way to commemorate the 40-year anniversary of the NCAA Tournament’s expansion to 64 teams than to create a flawless, universally beloved ranking of every men’s basketball champion in that era?

That is, of course, impossible, but I took a stab at it nonetheless. For such a monumental task, I tried to tether myself to some objective guideposts, creating a numerical scoring system as a starting point. Multiple factors went into those scores:

  1. Seed – No. 1 seeds received the most points. If you’re among the best teams ever, you’d likely have earned a top seed in your given year.
  2. Regular season champions – It seems reasonable to say that if a team was one of the all-time greats, it would have been the best in its conference and won the regular season title. Half credit was given for sharing the crown.
  3. Conference tournament champions – Winning this event earned an extra bonus. Teams that did not have a chance to play a conference tournament (some of the older Big Ten and Pac-10/Pac-12 squads) received half credit.
  4. Overall win percentage – This one was pretty simple. The fewer losses, the better.
  5. Difficulty of NCAA Tournament path – Teams that faced a more challenging path (based on the sum of seeds played) were given a slight reward.
  6. Dominance of NCAA run – I summed each team’s total margin of victory over six NCAA Tournament games to approximate their dominance. The higher the margin, the better.
  7. Talent – This measure was by far the most subjective. Was this roster loaded with stars and future NBA standouts? Or was it more of a strong college team without much shine beyond the title run?

Obviously, this entire system can be debated. There are no adjustments for the strength of a particular conference, so winning a loaded ACC is treated the same as winning a watered-down Big Ten.

But combining all of those factors led me to what I believe is a reasonable and defensible list. The best of the best separated themselves with their season-long dominance and emphatic victories in the NCAA Tournament, resulting in two top tiers of all-time greats.

A last note to all of the terrific teams of the 2019-20 season (I’m talking to you, Kansas and Dayton and San Diego State and Michigan State and Gonzaga and Baylor): You may insert yourself into this list wherever you see fit. That’s the beauty of the imagination.

Tier 5: Proof that March is mad

39. 1985 Villanova

Rollie Massimino’s incredible underdog story certainly got the expansion era off to a stirring start. In the first year with a 64-team field, No. 8 seed Villanova went on an incredible run through March and April, beating two No. 1 seeds and two No. 2 seeds in one of the most incredible Cinderella title runs in the event’s history.

That run culminated in a monumental upset of Patrick Ewing-led Georgetown in the title game, during which the Wildcats shot an absurd 78.6 percent from the field, knocking off the larger-than-life Hoyas with patience and efficiency.

Of course, the 1985 Wildcats are remembered more for the long odds of their run than for their dominance, which is how they ended up last in these rankings. They remain the worst seed (No. 8) to win the NCAA title in the 64-team era, and their combined winning margin — just 30 points in six games — is also the lowest ever since the expansion. Their overall winning percentage (71.4 percent) is the second-worst ever, narrowly ahead of 1988 Kansas (71.1).

So while Massimino’s miracle squad may bring up the rear in this particular list, the 1985 Wildcats remain one of the most storied examples of the magic of March Madness.

38. 2014 UConn

Three years after Cardiac Kemba carried UConn to a national title, his old sidekick Shabazz Napier similarly put the team on his back. He certainly had some help — Ryan Boatright and DeAndre Daniels each had some big moments — but this was Napier’s team, through and through.

The Huskies finished tied for third in the inaugural version of the American Athletic Conference, and they lost in the title game of the AAC tournament. They needed overtime just to escape an opening round NCAA Tournament matchup with Saint Joseph’s. They were led by Kevin Ollie, almost inarguably the most shocking NCAA champion coach of the past 40 years.

They did, however, face one of the toughest paths to a title ever, in part because they started as a No. 7 seed. En route to a championship, Ollie defeated Hall of Fame coaches Jay Wright, Tom Izzo, Billy Donovan and John Calipari. This Husky run was truly a lightning-in-a-bottle moment.

GO DEEPER

The March of UConn: At the top, on the edge and really uncomfortable

37. 1988 Kansas

Danny and the Miracles, as 1988 Kansas is now known, have some of the strongest branding of any title winner. Danny Manning carried a relatively anonymous supporting cast through the postseason, racking up 27.2 points per game in the Jayhawks’ six NCAA Tournament games.

Despite being an unheralded contender, Kansas stunningly took down two top-five teams, Duke and Oklahoma, at the Final Four. The Jayhawks had gone 0-3 against those squads during the regular season.

Though the Jayhawks’ run to a title was undoubtedly one of the more magical and captivating March moments ever, this team was clearly lacking relative to other champs. Kansas lost 11 games, finished third in the Big Eight and lost in the semifinals of the Big Eight Tournament. It was also one of the lowest seeds (No. 6) to ever win it all.

36. 1997 Arizona

Arizona’s claim to fame (aside from being the last Pac-10/Pac-12 school to win a title) is that it is the only team in the 64-team era to beat three different No. 1 seeds en route to a championship. Lute Olsen’s Wildcats bled out the sport’s bluebloods, knocking off Kansas, UNC and Kentucky on their surprising run.

Obviously, that feat is impossible for No. 1 seeds to accomplish (they can only play two others in a single tournament), but it is still impressive.

The Wildcats were young but loaded with talent in the backcourt. Mike Bibby and Jason Terry both developed into lottery picks, Michael Dickerson was also a first-round pick, and Miles Simon averaged 18 points per game and won Most Outstanding Player at the Final Four. Oh, and freshman walk-on/future head coach and ESPN analyst Josh Pastner was on this team, too!

It’s hard to rank Arizona much higher than this, though. The Wildcats finished fifth in the Pac-10 and lost nine games overall.

35. 2011 UConn

Jim Calhoun’s “worst” title team at UConn, the 2011 Huskies had a roller-coaster season. At the heart of everything was Kemba Walker, who went on one of the most incredible March heaters ever seen. “Cardiac Kemba” and his Huskies went 14-0 in tournament settings that year: 3-0 at the Maui Invitational, an astonishing 5-0 in five days at the Big East tournament (featuring an iconic Kemba stepback game winner) and, of course, 6-0 in the NCAA Tournament.

Despite Walker’s brilliance (and some help from second-in-command Jeremy Lamb), UConn had some major flaws in its profile. The Huskies went just 9-9 in the Big East, losing seven of their final 11 regular season games. They were barely even ranked (No. 21 in the AP Poll) entering the Big East tournament.

Additionally, 2011 UConn also played arguably the ugliest national championship game in history, a 53-41 rock fight against Butler in which the two teams combined to go 10 of 44 (22.7 percent) from beyond the arc. That did not factor into this ranking, but maybe it should have.

34. 1989 Michigan

No champion of the last 40 years had a stranger coaching situation than the 1989 Wolverines. Just prior to the start of the NCAA Tournament, head coach Bill Frieder announced he would take the Arizona State coaching job at the conclusion of the season.

Legendary Michigan football coach Bo Shembechler, the athletic director at the time, swiftly dismissed Frieder and declared that “A Michigan man will coach Michigan!” Lead assistant Steve Fisher took over and led the Wolverines on a dramatic run to the national title.

Michigan squeaked by Illinois 83-81 in the national semifinal and then edged Seton Hall 80-79 in overtime for the championship. The Wolverines also finished just third in the Big Ten regular season standings; the dominance just is not there to rank highly on a list like this.

The wild coaching storyline overshadowed a talented roster led by eventual three-time NBA All-Star Glen Rice, who parlayed the national title into the No. 4 pick in the NBA Draft. Three other Wolverine champions were selected in the first round the following year, though none of that trio made the same kind of professional impact as Rice.

Lowest-seeded champs of 64-team bracket

Year Team Seed

1985

8

2014

7

1988

6

2023

4

1997

4

Tier 4: Memorable, but not elite

33. 2006 Florida

After a disappointing 5-6 stretch in January/February that doomed the Gators to third place in the SEC standings, they went on a tear in both the SEC and NCAA tournaments.

Joakim Noah emerged as a national icon, a boisterous winner who dominated the paint along with frontcourt bash brother Al Horford. Corey Brewer was another future pro, and the backcourt of Taurean Green and Lee Humphrey filled their roles perfectly.

Florida’s handling of No. 1 seed Villanova in the Elite Eight emphatically announced the Gators’ arrival on the national stage. They did, however, benefit from getting to play two No. 11 seeds en route to the title, including Cinderella story George Mason in the Final Four.

Ultimately, 2006 Florida’s most noteworthy legacy is that it became 2007 Florida. Every key piece returned, and the 2007 version was clearly a “leveled up” edition of the reigning national champs.

32. 2023 UConn

This UConn squad is remembered most for its thorough drubbing of every opponent in its path. In an upset-filled NCAA Tournament, no opponent came within 13 points of the eventual national champion Huskies.

Their most impressive performance was a 28-point destruction of Drew Timme’s Gonzaga to reach the Final Four, en route to a combined margin of victory of 120 over six Tournament games, the fifth-highest total of the last 40 years.

This team was only a No. 4 seed, though, and the Huskies did not win the Big East regular season title nor even make the Big East tournament final. They lost six of eight games in late December/January and were one of just five champs to win less than 80 percent of their games, and they did not beat a No. 1 or No. 2 seed in their route to the championship.

Of course, this roster was the breeding ground for 2024’s juggernaut. Donovan Clingan flashed his incredible impact as a highly useful reserve, and Tristen Newton and Alex Karaban each started 38 of the Huskies’ 39 games.

31. 2003 Syracuse

Carmelo Anthony’s magical run through the 2003 NCAA Tournament was the first true “one-and-done” moment, two years before the NBA implemented the rule preventing players from jumping straight from high school to the pros.

Anthony’s preternatural scoring talents were the story of that Syracuse squad, even moreso than Jim Boeheim capturing his lone national championship. The hyper-talented freshman averaged 20.2 points per game during the NCAA Tournament and racked up double-doubles in each of the Orange’s final three victories, including a 33-point, 14-rebound explosion to beat Rick Barnes, TJ Ford and Texas in the Final Four.

As just a No. 3 seed, though, it’s hard to make the case that this Syracuse team lands among the all-time greats. The Orange did go 30-5 overall and shared the Big East regular season title with Pitt, but they fell to UConn in the Big East tournament semifinals.

Plus, the roster beyond Anthony was mostly nondescript. Gerry McNamara (who hit six 3s) and Hakim Warrick (who swatted away a game-tying 3 with seconds to go) starred in the title game, but McNamara never played in the NBA, and Warrick never rose above a solid role player.

30. 2017 North Carolina

Someone had to be the lowest-ranked No. 1 seed on this list. Three factors held the 2017 Heels back.

First, UNC did not win the ACC tournament and suffered seven losses on the season, a tough hit to the overall body of work. Second, it barely survived on multiple occasions in the Big Dance, needing a Luke Maye buzzer beater to down Kentucky in the Elite Eight and barely surviving a tough Oregon squad 77-76 in the Final Four. And finally, the roster lacked high-end talent relative to its national champion peers.

On the bright side, UNC played one of the toughest paths possible for a No. 1 seed (16-8-4-2-3-1) and won the ACC regular season title outright. The Heels also beat one of Mark Few’s best Gonzaga teams in the national championship.

An intangible plus for Carolina: It lost in the 2016 title game on Kris Jenkins’ buzzer beater, which means this core was oh-so-close to being back-to-back champions.

29. 1987 Indiana

Another team hurt slightly by not having a chance to win a conference tournament, Bob Knight’s last of three NCAA titles as a coach proved he could still get it done in the 64-team expansion era.

His 1987 Hoosiers shared the Big Ten regular season crown with archrival Purdue, just edging out Iowa and Illinois. All four schools finished in the AP poll’s top 11, evidence of how loaded the conference was.

Although the roster was top-heavy, Indiana did have some solid talent. Steve Alford is one of the best college guards of all time, twice earning first-team All-America honors while racking up nearly 2,500 career points. Three other Hoosiers saw brief stints in the NBA, though none stuck long-term.

The 1987 Hoosiers’ lasting legacy, though, is Keith Smart’s game winner to beat Syracuse in the national title game. A seemingly unorganized final possession ended in Smart’s pull-up jumper, creating an iconic March moment.

28. 1991 Duke

At long last, Mike Krzyzewski captured a national championship. In his 11th season at Duke, and after four previous Final Four appearances, his Blue Devils got over the hump.

That run included a stunning upset of previously undefeated UNLV as big underdogs in the national semifinal, snapping the Runnin’ Rebels’ 45-game winning streak. The Blue Devils followed it up with a win over Roy Williams and the Kansas Jayhawks to secure the title.

The Blue Devils’ 1991 run set the stage for one of the best college teams ever. All of Duke’s stars — Christian Laettner, Bobby Hurley, Grant Hill — returned to school in 1992 and tore through the best the country had to offer.

This squad was more of a plucky underdog. Yes, the Blue Devils won the ACC regular season, but they also lost seven games, including a 22-point shellacking at the hands of archrival UNC in the ACC tournament. This was also Coach K’s only national title team that was not a No. 1 seed.


Nolan Richardson (middle) led the Razorbacks to the Final Four in three of his 17 seasons, going all the way in 1994. (Doug Pensinger / Getty Images)

Tier 3: Rock-solid champs

27. 1994 Arkansas

The Razorbacks put together a solid case in the regular season, winning the SEC title by two games. Including a defeat to Kentucky in the SEC tournament semifinals, Arkansas lost just three games all season.

The Hogs suffered in this analysis because they had a weaker total win margin in the NCAA Tournament (just plus-67 in the six tournament games, a bottom-10 number among the champs) despite playing by far the weakest run of opponents for a champion in the last 40 years. In order, Arkansas beat seeds numbered 16, 9, 12, 11, 9 and 6 — not a single elite foe among them.

Of course, Arkansas can do nothing but beat the opponents in front of them. Only Duke in the title game actually got within seven points of the Hogs, so perhaps their overall dominance is being underrated.

Led by Corliss Williamson, the Hogs perfectly executed head coach Nolan Richardson’s “40 Minutes of Hell” style, with several unheralded guards helping Arkansas rank third nationally in steals.

26. 2013 Louisville

Yes, folks — the 2013 title goes to Louisville in our analysis. We are not in the business of vacating championships.

Rick Pitino’s Cardinals easily won the Big East tournament after sharing the regular season title. And they would have won it outright if not for an epic five-overtime loss at Notre Dame in early February.

Louisville then faced a relatively soft string of foes in the Big Dance, most notably getting to handle No. 9 seed Wichita State in the Final Four. The national title game was one to remember, though: Michigan’s Spike Albrecht was a flamethrower in the first half, but Louisville gunner Luke Hancock answered back with a barrage of his own and ended up winning the Final Four’s Most Outstanding Player award.

The Cardinals also got dinged by my subjective talent ranking: No Cardinal, not even the electrifying Russ Smith (aka Russdiculous), made any impact in the NBA. This squad perfectly embodied Pitino’s vision of a terrifying defensive group where the whole was greater than the sum of the parts.

25. 2004 UConn

Five years after his first title, Jim Calhoun returned to the sport’s apex. And once again, the Huskies squeaked past a loaded Duke team to get there, this time in the national semifinals.

For a No. 2 seed, UConn had tremendous college talent. Emeka Okafor fueled what was easily the country’s best two-point percentage defense, and Ben Gordon was a lethal long-range shooter who went No. 3 in the NBA Draft after Okafor went second.

The Huskies had four more players who would eventually get drafted in the first round. The 2004 tournament’s young role players would become a terrorizing unit of their own in 2006.

All that praise aside, UConn did not even win the Big East in 2004, landing a game behind Pitt. The Huskies got the last laugh over the Panthers, though, knocking them off in the Big East tournament championship.

24. 2019 Virginia

A year after becoming the first No. 1 seed to lose to a No. 16 seed in the opening round, the Cavaliers wrote the NCAA Tournament’s ultimate redemption story.

A talented nucleus of Ty Jerome, Kyle Guy and DeAndre Hunter led the charge, all eager to wipe away the memory of that infamous 2018 upset at the hands of UMBC (which Hunter missed with an injury). The 2019 season had several truly great teams, but after a wild postseason, Tony Bennett’s team was the last one standing.

Virginia’s overall resume is hurt by only sharing the ACC regular season title (with Zion Williamson, R.J. Barrett and Duke) and losing in the ACC tournament semifinals. Plus, the Hoos’ NCAA Tournament run was the opposite of dominant. Their final three victories came in dramatic (some would even say lucky) fashion.

Against Purdue in the Elite Eight — an all-time display of shot-making by both teams — point guard Kihei Clark tracked down a long tap-out rebound off a missed free throw and hit Mamadi Diakite for a buzzer-beating jumper to send that game to overtime. In the Final Four, UVA survived a 14-0 Auburn run in the final five minutes thanks to a foul on a corner jump shot, after which Kyle Guy coolly buried three straight free throws to win. And in the national title game, Virginia again needed a game-tying shot, this time a corner three from DeAndre Hunter, to force overtime.

The banner hangs forever, of course, but repeatedly needing that level of late heroics is a limiting factor when comparing the Cavaliers side-by-side to other champions.

23. 2000 Michigan State

This year marks a quarter-century since a Big Ten school last won a men’s college hoops title, a stunning drought made all the more confusing by the amount of teams the league has sent to the Final Four in that span (15).

Thus, the legacy of the “Flintstones” lives on — that being the nickname given to Mateen Cleaves, Morris Peterson and Charlie Bell, who hailed from Flint, Mich., played together since grade school and reached the pinnacle of college basketball together, earning Tom Izzo what remains his only national championship.

Michigan State had some strong accolades, sharing the Big Ten title with Ohio State (ignoring a couple of vacated OSU wins) and winning the Big Ten tournament. The Spartans did drop seven games during the season, though, including one of the worst losses you’ll ever see for a No. 1 seed: a 53-49 defeat in a strange road game at Wright State, which finished 11-17 on the season.

22. 1993 North Carolina

A year after Duke wrapped up back-to-back championships with one of the best college teams ever, legendary coach Dean Smith captured his second national title in Chapel Hill.

These Heels used the tough, physical duo of center Eric Montross and power forward George Lynch to batter foes into submission in the paint. They put together a strong regular season, wresting the ACC title from Duke, and only lost four games all year. Frustratingly, one of those was in the ACC tournament final to Georgia Tech. Still, UNC navigated an extremely difficult NCAA Tournament path, knocking off two No. 2 seeds and exacting revenge on No. 1 Michigan in the title game (UNC had lost to Michigan in Honolulu in late December).

UNC’s ranking in this exercise took a hit on the basis of talent. After Montross and Lynch, the Heels lacked true high-end pieces, and none of the guards were able to stick in the professional ranks.

21. 1986 Louisville

Denny Crum’s second national title team is one of our highest-rated No. 2 seeds on the list, in large part due to its outright regular season and conference tournament titles. It’s possible the Cardinals got slightly overrated here, as their dominance of the Metro Conference does not adjust for the caliber of the league, which sent only two other teams to the NCAA Tournament.

Notable Cardinals include Billy Thompson, an honorable mention All-American; senior guard Milt Wagner; and “Never Nervous” Pervis Ellison, a true freshman starter who eventually blossomed into an All-American and No. 1 overall pick in the 1989 NBA Draft. And who can forget Kenny Payne, whose playing career far outshined his coaching tenure with the Cardinals.

Louisville’s NCAA Tournament run had some ups and downs, including a somewhat easier path in the Elite Eight (where it beat No. 8 seed Auburn) and Final Four (where it beat No. 11 seed LSU). The Cardinals then thwarted Coach K, Jay Bilas and Duke in a fantastic title game that saw Louisville narrowly prevail 72-69.

20. 2022 Kansas

Even Kansas fans would likely agree this was not one of Bill Self’s apex Jayhawk squads, but when it comes to the fickle, single-elimination NCAA Tournament, you never know who will actually reach the mountaintop.

Of course, this team was no slouch. The 2022 Jayhawks won the Big 12 tournament after sharing the regular season crown, earning a No. 1 seed in the Big Dance. Ochai Agbaji, Christian Braun and Jalen Wilson have all carved out roles as NBA wings early on in their careers.

The Jayhawks’ path was not overly challenging, though, beating No. 10 seed Miami to go to the Final Four and No. 8 seed UNC in the national title game. Plus, those Heels led by 15 at halftime. Fortunately, Remy Martin caught fire in the second half, burying several crucial triples in the stunning comeback.

Had Martin been healthy all season, KU might have avoided some of its five Big 12 losses and won the conference outright. An injury asterisk makes sense here, considering how impactful Martin was at full strength.

19. 2015 Duke

This ranking could be controversial. In an epic college basketball season that featured Kentucky going 34-0 before the NCAA Tournament, an all-time great Wisconsin offense, plus terrific versions of Arizona, Villanova, Virginia and others, Duke rose to the top. The freshman trio of Jahlil Okafor, Tyus Jones and Justise Winslow, along with savvy veterans Quinn Cook, Amile Jefferson and Matt Jones, outlasted everyone else.

However, as great as this Duke team was — and as awesome as 2015 was as a year in college basketball — the Blue Devils’ resume falls a little short of the all-time greats.

Duke did not win the ACC regular season title, finishing a game back of Virginia. Duke did not win the ACC tournament, either; in fact, it lost to eventual champ Notre Dame in the semifinals. It’s hard to stack these Blue Devils up with other legendary champions if they could not prove themselves to be the best team in their own conference.

Of course, the roster was quite loaded for a college team. Okafor, though he did not end up an NBA star as expected, was an All-American interior force in college, and Winslow was drafted in the lottery for a reason. Jones remains a solid point guard option in the NBA, and Cook earned some professional minutes as well. Grayson Allen — a little-used role player who was arguably the MVP of the national title win over the Badgers — has also evolved into a key piece in the pros.

18. 2010 Duke

Placing 2010 Duke ahead of 2015 Duke will likely surprise many Blue Devils fans. However, before surviving one of the most famous near-misses in NCAA Tournament history, this Duke squad was impressively dominant.

The Blue Devils convincingly ran through the first five rounds of the NCAA Tournament, with only Baylor in the Elite Eight coming within single digits. They dismantled an impressive West Virginia squad (including current Boston Celtics coach Joe Mazzulla) 78-57 in the national semifinal. And before the Big Dance, they shared the ACC regular season title and won the ACC tournament.

This roster was not loaded with staggering professional talent or depth, but it fit together perfectly. Kyle Singler, Jon Scheyer and Nolan Smith handled the scoring; that trio rarely left the floor and accounted for 68.0 percent of the Blue Devils’ points. Meanwhile, the frontcourt group of Brian Zoubek, Lance Thomas and Miles Plumlee handled the dirty work, dominating the offensive glass and providing outstanding interior defense.

Gordon Hayward’s shot may have been the most memorable moment of the 2010 postseason, but Duke ultimately reigned supreme, capturing Coach K’s fourth of five titles.

Coach K’s national title teams

Year Seed Title game Overall ranking

2

72-65 vs. Kansas

28

1

71-51 vs. Michigan

2

1

82-72 vs. Arizona

6

1

61-59 vs. Butler

18

1

68-63 vs. Wisconsin

19

17. 2002 Maryland

When players return to college citing “unfinished business,” 2002 Maryland should be one of the shining examples for how that mission can go right. In 2001, the Terrapins made the Final Four but fell to bitter ACC rival Duke in the national semifinal. Starting forward Terence Morris graduated, but four starters — including superstar guard Juan Dixon — and three reserves came back for another go-round.

That returning nucleus certainly finished its business. The 2002 Terrapins went 15-1 in the ACC, with the only loss coming at a mega-talented Duke team, and finished 32-4 overall. They won all six NCAA Tournament games by at least eight points, including a rousing semifinal matchup with a stacked Kansas squad.

Maryland did come up short in the ACC tournament, falling in the semifinals to No. 4 seed NC State. Plus, its overall talent level does not quite measure up to some of the elite champions; not even the brilliant Dixon ended up as a consistent starter in the NBA (shout out to Steve Blake’s gritty 13-year career as a role player, however).

Ultimately, this Maryland team was more about the cohesion of a group that played a ton of games together. Thus, though they went on a highly impressive run, these Terrapins land near the middle of the pack.

16. 1998 Kentucky

Rick Pitino jumped to the Boston Celtics in 1997, leaving college for a chance to build a legacy in the professional ranks. He left plenty in the cupboard, though, and Tubby Smith — hired away from SEC rival Georgia in May of ‘97 — was able to carry on Pitino’s major momentum in Lexington.

A dominant frontcourt led by Nazr Mohammed, Scott Padgett and Jamaal Magloire buried teams in the paint, and Kentucky led the country in both block rate and two-point percentage defense, per KenPom. That interior dominance helped Kentucky win the conference regular season and tournament titles.

Surprisingly given those crowns, Kentucky only received a No. 2 seed in the NCAA Tournament. That placement was a slight (and perhaps unfair) knock in this analysis.

One factor on which I had a hard time deciding: Should I discount this Wildcats team for being coached by Smith, who was much more of a journeyman than Hall of Famers Rick Pitino and John Calipari? I did not include coach mystique in my rubric, but it does somewhat influence how I view this Kentucky team.

15. 2005 North Carolina

One key item not factored into a broad “Did this team win its conference title?” criteria: the strength of that conference. If I were adjusting for that, 2005 UNC would get a sizable bump for winning an outright ACC title in a league that also included Duke (No. 1 seed in the NCAA Tournament) and Wake Forest (No. 2 seed).

The 2005 Tar Heels also beat a fantastic Illinois team in the national championship game, and they were overflowing with talent: their sixth man, Marvin Williams, was drafted No. 2 overall.

Sean May, Rashad McCants and Raymond Felton formed an outstanding trio of juniors that arrived as a heralded recruiting class back in 2002. Roy Williams did not bring in that group — shout out to Matt Doherty — but in his second season in Chapel Hill, Williams led it to a championship.

The knocks on these Heels: They did not win the ACC Tournament (and their loss was to Georgia Tech, not Duke or Wake), and they had a couple of close calls in the NCAA Tournament despite a path that did not feature a top-four seed until the title game.

14. 2016 Villanova

Kris Jenkins’ title-winning buzzer beater is one of the most memorable shots in NCAA Tournament history, and Jay Wright’s subtle “bang” to himself as the shot went in was a historically cool move.

The highest-rated champion of any non-No. 1 seed, these Wildcats received a considerable bump for a huge 124-point cumulative win margin in the NCAA Tournament, all while facing the toughest path (by far) for a No. 1 seed or a No. 2 seed champion. They also won the Big East regular season title, though they lost by a basket to Seton Hall in the conference tournament final.

You could definitely argue that the Cats’ 44-point shellacking of Oklahoma in the Final Four is skewing their total margin of victory. But that game also exhibited the terrifying ceiling of this squad, and it avenged a 23-point loss to the Sooners on Dec. 7, 2015, in Honolulu.

That Final Four victory even foreshadowed the dominance of the 2018 team, which was led by this squad’s role players (Jalen Brunson, Mikal Bridges, Phil Booth, even the redshirting Donte DiVincenzo and Eric Paschall).

Tier 2: Definitely dominant

13. 1999 UConn

Duke’s 1999 squad is the only team in the KenPom era to clear the Everest-esque peak of plus-40 in Net Rating, and the Blue Devils were the heavy, heavy favorite to win the title.

The ‘99 Huskies were no slouch either, though. Led by future NBA champion shooting guard Rip Hamilton and bowling ball point guard Khalid El-Amin, the Huskies won the Big East regular season and tournament titles. Their 34-2 overall record is eye-popping, and their winning percentage of 94.4 is tied for the second-best mark for a champion in the 64-team era.

It speaks to how impressive that Duke team was that despite those incredibly impressive accolades, the Huskies were still 9.5-point underdogs in the championship game.

Before that game, UConn’s path was not overly imposing; the Huskies beat No. 10 seed Gonzaga (the first ever Zags team to make a run) in the Elite Eight and then got No. 4 seed Ohio State in the Final Four. But the Big East dominance places these Huskies on the fringe of the top 10.

12. 1990 UNLV

Jerry Tarkanian’s run in the desert set the bar extremely high for all future UNLV coaches. The 1990 title team may have been slightly inferior to the 1991 version that started 34-0 before losing in the Final Four, but these Runnin’ Rebels were stuffed with NBA talent and showed it on the biggest stage.

UNLV survived a scare in the Sweet Sixteen, barely edging plucky No. 12 seed Ball State 69-67. The Rebels hit the gas pedal after that, though, blitzing Duke in the national championship 103-73. That 30-point margin remains, by far, the biggest title game blowout in the 64-team tournament era.

The Rebels’ overall grade in this analysis was hurt a bit by two things. First, they faced one of the weakest paths to a title ever, facing three double-digit seeds while not playing a single No. 1 or No. 2 seed. Second, they shared the Big West regular season title with New Mexico State (outright titles were given a boost).

The talent on this squad — all of which returned for that 1990-91 campaign — was staggering. Larry Johnson was the No. 1 pick in the 1991 NBA Draft, while Stacey Augmon (No. 9) and Greg Anthony (No. 12) were not far behind. All three had long, successful NBA careers.

Remarkably, none of that trio earned the 1990 tournament’s Most Outstanding Player award; that actually went to guard Anderson Hunt, who erupted for 49 points over the two Final Four games in Denver, Colo.

11. 2021 Baylor

If there was any team I wanted to bump up on circumstantial grounds, it was this Baylor team. For the entire 2020-21 season, it was clear these Bears were one of the two best teams in the country. They got off to a 17-0 start, with just two opponents even getting within single-digits. They seemed destined to meet fellow juggernaut Gonzaga in one of the most highly anticipated championship games in history.

But the 2020-21 season was far from normal, and a COVID-19-related shutdown for most of February threw off Baylor’s rhythm. The Bears did not look the same coming out of that stoppage, barely edging an Iowa State team that went winless in Big 12 play before taking their first loss at Kansas. Baylor also fell in the Big 12 tournament semifinals to Cade Cunningham-led Oklahoma State.

But then the NCAA Tournament started, and Baylor rediscovered its elite identity on both ends of the court. The Bears led by double-digits for essentially the entire 80 minutes of the Final Four, blasting Houston and dominating that long-awaited showdown with Gonzaga.

Despite being arguably the best shooting team to win a title (they shot 41.3 percent from beyond the arc as a team to lead Division I), the Bears’ calling card was their suffocating defense. Guard Davion “Off Night” Mitchell and forward/linebacker Mark Vital fueled a relentless unit. Had health and safety protocols not thrown a wrench into Baylor’s season, these Bears could have been the first undefeated champion since 1976 Indiana.

10. 1995 UCLA

Before his trailblazing lawsuit against the NCAA, Ed O’Bannon was a terror on the court, racking up 20.4 points and 8.3 rebounds per game for the national champion Bruins. He and younger brother Charles O’Bannon formed a dynamic duo on the wing, and senior floor general Tyus Edney controlled the game as an extension of coach Jim Harrick. Big man George Zidek also became a first-round draft pick following the Bruins’ championship run.

Per official NCAA records, UCLA went 32-1, but the Bruins actually lost two games; a home loss to Cal was later deemed a Golden Bears forfeit due to NCAA infractions. However, the game happened, so it counts as a loss in this analysis.

UCLA is the highest-ranked team on this list to get the somewhat unfair penalty of not winning a nonexistent conference tournament. Had the Bruins won a hypothetical Pac-12 tournament, they would have flirted with Tier 1.

9. 2018 Villanova

Part of me expected the 2018 Wildcats to rank higher in this exercise. They were, after all, one of the most dominant NCAA Tournament teams ever, blitzing a strong collection of foes by a combined 106 points. No opponent got closer than 12 points, and Villanova’s demolition of fellow No. 1 seed Kansas in the national semifinal (in which it jumped out to a 22-4 lead) was stunning to behold.

However, the Wildcats did not even win the Big East that season, ending up a game back of champion Xavier. A midseason injury to starting guard Phil Booth is partially to blame, and connoisseurs of context might push this team up higher as a result; I would have no issue with that adjustment.

This Villanova team was, after all, loaded with talent. Jalen Brunson was the National Player of the Year and is now an NBA All-Star, and Mikal Bridges was also an All-American via several publications. Donte DiVincenzo was a laughably overqualified sixth man in hindsight, as was seventh man Collin Gillespie, a future Big East Player of the Year. Omari Spellman and Eric Paschall both saw time in the NBA.

The Wildcats are remembered as one of the elite early adopters of a five-out offense. Everyone could bury a 3 at any moment, and it is no surprise that they rank among the most efficient offensive attacks in the history of Ken Pomeroy’s college basketball ratings.

8. 2008 Kansas

Winning a title is, in itself, an incredible accomplishment. But doing so the way Kansas did — in overtime, after an outrageously clutch game-tying three-pointer from Mario Chalmers — might have been just a little sweeter. That shot prevented John Calipari from winning a title at Memphis; he left for Kentucky just one year later.

The 2008 Final Four is also notable for being the first to feature all four No. 1 seeds. In a mini-tournament of the true elites of that season, Kansas emerged victorious, and its obliteration of UNC in the national semifinal fueled the Tar Heels’ pursuit of their own title in 2009.

But before that loaded Final Four, Kansas actually faced one of the easiest region paths ever — at least by seed. The Jayhawks beat No. 12 seed Villanova in the Sweet 16 and No. 10 seed Davidson in the Elite Eight, though it feels foolish to label any postseason run that features a clash with Steph Curry as “easy”. Kansas barely survived that brush with all-time greatness, edging Davidson 59-57.

The Jayhawks got a slight knock in the nebulous “talent” rating portion of this analysis. Though seven players from the roster did play in the NBA, none developed into a star.

7. 2007 Florida

The third back-to-back title winner on this list is more than deserving of the top 10. Joakim Noah, Al Horford and Corey Brewer formed the nucleus of Billy Donovan’s juggernaut, but the Gators also returned Taurean Green and Lee Humphrey, giving them the rare distinction of bringing back all five starters from a national championship squad.

The preseason No. 1 team in the country, Florida started somewhat slowly, losing twice in the first month of the season, including at unranked Florida State. The Gators also ended slowly, losing three of their final five regular-season contests, all to unranked teams. But when it got down to business, the Gators reminded everyone of their dominance.

They steamrolled through the SEC tournament, winning three games by a combined 59 points, then enduring some spirited challenges in the NCAA Tournament but won every game by at least seven points. That included topping Greg Oden, Mike Conley and a wildly talented Ohio State team in the championship game.

6. 2001 Duke

A vintage Coach K Duke squad, these Blue Devils combined a senior star (forward Shane Battier) with an elite underclassman (Jay Williams) and filled in the gaps around those two with more future NBA players plus a veteran leader or two.

The roster is one of the most talented of any on this list. Williams and Battier were a devastating duo, and both became top-six picks in the NBA Draft (although Williams stuck around another season). Mike Dunleavy Jr., himself a top-three pick in 2002, and Carlos Boozer, a future two-time NBA All-Star, constituted the supporting cast. Chris Duhon, a freshman starter at point guard, also played in the NBA for a decade.

The most iconic ‘01 Duke moment actually came in January. Trailing 90-80 at Maryland late, Williams led The Miracle Minute as the Blue Devils stunningly forced OT and escaped with a 98-96 win.

The 2001 Blue Devils received small knocks for winning just a hair under 90 percent of their games (four total losses) and sharing the ACC regular season title with North Carolina. Fortunately, Duke got the last laugh against those Heels by trouncing them in the ACC tournament final 79-53.

5. 2012 Kentucky

John Calipari’s lone champion in Lexington, this loaded squad had a relatively comfortable run through the 2012 NCAA Tournament. No opponent — including archrival Louisville in the Final Four — came closer than eight points. Calipari’s Cats also posted the highest overall winning percentage (95.0) of any title winner in the past 40 years.

As in 1996, Kentucky bulldozed through the SEC with a spotless 16-0 mark and did not post a losing record against any team. It swept two regular-season meetings with Vanderbilt before falling to the Commodores in the SEC tournament final, and it avenged an early-season loss at Indiana (the Wat Shot) by sending the Hoosiers packing in the Sweet 16.

The Wildcats had a staggering six players selected in the 2012 NBA Draft, including the unmatched feat of having the No. 1 pick (Anthony Davis) and the No. 2 pick (Michael Kidd-Gilchrist). That helped Kentucky tie for the highest talent rating I assigned to any champion.

This team fell just short of the elite tier by missing out on the SEC tournament crown and showing slightly lesser dominance in the Big Dance. Although no one got particularly close, Kentucky did not win a single game by more than 16 points, and its combined winning margin of 71 was a pedestrian number compared to many other champions.

4. 2009 North Carolina

The 2009 Tar Heels get some credit for winning an outstanding ACC, separating from a pack that included strong versions of Duke, Wake Forest and Florida State, among others. North Carolina also warrants praise for rolling to Roy Williams’ second of three titles in Chapel Hill after being the first unanimous preseason No. 1 in the history of both the AP poll and the Coaches Poll.

The Heels won every NCAA Tournament game by at least 12 points en route to the fourth-highest total postseason margin of victory in the 39-champ sample. That was despite facing one of the toughest paths for a No. 1 seed in history. Even putting seeds aside, UNC’s last four opponents in the NCAA Tournament were all in the KenPom top 13; the Heels won those games by an average of 16 points.

This UNC team was led by Tyler Hansbrough, one of the best college players ever. Ty Lawson, Wayne Ellington and Danny Green all carved out long NBA careers, and reserve big men Ed Davis and Tyler Zeller both developed into first-rounders down the line, as well.

Tier 1: The G.O.A.T. debate

3. 1996 Kentucky

The Wildcats make three appearances on this list, and while the 2012 team was dominant as well, the 1996 version was Kentucky’s best to win a title. (And oh, what could have been in 2015.)

UK ran through the SEC, going 16-0 and winning just one conference game by fewer than 13 points. A hiccup against Mississippi State in the SEC tournament final knocked them a tiny bit in my evaluation, but the Cats responded by torching their four foes in the Midwest region of the NCAA Tournament by an average of 28.3 points.

This roster was loaded, with four picks in the 1996 draft who went on to long NBA careers. Star forward Antoine Walker went sixth overall, while first-team All-American Tony Delk and Swiss Army knife Walter McCarty were taken 16th and 19th, respectively. Current Wildcats head coach Mark Pope was a second-rounder. As if that was not enough, three future first-rounders (Derek Anderson, Ron Mercer, Nazr Mohammed) made up the supporting cast.

Another differentiator about these Wildcats: No team has true bragging rights against them. They only lost two games all season (to UMass in Detroit and to Mississippi State in the SEC tournament), and they beat both those squads in separate meetings. They waxed the Bulldogs in Starkville in early January, and they got revenge against John Calipari, Marcus Camby and the Minutemen in the national semifinals.

2. 1992 Duke

I strongly considered bumping these Blue Devils to the top overall spot, and they will surely have an ardent army of supporters. They went 38-2 and won both the ACC regular season and tournament titles. And they never got blown out: The Blue Devils’ only two losses all season were by margins of four and two points.

Ultimately, 2024 UConn’s utter dominance against all comers in the postseason — including another No. 1 seed, Purdue, in the national title game — just barely elevated the Huskies to No. 1. In contrast, ’92 Duke needed one of the most iconic plays in men’s basketball history — Grant Hill’s full-court pass and Christian Laettner’s picturesque pirouette jumper — to even reach the Final Four. After that 104-103 overtime thriller against Kentucky, the Blue Devils barely escaped another No. 2 seed in the national semifinals, beating Indiana 81-78.

That epic Elite Eight showdown with the Wildcats could be a divisive item. Should generating an iconic March moment with such a memorable play actually make the case for Duke as the greatest champ of the past four decades, rather than against it? Obviously, my opinion shades towards the latter, but that Laettner jumper was an all-timer.

Those tiny, tiny blemishes aside, this Blue Devils team was loaded. It had the National Player of the Year in Laettner, a future No. 3 pick in Hill and one of the best college point guards ever in Bobby Hurley. Having Mike Krzyzewski, a five-time champ and arguably the best coach in NCAA history, on the sideline is simply another cherry on top.

1. 2024 UConn

What are the chances the best champion of the past 40 years was actually last year’s? Remarkably, it might actually be the case.

The Huskies check every box you could ask for in a dominant team. They won the Big East regular season title by four games in a conference that featured a No. 2 seed (Marquette) and a No. 3 seed (Creighton). They also won the conference tournament at Madison Square Garden. They went 37-3 overall, and against a respectable run of opponents in the Big Dance (i.e., no upstart Cinderellas), they won every game by 14 or more points. The Huskies accumulated the largest total margin of victory (plus-140 points in six NCAA Tournament games) for any of the 39 champions ranked in this exercise. In UConn’s final 13 games, only two opponents even came within single digits. That is dominance on full display.

UConn lost only once all season at full strength. One NBA lottery pick, Stephon Castle, missed the Huskies’ loss at Kansas, and fellow top-10 selection Donovan Clingan managed just 14 minutes before sitting out the remainder of a loss at Seton Hall.

From a talent perspective, UConn is right up there with any champion. Clingan, aka “Kling Cong,” is arguably one of the best college rim protectors ever, and Castle was an easy one-and-done NBA prospect. Point guard Tristen Newton, the Huskies’ third NBA Draft choice on the roster, was a consensus first-team All-American and a returning starter from the 2023 UConn title team. Forward Alex Karaban was also a key starter on that 2023 team, and shooting guard Cam Spencer posted the highest individual offensive rating in the country (per KenPom).

Like the squad that came in as first runner-up, this Huskies team was a back-to-back title winner — only the third such squad to accomplish that feat in this 40-year span. Whether that means anything toward the search for the “best” champion is debatable, but it certainly did not hurt.

The Rankings and Tiers series is sponsored by E*Trade from Morgan Stanley. The Athletic maintains full editorial independence. Sponsors have no control over or input into the reporting or editing process and do not review stories before publication.

(Illustration: Kelsea Petersen / The Athletic; Photos: Chris Graythen / Getty Images, Focus On Sport / Getty Images, Manny Millan / Getty Images, Jamie Schwaberow / Getty Images)

Patrick Mouratoglou’s tennis partnership with Naomi Osaka and coaching superstars

The way phenomenal and accomplished athletes’ minds work can often catch regular folks off-guard. How is it that a tennis player like Naomi Osaka, a four-time Grand Slam champion and former world No. 1, would ever get to a place where she might question her ability?

It happens all the time, even with the all-time greats — a subset of the tennis species that Patrick Mouratoglou, the longtime coach and tennis media impresario, has spent most of his career studying. He coached the best of the best, Serena Williams, at the scene of so many of her greatest triumphs.

In September 2024, three-quarters of the way through her comeback season after giving birth to her daughter, Shai, Osaka hired Mouratogou to replace Wim Fissette. Osaka had reunited with Fissette (who coached her between 2019 and 2022) the previous summer, to prepare for her return to competitive tennis last January. At first, she was magnanimous about the relationship between improvement and outcome. When she came within a point of beating Iga Swiatek at last year’s French Open, Osaka wasn’t down: “Obviously the results aren’t resulting right now, but I think I’m growing every tournament,” she said in her news conference.

When the results still didn’t result, Osaka found herself again struggling with her confidence and decided to move away from the coach with whom she won two of those four Grand Slam titles.

Osaka, 27, hasn’t won a title of any kind with Mouratoglou yet, but she has come awfully close. She had to retire with an abdominal injury when she was up a set against Clara Tauson in the final of the Auckland Classic in New Zealand in January and she has played her best tennis since becoming a mother in the past five months, when her body has allowed her to do so.

“I just had to believe in myself a lot more,” Osaka said at the Australian Open after her second-round win over Karolina Muchova, one of the world’s most gifted players, who had eased past Osaka at the same stage of the U.S. Open four months prior. There in Melbourne, Osaka was talking about coming back to win the last two sets after losing the first 6-1, but she could have been talking about how, when healthy, she has rediscovered her swagger and her ability to take the racket out of her opponents’ hands.

That is not an accident.

In an interview in February from Los Angeles, where he and Osaka prepared for her comeback from that abdominal injury, Mouratoglou said they have been working on confronting those moments when she feels her belief slipping and on figuring out ways to overcome them.


Patrick Mouratoglou with Naomi Osaka at January’s Australian Open. (David Gray / AFP via Getty Images)

“You earn confidence with what you do every day in practice,” Mouratoglou said.

After two weeks of hard training, Osaka will try to bring that swagger to the BNP Paribas Open at Indian Wells, Calif., this week.

In the interview, Mouratoglou, 54, said he expects nothing less from Osaka, a player he says comes to the court every day with an open mind and a hunger to try anything to get better.

All the great ones do.

This conversation has been edited for clarity and length.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Naomi Osaka and the gravity of a superstar at the U.S. Open


How is her injury feeling?

She has no pain anymore. We have been serving, but slowly and progressively. She’s done the work to try to make sure she does not get hurt again.

What is it like to work with players at her level? How does she compare with Serena Williams?

I don’t compare anyone to Serena. It is very exciting, because of her potential. She has the potential to win very many more Slams. Her motivation is very high. Tennis is a big priority and she is prepared to come back all the way.

How do you know if you are a good fit with her? 

I don’t know if it’s a good fit — all the players are different, and as a coach you need to adapt.

Is it any different when you are coaching a superstar rather than some of the players you have worked with who are not at that level?

It’s very important when you work with a superstar that you do the same as if the player is not a superstar. You need to talk to a person in a normal way, like she is a normal player. When they achieve so much they have certainties about what they do, but they have to be open enough to learn and continue to grow. That’s where Naomi is. She really wants to improve. She’s really taking the advice, and giving 100 percent. She is not scared. That’s the champion’s mindset.

It’s interesting you say that. I would have thought people who have won so much in the past think they know how to do it again. 

They are champions because they are doing what it takes to improve; their ability to trust the person working with them to tell them what to do and what it takes. That makes them champions.

Rafa (Nadal) and Novak (Djokovic), they went through so many technical changes. They see the sport as a race. Everybody is improving. That is how Serena was seeing the world. If you’re happy with what you have and don’t try new things, you will be overtaken by others. The progress comes from seeing which areas you can get better with.

Why is Osaka better now than she was last year?

Her confidence is much higher. This comes from what she has done at practice. She’s practising extremely well. She pushes herself. Her game has gained in consistency. A player has to be aware of how she is feeling, even if she feels she is losing confidence. Before, she didn’t express it to herself. Most of the matches, she lost because she stopped believing and this is not allowed.

We do practice matches. She is aware of what she is feeling. We talk about it. We work on it in the moment. It’s fine to have that feeling, it’s natural — there is no shame in being nervous. We just have to be aware of it. It can affect you but it can’t affect you too much — Novak gets super-nervous or angry, but the most important thing is the ability to come back very fast. Otherwise, you are losing points and points and points. You have the right to become nervous and lose confidence, but not too much and not for too long.

You don’t talk much during matches other than small messages of encouragement. Why?

There is not so much to say, unless I see she is not following the plan one way or another. The match, we prepare it before. The only thing I can do is to support her.

In the Muchova match in Melbourne, Muchova was playing great and Naomi was struggling to get to her level. I’ve seen that in the past year. I found out that when she was in trouble, her confidence level would drop a lot and the game was affected.

Her first tournament in China, she had lost 20 matches in a row when she had lost the first set. This time, she didn’t let what was happening on the court play with her mind.  It’s impossible not to be affected by the score. They need to be affected by the score. How much it affects you and does it affect you in a way that can harm you is the question. You want to be affected but stay under control. Keep believing in what you are doing.

Is that what she did against Muchova? 

She stayed mentally there. You don’t go away. Nobody plays perfectly from the first point to the last.

When you coached Serena, you went up against Osaka. Did you share your old game plans with her?

No. You don’t want to reinforce the spots that are weaker. I also don’t think you win by improving your mistakes so much. You prepare solutions, and you make your strong points better. If someone has a good game plan to beat Jannik Sinner, I would like to see it. Players at that level, you have to catch them on a certain day when there are weak spots.

I want my players to know how to turn their strengths into weapons: ‘What is my player’s game style and how do they win points?’.

So what are Osaka’s strengths at this point that should be her weapons?

When she is at the top of the game, she plays faster than anyone. She makes it very difficult to organize a point against her. She comes back to you with the ball in such a short time. When the ball touches the racket, it goes so fast to the other side of the net, and she can be very accurate with hitting her spots.

She also has big room for improvement. She can return better, be more aggressive on the second serve, take time away from the opponent better. The good thing is that she is extremely open to new ideas. I told her what I thought when I arrived and she told me she was very excited to get to work because she believed she was going to learn new things.


Naomi Osaka holds the Australian Open trophy after the 2019 final. (Getty Images)

Is that what the best ones tell you?

Absolutely. They forget what they have achieved one minute after they achieve it. Serena finishes 2012 winning Wimbledon and the U.S. Open and the Olympics and the WTA Tour Finals. She’s walking off the court and tells me to come up with a plan for her to win the French Open. She says, “I’ve been chasing it for 10 years. I want to win Roland Garros, make a plan for me to win it.” (Williams won the 2013 French Open.)

The past is the past. It’s important not to look at the past. ‘Let’s move on. Always focus on the journey, where we want to go’. That’s Naomi right now. She’s very ambitious. She believes her story is still to be written. That’s important, because when you hold a trophy it only lasts a few minutes. You have to be excited about what’s next.

What has changed about tennis in recent years?

In general, the fitness level has improved a lot. It’s easy to explain. All of the top players travel with a fitness coach and physiotherapist. It was not true before. The movement of the players is so much better. On the women’s side, (Aryna) Sabalenka, for her height, is moving so well. And then Iga (Swiatek) and Coco (Gauff).

(Carlos) Alcaraz, Sinner, it’s crazy how they move on the court. Even someone like Tomas Machac. So it’s harder to hit winners, to get the ball through the court. If Naomi keeps evolving as she is, she will be able to hit as many winners again.

Naomi said she didn’t know if you would actually be a good coach, because you had coached Serena and she wondered whether Serena even needed coaching. Others sometimes question how much impact you have when you are coaching these all-time greats? How does that affect you? 

People who say that don’t know what they are talking about. If I coach Naomi and she doesn’t do something well, I’m going to hear about it. I take no special pride in coaching champions. For me, if I don’t bring her to her top level, I didn’t do a good job.

(Top photo: David Gray / AFP via Getty Images)

Accused of giving away his team’s pitches, Derek Bender reckons with the world’s mistrust

SCHENECTADY, N.Y. — Every once in a while, Derek Bender will send a text to one of his former teammates. Or he’ll call, and leave a voicemail.

But, after what happened on Sept. 6, he has not received one text back. Not one call. He’s been left on read, a ghosted pariah to a team that has nothing left to do with him.

More than five months have passed since the day the former Minnesota Twins minor league catcher was accused of giving away pitches to opposing batters on the Lakeland Flying Tigers, trying to ensure his team would miss the playoffs so a long, tiring season would end, according to the allegations against him. A week later, he was released, barely a month after receiving a $297,500 signing bonus as a sixth-round draft selection.

Since then, Bender has existed in a kind of baseball limbo: technically still a professional baseball player, but shunned by the rest of that fraternity. He’s reached out to players in his draft class, guys he lived with at the spring training complex, friends and teammates.

Silence.

“There are a lot of times where you’re talking with people that you thought you were friends with, they just don’t look at you the same,” Bender said. “I’ve heard my friends get questioned about me, why they’re still friends with me. That’s hard to hear.

“It’s not like I’m getting accused of committing a crime.”

Bender is right. He faces no legal consequences. He broke no laws.

But he is accused of betraying the people he worked with. He is accused of undermining every single one of them, all to deliberately lose a game, stay out of the playoffs and ensure a competitive season would come to an early end. The game’s history is filled with players who are accused of cheating for their own benefit. This stands out even among those.

Bender is trying to stay in baseball, and he is trying to regain some level of control over his life. But he is also coming to terms with his situation: That for the rest of his life, in a professional or personal environment, those around him may have a nagging thought in the back of their minds.

Can he be trusted?

When the story of the Twins minor league catcher accused of selling out his own team went viral on ESPN in September, Bender declined to comment. He hasn’t spoken at all about the matter until agreeing to a February interview with The Athletic in his rented house near Albany, N.Y.

Major League Baseball has been investigating Bender for months for a violation of Rule 21(a), which prohibits players from intentionally losing games, or attempting to lose games. And because it remains ongoing, the Twins, Tigers, MLB and players’ union all declined to comment for this story.

League sources briefed on the investigation say the inquiry has uncovered evidence against Bender. More than a dozen people have spoken to investigators, including multiple with direct knowledge of the alleged conduct. Notably, there was no video broadcast of the game, despite the other five games in that series being aired. If the league finds he violated the rules, he’d be looking at a permanent ban, with the opportunity to apply for reinstatement after a year.

For the first 25 minutes of a 90-minute interview, the conversation circled around the only truly relevant question. He talked of his practices with the Siena College baseball team. Spoke of the hours leading up to his final game with the Twins.

Finally it came time to ask the question that Bender had yet to proactively answer himself.

“You were accused of giving away pitches as they were coming up to bat. Did that happen?”

“No,” Bender said, with an almost indignant chuckle. “And I’ll live with this until the day I die. I never gave pitches away. I never tried to give the opposing team an advantage against my own team.”


On the morning of Sept. 6, Bender wanted the Fort Myers Mighty Mussels’ season to be over. He’d said as much to teammates, joking prior to their doubleheader against Lakeland that it wouldn’t be a bad thing if they let a grounder slip under their gloves.

A couple losses would eliminate them from playoff contention, and that’s exactly what Bender was counting on. But he says he wasn’t serious, and he wasn’t talking about actually throwing a game. His desire to leave was rooted in a need for a reset that he felt would help improve his game.

“A lot of us are coming off of college seasons, coming off of a pretty grueling summer schedule,” Bender said. “Then you get there and you’re hitting .200, you’re facing some of the best stuff consistently you’ve ever seen. You’re sinking or swimming, and you’re pretty close to sinking.

“The conversations are that everybody’s ready to go home.”

It was immaturity like this, he said, that came to define his final week in Fort Myers. He’d verbally sparred with player development coaches, arguing with them on his offensive approach.

During a rain delay two days prior, he’d done a tarp slide on Lakeland’s field — a huge no-no.

“That’s sometimes what you get with Derek. You get a lot of emotion, a lot of personality,” said longtime hitting coach and family friend Dan Sausville. “He’s a bold dude. … I gave him lots of advice to keep his mouth shut when he got to the minor leagues. I had given Derek some good advice, that he didn’t take.”

Sausville said that Bender was “in a bad place” that week, and that he had texted with one of Bender’s agents, discussing how Bender clearly needed to get home.

Bender was called into his manager’s office following that doubleheader against Lakeland. Lakeland manager Andrew Graham had informed his Fort Myers counterpart that his players heard Bender giving away pitches before they were thrown. Bender said he immediately denied it. Attempts to reach Graham and Fort Myers manager Brian Meyer for comment were unsuccessful.

The Athletic also attempted to contact numerous players and coaches from both teams, as well as the home plate umpire; none could be reached for comment.

Bender said there was nothing he said that could be interpreted as giving away pitches, and he couldn’t think of any reason someone would make it up.

Fort Myers had already lost six games in a row. And starter Ross Dunn, who had a 6.46 ERA, was yanked in the second inning after allowing five of the first seven batters that frame to reach in the 6-0 loss. His 1 2/3 innings matched his shortest start of the season.

Bender wasn’t allowed in the dugout the following two games. He watched from the bullpen as the season wrapped up. At first, he said, some teammates had his back. But support started to dwindle.

“I talked to him,” Bender said of his attempt at a conversation with Dunn. “I told him, ‘Whatever you’re hearing, it’s just not true. I wouldn’t do that.’ And he said, ‘I hope not, but it’s just what I’m hearing. But I hope not.’

“It’s the last time I’ve heard from him.”

Dunn could not be reached for comment.

When the season officially ended, Bender packed up. There were no heartfelt goodbyes. “I wanted to get the hell out.”

The Twins, Bender said, were willing to keep him in the organization. But they had one requirement. He needed to admit to everything and apologize for it.

He tried to own up to it, he said. He apologized. But when the club asked what he was sorry for, he came up empty. The Twins, team sources said, had already conducted an internal investigation led by GM Jeremy Zoll. In their mind, this was no longer just a question of immaturity. This was a player they could no longer employ.

“The only thing I had left was my character at that point,” Bender said. “Literally, the way they put it was, ‘If you want to die by the sword, we’ll release you.’ I knew there was no bluffing involved.”


It used to be cool to know Derek Bender, a hometown hero on a big-league path.

He played just one year of high school ball at St. James High in South Carolina, but remains in the program’s Hall of Fame.

“He set the tone in our program for how to work, different from any player we’ve had before,” said St. James head coach Robbie Centracchio.

Bender moved on to Coastal Carolina University, a baseball program that has produced major leaguers Tommy La Stella, Taylor Motter and Kirt Manwaring, among others, and won a national championship in 2016. Bender broke out for CCU in 2023 with 19 home runs and then excelled in the Cape Cod League that summer. There was talk of him as a Day 1 selection in the MLB Draft. The Twins were intrigued by the power potential in his right-handed bat.


Bender starred at Coastal Carolina, leading to his selection in the sixth round of the MLB draft. (John Byrum / Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

Now, he doesn’t leave the one-bedroom home he’s rented without his hood up, fearing that even a friendly chat might be had with someone secretly assuming the worst. He said he feels guilty because photos of him in his Coastal Carolina uniform were being used in news articles.

He’s spent the whole offseason running from this. Weeks of sleeping on couches of his friends’ college apartments in Toledo and Richmond to avoid going home.

He didn’t want to go back to his parents in South Carolina, a place so closely associated with a sport he’d begun to believe he’d never play again. Bender’s parents have taken his situation hard. His father, Dennis, checks MLB’s press releases every day to see if there’s an announcement from the league about his status, and has met with a lawyer about possible steps to sue. His mother, Diane, says she wakes up in the middle of the night and cries.

“It breaks my heart for my kid,” Diane said, “that it’s a possibility that he might not be able to play this game again at a high level. Because that’s all he ever wanted to do.”

Instead of moving back in with his family, he crashed with a childhood friend in Albany, where he’d grown up.

“I wanted to be around my friends,” Bender said. “… I wanted to be somewhere where baseball didn’t matter as much.”

Bender’s rental house isn’t messy, but isn’t clean either. There’s an uneaten and unheated burrito on his plate, and a jumbo Chick-fil-A cup rests on a small table in front of the chair where he sits. He’s wearing Timberland boots, black cargo pants and a T-shirt.

That he was speaking publicly at all was so controversial within his own circles that he said he was unable to sleep the night prior.

For months, Bender’s agency, Octagon, strongly advised him against doing an interview. It wanted to wait until the league resolved its investigation into him.

Bender took that advice, until he didn’t. Torn between the instinct to give his side and the need for patience, he eventually decided he couldn’t wait any longer.

“It’s about gaining control over my life,” Bender said. “And this whole situation. I’m not doing this as a last-ditch effort to get back into affiliate ball. It’s more of this is the start of me taking control of my life again. Because I’ve let this completely control me for months now.”

His primary agent, Jake Rosner, said he was unaware the interview had taken place. And after The Athletic reached out to Rosner to request comment, Octagon dropped Bender as a client.

“We would have preferred that he not do any media requests or sit down with anyone from the media until this investigation was closed,” said Rosner, adding that it indicated to them he was no longer taking Octagon’s advice.

“We don’t make comments when investigations are ongoing,” Rosner said. “That simple.”

Even though he is denying the allegations now, Bender said he trusted Octagon’s advice at the time, which is why he declined to comment when the story first broke.

What came after Bender’s no-comment to ESPN was something Bender never anticipated. He says he was unaware of the reporter Jeff Passan, a prominent and well-sourced baseball writer. As a result, Bender didn’t understand the reach his story would garner.

That is until about 10 p.m. that evening, when he was hanging out with friends. There, he experienced the surreal feeling of getting a push notification about himself.

Almost immediately, aggregated articles started pouring in from news outlets all over the country. Messages on all of his social media accounts. Bender and his buddies sat and watched it unfold in real time.

“I had to go dark for at least three days,” Bender said. “I had to private all my social media accounts. I was getting death threats and awful, obscene things said to me.”

The vitriol has simmered, as expected. The world has moved on from this story in a way that Bender still can’t.

And now with no agent and a shredded reputation, Bender awaits MLB’s verdict. He sat down with investigators in November, going over that inning pitch-by-pitch. Trying to convince them that he is innocent, with the possibility of a career-ending ban if they decide otherwise.

“I feel like my whole life has been centered around baseball, and for good reason, “ Bender said.

“This whole situation made me fall out of love with it. But I realized that I want to win more baseball games in my career. I love baseball. I love winning. I love being a part of a team. There’s nothing more I want to do.”


In the back of Bender’s car is a large Twins duffel bag that still carries all of his baseball equipment.

His relationship with the team that gave him a chance is complicated. In one breath, he’s complimentary: “I don’t fault anybody in the Twins organization. I think they handled it well.”

But in another, he says the exact opposite. “It never really felt like the Twins had my back.”

It remains a very real possibility that Bender’s Twins bag will be the last big league gear he’ll ever receive. He’s done the obvious calculation in his mind. This never would have happened to a first-round pick, he said. But a sixth-round pick? There’s no impetus for another team to take him on.

The sport of baseball could very easily continue on without Derek Bender.

“That’s the reality of it,” he said, fully accepting of that fact.

This accusation could follow him throughout his life, a detriment to any career path. The longtime hockey fan wants to someday be a psychologist for NHL players. But at just 22, Bender views his next job as a chance at redemption. He’ll earn just $1,200 this summer playing independent ball for the Brockton Rox of the Frontier League. It’s a move that’s more about proving to himself and everyone else just how much he cares about winning.

Even with a GM and coach who have known Bender for years, Brockton is playing this cautiously. And nothing is guaranteed until he actually takes the field. The results of MLB’s investigation could impact his ability to play, or Brockton’s desire to have him.

“I think the biggest thing was being willing to give a guy a second chance, to do what he’s trained his whole life to do, and what he loves,” said Rox GM Jerod Edmondson, who said he didn’t investigate the allegations before adding Bender. “I think everybody makes mistakes. He’s 22 years old.”

Sausville is Brockton’s hitting coach. There were stretches in which the two talked 20 times a day. And as a longtime confidant of Bender, he believes in Bender’s innocence. Even if MLB eventually says he’s guilty, Sausville will welcome him.

But he’s not blind to the circumstances that led Bender here, and remains open to the idea that there could be more to this accusation than he knows.

“After this is all said and done, he needs to sit in the mirror and ask himself: why isn’t everyone jumping up to stick up for me?” Sausville said.

“I think a lot of it comes from selfish immaturity. And also a one-track mind of, ‘I’m trying to make the big leagues … and I don’t care who I piss off on the way there.”

Bender wants to prove he can still be a catcher, even though he knows his only path might be a move to first base, recognizing that pitchers will be apprehensive to throw to him.

He wants to tell the world that he’s a person who loves those close to him. “I’m a loving friend, I’m a caring person. I’m a guy that (teammates) want in their foxhole.”

He wants people to accept that he’s a changed athlete, who’s done complaining about having to play. “You’ll never hear that come out of my mouth again,” he said. “I’ve worked really hard for this, and I don’t want it all to go away because of one accusation.”

But, he said, he doesn’t feel like he owes it to anyone to plead his innocence.

Bender might not feel an obligation to prove his credibility. But it nonetheless is something that, with every word he says, will be continuously scrutinized. It is not going away.

So, ultimately the question remains.

Can he be trusted?

“People will think whatever they want to think, whether I say it or not,” he said.

“Like let’s be honest. Nobody’s ever going to be here and say ‘Yeah, I did it.’ Most of the time, people are going to deny, deny, deny. People are going to make their decisions, whether I say it or not.”

The Athletic’s Dan Hayes contributed reporting to this story.

(Top Illustration: Demetrius Robinson / The Athletic; Photo: Isaiah Vazquez/Getty Images)

Lazerus: Bill Zito’s Panthers, Kyle Davidson’s Blackhawks and the road not taken

It’s entirely possible that four or five summers from now, Connor Bedard’s name will be etched on the Stanley Cup.

He’ll have won the Conn Smythe Trophy that spring, of course, after a truly absurd playoff run flanked by Michael Misa and Frank Nazar, with Artyom Levshunov logging a heroic 30 minutes a night on the back end. Kevin Korchinski will have racked up the points as his partner on the top pair, with Sam Rinzel lighting it up, as well. Alex Vlasic’s work as the shutdown defender will be the stuff of legends. That second line of Nick Lardis, Sacha Boisvert and Oliver Moore will have made those Blackhawks matchup-proof, forcing opposing coaches to pick their poison.

And man, who’ll be able to forget the way Samuel Savoie, Landon Slaggert and Marek Vanacker wreaked havoc on the newly christened Hair on Fire line, bringing energy to the team and fans out of their seats?

It absolutely could happen.

Kyle Davidson is counting on it, staking his reputation on it, testing Chicago’s patience on it. Davidson sold Danny Wirtz on his plan to gut the franchise and rebuild it through the NHL Draft, and that’s exactly what Davidson has done.

Eight first-round picks in the last three seasons. Two more this year. Two more the year after that. It’ll always be an amusing footnote in Blackhawks history that Davidson’s tank failed but the ping-pong balls fell his way anyway, landing him the centerpiece in Bedard. The rest has been done with ruthlessness and a lack of sentimentality. Davidson has had as clear a vision as any general manager in the game, and he has stuck with it every step of the way.

This is how professional sports teams operate these days, especially in a salary-cap league. When things are going poorly, you blow it up and start over. That’s just how it works.

The thing is, it hasn’t worked. Not in the NHL. Not in the cap era. Not yet. The Buffalo Sabres blew it up, tried to tank for Connor McDavid, and are going to miss the playoffs for the 14th consecutive season. The Detroit Red Wings blew it up, built through the draft, made some savvy picks that have worked out well, and are scratching and clawing to be the eighth seed in the East after eight long seasons without a playoff appearance. The Edmonton Oilers picked No. 1 four times in five seasons and landed the most talented player the game has ever seen, and they didn’t reach true contention until last spring — a decade after drafting McDavid and 14 years after taking Taylor Hall.

And the Blackhawks, eight years removed from their last true playoff appearance, are still years away from the next one.

Saturday, Davidson traded one of his three best players, defenseman Seth Jones, to the Florida Panthers, because Jones couldn’t take the losing anymore. Davidson did relatively well in the deal — getting goaltender Spencer Knight and retaining only $2.5 million a year of Jones’ massive contract — but it was still yet another trade that made the Blackhawks demonstrably worse. Always one step forward, two steps back.

Now let’s look at the team that acquired Jones. When Bill Zito took over as GM in Florida, the Panthers were still something of a league laughingstock. They hadn’t won a playoff series in a quarter-century. The roster was loaded with mediocre players in their mid-to-late 20s. They were stuck.


Florida Panthers GM Bill Zito hoists the 2024 Stanley Cup. (Bruce Bennett / Getty Images)

But Zito didn’t tear it down. He didn’t rebuild the Panthers. He remade them. He used every tool at his disposal — trades, free agency, the waiver wire — to reconstruct the plane while it was still in the air. Within four years, the Panthers were Stanley Cup champions, a model franchise, the envy of the league.

Look at how that championship team was built. Zito made one of the gutsiest trades in modern NHL history to land Matthew Tkachuk. He saw players who hadn’t yet reached their potential and got them, trading for Sam Reinhart, Sam Bennett, Brandon Montour and Eetu Luostarinen. He made smart signings in free agency, inking Carter Verhaeghe, Evan Rodrigues and Oliver Ekman-Larsson. And he found gold on the waiver wire, picking up Gustav Forsling — cast off by the Vancouver Canucks, the Blackhawks and the Carolina Hurricanes — and watching him become one of the best defensemen in the league. He dealt away his first-round pick in 2022. And in 2023. And in 2024. And in 2025. And in 2026. The only key players who came through the draft were already there when he arrived: Aleksander Barkov (No. 2 in 2013), Aaron Ekblad (No. 1 in 2014) and Anton Lundell (No. 12 in 2020).

It certainly wasn’t easy, and there certainly was some luck involved. Surely, Zito didn’t see Forsling becoming the player he is. Nobody saw a 57-goal season from Reinhart coming after six unspectacular seasons in Buffalo. And he did all this with Sergei Bobrovsky’s $10 million cap hit weighing him down, an albatross that eventually took flight. What Zito did is incredibly difficult.

But what Davidson is doing might be even harder.

Davidson had his chance to do this more quickly, to spare the fans all this misery. The 2021-22 Blackhawks had a 23-year-old Alex DeBrincat and a 23-year-old Brandon Hagel. They had a 26-year-old Jones and a 24-year-old Dylan Strome. And they had Patrick Kane posting 92 points.

Now? DeBrincat is with the Detroit Red Wings, on the verge of his fourth 30-goal season. Hagel is with the Tampa Bay Lightning, a burgeoning superstar enjoying his second 30-goal season and first point-per-game campaign. Strome is with the Washington Capitals, riding shotgun to history as Alex Ovechkin’s center, with 59 points in 60 games. Kane, despite playing just 100 games, has more points over the last two seasons than every Blackhawks player other than Bedard.

That’s more than Florida had when Zito took over. But DeBrincat and Hagel were too old (despite being a year younger than Barkov and Ekblad when Zito took over). Bedard was too important. The draft was the only path forward. The teardown was the only way.

It’s facile, and perhaps folly, to point all this out in hindsight, of course. There’s a reason so few GMs are willing to be as bold as Zito has been. It usually ends in a firing. Had Davidson tried to retool around his young rising stars and Kane on the fly back then, it’s just as likely that the Blackhawks would be stuck in the mushy middle the past few years as in the Stanley Cup Final.

But either of those scenarios sounds pretty darn good compared to what the Blackhawks have been the last four years, what they’ll probably be the next few years, and what drove Jones out of the city he was so excited to come to in the first place.

What’s done is done, but it doesn’t have to stay this way. It’s long past time for Davidson to get aggressive, to start trying to win for real. Yes, he made a run at Jake Guentzel last summer, but he came up short. He somehow has to convince Mikko Rantanen or Mitch Marner this summer to sign up for seven years of playing with Bedard. Or go after Wyatt Johnston or Noah Dobson or Evan Bouchard with an offer sheet. Or package some of the myriad picks and prospects and young players he has amassed to land a ready-made rising star.

Or all of the above. It’s what Zito would do. It’s what Zito has done. It’s what works.

It’s time to get bold. It’s time to get creative. It’s time to start winning again. Because the current path is not just excruciating; it’s extremely unlikely to work. History has shown us that. And it’s better to aspire to be the Florida Panthers than risk becoming the Buffalo Sabres.

(Top photo of Seth Jones: Bill Smith / NHLI via Getty Images)

Honestly, Ruben, maybe you should try not saying what’s on your mind for a change

A few years ago, I got into a lift with a former colleague I knew a little but wouldn’t exactly describe as a close friend. In the way that we all have done hundreds of times, I asked how he was, expecting a variant of the standard response: “Yeah, not bad thanks, mate. How are you?”

Instead, this colleague said flatly: “My wife wants a divorce.”

I can’t really remember how the rest of the conversation went in the short but excruciating journey to our floor, so paralysed by awkwardness was I. Did I offer sympathy, constructive advice, compassion? I hope so, but I can’t guarantee it. My colleague was merely saying what was on his mind, speaking his truth, but the lack of social filter, the brutal honesty of the interaction was too much and threw me entirely off-kilter.

Honesty is good. You shouldn’t lie. In most circumstances, it would be better if we all told the truth. In most circumstances. Not always.

There’s a lot to be said for the harmless lie, the artfully concealed truth, the slight diversion from your true feelings when it would be much better for all concerned just to hold back a little bit. Which brings us to Ruben Amorim.

The Manchester United head coach is a very honest man. Incredibly honest. In fact, he’s far too honest, seemingly a man incapable of hiding his true feelings when faced with questions from the media.

Here are a few examples of the extremely honest things he has said in public, since arriving at Old Trafford in November.

“I am not helping my players in the moment.”

“David Moyes is doing a better job than me, it’s simple.”

“I have to sell my idea, I don’t have another one.”


Ruben Amorim often bares his soul in press conferences (Carl Recine/Getty Images)

“Imagine what this is for a fan of Manchester United. Imagine what this is for me. We are getting a new coach who is losing more than the last coach.”

“We are the worst team maybe in the history of Manchester United.”

“This club needs a shock.”

That is really clear (that United could get relegated), so we have to fight.”

Amorim has always been like this. Some of his former players told The Athletic in January that honesty and clear communication are among his strengths. “We prefer the truth,” one of them said.

But while the managerial straight shooter can be useful, constructive even, there must be a point where it becomes counterproductive. His public self-flagellation won’t necessarily tally with what he says in the dressing room, but you feel it’s unlikely that his players would have been fired up after he declared them the worst team in United’s history — even if he did clarify a few days later that he was referring to himself more than his squad.

It sometimes feels like we, the public, are participating in a mass therapy session, that Amorim is unburdening his soul at every possible opportunity. Maybe that’s good, maybe it feels cathartic, maybe it’s better than bottling it all up.

Imagine if you were his friend and he was constantly telling you stuff like this, though. You’d do your best to help him but there must be a point where you’d say: “Come on, mate… give it a bit of a rest.” He’d be the guy at a party bumming everyone out if he happened to have a bad day.


Amorim has overseen 10 wins from his 23 games in charge of United (Carl Recine/Getty Images)

And there have been a lot of bad days at United so far. It’s impossible not to have some sympathy for Amorim; a young coach who had already achieved plenty but who was coming to the end of a cycle at Sporting CP and was given an opportunity he didn’t feel he could say no to.

He wanted to wait until the summer, as was sensible, but United insisted that he take the job there and then, as was very not sensible. Perhaps he should have held his nerve, trusted that he could finish the season in Portugal and still get a bigger job, and avoid the swirling mess of Manchester United altogether.

But there he is, looking increasingly beleaguered on the touchline and then, once he’s facing the cameras and the microphones, shows the world his truth.

All of this would be very different if things were going better on the pitch. If United were winning, then this column might have been about how refreshing his honesty is, how it’s surely a virtue that has helped relate to his players. But like most other things in football, everything is viewed through the prism of results.

He doesn’t seem to be playing a character or presenting a persona, as managers sometimes do in order to create some distance between their actual self and their public-facing self.

Which, for those outside of United, particularly the media, is great. Having a manager bare his soul rather than stare blankly down the camera and offer a set of interchangeable platitudes is entertaining, an interesting diversion from the norm, grimly fascinating even.


Amorim is an engaging speaker… but not one for sugarcoating (Alex Livesey/Getty Images)

For his sake though, it can’t be a good thing. Apart from the debatable benefits of public self-abasement, many of his statements only serve to emphasise the negativity around United — which doesn’t need much emphasising — and create more debate and fevered coverage.

Would anyone seriously be talking about the prospect of United being relegated, given the state of the bottom three, if he hadn’t mentioned it? What is the benefit of comparing himself negatively to Erik ten Hag or Moyes? These are the sort of things that might be true but you don’t need to actually say them.

Apart from anything else, from a self-preservation point of view, there must come a point where his employers think that he’s far too honest, that he is attracting more negativity to United than they can stomach.

Perhaps there was some evidence that the United boss can play the game when he downplayed Alejandro Garnacho’s reaction to being substituted against Ipswich Town in his latest press conference on Friday, saying that the 20-year-old will pay for a team dinner after disappearing down the tunnel rather than taking a spot on the substitutes’ bench.

Still, the advice to Amorim is just to dial it back a little. Everyone will understand if you try a little positive spin on things occasionally. Nobody will blame you for a little fib every now and then.

And if you get into a lift and someone asks how things are going, just say: “Yeah, not bad thanks, mate. How are you?”

(Top photo: Oli Scarff/AFP via Getty Images)

Is Arch Manning ready to take over at Texas, then the NFL? Just ask his former teammates

INDIANAPOLIS — Arch Manning is at least a year away from fielding questions at the NFL Scouting Combine. Still, his former Texas teammates fully expect the sophomore quarterback to eventually join them at the highest level.

“I think he can,” wide receiver Matthew Golden said Friday. “He has the heart to do it. Arch comes in each and every day, and he goes to work. He acts like a walk-on. He has a story. He’s trying to make a name for himself.”

Manning started two games for the Longhorns last year as a redshirt freshman while filling in for injured starter Quinn Ewers. Manning, who stands 6 feet 4 and weighs 225 pounds, finished the season with 939 passing yards, nine touchdowns, two interceptions and a 67.8 completion percentage.

The nephew of Peyton Manning and Eli Manning and the grandson of Archie Manning — all first-round NFL quarterbacks — the youngest Manning rushed for 108 yards and four touchdowns on 25 carries. His 67-yard touchdown sprint against UTSA was the longest by a Texas quarterback since Vince Young’s 80-yard run in 2005.

“He’s an amazing thrower, but what shocked me the most is that he can run,” receiver Isaiah Bond said. “I wasn’t expecting that at all, but Arch has some wheels on him. I’ve just never seen a quarterback run like that before, especially because he’s a big guy, too. So, to be moving at that speed, he is pretty amazing.”

In the past 25 years, Manning is the only FBS or NFL QB to post a touchdown pass exceeding 75 yards, a touchdown run for more than 65 yards and another 50-yard scoring pass in the same game. Manning did that against UTSA, a game he didn’t even start. Manning spelled Ewers in that game and completed 9 of 12 passes for four touchdowns and 223 yards while rushing for his 67-yarder in a 56-7 win.


Arch Manning, right, started two games in 2024 when Quinn Ewers was out with an injury. (David Buono / Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

As the nation’s No. 1 recruit in 2023, Manning immediately applied pressure to Ewers, who was No. 1 in 2021. Then with those performances, Manning’s presence intensified the tension on Ewers, which forced him to continually improve to remain a starter.

“It says in the Bible, iron sharpens iron,” Ewers said. “So, it was good for me and him to kind of get to work together. And we both are competing for the same job, but us being pals off the field was good for us as well.

“I wouldn’t trade any of that, because it’s the reality of the position. There’s always going to be a big name in the room or around the room. So, I’m glad that he was a part of our team, and I’m glad that I had to hear about it as well.”

After his two starts against Louisiana-Monroe and Mississippi State, Manning played sparingly the rest of the season, completing 6 of 12 passes for 38 yards and rushing 12 times for 26 yards and a touchdown. The Longhorns reached the College Football Playoff semifinals in their first SEC campaign.

With Ewers eyeing an NFL career, it’s Manning’s time to stand out at Texas. And his former teammates believe he is ready for the spotlight.

“He’s gonna be a great player,” Ewers said. “He’s a hard-working kid. I think that he has some traits that I had as well. He’s definitely got poise and composure, and I think that he’s ready for any moment that arises because he sat behind me, he saw how I did it. And then obviously he’s going to have his ways that he’s going to want to do it.”

“He can spin the ball real well,” Golden said. “He can run the ball, too. I feel like there’s nothing Arch can’t do. So, I’m excited to see what he’s going to do next year. For his caliber, how young he is, he understands the game at a high level.

“You can tell when he’s in the game. So, just waiting for him to get the opportunity to start. It’s gonna be good.”

(Top photo: Matthew Visinsky / Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

Neymar back to Barcelona: Is that a good idea?

No, you’re not dreaming, it is the year 2025.

You might be wondering how on earth, then, we are sitting here discussing the possibility of Neymar returning to Barcelona this summer.

After all, the Brazilian has just turned 33 years old and has only played 13 games of football in the past two seasons.

I’m not going to blame you for scratching your head. However, this is the world of football transfers — and the world of Barcelona football club — which means: don’t rule anything out. 

As unreasonable of a fit as he might seem for Hansi Flick’s Barcelona, it is an idea being explored behind the scenes, as reported by my colleague David Ornstein. 

I’ll start by laying out the state of play.

Neymar signed a six-month deal with his boyhood club Santos last month, after reaching an agreement with his Saudi club Al Hilal to leave on a free transfer. He moved to Saudi for €90million (£80m/$102m) in 2023 and scored once in seven appearances, with his stay disrupted massively by the anterior cruciate ligament injury he suffered while playing for Brazil just months after he joined.

His short-term contract at Santos will, in theory, allow him to get back in shape — and he has made a bright start, scoring twice in his six appearances so far. Despite the stuttering return with Al Hilal after his ACL injury, Neymar is now on a mission.

It is no secret that Brazil’s record goalscorer has pushed to come back to Barcelona multiple times since he joined PSG in 2017 for a fee of €222million — which remains a world record. Neymar never felt as comfortable in Paris as he did in Barcelona, and his entourage have let the club know that for years.

In 2019, the Barcelona president, Josep Maria Bartomeu, tried and failed to bring him back. Four years later, when Neymar left PSG to join Al Hilal, he tested the waters with Barcelona before committing to Saudi. At that time, the Catalans were drowning in a financial turmoil and they could not even dream of paying a fee to PSG. Neymar accepted the reality of the situation and agreed to join Al Hilal.  


(Fayez Nureldine/AFP via Getty Images)

But why should it be different now, with Barcelona still fighting over salary limits and player registrations? And most importantly, in what world can club executives think it is a good idea to sign an older player and risk disrupting the established order of a young squad bursting with talent? 

Pini Zahavi, the player’s agent, is a key figure when it comes to trying to understand what is happening here. Zahavi holds a tight friendship with the Barca president Joan Laporta, who has sanctioned in recent years the arrival of two of Zahavi’s biggest clients: Robert Lewandowski and Hansi Flick. The relationship between the agent and the executive has been essential in those transfers, and will surely be again in the future; Jonathan Tah, the Bayer Leverkusen centre-back available on a free this summer, is another player managed by Zahavi who has been linked with Barcelona.

With the club due to be playing at the renovated Camp Nou in 2025-26, the arrival of a star name like Neymar would be appealing to Laporta — to celebrate the return to the stadium and to help sell out the 60,000 seats initially available when the team does return.

Inside the dressing room, Neymar would have some influential allies. The club captain and star performer this season, Raphinha, has always been close to Neymar from their time together with the Brazil national team. Then there is Lamine Yamal, who grew up worshipping Neymar. The two met at the Globe Soccer Awards Gala in December and have been interacting with each other on social media in the months since.


(Marc Atkins/Getty Images)

One positive for Barcelona’s precarious financial situation is that Neymar would arrive on a free transfer, with his short-term deal with Santos expiring this summer. With his sight set on representing Brazil at the 2026 World Cup in the United States, Canada and Mexico, he may even agree to personal terms that were favourable to Barcelona in order to be back at a club he loves on the biggest stage.

From a football perspective, it is difficult to argue how this move would make sense. It’s hard to see how a 33-year-old Neymar, with his extensive injury record, would fit in Flick’s high-pressing system, which requires a significant amount of off-the-ball work from his forward line. This exact issue, in fact, is the reason why the 36-year-old Lewandowski has been dropped from the starting line-up several times this season.

It is no secret that Barcelona’s sporting director, Deco, is exploring the market for a new forward — preferably one that can play on the left-hand side as well as in a central position.

Club sources, who asked to speak anonymously to protect their jobs, told The Athletic that some of the players favoured by Deco are Liverpool’s Luis Diaz, Milan’s Rafael Leao and Newcastle’s Alexander Isak. They look like far more suitable profiles to how Flick wants his Barcelona to play — but all three will have plenty of suitors this summer should they leave their current clubs.

But what if Barcelona’s financial hurdles do Neymar a favour here? What if the club can’t fight to sign one of Deco’s top targets because of more registration problems? What if Neymar is the most feasible option available, and one that would please the club’s president and likely give a boost to matchday ticket sales? 

This is certainly going to be the biggest decision facing Barcelona this summer. As relevant as Laporta’s criteria has always been when it comes to Barcelona’s business activity, the preferences of Deco and the amount of money that the club recoup from player sales are important factors too. 

And, above them all, there should be the thoughts of Flick, the manager who has invigorated Barcelona and turned them into La Liga and Champions League contenders. No relevant signing will be made next summer without him giving it the green light — even if he and Neymar do share an agent. 

But, as we said: this is the sometimes unfathomable world of football transfers, and this is Barcelona, so don’t rule anything out…

(David Ramos/Getty Images)

Court Vision: Why is NCAA Tournament expansion talk a thing? Is Gonzaga really in trouble?

Did March sneak up on anyone else?

We have been enjoying the regular season so much that we kind of forgot it’s almost over. But the reality is, the first conference tournament bracket — thanks, Atlantic Sun — is already out. League titles are being clinched. The bubble is bubbling. All of the things!

But that means it’s time for one of our least favorite annual storylines: greedy, grubby fingers trying to wreck something that doesn’t need fixing.

1. NCAA Tournament expansion

On “College GameDay” two weekends ago, ESPN’s Pete Thamel reported (almost unprompted) that while NCAA Tournament expansion talks are still ongoing, decision-makers “seem to be down the road” with a concept that would alter the best postseason in sports by growing the field from 68 teams to potentially 76.

“We should know fairly soon,” Thamel said. “Two, three months. Something like that.”


Hubert Davis’ North Carolina Tar Heels are 1-10 in Quad 1 games this season. (John Byrum / Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

At the risk of calling expansion “imminent,” Thamel isn’t reporting this live on GameDay if it weren’t a serious possibility. And given that timeline, the NCAA and its television partners may settle on an agreement in time to adjust the 2026 tournament. All of which is a long way of saying, this very well may be the last Big Dance as we know it and as we’ve known it since 1985.

Mechanically speaking, what might going to 76 teams look like? An expanded First Four, per Thamel, with eight teams competing in Dayton — where the First Four is held annually — and eight more at another site to be determined (likely outside of the Eastern time zone, for logistical reasons).

Using The Athletic’s latest bracket prediction, let’s consider what this year’s field would look like with 76 teams. All of the following would be included, rather than sweating out their spots:

  • Indiana (17-11), which already has announced coach Mike Woodson will be stepping down
  • Wake Forest (19-9), which has one Top-25 win all season and has lost consecutive games to 11-17 NC State and 14-14 Virginia
  • North Carolina (18-11), which is 1-10 in Quad 1 games with a single victory all season over a team currently thought to be in the field
  • SMU (21-7), which has zero top-50 wins all season
  • Plus Cincinnati, Xavier, Boise State and TCU, which have combined to go 37-31 in their respective conferences with just two Top-25 wins

Other than SEC commissioner Greg Sankey, who wants that?

Regarding Sankey, whose tenure has included going scorched earth on everything college sports hold dear in pursuit of cartoonish stacks of cash, it should surprise no one that Thamel said expansion conversations have been “driven by the power conferences.” Sankey even told The Athletic last spring that automatic bids for smaller conferences should be “part of the review” of the NCAA Tournament. Suffice it to say, it’s obvious how this is going to go: More mediocre high-major teams (like the ones above) will be included while deserving mid-majors get left out in the cold.

Which of these resumes is more deserving of making the Big Dance?

STAT TEAM A TEAM B

RECORD

19-7

17-11

NET RANKING

49

36

KENPOM RANKING

43

38

QUAD 1 RECORD

4-5

3-11

Reasonable arguments can be made for both sides. It’s a coin flip. Do you prefer the total wins and better Q1 record or the metric rankings? Time’s up. Team A is … San Diego State, and Team B is … Georgia. In The Athletic’s latest bracket, those two face off in this season’s First Four.

The point is that both have defensible arguments for inclusion. But does anyone think that many — if any — of those additional bids are going to teams like SDSU? From the Mountain West, Missouri Valley or Big West, instead of the SEC?

If you do, I have a bridge to sell you.

The simple logic is that more games equal more revenue. NCAA Tournament revenue accounts for, at most, five percent of the budget at most high-major schools (although it’s more at mid- and low-majors). That’s not nothing, but in the grand scheme of modern college sports, it’s not the end-all, be-all. The motivation for expansion, then, is as much about “inclusion” as anything else. With Division I men’s basketball having ballooned to 364 teams — which is a story for another day — only 18.7 percent of Division I is represented in a 68-team field. And while 76 teams are only marginally better, at 20.9 percent of teams, that does move the needle at least a little closer to the 25 percent threshold recommended by the NCAA Division I Transformation Committee in January 2023.

But who cares what that committee recommended?

The NCAA Tournament has existed in its current iteration for four decades and has proven time and time again that it needs no alterations. Need anyone be reminded of Saint Peters’ Elite 8 run in 2022? Fairleigh-Dickinson in 2023? Florida Atlantic vs. San Diego State in the Final Four? People like Sankey aren’t advocating for more of those opportunities; they’re advocating for more dollars in their pockets and more of their toys in the sandbox — at Cinderella’s expense.

2. It’s time to talk Gonzaga

Gonzaga isn’t going to miss the NCAA Tournament, right?

It’s closer than you’d think and closer than the Zags truly have been to the cutline since maybe 2011. Mark Few’s team went 25-10 that season with just three top-50 wins in the regular season, compared to two sub-100 losses. It ultimately earned a No. 11 seed — one of just three times in the past two decades (the others being 2007 and 2016) that Gonzaga has been a double-digit seed.

Now compare that to this season. Gonzaga’s on the same pace: 22-8 with only two top-50 wins, both of which came in November. And while these Zags don’t have any sub-100 losses weighing down their resume, they don’t have any wins over sure-fire tournament teams. (Baylor and San Diego State — Gonzaga’s two top-50 wins — are solidly on the bubble.) Frankly, the computer rankings are carrying a lot of weight for Few’s team as Gonzaga is in the top 10 in both the NET and by KenPom. After Gonzaga, the next highest-ranked NET team with two or fewer Quad-1 wins is VCU, at 29.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

NCAA Tournament 2025 Bracket Watch: Auburn and Duke avoidance is a smart Final Four play

While Few’s team isn’t below the cutline, it would serve the Zags well not to fall flat in their regular-season finale vs. San Francisco on Saturday or in the WCC tournament. Bracket Matrix has Gonzaga as a No. 9 seed, but that’s before Tuesday’s, Wednesday’s and Thursday’s results factor in. (The SEC earned several massive bubble wins this week, like Arkansas over Texas and Georgia over Florida.)

With Saint Mary’s sweeping the regular-season series and clinching the WCC outright for the second straight season, it’s the first time since 1990-92 — when Few was still a fresh-faced assistant — that Gonzaga hasn’t earned at least a share of the WCC regular-season title in consecutive campaigns. That speaks to the team’s relative mediocrity as well as anything.

Gonzaga’s at the point where it’s going to get the benefit of the doubt from the committee. And it’s not like it has any bad losses, with an overtime road defeat at 20-win Oregon State as the worst of the bunch.

But it’s a situation worth monitoring during the next few weeks. I wouldn’t bet on the Zags missing the field if the bracket dropped today, but if nothing else, Gonzaga making a 10th consecutive Sweet 16 — which would break its tie with Duke for the longest such streak of the modern era — feels, unlikely.

3. A bubblicious spotlight

Three teams that, for better or worse, won’t go away:

Arkansas: This feels impossible given the Razorbacks’ early season “defense,” but it’s true: Arkansas has the fifth-best adjusted defensive efficiency in the country since Feb. 1, per Bart Torvik, ahead of juggernauts such as Duke, Tennessee and Houston. And it’s not like John Calipari’s team has been playing bad teams this month. Arkansas is 5-3 during that stretch with wins over Kentucky and Missouri, which are both tracking as top-four seeds. So, what gives?

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Men’s college basketball bubble watch: SEC hopefuls surging just before March

For starters, credit to Calipari, who most of the college basketball universe was doubting weeks ago. And why wouldn’t we? Arkansas defended ball screens about as well as you and I do, dear readers. The proof, from the Hogs’ first SEC game vs. Tennessee:

Does the primary defender stop his man? Nope. How about the screener’s defender stopping the roll man? Also no. It’s not quite a red carpet to the basket, but it’s as close as you’ll find in a high-major conference game.

Now compare that to Wednesday night and Arkansas’ ball-screen defense vs. Texas:

That’s the same primary defender, D.J. Wagner (No. 21), only he looks like a different player. He chased over the screen and prevented the easy drive or pull-up jumper. Meanwhile, Jonas Aidoo (No. 9) stayed level with the screener as soon as he rolled, cutting off any potential passing window. The roll subsequently got blown up on the backside by Johnell Davis. Julian Larry still attempted the post entry, and Aidoo came away with the easy steal. Overall, it was much stickier, stouter coverage.

Opponents have shot only 30 percent from 3-point range against Arkansas this month, per Bart Torvik, and that is a top-50 rate nationally. That’s more like Calipari’s old Kentucky teams, which relied on lanky athletes to disrupt opposing actions. Combine that defensive surge with Zvonimir Ivisic’s offensive ascent — the 7-foot-2 Croatian has the first three 20-point games of his career in the Hogs’ past six games while shooting 40 percent from 3 — and Calipari has a team that suddenly doesn’t look so fun to play against.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

What Georgia’s upset win over Florida means in SEC, NCAA race

Georgia: Maybe the biggest bubble result of the week was Georgia’s shocking 88-83 win over Florida. But the final score doesn’t nearly do that game justice. UGA led by as many as 26 points in the first half before Florida mounted a comeback. The Gators eventually went on a 13-0 run in the final few minutes to take their first lead all night, 79-78, with less than 90 seconds to play. But soon after, Blue Cain delivered what turned out to be the game-winning 3-pointer on his first attempt from deep in the game:

Georgia forced a turnover and a missed deep 3 on Florida’s next two possessions to seal it. Wildly, that completed Georgia’s first AP top-five win since January 2004, and it might be the final piece to the Bulldogs’ NCAA Tournament resume. A 5-10 SEC record is not anything to write home about, but the overall resume ain’t bad.

A nonconference, neutral-court win over St. John’s has aged marvelously, as has a home win over Kentucky in Georgia’s second SEC game. Plus, every loss is to a top-40 team. And with Texas, South Carolina and Vanderbilt left on the schedule, there’s room for Mike White’s team to stack a few more wins and eliminate any doubt.

North Carolina: Since the NET was first introduced in 2018-19, only one team has made the NCAA Tournament with a single Quad 1 win: Drake in 2021.

That doesn’t bode well for UNC, which is currently 1-10 in Quad 1 games. But the good news? The Tar Heels, who have won four straight behind a revamped starting lineup (albeit against terrible competition), have seemingly rediscovered some confidence, just in time for one last crack at a second Quad 1 win.

The bad news is that the game is against Duke, which looks like the best team in the country and led by more than 30 the first time the rivals faced off in early February.

On one hand, that matchup remains awful for the undersized Tar Heels. But at the risk of getting Tar Heels fans’ hopes up: What if Hubert Davis’ team has found something of late? Because very quietly UNC has posted the fourth-best adjusted offensive efficiency in the country during this winning streak, per Bart Torvik. (Don’t say anything about the 198th-ranked defense.) Admittedly, those wins have come against 12-16 Syracuse, 11-17 NC State, 14-14 Virginia and 16-12 Florida State. But the larger shift behind that surge might carry: Davis once again tweaking his starting lineup and finally adding some size.

He reinserted 6-9 graduate forward Jae’Lyn Withers, who started UNC’s first seven games, into the starting five, which allowed Davis to stop misplaying 6-6 freshman wing Drake Powell as a small-ball four. Those decisions in turn sent sometimes-starters Ian Jackson and Seth Trimble to the bench, although both still see significant minutes. It’s not a direct correlation, but that spacing and lineup balance have contributed to UNC, which shot a middling 34 percent from 3 all season, suddenly knocking down 44.4 percent of its 3s the past two weeks, good for the 15th-best rate in the country.

Is that sustainable? That’s both a Withers-specific and big-picture question. As for Withers, there is a massive discrepancy between his production in UNC’s first 25 games and its past four:

  • First 25 games: 4.6 points, 3.4 rebounds and 38.2 percent from 3 in 14 minutes per game
  • Past four games: 13.5 points, 6.5 rebounds and 62.5 percent from 3 in 23.5 minutes

Expecting a player who made 13 of his 34 3-point attempts during the first four months of the season to suddenly keep up a 10-for-16 rate is almost definitely setting Withers up to fail. But the spacing he provides might not be fool’s gold and might provide UNC its best chance of countering Cooper Flagg and Duke.

Beating Duke is UNC’s easiest way to push to the right side of the bubble, but even a loss in that game isn’t necessarily fatal if the Tar Heels’ newfound lineup leads them on a mini ACC Tournament run. Crazier things have happened.

(Top photo of Mike Woodson: Joe Robbins / Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

Watkins, Betts or Hidalgo? Our experts debate who should win women’s basketball POY

The Athletic’s debate series features two writers breaking down a specific topic. In this edition, Chantel Jennings and Ben Pickman debate which women’s college basketball player should win Player of the Year.

 

Chantel Jennings: As we head into the final week of the season, there seems to be one overriding theme in women’s college hoops this year: parity at the top level of the game. We’ve already seen four No. 1 teams, and a handful of others are serious contenders for the national title. This is far more crowded at the top than we’ve ever seen (at least in the modern era of NCAA women’s basketball).

With that, there’s also a significant level of parity in the national Player of the Year race, and I, for one, feel like — just as the AP poll has jostled between a few top teams — I’ve gone between a few players throughout the year.

Ben Pickman: I totally agree. Last season, it was a foregone conclusion that Caitlin Clark would win Player of the Year honors, but it feels like an open question this season. However, there appears to be a top three, in no order: Notre Dame’s Hannah Hidalgo, USC’s JuJu Watkins and UCLA’s Lauren Betts.

Where are you leaning?

Jennings: I must admit, I often see way too many sides of an argument (it is my lot as a middle child), so this choice is challenging. In all the years I’ve considered this debate internally (and publicly, on the internet), I reached my decision with a more unique final factor.

With that said, I’m leaning heavily toward Betts.

Every time I watch UCLA, I’m taken with her gravitational pull in terms of opponents’ focus and what that means for her teammates’ abilities. Put aside that she’s a double-double machine, and consider how much her vision and passing have been factors this year. She’s averaging nearly three assists a game and had 11 against Minnesota. She blocks three shots a game while averaging fewer than two fouls per game, and this is all while playing only 30 minutes a game.

Pickman: She’s not my pick, but it’s hard to be unimpressed. She is drawing fouls like never before (7.6 per 40 minutes, up from 5.5 last year, according to CBB Analytics). She remains effective around the rim, and the rest of her scoring within the paint has improved. She shoots 62.2 percent from within four to six feet of the basket, well above the DI average of 52.2 percent.

Jennings: Honestly, seeing South Carolina in person recently was a tipping point. I know, it’s weird that a game that didn’t include Betts or UCLA would be why I started feeling more strongly about Betts as my POY pick.

Pickman: Because you came away even more impressed with how she played when UCLA beat South Carolina earlier this year?

Jennings: That game was really impressive. Betts is still one of just two players this season to record a 10-plus point, 10-plus rebound and four-plus assist game against the Gamecocks (the other player was UConn freshman Sarah Strong). But that wasn’t the ultimate deciding factor.

South Carolina looks largely identical to last year’s team except for losing Kamilla Cardoso. And yet, the Gamecocks aren’t playing nearly as efficiently, consistently or quite as impressively as last season. Their outside shooting hasn’t been as solid and their defense isn’t quite as stout. Why is that? Well, they no longer have a 6-foot-7 center holding down everything in the middle of the floor.

Seeing South Carolina with Cardoso and without Cardoso has reinforced to me the value of a player who can clean up the glass, create second-chance opportunities and be an absolute scouting nightmare, while also making each of her teammates better. It’s a familiar argument for point guards, but it also applies to Betts.

I had three overriding thoughts after South Carolina-UConn:

1. UConn can win the national title if it puts six games together like that in March and April.

2. I still feel fine about South Carolina’s chances of making the Final Four.

3. Betts is the Player of the Year.

Pickman: I don’t think there’s much debate that Betts has been the country’s best center. Frankly, she might also be the nation’s most improved player. And yet, I’m leaning toward another Big Ten player: Watkins.

She’s averaging 24.2 points, 6.9 rebounds, 3.6 assists and two blocks per game. It’s a gaudy stat line, but it’s sometimes taken for granted because of Watkins’ success as a freshman. But consider this: She has been more efficient as a sophomore. Her usage rate is down, and yet she still leads the conference with 7.9 win shares, per Sports Reference. She controls every aspect of the game and plays with wisdom beyond her years. Her basketball IQ translates into her ability to force timely steals and to avoid fouling if she gets whistled early in a game.

Plus, in USC’s biggest game of the season — against the Bruins — Watkins became the first Division I player with at least 35 points, five blocks and five assists in the last 20 years. It’s hard to overlook that masterclass in this discussion.

Jennings: Watkins certainly does everything for the Trojans, but I don’t love comparing players with total stats because it doesn’t account for Watkins playing 4 1/2 minutes more per game than Betts. When you break down win shares per 40 minutes, Betts edges out Watkins (if only by a hair).

Watkins has been excellent this season while navigating a similar cross-country schedule as Betts, and she has done it with a largely revamped roster around her (unlike Betts). The Trojans said goodbye to a bunch of Ivy League grad transfers and welcomed one of the nation’s top high school recruiting classes and one of the best transfer portal classes. For the second year in a row, a largely new crop of players revolved around Watkins, and, like last season, she has thrived. That’s no easy task.

Pickman: Right. For the second year in a row, she has produced more points than any player in her conference. In my mind — and I’m not alone — she’s the most talented player in the country. Can you imagine USC without Watkins? She is a big reason it could still be a No. 1 seed for the second consecutive year, a feat the Trojans haven’t achieved since the 1980s.

Jennings: Hidalgo needs to be in this conversation, too. Even with the ball in her hands slightly less this season because the Irish welcomed back a healthy Olivia Miles, she has managed to increase her contribution to their success. It’s wild to think that six months ago many of us were wondering, “Is there really enough basketball to go around for two elite backcourt players like Miles and Hidalgo?” And the answer, emphatically delivered by both, has been: Oh, yes!

Hidalgo has become even more unguardable with her improved 3-point shooting. Her ability to finish at the rim has remained elite, but her free-throw shooting has increased, too, by 10 percentage points, making the decision to foul her an even tougher gamble. Defensively, she’s averaging fewer steals this year, but ask any coach who has faced the Irish this season and they’ll certainly say that Hidalgo causes even more headaches this season on defense.

But ultimately, I still think Betts has a great impact on her team and influence on the outcome of games for UCLA, so for that reason, she has my vote.

Pickman: Notre Dame is well positioned to get a No. 1 seed as well. All three of the players we’ve mentioned are locks for the All-America team, but each still has a lot to play for.

The Irish close their regular season against Florida State and Louisville, both of whom are ranked. They’re clinging to a slim lead in the ACC regular-season title race. UCLA and USC play Saturday in a matchup that will decide the Big Ten title. Big showings from Betts, Hidalgo and Watkins will impact their teams and also their award candidacies.

(Photo of Lauren Betts, left, and JuJu Watkins: Brian Rothmuller / Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

Why the Texas Rangers are betting on Joc Pederson for a championship revival

SURPRISE, Ariz. — The groundwork for Joc Pederson becoming a Texas Ranger was laid last September, when Rangers president of baseball operations Chris Young sat with Arizona Diamondbacks general manager Mike Hazen. The two men were discussing the divergent paths taken by their teams. After meeting in the World Series the year before, the runner-up Diamondbacks had gotten better. The triumphant Rangers had gotten worse. Young was trying to figure out why.

Part of the difference, Young recognized, was Arizona’s young players had improved while Texas’ group had stagnated. Hazen kept referencing the influence of Pederson, one of the eldest players on the roster, a part-time designated hitter with an outsized influence on less experienced players such as Corbin Carroll, Jake McCarthy and Pavin Smith. A lightbulb flickered for Young.

“I thought, ‘We’re missing some of that right now in our group,’” Young said.

Three months later, after Pederson inked a two-year, $37 million deal with Texas, Young received a message from Hazen: “He’s going to transform your offense.”

Pederson was the biggest addition for a franchise with an estimated $223 million payroll, a front office geared toward aggression and a roster with championship aspirations led by manager Bruce Bochy.

On the field, Pederson does mostly one thing, using his left-handed swing to crush right-handed pitchers. Not many were better at that than he was in 2024, when he slugged .531 with 22 homers and a .923 OPS against righties. His 151 wRC+ ranked 10th in the sport among hitters with at least 400 plate appearances. It is away from the diamond, though, where Rangers officials hope Pederson can be transformative.

At 32, Pederson acts as a baseball-centric combination of the Pied Piper and the Cheshire Cat, a font of wisdom and a source of insouciance for those trailing in his wake.

“People just gravitate to him,” said San Diego Padres senior advisor Logan White, who drafted Pederson for the Los Angeles Dodgers in 2010.

Seven topsy-turvy seasons in Los Angeles provided the foundation for Pederson’s perspective. His fashion sense led to middle-aged men wearing pearl necklaces during Atlanta’s 2021 World Series run. He gifted the San Francisco Giants’ support staff with customized black and orange Air Jordan 1s. When Carroll was floundering last summer, Pederson set him up with his personal hitting coach.

“As far as treating people behind the scenes, clubhouse guys, young guys coming up to the big leagues for the first time, he’s basically the best I’ve seen with that stuff,” former Giants president of baseball operations Farhan Zaidi said. “He treats people really well — and he treats people really well when no one’s looking.”

Pederson can do all this, in part, because he did not become the player he once thought he might become.

“A lot of superstars, it takes a huge toll on your mental, physical, emotional body to be able to post for 162,” Pederson said. “I’m like right in the next tier — I don’t play for 162. I’m more accessible. Teams you go on, it always seems like, ‘Oh, he’s the best player. That’s his team.’ But rarely does it ever work out like that.”

Pederson carries himself with a blend of self-confidence, self-deprecation and self-awareness. To connect with teammates, he relies upon his wealth of experience, his generosity with time and money, his sneaky sense of humor. After a fantasy football dispute in 2022 led to former San Diego outfielder Tommy Pham slapping him, Pederson established a new peak for droll athletic comedy when he told reporters, as an explanation, “I did send a .GIF in the group chat that was making fun of the Padres.” At his introductory news conference with Texas, he heralded the demise of the Houston Astros’ hegemony in the American League West. “They’ve put together a nice little run,” he said. “It’s coming to an end.”

To make that boast a reality, the Rangers will rely on a resurgence from their homegrown core and a boost from Pederson. Those two hopes are intertwined.

“Some people want to be a—holes to the young guys,” Pederson said. “I don’t get down like that.”


As the winter unfolded, Rangers officials chatted with Corey Seager, who had teamed with Pederson for six seasons in Los Angeles. Seager, the $325-million shortstop, is an insular presence who dislikes rah-rah speeches and can usually be found before games silently sharpening his swing in the batting cage. Marcus Semien, the team’s other nine-figure infielder, has a similar fixation on his craft; he has played in at least 159 games in every full season since 2018. “How many players can truly relate to being Marcus and Corey?” Young said. Pederson, as became clear to Young in conversations with Seager and others, could fill that void.

“Every team needs that kind of guy, who can keep you light, keep you flowing,” Seager said. “Especially in the down times. He doesn’t get down.”

The down times outnumbered the good for Texas in 2024. The ferocious offense from 2023 turned feeble. Postseason hero Adolis García slumped all year. Third baseman Josh Jung broke his wrist in April. Evan Carter, who starred as a 21-year-old call-up the year prior, suffered a season-wrecking stress reaction in his back. The group finished the season ranked 23rd in slugging percentage, 23rd in OPS and 23rd in weighted on-base average. The team ended up six games beneath .500, a backslide that puzzled Young, Bochy and the rest of the front office.

Owner Ray Davis was unlikely to authorize massive free-agent additions after doling out nine-figure deals in recent years to Seager, Semien and starting pitcher Jacob deGrom, who has pitched in nine games and undergone a second Tommy John surgery since signing a five-year, $185 million contract. The largest expenditure for Texas this winter was a three-year, $75 million deal to bring back starter Nathan Eovaldi. Young still sought to change the composition of the lineup and alter the chemistry in the clubhouse.

The adjustments started in December with the acquisition of Miami Marlins infielder Jake Burger. Two weeks later, Texas dealt first baseman Nathaniel Lowe to Washington. Burger replaced Lowe at first base; Pederson took Lowe’s place as a source of left-handed-hitting thump.

Burger and Pederson punished fastballs in 2024 at about the same value as higher-profile sluggers such as Bryce Harper and Max Muncy, according to Sports Info Solutions. The Rangers identified the duo as crucial in a division that includes excellent fastball purveyors including Seattle’s trio of George Kirby, Bryan Woo and Logan Gilbert, plus Houston’s Framber Valdez.

“In our division, you’ve got to be able to hit righties,” Young said. “And you’ve got to be able to hit fastballs.”

Pederson does both. He also offered a relatability that Rangers officials thought might benefit youngsters such as Carter and outfielder Wyatt Langford.

“Not every player can be Joc Pederson,” Young said. “The fact that he views himself as more similar to most of the guys on the team, and not the superstars, speaks to his character.”


On the day before the Rangers’ first official workout, Pederson wandered through the clubhouse with a team-issued beanie cocked halfway up his forehead. On his third loop through the room, a visitor inquired about his meandering.

“I don’t know what I’m supposed to be doing,” he said. “I’m just trying to find my way. I’m just trying to find my way.”

He grabbed his iPhone and realized his immediate purpose.

“No,” he said, “I have groundballs at first at 9:30 a.m.”

Pederson did not take the field once for the Diamondbacks in 2024. He likely will fill a similar role for Texas. He has gained weight and lost speed since his days in the Dodgers minor-league system, when team officials dreamed about him becoming a five-tool player in center field. He was a multi-sport star at Palo Alto High in the Bay Area, the No. 1 wide receiver on a football team that also included future six-time Pro Bowler Davante Adams. He fell out of the early rounds of the MLB draft in the summer of 2010 because of worries about his willingness to sign.


Pederson was an All-Star in his first full season with the Dodgers. (Alex Trautwig / MLB Photos via Getty Images)

“The word on the street was $1 million, or he was going to go to USC,” said Logan White, the former Dodgers scouting director.

With Pederson still available in the 11th round, White took a flier. He suspected Pederson was bluffing. One of White’s part-time scouts, Larry Barton Jr., hounded him about getting Pederson to sign. “This guy’s going to be the next Freddie Lynn,” Barton said, as White recalled. As the deadline approached, White upped his offer to $600,000. He called Pederson to make one last pitch to sell the teenager on the Dodgers.

White’s intuition was correct. Pederson did not want to attend college. But the offer was still less than he sought. He asked White for a minute to think. Pederson put down the phone and grabbed a coin. Heads meant college, tails meant pro ball. “Tails never fails,” he said. The story, when White eventually heard it, left the longtime executive flummoxed. “To this day, I don’t know if it’s true or not,” White said. “Knowing Joc, it would not surprise me one iota.”

Pederson zipped through the minors. He was 22 when he debuted in 2014. A year later, he made his first All-Star team. But his performance cratered in the second half and he spent most of the Dodgers’ National League Division Series loss on the bench. As the years passed, his defense in center field degraded and left-handed pitchers picked him apart. He became a platoon player deployed mostly against righties, a designation that frustrated him. As the Dodgers set a franchise record for victories in 2017, Pederson was demoted late in the summer. He shrugged off the insult in time for October. In a rollicking seven-game defeat to the Houston Astros, Pederson hit three home runs and slugged .944.

He did not understand it then, but he was banking experience that would connect him with future teammates. “I’ve been in the ‘best player in the game’ category when I got called up to getting benched after being an All-Star,” Pederson said. “I’ve been sent down and then almost won the World Series MVP. I’ve done a lot of things where I’ve been at the top and the bottom.”

As a young player, Pederson felt welcomed into the clubhouse by veterans such as Carl Crawford and Adrian Gonzalez. He often carpooled to Dodger Stadium with Clayton Kershaw when Kershaw wasn’t starting. Pederson also grew accustomed to winning. He never missed the postseason as a Dodger. He excelled against elite pitchers on the October stage, whether it was swatting a game-tying dinger off Max Scherzer in a 2016 elimination game or taking Tyler Glasnow deep in the 2020 World Series.

Heading into free agency, Pederson said he eschewed more lucrative offers to sign a one-year, $7 million contract with the Chicago Cubs for 2021 because the club offered him the chance to play every day. He hit better against lefties but he missed the thrill of contending. A lifeline emerged when the Braves acquired him that summer to mitigate a season-ending injury to Ronald Acuña Jr.

Pederson became a part-timer again. He found he did not mind it, as long as the team was winning. He thumped righties. He lightened up the clubhouse with banter and outlandish fashion statements. After he got attention for wearing a pearl necklace on the diamond, Truist Park sold replicas for $5. He added a second World Series ring to his jewelry collection that October.


Pederson’s jewelry choices sparkled a fan phenomenon. (Daniel Shirey / MLB Photos via Getty Images)

The experience crystallized for Pederson how he wanted the rest of his career to unfold. He might never become a perennial MVP candidate. But he could embrace his place within a clubhouse hierarchy and aid those around him.

“I’ve played with so many people who are like, ‘I need to be playing. I need to be playing over this guy,’” Pederson said. “Where they’re just haters, and the word gets around. Like, ‘Oh man, you should hear what f—ing so-and-so’s saying on the bench, he’s just hating on [his teammate] because he’s not in there.’ That’s not it. There are a lot of guys who are like, ‘Oh, I should be playing,’ this and that. And it’s like, ‘This is why you’re always on a f—ing losing team.’”


On a trip to St. Louis last April, Hazen was chatting with Arizona manager Torey Lovullo about the trajectory of Jake McCarthy, a first-round pick in 2018 who had yet to establish himself. Lovullo offered a reason to feel encouraged. The manager had noticed how McCarthy was leaning on Pederson.

When Arizona signed Pederson to a $12.5 million deal for 2024, team officials were uncertain about his potential role in their clubhouse. Pederson had posted an .821 OPS during his previous two seasons in San Francisco, but the team struggled during those years and his pregame predilection for the Filipino card game Pusoy as the 2023 season capsized aggravated some within the Giants orbit, as The Athletic reported. Zaidi, who had bonded with Pederson during their shared time in Los Angeles, remains steadfast in defending his former player. “In the clubhouse, he really cared,” Zaidi said. “He developed connections with the staff, the front office. He really took after young players.”

As McCarthy started to stabilize, Hazen recognized Pederson might have more to offer than 400 useful at-bats. Hazen began referring to him as “our assistant G.M.” Pederson was invited to pregame meetings with Hazen, Lovullo and the two actual assistant general managers, Mike Fitzgerald and Amiel Sawdaye. “He knows everything about baseball,” Hazen said. “Like, the whole league. So he has an opinion on all the players. He knows everybody. It was valuable insights.”

Lovullo leaned on him, too. “You crush pitchers for us,” Lovullo would tell Pederson. “That’s what you’re here for. But if you have anything left in your tank, can you help out?”

Pederson could relate to players clambering for a foothold. “You talk to him and there’s no ego,” McCarthy said. “He talks to you as an equal.”

He could also relate to struggling stars like Corbin Carroll. After winning the National League Rookie of the Year award and finishing fifth in the MVP race in 2023, Carroll scuffled through last season’s first half. After the All-Star break, Pederson invited him to hit with Marlon Byrd, a 15-year veteran who has moved into private coaching. Carroll connected with Byrd on July 29, as the Arizona Republic reported last year. Across the rest of the season, Carroll posted a .931 OPS.


On the Diamondbacks, Pederson brought levity, thump and guidance. (Norm Hall / Getty Images)

Pederson paid Byrd to fly to Phoenix for every Diamondbacks homestand in 2024. The two will continue to work together this season. As he has bounced from team to team, Pederson explained, he has come to appreciate the stability of a coach familiar with his approach and his mechanics. He tries to blend that with the information offered by the team’s coaching staff.

“I’m going to do my thing,” Pederson said. “I’ll take in your information, and I’m going to filter it and see what’s good. I’ll do that with every coach. You do that with everything. You read something online: ‘Shohei Ohtani just got traded.’ You would look at the source. ‘Hmm, let me filter this. Does it seem right? Eh …’ You can’t listen to everything people say.”

That perspective is the hard-earned product of more than a decade in the majors. Pederson does not like to advertise himself as an instantaneous clubhouse leader or a vibes guru or a sage for rookies. But reputations spread quickly. Before the Rangers position players were even required to report to camp, Carter sought him out for what Pederson called “conversations about growing, as a human and as a baseball player.”

Pederson did not want to say much more about those conversations. He can be evasive during interviews, uninterested in revealing insight into his psyche. But at the end of a conversation this spring, he offered a parting quip to a reporter that conveyed what mattered to him.

“Don’t make me look like a jackass, all right?”

(Top photo: Lindsey Wasson / Associated Press)

With Rubiales gone (and guilty of sexual assault), is Spanish football rethinking how it treats women?

Last Friday night, Spain’s women’s team played their first game since Luis Rubiales was found guilty of sexual assault for kissing Jenni Hermoso after the 2023 Women’s World Cup final. 

Spain came from 2-0 down against Belgium in Valencia with 20 minutes left to win a thrilling game 3-2. Hermoso was not involved, having again been left out of the squad by coach Montse Tome. But she was on the minds of many.

A day earlier, judge Jose Manuel Clemente Fernandez-Prieto found Rubiales, the former president of the Spanish Football Federation (RFEF), guilty of sexual assault and issued him with a fine of more than €10,000 (£8,300; $11,400) for the kiss on Hermoso as she received her World Cup winners’ medal. The judge found Rubiales and his three co-defendants — former women’s coach Jorge Vilda, ex-Spain men’s team sporting director Albert Luque and former Spanish Football Federation (RFEF) marketing director Ruben Rivera — not guilty of coercion for their efforts to persuade Hermoso to publicly say she had consented to the kiss. Rubiales intends to appeal the decision.

The two-week trial at Spain’s Audiencia Nacional, the country’s high court, in San Fernando de Henares near Madrid demonstrated the RFEF’s lack of respect for Hermoso and her team-mates, going back long before the World Cup.

GO DEEPER

The Rubiales-Hermoso court case revealed so much – and the story is not complete yet

Spain were far from their best in Friday’s UEFA Nations League game. Belgium’s opening goal followed a mistake by team captain Irene Paredes, who was among the national team players called as witnesses to the trial in Madrid. But they showed impressive collective effort in staging a fightback.

“What we want is to win games,” Arsenal’s Mariona Caldentey said in the stadium’s mixed zone afterward. “It’s been a difficult few months for everyone. Now the sentence is out, everything’s been said and done, we’ve come out to win — and in the end, we’ve done it.”

Recently elected RFEF president Rafael Louzan attended the game in Valencia and has spoken about a new era of openness and inclusivity.

But, for many of those within women’s football in Spain, the feeling is that the battle for full respect and equality goes on.


After the World Cup final in Sydney, many in Spanish society and football spoke about an urgent need for reform. At a moment of intense global focus, Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez and other government ministers quickly called for action and change.

Once FIFA suspended Rubiales and the eyes of the world drifted away, the impetus for real change and modernisation at the federation’s Las Rozas headquarters also started to stall.

Rubiales’ handpicked successor Pedro Rocha quickly fired Vilda as coach, but replaced him with his assistant, Tome, who had been in that role at the 2023 World Cup. Hermoso was not called up in her first squad, with Tome claiming she wanted to “protect the player”, which she was asked about when she gave testimony in the Rubiales trial. Tome told the court Hermoso was not selected for “sporting” reasons and that “protecting her came into that because of the situation we were experiencing”.


Vilda’s former assistant and current Spain women’s coach, Tome (Jose Miguel Fernandez/NurPhoto)

It was Hermoso and her colleagues who helped force the first real changes. Eighty-one national team players said they would not play for the team until serious reforms were made to end structural sexism at the federation.

After an awkward stand-off — which required mediation from players’ union FUTPRO and government intervention — interim president Rocha agreed to some measures. He fired figures deemed part of Rubiales’ inner circle when he was at the RFEF — former general secretary Andreu Camps, integrity director Miguel Garcia Caba and communications director Pablo Garcia Cuervo.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

The Rubiales-Hermoso court case revealed so much – and the story is not complete yet

More of Rubiales’ closest associates were forced out in March 2024, including legal adviser Tomas Gonzalez Cueto, when Spanish police raided the federation’s headquarters as part of an investigation into alleged corruption during Rubiales’ time in charge that is still in the evidence-gathering phase. Rubiales and Cueto have both denied any wrongdoing.

Rocha himself was investigated as part of that operation — and the Spanish government tried to force him out too but he denied being involved in any corruption and clung on to power. As the political and legal struggles continued, attempts to implement better structures for women’s football were stymied.

“We could hardly do anything,” FUTPRO president Amanda Gutierrez tells The Athletic of her organisation’s lobbying on behalf of its members, including Hermoso. “There were many situations we wanted to talk about and negotiate, but it was not possible. They could not take significant decisions as Rocha was not a permanent president.”

A lack of professionalism and concern for the team was again shown in November 2023, when Paredes, Ivana Andres, Esther Gonzalez and Caldentey missed a key Nations League game against Switzerland due to mistakes in submitting the official squad to UEFA and then the teamsheet on the day of the game.

The federation did hire Markel Zubizarreta as sporting director of women’s football in November 2023, filling a role Vilda had occupied alongside his coaching role.

Zubizarreta was the architect of Barcelona’s all-conquering women’s team — who won 16 trophies, including four league titles and two Champions League trophies — and was respected by the players. But less than 12 months later he left to become global sporting director at Michele Kang’s Kynisca Sports group, which runs U.S. side Washington Spirit, Lyon in France and London City Lionesses. 

“One of the changes we asked for was to have a proper selection process for hiring staff, not just placing friends or contacts in roles,” Gutierrez says. “Markel was perfectly qualified, with wide experience in the sector. But we had the bad luck that Kang came and made him an offer he could not refuse.”

During the recent trial, the prosecution pointed out that, before the World Cup, the federation had in place a “protocol of action against sexual violence”, under which Rubiales’ actions after the final should have been punishable.

Rubiales admitted while giving evidence to having ratified this protocol “in a hurry” just before the World Cup, under pressure from the government, but claimed not to know its contents. Hermoso and Tome testified they were not aware it existed.


Rubiales during his trial in Madrid (Thomas Coex/AFP via Getty Images)

In the weeks after Sydney, FUTPRO made a formal complaint to a Spanish government body, which in March 2024 mandated the federation update this protocol and make sure everyone at the RFEF know about it. 

Asked whether these changes had been made, an RFEF spokesperson replied: “The problem here before was not the regulations that existed, it is that they were not applied. This is a new era, Rubiales and his people are all gone now, the difference with the past is like night and day.”

The trial also showed how Hermoso was left completely alone after events in Sydney, as the entire federation apparatus was put in place to protect Rubiales — actions that led to the prosecution charge of coercion against the four accused at the trial.

Most of the staff involved in that operation no longer work at the RFEF. Some of those who still do — such as women’s team press officer Patricia Perez — were fully supportive of Hermoso as they gave evidence at the trial.

Other figures still at the federation were not so clear. Tome appeared to try to steer a neutral course. Luis de la Fuente, the European Championship-winning men’s national team coach, appeared more concerned with protecting his reputation than securing justice for Hermoso. He made multiple attempts to distance himself from any of the discussions about Hermoso and how the RFEF dealt with the fallout from the sexual assault by Rubiales. 

“If a player came out today and made an official complaint, the federation would respond,” Arantxa Uria, vice president of Spain’s Association for Women in Professional Sport, tells The Athletic. “There is now more media attention, which offers protection. We still have the doubt about whether — if it was not made public — how they would act. Jennifer was always very alone, and remains very alone.”

At all international tournaments, FIFA mandates that teams nominate a ‘safeguarding officer’, responsible for protecting all those taking part from harm or abuse. For Spain at the World Cup, this was team psychologist Javier Lopez Vallejo, who said in court he had no formal training in this area, and added that he saw nothing during the tournament that he should have been concerned about. The RFEF did not respond when asked if any current staff had taken any of FIFA’s official safeguarding courses.


While the Rubiales trial took 18 months to be investigated and tried, the regional barons who have long dominated the federation successfully headed off the government’s talk of electoral reform.

Last December, Galician regional president Louzan was elected the new permanent president of the RFEF, despite being found guilty in May 2022 of misuse of public funds during his former job as governor of the city of Pontevedra. That decision was overturned by Spain’s supreme court in February, clearing him to continue in his role at the football federation.

Gutierrez says the idea of a complete outsider — perhaps even a woman — coming in with a clean broom to sweep up the federation was always unlikely.

She argues that some progress has been made. FUTPRO’s lobbying led to Spain internationals Ona Batlle and Patri Guijarro, plus two female referees and two coaches, becoming members of the 142-strong ‘general assembly’, which ultimately controls the federation and elects its president. “That it took until (November) 2024 to have any women’s players in the assembly is crazy, but shows where we are coming from,” Gutierrez says.

In January, a new ‘convention agreement’ was signed between the top division of women’s football in Spain (Liga F) and FUTPRO. That included a strengthening of the league’s own sexual abuse protocol and initiatives to protect mental health — but the minimum wage in Spain’s top division is still just €22,500 a year.

Another high-profile incident took place in Spanish women’s football during the trial. Video footage circulated on social media appearing to show Barcelona defender Mapi Leon inappropriately touching Espanyol player Daniela Caracas during a Liga F clash. 

Espanyol released a statement expressing their “total discontent and condemnation” of an action that they said “violated the privacy” of Caracas. Leon said, “At no time did I violate, nor did I have the intention to violate, the privacy of my professional colleague Daniela Caracas.”

Liga F has not made an official statement on the incident. FUTPRO offered its support to both players to “clarify what happened and help in any relevant way”.

No official action has yet been taken, and Leon — who has not represented Spain since stepping away in protest at problems with Vilda and the RFEF in July 2022 — has continued to play for Barcelona.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Espanyol call for action after ‘unacceptable’ Leon incident with Caracas during Liga F game

There are other ways the convention agreement does not appear to have made a significant difference.

“The new agreement signed recently for the women’s players was promoted as a great step forward,” says Uria. “But the players still earn the minimum salary of any Spaniard. There was no real advance.”

Just before the trial started, the federation named a new director of women’s football — Reyes Bellver, a lawyer who has respect among players and others within the game. 

“They are talking about wanting to change things, a lot,” says Uria. “We will have to wait and see what job (Bellver) does, what measures she can take within the federation structure. Just hiring a woman for a certain role is not enough. We want to see real changes made, not just nice words.”

Louzan’s new board of 30 directors features 15 women, as mandated by Spanish law. These include Liga F president Beatriz Alvarez Mesa and Maria Jose Rienda, a former head of the government’s Superior Sports Council (CSD). Although Alvarez is the only female among the eight vice presidents, RFEF sources — who, like all those cited in this article, asked to remain anonymous to speak freely — maintain the new regime is serious about having women in senior positions of power. Other reforms at the federation since Rubiales left include changes made to its government mandated ‘Equality Plan’, a new equality strategy and a new department of equality. 

“We’re going to continue in the line of unity, consensus, hard work and absolute transparency,” Louzan told an assembly meeting that took place during the trial. “The moment has come to do everything that could not be done until now. We’ve initiated a transformation process for this institution, which needs to modernise and adapt to new trends.”


Spain celebrate their late winner against Belgium last week (Jose Miguel Fernandez/NurPhoto.)

Those words have been welcomed, but everyone involved also knows Louzan was a vice president throughout Rubiales’ presidency. The Galician met with the Spanish government on Monday and issues known to be on the agenda included Spain’s hosting of the 2030 men’s World Cup. There have been very few specific reforms implemented that directly help the women’s team.

Louzan has announced that Liga F will receive €2.5million from the RFEF to develop women’s football. The federation declined to specify how much of its €379.6million budget for 2025 would go towards the women’s game, but said it spent significantly more on women’s football than it earned.

This argument is not accepted by Gutierrez, who pointed to Zubizarreta’s role as women’s sporting director remaining currently vacant.

“The players are not asking for the same salary as the men, they’re asking for the same resources — the same installations, hours, transport, equipment, staff,” she says. “This is our battle. Have we achieved that yet? Obviously not. Hopefully, someday, we will have this equality of conditions, and the players will be free to perform to their best level.”


As Caldentey said last Friday, Spain’s women’s team are focused on winning games on the pitch. The issue remains whether their undoubted talent is backed up by structures and support from the federation.

The word from the RFEF is that this is a new era, that the guilty verdict should allow all involved to draw a line and move on. It is not so simple.

“The guilty verdict for sexual assault seems correct, but it’s strange there was no guilty verdict for coercion,” Paredes said at a press conference from the team camp last week. “That sums up what the dressing room feels.”

Tome said last week that “each person can have their own thoughts about something” when asked about the effect of the case on the squad. The coach’s own testimony at the trial did not convince everyone that she fully backed Hermoso and it remains strange to see Spain play without their record all-time goalscorer involved.

“The players are professionals, and they have shown (in the past) they are capable of handling anything,” Gutierrez says. “But it’s true that it would be better if these bad feelings did not exist, and that they could just perform to their best level. The space for improvement is so huge. There is still a long way to go.”

(Top photo: Clive Brunskill/Getty Images)

NHL agent poll: Best and worst owners, Connor McDavid’s contract, future GMs

Who are the best and toughest front offices to deal with in the NHL? Which owners are known for giving players what they need? What does the league need to do to improve?

Asking players these questions can yield some pretty good results, but there are limits to that approach. Players have relatively limited exposure to organizations outside their own. And some shy away from expressing controversial takes — even anonymously.

Want an unvarnished opinion on all things NHL? Talk to an agent. Agents often represent several players, whose employers span multiple teams and divisions. They spend their days talking to players, other agents and NHL general managers. And they’re experts on the business side of hockey.

Over the past several months, The Athletic polled 19 agents, who combine to represent hundreds of NHL player contracts, on 10 key questions facing the league and its future. Agents were granted anonymity to encourage honest and candid answers.


1. What is the area the NHL can improve the most?

What’s holding the NHL back? Mainly marketing, agents said.

The bulk of responses centered around the league’s perceived failings when it comes to selling the game and its star players, bringing in new audiences and growing hockey-related revenue (HRR). To be fair, though, all agents were polled before the recent 4 Nations Face-Off, which was a grand success for the NHL and the NHL Players’ Association.

“The NHL has a compelling product, it’s the most exciting live experience of any of the major pro sports,” one agent said, echoing the majority of respondents. “Yet (the folks) running the league seemed content for decades to be focused more on fighting the players over using them to grow the game.”

“This is where the NBA has probably done a better job than us and the NFL is hitting on all cylinders,” another said. “Just using the crest and the trophy is not enough anymore.”

One agent, however, noted a hurdle faced by the league in promoting player personalities: the players themselves.

“I would like to say ‘selling their players better,’ but the guys are so humble, it’s hard to sell them,” the agent said. “Other sports leagues do that better, but their personalities are bigger.”

Meanwhile, more than one agent highlighted the NHL’s problem in getting the games in front of viewers.

“We’re missing the opportunity to expand the game to a more casual fan,” one said. “We haven’t quite unlocked what the key is to bringing the live experience to TV in a better way. If you watch old games from the ’60s or ’70s, they’re kind of shot more or less the same way as now.”

How the league sets up the schedule and its key events drew criticism as well. Here are some other areas in which agents feel the league could improve:

On the playoff format: “I wouldn’t mind them going back (to) 1 seed vs. 8 seed instead of the divisional stuff. There’s got to be incentives to having great regular seasons. Same matchups every year in the playoffs.”

On expanding the playoff field: “The league continues to grow and it sounds like we’re going to continue to grow beyond the 32, so I’m really surprised the owners haven’t pushed this for their own selfish reasons. For certain markets, it would create hope right to the end.”

On scheduling: “With the 4 Nations, Olympics, the World Cup — I think the PA, the league have failed the players, the fans, the owners instead of really understanding the wear and tear it has on the product.”

On scheduling: “I’d like to see staggered start times, and I don’t know how we go three or four nights with literally no games or one or two and then all of a sudden everybody plays.”

On player safety: “My thing here lately is the inconsistencies with player safety. For some things that go unpunished and some things that do, I can never get a read on what they’re doing or thinking. Some of these things that should be suspensions and certainly significant fines, they slip by. There’s no punishment. And others that are borderline, there’s heavy stuff. There needs to be a consistent standard.”

On the de-centralization of the draft: “I hate (the change). It’s a big thing for that city to have. I think the draft is an amazing thing.”

The answers in this category offer more evidence of how far the NHL has come in the Sun Belt.

On-ice success is, of course, a big factor here, but so are other areas. Atmosphere, culture and leadership matter a lot, too.

“You have to look at Tampa with the way the owner’s very good at being hands-off,” one agent said. “(Owner Jeff Vinik) sat back, hired the best people and let them do their jobs.”

“Tampa is awesome,” echoed another. “Players want to be there. They’re buying houses there and spending post-career there.”

For similar reasons, the other Florida team ranks high on agents’ lists.

“(The Panthers) are in sync and connected between ownership and management,” an agent said. “They turned things around in short order with (GM) Billy Zito going in there. They’re fair. They’ve developed in short order to become a destination. Those guys take less to go there because of the tax advantages down there.”

In Vegas, one of the league’s youngest franchises has quickly gained a reputation for winning — at all costs.

“They’ve been consistently competitive,” an agent said. “They don’t hesitate to do whatever it takes, although it may be cold-blooded at times to improve the franchise. But if you’re rating them on their ability to execute on a game plan, I think from Day One they’ve been pretty impressive.”

The Dallas Stars also received credit for on-ice success.

“From top to bottom, their scouting is outstanding, their development is outstanding. Obviously management,” an agent said.

Added another: “They’ve just found so many players. And frankly they’re really good people.”

One somewhat surprising entry here might be the Jets. One agent praised the team for on-ice success in the face of attendance and business concerns.

“They are able to draft, develop very well,” an agent said. “The West is a beast, but I’m impressed, for a smaller market, how they’re able to operate.”

The Maple Leafs, on the other hand, received credit on the business side in spite of on-ice struggles (at least in the playoffs).

“I think they’ve outdone the Rangers. They’ve outdone Boston. They’ve outdone Montreal,” an agent said. “So I’ve got to give them their due as far as growing revenues in this business and running it like a corporate enterprise.”

Several agents struggled to limit their answer to just one team, so 25 of the NHL’s 32 teams received at least one vote.

In this category, words like “reasonable,” “accessible” and “honest” carry a lot of weight.

That’s the case when it comes to Tampa GM Julien Brisebois.

“Julien’s pretty straightforward,” one agent said. “Very accessible, easy to deal with. Player-friendly.”

“They don’t mess around,” added another. “I like JB.”

It’s the case with the Wild and GM Bill Guerin, too.

“Bill Guerin’s reasonable and easy to deal with and easy to have a conversation with,” an agent said. “Very honest.”

“Billy G’s always fair,” added another.

Minnesota and Guerin also received credit for staying competitive in the face of salary cap-related issues over the past several seasons.

“It’s truly amazing how competitive they’ve been the last three years spending $13-$15 million less than anyone else. Imagine if they could have fielded full rosters.”

People love Jim Nill in Dallas.

“Classiest, most honest guy in the league,” said one agent.

Some agents noted a desire to deal with former player agents, such as Zito of the Panthers.

“I like dealing with Billy Zito. He’s been on both sides of it,” one said.

Canadiens GM Kent Hughes is another former agent. His partnership in Montreal with front-office veteran Jeff Gorton was a highlight for one agent.

“Kent Hughes is a very charming guy, and right into it. Jeff Gorton and him, I met with those guys, they were like two brothers fighting when I talked to them. They’re funny. To actually rebuild is hard. They’ve done a nice job over there. They’re on the right track.”

Interestingly, the Ducks and Islanders — Nos. 1 and 2 in this poll’s “most difficult to deal with” category, respectively — each drew a mention here.

“I know it’s a crazy thing to say, but I have such trust in dealing with Lou,” an agent said of Islanders GM Lou Lamoriello. “He’s so honest. What he says is what he means, and vice versa.”

Another agent felt similarly about the regime in Anaheim: “I like the old-school, straight-shooting guys.”

As most agents quipped at first, “This would have been easy a year ago — Arizona. Poor Billy (Armstrong) had his hands tied, but the rest was unstable as hell. Not anymore in Utah.”

Forced to choose a new answer, most agents picked Buffalo due to more than a decade of struggles.

The Sabres haven’t made the playoffs since 2011. They haven’t won a playoff series since 2007. They’ve been rebuilding for what seems like forever. And they’re currently holding down last place in the Eastern Conference.

“Buffalo has just decades of mediocrity and is just a mess,” one agent said.

Multiple agents brought up Anaheim: “The Ducks are not run well enough and are so difficult to deal with.”

The Blackhawks garnered votes here for a perceived mismanagement of their rebuild so far — especially after adding Connor Bedard.

“When you got it all, you’ve got to run it like you do. I don’t think they have a plan,” one agent said. “It should be getting done right. For what they’ve been given, Chicago and Detroit are the biggest letdowns. They’ve been given the keys to the kingdom, but my gosh.”

Two agents wondered about the Yzerplan in Detroit.

“They’re really unstable,” one said. “There’s no plan, although they may say there’s one.”

One agent questioned the strategy in Nashville.

“They spent $108 million on free agents this summer — older free agents, but yet they just have five first-round picks just sitting there and not developing. So what’s the plan? What’s the direction?”

One agent described the Ducks front office as something of a throwback.

“When I started, everybody was angry and telling you to go f— yourself,” one agent said. “So I kinda miss that. Anaheim, personality-wise, they’re tough. (GM Pat Verbeek) is cranky and runs the show himself and (assistant GM Jeff Solomon) is a grinder. I like those two guys, but tough. I appreciate when they’re a–holes.”

“Verbeek is ridiculous. He draws lines in the sand and sticks by it irrationally,” one said.

“The guy that makes Anaheim tough is Jeff Solomon,” another added. “He does all their contracts. Something as simple as doing entry-level deals … there’s always something they nickel you.”

A so-called old-school mentality was a theme here. So, no surprise that the New York Islanders, with a front office led by the eldest statesman of NHL GMs, fall into the category.

“They’re the biggest pain in the ass to deal with,” one agent said. “A lot of old-school people, and (Lou Lamoriello) has no ability to let someone else have responsibility. It’s all through him, and every conversation is draining.”

“I respect the Islanders, but Lou definitely holds tight,” an agent added. “When he locks in his heels, he locks in his heels.”

Complaints about Carolina, which tied for second here, centered on owner Tom Dundon’s management style.

“It’s dysfunctional how the owner micromanages everything,” an agent said.

But for the most part, answers in this category came down to how tough a front office was perceived to be in negotiations.

An agent on the Golden Knights: “(GM Kelly McCrimmon) is a tough customer.”

And on the Predators: “Nashville is like pulling teeth dealing with them on contracts at all levels.”

Tampa’s Jeff Vinik has found a winning formula — on and off the ice.

“I think he’s done a wonderful job,” an agent said. “He walked in there and turned the franchise around. First-class all the way. I mean, just look at what the area around the rink used to be like compared to now. He’s got to be one of the best owners in sports.”

Another agent put it simply and enthusiastically: “My players say he’s the best owner ever.”

Added another, “That guy gets it. He got it from Day One. He’s done all the right things and hired the right people and stayed out of it, but also done all the things that he needed to do for the market.”

With all the answers here, high rankings go to owners who have deep pockets and are perceived as willing to spend.

That’s the case in Toronto, one of few NHL teams with a corporate ownership structure rather than an individual owner. Agents appreciated MLSE’s willingness to spend on more than player salaries.

“They have the money to basically do whatever they want,” one noted. “They treat their players great.”

“There’s no cost spared with the Leafs,” added another. “If you need an MRI, they’ll get you 35 of them.”

How about the new guy? Utah’s Ryan Smith isn’t new to sports ownership (he has owned a majority stake in the NBA’s Utah Jazz since 2020) and he’s already garnered at least one solid review in his debut NHL season.

“He’s new, but a $3 hot dog, $3 water, $3 pop? It feels like he’s part of the people. He’s the new wave.”

Carolina Hurricanes owner Tom Dundon ran away with this category — something that could raise some eyebrows, given the relative success of his organization.

What’s clear from agents’ comments is that this isn’t really about any specific business decision or issues with spending (a more common sentiment the last time we did this exercise in 2022). It’s more about Dundon’s communication and leadership style, with several describing him as overly involved.

“I don’t know how he has the time or the energy. He’s the de facto GM,” one agent said.

“A lot of people in our business hate it that Tom is so f—ing involved, and he is basically the manager and he has a lot of strong opinions, too, and he’s not afraid to tell all of us privately those opinions.”

“His GMs and assistant GMs … have to ask him permission for anything,” added another.

The idea that the owner’s involvement is affecting the culture was raised several times.

“They’ve got some smart people there, but you just feel their culture by not even working there, just being around it. And it’s not a great one.”

One agent joked: “The worst part of Dundon lapping the competition here is he’s probably proud of it.”

Buffalo’s Terry Pegula took the second spot in this category, but the comments were more focused on a perceived lack of involvement — and a lack of on-ice success.

“Buffalo has swung and missed a lot,” one agent noted.

“He has not done anything,” another said of Pegula. “He’s in left field.”

One agent said a lack of involvement was reason for the Ducks’ Henry Samueli to earn votes, too. “Ownership that isn’t involved when they should be frustrates me. Like, get involved.”

“Whatever the f— he wants.”

That pretty much sums up the general feeling on this one.

When Connor McDavid’s current deal expires after the 2025-26 season, the question isn’t whether he’ll become the highest-paid hockey player of all-time; it’s how much he will make.

The current CBA limits a player to 20 percent of a team’s salary cap. With the cap expected to jump above $100 million for the first time as McDavid’s deal expires, could he be the league’s first $20 million man?

“McDavid should make the max. It’s imperative that he does,” one agent said. “He’s the best player in the league. With that carries the obligation to be paid the highest amount possible, end of story.”

“He’s worth every penny at 20 percent,” another added.

“That guy better get 20 percent of the upper limit,” said another. “He’s by far the best player in the game and will be for awhile and should lead the charge. Our whole league works towards a ceiling, and he should be it.”

Some noted the need to balance a desire to get paid and the desire to win.

“He’s got to decide if he wants to win or not,” one agent said. “He has every right to ask for 20 percent and then go backwards.”

“I would suggest it’s going to be whatever Connor McDavid decides is most appropriate,” another agent said. “I’m sure a lot of people know this, but when he did his last contract, the night before he signed it, he called and took a couple million right off the top because he felt he was taking too much money and they needed more to be able to build the team.”

Another agent noted that McDavid’s contract will need to compare favorably to the eight-year, $112 million extension signed by Oilers teammate Leon Draisaitl in September, which carries an AAV of $14 million.

“I think Connor realizes Stanley Cups are the most important thing, but obviously Leon’s contract’s out there, so I would say a million dollars more than Leon.”

Another agent agreed on that ballpark.

“I’d say 15 percent of the cap, because you need to leave 5 percent cushion for the team to have money to spend to win,” the agent said. “I think that’s fair. Because if the cap goes to $115 million, that’s $15 or $16 million.”

7a. What is the biggest issue in the next CBA negotiations?

The current collective bargaining agreement expires after the 2025-26 season, and the NHLPA and NHL appear confident a deal will be reached amicably.

“I think we are in a good place in terms of our collective bargaining relationship, in terms of our overall relationship,” NHL commissioner Gary Bettman said ahead of the opening game of the 4 Nations Face-Off.

Indeed, many agents are hopeful the next round of negotiations will feature less animosity than we’ve seen in the past.

What are the big issues likely to arise?

“I hope none,” said one agent. “I hope we’ve ironed them out. We’ve had enough battles in my life — over 30-plus years as an agent. We don’t need a battle.”

Still, this question yielded an array of concerns on agents’ minds. Most of them center around money — and exactly how it is divided between owners and players. Several agents noted, for example, that players should get a piece of expansion fees.

“If it’s going to be a real 50-50 partnership, it should be in respect to everything, and I’m not just talking expansion fees,” one agent said. “I’m talking more along the lines of all the insurance and everything that all comes out of the player’s share. Those expenses should be 50-50 as well.”

Escrow came up with nearly half the agents.

“It’s always escrow,” an agent said. “Escrow will be fine as long as HRR keeps going upwards. It’s just making sure HRR continues to grow so everyone can share and it doesn’t rear its ugly head again.”

But a falling Canadian dollar had some worried about the potential hit to HRR.

“The problem we’re having with the Canadian dollar that’s going to be a huge issue because HRR is driven by Toronto, Montreal, Vancouver — they contribute so much. I think we’re going to be into another pickle a couple of years from now.”

Others had thoughts on adjustments to the salary cap.

“(There should be a) luxury tax for teams that want to spend over the cap,” one said.

Another added there should be focus on keeping the cap floor at a sufficiently high level: “I feel like as the cap goes up you’re going to have more and more teams having self-imposed budgets, so that’s a concern.”

7b. What’s an under-the-radar issue that should be addressed?

This was another question that drew a wide array of responses.

The idea that tax regimes in certain markets make teams more or less desirable to players was raised more than once. Is there a better way?

“The cap should be set off teams with no state tax,” one agent said, echoing a few others. “Meaning Wild or Rangers or whoever could spend their percent difference to that of Vegas. Even (the) playing field.”

Not everyone agreed, though.

“That’s a thing I’m sick of hearing about,” an agent countered. “Nobody was talking about this 15 years ago when the Panthers were terrible. It’s complete bulls—. That’s not why players go there. They go there to win.”

Here were some other popular talking points:

On travel: “Cross-conference travel and rivalries. I think they should add an extra in-division game or two in their conference rather than, say, Tampa go to Vancouver. That travel is so taxing and they don’t draw well.”

On new CHL-college rules: “I think there will be a lot of discussion about the four-year college free agency thing. Teams hate that. Agents love it where the guys can basically walk after four years. I think there’s going to have to be a lot of modification based on the CHL-NCAA changes just to try to get people on some sort of level playing ground.”

On signing bonuses: “The signing bonuses haven’t even kept up with the cost of living expenses. If you’re a rookie in New York and told to get an apartment, you’d rather stay in the hotel for three more months. To me, Connor Bedard making a $95,000 signing bonus is crazy. That’s the same as a college free agent. I go to Hawks games and there’s 16,000 Bedard jerseys. Maybe there should be an exception for first-round picks.”

On player safety: “The player safety department needs to be overhauled.”

On waivers: “That entry-level players have to wait so long before they’re eligible to be put on waivers. I think a team should have two years to assess the talent of a player and develop them.”

“Good players getting trapped in the minors for too long.”

It’s not entirely surprising that an overwhelming majority of agents are in favor of expansion.

After all, as one agent put it, “More jobs. Agents would always be for that.”

“I want the NHL to go to 40 teams. Forty-five teams,” another added. “The more the merrier. If we get to 50, I’d be thrilled.”

Some did note, however, that the league should be careful not to dilute the talent pool.

“I don’t think there’s enough good players to expand,” one said.

Most disagreed, arguing more opportunity will result in more stars.

As for where the NHL should go next?

“Going to strong TV markets is the low-hanging fruit and most important element, so Houston makes the most sense,” one agent said.

“Add teams in the U.S. Avoid the Canadian dollar,” another said. “Add Houston and Atlanta, and then realign. Why’s Utah in the Central?”

Here’s what agents had to say on the options:

On Phoenix: “Phoenix can work with the right owner and building. Utah, you see how much difference ownership makes right off the hop. It changed almost immediately.”

On Houston: “Fourth-biggest market in the U.S., and it never gets mentioned. It’s a no-brainer.”

On Quebec City: “I have no idea why they’re not in the league if Winnipeg is.”

On Quebec City negatives: “I don’t want another Canadian city; we need to generate revenue.”

On Atlanta: “Bad ownership plagued them last time. Horrible ownership actually, so find the right group and location, it could work.”

On Atlanta negatives: “F— Atlanta. We’ve tried that a million times. There’s no way.”

On Atlanta negatives: “I’ll believe this Atlanta stuff when we see it. We’ve been there twice. They seem to think it’ll work a third time. We’ll see.”

On Kansas City: An agent pointed to the NFL’s Chiefs as an example. “Maybe they can get that market.”

On Toronto: “I think it’s the most insane thing in the world that there’s not two teams in Toronto. It’s crazy.”

Several agents described the current NHL schedule as a “grind.” Adding more games is unpopular.

More teams having a shot at the postseason, though? There might be something there.

“I would probably be in favor of some play-in games,” one agent said. “I think it’s worked well in baseball and it’s been good for TV and would be good overall for HRR.”

Another added, “It’s so hard to make the playoffs, so if we can take the teams that were like one regulation loss away from making it, I think that’d be fun.”

Still, there were several who emphasized that the schedule is too long as it is.

“There’s too many games. If anything, I would reduce the number of games,” one of eight agents who responded “no” said.

A main target for reducing the workload: the preseason exhibition schedule.

“The exhibition situation has been so poorly run,” an agent said. “It’s so imbalanced. There’s really no rhyme or reason to it. Most teams, at most, really have one spot you can fight for in training camp if everybody’s healthy.”

One agent said the season needs to start and end earlier.

“Yes (to adding regular season games), but no more than two games and as long as the exhibition season gets cut down to balance it out. And the Stanley Cup needs to be awarded no later than the first week in June. Why not start the season Sept. 15?”

Seventeen GMs-in-waiting garnered votes as the one to watch — including two agents who selected themselves.

Penguins assistant GM Jason Spezza received the most mentions, though.

“From the very beginning, even when he was in his last year as a player, he had a thirst for knowing everything he could learn,” one agent said. “He’s very, very thorough in everything he does and is learning every part of the organization. Kyle (Dubas) gave him access to everything in Toronto and now Pittsburgh. Jason approached it like he did everything else – just 100 percent.”

Another member of Dubas’s front office was praised by one agent: Vukie Mpofu, the Penguins’ director of hockey operations and legal affairs.

“One of the sharpest, committed and genuinely good young people. He’s a star,” the agent said.

In the two-vote club, Leafs AGM Brandon Pridham and Panthers AGM Brett Peterson stood out.

“I think he does a lot of work and doesn’t get a lot of credit,” an agent said of Pridham. “He’s quiet, but I think he’s done yeoman’s work there for a lot of years and doesn’t necessarily get on people’s radar.”

Another said of Peterson: “Former agent. He’s very smooth, very smart. He’s in tight with USA Hockey, well schooled by Billy Zito. He’s an impressive guy.”

Speaking of former agents, Canucks AGM Émilie Castonguay — the first Canadian woman ever certified as an agent — received a vote.

“She’s a strong presence. Smart and has the right edge,” an agent said. “Not only does she have a strong legal education, she has navigated the game from all sides, player-agenting and managing. She’s a skilled communicator and strategic thinker.”

(Illustration: Will Tullos / The Athletic)
(Photos: Patrick Smith, Jeff Vinnick, Richard T. Gagnon, Bruce Bennett, Chris Tanouye / Getty Images)

Yankees will no longer play Frank Sinatra’s ‘New York, New York’ after losses

TAMPA, Fla. — Just days after the New York Yankees amended one of the most recognizable rules in American professional sports, another iconic tradition for the organization will change in 2025.

Following losses, the Yankees will no longer play Frank Sinatra’s “(Theme From) New York, New York” as fans exit the stadium. On Sunday at George M. Steinbrenner Field, the Yankees lost 4-0 to the Detroit Tigers in a spring training exhibition. After Yankees prospect Brendan Jones grounded out to end the game, Sinatra’s “That’s Life” replaced the usual “New York, New York” on the loudspeakers. It is customary for the team to play “New York, New York” as soon as the game concludes, no matter the result.

“We will be rotating through a number of different songs after a Yankees loss this year, none of them will be ‘New York New York,’” a Yankees spokesperson said. There will not be a specific Yankees loss song, the spokesperson added.

The Yankees first debuted the iconic Sinatra song in 1980, after then-owner George Steinbrenner wrote a letter to the singer requesting permission to play it as fans left the stadium. Since then, it has become synonymous with the franchise. Moving forward, the song will only play after Yankees victories with a rotation of different Sinatra songs playing after losses, which is how Steinbrenner originally instructed the Yankees to handle losses.

It’s been a significant week of change for the Yankees’ identity. After 49 years, owner Hal Steinbrenner announced the team would lift its ban on beards, calling the policy “outdated.” Now, after 45 years, another long-standing tradition has been altered.

Since Friday, both Yankees captain Aaron Judge and general manager Brian Cashman have emphasized their desire for the team to carve out its own identity while still honoring its rich history.

“The New York Yankees are different,” Cashman said Friday. “We want to remain different. This is a special place in baseball history. That logo has a lot of meaning behind it. We want our past and present players to recognize that and the future players to recognize that. There’s still going to be things that we’re going to hold on to that are important for us, which is always trying to be a championship-caliber franchise and chase winning.”

(Photo: Patrick Smith / Getty Images)

Journeyman Brian Campbell stuns even himself with first PGA Tour win: ‘I’m freaking out’

Brian Campbell came out on top at the Mexico Open on Sunday night as viewers were treated to some sudden-death playoff chaos between two antithetical player profiles: Campbell, a journeyman and one of the shortest hitters on the PGA Tour, and Aldrich Potgieter, the 20-year-old South African prodigy who currently leads the tour in driving distance.

Campbell defeated Potgieter after two playoff holes, marking his first PGA Tour win in just 28 starts. The Mexico Open field included just two players ranked in the top 40 in the Official World Golf Rankings, but the 31-year-old Campbell will earn a trip to Augusta National for his first Masters with the victory. He also claimed a spot in the Players Championship, the PGA Championship and five of the remaining signature events on tour.

Ten years of chugging along and 159 starts on the Korn Ferry Tour without a victory defined Campbell’s path to this win at the Vidanta Vallarta Course in Nuevo Vallarta, Mexico. The University of Illinois alum first graduated from the Korn Ferry Tour in 2016 but was quickly relegated after missing 13 of 20 cuts. He finally found a groove last season in the minor leagues, finishing seventh in the KFT’s points ranking to earn his tour card again. Three starts later he played his way into the winner’s circle. It didn’t happen without a few hiccups along the way.

“I’m literally freaking out on the inside, I have no idea what’s going on,” Campbell said to the Golf Channel following the conclusion of the playoff. “To be in this position is just so unreal.”

Potgieter began Sunday’s final round with a one-stroke cushion over Campbell after firing a second-round 61 and a third-round 67 to tie the 54-hole scoring record at the event. Potgieter is only 10 starts into his PGA Tour career, but he is no stranger to competing and winning on the game’s biggest stages. Potgieter’s amateur résumé includes the Amateur Championship, where he became the youngest champion in the event’s history at age 17. With only 12 measured drives thus far on the PGA Tour, Potgieter has emerged as the longest hitter on tour, surpassing Rory McIlroy with an average of 328.7 yards off the tee.

The Vidanta Vallarta Course this week fit Potgieter’s game perfectly, allowing him to use his length off the tee to its full potential, as offline drives are not particularly penal on the Greg Norman design. However, it became apparent that the bombs-away game plan wasn’t the only way to attack the course, as Campbell continued to hang around the top of the leaderboard. On Sunday, NBC commentators compared Campbell’s ball speed to that of a senior tour player. He ranks last according to the tour’s driving distance statistics — 182 out of 182.

“He’s playing a different course than we are,” Campbell said of Potgieter’s game. “It’s been honestly fun to watch.”

Neither Campbell nor Potgieter had their best on Sunday, but both plugged away. Potgieter struggled out of the gates while Campbell floated around even par. The pair finished regulation play tied at 20-under, surpassing Isaiah Salinda’s clubhouse lead at 19-under.

The power of sudden-death pressure was on full display as both players hit multiple wayward shots en route to the final result. On the second playoff hole, Campbell’s drive was headed well beyond the out-of-bounds fence when it ricocheted off a tree and back into play. Potgieter then stood with an approach shot nearly 100 yards shorter than Campbell’s.

Instead of capitalizing on the opportunity, Potgieter’s attempt to reach the par-5 18th hole in two left him short of the green, in a bunker. He failed to get up and down, while Campbell made a birdie with a short wedge in his hands after laying up. After nearly handing the tournament to his opponent off the tee, Campbell couldn’t believe the outcome.

Required reading

(Photo: Hector Vivas / Getty Images)

Amid the 4 Nations noise, Canada reclaims its throne as ‘the king of hockey’

They crossed the 49th parallel, from Manitoba into North Dakota — and drove through day and night — across eight states and more than 3,000 kilometers, according to the Canadian odometer on their Nissan Murano.

Two canceled flights meant they were desperate. So they piled into a car, stopping only for gas. And, despite a two-hour detour through Milwaukee, off a middle-of-the-night wrong turn, they made it to Boston in 30 hours.

They were five among the thousands of Canadians who lined up outside TD Garden hours before the start of the NHL’s 4 Nations Face-Off final between Canada and the United States.

“We’re here for the Maple Leaf,” said Matt McLeod. And they were there for their childhood friend Seth Jarvis, who was living his dream of playing for Canada.

But at the most hyped international hockey game in more than a decade, everyone had their reasons to care. And beyond the 60 minutes and overtime, it felt like there was so much more than a win at stake.

With more than a decade of built-up tension between the two rivals, heat on the ice was inevitable. But for many, the championship game wasn’t about bragging rights alone.  A looming trade war between the United States and Canada, following tariff threats by President Donald Trump and repeated claims that he’d like the sovereign neighbor to become the country’s 51st state, created an unparalleled level of hostility between the two nations.

Canadian fans booed the American national anthem when the teams met in a round-robin match in Montreal, which was followed by three fights in the first nine seconds of the game.

It was impossible to ignore the wider implications, especially when the U.S. team’s general manager Bill Guerin said his players used the political tensions as inspiration and invited Trump to attend the final. Before the championship, Trump encouraged the Americans while taking another shot at Canada becoming the 51st state and referring to Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau as a governor.

Outside TD Garden, that tension was evident hours before the opening face off.

“Welcome to the USA, Canada’s 11th Province,” read a massive sign carried by Ian MacKinnon, as fans dressed in Canada and USA jerseys shuffled in a queue that stretched down Causeway Street. He’s an American, by way of grandparents who first immigrated to Nova Scotia. MacKinnon doesn’t care much about sports, but he biked there with his sign in hopes of making a point and maybe offering a touch of levity.

“The way the series started with fist fights in the first 10 seconds, I felt maybe tonight I could make people smile,” MacKinnon said.

And most people did, while some tossed light jabs.

“51st state!” one man yelled as he passed in line.

“U-S-A! U-S-A!” chanted another.

One fan tried to rip the sign from MacKinnon’s hand, but he held firm.

In the concourse, American fans posed with Mark Goggin, who’d painted his face red and white, with temporary tattoos of a cartoon moose and beaver on each check. Goggin crossed the border from his home in Windsor to catch a flight from Detroit with his son. As innocent and playful as most of the interactions between the fans were, Goggin felt the wider implications that the game carried seemed somewhat lost on his American counterparts. They didn’t seem to appreciate just how serious Canadians have taken the threats and taunts, he said. It might be fun and games to them, but in Canada the aggression has spurred a rush of patriotism.

“Canadians are so pumped to win this game. Because we can’t beat Trump, right?” Goggin said. “It’s the only thing we can beat them at — hockey.”

His eyes reddened as he described the emotion many Canadians carried into the final.

“It’s so big for Canadians,” Goggin said. “It’s more than a game.”


Mark Goggin’s rooting interests were easily discerned. (Dan Robson / The Athletic)

Harjinder Sidhu flew from Winnipeg to attend the game with his brother and his 5-year-old nephew, who traveled from Edmonton. The 30-year-old said the outside context matters.

“Canada will never be the 51st state. … It’s very disrespectful,” he said. “Our soldiers have died next to their soldiers in wars, which we do happily because they’re our brothers. But that brother is acting a little too aggressive right now. And today we’ll show them who’s the king of hockey.”

For more than a century, hockey has been Canada’s game. But it has long been anticipated that the Americans would catch up and possibly surpass Canada. Recent trends underscore that reality. The majority of Canadian NHLers play for American teams. And as has been pointed out many times, no Canadian team has won a Stanley Cup since 1993.

That tension filled the TD Garden too. It hung uncomfortably when Wayne Gretzky, hockey’s greatest icon, stepped onto the ice representing Canada in a pregame ceremony wearing a suit, to respectful stick taps and cheers. Mike Eruzione, captain of the 1980 Miracle on Ice team, followed to a riotous roar wearing a U.S.A. jersey — fist-bumping the American players and waving his hands to pump up the crowd as they chanted “U.S.A.”

It wasn’t lost on many Canadians watching that Gretzky, star of the famed 1987 Canada Cup winning team, attended President Trump’s election victory party at Mar-a-Lago and his recent inauguration ceremony.

A smattering of boos greeted the Canadian national anthem, but a chorus rose alongside singer Chantal Kreviazuk, who made her own comment on the moment by changing the lyrics in a verse from “in all of us command” to “that only us command.” Kreviazuk later posted on Instagram that she believed Canadians needed to stand up and use their voices in the face of a “potentially consequential moment.”

“We should express our outrage in the face of any abuses of power,” she wrote.

A hockey game happened, and a thrilling one, with a crowd heavily on the American side.

But after the most dramatic show of international men’s hockey in more than a decade — sealed by Connor McDavid’s overtime winning goal — it was Canadians piling on the ice and embracing in the stands. American fans streamed out into the concourse as “O Canada” played once more, to fireworks around a giant Canadian flag. The red-and-white jerseys filled the lower bowl, surrounded by empty seats.

Drew Doughty sang as loud as he could. It had been so long since he’d last felt this moment, and he didn’t know if he’d ever feel it again.

And later, in the locker room, the Canadian players belted “We Are The Champions” by Queen, Molson Canadian and Moet sloshing on the floor. Their reign as the world’s greatest, secured for at least another year.

Above, in the concourse, a chant of “Can-na-Da, Ca-na-da” echoed as fans marched toward the exits, and out onto Causeway Street.

A woman in a grey sweater with a U.S. flag on it shouted after them: “You’ll be the 51st state soon.”

But no one bothered to listen.

As the champagne dried on the locker room floor, and other Canadian players reveled in the hallway en route to the team’s afterparty at a nearby bar, Mark Stone acknowledged that the political tension weighed on the team throughout the series.

“I definitely read and saw everything, Saturday to tonight,” Stone said. “It’s hard to stay off that stuff, the way the world is with social media. This game meant a lot to us, a lot to our country, and we’re proud to put on that jersey and get a win for our country.”

In the hall, Brad Marchand, Sidney Crosby and Nathan MacKinnon posed for a photo together. MacKinnon held up a Canadian flag. Crosby, the captain, clutched the 4 Nations Cup.

Seth Jarvis and the friends who’d driven from Winnipeg, piled in to pose for some photos, too. They wore the sweaters of Crosby, McDavid, MacKinnon and Mitch Marner — just a few among the thousands that still filled Boston’s streets, shouting and laughing and cheering, for a victory that felt so much bigger than a game.

(Illustration: Eamonn Dalton / The Athletic. Photos: Dan Robson / The Athletic; Brian Babineau / 4NFO/World Cup of Hockey; Bruce Bennett, Ben Jackson / 4NFO/World Cup of Hockey via Getty Images)

‘Never refer to us as Tottenham’ may seem a small edict but it says a lot about the modern game

Back in my early twenties, I was at a party at a rooftop bar trapped in a round of small talk with a friend of a friend. Scrambling around for conversation, I asked her where she came from. “Folkestone,” she said. If you don’t know, that’s a coastal town in Kent, in the south east of England.

Without hesitation, I replied: “Folkestone Invicta” — the name of the town’s local non-League club, currently playing in the seventh tier of English football. To this day, I have never forgotten the look on her face: one of almost total boredom and indifference, but for a trace amount of pity.

Yet, to paraphrase a certain Premier League club’s ‘Brand Playbook’: in a world full of Uniteds, Citys and Rovers, there is only one Invicta — Folkestone Invicta.

And back in 1936, if the club’s founders had thought ‘Invicta’ was unique enough to be the club’s name on its own — no need for the ‘Folkestone’ part — then not only could I have avoided that moment’s awkwardness decades later, but those founders would have been almost a century ahead of their time.

As The Athletic revealed on Friday, Tottenham no longer want you to call them Tottenham. It is ‘Spurs’ for short, thanks. And that’s not the only bit of preferred nomenclature.

“When referring to the team or the brand, please use ‘Tottenham Hotspur’, ‘Tottenham Hotspur Football Club’ or ‘THFC’,” the club wrote in guidance sent to Premier League broadcasters this month. “Never refer to our Club as ‘Tottenham’, ‘Tottenham Hotspur FC’ or ‘TH’.” Never. Or else.

It raises many questions, not least, what is the material difference between the terms ‘Tottenham Hotspur Football Club’ and ‘Tottenham Hotspur FC’? I don’t know. But I’m going to use the prohibited versions for the rest of this column in the hope of provoking somebody at Tottenham Hotspur FC into telling me.

There is a reason for the ‘Spurs’ preference, at least. Tottenham argue Tottenham is the name of the area, not the name of the club, and this has been their policy for years. Trawl through search engine results and you’ll do well to find a single use of ‘Tottenham’ without ‘Hotspur’ attached to it on the club’s website.


The Tottenham Hotspur Stadium (James Gill – Danehouse/Getty Images)

Tottenham have consistently been referred to as ‘Spurs’ in fixture listings on the Premier League’s official website for some time. Go back through the league’s official social media feeds and practically the only mentions of the word ‘Tottenham’ are references to the ‘Tottenham Hotspur Stadium’.

In a way, the club is merely going back to its roots. When a group of schoolboy cricketers founded the club in 1882, their choice of name was ‘Hotspur FC’. The ‘Tottenham’ was only added two years later because, as the possibly apocryphal tale goes, they began receiving the post of another club called Hotspur.

It is not as if the club has actually changed its name and eradicated any geographical marker altogether, either. Another in north London set the precedent for that back in 1913 upon relocation from Woolwich. So, does any of that make this diktat more explainable?

In response to Friday’s news, some Tottenham fans have rightly said that with Ange Postecoglou’s side in the bottom half of the table, after being knocked out of both domestic cups in the space of three days this month, they and the club itself have bigger things to worry about.

Others have suggested it is simply related to copyright, as the term ‘Spurs’ would be easier to trademark than the name of the surrounding area. Except Tottenham already list the word ‘Tottenham’ among their registered trademarks.

And even if they didn’t, what would that have to do with how the club is referred to on Soccer Saturday’s vidiprinter?

But it is hard not to agree with another strand of the reaction, from the Tottenham fans and supporters of other clubs who see this as a disappointing sign of where football is currently at; another small brick paved in a road that the sport as a whole has already travelled a long way down.


But are Tottenham Hotspur fans allowed in? (Jacques Feeney/MI News/NurPhoto via Getty Images)

Many Manchester United supporters still lament the removal of the words ‘Football Club’ from the crest in 1998 — controversial at the time, but the same words or the initials ‘F.C.’ are now regularly dispensed with little comment.

Six years ago, Liverpool failed to trademark the city’s name for merchandising purposes. Chelsea had more success of a sort earlier this season, celebrating their 120th anniversary with a new, alternative club crest featuring their lion rampant regardant above the letters ‘LDN’.

Similarly, in 2016, West Ham United added the word ‘London’ to their revamped crest, although at least put that to a vote among supporters first.

And this sort of thing is far from a Premier League phenomenon. Paris Saint-Germain’s rebranding accentuated the word ‘Paris’ on their logo, not so much the ‘Saint-Germain’, and UEFA uniformly refers to the club as ‘Paris’ rather than ‘PSG’.

On the surface level, Tottenham’s ‘Spurs’ preference is different from some of those examples. Rather than more closely associating themselves with a larger metropolitan surrounding, they have gone the other way: drawing a line between ‘Spurs’ the team and ‘Tottenham’ the area in its justifications.

But there is a common thread between such decisions. All are fundamental attempts to make a club’s identity something that can be more easily swallowed and digested. In other words, something that can be consumed, especially on the global market.

Too often, that comes at the expense of what a club is: its history, its culture, its locality. It is said often enough to be a cliche nowadays, but it is still ignored enough to bear repeating: football clubs are representations of their communities first and foremost, global brands second.

The overwhelming majority of clubs recognise that in the creditable work they do within those communities, but are quick to forget that responsibility in their marketing departments when it is time to think about what will sell better on a plastic water bottle.

Tottenham are by no means alone in that. It often feels like clubs who want to get ahead in football’s present landscape have to prioritise where they are going over where they have come from. Referring to the club as ‘Spurs’ rather than ‘Tottenham’ is a small but not insignificant shift. And enough to remind me that, one of these days, I might have to get myself down to Folkestone Invicta.

(Top photo: Jacques Feeney/MI News/NurPhoto via Getty Images)

Tottenham are asking not to be called Tottenham

Eagle-eyed viewers of Sky Sports’ coverage of Tottenham Hotspur’s 1-0 win against Manchester United last Sunday will have noticed a change.

When head coach Ange Postecoglou was interviewed before kick-off and asked about the lift of having players back from injury, he was described as “Tottenham Hotspur Head Coach”. When the Tottenham starting XI was displayed down the left-hand side of the screen, it said “Spurs” at the top. And when the graphics showed the team in their positions, starting with a cutout of Postecoglou, arms crossed, the word across his chest was “Spurs”.

Nothing too surprising about that, you might think. Tottenham Hotspur is the name of the club. Spurs is their common nickname.

But if you saw the Sky Sports coverage of Tottenham’s 3-2 defeat at Everton on January 19, it looked subtly different. During Postecoglou’s pre-match interview, he was described as “Tottenham Head Coach”. The team graphic just had the word “Tottenham” at the top. And the cutout image of arms-crossed Postecoglou again had “Tottenham” written across his chest. When Sky Sports showed the current Premier League table, it was “Tottenham”. And the form table, in which they were 18th out of 20, “Tottenham” again.


Sky Sports’ form guide graphic on January 19 (Sky Sports)

So what changed? What happened to the word ‘Tottenham’ over the last few weeks?

The answer lies in an email that was circulated to Premier League broadcasters on February 10, that has been seen by The Athletic. Titled “Tottenham Hotspur Naming Update”, the email makes clear how the club wants to be referenced.

“Tottenham Hotspur have provided clarification regarding the club’s name. They have requested that the club are primarily known as Tottenham Hotspur, with Spurs being the preferred short version. The club have requested that they are not referred to as Tottenham.”

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

What is Arsenal? Why are teams United? Uh, Hotspur? Clubs’ names explained

This guidance has gone out to Premier League broadcasters all around the world. The changes that Sky Sports made to their graphics have also been made by other networks that show Tottenham matches. The Premier League website is in line too. It is always “Tottenham Hotspur” or “Spurs” there, never “Tottenham”.

The club’s explanation for this is simple: Tottenham is the name of the area, but not the name of the club. It is long-standing club policy not to refer to themselves as ‘Tottenham’. There is nothing new about this, it has been the club’s position going back to 2011.


Sky Sports’ league table graphic on February 16 (Sky Sports)

What specifically changed is that in November last year, the club unveiled a “remastered brand identity”, which was “rolled out across all the Club’s physical and digital touchpoints”. This came with a “Brand Playbook”, which explains in comprehensive detail what the new brand identity means. Towards the end of a section titled “Tone of voice” (“Defiant, Authentic, Rallying, Energetic”), there is a paragraph that makes very clear how the club wants to be described.

“In a world full of Uniteds, Citys and Rovers, there is only one Hotspur, Tottenham Hotspur. When referring to the team or the brand, please use ‘Tottenham Hotspur’, ‘Tottenham Hotspur Football Club’ or ‘THFC’. Never refer to our Club as ‘Tottenham’, ‘Tottenham Hotspur FC’ or ‘TH’.”

This month’s fresh guidance to broadcasters is an apparent attempt to underline this, and to make sure that ‘Spurs’ rather than ‘Tottenham’ becomes the common shorthand when ‘Tottenham Hotspur’ does not fit.

On the one hand, there certainly is an argument to be made that ‘Tottenham’ is just the name of the local area, and not the name of the club itself. There are plenty of Premier League clubs for whom no one would just use the first geographical part of the name.

You would get some strange looks turning up at Villa Park saying you were looking forward to watching ‘Aston’ play. Very few would refer to the side who play at Molineux simply as ‘Wolverhampton’, or at the City Ground as ‘Nottingham’. And that is before we confront the thorny issue of places, including Manchester or Sheffield or Bristol, where two clubs share the same regional descriptor.


Tottenham fans have long referred to their team as… Tottenham (Julian Finney/Getty Images)

But on the other hand, there are clubs where the first part of the name does the job. Everyone knows who Newcastle or Leeds or Leicester are. And for many Spurs fans, the name ‘Tottenham’ is perfectly serviceable in telling the world who they support. It has always been commonplace in the Spurs community in a way that ‘Aston’ never has been at Villa Park.

It does lead you to question why ‘Spurs’ might be preferable to ‘Tottenham’ as the shortened name of the club. ‘Spurs’ certainly is distinct “in a world full of Uniteds, Citys and Rovers”, although maybe less so in the global marketplace, given San Antonio Spurs in the NBA. Still, it is memorable and punchy and looks good emblazoned on merchandise.

go-deeper

‘Hotspur’ is certainly unique and indispensable heritage. The name comes from when a new football club was established in the area in 1882, and two brothers, Hamilton and Lindsay Casey, were searching for a brand identity of their own. They named their club after Henry Percy, the box-office medieval knight who tried to overthrow Henry IV and was killed at the Battle of Shrewsbury in 1403. His nickname was ‘Hotspur’, hence the name of the club, and hence the club’s logo too. This is history worth clinging to.

But Tottenham is inseparable from Tottenham Hotspur too. It was on Tottenham Marshes where the Casey brothers started playing 143 years ago, Tottenham where the old White Hart Lane ground was opened in 1899, closing in 2017, and then Tottenham where the futuristic new stadium was opened in 2019. Other than their brief spell at Wembley while the new stadium was built, Tottenham Hotspur have always played in this very specific corner of north-east London. This is the club’s home, and their community, for whom they do so much good work.

For many fans, there is no distinction between the club and the area itself. They are synonymous. And they will continue to be ‘Tottenham’ regardless of what the guidance says.

(Top photo: Catherine Ivill – AMA/Getty Images)

U.S.-Canada 4 Nations Face-Off final draws 9.3 million viewers, most-watched NHL-sanctioned game in decades

Take two proud hockey countries in a best-on-best final, add a massive dose of geopolitics into the equation, and then conclude the matchup with a historic overtime goal by the game’s best player. It’s a recipe for a historic viewership number — and that’s what we saw with Canada’s 3-2 overtime win over the United States on Thursday at the 4 Nations Face-Off in Boston.

The game drew an astonishing 9.3 million viewers on ESPN, per Nielsen. To put this in perspective: That tops Game 7 of the NHL Finals between Boston and St. Louis in 2019 which drew 8.9 million viewers on NBC — the most-watched NHL game since the league returned to broadcast TV in 1995.

In Canada, Sportsnet said the game averaged 5.7 million viewers and peaked at 7.3 million when Connor McDavid scored the OT winner. Add in 1.18 million viewers on TVA, as per Adam Seaborn of Better Collective, and the game averaged nearly seven million viewers. Canada’s population is 40 million.

So adding the two countries up: The game drew more than 16 million viewers in North America.

The earlier round game between the United States and Canada — a 3-1 win over Canada on a rock ’em sock ’em Saturday night in Montreal — averaged 4.4 million viewers on ABC and peaked with 5.2 million viewers in the 10:45 quarter-hour. That had been the most-watched non-Stanley Cup Final hockey telecast in the U.S. since a Blue Jackets-Bruins playoff game on NBC in 2019 that averaged 4.5 million. The NHL said the combined North American audience for last Saturday’s game was 10.1 million viewers.

The tournament clearly showed the desire of hockey fans who have been dreaming of best-on-best for years. Next stop for best-on-best: The Olympic Games next year in Cortina-Milan.

Required reading

(Photo: Vitor Munho / Getty Images)

MLS preview roundtable: Staff predictions for league’s 30th season

MLS’s 30th season kicks off Saturday a few miles away from where the league’s 29th campaign ended. The LA Galaxy won MLS Cup a shade over two months ago, but rival LAFC will lift the curtain on 2025 when they host Minnesota United Saturday afternoon.

It marks the start of a season that will feature plenty of new impact signings (the league’s outgoing transfer fee record was broken twice), a new club (welcome, San Diego FC!), some USMNT arrivals seeking a pathway to the top of Mauricio Pochettino’s depth chart (hello, Brandon Vázquez and Luca de la Torre) and a big, shiny spotlight on Lionel Messi and everything his Inter Miami does along the way (in frigid temperatures or otherwise).

A new season is an excuse to make our annual sure-to-be-right predictions, so we’ve polled The Athletic’s soccer writers Paul Tenorio, Pablo Maurer, Jeff Rueter and Felipe Cardenas for their insight on a number of topics. Who will win it all? Who will be terrible? Who will surprise? Who deserves your attention?

We’ve covered it all below to take you the rest of the way to first kick in L.A.


Join The Athletic’s MLS WhatsApp channel. All the latest MLS updates straight to your phone with exclusive content from our writers in the form of messages voice notes, videos and more. All our experts will bring you their views and observations as MLS embarks upon its biggest season yet.


Predictions: MLS Cup winner, Supporters’ Shield winner (best record), Wooden Spoon recipient (worst record)

Tenorio:

  • MLS Cup – Inter Miami: Messi and Co. prioritize the CONCACAF Champions Cup and the playoffs, and win one of those two trophies.
  • Supporters’ Shield – FC Cincinnati: Losing Lucho Acosta hurts, but adding Evander and Kévin Denkey should put an already strong team over the top this season.
  • Wooden Spoon – Houston Dynamo: Toronto looks rough, and it seems like this is a tear-it-down year, but I really don’t like the sales the Dynamo made this offseason and the replacement value of the players coming back in. Houston will be in some trouble if they don’t add talent.

Cardenas:

  • MLS Cup – Inter Miami: Messi doesn’t have to win an MLS Cup title. His legacy as (arguably) the best player ever is already cemented. But I find it hard to believe that he won’t win at least one while he’s playing in the United States
  • Supporters’ Shield – FC Cincinnati: Miami will be better than they were during their record-breaking season in 2024. They could repeat as Supporters’ Shield champions. I think Cincinnati walks away with this one, though (in a tight race).
  • Wooden Spoon – Nashville SC: Feels like Nashville are hovering slightly above irrelevancy in MLS. They don’t have stars, and you need those players in this league. B.J. Callaghan’s first full season will be a difficult one that will reset the club’s strategy.

There should be plenty for Lionel Messi and Luis Suárez to celebrate this season in MLS. (Manuel Velasquez/Getty Images)

Maurer:

  • MLS Cup – Inter Miami: Ambition gets you a long way in MLS, and Miami, at this point, are overdue. If they stay healthy, Messi & Co. will finally lift their first meaningful trophy (with apologies to the Leagues Cup.)
  • Supporters’ Shield – FC Cincinnati: Acosta’s shock transfer stole the headlines but, on balance, this team has only gotten better. Highly watchable, highly competitive, and this year, they’ll win the Shield.
  • Wooden Spoon – San Diego FC: A couple of splashy signings, yes, but a whole mess of unanswered questions as well. MLS has had a couple of outliers but at the end of the day, life is tough as an expansion team. Feel free to tape this one up in the locker room, Mikey Varas. “They don’t believe in us” is an MLS tradition, at this point.

Rueter:

  • MLS Cup – Seattle Sounders: MLS’s most complete squad is better built to compete on all fronts (well, besides the Club World Cup). They’ve cobbled together unparalleled depth and MLS nous among a roster of prime-aged players.
  • Supporters’ Shield – FC Cincinnati: Expertly navigated what could’ve been a mission-critical Acosta subplot and got better along the way. It helps that they won’t need to worry about the Club World Cup, either.
  • Wooden Spoon – Toronto FC: Lorenzo Insigne is already the worst signing in MLS history given his bloated wages and lack of impact, and I don’t see room for a belated bounce-back. A rudderless franchise that needs time to dig out from Bill Manning and John Herdman’s mistakes — but hiring Robin Fraser was a step in the right direction.
go-deeper

GO DEEPER

USL answers: Can new division rival MLS and will pro/rel work

Who will be the splashiest summer signing?

Tenorio: Antoine Griezmann to LAFC. This one has been rumored for some time and I don’t think LAFC is keeping a DP spot open for the sake of it.

Cardenas: I agree with Paul. Griezmann to MLS is inevitable. He’s an avid NFL fan (with a Spanish-language NFL podcast) who recently made his way to the Super Bowl in New Orleans. He seems to be looking forward to life in the U.S., specifically in L.A. As for Kevin De Bruyne, you ask? The Belgian seems destined for Saudi Arabia.

Atletico Madrid and France star Antoine Griezmann


Might Antoine Griezmann make his way to MLS this summer? (Florencia Tan Jun/Getty Images)

Maurer: Gio Reyna to… anywhere other than the Chicago Fire. This one may feel far-fetched, but Reyna simply needs minutes. Dortmund’s asking price has likely decreased significantly over the last year, bringing him into range for an MLS side. Whether Reyna would want to come back to the States is an entirely different story. Few would blame him.

Rueter: If Norwich City fails to earn promotion, Josh Sargent could be available for a fee similar to what Atlanta paid Middlesbrough for Emmanuel Latte Lath (more than $20million). St. Louis City expressed interest and playing through the summer (should he stay healthy) could bolster his case for the 2026 World Cup.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Promising Champions League for USMNT stars turns dire in a flash

Boldest Messi take for the season

Rueter: Messi helps Miami reach the conference final, where an extra-time defeat causes Miami to offer an even more lucrative package that ultimately brings him back for one more year.

Maurer: Messi will do the double, winning the league’s MVP and also its Golden Boot. Not that the famously competitive Argentine needs any added motivation, but his ownership stake in Miami — and the fact that this could be his final year playing in the league — may just give him the added nudge he needs. Scorching take, I know.

Cardenas: Messi’s numbers in 2025 won’t be spectacular. He’ll slow down a bit and Miami will monitor his fitness carefully going into the Club World Cup. He’ll still have an MVP-caliber season, but he won’t repeat as the winner of the award.

Tenorio: I could see a scenario in which Messi announces a six-month contract extension that lets him open the new stadium, takes him through the end of the 2026 World Cup … and that’s it.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

The USMNT wild card with a penchant for the unpredictable

Biggest surprise team (for better or worse)

Maurer: The San Jose Earthquakes, 2024 Wooden Spoon winners, will make the postseason in 2025. Never underestimate the power of American men’s soccer’s greatest coach fighting for his legacy (adding Chicho Arango doesn’t hurt, either). The Quakes won’t set the league on fire, but they’ll do enough to make the playoffs.

Tenorio: I second Pablo’s prediction. Never bet against Bruce Arena. I learned that lesson when he went to New England.

New FC Dallas star Luciano Acosta


Luciano Acosta has taken his goals and assists to Dallas for 2025 (Andy Lyons/Getty Images)

Rueter: With Eric Quill on the touchline and Acosta pulling the strings, FC Dallas leap to fifth in the Western Conference in their most entertaining season since the heyday of Mauro Díaz and Fabián Castillo.

Cardenas: In Wilfried Nancy’s final season in MLS, the Columbus Crew will miss the playoffs. Cucho Hernández’s absence will regress the Crew’s attack, and by the summer, Nancy will move abroad to start the next chapter of his coaching career.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Out in the cold, Greenland eyes Concacaf for sporting legitimacy

Over/Under: 0.5 MLS clubs getting out of the Club World Cup group stage

(Inter Miami are in a group with Porto, Palmeiras and Al Ahly; the Seattle Sounders are grouped with Paris Saint-Germain, Atlético Madrid and Botafogo)

Rueter: Under, but I’m sure both clubs will appreciate the extra allocation money for their attempts.

Maurer: Under. MLS has always craved the opportunity to prove itself a “league of choice,” but it still has a long way to go. It’ll be fun to watch either way.

Tenorio: Yeah, I’m going to take the under on this one, too.

Cardenas: Miami might scrape through, but if the Sounders make it out of Group B, well, the U.S. might win the 2026 World Cup. And we know that’s not happening. Under.

(Top photo: Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images)

Jenni Hermoso was not the victim people wanted her to be – we should be grateful to her for that

The important thing about the sentencing of Luis Rubiales is not whether he will go to prison, or how many thousands of euros he will have to pay to compensate Jenni Hermoso, the World Cup-winning footballer he kissed without consent while the world was watching.

The important thing is that it represents an end to the impunity of this powerful man who believed himself to be above the law.

Rubiales’ sentencing provides a reminder that the law is, and should be, the same for everyone.

Many will remember Hermoso for being ‘the one who was kissed’, rather than as the best striker the Spain women’s national team has ever had. As an iconic player who has scored more goals for her country than any other woman in history and who played a vital role off the pitch, too, in transforming women’s football in Spain.

The superstar who, at the age of 33 and towards the end of her career, helped her country win its first Women’s World Cup.

She was humiliated in front of the watching world by Rubiales when the former head of the Spain Football Federation (RFEF) kissed her after she was handed her World Cup winner’s medal on August 20, 2023. She will have to live with that forever.

“Since that day, my life has been on standby,” Hermoso said during her testimony in Rubiales’ trial at Spain’s High Court in Madrid in early February.

Rubiales denied her the best day of her life and took away her freedom.


Hermoso, flanked by team-mates Alexia Putellas and Irene Paredes, lifts the World Cup (Joe Prior/Visionhaus via Getty Images)

The trial lasted two weeks. The judge delivered his verdict in less than one.

Rubiales, 47, was found guilty of sexual assault but he and the three other co-accused — the former Spain women’s head coach Jorge Vilda, the former Newcastle United forward and ex-RFEF sporting director Albert Luque and former marketing director Ruben Rivera — were acquitted of coercion. The prosecution alleged they had coerced Hermoso to agree with Rubiales’ version of events. They denied any wrongdoing.

In the written reasons for the verdict, the judge gave full credibility to Hermoso’s testimony. The court statement said: “There was no reason or motive for her to be untruthful in her narration of the facts with the sole purpose of harming Rubiales.”

Rubiales has been fined more than €10,000 (£8,289; $11,400) and the ruling from Spain’s High Court bans him from going within 200 metres of Hermoso and communicating with her for one year. He was also ordered to pay a further €3,000 for moral damages and half of Hermoso’s legal costs.

In 2022, legislation was passed in Spain, referred to as the ‘solo si es si’ law (‘only yes means yes’), stating sexual consent must be affirmative by acts that “clearly express the will of the person” and that it cannot be assumed by default or through silence.

The new law no longer distinguishes between ‘abuse’ or ‘sexual assault’, but it does distinguish between a wide range of offences by also establishing that violence or intimidation is not necessary to commit a sexual assault. That means a new range of sentences that now go from four to 12 years, whereas before it was from six to 12.

Although criticised by some as it meant sentences already handed down would be reviewed and reduced, feminist organisations consulted by The Athletic said what the victim often needs was for someone to believe them, rather than a greater or lesser sentence.

The judge’s verdict on Thursday was the equivalent of an “I believe you” to Hermoso — in the most public of settings, and one that will be reported and broadcast across the globe. Rubiales was not sent to prison, but what is important to Hermoso is that she can finally feel like people believe her.


Rubiales outside the court in San Fernando de Henares (Oscar del Pozo/AFP via Getty Images)

The trial leaves us with many things to think about, one being the repeated revictimisation of the victim in court. When cross-examining Hermoso, the defence lawyers focused on the player’s behaviour after Rubiales sexually assaulted her. They wanted the perfect victim, one who refused to celebrate a World Cup because of what had happened. One who couldn’t laugh or who couldn’t party. They wanted a victim who just cried in the corner for something that was not her fault.

In her testimony to the judge on the first day of the trial, Hermoso was impressive. She showed herself to be the strong person anyone who has met her or followed her career knows that she is, and she portrayed an imperfect victim, certainly in the eyes of the defence lawyers. She was a victim who, despite what had happened, could enjoy her professional success — that she and her team-mates had been crowned champions of the world.

go-deeper

Hermoso did not cower in front of her aggressor in court. She had the option of testifying without Rubiales in the courtroom, but she said no. She sat down metres away from her attacker to give her statement and to answer questions from his lawyer, Olga Tubau. She even maintained her concentration and kept her cool on the multiple occasions Rubiales was whispering and commenting while she was talking.

“I don’t have to be crying in a room or throwing myself to the ground when the act happens to imply that I didn’t like it (the kiss),” Hermoso told the court. “At that moment, when I’m celebrating being world champion, drinking alcohol and eating, I’m happy and smiling because it’s the greatest achievement I can get in my life.”

Society often looks for the perfect victim, the one who acts the way everyone wants them to act. The aggressor may make mistakes, they are a human being. But the victim must act like a victim or they will be publicly discredited.

If this trial has taught us that a woman can be sexually assaulted and behave however she wants afterwards and still be considered a victim, then we should be eternally grateful to Jenni Hermoso for that.

The courage she has shown will help those victims who follow.

(Top photo: Hector Vivas/Getty Images)

Why Lewis Hamilton feels revitalized at Ferrari: ‘I’m exactly where I’m supposed to be’

When Lewis Hamilton put on his Ferrari race suit for the first time ahead of his maiden test for the team last month, he needed a moment to adjust to his new look.

While putting on a set of overalls is automatic for racing drivers, completed thousands of times through their careers, donning the iconic red of Ferrari is an honor bestowed on so few. And after 12 years in the silver and black of Mercedes, this was a big change for Hamilton.

At last, he was in Ferrari red. The excitement and anticipation he felt had been long in the making. Now, after F1’s season launch in London and his first test in the 2025 car, it is a reality.

Such wonder is something only Ferrari can stir. No matter how many world championships or races you win, the feeling of being part of F1’s most famed, successful team is unmatched. It’s what made Hamilton want to make the move and why he has radiated excitement since starting at Maranello in the middle of January.

Nearing the new season and the official start of his next chapter, Hamilton’s enthusiasm has shown zero sign of subsiding. After a sobering final year with Mercedes that appeared to sap some of the fizz from his love for F1, often hamstrung by an underperforming car, Hamilton has a fresh spring in his step.

He’s revitalized. Renewed. And, importantly, he is hopeful the record-breaking eighth world championship he came within one lap of winning in 2021 is within his sights once again at Ferrari.

“They’ve got absolutely every ingredient they need to win a world championship,” Hamilton said. “It’s just about putting all the pieces together.”


Adjusting to a new environment is not something Hamilton has done a lot during his F1 career.

Unlike more journeymen F1 drivers — on Tuesday, Carlos Sainz noted he’s driven for half the grid in 10 years — Hamilton is moving to just his third team. It will be the first time he has driven without Mercedes engines and the first time he’s not racing for an English team.

“This step is huge,” Hamilton said on Wednesday after his first test in Ferrari’s new car. “It couldn’t be any bigger.” There’s been plenty of adjustment, ranging from the vibration of the Ferrari engine behind him to the different steering wheel functions and processes. Hamilton feels a newfound appreciation for drivers who have made those switches and been successful immediately, but he is embracing the change.

“Every day, I’m experiencing something new, which actually is really exciting,” Hamilton said.

That includes learning Italian. While Ferrari conducts all of its meetings in English, Hamilton started taking Italian lessons last year to interact better with his mechanics and engineers, like chit-chatting about day-to-day life. Learning a new language has always been one of Hamilton’s dreams. He even gave a speech in Italian at Ferrari’s factory last week and is eager to immerse himself in Italian culture — including the food. “Last week, I had three pizzas,” Hamilton revealed, noting that while he has indeed lost weight, he knew he could not keep that up.


Vasseur and Hamilton debuted the SF-25 at F1 75 Live on Tuesday. (Sam Bloxham/Getty Images)

The effort Hamilton has made with his new colleagues has not gone unnoticed. On his first day visiting the factory, he tried to meet and shake hands with all 1,500 team members. “He’s quite amazing with people,” said Jerome d’Ambrosio, Ferrari’s new deputy team principal who worked with Hamilton at Mercedes. “The team already loves him after the first day.”

Hamilton has also enjoyed many aspects that make Ferrari unique, such as having the entire team under one roof — Mercedes’ engine facility was a 40-minute drive from the F1 team headquarters — and even a test track on its doorstep.

Hamilton is also already working well with his new teammate, Charles Leclerc. While the pair had chatted in the past, it was only upon Hamilton’s official start at Ferrari that they could start working together. They’re already playing games of chess against each other, even during Tuesday’s F1 75 Live event at The O2 — Hamilton is 3-2 up, according to Leclerc. They’re showing signs of a good partnership.

“The first weeks of collaboration between the two is mega-good,” said Ferrari team principal Fred Vasseur. “I’m not surprised at all. We are starting in very good shape now. The most important thing is to keep this relationship, to continue to work as a team, and to push as a team.”

Vasseur said Hamilton was the “perfect fit” for Ferrari right now, while Leclerc thought the Briton was joining at the ideal point as the team’s mentality is now stronger than ever, in part thanks to Vasseur’s leadership. No longer in a rebuild, the championship is a realistic goal for Ferrari.

“The fact Lewis has joined the team has been a big boost and has been amazing in so many ways,” Leclerc said. “But I feel like the team is very, very calm and very calm and very clear in what is the direction to work in and not getting too affected by everything that is going on around the team. That is extremely important and great to see.”


What matters most is how Hamilton performs when the new F1 season begins and how Ferrari compares to the competition.

Hamilton was adamant Ferrari had all the ingredients to win the world championship for the first time since 2008. The team only fell 14 points shy of the constructors’ crown last year, losing to McLaren. An incredibly fine margin — but a decisive one. Entering a season where Vasseur expects four teams to be in contention for race wins, every last thousandth of a second will matter.

“It’s not a matter of changing the car completely or whatever,” said Vasseur. “If we are able to bring a small bit of performance on one or two topics, it’s already a huge step forward. And Lewis is coming with his own experience, with his own background. He will help the team to develop in every single area.”

Ferrari opted for one major design change with its 2025 car: switching from a push-rod suspension to a pull-rod design, believing it would clean up the airflow around the car and allow for greater aerodynamic development after it had exhausted all areas with last year’s model. Although the SF-25 is an evolution of last year’s model and the overall car concept remains the same, reducing the learning curve the team will go through, every single part is new.

Even if Hamilton has confidence in Ferrari’s title-winning ability, he noted just how fierce the competition is set to be this year. “It’s far too early to know what the year is going to be like,” Hamilton said. “What we do know is that it’s going to be very close between the top teams. We’ve not seen the other cars; we’ve not been on the track with the other cars.”


Lewis Hamilton greets fans at the end of the day’s running at Fiorano Circuit on February 19, 2025. (Emmanuele Ciancaglini/Getty Images)

An eighth drivers’ title is the goal, but Hamilton’s appreciation for Ferrari runs deep and he knows how significant ending the team’s title drought will be — if anything, more significant given how invested everyone at Maranello (and across Italy) is to make it happen. “That’s what I’m working towards,” he said. “I don’t think about the number eight. I’m thinking about the first championship that the team has won for some time.”

Hamilton knows how much hard work still lies ahead to get ready for the new season, but the spark he has rediscovered with this move to Ferrari is obvious from every single interaction. It has given him a fresh lease of life in many ways. At 40, there is no sign he is thinking about how his F1 career may end. He feels young and remains in peak physical condition. And this new project is only spurring him on.

“The energy that I’m receiving from the team, there’s magic here,” Hamilton said. “It’s going to still take a lot of hard work and grafting from absolutely everyone and everyone is putting that in already to achieve it.

“But it’s also about belief. Everyone here dreams of winning with Ferrari, every single person in this team.”

After a difficult few years, that belief is coming back to Lewis Hamilton. The coming weeks will reveal just how genuine his title chances are in his first year in red. But for now, things feel good.

“I know I’m exactly where I’m supposed to be,” Hamilton said. “It feels natural, it feels right.”

(Top photo of Lewis Hamilton: Sam Bloxham/Getty Images)

How Missouri and Dennis Gates launched a storybook turnaround from an 0-18 SEC nightmare

COLUMBIA, Mo. — Dennis Gates is wearing a Lululemon hoodie with a hole in the right elbow. Gray sweats. Gray high tops. Same outfit he wore yesterday, same one he’ll wear tomorrow. On game days, Missouri’s coach is always in the same black suit, a gold tie and the shoes he wore to his introductory news conference five and a half years ago for his first head coaching job, at Cleveland State.

It’s not superstition. Gates does not want to waste time or energy on what to wear each morning. Fittingly, he wears the same face every day, too. Prefers that you cannot tell whether he won or lost. “That’s my temperament,” he said, “and I remain steadfast in it.”

And a year ago, boy did it come in handy.

After a successful first year — 25 wins, the program’s first NCAA Tournament victory since 2010, a fourth-place finish in the SEC — Gates’ honeymoon phase at Missouri came to an abrupt halt in Year 2 with the program’s first winless conference season (0-18) since 1908.

No matter the era, few coaches survive not winning a conference game. The last coach before Gates to go winless in the SEC — Bryce Drew at Vanderbilt in 2019 — was fired. A.M. Ebright was the coach of those 1907-08 Tigers, Missouri basketball’s second year of existence and first in a conference (the Missouri Valley). That was also Ebright’s only season ever as a head college basketball coach; he coached the University of Kansas baseball team the next year, then moved to Wichita to practice law.

“I don’t know of an 0-18 coach that ain’t got fired,” Gates said.

But Gates just kept operating how he had in his first season, leaning on a line from one of his favorite poems, Rudyard Kipling’s “If”, as his mantra:

If you can meet with Triumph and Disaster
And treat those two impostors just the same

There were excuses to be made — and we’ll get to those — but Gates kept his cool throughout the year. No blowups. No finger pointing. Same tone. Same rhetoric.

“He is the most even-keeled person emotionally that I’ve ever seen,” said Gabe DeArmond, who has covered Missouri athletics since 2003. “When things are not good, it frustrates people that he isn’t more angry. But then when things are good, he insists they’re not playing well.”

Now things are good: Gates’ third Mizzou team is 19-6, No. 15 in the AP poll and 8-4 in an SEC being discussed as the strongest conference ever. Only two high-major programs have made the NCAA Tournament following a winless conference season — 1987-88 Maryland and 2020-21 Iowa State.

In the transfer portal era, it’s possible to flip a roster quickly, as programs like Michigan and Louisville have shown this season. Missouri has not shied away from that strategy, with five transfer players contributing, but at those other places, there’s a new head coach in town, easily able to run off the guys who were on the court for the previous season’s losses.

Instead of stripping the program back down to its studs, Gates held on to his core: Five players in his current rotation, including three starters, are holdovers. The team that will welcome in No. 4 Alabama on Wednesday night has no shortage of memories from how far it has come in a short time to be jockeying for position with the best teams in the country.

“We had to be a participant in our own rescue,” said Tamar Bates, one of those returners. “Literally in real time we’re seeing ourselves write our names in history books.”



The Tigers’ upset of rival Kansas in December offered a glimpse at the potential of the team that has held its own in a brutal SEC. (Jay Biggerstaff / Imagn Images)

And lose, and start again at your beginnings
And never breathe a word about your loss

In June, Gates told his staff members to switch offices, essentially move out and move back in. They even put up fresh coats of paint. “They looked at me like I was crazy,” Gates said.

The head coach kept his office but rearranged the furniture. He wanted everyone to reprogram their brains into thinking the 2024-25 season would be Year 1.

“Reset. No residue,” Gates said. “If we’re going to ask the returning players, which was the core guys, to do it, we have to do it.”

First, a refresher. Last season did happen, and the excuses were plentiful. “Jason,” Gates shouted to sports information director Jason Veniskey, sitting at the back of his office. “Do you have the number of injuries that we had?”

The 2023-24 Tigers had injured or sick players miss a combined total of 111 games.

“We didn’t have the closers,” Gates said. “Everybody had to play out of position at that point.”

For his sanity, Gates was convinced his processes were good processes. He was told by peers Cleveland State was a bad job when he inherited it in 2019 coming off four straight losing seasons, and he had the Vikings in the NCAA Tournament in Year 2. He flipped Missouri even faster.

Had they been healthy, the consensus inside the walls at Mizzou Arena goes, the Tigers would have been competitive in ’23-24. In hindsight, there were some holes in the frontcourt, but the roster had a chance. John Tonje, who is now leading No. 11 Wisconsin in scoring amid a first-team All-America campaign, would have been the star, but he played only 78 minutes over nine games because of a foot injury, and 3-point marksman Caleb Grill missed all but nine games with a wrist injury.

During summer workouts, Grill even told assistant Kyle Smithpeters that it was one of the best teams he’d been on, and he’d been on back-to-back tourney teams at Iowa State. In the preseason, the Tigers were up 17 with three minutes to go when they pulled their starters in a secret scrimmage against Marquette, which went on to make the Sweet 16.

But once it started going south…

“You do what most coaches do: You question everything you’ve ever known that’s worked,” Smithpeters said. “You try to change and it still doesn’t work and you basically lose your damn mind. And Dennis did a great job of not losing his mind.”

Gates took satisfaction in the fact that nearly every SEC coach would commend how hard the Tigers played in their postgame news conferences. And some privately asked him, “How have your guys not checked out?”

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

NCAA Tournament Bracket Watch 2025: Duke warned, Purdue humbled, SNL eras ranked

Gates leaned on lessons he learned from his former boss Leonard Hamilton, who also experienced a winless conference season in 1994 at Miami, then went .500 in the ACC the next season and made the NIT. Hamilton frequently talked about that season when Gates was his assistant at Florida State from 2011 to ’19.

“He was teaching me something that nobody could teach other than him,” Gates said. “And most people would just sweep that s— under the rug as if it never happened.”

Most, he added, would “combust.” So why did he not?

“I’m too tough for that. Because I know Leonard didn’t. He never shared a story about combusting.”

What Gates did instead was start planning for his third year before the second ended. He was able to hold on to his incoming freshman class in the face of inquiries from other coaches, then hit the portal to address his needs. The 2023-24 Tigers were too small to play good defense and lacked offensive firepower. Gates’ first team at Mizzou was built around a playmaking forward in Kobe Brown. He saw Mark Mitchell, a former five-star recruit on his way out of Duke, as a similar force. Former Iowa guard Tony Perkins satisfied the need for a physical guard who could score. Marques Warrick, the leading scorer from a winning Northern Kentucky program, and Jacob Crews, a 6-8 shooter who averaged 19.1 points on a conference champ at UT Martin, provided depth and more scoring. The final addition, South Carolina 7-footer Josh Gray, had been one of the best rebounders in the SEC the last two years.

When the new and old players got to campus in June, the first order of business was team-building exercises. No basketballs. No matter where they’d played last season, Gates was holding up the neuralyzer. It was time to erase memories.

“The past is the past,” Grill said. “You can only control what’s going forward. You’ll have anxiety about last season if you think about last season and that’s an uncontrollable. That’s already over. The only thing you control is how you go forward each day.”



Missouri has flipped its trajectory with an even mix of contributions from returnees, like Caleb Grill (31), and transfers, like Tony Perkins (12) (Matt Pendleton / Imagn Images)

If you can wait and not be tired by waiting

On June 1, Gates made a bold proclamation to his team, one that would be picked to finish 13th in the SEC this preseason: By Christmas, the Tigers would be ranked.

In his vision, Gates believed beating Illinois in the Braggin’ Rights game would be what pushed his team into the rankings. The Tigers beat rival Kansas earlier in December but lost a close one to the Illini on Dec. 22. The next day Gates sent a picture of the AP Top 25 to his players and their parents with a message.

“We belong and we are a top 25 team in the country,” he wrote.

Four weeks later, he was proven right.

The formula does work. Gates builds teams much like he once did alongside Hamilton: with long athletes who produce a whole lot of deflections. The Tigers rank fifth nationally in steals rate, which has helped them lead the country in transition points per game (20.6), per Synergy.

Bates said this group has “lived in the details.” Before a game against Oklahoma last week, Missouri assistant coach C.Y. Young showed the Tigers a clip of Tom Brady talking about his preparation and ability to read a defense pre-snap. Young told the Tigers their superpower was their ability to carry out a scouting report. Later, a series of clips played of Oklahoma getting beat off the dribble to the basket. The message was clear: Get to the basket.

The Tigers followed it to the extreme in their 82-58 win, attempting only 12 3s and scoring 40 points in the paint and another 26 at the free throw line.

While usually the Tigers shoot a lot more 3s — an analytics-friendly 41.9 percent of their field goal attempts come from deep — the performance was otherwise exactly what Gates endlessly preaches, forcing the opposing defense to scramble with a string of passes that lead to a great shot. “Dominoes” is the word most often heard at a Mizzou practice.

It’s winning, unselfish basketball, and what’s most satisfying is seeing narratives about some of Mizzou’s stars get rewritten. Grill was booted from Iowa State two years ago after he “said something I regret,” as he explained in a statement at the time. While Missouri’s coaches never had issues with how he talked to them, he was emotional. “Every shot was a make or break,” Smithpeters said. Early last season, Grill got ejected from a game at Minnesota when he bumped an official and had some choice words.

Now, Grill is the old head at Mizzou facilities. He’s the type to pull a teammate to the side and talk one-on-one. He comes off the bench because he learned to appreciate last season how much more you see from the bench. He’s still fiery, but not reactionary.

“He has just exceeded every expectation I had for him as a human being from being able to handle pressure situations,” Smithpeters said. “That’s what’s allowed him to have so much success.”

Bates transferred from Indiana two years ago and had his character called into question on social media by former ESPN analyst and Hoosier alum Dan Dakich. When Gates named captains this summer, he purposely didn’t announce Bates, because he thought there was another step he needed to take as a leader. “He was pissed,” Gates said. “It was almost like, ‘I’ll show you.’”

Bates said he needed to learn how to use his voice as a weapon. He eventually was named a captain and is putting up career-best numbers, leading the Tigers in scoring. Bates also helped land Mitchell; the two knew each other from growing up in Kansas City. “Even though they went 0-18, he kept talking about the culture,” Mitchell said. “There’s losing cultures and winning cultures. He said this is a winning culture.”

Mitchell had lost some of his confidence as a role player at Duke and was looking to “get back to being myself.” Gates has put the ball in his hands and allowed him to play like a point forward.

Gates knew he had something special this summer when it quickly became apparent that Mitchell, the most talented guy on his roster, was the most unselfish.

“When you find that out about a person, it disarms everyone,” Gates said.

That helps explain how the Tigers are one of the most balanced teams in the country, with eight guys averaging more than 5.0 points per game and the big three (Bates, Mitchell and Grill) averaging 13.4, 12.9 and 12.8. An offense that ranked 136th in adjusted efficiency last year is up to No. 11 at KenPom.

Gates’ only regret is that the players who graduated aren’t around to experience the turnaround. He took a moment himself to enjoy it during the court storm following the Kansas win, climbing into the end zone bleachers where the band sits so he could watch his players celebrate.

“That’s part of the reward of coaching,” he said. “They’re going to forget games. They’re going to forget individual performances. These guys are sometimes going to forget championships. They’re not going to forget when the world thought less of them in this way. And they were able to now do something that nobody thought they could do in a special way.”

Gates often tells his players that their most important opponent is themselves, because he has the confidence that they can beat anyone.

Back in June, he gave them one final destination: San Antonio, the home of this year’s Final Four.

“Where we end is going to really dictate how great of a story we are really a part of,” Gates said. “Because we’re living in a story that can be a f—ing documentary.”

(Top photo: Stew Milne / Getty Images)

Canadian teammates on Sidney Crosby: ‘When he’s in your locker room, you always think you’re going to win’

BOSTON — When Drew Doughty got his first taste of best-on-best hockey, he was the youngest member of Team Canada at the 2010 Vancouver Olympics, and things didn’t start so well for him.

Naturally, it was a conversation with one of the “veterans” that helped him reverse course and turn the event into a career-shifting experience.

Never mind that the player was just two years, four months and one day older than Doughty. It was the type of player who was born a veteran.

It was Sidney Crosby.

“He was young,” Doughty recalls, “but I remember after one of our first practices I was walking onto the bus and he was like, ‘Hey, come sit beside me.’ That was the first time I had a real conversation with him. He knew I was nervous as hell, and he brought me in and sat me down.”

On the surface, that’s a pretty simple anecdote. But it starts to take on more heft once you see the pattern repeat itself again and again in stories shared by Canadian players and staff who have worked with Crosby under the searing heat lamp of the national team environment.

In addition to the physical and mental gifts that made him one of the sport’s few truly generational players, the 37-year-old possesses a level of awareness and emotional intelligence that have taken him to another level entirely.

As close friend Nathan MacKinnon puts it: “I’m sure there’s a lot of successful people that no one really wants to be around, but guys just gravitate towards him. He’s got an awesome personality. He’s a great storyteller. He’s just a fun guy to be around.”

It’s no coincidence that Crosby now finds himself in position to claim a fourth consecutive best-on-best tournament victory when Canada faces Team USA in the championship game of the 4 Nations Face-Off on Thursday night.


Teammates say Sidney Crosby has a “calming effect” under the bright spotlight of the Canadian national team. (Minas Panagiotakis / Getty Images)

His ability to connect with teammates shines through most in short-term, high-pressure tournaments, where even NHL stars battle nerves. Not only does Crosby understand how to bring a team together, but also he helps keep it together when the pressure spikes. Remember that these events typically feature multiple single-game eliminations, an outsized amount of attention and the uncertainty built into a game decided by a bouncing piece of rubber on ice.

“When he’s in your locker room, you always think you’re going to win,” says former teammate Matt Duchene of Crosby, with whom he won an Olympics, a world championship and a World Cup.

“It’s just the aura he gives off in there. The quiet intensity and confidence he has — you know there’s no moment too big for him. Even if he maybe feels nerves or whatever inside, he sure doesn’t show it.”

Even as the oldest participant at the 4 Nations, Crosby continues to demonstrate an impeccable sense of timing. When Finland scored twice with its goalie pulled on Monday afternoon, it was Crosby who halted the freight train by delivering an open-ice hit on Mikael Granlund before firing the puck into an empty net.

“He’s a leader,” teammate Brandon Hagel says. “He’s the best in the world, in my opinion. There’s no guy that does it like him — the way he portrays himself and how humble he is. It’s incredible to watch. Even last night, it gets a little close, who is it that puts the icing on the cake?

“It’s Sid.”

This has been a different national team experience than those that came before it.

MacKinnon says it’s Crosby’s first time playing with a team full of his biggest fans and, while half-joking, that sentiment rings true. Doughty and Brad Marchand are the only players he’s previously won with. And ask the younger players on the roster about their personal encounters with No. 87 during this event and they light up.

Mitch Marner says his overtime winner over Sweden was surreal because it came on an assist from his boyhood hero. Thomas Harley calls Crosby a “god,” adding, “You’ll go blind if you look at him too long.” And 23-year-old Seth Jarvis is still buzzing about the fact Crosby took the time to introduce himself following a Carolina Hurricanes-Pittsburgh Penguins game in January.

“Well, f—,” Jarvis says. “I wasn’t about to approach him. I’d be a little starstruck.”

Those personal touches go a long way toward creating a comfortable team environment.

Ryan Getzlaf, who won two Olympic gold medals alongside Crosby and now serves as Hockey Canada’s player relations adviser, says, “Sid’s a different cat” in a best-on-best setting because of how eager he is to diagram plays and break the game down to a minute level.

Asked if that would be intimidating for a team of players who grew up idolizing him, Getzlaf replies: “No, not at this level. If he’s talking to you, you probably feel good.”

At his core, Crosby is a details guy.


Nathan MacKinnon and Sidney Crosby have been among Canada’s top 4 Nations performers. (Maddie Meyer / Getty Images)

When he met Hockey Canada executive Scott Salmond for breakfast in Calgary in October, Crosby already knew which countries were seeded in the same pool as Canada at the 2026 Milan Olympics. He asked questions about club teams playing in the Champions Hockey League in Europe. Salmond doesn’t think he’s ever had a more thorough discussion with a player.

Throughout the 4 Nations tournament, head coach Jon Cooper has raved about Crosby’s impact on the group. While wanting to keep specific details in-house, he notes that a book could be written about the way his captain conducts himself and helps put the team in position to win.

“There’s no shock or surprise about why this kid has won as much as he has,” Cooper says. “There’s not a flaw in him, in any way. You talk about cool things to be a part of. This is a cool thing to be a part of because he’s here.”

As a reminder of how long Crosby has been doing this for Canada: Cooper was still coaching in the USHL when he scored the Golden Goal in Vancouver. Crosby’s the only member of the Triple Gold Club to complete all three legs as a captain, and Scott Niedermayer, the last man to wear the country’s “C” before Crosby, believes he was ready to be a leader even as a 22-year-old under an intense spotlight at the 2010 Games.

“He could have been captain in Vancouver, too,” Niedermayer says. “He understood what it took to have success not only as an individual but probably more importantly as a team.”

The national team has gone 47-6 with Crosby in uniform, dating to the 2004 World Juniors. Prior to that, he once served as a stick boy for a Canadian world junior summer camp in Halifax.

You can take the boy out of Cole Harbour, Nova Scotia, but fame and fortune never took any of the Cole Harbour out of Crosby.

Marchand could only chuckle during a recent dinner at his buddy’s house in suburban Pittsburgh when he walked into the living room and saw a rocking chair made entirely out of wood from Halifax.

“That’s what he sits in every day,” Marchand says. “He’s just a very down-to-earth guy, which at his level and the things that he’s accomplished doesn’t happen often. A tremendous amount of respect for him.”

Everyone here does.

There are no shortcuts to the unfathomable heights Crosby has climbed. His trophy case is spilling over, and still he grinds on for more, putting up five points in three games during a 4 Nations tournament where he’s played through injury. He’s built a compelling argument to go down as the most accomplished Canadian men’s hockey player of all time.

Crosby believes the best leaders command a room simply by being themselves, and so as the hours and minutes tick down to puck drop on Thursday’s 4 Nations championship he won’t stray from a highly focused and concentrated gameday routine. And any teammate looking in his direction will have full confidence that Captain Canada is ready to lead the way.

“He has a calming effect,” Duchene says. “I remember at the (2014) Olympics really feeling that way. I was 22 years old and looking at him and guys that had been there, done that, that helps you feel a little bit more brave going out there representing Canada.”

(Top photo: Vitor Munhoz / Getty Images)

How Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi’s sons became pawns in viral betting ploy gone awry

The graphics sprang up across social media, some in the yellow and blue of Saudi Arabian team Al Nassr, others in the flamingo pink of MLS side Inter Miami. The source of engagement was hardly new: Messi vs Ronaldo, the forever war of global football.

Except, this time, it was not about Cristiano and Lionel, the duopoly that defined a generation — instead, it was their sons: Cristiano Jr and Thiago.

The eye-catching post on X came on Feb. 7, from an account that presented itself as “Skye Sports Premier League (fan).” The caption read: “Ronaldo Jr and Thiago Messi just scored 10+ goals in their last match.” Followed by a flames emoji and a head-exploding emoji, the two graphics accompanying the post laid out a chain of events. Ronaldo, aged 14 and whose image was used in the graphic, had scored 10 goals in a 10-9 victory for Al Nassr’s youth team against Al Ittihad, while in the corresponding graphic, Thiago Messi, aged 12, had scored 11 goals in a 12-0 win for Inter Miami in the Under-13 MLS Cup against Atlanta United.

The post threw up curiosities. The first instinct is natural intrigue: are mini Messi and child Cristiano really this good? But then, the rational side took over: was any of this actually true?

Amid a search on X, Facebook or Google, the lay reader could very much be forgiven for believing the post to have been accurate.

Reports followed from mainstream outlets, including the Daily Mail, OneFootball, CNN Chile and the Spanish newspaper Mundo Deportivo. On Facebook, one of the world’s most-followed football reporters, Fabrizio Romano, posted an image of the graphic claiming Messi had scored 11 goals, with the caption “Thiago Messi cooked.” Romano has 22 million followers on Facebook alone and received 245,000 likes on his post. Other major accounts posted similarly, including TNT Sports, which broadcasts the Premier League and Champions League in the UK and Ireland, sharing Messi Jr’s exploits to its 2.1 million following on X and 4.5 million on Instagram. None of these accounts posted images or clips from a game, so there did not appear to be any evidence.

The reason for that? Neither achievement was real.

The MLS Under-13 Cup does not exist. At that level, MLS youth age groups play in MLS Next, where games are 35 minutes per half, meaning it is also impossible for Messi to have scored in the 76th, 87th and 89th minutes of the game, as the graphic had suggested.

Spokespeople for Atlanta United and Inter Miami confirmed to The Athletic the game did not take place, although Inter Miami did say Thiago Messi plays in the club’s academy. The Atlanta official joked that the graphic must have been sent to him 10 times during the previous five days. A spokesman for Al Ittihad in Saudi Arabia also said that the viral claim involving Ronaldo Jr, which supposedly ended 10-9, was untrue. He pointed us to the website of the Saudi Arabian Football Federation, where scores for games in the under-15 league are recorded.

There was a match between the under-15 sides of Al Ittihad and Ronaldo’s Al Nassr in mid-January, except it was won 4-2 by Al Ittihad. The goalscorers are not recorded on the site and The Athletic has not been able to establish whether Ronaldo scored or even played in that game. A spokesperson for Cristiano Ronaldo confirmed that the viral claims on social media were false.

So, what exactly is going on? Take a deep breath because these claims form just one part of a clumsy web of viral content, in which Ronaldo, Messi and their children are part of the collateral. This is a story that appears to emanate from an advertising campaign gone awry by an Australian gambling company — Stake — leaving celebrities, broadcasters, a Premier League football club, UFC, a Formula 1 team, X and even a porn actress caught in the crosshairs.

The most obvious original explanation had been that these claims about Ronaldo and Messi’s children were simply the latest frontier in the most famous rivalry in football fandom. In their book, ‘Messi v Ronaldo: One Rivalry, Two GOATs,’ Jonathan Clegg and Joshua Robinson write that “siding with Messi or Ronaldo has become not merely a statement of preference, but something closer to an article of religious faith.”

They add: “In the darkest wastelands of the internet — obscure subreddits, men’s fitness forums — it is fought on a battlefield of rage-tweets, vitriolic screeds, and dubiously sourced statistics wielded like a blunt weapon.”

Messi and Ronaldo


Messi and Ronaldo at the draw for the 2019-20 Champions League group stage (Harold Cunningham – UEFA/UEFA via Getty Images)

In this context, the achievements, real or imaginary, of their children became a tool in a petty squabble. William Dance, a researcher at Lancaster University specializing in disinformation in online spaces, tells The Athletic: “Misinformation flourishes when there’s high emotion involved. In football, it tends to be excitement, but the nature of the sport is that there are always continuous updates about players, especially mega-celebrities like Messi and Ronaldo. They become their own information ecosystem. People are more susceptible to misinformation because they suspend their disbelief around these figures.

“When they also have that binary position … that leads you to a system where people entrench to the far poles. Algorithms on social media actively promote this content, irrespective of whether it’s true or not. You’ve got people who are predisposed to believe this because of the environment, and then you’ve got algorithms actively promoting it. Whether it’s celebrities, politicians or even during the pandemic, when it impacted scientific experts, you find that the misinformation targeting them often bleeds into those surrounding them as well. Children or families end up being collateral damage.”

Hyperbolic claims about Ronaldo’s son had been circulating for weeks before the Messi counterclaim emerged. On Jan. 29, a since-deleted tweet posted by a Ronaldo fan account called @owngooal, again using the 14-year-old’s image, claimed he had scored all seven goals in a 7-0 win against Al Hilal. This was viewed over four million times, yet the most recent result between the two teams in the under-15 league was a 1-1 draw in October. On Feb. 4, another one landed from the same account, seen by 4.3 million people, claiming he’d scored 10 goals in a 10-9 win — again untrue.

The earliest trace of a similar pro-Messi post that I could identify appears to be from Feb. 5 and emanates from the fan account @MessiFCWorld. This claims that Messi’s son scored 11 goals against Atlanta United. This was seen by more than one million people on X and was reproduced extensively on social media and legacy media outlets.

Neither the Messi fan account, nor the Ronaldo one – neither of which are affiliated to the players – commented when asked by The Athletic if they were the originating sources of the misinformation.

In the days that followed claims of Thiago Messi’s exploits, the Ronaldo fan account went further, claiming their own prodigy had scored 12 goals in a 12-11 win against Al Hilal, notching up another three million views. Then, on Feb. 14, the same account claimed that the apparently unstoppable child of Ronaldo had scored all 15 goals in a 15-0 win against Al Ittihad, in a post retweeted more than 400 times.

As The Athletic studied the many posts springing up, it appeared there was more to this story than peculiar oneupmanship. That is because the logo of Stake.com, the Australian online casino and betting company, often seemed to be scrawled across the graphics of posts discussing the sons of Ronaldo and Messi. Neither player has a commercial relationship with Stake, but the company is the shirt sponsor of Premier League club Everton, as well as a sponsor of UFC and the title sponsor of Swiss Formula 1 team Sauber.

It has been in the news over the past week after the company announced it was to give up its license in Great Britain. This followed the start of an investigation by the Gambling Commission into an advert featuring the porn actress Bonnie Blue. Blue, whose real name is Tia Billinger, shot to fame in January when she attempted to break a world record for sex with the highest number of men within a 12-hour timeframe.

The investigation into Stake came when a post on X included a video recorded outside Nottingham Trent University, detailing the porn star’s “promise” to perform another feat of sexual stamina. Stake’s logo was visible on the video in the X posts, albeit not posted from an official Stake account.

It was seen millions of times across the various accounts from which it was posted. There is no suggestion the actress was involved or aware of Stake’s logo being superimposed. The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA), the UK’s advertising regulator, received complaints, including one seen by The Athletic by the Coalition to End Gambling Ads (CEGA), which said the advert breached the ASA code on multiple levels, including indecency and a clause that says “marketing communications must not link gambling to seduction, sexual success or enhanced attractiveness.” This was referred to the Gambling Commission, which began an investigation.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Explained: Stake, Everton and how a porn star led to a Gambling Commission warning

Stake did not cite the investigation when announcing its departure from Britain, instead calling its decision to leave “strategic” and claiming it wished to focus on growth markets in Italy and Brazil.

So, what’s this all got to with the children of Messi and Ronaldo? Well, the watermarking of Stake’s logo in tweets is also present in the claims by @OwnGooal of Ronaldo Jr’s seven-, 10-, 12- and 15-goal hauls. These were viewed millions of times on X across multiple accounts. In one instance, a post by the fan content creator UTDTrey (1.3 million followers) shared Ronaldo Jr’s fake 10-goal haul with the caption, “Might be time to start telling Thiago Messi to come outside.” This post watermarked the Stake logo across the bottom of the graphic. Another account shared a 10-tweet thread with the Stake logo attached that claimed (often falsely) that 10 professional football players had faked their age. Another account called @TeamCRonaldo shared pictures of Ronaldo’s mother and also pictures of several of his children, all with the Stake logo across the bottom once more. Ronaldo’s spokesperson confirmed he had no relationship with Stake and that his actual team has no involvement in this account.

Jack Jones is a partner at Sheridans, a law firm, where he advises clients in advertising, sport, games and digital media industries on commercial and intellectual property issues. He warns that individuals whose image has been used without permission can “consider legal action for unlawful processing of their personal data, privacy, false association and passing off.”

The Athletic asked all of the accounts mentioned to clarify if they had a commercial relationship with Stake, or if either Stake or an agency claiming to represent Stake had provided any guidelines for the type of content that should be attached to the logo, but none replied. Stake, too, did not respond to the question about guidelines.

This type of misinformation and controversial use of photos is significant because it appears to be the consequence of a guerrilla advertising campaign which has seen Stake promoted by football fan accounts on social media that have five, six and seven-figure followings. The Athletic has spoken to people who operate accounts that have been approached, some who spoke on the condition of anonymity because they did not wish to disclose business arrangements publicly.

Multiple fan accounts said they had been asked to use a Stake logo in their graphics and that they were incentivized by the amount of engagement a post creates. The Athletic has been told that accounts that partner with Stake are paid via cryptocurrency, a claim to which Stake did not respond.

The use of Ronaldo and Messi is likely because they are proven drivers of engagement online. As an example, Ronaldo’s YouTube channel recorded 45 million views when he took a “Couples Quiz” with his partner, Georgina Rodriguez, five months ago, and 21 million when Rodriguez assessed his outfits. As such, any material — true or otherwise — about Ronaldo, Messi and their families is likely to drive engagement, which in turn increases the returns for these content creators.

The Athletic has seen evidence of an intermediary, a digital agency called Elevate Media, offering via direct message on X to broker deals with fan accounts on behalf of Stake. In direct messages posted on Twitter, Elevate offered an “upfront fee” to one account to promote a logo and in a follow-up tweet, they said, “All videos and photos must be posted with the Stake banner.” Separately, we have seen evidence of an account being offered by Elevate the chance to earn around $5 or $6 per 100,000 views for promoting an unspecified brand logo, with promise that several Twitter pages “are making between $5,000 and $10,000 from the deal.”

Elevate did not respond to any questions and Stake also did not respond to questions about Elevate.

Following two emails from The Athletic to Elevate, the company’s brand account @Arthur_Elevate appeared to have been disabled on Monday, saying it no longer existed. Later the same day, the account appeared to have been restored with a new username.

Another fan account told The Athletic it was offered a paid partnership to use a Stake logo by a middleman agency and was asked to continue the negotiation via an anonymous account on Telegram. Others said they partnered directly with Stake, while a spokesperson for Stake told The Athletic: “The presence of the Stake logo on content does not necessarily indicate a formal relationship or sponsorship by Stake.”

Stake did not clarify which accounts have formal, or informal, relationships of any kind with the company, but it would appear that the practice of watermarking Stake onto graphics has become a trend in itself within content creating circles. Stake did not respond when asked what, if any, regulatory or legal guidelines were provided to partner accounts or agencies that may be partnering with accounts on their behalf. A spokesperson said: “Stake does not condone the unauthorized or inappropriate use of its logo. When made aware of such instances, Stake reviews the matter and takes appropriate steps, which may include requesting removal of the content.”

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

130 v 108: breaking down the astonishing international scoring of Ronaldo and Messi

Stake’s advertising approach has further potential consequences, most notably because the UK’s ASA rules say that marketing communications for gambling must “not include a child or young person,” or “include a person or character whose example is likely to be followed by those aged under 18 years or who has a strong appeal to those aged under 18.” The code also states that “marketing communications should be legal, decent, honest and truthful.”

The posts on X have also been visible to users in the United States. This means the posts featuring Stake may also be at risk of breaching X’s advertising regulations, as first outlined by 404 Media. X forbids the promotion of gambling content, except in specified countries where it is permitted with restrictions. For the U.S., these restrictions include that the advertiser must be “domiciled” in the U.S., yet Stake was founded in Australia and is owned and operated by Medium Rare NV in the Caribbean island of Curaçao, according to Stake.com. The website in the U.S., called Stake.us, says it is owned by Sweepsteaks Limited and provides an address in Cyprus. Stake did not respond when asked if it is breaching X regulations, while X also did not respond. The American Gaming Association’s responsible marketing code for sports wagering also states that “influencers or athletes appearing in advertising should be a minimum of 21 years old.”

Stake’s logo has also been watermarked across hundreds of posts on X seen by The Athletic responding to viral moments in European football, including fan accounts taking footage or screenshots from broadcasters that own the rights to the action. The Athletic has seen graphics posted by these accounts in recent weeks using moving or still images from Premier League broadcasters, including TNT Sports in the UK, NBC in the U.S., Viaplay in Scandinavia, Ziggo in the Netherlands and beIN Sport in the Middle East and North Africa region. The lawyer Jones explains that this can cause problems because rights holders are monitoring whether it is “fair use by fans engaging with their sport” or “a commercial use.” As the posts, or Stake, may be commercially benefiting by applying the betting company’s logo to the rights holder content, it may be deemed the latter.

A spokesperson for beIN told The Athletic: “BeIN have no partnership whatsoever with Stake. This is a combined case of piracy and illegal advertising. We are issuing a takedown order immediately for the content that has been illegally obtained from our channels, and looking into further measures to make sure this doesn’t happen again.”

Jones added: “There is a common misconception that what is in the public domain is free to use. This is not always the case. Fan accounts largely post social content owned by rights holders, online clips and images, which contain intellectual property. Rights holders have partners that pay money to associate with their brand or content and are therefore incentivized to monitor and enforce. Partnering with Stake, a gambling business hugely under the microscope, puts fan accounts on the radar of rights owners as it’s not only commercial use, but also an association with a business that would not be able to legally operate in some countries, as some countries forbid sports betting or advertising of sports betting. This puts fan accounts in the firing line of legal action and enforcement.”

When The Athletic first approached Stake with many of the issues raised within this article last week, we did not receive answers, and the posts flagged, particularly using the images of Ronaldo’s family and Messi’s son, remained online. However, after The Athletic approached Everton, UFC, Sauber and the Premier League on Friday, Stake then replied on Saturday morning via a spokesperson to say they take “appropriate steps which may include requesting removal of the content, when made aware of the unauthorized or inappropriate use of its logo.”

Several of the posts then appeared to have been deleted overnight — which is why they are included as screenshots rather than embedded tweets in this report — but long after amassing millions of views and awareness for days, weeks or months for Stake. Even this weekend, after Stake was alerted to numerous concerns, accounts that claim to be partnered with the gambling company continued to use images from Premier League broadcasts, or images they do not own, and slapped the Stake watermark across their posts. The Premier League say their match footage is only made available to official broadcast licensees and partners and that any unauthorized use outside these relationships would be an infringement of the Premier League’s rights.

For Everton, it is particularly awkward if their front-of-shirt sponsor is deemed to be connected to the misuse of Premier League footage. Everton, who The Athletic understands intend to retain a partnership with Stake that ends in the summer of 2026, held discussions with the company this week amid the blaze of negative publicity. They declined to comment for this report, as did the UFC and Sauber.


Stake.com advertising on the Everton shirt during the Premier League match in 2023 (Marc Atkins/Getty Images)

Dylan Penketh co-runs UtdDistrict, a Manchester United fan-led media outlet that has 947,000 followers on X, and he explained how some accounts that claim to have Stake partnerships conspire to translate the deal into money. He said: “We got the message from them (Elevate). I have no idea about the legitimacy of that one or if they were acting on behalf of Stake. I’ve always said to the guys I work with, ‘We’re never going nowhere near anything like this’. But so many people have. The Messi-Ronaldo stuff is part of it. But it’s everywhere.

“There are big fan accounts with millions of followers constantly throwing all this stuff out. I have also been told there are WhatsApp group chats between big accounts that all have Stake deals where they interact with each other to inflate each other’s numbers. Someone will purposefully say something really outrageous on their one big account, send it to another person and go, ‘Can you quote disagreeing with me?’ This then boosts engagement and engagement inflates the numbers, then they get more money. The news can be completely fake. It can be completely real. The whole point is you need to drive as many engagements as possible.”

Jones, the legal expert, calls it “a high-risk marketing strategy.”

“Gambling is a heavily regulated industry, including its marketing,” he said. “Appropriate checks, balances and approvals should be undertaken when promoting/advertising gambling to ensure compliance. Many content creators may not be aware of or fully appreciate the laws of promoting gambling. Falling foul could amount to public relations disasters, but also legal escalation from regulatory bodies and the rights holders themselves.”

(Illustration: Eamonn Dalton / The Athletic; photos: Carlos Sipán, Abdullah Ahmed, Pierre Suu, Emma Garcia / Getty Images)

Potential NFL salary-cap cuts for all 32 teams: From Cooper Kupp to Davante Adams and more

Not every NFL team is blessed with cap space this offseason. The New England Patriots, for example, have little worry and plenty incentive to spend at an estimated $119 million in cap space, according to Over The Cap. Other teams, such as the New Orleans Saints, with a $51 million hole to climb out of, have plenty of cap gymnastics ahead over the next few months.

But no matter where any team falls on the cap space spectrum, everyone could stand to create some room for themselves as free agency revs up. That’s where The Athletic’s NFL beat writers come in. Which players could be salary-cap casualties in the coming months? We have one for all 32 teams below.


Arizona Cardinals: Jalen Thompson, S

GM Monti Ossenfort has avoided big swings, which often frustrates the fan base. But it has put the Cardinals in a good place and positioned them to improve the roster. Per Over The Cap, Arizona ranks fourth in the NFL with $71.3 million in available cap space. There’s not an obvious potential cap casualty on the roster. Thompson is a possibility. He has started for most of his six seasons. He’s dependable. He’s also entering the final year of his contract. The Cardinals in December locked up safety Budda Baker. They drafted Dadrion Taylor-Demerson in the fourth round of last year’s draft. This might be the place. Releasing Thompson, 27 in July, would save Arizona nearly $6.6 million in cap space. — Doug Haller

Atlanta Falcons: David Onyemata, DT

Financially, it makes more sense to move on from fellow defensive tackle Grady Jarrett, but he seems untouchable in Atlanta even though he and Onyemata both will be 32 when the season begins. The Falcons would incur an $8.8 million dead-cap hit, but releasing Onyemata would save the same amount in total cap dollars, and while his play has been solid in the two years (seven sacks, 14 TFLs) since signing as a free agent in 2023, it hasn’t been stellar, and the Falcons need to get younger up front (releasing Jarrett would save $16 million on the cap and result in just $4.1 million in dead-cap hit). — Josh Kendall

Baltimore Ravens: Marcus Williams, S

This has been viewed as a formality since the free-agent acquisition from 2022 was benched and made a healthy scratch for the final seven games. Williams restructured his contract last month to make it easier for the Ravens to move on as both sides understand the need for a fresh start for the 28-year-old safety who will likely be a post-June 1 release. Veteran cornerback Arthur Maulet is another potential salary-cap casualty for the Ravens, whose cuts could go deeper than they’d like because of a tight cap situation. — Jeff Zrebiec

Buffalo Bills: Von Miller, Edge

The Bills don’t have many obvious cap casualty candidates this offseason, but they must do something about Miller’s contract. The now rotational pass rusher is entering his age-36 season, and carries the second-biggest cap hit on the team at $23.8 million. That’s an untenable situation, given his small role. If the Bills cut him, they would save $8.4 million on the 2025 salary cap. But because he’d still hold a $15.4 million dead cap hit if released, the Bills could negotiate a pay cut with Miller equal to or greater than how much they’d save on the cap to cut him. However, without a pay cut, Miller is likely to be released. — Joe Buscaglia


Buffalo Bills pass rusher Von Miller, who turns 36 in March, could be a salary-cap casualty this offseason. (Timothy T Ludwig / Getty Images)

Carolina Panthers: Miles Sanders, RB

The writing has been on the wall for Sanders since 2023 when Frank Reich and Duce Staley — Sanders’ two biggest supporters — were fired after 11 games. Sanders, who signed a four-year, $25.4 million deal that year, took on a reduced role behind Chuba Hubbard. Even with backup Jonathon Brooks likely sidelined for 2025 after a second ACL surgery, the Panthers can find cheaper options than the 27-year-old Sanders. The Panthers will create $5.23 million in cap space by cutting Sanders, who will always have his two-touchdown game at Atlanta in Week 18 when Hubbard and Brooks were out. — Joseph Person

Chicago Bears: Gerald Everett, TE

After signing a two-year, $12 million contract to be the pass-catching tight end to complement Cole Kmet, Everett fell into the Bears’ No. 2 tight end curse. He finished with only eight catches for 36 yards. With a $6.5 million cap hit in 2025 and only $1 million of dead cap if he’s cut, it’s hard to see Everett sticking around to be part of Ben Johnson’s offense. He’ll be 31 in June, and while the Bears’ coaches clearly struggled last year to incorporate the tight end position, Everett’s poor production and high cap charge are a bad combo. — Kevin Fishbain

Cincinnati Bengals: Sheldon Rankins, DT

Rankins is one of many veterans on the Bengals roster likely to be let go this offseason (OL Alex Cappa, DL Sam Hubbard, LB Germaine Pratt). He’s the most certain of the group. The 31-year-old disappointed when healthy this season, only managing one sack and four pressures, then missed the second half of the year with an illness. Cincinnati gave Rankins a two-year, $24.5 million deal last year but will save $9.6 million against the cap. He has a roster bonus due March 17 that he will not see. — Paul Dehner Jr.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Watch: What would a perfect offseason look like for the Bengals?

Cleveland Browns: Ogbo Okoronkwo, Edge

The Browns face a series of important salary cap-related decisions, and they could save $3 million by designating Okoronkwo as a post-June 1 cut ahead of his age-30 season. They also need to make difficult decisions on the future of veteran defensive tackles Dalvin Tomlinson and Shelby Harris — while also dealing with Myles Garrett’s trade request. It’s not been a fun few months for the Browns in just about any capacity. — Zac Jackson

Dallas Cowboys: Donovan Wilson, S

It’s more likely that Wilson remains on the team, but if there was going to be a salary-cap cut in Dallas, the safety position stands out. Wilson’s 2025 base salary is $6.5 million. Cutting him would leave $3.3 million in dead money. Wilson started every game last season, finishing third on the team in tackles and fifth in sacks. He ranked 61st among all safeties on Pro Football Focus.

The other option would be safety Malik Hooker, who also started every game last season. Hooker, who finished fourth in tackles and tied for the team lead with two interceptions, has a base salary of $5.5 million in 2025 and $6.5 million in 2026. Cutting him would leave Dallas with $4 million in dead money. Hooker finished 41st among all safeties, according to PFF. There is also a slight age difference. Wilson turns 30 this month. Hooker turns 29 in April. Again, the Cowboys will probably keep both, but the two starting safeties would be candidates if a cut had to happen. — Jon Machota

Denver Broncos: Alex Singleton, LB

This won’t be the same seismic offseason for the Broncos as in 2024, when they traded wide receiver Jerry Jeudy and cut safety Justin Simmons. Those moves were made, at least in part, to account for the financial ramifications of cutting quarterback Russell Wilson. The Broncos are operating with more than $50 million cap space and won’t be forced into cost-saving moves.

Still, the Broncos may take a look at Singleton’s contract as they reshape the inside linebacker room. The 32-year-old is coming off an ACL injury he suffered early last season and has no guaranteed money remaining on the three-year contract he signed in 2023. The Broncos would save $5.6 million by releasing him, according to Over The Cap, with only $1.3 million in dead money left behind. Safety P.J. Locke ($4.2 million savings if released) is another candidate to watch. — Nick Kosmider

Detroit Lions: Za’Darius Smith, Edge

It’s certainly possible Smith finds his way back to Detroit next season, but it’s hard to see it happening on the contract Detroit inherited via last year’s trade with Cleveland. Cutting Smith prior to June 1 would give the Lions nearly $6 million in cap savings without any dead-money penalties. Smith, 32, was a perfect fit with Detroit down the stretch last season and was the team’s best pass rusher after Aidan Hutchinson’s injury. Even if Smith is cut, look for Detroit to explore bringing him back on a new deal. — Nick Baumgardner

Green Bay Packers: Jaire Alexander, CB

Alexander has played in only seven games each of the last two regular seasons because of four separate injuries. There may be a disconnect off the field that hasn’t become public, too, despite general manager Brian Gutekunst saying otherwise. Cutting or trading the two-time second-team All-Pro before June 1 would free up about $6.8 million in cap space. Alexander has the third-highest cap number on the team for 2025 behind quarterback Jordan Love and defensive end Rashan Gary. That may not be worth it for how little he’s been available and whatever else might be going on with the 28-year-old. — Matt Schneidman

Houston Texans: Denico Autry, DT

Autry never lived up to the expectations the Texans had for him when he inked a two-year, $20 million deal last season. Autry, 34, wound up starting just two of the 10 games he appeared in and had 13 tackles and three sacks. Cutting him with a post-June 1 designation would translate into a savings of $9 million for the Texans, who are projected to have just more than $3 million in cap space entering the 2025 league year. — Mike Jones

Indianapolis Colts: Braden Smith, RT

Smith, who is entering the final year of a four-year, $70 million contract extension, missed the last five games of the season due to an undisclosed personal matter. Obviously, we can empathize with whatever kept Smith, known for playing through injuries, away from the field. From a football and financial standpoint, however, the writing has been on the wall for Indy to cut ties with him this offseason, even if he had played in every game in 2024. Doing so would save the Colts $16.75 million against the cap with only a $3 million dead cap hit. His salary is not tenable for a player who, aside from the 2024 season, missed seven games in 2023 due to wrist, foot, hip and knee injuries. The 28-year-old is likely past his prime, and it may behoove the Colts to go with 2024 draft pick Matt Goncalves at RT and spend the savings elsewhere. — James Boyd

Jacksonville Jaguars: WR Christian Kirk

The Jaguars don’t have a lot of options to easily free up chunks of cap space. They could certainly part with a handful of depth players, including wide receiver Josh Reynolds, to save $4 million, but the big moves would come down to Kirk and tight end Evan Engram. Cutting Kirk would save $10.4 million in cap space if the Jags need to make a splash move. His production has declined each of the past two seasons due to injuries. They also could free up $6 million in cap space by parting with Engram, which might be more of a consideration after the draft if the Jaguars tap into the talent at that position. — Jeff Howe

Kansas City Chiefs: Skyy Moore, WR

The Chiefs don’t have an ideal candidate for this category. This offseason will likely be similar to the past two years for the Chiefs. They can create plenty of salary-cap space by converting a large chunk of Mahomes’ $32.3 million roster bonus into a signing bonus. Another way to create a small amount of space is by releasing Moore, the 2022 second-round pick. Moore has struggled in the past three years and hasn’t done enough to have a defined role in the offense. The Chiefs would save $1.6 million by releasing him, according to Over The Cap, with just $467,819 in dead money. — Nate Taylor

Las Vegas Raiders: Gardner Minshew, QB

Minshew was terrible in 10 appearances last season and won’t be in the Raiders’ plans at quarterback. If they cut him straight up, they’ll free just $3 million in cap space while taking a dead money hit of $10.82 million, according to Spotrac. If they cut him with a post-June 1 designation, however, they’ll free up $6 million in cap space. The dead money hit would be spread across the next two seasons, with $7.82 million coming in 2025 and $3 million hitting the books in 2026. — Tashan Reed

Los Angeles Chargers: Joey Bosa, Edge

Bosa has a $36.47 million cap hit for 2025, according to Over The Cap. That is the highest cap hit for any edge rusher in the league this year. Bosa has not been close to that level of player in quite some time, largely due to injury. He has only played in 28 of a possible 51 regular-season games over the past three seasons. He has 14 combined sacks in that span. The Chargers do have cap flexibility this offseason. They have the sixth-most effective cap space in the league. But even with that space, keeping Bosa at this number just does not make sense. The Chargers can save $25.36 million in space by cutting or trading Bosa. — Daniel Popper

Los Angeles Rams: Cooper Kupp, WR

If the Rams can’t trade Kupp, they could cut him. His salary in 2025 is tricky. Cutting Kupp prior to June 1 would incur $22.26 million in dead money, while only saving $7.5 million. His roster bonus of $7.5 million is due March 17. Cutting Kupp after June 1 would incur $14.8 million in dead money while saving $15 million, but the team has made it clear it is ready to move on. The Rams did not ask Kupp to restructure his existing contract, a league source said, although they probably would be willing to eat some of the money owed to him to actually get a trade done. — Jourdan Rodrigue

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Cooper Kupp trade proposals: 9 teams that could make a play for Rams receiver

Miami Dolphins: Jason Sanders, K

The Dolphins’ salary cap is in rough shape, and unfortunately for them, they don’t have many easy outs to free up space. For the biggest impact, they may wind up restructuring or extending contracts for big-money players such as LT Terron Armstead and LB Bradley Chubb — cutting them would incur huge dead-cap hits ($32.7 million for Armstead and $27.3 million for Chubb) — and push more of their money into the future.

Miami found some relief by cutting a few low-cost veterans in RB Raheem Mostert, CB Kendall Fuller and TE Durham Smythe last week. That, however, doesn’t leave many palatable options left. Sanders is a good kicker and fairly compensated with a cap hit of $4.7 million in 2025. But the Dolphins need cap space, and cutting him would save $3.3 million. — Jim Ayello

Minnesota Vikings: Ed Ingram, G

The Vikings benched Ingram in Week 11 after three seasons as a starter at right guard. A second-round pick in 2022, Ingram struggled in pass protection for the third straight season. Minnesota’s offseason will revolve around revamping the trenches. Ingram is not a viable option if the Vikings are committed to vastly improved play. Cutting him makes sense.

The Vikings could save a minimum of about $3.3 million on the cap with the move. That number could actually increase, depending on whether Ingram receives a proven performance escalator. Minnesota already has close to $60 million in cap space for 2025, so this move is not a necessity. That said, the Vikings need to upgrade their interior offensive line, interior defensive line, cornerback and running back. More money to spend will help. — Alec Lewis

New England Patriots: Kendrick Bourne, WR

It might seem crazy for the Patriots to cut arguably their top player at arguably their biggest position of need, but they could yield $4.9 million in cap savings by cutting Bourne before June 1 (or $6.3 million if they do it with a post-June 1 designation). Bourne missed the start of last season while recovering from a torn ACL and posted 305 receiving yards in 12 games. As he enters his age-30 season, it might be time for the Pats to move on. — Chad Graff

New Orleans Saints: Derek Carr, QB

Carr is the most obvious candidate as the Kellen Moore era begins in New Orleans. During his introductory news conference, Moore was noncommittal about the quarterback’s future with the team. Cutting Carr would add more dead money to the Saints’ league leading total, according to Spotrac.com, but the franchise has a lot of those contracts coming off the books in 2026, which would provide some relief. Even if the Saints stick with Carr, they’ll likely need to restructure his deal as they are roughly $51 million over the projected salary cap in 2025. — Amos Morale III


The New Orleans Saints, who have the league’s worst cap situation, might opt to release Derek Carr this offseason. (Julio Aguilar / Getty Images)

New York Giants: Graham Gano, K

The Giants don’t have any albatross contracts to shed this offseason and they’re in a healthy enough cap situation that they don’t need to make any cap cuts. Still, a $5.7 million cap hit is excessive for the 37-year-old Gano, who has missed 16 games due to injury the past two seasons. The Giants can create $3.2 million in cap savings while eating $2.5 million in dead money by dumping Gano. That’s not an overwhelming financial impetus, but a team in the Giants’ position can allocate that money better. — Dan Duggan

New York Jets: Davante Adams, WR

Now that we know Aaron Rodgers will not be returning (he’ll also likely be cut and designated post-June 1), don’t expect his two running mates — Adams and Allen Lazard — to return either. Adams played well for the Jets but he only came to New York to play with his friend. His contract is mostly non-guaranteed, so cutting or trading him would save $29.8 million in cap space with an $8.3 million dead-cap charge. The Jets don’t have a lot of cap casualty options outside of the two former Packers receivers. — Zack Rosenblatt

Philadelphia Eagles: Darius Slay, CB

The Eagles began their succession plan at cornerback last year by spending their first two draft picks on Quinyon Mitchell and Cooper DeJean. Both were finalists for Defensive Rookie of the Year. Slay, 34, battled multiple injuries during the season. He missed one game with a knee injury, another with a groin injury and sat out the regular-season finale while resting the entire week. The six-time Pro Bowler is still playing well, and perhaps, like Jason Kelce, Fletcher Cox and Brandon Graham before him, Slay will be afforded some say in when it’s time for him to leave. But his cap hit is the sixth highest for an Eagles team that needs a little wiggle room, and a cut with a post-June 1 designation not only saves the Eagles $4.3 million in 2025, but also $17.7 million in 2026. — Brooks Kubena

Pittsburgh Steelers: Larry Ogunjobi, DT

Ogunjobi signed with the Steelers in 2022 after tallying double-digit TFLs and QB hits in three of his first five seasons. But during his three years in Pittsburgh, he’s only once reached double digits in any category (QB hits in 2022), while playing through numerous injuries. The Steelers, who are scheduled to employ the NFL’s highest-paid defense for the fourth consecutive year in 2025, can save $7 million of Ogunjobi’s $10 million cap hit by cutting him. While that would leave a hole on the defensive front, the Steelers can fill it with a younger, less-expensive option in the draft. Whether the Steelers make this move or not, expect them to target a defensive lineman early on draft weekend. — Mike DeFabo

San Francisco 49ers: Javon Hargrave, DT

General manager John Lynch already has said the 49ers will release Hargrave, who missed most of the 2024 season with a triceps tear, and allow him to become a free agent next month. Hargrave, 32, was the team’s big-splash free-agent signing in 2023 when he agreed to a four-year, $84 million deal. But he played only one full season in San Francisco before being injured in Week 3 this past season. Lynch said the 49ers would be interested in re-signing Hargrave, but it would have to be at the right price. Hargrave’s market will be interesting in a year in which the draft is believed to be deep at defensive tackle. — Matt Barrows

Seattle Seahawks: Dre’Mont Jones, LB

Jones signed a three-year, $51 million deal in March 2023, the richest external free-agent deal of the John Schneider era by average annual salary. The contract was restructured last season, increasing Jones’ 2025 cap hit to $25.6 million. Seattle saves $11.5 million by trading or releasing Jones, who might be the team’s fifth-best pass rusher when everyone is healthy. Jones is only 28 and a decent pass rusher, but his current cap figure appears to be untenable. Also, Seattle would save $17 million by trading or releasing Tyler Lockett, who turns 33 in September. — Michael-Shawn Dugar

Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Jamel Dean, CB

Dean’s cap hit in 2025 of $15.2 million ranks eighth highest among NFL cornerbacks. And the Bucs, who reportedly have $11.7 million in cap space, will be looking for ways to trim. Dean is a solid player but he will be 29 in October and never has been a big-play producer or shutdown corner. Over the past two years, he has missed nine games and parts of five others with injuries. Cutting Dean would leave the Bucs thin at cornerback, however. — Dan Pompei

Tennessee Titans: Treylon Burks, WR

The designated replacement for AJ Brown, the other side of one of the worst personnel moves in franchise history and one of the worst in recent NFL memory, needs a fresh start. And the Titans need to stop waiting for him to be a factor. The 2022 first-round pick has been banged up, playing in 27 of 51 possible games. He hasn’t done much with his opportunities — 53 catches for 699 yards and one touchdown. His 2025 cap hit and the dead number if the Titans move on from him are the same, $4.6 million. That’s worth moving on and rebuilding the receiving corps around Calvin Ridley. — Joe Rexrode

Washington Commanders: Jonathan Allen, DT

One season remains on Allen’s four-year, $72 million extension. The terms included a $22.47 million salary-cap hit but only a $6 million dead-cap charge. Washington has significant cap room regardless, but it also has DT Daron Payne counting north of $20 million and an Allen replacement in 2024 second-rounder Johnny Newton on the roster. Allen’s streak of healthy seasons ended with a pectoral tear, though he surprisingly returned before the playoff run. His power and pass rushing would be missed. However, his sack totals have declined annually since recording nine in 2021, and he is entering his age 30-season. — Ben Standig

(Top photos of Cooper Kupp and Davante Adams: Brooke Sutton and Perry Knotts / Getty Images)

Q&A: Rose Zhang on her TGL investment, the LPGA’s future and slow play

There are a lot of things to admire about Rose Zhang. Before turning pro two years ago, she was arguably the winningest amateur in the history of women’s golf. Now she’s competing on the LPGA and already has a pair of professional wins at age 21. Zhang is as poised as they get and her youth — combined with a swing that could make a robot look inconsistent — has allowed her to become one of the faces of the game’s Gen-Z movement.

Zhang is doing it all while attending Stanford University as a communications major, taking 22 credits this winter (she completes one 10-week quarter each year to balance school with the international LPGA schedule). As Zhang finishes her third-to-last quarter of classes en route to a 2027 graduation date, she caught up with The Athletic to talk about the state of the LPGA, her adjusted preseason game plan and her new foray into golf’s simulator experiment. Zhang is now a minority investor in The Bay Golf Club, TGL’s San Francisco team. According to TGL, active discussions are taking place with the LPGA to devise competitions that could integrate top female players. With virtual holes, players in a mixed event could all hit from the same tee boxes with the technology adjusting for appropriate distances. The prospect of that arrangement is certainly enticing, and Zhang, for one, is intrigued by it.

This conversation has been edited for clarity and length.

You’re the newest investor in TGL. How did that come about?

I’d heard about it on social media, but I never really thought about becoming an investor. My agency brought the opportunity to me. It’s low stakes for me because I’m not the one playing out there. It’s cool to be on the investing side of things, this is one of the first things I’ve invested in, in the golf world at least. The Bay Area has played a huge role in my life and career. I’m a student-athlete at Stanford, I play a lot of golf in the city of SF and being able to be a part of it in a more meaningful way was my first thought. To see other athletes like Steph Curry, Klay Thompson, Andre Iguodala involved makes it even more amazing. It’s going to be cool to watch the team on TV and say, “Oh, I have a little part in that!” Not really … but I do. I’m invested in it emotionally too.

Have you watched much TGL?

I have, with the cool technology and the indoor facility it gives an energy that even non-golfers can enjoy. I think it’s a really good platform to expose different parts of the game, show people’s personalities, and have a little bit of fun. Some of my non-golf friends are like, “Oh, this thing is like a whole stadium and you’re playing golf indoors? What does that even mean?” You’ve got all these crazy lights — it basically turns into a show. It’s a good source of entertainment for those who aren’t exposed to it. You don’t get to see golfers’ personalities because we don’t talk. The entertaining side of all of this is that players are mic’d up and get to interact with fans and each other. People like to see competition and camaraderie but some kind of flare to each personality.

Should LPGA players be a part of TGL?

I think that’s a topic for discussion. That would definitely be very interesting. It brings a lot of variety with the format that it is — indoor golf, one vs. one or team vs. team. Having diversity really brings this sort of platform to life. I can definitely see the LPGA hopping on board with it, having specific players participate in a TGL event. I played “The Match” with Rory McIlroy, Lexi Thompson and Max Homa. It’s similar to that, but it’s inside and indoors so it’s fair play for everyone. I think a lot of people don’t understand, there are a lot of characters out there on the LPGA Tour. You’ve got a lot of people with personalities that are so suited for this type of format.

Who should TGL recruit from the LPGA?

We’re talking about popular characters here. To start off, in my opinion, I’d love to see Meghan Khang hop on there. She knows how to talk, that’s for sure. Charley Hull is a world renowned name, it’d be really entertaining to see what she does. If you want really good players, you’ve got Lydia Ko, you’ve got Nelly Korda.


A highlight of Zhang’s 2024 was her appearance on a winning Solheim Cup team. (Gregory Shamus / Getty Images)

You made your season debut at the HGV Tournament of Champions and posted at T10 finish, but we know that was just a break from your winter studies at Stanford. How has your offseason been treating you?

It’s been a lot more academic than actual golf. I’m excited, I’m doing a lot of cool projects. I’m hosting an AJGA event. I’ve been focusing on school, hanging out with friends, and being with people I haven’t been able to hang out with in the last two years. It’s really nice to have some bonding time and just enjoy the offseason a little bit more. It’s a grind, given I’m still balancing academics and golf. But the grind honestly challenges me.

What classes are you taking this semester?

I’m taking a Politics of Algorithms, Deliberative Democracy and its Critics, a Hebrew Jewish Short Stories class, a Science Technology & Society class and a class called Sleep and Dreams. It’s a cognitive science class. You get bonus points if you fall asleep in lecture. You get woken up by a squirt gun.

Did you intentionally decide to take a step back from golf and throw yourself into school this year?

Definitely. Especially with last year, I was able to balance golf and school, but my social life was deterred a little bit. I had a lot of difficulty in balancing myself and my health, physically. It was a little bit hard to navigate in that sense. This year I was a lot more intentional. I’m taking 22 units of classes. That’s a big load for any student. I essentially decided to finish my academics and prioritize that, and then when I could rest and recover that’s when I could spend time with people. Just be a little bit lower maintenance, so when I start playing at the end of March I’m not completely tired and wiped out from the last three months. It’s been a lot better. I personally wish to prepare the best way I can starting in March. With a super long season my priority is to rest a little bit more.

What have been some of those hiccups in your health?

Everything piled up on its own. I did a lot of intense practicing at school, and I had a lot of class as well. I also just went full speed into the season. I spread myself a little thin in practice and the way I was doing things. By the end of the year, I had this recurring thing with my wrist that started back in 2020, and it just came back. I don’t want it to remain chronic, so that’s a priority. I’m slowly starting to load my wrist again to make sure it’s strong. You can go to physical therapy and have the inflammation resolved, but to strengthen it or at least bring it back to its normal performance, you’ve going to need to do circuits that involve resistance and weight. That’ll get me where I want to be.

Do you have any mindset changes or goals you’ve hoping to make in 2025?

The No. 1 thing that I have in mind — and I was talking to my entire team about it — is I just want to make sure I’m intentional with the things I’ve been doing and the schedule I curate with them. I want to stay accountable for balancing everything and actually do everything, for example. Making sure I’m going through workouts with my trainer, resting my body and relaxing it, giving myself times where I can work with my coach and practice efficiently. I created a schedule for myself, and I wish to just go with that. So when things happen on tour and there’s a lot going on, I have a plan to fall back on. Last year, I misdirected in the way I was preparing myself for events. So that’s the main priority this year. I’m not so worried about the results as much. If you’re able to plan the process and go with it, that’s when results come.

Do you find comfort in sticking to a process?

I find freedom in it. Once you know you’re on a trajectory that you curated, that’s when you have a little bit more agency to at least think about if you need to deviate plans. I was doing a little bit too much of going here, going there — not fulfilling my priorities.

You started using AimPoint this fall. Has it been helping you and what has the process been like learning it?

I started using it at The Annika, actually, and that week was my best putting week on tour to date. I feel very encouraged by it. Obviously, I still have to do some practice. I do believe that it’s helped me a lot, especially with my confidence. And the slow play thing — if you do it right, it doesn’t slow other people up. As long as you’re courteous, that’s the biggest thing.


Zhang changed her putting routine late last year, switching to the AimPoint strategy. (Julio Aguilar / Getty Images)

Speaking of slow play, the LPGA released a new slow play policy. Do you think the tour has a slow play problem?

It’s definitely been voiced by a lot of players. We take a lot of time waiting, especially on par 5s and par 3s. It slows up your day, and it slows things for those who are watching. At the end of the day, I think it’s up to players to create their routine to allow them not to be the slow player out there. There are players who struggle with that, which I understand. I’m just glad the LPGA has this regulation for everyone to follow. I’m not really a fast player, but I get paranoid about being slow. I grew up playing junior golf on the AJGA, and you get these red cards when you’re slow.

The LPGA is on the hunt for a new commissioner. What should their top priorities be?

There’s a difficult balance in the business aspect of golf and the actual competitive world of golf, so I understand how challenging it is. The biggest thing I’d wish for the new commissioner to do is at least provide communication or at least clear communication for what they intend on doing, and what you wish to relay to the players. You have to grow the LPGA through engagement, through deals, through sponsorships. This requires a lot of EQ and requires a lot of intelligence in that sense. I’d say with that, the new commissioner really needs to embody those basic things that could really elevate the LPGA. It’s not easy. They have to have the players’ best interests too, which is a fine line to tackle. That’s why I say communication is super key. If the players understand where the business mind comes from, they may want to critique things but they’d also be OK with things if they at least have a voice that can tell them what’s going on. That’s the biggest thing.

Do you think the LPGA does enough to promote its stars?

I don’t believe so. I speak for a lot of players who also believe that. The reason is, I think it takes characters to really showcase what the tour is about — to give people a story or something to engage with. The LPGA has been trying. I don’t think that it’s not happening. They’re in the process of creating more engagement for LPGA players to be exposed to the public. There are already characters on tour who are willing to fill those shoes. It’s honestly just the strategic side of things now. Exposing them to platforms, media and other people. A lot of players are already willing to do so. You need to have both ends of the stick. The player who is willing to put themselves out there, and a tour that is willing to push you out there. There are a lot of initiatives happening behind the scenes. I’m not discouraged by them not doing anything, it’s more so they just haven’t done much yet.

(Top photo: Cliff Hawkins / Getty Images)

The best Victor Wembanyama cards to collect: Rookie cards and where to find his autographs

There are some athletes who at a young age simply seem destined to achieve greatness, and Victor Wembanyama is one of them.

I haven’t seen the basketball card hobby this exited about a player’s rookie cards since LeBron James’ NBA debut in 2003. Collectors are buying up cards of the San Antonio Spurs’ center with hopes that he becomes the best big man of all-time. And so far, his sky-high potential has translated into strong production on the court, winning the 2023-24 NBA Rookie of the Year Award by unanimous decision. 

So what are the best options when it comes to collecting Victor Wembanyama trading cards? Here are our picks.

Top pick (full recommendations below)

2023 Panini Donruss Optic #225 Holo rookie card

 

Wembanyama’s 2023-24 Donruss Optic #225 Holo parallel rookie card is my best value recommendation based on scarcity in gem mint grades and price (currently about $300 in a PSA 10 grade). Optic’s connection to the historic Donruss brand and its iconic “Rated Rookie” logo that adorns the cards of first-year players makes it especially appealing to collectors. Holo parallel cards radiate a rainbow-like sparkle and are one of the most desired variations for basketball rookies because of their more limited supply compared to base cards.

Things to know before buying

The value of sports cards can fluctuate for various reasons such as condition, print runs, or graded population. Other factors that can cause prices to go up or down include player performance, market trends, and health of the wider economy. The secondary sales market for individual cards of a given sport generally hits its lowest point during the offseason (in other words, you can usually find better prices in the offseason than during the season). My recommendations are not an attempt to promote specific investment behavior or trading advice, but to guide and inform readers about popular and unique cards that are celebrated by the sports card community. 

While the demand for Wembanyama cards is currently very high — he was among the 10 most searched athletes on eBay every month in 2024 — so is the supply. Even though he is just in his second year in the NBA, Wembanyama already has the sixth highest total population of graded cards all-time among athletes across all sports, with more than Derek Jeter or Tom Brady, according to Gemrate, which tracks graded card populations.

Ultimately, the best cards to collect are always the ones you will personally enjoy most, regardless of whether they go up or down in value. The recommendations below should serve as a starting point for cards to consider, but a big part of the fun in collecting is the hunt for the cards you like.  

“Raw” cards vs. Graded cards

Cards can come out of the pack (their “raw” state) with a wide variety of imperfections that can impact their value. Card grading is a process in which an expert of the field determines the condition of a card based on a number of factors (including corner sharpness, image centering, print imperfections, and more) and assigns a numerical grade, usually on a scale of 1-10 (with the latter being close to perfect) and sealed in a protective case. There are a number of grading companies, each with their own unique grading scales, but PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator) is by far the largest and most prominent in the industry. Cards graded a “PSA 10” can carry a significant value multiplier compared to raw cards or those graded by other companies. 

It’s fine (and often cheaper) to buy cards raw, but if you want to ensure authenticity and/or a minimum condition level, and you’re not experienced at determining card condition for yourself, you may want to buy a graded card instead — particularly if you’re buying online and only able to see the card in photographs. 

Best low-end (~$1-$99) Victor Wembanyama cards

This is a category for collectors who are on a tighter budget or aren’t as concerned about the long-term monetary value of the cards they buy. 

2023 Panini Hoops #277 rookie card

 

The 7-foot-3 sensation’s 2023 Panini Hoops #277 card is a budget-friendly base rookie that’s modestly priced in PSA 10 graded copies. As I write this, raw examples are selling on eBay for as low as $5, and PSA 10s are fetching between $25 and $45.

Hoops is one of Panini’s low-end basketball releases printed on traditional paper card stock. (In many cases, the value, condition sensitivity, and desirability of a card can depend on the quality and thickness of the card stock.) Hoops cards were introduced to collectors in 1989 when the inaugural set included a rookie card of another Spurs center with huge expectations coming into the league, David “The Admiral” Robinson.

If you’re looking to add an inexpensive Wembanyama base rookie card to your collection, this is a great first choice and a practical alternative to his Donruss rookie.

More expensive variations and parallels: Blue, Hyper Blue, Impulse, Neon Green, Purple, Purple Winter, Red Backs, Teal Explosion, Winter, Yellow, Premium Box Set (/199), Silver (/199), Green (/99), Hyper Red (/99), Gravity (/75), Red (/75), Blue Explosion (/59), Artist Proof (/25), Hyper Green (/25), Orange Explosion (/25), Red Explosion (/15), Artist Proof Gold (/10), Hyper Gold (/10), Artist Proof Black (1/1)

2023 Panini Prizm #136 rookie card

Prizm is Panini’s flagship brand, so I had to include Wembanyama’s 2023 Prizm #136 base rookie card here. Prizm is printed on chromium card stock, which his thicker and has more of a metallic shine than paper stock cards. 

Despite Prizm’s popularity, this card lands in the low-end section of the price ranges because it has high print runs, particularly in recent years. PSA has graded over 40,000 copies of his Prizm #136 base rookie with nearly 25,000 receiving a PSA 10 grade. As a result of that high supply, collectors can purchase gem-mint graded examples for less than $100. 

However, Prizm offers an abundance of variations and parallels (see the long list below) that I’d recommend pursuing if you want a much more limited Wembanyama Prizm rookie card.

Prizm’s growing print runs combined with the brand’s mainstream appeal to both novice and experienced collectors alike makes it one of Wembanyama’s most transacted rookie cards.

More expensive serial numbered parallels of this card: Silver, Red Prizm (/299), Red Seismic Prizm (/299), Teal Ice Prizm (/225), Blue Prizm (/199), White Prizm (/175), Blue Fast Break Prizm (/150), Purple Ice Prizm (/149), Blue Sparkle Prizm (/144), Blue Ice Prizm (/125), Red Fast Break Prizm (/100), Blue Seismic Prizm (/99), Purple Prizm (/99), Choice Red Prizm (/88), Multi Wave Prizm (/88), Purple Fast Break Prizm (/75), Red Power Prizm (/75), Orange Wave Prizm (/60), Pink Fast Break Prizm (/42), White Wave Prizm (/38), Blue Shimmer Prizm (/35), Purple Pulsar Prizm (/35), White Ice Prizm (/35), Green Pulsar Prizm (/25), Mojo Prizm (/25), Gold Sparkle Prizm (/24), Bronze Fast Break Prizm (/20), Choice Cherry Blossom Prizm (/20), Gold Prizm (/10), Gold Shimmer Prizm (/10), Wave Gold Prizm (/10), Choice Green Prizm (/8), Green Sparkle Prizm (/8), Lucky Envelopes Prizm (/8), Black Gold Prizm (/5), Green Shimmer Prizm (/5), Neon Green Fast Break Prizm (/5), Black Prizm (1/1),  Black Shimmer Prizm (1/1) Choice Nebula Prizm (1/1)

Best value (~$100-$499) Victor Wembanyama cards

This is a category for collectors looking to pay a bit more for cards that have some degree of scarcity and have a better chance at retaining or increasing in value long-term. 

2023 Panini Donruss Optic #225 Holo rookie card

Panini’s Donruss Optic sets are the premium, chrome-ified versions of standard Donruss and its classic “Rated Rookie” cards, which were first introduced in 1984. 

For this particular recommendation, I wanted to move away from base cards and suggest one of the more memorable refractors that’s been a highlight of Optic since 2016: the “Holo” parallel. This parallel has a reflective prism-like effect when held up to the light and is a more limited card that runs parallel to the base set. 

Wembanyama’s 2023 Panini Optic #225 Holo rookie card has a unique rainbow-like shine and showcases his giant hands around the basketball as he attempts to make a pass. The exact number of Holo parallel cards printed per set is unknown, but it’s substantially less than base cards. Collectors can find six Holo parallels in every sealed hobby box and two per blaster box (on average).

According to PSA, there are less than 2,300 examples of Wembanyama’s Optic #225 Holo rookie card graded by the company and less than 1,100 have received a PSA 10 grade. (For comparison, there are around 6,300 PSA graded examples of the popular 2023 Prizm #150 Silver parallel and about 4,200 PSA 10s.)

The nostalgic aspects of Donruss’ Rated Rookie cards and the limited quantity of Wembanyama Optic Holo PSA 10 graded cards make this one my best value recommendation. Not to mention, It’s also priced lower than his Prizm #136 Silver parallel. Raw and PSA 10 copies of his Optic Holo #225 rookie card are fetching between $100 and $300 on eBay.

More expensive variations and parallels: White Sparkle, Red Velocity (/299), Aqua (/249), Blue Seismic (/249), Premium Box Set (/249), Orange (/199), Lime Green (/149), Red Seismic (/130), Copper Glitter (/99) Fast Break Purple (/99), Hyper Orange (/99), Red (/99), Red/Gold International (/99), Red Choice (/88), Pink Velocity (79), Green Glitter (/77), Fast Break Red (/75), Red Glitter (/75), Green International (/65), Blue (/49), Fast Break Blue (/49), Green Velocity (/49), Black Velocity (/39), Fast Break Pink (/25), Pink (/25), Blue Mojo Choice (/24), Purple Stars (/17), Blue Glitter (/15), Fast Break Gold (/10), Gold (/10), Gold International (/10), Black Gold Choice (/8), Lucky Envelopes (/8), Fast Break Red and Yellow (/7), Fast Break Neon Green (/5), Green (/5), Black (1/1, Fast Break Black (1/1), Gold Vinyl (1/1), Nebula Choice (1/1)

2023 Panini PhotoGenic #200 rookie card

I typically stick to cards from traditional releases that have built a large following, but sometimes sets that have debuted in recent years, like Panini’s PhotoGenic Basketball, can be worthy of consideration too. Launched in 2021 as an online-exclusive, these photography-centric cards use some of the finest and most distinctive images of the NBA’s top rookies, stars, and legends. 2023 PhotoGenic base rookies are short-printed and come with only three rookie cards per box, so the chances of pulling a Wembayama #200 out of a pack are not in your favor. As a result, the base rookie card has a low PSA graded population with less than 50 gem mint PSA 10 copies in existence (for the time being).

The card’s image of Wembayama denying Giannias Antetokounmpo’s dunk attempt truly represents his gifted shot-blocking ability. This is one of the best-looking rookie cards of his that Panini has to offer, in my opinion. It’s also worth noting that this is the first card I’ve mentioned showing the 21-year-old playing in an NBA game rather than images used from photoshoots. PSA 10 sales on eBay are in the $350-$450 ballpark.

Additional variations and parallels: Silver (/99), Diamond (/75), Wedges (/49), Maze (/25), Gold (/10), Fireworks (/5), Platinum (1/1)

Best high-end (~$500+) Victor Wembanyama cards

This is a category for collectors looking to acquire the most desired Wembanyama cards on the market. 

2023 Topps Chrome #CG-VW Autograph

Topps lost the exclusive license to produce NBA cards to Panini in 2010, but after a long hiatus, Topps Chrome Basketball made its return in 2024, reintroducing the product with Wembanyama rookie cards and autographs as the set’s main attraction. However, you won’t find a Topps Chrome Wembanyama rookie or autograph card with a Spurs logo. Yet.

Panini still has the exclusive NBA trading card license for a bit longer, meaning they are the only card manufacturer that can print official NBA team names and logos on their trading cards. Unlicensed cards, like those currently produced by Topps for basketball, generally generate lower collector interest, but Wemby’s Topps Chrome autograph is one of his most prized high-end cards since he’s only signing cards produced by Topps. Fanatics (which owns Topps) may not be able to produce NBA-licensed cards right now, but they do have exclusive trading card autograph and memorabilia deals with superstars like Wembanyama, and most recently Duke freshman phenom Cooper Flagg.

Raw examples of this card are selling on eBay for close to $1,000 and PSA 10’s are fetching between $2,000-$2,500.

Additional variations and parallels: Refractor, Purple Geometric Refractor, Gold Refractor (/50), Orange Geometric Refractor (/25) Black Wave Refractor (/10), Red Geometric Refractor (/5), Black Geometric Refractor (/2), SuperFractor (1/1)

2023 Panini Crown Royale #11 Kaboom!

Since Wembanyama has no Panini rookie autograph cards with a Spurs or NBA logo, hobbyists have been chasing his most visually captivating inserts with extremely low print runs (known as super short prints). Out of the popular insert cards produced of the Frenchman, Wembanyama’s Panini #11 Kaboom! from Crown Royale is one of his most valuable. In 2024, his Kaboom! Gold parallel 3/10 sold in near-mint condition (PSA 7 grade) for $40,260 at Goldin Auctions. Wembanyama was also featured on the 2023 Kaboom! checklist for Panini’s Crown Royale Euroleague Basketball release, but is pictured wearing his LDLC ASVEL Villeurbanne jersey from 2021.

Value put aside, Kaboom! cards have become some of the most sought-after inserts of the modern era thanks in part to their relative scarcity and flashy, comic-book style design.

Additional variations and parallels: Gold (/10), Green (1/1)

Other cool Victor Wembanyama Cards

2023 Sports Illustrated for Kids #1053

One of Wembanyama’s first cards before his time with the Spurs can be found in a Sports Illustrated for Kids magazine. The card’s image captures him soaring through the air for a dunk while playing for Metropolitans 92 in France’s LNB pro basketball league. 

The monthly magazine for young sports fans has produced cards in each issue since 1989 and has included early cards of legends across various sports, such as Tiger Woods, Serena Williams and Tony Hawk.

SI for Kids come with a sheet of nine perforated trading cards that can be individually removed by gently folding and tearing along the perforated lines. Since these cards have to be pulled apart, there’s a higher risk of the card being damaged. These cards often have image centering issues too — a key element considered by graders. These issues have resulted in a minuscule number of PSA-authenticated examples in high grades. Only eight copies have received a PSA 9 and none have earned a gem-mint 10 grade.  Out of the nearly 1,700 cards submitted to the company for authentication, PSA 6 was the most common grade received, with around 450 copies in existence.

Raw sales of Wembanyama’s SI for Kids card span from $30 to as high as $150 depending on the condition and how centered the borders are. Personally, I’d be interested in buying a complete copy of the magazine that the card was issued in so I could carefully remove it from the sheet myself. The 2023 January/February issue of S.I. for Kids including Wemby’s card can be found on eBay with sales in the $100 range, give or take.

2023 Topps Now Yankees Event Worn Jersey Relic #472B

In the summer of 2023, the Yankees invited Wembanyama to throw out the ceremonial first pitch before a game in New York, which happened to be two days before the NBA draft, where he became the No. 1 overall pick. Topps Now — a print-on-demand product used to quickly commemorate milestones and significant moments — produced MLB-licensed Wemby cards that featured a piece of the Yankees jersey he sported during the occasion. Cards including a piece of memorabilia or relics are common in the hobby, but this “event-worn” baseball jersey of an NBA player is an unusual sports card crossover.

2023-24 Panini Court Kings Acetate Rookies

Panini’s Court Kings sets have some of the best eye-appeal of any basketball cards, and the Acetate Rookies inserts are among the most unique. Acetate cards are made from a clear plastic instead of the usual paper-based stock, allowing designers to make parts of the card see-through. The Acetate Rookies inserts were only available outside the U.S., adding a further level of intrigue to them. Perhaps because they’re not as well known among American collectors, they tend to be pretty cheap despite how cool they look and how limited they are, so you can still get an ungraded copy for $50 or less.

Getting the best price

Prices for a certain trading card can vary wildly and fluctuate quickly, making it important to check recent sales of a given card to make sure you’re buying at a fair value. You can check recent sales of an item on eBay by selecting the “sold items” filter on search results. You can also run a search on 130point.com, which is a free site that provides sales data from a number of top online marketplaces. There are also several apps that provide more in-depth sales data, often charging subscription fees for full access. 

To account for outliers and scams, it’s important to consider multiple previous sales, not just the single most recent. It’s also important to note the recency of those sales and any real-world factors that could affect changes in value. 

Why you should trust us

As a second-generation collector, Tyler Holzhammer started collecting cards and attending the National Sports Collectors Convention at 10 years old. He’s evolved his passion as a collector into a career, previously providing sports card content and market analysis for companies like Sports Card Investor and Goldin Auctions. Tyler’s sports card collection is centered around players from his favorite teams, the Los Angeles Rams and the St. Louis Cardinals.

Our other recommendations

The Athletic maintains full editorial independence in all our coverage. When you click or make purchases through our links, we may earn a commission.

(Top photo: Darren Carroll/NBAE via Getty Images; card images: eBay)

The impact of being only player from your country to play in the Premier League

Gunnar Nielsen’s Premier League career was brief.

Extremely brief, in fact: it lasted 17 minutes. The goalkeeper was introduced as a late substitute for Manchester City against Arsenal in 2010 after Shay Given had aggravated a shoulder injury he picked up a week earlier when diving in vain for Paul Scholes’s late winner in the Manchester derby.

But it was a big deal back home. Those 17 minutes represented the first — and only — time a player from the Faroe Islands had played in the Premier League. It was such a big deal that a local radio station couldn’t even wait until the game had finished to call his brother for some reaction. Happily, Nielsen kept a clean sheet, avoiding the decidedly awkward prospect of his brother having to offer some live, on-air comment on an embarrassing blunder.

“He was so nervous he couldn’t say a word,” Nielsen says now. “He just gave the phone to my sister-in-law.”

Nielsen is part of an unusual little club of players, a group that was joined recently by new City signing Abdukodir Khusanov, the defender from Uzbekistan: they are two of 18 men to be the only players from their respective countries to make an appearance in the Premier League.


Neilsen made his only Premier League appearance in April 2010 (Neil Tingle – PA Images via Getty Images)

So as you can imagine, it was pretty big news in the Faroes when Nielsen made his appearance. TV and radio coverage was a given, but his almost literal 15 minutes of fame was the talk of the town. “I spoke to a bouncer at a nightclub who I knew,” Nielsen says. “He said the only thing everybody spoke about on that Saturday evening was how I made my appearance in the Premier League.

“It was such a big thing when it happened. I remember people were sending me pictures and texting me and calling me — to this day I meet people who still say they remember where they were at that exact time when I came on.”

Khusanov is the second player to join the club this season, after Ipswich Town striker Ali Al-Hamadi became the first Iraqi to grace the division when he came on in the opening game of the season against Liverpool.

For the sake of completeness, the others are: Victor Wanyama (Kenya), Henrikh Mkhitaryan (Armenia), Onel Hernandez (Cuba), Junior Firpo (Dominican Republic), Nathaniel Mendez-Laing (Guatemala), Danny Higginbotham (Gibraltar), Ryan Donk (Suriname), Ali Al-Habsi (Oman), Jordi Amat (Indonesia), Hamza Choudhury (Bangladesh), Dylan Kerr (Malta), Mbwana Samatta (Tanzania), Frederic Nimani (Central African Republic), Neil Etheridge (Philippines) and Zesh Rehman (Pakistan).

By definition, the nations on that list are not traditional football powerhouses. Some of the players had a slight leg-up, given that they were born and raised in bigger or more recognisable football environments, but played for another country due to a familial connection. Amat, Choudhury, Rehman, Etheridge, Hernandez, Firpo, Mendez-Laing, Higginbotham and Donk fall into that category.

But some of the others grew up in surroundings where there simply weren’t any role models to show them the path to one of Europe’s big leagues. They are trailblazers.

“You need to see someone that’s done it before,” Nielsen tells The Athletic. “We’re closely connected to Denmark, so you’re looking up to players from there, but (not having a Faroese example) did not make it easier. There hadn’t been anyone in the Premier League from the Faroe Islands, and even though there were some young players who had been on youth contracts at some Premier League clubs, there wasn’t anyone to look up to in that sense.”

Wanyama didn’t have a compatriot to show him the path to the Premier League either but he was lucky in that he, at least, did have some more immediate role models, such as his brother, McDonald Mariga, who joined Parma in Serie A when Wanyama was 16. Before that, Wanyama followed Mariga to Helsingborgs in Sweden, briefly returning home when the elder brother went to Italy, before properly starting his European journey with Beerschot, in Belgium. It also didn’t hurt that his father, Noah, played for and coached Nairobi-based side AFC Leopards.


Wanyama playing for Tottenham in 2019 (Shaun Botterill/Getty Images)

“I grew up in a football family,” Wanyama tells The Athletic. “I used to watch the Premier League — I grew up watching those games. When I was 11, I was already dreaming about being there one day. I loved Roy Keane and Paul Scholes.

“My father was a coach, my brother played: it was something very deep. It was in our blood. I wanted to play on the biggest stage. I was aware the Premier League was the toughest league in the world. I knew it would be tough to get into, which motivated me.”

Etheridge’s situation was slightly different. Born and raised in England, the goalkeeper qualified to play for the Philippines through his mother. He would travel to the Philippines fairly regularly growing up but, for various reasons, didn’t go back for years. Then, at 18, his former team-mates in the Chelsea youth team and Filipino internationals James and Phil Younghusband suggested him for a place in the squad too. He made his debut in 2008, has clocked up more than 80 caps and was named national team captain in 2022.


Neil Etheridge in action for Cardiff against Manchester City in 2019 (Oli Scarff / AFP)

“I just felt a connection with the country and the people,” Etheridge says from Thailand, where he is now playing. “The Philippines is an extremely proud country. The culture and blood runs through you. I was only 18, but I saw a chance to make a change in a country that is not necessarily football-orientated. Basketball is the No 1 sport. Back then, football wasn’t really a sport that was recognised.”

He’s not kidding. They had sunk to 195th in the world around the time Etheridge was first called up, and had little to no record in international competition. Their highest ranking in the intervening years of 111 might not seem great, but they qualified for the Asian Cup for the first time in 2019 and made it to the second round of qualifying for the 2014 World Cup, again the first time the team had gone that far.

Etheridge achieved most of this before playing in the Premier League for the first time, eventually doing so in 2017 after winning promotion with Cardiff. “It was a massive deal,” he says. “Although it wasn’t as big as if a Filipino played in the NBA, and Manny Pacquiao is the No 1 sportsperson in the country by a country mile. I was probably more recognised as the first South East Asian player to play in the Premier League, rather than the first Filipino.

“I’ve been able to do a lot of first. In 2010, we reached the semi-finals of the South East Asian Cup (AFF Cup) for the first time and that was when football blew up in the Philippines. Even now, 15 years later, it’s still in infant stages, but it’s something I’m proud to be a part of, to put football on the map in the country.”


National identity can be a slightly complicated, non-binary and sometimes fluid thing, so it’s worth offering some parameters: the players are defined as being ‘from’ their particular country either if they were born there and haven’t represented another country, or if they have represented that country at full international level.

There are some curiosities on the list. The Premier League has seen several players who were born in Suriname and went on to represent the Netherlands (Regi Blinker, Edgar Davids, Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink), but Donk, the only player to represent Suriname, was born in the Netherlands.

A few on the list weren’t classed as being from their respective nations while playing in the Premier League. Higginbotham played a few games for Gibraltar, but those were a long time after his Southampton/Sunderland/Stoke City pomp. Mendez-Laing’s debut for Guatemala came when he was in League One with Derby, a few years after his top-flight days with Cardiff.

Danny Higginbotham


Danny Higginbotham back in his playing days for Stoke City in 2010 (Mike Egerton/PA Images via Getty Images)

Then there are the grey areas, such as former Brighton & Hove Albion midfielder Mahmoud Dahoud, who is counted on some lists as Syria’s sole representative. He was born in Syria and raised in Germany, for whom he played two friendlies in 2020 so was thus regarded as German while in England. However, in 2024, he switched allegiance to the nation of his birth and was called up to Syria’s squad… only to pull out before actually playing. He may still represent them in the future, but we’re not counting him for now.

Then there’s Equatorial Guinea. Emilio Nsue, who was born and raised in Spain and made four appearances for Middlesbrough in the Premier League, played 45 times for Equatorial Guinea between 2013 and 2024 and won the Golden Boot at the 2023 Africa Cup of Nations. However, he might not count, as in 2024 FIFA ruled he had been ineligible the whole time.

Back in 2013, the Equatoguinean Football Federation applied to their Spanish counterparts for Nsue to switch nationalities (he had made several competitive appearances for various Spain youth teams), but to say the least there were some irregularities with the process. They defaulted two 2014 World Cup qualifying games due to Nsue’s ineligibility, but they kept picking him anyway, and did so at various intervals over the following decade. It genuinely seems that FIFA only noticed due to his heroics at AFCON, at which point they declared his whole international career null and void.

So…does he count? Are we getting into a weird, metaphysical area by acting as if Nsue’s international appearances literally never happened, rather than administratively never happened? If so Pedro Obiang, the only other Equatorial Guinea international, becomes the 19th individual on this list. But for now, we’ll go with tangible reality and credit Equatorial Guinea with two Premier League players.


Of course, the Premier League is not the pinnacle for everyone. It’s not necessarily the case that every player slept on Barclays bed sheets and their only desire as a kid was to play in England.

Take Wanyama, for example. “It was a bigger deal to play for Celtic,” he says, “because it was the team I grew up supporting. Particularly in the Glasgow derby.”

For most of these players, playing in the Premier League was a source of personal pride, but the hope is they can be the inspiration and role model that they didn’t have when they were younger.

“Without wanting to blow my own trumpet,” says Etheridge, “if it wasn’t for me and the success I’ve had, there would be a lot of football players who wouldn’t have had a career in the game. A lot of people wouldn’t even have known that the Philippines had a team, if it wasn’t for the likes of myself, and the success I had later in my career, playing in the Premier League, being able to really enhance our national team. There are a lot of people around the world who have decided to play for the Philippines because they now know what the Philippines national team is.”

Wanyama adds: “I’m proud if I have made young players dream, to believe in themselves that they could play in the Premier League one day. Now everyone wants to be there, and they know the door is open to them. They believe they can do it too.”

(Top photos: Getty Images)

Premier League ACL injuries: Examining the scale and causes of this season’s ‘epidemic’

Anterior cruciate ligament injuries.

They are four words that strike dread into the hearts of footballers at every level and, at the Premier League level, they are being heard more frequently than ever. In fact, this season is on course for a record number of ACLs since injury data began.

According to Ben Dinnery, head of injury analyst website Premier Injuries, there have been 10 ACL injuries in England’s top flight so far this season, putting the league on course for a record number in 2024-25.

This year alone, there have been seven ACL injuries, most recently Manchester United defender Lisandro Martinez.

For context, the average number across the six seasons between 2017-18 and 2022-23 is just 6.3; between 2012-13 (when Premier Injuries’ data collection began) and 2016-17, the average was 10.4. As it stands, the Premier League is on track to end the campaign with 13. There have been 20 recorded incidents to WSL players since January 2024, according to Premier Injuries.

This is a breakdown of Premier League players who have suffered an ACL injury this season:

Premier League players with ACL injuries this season

Player Club When sustained How sustained

Yerson Mosquera

Wolves

September

Club match

Rodri

Manchester City

September

Club match

Abdul Fatawu

Leicester City

November

International match

Enes Unal

Bournemouth

January

Training

Gabriel Jesus

Arsenal

January

Club match

Chadi Riad

Crystal Palace

January

Training

Orel Mangala

Everton

January

Club match

Wes Burns

Ipswich Town

January

Club match

Radu Dragusin

Tottenham

January

Club match

Lisandro Martinez

Manchester United

February

Club match

The table highlights that centre-back has been the position most frequently affected in terms of ACLs but there have also been a selection of midfielders and forwards to have suffered the injury. Wolves are the only club to have suffered more than one ACL injury.

For more detail on the comparative rise in ACL injuries in the Premier League, The Athletic spoke to Nick Worth, a consultant sports physiotherapist with experience working in the medical departments at various professional clubs, including West Brom and Fulham.

GO DEEPER

ACL injuries in women’s football: Why the high risk and can they be prevented?


What causes an ACL injury?

“ACL injuries typically happen when you have weight-bearing on a slightly bent knee, and there is a rotational element.

“Imagine a player’s studs get stuck in the ground as they twist. That may mean that their anterior cruciate ligament gets stretched to the point where it cannot hold, and that’s when it gives.”

Why are they so serious?

“Without an ACL, you would have what’s called functional instability. Without it, your tibia (or shin bone) slides forward on the femur, the upper part of your knee, and if you’re not stable, your knee can sometimes give way. That’s why it’s so important to ensure it’s stable and fixed.

“The repair requires a surgeon to move another bit of the body, either a piece of the hamstring tendon or a bit of the patella tendon (the middle section of the bit under your kneecap). That takes time to bed in, heal and strengthen, which is why recovery takes so long.”

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Why do so many play on after damaging an ACL? An expert explains

Are there particular periods in a season where ACLs are more prevalent?

“Probably not, because it can happen when someone lands awkwardly, or they twist. Quite a lot of the time it’s not due to a tackle. It’s often from someone turning or changing direction quickly, or they may go up for a header and land badly.

“The only thing is that, sometimes, when people are more tired, your muscular control of the knee is not so good. If you’re playing games on Tuesday and Saturday for several weeks, the chances of being slightly fatigued are higher, but they can happen at any time.”

Why might there be a spike in ACL injuries this season? Could the lack of a winter break be an issue?

“If you look at what’s happened over the past few years, with the number of games being played and the added time in matches now, and even looking at the extended European tournaments with more games, it increases the potential of being fatigued. But this has been going on for years.

“It’s really difficult to predict exactly why there are periods with lots of ACL injuries and those when they are few and far between. But if you land badly, it doesn’t matter how strong your legs are, an ACL can still go.”


Gabriel Jesus suffered his ACL injury in an innocuous challenge with Bruno Fernandes (Alex Pantling/Getty Images)

“Pitches sometimes make a difference, in terms of the way that boots interact with them. The kind of fibres within a pitch sometimes mean that a player’s boot may get stuck.

“They’re happening all the time; I think it’s just the level of players (in the Premier League) who seem to be getting them at the moment, which is probably heightening the interest.”

Does age play a part in susceptibility to ACL injuries?

“It’s not necessarily an issue but, again, the older you are and the more games you play, the chances are that you’re going to fatigue more. Certainly, at 30 years old and onwards, you’re probably more susceptible because you’re less mobile and possibly more fatigued.

“You’re not going to recover as quickly as someone who’s 25, for example. So I think that plays a small part, and it shouldn’t be ignored, but I don’t think it’s ‘just because you’re old means you’re going to be more likely to get an ACL’.

“The mechanism of the injury means you have to put your body in a slightly awkward position to actually get the ligament on the stretch. That’s going to cause damage to anyone.”


Rodri’s knee injury had a profound impact on Manchester City’s season (Michael Regan/Getty Images)

ACL injuries dipped in the Covid and post-Covid seasons. Could the break or perceived lack of intensity have helped cause that?

“I can certainly see that having the rest period would have helped. Having a mid-season break and more opportunity to rest between games is better for recovery.

“You’d have to look at more detailed data regarding the intensity to know whether the number or intensity of sprints differed in Covid games. I can understand there probably was a little bit of that: they possibly lacked a bit of intensity.

“I think the biggest thing that would have reduced it is having fewer games because the travelling would have been reduced. That would then mean that people can recover between Saturday and Saturday. Fewer midweek games and less fatigue are probably the biggest things.

“With the expanded Champions League and Europa League this season, people are travelling more, and players are playing more games, and that’s not helping overall.”

What can clubs do to reduce the chance of players suffering them?

“It’s about the recovery strategies and the prehabilitation. For example, doing exercises that involve the quads and the hamstrings to stabilise the knee.

“Hamstrings help replicate what an ACL will do in the knee, so it’s about ensuring they’re stable and put through different demands. You want the musculature to support the knee so it’s not just the ligament that’s going to be under stress if they land in a particular way.

“Balance exercises, flexibility and strength work are really important. Just being able to control certain movements like they would in a game. For example, hopping, jumping, turning, that type of thing.

“The type of repair makes a difference, whether it’s a bone-patella-bone or hamstring tendon. Different surgeons have different approaches: some wear braces, and some wear crutches. It varies quite a lot.

“The surgical management varies from place to place or team to team. Ultimately, it’s a long time out, but that’s because it takes a long time to recover. The longer, the better; you don’t always benefit by rushing players through. Taking a bit more time for them to recover and get strong is normally really helpful.”

(Top shot: Paul Ellis/AFP via Getty Images)

Remembering Wilt Chamberlain’s 1 year with the Globetrotters: A ‘childhood dream’

Sonny Hill recalls a time when he and his childhood friend, Wilt Chamberlain, would go to the movies to watch newsreels where the Harlem Globetrotters often appeared. Seeing players like Reece “Goose” Tatum and Marques Haynes, two of the franchise’s top showmen during that time, resonated with Chamberlain and sparked an ambition.

The Globetrotters’ mission of breaking down racial barriers and stereotypes grabbed Chamberlain’s attention. But the concept of entertainment was something that stuck with Chamberlain until he died on Oct. 12, 1999.

Chamberlain played 14 seasons in the NBA, but the one season before he became a face of the league, he was a face of the Globetrotters.

“Playing with the Globetrotters was Wilt’s childhood dream,” Hill, a Philadelphia Sports Hall of Famer and current sports radio personality, told The Athletic, “and he was able to fulfill it.”

Chamberlain did not have the lengthy tenure other Globetrotters had. He played the one full season, 1958-59, and sparingly during some NBA offseasons and post-retirement. But Chamberlain didn’t need much time to set a bar for the future of both the Globetrotters and the NBA, becoming a basketball and societal icon who bridged two entities.

“When Wilt and I grew up together, the Globetrotters were the team that we wanted to identify with,” Hill said. “So, upon seeing them, when he got older, he wanted to play for the Globetrotters.”

Chamberlain, in an interview on “MSG’s Vault,” said playing with the Globetrotters first rather than starting his career in the NBA was all about “the roots.”

“The days with the Harlem Globetrotters were some of the most pleasant ones of my life,” he said. “They were fun. They were a chance to see the world, learn and meet people. Also, let it be known that it was the Harlem Globetrotters that helped the NBA really get started. They are so powerful right now and at the apex of popularity, but back years gone by, they weren’t doing so well. Guys like the Globetrotters came in and helped to bring people to the stands to watch NBA teams.”


Remembered by many for his 100-point scoring outing against the New York Knicks in Hershey, Pa., in 1962, Chamberlain led the NBA in scoring for seven consecutive seasons and was the NBA rebounding leader for 11 of his 14 seasons. He also won two league championships and was a four-time league MVP.

Chamberlain is one of the game’s most dominant athletes of all time, but his stint with the Globetrotters was an opportunity to showcase his skills as an entertainer. He began his professional career with the Globetrotters in 1958 as part of a sold-out world tour in Moscow following his collegiate career at the University of Kansas. He spent three years in Lawrence, Kan., intertwining basketball with a coveted track and field career. In addition to averaging 29.6 points and 18.9 rebounds per game on the court, he also was a three-time Big Eight Conference champion in the high jump.

The Globetrotters gave Chamberlain a chance to become even more of a versatile individual once he left Kansas. The Globetrotters perform their famous Magic Circle as a warmup to the tune of “Sweet Georgia Brown” before every game. Chamberlain fit in well and honed his art of showmanship by participating in one of the Globetrotters’ most important routines as a rookie.

“When I say he was in that circle … you can’t be in that circle and not be able to (perform),” Hill said. “That’s how good he was. That’s how agile he was, how knowledgeable he was. That’s how quick he could learn what was going on.”

Hill also noted that the franchise assisted with Chamberlain the basketball player thinking outside of the box. A 7-foot-1, 275-pounder was expected to play center in those days. The Globetrotters, however, had other ideas.

“With the Globetrotters, he didn’t play inside,” Hill said. “He played mostly on the outside.”

Abe Saperstein, founder and owner of the Globetrotters, was known as a masterful promoter with a business-savvy mind built for sports entertainment. He saw the immediate potential that Chamberlain could bring to the team. Adding the dominant 7-footer was considered a financial risk to some, but Saperstein paid a substantial amount in the $50,000 range for Chamberlain to wear a Globetrotters uniform, according to Hill. The average median income of families in 1958 was $5,100.

“Abe Saperstein saw the opportunity for Wilt to be with the Globetrotters and for them to make even more money, because Wilt had been seen as this phenomenal basketball player since he was in high school,” Hill said.

The NBA didn’t integrate until 1950, when Earl Lloyd, Chuck Cooper and Nat “Sweetwater” Clifton made history. The league grappled with increasing its favorability. Chamberlain’s popularity coming out of college naturally sparked conversation for the Globetrotters. He was a hit on and off the court. In addition to being a must-watch player, he also had matured into a must-watch television sensation, making regular appearances on “The Ed Sullivan Show.”

“He would talk about how phenomenal he was as a basketball player (on the show),” Hill said. “He had developed to the point that people knew who he was, and he was somebody that people wanted to identify with.”

The Globetrotters already had won over millions of fans by popularizing the slam dunk, fast break and their legendary in-game weave, but the franchise’s fan base, now consisting of more than 148 million people in 123 countries and territories, saw an uptick then when the 7-footer wore the uniform. Chamberlain played alongside legends like Meadowlark Lemon and Charles “Tex” Harrison, and he helped pave the way for a few future legends, including Louis “Sweet Lou” Dunbar, Fred “Curly” Neal and Hubert “Geese” Ausbie.

Chamberlain’s one successful year with the Globetrotters turned the heads of NBA executives, making way for Eddie Gottlieb of the Philadelphia Warriors to draft him in 1959.

“When Wilt came into the league, Wilt actually built the NBA,” Hill said. “The foundation of the NBA was really built off Wilt. The ratings went up, the fan base went up, the coverage went up, the notoriety went up. Everything went up because people knew who Wilt Chamberlain was, and that gave the NBA an international person that people could identify with.”

But even after making his NBA debut, Chamberlain stayed true to his roots, playing for the Globetrotters in summers during their European tours. He was an unstoppable force in the NBA, but the daily grind was exhausting. Chamberlain playing with the Globetrotters during the offseason reminded him of how to enjoy a game that didn’t feel like work.

“Wilt set the precedent,” said Dunbar, the team’s director of player personnel and coach who played with the franchise 27 seasons and has been affiliated with the team in some capacity for 48 years. “Guys could have played anywhere in the world, but Wilt said those were the best years of his life, playing with the Harlem Globetrotters, because that becomes your family.

“He did go to the league and set all those records, but Wilt was a dominating factor (with the Globetrotters).”


Dunbar thought so highly of Chamberlain that he chose No. 13 as his jersey number in junior high school. He said he “thought Wilt could do no wrong” when he first started watching the game. As a 6-foot-9 big, Dunbar modeled his game after Chamberlain’s. It resulted in Dunbar having a decorated career at the University of Houston, where he became an All-American and later was inducted into the University of Houston Athletics Hall of Honor in 2008. Dunbar also was a fourth-round NBA Draft pick of the Philadelphia 76ers in 1975.

“I wasn’t as tall as Wilt, but growing up, I was the tallest kid around, so (Chamberlain’s game) etched my mind,” Dunbar said. “Wilt was strong. He was just a true athlete. I loved to see the man play.

“I watched him when he was in Philadelphia, and I watched him when he went to the Lakers. I watched him all the way until he quit playing the game.”

Dunbar still remembers the first time he met Chamberlain. The two, along with Harrison, met in Hawaii. Although a majority of Chamberlain’s time was spent catching up with Harrison, who was Chamberlain’s roommate with the Globetrotters, Dunbar was in awe of Chamberlain’s presence, calling it an “absolute honor” to meet the Hall of Famer.

“Tex used to talk about him all the time, about how (Chamberlain) could do everything,” Dunbar said.

Chamberlain’s basketball resume will lead with all of his NBA accomplishments, but stepping away from the league to work with the Globetrotters gave Chamberlain a certain freedom of expression. His No. 13 Globetrotters jersey was retired on March 9, 2000, at his high school in Philadelphia. The storied college career and multiple pro accolades, however, played just a small part of who Chamberlain was.

He really was about the fun nature of the game. And that fun was enhanced and supported by the Globetrotters.

Hill said the Globetrotters made Chamberlain feel comfortable, similar to that young boy who used to watch the Globetrotters on newsreels.

“Wilt’s feeling was that he was free. He could just be himself,” Hill said. “He could inclusive to what the Globetrotters were known for. The entertainment, the ballhandling, that all made him feel free.”

(Illustration: Kelsea Petersen / The Athletic; photos: TPLP / Getty Images)

NCAA committee recommends adding flag football as emerging sport for women

An NCAA committee recommended on Wednesday adding flag football to its emerging women’s sports program, a significant step toward it becoming an officially sponsored championship sport in all three divisions.

The NCAA said at least 65 schools are already sponsoring flag football at either the club or varsity level, with more moving in that direction. With a push from the NFL, flag football also has been added to the 2028 Los Angeles Olympic Games.

The NFL has vigorously promoted flag football for several years, including starting a global ambassador program in 2022. Domestically, the league and its teams have been pushing for flag football to be sanctioned as a varsity sport in high schools around the country.

Once in the NCAA’s emerging women’s sports program, flag football would need a minimum of 40 schools sponsoring it at the varsity level and meet minimums in games played and player participation to be considered for NCAA championship status.

The NCAA’s emerging women’s sports program was created to help facilitate more opportunities for women and give schools more opportunities to sponsor teams.

The last sport to move through the program was women’s wrestling, which was approved last month to become the NCAA’s 91st championship sport. The first women’s wrestling championship will be held in 2026.

Five other sports are currently in the program: acrobatics and tumbling, equestrian, rugby, stunt and triathlon. Five sports have previously emerged from the program to earn NCAA championship status: rowing (1996), ice hockey (2000), water polo (2000), bowling (2003) and beach volleyball (2015).

(Photo: Isaiah Vazquez / Getty Images)

Travis Kelce passes Jerry Rice for most career Super Bowl receptions in loss to Eagles

Despite missing out on another championship ring, Travis Kelce added another accolade to his resume Sunday when he surpassed Jerry Rice for most career Super Bowl receptions in the Kansas City Chiefs’ 40-22 loss to the Philadelphia Eagles.

Kelce, 35, logged four receptions for 39 yards to give him 35 total catches through five Super Bowl appearances, passing the Hall of Famer Rice’s mark of 33 receptions in four Super Bowls.

The Super Bowl record comes one year after Kelce surpassed Rice’s career postseason receptions record.

Kelce failed to tally a catch in the first half of Sunday’s lopsided game as the Chiefs quickly fell behind by three-plus scores. But the legendary tight end salvaged his stat line in the second half and broke Rice’s record after hauling in two late third-quarter catches and a 9-yard reception at the 7:54 mark of the fourth quarter.

Rice still holds a host of other Super Bowl records, including single-game receiving yards (215), career receiving touchdowns (eight) and career receiving yards (589).

With his 39-yard night Sunday, Kelce moved past Lynn Swann and Rob Gronkowski into second place on the career receiving yards list, now sitting at 389.

Required reading

(Photo: Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images)

From Super Bowls to Michael Jordan, Muhammad Ali to ‘last resort,’ the Superdome has seen it all

NEW ORLEANS — Spring 1982. Sixteen seconds left in the NCAA final, and a skinny freshman from North Carolina buries a jumper that delivers a championship and changes his life.

He showed up in New Orleans that week as Mike Jordan. He left as Michael.

By that point, the sprawling steel building that provided the stage for Jordan’s arrival into the national consciousness — the seven-year-old Louisiana Superdome — was used to gripping theater unfolding within its walls. In November 1980, as the seconds ticked away at the end of the eighth round of the world welterweight championship, boxer Roberto Durán, tired of chasing Sugar Ray Leonard around the ring, waved his glove at the referee and staggered to his corner. “No más, no más,” Durán muttered. It was the first time a world champ had voluntarily conceded the title in 16 years.

Two years prior, the same stadium witnessed the last of Muhammad Ali’s 56 professional wins, a unanimous decision over Leon Spinks that took back the WBA heavyweight title.

Pete Maravich ran the break here. Keith Smart’s jumper won Indiana the title here. Chris Webber called a timeout he didn’t have here.

In 1978, the venue hosted the first prime-time Super Bowl. Thirty-five years later the lights went out in another. Tom Brady won his first here; Brady’s idol, Joe Montana, won his last here.

In 1981 the Rolling Stones performed in front of 87,500 — then a record crowd for an indoor concert. The pope visited. Presidents, too.

But for native New Orleanians, nothing will match the night Steve Gleason’s blocked punt helped make a city feel whole again.

Not after the devastation wrought when Hurricane Katrina made landfall on Aug. 29, 2005. As levees broke and parishes flooded, the Superdome became “a refuge of last resort” for displaced citizens. Thousands crammed inside with nowhere else to turn. The plumbing failed. The air conditioning failed. Vicious winds peeled off parts of the roof. Urine pooled on the floor. Blood stained the walls. One man reportedly jumped to his death from a stadium balcony.

A city was left reeling, its citizens scarred, its iconic stadium battered.

Twelve months later the Superdome was restored, and with it, New Orleans. Doug Thornton, executive president of ASM Global, the company that runs the stadium, watched Saints fans file through the gates the night of the home opener with tears rolling down their cheeks. “They never thought they’d get to come back in,” he says now.

What followed was a moment so symbolic the team erected a statue to commemorate it.

After forcing the Atlanta Falcons into a three-and-out on the first possession of the game, Gleason laid out to block a punt attempt by Michael Koenen. Saints teammate Curtis DeLoatch recovered the ball as it rolled into the end zone for a New Orleans touchdown that kicked off a cathartic celebration. “I’ve never been in a stadium louder than that,” ESPN’s Mike Tirico later told NFL Films.


“Rebirth,” the statue commemorating Steve Gleason’s iconic 2006 punt block, was unveiled outside the Superdome in 2012. (Jonathan Bachman / Getty Images)

The Superdome’s eighth Super Bowl arrives Sunday; no other stadium has hosted more than six. It’s a testament to the rarest of American sporting venues, one that has stood the test of time despite a host of factors fighting against its longevity, including architectural advances and the worst Mother Nature has to offer. More than that, amid the era of multibillion-dollar, state-of-the-art stadiums, fewer and fewer NFL franchises call downtown home.

The Saints still do. And that’s how New Orleans prefers it.

Stadiums that have hosted the most Super Bowls

Stadium City Super Bowls

Caesars Superdome

New Orleans, La.

8

Hard Rock Stadium

Miami Gardens, Fla.

6

Orange Bowl

Miami, Fla.

5

Rose Bowl

Pasadena, Calif.

5

State Farm Stadium

Glendale, Ariz.

3

Tulane Stadium

New Orleans, La.

3

Raymond James Stadium

Tampa, Fla.

3

Qualcomm Stadium

San Diego, Calif.

3

“I’ve spent half my life in this building,” says Thornton, whose office for the last 28 years has been inside the since-renamed Caesars Superdome. “We’ve always joked that New Orleans viewed the Superdome as its living room. It’s where we watch our kids graduate high school. It’s where we come together for Saints games. For monster truck rallies. For all these major events we host every year like the Sugar Bowl.

“People just revere this place.”

Macie Washington tends bar at Walk-Ons a few blocks from the stadium. New Orleans without the Superdome? The thought lingers in her mind for a few moments. She grows quiet. She’s never considered it.

“Everything that happens in the dome, we feel it here,” she says. “It’s the heart of our city.”

Consider similar venues erected in the same era, during what was then a new wave of American ingenuity: Houston’s Astrodome (opened in 1965, closed in 2008), Detroit’s Pontiac Silverdome (opened 1975, closed in 2013); Seattle’s Kingdome (opened 1976, closed in 2000); Minneapolis’ Metrodome (opened 1982, closed in 2013), Indianapolis’ RCA Dome (opened 1984, closed in 2008). All but the Astrodome have been razed.

The Superdome still stands, and thanks in part to a recent $557 million facelift that was spread across four NFL seasons, will have a different look for Super Bowl LIX. More than $100 million of that came directly from Saints owner Gayle Benson, according to Jay Cicero, president and CEO of the Greater New Orleans Sports Foundation. “If that’s not proof they wanna stay put, I don’t know what is.”

Cicero doesn’t mean stay put in New Orleans. He means stay put in the Superdome.

“To continue to plan and fund renovations in the stadium rather than tear it down and build a new one from scratch?” Cicero continues. “That just speaks to how important it is to New Orleanians.”

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Roger Goodell lauds Saints’ transparency on connection to archdiocese

Thornton says the original price tag for the building, way back in 1967, was around $42 million. But by its long-delayed 1975 unveiling, the cost had jumped to $160 million. It was a means to an end. The city wanted an NFL franchise. Legend has it longtime league commissioner Pete Rozelle told New Orleans businessman Dave Dixon — who spearheaded the push — that his city could have a team so long as it met one critical condition.

“You better build a stadium with a roof because of all the thunderstorms,” Rozelle said.

Dixon obliged. Louisiana erected the biggest domed stadium in the country. The building covers 13 square acres. At its apex, the roof is 273 feet from the floor. “Two million square feet under the roof,” Thornton marvels. “When it opened it was twice the size of the Astrodome.”

It is also the NFL’s fifth-oldest active stadium and will climb to fourth after the Bills vacate Highmark Stadium in the coming years (and third if the Bears ever leave Soldier Field). The recent renovations, spurred by Benson and the Saints organization, have modernized the facility and opened up the concourses for easier movement.

“It looks more like a nightclub now versus a coliseum,” adds Sam Joffray, who spent 25 years with the Greater New Orleans Sports Foundation and actually designed the stadium’s first website back in the mid-1990s. “It’s a pretty amazing example of what can happen if you keep reinvesting in a venue instead of tearing it down.”

NFL’s oldest stadiums

Franchise Stadium Year opened

1

Soldier Field

1924

2

Lambeau Field

1957

3

Arrowhead Stadium

1972

4

Highmark Stadium

1973

5

Caesars Superdome

1975

6

Hard Rock Stadium

1987

7

EverBank Stadium

1995

8

Bank of America Stadium

1996

9

Northwest Stadium

1997

10

M&T Bank Stadium

1998

One message is plastered throughout the city this week, from the beads volunteers are handing out at the airport to signage lining the Ernest N. Morial Convention Center: This is what we do. New Orleans prides itself in its ability to host major events, and at the center of that is the colossal stadium — a short walk from just about anywhere downtown — that transformed the city’s potential from the minute it opened.

“The Superdome put New Orleans on the map,” Thornton says. “Before it was constructed, our major industries were oil and gas and shipping. Now, our major industries are tourism, oil and gas and shipping.

“I always joke,” he continues, “that as soon as someone shows up for the Super Bowl here, they’re handed a hurricane from Pat O’Brien’s at the airport and they head to the French Quarter and they never leave.”

Like Lambeau Field in Green Bay, Fenway Park in Boston, Wrigley Field in Chicago and Madison Square Garden in New York, the Superdome has forged a uniquely intimate relationship with a city and its residents. “We’re not the biggest market in the world. Actually we’re pretty small compared to most NFL cities,” Cicero says. “But we can compete for these major events and host these major events, and it starts with a truly amazing, amazing venue. The Superdome is just part of the fabric of New Orleans.”

It’s why the Saints have no interest in finding a new home.

It’s why the Super Bowl keeps finding its way back to New Orleans.

“This community has such a way of putting its stamp on it,” NFL commissioner Roger Goodell said earlier this week when asked why The Big Easy remains such a consistent player in the league’s Super Bowl rotation. “I think the people here wrap their arms around it and make it better. I think we’ve realized that this is a place that is sort of perfect for the Super Bowl.”

(Illustration: Dan Goldfarb / The Athletic; photos: Aaron M. Sprecher, Manny Millan, Bob Rosato, James Drake / Sports Illustrated via Getty Images)

Super Bowl LIX media preview: Tom Brady, record audience, Terry Bradshaw’s future and more

Richard Deitsch and Andrew Marchand are sports media writers for The Athletic. They converse every couple of weeks on sports media topics. This week, they discuss the Super Bowl from a media perspective, including:

  • Tom Brady’s Super Bowl broadcaster debut
  • Viewership potential for the game
  • The future of Super Bowl pregame shows
  • Netflix becoming an NFL player

Richard Deitsch: I’m seeing Tom Brady in my sleep given how much this site has written about him over the past five months. But here’s the reality: We both agreed prior to the start of the NFL season that Brady’s debut as a Fox NFL analyst was the biggest sports media story of the NFL season.

My thesis has always been that Brady’s broadcasting year would ultimately be judged by the viewing public on how he performs in the Super Bowl. That’s the final test, but it’s more than a test: It is the football public’s ultimate engagement with Brady in his first year on TV.

We both know that his Fox Sports bosses and sports television executives look at it differently. They will judge him on progress from Week 1 to Week 21. Fox believes he has improved significantly throughout the season.

However, there will be 115 million-plus people watching Brady on Sunday. That is an enormous jury. How do you see this?

Andrew Marchand: I agree, but there are several different audiences for the Super Bowl:

There are the hardcore fans there every week that produce the 15 (million) to 35 million or so viewers for games each week. The more casual fans that begin watching in the playoffs push the numbers into the 40 (million) and 50 million range. Then comes Super Bowl viewers.

The deciders are that first group, as they care much more about the broadcast. The other two groups may have some opinions, but ultimately will likely just be impressed that Brady is on the call.

If he does amazing or has an awful performance, then all three sets will chime in. He is way better than Week 1, but he’s not John Madden just yet.

If he has a “16-for-24, two touchdowns and one interception” performance, I think Fox would take it. They would love “400 yards and five touchdowns,” but I don’t think they will be greedy.


AM: How many eyes do you think will be watching this game?

RD: The current viewership record came last year when an audience of 123.4 million viewers watched the Kansas City Chiefs beat the San Francisco 49ers in overtime. That topped the previous record of 115.1 million viewers for the Kansas City-Philadelphia Eagles matchup two years ago.

Look, there is no Chiefs fatigue; the data does not lie. The AFC Championship Game averaged 57.7 million viewers, the most-watched AFC title game in history. If this game is tight late — and I think it will be — I think we see a new record. Put me down for 124 million. You?

AM: This is a bad omen for Fox — we agree! I’m going 124.5 million viewers and a record.

You are on point on the fact that Chiefs fatigue is overrated. Viewers like the big-name teams, and Kansas City is going for history (three Super Bowl championships in a row) with maybe the greatest quarterback ever.

There may be some hate watching, but the people who have such strong feelings are watching no matter what. The records come at the edges, and I think Fox and the NFL pick that up.


AM: How about the pregame show? You into it? Or a big waste of time?

It could be the last Super Bowl pregame show for Jimmy Johnson and Terry Bradshaw. After two of the last three Super Bowls because of the new TV contracts with the NFL, Fox won’t have the big game for four years as it is NBC (2026), ABC/ESPN (2027), CBS (2028) and then Fox in 2029.

RD: So here is the interesting thing with NFL pregame shows: They continue to draw more viewers than you might think.

For instance, “Fox NFL Sunday” averaged 4.42 million viewers this season. You can make a lot of advertising money off those numbers. I mean, if “First Take” averaged 600,000 viewers over a year they would hold a Rose Bowl parade in Bristol, Conn.

I find the pregame shows increasingly less relevant these days with younger viewers. We also don’t often see them pop on social media, the coin of the realm for young people.

Fox Sports clearly will be bringing in younger staffers soon, but the NFL pregame show often feels like a relic of a different time. I’ll watch because we get paid to watch, but I find it less interesting every year.


RD: One of the things I get asked about from a lot of readers is whether a Super Bowl will ever go behind a paywall where a Netflix buys it.

I don’t think this happens in our lifetime. Now, if you asked me whether I can see a Netflix or Amazon have the divisional playoffs in the next 20 years, I absolutely see it. What about you?

AM: I’m more bullish on this lifetime, but I’d like to know how long that means. Amazon and Netflix are thinking big, global.

The NFL can have Roger Goodell do songs and dances about the fans this and the fans that, but if the digital players offer way more money, I could see Amazon or Netflix having a Super Bowl maybe when the NFL opts out of its current TV deals. I don’t think that is a wild thought in four or five years when those opt-outs happen.

If broadcast TV gets significantly weakened over time, I think the idea of a subscription-based Super Bowl becomes more likely. It really depends on where The Great Rebundling takes place and how strong the networks can continue to be. But in a TV-by-subscription world, it’s hard not to bet on Netflix’s and Amazon’s long-term models for big events if they want more.

(Illustration: Demetrius Robinson / The Athletic; Sam Hodde/Getty Images, Mikayla Schlosser/Kansas City Chiefs via AP, Kara Durrette via AP)

One last MLB free agent for every team: Finding new homes for 30 available players

Spring training is around the corner, and the free agent market has been stripped of its universal impact. What’s left — with very few exceptions — are players who would barely move the needle on one roster but fill a specific need on another. So, let’s find those guys some uniforms and get on with it. Here’s one remaining free agent for every major league team. 


Arizona Diamondbacks

Kenley Jansen, RHP

A few days ago, we might have paired the D-Backs with a right-handed bat, but they just filled that need by re-signing Randal Grichuk. So, what’s left is to solidify the back end of their bullpen. Putting Jansen in the ninth would leave Justin Martinez to serve as a high-octane setup man. And playing for a good team would give Jansen a chance to get the 31 saves he needs to tie Lee Smith for the third-most saves in history. 

Athletics

Nick Pivetta, RHP

The A’s have already signed one free agent attached to the qualifying offer. So, what’s one more? Add Pivetta to Luis Severino and Jeffrey Springs, and the A’s would have a completely new top of the rotation while leaving room for young arms JP Sears, Joey Estes and Mitch Spence to round out the group. With a young and exciting lineup, and a couple of legitimate late-inning relievers — Mason Miller and Jose Leclerc — another proven starter could really raise the floor in Sacramento. 

Atlanta Braves

Kyle Gibson, RHP 

Stability. That’s all we’re looking for here. The Braves have done very little this offseason — Jurickson Profar and not much else — and are counting on the return of Spencer Strider and Ronald Acuña Jr. to meaningfully raise their ceiling. Fair enough. Strider, Chris Sale and Reynaldo Lopez are the impact starters at the top of the rotation, but another veteran starter would help solidify the group and protect against further injury.  

Baltimore Orioles

John Means, RHP

The Orioles just filled their last glaring need by signing Ramon Laureano to provide some right-handed balance in the outfield. The market doesn’t offer meaningful upgrades to their rotation, and their bullpen is more or less full, but a reunion with Means — who underwent Tommy John surgery last summer — would bring back a former All-Star and begin building depth for next season. 

Boston Red Sox

David Robertson, RHP


Entering his 17th season, David Robertson just keeps delivering strong performances. (Kiyoshi Mio / Imagn Images)

Massive impact would come from signing Alex Bregman, but short of that, the Red Sox could use another dependable arm in their bullpen, and Robertson, who pitched like his old self as a 39-year-old last season. He would give the team another experienced reliever who could even be an option in an uncertain ninth inning. 

Chicago Cubs

Jalen Beeks, LHP

Recent trades for Ryan Pressly and Ryan Brasier have given the Cubs some much-needed help in the late innings, and a late deal with Beeks would give them another experienced reliever who’s been everything from a long man to a closer. Beeks would also give the Cubs some left-handed balance in their pen. Caleb Thielbar is their only lefty at the moment. 

Chicago White Sox

Brendan Rodgers, 2B

Throw a dart at a list of free agents, and you’ll probably hit a name that could help the White Sox. They could really use a veteran pitcher, but how many veterans really want to be a part of such a rebuild? For Rodgers, though, the White Sox could provide an opportunity to play every day and build back some value after a couple of down seasons in Colorado. 

Cincinnati Reds

Phil Maton, RHP

The Reds have plenty of role players and a full five-man rotation (though an additional starter wouldn’t be the worst thing in the world). What they don’t have is a single reliever who FanGraphs projects to have an ERA below 4.15. It’s not necessarily a bad bullpen, but it lacks a standout aside from Alexis Díaz (who’s not even the best reliever in his own family). So, let’s add another solid arm into the mix and let Terry Francona sort it out in spring training. 

Cleveland Guardians

Kiké Hernández, CF/2B 

Defensively, center field is the Guardians’ most glaring need. In terms of experience, they’re thinnest at second base. And their everyday lineup includes only one strictly right-handed hitter. Well, Hernández would address all of that. He would be their best defensive option in center, their most experienced option at second, and another right-handed bat on a roster loaded with lefties and switch hitters. Maybe Lane Thomas would still play center field against righties, but Hernández could play there against lefties and in the late innings. Maybe Juan Brito is ready to play second, but Hernández would free him to also help out at other positions.

Colorado Rockies

James McCann, C

You might think it would make sense to give the Rockies a veteran starter. But their starting pitchers already are veterans! Or maybe give them an experienced reliever. But who would want that job? So, let’s give the Rockies the most boring addition possible: a new backup catcher. Playing McCann behind Jacob Stallings would free Hunter Goodman to continue playing all over the field (first base, catcher, outfield corners) to see if his immense power will play at the big league level (he had a .228 on-base percentage but slugged .417 in a half season last year).

Detroit Tigers

Justin Turner, 1B

You know what would be really fun? Putting Alex Bregman in Detroit. But in this market, Turner is the next best thing. The Tigers definitely need another right-handed hitter — Gleyber Torres and Matt Vierling are their only everyday righties — and Turner could play first base and DH while letting manager A.J. Hinch mix and match with lefty hitters Kerry Carpenter, Colt Keith and Jace Jung. Turner would also give the Tigers a massive clubhouse presence as they try to build on last season’s breakout.

Houston Astros

Alex Verdugo, LF

We sent Bregman elsewhere, which means this version of the major league multi-verse won’t have the Astros filling their left field void by shifting Jose Altuve from second base. So, let’s give them a real left fielder. Bonus points for the fact Verdugo hits left-handed (the Astros’ only everyday lefty is Yordan Alvarez). FanGraphs is still projecting Verdugo to have a 1.1 WAR season, which is better than Ben Gamel and Taylor Trammell — the two left-handed outfielders currently jockeying for Astros’ playing time — have produced in the past four seasons combined. Verdugo hasn’t been especially good in a few years, but he’s the best of what’s left.

Kansas City Royals

Brandon Drury, 3B/2B


Brandon Drury had an ugly season, but before that he was a standout contributor for three years. (Stephen Brashear / USA Today)

According to FanGraphs WAR, there was not a player in baseball less valuable than Drury last season. He was a full 2.1 wins below replacement. So why would the Royals want him? Because they actually have enough infielders — if this signing goes belly up, they’re covered at second and third — but Drury had a 118 OPS+ from 2021 to 2023, and he generated that offense while playing first, second, third, left and right. Basically, Drury would be a chance for the Royals to maybe find some cheap offense. Their projected Opening Day roster on FanGraphs includes seven hitters projected to have a sub-100 wRC+. That includes their entire bench and their starting third baseman, Maikel Garcia, who’s a great defender but had a 69 wRC+ last season. If Drury can bounce back to be just league average at the plate, he could help the Royals at multiple positions.

Los Angeles Angels

Craig Kimbrel, RHP 

The Angels are in wing-and-a-prayer territory, anyway. They need a ton of things to go right, and those things range from Mike Trout’s health to Kyle Hendricks’ sinker. Scott Kingery and Jo Adell are involved. Yoán Moncada just joined them. There’s a Rule 5 pick in there, too. It’s a lot. So, why not add one more wild card? Kimbrel was an All-Star in 2023 and he saved 23 games last season, but he also pitched so poorly that the Orioles released him in September. How many teams are in a position to give Kimbrel even a chance to close again? The Angels are! If Kimbrel stinks and Ben Joyce wins the job, so be it, but the Angels bullpen is crawling with 20-somethings, and adding a veteran to the mix wouldn’t be the worst idea.

Los Angeles Dodgers

Clayton Kershaw, LHP

What do you get the team that has everything? How about a Hall of Famer? And, in this case, it’s a Hall of Famer who is almost certainly going to re-sign with them eventually, anyway. Kershaw to the Dodgers is basically the free square in free agency bingo, but we’ll gladly take the gimme.

Miami Marlins

Cal Quantrill, RHP

The Marlins would be a reasonable landing spot for all sorts of free agency leftovers. Michael A. Taylor would give them a legitimate defender in center. South Florida native Anthony Rizzo would be a veteran presence and a left-handed option at first base. Pretty much any free-agent reliever would become the most experienced guy in their bullpen. But Quantrill feels like an upside play for their rotation. He’s only two years removed from a couple of encouraging seasons in Cleveland. Best-case scenario: Quantrill rounds out the Marlins rotation in April before becoming a trade chip in July. 

Milwaukee Brewers

Paul DeJong, SS

This is the only remotely viable shortstop left on the free agent market (the next-best was Nick Ahmed, but he just signed a minor league deal with the Rangers). Signing DeJong would let the Brewers keep Brice Turang and Joey Ortiz at second and third, where they’re excellent defenders. DeJong would also give the Brewers another right-handed bat (their regular lineup already has four lefties).

Minnesota Twins

Luis Urías, 3B/SS

The Twins want to add infield depth, especially shortstop depth, and this just isn’t the free-agent market for teams that need a shortstop. There’s really only one free-agent shortstop left, and this hypothetical exercise has him landing in Milwaukee. The fact Urías, who hasn’t played a big league game at short, is even on the radar for such a role speaks to just how few options are out there (Ahmed recently signed a minor league deal with the Rangers). For teams in the market for a viable shortstop, it’s pretty much DeJong-or-bust.

New York Mets

Brooks Raley, LHP

Our first draft suggested the Mets re-sign Pete Alonso. Then they actually did! So, we went back to the drawing board and found a Mets roster that has basically everything covered. The Mets have seven experienced starting pitchers, at least six guys who could get time at second base, and a pretty solid bullpen. So, we’ll suggest bringing back Raley, who pitched well for the Mets the past two seasons before Tommy John surgery last summer. He won’t be available until the second half, at which point the Mets might be happy to have the extra lefty.

New York Yankees

Colin Poche, LHP 

The Yankees have done most of their heavy lifting, and short of Bregman, there’s no free-agent infielder who meaningfully improves them at second base or third. But they could use a second left-handed reliever to pair with Tim Hill, and Poche is a proven commodity in the AL East. 

Philadelphia Phillies

Héctor Neris, RHP

With every team, there’s a desire to come up with an interesting addition that fits one specific need, but the Phillies basically addressed the most glaring needs in December when they traded for Jésus Luzardo, signed Max Kepler and signed Jordan Romano. The free-agent market really doesn’t offer any other ideal fits. Neris at least would give them one more veteran arm, and a familiar arm at that. He would fit about as well as anyone. Basically, just give the Phillies one of the last relievers standing, hope all their big bats stay healthy, and call up Andrew Painter in June. 

Pittsburgh Pirates

Lance Lynn, RHP

At 37, Lynn has considered transitioning to a bullpen role, and that’s where he might best fit the Pirates. The team could go the usual route and sign one of the remaining free-agent relievers — Andrew Chafin? Dylan Floro? Scott Barlow? — but Lynn feels like an upside play. If he thrives in a one-inning role, Lynn would give the Pirates a veteran arm to pair with David Bednar. And, frankly, with Johan Oviedo returning to the rotation from Tommy John surgery, Lynn could end up being a welcome fallback option should the Pirates need a starter instead. 

San Francisco Giants

Mark Canha, DH/RF

This is probably out of the Giants’ price range, but the team did trade for Canha at last year’s deadline, and he delivered a .376 on-base percentage in the final two months. Canha doesn’t have the power typical of a DH, but his on-base skills are valuable, and the Giants don’t really have a better option at DH. Canha can also play first base and right field, two spots where the Giants have left-handed hitters and could use the right-handed option. Alternatively, the Giants could add a depth starter or bring in another relief pitcher, but it’s hard to imagine them doing anything to wow you at this point. 

San Diego Padres

Jose Quintana, LHP

The first thought was to add J.D. Martinez or Rizzo to an already aging lineup and see what happens (the Padres don’t really have a DH as long as Luis Arraez is playing first base). Maybe the Padres could do that, but if they’re going to keep exploring trades for either Dylan Cease or Michael King, they’re going to need someone else to fill the innings. Frankly, the Padres could probably use the pitching depth anyway, and Quintana, 36, is coming off another solid season. 

Seattle Mariners

Jose Iglesias, 2B

The Mariners are all about being reliably decent, so here’s a veteran second baseman who tends to hit OK while playing solid defense. He would add stability to a questionable Mariners infield and improve the bench by freeing Dylan Moore to serve as a super-utility man. Otherwise, maybe David Peralta as a left-handed bat off the bench? 

St. Louis Cardinals

Jose Urquidy, RHP

The Cardinals seem content to just kind of exist this offseason. Maybe they’ll trade Nolan Arenado and open the door to another right-handed bat or add a guy like Andrew Heaney for a bit of rotation depth, but if the Cardinals are going to keep their focus on the future, we’ll do the same and take a look at a two-year deal with a guy recovering from Tommy John surgery. Urquidy probably won’t help much this season, but he could give the Cardinals a leg up in their search for 2026 rotation depth (Steven Matz, Miles Mikolas and Erick Fedde are free agents after this season).

Tampa Bay Rays

Kevin Pillar, CF 

The Rays could use another right-handed bat and a backup in center field. Pillar, 36, had an .852 OPS against lefties last season, and while he’s no longer among the elite center fielders in baseball, both Defensive Runs Saved and Outs Above Average had him as a positive defender in center last season. He would provide a veteran presence alongside starting center fielder Jonny DeLuca. 

Texas Rangers

Kendall Graveman, RHP

The Rangers seem to be collecting relievers who aren’t quite closers but are certainly comfortable pitching the late innings. Chris Martin, Robert Garcia, Jesse Chavez, Hoby Milner, Jacob Webb and Shawn Armstrong have all been added to the bullpen this offseason, so we’ll add one more to the mix. Graveman was a pretty good late-innings arm before shoulder surgery cost him all of 2024. He seems like a worthwhile addition to this hodgepodge bullpen the Rangers are putting together.  

Toronto Blue Jays

Alex Bregman, 3B

This is the splash the Blue Jays have been trying to make for a couple of years. Bregman is a better fit — both short-term and long-term — than Alonso would have been, and he would give the Blue Jays one of the best infields in all of baseball alongside Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Bo Bichette and Andrés Giménez. Bregman is basically the biggest move any team could make, and the Blue Jays are as motivated as anyone to make it. 

Washington Nationals

Kyle Finnegan, RHP

The Nationals are in a tough spot in a loaded NL East, but they went out of their way to add a couple of meaningful bats (Josh Bell, Nathaniel Lowe), they took an interesting gamble on Mike Soroka, and they have a couple of young outfielders just waiting to establish themselves as big league stars. Why do all that and leave the ninth inning unprotected? Finnegan has his shortcomings, but the Nationals never really replaced him this offseason, and at this point, bringing him back would be their best way to improve the bullpen.

(Top photo of Jansen: Billie Weiss / Boston Red Sox / Getty Images)

F1 teenager Kimi Antonelli just got his driver’s license — right on time to replace Lewis Hamilton

Andrea Kimi Antonelli was more nervous than he had been for some time. A racing driver’s career can often hinge on sliding doors moments such as these.

The 18-year-old wasn’t trying to secure a Formula One drive. He completed that mission months ago when he signed with Mercedes to replace Lewis Hamilton.

He was about to sit his driving test.

Thirty minutes later, the Italian teenager beamed beneath his mop of curly hair and raised a thumb to the camera. He’d passed — first time, of course. There would be no need to squeeze in another test between the hectic travel demands of the F1 calendar. And the ‘honor’ of being an active F1 driver without a road license — once true of Max Verstappen, who debuted at age 17 — will not apply to Antonelli.

It was an early dose of pressure handled well by the driver who will debut for Mercedes at the Australian Grand Prix on March 16, stepping into the cockpit vacated by Hamilton, a seven-time world champion 21 years Antonelli’s senior.

Antonelli knows he cannot expect to emulate Hamilton’s 12-year run at Mercedes, which yielded six world championships and 84 race wins to become the most successful driver-team partnership in F1 history. But he is taking in all the support he can ahead of his debut season.

“I’m the next Mercedes driver and I’m taking the seat of someone who made history in the sport, so it’s a big privilege,” Antonelli told The Athletic in an interview. “It’s a big responsibility, but I’ve got the right people around me.”


Cars have always been a central part of Antonelli’s life.

His father, Marco, watched how young Kimi played with toy cars and decided to take him go-karting at five.

Kimi instantly fell in love with the sensation of speed. (Antonelli goes by his middle name, which has no connection to the 2007 world champion Kimi Raikkonen.) Yet Marco, who still races in sportscars with his own GT team, Antonelli Motorsport, which competes across Europe, was initially wary of pursuing it too seriously. He didn’t want Kimi to get hurt in what can be a ruthless world.

“Sometimes motorsport can be cruel,” Antonelli said. “He was afraid that I would have been too hurt from disappointment, so he wanted to avoid that. But seeing that I really loved driving and really loved the sport, he decided to give it a go. He could see, without me really telling him, that I had the passion for motorsport.”

That love was furthered by father-and-son Sundays spent watching F1 races together. While Antonelli would have grown up watching Hamilton, Sebastian Vettel and Fernando Alonso, his racing heroes are from much further back. His dad showed him the famous race between Gilles Villeneuve and Rene Arnoux at Dijon in 1979, regarded by many as the greatest on-track battle of all time, which gave him an appreciation of the sport’s history from a young age.

“It was just amazing,” Antonelli said. “You see how different it was, compared to now, the safety, the cars. You also appreciate the way the drivers were still battling on track despite knowing that the cars were not as safe as today. They were still going for it and you really appreciate seeing those battles.”

Villeneuve and Ayrton Senna emerged as Antonelli’s favorite drivers, in part thanks to their tenacious style on the track. “Ayrton is my hero, but Villeneuve, now I understand why my dad was such a big fan of him,” Antonelli said. “He was a lion on the track.”

After first using 12 as his racing number in Formula Four, Antonelli chose it for his F1 debut season as a nod to Senna, who raced with 12 through the first four years of his career, including his first championship season in 1988. By coincidence, Villeneuve also raced with 12 in 1978 and 1979.


While the history lessons Antonelli received as a child furthered his passion off the track, on the track, he quickly excelled, rising up the go-karting ladder. His progress put him on the radar of top talent scouts, among whom was Gwen Lagrue, Mercedes’ junior guru. This led to Antonelli meeting Mercedes team principal Toto Wolff at age 11 before signing to its young driver program at 13.

It was Antonelli’s character as well as his ability that impressed Wolff. By the time he stepped up to single-seaters and continued winning everything he laid his hands upon, including both the Italian and German F4 titles in his first year before the Formula Regional title in 2023, it was clear the teenager had the makings of something special. In the long term, a place in the future Mercedes F1 lineup alongside George Russell has always been in the mind of the team’s management. It was just a matter of timing.

When Hamilton, who many expected would end his career at Mercedes, revealed last January that he would be leaving for Ferrari in 2025, it took Wolff five minutes to decide Antonelli, then just 17, would be the man to replace him.

“We have a great relationship, not only professionally, but also outside of the track,” Antonelli said of Wolff. “He’s a great guy, really supportive during great moments but also during difficult moments. I’m super happy to be with him. He’s been giving me a lot of help.”

Wolff has even entrusted Antonelli with teaching his six-year-old son, Jack, how to go-kart. “He’s not bad, he’s been improving quite a lot,” Antonelli said. “Every test, he was getting better and better. It was nice to see.”


Antonelli leaves his car after crashing during his first practice session, ahead of the Italian Grand Prix in 2024 (Gabriel Bouys / AFP via Getty Images)

The one thing both Wolff and Mercedes have been eager to avoid is putting too much pressure or expectation on Antonelli. A crash just minutes into his first F1 practice outing at Monza, one day before he was announced in the 2025 seat, was brushed off as part of the learning curve. Mercedes doesn’t expect an 18-year-old to replicate what Hamilton achieved.

Debuting for such a high-profile team at such a young age is rare in F1. Typically, young drivers will get their first opportunity further down the grid to learn the ropes and make a name for themselves before proving they are ready for a top seat. Russell spent three years at Williams before getting the Mercedes drive. Red Bull initially placed Verstappen at its sister team, Toro Rosso, before promoting him during his second season.

The one great, successful exception to the rule in recent F1 history is the man Antonelli will replace: Hamilton. He was given a McLaren seat for his debut season in 2007 and came within one point of winning the championship as a rookie. It’s an impossibly high bar, one there is no expectation for Antonelli to meet.

Antonelli’s youth meant his step up to F1 required an extra degree of preparation. Alongside his Formula Two racing commitments last year, he conducted an extensive amount (just under 20 days) of private testing in old cars, with his pace impressing the engineering team. Antonelli was also able to embed himself with the Mercedes engineering crew at races through the second half of the season, getting to know the voices and faces he will lean upon through 2025.

Antonelli feels a responsibility not only toward Mercedes but also toward his native Italy. While the nation has a rich, unparalleled history in motorsport, with Ferrari becoming a de facto national team, it has not produced a world champion since Alberto Ascari in 1953 nor a grand prix winner since Giancarlo Fisichella’s last success in 2006 with Renault.

“There’s a lot more hype around, of course, heading into next season,” Antonelli said. “Definitely, you feel a bit of responsibility because you know you’ve got Italy behind you. Everyone expects me to be successful, especially because I’ll be racing a Mercedes.

“But it’s also really exciting. I cannot wait for next year to get started and also I cannot wait for my home race at Imola. I would love to see so many Italians cheering.” The swathes of red for Ferrari that typically cover the grandstands at Imola may well be interspersed with Mercedes’ silver and black this year.


At Imola, Monza and beyond, the adjustment to fame will be hard for Antonelli to truly prepare for until it happens. He’s already getting recognized a lot more. Fans stopped him every few steps as he walked through Milan Malpensa airport last year off his flight from Heathrow; Antonelli graciously paused for selfies each time. He admitted it felt “a bit strange” to begin with, but he knows it’s part of the job. “When you get used to it, it’s normal.”


Antonelli, 18, and Bearman, 19, will join the F1 grid this year. (Joe Portlock / Getty Images)

Normal in F1, yes, but Antonelli is still a teenager — part of F1’s new wave of talent that has transformed the look and dramatically reduced the average age of the grid for 2025. Away from racing, he enjoys playing padel (the hobby of choice for much of the grid) and has already enjoyed some spirited matches with his new teammate, Russell. But he also likes to keep sharp by go-karting or even doing sim racing with his friends.

An endearing element of Antonelli’s rise last year was his friendship with his F2 teammate Ollie Bearman, who will also graduate to F1 this year with Haas. Both racing for Prema, they made several fun social media videos together and struck up a good relationship away from the track. It’s something Antonelli hopes can be of help to them both as they make the leap to F1.

“He’s a great guy, he’s quick,” Antonelli said of Bearman. “I’ve learned a lot from him. I’m happy to be sharing the grid with him next year. Because we’re going to be new next year, especially at the start, just the fact we’ve known each other and we’ve been racing together, it will help.”

When it comes to handling the leap up to F1, Antonelli will look to all the support he can get. While he will be one of six full-season rookies on the F1 grid this year, he and Red Bull’s Liam Lawson, who already has 11 races to his name, are likely to draw the most attention for the fact they’re with front-running teams that won races last year.

It makes the preparations for Antonelli all the more important. Mercedes will start 2025 trying to find the consistency it lacked for so much of last year. Russell will morph into the role of team leader following Hamilton’s departure, but for Antonelli, it’s all about getting the basics right and not letting the occasion over-awe him. “It’s going to be a big season ahead,” Antonelli said.

Now, with his driver’s license, F1’s youngest driver is ready for anything.

(Top photo: Clive Rose/Getty Images)

The baseball statistic that’s changing MLB — for better or worse

Major League Baseball recently released a report about pitcher injuries. It was the culmination of interviews with 200 subject-matter experts about the growing rash of arm troubles in the sport, and the word “stuff” was used 47 times. The report includes entire sections about the concept of stuff metrics — like Stuff+ — and how they may relate to pitcher health.

The study of the physical characteristics of a pitch, and how they relate to outcomes, has been improved immensely over the past few years by new technology and machine learning techniques. Now a number like Stuff+ can tell you how good a pitch is based only on its velocity, spin

, and movement. The recent explosion in the use of pitch types like sweepers, hard sliders and cutters across the league can be tied back to these metrics, which pointed to these pitch types as underrated.

“It’s been an important tool for us as we evaluate and develop our pitchers,” said one major-league pitching coach, one of multiple team employees who were granted anonymity because they weren’t approved to talk about these metrics publicly.

“Stuff+ has really helped bridge the gap between how the public and front offices think about pitchers and pitch quality,” said an MLB team analyst. “Teams keep their own metrics internal, obviously, but given how similarly teams build these metrics and how similar Stuff+ is to what these teams have, Stuff+ helps the casual observer understand what teams are seeing in pitchers.”

But it’s not just the doctors, coaches and analysts who care about these metrics. A player helped inspire one of the first stuff metrics. Brandon Bailey, now a pitching coach in the Dodgers organization, had the generative question in 2018 when he was pitching. He had a curve and a slider, and the Astros wanted him to either throw the curveball harder, or the slider with more movement. He didn’t know which idea was better.

“He asked us: Which should I do?” said Kyle Boddy of Driveline. “We were like, ‘Oh, that’s a good question. Can we quantify this?’ That was the first question that led us to develop Stuff+.”

Clearly, these stuff metrics are here to stay. They’re in the bullpen when the coach is assessing his guys, they’re in the offseason plans when pitchers get homework assignments, they’re in the scouting reports hitters mull over before the game and they’re in the office when the analysts are trying to find undervalued players to acquire. They’re now up on many of the best statistical websites in baseball and in most teams’ lexicons when it comes to developing and acquiring players, and they’re increasingly part of the regular parlance of the sport.

But, before we get into the ramifications of these new numbers, it makes sense to understand them better.

What is Stuff+?

Aptly named, Stuff+ is a number that evaluates a pitcher by studying his movement, velocity, spin and release points. It’s generally trying to remove the context of how a specific pitch performed on the field by looking at how certain combinations of shapes, velocities and spins usually perform across baseball and then assigning that value back to the pitch itself. What started with a revelation like “hard sliders that drop a lot are good” has become more complicated, but the analysis comes from the same place.

Pioneered by former Cubs research and development analyst Jeremy Greenhouse in 2009, the framework and concepts within were pushed forward by analysts like Harry Pavlidis at Baseball Prospectus and many others in the field, including Alex Chamberlain with FanGraphs and Tom Tango with Major League Baseball.

Working with Ethan Moore, we debuted a Quality of Stuff metric here at The Athletic in 2020 before Max Bay (now with the Dodgers) brought Stuff+ here a year later and eventually on to FanGraphs, where it now lives in a sortable leaderboard. Driveline Baseball first posted about its model, built by now-Phillies R&D head Dan Aucoin, in late 2021 but had already been using it before it went public. Now there are many competing models available publicly, and most teams have their own private versions.

The most basic and powerful pillar of Stuff+ is that velocity is good. That’s no surprise, but it’s not just that the velocity of the fastball is good for itself. The velocity of the fastball is also good for the secondary pitches, which we define off the fastball using velocity as the “anchor.” This is because hitters have to time the fastball — they have to be able to swing early and hard enough to hit the pitch that is still the most common in baseball. When they do so, they open themselves up for mistakes and swings and misses.

Here’s a look at Max Fried’s fastball and curveball, which sit a whopping 18 mph apart. Look at where the curveball is when the fastball crosses the plate.

If you swing to time that fastball, you’ll miss the curveball by feet, so velocity is very important for whiffs. Movement is also key because it can influence the results of a ball in play. Movement can be difficult to talk about and understand in pitching terms because it’s defined theoretically. Here’s an example.

We know that “ride” is good on the fastball, and that Logan Gilbert has 16 inches of it. That means the spin on his four-seamer helps the pitch counteract the effect of gravity. The ball doesn’t rise, but it does drop less than the hitter would expect it to. Gilbert’s fastball has 16 inches more ride than a pitch that spins like a bullet and is only affected by gravity.

It turns out that the Mariners’ starter actually throws a slider with one inch of horizontal movement and zero inches of vertical movement, so almost exactly this theoretical bullet pitch. If we overlay his fastball and slider, we can get a sense of what 16 inches of ride looks like in the real world.

Using machine learning, Stuff+ can test all sorts of different combinations of movement and velocity and spin and release points to find the best stuff. That makes it hard to produce top-line outcomes like “ride is good.” Even if ride is good, it’s more complicated than that because velocity, spin and release still matter.

Here’s an example of some feature interactions within the model. In this case, you have slider velocity (x-axis) against slider drop (y-axis), where the colors indicate the Stuff+ of each combination of velocity and drop around the league. If you look for the red (good), then you’ll find that generally it’s good to throw your slider harder, but that drop still matters. All of the features have this sort of complicated interaction, and that adds up to a single number.

One surprise from these models is that release point is incredibly important. What seems likely is that hitters see a release point and then automatically expect a certain type of movement from that slot. Pitchers who can play with that expectation — like Josh Hader does with his unique fastball — do really well in stuff models.

In this next visual, we can see how Bryce Elder and Clay Holmes throw their sinkers from almost the same arm slot but with different movement. Elder’s sinker shape is more expected given its high release point, so his sinker has an 80 Stuff+ (a Stuff+ score of 100 represents the average for all pitchers). Holmes gets four more inches of drop on his sinker from the same slot, so he has a 112 Stuff+. And the results follow, as Elder has allowed a slugging percentage that’s more than 100 points higher on his sinker in his career.

This finding has turned some of baseball’s traditional wisdom on its head, as a short pitcher with lots of ride (like Shota Imanaga) might receive preferential treatment from today’s teams over a taller pitcher with the same ride. Unexpected movement is huge.

“I wish I could be shorter, actually,” the 6-foot-3 Cal Quantrill once told me. “If I was shorter, it might improve the angle of some of my pitches.”

Unable to change their stature, pitchers have often turned to the baseball’s seams to produce unexpected movement. Clay Holmes has leveraged his knowledge of “seam-shifted wake” — a phenomenon in which seams can gather on one side of the ball and drag it in a certain direction — to make his sinker move like pitches thrown from lower arm slots. He gets tremendous drop from an over-the-top slot because of the seam effects on the fastball he throws.

These are the things that teams seem to value in today’s pitchers: velocity, spin and unconventional combinations of movement and release points. That’s what you’ll see at the top of the Stuff+ leaderboards today, too.

What has Stuff+ brought to the game?

The research that produced Stuff+ contained discoveries that have changed how teams think about player acquisition, player development and in-game strategy.

The most obvious thing that came out in the first runs of the stuff models was that sliders performed so much better than any other pitch in the model. This led to the idea that they were being underutilized. In every season since Statcast was introduced, the league has thrown more sliders.

A closer inspection of the best sliders revealed that a certain type of sideways slider was particularly useful, especially against same-handed hitters. That pitch didn’t have a single name at first, going by the Dodger slider, or the whirly in the Yankees organization, and eventually turning into the sweeper in the collective consciousness. Some teams went all in, like the Mariners as they taught it wholesale in the minors, and others were more tentative, but there have been more sweepers with every season since Statcast was born.

These models have been able to incorporate seam-shifted wake since Statcast went to Hawkeye technology in 2020. Since then, we’ve seen an increase in sweepers, cutters and sinkers, which can all use seam effects to increase unexpected movement.

The last pitch listed is the most remarkable. Sinkers fell out of vogue during the first pitch-tracking era (2008-2015) when ride was first quantified, because a good four-seam with ride gets more whiffs. Now that teams know how to produce seam-shifted movement better, they’re able to produce sinkers that reliably affect the way batted balls perform, and they’re coming back.

This itself may end up as the biggest legacy of the stuff movement among analysts. That the batting average on balls in play (BABIP) was around .290 across the league year in and year out led Voros McCracken to create a theory of Defensive Independent Pitching in 1999. Because pitchers demonstrated more year-to-year control over their strikeout and walk rates, he reasoned, it was better to hone in on those when evaluating pitchers. Essentially, pitchers weren’t seen as having control over what happens on a ball in play, even if that’s not the most correct way to sum up his research.

In the most recent revamp of Stuff+ on FanGraphs, though, the link between pitch shapes and batted-ball outcomes becomes even clearer. Sometimes the statistics have to catch up to the common wisdom, and it turns out that having more sophisticated tracking data helped the model understand that certain physical characteristics of pitches were a reliable predictor of things like ground-ball rates, home-run rates and — yes — more extreme BABIPs than McCracken might have projected in the past.

“I think that’s probably simply because BABIP does such a poor job predicting itself — it needs help,” said McCracken about these new findings. “Strikeouts already predict strikeouts really well.”

In a way then, Stuff+ doesn’t refute his research, it simply refines it. Now Stuff+ can help us project BABIP better and show just how much control a pitcher can have over a ball in play.

Analysts tend to like models like Stuff+ because it helps them acquire pitchers who can do things (like suppress hits and home runs) that old models won’t pick up on. Pitching coaches value these models because — after evaluating only a handful of pitches — they can produce roadmaps for their pitchers who want to improve.

“Stuff+ has been an accurate indicator of how a particular guy’s pitches are performing at the big-league level — not only relative to the league but in relation to his arsenal,” said a major-league pitching coach. “If one is doing really well — this might impact how much we are throwing it, meaning we may bump up the usage.  If one is doing poorly — it allows us to double-click on it and investigate why this might be the case: Is it the strikes? Is it the whiff? Is it the shape of the pitch?”

So, when a team picks up a pitcher with a funky release point, and coaches a pitcher to throw more sliders, pick up a sweeper, add a sinker or tweak a pitch shape, it is often acting in ways that Stuff+ would guide it. This has probably been a part of the rise of strikeouts across the league, because pitchers can optimize their stuff in ways that before were more intuitive and are now more precise.

If this Pandora’s box has been opened, it doesn’t seem likely to be shut, but there are a few hopeful ways forward. One is for hitters to use the same sorts of scientific tools to help their process. This is underway now, with the most modern approaches to hitting development including technology and concepts that pitchers have long valued. As hitters understand their bat paths with bat path grades that now resemble early Stuff+ grades, they can better fight fire with fire.

And then there are rules changes that can help the hitter. We’ve seen things like sticky stuff enforcement, the pitch clock and shift restrictions that lean toward boosting offense. One team analyst thought that baseball could paint lines on the ball that would help hitters better see the spin and better react to pitches. That could be viable, given the other changes baseball has recently seen.

Of course, since Stuff+ values velocity, spin and funky movement, and helps pitchers see the way toward optimizing their arsenals, it becomes obvious that there might be a link between the rise of these metrics and the rise of injuries across the game. Putting these things on one table brings that into focus.

But the research linking specific aspects of stuff and injury rates is a little murkier. For certain, velocity has a huge role. But is it how close a pitcher throws to their own personal maximum, as Glenn Fleisig found in his peer-reviewed study? Then why does a bigger velocity gap not lead to better health outcomes?

Or is velocity generally a stress on the elbow, as Driveline found? And if 80 mph sliders are fine, but 90 mph sliders are actually more stressful, as at least one study found, then maybe breaking ball velocity is one of the biggest strains on elbows?

Despite Dr. Keith Meister sounding the alarm bells about sweepers, there is no research directly linking sweepers to more risk. Are pitchers throwing with too much intensity in their pitch design sessions? How would that be knowable across the sport when those sessions aren’t tracked by the league?

As the rate of Tommy John surgeries on torn elbow ligaments has plateaued, overall days on the injured list have not. The biggest problem facing baseball is probably not that stuff metrics have found a way to characterize excellent pitches, though — that kind of work has been going on for nearly 20 years and seems impossible to stop. The problem is that velocity is good and is also a stressor, and there’s no way to tell a young pitcher who might make the big leagues that he needs to throw softer. They’re capable of doing the math, and they’ve made a calculated choice, as Justin Verlander pointed out about his pitching style.

In other words, players are always going to try to be better, just like Bailey when he asked the question that begat one version of Stuff+. If the sport is serious about improving injury, funding a bilateral effort would be a start, and adding rules changes that incentivize teams to carry pitchers who can go further into games (like a reduction in injured list slots) would do more than simply asking players to stop trying to throw nastier pitches.

What’s next?

Not everyone likes Stuff+, of course, beyond those linking it to injury.

“You can never get pitching into one number,” said Max Scherzer about the stat. “Even if you are able to, you’re still missing something.”

The effort to quantify aspects of pitching that stuff metrics miss is well underway despite his skepticism. Driveline (with Mix+ and Match+) and Baseball Prospectus (with its recently released arsenal stats) have attempted to put a number on the value of having wide arsenals with different movement and velocity profiles. Over at FanGraphs, Michael Rosen did some work on release angles that might better quantify command. To improve as a pitcher, you have to understand what the best do. So analysts will continue to try to define the best processes for pitchers.

“If you cannot measure it, you cannot improve it,” as Lord Kelvin, the legendary physicist, once proclaimed.

“We posted leaderboards with the Reds — we posted Stuff+, Command+ and times to the plate, those were the things we cared about,” said Boddy of his time as pitching coordinator. “Our coaches were being evaluated on that, we were determining who our best coaches were based on it. We found coaches that helped pitchers outperform our Stuff+ projections, like Brian Garman, our pitching coach at Dayton, and Forrest Herrman, our pitching coach at Daytona. Big shock, both are coordinators now.”

That said, every time analysts make an advancement that spreads throughout the game, like Stuff+, it quickly ceases to be an advantage. Boddy thought that 28 of 30 teams had their own internal Stuff+ model, and other analysts agreed that he wasn’t far off.

So maybe the future is more about the exciting research being done in biomechanics that could set a team apart. Over at NTangible, they feel they’ve built a better test of makeup — the attitude and energy that fuels the most successful players — which is notoriously difficult to define, scout and measure. At the winter meetings, people from all parts of baseball emphasized soft skills as a way to successfully bridge the gap between data and play on the field.

Despite the urge to quantify everything, there’s also the truth that the unquantifiable will always be important, and will remain a possible edge for a team that understands it best (including finding a way to quantify it). These more nebulous aspects of the game will always be a source of chaos in the machine of any metric. And that’s a good thing — it’s a sport, not a simulation.

(Graphics: Drew Jordan and John Bradford/ The Athletic; Illustration: Dan Goldfarb / The Athletic; Photo of Clay Holmes: Andrew Mordzynski / Icon Sportswire / Getty Images)

Inside the top-secret trade negotiations that made Luka Dončić a Laker

The Athletic has live coverage of the 2025 NBA trade deadline

The Los Angeles Lakers walked away from the most stunning trade of the century with an unexpected bonus. The Lakers now employ 25-year-old Luka Dončić, and they didn’t even have to part with both of their tradeable first-round picks to land him.

Late Saturday, the Dallas Mavericks agreed to send Dončić to the Lakers for 10-time All-Star and defensive anchor Anthony Davis, Max Christie and the Lakers’ first-round pick in 2029. In the process, the Lakers held onto their 2031 first-rounder.

The Mavs, desperate to find Dončić a new home as soon as possible, did not press for it.

The Lakers’ logic, according to league sources, was that parting with both of their first-rounders would be too perilous. Dončić’s contract can expire in 2026 when they couldn’t know his interest in re-signing. And they had no chance to find out before pulling off an exchange that shook the NBA.

The Lakers could not talk to Dončić’s agent, Bill Duffy, about the trade because both sides, Dallas and Los Angeles, wanted to keep negotiations a secret. Mentioning the behind-the-scenes details to agents would put the information at risk of becoming public, which the Mavericks especially thought would be too flammable. If a trade didn’t materialize, then they believed the prospect of being left with a disgruntled franchise centerpiece could be disastrous.

Though Mavs general manager Nico Harrison seemed to indicate in a news conference Sunday that he spoke only to the Lakers about Dončić, Dallas called at least one other team to inquire about a deal that would flip Dončić for another star, league sources told The Athletic. But the Mavericks didn’t enter deep negotiations with anyone but the Lakers. Harrison, who was once the longtime Nike representative for the late Kobe Bryant, already had a strong relationship with Lakers general manager Rob Pelinka, who was Bryant’s longtime agent.

At Harrison’s news conference, he praised Pelinka’s ability to keep talks quiet, even as they went on for weeks, though concealing the availability of a young star was in Pelinka’s interest, too. If the rest of the league learned the Mavs wanted to move Dončić, it could flood Dallas’ inbox, possibly with offers that bested the Lakers’.

So without the ability to gauge Dončić’s appetite to remain in L.A. long term, the Lakers expressed they couldn’t go all the way in for him, league sources said. And the Mavericks acquiesced, eventually agreeing to deal Dončić, along with Maxi Kleber and Markieff Morris for Davis, Christie and one first-rounder. For salary-cap reasons, the Jazz also took on Jalen Hood-Schifino and two second-round picks.

Now that the trade is official, answers are emerging. Dončić is ecstatic about joining the Lakers, and all early signs point to a long-term future with the team, a league source said.

Harrison hinted during his news conference why the Mavericks were so eager to unload someone of Dončić’s caliber, picking 31-year-old Davis as the running mate for 32-year-old Kyrie Irving rather than the younger, generational talent who was third in MVP voting last season. He mentioned “the culture we wanted to create” and added “we believe (the players we are bringing in) exemplify that,” a contrast to his thoughts on Dončić.

The specifics behind why the Mavericks drifted away from Dončić, beyond vague questions about his conditioning and off-court habits, remain in question.

The team is under fresh ownership now, as well, with Patrick Dumont taking over for Mark Cuban, who now holds a minority stake in the team and is no longer a primary part of the decision-making process.

“There’s some unique things about his contract that we had to pay attention to,” Harrison said. “There’s other teams that were loading up (to acquire him as a free agent). He was going to have to make his own decision at some point of whether he wants to be here or not, whether we want to supermax him or not, or whether he wants to opt out. So I think we have to take all that in consideration and feel like we got out in front of what could have been a tumultuous year. ”

But in recent NBA history, this trade has no comparison point — a player as young and as good as Dončić, dealt to a conference rival without even asking to be traded. A league source close to Dončić said he wanted to be in Dallas his entire career, which Dončić himself essentially said in the goodbye note to the city he posted to social media on Sunday: “I thought I’d spend my career here and I wanted so badly to bring you a championship.”

“He wanted to be like Dirk (Nowitzki),” the source said, referencing the Mavericks legend who played 21 seasons in Dallas and was NBA Finals MVP for the team’s lone title in 2011.

If the Mavericks were at all motivated by a belief that Dončić wanted to eventually head elsewhere, the source close to him insists that was not the case. This was not Dončić rejecting the Mavericks; it was Dallas rebuking him, and doing so in an unorthodox manner.

To the extent that NBA stars of Dončić’s caliber are traded at all, the return haul often includes a truckload of draft picks because a rebuild is on the horizon.

Brooklyn traded 34-year-old Kevin Durant to the Suns in 2023, and it cost Phoenix four first-rounders along with key role players, whom they traded for more picks. The Blazers dealt 32-year-old Damian Lillard to the Bucks and received an unprotected first-rounder, multiple first-round swaps and All-Star guard Jrue Holiday, whom they immediately flipped for more first-round picks. Nearly three years ago, when the Utah Jazz moved Donovan Mitchell and Rudy Gobert in separate trades, they received a combined seven future first-rounders.

In each of those cases, the teams trading away their main star (or stars) were starting over. On Sunday, Harrison, and coach Jason Kidd, insisted the deal to acquire Davis was made to win now and in the future, with one eerie caveat.

“The future to me is three, four years from now,” Harrison said. “Ten years from now, I don’t know. They’ll probably bury me and J(ason Kidd) by then. Or we bury ourselves.”

Dončić would have been eligible for a supermax extension this summer had the Mavericks held onto him. Yet, Dallas was worried about handing him that much money, league sources said.

An extension for Dončić could have reached $345 million over five years, starting with a salary that’s 35 percent of the cap, the largest contract a player can receive. Davis is already on a 35-percent max contract that kicks in next season. If Dallas were to extend him in a year and a half, when he’s eligible, it would presumably be handing him another 35-percent max, which would run until his age-37 season.

The dollars are essentially the same for either Davis or Dončić. In that sense, the Mavericks’ logic wasn’t to avoid handing out a supermax. This was Dallas proclaiming it would rather have a mid-30s Davis than a 20-something Dončić for the same price.

The Mavericks believe the acquisition of Davis will give them another defensive backbone, though it’s not like Dončić prevented them from elite defense during their NBA Finals run a year ago. Dallas ranked seventh in points allowed per possession following midseason trades for Daniel Gafford and P.J. Washington and shut down elite attacks for three rounds before running into the juggernaut Boston Celtics and falling three victories short of a title.

It might not be done adding to this year’s roster.

To complete the deal, Davis waived his $5.9 million trade kicker, a bonus he was due if the Lakers flipped him to another squad. The money would have come out of Los Angeles’ pocket but would have counted against Dallas’ cap sheet. Now that it doesn’t exist, the Mavs have breathing room.

Though they didn’t do this deal to get out of the tax, the trade takes the Mavericks beneath the luxury-tax threshold and $6.2 million below the first apron. In fact, it’s possible they crest back above it before the Feb. 6 trade deadline. Creating that room below the first apron opens up more types of moves to make over the next three days and even beyond. They can now take in more money than they send out in a trade and can also sign buyout players, neither of which would be legal if they were above or dangerously close to the first apron.

The Lakers, on the other hand, preserved their valuables. Not only did they keep their 2031 first-round selection; they also held onto 26-year-old Austin Reaves, an 18-points-per-game scorer. Most importantly, they can now build around Dončić instead of James — a first not only for the Lakers in their seven seasons with him but also for James in his decorated, 22-year career.

James is 40. You wouldn’t know it by his statistics — averages of 24.0 points, 9.1 assists and 7.6 rebounds on 38 percent shooting from 3-point range — but he is pondering retirement. He has not said when his last season will be, but sources close to him acknowledge it could be within the next two years.

For at least the last decade, dating back to his second stint in Cleveland, James almost yearly demands the team he’s playing for to make upgrades to the roster. He offered a similar sentiment last month (as did Davis, for that matter), and the Lakers stunned both of them by trading Davis.

In a way, the Lakers did exactly what James asked, and with more shock and awe than at any other time in James’ career when a team has yielded to his demands. The Lakers now have two ball-dominant, brilliant scorers, dazzling passers and playoff performers in Dončić and James.

That’s why James was not upset by the trade, a league source said. He was shocked when he was informed of the trade by his agent Rich Paul, who also represents Davis, while at dinner with his family in New York after recording a triple-double in a win over the Knicks on Saturday night at Madison Square Garden. James’ chief concern, according to the same league source, was Davis’ emotions following the trade. Otherwise, James viewed it as a “business decision” the Lakers needed to make, and not just because he wanted roster changes. The future will soon be here in which James is no longer involved.

The Lakers, sitting at 28-19, fifth in the Western Conference, looked at their roster and did not believe whatever player they could get for the two first-rounders would provide enough to vault them to championship level. So they went the opposite direction.

They know trading away Davis, a perennial All-Defensive contender, will crush their ability to protect the rim. They understand there will be nights of high-scoring bouts with the current roster — though an offense with James and Dončić can pulverize opponents, too.

The Lakers could now use a big man, someone to protect the paint, but not many centers whose names are prevalent on the market appeal to them, league sources said. And just as they wouldn’t part with the 2031 first-rounder for Dončić, they have no plans to give their best remaining draft asset away for a patch-up role player.

They will be resistant to long-term money. Trading Davis means Los Angeles can now target max cap space in the summer of 2026, which could have a packed free-agent class. As of now, they have only Jarred Vanderbilt, Dalton Knecht and Bronny James under contract for 2026-27, when Dončić has a player option, as does Reaves. The Lakers could hold onto both and still have enough room to sign another star.

At that point, Dončić will be only 27 years old.

Contrast that with the post-James possibilities before they made this trade.

Davis is eligible for a massive extension in 2026, one that would take him through his age-37 season. But the Lakers had reservations about handing him so much money into his late 30s. Could a high-paid, post-prime Davis have kept the Lakers competitive by himself?

Now, Los Angeles has a top-five player. The post-James future looks different — as does the post-Dončić one in Dallas.

More on the stunning Luka-Anthony Davis trade:

(Illustration: Eamonn Dalton / The Athletic; Joshua Gateley, Jamie Sabau/NBAE via Getty Images)

Why didn’t Arsenal or Man Utd sign a forward? Have Spurs done enough? Key transfer window questions answered

The transfer window might have closed on Monday night, but the question marks remain.

As you sit here on Tuesday morning, you might be left wondering about the business your team did — or in a lot of cases, didn’t do. Why have they not brought in that extra player? Why did they let one of their key men go? And is the squad in a stronger place than it was?

Here, The Athletic has assembled its club experts to run through the key questions — and answers — after deadline day.


Why didn’t Arsenal sign a striker?

Ultimately, Arsenal couldn’t find the right player at the right price in this window.

Long-term targets such as Alexander Isak and Benjamin Sesko were unavailable this month. The club did look to capitalise on a PSR situation at Aston Villa with a move for Ollie Watkins, but Villa chose to sell Jhon Duran to Al Nassr instead.

Manager Mikel Arteta and the club were aligned in the view that they didn’t want to simply bring in a “body”. They wanted a No 9 who could make an immediate impact in the remainder of the season.


Isak was not available this month (Molly Darlington/Getty Images)

Watkins fit the bill. When that deal died, there was no obvious alternative that didn’t compromise Arsenal’s summer plans in some way. Even in the case of Watkins, Arsenal showed they were not simply prepared to pay Villa’s £60million ($74.4m) asking price.

It leaves Arsenal looking very light up front, with Kai Havertz the only fit recognised centre-forward in the squad. Arsenal have taken a calculated gamble that Havertz can carry them through to the end of the season when they will return to pursuing their primary attacking targets.

James McNicholas


What were Manchester United thinking?

United’s decision to step back from signing a replacement for Marcus Rashford, who remains the team’s third-highest scorer in the Premier League on four goals, ahead of Joshua Zirkzee and Rasmus Hojlund, has been met with severe concerns among the fanbase. United have lost 11 times in the Premier League to sit 13th and have failed to score in a third of their 24 games so far.

From United’s perspective, the January plan was to lose players deemed at odds with the culture, add a left wing-back, and stay financially restrained ahead of the summer, when a long-term centre-forward can be recruited. The £5m loan fee demanded by Bayern Munich for Mathys Tel, with no buy option, was deemed too expensive by United.


Tel’s loan fee was deemed too much for Manchester United (Sebastian Widmann/Getty Images)

Critics argue United would have had more budgetary flexibility had the multi-million-pound cost of sacking Erik ten Hag, hiring Amorim, and dismissing Dan Ashworth not gone on this season’s accounts.

Though Amorim said United were “trying everything to improve the team” during a press conference after the Crystal Palace match, he also showed he understood the financial picture by adding: “Without doing mistakes of the past, trying to balance the urgency of the moment.” United’s consistent loss-making is the result of decisions made by the previous regime.

Instead, United chose to primarily invest in Patrick Dorgu, the 20-year-old wing-back who arrived in a deal judged fair value, potentially worth €35million, and in a position needing strengthening.

Laurie Whitwell


Chelsea are usually so active in windows — why was it different this time?

Before the window opened, Chelsea fans were hoping to see a lot of recruitment in some key positions, but the club never intended to spend lavishly.

The window shut with not much business done to show for all the noise surrounding the club. Chelsea bought defender Mamadou Sarr from sister club Strasbourg with the summer in mind. A deal for 19-year-old midfielder Mathis Amougou was finalised on deadline day and Trevoh Chalobah was recalled from a season-long loan at Crystal Palace. Amougou has arrived more for his potential than as an immediate starter.

This is not the kind of activity that will get many pulses raised in the stands. However, like 12 months ago when no one arrived apart from Cesare Casadei coming back from a loan at Leicester City, Chelsea did not expect to be that active.


A deal was agreed for Amougou on deadline day (Euan Cherry/Getty Images)

Chelsea’s thinking about where they were looking to strengthen solidified the longer the window went on, but it always had to be the right deal for the right price.

A left-sided winger, due to Mykhailo Mudryk’s suspension for failing a drugs test, striker and midfielder were on the agenda.

The complication of getting players off the books also played a role in what took place. For example, despite interest from Bayern Munich and Manchester United, Christopher Nkunku has stayed at Stamford Bridge because neither club were prepared to meet their £65million asking price.

Joao Felix, Renato Veiga, Carney Chukwuemeka, Ben Chilwell and Axel Disasi all leaving on loan deals ended up summarising more about where Chelsea’s main priorities lay. However, all of these negotiations were not concluded until the end of the month.

Simon Johnson


Did Spurs do enough to fix their season?

The arrival of Antonin Kinsky from Slavia Prague solved Tottenham’s biggest problem at the start of the window. Guglielmo Vicario suffered a fractured ankle in November and Fraser Forster was deputising for him. However, Forster is clumsy in possession. This makes him an awkward fit for Ange Postecoglou, who likes his goalkeepers to be brave on the ball. Kinsky made an instant impression with his performance in the Carabao Cup semi-final first-leg victory over Liverpool and has played every game in the Premier League since.

The other areas Spurs desperately needed to reinforce were defence and upfront. Austrian centre-back Kevin Danso has arrived on loan with an obligation to buy from French side Lens. It is not enough, though, as Radu Dragusin has suffered an anterior cruciate ligament injury that will keep him out for the rest of the season, while Cristian Romero’s recovery from a quad issue has been described as a “slow burner” by Postecoglou.


Spurs made an offer for Guehi (Shaun Botterill/Getty Images)

Acquiring Crystal Palace’s captain Marc Guehi would have been a statement signing, but they failed to pull it off — which leaves them still short of options in defence.

The most eye-catching deal was Mathys Tel, who joined on deadline day from Bayern Munich on loan with a €55million (£45.7m; $56.9m) option to buy. The 19-year-old forward is talented but raw. Ideally, they would have signed an older and more experienced player.

The new additions should help Spurs progress deep in the Europa League and FA Cup, while all three of them might have important roles to play against Liverpool at Anfield on Thursday in Tottenham’s biggest game of the season — the Carabao Cup semi-final second-leg.

Jay Harris


Is Liverpool buying no one a sign they might keep Van Dijk, Salah and/or Alexander-Arnold?

Liverpool’s inactivity in the January window is more a reflection of their satisfaction with the current depth of Arne Slot’s squad. The Dutch head coach had made it clear that he was happy with the options available to him for the rest of the season as they continue to challenge on four fronts.

Federico Chiesa and Joe Gomez didn’t even make the bench for Saturday’s hard-fought 2-0 win at Bournemouth that kept them on course for Premier League title glory. As for the futures of Van Dijk, Salah and Alexander-Arnold, who are all out of contract this summer, the trio have been made contract offers in recent months, with Liverpool keen to retain their services.


Liverpool want to keep Van Dijk (Mike Hewitt/Getty Images)

Talks remain ongoing and until there is clarity, the club won’t know the extent of the business that needs to be done this summer in terms of recruiting replacements. That process was never going to start in January.

Real Madrid wanted to buy Alexander-Arnold during the winter window, but their approach was instantly rebuffed by Liverpool, who made it clear he was going nowhere midway through the season. The Spanish giants are now hoping to convince the England right-back to join them on a free transfer this summer.

The uncertainty over key personnel hasn’t proved a distraction for Slot’s side, who find themselves six points clear at the top of the Premier League with a game in hand.

James Pearce


Have City got the players they need?

Only time will tell!

It appears obvious with young centre-backs Abdukodir Khusanov and Vitor Reis that City are happy to give them time to get to grips with life in England and Premier League football so they can fulfil their potential and contribute to Pep Guardiola’s first team later down the line.

They hope that Omar Marmoush will inject more quality straight away and at the age of 25 and with his recent record in the Bundesliga, that appears a fair ask for a player with obvious quality. In his two outings so far, he has added more energy than much substance in possession, but it is early days and he has hardly been dropped into the most stable of teams.

The especially interesting one is Nico Gonzalez given City did not intend to pay the release clause before the weekend but did agree a deal that will total €60million. This figure is the same as his release clause, but the deal is structured differently. It suggests a degree of panic after the defeat at Arsenal and the glaringly obvious need to strengthen the centre of midfield. As long as they have the right man, then they will not mind too much about overpaying — they normally walk away in these scenarios. But after trying and failing with Kalvin Phillips and Matheus Nunes, they really need to get a midfield signing right.

Sam Lee


Are Villa stronger after selling Duran and signing Rashford and Asensio?

Aston Villa’s window was frenetic and fast-paced and best-laid plans routinely changed. They missed out on several targets but ultimately ended with a flourish after the high-profile signings of Marcus Rashford from Manchester United, Marco Asensio from Paris Saint-Germain and Axel Disasi from Chelsea.

In total, Villa signed five players with eight departing. They were linked to far more. They failed to sign Loic Bade (Sevilla), Oscar Mingueza (Celta Vigo) and Joao Felix (Chelsea) — there were more — and made good money on Jaden Philogene joining Ipswich Town and Jhon Duran heading for Saudi Arabia, receiving around £85m in fees overall.


Rashford has joined Aston Villa on loan (Ben Roberts Photo/Getty Images)

They spent carefully on incomings, with Donyell Malen being negotiated for two weeks before striking a €18m (£14.9m, $18.6m) deal with Borussia Dortmund. Villa recruited young right-back Andres Garcia from Levante for €7m. As for two of the other signings, Rashford and Asensio, they are on significant salaries and Villa are paying for most of it.

Villa also did manage to bring Disasi in late on deadline day, dealing with a serious gap in defence.

Jacob Tanswell


Why did Newcastle let Lloyd Kelly join Juventus (and not sign anyone)?

Put simply because, from a financial outlook, the deal just became appealing.

Heading into the window, unlike Miguel Almiron, Kelly was not necessarily viewed as a likely candidate to leave. The 26-year-old only joined from Bournemouth in July and with Newcastle keen to reduce the age profile of their defence and Kelly able to play both centre-half and left-back, he was viewed as a long-term addition.

Even early underwhelming performances did not change Eddie Howe’s view that Kelly could be a success, even if that turned out to be as a squad player who could cover two positions.

But when Sven Botman immediately usurped Kelly in the pecking order upon returning last month and with the former Bournemouth player last starting a Premier League match in November, once interest was shown, Newcastle’s hierarchy felt they had to at least explore deals for PSR reasons.


Kelly last started a Premier League game in November (Stu Forster/Getty Images)

Although Fenerbahce were not capable of tempting Newcastle to sell, and despite Juventus’ initial loan and low-ball enquiries falling short of the club’s valuation, eventually Paul Mitchell, the sporting director, negotiated an initial loan with an obligation to buy, potentially worth £20million.

For a player who has started only four league games and played just 302 top-flight minutes this season, the fee is borderline remarkable. Newcastle can bank it for the 2025-26 accounts, too, so it bolsters their PSR position heading into the summer, while Kelly’s wages are also off the books and he can potentially be replaced in the summer by a player on a lower salary.

Ideally, from a footballing outlook, Howe would not have lost a squad member of Kelly’s age and Premier League experience who can cover two positions. But from a purely business standpoint, it makes sense.

Newcastle have been adamant that they did not have the PSR capacity to recruit first-team signings this month and that Kelly’s sale is part of their financial housekeeping ahead of what is expected to be a busy summer.

Chris Waugh


Why haven’t Napoli spent any of the Kvaratskhelia money?

Napoli haven’t sat on their hands since the sale of Khvicha Kvaratskhelia.

The club’s sporting director, Giovanni Manna, has worked a number of angles to further reinforce a position covered ably by summer signings David Neres and Leonardo Spinazzola. Napoli flew out to Barcelona to talk to Alejandro Garnacho’s agents, however, their valuation of the young Argentine differed from the one held by Manchester United.

Karim Adeyemi, the rapid Borussia Dortmund forward, was another option Manna explored without success. While coach Antonio Conte hammered home what a loss Kvaratskhelia represented on the pitch, attention turned to more feasible alternatives than Garnacho and Adeyemi.

Napoli spent the last days of the window pursuing Allan Saint-Maximin, the ex-Newcastle entertainer now of Fenerbache. Even that was, to use Manna’s phrase, “a bit complicated”. On deadline day, they did add Noah Okafor on loan from Milan and they will have an option to buy the 24-year-old.

James Horncastle


Why did Brighton let Evan Ferguson join West Ham?

Evan Ferguson’s goals and appearances have fallen off a cliff since a hat-trick for Brighton against Newcastle in a 3-1 home win in September last season and another goal in a 3-2 victory at Nottingham Forest two months later. That took his tally to six goals in the opening 12 league games of the 2023-24 campaign under former head coach Roberto De Zerbi.

The talk at that stage was that the Republic of Ireland’s golden boy was a £90m No 9 in the making. A succession of injuries and irregular appearances since then have sapped Ferguson’s form and confidence. He went 33 appearances in all competitions without scoring over a period of 11 months before finding the net as a substitute in a 2-2 home draw against Wolves in October under De Zerbi’s successor Fabian Hurzeler.


Ferguson has struggled for goalscoring form (Mike Hewitt/Getty Images)

Ferguson has dropped behind Danny Welbeck, Joao Pedro and Georginio Rutter in the pecking order for the centre of Hurzeler’s attack. Widespread interest in loaning or buying him from top-flight clubs at home and abroad illustrated sustained faith in his potential.

West Ham were always the frontrunners once Graham Potter became head coach. Potter gave Ferguson his debut as a 16-year-old at Brighton before leaving for Chelsea in September 2022. Also, given both clubs are off the pace in the fight for European qualification, there is little prospect of West Ham achieving that goal at Brighton’s embarrassing expense.

Indeed, returning to goalscoring form under Potter, with the prospect of regular game time lacking at Brighton for the rest of the season, is what his parent club want to enhance his development and restore value before a fresh look at the situation in the summer.

Andy Naylor


Why did Al Nassr start bidding big at the end of their window?

Al Nassr were one of the four clubs taken over by Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund (PIF) in June 2023, which puts them in a position of having the means to splash the cash in a way many other clubs are unable to.

Their winter transfer window began with the appointment of a new chief executive, Majed Al-Jamaan, one of their former players, to replace Guido Fienga. It ended with a £64.5m plus add-ons deal to sign Jhon Duran from Aston Villa and two failed bids, with the second one worth £61m, for Brighton & Hove Albion’s Kaoru Mitoma.


Ronaldo’s side Al Nassr spent big on Duran (Abdullah Ahmed/Getty Images)

Sources close to Al Nassr, speaking on the condition of anonymity to protect relationships, noted the arrival of Al-Jamaan as one of the factors for making a splash in January, while also pointing out that midfielder Seko Fofana and Cristiano Ronaldo’s strike partner, Anderson Talisca, both left the club in January, which meant replacements were needed.

Supporters have become frustrated at their side’s inability to compete for the Saudi Pro League title — Al Nassr are third, eight points behind joint leaders Al Hilal and Al Ittihad (also owned by PIF). There is a sense of Al-Jamaan wanting to inject some energy back into the stadium with attendances falling and give themselves a better chance of winning the AFC Champions League.

Dan Sheldon


Madrid wanted a defender — can they cope without one?

As always at Real Madrid since Carlo Ancelotti returned in 2021, it depends on who you ask.

For the board, there is no doubt they can. They share a belief with Ancelotti that the ideal scenario would be to have some reinforcements. But for them, it is more important to take maximum care of their accounts and they traditionally do not believe in the options available in this winter window. They also believe that there are solutions within the squad to deal with the numerous injuries and highlight the role that academy players can have.


Ancelotti’s side have not added a defender this window (Damien Meyer/AFP via Getty Images)

Ancelotti thinks differently, as happened in the past. In the summer of 2023, he asked for the signing of Harry Kane to cover the departure to Saudi Arabia of Karim Benzema and the club only made superficial moves for the Englishman, who joined Bayern Munich. In January 2024, after serious knee injuries to Eder Militao and David Alaba, Ancelotti asked for a centre-back, which never arrived. The same happened after they failed to sign Leny Yoro in the summer.

A training ground source told The Athletic weeks ago that: “Without a right-back, it is impossible to win the Champions League.” Dani Carvajal picked up a serious knee injury in October, so the only right-back available since then has been Lucas Vazquez. Real Madrid tried to bring forward the signing of Trent Alexander-Arnold to this window, but Liverpool rejected their attempt in December.

Mario Cortegana


Barcelona did not make any signings, but was this a successful window for them?

Yes, it was a successful one.

The name most commonly mentioned at Barcelona’s senior offices as a potential reinforcement was Manchester United’s Marcus Rashford, but he was seen as a non-priority player given how prolific Flick’s front line with Raphinha, Robert Lewandowski and Lamine Yamal has been this season.

But Deco’s biggest success has been, by far, securing key pieces in the squad for the foreseeable future.

Barcelona’s priority was to solve the contract situation of every player with 18 months left in their current contract. Pedri and Gavi were the two stand-out names in that department and both signed five-year extensions up until 2030.


Araujo has signed a new contract (David Ramos/Getty Images)

Captain Ronald Araujo also signed a new deal, despite having his future in doubt amid interest from Juventus this month. The centre-back’s long-term future at the club is not assured, though.

Barcelona and the player’s camp agreed to sign a new contract up until 2031, but with a low release clause to allow Araujo to find a way out in the summer if his situation at the club is not what he expects. Meanwhile, the club have shielded themselves from a rushed sale.

There is still more work to be done in that regard, as Frenkie de Jong, Andreas Christensen and Eric Garcia all have contracts expiring in the summer of 2026.

If, on top of that, you add the sell-on clause that Barcelona are going to cash in for Porto’s sale of Nico Gonzalez, a La Masia product, to Manchester City — expected to be worth around €20million — this was a decent window for the club.

Pol Ballus


Who moved on deadline day?

  • Mathis Amougou (St-Etienne to Chelsea)*
  • Marco Asensio (Paris Saint-Germain to Aston Villa, loan)
  • Tyler Bindon (Reading to Nottingham Forest)
  • Lewis Carrol (Aberdeen to Nottingham Forest)
  • Ben Chilwell (Chelsea to Crystal Palace, loan)
  • Carney Chukwuemeka (Chelsea to Borussia Dortmund, loan)
  • Axel Disasi (Chelsea to Aston Villa, loan)*
  • Marcus Edwards (Sporting CP to Burnley)
  • Joao Felix (Chelsea to AC Milan, loan)*
  • Evan Ferguson (Brighton to West Ham, loan)
  • Santiago Gimenez (Feyenoord to AC Milan)
  • Nico Gonzalez (Porto to Manchester City)
  • Lloyd Kelly (Newcastle to Juventus, loan with £20m obligation to buy)
  • Alvaro Morata (AC Milan to Galatasaray, loan)
  • Mathys Tel (Bayern Munich to Tottenham Hotspur, loan)

*not confirmed as of 12am on February 4

(Top photos: Getty Images)

Julie Stewart-Binks on a career derailed by alleged sexual assault: ‘What could my life have been?’

Last week, Julie Stewart-Binks sat in an empty lounge on the rooftop of a hotel near her apartment in New York City. She is about to watch a clip from her time as a Fox Sports host and reporter. It is a moment that she thinks about often, but one that she has never wanted to relive in full. She hits play on the video, then her hands jerk back toward her chest, as if bracing for a blow.

In the clip, Stewart-Binks, then a 28-year-old Fox Sports 1 on-air personality, is on the set of a pop-up show – “Jason Whitlock’s House Party By the Bay” – for the 2016 Super Bowl in San Francisco. The set is meant to evoke a Super Bowl party. Red Solo cups. Beers chilling in an ice bucket on the coffee table. Whitlock and the day’s guest – New England Patriots tight end Rob Gronkowski – are behind a desk; Stewart-Binks is on a gray couch flanking them.

The group is discussing Gronkowski’s disclosure that he moonlighted as a stripper in college. Stewart-Binks then says: “If you have a chance to make some more money, using maybe me as an example, do you want to show us a little ‘Magic Mike?’” (A reference to the 2012 movie about male exotic dancers.) Gronkowski, a little surprised, asks Stewart-Binks if she wants a lap dance, to which she replies: “Yeah.” Gronkowski seems to be stalling. He asks about music and remarks: “Where are your friends? I would need, like, a bachelorette party?” Stewart-Binks keeps urging him on, as does Whitlock, and Gronkowski eventually moves from behind the desk, over to the couch. He dances briefly in front of Stewart-Binks, then straddles her and thrusts his hips toward her, grinding on her as the cameras roll. Stewart-Binks, laughing, takes out some crumpled dollar bills and hands them to Gronkowski. The dancing lasts about six seconds.

As she watches the clip, Stewart-Binks’ face reddens and her chest breaks out in hives. She begins to cry. “I will spend my entire life trying to make up for this,” she says, wiping away tears with a shaking hand. “I will die trying to make up for this moment that’s clearly not who I am.”

The Gronkowski segment was the defining moment in Stewart-Binks’ four years at FS1 (2013-16). As the clip spread across the internet, FS1 was derided as a “circus act,” but Stewart-Binks took the brunt of the criticism. She was accused of setting back the efforts of women working in sports journalism and betraying feminism entirely. Some of the criticism came from friends and colleagues.

Now, she wants those critics to know why she participated in the segment, and providing that context requires sharing what she says happened to her in the days beforehand.

On Friday, Stewart-Binks, 37, filed a lawsuit in Los Angeles County Superior Court against Fox and Charlie Dixon, an executive vice president and head of content at Fox Sports and FS1, the company’s sports network. In that lawsuit, she alleges that about a week before the Gronkowski segment she was sexually assaulted by Dixon during a meeting at a hotel that he organized under the auspices of talking about her Super Bowl week duties. Dixon is also a defendant in a lawsuit filed earlier this month by former FS1 hairstylist Noushin Faraji. In Faraji’s complaint, she claimed that “executives and talent were allowed to physically and verbally abuse workers with impunity,” and she alleged that Dixon groped her at a co-worker’s birthday party in January 2017, among other allegations.

Dixon did not respond to text, voice and email messages seeking comment. Fox Sports said in a statement: “These allegations are from over eight years ago. At the time, we promptly hired a third-party firm to investigate and addressed the matter based on their findings.”

Days after the alleged assault, when producers in San Francisco told her that FS1 wanted a viral moment out of Gronkowski, she said she never considered the implications of the stunt, only what would happen if she refused with Dixon watching from the set. “I was in a really f—ed-up place that I could not tell people about,” she said.

In her complaint, Stewart-Binks said she detailed the allegations against Dixon to a Fox human resources official in 2017 but that Fox “egregiously made the deliberate decision to protect Dixon and allow a sexual predator to remain an executive at Fox for nearly a decade.”

“They knew and didn’t do anything about it,” Stewart-Binks said in an interview earlier this month. “It meant they didn’t care about the damage done to me and how it affected others.” She then added: “This has been accepted for so long. I’m sitting here wanting it to be different.”


Fox Sports executive vice president Charlie Dixon in 2018. (Travis P. Ball / Getty Images)

Stewart-Binks grew up in Toronto, and her mother was a broadcast reporter and her father worked in the medical device industry. She played right wing on a boys’ house league hockey team and also trained as a figure skater and a cellist.

She attended Queen’s University and obtained degrees in both drama and physical and health education but developed a passion for broadcasting and later got a master’s degree in international broadcast journalism from what is now known as City St George’s, University of London.

Her entry into sports journalism in Canada was scrappy and unglamorous. She covered Ontario Hockey League games on a volunteer basis, staying at a friend’s house in Kingston, then taking a bus to Niagara, where she’d bunk with her grandmother in a retirement community. Later, as a reporter and anchor for CTV in Regina, Saskatchewan, she drove across the Canadian prairies shooting and editing sports television packages on curling and anchoring the nightly newscasts. To save money, she lived out of a friend’s basement.

In 2013, she was plucked out of relative obscurity by an agent at Octagon (the late John Ferriter) and flown to Los Angeles to meet with Fox Sports executives and screen test for the launch of FS1. She was hired by the fledgling network as an update anchor and went on to host “Fox Soccer Daily.” She also worked as a sideline reporter for Major League Soccer, hosted FS1’s coverage of the 2014 Winter Olympics and covered the 2015 FIFA Women’s World Cup. She spent 65 days on the road that summer and was tabbed as one of Awful Announcing’s “Rising Stars.

But, according to her complaint, by early 2016, her allies within FS1 — executives like Scott Ackerson and Rick Jaffe — had departed and a new regime — Dixon and fellow executive Jamie Horowitz — were in place with a new vision for the network.

Stewart-Binks still liked her job. She got to cover soccer and hockey – sports she loved – and work as an anchor and a host. She was part of a tight-knit group that helped launch FS1. But her future was uncertain. The network had until April 1, 2016, to pick up a one-year option in her contract. If it did not, she would lose a high-profile job. She felt she needed to show the Dixon-Horowitz regime that she was a versatile and dynamic talent.

When Whitlock requested her to be a part of his show during the 2016 Super Bowl week, she felt she had an opening to do that. And then Dixon asked her to come to his hotel, writing that he wanted to “go over expectation(s)” before a group meeting the next day, according to her complaint. After receiving that text, Stewart-Binks shared her excitement with a friend about getting face time with her boss and curated her outfit for the meeting – a suede jacket and designer heels – hoping to convey style and professionalism.

The lawsuit sets out in detail how they met at the bar at a hotel in Marina del Rey, Calif. She ordered a single glass of white wine. Dixon asked what she had been told about her role on Whitlock’s show during Super Bowl week. He then told her he didn’t think she should be going to the Super Bowl at all and that she was ill-suited to host and wasn’t funny or interesting or talented enough to draw in viewers.

In an interview, Stewart-Binks said she was shocked and confused by Dixon’s remarks. Why was he denigrating her so strongly, and, just before she went on an important assignment for the network? She tried to stay calm, even when he remarked, according to the complaint, that the only way anyone would be willing to watch her was if she “got up on this bar and took your top off” and then added: “You’re not hot enough to be a hot girl on TV.” She said in her interview with The Athletic that she responded to Dixon: “I didn’t get my master’s degree in ‘hot girl.’”

Stewart-Binks said Dixon’s tone then changed. He stopped criticizing her and asked about her professional aspirations. The complaint states that Dixon then ordered two beers from the bar and urged her to come to his room and drink them, adding that he had a great view from his balcony. She didn’t think it was a good idea, she said in her interview and in the complaint, but she felt she couldn’t say no to her boss.

“You have autonomy over yourself to say ‘no’ and leave. But you don’t, and you say ‘yes’ because he held the power to everything,” Stewart-Binks told The Athletic.

The legal complaint describes Dixon’s shirts – colorful tees with slogans and pictures – laid out on one of the beds in his room. Dixon suggested they step out on the balcony. Once outside, Dixon, according to the complaint, “swiftly pushed her against the wall of the hotel and pinned her arms to her side. With her arms forcefully held down and his body pressed against hers, Dixon tried to force his tongue into her mouth.” Stewart-Binks’ mouth remained shut but Dixon “ignored her, continuing to press against her body and lick her closed mouth. While keeping one of her arms pinned, he moved his other arm from pressing her upper elbow against the wall to her body and towards her chest. Stewart-Binks seized the moment of partial freedom to push him away, say ‘get off of me’ and rapidly leave the hotel room.”

Once in her car, she called the same friend with whom she had earlier shared her excitement about meeting with Dixon. “I remember getting a very upset phone call,” the friend told The Athletic. “It was the overall disappointment of ‘I can’t believe an executive did this.’” Stewart-Binks later called her mother, according to the complaint, and the two women concluded that it would imperil her career if she spoke out about what Dixon had allegedly done.

Stewart-Binks went back to work frightened about the implications of fending off Dixon and also what his remarks about her lack of talent meant for her career going forward. At a meeting the day after the alleged assault, she said Dixon ignored her. She believed her future was “very much hanging in the balance” as she arrived in San Francisco for Super Bowl week. Her anxiety was ramped up by producers there who were hell-bent to “make a moment” that would garner attention, she said.

“I was told … that I was not capable of being able to do a moment like this on television. And that I was not interesting, funny, talented, smart. And so I felt the need to prove that I was all in, and that I was not scared to do something like (the Gronkowski stunt). Had I not (done it), I would have felt like I failed and that I would have confirmed what (Dixon) told me.”

The reaction to her role in the Gronkowski segment surprised and stung her, she said in an interview. People she knew in the industry, some whom she considered friends, were among those voicing their disappointment with her choice to participate. Her co-worker and friend, Katie Nolan, told GQ that she disapproved of the bit. (Nolan later apologized to Stewart-Binks in a podcast and clarified her remarks.) Stewart-Binks recalled receiving a text message from Grant Wahl, the late Sports Illustrated soccer writer she admired, that read: “That’s not who you are.”

Fox promoted the Gronkowski segment on social media and elsewhere. The network got its viral moment. But when the backlash grew strong enough, Fox stopped, and the same men in the production meeting eager to “make a moment” went largely silent. Stewart-Binks’ bosses didn’t address the incident at length until six weeks later; Horowitz said at that time that he was supportive of Stewart-Binks for doing a “fun bit” and thought Gronkowski “maybe … took it a half step too far.”

In her lawsuit, Stewart-Binks said the network instructed her not to comment on the incident, and her agency, CAA, advised her to ride it out. Less than two months after the Super Bowl, Stewart-Binks was informed that Fox would not pick up her contract option with one executive telling her that there was “nothing for her to do here,” according to the complaint.


According to the complaint, Stewart-Binks was contacted by a Fox human resources official in June 2017 and asked about Horowitz’s behavior when Stewart-Binks worked at Fox Sports. Stewart-Binks didn’t have anything substantive to share about Horowitz, but the complaint states that she disclosed to the HR official what Dixon allegedly said to her in their January 2016 meeting and what allegedly happened in his hotel room afterward.

Horowitz was fired following the probe, but Dixon remained at the company.

After Fox, Stewart-Binks worked as a part-time soccer reporter for ESPN, a rinkside reporter for NHL on TNT, a host for BetRivers Sportsbook Network, did stand-up comedy, was a host for the CBC’s 2024 Olympic coverage, among other jobs. She’s continued to scrap to find work but believes the Gronkowski segment has impacted her ability to get other jobs.

When the Faraji lawsuit against Fox and Dixon was filed, Stewart-Binks received text messages from people she had told about her interactions with Dixon. On page eight of the 42-page complaint, there is a reference to a host who reported Dixon to the company. She believed that Faraji, with whom she worked at FS1, was referencing her. Reading about what Faraji allegedly endured was a “tipping point,” Stewart-Binks said. “I didn’t want to hold onto it anymore.”

Stewart-Binks said she has experienced bouts of self-doubt since leaving Fox Sports, Dixon’s criticism of her abilities still ringing in her ears. “I had a different view of what my life would be like than what it is. And I’m very grateful for everything I have. But sometimes I think … well, what could my life have been had this not happened?”

(Top photo: Hatnim Lee for The Athletic)

Looking to calm your nerves? Here are 4 tips from Super Bowl champions

While running out onto the field for the first time before Super Bowl LIV’s kickoff in 2020, Chiefs punter Dustin Colquitt remembers looking up and seeing a piece of trivia on the video board: If the Chiefs win today, Dustin joins his dad, Craig, and brother, Britton, as a Super Bowl champion.

It immediately triggered a bout of overthinking and anxiety.

“Oh crap,” Colquitt thought.

To calm his nerves, he used a simple remedy: a series of breathing exercises on the sideline.

People everywhere deal with similar surges of pressure or nervousness. The professional football players who have made it to the Super Bowl are experiencing those same feelings, but on a public stage, elevated for tens of millions to see. The extremeness of it all forces them to figure out how to conquer those emotions in ways we can also apply ahead of a big job interview, a public speaking engagement or any pressure moment in our lives.

Here are four tips on how to quiet your mind from Super Bowl champions.

Find a helpful distraction

In the middle of Super XLIX in 2015, Seahawks wide receiver Doug Baldwin felt some anxiety creeping in. It was weird to him, after entering the game with what he called an “overwhelming sense of confidence.” But he knew where the anxiety was coming from.

“This may sound silly, but as a receiver, the confidence of being able to catch the ball sometimes leaves you,” he said.

It’s why he had practiced a few techniques ahead of time, one of which he started to do at that moment.

He closed his eyes and stuck his hands out in front of him. Then, using his thumb, he touched each one of his fingertips, one by one, and repeatedly tapped his fingers.

“What it was doing was re-grounding me in that moment,” Baldwin explained. “Kind of helping me get in tune with my body. The simple touching of your fingertips, that sends electro signals throughout your body.”

It also serves as a distraction, something Baldwin knew he needed in pressure-packed moments. Only an hour or two earlier, he preoccupied himself on his phone with his favorite strategy game at the time, “Galaxy On Fire: Alliances.”

“I could distract my mind and go to something that was a little bit more controllable and lighthearted,” he said.

Other Super Bowl champions, like Colquitt, had similar approaches with music. Colquitt said while some of his teammates got ready for big games with loud hype music, he preferred the calmness of Bob Marley and Jimmy Buffett. The consistency of his music selections also helped ease his mind.

“I knew that if I listened to my music, it felt like just another game, just another opponent,” he said.

Breath work can quickly recalibrate you

While preparing to play in the Super Bowl, Colquitt took a moment for himself, like he did before every game, to simply focus on his breathing. With indie rock music still humming in his ears, he started with the number 13.

For 13 seconds, he held his breath, then released his breath slowly for another 13 seconds. Counting down by increments of three, he held his breath for 10 seconds and released it for another 10 seconds. Until he got down to three.

“It would start kind of slowing my heart rate down,” Colquitt said. “In between that and the music, it kept me at a calm or a peace. Just kind of took the nerves out of everything.”

Similarly, before former Steelers guard Willie Colon played in Super Bowl XLIII, he put on his uniform, listened to the song  “Closer” by Goapele on repeat and began to count.

“I would count to 10 and then from 10 go all the way to one and then go all the way back to 10,” he said. “Just counting and focusing on my breathing really calmed my nerves. That was something that always helped me.”

For Patriots cornerback Logan Ryan, breath work was not only helpful before pressure moments, but during them, too.

Ryan was in his second year in the NFL when he made his first Super Bowl in 2015, and even though the Patriots won, he wasn’t pleased with his mentality.

“I found myself playing it safe,” he said. “I didn’t want to be the reason we lost. I just wasn’t taking a risk because I knew what was at stake. I told myself I was never going to play a Super Bowl like that again.”

When he made the Super Bowl with the Patriots a second time, two years later, he resolved to not be afraid of the moment and play fearlessly.

By his third Super Bowl in the final year of his career, this time with the San Francisco 49ers in 2024, he said he was in the “most zen state he ever played a game.”

In large part that was because of breathing techniques he had learned to center himself. Through breath work, he mastered how to track his heart rate and drop it. On the bench during the game, and even on the field before plays, he used the technique to get into a relaxed state.

“Just let it go,” he said. “Don’t be afraid of making a mistake. I really just wanted to be in the moment, and I think the breath work really kept me in the moment.”

Both Ryan and Colon still use breath work to calm their minds before big meetings or broadcasting games.

Visualization can be powerful

Every night before a game, Seahawks linebacker K.J. Wright would take 10 minutes alone. No phone, no TV, just total silence.

For those 10 minutes he would play out the upcoming game in his mind.

“I’d talk to myself,” he said. “I’d say: ‘You’re going to make every tackle. This is what’s coming your way.’ Just bringing that energy to me, bringing that positive success to me. That was a freaking game-changer. I swear by that.”

Another Seahawks linebacker Malcolm Smith, the MVP of Super Bowl XLVIII in 2014, had a slightly different twist. While he prepared during the week for perfection, he also reminded himself before the game that imperfections are part of it and that was OK.

“You knew you were going to make a mistake; it’s not going to be perfect,” he said. “Don’t set the expectation that it’s going to go perfect. You’ll make a mistake, knock it out and just keep going.”

Embrace the big moment

Sometimes the immensity of an opportunity can overwhelm. Both Smith and Baldwin leaned into it.

Smith continuously reminded himself that the hype of the Super Bowl shouldn’t freak him out; it should excite him. He was calmer in that game than any other game he ever played in, he said.

“There was no imposter syndrome because we had proven that we deserved to be there,” Smith said. “Typically if you have a big day, it’s often because you earned that opportunity to be there. That helped me to calm down and be present.”

“Let the moment be the moment,” Baldwin said. “Enjoy the moment and be present with the moment, regardless of what comes in that moment. It’s a very powerful antidote to anxiety and doubt.”

Bruce Arians, who won a Super Bowl in 2021 as the head coach of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, just wanted to be himself. So he did what he always did the night before a game: a couple of drinks and a good night’s sleep. After all, he figured that had been good enough to get him to the Super Bowl.

“I never tried to change,” Arians said. “I tried to stay the same. Just keep the routine the same so there’s no more extra hype.”

(Photo: Grant Halverson / Getty Images)

The revamped Champions League: A success or a Super League devoid of jeopardy?

At a time when some events are banning phones to ensure the audience is properly engaged in the experience, the perceived success of the new Champions League format was instead captured by the image of Aston Villa and Club Brugge players huddled around various devices anxiously checking the scores in Barcelona and Zagreb to see if they’d made the top eight and play-offs respectively.

Wednesday’s scenes at Villa Park and the Etihad Stadium had a palpable charm to them. Here was a modern twist on transistor radios being held to one ear, game-states being passed by word of mouth followed by cheers or curses, progress or elimination. This was presented as a welcome novelty, something that didn’t used to happen in the group stage the league phase has replaced. All hail the league phase!

The broadly positive reception to the new formula called to mind Harry Lime’s immortal line in The Third Man. “In Switzerland, they had brotherly love, they had 500 years of democracy and peace, and what did that produce? The cuckoo clock.” Lime perhaps wouldn’t have been so disdainful if he’d known about the Swiss model, as the new Champions League format is known.

But aside from delivering more money to the clubs, more games to the broadcasters and more revenue to itself, did UEFA’s overhaul work?

There were some great stories during the league phase, from Lille and Brest over-performing to Manchester City’s unexpected psychodrama. Lille, for instance, lost their coach Paulo Fonseca to Milan in the summer and sold their best young player, Leny Yoro, to Manchester United. They needed to go through two preliminary rounds, where they eliminated Jose Mourinho’s Fenerbahce, just to make the league phase.

When Ruben Amorim’s Sporting beat them on the Swiss model’s opening night, most people would have tipped the Lisbon side, not Lille to be the gatecrashers into the top eight. But, no. Lille bounced back to beat champions Real Madrid, then neighbours Atletico. They drew with Juventus and only lost to Liverpool after going down to 10 men.


Remy Cabella celebrates with Ngal’ayel Mukau as Lille thump Feyenoord 6-1 on Wednesday (Rico Brouwer/Soccrates/Getty Images)

But past editions of the Champions League did not lack storylines like Lille’s, so it is hard to attribute theirs to the new format.

Brest, perhaps, benefited from playing eight games and eight different opponents instead of six against three other clubs, as was the case in previous seasons. It feels a long time ago now but the momentum for their qualification to the upcoming play-off round came from a light introduction to Europe’s elite club competition.

To the neutral, their fixtures felt less Champions League and more Austrian Bundesliga or Mitropa Cup in the early months as they beat Sturm Graz and RB Salzburg, then creditably held Bayer Leverkusen to a draw before overcoming Sparta in Prague. It was a heartwarming tale, even if Brest’s Cinderella story was a bit like giving Cinders a dating app with the best possible algorithm to help her find her happy-ever-after.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

The miracle of Brest, a club a world apart from Champions League opponents Real Madrid

They were trumpeted as the second-best new addition to the Champions League. The other was the buzzword of the final night simulcast.

As the competition clashed for the first time with the winter transfer window, the notion of jeopardy was roundly heralded as the Champions League’s best new signing, hyped as a prospect capable of drawing more attention than the usual cast of stars. But, make no mistake, a lot of smoke and mirrors were in use here.

Part of the jeopardy came from missing out on the top eight.

Atalanta and Milan fell out of it on Wednesday. Their punishment? Two more games on their schedule in the play-offs. Is that a penalty? Fans of clubs tend to want to see them in action as much as possible, particularly in the Champions League, so this did not seem much of a penalty. On the contrary, it could be interpreted as a bonus by anyone apart from the coach and the players who have to factor in more effort, preparation and fixture congestion.


Yunus Musah sees red in Zagreb and Milan are beaten – and condemned to play two more games (Marko Lukunic/Pixsell/MB Media/Getty Images)

At one end of the standings, Liverpool could send the kids to play PSV in Eindhoven. At the other, nine teams had already been eliminated before the final gameweek. The bulk of the remainder were either sure of qualification or almost sure of it, which meant the jeopardy was jostling for position in a table so large it felt like watching midfield overtakes in the Indy 500.

As a viewer, it was hard to keep up and stay on track.

The real drama came from the random coincidence of the new format’s introduction with the one season in Pep Guardiola’s 17-year coaching career when his team are spluttering. In the end, though, the extension of the opening phase from six games to eight allowed big clubs like City, who left it last-minute compared with Paris Saint-Germain and Real Madrid, enough rope to pull themselves out of trouble.

It used to be that 10 or 11 points was the benchmark for qualification from a six-game group. Though in 2013, 12 points weren’t enough for Napoli. This time round, in the inaugural league phase, City, Sporting and Club Brugge reached the play-offs with 11 points from two extra matches. Less from more somehow represented progress.


City diced with disaster, left it late, and still reached the play-offs (James Gill – Danehouse/Getty Images)

The tie-breakers were unsatisfactory, too.

While Brugge celebrated in defeat in Manchester, Dinamo Zagreb were downcast in victory at the Maksimir. They had beaten Milan but missed the play-offs on goal difference. It raised the question: is goal difference a fair differentiator when you’ve played a different set of fixtures to, in Dinamo’s case, City, Sporting and Brugge?

Away goals would not represent a perfect solution either, as you don’t play every team home and away.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Eighteen Champions League games, one unusual assignment: watch every match (in five-minute segments)

By playing eight different teams, there is more variety, more curiosity and less sameness. However, the new format throws up another conundrum: when is a league not a league? By not playing everyone, your club’s fixtures can feel abstract and that abstraction could be like lifting the lid on Pandora’s box. Because if home and away isn’t a thing, does it matter where these games are played? Might it open the door to UEFA Champions League fixtures in New York and Riyadh?

We should never forget the original sin of this format change was the challenge posed to UEFA by a Super League. The Swiss model is an open model. It isn’t closed to entry. But it does secure clubs more revenue — albeit not as much as some think they would make in a new competition — and the 16-team play-off round works like a safety net from elimination that keeps the under-performing elite in the competition instead of sending them down to the less lucrative, more tiring Europa League as in previous years.

So as with the illusion of jeopardy, the other trick here — a compromise, really — is that this is a Super League approximating format under UEFA branding.

“Are you not entertained?”

I’ll leave you with the image of Aleksander Ceferin, bloodied by the Super League insurrectionists, throwing his sword onto the Colosseum gravel.

Is it a thumb-up, a thumb-down, or is your fist still hovering uncertainly in the air?

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Champions League play-offs draw analysed: Man City face Real Madrid, relief for Bayern, Milan and Juventus

(Top photo: Michael Regan – UEFA/UEFA via Getty Images)

Five stars, seven figures, zero eligibility: Why are the Bewley twins still paying?

DAYTONA BEACH, Fla. — It’s a scene inside the Lemerand Center on an unfairly cold Wednesday night in early January.

A junior college men’s basketball game is happening in a 1,000-seat gym. Everyone is here for that, including two players who were never supposed to be. But play has been paused. Security is defusing an altercation between the Daytona State College and Santa Fe College women’s hoops teams, who faced off earlier and are now pointing and yelling at each other across the bleachers. One of the Santa Fe players holds back a teammate by yanking on her shirt.

Some of this owes to Daytona State’s baseball squad raising the temperature by sitting behind the visitors bench and trolling them ruthlessly. And now, here come the Santa Fe women, who have been relocated to a section right next to them. The baseball dudes knowingly simmer down. “We don’t want no trouble, guys,” one of them concedes.

But if there’s a trigger to all of it, it’s a tie-up during the first half. A missed shot, some wrestling for the rebound, some choice words and Daytona State’s Ryan Bewley shoving a guy who got in the face of his brother, Matt. That’s when the mercury really jumped. And it brings us to the pertinent question.

What in the world are Matt and Ryan Bewley doing here?

Once upon a time, the 6-foot-9 Bewley twins were the first to hit a new switch on the traditional track for elite basketball talent: Top 15 phenoms who signed with a then-nascent operation called Overtime Elite, exchanging their last two years of high school for training, exposure to scouts and millions of internet eyeballs plus compensation. This was May 2021, one month before a Supreme Court ruling tore down barriers to college athletes profiting off their name, image and likeness (NIL). At the end of two years with Overtime, the Bewleys weren’t ready for the NBA nor eligible to play in the NCAA, fishhooked by the fine print of their choice.

The timing was excruciating.

Why it matters anymore is the issue.

Matt and Ryan Bewley, now 21, started by awing grassroots crowds across Florida. They then went from a throbbing 100,000-square-foot training facility in Atlanta to the far South Side of Chicago and court-ordered basketball purgatory to, on this night, a junior college with 16 women’s golf banners hanging in its gym. They are playing again. There is a joy in that. It helps wash down the thought that NCAA programs blithely use NIL money to make millionaires every year, and it’s completely fine. And they’re the ones paying, still.

“People think me and him just fell off the face of the earth,” Matt Bewley says. “It low-key feels like we’re the only people in the world that are going through what we’re going through.”


If the Bewley boys from Fort Lauderdale were not a figurative tag team, born a minute apart and bonded at every step in their basketball lives, they might have been an actual tag team. They were professional wrestling fans growing up, and that might be underselling it. “Bro,” Matt says, “that’s all we did.” They each can recite their top five all-time grapplers (the Undertaker and “Stone Cold” Steve Austin make both lists), and their enthusiasm occasionally broke the barrier to reality, among other things. Neither is sure who tried to powerbomb whom. They do remember the smashed window, their father asking what happened, and both of them shrugging and saying they didn’t know.

“We got in trouble so many times,” Ryan says. “Broke the bed. Broke the window. Couple of walls have holes in them.”

Given that, and given that they were both 6 feet tall by age 10, it is no shock their mother, Marlene, decided to funnel her kids’ energy into something constructive. They started organized basketball at age 11 in a rec league at the city of Tamarac Community Center. Within a couple years, the Bewleys caught the eye of a local trainer who started working with them daily. By eighth grade, they’d joined Team Breakdown, a prominent Florida grassroots program.

During the summer before their ninth-grade year, they played up against 17U competition at AAU events, leading the world in double-takes induced and creating their own mythology. The Bewleys received power-conference scholarship offers from Iowa State, Florida and South Florida before they attended their first high school class. “They were like grown men playing against little kids,” says Eddie Placer, a guard from Orlando who is now a teammate at Daytona State. “That’s what it looked like out there.”

“We always compared them to the X-Men,” says Gerald Gillion, who has known the Bewleys since they were 13 and who served as Chicago State’s head coach for their one year on campus. “Really powerful mutants that, in the right situation, can do some very, very good things.”

Following two dunk-filled seasons at two different Florida high schools, the road forked. A new venture built by the media company Overtime, one that counted Amazon founder Jeff Bezos and more than 25 NBA players among its initial investors, made its pitch: Complete a high school education while training and playing at an academy in Atlanta, receiving exposure from a brand with a combined social media audience of more than 50 million people. Overtime Elite offered a minimum $100,000 salary plus bonuses and company stock to any player willing to take the leap. The aggressively untraditional terms were no secret. System disruption was the entire point.

Ryan Bewley was on board, primed for something more than Florida high school competition. “Iron sharpens iron,” he says now.

Matt Bewley was not, struggling with the idea of leaving home and friends behind. “I just felt like I was growing up too fast,” he says.

A visit to Overtime Elite’s facilities and reconsidering how reported seven-figure contracts would impact, well, everything in life recalibrated his thinking. The family likewise took into account the uncertainty of post-pandemic basketball in Florida and weighed it against predictable high-end training — “A path to getting to the league,” their father, Prince, says — combined with a centralized education structure and small class sizes. “It encompassed everything we needed,” Marlene says.

On May 21, 2021, the news release dropped: Five-Star Prospects Matt and Ryan Bewley Make History as First Signings for Overtime Elite. “Signing these two great pillars for our program is an exciting beginning,” Brandon Williams, the organization’s head of basketball operations, said in the statement. Every report about the deal included a note that the Bewleys were forfeiting high school and NCAA eligibility. (In the very next recruiting cycle, Overtime Elite offered prospects a plan for joining while also maintaining an ability to play Division I basketball.)

It can be true that teenagers may not be altogether concerned with details — “I don’t think anybody at that age can understand the repercussions of anything,” Matt says — and also that obliviousness is not an out. “Going into it, the eligibility part of it, maybe at that particular time, I didn’t completely understand,” Marlene says.

Says Prince Bewley: “What sold me was, every day, the training, the facility, the coaches, the environment was to train these guys like an NBA-type thing. But they’re high school players. That’s it.”

Exactly one month later, the Supreme Court upheld a lower court’s ruling in NCAA v. Alston that cleared the way for college athletes to profit off NIL. It might’ve been a footnote in the Bewleys’ story had their chosen route worked out. It didn’t. Overtime Elite fulfilled its promise of development and exposure; 20 of the original 26 players to sign have spent time on professional rosters somewhere worldwide. (And one is a football player at Georgia.) The Bewleys simply did not rise to that level. They scored and rebounded but also averaged less than an assist per game and didn’t make a single 3-pointer between them in the 2022-23 campaign. They were not pro prospects. Not yet. They were, in fact, provided the option to spend a third year with Overtime Elite. Instead, they decided to make a run at Division I college basketball, against the headwinds of their choices, insisting that they do not regret them.

“Obviously, there are situations you go through in life where you’re like, damn, I should have made a different decision,” Matt Bewley says. “But nah, I feel like it’s just part of the story. That’s all it is. Wherever else we go, wherever this takes us, it’s just part of the story.”

They turned the corner and ran over traffic spikes. The Bewleys signed with Chicago State, a Division I program with a sympathetic coach in Gillion and zero winning seasons since 1986. They were heralded as “once-in-a-generation-type talents” who would have an “immediate impact.” The Bewleys applied for amateur certification in June 2023 and, later that month, the NCAA informed the school they were unlikely to get it. On Oct. 31 — one week before the first regular-season game — the NCAA made it official: non-certified. In short, the NCAA ruled the Bewleys had made too much money, beyond its acceptable limits for amateurs.

The Bewleys filed a federal antitrust lawsuit the next day, seeking a temporary restraining order and injunction against the NCAA. A judge in the U.S. District Court of Chicago denied them on Nov. 14. After a December hearing, the judge then denied the Bewleys’ request for reconsideration and a preliminary injunction on Jan. 14, 2024, concluding that they “have not established a likelihood of success on their claims that (the NCAA’s) bylaws are unreasonably anticompetitive or restrictive.”

The door wasn’t dead-bolted shut. It was removed and replaced with a concrete wall. The Bewleys were seemingly the only people to sue the NCAA and lose.

“You know how you have that passion for something?” Ryan Bewley says now. “And that love for something? And it just gets taken away from you? … And you keep trying and trying and trying, and people are in your ear saying, it’s going to get better, it’s going to get better — and it doesn’t get better. It’s like, aw, man, your hopes are too high.”

They now couldn’t play competitive basketball while marooned on a campus a good 30-minute drive away from anything interesting. “Some days, I cried,” Ryan says. The judge’s initial ruling bruised them so badly, they declined to accompany Chicago State to the Cancun Challenge in November; by 2024, they couldn’t travel with the team even if they wanted to. “Me and him were legit depressed,” Matt Bewley says. When they did join everyone in the gym, the Bewleys served as high-end scout-teamers. “Practice dummies,” as Ryan puts it, and they admit their personal investment levels dropped accordingly.

“It was so bad I used to be scared to even go to the park and play a pickup game,” Matt says. “Because I’m just like, yo, I haven’t done anything.”

At the end of the school year, the Bewleys returned to Florida and entered the NCAA’s transfer portal. Maybe they could join Gillion at Long Island University, where he’d taken an associate head coach spot. High-major coaches called, Marlene says, trying to sort out the twins’ status. But weeks went by. Nothing changed, and no one wanted to risk another year of idle exile. Matt considered quitting basketball. He figured he’d find something, he says now, that tall people could do.

It was mid-summer when Joey Cantens, the head coach at Daytona State College, logged into a database that ranks the available players in the portal. He noticed two familiar names near the top of the list.

On a whim, Cantens called Gillion, whom he’d known for almost two decades.

“Hey,” Cantens asked, “what are the twins doing?”


A few weeks after competing in a U20 European championship tournament in July as Great Britain’s point guard, and a few days after settling in for a year of junior college basketball in the United States, Tyrese Lacey arrived at the doors of the Lemerand Center to let his coach in the building. The sight of two extremely large humans flanking Cantens staggered him. On the elevator ride to the second floor, Lacey confirmed that, yes, in fact, these extremely large humans were related.

The elevator doors opened. The tour continued. You know they’re the Bewley twins, the Birmingham, England, native was told, expectantly.

“I’m like, ‘Who the hell are the Bewley twins?’” Lacey says now.

That was the question, wasn’t it?

In August 2024, two former five-star prospects were at the doorstep of an 11,000-student commuter school with a $3,100 tuition for Florida residents. Three years removed from famously upending an ecosystem. A year and a half removed from competitive basketball. Walking existential crises. When the Bewleys first entered the transfer portal in the spring of ’24, junior colleges across the country reached out to gauge their interest. The brothers didn’t reply. “I’m like, obviously me and him are never going to juco,” Matt says.

But eligibility in this realm works differently. The Bewleys could play. Immediately. Unless they intended to spend another season in suspended animation, they were out of alternatives.

“This is literally the purpose of community college,” Cantens says, “is to serve kids like them.”

Daytona State offered a soft landing to boot. Cantens was an energetic 38-year-old with experience as a Division I staffer at both Florida Gulf Coast and USC, whose Daytona State teams had won 55 of 63 games the previous two years while deploying a high-tempo, 3-pointer-heavy modern offense. Most critically? The Miami native played for the same AAU program as the Bewleys. He knew the people they knew. “That’s just family,” is how Matt puts it. As for the infrastructure, the twins could do far worse. A $16 million residence hall, opened in 2022 and steps away from the gym entrance, housed athletes. The cafeteria, not much farther away, served three meals a day. There was a stash of nutritional snacks available every day and an athletic trainer who whipped up post-workout smoothies. No strength coach or video coordinator. No zero-gravity treadmills or charter flights. But hardly a basketball skid row.

In a lower corner of the whiteboard in Cantens’ office, there’s a program mantra scribbled in black ink: This is a transient program for future pros. Not a dead end program for losers. “We start practice and if you’re not here an hour and a half early, doing your lift routine, your stretch routine, your shooting routine, if you’re not getting protein after practice — I have a problem with you,” Cantens says. “Because you’re not setting yourself up for success.”

The Bewleys signed on. How it would go was a cliffhanger for everyone.

Weary after the previous three years and wary of more disappointment, the twins kept to themselves in the early days. “You could tell there was still a dark spot there,” Lacey says. They’d sat on the couch in Cantens’ office and insisted that all they wanted was to be part of a team and chase a championship. Cantens didn’t totally buy it, suspicious the Bewleys were parroting some well-rehearsed lines from Overtime Elite media training. Someone like Isaiah Dorceus, a guard who didn’t have gaudy rankings and who isn’t 6-9 and who had one year left to prove worthy of a Division I roster spot, simply didn’t want anyone to wreck the good vibes.

Pickup games riddled with trash talk chipped away at the twins’ shells. So did team trips to the beach. Two players who admittedly don’t get up early for much of anything submitted to 5 a.m. workouts. They also forged ahead when it became clear their conditioning levels were not 5 a.m. workout-ready. (“I think the first workout, I made Matt throw up,” Cantens says.) It wasn’t long before the Bewleys were just two more players at Daytona State with bendy-straw career paths.

“They live in the dorms like everybody else, they eat in the cafeteria like everybody else, they get yelled at by me like everybody else,” Cantens says. “And they do a good job of cheering their teammates. And when you see that, you realize, OK, this is real. They really just want to be part of something that they missed.”

As Ryan Bewley puts it, simply: “I’m having that joy again, you know?”

To be clear: They absolutely want something more. They believe they are future NBA players.

But functional jump shots and defensive awareness, not pro roster spots, are the next rungs on the ladder. Seeing the Bewleys play is seeing the possibilities everyone sees. Matt’s end-to-end speed and chin-at-the-iron vertical on lobs. Ryan’s raw feel that, if honed properly, could make him an enviable offensive facilitator at his size. It is the stuff that draws coaches from Illinois, LSU, Penn State, St. Bonaventure, James Madison, Vermont and more to this outpost on the Florida coast, just in case.

It’s also seeing the hitch at the top of Matt’s jumper and realizing he hasn’t attempted a 3-pointer all season for a reason. It’s seeing Ryan hoist shots from the side of his head, almost like a catapult, casting at least a little doubt on the translatability of his 35.7 percent 3-point shooting. The numbers — 10 points and six rebounds in 18 minutes per game for Ryan, 9.5 points and five rebounds in 12.8 per game for Matt — are fine. They don’t obscure the truth.

“If you don’t allow them to play at a four-year school, their only chance to get developed is at a juco, for two years,” Cantens says. “At that point you better be ready to play for money overseas, somewhere. Unfair to them. Everybody else gets four or five years. (They) only get two to figure it out.”

Matt and Ryan Bewley can’t play major college basketball.

And they probably need to.


In a second-floor conference room that’s also used for film study and reheating leftovers, at a junior college occupying a few acres between a spring break mecca and the world’s most famous speedway, a modern college basketball conundrum is relitigated.

The Bewleys believe what they received for what they did at Overtime Elite — playing basketball that a media entity turned into content, signing Topps cards via Overtime’s licensing agreement with that company, doing photo shoots for other sponsors, and more — is equivalent to NIL compensation. The courts didn’t buy it. The Bewleys voluntarily dismissed their lawsuit in April 2024 but plan to refile based on the upcoming House v. NCAA settlement, after which schools effectively will pay student-athletes via revenue sharing. “That wedge the NCAA wants to put between Matt and Ryan and other athletes is getting smaller and smaller as the NIL world continues to develop,” says Dominique Price, the twins’ Chicago-based attorney. The Bewleys likely have exhausted the NCAA’s traditional paths to eligibility reinstatement already. (An NCAA spokesperson says the organization cannot comment on individual student-athletes.)

In the meantime, the No. 1 recruit in the Class of 2025, forward AJ Dybantsa, will play for BYU next season after receiving an NIL package reported to be worth at least $5 million.

“I don’t think it’s fair at all,” Matt says. “I never said this out loud, but I’m going to say this: It feels like everybody is living their life because of me and Ryan. You see NIL. You see all this other stuff. I think the reason why there even is an NIL is because of me and Ryan.”

“They’re getting paid to play,” Ryan says. “It doesn’t make any sense.”

The saga isn’t a regular conversation topic among their teammates. But there are thoughts on it at Daytona State, where the idea of opportunity is a little deeper and a little more desperate.

“It’s messed up that they’re going through this,” Placer says.

“Nothing should be stopping players from being able to play at the next level, in something they love to do,” Dorceus says.

“They’ve made money. But (other) people are making money as well,” Lacey says. “So what’s the issue now? What’s the difference? Because they signed it a bit earlier? They did their punishment. They did a year off. They didn’t play that year, and people were getting money that year. What is the difference now? Let the boys play.”

The next night, after all the hostilities end against Santa Fe College, Matt and Ryan Bewley walk past a locker room whiteboard framed by motivational placards — “WHAT DOES IT TAKE TO BREAK YOU” is a little on the nose — and inspect the box score. Once Cantens finishes his postgame remarks, the twins bring some concerns to assistant coach David Watkins.

Ryan is confused about having zero blocked shots. Matt insists his rebound count is too low. Watkins laughs. He promises he’ll check the film, but it doesn’t appear the Bewleys will let this go. All they have is what they do here.

Maybe something changes. Maybe all the gray burns off and lets some light in. “I’m spiritual anyways,” Prince Bewley says. “I’m hoping for a miracle.” Failing that or a favorable judge’s ruling, they’ll reassess and consider testing the NBA Draft waters for feedback or exploring overseas options or just staying put. For now, though? There is nothing else but what happens in a place they never expected to be.

“Hey,” Matt Bewley says, “we’re all trying to claw to the top together.”

(Illustration: Demetrius Robinson / The Athletic; photos: Courtesy of Daytona State College; Michael Conley / Associated Press)

Man City’s Premier League charges – exploring what their past cases and evidence reveals

On February 6, 2023, Manchester City were charged by the Premier League with more than 100 breaches of the competition’s rules.

As champions in six of the past seven seasons, the eventual verdict of an independent commission will have a seismic impact on the Premier League, regardless of which way their decision goes.

Each of the 115 (or more accurately 129) charges is related to the competition’s financial fair play rules, which are complicated and ever-changing — with both sides fighting tooth and nail over the details of each alleged breach.

One key part of the evidence in the bundle is internal emails from Manchester City, published by German newspaper Der Spiegel, which suggest potential wrongdoing. These formed the basis of a UEFA case against City — where the club were initially found guilty, before being cleared in July 2020 by the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS). You can read that ruling in full here.

In the latest case, the Premier League has since gathered what it believes is further evidence through the process of disclosure. City have insisted throughout the process that they have not broken any regulations.

That hearing is now over and the three-person panel has gone away to make its judgment. Its decision is expected before the end of the season.

But it is worth explaining exactly what it will be ruling on, so here is an explanation of the charges, broken down, using all the publicly available information and rulings about City’s case and graphic illustrations of the key points.


Fifty-four charges of failure to provide accurate financial information

These charges range over nine seasons, the longest such span of the alleged breaches. A complicating factor is that Premier League rules on this subject are often subtly revised, meaning the information City had to provide might have changed each season.

Generally, this addresses the demand for clubs to release financial information in order to demonstrate their adherence to FFP. Think of it like declaring all of your income so that a correct tax amount can be calculated — failure to do so is an offence.

The below graphic, like all others in this article, is based on the published judgment by the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS), with its context and the page it refers to noted above each excerpt.

Fifty-four charges are a lot, but they are all governed by the same principle.

Each individual charge in this section — for example, in 2014-15, City are accused of breaching six Premier League laws — relates to the specifics of what they were expected to provide information on. These include separate financial areas such as revenue, related parties, and operating costs. Effectively, City are alleged to have breached five or six clauses every year for nine years.

But rather than 54 separate cases, there is one key broader question at hand: were all of these figures accurate? To get specific: were Abu Dhabi-owned City reporting the true revenue they were gaining from sponsorship deals with Abu Dhabi-linked companies as they maintain, or only declaring part of it?

Discussion in the Der Spiegel emails as published in the CAS ruling shows City executives discussing cashflow between sponsors and the football club, as well as what they were expected to show for auditing purposes. Under Premier League rules, City were expected to provide “(in) the utmost good faith, accurate financial information that gives a true and fair view of the club’s financial position”.

Initially, Manchester City were found guilty by UEFA’s adjudicatory chamber, which stated it was “comfortably satisfied” that City “did not truthfully declare their sponsorship income as payments purportedly made by sponsors were in reality payments from (owners) ADUG or (Sheikh Mansour).”


City subsequently appealed the case to CAS, arguing that UEFA, European football’s governing body, was misreading the emails.

In the CAS case, though found guilty by the initial panel, the appeal committee found that they could not consider the legitimacy of the alleged payments from Etisalat because they were time-barred — a barrier which is not expected to affect the Premier League, according to legal experts consulted by The Athletic.

The CAS panel decided that evidence related to the Etisalat sponsorships was time-barred, meaning they could not consider it when making their final judgment.

Two of CAS’ three-man panel dismissed the main charges that City had received disguised payments through Etihad and Etisalat, finding that all claims relating to payments from Etisalat were time-barred, as were some of those from Etihad, and that in any event, the charge of providing incorrect information had not been established.

The Premier League is unlikely to be blocked by time-barring rules in the same way UEFA was, while it is also understood that the legal process of disclosure has resulted in it gaining additional documents than those UEFA had.

If the commission finds on “the balance of probabilities” that City failed to provide accurate financial information, based on misreporting the origin of sponsorship money, the club will be found guilty.


Fourteen charges of failure to provide accurate details for player and manager payments

This is another alleged example of failing to share correct information for FFP purposes but differs slightly. Rather than being accused of injecting funds into the club by disguising it as sponsorship deals, here City are charged with hiding money being paid out to players and coaches.

Effectively, this has the advantage of being off-the-books, meaning portions of salaries would not count under the FFP cap. The Premier League alleges this occurred between 2009 and 2016.

The most high-profile examples discussed in the leaks from Der Spiegel relate to alleged payments made to manager Roberto Mancini and midfielder Yaya Toure during their days at the club.


(Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images)

In Mancini’s case, City’s then manager signed a deal with Abu Dhabi club Al Jazira — owned, like City, by Sheikh Mansour — which would pay him £1.75million annually for a minimum of four days’ work per year. The Premier League will claim this constituted part of his City salary, with executives at the club (including the chief financial officer and head of finance) sharing emails related to the Al Jazira payments. Mancini and City have always denied any wrongdoing.

With Toure, the questions relate to image-rights payments allegedly made by Sheikh Mansour’s Abu Dhabi United Group (ADUG) rather than City themselves, and subsequently were not declared as salary. As with Mancini, club and player deny any wrongdoing.


Seven (or 21…) charges of breaching profit and sustainability rules

The exact subject matter here is slightly less certain; it is based on information gathered during the Premier League’s investigation rather than the leaked emails. The charges can be split into alleged breaches over three seasons: 2015-16, 2016-17 and 2017-18.

Arguably, this is where it is more accurate to use 129 charges rather than 115 to describe the total number of offences allegedly committed by City. The Premier League has charged them with breaching seven PSR rules in each of those three seasons — during early explanations of the case, these were grouped as a total of seven charges rather than added together to make 21.

The Premier League has not engaged with the media on any aspect of the case since February 2023, including confirming the current number of charges.

While Everton and Nottingham Forest were also charged with breaching PSR rules, their situations are not directly comparable with City’s — those two clubs were subject to an updated Premier League rulebook from 2022-23 onwards and their cases only related to whether they exceeded the maximum allowable loss, where the rules in their entirety are far broader.


Guardiola’s side are still awaiting their fate, but City deny any wrongdoing (James Gill – Danehouse/Getty Images)

Regardless, the Premier League’s historic PSR rules indicate areas in which it may seek to prove wrongdoing by City.

For example, Rule E.53.2.2 states that a PSR balance sheet should be “to the best of the club’s knowledge and belief, an accurate estimate of future financial performance”. If any of the charges already discussed should be upheld, it is clear how City may be in breach.

Rules E.54-57 relate to related party transactions, which are relevant to the Abu Dhabi-linked sponsorship deals City are alleged to have illicitly struck.

Finally, Rule E.59 relates to the well-known “losses in excess of £105million” limit — again, if previously discussed charges are upheld, a recalculation of City’s PSR submissions with the new figures may find them in breach of this permitted total.


Five charges of failing to comply with UEFA’s FFP regulations

In 2014, City made a deal with UEFA after £118.75million of sponsorship was questioned and the club’s own accounting was rejected. Their settlement saw City repay UEFA €20m from TV revenue, as well as submitting themselves to future spending guardrails. City publicly announced their displeasure with UEFA’s findings.

These charges, however, are slightly different, beginning in the 2013-14 season and continuing until 2017-18. In some sense, this predominantly comes under UEFA’s remit, but the Premier League has its own rules requiring that clubs also follow the continental ones — these are the laws that City are alleged to have broken.

The Premier League has not explained exactly which UEFA rules it is referring to. For example, Rule B.15.6, as it stood from 2014-15 until 2017-18, simply reads: “Membership of the league shall constitute an agreement between the league and each club to be bound by and comply with the statutes and regulations of UEFA”.

But it is likely to relate to the possibility that if City’s true PSR numbers are found to be different to their publicly declared ones, they break UEFA’s maximum-allowable-loss restrictions as well as those of the Premier League.


Thirty-five charges of failing to cooperate with Premier League investigations

This is straightforward to explain, although 35 is another very high number.

Simply put, the Premier League accuses City of breaking numerous rules related to “acting in good faith” since its investigation began in 2018 — the charges relate to each of the seasons from 2018-19 to 2022-23, inclusive.

They were found to have done similar by UEFA.

Specific rules City are alleged to have broken include the failure to release documents to the Premier League by insisting they are confidential, and not providing “full, complete, and prompt assistance to the (Premier League) board”. City expressed their surprise at this during the initial public comments following the charges, “given the extensive engagement and vast amount of detailed materials that the EPL has been provided with”.

To get some sense of the mood of this process, one witness who had already been spoken to by City’s lawyers described it as “hardcore”, “aggressive”, and “no-holds-barred” — though this is more illustrative of the enmity between the two sides rather than specifically related to non-cooperation.

Initially, the CFCB hearing found that City had breached Article 56 of its laws by failing to provide requested information and at one point advancing a case that the club’s ownership “must have known to be false”.

City appealed to CAS, stating they did not need to authenticate the leaked emails and arguing they went beyond what was needed in helping the panel.

City's lawyers told CAS they had cooperated as far as was reasonable and had no need to authenticate leaked emails.

However, the CAS upheld the decision of the CFCB, pointing to the club’s failure to provide witnesses, complete copies of the leaked emails, and prevaricating over the identity of the mysterious “Mohamed”.


What comes next?

With closing arguments made on December 6, the three-person commission is now compiling its verdict. The identity of that panel has been tightly guarded.

There is no set time frame on how quickly it must reach a decision, unlike last season’s PSR cases involving Everton and Forest. Those cases took around a month to reach their judgments, while City’s case is far more wide-reaching and complex.

Nevertheless, all parties expect a decision to be released before the end of the season. With the process governing a case of this scope effectively unprecedented, it is not clear whether City, if guilty, will immediately be given their punishment or whether that will be finalised at a later date. City have denied any wrongdoing throughout.

Both sides have the right to appeal any verdict. English (and European) football awaits.

(Top photos: Getty Images; design: Eamonn Dalton)

For Palisades High players, baseball offers normalcy amid a charred L.A. landscape

CHEVIOT HILLS, Calif. — The Palisades Charter High School J.V. baseball team huddled on the all-dirt infield of their temporary home, a makeshift venue for a displaced team. The playing surface and outfield grass were patchy and uneven. With no mound, its primary use was for softball.

But it was what they had to work with. And the tragic circumstances — a fire that ravaged their school and city — that led them to this spot mattered little in that moment. What was important? The varsity captain, Ryan Hirschberg, was displeased with the junior varsity group’s effort and focus during their joint practice.

“The only reason, J.V., that you had to run today, is that you weren’t paying attention,” Hirschberg told the team after practice had ended.

“It’s not because we want to make you guys run. If we mess up, we’ll run too.”

Hirschberg is running players-only practices until coaches are allowed to join in early February, and so he did his job. Scolded them for it, then watched as they all ran mandatory sprints past the outfield and onto an adjacent field.

At that moment, this practice felt very serious. The consequences of failure felt legitimate. And there would be real punishments for not locking in on the purpose of their presence at Cheviot Hills Recreation Center, a public park the city had permitted the team to use to prepare for their season.

But in many ways, baseball didn’t matter. How could it for Ian Sullivan? A lefty pitcher whose home burned down, the fire taking with it all of his tangible childhood memories. How could it for Jett Teegardin? A junior infielder who visited his burned-down neighborhood a day later, before returning to the hotel that’s become a temporary home.

Yet in this moment, baseball mattered more than anything because they wanted it to matter. The Palisades fire upended life for all 38 baseball players who populate the J.V. and varsity rosters. They’ve come together to support one another through a traumatic experience. They don’t know where they’ll play this year, or with what uniforms or equipment, but they are determined to field a team, have their season, and now, with added meaning, compete for a championship. Baseball, for them, is a brief escape from tragedy. But it is also a chance to do something for a community that desperately needs something to rally around.

“Situations like this build character, and they show people who you are,” said Hirschberg, who has donated clothes, organized practice, started a GoFundMe that’s raised $13,000 and simply been a friend to teammates who need one.

“People don’t get to see the best of you in the best of times. It’s the worst of times where you have to show people who you are.”


On Tuesday, Jan. 7, a now infamous fire overtook the Palisades and other neighborhoods in Los Angeles. It killed dozens and destroyed thousands of homes, charring the lives and worldly possessions of everyone in its wake.

The high school — which has been used as a set for films like “Freaky Friday” and shows like “Modern Family” — was significantly damaged. And while much of the baseball field remains intact, the surrounding area was heavily impacted. The facility is inaccessible. The uniforms and equipment within it are likely unusable.


The area around Palisades Charter High School was heavily damaged. (Genaro Molina / Los Angeles Times via Getty Images)

Head coach Mike Voelkel doesn’t know where they’ll play home games this season — the hope is a mix of Loyola Marymount University, UCLA and other local colleges — but it doesn’t matter. His team will play every game on the road, if it comes to that.

“I told the kids, I said, ‘We’re playing. I don’t care how,” Voelkel recalled. “We’ll go get T-shirts if we have to. For recovery, for wellness. For the promotion of a young kid’s development. It’s important that you get back out there.

“Some people have a tendency to dwell on it, or play the victim. Those are the kind of people that stay there, sometimes the rest of their lives. I was going to do everything I could to get our kids back on the field.”

Voelkel, who lives south of the Palisades, remembers waking from a nap on the afternoon the fires began. He’d already received an email that morning instructing staff to not come ito work.

His TV was tuned to Spectrum News, where he saw California governor Gavin Newsom in the Palisades on his screen. It was then he realized just how concerning the situation could become.

He began contacting players and their families, many of whom were evacuating. A coach of 18 years, Voelkel had put so much emotional and physical labor into that team and facility. He spent that day not knowing if it would all be over.

Classes at Pali High, as it’s known colloquially, have since shifted to being completely online. But the physical separation didn’t stop his team from immediately jumping into action to help each other. Voelkel’s wife, Norma, who works in real estate, started working to make sure everyone had a place to stay.

Players were delivering supplies to their teammates. One player drove to the home of another who was out of town to collect essentials, in case the fire eventually got to them too. Major prominent companies and people started reaching out to offer supplies. Los Angeles Dodgers manager Dave Roberts said he and some players are planning to attend a practice in the near future. The team also donated baseballs. Cincinnati Reds pitcher and L.A. native Hunter Greene donated cleats. The Pali High basketball team received tickets to Los Angeles Lakers-Golden State Warriors from Steve Kerr, who is an alum.

The support is appreciated; it doesn’t erase the trauma of having their season and lives turned upside down, the tragedy still playing out as this baseball team immediately works to rebuild. When they do take the field again, their new jerseys will have a “Pali Strong” patch stitched on them.

Voelkel was asked what this season will mean, but cut off the question before it could be completed.

“A victory,” he said flatly, so assured in the answer.

“To take all of this stuff. To piece it together. To get our families taken care of. There’s so many things. I’d like to win games, I’m very competitive. But in this situation, you have to look at the whole. There are other things that far, far outweigh the winning.”


The practice uniform on Jett Teegardin’s back was delivered to him days prior by Hirschberg. It’s one of the only sets of clothes he has.

He packed to leave for two days max, believing he and his mom would have a home to return to soon. That night, they looked at their Ring doorbell camera and saw embers flying around the neighborhood.

The next day, he returned to a home that no longer existed. Even the contents of their fireproof safe were destroyed. The neighbors he grew to love are now displaced with their community gone.

“It’s very hard. You picture yourself in your house, your room, everything that’s gone,” Teegardin said. “I was a sperm donor baby. So I didn’t really have a father figure. I’m just trying to be there for my mom, mainly. Throughout every situation, I’ve always tried to be there for her.

“Me talking to her to make sure she’s OK, makes me OK. Knowing she’s OK makes me 10 times better.”

When Ian Sullivan thinks about what he’s lost, his mind goes to his game balls. The one he earned when he was 8 years old. The yearbooks, trophies, pins from his trip to Cooperstown, N.Y. — all the relics of his childhood.

On the day he was ordered to evacuate, Sullivan thought the winds would blow the fire in the opposite direction. His parents were working, so he packed family photos, their cat and dog, then left, thinking it would be a short departure.

Instead, a week after the fire, Sullivan and 12 of his friends from fifth grade met up at a friend’s house in Calabasas. Nearly all of their homes had been destroyed. The meet-up served as a chance to be together.

“It’s a dark time right now, but light will always shine through the dark.,” he said. “The Palisades is going to be back. I feel like I’m not just playing for myself and my teammates, but I’m playing for my town, and my home.”

After the fire, Sullivan and Teegardin sent a group text message to everyone on the team. They knew that teammates might be cautious around them, given their circumstances. Sending the text, they hoped, would break down that wall.

“If this fire isn’t something to light your ass, to get you motivated to win this year, then I don’t know what is,” they wrote.

The responses started flooding in. “Hell yeah,” one sent. People that never contributed before were co-signing the messages with encouragements of their own.

“I think everyone’s more motivated than ever,” Teegardin said. “That was everyone’s spark to try their best. … We have to win now. We have to do this for us, and for our coach.

“This fire, it’s brought us a lot closer.”


It was a picturesque Wednesday afternoon, the sun just beginning to set over the practice, as a parkgoer approached the practice, curious about what was happening.

This was a regular occurrence, according to the players. People were curious for more information about what they were dealing with.

This man, with his dog, approached the gate separating the field and the sidewalk. He asked Sullivan, who was there rehabbing his injured arm, what team they were with. A conversation ensued — talk of the fire, lost homes and the upcoming season. The chit-chat was so relaxed and friendly, almost non-reflective of its subject matter.

“Good luck,” he said to Sullivan. “It’s so horrible.”

A father, Joe Stanley, had driven three of the players to practice. He sat, watching intently from the top row of the bleachers, donning a cap from the team.

“I think it’s resilience and pride, definitely. These kids are like a family,” Stanley said. “They spend a lot of time together and are a tight-knit group. This is great. They need this.”

There’s a feeling of normalcy to it all. But even amid that lull, these kids are keenly aware of their reality. Jude De Pastino, a junior, said that everyone on his team is experiencing trauma, even if they don’t feel it yet. Practice, he said, brings some normalcy.

In the first four days after the fire, he was “in a state of shock.” He traveled into the Palisades with a group of friends who’d all lost their homes. Logan Bailey, a senior captain who did the same, said he saw live wires zapping in the street, with telephone poles burning down. He said it appeared almost surreally cinematic.

“It’s beyond what you can imagine, pictures really don’t do it justice,” De Pastino said. “Our whole lives as we know it have quite literally been flattened.”

The group huddled again, just before the sun fully set, after nearly three hours of practice. Parents’ cars started filling the parking lot, waiting to pick up their sons. This reprieve was special. It was needed, and it will continue almost daily until the season starts in late February.

But for now, that reprieve was ending. And real life, scarier and more uncertain now than it’s ever been, was once again awaiting them.

“This is one of those stories you tell on your deathbed,” Bailey said. “You can be as old as it gets, and it still never leaves your mind. It’s going to stick with everyone here, for the rest of their lives.”

(Illustration: Demetrius Robinson, The Athletic; Photos: Josh Edelson / AF via Getty Images, Sam Blum)

Ahead of 2025 debut, Scottie Scheffler details how he hurt hand in ‘stupid’ kitchen accident making ravioli

PEBBLE BEACH, Calif. — Scottie Scheffler was attempting to make homemade ravioli on Christmas Day — with limited equipment in a rental home — when he realized he’d made a serious mistake. He decided to use an empty wine glass to shape and slice his pasta dough.

“I had my hand on top of it and it broke, which, side note, I’ve heard nothing but horror stories since this happened about wine glasses, so be careful,” Scheffler said Tuesday. “Even if you’re like me and you don’t drink wine, you’ve got to be real careful with wine glasses.”

The stem of a wine glass stabbed Scheffler in the upper palm of his right hand. That’s the crux of the incident that led to a surgical procedure and took the 2024 PGA Tour Player of the Year out of his first two tournaments of the season, The Sentry in Maui and the American Express in Palm Springs.

The No. 1 player in the world is making his first tournament start of 2025 this week at the Pebble Beach Pro-Am, which begins on Thursday. It comes after a two-week long hiatus from golf and physical activity, as well as a steady process of easing back into training and playing. That period was frustrating for a player who thrives in competition. Scheffler doesn’t like to sit back and watch.

“It’s one of those deals where immediately after it happened, I was mad at myself because I was like gosh, that’s so stupid, but you just don’t think about it when you’re in the moment,” he continued. “Yeah, definitely been a little more careful doing stuff at home.”

Immediately after the incident, a friend of Scheffler’s who happens to be a surgeon came to the rescue and helped stop the bleeding. The next day rolled around and the wound was no longer open, but the pain remained, and Scheffler felt a general lack of range of motion. He decided to reach out to a hand doctor he’d worked with on a thumb injury while in college. They opted for surgery. Scheffler said that he does not expect his right hand to incur any long-term damage.

Scheffler spent his recovery time reflecting and analyzing an historic season that included seven wins on the PGA Tour — the most since Tiger Woods won seven in 2007 — plus an Olympic gold medal and the Hero World Challenge. He re-watched film of his tournament rounds and took his mind back to those cruise-control moments in competition, taking note of both his swing positions and demeanor.

“There’s a few tournaments I looked back at where the thing that stuck out the most was that I never really overreacted to stuff, I kind of stayed in it and kind of waited for my moment to get hot,” Scheffler said.

Required reading

(Photo: Kevin C. Cox / Getty Images for The Showdown)

How the Australian Open became the tennis Silicon Valley, from roofs to party courts

MELBOURNE, Australia — There are plenty of reasons to travel to Melbourne for the Australian Open each January, especially from a winter climate.

It’s sunny, it’s warm and Aussies at Melbourne Park are good with beer at noon and banter all day. Roger Federer had it about right when he nicknamed this event the “happy slam”.

The Australian Open also doesn’t treat tennis like a fragile museum piece, never to be touched or tweaked because ‘that’s not the way it’s done’, or one of those other haughty phrases the guardians of the game use to rationalize their stodginess.

This is the signal Grand Slam: the event that starts each season and offers a window into where tennis is headed with remarkable and deliberate regularity, all on the north bank of the Yarra River. Retractable roofs; 10-point deciding tiebreaks; cameras in the player tunnels and glitching cartoon tennis stars: it all debuted here. What California is to America, Australia has often been for tennis — the lab where new stuff goes for a test drive before being pushed out in so many other places.

“We’ve always tried to keep pushing the business,” said Machar Reid, the head of innovation for Tennis Australia, in an interview in Melbourne.

This year’s innovations have been especially visible. Coaches are sitting in pods on the three main courts with tablet computers packed with live stats, rather than in a box above the court and in the stands, where they had to lean over to chat with players craning their necks and cupping their ears to hear a potential gem among the noise.


Carlos Alcaraz talks with his coaching team during his fourth-round match against Jack Draper. (Clive Brunskill / Getty Images)

Even players who were against allowing any coaching, who really hated having a rule against coaching when it was happening match in, match out, have got on board.

“I always thought tennis is an individual sport where you kind of have to figure things out on your own in a way,” said Alexander Zverev, world No. 2.

“If tennis is going that way, then it should go that way to 100 percent.”

Novak Djokovic and his coach Andy Murray are having a face-to-face chat between sets. Iga Swiatek and her coach Wim Fissette are trading words between points. That kind of closeness is natural for a tournament that turned its underbelly — the tunnels under Melbourne Park that house the player areas and allow the best in the world to move freely and privately between the gym, the lounge, and their matches, bumping fists and talking shop as they go — into one large Big Brother live feed.

It’s probably a safe bet this is all coming soon to a tournament near you. Maybe not the Big Brother.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

The cartoon tennis stars of the Australian Open have gone viral. Can they change sports media?


The AO, as it calls itself (a little less grand than Wimbledon’s “The Championships”) was the first Grand Slam to have one retractable roof, then two, then three. It was the first to bring cameras into the bowels of the stadium, following players as they walked to the court through that fancy tunnel with all the photos and names of past champions.

The net camera first became a main staple here, according to organizers. It had the first heat scale, and the first air quality scale.

The U.S. Open fashions itself as a food and style and tennis technology hotbed. Tennis Australia has gotten some heat for that this year, as the tournament, along with some other Grand Slams have done away with the electronic let sensor. The chair umpire makes the call based on whether they hear the ball tick the net, a system tournament officials insist is reliable.

Players don’t agree. Zverev called it “quite ridiculous”.

“Every single corner of everything has a camera. We have video review and all the high-end technologies that we can possibly have. But a simple let machine that we’ve been using for the past 25 years is not available at a Grand Slam.”

Chances are, most spectators don’t pay it any mind. At the Australian Open, fans come for the tennis, but stay for the music festival.

All afternoon and into the evening, there are guitarists and singers performing in the main plaza between the courts, where fans take a break from the matches — if they ever make it to them in the first place. Those couches and pillows strewn across the shaded, artificial grass where the music plays make for an awfully pleasant spot to spend an evening sipping lager and whiskey.


Tennis fans enjoy the ‘Finals Festival’ at the Australian Open in 2023. (Kim Landy / Getty Images)

Last year, the tournament introduced innovations — by tennis standards — that have been long overdue.

Ushers began letting people take their seats between every game, rather than having to wait for a changeover, the old rule penalizing fans for going to the toilet, making them potentially miss 20 minutes of action. Players were caught slightly off-guard on the first day, but quickly got used to it and the change has spread elsewhere, especially in the higher sections of stadiums.

“We have been a little bit behind the other sports with changes and trying to keep the pace with the evolution of society and the new generation that we all know doesn’t have that much of a great attention span, and they want the movement,” Djokovic said Thursday night, after his third-round win over Tomas Machac. “That’s one of the ways to really try to open up a bit more and not have strict rules.”

There was another change — a bar and cafe next to a court instead of a bank of stands, with music and no limitations on noise during play. Last year, there was one. This year there is another. And just like that, taking a child to a tennis match, or catching up with a friend a few feet away from the action, becomes doable. Watching tennis no longer feels like the punishment your parents hand down when you misbehave: sit still and be quiet for the next three hours!

On the afternoon of the first Saturday, Rachel and Miki Petrovic, who were on their annual trip to the Australian Open from their home in Serbia, took in an otherwise forgettable doubles match over a beer as their seven-week-old infant, Violetta, rested beside them in a stroller.

“I have a baby,” Rachel told The Athletic. “Here I don’t have to worry about being annoying.”

A few feet away, Andrew Matthews and Danny Sincic, longtime Melbournians and attendees but first-time party-court visitors were enjoying a ginger beer and an IPA.

“Never been to anything like this,” Sincic said. “Makes it feel a bit more social than having to sit in the stadium without talking.”

“I don’t know how the players feel, but it’s good for us,” Matthews said.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Collins: Australian Open controversy has sparked ‘six sponsorship opportunities’


The players are basically fine with it. At this point, they know that when they play tennis in Melbourne Park, it might feel like a rugby match — especially if they play an Aussie. Chair umpires and stadium officials will attempt to keep the hometown faithful in line, but they don’t try that hard.

After all, that would rob the tournament of its more moments, such as Danielle Collins’ second-round win over home favorite Destanee Aiava. After enduring more than two hours of harassment from the Australian fans, Collins blew kisses to the crowd and thanked them in her on-court interview for helping her land a “big fat pay check”.

Djokovic, who ends up trolling crowds more often than anyone, gave Collins his full backing.

“Big fan of Danielle Collins,” he said the Thursday night after Collins’ interview. “We should try to look to connect more with the younger people and bring them. I want to see a little bit more entertainment.”

He has thoughts, including on-court dancers during changeovers or some version of a Super Bowl half-time show mid-match. Coco Gauff points out that in a sport with one-minute changeovers, it doesn’t really work. Maybe, somewhere in Melbourne, it’s already been noted on a whiteboard.

(Top photo: Brett Price / VWPics via Associated Press)

Antony: From a €95m Man Utd signing to a low-key loan exit in under three years

For INEOS, a regime intending to get to grips with Manchester United’s status as a loss-making enterprise, the potential €100million deal to bring Antony to Old Trafford stands out as a particularly acute example of the kind of lavish spending that has put the club in a precarious financial position.

With the Brazilian now in the Spanish city of Seville, having joined La Liga’s Real Betis on loan until the end of the season, United fans will be left contemplating how a player with such a price tag — £84.1million/$105.1m at the current exchange rate, the second-most expensive transfer in club history behind the re-signing of Paul Pogba in summer 2016 — could deliver just 12 goals and five assists in two and a half seasons.

The truth is United knew they were paying over the odds even at the time, according to sources familiar with the matter, speaking to The Athletic on condition of anonymity to protect relationships.

That awareness can be seen in Antony’s salary, which is akin to that of a mid-ranking member of the squad rather than a star signing. Antony agreed terms worth £140,000 per week for seasons when United are in the Champions League, plus bonuses based on individual performances, but because they are only competing in the second-tier Europa League this term, thus invoking the standard 25 per cent cut for their players, his salary has been around £105,000 a week.

Antony’s representatives had, when negotiating his deal, pitched at £250,000 per week, which would typically be commensurate with a transfer involving such a fee. Securing that would have represented a five-fold rise on what he had been earning at his previous club, Ajax of the Netherlands.

But his leverage in talks with United was weakened because he had told Ajax he wanted the move and, in his attempts to secure it, he stopped turning up for training in the closing days of that summer 2022 window. Figures at United were able to push back in contract talks in the knowledge Antony was desperate to join the Premier League club and they intimated improved terms could be on the cards if he did well, but that he would have to accept entry-level terms at first.


Antony scored on his United debut against Arsenal in September 2022 (Shaun Botterill/Getty Images)

Sticking to a relatively modest salary for a club of their revenue meant United had options when surveying the market for Antony this window. Betis, whose median salary is around £40,000 per week, according to Capology, could afford to push the boat out a little for the 24-year-old. They will cover 84 per cent of his wage at a minimum, plus potential bonuses based on achievements, with only former Real Madrid and Spain forward Isco thought to be earning more than him in their squad.

But the disparity in Antony’s wage compared to his transfer fee, which is still the 18th highest in football history, is evidence of United appreciating that they were paying an excessive amount to Amsterdam-based Ajax even while signing the paperwork.

There was internal pushback over the money involved from people minded to protect the club’s finances and the decision on confirming the move was not unanimous, but senior figures decided they could live with the transfer premium given the circumstances, partly because the salary was not that high. Financial fair play (FFP) regulations and the club’s cash levels were a consideration, but they did not dominate thoughts in 2022 the way they do at present.

Antony was intended to be a starting winger, which would have made the overall cost more palatable, but his status on the periphery of the side for the majority of his time at United has accentuated his enormous cost.

How United got to that point is a case study of everything those now in charge of the club are determined to avoid.


Erik ten Hag’s first summer as Manchester United manager, in 2022, was overshadowed by the failed pursuit of Frenkie de Jong, which coloured conversations for months. The €85million set aside for midfielder De Jong’s proposed move from Barcelona caused a blockage on spending in other areas, with United only freeing up major funds for Ajax defender Lisandro Martinez (in a deal worth £57m) by the time Ten Hag went off on pre-season (Christian Eriksen, a free agent, and Feyenoord full-back Tyrell Malacia were the other signings).

Ten Hag wanted Martinez and Antony from his previous club, but at that stage, Ajax would only sell one and the manager prioritised the Argentina international centre-back.

United had scouted Antony since his days at Sao Paulo’s academy, when he was only 15 years old. Reports to the club at that time said he had very good pace and technique but strongly favoured his left foot and had predictable decision-making. It was proposed he would need to get stronger and develop his weaker right side to succeed in the Premier League.

Antony’s summer 2020 move to Ajax saw United’s European scouts track his progress in the Netherlands, but during Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s time as manager, some staff still valued him at only around £25million.

His record in the 2021-22 season of 12 goals and 10 assists in 33 games, including the Champions League, put him on the radars of Premier League sides looking for right-wingers the following summer. Liverpool, with Mohamed Salah’s contract up for renewal, had Antony on a list, as did Tottenham Hotspur. The anticipated fee at that stage was regarded as between £40million to £50m. He was also a full Brazil international, having made 11 senior appearances for his country to that point.


Antony had played under Erik ten Hag at Ajax before joining United (Michael Regan/Getty Images)

Midway through that window, United cut off talks with Ajax on Antony and privately communicated they would not pay more than £60million.

United had alternatives for the right-wing role, most prominently his fellow Brazilian Raphinha, who had scored 11 goals in 35 Premier League games to save Leeds United from relegation, but the Old Trafford recruitment team, together with Ten Hag’s personal influence, rated Antony as the better signing, partly due to him being three years younger. In any case, Raphinha indicated he preferred Barcelona and his £55million transfer to the Camp Nou was sealed in mid-July.

Cody Gakpo was another alternative to Antony, albeit he typically operated on the left or up front for another Dutch club, Eindhoven’s PSV. At one point, United looked to bring in both players, as doubts about Cristiano Ronaldo’s future back at the club continued (he would eventually leave in the November).

United agreed personal terms with Gakpo but, in the final days of the window, stopped short of making a bid to PSV as the rising cost of Antony became clear. The following January, Gakpo joined Liverpool in a deal worth up to £44million.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Antony, Manchester United’s €95million problem

Player recruitment is an inexact science and there are a multitude of reasons for how signings work out, but comparing Antony’s post-transfer impact with those of Raphinha and Gakpo, who cost their new clubs £14million more in combined fees, is a painful case of sliding doors for United fans. This season, Raphinha has 22 goals and 11 assists in 30 games for Barcelona and is currently ranked second top-scorer in the Champions League, while Gakpo has 14 goals and five assists in 32 games for Liverpool.

Back in August 2022, United returning to the bargaining table for Antony was partly triggered by the continued uncertainty over Mason Greenwood’s availability — on a football level, his absence took away a right-wing option — and more sharply the back-to-back defeats to Brighton and Brentford which kicked off Ten Hag’s reign.

United, with football director John Murtough leading the sporting department, did not want a manager they had chosen after a five-month process to fail. Meanwhile, chief executive Richard Arnold was alarmed at the prospect of missing out on Champions League revenues and the threat of kit manufacturer Adidas cutting payments due to a non-Champions League participation clause. United’s kit sponsorship deal at that time meant Adidas would shave 30 per cent off the £75million-per-year contract for a second season absent from Europe’s elite competition, equating to £22.5m.

Several sources reported a sense of panic at Carrington, the club’s training complex, during those days. Pressure was also being felt from supporters eager to see a new attacker, with Ten Hag pushing to sign a forward.


Antony celebrates scoring against fourth-tier Newport in the FA Cup in January 2024, ending a 31-game goal drought (Athena Pictures/Getty Images)

Arnold and Murtough held talks with Ajax chief executive Edwin van der Sar, bidding €80million, €90m, then €100m. In an interview with The Athletic in November 2022, Van der Sar said: “We would have liked to keep him here one year longer — there was not a dire need to sell him, we had money in the bank — but the fee got so high. We challenged United to go as far as possible. They have a potential world star.”

Ajax stood firm on their valuation, having let five other players leave that summer and being aware that another sale might seriously damage their new head coach Alfred Schreuder. Ten Hag’s replacement lost his job five months later.

Joel Glazer, then United’s co-chairman, was convinced to sanction the spending after seeing how much Antony wanted to join United.

The final terms were €95m guaranteed, with a potential €5m more in add-ons, which are not thought to have been realised.

Antony started well, scoring in each of his first three Premier League appearances, against Arsenal, Manchester City and Everton, and he delivered an excellent winner against Barcelona to crown a stirring European night at Old Trafford in February 2023. In the middle of that season, he started a group game for Brazil at the 2022 World Cup and came on in their quarter-final against Croatia. Ultimately, United qualified for the Champions League by finishing third in the Premier League, going some way to justifying his move.

In the summer of 2023, fellow winger Anthony Elanga was sold to Nottingham Forest for £15million, with his minutes at United restricted.

That September, Antony spent a month out of the squad after police launched an investigation due to his former partner, Gabriela Cavallin, making allegations of assault against him. Antony denied those allegations and similar ones by two other women — Rayssa de Freitas and Ingrid Lana — made in Brazilian media. The case in Brazil is now closed, but as of last week, Greater Manchester Police were still investigating the alleged incidents that are said to have occurred in the United Kingdom.

As previously reported by The Athletic, the potential police action did not show up on background checks made by United before signing Antony.


Antony scored the decisive goal as United beat Barcelona 4-3 on aggregate in the Europa League knockout round play-offs in 2023 (Alex Livesey – UEFA/UEFA via Getty Images)

His form, which had undulated during his first season, hit the skids. He then fell out with Ten Hag over being asked to play left-back.

In February, Ten Hag overlooked Antony for the visit of Fulham, turning to Omari Forson, a 19-year-old academy graduate who was making his first senior start. The next month, Ten Hag gave Antony brutal criticism in the dressing room after his display from the bench in a 2-0 win against Everton, to the extent that the player looked affected.

Antony featured in around half of United’s Premier League games last season, totalling 1,323 minutes from a possible 3,420.

During an interview in pre-season in Los Angeles last August, Antony said that he had learnt from his issues and would look for self-improvement by writing himself notes. By the final stages of Ten Hag’s United tenure in the autumn, he was getting more minutes, notably being sent on ahead of Amad away to Fenerbahce in the Europa League on October 24.

On the sidelines that night, Amad appeared deeply frustrated. Ten Hag defended his decision by pointing to Antony’s performances in training. Given Amad’s emergence to prominence since Ruben Amorim’s November appointment as Ten Hag’s replacement, fans will see another link in the chain reaction of Antony’s arrival.

Amorim tried playing Antony as a wing-back, but his exit now will make room in his squad, and in the accounts, for a new arrival to more suitably fit the new head coach’s 3-4-2-1 system.

United are in talks with Italian club Lecce for 20-year-old Denmark international Patrick Dorgu and are considering triggering the buyback option on Alvaro Fernandez Carreras, 21, who has impressed since moving to Benfica last summer.

United will hope Antony can enjoy a productive loan at Betis to raise his value ahead of an expected permanent summer exit.

At a cost of £82million upon signing, his transfer fee can be spread over the length of his five-year contract, meaning a remaining book value of £34.2m. Getting a club to match that figure, allowing United to offset his price for the purposes of financial regulations, will still be a tough ask.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

‘Good or bad, he tells us everything’ – Understanding Ruben Amorim’s brutal honesty

(Top photo: Yagiz Gurtug/Middle East Images/AFP via Getty Images)

Top 100 MLB prospects 2025: Keith Law’s rankings, with Roman Anthony at No. 1

Welcome to this year’s ranking of the top 100 prospects in baseball. I’ve been compiling and writing such rankings for 18 years now, and those of you who’ve read them before will find the format here similar to those from the recent past.

My farm reports covering at least 20 prospects in each team’s system, plus notes on prospects who might appear in the majors this year or might be breakout prospects for the 2026 rankings, will appear the week of Feb. 3.

For the second year in a row, the most recent draft class is well-represented in the top 100; last year’s list had 20 players from the 2023 draft class, and this year’s list has 15, with more appearing on the “prospects who just missed” column that will run on Wednesday. The 2024 draft was not very good, but the minors right now … the minors are not good, my friends. It’s just not very deep, and getting to 100 names I felt good about was as hard as it has ever been.

Some of it is the increasing pace with which teams are calling up top prospects, as 12 of my top 20 prospects from last year’s list have graduated, but the bigger cause, in my opinion, is the forced contraction of the minor leagues back in 2021, which has rushed more players to Low A before they were ready and generally shrunk the time teams are giving to prospects who need more development.

Even guys who struggle in A-ball tend to move up because players are coming right behind them who need those at-bats or innings, and the result is more guys stalling out or regressing or just never taking the step forward that scouts and/or analysts expected. With continued rumors that MLB wants to cut yet another entire rung from the minors, this year’s top 100 should be a stark warning that the league is trying its best to strangle the goose that lays the golden eggs.

To be eligible for this list, a player must still retain Rookie of the Year eligibility for 2025, and have no experience in NPB/KBO, as those are major leagues and calling, say, Roki Sasaki a “prospect” is pretty silly (not to mention it takes up the space I’d rather use on an actual prospect).

I also don’t include the international free agents who just signed in January, since in nearly all cases those guys haven’t been scouted by other teams in a year or more. I know of one such guy who was under a verbal agreement with the team that signed him before he turned 13. No one has an up-to-date scouting report on him. That’s just not happening.

I tend to favor upside in prospects more than certainty, but there is value in both. A player who is all ceiling and no floor isn’t as valuable, in the trade market now or in considering his expected value in the long term, as one who has a somewhat lower ceiling but a much higher floor. I want players who might be stars. After that, I want players who might be above-average big leaguers — but I also try to keep in mind that many of these prospects won’t reach their ceilings, and to consider what other scenarios exist for their futures.

I use “seasonal age” for players, which is their age on July 1, 2025, the midpoint of the calendar. I use the 20-80 scale for tools (or 2-8 — same scale, different dialect), where 50 is average, 60 is plus, 40 is well below average, 80 is Pete Crow-Armstrong’s defense, and 20 is Yasmani Grandal’s foot speed. I try to discuss players’ tools, their frames, their level of athleticism and other physical attributes, as well as their skills, their aptitude, and other mental or intellectual attributes as well.

This is comparable to how major-league teams evaluate players, although they will always have the advantage of access to more and better data than those of us on the outside can get. The least I can do is try to reflect how the industry thinks about players, and give you the most accurate possible picture of the prospects in these rankings through both the lens of my own evaluations and those of the people within the industry whom I most trust.

When referring to starting pitchers, I acknowledge that that role is still evolving and we don’t have 200-inning guys anymore, with a lot of “five-and-dive” (throw five innings and hit the showers) or twice-through-the-order guys, but I will still talk about league-average starters and sometimes refer to back-end (fourth or fifth starters) or above-average (ace, No. 2, and some No. 3) starters. Bear in mind that there is a range around any projection or prediction for a player — if I say I think someone’s a No. 4 starter, he might have a ceiling as a No. 3 or more, and the floor of a middle reliever or a bulk reliever, where the No. 4 starter projection is the most likely or median outcome I see.

And now, on to the rankings …

Loading

Try changing or resetting your filters to see more.

2024 Ranking: 22

Anthony has shot through the minors, reaching Triple A in his second full pro season out of high school, thanks to one of the best swings in all of the minors and an extremely advanced approach for a hitter so young. A 2022 second-round pick, Anthony changed his setup that offseason, freeing up his hands to loosen his whole swing through contact while also getting his hips and legs more involved to help him hit the ball harder, and it paid off almost immediately.
Since his early 2023 promotion to High A, he’s hit .294/.405/.521 across three levels, finishing last season in Triple A with as many walks as strikeouts at that stop. His average exit velocity for Triple-A Worcester was 88 mph, although he did start to hit the ball on the ground more (52 percent) in that brief stint, not a major concern but something to watch as he gets so close to a promotion to the majors. He’s very disciplined for his age, chasing just 20 percent of the time in Triple A, with a whiff rate under 9 percent, picking up spin very well even at a level when he was facing guys who’d pitched in the majors.
Anthony has mostly played center in the minors, but he’s not very rangy and he’s maybe an average runner, so he’s much more likely to end up in a corner, supplanted in center by someone with plus range. He’s got a chance to be a 30-homer, high-average, high-OBP guy in right field, maybe with plus defense there, which is a “best player in the league” profile.

2024 Ranking: 40

Walcott started the year in High A as an 18-year-old, joining Ethan Salas as the only players that young to start 2024 anywhere above Low A, and he started very slowly, hitting just .196/.326/.315 through the end of May. From then on, he cooked, hitting .296/.351/.511 until a late-season promotion to Double A, so that on the whole he ended the year with an OBP 17 points above the Sally League average and a slugging percentage 78 points above it — all as the league’s youngest regular.
The Bahamian-born Walcott looks like a man among boys, as he’s 6-foot-4 or 6-foot-5 and clearly more than his listed 190 pounds, with a wide frame that’s going to let him pack on some upper body strength. He’s an excellent athlete with above-average speed and gets very high marks for his feel for the game, including his ability to make in-game and in-season adjustments. He’s got tremendous bat speed and already produces hard contact at a very high rate, so there’s every reason to hope he can be a 30-homer guy with a high average even if his strikeout rate remains in the 24-25 percent range.
Walcott is a shortstop now, and not bad there, but he’s extremely likely to outgrow the position — he’s going to be larger than Carlos Correa or Corey Seager, two bigger guys who defied expectations to remain at short. At worst, you’ve got a right fielder who hits for average and power. He won’t even turn 19 until the first week of March, so he has plenty of time to keep turning these immense physical gifts into baseball skills. I think he’s underrated already, and he’s my pick to be the No. 1 prospect a year from now.

2024 Ranking: 20

Basallo might be hopelessly blocked at the moment by Adley Rutschman, but he’s the best catching prospect in baseball right now, having produced at every level up through Double A before his 20th birthday while showing enough tools and athleticism to project as an above-average defender. Signed for a $1.3 million bonus in January 2021, Basallo has a fantastic swing that’s short to the ball but hard enough to produce plus power already, with more to come as he matures. He’s shown excellent plate discipline so far, and has hit left-handed pitching extremely well throughout his career, avoiding the platoon concerns that bedevil so many left-handed hitting prospects.
Even in a tough debut in Triple A, where he really struggled to adjust to changeups, he still topped 110 mph (off a lefty!) and averaged 91 mph across all balls he put into play. He’s got at least a 70 arm and is athletic enough to become a 55 receiver and blocker, although right now he’s succeeding more on his pure physical ability and needs more polish on the finer points of catching.
Basallo will probably be ready for a big-league role by the end of 2025, which will present a big dilemma for the Orioles, as they’re one of the only teams in baseball for whom he wouldn’t be a huge upgrade behind the plate — and if Rutschman is “just” a 3-4 WAR player, as he’s been the last two years, I’m not so sure that he’s the better option.

2024 Ranking: 15

Jenkins has earned comparisons to Larry Walker since he was a high school junior, which I always suspected was at least a little bit driven by his first name, but there are more similarities than that. Jenkins is also a tall, athletic, and very strong left-handed-hitting corner outfielder, and he’s advanced quickly through the low minors when healthy by showing exceptional swing decisions — he seldom swings and misses (just 17.5 percent last year) and doesn’t chase pitches out of the zone very often (24.6 percent), unusual for a hitter of his size and power potential.
He has a fantastic left-handed swing that gets him to the ball quickly and puts the ball in the air more often than on the ground, while he’s shown the ability to go the other way when pitchers try to attack him on the outer third. That feel to hit as a 19-year-old who’s already reached Double A is part of what makes him so exciting as a prospect; he already can hit, and there’s size and strength here for plus power as he continues to grow and develop.
He’s mostly played center in the minors, but I still think he’s heading to right field between his size and just average speed so far. He also missed almost two months to start 2024 with a hamstring injury, so he hasn’t played a full season yet. He should return to Double A to start 2025, and if he stays healthy, I wouldn’t be surprised at all to see him get a call-up in September given how much hard contact he’s already making as a teenager.

2024 Ranking: 37

If Emerson had stayed healthy all year, he would have been close to the very top of this list, just based on how good he looked and how well he performed when he was able to take the field. The 22nd pick in 2023, Emerson went to Low A to start last year as an 18-year-old — his birthday is in late July — and hit .293/.440/.427 in 40 games, walking more than he struck out. The Mariners bumped him up to High A in early August, and he hit .225/.331/.317 in 29 games there — but still made plenty of contact — and then hit .370/.436/.537 as one of the youngest players in the Arizona Fall League.
The bad news is that he played a total of 83 games between the regular season and the AFL, hitting the IL in April with an oblique strain, breaking a bone in his foot by fouling a ball off it in mid-May, and then leaving Arizona in early November after straining a hamstring. He’s played about 80 percent of his pro innings at shortstop and has shown the range and instincts to stay there, even though he’s just an average runner; if his propensity to get hurt continues as he matures, he may be better served moving to third or second, but he’s so much more valuable at short that he’ll probably stay there at least through the high minors.
He has all of the ingredients to be a hitter for a high average and OBP, with a short path to the ball, excellent bat speed and a strong approach for his age. He might only lack the power to get to the upper echelons of MLB position players, but he also has an extra year (so to speak) to develop that when compared to other elite shortstop prospects.

2024 Ranking: 14

Clark was the third pick in the loaded 2023 draft, and while I know some Tigers fans gnashed their teeth when Wyatt Langford (taken fourth) reached the majors last spring, Clark is one of the very best prospects in the minors and still projects as a star, especially coming off a very strong 2024. Playing at just 19 the entire season, Clark hit .286/.386/.421 in the pitcher-friendly Florida State League, then hit .264/.344/.421 after a July promotion to High A, while stealing 29 bases in 33 attempts on the year.
His pitch recognition and selection remain very strong — he whiffed just 8.1 percent of the time he swung in Low A, and chased just 22.6 percent of the time, per Statcast data from that level — and he topped out at 106 mph in exit velocity, but he hit the ball on the ground a ton, as he can get too firm on the front side and ends up on top of the ball too often. He’s a true center fielder who was a 55 runner last year, down from 70 speed in high school, and showed just an average arm, all of which was also a bit down from high school, possibly just the result of a much longer season and more frequent play than he’d experienced before as an amateur in Indiana.
His floor is a regular in center with high on-base percentages and plus defense; his ceiling, if the Tigers help him regain some speed and get him to loosen up his front side to drive the ball more, is a 25-homer/40-steal on-base machine.

2024 Ranking: 7

Crews was the second pick in the 2023 draft and made his major-league debut about 13 months after signing, advancing quickly through the minors as expected but without the dominance that most people anticipated. Crews hit .274/.343/446 in Double A, in a good hitters’ park in Harrisburg, and .265/.340/.455 at Triple-A Rochester. It was a solid performance, boosted by above-average defense in center field, but he’s not just any prospect — he won the 2023 Golden Spikes award after starring at LSU and beating up on SEC pitching for three years.
The good news is that his batted-ball data points to better results going forward, as he ran into some bad luck in the majors despite hitting the ball pretty hard in a small sample; his hard-hit rates in Triple A (43.3 percent) and the majors (44.7 percent) were both above the median, even though he was just 22 and young for both levels. He’s closed off some of the trouble he had in 2023 with fastballs up in the zone, and missed just 10 percent of the fastballs he swung at in the majors. He hit lefties fine in his brief sample in the big leagues as well, struggling mostly against breaking stuff from righties, especially down and away.
Even with the tepid performance in the high minors, he still shows the underlying characteristics of an above-average hitter in the big leagues, and that coupled with what is probably grade 55 defense in center — or plus if he moves to a corner at any point — would still make him at least a consistent 3-4 WAR player right now. I’m still hopeful there’s more upside here with the bat than he’s demonstrated in his year-plus in pro ball.

2024 Ranking: 38

Williams is the most enigmatic prospect in the minors to me: He does absolutely everything you’d want a position-player prospect to do, except he strikes out way too often — he does all of those other things despite a 28.5 percent strikeout rate in Double A last year that should be, if not disqualifying, a major demerit on his scouting report.
Williams is a plus defender at short with an easy plus arm. He has 70 speed and shows above-average to plus power, hitting 20 homers for the second year in a row. He doesn’t chase pitches out of the zone much at all — his chase rate last year was 22 percent according to Synergy Sports, which puts him well below the overall MLB rate, but when he does chase, he nearly always whiffs, and he also misses pitches in the zone more than you’d like. It’s a decision issue rather than a mechanical one, but Williams performs so well in spite of the whiffs that changing his approach risks taking away some of the production as well.
His 2024 season may also undersell his abilities, as he was hit on the hand by a pitch in June, missed just six days, and wasn’t the same hitter afterward. He was hitting .294/.376/.552 with a 27.1 percent strikeout rate at the time of the injury, then hit .220/.324/.382 with a 29.4 percent strikeout rate after his return, which makes me suspect he was more hurt than he let on and just played through it. At worst, he’s a shortstop with plus power, defense, and baserunning value who might just hit for a lower average because of the strikeouts. That’s a 4-WAR player in a full season because of the value of the position, and I wouldn’t rule out him getting beyond that with even tiny adjustments to his swing choices.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Campbell was my minor league player of the year for 2024 after he posted a .330/.439/.558 line across three levels, from High A through Triple A, in his first full year in pro ball. The Red Sox took him in the fourth round in 2023 as a redshirt freshman at Georgia Tech, betting on the makeup and the athleticism, and that good scouting work paid off as he not only hit at every level but did so while playing four positions — second, short, third, and center. He’s a plus runner who’s fast enough to play any of those spots, but his fringy arm probably limits him to second or center, with second his best position right now and in the long run as well.
His swing has a little funk to it and he can get flat through contact, resulting in a 60 percent groundball rate in his brief time in Triple A, but he has an incredible eye at the plate and gets the bat to the ball consistently enough for hard contact. He does have some holes he’ll have to work on, including four-seamers up and anything moving down and in under his hands or at his front hip, some of which may just be a function of his limited experience before getting to Triple A. He’s also already gained 10-15 pounds of further muscle this winter, which could help with bat control and getting some more loft through contact. He could easily be a plus defender at second and at worst should post high OBPs with 20-30 steals and 50+ extra-base hits a year.

2024 Ranking: 4

The 2024 season was a lost year for Lawlar, who tore a ligament in his right thumb in March, then hurt his left hamstring twice while on rehab assignments, limiting him to just 104 regular-season PA and keeping him out of the majors entirely after he debuted in 2023. He did go play for Licey in the Dominican Winter League and doubled his playing time for the calendar year, although he didn’t hit as well there, leaving him probably no further along than he was this time last year.
He’s a really athletic shortstop who has shown he can make hard contact to hit for high averages, hitting more line drives to the gaps than balls into the seats, only getting to more power when he played in the hitters’ havens of Amarillo and Reno in 2023. His swing is pretty short to the ball, with good follow-through that’s on a lower plane for line drives, and his wrists are so strong that he’s going to at least get to a high doubles total and probably still hit 15-20 homers at his peak. He didn’t run much last year but has plus speed and good instincts on the bases, all of which could also help him if he ends up moving to center field in deference to a plus defender at shortstop. If left at the position, he could be a 50/55 defender, thanks to some strong work by Arizona’s player development crew.
I did note some concerns about him lunging out of his swing in 2023, but that’s all on the back burner now as we wait to see the healthy version of him return this spring training. He’s got a strong floor as an everyday guy, at short or center or maybe even second, but if he can stay healthy and push that power to more like 20 homers or 60+ extra-base hits, he’d be more of an All-Star.

2024 Ranking: 29

Jobe is the best pitching prospect in the minors right now, although every candidate for that list has missed some time with injuries in the past two years, Jobe included, so buyer beware. He’s got a four-pitch mix highlighted by a high-spin four-seamer that sits 94-98 when he’s starting and an elite changeup, one of the best in the minors, that has tremendous late tumble, and that he can throw to both sides of the plate and uses against left- and right-handed batters. He’s also got a sweeper-slider and a hard slider, both of which are more weapons against righties, although the sweeper is probably going to be the fourth pitch in his arsenal in the majors.
He has cleaned up his delivery somewhat since 2023, so he should be better positioned to repeat it and throw both more strikes and better strikes going forward, as high walk rates have been one of the only negatives on his report to date — he walked 12.6 percent of batters he faced in Double A and Triple A last year, which is a giant gift to batters given how hard his stuff is to hit. He’s also had a lot of non-arm injuries, missing the first half of 2023 with a lower back injury and two months of 2024 with a hamstring strain, so he’s thrown just 252 2/3 total innings in three full pro seasons, including time in the AFL in 2023. That may point to a limited workload in 2025, especially since he’s likely to spend most or all of it in the majors. It’s No. 1 starter upside if he can go from 45 control to 55, which he certainly should given his athleticism and where the delivery stands now.

2024 Ranking: 34

Painter was supposedly on the bubble to make the Phillies out of spring training in 2023, when he was still 19, but ended up with a UCL tear that required Tommy John surgery and wiped out that season and all of 2024 as well. He returned during the Arizona Fall League this offseason and threw 15 2/3 innings over six outings, still pumping 96-98 with good carry, showing a plus curveball and slider, with only the changeup lagging behind.
He’s built like a workhorse starter at 6-foot-7 and a listed weight of 215 that’s probably out of date by 10-plus pounds, although the elbow tear and two lost years at least push his timetable to take 30 turns in a big-league rotation back a bit. He’s probably going to demolish Triple-A hitters this year and end up in the majors in some kind of relief or swing role as the Phillies manage his innings and try to develop his changeup and his command, especially coming off a layoff where he’s likely to still have some rust. The healthy version of Painter should be a 200-inning, No. 1 starter.

2024 Ranking: 89

Miller was the Phillies’ 2023 first-round pick, coming off a senior season at J.W. Mitchell High School north of Clearwater that ended for him in early March when he broke a hamate bone. Between the injury and the fact that he was 19 at the draft, he slid down some teams’ draft boards, which was the Phillies’ windfall when they selected him with the 27th pick, as he’s quickly become their best position-player prospect.
Last season, he ripped through Low-A Clearwater with a .275/.401/.483 line in 39 games where he topped out at 108 mph, then started slow in High A before taking off in his last month and a half there, ending up with a .258/.353/.444 line before a final-week promotion to Double A, all very impressive for a player in his first full year in the minors.
He has exclusively played shortstop since he signed, and contrary to predraft reports, he’s played it really well, to the point where no one seems to question whether he can stay at the position. He’s got very good instincts and shows above-average range in both directions, with a plus arm, playing defense like he wants to make every play. I saw him right after the promotion to High A and noted an overly aggressive approach and tendency to get on top of the ball; within about two weeks, he’d already adjusted and was seeing more pitches and driving the ball again. He’s even a plus runner now who stole 23 bases in 28 attempts last year, likely adding even more value to his game.
Miller has played just 122 games in pro ball, and won’t turn 21 until June, so he’s still got time on his side and I think more power to come. With Trea Turner’s defense slipping — his Runs Above Average on defense hasn’t been positive since 2021 — Miller might be the Phillies’ future at shortstop, and sooner than you think.

2024 Ranking: 26

Shaw might be the Cubs’ starting third baseman this April, and he’s earned the shot after reaching Triple A in his first full pro season and hitting better as the season progressed. Shaw started 2024 in Double A, where he overcame some bad luck on balls in play to hit .279/.373/.468 with just a 17.5 percent strikeout rate, and then bumped up to Triple A and hit .298/.395/.534 with a 19.7 percent strikeout rate. He makes very consistent hard contact, averaging 89.3 mph in Triple A with a 90th percentile exit velocity of 106. He utilizes a very rotational and clean swing that tends to put the ball in the air.
He’s a shortstop by trade but has played second and third as well in the minors, a reflection of the Cubs’ needs, with second base probably his best position and his third-base defense playable if not quite average yet. He’s a 55 runner with excellent instincts and could probably handle center or left if needed. Shaw is one of the best bets to hit for a high average of any prospect in the minors, and should add another half-grade of power to get last year’s 21 homers up into the 25-30 homer range in his best years. Depending on his position and how much he can improve his defense, he could be a 5-WAR player at his peak.

2024 Ranking: 12

Quero was No. 12 on last winter’s top 100, but had just one regular-season plate appearance in 2024 before he tore the labrum in his throwing shoulder, eventually undergoing surgery to repair it that ended his season. He’s supposedly on track to be ready for spring training, so in theory he’s still just as good of a prospect as he was a year ago, with his throwing probably the biggest question, although the loss of a year of at-bats also hurts just about any prospect this side of Chipper Jones. It was particularly a shame for Quero after he worked to improve his conditioning the prior year so he could hold up under a full year of catching duties.
As a hitter, he shows a short swing with strong follow-through, hitting 16 homers in 90 games in 2023 and projecting to 20-plus homers in his peak years in the majors. He had shown a tendency to swing too hard, mitigating it so far because he has strong hands and wrists to control the bat through the zone. He’ll have to shake off the rust from the layoff, and then can resume working on recognizing changeups from lefties and spin from righties, both of which were vulnerabilities for him in 2023. Assuming his arm is OK — it was probably a 70 on pure arm strength, so he has some wiggle room — and the surgery hasn’t adversely affected his swing, he still projects as a star who’s a plus defender and a very strong hitter for the position.

2024 Ranking: 86

Rushing bounced back from a concussion he suffered in 2023 that impacted his performance, putting together a superb 2024 season that has him banging on the door of Chavez Ravine, hitting .271/.385/.512 between Double A and Triple A with solid defense and improved performance against velocity. Rushing has shown excellent zone awareness since his debut, with a chase rate of just 21 percent across both levels last year, and his hard-hit rate in Triple A was 44 percent, comparable to Alec Bohm and Kyle Tucker in the big leagues.
He can overstride a little and get off balance, especially given how hard he swings, but when it’s all synced up his swing is geared to produce hard contact in that ideal zone of angles off the bat for power. He’s a solid receiver who threw out 30 percent of runners last year, and might be underrated as a defender because he’s such a good hitter (something baseball fans who were online in the 1990s might know as Nichols’ Law of Catcher Defense — a catcher’s defensive reputation is inversely proportional to their offensive abilities).
The Dodgers just gave Will Smith a mammoth contract, but he’s also been banged up quite a bit the last two years, so Rushing’s imminent arrival in the majors might be right on time. If he’s even a .340 OBP, 20-homer guy, which seems reasonable given his production and underlying data from 2024, that would make him one of the most valuable catchers in baseball.

2024 Ranking: 3

Salas was one of two 18-year-olds to start 2024 above Low A, along with Walcott. Salas’ season was very good in context, but didn’t quite live up to the hype or the scouting reports coming into the year. He hit .208/.288/.311 for High-A Fort Wayne, with just a 21 percent strikeout rate; his .256 BABIP does point to some bad luck, but his contact quality went backwards as well, and the easy power he showed in 2023 — or can show in BP — was absent in games most of the regular season. He was better in the Arizona Fall League, hitting as many homers there (4) in 23 games as he did in 111 games for Fort Wayne, which plays in a bad hitters’ park.
He’s still a plus defender and earns praise for his work with pitchers and coaches, giving him a very high floor as a catcher who has shown great contact skills and at least shown plus power in BP. He won’t turn 19 until June 1, so he has a ton of time to bring all of this together. However, at the very least there’s a lot more skepticism about his probability to become a star among other scouts and execs than there was a year ago.

2024 Ranking: 27

The Orioles went under-slot with their top pick in the abbreviated 2020 draft so they could go over slot for two players in the fourth and fifth rounds, and Mayo, the fourth-rounder, has more than justified their approach, as he’s already reached the majors at age 22 after hitting well at every stop in the minors.
Mayo spent most of 2024 in Triple A, hitting .287/.364/.562 there with 22 homers in just 89 games around an IL stint (he broke a rib trying to catch a foul ball). His batted-ball data from that level was just as impressive — his exit velocity topped out at 114.9 mph, his 90th percentile EV was 107.2 mph, and his hard-hit rate was 41 percent, all of which would be above the major-league medians for those figures. His Barrel rate was over 12 percent, which would have ranked in the top 50 had he done it in the big leagues.
He’s 6-5 and does have long levers so his swing can get big, some of which is the natural tradeoff for the kind of power he displays, but may also point to a longer adjustment period in the majors as pitchers exploit that length. He hasn’t swung and missed excessively in the minors, however, and he has made small adjustments to his approach and his mechanics as he’s moved up, so there’s every reason to think he’ll do so in the majors. He’s played third and first in pro ball and has made himself into a capable defender at the hot corner, but first base will always be the easiest option — or possibly right field, as he has plenty of arm and moves well enough for a corner outfield spot. His bat looks like it’ll play anywhere, with 30-35 homer upside and a good enough plan at the plate to eventually get to league-average or better OBPs.

2024 Ranking: 48

Chandler was part of the Pirates’ 2021 draft class, where they took Henry Davis with the first pick and went well under slot so they could sign several other first-round talents to over-slot deals — with Chandler by far the best of the group to date. The former quarterback-shortstop-pitcher is now exclusively on the mound, and 2024 was a big step forward for him, as he moved through Double A to Triple A and cut his walk rate from 10.9 percent in 2023 to 8.6 percent across all of last year.
Chandler has one of the best four-seamers in the minors, 94-99 with exceptional shape and life, giving it the illusion of rise, and hitters just can’t do anything with it: Triple-A batters whiffed on it 27 percent of the time they swung, and when they did hit it they were more likely to go the other way because they couldn’t pull it. He’s mostly fastball-slider-changeup now, barely using the curveball, so he can focus on improving just one breaking ball. It’ll probably always be his third-best pitch, but it was effective against righties last year, and his changeup is still a plus pitch for him that he can use against both sides.
The Pirates let him work a little deeper into games in 2024 and he showed no loss of stuff, while this was the second year in a row that he pitched a full season, so he should be ready to step into the big-league rotation by midyear. He only became a full-time pitcher in 2023, so he may still have more growth ahead of him on the mound than the typical 22-year-old, and he’s every bit the athlete you’d expect from someone who was committed to Clemson for two sports. Even if the slider is never more than a fringe-average pitch, he looks like he’ll at least be a No. 2 starter with the two elite weapons and the potential for above-average command as he matures.

2024 Ranking: 79

Schultz has gone from barely pitching as a senior at Oswego East High School outside Chicago as he was dealing with mono to becoming the best left-handed pitching prospect in baseball just two years later. He’d made only 16 appearances in the minors coming into 2024, having missed time the year before, but spent most of his season in Double A as a 20-year-old and dominated, striking out 32 percent of batters he faced and posting a 1.48 ERA.
He’s 6-9 and really uses the height to his advantage, coming at hitters from a low slot with good extension so that hitters make weak contact on his fastball even though it doesn’t miss many bats. He’ll sit 93-96 as a starter, with high spin rates but not a ton of life to it, a plus-plus slider as his out pitch, along with a high-spin curveball and perhaps too-firm changeup, although so far he’s had no issues with platoon splits.
He’s going to earn comparisons to Chris Sale as another lanky low-slot lefty, but he’s a different animal; he might never miss bats at the same rate, but will generate a lot of weak contact and keep the ball in the park instead. As long as he stays healthy — and that’s not guaranteed, as the history of 6-9 or taller pitchers is pretty grim — he’s going to have a long run of giving hitters nightmares as a top-end starter.

2024 Ranking: 47

Rodriguez had a typical year for himself — he walked and struck out a lot, made very hard contact, and got hurt. In 47 games total across four levels, he hit .280/.459/.567 with a 24.4 percent walk rate and 29.7 percent strikeout rate, hitting nine homers in that span, or roughly a 31-homer pace. He injured his right thumb while stealing a base in April, tried to come back and play through it, but reinjured it in September and ended up having a “cleanup procedure” on it after the season. He makes extremely hard contact when he’s healthy, though. Even in his brief time in Triple A, he put 13 balls in play, peaking at 114.6 mph and averaging 90.1. And his knowledge of the strike zone is real; he even brought his chase rate down from about 14 percent last year to 11 percent this year and just 8 percent in his brief time in Triple A.
Rodriguez calmed down his leg kick a little bit last year, although it doesn’t seem to have made much difference in his results, and he still probably needs to swing more often at pitches in the zone. If he stays in centerfield, with this power and patience he could be a better Mike Cameron (46.7 career WAR, so don’t scoff). It’s more likely Rodriguez ends up in right field, where his unusual profile as a hitter will still make him an above-average regular, and there’s the potential for more if he gets a little more aggressive at the plate — and can stay on the field for a full season.

2024 Ranking: 21

Domínguez may never quite be the Mickey Mantle-esque star that the earliest hype around him indicated, but he’s going to be a very good player — more so if the Yankees just leave him in center field and let him hit. Signed for a $5 million bonus as a 16-year-old in 2019, Domínguez was very physically mature for his age then, and showed plus power early on in his career as a result. He’s also a 70 runner and has 30/30 upside if he hits enough to get to it, and so far, he has hit for contact and average up through Triple A, hitting .287/.363/.465 there last year in his return from 2023 Tommy John surgery.
He’s a switch-hitter with really good swings from both sides of the plate, but has always been better from the left side and has struck out 29.3 percent of the time when batting right-handed over the last two years, one thing that bears watching as he moves to the majors. He’s a natural center fielder and a good one, with range from that plus speed along with solid instincts to read balls off the bat. There’s some hit tool risk, especially against southpaws, and he doesn’t have the same room for physical projection that most prospects his age still do. I see enough present strength and power — his EV50 in Triple A was 101.6 mph, which would have ranked fourth on the Yankees last year — to project him as a 25-30 homer guy as is, and with the speed and defense that still makes him a well above-average regular and occasional All-Star.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

McGonigle was the Tigers’ second pick in 2023, but took home a first-round bonus to buy him away from a scholarship to Auburn, and his pro debut made that look like a screaming bargain for Detroit. (It helps that the current draft bonus system wildly undervalues the best players.) His 2024 was bookended by injuries, but after recovering from a hamstring strain, he hit .326/.407/.470 in his 60-game stint in Low A, then got off to a solid start in High A before he broke the hamate bone in his right hand, ending his season.
The middle infielder from a small private school outside of Philadelphia has a very clean, simple swing with good hip rotation to drive the ball to the gaps, and the excellent ball-strike recognition he showed as an amateur has certainly carried over — he walked more than he struck out at Low A and at High A, with 11 walks and just four strikeouts in 14 games at the latter stop. He’s played short and second in pro ball but doesn’t have the range or quickness for shortstop, profiling much better at second and perhaps ending up a 55 defender there.
If there’s a knock on his game, it’s that he’s not as projectable physically as most of the guys ahead of him on this list; he makes plenty of hard contact now, but there’s not much room on his 5-10-ish frame to get stronger, so any further power gains (he had five homers in 74 games, although the Florida State League is bad for power hitters) will have to come from swing tweaks. He’s probably going to have a very long career as an above-average regular who ranks among the league leaders in OBP with just average or fringy power and solid defense at second … and, if he hits what I’d arbitrarily call a 95th percentile outcome, retire with 2,500 hits.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Celesten might be a superstar, if he can stay on the field and make the most of his prodigious physical abilities. Signed in January 2023 for a $4.2 million bonus, Celesten missed all of the 2023 complex season with a hamstring strain, then went to the Arizona Complex League (skipping the DSL) to start 2024 and hit .352/.431/.568, which put him in the top 10 in the league in average and slugging among all players with at least 100 PA. He missed a month with wrist pain, returned for one game in late July, and then shut it down, eventually undergoing surgery to repair a broken hamate bone. The team said it was an old injury, so he did all that at the plate while playing through an injury that typically saps a ton of power from a hitter. He’s a true switch-hitter with plus speed, an above-average to plus arm, and good actions at shortstop, lagging behind in some of the less tangible aspects like his internal clock and getting better reads off the bat. If he has the work ethic to match his tools, he’s going to be a superstar.

2024 Ranking: Ineligible

Bazzana was the first pick in the 2024 draft out of Oregon State, where the Australian infielder had starred for three seasons as the Beavers’ second baseman, finishing with a .407/.568/.911 line as a junior. Cleveland sent him right to High A, where he struggled a little out of the gate, enduring a five-game hitless stretch in his second week there before warming up for his last month-plus at the level and ending with a .238/.369/.396 line in his pro debut.
He’s a very polished WYSIWYG (what you see is what you get) player, offering little in the way of physical projection but also earning plaudits everywhere for his acumen for the game, leading evaluators to believe he will be able to make adjustments as he faces better pitching. He has an odd start to his swing with the bat back behind his rear shoulder and pointing down, but he’s ready when it matters and has a short path to the ball once his hands get started. He showed incredible plate discipline in college and most of that carried over into the minors, as he still didn’t chase much (22 percent) and only struggled against sliders in that brief stint, particularly left on left.
Bazzana is limited to second base or possibly left field. Cleveland’s trade of Andrés Giménez clears the keystone for him, and there’s every reason to expect him to see the majors some time this year given his advanced approach and present power/strength. Even if he’s just average on defense, his propensity to hit for high averages and get on base with probably 20ish-homer upside should still make him an All-Star.

2024 Ranking: 25

De Paula is one of the best pure offensive prospects in the minors right now, with an incredible approach at the plate that resulted in a .268/.404/.405 line between Low A and High A with 84 walks (good for 14th in all of the minors) and just 95 strikeouts. He makes hard contact right now, with strong exit velocities that you might not infer from his power output (just 10 homers, 17 doubles, three triples), as he doesn’t get the ball in the air as often as you’d like just yet. He’s a 40 runner and isn’t a great defender anywhere, so the hope is he ends up a 45 defender in an outfield corner, while the fear is he ends up at first base or at DH.
The bat will play anywhere, especially if his power emerges with age and more muscle on his 6-3 frame, particularly in his wrists and forearms, allowing him to control the bat head better through contact to hit the ball on a line. I’m betting on that happening given his age, physique, and exceptional command of the strike zone.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Baldwin is such a good defender behind the plate that he’s almost certainly going to be someone’s everyday catcher, and if his raw power keeps showing up in games as it did after a midseason promotion to Triple A, he’s going to make some All-Star teams. He was Atlanta’s third-round pick in 2022 out of Missouri State, where he wasn’t a full-time player until his draft year, and he’s improved substantially as a hitter since entering pro ball, loosening up at the plate to try to get to more of that plus power. He had a slow start in Double A but Atlanta promoted him to Gwinnett in early June, after which he took off, hitting .298/.407/.484 at the higher level with 12 homers in 72 games.
He hits the ball extremely hard — his average exit velocity in Triple A was 92 mph, his EV50 was 103, and his 90th percentile EV was 107 — so there’s every reason to think the power is real. He whistles the bat through the zone with excellent bat speed, and even with a pretty high starting position he hasn’t had trouble getting to pitches at the bottom of the strike zone so far. He’s an outstanding blocker and receiver with plus arm strength but just fringy accuracy so far, leading to a career 20 percent caught stealing rate in the minors. A 20-homer catcher with plus defense will rank among the best backstops in the majors, and Baldwin looks like he can be at least that, and probably will debut this year.

2024 Ranking: 8

Mayer looked like he was on track to be the top prospect in baseball around midyear, but he got hurt yet again, with his last game in 2024 coming on July 30, further underscoring his history of missing time with injuries. He was in the midst of a bounce-back season at the plate, returning to Double A and hitting .307/.370/.480 there while cutting his strikeout rate from 26 percent to just under 20 percent, when the injury struck, although he was promoted on paper to Triple A after he hit the injured list.
Mayer has a very pretty left-handed swing with good loft in his finish, projecting to plus power down the road, probably 25-30 homers a year. He’s a strong athlete and has the arm and hands to be a plus defender, flashing that range at times but needing to be more consistent on routine plays. He murders fastballs, with the bat speed to catch up to top-end velocity, while offspeed stuff gave him more trouble than ever in 2024. It may be mechanical, as he’s locking his front knee very early and trying to hit with a completely firm front side, leaving him vulnerable to stuff down at or below his knees; if that’s the issue, it’s also fixable, and he hasn’t always hit this way.
More concerning is that Mayer has yet to play in 100 games in a pro season, topping out at 91 in 2022, missing time due to a lumbar strain (2024), shoulder inflammation (2023), a sprained wrist (2022), and “back issues” (2022). He’s 22 now and still has superstar potential — a 30-homer shortstop with plus defense and what should be above-average OBPs is going to be the best player on his team in most cases. He has to show he can play 140 games in a year and get back to hitting offspeed stuff to be that kind of prospect again.

2024 Ranking: 85

Eldridge played as much as any prospect in 2024, with 565 total plate appearances across four levels of the minors and a stint in the Arizona Fall League, where he was understandably gassed. He performed well at the first three stops as a 19-year-old in his first full pro season. He was a two-way player in high school who had arm strength as a pitcher but no breaking ball to speak of, so while the Giants sort of said he’d continue to pitch when they drafted him, everyone wised up and told him to go hit.
He’s 6-7 but has a short swing for someone that size, one that’s far more geared towards contact than the kind of big-fly, loft-oriented swing you might expect from such a tall hitter, and he kept his strikeout rate to just 25 percent until he got to Triple A, which is always the biggest concern with any hitter his height (or taller). He looks like he’ll be a huge power hitter, but while he makes hard contact, I’m expecting higher averages and doubles totals but a more modest home run output in the 20-25 homer range.
He has played some right field but it’s apparently an Eldridge horror show out there, so first base it will be. He still has work to do there, but there’s really nothing stopping him from becoming at least a 55 defender at the position, and he does give fielders a big target for their throws. The Giants pushed him very hard last year, so 2025 should be a consolidation year for him, where perhaps he starts in Double A and gets a long run there before moving up to the hitter-friendly PCL. He’s their next franchise player, but needs time to be ready to deal with major-league pitching, especially as he had more trouble with offspeed stuff as he moved up the ladder last year.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

The Mets wanted Sproat so badly, they drafted him twice. He decided not to sign in 2022, choosing instead to return to Florida to try to improve his draft stock, and he did, going a round higher in 2023 and probably making another $500,000 in the process. He reached Triple A in his first full pro season, dominating High-A and Double-A hitters with a five-pitch mix. He had a 2.05 ERA on the season and 110 Ks with 31 walks in 87 2/3 innings when he was promoted to Triple-A Syracuse. He struggled in seven starts there, allowing 36 hits, including seven homers, in just 28 innings, as his fringy command came back to bite him, with too many fastballs left about belt-high and more experienced hitters better able to pick up some of his offspeed stuff.
He works heavily off a four-seamer that’s been up to 99-100 and sits 96-97, while his best pitch is a slider that’s above-average to plus depending on the day; he’ll throw a decent change, a curve, and a two-seamer as well. It’ll always be control over command, as he’s so aggressive that it’s hard to foresee him ever toning it down enough to be precise with his locations. He’ll have to do a little bit of refinement to make the last leap to the majors, as hitters will hit your stuff, no matter how good it is, if you put it on a tee for them. He has some similarities to Edwin Jackson, a huge stuff guy who was more of a No. 4 starter for most of his career, although I think Sproat has better control than Jackson did at the same age.

2024 Ranking: Ineligible

De Vries signed last January for $4.2 million, the second-biggest bonus in the 2024 international free agent class, and the Padres were unusually aggressive with him — who am I kidding, they always do this — in sending him not to the DSL, not to the Arizona League, but to Low A, making him the only 17-year-old regular anywhere in full-season ball last year. He more than held his own, hitting .237/.361/.441 with a very respectable 23.3 percent strikeout rate that was slightly better than the Cal League average. He has a real knack for centering the ball and as he gets stronger his batting average is going to climb very quickly, since he already has the contact skills. He knows the strike zone extremely well for someone so young, and he rarely misses fastballs; he had more trouble with other pitch types, unsurprising given his complete lack of prior experience anywhere in pro ball, but didn’t panic with two strikes and only swung and missed slightly more often in those spots. His regular season ended in mid-August when he strained his right shoulder on a diving play, but in a sign that the injury wasn’t too serious, the Padres sent him to the Arizona Fall League, where he was, of course, the youngest player. He turned 18 in October, so he’s younger than some high school players who’ll be drafted on Day 1 this upcoming July. De Vries was already showing signs of adjustments when he got hurt, cutting his whiff and chase rates on various pitch types in the second half, and he has barely begun to grow into his 6-2 (actual height) frame. He’s got a chance to stick at shortstop, he’s a plus runner, and he might end up with 20+ homer power. Give him a full, healthy year along with the benefit of all the experience he got in 2024 and he might be a top 10 prospect by next January.

2024 Ranking: Ineligible

Wetherholt might have gone No. 1 in last year’s draft had he had a full, healthy spring for West Virginia, but a hamstring injury limited him to 36 games for the Mountaineers, just 27 of them in the field, so he ended up going No. 7 to the Cardinals — and that looks like a steal for St. Louis. Wetherholt had one of the best swings in the draft class and a long track record of hitting for average and high contact rates, hitting .449/.517/.787 as a sophomore and then .331/.472/.589 despite clearly playing hurt for some of his junior year.
He’s not very physical, but makes plenty of hard contact — his hard-hit rate in Low A after the draft was 55 percent, exactly the same as his hard-hit rate from the spring, and he topped out at 109 mph in Palm Beach — thanks to a short, efficient swing that gets the most from his lower half (when his lower half is intact). He moved to shortstop from second and third as a junior, but of course never played it at full strength after the first weekend, so while the safe bet is that he ends up at second base, he hasn’t had a chance to show much at shortstop yet. Regardless of his position, his swing mechanics and his approach at the plate point to high averages and a lot of doubles power, enough to make him a long-time regular who might challenge for some batting titles.

2024 Ranking: 28

“The Jaguar” made his big-league debut in September, just over three years after the Cubs acquired him from the Yankees for Anthony Rizzo in a trade that worked out well for both clubs. Alcántara started slowly in 2024 and hit the injured list in early June with an injury to his left shoulder, but after he returned, he took off at the plate, hitting .292/.388/.459 between Double A and Triple A in 63 games before the callup. He’s 6-6 and lanky, with a ton of room to keep filling out and adding power beyond what he already shows — nearly half of his balls in play in Triple A were hard-hit (95 mph or better exit velocities) — while he’s still developing the wrist and forearm strength to stay on plane through contact and get the ball in the air more, with a 51.7 percent groundball rate in the minors last year.
Alcántara has worked his way up to become a plus defender in center as he’s improved his focus and his reads on balls off the bat. He’s not ready for the majors yet, between the tendency to get on top of the ball and some real trouble with sliders once he reached Triple A (he whiffed at just over half of the ones he swung at there), but with his plus defense and speed and the 30-40 homer potential, he has the most upside of anyone in the Cubs system.

2024 Ranking: Ineligible

Condon was the No. 1 player on my predraft rankings last year and went to Colorado with the third pick, but his post-draft performance couldn’t have differed more from what he did in the spring for Georgia. Condon won the Golden Spikes Award with a .433/.556/1.009 line for the Dawgs, hitting 37 homers in 60 games, setting the school’s career home run record and the NCAA’s single-season record since they switched to BBCOR bats. In 109 PA for High-A Spokane, however, Condon hit .180/.248/.270, struck out 34 times (31.1 percent), and walked just four times. Pitchers saw a 6-6 hitter with long levers in the box and went after him hard in with fastballs and soft away with sliders and changeups.
Condon is an impressive athlete who made extremely hard contact as an amateur, ranking among the leaders in Division 1 with a 90th percentile exit velo of 111.8 mph, and he did adjust in the spring when pitchers went after him with breaking stuff, forcing them to come back to the fastballs on which he feasted. He’s played third base and all over the outfield, playing passably at the hot corner and in center, but the broad consensus is that he’s going to end up in right given his frame and likely eventual size. He did have a lingering hand injury when he first signed that may have affected him at the plate, but that can’t explain away all of the struggles. Perhaps he was pressing; perhaps he just hadn’t seen breaking stuff of that quality before; perhaps it’s just a tiny sample.
I don’t think his ceiling has changed at all — he’s a 30-homer bat with the kind of contact quality that leads to high BABIPs and averages, and he should be a plus defender in an outfield corner — but there’s more uncertainty here than there was on draft day.

2024 Ranking: Ineligible

Kurtz was the best hitter in a loaded Wake Forest lineup last spring, leading the team formerly known as the Oakland A’s to take him with the No. 4 pick, after which he continued to rake in his pro debut. He hit .368/.520/763 in 50 PA between High A and Double A, hurt his hamstring, then hit .353/.450/.608 in 60 more PA in the Arizona Fall League. He’s limited to first base — the horror — so he needs to hit, but so far he’s hit everywhere, and it’s especially promising that he’s been swinging the bat more since he signed, as he walked a ton in college (78 times last spring) and could look passive at the plate. He’s up from swinging 33 percent of the time in college to 38 percent in the minors, and that’ll probably increase a little more as pitchers realize just how good his ball/strike recognition is. When he does swing, he makes extremely hard contact; his 90th percentile exit velocity at Wake Forest was over 111 mph, and he continued to hit the ball hard in his brief time in the minors.
There’s a good chance for 30-homer power with 70-80 walks or more per season, and that’s going to make him a star and possibly the best player in the Sacra … er, the Athletics lineup.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Arizona took Crisantes in the seventh round in 2022 out of Nogales (Ariz.) High School, just a few minutes from the U.S.-Mexico border, but the infielder didn’t debut until 2023 or play a game in the field until 2024 after he underwent two Tommy John surgeries — the second to repair the first — as a high schooler. Through 121 games in the minors, however, he’s hit .342/.427/.486 with a really mature approach and enough hard contact to project him to a 60 or better hit tool in the majors. It’s a really simple, clean swing with a little loft in its finish, producing a 27.4 percent line-drive rate in 2024, and he’s strong enough already for well above-average contact quality for a teenager. (The MLB average line-drive rate in 2024 was 19.6 percent.)
His defense is a work in progress between his recovering arm and several years off the field; he probably fits best at second base, as he’s athletic enough for the position and it doesn’t require a ton from his arm, while he lacks the range for short or the twitchiness for third. There’s always a lot of risk in prospects whose value is primarily tied up in their hit tool — not to be too obvious, but if they don’t hit for high averages, they have nothing to fall back on — which is why Crisantes isn’t even higher on this list. Everything about Crisantes, from the swing to the batted-ball data to the performance, says he’s going to hit a ton.

2024 Ranking: 54

Teel was part of the four-player package that Boston sent to the White Sox for lefty Garrett Crochet, and right now he seems like the best bet to be Chicago’s primary catcher this year after he finished 2024 in Triple A. The Red Sox 2023 first-round pick out of Virginia, Teel started his first full pro season in Double A, hit .299/.390/.462, then moved up to Triple A with Kristian Campbell and hit .255/.374/.343 in 28 games at that last stop. He’s an excellent athlete who moves very well behind the plate and has a plus arm, with solid-average speed that’s more evident underway than out of the box. He’s got quick hands at the plate and a short path to the ball with a little loft in his finish, way more likely to hit for average than for power given his good-not-great contact quality and the way his swing works.
He has had some trouble with lefties in pro ball, striking out 31 percent of the time he’s faced them in only about 130 PA, and he’ll need more reps against southpaws to avoid becoming a platoon player. His glove is ready, and his bat is at least ready enough to make contact against righties. The White Sox have the luxury of time to let him continue to develop in the majors and hope he reaches his upside of a solid-average or better regular behind the plate.

2024 Ranking: Ineligible

Montgomery was No. 4 on my predraft board last year, but slipped to the No. 12 pick after he broke his ankle in Texas A&M’s Super Regional series in June. The Red Sox drafted him, although that will become a point of trivia since he never played a single game for Boston before they traded him this offseason to the White Sox in the Garrett Crochet deal, giving Chicago two of the top six players from my 2024 draft board along with their own first-round pick, lefty Hagen Smith.
Montgomery is a switch-hitter with power both ways, hitting much, much better from the left side, making consistently hard contact — his hard-hit rate last spring for Texas A&M was a nice 69 percent, putting him in the top 1 percent of all Division 1 hitters. He was a two-way player through his sophomore year at Stanford before he transferred to College Station, so of course he has a plus-plus arm and is at least a 55 defender in right. The two big questions around Montgomery are whether the ankle injury will affect him at all going forward and whether he should give up hitting right-handed, as he struck out 29 percent of the time that way last spring with just a .227/.395/.485 line (versus .355/.465/.819 left-handed). It’s 30-homer upside with strong defense and the hard contact to keep his batting average above the median as long as he comes back at 100 percent.

2024 Ranking: 73

Hence would be one of the absolute best pitching prospects in baseball if he showed he could stay on the mound for a full season of work, but the 2020 draftee has yet to reach 100 innings in any one season — just pitching extremely well when he is on the mound. He’s small, listed at 6-1, 195, but very, very athletic, and his arm is electric. He’ll touch 98 and sit 94-95 as a starter with a 70 changeup and a slider that’s at least average and plays up because it’s a different look and shape than the other two pitches. He’s never had a serious arm injury, missing most of 2021 with shoulder discomfort that never required surgery, losing about a month of 2024 with some kind of strain or pull in his side. He did go 90+ pitches in several starts for the first time last year, and posted his best strikeout rate (34.1 percent) and ERA (2.71) of any stint he’s had in full-season ball.
He might be a guy who pitches like a No. 1 or a No. 2 but only does so on the workload of a swingman or a back-end starter, although I never like to underestimate a player who’s this athletic.

2024 Ranking: Ineligible

Burns was the No. 2 pick in the 2024 draft and the first pitcher taken, coming off a dominant spring at Wake Forest that saw him strike out more than 40 percent of opposing batters. His fastball has been up to 100 and sits 96-98 with big induced vertical break, and his slider is a 70 with late, tight break along both axes. College hitters couldn’t touch the slider, whiffing two-thirds of the time they tried (so the lesson is never try). He has a 55 curveball and a straight changeup with some tumble to it that is his weakest pitch, probably his main area for work going forward now that he’s in pro ball.
He has some effort to his delivery, including a slight head-snap, but so far he hasn’t had any trouble throwing strikes or locating his main two pitches. If his command and control hold up, he’s a potential No. 2 starter, and could follow another former Wake Forest pitcher, Rhett Lowder, in reaching the majors inside of 15 months of his draft day.

2024 Ranking: 43

Crawford held serve last year, continuing to hit the ball hard and get on base at a high clip (.360 overall between High A and Double A), but also continuing to put the ball on the ground 60 percent of the time because his swing has him coming down at the top of the ball. He’s a 70 defender in centerfield and an 80 runner who swiped 42 bags in 51 attempts last year and probably could steal 60 without breaking a sweat. He overstrides at the plate, so he’s frequently off-balance, and doesn’t load his hands at all from a high setup, resulting in a bat path that often has him coming down towards the zone. Some of this is a matter of strength, as Crawford was all projection when the Phillies drafted him in the first round in 2022, and he still has a lot of physical growth ahead of him, but some is mechanical and it’s time for him to make some real adjustments to get in better position to drive the ball.
He’s going to have plus raw power, and that combined with elite defense and speed will make him an impact player for a long time if he can change his swing to get that raw power into games.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Arias destroyed the Florida Complex League last season as an 18-year-old, hitting .355/.471/.584 to win MVP honors and earn a bump up to Low A, where he more than held his own with a .257/.331/.378 line and just a 17.4 percent strikeout rate. He’s got tools and athleticism to spare, showing excellent bat speed and wrist strength already, along with a fantastic swing that has great rhythm to it and lets him get his lower half involved for more power. He’s a true shortstop with soft hands and solid instincts already, showing a plus arm and above-average speed on both sides of the ball. Arias just turned 19 in November and probably gets to High A at some point this year, given how good his contact skills are already. He has the upside of a plus defender at short with above-average OBPs and 20 homers a year, with the only major risk just his age and the distance he has to travel to get to the majors.

2024 Ranking: Ineligible

Smith was a draft-eligible sophomore last year who reworked his swing and his body to surge to a .387/.488/.654 line in his sophomore year at Florida State, raising his average by over 100 points, and landing with the Cubs at the No. 13 pick. He then had the best pro debut of any prospect in the draft, hitting .313/.396/.609 across three levels and finishing up in Double A. That ended his Cubs career, as they traded him to Houston in the Kyle Tucker deal this offseason, immediately making him the Astros’ No. 1 prospect.
Smith’s swing gets the bat to the zone quickly, and he makes a lot of very hard contact, topping out over 115 mph in the spring for Florida State, and the Cubs already managed to get him to lift the ball more often to turn that loud contact into more power. He’s only played third base since signing and that’s his best long-term outcome; that seemed like wishful thinking as recently as 2023, but his improved conditioning gives him a chance to stay there, with first base or right field also possibilities. He looks like he can flat-out hit, and might get to 25 homers too. If he does that as a third baseman, he might be able to fill Alex Bregman’s shoes in Houston and make a few All-Star teams.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

The Brewers went over slot in the sixth round in 2023 to sign Pratt, who was 40th on my draft board (so an early second round talent), and his first full season was a rousing success. Pratt played at least 55 defense at short, with some scouts saying it’s already plus, and he showed a way better approach at the plate than just about any high school hitter from Mississippi I can remember. He hit .295/.394/.395 in Low A last year, with a 12.2 percent walk rate and just an 18.3 percent strikeout rate in a league where the overall strikeout rate was 25.3 percent. He moved up to High-A Wisconsin for the playoff run and had a harder time … except that he launched five homers in 23 games there, more than he had hit in 73 games in Low A.
There’s power in there, maybe 15-20 homers a year, although even if he’s more in the 10-12 category, plus defense and really strong on-base skills will make him a solid or better regular at shortstop. If his power output does keep improving as he gets a little older and stronger, he’s got a chance to be a 4-5 win player.

2024 Ranking: 46

Young had another very solid year at the plate while being young for his level, hitting .271/.369/.390 as a 20-year-old in Double A, all comfortably above the averages for the Texas League (.240/.327/.374), even though he was the fourth-youngest regular at the level. He’s always been an advanced hitter for his age with exceptional feel for contact; data from Synergy Sports show him with a whiff rate of just 19 percent last year, and nothing over 22 percent on any of the big four pitch types.
His swing is handsy and doesn’t generate much power, although he does make hard enough contact to keep his average up, and gets the ball in the air enough to maybe see him as a 40-doubles, 10-homer guy in the majors. He can play shortstop but probably will end up superseded by a plus defender, while he’s played extremely well at second and might be a plus defender himself at that spot. He’s a no-doubt big leaguer, with the floor of a very good platoon infielder who can play multiple spots but maybe sits against good lefties, and a strong probability that he’s at least a solid-average regular at one of the two middle infield positions.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Ballesteros is one of the best pure hitters in the minors, and if you really believe he can catch, he’s a top 20ish prospect — but his body is less than ideal for the position and he’s probably going to end up somewhere else. Ballesteros played all of 2024 at age 20 and hit well at three stops, .299/.372/.495 in Double A, .281/.340/.454 in Triple A, and then .317/.376/.557 in 19 games in the Arizona Fall League. He doesn’t miss pitches in the zone, although to be fair, his strike zone isn’t very big, but does get overly aggressive with two strikes and expands the zone significantly. He may always just be a “swing first, ask questions later” hitter, since he can make contact with so many pitches, and he’s got grade-55 power already.
He’s heavy, even after losing some weight (and keeping it off) in the last year, and that’s going to make it hard for him to handle everyday catching duties, as he’s not very agile behind the plate, and his just-average arm doesn’t help matters. He could be an occasional backstop who mostly handles first base and/or DH, gaining a lot of value from the games he does catch and from what should be consistently high batting averages with 15-20 homers a year.

2024 Ranking: 99

Detroit picked up Liranzo along with Trey Sweeney in the trade that sent Jack Flaherty to the Dodgers, only to go on an improbable run to the playoffs after the deadline, which seems like a win-win to me. Liranzo started the year slowly for High-A Great Lakes, and was hitting .220/.344/.356 at the time of the deal, but then somewhat inexplicably took off with the change of scenery — he hit .315/.470/.562 in 26 games for the Tigers’ affiliate in West Michigan, then went to the AFL and hit .375/.492/.667 in 15 more games, walking more than he struck out at both spots.
He’s pretty mobile behind the plate and has a 70 arm, needing to work more on receiving to remain a full-time catcher. His bat is special — he’s got a quiet, easy swing that still produces plus raw power because he’s so strong to begin with, and his ball/strike recognition is excellent already. He had no trouble adjusting to offspeed stuff in the AFL, in contrast to much of the regular season where he ran into some difficulty with sliders and changeups. He was on the younger side for High A at age 20 and probably should spend all of this year in Double A to work on his catching and keep tightening up that pitch recognition. It’s 25-homer, .350+ OBP upside in a switch-hitter, and if he’s even a 45 catcher, he’ll be a 4-5 win player in his peak years.

2024 Ranking: 60

Lowder reached the majors just over a year after the Reds took him with the No. 7 pick out of Wake Forest, showing three pitches with a ton of movement albeit a little less velocity than he had shown in college. His best pitch as an amateur was his changeup, which is hard to pick up out of his hand and has both fading and tumbling action to it, but it was actually less effective at generating whiffs than his 92-95 mph four-seamer or his high-spin slider in his six big-league starts, even just against lefties.
All three of his pitches should be above-average, with the run helping the fastball play up and sharp downward break to the slider, so it was surprising that he gave up so much contact, with a 41 percent hard-hit rate, in his debut. Even with that high contact rate, Lowder was very lucky in the majors, with a 1.17 ERA but a 3.10 FIP, and even that latter figure doesn’t adjust for the improbability of allowing 0 homers in 30 innings. He’s major-league ready and probably a league-average starter given his current velocity and what looks like 55 control and maybe 45 command, with of course the chance to get beyond that if he starts working less in the heart of the zone with his fastballs. (You may not give a damn, but he’s the first player named Rhett in big-league history.)

2024 Ranking: Ineligible

The top lefty in the 2024 draft class, Smith got better every year at Arkansas, culminating in a year where he struck out 17 batters in his second outing against an Oregon State lineup that featured eventual No. 1 pick Travis Bazzana. Smith worked at 92-97 with a plus slider and gets some added deception from a funky delivery and a starting position on the extreme first-base side of the rubber, although that latter point makes it harder for him to locate his fastball or changeup to his glove side (which would be inside to righties). He takes a huge stride towards the plate and generates a ton of arm speed, coming from a slot below three-quarters which, given who drafted him, brings the name “Chris Sale” to mind.
He had Tommy John surgery in high school, missing his senior year, but has been healthy ever since and saw his velocity and results creep up each year. He’s a potential No. 2 starter, although I’d like to see him move a little more towards the middle of the rubber so he can work more effectively to both sides of the zone.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Boston shocked everyone in 2020 when they took Yorke, a high school second baseman who had to move off shortstop after shoulder surgery, in the first round, but his first full pro season in 2021 appeared to vindicate them when he hit .325/.412/.516 at both A-ball levels. His follow-up in 2022 was marred by multiple injuries, including a nagging left wrist issue that interrupted his stint in the Arizona Fall League, and his 2023 fell somewhere in between, so it seemed like he’d settled in as a future regular but one without much upside. He did nothing after returning to Double A to start 2024, but from the moment Boston promoted him to Triple A, he turned into Rogers Hornsby, hitting .333/.420/.498 even through a trade to the Pirates for Quinn Priester. Those numbers came with tons of hard contact: He peaked at 111 mph, half his balls in play were hard hit (95 mph+), and the average velocity of that upper half (his EV50) was 101.9 mph, all of which were comfortably above the MLB medians.
His swing is very simple and direct; it doesn’t have a ton of loft, so he’s probably not going to be a big power guy (barring a swing change), and instead should run high BABIPs and averages, maybe challenging for the league lead in doubles. He’s a solid-average defender at second and his throwing has improved enough that he’s not going to have any trouble staying there, although the left side of the infield is probably out of the question. My evaluations of Yorke have been all over the place since he was drafted, so take this with even more grains of salt than usual, but I’m buying Yorke now as a future 55, an above-average regular who’ll have some years when he’s an All-Star because he hits for such a high batting average.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Rocker’s road to the majors was … uh, rocky? Sorry, I’ll work on that. He was the No. 10 pick in 2021, but the Mets didn’t like something in his post-draft physical, so he went to indy ball and pitched well enough to go No. 3 to Texas in 2022, but blew out his elbow six starts into his pro debut the next year. He returned in 2024 and the Rangers kept moving him up as he kept posting, eventually getting him three starts in the majors in September where he looked as good as he had since his freshman year at Vanderbilt.
He had lowered his arm slot back in 2022, but it’s back to its original position, which allows him to get more depth on his slider. The slider is easily plus and might be a 70 once again, and keeps him on top of his 94-97 mph four-seamer. His path from here is largely about him — he has succeeded in the past by out-stuffing guys, and being very aggressive with those two main pitches (he has a curve and changeup, but uses them less), but in the big leagues he’s going to have to show better command to get ahead of hitters and to avoid a lot of four-inning, 85-pitch starts. This is a bet that he’ll make those adjustments and end up at least a mid-rotation starter, perhaps someone who pitches at a higher level than that but needs to skip some starts here and there to keep him healthy.

2024 Ranking: 33

Ryan’s 2024 season featured his big-league debut, so yay, but it was bookended by two injuries, the latter of which probably will keep him out until 2026 as he underwent Tommy John surgery in August. He started the year on the shelf with a sore shoulder, but did reach the majors for four starts where he showed electric stuff, sitting 96-98 with ride on the four-seamer and both the slider and cutter flashing 55 or better. The cutter was new for him in 2024 and gives him another weapon for lefties, as it looks just like his four-seamer but has a little last-second break downward to fool hitters, although in the majors he leaned on the changeup more than the cutter. He’s a converted infielder who’s very athletic on the mound and has already made incredible progress in command and control and has shown the ability to make adjustments from one year to the next. The injury and the lost time do hurt his overall outlook. He’s a No. 2 starter if he comes back at 100 percent and can hold up for a full season.

2024 Ranking: 67

Quero came to the White Sox in the 2023 deadline deal that sent Lucas Giolito (briefly) to the Angels. He reached Triple A last year in his first full year in Chicago, hitting well at two levels with very strong OBPs. He’s an advanced hitter for his age, which balances out some of the lack of projection in his body, as he’s not likely to get that much stronger and further improvements will have to come from tweaks to his mechanics or swing decisions. He’s a switch hitter who’s definitely better from the right side, with large platoon splits the last two years — in that span, he hit .342/.440/.510 against lefties, and .242/.351/.370 against righties. His biggest area of improvement last year was using his strong ball/strike recognition to swing more — he swung at 39 percent of pitches he saw in 2023, then upped that to 47 percent last year, and, lo and behold, he hit better across the board, including boosting his slugging percentage against right-handed pitchers by 111 points. He hit 16 homers last year, but doesn’t project to produce much if any more power than that; he’s more likely to be a high-doubles guy with strong on-base skills.
Quero remains a solid-average defender with an average arm, still working on some of the finer points of the position but also a no-doubt catcher whose bat looks like it’ll make him a regular there. He may be better off in some kind of soft platoon role, depending on how much of the improvement against righties was real, but there’s still everyday ceiling here.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Genao had a disappointing year in 2023 in Low A, hitting .263/.345/.385 in 72 games after missing the first two months with a torn meniscus, but he went back to Low A to start 2024 and hit all year long — .341/.383/.553 repeating Low A, then .322/.377/.463 after a June promotion to High A. He’s grown substantially since he was first measured at his “official” height and weight of 5-9, 150, gaining significant strength but also getting to the point where he might end up outgrowing shortstop. He’s a switch-hitter who’s better from the left side but capable enough from the right side to keep it up, actually hitting with more power right-handed in each of the last two years. He’s an average runner and not terribly twitchy, with second or third base more likely than shortstop, but his bat should still make him an above-average regular at either spot.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Mathews was a senior sign out of Stanford in 2023 who succeeded with a plus changeup and above-average command but worked at 90-92 when going once a week. He gained a ton of velocity last offseason, however, working 92-97 on the four-seamer, with a slider that’s more effective now in the mid-80s despite low spin rates and soft break. The result was that he raced from A-ball through four levels and led all minor-league pitchers with 202 strikeouts, only running into some trouble when he got to Triple A.
His arm speed on the changeup is just like it is on the fastball, but the pitch comes out 10 mph or more slower and has some tumble as well, flummoxing hitters who think it’s coming in at 94, and the funk in his delivery further adds to the deception of the pitch. That said, I don’t love the delivery; there’s a lot of effort behind the funkiness, and he takes a modest stride with some head-snap at release. He was badly overworked as a college senior, especially in the postseason, and then saw his velocity jump up very rapidly inside of a year, which seems in my experience to often precede elbow injuries (this is based on anecdotal evidence, to be clear). He’s clearly passed most of the Cardinals’ other pitching prospects and is probably the best guy called up for a rotation spot in the majors if there’s an injury — or if they move one of their veterans in a trade before Opening Day.

2024 Ranking: 44

I wish the Brewers would just give Black the first-base job and call it a day; he should outperform Rhys Hoskins’ 2024 line quite handily after hitting .258/.375/429 in Triple A last year. Black is extremely disciplined at the plate and already has a reputation for fighting for every strike; his chase rate is good at 20 percent (just in Triple A), not exceptional, but he connected with those in some way more half of the time, either fouling them off or putting them in play. He rarely whiffs and has shown he can hit lefties up through the top levels of the minors. He doesn’t throw well enough for the left side of the infield after shoulder surgery, although he runs well enough to maybe play center and certainly could play second if the Brewers didn’t already have Brice Turang there. He’s a very capable first baseman, if an untraditional one, with average power and his real strength in getting on base. Black would be more valuable at another spot, which is why he’s in this place in the rankings, but for his current team he’s also their best internal option at a less-valuable position he can play.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

White was the Marlins’ second pick in the 2023 draft, a huge high school lefty out of Massachusetts who had big stuff but questions around his long arm swing and present command. He turned a lot of that on its head in spring training last year, showing up in incredible shape and with a clear determination to get better any way he could, and ended up pitching better after a midyear promotion to High A. White topped out at 97.6 mph in the Florida State League last year and sat 94-96 with his high-spin four-seamer, getting good ride at the top of the zone, along with an easily plus changeup and a slider that looked about average but played exceptionally well even at a relatively low velocity for the pitch (mostly 78-82). His delivery is pretty easy, perhaps still lacking deception — a concern scouts raised when he was an amateur — but it didn’t affect him anywhere in A-ball and I wouldn’t change anything right now. If he gets more power to the slider, which at least has above-average spin rates to work with, he could easily have three plus pitches, with a 200-inning starter’s build and what now looks like at least average command. White did a great job preparing himself for the season last winter and the Marlins might have a future ace.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Hope was part of the four-player trade that sent Michael Busch and Yency Almonte to the Cubs, bringing Hope and Jackson Ferris to the Dodgers, a deal that got the Cubs their best season from a first baseman since 2019, but that has also given the Dodgers two of their top six prospects. Hope seemed like a longshot when the Cubs took him in the 11th round in 2023 out of a small high school in central Virginia; he was a tremendous athlete with plus speed but no history of hitting even decent pitching and poor instincts in the outfield. Fast forward a year and he’s become a much, much better hitter in every way, improving his pitch selection and recognition, getting stronger (to the point where he probably doesn’t have a lot of physical projection left), and becoming at least an average defender in an outfield corner.
He doesn’t chase pitches out of the zone and he really doesn’t miss anything inside, regardless of pitch types. He is more vulnerable to velocity up and/or away and pitchers are going to try to attack him there or down with offspeed stuff, but he’s made so many adjustments already it seems reasonable to bet he’ll adjust again as needed. He’s every bit of a 70 runner and shows plus power already, and you can project 30/30 on him pretty easily if he continues to hit and control the zone as he moves up the ladder. He did have some more trouble with better pitching in the AFL, and the move up to High A and a worse hitter’s environment this year will tell us more about just how advanced he is and how much time he might need to get to the majors. Hope’s upside is enormous, with a wide variance in potential outcomes.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Briceño signed with the Tigers in January 2022 for $800,000 as a catcher with some offensive potential, but at this point it looks like he’s just going to be a first baseman who mashes. He had played only 11 games above the complex leagues coming into 2024, then got hurt 28 games into the Florida State League season, missing three months with a strained PCL in his right knee. To make up for some of that lost time, he went to the Arizona Fall League, where he was one of the youngest players at 19 and one of a very small number of players there who hadn’t played above Low A yet. In 25 games, he hit absolutely everything. It’s a hitter’s environment out in the desert, sure, but his .433/.509/.867 line was good enough to lead the league in average and slugging.
He’s a big guy, listed at 6-4, 200, and probably stronger than that, but his swing is very easy and quiet, and he’s reached 109 mph in each of his two stints in Low A already, with an EV50 just over 100 mph. He also showed strong pitch recognition in the Florida State League and in Arizona, and rarely swung and missed; if there’s a knock on his offense, it’s that he’s a little too pull-heavy now, although he’s also hardly had the need to try to do anything else. He only played first base in Arizona with Thayron Liranzo there, and Briceño was already iffy as a catcher even before the knee injury. I think his future is at first, and it might behoove the Tigers to just put him there now and let him go rake rather than slow his development or risk further injury at a position he’s already unlikely to play. He might be a top 20 prospect in a year from his bat alone.

2024 Ranking: Ineligible

Caglianone was a two-way star at Florida, hitting 35 homers as a junior while also making 16 starts, although his future is much brighter as a hitter than on the mound. He has 80 raw power and did work to cut his strikeout rate from his sophomore year (18.1 percent) to his junior year (8.2 percent), missing less often on pitches in the zone. He still chases pitches out of the zone way too often, doing so nearly 40 percent of the time last spring, and needs to develop more of a two-strike approach and work on going the other way on pitches outside, as he’s very pull-heavy.
As a pitcher, has been up to 99 and shows at least an average changeup, but it’s a cross-body delivery with a lot of effort to it, resulting in well below average control (15.4 percent walk rate in two years for the Gators), and he’s already had one Tommy John surgery in high school. The Royals have said so far that they intend to let him hit and pitch, which probably means he’s going to stay at first base to protect his arm; I’d love to see him just focus on hitting, given the 40-homer upside and the need for some big adjustments, which might also let him handle right field.

2024 Ranking: 30

Williams had a breakout year in 2023, but he started to feel pain in his right wrist during an awful start in April last season and eventually had surgery that kept him out for exactly four months, limiting him to 30 total games including his rehab assignment. He didn’t hit well anywhere except for the one six-game series he spent in Triple A, still drawing plenty of walks but without any impact when he did make contact — which could easily be a result of the wrist injury. He went to the Fall League to pick up some more at-bats, and was a 45 defender at short there and running closer to average than plus, and might be better suited to second base regardless of the presence of Francisco Lindor at shortstop in Queens. It’s a compact swing combined with very good ball/strike awareness, and he could be a high-average/high-OBP second baseman with 55-60 defense, which would make him a solid or better regular. His 2024 season was just a lost year, and while he can’t get those at-bats back, it’s also possible that we’ll have to just disregard what he did do when he played because he wasn’t 100 percent.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Keaschall was the Twins’ second-round pick in 2023 out of Arizona State and finished his first full pro season in Double A, hitting well at two levels with very high contact rates and some surprising power. Keaschall has always shown good awareness of the strike zone and that carried over into pro ball, with a chase rate under 20 percent on the season, and excellent pitch recognition to go along with it. He’d had issues with fastballs up in college, but he’s looser at the plate now and gets to those pitches more often. He’s also staying back longer before transferring his weight to his front side, allowing him to get more power from his lower half and helping him swat 15 homers in 102 games last year.
He’s close to a 60 runner and should end up a 55 or better defender at second, just lacking the arm to move to short or third, and range-wise he looks more than capable of handling centerfield. He played with a torn UCL last year and ended up undergoing Tommy John surgery in August, so we’ll have to see what his arm strength looks like on his return. He’s a very likely regular as long as he can still handle the throws from second base, and his bat might even profile if he has to move to left in the worst case scenario.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Dana did not belong in the big leagues last season, and his 9.58 ERA in three starts shouldn’t be held against him. He had a wildly successful year as a 20-year-old in Double A with just 76 innings of previous pro experience. He posted a 2.52 ERA in the minors, striking out 27.2 percent of batters and walking just 7.2 percent, making 23 starts for Rocket City and then the three more for the Angels to make for about as full a season of work as you’ll find for a 20-year-old pitching prospect.
Dana mostly works with a 92-95 mph fastball and an above-average slider, with an occasional changeup that has good deception and a little tumble, and a curveball that’s not bad but that he barely uses. He’ll have to use the changeup more to continue to keep lefties in check, as he did in Double A, but otherwise he has a good pitch mix and his delivery should get him to at least above-average command. He’s got a solid floor as a No. 4 starter and is young enough to keep refining his pitches and his overall pitching plan and get to a No. 2.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Rosario posted a 7.11 ERA in his draft year for the University of Miami, and a 7.05 ERA as a sophomore, despite a good arm and a potential out pitch in his splitter that he barely used, as Miami had him working more sinker/changeup. The Rangers took him in the fifth round for the quality of his stuff — obviously not for the quality of his results — and told him to throw the splitter and go with a four-seamer up, and voila!, instant prospect!
He works from the extreme third-base side of the rubber, getting some more deception against righties, as he has the splitter for lefties and can still be effective against them even without throwing offspeed stuff on the inner third to them. He has elite control already, pounding the strike zone with his fastball and walking just 3.7 percent of batters he faced at both levels of A-ball last year, although that’s likely to go up as older hitters lay off the splitter when it’s out of the zone. He repeats his delivery to keep up the control, and while he’s not very tall he looks strong enough to handle a starter’s workload. Even as is, sitting 92-95 with the plus splitter and a maybe-average slider, he should be a mid-rotation starter and get to the majors this year.

2024 Ranking: Ineligible

Waldschmidt got first-round buzz for much of the spring of 2024 but ended up sliding to the No. 31 pick, possibly because teams had concerns about the ACL tear he suffered a year prior. Right now that looks like a boon for the Diamondbacks, who took him with their second selection of the draft. He had one of the best pure hit tools in the draft, rarely missing a fastball and generally not chasing much on any pitches. He hit .370/.500/.653 for Kentucky despite a wide setup and no stride, which limited how much he could generate power from his lower half and resulted in a swing that could get too steep as he tried to loft the ball. He does have room to add 20-25 pounds, and has already made some small mechanical adjustments to try to loosen up his hips and keep his swing in that optimal range for power. In instructional league, the DBacks tried him at third base, where he last played as a freshman at Charleston Southern before he transferred to Kentucky, but the results weren’t good and he should just go to an outfield corner and stay there. He has .300 average/25-homer upside if he can loosen up those hips.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Montes is a huge, lumbering prospect from Cuba who hits the ball exceptionally hard, so the natural comparison is to a young Yordan Alvarez, who was older than Montes when he first played in full-season ball but reached the majors days before his 22nd birthday. Montes is extremely strong and has produced exit velocities well north of 110 mph, with clear 40 homer upside as long as he hits enough to get to it. He’s not as natural of a hitter as Alvarez, although the Mariners worked with him on pitch selection and a two-strike approach last year and he did see better swing decisions overall. He raked in Low A as a 19-year-old, hitting .309/.411/.527 with just a 19.1 percent strikeout rate, then moved up to High A around the midpoint and hit .260/.378/.427 there with a 29.6 percent strikeout rate, still making hard contact but a lot more whiffs on stuff in the zone.
He’s going to end up at first base, as he’s already really big for an outfield corner and doesn’t have much range, but there’s a pretty good chance he hits for enough power and takes enough walks to be an above-average regular there. I don’t think Montes is really the next Yordan; he doesn’t have the same kind of hit tool, but he also doesn’t have Yordan’s knees, which both required surgery when he was 23 and made him even less mobile than he was before.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Ingle was a part-time catcher at Clemson when Cleveland took him in the fourth round in 2023 and announced him as a catcher, a project that of course would make his high-contact, low-power bat a lot more viable. A year and a half later, the project looks like a resounding success, as Ingle reached Double A last year, has walked more than he’s struck out as a pro, and has improved his defense to the point where he’s clearly going to stay at catcher.
Ingle knows the strike zone extremely well, and he whiffed just 14 percent of the time he swung last year, with a short, quick swing that has a little more lift in its finish than it did in college, bringing his groundball rate down from 55 percent as a college junior to 45 percent last year. His defense isn’t pretty but he can catch and block, and a quick transfer helps his fringy arm play up to the point where he’s adequate against the running game. He hit 11 homers last year between High A and Double A, all off right-handed pitchers, and he’ll have to show he can make better quality contact against lefties, whereas now he just walks against them. He’s small but well put together, and with his contact and on-base skills he could be a .375 OBP/.400 SLG guy, which is a heck of a regular behind the plate even if he’s just fringy defensively.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Freeland broke his hamate bone in his draft year in 2022, then struggled in his full-season debut in 2023, hitting .240/.345/.362 in High A while dealing with some minor injuries. His production took off last year after getting fully healthy and making some small adjustments to his swing. He ripped through High A and hit .245/.370/.422 in half a season in Double A before a promotion to Triple A to finish the season, where he hit .243/.335/.396 but had some excellent underlying data. Born with a clubfoot that required several surgeries, Freeland runs close to average and plays an average-ish shortstop now with a plus arm. He’s dabbled a little at second and third, playing about 50 innings at each spot last year, and the odds are he’ll end up at one of those spots in the long run.
He’s a switch-hitter who doesn’t post huge exit velocities but also doesn’t post a lot of low ones either, averaging over 91 mph in his brief Triple-A time despite never hitting anything above 107. He’s also a very disciplined hitter who doesn’t chase or whiff very often, and has shown above-average power already, with 53 extra-base hits last year, including 18 homers. There isn’t really any projection here beyond further developing the hit tool against better pitching. He doesn’t really need to do anything more to be a solid regular at second or third, or an above-average one if he does manage to stick at shortstop.

2024 Ranking: Just missed

Chourio spent all of 2024 in Low A as a 19-year-old and ended up ranking 10th in all of the minors with 86 walks, the most drawn by any teenager in minor league baseball last year. Jackson’s younger brother is also a centerfielder and an excellent athlete, a switch-hitter and centerfielder right now who could end up in a corner as he continues to fill out and who may end up just hitting left-handed. He’s a strong defender right now up the middle with above-average speed, so if he can maintain that even with the physical projection he has left, he could remain in center in the long term.
His plate discipline and hand-eye are outstanding, leading to chase and whiff rates well above (better than) average, although he needs to add some hand strength to get some more consistent loft in his finish. His groundball rate in 2024 was 49.3 percent, which was actually his lowest rate at any stop in pro ball. He’s been much better from the left side; batting right-handed last year, he hit just .245/.409/.283, with more walks (16) than total bases (15). It might be a bat speed question, as his right-handed bat path looks fine and he actually gets a little more loft than he does left-handed.
He doesn’t have Jackson’s ceiling, but there’s a scenario here where Jaison stays in center and figures out hitting against lefties enough to be a grade 60 player, with 20ish homers and very high OBPs, and the floor is really solid given his very real patience and likelihood of plus defense in a corner. His 2024 did end with a broken wrist, so it’s possible he won’t get all the strength back until some time this summer.

2024 Ranking: Ineligible

Rainer was the second high school player taken in the 2024 draft and the top high schooler on my draft board, ranking highly as a true shortstop with a plus arm and sneaky power that gives him the chance to be a two-way impact player. He’s a plus defender with great instincts, showing real leadership on his high school team on the field (such as directing other players on positioning) and a plus arm that’s been up to 95 on the mound. He’s power-over-hit right now, with a lot of leverage in his swing and good loft to drive the ball to all fields, but his bat speed is just fair and when he saw good velocity as an amateur he struggled. He’s still pretty raw, especially for a California high school kid, with a lot of room for physical and skills improvements, and the Tigers will probably be able to help him tighten up the swing to be shorter to the ball. It’s 20-homer upside in a plus defensive shortstop as long as he hits enough to get to it.

2024 Ranking: 59

Nimmala was one of the youngest draftees in 2023, turning 18 four months after he was picked, and as such should have started 2024 in the complex league rather than Low A, but after a torrid spring training the Jays sent him to the Florida State League … and he struggled, hitting .167/280/.306 with a 34 percent strikeout rate before the Jays sent him back to the complex to reset. After three weeks there, he went to the complex league for a few games, then returned to Low A and hit .265/.331/.564 the rest of the way. He ended up leading the Florida State League in slugging (.476) and finished fifth in the league with 15 homers, all as the league’s youngest qualifying hitter. He’s a true shortstop with good actions and a plus arm, and the power he showed on the field is legit, as he’s got very strong hands and wrists, with a swing that’s very rotational and puts the ball in the air a ton — his groundball rate in Low A last year was just 31.4 percent. He’s still only 19 and remains projectable enough to end up a 30-homer bat in a few years; right now it’s more consistently hard contact (his 90th percentile EV in Low A was 102.3 mph, and his EV50 was 99.0 mph on the dot) than huge top-end EV (peak was 107). He’s still a high-risk, high-reward player, as he continued to strike out 29.7 percent of the time in his second go-round in Low A, and generally needs to tighten up his pitch recognition and bring his chase rate (31 percent) down at least a little. I keep coming back to his results for his age, though — he was younger than Dante Nori, the Phillies’ first-round pick in 2024, for one example — and the potential for big power at a position up the middle. He’s still every bit the prospect that made him a first-rounder in the 2023 draft — and a top-10 talent on my own board.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Caba was the centerpiece of the trade that sent Jesús Luzardo to the Phillies, as the Marlins went for some ceiling by adding the young shortstop, who is one of the best defensive infielders in the minors. Caba might be an 80 defender already, with a plus arm, incredible instincts, and quick actions at the position. He played all of 2024 at age 18 and hit .254/.427/.335 in the Florida Complex League, walking 51 times and striking out just 34, before a late-season promotion to Low A, where he still made contact but only hit .179/.304/.190. His approach is real — rather than that of someone who is up there to walk — and now he needs to get stronger to be able to do more when he does put the ball in play. His swings are good from both sides of the plate; he can open his hips too early from either side, robbing him of some of the power he might get from his lower half. He only turned 19 in November, so he’s going to get stronger from here. He doesn’t need plus or even average power to be a quality regular given his defense and his on-base skills.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Cleveland drafted Velazquez in the first round in 2023 and immediately moved him out from behind the plate to allow him to develop his bat and perhaps reach the majors more quickly than he otherwise would have. His first full pro season was a promising sign in that direction. He got off to a great start as a 19-year-old in Low A, hitting .261/.371/.441 in the first half, before wearing down in the second half. He’s a big, strong kid, but a better hitter than you might expect at first glance, striking out just 20.1 percent of the time in Low A even as one of the youngest players in full-season ball, and he does make hard enough contact to project to 25 homers at his peak. He hits with a wide stance and no stride, just a toe-tap for timing, so he doesn’t get all the power he could out of his lower half and his swing can flatten out because he doesn’t fully rotate his hips.
The Guardians tried him in left field last year as well as at first base, and he was capable enough that they’ll probably keep that alive as a possibility for him going forward. His future is in his bat, with contact skills and zone awareness that set him up very well for future success, and cleanup-hitter upside if he loosens up a little to drive the ball more easily.

2024 Ranking: 49

Horton was getting close to a big-league callup last year when he suffered what was first called a lat strain in his start on May 29. It turned out to be a Grade 2 strain of the subscap muscle in his rotator cuff, and his season was over. He’s still rehabbing and should be good to go for spring training, although the Cubs may choose to keep him on a pitch or innings limit as he builds back up.
Horton has two plus pitches in his wipeout slider, which he added near the end of his last year at Oklahoma, and a changeup that’s improved substantially since the Cubs got their hands on him. His fastball is 92-96 but plays down from it because he doesn’t have a lot of deception. It has a little cut and pitch models like it, but hitters like it too, hitting it hard when it’s in the zone. He’s probably going to have to be a 40 percent fastball guy and work more to the edges of the zone with it, as it’s not a high-ride pitch for the top of the zone and definitely not one he can use in the heart to get whiffs, but he has the two real weapons to get guys out and has shown above-average control up through Double A. He’s a starter as long as he’s healthy, maybe a No. 3 who takes a little while to figure out his optimal pitching plan. We’ll know a lot more once he gets into a game in Arizona.

2024 Ranking: 75

Dollander’s 2024 season was sort of a consolidation year for him, as he got some of his slider back but doesn’t have it as a consistent plus pitch as it was back in 2022. As a sophomore at Tennessee, he had a wipeout slider, easily a grade 70, and may have been the best college pitcher in the country that spring, but that offseason he went to some sort of self-styled expert and switched to a sweeper that was ineffective — although it helped the Rockies get him at the ninth pick in the 2023 draft. His changeup has improved significantly in the last two years to be a solid-average pitch, with a little wiggle at the end to help but mostly deceiving hitters from how he throws it. The slider is the key; when it’s on, it’s 85-87 with hard tilt and a big move away from right-handers. It can end up more cutter-like at 89-90, still effective but with a different shape that makes it look more like the fastball, and could even be his best approach to lefties rather than the changeup. The Rockies have already helped him get part of the way back to his 2022 form, and if they can get that slider to be more consistent, it’ll be a real out-pitch, and the weapon he’ll need given his just average command and control. He has a fourth starter floor, but more upside as the slider develops or recovers.

2024 Ranking: Just missed

Mitchell’s first year in a full-season league was a mixed bag, a net positive at the end that didn’t answer some of the concerns that dated back to when the Royals first drafted him at No. 8 in 2023. He’s got power, nearly getting to 20 homers as a teenager in Low A, and the Royals have helped loosen him up a little by reducing the very wide stance he used in high school to a more typical one that has him back in the box to start, giving him lots of room to stride forward and get his hips rotating. He showed excellent ball-strike recognition last year as well, and while he had some difficulty with offspeed stuff, he’s laying off more of those pitches when they’re not strikes than he did before.
He seemed to wear down by the summer; he hit .257/.391/.468 in the first half, striking out too often (31.2 percent), then hit .195/.338/.372 from the All-Star break until a promotion to High A for the last two weeks of the season. Mitchell isn’t much of a runner, at least not by the stopwatch, but he’s improved his baserunning significantly and stole 25 bags in 32 attempts. He has a cannon of an arm, with average to above-average receiving and blocking skills now that could end up plus. Mitchell has already made some big adjustments since he signed, which is the best harbinger of a player’s ability to make further adjustments. I’m encouraged by the progress in his swing decisions; if he continues that trend, he’s going to end up an above-average regular, even if it takes him another three or so years to get to the majors.

2024 Ranking: 78

Arroyo missed all of the 2024 regular season after tearing the labrum in his left shoulder in March, undergoing surgery that kept him out until the Arizona Fall League, where he played 18 games but looked understandably rusty. He has the tools to be a plus defender at short, with excellent range and a strong arm, but remains very inconsistent in the field, lacking great timing, dropping his arm on a lot of throws, and otherwise making scouts question whether he’ll have the skills to stay there long term. He has bat speed and has shown he can handle good fastballs, still needing to get stronger and to improve his breaking-ball recognition. He’s also an above-average to plus runner who should add value on the bases.
He’s still just 21 and has time to add that strength and work on the pitch recognition, although he’s lost probably 400 or so at-bats that he can’t easily recover due to the injury. Arroyo has everyday ceiling as a shortstop if he can bear down and get more consistent on defense, or he could be a solid regular at second base if he fills out some more and starts hitting the ball harder.

2024 Ranking: Ineligible

I very rarely put international free agents on my top 100 before they’ve played a game in the U.S. complex leagues, but two things worked in Made’s favor this year: the minors are as thin as ever in elite prospects, and he’s really *&^ing good. Made signed for just $950,000 in January 2024 and had a reputation as a power-over-hit guy, but instead he showed up in the DSL and showed a way more mature approach at the plate than expected, walking more than he struck out — that’s not that hard to do in the DSL, just don’t ever swing — and making very good swing decisions. He’s barely begun to fill out but already makes hard, loud contact from both sides of the plate, getting compared to Jackson Chourio at the same age, but with better batted-ball data. He’s a shortstop now with a plus arm that will help him with a likely move to third base once he’s a little older, and the Brewers have already given him time at third and second, so they may be thinking along the same lines. He could easily be a top 20 prospect at this time next year if the approach and the loud contact carry over to the ACL or even Low A.

2024 Ranking: 61

Ford had a mixed year in 2024, moving up to Double A and continuing to get on base, albeit with slightly worse results across the board at the plate, while his defense behind the plate was worse and there’s more chance now that he ends up at DH than there was a year ago. He still has very strong plate discipline, chasing pitches out of the zone just 19 percent of the time, about one-third of those were pitches just one ball’s width outside of the zone. He has shown he can lay off many right-handers’ sliders down and away. He has more raw power than his .367 slugging percentage would imply, but last year he just didn’t square the ball up anywhere near as consistently has he had before, and his tendency to pop up pitches a little above the belt got worse. He’s a plus runner and great athlete who moves well behind the dish, but he’s a 45 receiver right now and his plus arm hasn’t translated into even average caught-stealing rates.
The Mariners did try him a few games in left field this year, but the early returns weren’t promising. He’s 21, knows the strike zone, has untapped power, and is very athletic, all reasons to still believe there’s upside here, but Ford’s 2024 season was kind of a disappointment, and if he doesn’t stay behind the plate I’m not sure the bat will profile as a regular at any other spot.

2024 Ranking: Ineligible

King spent two years at Division II Wingate University, then transferred to Wake Forest for his junior year and excelled for the Deacons despite the huge jump in competition, hitting .308/.377/.577 with just a 12 percent strikeout rate. He mostly played third base and centerfield for Wake, occasionally moving to shortstop when Marek Houston was hurt or needed a day off, but the Nats took King with the No. 10 pick and only played him at short in his pro debut. He’s a 55 defender there now and could still improve given his lack of experience and limited instruction there.
He’s got a quick bat and is very aggressive at the plate, especially early in counts, because he can put so many pitches in play, even ones out of the zone — for now, at least, as that doesn’t always work as you get further up the ladder. He’s got sneaky pop, maybe good for 15 homers a year, but his game is going to be much more about hitting for contact and average, since his current swing doesn’t get a ton of lift on the ball. His 55/60 speed makes him a solid defender in center if shortstop doesn’t work out, but he’s most valuable at short and I think he’s going to hit more than enough to be a very good regular there.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Arroyo needed to get to more power, and he did in 2024, repeating Low A and boosting his slugging percentage by 127 points, then heading up to High A and hitting .290/.397/.519 — all before his 20th birthday. He signed in January 2022 with the reputation of being an advanced hitter, and that’s been true, as he has a great approach that has him aggressive within the strike zone without expanding outside of it too often. He’s short with a stockier build, with really no chance to stay at shortstop, so there was more pressure on him to hit the ball harder, and he did so, with big improvements in his batted-ball data and his power output. He hit five homers total in 61 games in 2023, then hit 23 in 120 games last year. He barrels the ball very consistently and puts it in the air over 60 percent of the time. In the field, he has a plus arm and good enough hands to stay on the dirt somewhere, playing almost all of his reps at second base last year but with third base also a possibility as long as he doesn’t get much bigger from here. We’ve seen plenty of undersized infielders become All-Stars in recent years because they could square the ball up for frequent hard contact, including José Ramírez and Alex Bregman. That’s Arroyo’s absolute best-case scenario, of course, but as long as he stays on the dirt he should be at least an everyday player.

2024 Ranking: 64

Bradfield’s full-season debut went pretty much as expected, as he continued to play elite defense in center and show 80 speed, but he hasn’t made any changes at the plate to try to drive the ball more consistently. He’s one of the best defensive centerfielders in the minors, with huge range thanks to his speed and good reads off the bat, and that and his speed give him a pretty clear floor as a fourth outfielder. That’s buttressed by his high-contact approach; he whiffed only 15 percent of the time he swung last year, according to data from Synergy Sports, and chased pitches out of the zone only 17 percent of the time.
He’s still got an overly complicated swing that results in a lot of groundballs, although the Orioles are working with him to try to get him to hit more line drives to the outfield, even just over the infielders’ heads, and let his legs do their thing. He’s slight and not likely to ever hit for more than below-average power, but he’s strong enough to ambush the occasional pitch and pull it out to right. He started 2024 slowly but improved as the season went on, finishing with a month in Double A where he hit .287/.395/.396, which I think is probably his best-case scenario in the majors. Add defense that could be +15 runs in a full season in center and you’ve got a 5-WAR player. He just has to keep progressing at the plate, mechanically and in production, to get there.

2024 Ranking: 50

Collier’s 2024 season was a mixture of some very good stuff and some bad as well, as he mashed as a 19-year-old in High A but also showed up way bigger than he had the year before and he needs to get his conditioning under control. He was one of only nine teenagers to play all of 2024 at High A or above, only turning 20 in November, and hit .248/.355/.443 with 20 homers, tying for second in homers in the Midwest League behind a 23-year-old. He continued to improve his swing decisions, cutting way down on his chase rate from 2023 and picking up pitch types better, even as he was very young for his level.
The bad is that Collier has let his body get away from him, as he’s gotten so heavy that he might end up at first base, which is a waste of his athleticism and raises concerns about his makeup and work ethic. There’s just no reason for a 19-year-old with his frame to get this heavy — he’s listed at 210, but I’d guess he’s closer to 240 — this soon. His 30-homer upside would still make him a regular at first or DH, and he’s probably to end up with 60+ walks a year. He’s more valuable at third base, of course, with a strong enough arm for it, and he’s also going to put himself at risk of back and knee problems if he doesn’t manage his size.

2024 Ranking: Ineligible

Griffin was the best tools prospect in the 2024 draft class — meaning he had the best overall combination of physical tools, with potential 60 or 70 grades in power, speed, arm, and fielding in centerfield, but no one seems to know if he’s going to hit. The Pirates took a shot with the No. 9 pick in the draft and will have to be patient, as the history of high school hitters from Mississippi is pretty dismal because of the caliber of competition those hitters face as amateurs. He’s played short and center but looks much better in the outfield, with pro reports on his shortstop defense from instructs not especially glowing, and he’s got a 70 arm that produced low-90s velocity when he pitched. It’s also huge raw power with a swing that generates a ton of leverage, both good from his hip rotation and bad from his deep hand load that creates a longer path. He does have quick hands and should be able to adjust to a shorter swing without sacrificing much power if any, assuming the Pirates decide to go that route. There’s a ton of risk here — multiple scouts have seen him, raved about the tools, and told me “I just don’t know if he can hit” — but Griffin offers 30/30 upside with plus defense in center.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Sykora was the first pick on Day 2 of the 2023 draft, and signed with Washington for a first-round bonus. All he did in 2024 was pitch like a first-rounder, as he struck out 39.2 percent of Low-A hitters he faced and walked just 8.2 percent in 85 innings across 20 starts, posting a 2.33 ERA. He’s a giant already, and his delivery has arms and legs flying everywhere, so it must be terrifying for hitters to see all of that mass coming towards them, followed by a small projectile that might be moving at 99 mph. He sits more 93-96, with a slider that ranged from the upper 70s to the mid-80s with short but abrupt downward break, and a heavy split-change around 83-85, with both of the offspeed pitches missing a ton of bats this year.
The arm is still kind of late relative to his front leg, and all the moving parts in the delivery make me suspect it’ll always be more control than command for him. He also doesn’t seem to pitch down with his four-seamer at all, which might not be an issue but just strikes me as unusual. Sykora pitched like a future ace last year, and he has two pitches that could get him there. He may have simply out-stuffed Low-A hitters, however, and I would like to see him do it against more advanced hitters before buying in completely.

2024 Ranking: Ineligible

Caldwell would have been a top-10 pick in the 2024 draft if he were 6-1 rather than his actual height, which is definitely less than his listed 5-9 and might be as little as 5-6. No one doubts that he can play, though — it’s potentially three plus tools in his hit, run, and field grades, with an average-ish arm and below-average power. He’s got a compact swing and excellent plate discipline, approaching at-bats like a leadoff hitter whose job is to get on base any way he can. There’s definite bat speed here, enough to turn on good velocity, but there isn’t average power now and he doesn’t have the projection to get there. His best route to becoming a regular — or even an above-average one — is to be a high-OBP, high-contact hitter who steals bases and plays plus defense in center, even with six-to-eight homers a year. He’s not the next Corbin Carroll, another undersized outfielder who the Dbacks selected and developed into a superstar, but he could move quickly through A-ball if his plate discipline is really as good as advertised.

2024 Ranking: 90

I still believe Misiorowski is 100 percent a reliever, but I also think he’s going to be one of the best relievers in baseball once he gets accustomed to the role. His stuff is so good that he punched out 30 percent of batters he faced in Double A and then again in a brief stint in Triple A, even though he’s got maybe 40 command if you’re kind. He averaged 98 on his four-seamer in Nashville, topping out at 100.7 mph, and his slider sits 90-93, with both pitches easily grading out at 70 and possibly 80. His low- to mid-80s curveball gives him a different look, with some sharp downward break, although his command of that pitch is the worst of the three. He routinely gets more than 7 1/4 feet of extension, so hitters really have no chance, and given how wild he is anyway, who can blame them for standing there and not swinging? He walked 14.3 percent of batters he faced last year, with maybe the best two-pitch combo in the minors, where he could send hitters a telegram to tell them what’s coming and they still couldn’t hit it. It’s a very high-effort delivery and he hasn’t toned it down at all since he signed, which further points to a relief role. If he moves to the bullpen, I think he’ll strike out 40 percent of batters or more and continue to limit hard contact, and become one of the best relievers in the majors. I just do not see any way that delivery and command could work in a rotation.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

No player on this list surprised me more by making the cut than del Castillo, who didn’t make my Arizona top 20 last year, when I said he “could surface as a capable backup, with some on-base skills and enough defense to catch once or twice a week.” Oops. He hadn’t hit much at all in a stint in Triple-A Reno, one of the minors’ best hitters’ parks, in 2023, but returned there in 2024 and hit .311/.392/.597 with a career-high 26 homers, hitting well on the road as well.
He was originally drafted in 2021 as a below-average defensive catcher who could hit but didn’t show much power. He’s worked to improve his receiving and blocking to the point that he’s an average defender with a 45 arm who can really hit and probably has 20-homer power. He barreled up 10 percent of balls he hit while in Triple A, and his EV50 there was 101 mph, with a swing geared to produce hard line drives. He’s best suited to a hybrid role where he catches some of the time and plays first or DHs the rest of the time to get him into the lineup as much as possible. I don’t think he’s a star, but I do think he’s an everyday player right now.

2024 Ranking: 56

Taylor had a weird first full year in pro ball in two ways — he ended up hitting for more power with less contact than I think anyone reasonably expected, and the way he got to all those strikeouts (24.8 percent in High A, 36.8 percent in Double A) was kind of unusual as well. Taylor hits the ball hard and ended up with a great line in High A beyond the strikeouts, hitting .269/.389/.513 with 44 extra-base hits in 84 games, before struggling in 30 games in Double A, where he hit .194/.290/.435 — still showing power, but of course with way too many Ks. He did raise his bat path a little, making it steeper to manufacture some more lift, which might explain the increase in strikeouts — he actually doesn’t chase much at all, and he doesn’t miss a ton in-zone, but when he does expand, it’s kind of disastrous for him.

2024 Ranking: 81

Regular readers of mine know I don’t like DeLauter’s swing — at all, really. It’s the worst-looking swing on this list. I’m not even sure who’s second. But DeLauter has also had success everywhere he’s played so far in the minors, and the biggest knock on him right now isn’t the fact that looking directly at his swing will turn you to stone, but that he hasn’t been able to stay on the field for a full season. Since the Guardians took him with the No. 16 pick in 2022, at which point he was already out with a broken bone in his left foot, DeLauter has played in just 96 regular-season games, plus two stints in the AFL. The original fracture cost him the remainder of 2022. He required surgery in that winter after he re-fractured it, then suffered another fracture in that foot in April 2024, then developed turf toe in his first game back from that injury. He strained his hamstring in late August and missed another month.
On the plus side, he’s hit very well when he’s been able to play. He destroyed A-ball pitching, hit .271/.353/.436 in 36 games in Double A across two years, and went 7-for-23 with two homers in Triple A this year, followed by his second straight year of excellent production in the AFL.
As for the swing, he opens his hips very early and then almost drags the bat through the zone, with a swing that looks like he’s trying to scoop the ball and pull it out to right. As a result, he doesn’t hit anything on the outer third for any power at all, and in a small sample so far lefties have really crushed him, especially with breaking stuff. He’s going to have to make some adjustments to get him on time to the zone more consistently, and I think major-league pitchers are going to attack that front hip with velocity up and in, which he can only hit on the ground, and then go soft away to exploit the swing. Nobody has really done that effectively so far in his career, however, so maybe he’s just good enough to work around them and use his high contact skills to force pitchers to pitch to his strengths — Dustin Pedroia did something similar, and he had a very unorthodox swing as well. DeLauter’s also a 55 runner and might be a plus defender in a corner, although I think his propensity to get hurt probably makes centerfield a non-starter.

2024 Ranking: 94

Mauricio missed all of 2024 after tearing his ACL while playing winter ball, then had a minor setback in his rehab that might delay his return further, although right now he’s expected to be ready for the start of the regular season. Prior to the injury, he was the Mets’ top prospect, with lightning in his wrists that produces grade-70 power, peaking at 117 mph in his brief major-league debut. He’s just way too aggressive at the plate, chasing offspeed stuff out of the zone at a rate that’s not going to be sustainable for a major-league regular — which is why the loss of a year-plus of plate appearances was so damaging for him, as he needs to work on ball/strike and pitch recognition, and the best way to do that is by playing. I’ve said before he reminds me a ton of Alfonso Soriano, who had similarly electric wrists, never figured out shortstop, and wasn’t anything close to “patient” at the plate, but improved his approach enough to hit 412 homers and play 16 years in the majors. That’s a best-case scenario for Mauricio, and probably more unlikely after the injury. We’ll have to see where he is on his return, what he’s swinging (or not swinging) at, and how he moves in the field.

2024 Ranking: 24

This is the, uh, get off the pot year for Johnson, as it is for several of his classmates from the 2022 draft (Druw Jones, Cam Collier). He’s entering his age-21 season and still hasn’t shown the plus hit tool everyone seemed to think he had as an amateur. Johnson failed to post a .250 batting average for the second year in a row and hit for even less power in 2024 than he had in 2023, again drawing a ton of walks while hitting too many groundballs and pop-ups. Johnson has excellent bat speed and clearly knows the strike zone, and he showed real progress during the season as the Pirates worked with him on his swing decisions to get him to do more damage on pitches on the inner half. He also moved further back in the box, and as a result of those adjustments, he cut down on his whiff and chase rates after the All-Star break and pulled the ball more often. Unfortunately, none of it translated into more hits or more power. A .237/.367/.386 season line isn’t going to make him more than an extra guy in the majors. He has too good of a swing and too much plate discipline to not hit at least in the high .200s.

2024 Ranking: 92

Meyer was the No. 10 pick in the 2023 draft, far and away the best high school pitching prospect in that draft class, but he showed up for his first spring training behind his peers, with his fastball velocity down several ticks after his personal offseason program. While his velocity did eventually improve, it was a harbinger of a first year that was a mixed bag, to put it mildly. He’d touched triple digits in high school with high spin rates on his fastball and two breaking balls, but in his first outing in the regular season last year he was just 90-93, building up to 93-97 in his final outing in Low A on May 25. He’s got a very long arm swing and his arm can be a little late, despite which he still shows a plus slider that generated a 41 percent whiff rate in Low A. His changeup continued to improve and it’s plus when he lands it, with too many finishing out of the strike zone right now, while his curveball backed up and wasn’t the same plus weapon it was for him in high school. His control overall was nowhere near where it should be, as he walked 16.3 percent of batters he faced in Low A and 17.9 percent in High A, approaching a level where it’s fair to question if he’ll ever have the control to be a major-league starter. Meyer showed No. 1 starter stuff in high school and he flashed some of it last year, but this wasn’t the same guy the Marlins drafted. I’m not giving up on him as a future above-average starter, to be clear, as the stuff is too good, but am acknowledging that his odds of ending up a reliever went up even as he got through his age-19 season without injury.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Hamm was Detroit’s fifth-round pick in 2023 after his first full year as a starter for Middle Tennessee State. He had an unusually high arm slot — nearly over the top — for a starting pitcher but a real weapon in his curveball. He went to High A last year and cut his walk rate from 10.4 percent in 2023 before the draft to 7.8 percent in the minors this past season, striking out 30.6 percent of batters with a full assortment of pitches. His curveball is still plus, his slider is at least solid-average, and his straight changeup is surprisingly effective — it’s hard to throw a changeup from that high of a slot, but he does it, and hitters don’t especially care for it. He’s working much more to his glove side now than he did in college, using the fastball and slider that way, since the slider is his only pitch with much horizontal movement, and he had no platoon split at all in High A last year. The knock on Hamm is that he didn’t hold his velocity all season, and he got hit a little more as the fastball velo declined over the course of the summer. It was his first full pro season, and he only spent one spring as a full-time starter in college, so this was the most he’d ever pitched without some kind of break or layoff, which is the only reason I’m willing to cut him some slack on the velo dip. If that happens again, he’s probably a reliever, and has the weapons to be a good one. His spot on the top 100 is a bet that he’ll stay a starter with more experience and perhaps a little work with the Tigers’ strength and conditioning team, ending up a solid No. 3 or more. If that doesn’t work, he could be a bulk reliever given how many effective offspeed pitches he has, just working less than a starter to try to keep his velocity up.

2024 Ranking: 41

Jones’ second full year in the minors went a lot better than his first. For one thing, he stayed healthy all year, playing 109 games after playing just 41 (including rehab games) the year before. For another, he started to produce for the first time in pro ball, hitting .275/.409/.405, tying for 12th in all of the minors with 85 walks — same as his draft classmate Termarr Johnson. It’s not all good news, as he still hit the ball on the ground way too often (57.2 percent of the time) for a guy with plus raw power, and his defense in center was more often grade 60 than 70 — or grade 80, like his father’s.
He’s shown more in-game power the other way than to his pull side, and doesn’t really try to turn on stuff on the inner third yet. His ball/strike recognition turned out to be much more advanced than expected, and the fact that he came back as well as he did from a 2023 season that was ruined by multiple injuries and some visible uncertainty at the plate is a positive sign. He could still end up just an extra outfielder but I think it’s too soon to assume that, given the power and plus defense he showed as an amateur.

2024 Ranking: Ineligible

The Jays’ 2024 first-round pick at the No. 20 pick was ranked 13th on my own board, and the No. 3 starter in the class (again, my rankings), coming off a dominant year for East Carolina where he struck out 145 in 93 innings (40.3 percent) and posted a 2.03 ERA — and didn’t turn 21 until two weeks after the draft. He has one of the shortest arm actions I’ve ever seen on a prospect of his caliber, but the stuff that comes out is undeniable, as he has a 91-96 mph four-seamer and a plus splitter with huge bottom and even some lateral movement, along with a decent slider in the mid-80s he uses mostly versus right-handers. His short arm stroke and the shape of his stuff make him much more of a north-south pitcher and I think he’ll have to find something to work a little more east-west, just to keep hitters honest on both sides of the zone. The delivery does worry me, because it’s unusual, and short arm actions like this generally end up in the bullpen. He’s been healthy the last two years as a starter for ECU, however, and I wouldn’t change anything given how good the stuff is. I’d move him as quickly as possible, as you’re not waiting for any projection on the current pitches, and see a potential No. 3 starter in the near future.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Cespedes’ stateside debut was limited to 25 games and 105 PA before he broke a hamate bone, but he flashed some of why he earned a $1.4 million bonus in January 2023. He’s small but strong, with a powerful swing for someone his size that backs up the numbers he’s produced so far, with 11 homers in 71 career games between the DSL and Florida Complex League. He hit .319/.400/.615 in that brief stint in Florida last year, striking out just 19 times in the 105 PA, showing strong command of the strike zone already. He’s not going to stick at shortstop, however, and might end up at third base rather than second given his frame and how his body looks now at age 19. He’ll move to Low A this year and may take some time to get all his hand strength back; beyond that, he looks like a hitter who could move quickly through the low minors because he’s stronger and more polished than the typical teenaged hitter, with the upside of an above-average regular at third with fringy defense but a strong all-around offensive game.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Lombard was the Yankees’ first-round pick in 2023 out of a South Florida high school, and he spent all of 2024 in full-season ball when he would previously have spent it at the now-defunct short-season level — yet another example of a player hurt by the contraction of the minors. His overall line of .231/.338/.334 is unimpressive, but under the hood there’s quite a bit to like. Lombard injured his hamstring in April, spending two weeks on the injured list but apparently battling it on and off throughout the year even after he returned. He did make some hard contact that didn’t show up in his stat line, topping out at 110 mph, and there is still a ton of projection on his 6-2 (or taller) frame to come into more bat speed and eventually in-game power. He just wasn’t ready for full-season ball; he could pick up offspeed stuff pretty well but had a hard time catching up to plus fastballs and ended up behind in the count too often. When healthy, he’s a plus runner, which might slide down towards 55 speed as he gets bigger. He’s also likely to move off shortstop but end up a plus defender at third or second, probably third given his above-average arm and eventual size. There’s a lot of maybes here, and the surface numbers aren’t impressive; just bear in mind that, like a lot of teenagers, he didn’t belong in whatever the heck Low A is at this point, and that he got on base as well as he did, flashing some very hard contact for a teenager, is actually very promising.

2024 Ranking: Unranked

Mack was the No. 31 pick in the 2021 draft, then missed most of 2022 with injuries and had a disappointing 2023 in High A, hitting .218/.295/.287, although he did stay healthy enough to get 503 plate appearances. He returned to High-A Beloit to start 2024 and took off, hitting so well in 13 games that the Marlins very wisely bumped him up to Double A, where he hit .241/.322/.456 with 22 homers in 112 games and a 25.7 percent strikeout rate as a 21-year-old. Only four minor-league catchers hit more homers than Mack did last year; two are on this list, one can’t really catch, and the last is 33 years old. It’s all-fields power — nine of his 24 total homers on the season were to left or centerfield. He’s improved behind the plate to become an above-average receiver and maybe even a plus framer, while he’s always had a plus arm and threw out 34 percent of runners last year. He still has to work on some pitch recognition, as he was way better against fastballs and his inexperience against pitchers who could really spot a slider or drop a changeup away showed. The bar to be an everyday catcher in the majors is so low, however, that even if Mack ends up a .290 OBP guy with 20 homers and 55 defense, he’d be a very good regular, and that’s well within his reach.

2024 Ranking: 93

Stewart moved up to High A last year and hit .279/.391/454 in 80 games for Dayton as a 20-year-old before suffering an “off-field” injury, tearing a tendon in his wrist. It required surgery and ended his season. He continues to show a very advanced approach, recognizing all pitch types and commanding the strike zone, and has tweaked his swing since he first signed to hit far more line drives and fewer groundballs. He had a 27.8 percent line-drive rate in 2024, which would have ranked third in the Midwest League if he’d qualified, and he makes hard contact, just without enough loft or huge exit velocities to put the ball in the seats. It’s a short path to the ball with some lift to it, but with more doubles power that puts a lot of line drives into the gaps. I don’t think he’s got the projection left to end up a 20-homer guy, but he has a reputation as both a hard worker and a guy who likes to work out, so I wouldn’t say it’s impossible. He’s a fringy defender at third and played some second as well in 2024, probably a 45 defender at either spot, with first base the default option if he can’t stay elsewhere on the dirt. The worst-case scenario is he’s a 10-homer first baseman with above-average OBPs, a regular on some teams but not all; the best-case one is where he sticks at third, gets stronger for 20+ homers, and has OBPs close to .400 … which would probably make him an MVP candidate, now that I spell it out.

 

(Top photo illustration by Demetrius Robinson / The Athletic; Photos from left to right — Jackson Jobe, Samuel Basallo, Roman Anthony, Sebastian Walcott: Tim Warner, Christopher Pasatieri / Getty Images; Brace Hemmelgarn / Minnesota Twins / Getty Images; Chris Bernacchi / Diamond Images via Getty Images)

How Unrivaled became the WNBA free agency hub of all chatter, gossip and deal-making

MEDLEY, Fla. — On the eve of WNBA free agency beginning last Tuesday, several league decision-makers gathered under the same roof.

Inside Unrivaled’s Wayfair Arena, Las Vegas Aces coach Becky Hammon sat next to a basket stanchion with team president Nikki Fargas to her left, watching the end of the 3×3 league’s opening weekend. Dallas Wings front office members observed the action across the court from them. Seattle Storm brass sat off the floor in one corner of the show court, and the Los Angeles Sparks representation was a few rows up. The Atlanta Dream contingent watched closer to center court.

WNBA teams attended to support their players as well as the launch of a new league that could shift historic offseason routines and keep more star players in the U.S. during the offseason. But there was other work in Florida: Free agency negotiations officially began Tuesday.

With some convenient scheduling, Unrivaled became the epicenter of all the chatter, gossip and deal-making.

“This is the best place to be able to recruit free agents,” said Phoenix Mercury guard Natasha Cloud, who is playing on Unrivaled’s Phantom Basketball Club.

The beginning stages of Unrivaled overlapping with WNBA free agency wasn’t one of the league’s original goals, co-founder Napheesa Collier said. But it’s undoubtedly added to early buzz — Satou Sabally, for instance, used her first Unrivaled media availability to share with reporters that she had told the Wings she wanted to be traded — and it’s increased convenience for free agents, coaches and GMs.

Courtney Vandersloot is an unrestricted WNBA free agent, playing with Unrivaled Mist Basketball Club. Her first true free agency experience came after the Chicago Sky’s 2021 title. That offseason, she was playing in Russia, at UMMC Ekaterinburg, taking remote evening meetings after long practice days. “It was late nights. You’re relying on technology, hoping that the internet works,” Vandersloot said. “It doesn’t feel very personable.”

Now?

WNBA teams have posted up at hotels across the Miami area, squeezing in meetings after Unrivaled practices and around players’ schedules.

GO DEEPER

Grading and analyzing every WNBA free agency signing: Kelsey Plum heads to Los Angeles Sparks

Eight WNBA free agents, including those who are cored and restricted, are on Unrivaled rosters. Sabally, Vandersloot, Alyssa Thomas, DiJonai Carrington and Brittney Griner highlight the list. Others could potentially be on the move via trade, too. Jewell Loyd, a member of Unrivaled’s Mist Basketball Club, is on the move to the Aces, in a deal that seems likely to have a domino effect throughout the league.

Leading into Unrivaled’s opening weekend, multiple players were light-hearted about the implications of being together in one place during free agency. Vandersloot said anyone who gave her a pack of IPAs “might have a head start” in recruiting her. Sabally joked that she had already received a few cups of coffee.

Cloud said she wants what’s best for Sabally. But she added: “If that is Phoenix, I will literally tell her I will give up my apartment if she wants that too.”

As Feb. 1, the date deals can be announced, approaches, the reality of negotiations looms larger, and the quips have dissipated.

“It was a total shift. People are lingering in the hallways, having full-blown conversations,” one player granted anonymity to speak freely about the recruiting process said. “We’re not joking anymore.”

The WNBA is preparing to enter its 28th season, but robust free-agency recruiting is still a relatively new part of the winter. Aces guard Chelsea Gray said in an Uninterrupted mini-documentary about her 2020 free agency: “You hear about it happening on the men’s side. Why not have it happen on the women’s side? Why not have people be like, ‘You need to fly her out?’”

Two offseasons ago, Istanbul, Turkey, became the crossroads of the cycle as the New York Liberty, Washington Mystics, Minnesota Lynx and Storm tried figuring into the Breanna Stewart sweepstakes. A team traveling abroad demonstrated interest in building a relationship.

Now, Unrivaled is that crossroads of the free agency world, and players can conveniently build relationships with each other. Peer connections are the benefits of everyone gathering in one place.

“You’re able to talk to other players directly, and you can figure out what type of resources, how important is their team to the owners? If you have an owner of a team that doesn’t prioritize the women’s team, they’re going to talk about it, and that’s a place where I would (be) less likely to go,” Sabally said.

Players can cross-pollinate their thoughts on facilities. Multiple players at Unrivaled, both free agents and players signed to deals, said that topic had come up in the meal room, sauna and weight room.

“It’s been fun hearing players trying to get certain players to join teams. You’re kind of just able to hear other people’s experiences as well,” New York Liberty star Sabrina Ionescu said.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Unrivaled’s an instant hit, but can the new women’s basketball 3×3 league sustain?

Not every franchise flocked to Florida right away. Minnesota Lynx head coach and president of basketball Cheryl Reeve and assistant coach Eric Thibault were spotted at last Wednesday’s EuroLeague game between Fenerbahçe and Umana Reyer Venezia. Free agent bigs Emma Meesseman and Tina Charles play for the Turkish club as does Minnesota forward Nina Milić.

But by Friday night’s Unrivaled action, they had arrived in Florida.

Lynx guard Courtney Williams said she wasn’t planning to recruit free agents. But Williams admitted that could change in an instant.

“If (Cheryl) gives me a call,” Williams said, “I’m gonna start chatting.”

(Illustration: Dan Goldfarb / The Athletic; Photo: Carmen Mandato / Getty Images)

Marchand: NBC’s Mike Florio is wrong in his Fox criticism about Tom Brady

Everybody wants to cover sports media, but maybe everyone shouldn’t.

Mike Florio, “Pro Football Talk” aggregator/insider/gadfly extraordinaire, is on the most watched pregame show, NBC’s “Football Night in America,” every Sunday night, but he fashions himself a little bit of the league’s and media’s police. Some of the stuff he does can be pretty good.

Others, not so much.

This week, on the “SI Media with Jimmy Traina” podcast, Florio praised NBC over its rival network, Fox, regarding Tom Brady, the $375 million TV game analyst who owns a 10 percent stake in the Las Vegas Raiders.

“I’ve been with NBC for 15 years now,” Florio said. “There is no way in hell NBC would give Tom Brady a microphone when he owns a piece of a team. They would never do it.”

Well, except when Dale Earnhardt Jr. owned cars in the Xfinity Series on NBC. Earnhardt called races in the league, just not his own. That has been Fox’s arrangement with Brady so far.

On top of this, NBC just acquired the rights to the NBA and has had talks with Dwyane Wade, a minority owner of the Utah Jazz, and Grant Hill, who currently is a TNT analyst and has an ownership stake in the Atlanta Hawks.

“They would never do it,” Florio told Traina. “They would say, ‘Tom, you’ve got to pick a lane.’”

When asked if this is accurate, an NBC Sports spokesperson said, “We’re not going to comment on hypotheticals.”

Florio created Pro Football Talk almost a quarter century ago, and it is a pretty incredible story of how he transformed from a lawyer with a hobby to an institution that rivals the top football sites and has him front and center on a premiere studio show. But when he made a partnership with NBC, no matter how close he goes to the edge — and he goes further than a lot of people — he went into business with the network and its relationships.

With that, Pro Football Talk’s past criticism of Mike Tirico at ESPN has vanished since Tirico became NBC’s franchise player. Florio, the no-holds-barred, will-aggregate-everything-and-anything, failed to ever post about his teammate, “Football Night in America’s” Tony Dungy’s 2023 apology after commenting on the myth that litter boxes were being put in school bathrooms for children who identify as cats. There was no feline first-grader post on PFT.

“There is a fundamental difference between being a good teammate to a co-worker and owning a percentage of and having a significant voice in the direction of a team that competes in a league that you are covering,” Florio told The Athletic on the comparisons between him and Brady.

All this is not to say that Florio’s overall point about the inherent conflict of interest with Brady’s ownership stake in the Raiders and calling out Fox doesn’t have merit. In an ideal world, it is one or the other.

In Florio’s world, Fox should have given Brady an ultimatum on his $375 million contract to broadcast games or go own the Raiders. Even if you agree with Florio, Fox may not have the right to just back out of a contract.

Florio has built a lucrative business, rewriting, opining and reporting NFL news. He goes all-in a lot of times. In this case, he shouldn’t have. You know glass houses, rocks and all.

(Photo: Mike Ehrmann / Getty Images)

Mourning Michael Newberry: ‘He made me proud beyond words – I don’t know why that night he felt he couldn’t ring us’

“Me and Michael would always talk, every day, without fail,” says Ethan Devine.

On December 30, Devine sent Michael Newberry, the former Newcastle United youngster and his title-winning Linfield team-mate and close friend, a message on his 27th birthday. It will be forever unopened. Michael, a defender with Cliftonville in the Northern Irish Premiership, had passed away suddenly.

Michael’s life revolved around football and growing up on Stanhope Street — less than a 10-minute walk from Newcastle United’s home, St James’ Park — was only ever going to be defined by the city’s football club. The defender joined Newcastle’s academy aged 11 and, seven years later, won the highly coveted Wor Jackie Trophy: awarded to the club’s most promising youth prospect each season, ahead of future first-team regular Sean Longstaff.

Injuries prevented Michael from a first-team appearance at Newcastle, but he carved out a professional career in Iceland and, later, Northern Ireland, playing at Linfield alongside Devine as they won a league title together in 2022. “We became close, along with a few others,” says Devine. “It was Michael who helped mature me as a man. He kept me on the right path and was such an important person in my life.”

Cliftonville travel from the north of Belfast to the south of the capital to take on Michael’s former club Linfield today in the first meeting since his passing. His team-mates, friends and family are still trying to come to terms with their loss.


Michael holding Devine’s daughter (Photo courtesy of Ethan Devine)

On an icy lunchtime in Newcastle, Adrian Salem is in the warmth of his local pub. It is packed as Newcastle’s Premier League game kicks off.

For Adrian, football can provide the escapism that is essential after the most difficult days of his life. Saturdays have not been the same since Michael, his younger brother, died.

Adrian, eight years older, recalls how their father, also Michael Newberry and a former non-League footballer at nearby Gateshead, took them to training sessions. Michael would show off the skills he was learning to his brother. In return, Adrian — passionate about boxing — had Michael as a sparring partner.

Michael was understandably disheartened after leaving Newcastle in 2018. “He was telling us that he hadn’t made it,” Adrian recalls, shaking his head. “Every time we spoke, I told him how proud we all were of him and how others looked up to him. I would always give him a cuddle.”

Adrian, a keen boxer, spent hours practicing his skills with Michael (Adrian Salem)


Adrian, a keen boxer, spent hours practising his skills with Michael (Photo courtesy of Adrian Salem)

Michael’s football journey began at Red House Farm — a junior football club in Gosforth, north of Newcastle. “Michael was a great young lad, he was always smiling,” Mark Bolam, his coach from the youth club, says. “He loved football and was a really popular kid.”

Bolam recounts how Michael, even after signing for Newcastle, would return to training sessions and matches to support the team. “He got on so well with all the lads; there was a real bond. I remember Peter Beardsley (the former forward who captained Newcastle, before becoming a coach at St. James’ Park, including a spell as caretaker manager in 2010) at Newcastle telling me that Michael was the first player at training and the last one to leave. He would help set up our sessions.”

Michael, left, began his youth career at Red House Farm (Red House Farm)


Michael, left, began his youth career at Red House Farm (Photo courtesy of Red House Farm)

At Newcastle, Michael was elevated above his age categories, playing for the under-18s aged 15. He struck up a centre-back partnership with Owen Bailey, one year his junior, from the under-14 side through to under-21 level.

“Michael was ahead of his time — a modern player,” says Bailey, now a midfielder with League Two side Doncaster Rovers. “He was fast, strong, good on the ball.”

Bailey, 25, describes how Michael was “one of the nicest lads I’ve met. He would go out of his way to make sure everyone was fine from a personal perspective before worrying about football, especially the younger ones. In that environment, everyone is competing for scholarships and pro contracts.”

Michael was elevated above his age category in Newcastle's youth system (Adrian Salem)


Michael was elevated above his age category in Newcastle’s youth system (Photo courtesy of Adrian Salem)

Bailey says it was evident Michael was one of the standout players. “He never acted like he was — there was real humility,” he adds. “He clicked with everyone and had a laugh. He was such a good, funny person. He was the perfect example of the Geordie character: worked hard but didn’t take himself too seriously.”

That view was shared by another team-mate at St James’ Park, Dan Barlaser, the Middlesbrough midfielder. “He worked so hard in the gym — he was always in great shape,” Barlaser told the Newcastle programme. “He was always smiling, laughing. I will cherish those memories.”

Michael Newberry on the far left, watches a training session alongside Newcastle team-mates Ivan Toney, Sean Longstaff and Dan Barlaser (Serena Taylor/Newcastle United via Getty Images)


Michael, far left, watches a training session alongside team-mates Ivan Toney, Longstaff and Barlaser (Serena Taylor/Newcastle United via Getty Images)

Despite being two of the most promising players in Newcastle’s youth system, neither Michael nor Bailey would play for the senior side. “He was really close,” Bailey says. “But there was a lot of change in the academy and that didn’t help anyone. A lot of the best talents dropped off the radar.”

Having signed a professional contract, Michael had a hairline fracture in his back that ruled him out for eight months during his final year at the club. Later, Newcastle’s under-23 captain Bailey suffered knee injuries that prevented him from playing for 18 months. The timings meant neither was offered further contracts.

Bailey argues Newcastle’s geographical isolation makes it particularly difficult for young players to continue their careers. Unlike other English urban centres such as London, Manchester, Liverpool, Leeds or Birmingham, there is not a deep network of local clubs in the north east as alternatives. Bailey resurrected his career at Gateshead, then in the sixth tier.

Michael, who grew up a 10-minute walk from St. James' Park, was a lifelong Newcastle fan (Adrian Salem)


Michael, who grew up a 10-minute walk from St. James’ Park, was a lifelong Newcastle fan (Photo courtesy of Adrian Salem)

Michael had interest from Blackburn Rovers and a trial with Motherwell in Scotland, before agent Nick McCreery told Michael that Icelandic club U.M.F. Vikingur had offered a contract.

Adrian believes Michael’s left-field move had been influenced by his own career. Adrian served in the army in Afghanistan and Iraq and has since worked in India and Dubai. “Michael maybe saw that and felt nothing would stop him moving away,” Adrian says.

Michael spent three seasons playing regularly in Iceland. “He was having the time of his life,” Adrian says, before adding that it was a challenge. “It was a vast, empty area. It’s one thing to experience that, but living there for that length of time is a lot. We knew he eventually missed home.”

Michael alongside his brother Adrian (Adrian Salem)


Michael alongside his brother (Photo courtesy of Adrian Salem)

Michael was capped by Northern Ireland’s youth teams. Qualifying through his grandfather’s Belfast roots, he played for the under-17 and under-19 sides.

It was there that he first worked with David Healy and Ross Oliver. In January 2021, Michael signed for Northern Ireland champions Linfield, who were managed by Healy with Oliver as his assistant. “This was such a big deal,” Adrian says. Not only was it a proud moment for the family with their roots, but Linfield are the biggest club in the country. “I’m English and I’ve pals who support Linfield. It made me proud beyond words.”

Michael had won the Wor Jackie Trophy at Newcastle, named after Jackie Milburn, who remains Newcastle’s second-highest goalscorer, having scored 200 competitive goals. After leaving Newcastle in 1957, Milburn moved to Belfast and as player-manager won nine trophies.


Michael joined Linfield when they were top of the league and had won the previous two titles, arriving at the same time as midfielder Cammy Palmer, who came from Scotland. “We clicked straight away,” says Palmer, who stayed in the same hotel with Michael before they moved in together. Palmer, three years younger, remembers driving the pair to training in a car full of suitcases and backpacks.

“He was always there for a chat, no matter what,” he adds. “We both missed our families and friends, but we had each other and grew into the club and the city.”

They helped Linfield win another two league titles. “He got on with absolutely everyone. My wife came over and there was never any problem.”

Cammy Palmer and Michael lived together after both joining Linfield in January 2021 (Cammy Palmer)


Palmer and Michael lived together after joining Linfield in 2021 (Photo courtesy of Cammy Palmer)

When Michael scored his first Linfield goal, Healy told Palmer in the dressing room he would need to start chipping in or he wouldn’t have the bragging rights. They became close friends with team-mates Conor Pepper and Kirk Millar. “We would go round to Conor’s house to play poker,” Palmer says. “We socialised a lot. It was a good team and the bonds were close.”

Palmer says what he remembers most about Michael was how he regularly sat with different groups and prioritised checking in with the youngsters. “We always had a laugh, but he was there for me when I needed a chat or felt I was struggling. I hope I was that person for him.”

In January 2022, a year into Michael’s and Palmer’s time at Linfield, the club signed Devine from Championship club Knockbreda. A then-20-year-old who had never played in the top flight, the move was a big step in the striker’s career. “As soon as I arrived, Michael looked after me,” Devine says.

Devine and Michael won multiple trophies together at Linfield (Ethan Devine)


Devine and Michael won multiple trophies together at Linfield (Photo courtesy of Ethan Devine)

Last summer, Michael left Linfield for Cliftonville. He moved in with three team-mates who all transferred clubs that summer: Arran Pettifer, Axel Piesold and Taylor Steven. “He was like the father figure of that house,” Devine says. “He was always trying to look out for people.”

On Christmas Day, Michael made dinner. “He would have known what it was like not having a support base — that summed him up,” says Palmer.

The following day, Cliftonville lost against Crusaders. Michael played the full match. On December 30, Cliftonville were scheduled to play Dungannon Swifts and on the previous night, he and Devine chatted as normal. “That friendship probably got even stronger when we were not at the same club,” says Devine.

It was the last time Devine and Michael spoke.

Ethan Devine and Michael became close friends away from football and would talk every day (Ethan Devine)


Devine and Michael became close friends away from football (Photo courtesy of Ethan Devine)

Michael’s brother, Adrian, could not process the news — he still can’t. “I had told him that he could pick up the phone to me anytime, it would not matter why,” he says. “I don’t know why that night he felt he couldn’t ring us. He was my little brother. I held him in my arms when he was a baby. We were always there for each other. I loved Michael so much.”

As news circulated of Michael’s death, Linfield and Cliftonville requested to the NI Football League to postpone their matches that night. The league agreed, but the other four games went ahead.

Devine, now on loan at Ballymena United, and Palmer, at Glentoran, were scheduled to play. Devine chose not to, Palmer did. “That day I wasn’t really present, my mind wasn’t there,” Palmer says. “I was very emotional. I just kept thinking of all the memories and what his family were going through. I spent the day messaging Linfield players. They were distraught. I didn’t know how to think.”

Michael and his brother Adrian, who is travelling to Belfast for the first time for Linfield vs Cliftonville (Adrian Salem)


Michael and his brother, Adrian, who is travelling to Belfast for the first time for Linfield vs Cliftonville (Photo courtesy of Adrian Salem)

Newcastle remains Adrian’s community and is where Michael’s funeral took place on January 16. He never had the opportunity to take up his brother’s offer to experience Belfast and is travelling to Windsor Park for Linfield vs Cliftonville.

“If there is one thing to learn from this, it’s to always remind people of how much they mean to you and how much you love them,” says Adrian.

  • If you would like to talk to someone having read this article, please try Samaritans in the UK or U.SYou can call 116 123 for free from any phone

(Top photos: Adrian Salem)

Lewis Hamilton’s first week at Ferrari: Louboutin boots, a dream fulfilled and a proud mom

“This is the one!”

Lewis Hamilton could not hide his excitement as he walked among the road cars in the ‘heritage section’ of Ferrari’s headquarters in Maranello, Italy.

As he spotted a bright red Ferrari F40, one of the rarest of the manufacturer’s road cars, in the middle of the floor, he paused. Spreading his hands across the rear spoiler, a smile engulfed his face. He’d found his favorite.

It was this kind of wonder that Hamilton, a seven-time world champion who has seen and won it all in Formula One, sought when he decided to move to Ferrari. For all the success he enjoyed with Mercedes, nothing could match the history and the magic of F1’s most iconic team.

The moment he had dreamed about since childhood, becoming a Ferrari driver, had finally arrived.


Day one at Maranello had been almost a year in the making for Hamilton. Since announcing his shock decision to quit Mercedes after 12 seasons, he endured a difficult and, by his own admission, occasionally awkward final year. Closing that chapter in Abu Dhabi may have been emotional, yet Hamilton knew it was giving way to something new and exciting.

To mark the start of this era, uniting F1’s most successful driver and most successful team, every detail had to be meticulously planned. Ferrari F1 team principal Fred Vasseur was reluctant to have a big presentation or media event, not wishing to add any extra work or distraction to the team’s plate amid its preparations for the new season.

But it had to make Hamilton’s first week at Maranello memorable.

The F40 housed in the ‘old’ side of Ferrari’s factory — the headquarters is split between the historic part of the facility, noted by its yellow buildings and walls, and the ‘new’ side that is red — was wheeled through the Italian drizzle to the Piazza Michael Schumacher, named after the great who won five of his seven F1 titles for Ferrari. On it stands the house of Enzo Ferrari, the founder of the legendary manufacturer who had watched many legends sample his red cars from the window. History resides wherever you turn at Maranello.

Hamilton met with Vasseur and Ferrari CEO Benedetto Vigna before posing for photos outside the house next to the F40. Even Hamilton’s outfit for the day had been carefully planned by his stylist, Eric McNeal, right down to his red-soled Louboutin boots. The first official pictures of Lewis Hamilton, Ferrari F1 driver, quickly went viral and became the most-liked photo on F1’s Instagram page in less than 24 hours, as well as gracing all the front pages of the Italian sports newspapers the next morning.


Hamilton’s arrival photo went viral and made headlines around the world — especially in Italy. (Clive Rose / Getty Images)

Hamilton also made time to visit the fans, Ferrari’s loyal tifosi, who had congregated outside the factory gates at Maranello since the early morning hours, desperate to glimpse their new hero on his first day.

While at McLaren and Mercedes, Hamilton struck a strong bond with his fans (known as ‘Team LH’) and wants to rekindle that kind of relationship at Ferrari.

“I don’t know really what to expect, but I’m really looking forward to connecting with that community,” Hamilton said in a press conference last August. Taking a few minutes with fans to pose for pictures and offer signatures as they chanted his name was a good first gesture. It created a bystander out of Ferrari president John Elkann, one of the key brokers in signing Hamilton and perhaps the most powerful figure at Ferrari.


A lot rests on 2025 for both Ferrari and Hamilton. Ferrari missed out on its first constructors’ championship since 2008 by just 14 points, while Hamilton is still searching for a record-breaking eighth world title. His struggles with the Mercedes car through 2024 made for a season of lagging behind teammate George Russell. Shaking off that funk and proving he still has the edge that once made him near-impossible to beat at the peak of his powers in F1 is a critical part of this move.

It made Hamilton’s time getting to know his new colleagues through a factory tour and subsequent meetings on Monday and Tuesday vitally important. Hamilton always took strength from the closeness of his relationships with his teammates at Mercedes, particularly with his race engineer, Peter Bonnington, who he likened to a brother. Taking over that role will be Riccardo Adami, who was the engineer for Carlos Sainz (the Spaniard affectionately nicknamed Adami ‘Ricky’) as well as four-time world champion Sebastian Vettel, and will now be the voice on the end of the radio to Hamilton through races.


Hamilton suiting up for his first test at Fiorano. (Ferrari)

Ferrari planned Hamilton’s first on-track outing behind the wheel of its 2023 car for Wednesday at its private test track, Fiorano, which is adjacent to the factory. But it was always weather-dependent, making it hard to predict in the depths of January in northern Italy.

Preparations through Monday and Tuesday included a seat fitting and sampling Ferrari’s simulator, giving Hamilton a chance to feel, at least virtually, how his new car would perform. One of his great struggles through 2024 was feeling confident and balanced with the car, particularly under braking with his late, aggressive style. Over a single lap, Hamilton often failed to get the most out of the car. The simulator will have at least given a first read of what he can expect from the Ferrari this year, even if nothing compares to the real thing.

Hamilton’s new race helmet design for this year returns to the yellow he first used as a child in go-karts to allow his father, Anthony, to easily spot him on the track. Shots of the helmet, as well as Hamilton posing in the classic red Ferrari race suit for the first time, were shared with the world, building up excitement before his first on-track running. All that was required was for the weather to play ball.


Driving a two-year-old F1 car on a misty, cold day around a short test circuit may not have the hallmarks of a special moment, but for Hamilton, this was a day he had dreamt of since playing as Michael Schumacher on video games as a teenager, wondering what it might be like to be in the cockpit of the red car someday.

Just as it was for Schumacher at Fiorano at the end of 1995 ahead of his move to Ferrari for the following season, Hamilton’s maiden outing was both understated and poignant. After changing into his new red race suit in Enzo Ferrari’s house, Hamilton walked over to the simple garage setup next to the track, no bigger than a gas station forecourt (and branded like one, thanks to team partner Shell) and was greeted by his team. As the engineers ran through the processes, Hamilton scribbled down things to remember into a small notebook.


Hamilton and Ferrari’s crew hit the ground running this week (Ferrari)

There were a number of new faces in Ferrari gear for Hamilton to get to know, but a few watched on with added fondness, including dad Anthony. Vasseur had worked with Hamilton in junior categories and they always remained friendly, paving the way for their reunion almost 20 years later. Jerome d’Ambrosio, the deputy team principal, and Loic Serra, the chassis technical director, both worked at Mercedes when Hamilton was there.

But maybe the most essential and surprising returnee was Angela Cullen, Hamilton’s former trainer and performance coach.

Hamilton and Cullen worked together for seven years before suddenly splitting just two races into the 2023 season. Cullen had been a core part of Hamilton’s inner circle, overseeing his physical preparations and helping him ahead of races. She spent last year working in IndyCar but is now back with Hamilton’s team after signing with Project 44, his management company that looks after his business interests. Her return is important for Hamilton, who will take comfort in having some familiarity during the big adjustment that comes with joining a new team.

At 9:16 a.m., Hamilton peeled out of the garage and onto the track. At last, he was a Ferrari F1 driver. Fans and TV cameras had gathered at a couple of vantage points overlooking Fiorano to catch a glimpse of the famous #44 emblazoned on the Ferrari, including one on a bridge next to a busy road. No length is too great for the tifosi.

Testing an old car would not have given Hamilton much in terms of accurate readings of how the new season may go, yet it at least offered the chance to adjust to Ferrari’s way of working. The SF-23 car, the only non-Red Bull winner of 2023, offered a first understanding of the power delivery of the Ferrari engine and the functions of the steering wheel, both of which will differ from what he was used to at Mercedes.

Hamilton only managed 30 laps through a handful of runs in the morning, completing an installation run on wet tires before switching to slicks, and there were images of him locking up at points, yet it was never about outright pace or performance. The race drivers are limited to 1,000km of private test running in old cars through the year, meaning Hamilton’s 89km run, followed by teammate Charles Leclerc’s 42km run in the afternoon, leaves plenty of room for more ahead of the new season. A further outing is planned for Hamilton in Barcelona in the coming weeks before his first run in the 2025 car on February 19 at Fiorano, one day after the F1 season launch event at The O2 in London.

Neither the limited running nor the weather would stop his Ferrari debut from being, to quote Hamilton, “one of the best feelings of my life.”

Once his run was complete, he was taken in a black Alfa Romeo road car to get out and wave at the dozens of fans who stood behind one of the fences. His mother, Carmen, stood taking photos on her phone. Watching her son in Ferrari red for the first time, she drank in the moment. Hamilton could not help but break into a smile at the chants of, “Olé!, olé, olé, olé! Lewis, Lewis!” that greeted him. The tifosi have already warmed to Hamilton, instantly becoming their new hero.

“I already knew from the outside how passionate the Ferrari family is, from everyone in the team to the tifosi,” Hamilton said. “To now witness it firsthand as a Ferrari driver has been awe-inspiring. That passion runs through their veins and you can’t help but be energized by it.”

Ferrari perfectly balanced making Hamilton’s arrival a ‘moment’ without detracting from the focus, which must be on its performance. It knows how important this year will be coming off the back of a 2024 season that will go down as a near-miss but also a big swell in momentum that has ignited hopes just at the right time. As much as this week featured public nods to the new beginning, the behind-the-scenes work and adjustment was what really mattered to Hamilton.

It is a week that will have rekindled a lot of Hamilton’s love and passion for F1. As committed as he was to the Mercedes project, even through the toughest of times, the on-track difficulties caused that flame to flicker.

This change to a new, ambitious project, one which carries the weight of an expectant fanbase, a nation’s sporting pride and the history of those who’ve come and succeeded before in Ferrari red is precisely what Hamilton needed.

Now, it’s about working hard to make the adjustment as smooth as possible, before his full debut in Australia on March 16 truly begins his Ferrari era.

Top photo: Clive Rose, Alessandro Bremec via Getty Images; Design: Will Tullos/The Athletic

Ravens TE Mark Andrews says he’s ‘devastated’ in first public comments since playoff loss

Baltimore Ravens tight end Mark Andrews took to Instagram on Thursday, breaking his silence following multiple fourth-quarter miscues — a lost fumble and dropped two-point conversion to tie the game — during the team’s 27-25 AFC divisional loss to the Buffalo Bills on Sunday.

“It’s impossible to adequately express how I feel. I’m absolutely gutted by what happened on Sunday,” Andrews wrote. “I’m devastated for my teammates, my coaches and Ravens fans. I pour every ounce of my being into playing at the highest level possible, because I love my team and the game of football like nothing else. That is why it’s taken me until now to collect my thoughts and address this publicly.”

In the days following Baltimore’s season-ending loss, a GoFundMe fundraiser, originally organized by Bills fan Nicholas Howard, has accumulated over $100,000 across more than 3,000 donations to a charity close to Andrews’ heart, Breakthrough T1D. Established in 1970, the non-profit organization focuses on global type 1 diabetes research and advocacy for those who, like Andrews, have been impacted.

“Despite the negativity, I’ve seen heartfelt love and encouragement, including from those who have generously donated to the Breakthrough T1D organization,” Andrews wrote on Thursday. “Even when the moment seems darkest, perspective can reveal that there’s still a lot of light in this world. I’m now going to do my part to bounce back and contribute to it.”

What’s next for Andrews?

That Andrews didn’t speak to reporters after Sunday’s game and again wasn’t present in the locker room Monday was out of character for the veteran tight end. He’s long been one of the Ravens’ most accessible and accountable players. He was awarded the Ravens’ Media Good Guy earlier in his career for his cooperation with the media.

Obviously, his comments on his Instagram account aren’t going to make this a non-story. Whenever Andrews next meets the media, his fourth-quarter fumble and the drop of a potential game-tying two-point conversion pass in a two-point loss to the Bills will remain prominent storylines. However, it wasn’t going to be hard for the Ravens and for Andrews to move forward from this bitter loss without the tight end addressing it in some fashion.

This was already shaping up to be an interesting offseason for Andrews. He’s in the final year of a four-year, $56 million contract. His salary-cap number rises to $16.9 million in 2025. Ravens head coach John Harbaugh maintained Wednesday that Andrews is a huge part of the team’s future, but complicating matters is the fact that Baltimore’s other two tight ends, Isaiah Likely and Charlie Kolar, are both headed into the final year of their contracts.

General manager Eric DeCosta acknowledged that the team will have some difficult decisions to make at the tight end position going forward. — Jeff Zrebiec, Ravens senior writer

Required reading

(Photo: Al Bello / Getty Images)

The Australian Open’s cartoon tennis players: AO Animated, YouTube and the future of sports media

MELBOURNE, Australia — One moment, they are playing tennis. The next, they disappear from the court, or melt into a puddle, or do a backflip mid-point. Their rackets flail independently from their hands and sometimes disappear completely. Their heads are oversized. They are the best tennis players in the world; they are the undisputed stars of the 2025 Australian Open.

They are also cartoons.

There’s Daniil Medvedev, last year’s finalist, whaling his racket into the net.

There’s Madison Keys, this year’s semifinalist, running down a ball before backflipping into the air and disappearing, causing Elena-Gabriela Ruse to miss a volley.

And there’s Jack Draper, feeling the effects of five three-set matches in a row and dissolving into the court.

These clips are courtesy of AO Animated, a YouTube livestream produced by the Australian Open that delivers video-game-style broadcasts of the matches played on Melbourne Park’s three show courts: Rod Laver Arena, Margaret Court Arena and John Cain Arena. It uses tracking data from the Hawk-Eye system used for electronic line calling (ELC) to map the movement of the players and the trajectory of the ball, before overlaying the skins — facial features, kits, the racket — that turns that data into a cartoon player.

This means that for all the fun of the glitches, the feed is a faithful reproduction of the live tennis, just on a short delay. There’s real commentary, crowd noise and chair umpire calls, alongside bobble-headed figures who bear only a passing resemblance to the players they’re representing. In a throwback to old computer games, the protagonists occasionally have minds of their own.

The tournament trialed a primitive version in 2023, with no players and just a ball being tracked back and forth. In 2024, there was animation for just one court, but this year, there are three and the viral moments have captured the tennis world’s imagination. Viewership has increased from 246,542 in the first six days of last year’s event to 1,796,338 in the same timeframe this year.

The cartoon players, prone to glitching limbs, lost rackets and sometimes swapping places on the court, have won acclaim from their real-world counterparts.

“It’s funny,” Carlos Alcaraz said in a news conference last Wednesday. Leylah Fernandez, the world No. 30, was scouting an opponent on YouTube and clicked onto one of the streams thinking it would be useful before getting a pleasant but strange surprise.

Then Daria Kasatkina, the Russian world No. 10 who runs a vlog through YouTube, cut to the heart of why this seemingly quirky bit of fun is also a harbinger for the future of tennis media, as well as the growth of the sport. There is no subscription to pay, no ticket and travel to buy, and no need to search a litany of television rights and providers to figure out which broadcaster is hosting the tournament in the place that a budding tennis fan might call home.

“It’s for free,” Kasatkina said in a news conference.


The economics of Grand Slam media rights — determining which channels show the four biggest tennis events in the world — are relatively straightforward. The Australian Open, the French Open, Wimbledon and the U.S. Open sell their media rights to broadcasters; historically, television networks that built their portfolios on the strength of cable television. Some of them (including ESPN, Warner Bros Discovery and, most recently, Tennis Channel) also have direct-to-consumer streaming.

ESPN will pay $2.04billion (more than £1.5bn) to air the U.S. Open through 2037, while Wimbledon’s broadcast deal with ABC and ESPN networks comes in at $52.5million per year, according to SP Global. Warner Bros Discovery has a 10-year deal worth $650m in place to broadcast the French Open in the United States beginning in 2025.

Grand Slam tournaments also have to protect the value of their in-person experience. If fans can watch a major with relative ease from anywhere, there is less value in having a real ticket. As a result, those broadcast deals come with aggressive restrictions on sharing, editing, and uploading clips on sites such as YouTube, TikTok, X and Instagram — the places where the most people would have the most opportunity to discover tennis.

These restrictions extend to the Grand Slams themselves, which give up a degree of control over how they can promote themselves on social media. Since AO Animated is created by the ELC tracking data and not the broadcast feed from television cameras, it can stream live alongside the real match, creating a free-to-air tennis broadcast just two minutes behind the real action. Rather than bristling at AO Animated potentially taking eyeballs away from their live footage, Eurosport and beIN Sports are hosting it on their online platforms.

GO DEEPER

Why tennis disruptors are waiting for the sport to disrupt itself

“We knew we were sitting on this asset, ELC, and it started with that,” Machar Reid, Tennis Australia’s director of innovation said in an interview at Melbourne Park this week.

“We’re using it for the skeletal data, with 29 points on the skeleton. That’s being tracked 50 times a second by the 12 cameras. That allows you to create a 3D mesh and then you put the skin over the top. There’s almost an infinite number of avatars you can have.

“There’s something in it, around building a community to allow people to chat about what’s happened and connect with the sport differently.”

The community chat is a staple of YouTube, Twitch, TikTok and other streaming platforms, which tennis has been institutionally slow to embrace. The NBA, NFL and NHL have used this gamified version of sports broadcasting: in December, Disney+ broadcast the NFL game between the Dallas Cowboys and Cincinnati Bengals as The Simpsons on Monday Night Football. It complements the Formula One drivers who stream on Twitch, the world-famous footballers who love esports, and the athletes who use TikTok.

Taken together, these platforms and free avenues into tennis widen how fans can discover the sport. They might go from being a fan of Coco Gauff the TikToker to Coco Gauff the tennis player to tennis the sport. Or they might see a funny clip of a cartoon version of an elite athlete dissolving into the floor and wonder what on earth is going on.


These characters are drawn by Tennis Australia’s Mark Riedy, who works on the Australian Open’s gaming content.

Riedy works in a bunker, surrounded by computer screens and feeds of all the matches being converted into animation. Riedy designed the graphics, the players and the stadiums; he regularly pops into the YouTube chat to engage viewers with questions and answer some of their queries. He likes to keep it lighthearted, embracing the glitches that have captured the imagination.


Mark Riedy in the animation room at Melbourne Park. (Tennis Australia)

Sitting in the bunker during Emma Raducanu’s third-round match against Iga Swiatek, he tells The Athletic that the idea first came to him because he thought a gamified version of tennis would attract fans with no viable route to the broadcast footage. The tournament has the rights to the pre- and post-match action, so when the warm-up ends and a player takes to the service line to start the match, the footage dissolves into the cartoon world. It’s like a reverse Wizard of Oz and its mid-film switch from black and white to glorious technicolour.

This also means there is no way of checking everything’s working until the very first point, which creates another layer of jeopardy. That includes the main characters, with their big heads, oversized tennis balls and volatile rackets.

But part of the success of AO Animated is that its creators are not too precious about it. They want it to be fun and engaging first and foremost, like the look of the players — which, with their big heads, are hardly realistic.

“It’s definitely intentional,” says Xavier Muhlebach, the tournament’s head of original content.

“We wanted something that was cutesy and kid-friendly, but not exclusively for them. I can sit back and enjoy and have a laugh and watch that and not feel like I’m stuck in a loop watching Blue’s Clues or something.”

Riedy adds: “It’s fun to have a bit of a cartoony look to it. There’s the real version if you want accuracy.

“We might get a scenario where we have proper models for every single player, but at the moment, it’s like a character editor in a video game. You just pop it up and you can change the shape of the head, eyes and everything. It was about creating a character that was editable and changeable and, at the moment, there are enough different hairpieces and caps and things.”

The following day, he sends over an AO Animated version of this reporter, suffering against Alcaraz.

There are other challenges that make the stream tend towards the surreal. The ELC cameras are mainly behind the players, so when they hunch over, the racket — a challenge to track because of the speed at which it moves — can disappear. There is no finger animation (on Riedy’s wishlist for next year) and the cameras stop tracking the players at around six metres behind the baseline, or if they bend down. This explains Draper’s apparent melting into the court against Alcaraz.

Riedy gets on the front foot in the comments by poking fun at any misfortune. “That’s a big drawcard. Just putting this up without the chat, I don’t know if that would have had the same response,” he says.

“It would be different and be very passive, whereas this is more community driven and they’re actually talking about the tennis but also the tech,” Muhlebach adds.


The race to future-proof tennis from an ongoing decline in cable television revenue, which will eventually start to affect the value of broadcast rights, has also created something of a media arms race between the majors. The French Open introduced umpire head cams last year, which were intended to check line calls but instead became famous for making the players look like whinging toddlers.

Tennis Australia has set up its first venture capital fund, the A$30million (£15.2m; $18.6m) AO Ventures, which it says will “provide early backing to high-growth technology-led startups that are innovating in the worlds of sport, entertainment, media and health.”

Further developing AO Animated is another aim, with a desire to add “emotion tracking” so that players can celebrate and despair. There are plans to animate the entire complex, as well as adding commentators that include color not to the real tennis being animated, but to the quirks of the animation itself.

As much as the most important figures in this initiative are the tournament and the fans, as with the sport of tennis, it’s the players who create the value and draw the crowds. The animated tennis is only as good as the tennis being played. World No. 1 Aryna Sabalenka was jokingly unimpressed by her character, sharing a clip on Instagram.

“We’re with them and asking for feedback,” Muhlebach said. “Others might be a bit more standoffish because they’ve been working on their own video game.” Sponsorship changes may also have an impact in the future, with players not infrequently signing new deals or, less often, changing their racket or clothing sponsor.

It’s unlikely that every major, let alone every tournament, will be populated with animated versions of Alcaraz and Swiatek bobbling around the court between points and occasionally backflipping into the stands all that soon. AO Animated is nevertheless one of the clearest signs yet that tennis understands how sports media is changing and that getting left behind could quickly become a death sentence.

One day, these animated tennis bobbleheads might rule the world. Until then, there’s always Daniil Medvedev and his disappearing racket.

(Illustration: Dan Goldfarb for The Athletic)

Ben Shelton slams ‘embarrassing and disrespectful’ interviews by Australian Open broadcasters

MELBOURNE, Australia — Ben Shelton, the 22-year-old American who made the Australian Open semifinals Wednesday with a win over Lorenzo Sonego, added his voice to the chorus of players who have been critical of the broadcasters and on-court interviewers in his post-match news conference.

“I’ve been a little bit shocked this week with how players have been treated by the broadcasters,” Shelton said.

He topped his list of complaints with Tony Jones, the Channel 9 sportscaster, who taunted Serbian fans, called Novak Djokovic names and yelled “kick him out” on air. It was an apparent reference to Djokovic being deported from Australia two years ago over Covid-19 protocols.

Jones apologized on the air, saying that he “overstepped the mark,” after Djokovic called his comments “insulting and offensive.” He had refused to do on-court interviews until he received the apology.

“I don’t think that was just a single event,” Shelton said. “I’ve noticed it with different people, not just myself.”

He mentioned American Learner Tien’s on-court interview, a stilted conversation at 3 a.m. in which an exhausted and dazed Tien, 19, became the object of some mocking when two questions left him a bit speechless after nearly five hours of tennis in the middle of the night. He had just knocked out Daniil Medvedev, the No. 5 seed.

“19 year olds aren’t meant to be that good,” the interviewer, John Fitzgerald, said. Then he asked Tien if he had ever heard of his next opponent, Corentin Moutet.

“I noticed it with Learner Tien in one of his matches,” Shelton said. “I think when he beat Medvedev, his post-match interview. I thought it was kind of embarrassing and disrespectful.”

Shelton then turned to his own experiences. After his fourth-round win over Gael Monfils, the interviewer said to Shelton that Monfils could be his father. Monfils is Black, as is Shelton, who responded, “is that a Black joke?”

He later said he did not think the interviewer meant any malice in the comment, but that it still made him uncomfortable.

“There are some comments that have been made to me in post-match interviews by a couple of different guys. Today on the court, ‘hey, Ben, how does it feel that no matter who you play in your next match, no one is going to be cheering for you?’

“I mean, may be true, but I just don’t think the comment is respectful from a guy I’ve never met before in my life.”

Shelton said he felt the broadcasters and interviewers were not doing a good enough job promoting tennis.

“I feel like broadcasters should be helping us grow our sport and help these athletes who just won matches on the biggest stage enjoy one of their biggest moments. I feel like there’s just been a lot of negativity. I think that’s something that needs to change.”

Tennis Australia was not immediately able to respond to Shelton’s comments.

(Nick Denholm / Getty Images)

After knocking off Ravens, ‘different’ Bills turn their attention to all-too-familiar Chiefs

ORCHARD PARK, N.Y. — With every Ravens turnover, every field goal forced instead of surrendering a touchdown, and every failed two-point conversion that kept the opponents just out of reach, it marched the Bills closer and closer to what they’ve been yearning to get back to for years.

At long last, the Bills have returned to the AFC Championship Game. Their 27-25 triumph over the Ravens exorcised several demons in both this season and previous ones.

Over the last three years, it’s been like a record stuck in a loop, repeating the same part of the song that drives everyone listening up the wall. In the divisional round, a super-talented Bills team with so much promise eventually yielded the way to the final four to another AFC superpower. First, it was the Chiefs. Then it was the Bengals. Then the Chiefs again. But this year… this year was different.

“You learn from all of the scars,” left tackle Dion Dawkins said. “You never want that feeling again.”

“I think there’s something kind of intangible about this team that feels different,” tight end Dawson Knox said. “It’s kind of hard to put your finger on.”

Knox isn’t alone. It’s a sentiment shared throughout the locker room, permeating throughout the fan base. Some think it’s the players. Others may point to how head coach Sean McDermott has evolved. However, that unquantifiable feeling about how the 2024-2025 Bills are different, in fact, yielded a different outcome than the past.

GO DEEPER

‘Let’s see who’s better’: Bills’ defense heard the haters, used motivation to upend Ravens

With all the talk centering on the Ravens and how the Bills would have to adjust to them, they forced the Ravens to adjust. The Bills kept Derrick Henry below the century mark after allowing him to hit nearly 200 rushing yards in Week 4. They took the fight to the Ravens’ defensive line, who, for good reason, drew rave reviews for their run-defending. The Bills running backs averaged 4.9 yards per carry on 26 attempts. They forced Ravens quarterback Lamar Jackson into two game-changing turnovers.

And by the end of the evening, there the Bills stood, with snow trickling down, allowing the scoreboard’s bright red, white and royal blue lights to shine a jumbotron-long banner even brighter.

“Next stop, AFC Championship.”

And that next stop is to Kansas City — because, of course it is.

The very Chiefs team that gave the Bills a cruel lesson on what it takes in the AFC Championship Game four years ago, who punished them for in-game mistakes and flawed decisions en route to a blowout loss, well, there they are again — the AFC gatekeepers of the Super Bowl.

Only 13 players from that AFC Championship Game Bills team remain on the roster. Allen, Dawkins and Knox were there, along with Micah Hyde, Matt Milano, Taron Johnson, Ed Oliver, A.J. Epenesa, Cam Lewis, Reggie Gilliam, Quinton Jefferson, Tyler Bass and Reid Ferguson.

The original 13 are acutely aware of just how poetic the upcoming showdown is.

“Yeah, 100 percent,” Lewis said. “I feel like we wouldn’t want it no other way.”

“I was watching the (Chiefs-Texans) game the other night with my girlfriend,” Epenesa started. “She was like, ‘What if the Texans win?’ I was like, ‘Yeah, you know, on paper they’re the lesser team, whatever, whatever, but how much sweeter would it be to be able to beat the team that got us a couple of times in the past and everything like that?’ So I’m definitely on that page right now as we have our opportunity to do something, and I’m looking forward to it.”

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Bills at Chiefs: How to watch, odds, expert picks for what should be an instant classic

A lot has changed for the Bills between the first AFC Championship matchup and now.

At that point, the Bills were simply novices. It was all new to them after only getting to the wild-card round the year before. They didn’t know what they didn’t know about deep playoff runs. The expectation was that they’d be back — and soon. It was only a matter of time.

“Soon” wasn’t quite what everyone expected. The Bills have learned difficult lessons, year after year, most of which were dealt to them by the very franchise they’ll face next weekend.

On Sunday, the Bills will have played in Kansas City more times than they have at any of their division rivals over the last five years. They’ve been there every year since that first AFC title tilt, with Sunday marking their sixth soiree at Arrowhead. It will be the eighth meeting between these two AFC behemoths over the last five years, four happening in the postseason.

But you don’t have to be reminded about how the last three have turned out. Most fans of the team have carried the weight like an elephant sitting on their collective chest.

AFC Championship Game in 2021 — a lopsided loss. AFC Divisional round in 2022 — a gut-punching loss with victory being so close they could taste it. AFC Divisional round in 2024 — another loss so close it had many wondering if the Bills would even return after an offseason roster refresh.

It all led to this year — the return to the AFC Championship Game coming in a year where no one thought it possible before the season. Standing before the Chiefs on Sunday will be the Bills, a sculpted Super Bowl contender, hardened by one excruciating playoff exit after another.

“For the guys that were there [in 2021], it’ll definitely I think be a little extra chip on the shoulder,” Knox started. “In a way, it can help. You can let it fuel you a little bit, but if you dwell on it too hard or too long, I think it’s distracting at a point. But if you kind of just let it lay underneath the surface, if it helps you bring a little extra motivation, a little extra work in the week, great. But we’re not going to be dwelling on that too hard.”

That’s one of many things that have changed about this Bills team.

Gone is the wily Allen, who, through all his brilliance, had a penchant for a back-breaking turnover. Gone are the one-dimensional, pass-happy Bills, who ran the ball well only after ample success through the air. Gone is the weak-link offensive line of the past that led to uneven results. And gone is a head coach who usually opted toward conservative in-game decisions.

In their place is a franchise quarterback playing the best football of his life, a running game that can take all the pressure off that franchise quarterback at any point during a game, an offensive line that is one of the team’s greatest strengths and a coach in complete trust of his players and the math, unafraid of fourth downs.

But opposing them will be a Chiefs team that has pivoted multiple times throughout its incredible run, all while remaining the class of the NFL. And certainly, a team eager to undo their lone loss of the 2024 regular season against the team that spoiled its perfect season.

The Bills and Chiefs are perfectly intertwined, both in their personal connectors and playoff histories. However, as always, neither can live while the other survives.

“History does have a way of repeating itself,” Dawkins said. “But sometimes, it has a different outcome. We’ll see how this one goes.”

 (Top photo: Tina MacIntyre-Yee / USA Today)

The Briefing: Is Levy the problem at Tottenham and what can Man Utd learn from Brighton?

Welcome to The Briefing, where every Monday The Athletic discusses three of the biggest questions posed by the weekend’s Premier League action.

During this set of fixtures, Darwin Nunez rebooted his navigation software to lift Liverpool past Brentford, Arsenal gave up a late two-goal lead over Aston Villa to lose ground, Nottingham Forest continued to thrill, Manchester City romped back into the top four and the bottom three all lost (again).

But here, after another defeat at Everton, we will ask whether Tottenham’s biggest problem is their manager or the man who hired him, what Manchester United could learn from the most recent mid-table team to beat them and why Andoni Iraola is destined for a bigger stage than Bournemouth.


Surely, someone must go at Tottenham — but who?

We all know the answer to this one: football clubs cannot sack their players and firing the assistant-kit manager is unlikely to elicit the desired reaction.

So, despite winning three straight manager-of-the-month awards last season, returning Spurs to European competition and providing plenty of entertainment for neutrals over the last 18 months, Ange Postecoglou’s days as Tottenham boss look numbered.

A 3-2 defeat at Everton on Sunday, which was not as close as the scoreline suggests, means they have picked up only one point from their last six league games and remain stuck in 15th, one place and four points better off than their most recent conqueror but on track to match the club’s worst league finish for 31 years.

Given the fact that better returns did not keep Mauricio Pochettino, Nuno Espirito Santo and Antonio Conte in the job, Postecoglou cannot claim that speculation about his future is unfounded. And his pleas for patience are not helped by the fact Everton just demonstrated what a fresh(ish) face and change of voice can do for a squad low on confidence.

But is it really all Ange’s fault? Was it his predecessors’ fault, too?

Tottenham have had top-six revenues and wage bills for a quarter of a century but still only won one trophy, the 2008 League Cup, during that time.

Where they have led the way, though, is on executive pay. Year after year, Tottenham chairman Daniel Levy tops that ranking. The 62-year-old, who joined the board in December 2000, gave himself a pay package worth £6.5million ($7.9m) last season, including a £3m bonus.


Daniel Levy cuts a glum figure at Goodison Park (Michael Regan/Getty Images)

OK, during his reign, Tottenham have built a new training ground and the best stadium in the country, and the club now boast soaring revenues (mainly thanks to that stadium). But he has also burned through 11 permanent managers, run up record levels of debt, posted financial losses for the last four years and sparked rows with his most loyal customers about ticket prices and concessions.

Maybe the problem is not whoever is in the dugout, it’s the bloke who keeps hiring and firing them?

Chairmen do not sack themselves, of course, particularly when they own big stakes in the business. But Levy had a front-row seat in the directors’ box at Goodison Park so he cannot have missed the “Levy Out” chants from the away end.

Levy runs Tottenham because he owns a third of the investment firm, ENIC, which owns the club. But Joe Lewis, his partner at ENIC, is now 87 and has passed his shares in the business to a family trust. And, for the last year, the Lewis family, who have always been open to offers, have actively been looking for a buyer for their stake.

Perhaps it is time for Levy to realise it is time for him to cash in his chips and let someone else have a go, too.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Daniel Levy’s Tottenham are seeking on-field vindication and off-field change


Manchester United need to accept their place – and learn

As bad as Manchester United have been at times this season, they are very unlikely to be relegated.

So, no, Ruben Amorim, the team you have chosen to manage is not the worst in the club’s history — United have been relegated five times in their history, so that is at least five sides this lot are better than.

But we all know what Amorim is getting at, don’t we?

Three wins in their last 10 league games, four defeats in five at home, 13th in the table, seven points behind 10th-placed Fulham.

But what do we expect? That is exactly where you would expect to find a team that Brighton beat home and away, lose at West Ham and Wolves and get thumped, at home, by Bournemouth. They even lost to Spurs.


Ruben Amorim did not pull his punches on Manchester United after their latest defeat (Stu Forster/Getty Images)

Manchester United are bang average. Actually, Fulham are average, so they are not even that good.

Now we have cleared that up, let’s focus on how they might snap out of this slumber.

Well, for starters, they could take a good hard look at Brighton, a team that have spent most of their history in the third tier of English football but have recently become part of the Premier League furniture thanks to clear leadership, targeted investment and smart recruitment.

Obviously, Manchester United should have greater ambitions than a comfortable existence in English football’s top tier but some humility would not go amiss at the moment, which means acknowledging that the likes of Brighton are better than them right now, on and off the pitch.

Amorim is not to blame for this state of affairs but he is partly responsible for fixing it. He needs help from above, of course, and it is at that level where the improvement is most needed. Sir Jim Ratcliffe may only have been in overall control for a year but so far the gap between mission statements and tangible results is stark.

In contrast, Brighton’s owner Tony Bloom barely says a word publicly. He does not need to, we can all see the results.


Anyone know where an underperforming giant might find their next coach?

I know this one!

In fact, so does everyone else who has been paying attention to what has been happening 90 miles west of Brighton for the last season and a half.

When Bournemouth’s new owner Bill Foley replaced the popular Gary O’Neil with Andoni Iraola in the summer of 2023, the consensus view was “what are you doing?”

O’Neil led Bournemouth to Premier League survival on the back of five wins in seven games, including crucial victories over the club’s relegation rivals.

But having made his fortune in financial services, Foley is an underlying numbers guy. He knew that the unheralded guy who had made unfashionable Rayo Vallecano a tough opponent for every team in La Liga was a better bet.

Nine winless league games into last season, that bet looked like a bust. But then Bournemouth beat Burnley and everything started to make sense. By the end of the season, Bournemouth had 12 more league wins and had climbed to 12th, with a record points haul.

That record is unlikely to last long, though, as Bournemouth’s 4-1 win over Newcastle United on Saturday was their 10th in 22 league games and took them to seventh in the table. But this was no ordinary away win.

Newcastle went into the game as favourites. One, they had won nine straight games. Two, in Alexander Isak they had the hottest striker in the country. And three, Bournemouth were missing 10 players through injury.

Faced with those odds, Iraola laughed and said words to the effect of “we attack at dawn” (almost literally, as the coaches taking Bournemouth’s fans on the 350-mile trip north left at 2am).


Andoni Iraola is a coveted coaching talent (George Wood/Getty Images)

With nine youngsters on the bench and central midfielder Lewis Cook at right-back, Iraola told his players to stick to their hard-running, high-pressing, up-tempo game and blitz Newcastle from the off. By the time Justin Kluivert scored the first of his three goals in the sixth minute, they should have been two up already.

Kluivert, whose famous dad Patrick once played for Newcastle, obviously got most of the post-match plaudits, but Ryan Christie and David Brooks were immense in midfield, Dean Huijsen and Illia Zabarnyi faultless in the heart of defence and what a player left-back Milos Kerkez is.

go-deeper

Earlier this season, I passed on some praise to Foley from a director of football at a rival club. The latter had said Bournemouth were worrying him “because they look like they know what they’re doing”.

“I’d rather they think we don’t know what we’re doing,” replied Foley.

Sorry, Bill, the secret is out. Iraola, and many of your players, are brilliant.

go-deeper

Coming up this week

  • We complete this weekend’s menu with a game between two sides badly in need of points but for very different reasons. Chelsea, the hosts, have not won in the league for a month and have been sucked into a scrap for Champions League football next season, while Wolves are fighting for league survival.
  • After a month on a diet of domestic games only, European competition returns on Tuesday, with big helpings of Champions League and Europa League football. Top-of-the-table Liverpool host Lille on Tuesday, with Aston Villa visiting Monaco.
  • The pick of Wednesday’s fare is Paris Saint-Germain versus Manchester City but not for the reason most would have predicted a few months ago, as this game is between the 25th and 22nd best teams in the Champions League so far this season. A defeat for either would leave that team with major Fear Of Missing Out. Arsenal, third in the rankings, have no such concerns ahead of the visit of Dinamo Zagreb.
  • Thursday, as everyone knows, is Europa League day, but this week’s best game is no afterthought as it is a “Battle of Britain” between Manchester United and Rangers. Tottenham will travel in hope to Hoffenheim. And if cross-border clashes, with a North American flavour, are your thing, there is a cracker in League One: Wrexham v Birmingham City.

(Top photo: Getty Images)

Projecting final 4 NFL playoff teams’ odds to win Super Bowl, with conference title game analysis

The road to the Super Bowl goes through Kansas City. After dispatching the Houston Texans, the Chiefs will play in the AFC Championship Game for a seventh straight year. They’re now just two wins away from the greatest achievement in the Super Bowl era: a three-peat. Standing in their way are the Buffalo Bills, who defeated the Baltimore Ravens on Sunday night, and now have a chance to dethrone the reigning two-time champions.

In the NFC, the Commanders shocked the world by upsetting the Detroit Lions on Saturday night and will try to repeat the feat next weekend against the Philadelphia Eagles, who took down the Los Angeles Rams on Sunday.

Jeff Howe breaks down each of the two conference championship game matchups before The Athletic’s NFL Projection Model, created by Austin Mock, reveals each remaining team’s odds of winning the Super Bowl.

AFC

No. 1 Kansas City Chiefs (15-2, 1-0 playoffs) vs. No. 2 Buffalo Bills (13-4, 2-0 playoffs)

The powers of the AFC wouldn’t budge this season, as the Chiefs and Bills will meet on the AFC Championship Game stage for the second time in four years.

The Bills finalized the showdown Sunday evening with a thrilling 27-25 victory against the Baltimore Ravens. Quarterback Josh Allen outdueled fellow MVP candidate Lamar Jackson, as the Bills star finished 16-of-22 for 127 yards with a couple of rushing scores to help ward off Baltimore’s comeback bid.

The Chiefs were somewhat shaky in their postseason debut, but they knocked off the Texans by a decisive 23-14 margin despite the visitors outpacing them in yards, time of possession, first downs and third-down conversions. That’s because the defense (eight sacks, 14 QB hits) and special teams still carry plenty of weight, and the Chiefs are the most well-balanced team in the field.

The Chiefs, if you haven’t heard, are on a quest to become the first team in history to win three consecutive Super Bowls. They’ve hoisted the Lombardi Trophy three times since coach Andy Reid and quarterback Patrick Mahomes aligned.

It hasn’t been an explosive season for Mahomes, who has more games with fewer than 200 passing yards (five) than over 300 yards (three), including the divisional round. But he hasn’t been making mistakes, accounting for 13 touchdowns (one rushing) since his last interception two months ago.

Mahomes also has 15 touchdowns against just two interceptions (both in the loss to the Cincinnati Bengals) in six AFC Championship Games. In fact, the Chiefs haven’t committed a single turnover over their past eight games. That’ll be a focal point against the Bills, who notched three takeaways Sunday against the Ravens and have forced multiple turnovers in 11-of-19 games this season.

Mahomes hasn’t gotten a lot of help. His offensive tackles have been poor — at least when left guard Joe Thuney isn’t moonlighting at left tackle — and his skill players have been in and out of the lineup with injuries.

But he’s still got Travis Kelce, who just ripped off the ninth 100-yard game of his playoff career. The 35-year-old future Pro Football Hall of Famer’s production dipped considerably during the regular season, but Kelce is as clutch as ever in the playoffs. He’s had at least 70 yards in 14 consecutive postseason games — averaging 99.1 yards per outing over that stretch — so Kelce is as automatic as it gets. He’s also led the league in receiving touchdowns in four of the past five postseasons.

And yet, the NFL’s modern-day dynasty will be tasked with one question all week: Can they stop Allen?

Allen completed 63.6 percent of his passes during the regular season for 3,731 yards, 28 touchdowns and a career-low six interceptions, and he added 531 rushing yards and a dozen scores.

Allen was 27-of-40 for 262 yards, one touchdown and one interception when the Bills beat the Chiefs 30-21 in Week 11. He added 55 rushing yards, including a 26-yard touchdown on a pivotal fourth-and-2. That was the Chiefs’ only loss this season with Mahomes as the starter, and it might have been the performance that launched Allen’s MVP campaign.

The Chiefs are 6-3 in the AFC Championship during the Super Bowl era, including 4-2 with Mahomes, while the Bills are 4-3. The Chiefs are 4-2 in the playoffs against the Bills, including three consecutive wins over the previous four years.

• Chiefs’ chances to win Super Bowl: 30.5%
Bills’ chances to win Super Bowl: 25.9%

Chances to win the Super Bowl

Team

  

Odds

  

33.8%

30.5%

25.9%

9.8%

NFC

No. 2 Philadelphia Eagles (14-3, 2-0 playoffs) vs. No. 6 Washington Commanders (12-5, 2-0 playoffs)

The NFC North wore the crown all season, but the NFC East is chasing the ring.

The Eagles and Commanders meet in the NFC Championship Game after splitting the regular-season series, with the Commanders claiming a 36-33 victory in their most recent meeting in Week 16 in Philadelphia. The Eagles needed a fourth-quarter comeback to beat the Commanders 26-18 in Week 11, so both games were close.

The Eagles may want an asterisk for their loss, as quarterback Jalen Hurts was knocked out early with a concussion, but their 33 points was the sixth-highest output of the season behind a strong Kenny Pickett performance. The far more important story was that the Eagles couldn’t win despite a 5-2 advantage in the turnover battle.

So what happens if the Eagles can’t drum up enough takeaways in the third installment? Maybe that’s also a moot point, as they had a narrow 1-0 edge in takeaways in the earlier win. It’s a rare occasion when turnovers haven’t made the difference in either outcome.

Still, the Commanders won’t want to test that theory any further. The Eagles have forced 30 turnovers in their last 13 games, including a couple of forced fumbles during a pivotal second-half stretch as they eliminated the Los Angeles Rams 28-22 in the divisional round.

GO DEEPER

The Commanders are a win away from the Super Bowl. Let that marinate for a bit

Daniels has had the Commanders’ offense playing at an elite level during their pair of road victories in the playoffs. They’ve scored on 11-of-16 possessions, excluding sequences to close out halves, and have punted just a single time. They’ve turned it over on downs three times — a risk-reward formula that’s been a net positive — but don’t have any interceptions or lost fumbles. They also have a missed field goal.

Daniels’ command in all situations has been remarkable. While the rookie possesses a clutch gene that’s come in handy during their game-winning drives this season, Daniels did an impressive job Saturday night of keeping the pressure on the top-seeded Lions, leading the Commanders to scores on four of their five possessions following a Detroit score. The exception was a missed field goal, so Daniels continuously kept the ball moving when the Lions were attempting to make a run.

Daniels will need to be great to get the Commanders to their first Super Bowl in 33 years, and the evidence suggests he’ll rise to that challenge. He passed for 1,522 yards, 17 touchdowns and four interceptions during their seven-game winning streak, and he added 422 yards and a score on the ground. However, three of Daniels’ nine interceptions this season have come against the Eagles.

Hurts and the Eagles passing attack has been pedestrian since his return from the concussion. He had 259 passing yards and two touchdowns in the two playoff wins, although he had 106 yards and a score as a rusher. Wide receivers A.J. Brown (three catches for 24 yards) and DeVonta Smith (eight catches for 76 yards) haven’t made much of an impact as a result.

But fear not, as the Eagles still have running back Saquon Barkley. The best offseason addition in the league had 324 rushing yards and two touchdowns in two playoff games, as he hasn’t slowed down since his torrid regular season.

These teams have one postseason meeting, with Washington taking their wild-card matchup in 1990. The Commanders are 90-86-6 in the all-time series.

The Commanders are 5-1 in conference championships during the Super Bowl era, while the Eagles are 4-4.

• Eagles’ chances to win Super Bowl: 33.8%
Commanders’ chances to win Super Bowl: 9.8%

(Photo of Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen: Ryan Kang / Getty Images)

Eagles ride Saquon Barkley, defense to NFC Championship Game in win vs. Rams: Key takeaways

The Philadelphia Eagles advanced to the conference championship game for the second time in the last three seasons after a snowy 28-22 win over the Los Angeles Rams on Sunday.

Lincoln Financial Field was covered in snow in the second half of the tightly contested NFC divisional matchup, but Philadelphia’s usual strengths — its No. 1-ranked defense (by yards allowed) and its Saquon Barkley-led rushing attack — were the difference yet again. That was especially key after quarterback Jalen Hurts was hampered by a left knee injury sustained while absorbing a sack late in the third quarter.

In addition to a pair of long touchdown runs, Barkley’s 205 rushing yards were good for the fifth-best postseason rushing total in NFL history, a fitting follow-up to his 302-yard performance during the two teams’ Week 12 meeting.

Philly now turns its attention to Jayden Daniels and the Washington Commanders with a Super Bowl appearance on the line when they play next Sunday. The NFC East rivals split their 2024 season series. They have met only one other time in the postseason, a 20-6 wild-card win by Washington in January 1991.

Defense continues its dominance

The Eagles’ defense gave Philadelphia chances to put the Rams away early. It forced two first-half field goals while backed up in the red zone. On the first instance, C.J. Gardner-Johnson supplied a major tackle for loss, following the motion on the play into the backfield. In the fourth quarter, Jalen Carter and Nolan Smith forced fumbles that gave the Eagles the ball in Rams territory. Both turnovers only resulted in field goals.

The Eagles forced a three-and-out with 4:47 left in the game, and Barkley immediately rushed for a 78-yard touchdown to threaten to put the game away. But the Eagles’ defense subsequently gave up a 10-play touchdown drive, which, followed by a three-and-out by the Eagles’ offense, forced Philly to defend the field one last time. They did. A turnover on downs deep in Eagles territory ended the game. — Brooks Kubena, Eagles staff writer

Ailing Hurts not playing at his highest level

Hurts, who finished with 128 passing yards Sunday, has now twice thrown for under 200 yards in the playoffs. Nick Sirianni has defended his franchise quarterback throughout the season, sermonizing different variations of “Jalen is a winner.” Indeed, Hurts fulfills a different role in this offense this season. He is more conservative in the pocket, leveraging Barkley and a top-rated defense on the way to more physical victories.

It’s fair to say Hurts was conservative last week against the Green Bay Packers. His play against the Rams on Sunday was poor. He took far too many sacks in consequential situations, including a safety that allowed the Rams to crawl to within one point, 16-15. He missed open receivers on multiple plays.

A.J. Brown had his own blunders, dropping two passes, including a deep ball near the pylon. The Eagles simply need better play from Hurts to fully take advantage of the opportunities their defense is supplying them. — Kubena

Eagles still waiting for offense to click

The Eagles failed to fully capitalize on offensive opportunities, and it nearly cost them. They built a 13-7 first-quarter lead on a 44-yard touchdown run by Hurts and a 62-yard touchdown run by Barkley. They were disjointed for most of the rest of the game. Hurts was sacked six times — three times in the final two possessions of the first half, in which the Eagles punted twice in Rams territory. Brown also dropped the well-placed pass from Hurts near the pylon in that stretch.

In the second half, the Eagles failed to score touchdowns off two defensive turnovers in Rams territory. Most inexcusable: Lane Johnson was flagged for a false start, wiping out a Brotherly Shove touchdown on fourth-and-goal at the 1. Jake Elliott, who struggled for stretches of this season, came through for the Eagles when it mattered most. He made all three of his field goal attempts on a field blanketed in snow.

This is the second straight week the Eagles offense has needed the defense to bail it out and give Hurts and company time to put the game on ice. Can the Eagles advance to the Super Bowl that way next week, hosting the Commanders in the NFC Championship Game? — Kubena

Required reading

(Photo: Sarah Stier / Getty Images)

What do the numbers say about competitiveness in the postseason for NFL, college football?

One evening after the inaugural 12-team College Football Playoff concluded with four blowout games staged on campus, ESPN host Scott Van Pelt and football analyst Tim Hasselbeck held a conversation that mirrored many like it taking place on social media and in barrooms.

The host teams won by an average of 19.3 points, and the closest outcome was Notre Dame’s 10-point victory against Indiana. Two games — Penn State over SMU (28 points) and Ohio State over Tennessee (25) — were non-competitive. Texas’ 14-point win against ACC champion Clemson was decisive as well.

“Are these the games you want?” Van Pelt asked the former NFL quarterback. “No one can be sitting there and going, ‘You want these blowout games.’”

Hasselbeck responded, “We’re going to have blowouts in these NFL games, too.”

The loud and contentious debate about whether Indiana and SMU deserved CFP at-large bids overshadowed the reality of postseason football in both college and the NFL. There are at least as many blowouts as there are memorable finishes. That was true in the four-team Playoff era, which began in 2014, and as Hasselbeck pointed out, it’s true in the NFL during the same time frame.

Since the Playoff system debuted following the 2014 season, there have been 40 CFP games. The average margin of victory in those games is 17.5 points. During the same time frame, there were 124 NFL playoff games, including 10 Super Bowls. The average margin of victory was 11.1 points per contest.

One fact has emerged from the CFP and NFL playoff data. No matter the round, location, level or seeding, it’s a coin flip whether postseason football produces a competitive game or a blowout. The numbers bear that out.

CFP average margin of victory

Games Margin

First round

4

19.3

Quarterfinals

4

14.5

Semifinals

22

16.5

Championship

10

20.1

Total

40

17.5

CFP data

The non-competitive nature of the CFP’s first round produced knee-jerk reactions and wild takes largely because of the participants. But the scoring margin was comparable to what transpired in the previous decade. Three of the four first-round CFP games were decided by at least 11 points, and two had victory margins exceeding 20 points.

Pundits largely scoffed at Indiana, which scored two late touchdowns at Notre Dame before falling 27-17 in the first-round curtain raiser. But of the 10 CFP games this season, it has had the third-closest result.

“This team earned it, the right to be here,” Indiana coach Curt Cignetti said afterward. “I’m not sure we proved that tonight to a lot of people.”

Regarding CFP history, Indiana’s loss ranked in the upper third as far as competitive final scores. Since the CFP’s debut in 2014, there were more games decided by 20-plus points (17) than by one score (12). More than two-thirds of the games (27) featured a margin of at least 11 points.

In 10 seasons, the CFP’s least competitive round was the championship. Only three of the 10 were decided by one score ,and all three took place from 2015-17 between Alabama and either Clemson (twice) or Georgia (once). The Bulldogs’ 65-7 romp over TCU concluding the 2022 season pushed the average margin to 20.1 points for the title round. While that score was an outlier, five of the 10 championship margins exceeded 20 points.

“These types of margins that we experienced in the first round of the College Football Playoff happen all the time,” Fox college football analyst Joel Klatt said on his podcast following the first round this year. “It’s been happening in the College Football Playoff four-team model forever. We’ve had some absolute duds for semifinals and in the championship game.

“And hey, by the way, there’s large margins in the NFL as well.”

NFL playoff margin of victory since 2014

Games Margin

Wild card

54

11.9

Divisional

40

9.9

Championship

20

12.6

Super Bowl

10

8.4

Total

124

11.1

NFL Playoff data

The NFL playoff model largely mirrored college football’s postseason results. Five of the six wild-card games last weekend were decided by at least 12 points — two eclipsed 20 points — and the average margin of victory was 15.2 points per game.

There was little variance between the AFC and NFC. In the 54 wild-card games, the average margin was 11.9 points per game (12.7 in the AFC, 11.2 in the NFC). Of the games at non-neutral sites, the divisional round featured the closest margin of victory on average with 40 contests decided by 9.9 points per game (10.9 in the AFC, 8.8 in the NFC). The championship round victory margin was 12.6 points per game (10.7 in the AFC, 14.4 in the NFC).

The Super Bowl’s recent run of competitive contests has become an anomaly to the overall data. Once derided for perpetual disappointment on the big stage — from 1982 through 1996 every NFL title game except for two featured at least a 10-point margin — the NFL championship game generated the closest outcomes of any playoff round (8.4 points per game). Six of the most recent 10 Super Bowls have been decided by one score, and only one featured a margin beyond 14 points.

But for the 114 NFL playoff games at home sites, the percentage of competitive NFL contests alongside blowouts was comparable to the college game.

Home field, one-score games

Perhaps the most coincidental statistic concerns home-field advantage. In both the AFC and NFC, home teams were 38-19 (76-38 combined) in 10-plus seasons, winning exactly two-thirds of the playoff games from the 2014 postseason onward. Home teams won by an average of 13.1 points per game, while road teams won by 7.9 points per contest.

In 10 seasons, top-seeded teams in both the AFC and NFC were 14-4 in the postseason, combining for a 28-8 overall record. Top seeds won by an average of 14.1 points per game, and their losses came by an average of 5.8 points per game.

With home-field advantage, seeding impacts the NFL much more than in college football, which applied it for the first time this year. All four teams hosting CFP games won, but the top four seeds earned a bye and have yet to host a game on campus. Combining the four on-campus contests with the 36 neutral-site CFP games, the higher seed posted a 21-19 overall record but was just 3-9 in games decided by one score. In one-sided contests featuring victories by more than one score, the higher-seeded team won 64.3 percent of the time. Top-ranked teams were 12-7 in CFP action, winning by 21.1 points per game and losing by 13.9 points per game.

Since 2014, the NFL postseason featured almost an even split between one-score games and blowouts. Of the 114 playoff games played at host sites, 59 (51.8 percent) were determined by one score while 53 (46.5 percent) were decided by 11 points or more.

College football has a lower percentage of one-score CFP contests with 12 of the 40 (30 percent) fitting in that category whereas 27 (67.5 percent) had margins that exceeded 11 points. Perhaps in the clearest difference between the NFL and college football, 42.5 percent of CFP games featured a margin of at least 20 points while only 16.7 percent of NFL games landed in that category.

(Illustration: Will Tullos / The Athletic; Photos: David Madison, Perry Knotts, Joseph Weiser / Getty Images)

Emma Navarro keeps her eye on the ball at the Australian Open as tennis limelight shines brighter

MELBOURNE, Australia — A seriously cold December afternoon in midtown Manhattan, in the lobby of a hotel off Central Park.

A 23-year-old woman looks up from a club chair near an elevator. She’s wearing a baseball cap, diddling around a bit on her phone.

“Hey,” she says.

Take another look. Oh, right, that’s Emma Navarro: U.S. Open semifinalist and a top-10 women’s player after just one full season of top-tier tournaments. She’s chilling ahead of a packed evening of photo ops, press gaggles, and an appearance at the New York Knicks NBA basketball game with a few other tennis players you might have heard of — Carlos Alcaraz, Ben Shelton and Jessica Pegula.

It might be fun. Then again, hanging out in this comfy chair, anonymously watching the bustle of her native city pass by is pretty cool too. There are many reasons why Navarro, who plays Ons Jabeur in the third round of the Australian Open Saturday, pursued tennis. Being a famous person was not one of them.

“The exact opposite,” she said the other day, after a second-round win in Melbourne over Wang Xiyu of China, her second consecutive three-set battle with the outcome up in the air until the final point.

She was at it once again Saturday, when she opened a packed Margaret Court Arena against Ons Jabeur, a three-time Grand Slam finalist and darling of the sport on the way back from a torrid few months with injury. After winning 20 of the first 24 points and surging to a 5-0 lead in the first set, she had to scramble in the third to prevail, saving three break points when serving at 1-2.

When it was over, she credited her parents for taking her and her siblings on six-hour bike rides when they were kids for her third-set prowess. Then she scribbled “me heart 3 sets” on the television camera. She should. She went 19-6 in matches that went the distance last season. On her way off the court, she was straight into signing autographs for fans hanging over the stands. The match was played in the light and shadow of lunchtime in Melbourne and Navarro is not yet fully adjusted to being center stage, day after day after day.

“It’s something that I work really hard at managing and feeling comfortable with being in the spotlight. It’s the opposite of my nature. It feels unnatural,” she said.


This happens in tennis sometimes. Not everything develops in sync. Not everyone who can fire forehands and backhand on a wire seemingly all afternoon is an alpha-dog extrovert, letting their life unfold in a series of Instagram posts and TikTok videos.

And so it is with Navarro, whose tennis life had been an exploration in incrementalism up until the summer of last year. At 18, after a terrific junior career — including a singles final and doubles title at the French Open — she still wasn’t sure she wanted to be a professional tennis player. So she went to the University of Virginia for two years, where she won the NCAA nationwide college-level women’s singles championship.

When she did turn pro, she opted not to pursue wild-card entries that might have been easily attainable, given that her father, Ben, is active in the tennis business and owns the ATP and WTA 1000-level Cincinnati Open. She was fine climbing her way through second-tier tournaments on the ITF and WTA 125 circuits.

GO DEEPER

Win or lose, Emma Navarro wants to hit one more ball

Navarro was outside the top 100 as recently as April 2023. She finished that year as world No. 32, the magic number for a Grand Slam seeding, and won her first WTA Tour tournament in Hobart, Tasmania, the day before the start of the 2024 Australian Open.

Then she played her way into the spotlight. She notched consecutive wins over Coco Gauff, first at Wimbledon and then the U.S. Open, where Gauff, now a friend, was the defending champion. She rose into the top 10 for the first time. And that’s when things started to get a little busy.


Emma Navarro is figuring out how to live in the tennis limelight. (Daniel Pockett / Getty Images)

A flood of interview and appearance requests. A commercial portfolio that now includes deals with Fila, Yonex, Red Bull, Dove, Fanatics, De Bethune and, as of Friday, Mejuri, the high-end jewellery brand that put her in a bespoke photo shoot in Charleston, S.C., in December. Navarro is the company’s first athlete ambassador.

For Serena Williams and Maria Sharapova, Naomi Osaka and Gauff, Iga Swiatek and Zheng Qinwen, something like that is just another day ending with a “Y”. For Navarro, it is, in her own words, “an adjustment”.

The adjustment has a tennis guise too, which might go some distance toward explaining Navarro’s first two matches here this month. Both ended up being tennis escape rooms, first on Rod Laver Arena and then on the site’s second stadium, Margaret Court Arena.

She was down a break of serve in the third set in both matches. Peyton Stearns, another former NCAA champion, had a match point against her in a second-set tiebreak that she couldn’t take. Stearns then served for the match in the third, but couldn’t get over the line.

In both cases, Navarro was in the first match of the day, putting her in the prime-time slot back in the States on ESPN — a slot that Gauff often plays in. Like the fame and exposure that winning and marketing deals carry, big court assignments and prime-time hours bring a not-so-subtle message of expectation.

In both matches, the usually steady Navarro sprayed balls from the middle of the baseline that she had roped back for much of last year, wearing down opponent after opponent. Then she found a way, stringing together her best shots of the afternoon in the handful of deciding points that made the difference twice over.

Against Jabeur, she raced through the first set to 5-0 before Jabeur started playing with the finesse that carried her to the brink of the biggest prizes in the sport. She got back to 5-4. Navarro still took the set.


For nearly her entire tennis life, Navarro had been the girl and then the woman who was thrilled when she showed up at a tournament and learned she was playing on Court 35 in the back of the facility.

“Like, put me in the forest,” she said.

That’s not happening anymore.

“You spend whatever 20 years working at something, mainly behind closed doors, and then all of a sudden you’re a form of entertainment for people,” she said. “People pay to come watch you do what you do. It’s definitely an adjustment.”

Navarro’s coach, Peter Ayers, has been working with her the past eight years. He said his way of getting Navarro used to being a new version of herself during the off-season was to stick with the formula that got her here.

“It’s always been a very methodical approach,” Ayers said during an interview in Melbourne. “We want her to get better without neglecting her bread and butter. It’s always a balance.”

For Navarro, who will never be one of the WTA tour’s giants, that means trying to play bigger and more aggressively within the parameters of her strengths. She is not about to start firing lasers, like some of her peers can do point in, point out.

“I’m very leery of just chasing velocity,” said Ayers.

There are other ways.

Ayers is a baseball guy. One of his favorite pitchers was Greg Maddux, the Atlanta Braves ace of the 1990s. Maddux was far from the hardest thrower, but no one could place balls on the edge of the strike zone as well as he could. “There’s a lot she can do with being more precise,” Ayers said.

Same with her strokes.

Navarro doesn’t have to try to out-hit players such as Aryna Sabalenka or out-spin Swiatek. But she can do a lot of damage if her feet are a step or two closer to the baseline more often, or even inside it.

Ayers, like Navarro, knows that life is different when there is a single digit next to your name on the rankings ladder. It’s been a while since Navarro sneaked up on anyone, as she did on Gauff at dusk in southwest London six months ago. People aren’t afraid of losing to her anymore, Ayers said; when that fear goes away, opponents can play free without worrying about the consequences.

“You’re getting everyone’s best shot,”  he said. “The idea is that makes you better.”


Emma Navarro has found herself on her heels in her two Australian Open matches to date. (Daniel Pockett / Getty Images)

Navarro has always been something of problem-solver, whether it’s figuring out an opponent, how she wants to spend her time and who she wants to be as a tennis player. In a sense, what she’s doing now, is figuring out another problem — how to exist as this new version of herself, the version that has been better than all but a handful of players in the women’s game for the past six months.

“The single-digit gets me a little bit,” she said. “It’s just so far outside my realm of expectations for myself.”

There’s been some revelations lately, though, that will hopefully begin to pay some dividends soon. There’s a way to play a certain kind of tennis and still be that woman sitting on a club chair in a hotel lobby, anonymously watching the world go by.

“My tennis can be alpha and I’ll let that do its job and I can just be me,” she said. “If I’m not feeling like myself, I’m probably not going to be playing my best tennis.”

(Top photo: Ng Han Guan / Associated Press)

Will Liverpool win this Premier League title – and, if so, when? Our experts’ views

It is 76 days since Liverpool moved back to the top of the 2024-25 Premier League table with a 2-1 home win against Brighton & Hove Albion — a position they haven’t relinquished since.

Arne Slot’s side are not always showing imperious form but have still only been beaten once in their 20 league matches so far and have a four-point advantage over second-placed Arsenal, with a game in hand, going into the weekend’s fixtures.

So, are Liverpool destined to win just their second domestic championship in 35 years? And, if they are, at what point in the coming months will that triumph become all but nailed-on? We convened an expert panel — some with affiliations to the Anfield side, others to Liverpool’s biggest rivals — and sought their views.


Pep Guardiola has fried all of our brains.

He’s shattered a lot of English football’s illusions about its exceptionalism during his nine years as Manchester City manager. He’s affected the way pretty much every team in the country play. He’s changed what we all expect our full-backs to do. And our central defenders.

More immediately, he’s altered what we all think a title race looks like.

For the past few years – with one exception – the standard for anyone hoping to win the Premier League has been, as Jurgen Klopp once put it, perfection. Even to be close to that meant getting more than 90 points from the available 114. Actually claiming the crown usually required more: 93, or 98, or 100.

This season is different. A total of 85 will probably do it, maybe even 82. That means our reactions to individual results are out of kilter: in a campaign when City do nothing but win, drawing once at home can be fatal; in one where there’s more leeway for their rivals, the damage is limited.

Liverpool’s current league position, of course, makes them favourites, even if that game they have in hand is the last league derby at Goodison Park — hardly a gimme. But there is little to suggest the four-point advantage Arne Slot’s team currently hold over Arsenal is likely to be decisive. This is not the sort of season where a lead, once obtained, will not be surrendered.


Arne Slot has made a superb start to life in English football (Paul Ellis/AFP via Getty Images)

Liverpool’s schedule, from here on in, is more challenging than Arsenal’s; it’s not unimaginable that they might draw three more games than Mikel Arteta’s side over the next four months.

Arsenal do not have a massive margin for error but I’d only be relatively confident that the twists and turns had ended if Liverpool came out of their game against them at Anfield, on the second weekend in May, with a three-point lead. And a superior goal difference, just to be safe.

Rory Smith


Call it a hard-bitten Evertonian self-defence mechanism, but I live with a chronic condition which presents as a persistent, underlying premonition of major Liverpool success. For example: they could be 18th in the 20-team Premier League table, managerless and riddled with injuries, and my nervous system would be preparing for an unlikely cup win and surge to a top-four finish.

So I’ve been tingling with the feeling that the 2024-25 title is coming to Anfield ever since they beat Real Madrid (in the Champions League) and Manchester City back-to-back in the space of five days as November became December.

A small part of me still just can’t rule out some astonishing City revival where they win every game between now and the end of the campaign in late May, as Liverpool drop points due to lingering defensive issues. Or that Arsenal will sign a decent goalscorer before this winter transfer window closes in a couple of weeks and really make it a contest.

But it would still be infinitely more likely that Liverpool will find another gear and triumph comfortably.

As it stands, I think it will only be after they have come through successive games against Chelsea and Arsenal in early May that I will completely make my peace with the forthcoming months of endless coverage, parades, plays, poems, films, statues and royal decrees that will accompany their record-equalling 20th top-flight championship.

Greg O’Keeffe

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Do Liverpool need new signings?


If you’re a fan of a rival club — Manchester United, say — there is often a point in a season where you have to make peace with the idea the “Bad Thing” might happen, and you start steeling yourself for when friends in the group chat/at five-a-side start gloating more.

For me, that arrived after Liverpool’s trio of fixtures against Tottenham Hotspur, Leicester City and West Ham United either side of Christmas. It wasn’t just that Liverpool were good. It wasn’t just that Manchester City and Arsenal were wobbling. It’s that Arne Slot found enough tactical solutions for the problems the Premier League throws at you.

Left-back is an issue for this team, Darwin Nunez’s pace doesn’t quite compensate for the speed of his decision-making, Alisson is not quite the force he used to be in goal. Alexis Mac Allister – understandably – can look a little leggy when he returns from long-haul international duty in South America with Argentina. Yet Slot keeps tinkering and tweaking while reminding his players at half-time that hard running is not an optional requirement to winning games.


Alisson – a fine goalkeeper, but is he in decline? (Justin Setterfield/Getty Images)

Liverpool’s 2019-20 title triumph saw a Jurgen Klopp-managed side beat Leicester City 4-0 away on December 26 (it might have been Naby Keita’s last good game for the club) and stamp their authority on the rest of the league. This season’s 3-1 win over them at Anfield on that date wasn’t quite the same (if only because Leicester were a lot stronger five years ago), but there is a similar sense that when Slot’s side switch it on, nobody in England can compete.

Carl Anka


In 2019-20, there were two games around this point in the season that made Jurgen Klopp’s side winning the title feel like an inevitability: the 4-0 away victory against Leicester City on Boxing Day and beating Manchester United 2-0 at Anfield on January 19. The latter was their 21st league win from the season’s first 22 matches. Absurd.

I haven’t experienced that feeling yet this season. It is a funny time to pose this question due to the current wobble Arne Slot’s team is having. Had I been asked this question after the victories over Tottenham Hotspur, Leicester and West Ham United before and after Christmas, I would be more positive. But two draws since to make it three wins in seven league games doesn’t scream title-winning form, although they haven’t lost any of those matches.

As a pessimist when it comes to this type of thing, my realistic answer is: only when it is mathematically impossible for them to be caught, or Virgil van Dijk is actually lifting the trophy.

However, I would love that 2019-20-esque moment to come in a Merseyside derby – ideally the next one, at Goodison Park on February 12, but more likely when Everton go to Anfield in the first week of April. Those games are so crucial to momentum, positive or negative.

Failing that, a positive result at home against Arsenal on the weekend of May 10-11 will probably be the key moment where I’ll believe it is happening.

Andy Jones


Over Liverpool’s last seven Premier League matches, they have dropped points in four. That doesn’t look or sound to me like an unstoppable procession to the title. They’re the favourites to win it from here, sure — but I’m not yet convinced.

The issue, of course, is that their most plausible challengers, Arsenal, have a similar propensity to drop points — and a significant gap to overhaul. They’re also without arguably their best player for a while yet with Bukayo Saka having recently undergone surgery for a torn hamstring — and that blow to their attack has been compounded by an ACL knee injury for Gabriel Jesus last weekend.

Much could depend on how much, if at all, Arsenal strengthen before the winter transfer window closes on February 3.

I feel that Liverpool and Arsenal — and Nottingham Forest, and Newcastle, and Chelsea — will continue to drop points here and there. It will be interesting to see if Manchester City can pick up enough points to close the gap and apply some pressure.

Liverpool host Arsenal on the second weekend in May. Arsenal’s mission for the next four months is to make that game matter — and I think there’s every chance they can.

Only if Liverpool win that one, to give themselves a commanding lead with a couple of weeks of the season to go, will I see them as champions-elect.

James McNicholas


Ever since Steven Pienaar of Everton slid in to secure a 4-4 draw at Old Trafford in April 2012, I’ve always made a point of holding onto hope in a title race.

Pienaar’s 85th-minute equaliser in a match Manchester United had led 3-1 after 66 minutes was a goal that helped Manchester City to make up an eight-point deficit with just six games to go and one of those incredible occasions where the desperate mental gymnastics — ‘They just need to lose at Wigan, drop points at home to Everton, and we’ll beat them at the Etihad’ — perfectly checked out.

But even my optimism can only stretch so far.

City are out of this race, Christian Norgaard’s stoppage-time header to deny them a 2-1 win at Brentford on Tuesday the latest reminder that the reigning champions are far too flaky to make up what is currently a 12-point gap.


Norgaard’s late equaliser for Brentford on Tuesday underlined City’s frailties (Clive Rose/Getty Images)

That realistically leaves Arsenal, who I just can’t see reeling Liverpool back in with their inconsistency in front of goal and injury disruptions to their right-hand side.

Arsenal have to go to Anfield in the season’s third-last round of fixtures, and unless they are practically faultless from now until then, it looks like being the fixture that could allow the current leaders to ease their way to glory.

Thom Harris


When you’re writing about something that may arrive in the future, there’s an understandable caution, a fear that you’ll be made to look ridiculous should your prediction turn out to be nonsense.

But even with that in mind, I’m pretty confident about this one: I won’t predict a point between now and the end of the season on May 25 when it will be clear Liverpool have the title in the bag — because I think it’s already in there.

If we’re picking a point when I became sure, it was probably not a single game, but that first week in December, when they beat Manchester City with relative ease, something that came not long before Arsenal drew with Fulham and then Everton.

The certainty is less about Liverpool, an excellent if not historically brilliant team, but more that I just don’t trust any of the chasing pack to be consistent enough to catch them. City are going through some stuff, Arsenal aren’t ruthless enough, Chelsea are wobbling, teams will figure out how to beat Nottingham Forest soon enough, Newcastle are the form team now but are an Alexander Isak injury away from trouble.

Liverpool will end as the last team standing, the best of a Premier League season in which the overall quality has evened out, without one single behemoth overshadowing the rest.

Nick Miller


It seems to me that only supporters of other clubs are certain that the 2024-25 title will arrive at Anfield.

If it doesn’t, it conveniently gives them the chance to say Liverpool choked. You build them up, you knock them down.

Like a lot of Liverpudlians, I am reasonably confident the season will end in championship success for Arne Slot’s team. Yet there is also caution due to recent memories, as well as longer ones. Under Jurgen Klopp, Liverpool led the way three times at this stage of a season but only once were they in the same position when the music stopped after 38 games.

Further back, the promise of teams led by Roy Evans, Rafael Benitez and Brendan Rodgers was marked in springtime before hopes faded on the run-in.

It is for these reasons that I will only be certain about the possibilities relating to Slot’s Liverpool when those currently chasing can no longer catch them.

Simon Hughes

(Top photo: Phil Noble/AFP via Getty Images)

Emma Raducanu and Iga Swiatek’s Australian Open match reunites two teenage Grand Slam winners

MELBOURNE, Australia — In 2020, Iga Swiatek won her first Grand Slam title at 19.

The following year, Emma Raducanu won her first Grand Slam title at 18.

The pair of teenage major winners have followed divergent paths since then. Swiatek has added four more Grand Slam titles to her tally, spending over 100 weeks as world No. 1 in the process; Raducanu hasn’t reached the final of a single WTA Tour event, let aloneanother major.

Their Australian Open third-round match on Saturday is one of the most consequential of Raducanu’s career since winning the U.S. Open in 2021. She has gone deeper in a Grand Slam before, reaching the Wimbledon fourth round last year, but she has never played an opponent ranked higher than world No. 7 at a major.

Raducanu’s career record against top-10 players is 2-7, with an 0-3 head-to-head against Swiatek, but she has won her last two matches against top-10 opponents at Eastbourne and Wimbledon respectively. After a heavily disrupted 2024, 2025 brings an immediate test against one of the best players in the world.

Swiatek and Raducanu, now 23 and 22 respectively, took very different trajectories en route to their first Grand Slam titles. Swiatek’s breakout tournament at the 2020 French Open came on the back of numerous Grand Slam main draw match wins and a junior Wimbledon title, while Raducanu won the 2021 U.S. Open as a qualifier, a once-in-history tennis moment.

Raducanu laughed Thursday when talking about breakthroughs in the wake of beating friend Amanda Anisimova 6-3, 7-5 to set up the meeting with the world No. 2.

“I know that she was playing since a very young age and my hours in comparison were probably a bit comical when I was 17 or 18, playing six hours a week,” she said in a news conference.

“I don’t think it was the same trajectory.”

In that junior Wimbledon title run, Swiatek met Raducanu in the quarterfinals. She won 6-0, 6-1.

GO DEEPER

Emma Raducanu has done all-or-nothing tennis. Now, can she just play?


The contrast has persisted since their respective first major titles, with Swiatek winning Grand Slams on multiple surfaces (clay and hard courts) while Raducanu either flattered to deceive in the wake of suddenly and infinitely increased expectations or suffered continual misfortune with injuries. Her career has been one of consistent rebuilds, while Swiatek has won at least one major in each of the past three seasons, picking up 22 singles titles and the 2024 United Cup’s “most valuable player” title after winning all of her singles matches.

In 2022, when Swiatek won both the French and U.S. Opens, Raducanu was having her first proper season on the WTA Tour — as a Grand Slam champion. Her results were good when presented as a rookie player trying to navigate a full season for the first time, with one semifinal and a couple of quarterfinals. They were less good by the normal standards of a Grand Slam champion. Raducanu ended the year ranked No. 75 after a first-round exit at the U.S. Open saw her lose 2,030 points and plummet from No. 11 to No. 83 in the space of two weeks.

It was a year of frequent coaching changes for Raducanu. Having won the U.S. Open with Andrew Richardson, she replaced him with Torben Beltz just two months after winning the title. By April 2022, Beltz was out and Dimitry Tursunov, who had worked with Annett Kontaveit while she reached No. 2 in the world, was in.

Tursunov didn’t continue beyond a trial period of a few months, telling Tennis Majors that there were “red flags” he could not ignore. Sebastian Sachs arrived in December 2022 and lasted until the following June, making it five coaches in less than two years for Raducanu. Richardson had replaced Nigel Sears in July 2021, just two months before her U.S. Open win.

“Anything that’s not necessarily serving me, I’m just pretty savage in terms of just prioritizing myself and focusing,” Raducanu said on Thursday in Melbourne. “Anything that wants to try and affect that, I don’t have time for it. No hate. I just don’t want to kind of let that in.”

Coaches are asked to put together PowerPoint presentations to explain their thinking — she has always had an incredible focus and demand for excellence. Even as a junior, she would seek out coaches who could help her with specific shots. She’s obsessed with the why of things and won’t just jump because she’s told to.

She said on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme in October 2023: “l ask my coaches a lot of questions. On certain occasions, they haven’t been able to keep up with the questions I’ve asked and maybe that’s why it ended.”

Beltz was brought in to improve her forehand and when that wasn’t happening, Raducanu saw little point in carrying on.


Emma Raducanu with Dimitry Tursunov at the 2022 U.S. Open (Julian Finney / Getty Images)

A big moment in the next Raducanu rebuild came at the end of 2023 when she hired Nick Cavaday as coach. The pair worked together when Raducanu was a junior and had discussed a possible partnership earlier in her senior career, with the timing on both sides not working out. He joined her team towards the end of a 2023 season that had been dominated by another recurring theme in her career: injuries.

She missed the majority of the season after double wrist surgery and an ankle operation, which together meant she played just five events and ended her season in April. While Raducanu was in the early stages of rehabilitation, Swiatek was scooping up a third French Open, her second in two years, and a fourth Grand Slam title overall.

Cavaday is still in place 13 months later, an eternity compared to how long her previous coaches have lasted. Raducanu responds to his clarity of thinking and style of communication, with a focus on offering evidence and data to support what he is saying. Cavaday’s technical expertise also allows them to work on specific shots — especially the forehand and serve — which has been a key factor in Raducanu’s previous coaching decisions.

At this year’s Australian Open, the forehand has been potent, but the latter is a work in progress. Raducanu will meet her opponent on Saturday with the more settled team, as Swiatek eases into life with Wim Fissette. Fissette has coached former world No. 1 players Naomi Osaka, Kim Clijsters and Angelique Kerber, winning six Grand Slam titles in total, and looks to be returning Swiatek to the devastating but controlled aggression that has seen her dominate the sport. Her succession of too-similar defeats under former coach Tomasz Wiktorowski, in which she descended into a tailspin of overhitting groundstrokes in the face of peaking opponents, looks a long way away.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Emotional intelligence, data, and tough love: Who is Wim Fissette the coach?

Swiatek is yet to suffer a defeat to Raducanu; Raducanu is yet to win a set against her. They crossed paths in 2024 for the third time after the Brit moved her ranking up from No. 285 at the start of the season to No. 58 by its close. She met Swiatek at the WTA 500 Stuttgart quarterfinal, which Swiatek won 7-6(2), 6-3.

Raducanu entered the tournament as a wildcard because she is a brand ambassador for Porsche, who also sponsor the event. Later in the year, Raducanu posted a picture of herself driving her £100,000 Porsche Cayenne after rumours spread that the company had taken back a car they’d gifted her when she was spotted taking a public bus in London. In December, Raducanu told a small group of reporters that she would cut down on sponsorship days.

Last year also brought that run to the Wimbledon fourth round, but it was overshadowed by her decision to withdraw from her mixed doubles with the retiring Andy Murray to protect her wrist ahead of her fourth-round match.

Raducanu felt she had no choice. Murray was gutted. His mother, Judy, called it “astonishing” on social media. Raducanu faced a lot of criticism for doing what most players would have done in the same situation before she said tennis “doesn’t feel different at all” when asked about Murray’s absence at the U.S. Open. She added that the way tennis works means that even someone like Murray moving on is “old news the next day.”

Even without that episode, Raducanu has faced challenges in connecting with the wider sporting public. In Melbourne, she spoke about the Murray situation in a less matter-of-fact way than previously.

“Afterwards, I sent him a long message, basically: ‘If I caused any trouble I guess at Wimbledon, that’s definitely the last thing I want,’” she told a small group of reporters.

“He’s someone that I’ve grown up looking up to and I don’t want any bad blood or harsh feelings with him.”

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Emma Raducanu and Andy Murray make up, Joao Fonseca learns on the court: Australian Open takeaways

Raducanu is aware of the importance of an athlete’s public image and met with a group of British journalists for an interview and an informal lunch in December in which she explained some of her goals for 2025. After hiring fitness trainer Yutaka Nakamura, who has worked with Grand Slam champions and world No. 1s Maria Sharapova and Naomi Osaka, Raducanu said: “I think I can become one of the best athletes in tennis. I think he’s really going to help with that.”

At that time, Raducanu had only just returned from a couple of months out after spraining foot ligaments at the start of September. She’d had a tricky period before that, too, opting against trying to qualify for the pre-U.S. Open hard-court swing and then arriving at the U.S. Open undercooked.

In her pre-tournament news conference, Raducanu spoke of how good she was feeling, but after losing to Sofia Kenin, Raducanu cried in her post-match duties. “I feel down, I feel sad,” she said.


Raducanu arrived in Melbourne under similar circumstances after a back spasm picked up while tying her shoelaces meant she arrived at the Australian Open with no match practice.

Both of her victories to date, against No. 26 seed Ekaterina Alexandrova and then former French Open semifinalist Amanda Anisimova, have been scrappy but clutch when necessary. She has won her last eight tiebreaks, including two against Alexandrova. Her tweaked serve has been shaky, but she has relied on her ground game and worked through physical issues to shield the problems with her serve. Raducanu received treatment on her back when 0-3 down in the second set against Anisimova, before winning seven of the next nine games to take the match.


Emma Raducanu has been impressive during her first two matches in Melbourne. (Shi Tang / Getty Images)

Her defensive tennis was outstanding against Anisimova, hustling across the baseline to draw errors by forcing one more shot out of an increasingly erratic opponent.

“I was able to get to some balls that maybe I wouldn’t have been able to previously,” Raducanu said afterwards.

When asked about their divergent paths over the past few years, Swiatek was philosophical. “Everybody’s story is different and everybody struggles with different stuff,” she said in a news conference on Thursday.

The expectation is that Swiatek will be too strong, but being in the position to take on the world’s best players feels like an important step for Raducanu.

“When we’re going to be out there on the court, whoever is going to play better will win, and that’s it,” Swiatek said.

(Top photo: Robert Prange / Getty Images)

PSR is not perfect, but the Premier League’s shock therapy has had an effect

An air of desperation hung over a handful of Premier League clubs last summer. Accounting years were drawing to a close across the top division of English football and the pressure was on to book profits before it was too late. Player sales were a must if a profitability and sustainability rules (PSR) breach was to be avoided before June 30.

Newcastle United’s business back then was a microcosm of the chaos. They reluctantly agreed to sell Yankuba Minteh, their then teenage winger, to Brighton & Hove Albion for £30million before sanctioning the exit of Elliot Anderson, the homegrown forward, to Nottingham Forest for £35m.

“We had no other option,” their head coach Eddie Howe told reporters in October about those two departures. “We couldn’t breach PSR, couldn’t face a points deduction, and the only two deals we had on the table at that time were the two deals we did.”

Newcastle, who had spent £320million in the first two and a half years under their Saudi Arabian owners, did not want to sell either Minteh or Anderson. Nor, you suspect, did they want to pay Forest £20m for Odysseas Vlachodimos, a third-choice goalkeeper yet to feature for them in the Premier League under Howe. Anderson’s sale, though, was reliant on Forest, who had breached PSR last season and were close to the line again, getting something in return, so Newcastle had nowhere to turn.


Newcastle did not want to lose Minteh to Brighton (Mike Hewitt/Getty Images)

Others were at it, too, with Aston Villa, Everton, Chelsea and Leicester City all concocting their own mutually beneficial deals to chase compliance. Close to £200million, most of it “pure profit”, was collectively banked by those six clubs in June’s final weeks and Tuesday brought confirmation that the trading had been worth it.

A 14-day assessment period of 2023-24 accounts and PSR calculations had not raised red flags within the Premier League and, unlike last January, when Everton and Forest were both charged, there was no cause for disciplinary action to be triggered.

Leicester’s case remains more complex than others, with the Premier League still believing they are on the hook for at least one charge amid the legal challenges back and forth, but 2024, the year of the asterisk, has left its mark.

The three PSR charges heard last season — two for Everton and one for Forest — resulted in a combined 12 points being deducted, the kind of shock therapy that was difficult to ignore.

It may never be known just how close Newcastle and others came to going beyond their spending threshold last season. Clubs’ 2023-24 accounts, which are due to be filed by the end of March, will give us clues, but the absence of transparency in the PSR process makes it difficult to offer fully informed analysis.

Clubs instead have to be judged by their actions and those madcap days of late June revealed anxieties ultimately born out of the penalties handed to Everton and Forest a few months earlier. That jolted the whole of the Premier League, heightening motivation to find quick profits in the transfer market once the season had concluded.

Howe admitted as much — Newcastle had no wish to sell Minteh or Anderson. Certainly not both. But, as Howe, the front-facing figure in that organisation, accepts, there was “no other option” but to accept £65million in transfer fees for the duo if a PSR breach was to be avoided.

Were Chelsea as close to the edge? That is unclear but their compliance owed as much to the sale of two hotels which are part of the wider site at their Stamford Bridge stadium to other companies owned by BlueCo, Chelsea’s parent company, as it did the late sale of defender Ian Maatsen to Villa for £37.5million. Others did not have the luxury of property deals enhancing the numbers.


Maatsen’s transfer to Villa helped Chelsea comply with PSR, but not as much as the sale of two hotels (Matt McNulty/Getty Images)

PSR continues to have its vocal opponents, such as Villa co-owner Nassef Sawiris, who told the Financial Times in June that the regulations were inhibitive and “not good for football”, but last season served the warning that overspending would still carry a sporting cost. Everton and Forest became the bad boys nobody wanted to emulate.

That was obvious with the sudden business done in June, and the wariness has been extended into this season.

Manchester United, traditionally one of English football’s strongest financial forces, have made it clear they have little scope to strengthen new head coach Ruben Amorim’s hand after their heavy losses of recent times. Newcastle also remain bound by financial constraints, with only about £60million spent this season. Villa’s net spend for the season, meanwhile, stood at about £26million going into the current winter transfer window.

Those three clubs could have spent more but learnt last season that punishments would then be unavoidable down the road.

It would not be fitting to congratulate the Premier League on strong governance when 115 charges of financial wrongdoing still hang over four-in-a-row title winners Manchester City and Leicester’s case remains unresolved, but last season served notice that rules had to be adhered to. Points deductions would be in the post to any club not complying.

“The Premier League submits that the only proper sanction is a sporting sanction in the form of a deduction of points,” it argued in Everton’s first PSR hearing, which brought an initial 10-point penalty, later cut to six on appeal. That exact sentence was repeated when Forest faced an independent commission.

PSR has its inconsistencies and imperfections, and might well lead to more scrambled, incoherent transfer business before financial years are out at the end of every June.

But the past 12 months — and no fresh charges this week — have made it clear to clubs that it is a sanction to be taken seriously.

(Top photos: Getty Images)

Will Ichiro Suzuki be the baseball Hall of Fame’s second unanimous selection?

Could Ichiro Suzuki become the second-ever player unanimously voted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum? Will Billy Wagner pick up the five votes he missed last year to gain entry in his final year of eligibility? Will CC Sabathia make it to Cooperstown on his first try?

Heading into the Jan. 21 announcement of the Hall of Fame voting results, all three scenarios are on the table.

The voting is conducted by the nearly 400 eligible voting members of the Baseball Writers Association of America; all of the 151 ballots logged on Ryan Thibodaux’s Baseball Hall of Fame tracker as of Tuesday afternoon have the box next to Suzuki’s name checked.

To this point, only famed Yankee closer Mariano Rivera has been elected to the Hall of Fame unanimously — not Babe Ruth, not Hank Aaron, not Ken Griffey Jr. nor Derek Jeter, just Rivera. Could Suzuki be the second?

Thibodaux said he doesn’t expect an answer to that until after the results are official.

“We haven’t seen him left off of any ballots yet and my guess is we won’t see one up until the results are announced,” Thibodaux said in a direct message on Bluesky earlier this week. “If anyone left him off, we likely won’t find out until after, if at all.”

Jeter was left off one ballot in 2020 and Griffey three in 2016.

Voters are not required to make their ballots public, but the Hall of Fame does allow voters to check a box on the ballot to release their selections following the announcement of the voting. Last year, a total of 385 ballots were returned, with 306 voters choosing to make their ballot public. Neither the voter who passed over Jeter in 2020 nor the three who left Griffey off their ballots in 2016 have been revealed.

Suzuki is not the only candidate trending towards induction. Sabathia is on 140, or 92.7 percent, which bodes well for the first-year nominee.

“I’ll admit to being a bit surprised at the strength of CC’s support so far. I had him eyeballed as perhaps a 75 percent bubble candidate, but he’s breezed along so far and has comfortably been in the low 90s for most of ballot season,” Thibodaux wrote. “Unless the late public and private voters have a wildly different evaluation of Sabathia’s credentials, it looks like he’ll be a first-ballot Hall of Famer.”

FanGraphs’s Jay Jaffe, author of “The Cooperstown Casebook,” said he’s been surprised by Sabathia’s showing in his first year on the ballot.

“I thought he was going to be somebody who would squeak in like (Joe) Mauer did last year,” said Jaffe, who created the Jaffe War Score system (JAWS) that is commonly referenced by Hall of Fame voters to help put candidates into historical perspective. “I don’t expect him to stay at 92 percent or even 90 percent, but I think something upwards of 80 percent is very likely.”

Wagner is on the ballot for the 10th and final time. After just missing the 75 percent mark a year ago, he’s trending steadily toward induction. As of Tuesday afternoon, he was at 84.1 percent on the public ballots.

It’s not just the raw numbers that are in Wagner’s favor; the trends are behind him, as well. After just missing out, he’s been added to eight ballots that didn’t include him last year and of the 141 public votes submitted, none who checked his name last year haven’t selected him this year. Another eight first-time voters have voted for Wagner, as well.

“There are still more first-time voters out there and he’ll need to maintain solid support from that group,” Thibodaux wrote. “There are also likely several dozen voters who aged out of the electorate this year. If he happened to have extremely strong support among them, then there still may be work to do to get him over the finish line.”

Carlos Beltrán was at 79.5 percent of the vote as of Tuesday afternoon and Andruw Jones was just below the threshold at 74.2 percent. According to Thibodaux, last year those who made their ballots public before the announcement averaged 7.55 votes per ballot. Voters who waited until after the announcement averaged 6.77 votes per ballot and private ballots averaged 5.8 names. Thibodaux, who began tracking balloting in 2012, said those trends have been steady through the years.

The current voting totals are not encouraging for Beltrán or Jones in relation to their 2025 hopes, but it is a positive for eventual induction. Next year’s first-year eligible class doesn’t have any players who have a career bWAR of 60 or more, such as Suzuki (60) and Sabathia (62.3). The top first-year players on next year’s ballot are Cole Hamels (59 bWAR) and Ryan Braun (47.1 bWAR).

Jaffe said the strength of Sabathia’s support bodes well for the future of not just Sabathia, but also Andy Pettitte, Félix Hernández, Mark Buehrle and Hamels.

“Andy Pettitte and Félix Hernández are almost diametrically opposed in terms of how they’ve gotten to this point, Pettitte with a very workmanlike career and a huge volume of postseason work that was very important in helping teams get to and win the World Series,” Jaffe said. “Félix had a very high peak and a lack of longevity, early burnout and no postseason experience.”

Pettitte, on the ballot for the seventh time, was at 31.8 percent as of Tuesday afternoon. Last year, Pettitte received 52 (13.5 percent) votes and this year he is already marked on 48 ballots, indicating a significant jump. Hernández, in his first year on the ballot, was on 25.2 percent of the votes revealed by Tuesday afternoon.

While the focus on voting is always on the 75 percent line needed for induction, the other marker to watch is the 5 percent needed to stay on the ballot.

Of the 14 names on the ballot for the first time, seven had not received a public vote as of Tuesday morning. Of the remaining seven first-year eligible players, only Suzuki, Sabathia, Hernández and Dustin Pedroia (12.6 percent) have received the necessary five percent to stay on the ballot.

That means 10 players are in danger of falling off the ballot, including a pair of catchers in Russell Martin (4.6 percent) and Brian McCann (4 percent) who would fall off the ballot after just their first year. Also facing the possibility of not receiving 5 percent are Torii Hunter (1.3 percent), who is on the ballot for the fifth time, and Francisco Rodríguez (7.9 percent), who is on the ballot for the third year. Mark Buehrle, on his fifth ballot, has 19 votes as of Tuesday morning, which will be enough to keep him on the ballot another year as long as no more than 380 ballots are returned. One more vote for Buehrle between Tuesday afternoon and next week’s announcement would guarantee the longtime Chicago White Sox starter a spot on next year’s ballot.

(Photo: Steph Chambers / Getty Images)

The Briefing: Arsenal’s worrying start to 2025, a fix for the FA Cup and Walker’s legacy

Welcome to The Briefing, where every Monday during this season The Athletic will discuss three of the biggest questions to arise from the weekend’s football.

This was the FA Cup weekend when Plymouth Argyle celebrated jettisoning Wayne Rooney by beating Brentford, Manchester City made short work of Salford City, Newcastle United were given a scare by Bromley and Tottenham Hotspur needed extra time to beat National League side Tamworth.

Here we will ask if their defeat by Manchester United is the start of something really bad for Arsenal, whether there is a better way to financially reward the giant-killers and where Kyle Walker ranks in the list of Premier League right-backs.


How bad is this going to get for Arsenal?

Things are really not going to plan for Arsenal in 2025.

Sure, it started quite nicely with a 3-1 win at Brentford, but since then they were meek in drawing with Brighton & Hove Albion, embarrassingly impotent in losing the first leg of the Carabao Cup semi-final 2-0 to Newcastle, and then there was the loss on penalties to Manchester United in the FA Cup third round on Sunday.

They can’t even blame referees for this one, having been on the good side of most contentious decisions. Maybe we should be praising Manchester United for their stout performance in holding out for an hour with 10 men after Diogo Dalot’s red card, but it’s hard to ignore that Arsenal seem to be in quite the funk at the moment.

Bukayo Saka is out for who knows how long, as is his replacement Ethan Nwaneri, Ben White is injured too and Gabriel Jesus — just after it looked like he was coming into some sort of goalscoring form — was taken off on a stretcher having injured his knee.

Maybe even more worrying than that is barely any of their fit players seem in form. Martin Odegaard is out of sorts, Gabriel Martinelli too, Mikel Merino hasn’t really got started and we won’t dwell too much on Kai Havertz’s afternoon against United, for fear of kicking a man while he’s down.

The positive spin is that they have created plenty of chances in the past couple of games: 49 shots over 210 minutes for an xG of around 6.44. The negative spin is that it’s no good creating chances if you can’t take any of them.

After the game, manager Mikel Arteta conceded that, while his team dominated the ball and created plenty of chances, “There is an element that is about putting the ball in the back of the net”. Quite so.

Maybe the gloom is too much. They haven’t lost in the league since the start of November. If they beat Tottenham on Wednesday, they could be three points off the top of the table — should leaders Liverpool lose to Nottingham Forest the night before. They’re looking good for automatic qualification in the Champions League. Maybe it’s better not to be in the FA Cup, given the fixture issues it could create.

But the signs aren’t great at the moment. It’s happening in probably the worst possible month, too: the inadequacies of their summer transfer window and not recruiting a proper goalscorer are being laid bare, so the clamour to fix that and spend some money in this window will grow and grow. Alternatively, maybe it could be the best possible month because they could actually buy someone to fix the problem. But don’t hold your breath.

At the moment, it’s a relatively brief poor run. The fear is that it could turn into something much worse than that.


Does the structure of the FA Cup need to change?

When the 90 minutes were up, the instinct was to be delighted for Tamworth that they had held Tottenham to a 0-0 draw. An amazing result that would now be rewarded with a lucrative replay at the Premier League side’s stadium.

And then you remember that replays are no longer a thing in the FA Cup, and a Tamworth team that featured builders and clothes shop workers would have to play another 30 minutes against a team of elite professional athletes, bringing their chances of avoiding defeat down to near zero.


Tamworth had a chance to beat Tottenham with almost the last kick of the match before the game went to extra time (Cameron Smith – Danehouse/Getty Images)

It is worth pointing out we probably shouldn’t weep too much for Tamworth specifically, given that they benefitted from this exact structure in the second round, beating Burton Albion after extra time and penalties. But this is illustrative of a wider point.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

In search of magic in the FA Cup third round

It feels less than ideal that replays have been eliminated in the name of easing workload, when Spurs went on both post and pre-season tours (to Australia, and Japan and South Korea respectively) in the summer.

Football finance expert Kieran Maguire estimated that a replay would have been worth £850,000 ($1million) to Tamworth, a club that has only recently been able to make their manager a full-time employee. Money that could be the lifeblood of a grassroots team has been sacrificed so the richest can top up their giant piles of cash with another few spoonfuls.

But it’s not quite that simple. First, the decision has been made and it’s not likely to be changed, so railing against it falls into the ‘old man shouts at cloud’ category. Second, fixture congestion is a genuine problem, and replays have gone in part because of the expansion of European competitions, which you can’t really blame the Football Association for. Third, extra time and penalties are often entertaining, as Arsenal vs Manchester United proved.

One way of fixing the problem is to change the structure of the FA Cup’s prize money. Tamworth will receive £25,000 for their third-round defeat, while their opponents pocket £115,000 for winning. Those amounts increase as the tournament progresses, so the team that wins the final in May gets £2m.

The winners do not need that amount of money. In the Premier League era, the FA Cup has been won by one of Manchester United, Manchester City, Arsenal, Chelsea or Liverpool on 28 out of 32 occasions. The last time a team from outside the top flight won it was in 1980. The prize money for the FA Cup is loose change for clubs that bring in north of £700m every year.

So why not spread the prize money out a little more evenly throughout the rounds. Even if you halved the amount for the winners, that’s an extra £1m into the pot for the minnows. Sure, it wouldn’t be £850,000, but it would be a more constructive use of the money.

Better yet, why not have some sort of reverse sliding scale, according to the status of the team that wins a game? Say, if you’re a Premier League team and you win a round you get £X, but if a Championship team wins the same game they get £X times two, down to a National League team who would get £X times five?

Sure, it’s not perfect and it would make budgeting tricky, but it would allow the big teams to get what they want — avoiding the indignity of having to play a much inferior team that they couldn’t beat for a second time — and distribute the money in football more usefully.

Modern football being the capitalist nightmare that it currently is, this will not happen. But it would be better for the game if it did.


Is Walker the Premier League’s greatest right-back?

If Kyle Walker has played his last game for Manchester City, it will represent a slightly odd exit for one of the key players in the most dominant team in Premier League history.

This isn’t the start of the break-up of the team that has won six of the past seven Premier League titles: Riyad Mahrez and Ilkay Gundogan left in 2023 (although a version of the latter has returned since), but Walker has been there since Pep Guardiola’s second season.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Kyle Walker, his request to leave Man City and what it means for player and club

His decline has been clear for a while and has been exposed on several occasions this season. Perhaps it would have been too much of an overhaul with Mahrez and Gundogan going that summer too but, in hindsight, it probably would have been better for all concerned if Walker’s mooted transfer to Bayern Munich had happened 18 months ago.

But that should not obscure what a sensational player he has been for City — and England — over most of the past eight years. He has undoubtedly been among the best right-backs the Premier League has ever seen, and you could make a decent argument that he’s the very best.

None of the other candidates — Gary Neville, Trent Alexander-Arnold, Paulo Ferreira, Cesar Azpilicueta, Pablo Zabaleta, insert your own choice here — had/have quite the same all-round skills, able to defend as effectively as they can attack.

While he has never quite had the tactical nous or technique to be the inverted full-back who moves into midfield, his pace and defensive skills meant he could cover for John Stones, or whoever Guardiola chose to fulfil that role. He could cover so much ground that in most games City could afford to play three at the back without losing a huge amount in defence: N’Golo Kante was frequently cited as effectively being two players in one for Leicester City and Chelsea in midfield, but Walker did a similar thing in defence.

Latterly, his uncertainty going forward has led to him looking like he has the yips when it comes to crossing, and losing a yard or two of pace has meant he has been burned rather embarrassingly more times than is comfortable. Timo Werner absolutely rinsing him in City’s 4-0 defeat by Tottenham earlier in the season springs to mind, but there are many other examples of how his tactical brain has not quite come to terms with his physical limitations.


Fulham’s Adama Traore sprinting past Walker earlier this season (Oli Scarff/AFP via Getty Images)

It does sometimes feel like people in England have not quite warmed to him: perhaps it is a corollary of playing for a broadly unpopular team; perhaps it is to do with his very public private life; perhaps people genuinely do not rate him. But we should not underestimate how good he has been.

It will be interesting to see how City adapt if Walker leaves, with AC Milan a possible destination. Prospective new signing Abdukodir Khusanov has been a centre-back to this point, but then again so was Josko Gvardiol. Does this mean Rico Lewis becomes a certain starter? Maybe Stones will be asked to fill in there. Perhaps Guardiola has some other tactical innovation up his sleeve.

But City will be saying goodbye to one of their defining players of this era. He will be missed.


Coming up

  • The lengthy FA Cup third-round weekend continues on Monday in Bermondsey, south London, with a prospective upset: Championship also-rans Millwall host National League also-rans Dagenham and Redbridge. It’s sort of a London derby — unless you’re a London purist and don’t think Dagenham counts.
  • Then there’s a bonus round of Premier League games, the highlight of which comes on Tuesday with what is, implausibly, a top-of-the-table clash between Nottingham Forest and Liverpool. Brentford host Manchester City, it’s Chelsea vs Bournemouth and West Ham United vs Fulham.
  • There’s another lively affair on Wednesday: the north London derby between Arsenal and Tottenham. Elsewhere, David Moyes takes charge of his second first game as Everton manager, as they face Aston Villa, while Leicester play Crystal Palace and it’s Newcastle vs Wolves.
  • And finally, on Thursday, Ipswich vs Brighton and Manchester United vs Southampton round off these midweek fixtures.
  • And throughout the week, the transfer window continues: will Manchester City sign Omar Marmoush and Khusanov? Will Manchester United find someone who’ll take Marcus Rashford? Will Walker get his move? Will Arsenal sign a forward? The Athletic’s transfer live blog will be up and running throughout the week with news and information from all of our club writers and, of course, David Ornstein.

(Top photos: Getty Images)

Nick Kyrgios and Alex de Minaur, the two poles of Aussie tennis at the Australian Open

MELBOURNE, Australia — Here on the island that was once the center of the men’s tennis world — the land of Laver and Rosewall, Emerson and Newcombe and other gods of the game — the strangest of dynamics has emerged.

The rest of the globe obsesses about Jannik Sinner and Carlos Alcaraz. Down here, it’s all about their own tennis yin and yang.

One is a top-10 player who will do whatever he can to avoid controversy, while dedicating every ounce of his energy to the sport. The other is an unranked unicorn, most at home in the middle ring of a three-ring circus. One has ground his way to the edge of the sport’s elite. The other, according to just about every other player and some big names of the past including Goran Ivanisevic and Andy Roddick, has more natural tennis gifts flowing through his veins than anyone on Earth.

The 2025 Australian Open is abuzz with the latest doings of both.

Alex de Minaur, the world No. 8, and Nick Kyrgios, who is back after a two-year battle with knee and wrist injuries, are the headliners for their country at Melbourne Park. Kyrgios emceed the night session on John Cain Arena Monday, before De Minaur headlines Rod Laver Arena, the pantheon of Australian tennis Tuesday night.

They are both celebrities of the moment; they could not be less alike.


Kyrgios has returned to the center of the tennis world as only he can, toting his confidence like a broadsword and swinging it in the direction of anyone he encounters, whether they want to duel or not. He doesn’t even have a ranking after so long out through injury.

Yet although he is at the bottom of the pecking order among his countrymen when it comes to numbers, there is no doubting who fills stadiums. He’s spent much of the past months trolling Sinner, the world No. 1, about his doping case, plastering lurid allegations about conspiracy on social media and filling comments sections with needle emojis. That included posting them in the comments of a fellow Aussie, and son of Lleyton Hewitt, Cruz, who put a photo up of him and Sinner which likely represented the best moment of his tennis life.

Sinner is none too pleased about this, if indirectly. “I don’t think I have to answer this,” he bristled when Kyrgios’ jabs came up in a news conference Friday.

For Kyrgios, wildly talented but always ambivalent about life as a tennis professional — and always willing to turn matches into spectacles with rants at umpires, officials and those seated in his own player box, and taunts towards opponents — it was business as usual.

He has sought more nuance in other areas of his life. In early 2023, Kyrgios pleaded guilty to assaulting his then girlfriend Chiara Passari in 2021, but was not convicted. He has been open about living through depression, and has said that his mental health contributed to his behavior.

“We watch sport because we want personalities,” Kyrgios said Friday. “Every time I step out on court, I don’t know if I’m going to be super-controversial in a good or bad way. Throughout my career, it hasn’t always been good, but it’s added a lot of excitement to the game. I think it’s important.

“There’s so many good players on the tour now. I think there’s not so many contrasting personalities.”

How big a star is Kyrgios around here? He lost his first-round singles match to Jacob Fearnley of Great Britain (like Andy Murray, a Scot) Monday night in straight sets. He was carrying an injury throughout, which made much of the action provisional — and for him, coming back from 18 months out, it may well have been a warm-up act.

He will want to pack stadiums for the doubles, which he will play with his close friend Thanasi Kokkinakis. The duo — known as the “Special Ks” — won the title here in 2022, a run that played to raucous, beered-up crowds that turned the doubles competition into a national happening.

In his post-match news conference after being beaten by Fearnley, Kyrgios made a stronger admission: “I don’t see myself playing singles here again.”


Nick Kyrgios drew the crowds at Melbourne Park (Graham Denholm / Getty Images)

His contrast with de Minaur could not be more stark. Kyrgios is 6 feet 4 inches (193cm) tall, a master of trick shots and creativity with one of the best serves in the world. De Minaur is a good half-foot shorter, and given how slight he is, he presents smaller than that.

Always envied for his unmatched speed, de Minaur spent the first post-pandemic years lurking in the world top 20. He carried the hopes of his country into a fourth-round match against Novak Djokovic here in 2023. Djokovic said he used the moment to take some revenge on Australia for deporting him the previous year, over his refusal to get vaccinated against Covid-19. He annihilated its favorite tennis son, 6-2, 6-1, 6-2.

Then, last May, de Minaur’s career arc veered upwards.

He is half-Spanish and spent much of his childhood there, but has never had much use for clay-court tennis events. He can run like a deer; he can switch directions like a scrambling puppy dog; he has a massive engine. He is ideally suited to the physical, intense game that the surface demands, and he has never relied on a big serve that a clay court might neutralize for his success.

He beat Daniil Medvedev — who hates clay — to make the 2024 French Open quarterfinals in a miasma of rain and cloud, screaming to his friends and coaches, “I love the clay. I love it here. I can’t get enough.”

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

‘English weather’ in Paris: How a rainy French Open changes everything on and off court

He got a slew of ‘I told you sos’ from those coaches. Then he made the quarterfinals of both Wimbledon and the U.S. Open, forced out of the former by a cruel stroke of bad luck when he got injured at the end of his fourth-round win. Balky hip and all, he battled his way into the year-end finals, entering the elite company of the top eight.

He was already a massive star in Australia. Beyond his homeland, he was best known as a star boyfriend, the guy who caught the next flight out of Acapulco, Mexico after winning the ATP event there last March to see his partner, English top-30 WTA player Katie Boulter, play her own final the next night in San Diego, California. The effort set the bar for all boyfriends, sports and otherwise, and crossed over from sports coverage into the television morning shows. He proposed to Boulter during the off-season. She said yes.

At the French Open last May, on a walk through the corridors underneath Court Philippe Chatrier at Roland Garros, he explained that he wanted to evolve from a grinder into someone with the extra oomph to hit the ball through the court occasionally. Maybe even get some easy points on serve. He was too easy to push around.

“I would get exposed and kind of bullied a little bit,” he said.


Alex de Minaur has risen to the top eight in the world in the past 12 months (Sean M. Haffey / Getty Images)

When de Minaur arrived on the ATP Tour six years ago, he was a little more than 150 pounds (68kg) dripping wet. He’s now up to about 167lb after some gym work, and during the past year, his weight and strength hit a tipping point. Finally, he could push the best players in the world back onto their heels with a combination of newfound power and more revs on his groundstrokes.

“It’s always been about getting stronger, putting a little bit more weight on me,” he said. “My weight of ball is also a little bit bigger and ultimately that’s what I needed to compete against the top players in the world.”

He couldn’t win a match at those end-of-year finals. Still, he believed he had arrived.

“I’ve crossed a big barrier in my career, and now it’s about making use of my position,” de Minaur said.


Kyrgios doesn’t disagree. In his news conference Friday, he recalled the first time he hit with de Minaur, when the latter was a teenager tagging along to a Davis Cup tie as a training partner. Kyrgios decided to play some balls with him late one day. He brought a beer to the court, thinking it wouldn’t be too serious.

“I was like, ‘I’ll go out there and teach this little kid a lesson’. (But) It was a really close set. I was in my prime. He was only 17,” he said. “To see how well he’s taken it upon himself to be our No. 1 player for the last three, four years — he’s grown.

“ I was there. I didn’t always deal with it the best.”

No, he did not. Can he do it now? Can he again be the player that reached a Wimbledon final?

Kyrgios will never approach a match with much humility. He has said his sport requires a certain amount of delusion.

“If I’m playing my style of tennis, my unpredictability, I have a chance against anyone. That’s the mindset you need to have,” he said Friday. “If I walked out on the court for the first time against Nadal, Djokovic, Federer, and was realistic, I probably wouldn’t have won. A kid from Canberra going out there, and beating them… You can’t be realistic. You have to think, ‘I’m the best tennis player in the world.’ Is that realistic? Probably not. But I think that when I’m out there.”

Here lies perhaps the lone similarity between the two, even if de Minaur expresses the sentiment somewhat differently. He has said that with passing each Australian Open, he’s arrived as a better version of himself. He’s learned plenty. Winning has bred confidence.

“If it was strictly based on rankings, it would be quite a boring sport, but anything can happen at this stage,” he said. “We’ve seen opportunities arise, lots of doors opening up.

“There’s always a chance. Every time you step out for a tournament, you always got to think that there’s a chance.”

(Top photos: Getty Images; design: Will Tullos)

Milk and murder: The tragedy that overshadows Liverpool vs Accrington Stanley

Belmont Drive runs parallel to Rocky Lane, a noisy thoroughfare in Liverpool that blurs into West Derby Road, connecting the city centre with Anfield and its famous football stadium.

Here, the peeling grandeur of brooding Victorian homes stand incongruously against steel-shuttered shops and their grilles, reflecting the different stages of Liverpool’s past as well as its present.

This was once a highly desirable area, where rich sea merchants bought mansions on Judges Drive. Now, it is synonymous with the red light district of Sheil Road and an abandoned orphanage — supposedly haunted — on the other side of Newsham Park.

Something else is notable about Belmont Drive. It is the location of a block of six flats, one of which was the scene of a murder that linked Liverpool and Accrington Stanley Football Clubs, a television milk advert and Merseyside’s violent drugs scene.

The killing occurred on July 27, 2022. According to the Crown Prosecution Service’s (CPS) account of the incident, the flat’s tenant, Mark Kelly, had left the property to top up the electricity meter. When he returned, he found Learoy Venner — who was living with Kelly temporarily — lying on his back on a camper bed in the lounge. He had suffered a brain injury so severe that the trauma was compared in a post-mortem examination to one akin to a victim of a car crash.

Venner, 53, had sustained his injuries after being punched and kicked in a frenzied attack by Kevin Spaine, a 43-year-old homeless man who was a frequent visitor to Kelly’s property as he bedhopped between flats. All three men were, according to the CPS, drug dependent. In February 2023, Spaine received a life sentence for the killing at Liverpool Crown Court and must serve a minimum of 18 years before he can be considered for release.

The incident would have been noted as shocking but, sadly, not all that unusual in a city that has grappled with drug-related crime for decades. The twist, however, emerged only during Spaine’s sentencing when it was revealed that he was one of the stars of arguably the most famous football-themed advert in British television history.

In 1989, Spaine, then aged eight or nine, had featured in a commercial for the United Kingdom’s Milk Marketing Board. In it, another young boy, dressed in a Liverpool shirt, pours himself a glass of milk after coming in from a game of football. When Spaine reacts in disgust, the boy tells him that Ian Rush — then Liverpool’s star striker — drinks it and that if he didn’t follow his example, he wouldn’t even be good enough to play for Accrington Stanley, then a non-League club.

“Accrington Stanley, who are they?” Spaine asks.

“Exactly,” replies his friend, which prompts a scrap between the two boys over the remaining milk in the glass.

It became one of English football’s most quoted exchanges, endlessly mimicked in playgrounds and pubs the length of the country, yet nobody knew Spaine had featured in it. Despite being a serial criminal offender across nearly 25 years, Spaine’s connection to the advert was never made because when local media in Liverpool had written about it, his surname had been incorrectly reported as Staine.

This weekend, in an FA Cup third-round tie at Anfield, Liverpool face Accrington, now in League Two (the fourth tier of English football), for only the second time. Ordinarily, it would be a tie suffused with romance, the epitome of a cup underdog having its day out at one of the sport’s aristocrats.

Instead, the vicious events that played out in a drug den less than two miles from Anfield on a summer’s afternoon in 2022 offer the grimmest of sub-plots.


You only get fleeting glimpses of Spaine in the milk advert: once when he enters with his friend and again towards the end when they pretend to fight over the glass. On neither occasion can you see his face.

The other boy in the advert was also born on Merseyside, although Carl Rice had already moved to Widnes in nearby Cheshire by the time he travelled to Shepperton Studios in Surrey in 1989, aged eight, where he met Spaine for the first time.

Both children were shot from different angles to try to help them relax and, when the advert was released, Rice did not know that only his face was going to be shown.

During a 2013 interview with the Liverpool Echo, Rice revealed he was paid just £90 ($110.80 at current rates) for his role, joking: “I think my dad spent it on Skol (lager)!” He recalled how eight children from the Merseyside area had been selected to travel to London, with Spaine and Rice making the final cut.

Rice compared the set to being “like a load of kids on their holidays”, but the experience had a huge bearing on his life, even if he never received royalties for it. It set him on a path to a successful acting and writing career, which included stints in famous British soap operas such as Coronation Street and Brookside, the comedy-drama Brassic, and more recently a minor role in the Disney film Cruella alongside Emma Stone.

In 2016, he even reprised his milk role in an advert for Black Cow, a UK-based vodka producer, that parodied the original, although the commercial was subsequently banned by the UK’s Advertising Standards Authority for potentially encouraging excessive drinking.

Rice has embraced the advert’s legacy. He attended Accrington’s FA Cup second-round win over Swindon in December, making a short film with Mitre, the competition’s ball manufacturers, in the process.

There are many reasons why the original advert became such a cultural touchstone in Britain. In 2013, Rice concluded it was because of his “broad Scouse accent, it was ludicrously strong and high-pitched”. The timing of its release also played its part: any link to Merseyside was always going to gain attention, especially in the 1980s, when Liverpool and Everton had dominated English football, sharing all but two of the league titles won that decade.

The city, too, was never far from the headlines. There had been race riots in the suburb of Toxteth in 1981, while the city’s far-left council had been taken to court by the government for passing an illegal budget four years later.


Toxteth burns during the 1981 riots (Keystone/Hulton Archive/Getty Images)

Liverpool was, in short, a city that generated strong opinions and the advert was effectively sending a powerful message: even Scouse urchins drink milk.

In 2006, Rice suggested Tottenham Hotspur was in the original script, only for the club to object, although quite why Accrington was chosen remains unclear. Perhaps it simply served as shorthand for a club which was as far removed from the elite as possible: Accrington were in the Northern Premier League Division One in 1989, English football’s eighth tier. It was another 17 years before they re-entered the Football League.

In 2012, former England cricketer and commentator David Lloyd, a non-executive director at Accrington, claimed the advert, which was still appearing on television screens six years after its release, helped boost the club’s profile, as well as providing a £10,000 cash injection. With Accrington on the verge of promotion to the Football League in 2006, its managing director, Robert Heyes, told the Manchester Evening News: “To this day it has brought us worldwide fame and thousands in merchandise sales to countries as far away as Australia, Canada and America.”


Accrington Stanley celebrate promotion to the Football League in 2006 (Gary M.Prior/Getty Images)

Yet next to nothing was known about Spaine, a Black boy from a family with deep connections to Liverpool’s music scene as far back as the 1970s.

When he appeared in court for the murder of Venner, it was suggested he was originally cast thanks in part due to his football talent. His defence lawyer, John Harrison KC, described him as “a very promising young footballer” but acknowledged that he had “a very long history of criminal offending”.

In his sentencing, covered in forensic detail at the time by the Liverpool Echo, it was revealed that Spaine had made around 40 court appearances for close to 100 offences over more than 20 years, with offences ranging from dealing and possession with intent to supply heroin and crack cocaine, assault, affray, wounding, threatening behaviour, theft and racially aggravated harassment.

Only three months before Venner’s murder, Spaine walked free from court having been handed an eight-week suspended prison sentence for assaulting an emergency worker before he was arrested again for another assault on an emergency worker. During his sentencing for Venner’s killing, prosecuting KC Alan Kent told the court that Spaine’s record pointed “to a man who is short-tempered, who starts fights and reacts in a violent manner”.


Belmont Drive is not exactly secluded.

The flat where Venner was killed is just a few hundred yards from Tuebrook police station, but it also sits by a busy road where the dull roar of car engines rarely subsides. If someone was fighting for their life inside one of the properties, it would be difficult to hear them.

According to the CPS, by July 27, 2022, Spaine was homeless and wanted to access the flat on Belmont Drive. Yet when he rang the doorbell, Venner ignored it, messaging Kelly, telling him that he didn’t want Spaine coming in.


The block of flats in Belmont Drive where the 2022 murder took place (Simon Hughes/The Athletic; house numbers blurred)

When Kelly returned to the flat, Spaine was still hanging around outside. Though he convinced Kelly that he needed a shower, the electric was out and Kelly left to get a top-up. Spaine followed him out soon after, but when he bumped into Kelly, he told him that Venner had left the property as well. Instead, Kelly would find Venner badly beaten. Though paramedics worked on him for longer than an hour, he later died in hospital.

Kelly was initially arrested, but it quickly became clear he was not responsible for the murder. Spaine was banned from his mother’s home under bail conditions following a row, but he went there regardless, telling her he wanted to get changed. She refused to let him in but passed him an outfit. Venner’s blood was later found on Spaine’s discarded clothing.

He denied murder but admitted manslaughter. In court, as reported by the Echo, he claimed he was in a “scatty situation” after a decade of crack cocaine abuse and that “things went t**s up” when he battered Venner to death.

Spaine also denied an intent to rob Venner on the day he received his benefits for drug money — insisting he would have sooner “run out of the Asda (supermarket) with a bag of steak” — and had instead retaliated after punches were thrown at him, as Venner supposedly tried to usher him from the property. After responding to “two swings”, Spaine responded with a flurry of punches and kicks before stopping when “he was no longer a threat”.

“We had chaotic lives, our lives were a mess,” Spaine continued. “I wasn’t thinking straight, Learoy weren’t — we were in a bad place. It all happened so fast. I hadn’t slept for days, I hadn’t eaten for days. How can you expect me to know what I was doing? I wasn’t in control.”

In sentencing, Judge Brian Cummings KC was sure that Spaine wanted to access the flat to try to access drugs or money but concluded this was not “a murder for gain”, accepting that an “eruption of violence occurred spontaneously”, Spaine having become agitated as he waited impatiently outside.


Spaine’s first significant encounter with the law came in 2001 when, aged 22, he was arrested as part of Operation Camelia — a major drugs investigation by Merseyside Police.

He was arrested an hour’s walk south of Belmont Drive in Upper Parliament Street, the road where he was living and one which dissects the Liverpool 8 area of Toxteth, the name a nod to its postcode. On one side there is the Georgian quarter —  home to some restored as well as faded townhouses — and on the other, the streets housing the city’s Black community.

“Parli”, as it is known locally, was the scene of the infamous riots of 1981, which took place when Spaine was just a baby. Those involved in the violence prefer to call it an uprising, an en-masse response to the treatment of a police force regularly accused of institutional racism.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Liverpool, L8 and the city’s complicated history with Black footballers

For a few years after the uprising, L8 became a frontline for disregarded youngsters. A freedom hung in the air, cafes played loud music and groups would stand outside shops eating food. The summers always seemed to be hot and streets like Granby thronged.

Dealers sold drugs, cannabis initially, before those with greater ambitions moved in and a heroin epidemic ripped through the city, with guns becoming a major problem in the 1990s, just as young men like Spaine and Venner were making their way in the world.

Full social consequences followed: addicts became sex workers and struggled with the stigma for years afterwards; thefts and muggings increased, forcing an older generation to feel more cut off than they already were because they were afraid to go out, especially in the dark.

Though many of the dealers are now in jail for a long time and the mood in L8 is much calmer, it took discipline to resist the pernicious environment. As Jimi Jagne, the son of Gambian and Chinese parents, who emerged as a community leader after the events of 1981, says, “Anyone else who got caught up in the wash was a victim.”

Though Liverpool 8 has increasingly become defined by a large Asian community, hardened attitudes and suspicion of outsiders remain. It is one of the reasons it is difficult to tell the full story of Spaine and Venner, whose families have strong connections to L8. The Athletic contacted several people from the community who knew Spaine but did not want to speak.


Kevin Spaine’s mugshot when he was arrested in 2023 (Merseyside Police)

It is a fair assumption, however, that Spaine fell prey to the same issues that plagued L8 in the 1990s, a period when many locals felt like the authorities gave up on the district altogether and drug dealers, some of them who established international connections, took hold.

According to the Echo, Spaine described himself in court as being a “dependent crack addict”, saying, “I was in a mad state — erratic, paranoid, fidgeting. My mind was ticking overtime. I was dealing with a lot of things. If me and Learoy weren’t on drugs, this wouldn’t have happened.”

In mitigation, Harrison argued that his client was “ruined and dominated by the abuse of illegal drugs”, subsequently leading to his long history of criminal offending. “It’s not an unfamiliar spiral to the court, but it is a tragic one,” he suggested.

Spaine looked a much older man than he actually was when, in his mid-30s, he posted a picture of himself on Facebook in 2016 wearing tatty Liverpool training gear. By that point in his life, Venner also had a major drug problem, to the extent that for a long time before his death, he was a virtual recluse.

When Spaine appeared in the milk advert, his voice had sounded full of youthful enthusiasm and innocence. What happened after is a bleak, sad story, far removed from the feel-good atmosphere that will envelope Anfield tomorrow as Accrington attempt to pull off one of the greatest shocks in the FA Cup’s long history.

The commercial will surely get an airing in the television broadcasters’ pre-match packages and Rush has acknowledged its legacy by inviting Rice to meet him before kick-off at tomorrow’s match.

If his life had taken a different course, Spaine would probably have been joining him at Anfield, sharing his memories and maybe even recreating that famous exchange with Rice for the television cameras.

Instead, he is facing years to reflect on a life of terrible decisions that sucked him away in a destructive vortex of drugs and violence that has claimed so many like him.

(Top photos: Merseyside Police, Milk Marketing Board, Getty Images; design: Eamonn Dalton)

Pacers’ Tyrese Haliburton heard the haters, and now he and Indiana are clapping back

The trolls finally got one, but not for long.

NBA social media has become a cesspool of negativity, where fans come together to commiserate about why this player is overrated and that team is garbage. Today’s athletes are so inundated with criticism from the anonymous morass that most of them have learned to push it away.

Even when it affects them, they rarely admit it publicly. Bullies only get their power from the acknowledgment. But everybody has their moments.

For the first month of this season, as his Indiana Pacers were losing and he was playing his worst basketball in years, that was Tyrese Haliburton. To the outside world, it looked like his dominant form from 2023 may have been a mirage. Internally, Haliburton started to wonder if they were right.

“I got too caught up in outside noise and allowing myself to think such negative thoughts about myself internally,” Haliburton shared with The Athletic recently. “It was the first time in my life that I had real self-doubt behind everything I was doing. … I feel like my personal struggles were leading to the team’s struggles.

“A lot of our games early, that we were right there to win, I just wasn’t playing my best basketball and I think that was taking away from us winning games.”

Last season, the Pacers marched on to the Eastern Conference finals, even if Haliburton’s form fell off after a midseason hamstring injury. They entered this campaign with hopes of taking the next step, but things went south early on as their star player still looked like a shell of himself.

When Haliburton was in a funk in the past, he would pull out his phone and seek the trolls trashing him. He often would do it during halftime, looking for fuel to power the Pacers’ redlining offense. Proving haters wrong was the cathartic release he needed to get in touch with himself and his game.

The problem was — from the moment this season started — he knew better than anyone that he couldn’t clap back. He went scoreless in the second game of the season, a blowout loss to the New York Knicks at Madison Square Garden, and knew something wasn’t right.

Haliburton was telling confidants that he was playing poorly, reading his mentions and actually agreeing for a change. That’s when his skills trainer Drew Hanlen could see the pressure was getting to the 24-year-old.

“This year, for whatever reason, it was just hurting him,” Hanlen said.

The more he struggled, the more he receded into old habits. Haliburton lost his aggression to attack the paint, unable to beat defenders with a first step off of that recovering hamstring.

He looked tentative, trying to sit back as a distributor and losing some of the edge that made him a two-time All-Star. The problem was twofold, starting with his health.

“He rushed back early last year to make the All-NBA 65-game rule and he was never fully healthy,” Hanlen said. “Then at the Olympics, he re-aggravated it. So after the Olympics, he couldn’t work out and had to let it heal. So he worked out zero times the entire summer.”

The breaking point came in Charlotte on Nov. 8, a 20-point loss that sent the team spiraling below .500. He once again missed every 3, couldn’t get to the line and fully accepted he was the problem.

“It was so bad,” Haliburton said. “That was the first time I was so frustrated with myself, so frustrated with the group. But it was more about myself. How can I be better?”


Pacers guard Tyrese Haliburton hit rock bottom in a loss at Charlotte on Nov. 8. (Robert Goddin / Imagn Images)

It started with cutting out the distractions and sources of anxiety. He deleted X from his phone in an attempt to go cold turkey on immersive doomscrolling. He started going back to church, recognizing he was getting caught up within himself and wanting to look at the positives in life.

“That’s been good for me to read my Bible more. It’s been good for me,” he said. “My relationship with the Lord has been really big for me internally, to be the best version of myself and just trying to pour energy into our group and that’s been helping us.

“After that, things have clicked and changed for me. I feel light years better.”

Haliburton was not the same player entering the season, but the Pacers changed as well. Andrew Nembhard showed in the postseason he could be the two-way guard the team needed, while Bennedict Mathurin’s return from a torn labrum added another scorer to the mix.

This roster did not call for Haliburton to dominate the ball like he did in the past, especially with his quickness in the half court diminished. To figure out his future with the Pacers, he had to tap into his past.

When he was drafted by the Sacramento Kings in 2020, he had to squeeze his distinct skill set into a crowded backcourt. De’Aaron Fox was the star point guard and Buddy Hield was the shooting guard, two traditional representations of the positions. Where did a fluid playmaker fit into the dynamic?

Hield taught him how to move in space to make himself open, even when the opposing coach wrote on the locker room whiteboard with a cascade of underlines to not let that happen. Though Haliburton said he initially couldn’t stand the way Hield played, they eventually found a synergy playing off each other. When the two friends were traded to the Pacers together, coach Rick Carlisle put the ball in Haliburton’s hands full time and they started running the two-man actions they were developing in Sacramento.

While the focus on Haliburton’s struggles in early 2024 focused on his hamstring injury, it coincided with Hield being traded to Philadelphia. But Nembhard’s emergence allowed Haliburton to operate as more of a two-guard, putting into practice the lessons he learned from Hield.

“Since Buddy’s been gone, I’ve learned to play off the ball a little bit more,” Haliburton said. “It’s been part of the growth figuring out how I can stay involved while off the ball, how I can use my gravity as a shooter. I just try to use my gravity to impact the game in other ways. I think that’s what I learned from Buddy, playing aside him for so long.”

Haliburton is not the typical point guard who can beat anyone off the bounce. He has a high dribble, is not overtly physical and doesn’t have a bag of go-to shots like most All-Star playmakers. He is someone who thrives in chaos, getting where he wants when he is up in transition or attacking against the grain of the defense.

Nembhard running point allows Haliburton to leak out in transition earlier, so he can then run around screens to catch the ball on the move. It also allows Haliburton to set up a cross-match early in a possession, like when he got Miami’s Haywood Highsmith off him before the play began so he could attack Tyler Herro in space.

Now Haliburton is finally starting to get downhill more consistently from give-and-go actions with Myles Turner by refining that combo guard role he first learned in Sacramento. In recent weeks, Turner and Haliburton have looked more in sync, as evidenced by Turner knowing where Haliburton was cutting even when getting the ball at an awkward spot on the floor.

“I think that Ty is finally starting to realize that he can get guys so much more open than just passing the ball,” Turner told The Athletic. “He talks to me, like, ‘Yo, go right here and do this and do this, and do that.’ And then lo and behold, I get the ball. So I think he’s starting to analyze the game a lot more, and then he picks and chooses his spots to start scoring.”

The true turning point came at the end of 2024. Haliburton had his worst performance since the first week of the season when they blew a fourth-quarter lead in Oklahoma City on Dec. 26 and then looked passive the next night in a blowout loss to the Boston Celtics.

But they stuck around Boston and he looked more aggressive than ever in a rematch two nights later, scoring 10 of his 11 baskets inside the arc to take the Celtics out in crunchtime. Sprinting over Turner screens while Nembhard handled the ball, getting to the rim suddenly seemed easy.

Haliburton recorded 33 points and 15 assists with six 3s and no turnovers at Miami last week. The only other time that has happened in NBA history was on Nov. 14, 2023 — by Tyrese Haliburton.

With Nembhard back in the lineup, Haliburton finally looks free.

“Their importance to each other is evident,” Carlisle said. “They complement each other well. Andrew allows Ty to play off the ball and when Ty has the ball, Drew knows the game and knows how to play without the ball too.”

Indiana fell into a hole when Nembhard missed 12 straight games in November due to left knee tendinitis, but the Pacers have flipped their season around since his return in early December. He is the spirit of their defense and the glue to their offense. Multiple players on the team called him their X-factor to winning.

They enter Friday’s game versus Golden State at 10-3 since Dec. 13, ranking fourth in the league in net rating at plus-8.7 over that stretch, per Cleaning the Glass. Indiana (20-18) has gone from 11th to sixth place in the Eastern Conference entering Friday, and Haliburton is finally starting to look like the All-Star he was a season ago.

He’s averaging 20.4 points and 9.6 assists per game while shooting 40.2 percent from 3 during this time. Of the 25 lineups with at least 300 possessions played this season, the Pacers’ starting group with Nembhard has the league’s best defensive rating, per Cleaning the Glass.

They are finally coming together now that Haliburton has the backcourt partner he needs to free up his game, looking like an evolution of the team that nearly beat the Celtics four times in the conference finals but never sneaked away with a win.

As Carlisle made clear recently during a West Coast trip in late December, the Pacers welcome all those expectations that were earned from last season’s run.

“We’re trying to win a championship,” he reminded a room full of reporters.

His presence alone is proof positive of their mission, as the coach who won it all with Dallas in 2011 came to Indiana a decade later with the expressed intent of turning this team into a legitimate title contender.

Their group moved closer toward that goal with the Pascal Siakam trade last season, landing the two-time All-Star forward who signed a four-year, $189.5 million extension in the summer. And when the Pacers stumbled early — due to a rash of injuries to nearly half of Indiana’s rotation — Carlisle wasn’t about to let any of the outside skepticism seep into his program. So he kept pushing.

“There’s nothing wrong with high expectations,” said the 65-year-old Carlisle, who is 11th all-time in wins among coaches. “What you don’t want is a situation of apathy, where expectations are low and all you’re ever doing is selling hope. That’s not why I came here, that’s not why (Pacers president of basketball operations) Kevin Pritchard is doing his job and that’s not what our ownership is about.”

Health remains an issue. Small forward Aaron Nesmith (left ankle) has been out since Nov. 1. There was the Nembhard injury. Second-year guard Ben Sheppard missed a month with an oblique and rib injury. Big men Isaiah Jackson and James Wiseman, who were slated to support Turner down low as key reserves, both suffered torn Achilles’ tendons within days of one another at the start of the season. The Pacers had to hit the transaction market earlier than expected to bring in Thomas Bryant as the new backup big.

The Pacers are over .500 now, but their identity is solidifying as the team gets closer to full health. The championship aspirations that seemed farfetched a few weeks ago are at least reasonable once again.

“It’s just not being satisfied. That was the message in training camp,” Turner said. “Obviously, we had a hell of a run last year, but let’s stop talking about last year. That’s over and done with. And yeah, we’re pushing toward a (NBA) Finals run. That’s really where all of our eyes should be in this locker room.”

The fans still flooding Haliburton’s mentions will probably laugh at that notion. He is still searching for consistency and will have to push through his latest mild ankle sprain to ensure he doesn’t fall back into old habits again. But he won’t have to face that music now unless he wants to.

“(Fans) can’t wait for a team to be doing bad so people can dunk on you on Twitter, you know what I mean? The s— is so stupid,” Haliburton said. “It’s just part of it. People want to see us not do well so they can talk s—.”

Now that Haliburton is in a better place, maybe he can crack his phone open, see a bunch of trash emojis and crack a smile. They can talk all they want, but he’s ready to clap back on his terms, one drive at a time.

(Top photo of Haliburton: Catalina Fragoso / NBAE via Getty Images)

Artificial intelligence could transform football. So what might the future look like?

“It’s totally feasible that an artificial intelligence (AI) agent could simulate more football in 24 hours than has ever been played professionally in the real world in the entire 150-year history of the game,” says Lee Mooney, who was head of data insights at City Football Group for six years.

“Think about how many games Pep Guardiola can possibly have played in, managed and watched. If you go back every generation which led to him being where he is now, through Johan Cruyff and Rinus Michels, that compound experience could potentially be simulated in just a few hours.

“All that problem-solving knowledge would be built perfectly into a single synthetic brain. It would make for fascinating potential for new tactics, training methods, ways of measuring performance, recognising human coaching skill and talent judgement.”

It may sound futuristic but football is already heading in that direction, the most well-publicised example being Liverpool teaming up with Google DeepMind to improve their corner-kick strategy using AI.

Mooney built an industry-leading department at Manchester City before founding MUD Analytics, which works with clubs in the Premier League, English Championship, Scottish Premiership and MLS. He is as well-versed as anyone in how new technology can be embedded in sport and transform age-old methods.

AI allows computers to learn and perform tasks and solve problems that usually require human intelligence. It is trained on huge amounts of information and simulates billions of variables, identifying and predicting future patterns.

As early as 1997, supercomputers were able to evaluate 200 million chess positions per second and defeat human grandmasters. In Formula 1, teams can spend a few days simulating millions of laps ahead of an upcoming Grand Prix, adjusting for the optimal race strategy.

Although there are still some steps to be made, the advancement in player tracking data means Mooney believes football could reach the point where clubs have trained AI to simulate matches against their upcoming opponents, modelling individual players based on their technical qualities and mechanics and producing 3D animations of how the real-life games might play out.

“You could set up to play Manchester City, train the AI agent to understand how they play and what their individual strengths and weaknesses are, and then play the game millions of times to find the most efficient strategies to beat them with the players you have,” says Mooney.

“We train airline pilots in simulators before flying, because we need to know it is safe. This sort of AI could give coaches their own safe playground to take risks and explore a much broader universe of tactics and solutions, before then risking their jobs. Animation can then show the most effective build-up structures to beat their press, how quickly to press, and what structure to recover back into. You’re training technology to understand the game in a virtual space to then inform real-world decisions.

“My instinct is you’ll end up with a powerful set of general principles which shows the best solutions to counteract their biggest threats. There is also the potential for it to recognise if players are waning in-game or if their decision-making is becoming compromised and so recommend a substitution live.”

The pace of change in technology may have been rapid and opened up the potential for these ambitious ideas to become realistic goals, but there is the caveat of realism when it comes to implementing them. “To execute it within a club setting requires stability of leadership vision and funding — two rare commodities in football,” says Mooney.

It may have felt like a vague, far-off world not too long ago, but the impact of AI is increasingly being felt in the workplace, and football is no exception. Many are unsure how it will manifest itself, but its use in recruitment, coaching, fitness and medical areas is going to accelerate rapidly, as it has in other sports.

The Athletic has spoken to leading figures in football across those areas to understand what AI could mean for the future of the sport, including:

  • 65 per cent of Premier League and Football League scouts surveyed by The Athletic believe AI is going to affect their role in the next five years
  • Clubs have started using large language models to cut out the need for people to read hundreds of scouting reports
  • The data analytics revolution was initially driven by a community outside football and there is a struggle to change the culture
  • Barcelona’s Barca Innovation Hub has invested in a science company, Omniscope, which is aiming to use AI to prevent injuries and extend the peak condition of players.

In November, Premier League side Brighton & Hove Albion, who leverage their owner/chairman Tony Bloom’s data tools for recruitment, dispensed with the majority of their full-time senior scouts.

The proliferation of data analytics in football over the past 15 years means there is not a Premier League club among the 20 now who do not use data as the first filter in their scouting operation.

But the new frontier is AI.

A recruitment source at one major English team, speaking on condition of anonymity to protect relationships, says that one of the main proponents of AI at his club recently remarked that scouts could start to be replaced by AI within the next two years.

A scouting data scientist, whose company works with various clubs across Europe, believes the holy grail will be when clubs no longer have to imagine how a potential signing would fit into their team. Instead, they will be able to use AI to translate all the data and video they have on the player’s style and the buying team’s tactics and use that to visualise just how they would perform in certain situations. “It’s not going to be liked, because there might come a time where it puts jobs at risk,” says a senior figure in a Premier League recruitment team. “It’ll be a cost-saving function in the future.”

Clubs already have huge libraries of scouting reports and performance and physical data, but it comes down to humans to interpret it all. AI can expedite that process by cutting out the need for someone to sit and read 100 different reports, instead rapidly picking out the players who best match the criteria the club’s models are looking for. “You could profile players from matches over a period of time and ask AI for the nearest version of a certain player,” says the Premier League recruitment figure.

GO DEEPER

The state of scouting: Data culture clash, job cuts and an uncertain future

It may not be sexy, but it is time-saving, which has made some scouts anxious that it could see their profession drastically culled.

“This suggestion that AI will get rid of scouts, I don’t get it at all,” says Mooney. “There are things models can’t see or they have wide confidence bands (a range of uncertainty in the estimate). How a player behaves under pressure, small-space ball manipulation, the timing of scans, the softness of their touch, their vision to see a pass: traits that are easy to see on video but hard, or slow, with data.

“There is going to be a delicate dance as these things evolve. For everything a machine can’t see now, there will be a branch of research closing that gap. It’s going to create a healthy tension between human and machine but also a real co-dependency — quality human input is essential for developing stronger and stronger analytical assets.

“I’ve used every experience I’ve had, working with some top forward-thinking coaches and football people, to make our technologies better, but through doing that I value the human side more. One challenge for people in the AI space is that a lot of those who are leading it can be too detached from the human side. They don’t see themselves as being vulnerable to advancements in technology.”

Mooney is already using AI and machine learning computer systems that are able to learn and adapt without following explicit instructions, by using algorithms and statistical models to analyse and draw inferences from patterns in data at MUD Analytics when it comes to financial budgeting and recruitment. He and his team have just built a model which sequenced 25 million player appearances, stretching back to the early 2000s, identifying patterns and traits that can predict the trajectory of potential signings.

The nature of the sport has already been changed by the insights data has delivered. Fewer players take shots from outside the box due to the low probability of them resulting in a goal, while teams generally keep possession and dribble less than they used to, with some fans lamenting that structured systems have reduced the presence of mavericks in the game.

“I’m reminded of the Jurassic Park line about the scientists being so preoccupied with whether they could, they didn’t stop to think whether they should,” Mooney says.

“Is this what sport is meant to be? It is my professional job to help teams win and get as much value from their money as possible, so I’m going to have to do it because if I don’t someone else will, and then you’re in an arms race where you’re bringing a knife to a gunfight.”


Ted Knutson, who founded leading data analytics company StatsBomb in 2013 before selling it to Hudl earlier this year, experienced the resistance to new technologies in football. 

The American was one of the early voices in the data analytics community and had groundbreaking success in his application of set-piece data while working for Midtjylland — controlled at the time by Premier League side Brentford’s owner Matthew Benham — as they scored 25 set-piece goals on their way to a first Danish league title in 2014-15.


Brentford owner Benham – left, with their head coach Thomas Frank – has been at the forefront of data innovation in football (Nick Potts/PA Images via Getty Images)

“I would go into clubs and show them how we improved other teams’ set-piece output but a coach would often say, ‘Yeah, that’s nice… so what?’,” says Knutson. “Football does not like change. We had to push really hard to change things on the event data (passing, shooting) side and using data in recruitment — it took 10 years for it to become really prevalent as the first filter in every Premier League club’s recruitment process.

“I see football teams where so much of what they need to do is just execute the basics, and they can’t do it. We’re asking: could we take really smart people and create sophisticated models like this? You could. Maybe in five years, you could do some of that but who is investing in that and pioneering it?”

StatsBomb’s work on pressing in football took the number of defensive events being measured from 30 per game to 300. Its work on expected goals, which took into account the positioning of all opposition players at the time of the shot, helped explain how Sean Dyche’s Burnley team had been seen as a statistical freak due to conceding a high volume of shots but few goals, when the reality was they smothered shots effectively. 

Knutson, who brought Paris Saint-Germain on board in StatsBomb’s first year, believes the single biggest point in terms of winning over traditional football minds was in quantifying skill sets for each position. By using data and converting the information into radars, which summarised a player’s effectiveness across a range of skills, coaches could better visualise it than hard numbers.

StatsBomb made another leap in 2021 when it launched its 360 product, with Liverpool its first users. This added the location of every team-mate and opposition player to the 3,400 events collected per match. StatsBomb then built on that breakthrough in NFL, tracking every player’s location on the field 30 times per second.

“NFL is harder, because there is much more occlusion (blocking). In football, players are separate and then occasionally at set pieces they run into each other,” Knutson says. “In football, that should get there in the next couple of years.”

Knutson is doubtful clubs will be the true pioneers in the AI space, given the time and resources required to make advancements, but also because the nature of professional sport means those teams who find an edge do everything they can to protect that intellectual property. It is why, at Brighton and Brentford, most scouts do not have visibility of the models working in the background at their owners’ data companies.

The rise of data analytics was organic and not restricted to early adopters inside football such as Liveprool’s former director of research Ian Graham. Amateurs were able to use publicly-available StatsBomb data sets and build upon the work that had been achieved so far. Many of those people now work in recruitment positions within professional football.

“The more challenging space for AI is tactically in training,” says Knutson. “A lot of the analysts don’t have a lot of coach in them, so there is always a credibility gap there.

“If some quantitative people got coaching badges, I think you’d see that change. In American sports, we are seeing statistical analysts become assistant coaches. We’ll probably see it gradually happen over here too. The other problem is the difficulty people who aren’t players find in getting coaching badges. It’s gatekeeping, and certainly holds back some of the coaching elements.”


When Albert Mundet helped launch the Barca Innovation Hub in 2017, the focus was tactical analysis.

Early strides were made in using data models to predict the positioning of individual opposition players and where gaps would appear, but he believes data needs to become more affordable before AI’s full capabilities can be unleashed in that area.

“Our original AI focus was on the tactical side, but we are betting a lot of our investments on injury prevention,” says Mundet, who is now general manager and reports into Barcelona’s club president Joan Laporta.

“The past 10 years, GPS has been at the core of performance monitoring, but we believe this is not enough. It is one piece of the whole cake. We believe the next wave is biomedical data, combining genomics data and other markers in the body. It exists in other industries, but football has not touched it. Mixing it with GPS could help improve the prevention of injuries, which are increasing because of the number of games but also because of how much more intense the games have become.”

Zone7 is a company already working in that area, as previously reported by The Athletic. It uses AI to assess physical data and determine the risk of a muscle injury. Liverpool, Napoli, Rangers and LAFC are among its clients.

Mundet believes Barca’s investment in Made of Genes, a start-up from the surrounding Catalonia region, as part of a €5million (£4.2m, $5.2m) funding round, has given them that forecasting ability too.

We are able to simulate the external load a player will experience at a specific moment in the future using a trained AI model based on historical data. Additionally, we can assess injury risk by combining this with genomic and metabolomic profiles through advanced AI models,” Mundet says. “We can help the coach make decisions on how to keep them healthy by reducing their exposure (in training and games). If we are going to be playing in quarter-finals, semi-finals and finals, we can help ensure the player arrives there with the optimal load and risk of injury”

Barca Innovation Hub’s latest investment could be the most profound yet in terms of its scale. It has invested in Omniscope, a techbio company founded by a disciplinary team in 2021, which is seeking to harness the advancements made in AI and immunology in the past few years to transform the diagnosis and treatment of illness. In sport, it believes it can translate into injury prevention and improved healing.

The human immune system can be difficult to understand given its complexity but Omniscope’s technology means that, via a blood sample, they are able to read millions of cells one-by-one — 100 times more than other technologies are capable of — to give the individual an inflammation score of between zero and 100. By using interpretative AI to identify gaps in the sequencing of the cells, it can diagnose early signs of disease, all while adhering to strict data privacy and ethical standards.

Essentially, it is building a foundational cell-by-cell model of the immune system with the aid of AI, which has never been done before. But the ability to heal quicker or, in the context of football, understand how to maintain healthy athletes, comes from generative AI.

Omniscope is driving the novel concept of piggy-banking healthy cells with the potential to reintroduce them to the body to fight diseases, or using AI to engineer therapeutic immune cells.

In football, Omniscope believes that if it can understand the immune system of a healthy athlete, it can use that knowledge to prevent injuries. It has already developed a specialised AI algorithm to comprehend the inflammation female players experience during their menstrual cycle and so can tailor care accordingly. 

“We’ve sequenced hundreds of samples and found that it works,” says Omniscope CEO and co-founder Vijay Vaswani, speaking to The Athletic. “We believe this technology has the potential to significantly enhance sports medicine and improve athlete health management.

“We collect blood samples during periods of optimal health to establish a baseline and integrate this data with wearable technology to monitor the player’s overall immune health status. Deviations from the baseline are often early signs of inflammation, illnesses and injuries. After injury and during recovery, we track, cell by cell, whether the healing process is working by looking at the immune response. For recurring injuries, I can again leverage comprehensive cellular data to power AI models which predict, monitor treatment effectiveness, and guide personalised future care.

“We can see processes of muscle scarring to complement an MRI. It gives the doctor and physiotherapist a magic window to reassess their strategy in real time. It’s the first time in athletic medicine that you’re not guessing on the return-to-play timeline.”

Using your own immune cells for therapy is approved by the FDA — a U.S. agency that protects public health by regulating the safety of food, drugs, medical devices and other products — but Vaswani says it has not been popularised yet due to high costs, lengthy processing times and requiring years of clinical complexity.

AI has helped speed up the process and made it significantly more affordable.

There is a potential from this that Vaswani believes could be revolutionary, significantly enhancing athletes’ longevity by maintaining their peak for longer.

“Athletes represent significant investments for clubs, and maintaining their career longevity is essential for maximising this investment,” he says. “Imagine if your favourite athlete continued to play many more years beyond traditional expectations. To be able to reintroduce your own biology in a non-artificial manner is unique. I think it will happen in the next five years, because AI learns and catalyses medicine. What we thought was far off is now within our grasp.”

The goal for Barca Innovation Hub in the coming years is to get to the point where it can start to use this convergence of immunology and generative AI to treat Barcelona’s first-team players.

“By integrating regenerative therapies within Barca’s cutting-edge sports medicine practices, we’re not only looking to accelerate recovery and extend playing years, but also to redefine the concept of peak performance,” Mundet says.

If it develops as they hope, the club’s young stars such as Lamine Yamal, Pau Cubarsi, Pedri and Gavi could stand to benefit.

(Top photos: Getty Images; design: Dan Goldfarb)

Could a small-market team be a surprise fit for Roki Sasaki? Parsing his agent’s words

At last month’s Winter Meetings in Dallas, agent Joel Wolfe held court in front of a large group of reporters and caused a stir when discussing his client, Japanese right-hander Roki Sasaki, who is expected to sign with a major-league team after the international signing period begins on Jan. 15.

Speculation about where Sasaki would ultimately land in MLB has simmered since his Nippon Professional Baseball debut in 2021, stoked by his stellar performance in the 2023 World Baseball Classic. The Dodgers are currently seen as a favorite, but it’s clear they’re not the only team in the hunt.

At the Winter Meetings, Wolfe said that Sasaki was looking for a team that has had success on the field and a history of developing pitchers. He also mentioned access to direct flights from his new city to Japan as a consideration. But perhaps most interestingly, he said that because of Sasaki’s personal experiences growing up in the spotlight in Japan, a small market team outside of the media glare might have a greater chance than some might think.

“I think that there’s an argument to be made that a smaller, mid-market team might be more beneficial for him as a soft landing coming from Japan, given what he’s been through and not having an enjoyable experience with the media,” Wolfe said. “It might be — I’m not saying it will be — I don’t know how he’s going to view it, but it might be beneficial for him to be in a smaller market.”

Teams took note, with some altering their presentations to account for the perceived preferences.

Sasaki, 23, was officially posted last month by Japan’s Chiba Lotte Marines. He can pick his team, but because he is not a free agent, he will be bound by international signing bonus limits.

Just before the new year, Wolfe held a teleconference and said 20 teams submitted pitches for Sasaki.

But where will he go? And could it really be a team outside of the big coastal juggernauts? Would it be possible to break down which teams might be good fits for Sasaki, using only the criteria Wolfe laid out? (While of course understanding that there are many, many factors at play beyond these.)

For this exercise, we looked at all 30 teams and graded them on four factors (history of success, small media market, pitching development and access to Japan), ranking each team from one through 30 based on a specific metric. The best earned 30 points and the worst earned one point in each category.

We don’t know who will ultimately win the Sasaki Sweepstakes, but perhaps some teams have a better chance than we previously thought.


History of success

What Wolfe said: “The best I can say is, he has paid attention to how teams have done, as far as overall success, both this year and years past. He does watch a lot of Major League Baseball.”

Methodology: This is pretty straightforward. Does the team win? For this, we’ll look at the winning percentage of MLB teams over the last four full seasons.

Limitations: Using just the regular-season win totals from the last four seasons doesn’t include postseason success. This formula also weighs each season equally, and the 2021 Orioles (52 wins) and the 2021 White Sox (93 wins) are in much different situations than their 2025 counterparts.

Team winning percentage, 2021-24

Team 2024 23 22 21 Total Points

98

100

111

106

415

30

89

104

101

88

382

29

88

90

106

95

379

28

94

82

99

92

367

27

93

92

86

95

366

26

80

99

86

100

365

25

95

90

87

82

354

24

85

88

90

90

353

23

80

79

81

107

347

22

74

89

92

91

346

21

93

82

89

79

343

20

89

75

101

77

342

19

92

76

92

80

340

18

83

71

93

90

337

17

81

78

78

92

329

16

91

101

83

52

327

15

82

87

78

73

320

14

83

83

74

71

311

13

86

78

66

77

307

12

77

82

62

83

304

11

89

84

74

52

299

10

78

90

68

60

296

9

63

73

73

77

286

8

62

84

69

67

282

7

86

56

65

74

281

6

41

61

81

93

276

5

76

76

62

61

275

4

69

50

60

86

265

3

71

71

55

65

262

2

61

59

68

74

262

2

Conclusion: The Dodgers are good. We knew that. Only once in the last four years has the team failed to win 100 games — and in that season, they won the World Series. With no repeat World Series winners over that period, it is clear that if winning is all that matters, joining the Dodgers is the way to go.

But don’t count out the Braves. Atlanta has the second-most regular-season victories over the last four seasons and a recent World Series title of their own. The Astros, who won the World Series in 2022, have the third-most victories over that time. The Rangers won a World Series in 2023, but only eight teams have fewer regular-season victories over the last four years.

If there’s a sleeper in this group, it’s the Milwaukee Brewers. Milwaukee’s won the fifth-most regular-season games (366) and only the New York Yankees have won more regular-season games (367) without a World Series title in that timeframe.

Small media markets

What Wolfe said: “I think that there’s an argument to be made that a smaller, mid-market team might be more beneficial for him as a soft landing coming from Japan.”

Methodology: Not all media markets are created equal. Boston is the seventh-largest TV market in the country, but playing in Boston is traditionally considered a particularly intense media experience. Boston, New York and Philadelphia have reputations as among the toughest media markets, while large markets like Los Angeles, Dallas and Atlanta don’t have the same reputation. For this exercise, we’ve used the 2024 Baseball Writers Association of America rolls and ranked each chapter by the number of members listed in that chapter as a reflection of the media attention.

Limitations: Using the BBWAA chapters just tells total numbers, it does not include just how many writers are at the ballpark every day. Also, there are five chapters — New York, Chicago, Los Angeles, Baltimore-Washington and San Francisco-Oakland — with two teams. Both teams share the same score, even if the media surrounding the Dodgers or Cubs is greater than the Angels or White Sox. The New York chapter is by far the largest because many national writers also live in New York. Of the one-team chapters, only Boston had more members in 2024 than Miami, although many of Miami’s members cover players from Spanish-speaking countries as much or more than the Marlins. Also, this metric does not include TV or radio coverage. It also doesn’t factor in the Japanese media, which travels to cover the country’s best players, regardless of where they are playing. In 2020, at least two Japanese media members were in Cincinnati for much of the season just for Shogo Akiyama, who spent that season mostly as a platoon player.

Media market size

Team Chapter Members Points

Milwaukee

8

30

Tampa Bay

10

29

Cincinnati

11

28

Colorado

13

27

San Diego

13

27

Cleveland

14

25

Kansas City

15

24

Arizona

16

23

Houston

17

22

Dallas-Fort Worth

18

21

St. Louis

18

21

Pittsburgh

19

19

Atlanta

20

18

Minnesota

20

18

Seattle

21

16

Detroit

23

15

Philadelphia

28

14

San Francisco-Oakland

30

13

San Francisco-Oakland

30

13

Toronto

32

11

Chicago

33

10

Chicago

33

10

Miami

34

8

Baltimore-Washington

37

7

Baltimore-Washington

37

7

Boston

39

5

Los Angeles

60

4

Los Angeles

60

4

New York

132

2

New York

132

2

Conclusion: The Brewers, Rays, Reds and Rockies could really bear down on Wolfe’s comments about small markets and media attention in their pitch.

Developing pitching

What Wolfe said: “He’s talked to a lot of players, foreign players, that have been on his team with Chiba Lotte. He asked questions about weather, comfortability, pitching development.”

Methodology: For this exercise, we’ll use Cy Young  Award voting from the past four years. This, of course, benefits teams with established pitchers and teams like the Yankees who sign big-name free agents, but using the cumulative voting totals hopefully gives credit to teams whose pitchers consistently garner votes. For pitchers who were traded during the season in which they earned points, we’ve used the team that pitchers started the season with because the bulk of the innings and the preparation were from the first team.

Limitations: This is less quantifiable than simple W-L records. Some teams are known for developing their pitchers at the minor-league level and some, like the Astros and Rays, are known for taking talented pitchers and improving them.

Using just the Cy Young voting limits the pool to mostly starters, which is OK since Sasaki is going to be signed and used as a starter. But this method only measures the very best performances, and how much of that is on the pitcher and how much of that is on the team? It also discounts previous advancements, such as giving the Yankees credit on Gerrit Cole, who became an ace while with the Astros and was drafted by the Pirates. It also gives more weight to the voting results, with unanimous selections earning a much higher point total than close decisions.

Cy Young votes, 2021-24

Team 2024 23 22 21 Total Points

0

86

88

207

381

30

133

28

48

141

350

29

199

64

75

0

338

28

0

210

4

123

337

27

59

204

7

0

270

26

18

6

224

14

262

25

0

0

210

0

210

24

210

0

0

0

210

24

0

13

20

172

205

22

0

0

97

93

190

21

18

86

32

7

143

20

141

0

0

0

141

19

0

0

66

73

139

18

0

115

0

8

123

17

0

68

45

0

113

16

0

0

0

113

113

16

47

42

0

0

89

14

0

0

82

1

83

13

67

0

5

0

72

12

38

31

0

69

11

25

31

0

0

56

10

53

0

0

0

53

9

0

1

0

41

42

8

0

19

10

0

29

7

1

16

6

1

24

6

0

0

0

23

23

5

4

0

1

3

8

4

5

0

0

0

5

3

2

0

0

0

2

2

0

0

0

0

0

1

Conclusion: The Blue Jays, surprisingly, top the list. Much of that comes from Robbie Ray’s 2021 Cy Young campaign, but the team also had third-place finishers in 2022 (Alek Manoah) and 2023 (Kevin Gausman). Manoah is the only one of those three to come up through the Blue Jays’ system (and we’ll ignore what’s happened since then), while Ray won the award in his first full season. Gausman’s third-place finish came in his first year with the team after signing as a free agent.

The Phillies finished second, followed by the Braves. The Brewers finished ninth by this metric, but that would seem low considering the pitching the Brewers have gotten over the last four years. The Astros, a team credited with turning around several pitching careers, finished sixth.

Direct flights to and from Japan

What Wolfe said: “When we supply information to our Japanese players, long before they come over here, one of the things that we provide for them is direct flights from Japan and the amount of time it takes for family to come and visit you. I think about five or 10 years ago that was something that maybe they weighed a little bit more, but now you can fly direct from Japan to most of the major cities in the U.S.”

Methodology: There are direct flights to Japan from 15 different airports in the continental United States. Toronto also has direct flights to Japan. For this exercise, we will use the distance from the team’s home ballpark to the nearest airport with a direct flight to Japan.

Limitations: There are a ton, but we’ll start with the fact that when traveling, the most relevant unit of measurement is time, not distance. However, variables including frequency of flights, schedules, traffic and overall distance come into play — a flight with a stop from the West Coast will likely take less time than a nonstop flight from the East Coast to Japan. And, yes, O’Hare airport may only be 14 miles from Wrigley Field, but there are times of day that it can be a long drive.

Direct flights to Japan

Team Nearest non-stop Miles from park Points

SAN

4

30

BOS

6

29

JFK

9

28

DFW

10

27

MSP

12

26

SFO

12

26

SEA

12

26

ORD

14

23

IAH

17

22

JFK/EWR

17

22

LAX

19

20

ORD

20

19

DTW

20

19

DEN

22

17

ATL

23

16

YYZ

25

15

IAD

28

14

LAX

39

13

IAD

61

12

ORD

80

11

EWR

85

10

SFO

96

9

DTW

157

8

IAD

238

7

DTW

251

6

ORD

298

5

SAN

360

4

MSP

435

3

ATL

450

2

ATL

655

1

Conclusion: San Diego is the clear winner here. San Diego International Airport doesn’t have the volume of flights available at LAX, but it does have the bonus of not being LAX or having LAX traffic, which can add hours to travel time. The Twins are a sneaky good spot with direct flights.

Of note: Though it isn’t reflected in our calculation, Seattle offers the shortest flight time (10 hours, 10 minutes) to Tokyo.

Final conclusion

Final totals

Team Total Wins Development Flights Media

103

20

26

30

27

97

28

25

22

22

91

29

28

16

18

89

26

22

11

30

81

22

20

26

13

78

27

27

22

2

77

21

30

15

11

77

24

29

10

14

75

23

10

26

16

75

14

17

26

18

72

30

18

20

4

70

12

24

19

15

63

18

12

8

25

63

25

7

2

29

59

9

2

27

21

58

16

8

29

5

57

13

11

23

10

55

19

6

28

2

55

5

21

19

10

53

10

16

4

23

52

6

19

3

24

48

15

14

12

7

48

11

3

6

28

47

17

4

5

21

47

2

1

17

27

40

7

24

1

8

39

2

16

14

7

39

4

9

7

19

38

8

13

13

4

30

3

5

9

13

Why are the good teams good? Well, those good teams win games, develop players and have money. Those three are actually tied to the categories given — with market size in part determining both direct flights to Japan and media attention, both of which impact revenue. That’s why it’s no surprise that the top three teams in our exercise are the Padres, Braves and Astros.

It is only when we get to fourth place that we have one of those small-market teams in the Brewers. The Brewers tick all those boxes, with an out-of-the-box pick in O’Hare International. (It may be in a different state, but O’Hare is just over an hour and a $114 Uber ride from Milwaukee.)

Will the Brewers be the pick? It seems unlikely, but Matt Arnold’s team can make some interesting points in its sales pitch.

The Padres had already been a team seen as having a shot at Sasaki’s services, and not just because of the team’s recent history of handing out major contracts and making big splashes. The Padres tick all the boxes that Wolfe laid out, both in general terms and in our exercise. While the top 10 is littered with big-market bullies, the Mariners, who have as much history with Japanese players as any team, finished 10th, followed by the Twins. Both teams are ahead of the Dodgers on this list, but somehow, it seems Los Angeles still has a pretty good chance of landing another Japanese superstar.

(Photo of Roki Sasaki: Eric Espada / Getty Images)

Ilona Maher sprinkles her stardust on England – U.S. rugby icon’s new team has had to find a bigger home stadium

Asked if she felt tired after spending over an hour posing for pictures with hundreds of fans, Ilona Maher channels Taylor Swift with her answer.

“I do get tired a lot but, as Taylor Swift said, ‘I get tired a lot but I don’t get tired of it’.”

The ‘it’ the 28-year-old rugby union player from Burlington, Vermont is referring to is the fanfare which follows her every move.

Fresh from making her 20-minute debut for Bristol Bears, the English team she has joined on a three-month contract, Maher had to tackle a queue of photo-seekers more than 250 yards long — taking up three sides of the pitch. Some had travelled across the Atlantic from Washington, D.C. to see a player who now transcends her sport. A 2024 Olympic bronze medallist who last year also featured on the cover of Sports Illustrated’s swimsuit edition and was named on Forbes’ 30 Under 30 list, Maher’s fame continues to snowball.

There weren’t any expectations placed on Maher to spend time with what seemed like every fan who attended her Bristol debut, but she did. “I saw the line of people staying out there and I was like, ‘I’m going to try to take as many photos as I can’,” she told reporters. 

With eight million-plus followers across Instagram and TikTok combined, Maher is the most-followed rugby player in the world. She took followers behind the scenes at the previous Olympics in Japan in 2021, when fans were barred from attending due to ongoing pandemic-related regulations and has a sense of humour that would not go amiss in some Saturday Night Live sketches. Mix that with a back catalogue of empowering, body-confident video messages, and she has a global audience of supporters, many of whom are young women and girls.


Maher came on as a second-half replacement for Bristol Bears on Sunday (Dan Mullan/Getty Images)

Over 9,000 were in attendance for Maher’s debut in Bristol, a city in the west of England, just over 100 miles from London, known, among other things, for being the birthplace of street artist Banksy. And just as when one of the anonymous political activist’s latest works pops up to huge publicity, Maher demands the same level of excitement in whatever she does.

Within 72 hours of her move to England being announced, Sunday’s game against local rivals Gloucester-Hartpury was moved from Shaftesbury Park (the 2,000-capacity venue where the team usually play) to Ashton Gate, the 27,000-seater stadium which is home to Bristol City’s men’s and women’s soccer teams, as well as the Bears’ men’s rugby side.

At that point, there was no guarantee Maher, whose every move is being followed by documentary filmmakers from Hello Sunshine (a production company founded by actor Reese Witherspoon that focuses on telling women’s stories), would even feature in the match after she was named as a replacement on the team sheet 48 hours before kick-off. Yet, the team’s attendance record of 4,101, set in 2022, was smashed. For a standalone game in Premiership Women’s Rugby (PWR), there has been no bigger crowd.

Rose Kooper-Johnson is a fellow New Englander, from Rhode Island, and has been living in the UK for the past six years. The 29-year-old works at the Bristol-based University of the West of England in student communications and had never watched rugby live before Sunday.

“Hearing she was coming to Bristol was really exciting,” Kooper-Johnson tells The Athletic. “She has been on Dancing with the Stars (Maher finished as runner-up in that show in November) and she’s just so cool and inspiring. If she can be a catalyst for getting more people into women’s sports, then that’s amazing. She has that ability to bring people together.”


Maher takes a selfie with fans after making her debut for Bristol Bears (Dan Mullan/Getty Images)

Maher’s arrival in England was always going to be impactful.

Having helped the United States’ rugby union sevens women’s team dramatically win Olympic bronze on the game’s final play in Paris last summer, she has timed her move to the sport’s 15-a-side format, where the matches last over four times longer (80 minutes to 14), feature twice as many players on the pitch and games are generally more attritional, to perfection. This is a World Cup year and Maher is eyeing a place on the USA roster. The tournament kicks off with host nation England taking on the Americans on August 22.

Friends Lucy Parkinson, Elvira Berninger, Abby Bevan and Maria East had travelled 130 miles from Bournemouth on the English south coast for Sunday’s have-to-be-there moment. Rugby union team-mates for Ellingham & Ringwood RFC, they usually only attend international women’s fixtures.

“We love all the other players but she (Maher) was the instigator. We were 50/50, like, ‘Do we come just because of the Ilona Maher effect? Yeah, let’s enjoy the hype’,” Bevan tells The Athletic, while East added that the attention on Maher “can only be a good thing for rugby”.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

How 17-year-old darts phenomenon Luke Littler achieved sporting greatness

Chloe and Luke Glover are season-ticket holders for the Bears’ men’s team, so are regulars at Ashton Gate, but the couple had never watched a women’s game before being drawn in by ‘Maher fever’. “She has brought quite a lot of attention to it so we thought we would come and see what it is all about,” Luke says.

Queuing up near food trucks selling churros and barbecued pulled pork are Cathy and her 16-year-old daughter Jasmine, who herself plays rugby union. “She (Maher) has had a big impact on a lot of young girls starting and getting into the sport in general. It has been a big topic, Ilona joining,” Jasmine says. “There are a lot more people looking for teams to join around Bristol, and with her joining a lot more people have even just come here… It was a lot harder to get tickets this time.”

Dings Crusaders under-14s girls’ team did not need to worry about getting tickets, as many of their players were employed to retrieve any loose balls during Sunday’s match. Nellie MacDonald, 12, plays for Dings and feels Maher had made “a massive change to everything already”, and her mum, Sam, agrees, saying, “The amount of people that are here, you can already see it is bigger than before.”


Maher speaks with TNT Sports presenter Jenny Drummond after the match (Dan Mullan/Getty Images)

The game was shown live on TNT Sports in the UK, and the league shared a pre-match social media post detailing its kick-off time in various time zones.

Whenever Maher’s face was beamed onto the stadium’s big screen, huge cheers erupted from the thousands gathered in the Dolman Stand and South Stand. The decibels rose when her name was read out before kick-off and, again, when she came on as a replacement during the second half.

Playing on the wing and wearing knee pads and her now-iconic matte red lipstick, Maher burst into a nerve-calming tackle within seconds. The American likes to run with ball in hand, but Gloucester-Hartpury turned up the heat and gave the home side little room to manoeuvre in a match the visitors won 40-17, scoring six tries in total.

Though Maher failed to get a touch of the ball during her time in the game, her introduction lifted the crowd and the team — Bristol scored their third and final try four minutes after she was introduced.

Finally, an hour and 11 minutes after first beginning her lap of fan selfies following the final whistle, Maher sat down for her own post-match press conference.

“I just try to be as equal as possible, because they’re going to do so much for me as maybe I’m doing for them,” Maher said. “They bought a seat and that seat is going to lead to hopefully some more seats. Fans are the revenue we need to bring in to make this league bigger. So it’s almost, I feel, like my duty. They’re doing so much so I want to do more for them.

“Some people came from America. I had some people say they came to this game from Washington, D.C. to watch… I put those (social media) videos out there for them. I want them to feel confident and love themselves and play the sport and understand what the body is capable of. It’s always just really cool that they’re out there and they stay out there.”

Maher, humble yet radiating confidence, takes ownership of the empire she has created, something she has achieved without necessarily being the best player in women’s rugby. 

“It’s cool to be the face of a sport that isn’t thought of as a women’s sport,” she said. “It’s a men’s sport. So to be the face of it and also the impact I’m having is felt across both men’s and women’s (rugby), I’ve had some of the best men’s players in the world be like, ‘Keep doing what you’re doing’ because I think everyone sees value in it. And if one rises, we all rise.

“I’m really proud of what I’ve done and the impact I’ve had on social media, not just in a rugby sense, in a body-positivity sense, the way people are treating themselves. So I’m proud. I think my family is 10-times prouder,” Maher added, with her sister, Olivia, who has moved to England with her, smiling from the back of the room. “And I love what I’m doing.”

Millions of people do.

(Top photo: Dan Mullan/Getty Images)

Predicting where the top 15 remaining MLB free agents will sign: Who lands Sasaki?

The Mets signed Juan Soto to a record-breaking $765 million deal, the Yankees landed Max Fried with a $218 million deal, and the Diamondbacks once again shocked the baseball world, adding ace Corbin Burnes on a $210 million pact.

However, there are still several teams — including the Royals, Twins, Padres, Mariners and Cardinals — that haven’t spent a single penny in free agency, although that could change soon. The free-agent market is still filled with talent. So where will these players sign?

Here are the top 15 remaining free agents and my predictions on where each will land.

(WAR is according to Baseball Reference. All statistics are from the 2024 season unless otherwise noted.)  


1. Roki Sasaki, RHP

Age: 23
WAR: N/A
ERA: 2.35 IP: 111 SO: 129 (NPB stats)
Agent: Wasserman

Seven teams have reportedly met with Sasaki and his agent, Joel Wolfe of Wasserman, in Los Angeles, including the Dodgers, Padres, Cubs, Yankees, Mets, Rangers and Giants. Other teams still could be added to the list, but in all probability Sasaki is probably going to sign with one of those seven.

Of that group, most in the industry believe he’ll end up signing with the Dodgers. However, I’m not in that camp because I think endorsement deals with Japanese companies are going to be important for him financially since he won’t be eligible for arbitration for three years or eligible for free agency for at least six years. In Los Angeles, he’d be in the shadow of both Shohei Ohtani and Yoshinobu Yamamoto, lessening his endorsement ceiling. And there are other reasons I don’t believe he’s destined for the Dodgers.

(Sasaki can only be signed through each team’s international bonus pools, which range from roughly $5.1 million to $7.5 million.)

I don’t think the Giants make a lot of sense for him based on their weak farm system and mediocre major-league roster. I view the Rangers as a long shot, though they would be a good fit because of their strong pitching room and leadership group. The Cubs also seem like a stretch to me. That leaves both New York teams and the Padres.

Wolfe recently provided an update on the 23-year-old star’s unusual free agency, but none of us know how this ends or what exactly Sasaki is thinking. His favorite player growing up was Masahiro Tanaka, which would lead me to guess he was at least somewhat of a Yankees fan. He considers Yu Darvish a godfather-type influence, and the Padres veteran mentored Sasaki during Japan’s championship run in the 2023 World Baseball Classic. Therefore, for no other reason, I’ll predict he signs with either the Yankees or San Diego.

Prediction: Yankees or Padres

GO DEEPER

What’s next for Roki Sasaki? Agent provides update on coveted free agent


Houston pivoted away from Alex Bregman. Where will he end up? (Alex Slitz / Getty Images)

2. Alex Bregman, 3B

Age: 30
WAR: 4.1
OPS+: 118
Agent: Boras Corporation

I was surprised Bregman reportedly turned down six years and $156 million to stay in Houston, because I thought he and his family were happy there and I didn’t think he’d necessarily take the most money and years in free agency. However, when he spurned the Astros’ offer, they pivoted, trading for third baseman Isaac Paredes and signing first baseman Christian Walker, which closed the door on a possible return to Houston.

I think Bregman would fit nicely at third base with the Mets, who could move Mark Vientos to first base. But there doesn’t seem to be much traction there. The Mariners could really use him at third base, but they don’t seem to want to spend any money. I also think the Phillies — and their ballpark — could work well for him, but they’d have to trade Alec Bohm first, and by all indications they never came close to making a swap.

That leaves the Tigers and Blue Jays as the most likely landing spots for Bregman, but neither one seems ideal. So he might want to sign a shorter deal with a higher average annual value and opt-outs, then look to go back on the free-agent market next offseason or after the 2026 season.

That said, Boston is my favorite spot for Bregman, who will turn 31 in March. They need a right-handed power pull hitter, and he would do significant damage to the Green Monster in left field. They could move Rafael Devers to first base and put Triston Casas at DH or they could just put Bregman at second base full-time. His leadership and ability to grind at-bats would help this young roster. He could be the final piece in getting the Red Sox back to the postseason.

Prediction: Red Sox

3. Anthony Santander, RF

Age: 30
WAR: 2.9
OPS+: 134
Agent: GSE Worldwide

The Santander market has been strangely quiet, but all indications are he’ll end up on a non-contending team and get his long-term contract. There is a lot of buzz in the industry about the Blue Jays being all-in on him, and they definitely need his 44-home run power in between Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Bo Bichette in their lineup. The Angels and Giants have also been said to have some level of interest.

Prediction: Blue Jays

4. Pete Alonso, 1B

Age: 30
WAR: 2.6
OPS+: 123
Agent: Boras Corporation

The staredown between the Mets’ brass and Scott Boras over an Alonso contract is starting to become epic. Who blinks first — owner Steve Cohen and president of baseball operations David Stearns or the superstar agent? The Mets do not want to move beyond their last offer and don’t think they have to because the first-base market has dried up. There are not a lot of options left for Alonso after the Yankees traded for Paul Goldschmidt, the Guardians signed Carlos Santana, the Diamondbacks traded for Josh Naylor and the Astros inked Christian Walker.

The Mariners would be a great fit, but they’re not in on any of the big free agents. The Angels have been mentioned as a possibility, but does anyone think they’d do another big — and potentially bad — contract for a 30-year-old power hitter after the Anthony Rendon, Josh Hamilton and Albert Pujols contracts all failed?

The Giants might be the only other viable option. Signing Alonso to a three-year deal with a high AAV and opt-outs might make some sense for them if they can stomach losing the draft pick compensation. (Alonso was one of 12 players to turn down the qualifying offer.) Maybe Alonso would go that type of route and prove a point to the Mets in the process.

However, at the end of the day, I just can’t see the Polar Bear in another uniform — at least not this year.

Prediction: Mets

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Mets mailbag: What’s the holdup with Pete Alonso? Are the Mets done in the rotation?

5. Jack Flaherty, RHP

Age: 29
WAR: 3.1
ERA: 3.17 IP: 162 SO: 194
Agent: CAA Sports

He’s the best starting pitcher left on the market, apart from Sasaki, and a potential difference-maker for a contending team. But Flaherty’s medical reports are going to determine whether he gets a long-term contract or has to take a similar deal to that of Walker Buehler, who signed a one-year, $21 million contract with the Red Sox.

I haven’t heard about Flaherty being connected much with the Braves, but I think that would be an ideal match for him. They lost Max Fried and Charlie Morton in free agency. Spencer Strider, who is recovering from internal-brace elbow surgery, won’t be ready for Opening Day. They have a lot of strong young arms for the back of their rotation but could really use another veteran.

I’ve heard a reunion with the Tigers is not out of the question. Flaherty pitched well for them last season, posting a 2.95 ERA over 18 starts before the trade deadline deal to the Dodgers. Other teams that have been linked to him include the Cubs, Giants and Blue Jays.

Prediction: Braves

6. Tanner Scott, LHP

Age: 30
WAR: 4.0
ERA: 1.75 SV: 22 IP: 72 SO: 84
Agent: MVP Sports Group

The most-impactful closer on the market has yet to sign and teams are lining up for him but waiting for the asking price to drop. The Red Sox are the clear front-runners for Scott. Their chief baseball officer, Craig Breslow, was a left-handed reliever in his playing days and seems obsessed with corralling lefty pitchers: He’s already signed three of them in free agency (Patrick Sandoval, Aroldis Chapman, Justin Wilson) and acquired two more via trades (Garrett Crochet, Jovani Moran). Red Sox manager Alex Cora prefers a single closer and Scott is the best one available.

The Blue Jays and Giants are also strong candidates to sign Scott as both could use an upgrade at the closer position. Other possible destinations include the Dodgers, Rangers and Diamondbacks.

Prediction: Red Sox


Jurickson Profar had a career year for the Padres, but is a reunion in the cards? (David Frerker / Imagn Images)

7. Jurickson Profar, LF

Age: 31
WAR: 3.6
OPS+: 134
Agent: MVP Sports Group

Profar was one of the best under-the-radar signings last offseason, when San Diego inked him for a base salary of $1 million. He rewarded them by slashing .280/.380/.459 with 24 home runs, 29 doubles and 10 stolen bases and made his first All-Star team. He’d like to return to San Diego but wants a three-year deal and I’m not sure if that will fit in the Padres’ tight budget.

I think the Braves would be a great match for Profar, but for some reason they seem satisfied with the combination of Jarred Kelenic and Bryan De La Cruz competing for time in left field. The Red Sox have been mentioned as a possibility too. But, to me, the Padres are by far the best fit for both the player and team, though he’ll likely have to drop his expectations and agree to a deal that works for both sides if he wants to remain in San Diego.

Prediction: Padres

8. Kirby Yates, RHP

Age: 37
WAR: 3.3
ERA: 1.17 SV: 33 IP: 61 2/3 SO: 85
Agent: Beverly Hills Sports Council

Yates might have to wait until Scott signs, then get with one of the teams that misses out on him. A return to the Rangers is possible, a move north of the border to Toronto makes sense, and the Dodgers are always looking for high-leverage relievers. The Braves really missed him last year, the Reds could use him to replace Fernando Cruz, whom they traded to the Yankees, and the Royals could surprise here too.

However, I like Arizona for Yates. After the splash signing of Burnes and trading for All-Star first baseman Josh Naylor, why not ink Yates to bookend their offseason?

Prediction: Diamondbacks

9. Ha-Seong Kim, SS

Age: 29
WAR: 2.6
OPS+: 96
Agent: Boras Corporation

After season-ending shoulder surgery, Kim has discovered his free-agent value isn’t what he had hoped. He’ll need to sign a short-term deal, show that he’s healthy next year and try to replicate his 5.8 WAR season from 2023.

The Giants had interest in Kim until they were able to land Willy Adames in free agency. Now, I think he’d fit great with the Red Sox, who could then keep Trevor Story at second base, allowing Marcelo Mayer and Kristian Campbell another year of development at Triple A.

However, the best team for Kim, without a doubt, is still the Padres. They also are a much better team with him at shortstop and Xander Bogaerts at second base than if they have to play Bogaerts at shortstop.

Prediction: Padres

10. Carlos Estévez, RHP

Age: 32
WAR: 2.1
ERA: 2.45 SV: 26 IP: 55 SO: 50
Agent: Premier Talent Sports and Entertainment

Like Yates, Estévez probably has to wait until Scott signs before he can find his next team. I think the Cubs, who need to build up their bullpen, are the best fit for him. They could use the strike-throwing power righty in high-leverage spots late in games. Teams such as the Blue Jays, Rangers, Red Sox and Giants also make sense for Estévez, who logged 26 saves between the Phillies and Angels last year.

Prediction: Cubs

11. Jose Quintana, LHP

Age: 35
WAR: 2.5
ERA: 3.75 IP: 170 1/3 SO: 135
Agent: Wasserman

Quintana still knows how to win and keep hitters off-balance. He gave the Mets 170 1/3 innings last season, going 10-10 with a 3.75 ERA over 31 starts. His results have always been better than his raw stuff thanks to his command in and out of the zone.

He’d be a solid signing for the Royals as a rotation replacement for Brady Singer, whom they traded to the Reds in November. Although the Royals claim they’re fine moving Kris Bubic to the rotation to replace Singer, they don’t have much starting pitching depth and they’ll miss the 179 2/3 innings Singer provided last year. Quintana, who turns 36 in January, is the perfect fit. The Giants, Tigers and Padres have also been linked with him.

Prediction: Royals


Jeff Hoffman made the All-Star team in 2024. Will he be a starter or reliever this year? (Tim Heitman / Imagn Images)

12. Jeff Hoffman, RHP

Age: 31
WAR: 2.0
ERA: 2.17 SV: 10 IP: 66 1/3 SO: 89
Agent: CAA Sports

Hoffman wants to follow in the footsteps of Clay Holmes, who is attempting to transition from the bullpen to the rotation. Holmes signed a three-year, $38 million deal with the Mets and that’s what Hoffman thinks he deserves. However, he hasn’t been offered that yet.

I’m told several teams like the idea of signing him and making him a starter, while other teams would prefer to keep Hoffman, who has 50 career starts, in the pen if they acquire him. Hoffman, who turns 32 this week, is coming off two stellar seasons for the Phillies. He posted a 2.41 ERA over 54 appearances in 2023 and backed that up with a 2.17 ERA over 68 appearances last year. A return to Philly would probably be best for Hoffman, but he would not get a chance to start with them. The Braves, Red Sox, Rays, Royals, Tigers, Astros and Nationals would all be solid landing spots.

Prediction: Nationals

13. Nick Pivetta, RHP

Age: 31
WAR: 1.8
ERA: 4.14 IP: 145 2/3 SO: 172
Agent: CAA Sports

I was shocked when Pivetta turned down the $21.05 million qualifying offer from the Red Sox, for two reasons: 1) I don’t think he’ll get close to that on the open market, and 2) tying himself to draft pick compensation weakens his value even more.

Because of that, he’s one of the players who might have to wait a while before finding his next home. The New York Post reported in December that the Reds had checked in on him, but after they signed Nick Martinez to the qualifying offer and traded for Singer, I can’t imagine them actually playing on Pivetta. One team that could make sense to salvage his offseason is the Blue Jays, who have struggled to find players willing to take their free-agent offers. Pivetta, who has a career 4.76 ERA over eight seasons, will turn 32 in February.

Prediction: Blue Jays

14. Alex Verdugo, LF

Age: 28
WAR: 0.8
OPS+: 83
Agent: MVP Sports Group

Verdugo was the starting left fielder for the American League champion Yankees but had a subpar year, batting just .233/.291/.356 with 13 home runs. He’s a good defender in left field, grinds day in and day out, and is respected in the clubhouse because of the edge with which he plays. If the Padres aren’t able to bring back Profar, they could pivot to Verdugo. Otherwise, he might have to accept a role as a fourth outfielder somewhere. The Giants, Pirates and Diamondbacks could make a depth play for him.

Prediction: Padres (if they don’t re-sign Profar)

15. Justin Turner, 1B/DH

Age: 40
WAR: 1.5
OPS+: 114
Agent: Vayner Sports

Turner turned 40 in November and wants to keep playing — and based on last year’s performance, he still has something left in the tank. He slashed .259/.354/.383 (114 OPS+) with 11 home runs. His leadership qualities are particularly valuable on a relatively young team. The Mariners, Guardians, Pirates and Diamondbacks are all logical fits for Turner to improve their benches. A return to Seattle might make the most sense based on the positive impact he had on the clubhouse after being traded by the Blue Jays at the deadline.

Prediction: Mariners

(Top photo of Roki Sasaki: The Yomiuri Shimbun via Associated Press) 

Patriots fire Jerod Mayo, expected to pursue Mike Vrabel as next head coach

FOXBORO, Mass. — The New England Patriots are making a change at head coach, splitting with Jerod Mayo just one year after he replaced Bill Belichick. Now, a franchise that once exuded stability and success like no other in the NFL is about to have its third coach in just three seasons.

New England fired Mayo less than 90 minutes after the season ended Sunday, a disastrous 4-13 campaign (and a Week 18 win that cost the team the No. 1 pick in the draft) in which Mayo routinely seemed to be in over his head in everything from game planning to his remarks to the media. While Mayo was given one of the worst rosters in the NFL, one overseen by executive vice president of player personnel Eliot Wolf, the early indications are that Wolf will remain with the Patriots, according to a team source.

Patriots owner Robert Kraft called the decision to fire Mayo “one of the hardest decisions I have ever made.”

“Unfortunately, the trajectory of our team’s performances throughout the season did not ascend as I had hoped,” he said in a statement.

It’s a shocking fall from 12 months ago when it was revealed that Mayo, then 37, was Kraft’s hand-picked replacement for Belichick after 24 years at the helm. Kraft had quietly put the succession plan in writing, meaning the Patriots didn’t have to interview a single candidate before handing Mayo the reins.

This time, that won’t be the case. The Patriots are expected to begin their search for a new head coach immediately, and, according to league sources, the early signs point to one person. Kraft and company are expected to pursue Mike Vrabel, the 49-year-old former Patriots linebacker who shined for Belichick from 2001 to 2008 during the team’s first dynasty, though the franchise must conduct additional interviews for the job in compliance with the league’s Rooney Rule.

Vrabel was the head coach of the Tennessee Titans for six years, leading them to two division titles and an AFC Championship Game appearance while amassing a 54-45 record. But last year, the trust in Vrabel began to erode when team brass watched Vrabel spend his bye weekend in Foxboro being inducted into the Patriots Hall of Fame while soaking up all things New England. During his on-field speech at halftime, Vrabel, still the Titans head coach, even said, “We’ve got a game to win,” in reference to the Patriots. Less than three months later, Vrabel was fired and didn’t land another head-coaching job.

“There’s got to be clear communication with ownership so that we understand as coaches what the expectations are,” Vrabel told The Athletic’s Zack Rosenblatt about what he’s looking for in his next job. “And I would like to be able to say that there’s a quarterback that you feel like you can win with — or that there’s a path to find the one that you can win with.”

For Vrabel, the Patriots likely check both of those boxes. Sources close to the situation believe Vrabel has shown interest in the Patriots’ potential vacancy in recent weeks. He also was interested in the Patriots gig a year ago after their split with Belichick before learning that Mayo had already been earmarked for the job.

At that point, the Patriots thought Mayo would be their coach for the next decade. Kraft and his fellow decision-makers saw Mayo as the right person to follow Belichick because he was a bridge to the franchise’s past success while offering a new path forward.

In the news conference announcing Mayo’s hiring last January, Kraft said he knew in 2019 that Mayo would be the next coach of the Patriots.

“I trust that Jerod is the right person to lead the Patriots back to championship-level contention and long-term success,” Kraft said at the time.

Instead, Mayo oversaw one of the Patriots’ worst seasons since Kraft purchased the team in 1994.

Mayo’s tenure started on a winning note with a surprise upset of the Cincinnati Bengals. Following four straight losses, Mayo turned to Drake Maye, the No. 3 pick in the 2024 NFL Draft, as his starting quarterback, and benched veteran Jacoby Brissett. In the middle weeks of the season, the Patriots pulled out a last-second win over their archrival, the New York Jets, and a victory over the Chicago Bears. Things were looking up.

Kraft and the Patriots knew this season wouldn’t bring a lot of wins. It was the first year of a post-Belichick rebuild. The roster was bad. But they hoped Mayo would establish a culture that led to excitement and improvement by the end of the season.

Instead, the Patriots became a punching bag. After a Week 14 bye, they were blown out by the Arizona Cardinals, blew a 14-point lead to the Buffalo Bills and lost 40-7 at home to the Los Angeles Chargers. A loss on Sunday to the Bills would have clinched the No. 1 pick in the 2025 draft, but rookie backup quarterback Joe Milton led the Pats to a surprising 23-16 win.

GO DEEPER

Jerod Mayo firing was as much about his command off the field as the Patriots’ play on it

In fairness to Mayo, many of the Patriots’ problems preceded him. The franchise is 10-31 in its last 41 games. The Pats haven’t scored 30 or more points in 45 straight games. They are 11-22 at home in the last four seasons. (Tom Brady lost fewer games at Gillette Stadium in his entire Patriots career, going 115-19 at home.) They’ve finished with a sub-.300 winning percentage in back-to-back years, something they hadn’t done since they were the AFL’s Boston Patriots in 1969 and 1970.

But there was no sense by the end of the season that Mayo had the team on track to fix its problems. No position on the roster besides quarterback improved under his tutelage. And while that is a notable exception, Maye’s success as a rookie also ups the importance of ensuring Year 2 is in the right hands.

“We have tremendous fans who expect and deserve a better product than we have delivered in recent years,” Kraft said Sunday. “I apologize for that. I have given much thought and consideration as to what actions I can take to expedite our return to championship contention and determined this move was the best option at this time.”

Mayo becomes the sixth one-and-done NFL coach in the last four seasons and the first one-and-done Patriots coach since Rod Rust went 1-15 with the team in 1990.

All of it proved to be too much too soon for Mayo. The original plan, as dreamt up by Kraft, would’ve been for Belichick to remain the Patriots head coach in 2024, break Don Shula’s all-time wins record and mentor Mayo. But after the succession plan was put into writing, the relationship between Belichick and Mayo deteriorated and Belichick, who was already insular in his approach, withdrew even further. The idea of having Belichick mentor Mayo quickly went by the wayside.

At that point, Kraft decided to split with Belichick and hand the reins to Mayo — even though it was a year earlier than planned and he hadn’t received the mentorship he originally planned on. Sure, Mayo would struggle early on. But the hope was he’d learn on the job and grow throughout the course of the year.

That didn’t happen. In a lot of ways, Mayo tried to be what Belichick wasn’t. As a former player, he tried to be a player-friendly coach, then blasted the whole team as “soft” after a Week 7 loss. He tried to be more affable than his mentor while speaking to the media, then had to walk back several remarks. He said the team would “burn some cash” in free agency, then reversed course a couple of days later and the Patriots didn’t sign any marquee free agents.

After a Week 15 loss, he was asked if offensive coordinator Alex Van Pelt should’ve called a quarterback sneak on an important short-yardage play and replied, “You said it, I didn’t.” The next day, he walked back those comments as “a defensive response.” Before a Week 17 loss, he told the radio and TV broadcast crews that Rhamondre Stevenson wouldn’t start the game to send him a message about his recent fumbles. Then Stevenson started the game.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Mike Vrabel, Brian Flores and the top candidates to be the Patriots’ next head coach

More importantly, the on-field product regressed in embarrassing fashion. As a former linebacker who learned under Belichick, defense was supposed to be Mayo’s area of expertise. But a Patriots defense that ranked seventh in yards allowed per game (301.6) in 2023 dropped to 23rd (348.7 yards per game) in 2024. The team’s rushing defense, which ranked fourth in 2023, fell to 25th in 2024. The pass rush struggled to get pressure as the unit ranked last in the league with 28 sacks. The defense also surrendered 30 points or more six times this season.

Offensively, the Patriots didn’t score more than 25 points in a game all season long. While Maye’s ascension was a bright spot, the team lacked playmakers in the passing game and the offensive line allowed the fifth-most sacks in the league. Only the Bears and Carolina Panthers averaged fewer yards per game this season, and only the Cleveland Browns and New York Giants scored fewer points.

Part of the problem was Mayo’s inexperience and lack of familiarity with the rest of the NFL. He was drafted 10th by the Patriots in 2008. The University of Tennessee product spent eight seasons with the Patriots, reaching two Pro Bowls, winning Associated Press Defensive Rookie of the Year honors in 2008 and being named a first-team All-Pro in 2010. He played the entirety of his career for Belichick. He spent five years as a position coach with the Patriots and only ever worked for one coach: Belichick. So when it came time to fill out his staff, Mayo didn’t have the Rolodex of league-wide contacts most head coaches do.

He interviewed more than a dozen offensive coordinator candidates because several declined his offer. In the end, Mayo began his tenure surrounded by a first-time front office leader (Wolf), a first-time offensive play caller (Van Pelt), a first-time defensive coordinator (DeMarcus Covington), a first-time special teams coordinator (Jeremy Springer), a first-time linebackers coach (Dont’a Hightower), a first-time offensive line coach (Scott Peters) and a first-time wide receivers coach (Tyler Hughes).

The inexperience showed.

Sources from within the Patriots’ previous regime expressed skepticism that Mayo was ready to be a head coach. Several leaders thought he needed more experience with game planning, play calling and handling big situational decisions. How’d this season play out? “About how we thought,” one said.

Whether it’s Vrabel or someone else, the incoming coach will inherit a rising talent in Maye at quarterback, Stevenson at running back, cornerback Christian Gonzalez and a stout defensive line led by Keion White and Christian Barmore. New England will pick fourth in the 2025 draft. The team will also have a plethora of cap space to address multiple needs on the roster — most notably wide receiver, offensive line, defensive back and pass rusher.

— The Athletic‘s Jeff Howe contributed to this report.

Required reading

• Is coach Jerod Mayo’s job in question after another frustrating Patriots loss?
• How does Drake Maye compare to Mac Jones? They’re closer than you might think
• Patriots’ offseason priorities: A look at the team’s shopping list in free agency

(Photo: Richard Heathcote / Getty Images)

Marcus Rashford at Manchester United. What’s going on?

It was a conversation with Ruben Amorim at the start of December that goes some way to explaining why Marcus Rashford has been absent from the Manchester United side for the past five matches.

United had just beaten Everton 4-0, with Rashford scoring two of the goals in a vibrant display on Sunday, December 1. But after that game, Amorim heard the forward had been out in Manchester on the Friday night, November 29, less than 48 hours before Everton’s visit to Old Trafford.

The United head coach does not want his players in bars so close to games and asked Rashford about his movements. The England international assured Amorim he had been misinformed about a late night.

Three days later, however, Rashford was left out of the starting line-up for the trip to Arsenal. While rotation was at play, those questions over his social life were also a factor in Amorim’s decision.

Since then, Rashford’s only start has come at Viktoria Plzen in the Europa League, a 2-1 win for United on December 12. After that, he was left out of four successive matchday squads.

The 27-year-old did return to the bench for the visit of Newcastle on December 30, a match for which team-mates Bruno Fernandes and Manuel Ugarte were suspended. “We have a lot of players outside,” Amorim said. “Every week I choose my players, he was there to be chosen, and this time he is here.”

That emphasis on “this time” implied there was no guarantee Rashford would be included “next time”, and Amorim declined to introduce him despite United trailing Newcastle 2-0 from the 19th minute, in what could be interpreted as a bigger statement than leaving him out entirely.

Amorim said: “I’m not making a point. I just want to win the game.”


Rashford reacts after United’s 2-0 defeat by Newcastle last Monday (Carl Recine/Getty Images)

That Amorim appeared to believe United had a better chance of staging a comeback victory with Rashford in a seat in the dugout rather than on the pitch speaks to the wider issues at play.

On Friday, Amorim confirmed Rashford had not trained this week due to illness and would likely be missing from the trip to Liverpool tomorrow. The striker’s future has now become one of the biggest issues confronting United in this transfer window.

“It depends more on him than me,” the head coach told Sky Sports on Friday in regards to Rashford. “He has to want it really, really bad. He’s here. He’s ready to play if I decide.”

The Athletic has spoken to multiple sources with knowledge of Rashford’s situation, who did so anonymously to protect relationships, to understand how a player with the best scoring record in United’s squad, a much-praised and decorated individual owing to his record of charity work, who earns one of the top salaries on a basic £325,000 per week when the club are in the Champions League, can be left out during a crucial period of the season.

It is a complicated situation, but one thing seems clear: Rashford’s prospects of an imminent return to favour under Amorim look bleak.


Since their talk after the Everton game, Amorim has given Rashford 118 minutes of football out of a possible 720.

He played the final half-hour both at Arsenal and in the following match at home to Nottingham Forest, then started against Viktoria Plzen, although Amorim substituted him on 56 minutes after a poor performance.

Two days later, on Saturday, December 14, in the final training session before facing Manchester City the following afternoon, Rashford put in a lacklustre display at United’s Carrington base, according to multiple sources, some of whom said he appeared fatigued.

Claims circulated Rashford had gone out the night before — on the Friday, 48 hours before the game with accounts reaching people at United. This, however, is strenuously denied by people close to the player. Rashford is also known to feel he does not behave differently from other Premier League footballers but faces much more scrutiny over his social life.

Amorim makes his decisions based on what he sees with his own eyes, in complete consideration of all aspects, and when United’s line-up and squad for the derby at the Etihad Stadium was posted in the team WhatsApp group that Saturday evening, it was clear to the players that their new head coach had taken strong action in a bid to jolt Rashford.


Rashford prepares to come on against Bodo/Glimt on November 28 (Justin Setterfield/Getty Images)

Amorim’s treatment of Rashford is aligned with those above him at United, namely INEOS director of sport Sir Dave Brailsford, chief executive Omar Berrada and technical director Jason Wilcox.

In the aftermath of United’s 2-1 win in the Manchester derby, Amorim indicated he had held talks with executives on how to handle Rashford. “For so long, for example with Rash, you try a thing, it doesn’t work,” he said. “Let’s continue to do the same thing? Or something different?”

Perhaps prime in his mind and theirs was the Belfast episode from last January, when Rashford went partying for two evenings in a row, a Wednesday and a Thursday, and was pictured entering a nightclub hours before being due to attend the Friday’s training at Carrington. He reported ill for that session, and initially told United he had only gone out on the Wednesday.

Rashford’s offer to play in that Sunday’s FA Cup tie away to Newport County was turned down by Erik ten Hag, the manager at the time, with United subsequently saying the forward had “taken responsibility for his actions” and the matter had been dealt with internally. Ten Hag restored Rashford to the starting line-up at Wolves in the league four days later, and he scored in a 4-3 win.

Amorim, though, is opting for a harder approach now.

How to best tap into Rashford’s mindset has been a topic of conversation at United for years and an incident during a session a short time before he went to Belfast provided a trigger for renewed internal discussion.

Steve McClaren, one of Ten Hag’s assistants at the time, was overseeing a small-sided tournament among United’s squad at Carrington. Rashford’s team made the final, which was close in score. As the game went on, McClaren, in his jocular manner, said he believed the contest was Rashford’s to win. In response, the player questioned why additional pressure was being put on him.

Sources say McClaren recognised in that exchange how Rashford required extra attention and, with Ten Hag already across the matter, he shared his thoughts with Brailsford.

The day after the Newport game, a Monday, Brailsford addressed United’s squad for the first time to outline the INEOS strategy, particularly in terms of raising standards across the club. Brailsford’s talk was in the diary rather than a reaction to Rashford’s indiscipline in Belfast, but it seemed to strike a chord with the player. He requested a one-on-one meeting with Brailsford and the pair spoke for 90 minutes.


Locally-born academy graduate Rashford has shouldered much of the focus and expectation at United for several seasons, under a variety of managers, and trying to fulfil instructions for those different approaches would be a challenge for any player. Including caretaker spells, he has played for eight managers/head coaches since his senior debut as an 18-year-old in February 2016. Conversely, he too has proved something of a conundrum for those in charge.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Marcus Rashford – what happened?

Ralf Rangnick felt Rashford trained brilliantly but was unable to replicate that level in matches. It perplexed Rangnick, who wondered what might be going on in the player’s life to cause the disconnect between ability and output.

The only clarity came on Rashford’s preference to play on the left. Rangnick needed him to occasionally operate on the right, once Mason Greenwood was no longer available, and explained he could drift inside from there to good effect. But Rashford told him he wished to start on the opposite flank, where he has done the best work in his career.

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer had wrestled with the same dilemma after the summer 2021 signing of Jadon Sancho, who also liked the left more than the right. In Solskjaer’s last game in charge, the 4-1 loss at Watford that November, Rashford was one of two half-time substitutes, with Scott McTominay the other player going off.

Ten Hag felt he had a good relationship with Rashford, working together in his career-best season of 30 goals in 2022-23, although things soured by the end, with a difference of opinion over the coaching approach. Rashford’s final goal for Ten Hag came in a Europa League game at Porto in early October, where he appeared at his most dangerous in an attacking sense. But the manager took him off at the break due to defensive lapses.


Rashford and Ten Hag at Aston Villa  in October (James Gill/Danehouse/Getty Images)

Last summer, new United co-owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe wanted to get Rashford firing. His salary, which runs until 2028, places him among the highest earners, and Ratcliffe wants value for money. But little appears to have changed in the past six months and so United have changed tack, endorsing Amorim’s decision to leave Rashford out.

With the winter transfer window now open, talks are expected to take place about a potential exit. Rashford has said he is now ready for a “new challenge”, although this came in response to stories that he was available for sale and it could be argued was an acceptance by him that United may have decided his future lies elsewhere. “When I leave, it’s going to be ‘no hard feelings’. You’re not going to have any negative comments from me about Manchester United,” he added in the same interview, posted on X on December 17.

Finding a club willing to match his current wages and part with a transfer fee appears implausible, unless he moves to Saudi Arabia’s Pro League. Such a proposition is not thought to appeal to Rashford at this stage of his career, which is looked after by his brothers and representatives Dwaine Maynard and Dane Rashford. He also has assistance from a personal PR assistant. On New Year’s Day, Rashford posted on Instagram to deny a story linking the agency Stellar with facilitating a potential transfer.

There was further intrigue at Companies House, the UK’s register of companies, where Rashford’s MUCS Investments Limited was issued with a striking-off notice for being two months late to file accounts for 2023-24. The notice states that if the company is dissolved, all properties and rights held are deemed to be bona vacantia and will belong to the Crown. Typically, the action of issuing the notice results in the accounts being filed. Sources close to Rashford say the company is dormant and his accountants are in the process of closing it as he was not using it.

Rashford’s view on possibly leaving United comes after two of his best friends in the dressing room departed during the summer, as Sancho and Aaron Wan-Bissaka signed for Chelsea and West Ham United respectively. He is close with Tyrell Malacia, but has tested the patience of other team-mates at times.

The sale of an academy-produced player would especially aid United’s profitability and sustainability (PSR) calculations and Amorim is on record as saying he can only make January additions to the squad with any money that comes into the club.


Amorim has said he wants to see a change in Rashford, but the forward is waiting for his return to the team, which has now stretched to five games.

Sources report his training levels have been mixed, with some good days and occasional bouts of illness. He was unwell and off work on the Monday after the derby, before attending Button Lane, the primary school he went to, to give out gifts to children and speak in an interview about his position at United. Rashford has also been absent from training for the past two days, which United say was sanctioned owing to illness.

There was a time when Rashford would have been a certainty to start against Liverpool, given he enjoyed some of his best games up against Trent Alexander-Arnold, and he remains one of United’s most potent attackers, even if that is not saying a great deal this season. He has seven goals and three assists, behind only Fernandes (16 goal contributions), Alejandro Garnacho and Amad (both 12).


(Gareth Copley/Getty Images)

His running statistics are slightly up on his career norms. Rashford is covering 10.2km on average per 90 minutes in the 2024-25 Premier League, compared to 9.97km and 9.57km in the previous two seasons, according to Opta. His top speed of 35.35km/h is similar to his past best, while he is making 21.33 sprints per 90, compared to 19.28 and 20.26 in 2023-24 and 2022-23 respectively.

Overall, Rashford has 138 goals in 426 matches for United, placing him 13th in the all-time list, seven behind Cristiano Ronaldo in 12th.

There can be no doubting his quality, but people at United talk about Rashford’s attitude needing to shift to meet the standards required and how, having turned 27 in late October, he should be setting an example for the younger players.

Are his off-field choices impacting the level he can reach when the whistle blows on matchday? Until Amorim and his team sense a meaningful improvement, the prospect of a continued absence, or a departure, will remain.

(Top photos: Getty Images; design: Eamonn Dalton)

Luke Littler: How the 17-year-old achieved sporting greatness and put himself on a path alongside Pele and Serena Williams

At the end of the second set of the final of the World Darts Championship, the biggest game in one of the biggest indoor sports in the world, Luke Littler calmly strolled off stage, gave his family a wry, knowing smile and rubbed his hands together like he had the prescient foresight of the beating he was about to dish out.

The man, no, the boy that 3,000 people had crammed inside London’s Alexandra Palace to see produce history, plus millions more watching at home and in pubs around the UK and the world, was doing it not just with dispassionate ease, or with flamboyant style, but with disdainful relish.

Darts finals have been won more handsomely — the sport’s all-time great Phil Taylor dished out three 7-0 whitewashes in his heyday — but not like this. Never like this.

Luke Littler is 17. He has facial hair that men many years his senior yearn to grow and in a sport that has its history rooted in pubs, Littler is not yet able to drink alcohol in one.

And yet he already carries the bravado and stage persona of someone ready to lead the sport down roads it has never visited before, which is exactly what he is already doing.


Like Pele and Serena Williams, Littler has won one of sport’s biggest prizes while still a teenager (Ben Stansall/AFP via Getty Images)

Littler has already helped push darts further towards the mainstream in the UK, with viewing figures on Sky Sports, a subscription service, up almost 200 per cent for some tournaments in 2024, following record numbers of 4.8 million for last year’s final (the most watched non-football event in the broadcaster’s history), which a then-16-year-old Littler lost to Luke Humphries.

Now, by becoming world champion, he has earned the right to enter the pantheon of youthful sporting legends. Sure, Pele was good with a football at 17, but could he throw three treble-20s at a red, green and black board from almost two-and-a-half metres away?

Serena Williams won the US Open at 17, Ian Thorpe was the same age when he won Olympic gold in the pool, Sachin Tendulkar was 16 when he made his India debut and snooker magician Ronnie O’Sullivan was 17 when he won the UK Championship. What sets Littler apart in his particular field is that he has become the greatest current player in the world in the entire sport before he has become an adult.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

How darts, a traditional ‘pub game’, became must-watch sport for Britons

Why is he so good? Is it natural talent? Well, he’s been playing darts since his dad bought him a magnetic dart board from the pound shop when he was 18 months old. He’s not old enough to vote, but he’s basically been practising for this moment almost his entire, short life.

And it’s not all youthful exuberance and freshness, either. Littler had mental scars from losing last year’s final despite being 4-2 up (he watched it back just hours before Friday’s match to recap what went wrong), but he was relentless and merciless in his pursuit of victory here in north London, bulldozing into a 4-0 lead against one of the greatest players to ever chuck an arrow, three-time champion Michael van Gerwen.

The youngster later said he felt nervous after taking that early lead, but his actions in obliterating one of the best players in the world suggested the exact opposite.

He unyieldingly hammered the treble bed like he was using a dart-sized jackhammer, ploughing perfect tiny holes in the helpless board as he sculpted his journey to greatness.

With the throwing hands of a sporting artist, Littler smiled and waved to the crowd, talking to them and himself throughout, in complete control of his own destiny.


Littler surpassed Van Gerwen’s record as the youngest darts world champion in history (James Fearn/Getty Images)

He didn’t just try to win, he tried to produce darts from the Gods while he was at it. He kept leaving himself on 170, darts’ biggest outshot to win a leg, which happened too frequently to not be deliberate. Darts players normally look pained when they miss a nine-darter (i.e. darting perfection of winning a leg with the smallest possible number of throws), but Littler just gave a nonchalant shrug when he missed the seventh dart like he knew he would get another chance.

A powerless Van Gerwen, the winner of 157 PDC (Professional Darts Corporation) titles, could only scowl and grimace like Dick Dastardly in a lime green shirt.

The Dutchman was once the youngest world champion, aged 24. The symbolism of a weighty dart-shaped baton being passed to the next generation here was irresistible.

Van Gerwen rallied, as champions do, clinging to Littler’s coattails as they swapped the next six sets, but it was never going to be enough in front of a deliriously partisan crowd, drunk on booze and throwing. He may give off the appearance of a combination of Bond villains, part Blofeld with his shiny bald head, part Jaws with a grille across his chops, but he could only play the bad guy for so long against a tidal wave of trebles and tons.

Littler was just too good. Whenever Van Gerwen came up for air, the teenager pushed him back underwater with one hand and hit double 10 with the other.

“Wow… wow,” Littler said to himself as he welled up having just hit double 16 to win 7-3, confirm the title and become £500,000 ($621,056 at current conversion rates) richer. He muttered “I can’t believe it” three times in his immediate post-match interview.

“At 2-0 up, I started getting nervous, but I said to myself, ‘Just relax’.

“That first game against Ryan Meikle, it’s the game that really mattered.”


Littler cried on stage after that second-round victory over Meikle before Christmas. He broke down, couldn’t finish an interview, left the stage and went to give his mum a hug.

On the train journey down to London earlier that day, he couldn’t wait for the match to start, but when he threw his first dart he basically, paraphrasing his own words, bottled it.

“I’ve never felt anything like that,” he later said after composing himself. “It was a weird feeling… it’s the biggest stage out there. It was probably the toughest game I’ve played.”

To prove his otherworldly nature, he had somehow produced the greatest set of darts ever seen in the history of the world championships at the end of that “toughest” match, averaging more than 140, but yes, he had started it like a glorified pub player by his own incredibly high standards.

“I’m thinking to myself; ‘What are you doing? Just relax’,” Littler said.


Littler during his walk out for the final against Michael van Gerwen at Alexandra Palace (James Fearn/Getty Images)

It’s no wonder, what with the enormous pressure on his young shoulders at being the favourite to lift the title aged just 17, a normal kid from Runcorn, a small town near Liverpool in the north-west of England, who eats kebabs and likes football.

Thereafter, throughout almost the whole tournament, he was imperious, reflecting the form that saw him rise from 164th to fourth in the world rankings last year.

Despite the unimaginable increase in money, fame, popularity and exposure, the 1.5 million Instagram followers, the endless television appearances and mixing it with Max Verstappen or his heroes at Manchester United, he stayed focused, winning 10 PDC titles, the Premier League, Grand Slam and World Series finals, plus hitting four perfect nine-darters along the way and earning more than £1million ($1.2m) in prize money.

He was the most searched athlete of the year on Google and the runner-up in the BBC Sports Personality of the Year award.

“Littler has captivated people because he’s relatable,” Sky Sports darts presenter Emma Paton told The Athletic earlier in the tournament. “He’s taken the sport to different places… Darts has never had this exposure before. It’s not even because of what he’s done in the sport, which has been ridiculous by the way, but it’s the impact he’s had on it.

“Compared to a lot of other sportspeople, darts players are refreshingly honest and are basically just being themselves and Luke is no different. He’s just a kid at the end of the day.

“People have asked me, ‘What’s it like speaking to Luke Littler? It doesn’t seem like he has loads to say’. I’m like, ‘He’s just very chilled out, he doesn’t really care that much, he’s just a 17-year-old kid’.”

Darts obsessive Littler plays exactly like that, like a kid having fun on the stage, ticking off his own personal bucket list of darting dreams.

He has an uncanny ability to detach himself completely from the enormity of the event, chat to the crowd, ignore his opponent and just play his own game, the old sporting cliche.

He relishes showing off the skills he’s honed over years of practice, expanding on the possibilities and limits that we thought the sport previously had. He tries irregular setup shots, he hits double-doubles or two bullseyes. He essentially takes the practice board to the world stage.

And then, when he needs to, a steely glint of determination emanates from his eyes and an unforgiving rhythm of 180s ensues. He can turn it on like few in the sport ever have before.


An emotional Littler reacts after winning the PDC World Championship (Ben Stansall/AFP via Getty Images)

“I sometimes say, every 17 years a star gets born,” a humbled Van Gerwen said. “He’s one of them… Every chance he got, every moment he had to hurt me, he did it.”

World champion, famous, a millionaire. What on earth next, other than impending adulthood?

“I just want to add to it, maybe get a few more,” Littler said. “If I want the 16 (Taylor’s record of world titles), then I’m sure I could possibly achieve it.

“I’ve been doing this since 18 months old on a magnetic board wearing a nappy.

“When I’d say to my mates I’ve got a darts competition, they’d be like, ‘Darts?!’ ‘Yeah, darts, have you not seen it?’”

They’re all seeing it now, thanks to an unassuming 17-year-old lad who can throw arrows like few ever have before.

(Top photo: Ben Stansall/AFP via Getty Images)

Organised crime, burners and cyber attacks: Inside Liverpool’s fight with ticket touts

A mother wipes away tears outside Anfield as she comforts her young son on a bitterly cold night.

Liz O’Driscoll, who has travelled to Merseyside from County Kerry in Ireland with eight-year-old Liam, has just been informed by Liverpool staff that the two tickets she bought for the Premier League game against Aston Villa are fake.

“We got to the scanner at the turnstiles and the light went red rather than green, so they sent us here to the ticket office,” she says. “I got them through the grapevine in Ireland. This fella said he knew someone who could sort it and put me in touch with him.

“I paid £200 through a banking app two months ago and the same day, he sent me the tickets via a link on a WhatsApp message. He talked me through how to save them into the wallet on my phone and other fans I showed them to on the bus earlier said they looked genuine.

“Now I’ve been told they’re duds. I’ve repeatedly tried ringing him but his phone is turned off. It makes me feel so cross. This is Liam’s first trip to Anfield and he’s been talking about nothing else for weeks. That’s why I’m so emotional.”


Liz O’Driscoll and her son Liam, who were the victims of a ticket-touting scam (James Pearce/The Athletic)

In the hour leading up to kick-off, there is a grim succession of similar tales from supporters who have been ripped off.

“I can’t believe this is happening,“ says Dylan Williams, who had driven for five hours from Porthcawl in South Wales with two friends after buying from a secondary ticketing site. “They just told me we’ve been scammed. I’m so gutted. £270 each down the drain. People who do this need to go to ****ing jail. They’re ruining people’s lives.”

A steward standing nearby in a fluorescent jacket shakes his head. “It used to be the case that you’d only see this type of thing when the really big games came along but now it’s happening every single home match,” he says. “It’s getting worse and worse.”

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

When fans visit Anfield for the first time: ‘It was hard to hold back the tears’


With Arne Slot’s Liverpool side top of the Premier League, leading the way in the Champions League and in the semi-finals of the Carabao Cup, there is a buzz of excitement around Anfield.

The redevelopment of the Anfield Road Stand may have lifted the stadium’s capacity beyond 60,000 last year but the demand for seats still far outstrips supply.

Liverpool have 28,000 season ticket holders and a further 11,000 tickets per game are hospitality seats. Visiting teams receive around 3,000 tickets, with the rest sold to members (who pay an annual fee of between £37 and £46) via a ballot.

The season ticket waiting list has been closed since 2017. Some of those who finally got the call when the redevelopment was complete had been on it for over 25 years.

With so many fans having little hope of obtaining general admission tickets through official channels, touts are capitalising as they illegally sell genuine tickets at hugely inflated prices. Others are fraudulently selling fake or cloned tickets, with Liverpool’s data showing that international supporters, many of whom are trying to visit Anfield for the first time, are being particularly targeted.


The redeveloped Anfield Road Stand has increased Liverpool’s capacity to over 60,000 (Nick Taylor/Liverpool FC/Liverpool FC via Getty Images)

The move from paper to digital tickets in recent years has arguably made it even easier for touts to operate as they no longer have to hang around Anfield on matchdays. Now, the touting operation has become an increasingly sophisticated, multi-million-pound operation, involving organised crime gangs both on Merseyside and further afield.

Liverpool discovered that gangs had been trying to infiltrate their ticket office by applying for jobs at Anfield and have also attempted to intimidate club employees in order to access tickets. In July and November 2024, online sales for members were subjected to sustained cyber attacks which were designed to illegally harvest tickets.

Now, Liverpool are fighting back. Last season, the club shut down close to 100,000 fake ticketing accounts following suspicious online activity, cancelled 1,500 tickets, and issued 47 lifetime bans and 136 indefinite suspensions.

So far this season, they have deactivated just under 20,000 ticketing accounts, cancelled 1,200 tickets, and issued 47 lifetime bans or indefinite suspensions. That final figure is expected to be a lot higher come May as a host of investigations continue.

Liverpool have three permanent members of staff dedicated to touting and sanctions regarding stadium and online behaviour. They are supplemented by a matchday touting response team of stewards.

Resources are being ploughed into data analysis which helps to flag anomalies when it comes to sales and distribution with greater verification checks on which accounts receive tickets.

Given the organised crime element, club staff leading the fight do not want to be named but some spoke to The Athletic under the condition of anonymity to lay bare the extent of the problem.

Liverpool are aware that a number of touts operate with burner phones rather than actually forwarding tickets to buyers. One scheme involves fans having to hand over their passport in return for a phone which has a ticket on. A post-match meeting point is then arranged for them to swap back.

Other touts are even more brazen and will actually scan buyers in at the turnstiles. They don’t want to forward tickets on as they would lose the credit for future sales.

As a result, it is difficult to put an accurate number on how many seats inside Anfield are being touted but club officials believe it runs into the thousands for each home game.


Since the Criminal Justice & Public Order Act in 1994, it has been illegal under UK law to sell or offer to sell tickets to football matches in England and Wales without the authorisation of the organisers. Liverpool work closely with Merseyside Police to seek criminal convictions for those caught doing so.

Prior to last month’s Premier League match against Manchester City at Anfield, a man suspected of being involved in ticket touting was stopped by officers outside the stadium and found to be in possession of around £2,800 in cash, which was seized. He has since been released under investigation as enquiries continue.


Police are alert to ticket touts operating around Anfield (Oli Scarff/AFP via Getty Images)

Chief Inspector Chris Barnes told The Athletic: “We will always take action to protect genuine fans who fall victim to touts when all they are trying to do is simply purchase tickets to support their team.

“Ticket touts want to exploit passionate fans to line their own pockets — and it won’t be tolerated by Merseyside Police. We believe the majority of ticket touts target visitors to the city who have little or no experience in purchasing tickets, so may not be aware that the prices they are paying are vastly inflated or that the way they have been sold is illegal.

“Ticket touts will also try to sell invalid or forged tickets, with fans turned away at the gates with no option to get their money back. Our activities to target touts operating both online and on matchdays will continue.

“Liverpool welcomes many thousands of tourists every year and we are determined to ensure that those who come to our city have a safe and enjoyable time protected from such fraud. Our advice to football supporters is clear: don’t buy from ticket touts.”

The club have been assisting with two major ongoing fraud investigations involving the sale of Liverpool tickets — one with Merseyside Police and another with North Yorkshire Police. The combined proceeds of those alleged frauds is estimated to be around £8million.

Conducting a test purchase with one website enabled Liverpool to establish who was behind it before they passed information on the police. It turned out those involved had set up hundreds of individual ticketing accounts within the club’s online systems.

There is a sense of frustration among club staff about the slow nature of the criminal justice system in the UK. They believe the sentencing guidelines do not act as a sufficient deterrent given the sums of money involved.

Last August, two Merseyside men, John Stuart and Greg O’Neill, were found guilty at Liverpool Crown Court for defrauding fans out of thousands of pounds prior to the Champions League final against Real Madrid in Paris in 2022. Stuart was jailed for eight months and O’Neill was given a two-year community order.

In October, John Gill, from the Liverpool suburb of Fazakerley, was sentenced to 17 weeks in prison after pleading guilty to selling two fake tickets outside Anfield prior to Jurgen Klopp’s farewell game against Wolverhampton Wanderers in May.

Liverpool are considering a change of tactic by going down the route of civil action in the form of asset recovery as they look to hit touts in the pocket.


One major headache for the club is secondary ticketing sites registered abroad, and therefore outside of the UK’s jurisdiction if tickets are fake.

A number of tickets for this Sunday’s meeting with Manchester United are being advertised on Madrid-based LiveFootballTickets.com. A seat in the Anfield Road Stand, with a face value of £50, is on sale for £349 — plus a ‘service fee’ of £104.70, the total cost comes to £453.70.

It is the same site that Dylan Williams and his two friends say they bought tickets from for Liverpool’s home game with Aston Villa in November. They paid £270 each but then learned that only one of the three tickets was genuine.

“We got sent a link which brings up this QR code on a members card,” explains Dylan’s friend David Davis. “It looks legit but the staff in the ticket office have told us they’re fakes. I’m furious. Someone has made some serious money off us. We’ll have to find a pub to watch the game instead.”


The fake ticket sold to Dylan, David and their friend, via a mobile phone app (James Pearce/The Athletic)

After being approached by The AthleticLiveFootballTickets.com said in a statement: “We can assure you that any tickets purchased with us are valid and genuine. We do not work with any ticket suppliers that provide fake tickets.

“We have been online for over 15 years, serving fans from all over the world. We have over 5,000 reviews on TrustPilot, with the vast majority being excellent.

“In the highly unlikely case you do not receive the tickets you ordered in time for the match or you have any problems with the tickets, and it’s the seller’s fault, we will refund 100 per cent of your money, plus we will offer you a credit worth 50 per cent of your original purchase towards another match. Every seller on our website is vetted and approved by us.”

Asked how they could justify tickets being sold at 10 times the face value, they added: “We are an online marketplace. We do not list any tickets, we allow other people to list tickets and set their own prices.

“Availability and prices are driven by market demand. They are not determined by LiveFootballTickets.”

Liverpool are regularly seeing apps that replicate the appearance of genuine tickets — fooling not just first-time visitors to Anfield.

There have been examples this season of fraudsters selling the same ticket up to a dozen times. The first of those fans to try to access the stadium gets in but for the others, there is just a sinking feeling as the red light flashes when their ticket is scanned at the turnstiles.

Liverpool have contacted social media companies in the hope they would help combat scams being run on their sites but they have shown little interest in joining the fight.

There is a dedicated page on the club website where fans are asked to report touting and the regular bulletins staff receive make heartbreaking reading. Earlier this season, a family of four flew over from Belfast for a child’s birthday and paid £800 per ticket. They were all fake. With the game completely sold out, there was nothing ticket office staff could do.

Liverpool have invested more funds in online security and put new tools in place.

They established that the sale of 500 £9 tickets for each home match to fans with an L postcode (a policy designed to help local fans access games) was getting “absolutely destroyed by touts”.

At times last season, there were up to 85,000 ‘people’ entering each of those ballots. Liverpool decided to change the rules so that the same payment card could not have more than four accounts attached to it. The number in the ballot for the next home game dropped to just 6,000 as life was made more difficult for the touts trying to hoover up tickets.


Liverpool are trying to ensure local fans get authentic tickets (Alex Livesey/Getty Images)

Now there is a two-day registration period before the local general sale, which gives the club’s data analysts the opportunity to assess who has signed up.

On the day that Slot’s side played Real Madrid in the Champions League in November, Liverpool cancelled 200 tickets which they believed had been accessed by touts with numerous accounts.

“Do you know how many of those affected contacted us to ask why? It was single figures,” reveals one staff member. “If I’m a genuine LFC fan and you’ve cancelled my ticket for Real Madrid, I’d be furious. Even those who got in touch asking what was going on, once we asked for some ID so we knew who we were talking to, they backed off and we didn’t hear anything else.”

Off the field, Liverpool have joined forces with Premier League rivals Manchester United, Chelsea and Arsenal in the fight against touting. Meetings have taken place this season with the sharing of data and information about what is working for each of them in terms of controls on accounts and online sales.

“We won’t eliminate touting but I believe we can get to a position where it’s marginal and we’ve got buy-in from senior executives with the resources to try to achieve that,” the Liverpool staff member adds. “A lot of things have to happen to get there but we have a duty to protect the wider fanbase.”

As for Liz O’Driscoll, having been conned out of £200, someone overheard her story and was able to sort out two tickets at face value for the game against Villa.

“I’m just so relieved for Liam,” she says. “He’s so happy he’s going into Anfield for the first time. I know other people sold fakes haven’t been as lucky.

“How do these people sleep at night having ripped people off?”

(Top photos: Getty Images; design: Eamonn Dalton)

2025 Pro Bowl Games rosters: Jayden Daniels, Sam Darnold headline first-time participants

Washington Commanders quarterback Jayden Daniels, Minnesota Vikings quarterback Sam Darnold and Las Vegas Raiders tight end Brock Bowers headline the list of first timers for the 2025 Pro Bowl Games, which the league announced Thursday.

The Baltimore Ravens lead all teams with nine Pro Bowl selections, while the Detroit Lions (seven players), Minnesota Vikings (six), Philadelphia Eagles (six), Dallas Cowboys (five) and Kansas City Chiefs (five) each placing at least five players on the roster.

The four teams without anyone making the Pro Bowl’s initial roster are the New York Jets, Miami Dolphins, New Orleans Saints and Tennessee Titans.

While he hasn’t participated in the Pro Bowl since 2021, as the Chiefs have won the last two Super Bowls, Kansas City quarterback Patrick Mahomes wasn’t selected for the first time in his seven years as a starter.

This year’s Pro Bowl Games will be held in Orlando, Fla., with the skills challenges occurring over two days at separate locations. The first part of the skills competition will happen in the Nicholson Fieldhouse on UCF’s campus on Jan. 30 and air at 7 p.m. ET on ESPN. The second part of the event, including the flag football game, will be at Camping World Stadium on Feb. 2. It will air on ESPN and ABC at 3 p.m. ET.

The NFL added a trivia element to this year’s skills competitions, which include traditional games of dodgeball and tug-of-war. “Passing the test” will have each quarterback answer five trivia questions about other Pro Bowlers from the 2024 season. Correct answers will give passers more time to attempt to hit targets.

Peyton and Eli Manning will coach the AFC and NFC teams again. The NFC defeated the AFC for the second straight year of the Pro Bowl Games in 2024.

Here’s a look at each conference’s initial rosters:

AFC

Offense

*Starter

Quarterback

  • Josh Allen, Buffalo Bills*
  • Joe Burrow, Cincinnati Bengals
  • Lamar Jackson, Baltimore Ravens

Running back

  • Derrick Henry, Baltimore Ravens*
  • Joe Mixon, Houston Texans
  • Jonathan Taylor, Indianapolis Colts

Fullback

  • Patrick Ricard, Baltimore Ravens*

Wide receiver

  • Ja’Marr Chase, Cincinnati Bengals*
  • Jerry Jeudy, Cleveland Browns*
  • Nico Collins, Houston Texans
  • Zay Flowers, Baltimore Ravens

Tight end

  • Brock Bowers, Las Vegas Raiders*
  • Travis Kelce, Kansas City Chiefs

Offensive tackle

  • Dion Dawkins, Buffalo Bills*
  • Laremy Tunsil, Houston Texans*
  • Rashawn Slater, Los Angeles Chargers

Offensive guard

  • Quenton Nelson, Indianapolis Colts*
  • Joe Thuney, Kansas City Chiefs*
  • Trey Smith, Kansas City Chiefs

Center

  • Creed Humphrey, Kansas City Chiefs*
  • Tyler Linderbaum, Baltimore Ravens

Defense

Defensive end

  • Myles Garrett, Cleveland Browns*
  • Trey Hendrickson, Cincinnati Bengals*
  • Maxx Crosby, Las Vegas Raiders

Interior linemen

  • Cameron Heyward, Pittsburgh Steelers*
  • Chris Jones, Kansas City Chiefs*
  • Nnamdi Madubuike, Baltimore Ravens

Outside linebacker

  • Nik Bonitto, Denver Broncos*
  • T.J. Watt, Pittsburgh Steelers*
  • Khalil Mack, Los Angeles Chargers

Inside/middle linebacker

  • Roquan Smith, Baltimore Ravens*
  • Zaire Franklin, Indianapolis Colts

Cornerback

  • Derek Stingley Jr., Houston Texans*
  • Patrick Surtain II, Denver Broncos*
  • Marlon Humphrey, Baltimore Ravens
  • Denzel Ward, Cleveland Browns

Free safety

  • Minkah Fitzpatrick, Pittsburgh Steelers*

Strong safety

  • Kyle Hamilton, Baltimore Ravens*
  • Derwin James, Los Angeles Chargers

Special teams

Long snapper

  • Ross Matiscik, Jacksonville Jaguars*

Punter

  • Logan Cooke, Jacksonville Jaguars*

Kicker

  • Chris Boswell, Pittsburgh Steelers*

Return specialist

  • Marvin Mims Jr., Denver Broncos*

Special teamer

  • Brenden Schooler, New England Patriots*

NFC

Offense

Quarterback

  • Jared Goff, Detroit Lions*
  • Jayden Daniels, Washington Commanders
  • Sam Darnold, Minnesota Vikings

Running back

  • Saquon Barkley, Philadelphia Eagles*
  • Jahmyr Gibbs, Detroit Lions
  • Josh Jacobs, Green Bay Packers

Fullback

  • Kyle Juszczyk, San Francisco 49ers

Wide receiver

  • Justin Jefferson, Minnesota Vikings*
  • Amon-Ra St. Brown, Detroit Lions*
  • CeeDee Lamb, Dallas Cowboys
  • Terry McLaurin, Washington Commanders

Tight end

  • George Kittle, San Francisco 49ers*
  • Trey McBride, Arizona Cardinals

Offensive tackle

  • Lane Johnson, Philadelphia Eagles*
  • Penei Sewell, Detroit Lions*
  • Tristan Wirfs, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Offensive guard

  • Landon Dickerson, Philadelphia Eagles*
  • Tyler Smith, Dallas Cowboys*
  • Chris Lindstrom, Atlanta Falcons

Center

  • Frank Ragnow, Detroit Lions*
  • Cam Jurgens, Philadelphia Eagles

Defense

Defensive end

  • Nick Bosa, San Francisco 49ers*
  • Micah Parsons, Dallas Cowboys*
  • Rashan Gary, Green Bay Packers

Interior linemen

  • Jalen Carter, Philadelphia Eagles*
  • Dexter Lawrence, New York Giants*
  • Vita Vea, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Outside linebacker

  • Jonathan Greenard, Minnesota Vikings*
  • Andrew Van Ginkel, Minnesota Vikings*
  • Jared Verse, Los Angeles Rams

Inside/middle linebacker

  • Fred Warner, San Francisco 49ers*
  • Zack Baun, Philadelphia Eagles

Cornerback

  • Jaylon Johnson, Chicago Bears*
  • Byron Murphy, Minnesota Vikings*
  • Jaycee Horn, Carolina Panthers
  • Devon Witherspoon, Seattle Seahawks

Free safety

  • Xavier McKinney, Green Bay Packers*

Strong safety

  • Budda Baker, Arizona Cardinals*
  • Brian Branch, Detroit Lions

Special teams

Long snapper

  • Andrew DePaola, Minnesota Vikings*

Punter

Kicker

  • Brandon Aubrey, Dallas Cowboys*

Return specialist

  • KaVontae Turpin, Dallas Cowboys*

Special teamer

  • KhaDarel Hodge, Atlanta Falcons*

Required reading

(Photo of Jayden Daniels: Lee Coleman / Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

Can a team led by Division II transfers become college hoops’ most dangerous mid-major?

KANSAS CITY, Mo. — Drake head coach Ben McCollum paced in the coaches’ locker room before speed-walking in to address his team.

His assistants had told him the players were a little quiet during warmups for the Wildcat Classic, a mid-December game against Kansas State in downtown Kansas City. Star point guard Bennett Stirtz attended the event they were about to play in as a fan a year ago. Isaiah Jackson, whose childhood home is 15 minutes from T-Mobile Center, had watched many games in the building but never stepped on the floor. When he walked through the tunnel for the first time, he took out his phone and captured the moment, then FaceTimed his parents after practice so they could see.

Stirtz and Jackson are two of the four starters who followed McCollum from Division II Northwest Missouri State when he was hired by Drake this offseason. They’d played in big games, but no environment like this. So McCollum decided to recycle a speech he’d given before the 2021 Division II national title game when he’d had a similar feeling.

“It’s always fascinating in these kinds of environments, what some people can do and what some people quite frankly can’t do, that they can do in a regular environment,” McCollum said.

He told his players to imagine there was a balance beam on the floor — four inches wide, five meters long. Could they walk across it? “Hell yeah you can,” he said.

Now raise it 10 feet in the air. You may think twice, but most could still make it.

Now what if it was 150 feet in the air?

“The same balance beam that you just told me you could walk across when it was on the ground because there was no repercussions to it, all of a sudden it lifts a little bit and you can’t walk across it anymore? Why?” McCollum asked. “Because you lost the ability to walk? No. You can still do that. Because you’re distracted by everything else around you.”

McCollum’s point: Block it out — the crowd, the noise — and just put one foot in front of the other.

A few hours later, the Bulldogs sprinted back into that locker room, knocking off a Big 12 team on a shot by Stirtz with 3.4 seconds left in overtime.

Drake opened 2025 as one of the final four undefeated teams in Division I, playing with a confidence reinforced by the results its leaders brought from the D-II ranks. The Bulldogs faced their first setback Wednesday, dropping their Missouri Valley Conference road opener 74-70 to UIC, but they’re off to a 12-1 start that no one saw coming, with three wins over high-major programs.

“They look good on film, but when you watch them in person, they’re even better,” said Vanderbilt coach Mark Byington, who called McCollum after Drake beat Vandy in November to ask if he’d get on a Zoom and talk through how he did it. “And what they’re better at in person is some details that you might not catch by watching film. And then when you see them in person, they hit every single detail.”

In 15 seasons at Northwest Missouri State, McCollum won 12 regular-season conference titles and four national titles. Long before he was coaching at their level, Division I coaches would mention that they’d been studying Northwest Missouri State’s offense. They expected McCollum to succeed in D-I, but not this much and this fast.

Meanwhile, McCollum’s players expect to win because they know McCollum is going to put them in the right places and always know exactly what to say.

“They’re a well-tuned machine,” Byington said. “I shook his hand after our game and told him this group can make a deep run in the (NCAA) Tournament. Not just win a game; they can make a run.”



McCollum won four D-II national championships at Northwest Missouri State, including three in a row. (Cody Scanlan / The Register / USA Today Network via Imagn Images)

Why did it take so long for McCollum to get a Division I job?

“I’m a slow trigger by nature,” McCollum said, “because I evaluate every decision quite a bit.”

In the last few years, McCollum was in the mix for several low- and mid-major openings, but he was always hesitant to move his family. Drake was a job he’d always eyed — he’s originally from Iowa, and it’s a program with a winning history in a strong league — but it still took him five days to accept after it was offered. “We had a good setup,” McCollum said. “And, you know, your culture doesn’t necessarily travel.”

That wasn’t necessarily true, because all it took to get three of his returning starters to go with him was one visit each to his office. If he were to go, would they come along? Stirtz, Jackson and Daniel Abreu said yes immediately.

Stirtz and Jackson both wanted their shot at D-I, too. They had the same two offers out of high school: William Jewell College and Northwest Missouri State.

Abreu, who did have two D-I offers in high school (Abilene Christian and Jacksonville), was ready for a challenge. “I was getting bored of the scouts after year two, playing the same teams over and over again,” Abreu said. “I can’t believe (McCollum) did it for that long.”

Those three yeses got McCollum off to a head start building the lineup he needed. Stirtz is the point guard who can do a little of everything; Jackson is the distributor and lockdown defender; the 6-6 Abreu plays with a physicality that allows him to guard up. McCollum had a big on the way in Cam Manyawu, a Wyoming transfer who followed assistant Bryston Williams to Drake.

The final piece needed was a shooter. McCollum had one at Northwest Missouri State but thought he was finished playing. Mitch Mascari had his MBA after five years in Maryville and had accepted a job as a credit analyst in asset management at First Trust Portfolios in Wheaton, Ill. He was supposed to start in two weeks, but after McCollum accepted the Drake job, Mascari started thinking maybe he too wanted his shot at D-I and put his name in the transfer portal on the final day it was open. McCollum called him right away, and Mascari asked McCollum what he thought he should do.

“Naturally, when you coach somebody for five years, you build up a level of trust and whatever probably opinion that I would have given him, he probably would have done it and listened,” McCollum said. “And so I couldn’t give him my opinion. I could just give him the positives and negatives of both. And then it was ultimately his decision to make and he chose to come and play.”

The one starter McCollum could not bring with him was Wes Dreamer, the conference player of the year who is now the leading scorer for a professional team in Germany. That meant McCollum had to do more teaching than his former Bearcats had witnessed before, and he had to rethink the team’s style of play.

Making this hot start even more unlikely is the possibility that McCollum may have as little depth as he’s ever had. Mascari has played every minute in five of the 13 games. Stirtz has come off the floor twice in the 11 games against D-I opponents — both in the final minute of comfortable wins over Stephen F. Austin and Belmont.

The offense is built around getting Mascari 3s and Stirtz a gap to drive, with Abreu making the occasional 3 and always looking for openings to cut. Whichever big is on the floor is a roller/cutter, and Jackson distributes while also providing timely drives or cuts to the basket. The former Bearcats have found in D-I that sometimes it takes more time to find a quality look, but they will exhaust every opportunity to get a great shot.

“We have to move it,” McCollum said. “All five guys have to connect to be able to create windows and avenues, to be able to get to the paint and get below the defense. We’ve had to invest in five or six different ways, where it’s just like if they guard this, then we have to go to this and this and that.”

Jackson says the difference between Division II and Division I is that these big schools play at a quicker pace and take “early, average shots.” McCollum has always believed that to beat good teams, you’re going to have to score against a set defense.

“We play a slower tempo because we don’t take bad shots, and we won’t take bad shots,” McCollum said. “We refuse to take them. And so it naturally slows the game down.”

McCollum’s players always feel like they have the answers to the test, and the coach has always been willing to scrap plans if the opponent throws a curveball. The offense is like a decision tree.

“A lot of our offense is predicated on how the defense reacts,” Mascari said. “So if a defense is reacting in a different way than we anticipated, we’re just going to do something else. Sometimes we’re walking down the floor, and we have no idea what we’re about to do. So how is the defense supposed to?”

Drake may lead the country in shot clock violations, which is part of the reason Drake is turning the ball over at one of the worst rates in college basketball — 20.5 percent of its possessions against D-I competition. The Bulldogs would rather run out the clock than take a mediocre shot, and they stay composed when the seconds tick away late in a possession. Against Vandy, they had three shot clock violations. “That never fazed them,” Byington said, noting Drake also made three late-clock 3s.

Defensively, the Bulldogs seem to rarely ever make a mistake, and McCollum is meticulous in demonstrating how to guard every action they will see, from the footwork to body position to where to be on the floor. He gives his players easy cues to remember.

“It’s not really what you know,” McCollum said. “It’s what they can comprehend and then execute.”

This may be the most impressive stat for Drake this season: Without one player taller than 6-8 in the rotation, Drake ranks 15th nationally in defensive rebounding rate and 17th in offensive rebounding rate. After getting out-rebounded by Stephen F. Austin in its first game against a Division I opponent, the Bulldogs have won the battle of the boards every game since. That aspect of this start astonishes even McCollum.

“They’re just destroying people on the boards,” McCollum said. “Defensive rebounding, we’ve always been No. 1 in the country (in Division II). Offensive rebounding, we’ve just been physical. We just go get the ball. Little chip on our shoulder.”


Three years ago Northwest Missouri State entered the season as the defending national champs with four starters returning. The Bearcats had gone 97-3 the previous three seasons. It was star guard Trevor Hudgins’ senior season.

And McCollum wanted them to fail.

Every preseason he puts his team through an exhausting conditioning test. Every player has to run 20 line drills and 20 down-and-backs in 20 minutes. You have to do both in one-minute windows and can’t start again until the beginning of each minute. If you don’t pass, you try again the next day. Before the test three years ago, the Bearcats had a hard lift — squats and resistance bands. They were being set up to fail.  “Our legs were done,” Jackson said.

Jackson was the only player who made time, but McCollum still made him run the next day with all of his teammates because he wanted to see them all pass it together.

“They need to teach themselves to respond,” McCollum said. “You don’t just respond to failure well. You’ve got to develop that habit through failing and then figuring out the response to it.”

Against K-State, Drake found failure. After leading 29-9 early, K-State started to chip away late in the first half, going on a 14-2 run. “That crowd popped,” Stirtz leaned over to tell Mascari at halftime.

Mascari had been on fire, making all six of his 3s in the first half. But K-State mostly took him away in the second half, face-guarding him and Stirtz. Midway through the half, K-State sharpshooter Brendan Hausen got a clean look for the first time and buried it to tie the game. It felt like K-State was in control, with Drake looking tired and hopeless in the half court.

With 23.9 seconds left, Abreu went to the free-throw line, the Bulldogs’ first loss looming if he missed. During the under-16 timeout of the second half, Drake had broken its huddle early, and Abreu was joking with a security lady stationed at the free-throw line. McCollum affectionately calls him Buddy the Elf because he’s always in a good mood. A day earlier, Abreu said that he never watches basketball — he prefers movies — and his ignorance of the basketball world is a gift. “The nerves aren’t there because I just don’t know,” he said.

He buried both free throws to force overtime.

“They’re tough. I mean they’ll outlast ya,” McCollum said. “That’s the thing, like there’s a level of toughness. There’s a level of outlast. There’s a level of, you know, who’s going to take it further? And we’ve just tried to train them to be able to create those habits to take it a little bit further and fight a little bit more.”

In overtime, Stirtz found the little bit more.

He scored five of Drake’s first seven points in OT, and after K-State’s Coleman Hawkins buried a 3 with 12.3 seconds left to tie the game, Stirtz got the inbound pass and calmly jogged the ball up the floor. Drake set up with all four teammates lined up on the baseline and let Stirtz go to work. Stirtz crossed over, got Hausen on his heels and buried the game-winner.

That was a response.



Stirtz and the Bulldogs have been undaunted by high-major competition so far. (Jay Biggerstaff / Imagn Images)

The hero returned to his locker stall and sat. He leaned back, hands on his lap and stared straight ahead in a daze.

Stirtz is a K-State fan. His grandparents are football season-ticket holders. Both his older brothers went to K-State, and his younger brother plans to enroll there next year. His mom wore a K-State shirt under her Drake shirt in support of Stirtz’s girlfriend, a K-State dancer who watched his game winner from the opposite baseline. In high school, Stirtz sent his film to K-State coaches. Once he got his Northwest Missouri State offer, the only ones he would have considered were Division I offers. Those never came. When Stirtz committed to the Bearcats, McCollum told friends he thought he’d stolen one.

Byington marveled at how Stirtz and the three other former Bearcats ever ended up at that level: “Those guys are probably starters on most SEC teams.”

Hyperbole? Maybe. But not with Stirtz. He’s so good that NBA scouts are starting to take notice. And college basketball is taking notice of the Bulldogs. They were picked fifth in the Missouri Valley in the preseason coaches’ poll. They were projected to win the league before Wednesday’s loss at UIC, according to Ken Pomeroy’s metrics, and nationally they’ve been on the verge of getting ranked. In this week’s Associated Press poll, they received the second-most votes among teams outside the Top 25.

Stirtz is as unassuming a star as you’ll find. He never celebrates a made bucket. He’s quiet off the floor. But in that overtime, Stirtz wanted the ball and he wasn’t going to let the Bulldogs lose. Against the school he had dreamed of playing for, Stirtz realized the fact that he was being face-guarded meant the Wildcats didn’t think they could guard him, and he started to believe it himself.

“I ain’t one for individual s—,” McCollum told his team once he got to the celebratory locker room, “but damn, that’s a big shot.”

Then McCollum reminded his players of the satisfaction of what they’d just accomplished. He nearly went into the next challenge, before catching himself, “I’m not even going to ruin the moment,” he said. “Let’s just get our prayer and get out of here.”

The Bulldogs knelt, and Abreu delivered the perfect line. “Dear Heavenly Father, thank you for Bennett.”

Stirtz then headed to the news conference, where he informed the media that his game winner was the first buzzer beater of his life. Technically, there were still those 3.4 seconds on the clock, but that’s just about the only flaw in this script, which somehow keeps getting better.

(Photo: Mitchell Layton / Getty Images)

Tom Brady walks away, WNBA ratings soar, and ESPN snags CP3: 2025 Sports Media Predictions

The famous wrestler Sting, in describing his character change in 1996 from a clear babyface to a darker, enigmatic character, offered the perfect axiom about predicting the future. Noted the Stinger: “The only thing that’s for sure about Sting is nothing’s for sure.”

This would be the same for sports media. There are some trends that look obvious (increased investment in women’s sports media; legacy media consolidation and layoffs; Netflix becoming a bigger sports player; more media leaning into sports betting revenue), but who knows? Still, we bring you some guesses for 2025.

1. Tom Brady will walk away from broadcasting before the start of the 2025 NFL season

I’ve previously said I’d put down big money that Brady will not finish his 10-year, $375 million contract with Fox, given all his various business interests away from broadcasting, including ownership. That remains true. The safer prediction would be that Brady walks away from his Fox deal after three or four years. But I’m going bold and saying Brady gets deeper involved with the Las Vegas Raiders in the offseason and decides to go all in with NFL ownership and his production company by the start of the next NFL season.

2. WNBA viewership will go up in 2025

This isn’t a moment for women’s sports; it’s been a movement for some time. Game 5 of the WNBA Finals — a 67-62 overtime thriller won by the New York Liberty — averaged 2.15 million viewers, the most-viewed WNBA Finals game in 25 years. The finals averaged 1.6 million viewers, up 115 percent over last season. It capped a fantastic year of viewership for the league — and this is where we absolutely mention that the catalyst for the viewership explosion was interest in Caitlin Clark. Overall, there were 32 WNBA television windows among its media partners that topped 1 million viewers during the 2024 season, including the WNBA Draft. That crushed the previous record of 15.

Beginning with the 2026 season, you’ll see new partners NBC and Amazon Prime Video as part of a long-term TV rights deal, and you should expect them to invest serious marketing dollars. Under the new agreements, Disney, NBC and Amazon will distribute more than 125 regular-season and playoff games nationally each season, including a minimum of 25 regular-season games on Disney platforms, 50 regular-season games on NBCUniversal platforms and 30 regular-season games on Amazon Prime Video. The league will also get a bump from a new franchise (Golden State Valkyries) and more offseason exposure for star players thanks to the new 3-on-3 women’s basketball league, Unrivaled, launching in January 2025.

Clark’s star will continue to rise, and if you think bad-faith actors knocking her for culture-war points are going to have an impact on viewership, I’d refer you to those who predicted NFL viewership was forever done. It’s arrow up for the WNBA.

3. ESPN Flagship will be an immediate hit

ESPN’s direct-to-consumer streaming service, code-named “Flagship,” will allow consumers to access the entire suite of ESPN networks without a traditional pay-TV subscription. That includes the full programming lineup of ESPN+ and what currently airs on linear ESPN. There will also be integration with ESPN Fantasy and ESPN Bet. Reports indicate a starting price of between $25 and $30 per month, and the price point is what I think will attract consumers initially. I think early subscriber numbers will exceed expectations, especially given recent big increases at YouTube TV.

The research firm MoffettNathanson, which provides trends in media, communications and technology to institutional investors, put out a note this month projecting that “after an initial investment of $75 million in FY (fiscal year) 2025 to get the service up and running (anticipating a launch at the tail end of FY 2025 in time for the start of the NFL season), we project an initial one million paid subscribers in FY 2026, driving subscription revenues of just over $200 million and ad revenues of $20 million.” I predict that number is higher by FY 2026.

4. Kevin Harlan will call NBA games for Amazon Prime Video

Ian Eagle has an agreement in place as one of Amazon’s lead broadcasters, and I predict Harlan joins him. A 1-2 game-calling combination featuring Eagle and Harlan will give the streamer massive instant credibility in the live-game space.

5. ESPN will opt out of its current MLB contract after the 2025 season

This is probably as close to a layup prediction as it gets. MoffettNathanson said opting out could save Disney/ESPN as much as $600 million in expenses, although most expect a restructured contract. Will ESPN get local games for Flagship?

6. UFC will be split between ESPN and Netflix

No inside intel from me — just a guess that UFC ends up echoing WWE and lands with both Disney and Netflix for its product. And thus begins Netflix going in big on sports rights.


The UFC’s Dana White will be looking for — and getting, according to Richard Deitsch’s prediction — huge media deals in 2025. (Steve Marcus / Getty Images)

7. ESPN finally commits to a dedicated women’s basketball daily studio show during the WNBA season

You have a transcendent audience draw in Clark, a litany of interesting All-Stars from A’ja Wilson to Kelsey Plum and an appetite for storylines both on and off the court. If ESPN wants the credit for building women’s basketball in America, as it always does, this isn’t even up for discussion given the multiple outlets it has. If this isn’t something that exists next year, the network should be crushed for it.

8. The Pac-12 will land at least one name-brand media company for its media rights

In November, the Pac-12 announced that Octagon will serve as the agency of record to guide the conference through the media-rights landscape. That signals to me that someone with some weight is going to bite, and I’ll take a flier that it will be WBD Sports, whose 2024 was defined by losing rights to the NBA on TNT. The 2026-27 season has Boise State, Colorado State, Fresno State, Gonzaga, San Diego State and Utah State joining Oregon State and Washington State. The league needs one more football-playing school to reach the threshold to remain recognized as a conference within the FBS division.

9. ESPN rents an active player or coach for the NBA Finals

It’s been clear for some time that ESPN management does not want a two-person booth for its NBA Finals coverage. It’s also clear that the network desires a notable name (e.g., Milwaukee Bucks coach Doc Rivers) to sell on the marquee.

Who could that be? My colleague Andrew Marchand posited in this piece in June that ESPN should already be courting the likes of LeBron James or Steph Curry in the event they would ever consider broadcasting. That’s an interesting long-term play. What I think is very likely for 2025 is someone such as Chris Paul becoming a guest game analyst for the Finals. Longtime NBA coach Monty Williams would also be an interesting one-off.

(Top photo: Michael Reaves / Getty Images)

Boise State wasn’t exposed in Fiesta Bowl loss, but College Football Playoff seeding was

GLENDALE, Ariz. — There were two Boise States on the field on New Year’s Eve.

One was a conference champion living out a dream season. A team carried to the College Football Playoff on the back of star running back Ashton Jeanty, and a storied program atop the Group of 5 conferences once more.

The other Boise State was an outmanned G5 roster putting forth a valiant but futile effort against a better and more talented Penn State squad.

Both versions coexisted in No. 3 Boise State’s 31-14 loss to No. 6 Penn State in the Playoff quarterfinals at the Fiesta Bowl on Tuesday night. The first deserves to be celebrated. The latter provided Big Ten runner-up Penn State a seemingly easier path to the semifinals than Big Ten champion and No. 1 seed Oregon or SEC champion and No. 2 seed Georgia, and will further fuel the narrative that an imperfectly expanded Playoff needs to adjust its seeding format as soon as possible.

For Broncos fans, and those inclined to root for Cinderella, a disappointing and frustrating performance won’t diminish a magical run. No, Jeanty did not break Barry Sanders’ single-season rushing record, coming up 27 yards shy in his lowest rushing output of the season. No, the sport’s preeminent underdog couldn’t pull off yet another Fiesta Bowl upset, on the same field that hosted the program’s defining victories. But 2024 will go down as one of the most memorable seasons in the history of Boise State football.

“I’m so proud of this team. It didn’t go our way tonight, but they re-established the standard in Boise to be a light on the hill, to the country, that had been lost for a little bit,” said head coach Spencer Danielson. “That’s a legacy that can never be taken from them.”

For the other CFP teams that weren’t on the field Tuesday, or fans of college football at-large — an admittedly hard-to-satisfy lot — the matchup underscored a crucial flaw in a system meant to reward conference champions, but designed before realignment thinned the Power 5 to a top-heavy Power 4.

The fault in this Playoff formula, with byes going to the four highest-ranked conference champions, was obvious well before the teams were splashed across ESPN on Selection Sunday, including ninth-ranked Boise State jumping all the way to the No. 3 seed courtesy of a Mountain West championship. It created a bracket where No. 1 Oregon is set to face sixth-ranked Ohio State, which is seeded eighth, and No. 2 Georgia meets fifth-ranked Notre Dame, which is seeded seventh, on New Year’s Day.

Those who understood the format have been warning of these unintended consequences for months. But seeing is believing, and Penn State drove that reality home in the Fiesta Bowl as the fourth-ranked team but No. 6 seed against the ninth-ranked but No. 3 seed Broncos. In a multi-billion-dollar tournament that was years in the making, it was simple negligence (or maybe stubbornness?) that allowed a higher-ranked but lower-seeded team to enter a neutral site, national championship quarterfinal as an 11.5-point favorite — a game the Nittany Lions ultimately won by 17.

“Obviously tonight, we didn’t execute the way we needed to, to win a heavyweight fight like we knew this was going to be,” Danielson said.


Boise State committed four turnovers and 13 penalties. (Mark J. Rebilas / Imagn Images)

Boise State wasn’t a charity case. It outgained Penn State 412 yards to 387, and plenty of its problems — including 13 penalties for 90 yards — were self-inflicted. But a Broncos team that lost only eight turnovers all season committed four on Tuesday, and it benefitted from an opponent that played with its food for the better part of three quarters. Penn State led from wire to wire, and outside of the lead briefly being cut to 17-14 early in the second half, the Nittany Lions felt in control the entire way.

“I think the Big Ten has prepared our guys,” Penn State coach James Franklin said. “Boise is a really good football team. … We were not taking them lightly. We talk about the maturity of our football team — I think that shows up.”

go-deeper

The loss isn’t an indictment of Boise State, or the 12-win season that preceded it. And this isn’t the same debate as those kvetching about Indiana and SMU earning at-large bids. There is no good-faith argument that the Broncos didn’t deserve a Playoff spot and a chance to compete for a national title.

This team exemplified the bigger-tent approach this sport has desperately lacked for decades. The same praises and criticisms that elevated Boise also apply to No. 4 seed Arizona State out of the Big 12, which was slotted 12th in the final CFP rankings and will play third-ranked and No. 5 seed Texas in Wednesday’s Peach Bowl. But the Broncos had the first crack at proving the doubters wrong, validating their “Please count us out” T-shirts. Instead, they left it even harder to justify a system that made the No. 5 and 6 seeds — and losing a conference championship — look more advantageous than the top two spots.

Boise State has nothing to apologize for. Offensive coordinator Dirk Koetter acknowledged to The Athletic last week that the Playoff’s seeding system will likely be changed, perhaps as early as next season. But it’s not as if the Broncos orchestrated or exploited the system.

“We didn’t make those (bye) rules,” Koetter said. “I’m smart enough to realize we might not be the third-best team, but we definitely deserve to be in there.”

Danielson echoed that sentiment after the game on Tuesday, just as the clock struck midnight back on the East Coast, ringing in the new year. College football in 2025 is better for having an expanded Playoff, widening the path to compete for a national title. Boise State earned its entry to that path this season, just like SMU and Penn State and Georgia and every other team in the field. That shouldn’t change moving forward.

Even if — at the same time, on the same field — Boise State was also the reason that path is bound to look a little different the next time the Broncos get there.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

‘This is jubilation’: Penn State relishes Fiesta Bowl win as Playoff charge continues

(Top photo of Ashton Jeanty: Christian Petersen / Getty Images)

Which team has the best front office in ‘big four’ leagues? Execs vote on their peers

Which front office is the best in sports?

In 2024, the answer to that question is the Oklahoma City Thunder, followed by the Los Angeles Dodgers and the Baltimore Ravens. At least according to their front-office peers.

At the start of each season this year, The Athletic polled 40 executives and coaches in each of the four major leagues — MLB, NBA, NFL and NHL — and asked them to rank the top five front offices, in order, in their respective sport. We polled the same number of executives and coaches (40) each time and used the same scoring system to rank front offices: First-place votes were worth 10 points, second-place seven, third-place five, fourth-place three and fifth-place one.

The Athletic then published the front-office rankings from the various leagues throughout 2024.

While there are slight differences in the number of teams in the four leagues — MLB and the NBA have 30 teams while the NHL and NFL have 32 teams — and varying sizes of front offices across the leagues, the scoring system offers an opportunity to make an apples-and-oranges comparison of front offices across different sports based on how their peers rated them.

In other words: This isn’t a scientific comparison of these front offices, but rather a ranking of which ones are viewed as the best by their direct competitors.

1. Oklahoma City Thunder

Total points: 354 points (29 first-place votes)
Governor: Clayton Bennett
General manager: Sam Presti
Head coach: Mark Daigneault

It’s one thing to be crowned the winner of this inaugural front-office “competition,” but this was a landslide victory for Sam Presti and his staff. So, why all the league-wide adulation for the job they do?

For starters, Presti — who learned under R.C. Buford and Gregg Popovich in San Antonio before taking over this front office during the Seattle SuperSonics days in 2007 — has long since proven himself to be an elite hoops architect. Building those Kevin Durant-Russell Westbrook teams (with James Harden early on) through the draft back in the day established that much. And his lack of a championship, quite clearly, was not seen by his peers as a disqualifier in this exercise.

But this latest Thunder creation is capable of two things that are typically impossible to accomplish at the same time: Title contention and (extreme) flexibility for the future. The master stroke that made it all possible — the July 2019 trade with the LA Clippers that brought Shai Gilgeous-Alexander, five first-round picks and two first-round swaps to town in exchange for Paul George — set the stage for what could be a very long run of success. The choice to make Mark Daigneault the head coach in November 2020, when he was elevated from their G League team after five years running that program, has been a hit.

The Basketball 100

The story of the greatest players in NBA history. In 100 riveting profiles, top basketball writers justify their selections and uncover the history of the NBA in the process.

The story of the greatest plays in NBA history.

BuyBuy The Basketball 100

Along the way, the Thunder have amassed a collection of draft picks that is unrivaled in all the Association (13 first-round picks through 2030 and 17 guaranteed second-round picks in all). The timing of this particular strategy is quite perfect, as the structure of the league’s latest collective bargaining agreement is such that the value of draft picks are at an all-time high. As one rival executive pointed out, Presti was as close to that negotiating process as anyone before the CBA’s ratification in April 2023 and clearly knew prioritizing picks was paramount in this era.

“OKC, they’re so well positioned, Jesus Christ, for the next five years,” one assistant GM said.

Even with this loaded collection of talent, in other words, they have the assets to keep adding. Presti isn’t a one-man show, though, as he relies heavily on a front-office group that also includes former Orlando Magic general manager Rob Hennigan, Jesse Gould (in his 16th season with the organization) and Wynn Sullivan (in his 13th season with the Thunder).

2. Los Angeles Dodgers

Total points: 284 (19 first-place votes)
Chairman: Mark Walter
President of baseball operations: Andrew Friedman
Manager: Dave Roberts

When Andrew Friedman left Tampa Bay for Los Angeles in the fall of 2014, he inherited a treasure trove of talent from Ned Colletti. Almost all those stars are gone a decade later, except for Clayton Kershaw. So are Farhan Zaidi, Alex Anthopoulos and Gabe Kapler, who acted as Friedman’s primary lieutenants in those early years. The organization remains a juggernaut, with Friedman now supplemented by general manager Brandon Gomes, assistant general managers Jeff Kingston and Alex Slater, and longtime advisor Josh Byrnes.

Friedman set a lofty goal for the franchise upon his arrival: He wanted this time to become known as “the golden era” of Dodger baseball. The team has never missed the postseason since he took over. The group has won two World Series in addition to winning the National League pennant in two other seasons. The acquisition of Shohei Ohtani has transformed the franchise into a financial behemoth.

One executive described a first-place vote for the Dodgers as “self-explanatory. They are elite at everything.” Billy Gasparino, the scouting director recently promoted to vice president of baseball operations, has drafted well despite picking in the latter half of the first round every summer. The farm system continues to churn out prospects. The roster tends to be well-managed. Friedman often corrects big-league deficiencies with midseason acquisitions; the stars he has acquired at the deadline include Max Scherzer, Trea Turner and Manny Machado.

“One of the things he does so well is knowing which stars to sign,” another executive said. With the notable exception of Trevor Bauer, Friedman has aced that assignment in recent years by landing Mookie Betts, Freddie Freeman and Ohtani. In part, another executive explained, that stems from the front office’s “insane discipline,” not wasting resources on mid-tier players so that when a star becomes available, the team can pounce.

“Andrew,” another executive said, “is the best at this.”

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

What are the Top 10 front offices in MLB? Here’s how 40 executives voted

3. Baltimore Ravens

Total points: 259 (15 first-place votes)
Owner: Steve Bisciotti
General manager: Eric DeCosta
Head coach: John Harbaugh

It’s been more than five years since Ozzie Newsome stepped down as Baltimore’s GM. His disciples have kept the Ravens in contention nearly every year since.

Eric DeCosta, who was a player personnel intern for the Ravens’ inaugural season in 1996 and has been with the organization ever since, took the reins from Newsome in 2019, and Baltimore’s 56 victories over his first five seasons were tied for the third-most in the league.

DeCosta handled quarterback Lamar Jackson’s complicated contract situation, working past a trade request to execute a five-year, $260 million extension in 2023. Jackson then won his second MVP award last season.

From a talent acquisition standpoint, DeCosta has steered the Ravens toward the trade for linebacker Roquan Smith, has a strong track record in the first (safety Kyle Hamilton, wide receiver Zay Flowers) and middle rounds (defensive tackle Nnamdi Madubuike, tight end Isaiah Likely), landed a priority free agent in running back Derrick Henry and created an environment where a veteran like linebacker Kyle Van Noy can thrive. Of course, those are just a handful of examples.

DeCosta also got out in front of the potential loss of receiver Hollywood Brown, flipping him and a third-rounder to the Arizona Cardinals for a first-round pick that netted center Tyler Linderbaum.

“Consistency,” an NFC executive said of what makes the Ravens’ front office so good. “They know what a Raven is and understand how to win with those guys.”

That’s a common refrain when discussing DeCosta and his staff. They recognize the types of players and people who will be successful in their program, and they’re certainly aided by the fact that head coach John Harbaugh has manned the sidelines since 2008. All involved know what to expect from one another.

The Ravens’ influence can be felt in many buildings across the NFL. Current general managers Joe Hortiz (Los Angeles Chargers) and Joe Douglas (New York Jets) have experience under Newsome, the architect of Baltimore’s two Super Bowl winners and someone commonly referred to as the best GM in history. Chicago Bears assistant general manager Ian Cunningham, considered a likely future GM, also worked for Newsome.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

What are the Top 10 front offices in NFL? Here’s how 40 executives and coaches voted

Total points: 258 (12 first-place votes)
Owner: Stuart Sternberg
President of baseball operations: Eric Neander
Manager: Kevin Cash

No roof? No problem. The Rays excel at adaptation.

When the Rays first emerged as a low-budget marvel in the late 2000s, the franchise relied on the leadership structure of owner Stu Sternberg, president Matt Silverman and general manager Andrew Friedman. Friedman departed in 2014. The collection of future decision-makers he hired includes Chaim Bloom, James Click, Matt Arnold, Peter Bendix and Erik Neander. Only Neander remains with the Rays, occupying Friedman’s former chair as the head of baseball operations.

Despite the turnover, the Rays continue to innovate and regenerate. The team has won 90 or more games in four of the past five full seasons and reached the World Series in the pandemic-shortened 2020 campaign. The roster has cycled through stars like Evan Longoria, David Price and Blake Snell. The franchise competes so consistently, on such a small budget, that one executive said it was obvious why rival owners reach into the Rays’ front office when making hires.

“You look at owners around baseball and what do they want? They want the intellectual property of the Rays,” the executive said. “It’s almost too attractive: ‘We can win without spending anything.’ But they constantly acquire undervalued guys, they get the most out of their players and they make the tough decisions.”

Sternberg may not make splashes in free agency, but the Rays do support a robust scouting department. Those scouts help the club make good choices when evaluating other clubs. Neander’s willingness to deal quality players pains him — it is also what keeps his club competitive. One executive described the Rays as “the scariest team in the league to trade with. Have developed well, great pro scouting department and very good at roster building. The pieces always make sense together on their major-league team.”

Total points: 251 (17 first-place votes)
Owner: Tom Gaglardi
President and CEO: Brad Alberts
GM: Jim Nill
Head coach: Peter DeBoer

When you see a team get nearly half the first-place votes, you think dynasty. The Stars have been to the Western Conference final three of the past five years and lost the 2020 Stanley Cup Final, so they are anything but a dynasty. What they have done well in 11 seasons with Jim Nill at the helm is make targeted draft moves and signings with a development system that may have overtaken Tampa Bay’s as the gold standard in the NHL. The Stars have picked higher than 12th just once in the past 10 years, and yet their lineup is filled with homegrown talent. And that one high pick, Miro Heiskanen (No. 3 in 2017), might be the most underrated player in the league.

Another aspect of Nill’s front office is how he deals with his fellow executives. Class still goes a long way in this league. “Everything they do is right and smart,” one senior adviser said. “And a lot is relationships because Jim may be the most respected GM in the league.”

“Jim’s a quiet guy,” a GM added. “Very rare do you read anything about him, but at the draft, I was looking at his table and I couldn’t believe all the people he’s surrounded himself with. Every one of them is good hockey people.

“You know, no one person can do this job. And if somebody tells you that, then their ego’s too big. Jim’s got no ego. A gentleman.”

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

What are the NHL’s Top 10 front offices? Here’s how 40 executives voted


Brad Stevens, president of basketball operations for the Boston Celtics, before Game 7 of the 2022 NBA Playoffs Eastern Conference Semifinals (Jesse D. Garrabrant / NBAE via Getty Images)

Total points: 250 points (9 first-place votes)
Governor: Wyc Grousbeck
President of basketball operations: Brad Stevens
Head coach: Joe Mazzulla

Brad Stevens has only been in charge for three full seasons since he moved up from the sideline to replace Danny Ainge, but the rest of the Celtics’ organizational infrastructure has been there roughly forever, including vice president of basketball operations Mike Zarren and assistant general managers Austin Ainge and Dave Lewin. The Celtics may have built their team on the elder Ainge’s 2013 swindle of the Brooklyn Nets that yielded the draft picks that became Jayson Tatum and Jaylen Brown, but it was Boston’s more recent work to build around those two under Stevens that won great admiration.

Stevens-era trades for Kristaps Porziņģis, Al Horford, Derrick White and Jrue Holiday established a championship nucleus around the Brown-Tatum core without breaking the bank in terms of asset costs. Finding Sam Hauser on the post-draft scrap heap and Payton Pritchard at the end of the first round extended their talent base. And when Ime Udoka was suspended and then let go, they pivoted quickly to a high-potential internal candidate (Joe Mazzulla), even though he hadn’t been a head coach before, and hit that hire out of the park.

As a result, the Celtics are the defending champions and well-positioned to make another run this spring. However, the team is for sale, so potential ownership change looms over the future; the roster is also about to get extremely expensive if the Celtics keep everyone, so tough decisions lie ahead.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

What are the Top 10 front offices in NBA? Here’s how 40 executives voted

7. Tampa Bay Lightning

Total points: 187 (9 first-place votes)
Owner: Jeff Vinik (sale in progress to Doug Ostrover)
GM: Julien BriseBois
Head coach: Jon Cooper

Any team with back-to-back Cups and three straight Final appearances within the past five years is going to garner praise. Julien BriseBois and his staff have made some incredibly hard decisions in recent seasons to try to keep the Lightning at an elite level — letting Steven Stamkos walk this summer was one of the toughest — and Tampa Bay, despite predictions to the contrary, has been able to keep its lineup fresh and in the hunt.

The BriseBois-Jon Cooper connection helps too — the longest-tenured GM-coach combination in the league.

“They’ve been out ahead of the pack for so long and keep evolving,” one assistant GM said. “They aren’t afraid to make mistakes and try again. That’s why they haven’t lagged behind.”

“They’re progressive,” another AGM said. “They use their geographical advantages to their advantage. They’re bold. And they’ve had success.”

And then there’s this comment from a GM that sums up what the Lightning are about: “Winning Cups. That’s what we’re in the business for.”

Total points: 174 (13 first-place votes)
Owner: Clark Hunt
General manager: Brett Veach
Head coach: Andy Reid

Andy Reid and Brett Veach are a formidable 1-2 punch for the two-time defending Super Bowl champions. Veach, who began his career as a coaching intern under Reid with Philadelphia in 2004, followed his mentor to Kansas City. Veach played a significant role in the decision to draft Patrick Mahomes in 2017 (under then-GM John Dorsey, whom he succeeded weeks after that draft). Veach rebuilt the offensive line and armed defensive coordinator Steve Spagnuolo with a talented young defense that ranked among the top 10 in scoring defense four of the past five years.

“Veach grew up around Andy, so I think there is a very clear vision on what types of players they’re looking for and what works in their system,” an executive said. “Along with the winning comes continuity, and I think that staff as a whole has a very strong understanding of what works there. I think Veach and (assistant general manager Mike) Borgonzi are good evaluators. They have an eye for talent along with an understanding of what plays in the league.”

While Mahomes’ deal could be reworked in the not-so-distant future, he’s currently the greatest bargain on the planet because the Chiefs were savvy enough to take care of him before the QB market boom. Mahomes, for his part, sought a long-term partnership that would help the team put together an elite roster around him. The 12 quarterbacks currently ahead of Mahomes in average annual salary have combined to win zero Super Bowls and have 19 playoff wins to his 15.

Said one general manager who voted Kansas City as the top front office: “They have the stability of that head coach along with a guy who is comfortable in that second chair.”

So while Mahomes and Reid have become the faces of the franchise, Veach has been quietly fortifying a roster that’s helped them win three of the past five Super Bowls.

Total points: 173 (9 first-place votes)
Owner: Vincent Viola
President and CEO: Matt Caldwell
GM and president of hockey operations: Bill Zito
Head coach: Paul Maurice

One assistant GM perfectly summed up the incredible transformation of the Panthers under Bill Zito and his staff: “It went from a place players avoided to a destination.”

Zito was hired prior to the 2020-21 season and took a team that had three playoff appearances in the previous 22 seasons to the promised land in just four years. There were plenty of big swings, but it’s the depth — built through shrewd drafting and signings — that puts the Panthers this high.

Also navigating Joel Quenneville’s removal early in the 2021-22 season counts for quite a bit. Making good personnel moves is at the heart of what constitutes success in this league, but avoiding pitfalls can be just as important.

“A bit of recency bias here, but management has done an excellent job of finding undervalued talent off the scrap heap (Gustav Forsling, Carter Verhaeghe, Brandon Montour, Eetu Luostarinen, Oliver Ekman-Larsson, maybe Nate Schmidt, etc.) while also making aggressive trades,” one senior adviser said. “Overhauled the roster into a championship squad in a short period of time.”

“Losing (Joel) Quenneville, hiring (Andrew) Brunette, winning the Presidents’ Trophy and still making the move with Paul (Maurice) — Billy’s not afraid to make decisions,” one GM said. “And he’s surrounding himself with some really good hockey people.”

Total points: 151 (3 first-place votes)
CEO: Jed York
General manager: John Lynch
Head coach: Kyle Shanahan

The 49ers, like the Chiefs, have a power coach who was instrumental in selecting the GM.

Kyle Shanahan and John Lynch, after enduring a 10-22 start to their tenure, have reached two Super Bowls and four NFC Championship Games over the past five years. Their 62 regular-season and playoff wins from 2019 to 2023 were the third most in the NFL.

Three former members of the Shanahan/Lynch front office have landed GM jobs elsewhere: Kwesi Adofo-Mensah (Minnesota Vikings), Ran Carthon (Tennessee Titans) and Adam Peters (Washington Commanders).

“From the top on down, they’re on the same page, share the vision on how to build a team,” an AFC talent evaluator said. “They hit on late picks, and those guys contribute. They’ve got the best roster (with) seven All-Pros.”

The Niners’ upper-echelon talent rivals any team in the league. They have extended many of their key pieces, even if negotiations have gotten contentious at times with Nick Bosa, Deebo Samuel, Brandon Aiyuk and Trent Williams.

“The issues they had,” said a general manager, referring to this summer’s Aiyuk and Williams holdouts, “were because they have so many good football players.”

The 49ers invested three first-round picks in the ill-fated 2021 draft trade up for quarterback Trey Lance, but the development of Brock Purdy from Mr. Irrelevant into a potential long-term franchise QB made up for Lance’s failure to launch in San Francisco. If they pay Purdy near the top of the market, the challenge then becomes balancing out the roster with those new cap constraints.

The Rest: Remaining teams that received votes

11-21

NFL voters praised Philadelphia Eagles general manager Howie Roseman and his front office for their analytical and forward-thinking approach to roster-building.

“Howie is really aggressive,” an NFL executive said. “That really stands out about the way they do things. They go for it. He’s not afraid to take risks on players. I think that’s a really good quality when you get into that role, and he’s quick to move on when something isn’t working. Those are attractive traits in a general manager. They’ve also always had guys in Philly who are good evaluators.”

Meanwhile, NBA voters tabbed the front office of the Miami Heat in part for its longevity and stability. Pat Riley has been with the Heat since 1995, and most of the people around him have too. Andy Elisburg, his deputy, actually predates Riley in Miami and has become one of the most respected executives in the NBA. Assistant GM Adam Simon started with the Heat in the video room in 1995 and is part of the team responsible for their hits in the draft and off the scrap heap. Eric Amsler, the VP of player personnel, is in his 21st season with the organization.

“In this day and age where everything is tenuous and owners are so capricious, how about Miami having that whole group there since 1995?” asked one NBA voter. “It’s an incredible testament to consistency and longevity.”

The Baltimore Orioles received a mixture of responses. Some MLB rivals harrumphed about the path president of baseball operations Mike Elias and Co. took toward building the Orioles. The franchise endured three wretched seasons before emerging as upstarts in 2022 and winning the American League East in 2023. If you draft in the top five every summer, some grumbled, you should land quality talent like Adley Rutschman and Jackson Holliday.

Others, of course, were more charitable. 

“They never tried to push too fast, let it all evolve, and they’re going to reap the benefits of that patience for a long time,” one MLB executive said.

And the Vegas Golden Knights drew this feedback from one NHL general manager: “Love them or hate them, they’re all about winning.”

22-32

In their first 48 years of existence, the Milwaukee Brewers made the postseason just four times. The club has reached the postseason five times in the past six seasons.

Only once in this recent run, in 2018, has owner Mark Attanasio authorized a payroll that ranked in the sport’s top 12. The team typically gets outspent by about 20 other clubs but remains formidable. 

“The Brewers are consistently good on a small payroll,” one MLB executive said.

The Colorado Avalanche turned a bleak decade from 2008 to ’18 into something special and are now trying to balance salary cap issues with competitiveness.

“Good drafting. Great core,” one NHL scouting director said. “Maybe some improvement needed in cap management, but otherwise solid.”

The New York Knicks were the most divisive front office in the NBA among league executives. Rival executives lauded their work but also had questions about the two big swings the team took this past offseason in trading for Karl-Anthony Towns and Mikal Bridges.

“I think they’re astute and they do a good job of it,” one NBA VP said.

Buffalo Bills general manager Brandon Beane earned high marks around the NFL and once again has the Bills in contention for the franchise’s first Super Bowl title.

“I think Beane is a top-five GM,” said one NFL general manager. “He is super smart, number one. It’s never about him. If you look at the drafting and free agents they have signed, how patient they have been with the head coach, got the quarterback right — that was a 50/50 deal. I’m a big fan of him. I’m a big fan of his coach. He’s got all the right stuff, in a tough market, by the way. This is not a place free agents are clamoring to go to.”

34-44

The word “culture” comes up often in discussions about the Minnesota Twins, who have been helmed by president of baseball operations Derek Falvey and general manager Thad Levine since the fall of 2016. 

“Everybody who goes there loves it,” one MLB executive said. “You hear it from every player who played for them. Derek Falvey has done a lot of hard work from a culture standpoint, and it’s made a difference.”

The Pittsburgh Steelers’ 2022 transition from longtime general manager Kevin Colbert to Omar Khan, who has been with the franchise since 2001, marks the most significant recent change for one of the NFL’s most stable organizations.

Mike Tomlin is the longest-tenured coach in the league and one of only three Steelers head coaches since 1969. 

“They are old-school,” one NFL executive said. “They have been in the same defensive system forever, and they are really good at finding players who fit it.”

The San Antonio Spurs were the class of the NBA for nearly two decades, an almost unbelievable reign. While the Spurs have hit some potholes in recent years and transitioned into rebuilding mode (adding Victor Wembanyama with the No. 1 pick in the 2023 draft helps), they still maintain respect around the league.

Montreal Canadiens executive vice president of hockey operations Jeff Gorton and general manager Kent Hughes haven’t been on the job long, but they have started the slow turnaround process for a team with some serious young talent. 

“Kent Hughes doesn’t BS,” one NHL assistant general manager said. “He just goes about his business. I think they have a good plan.”

47-57

Several MLB executives went out of their way to praise Philadelphia Phillies president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski, the dapper wheeler-dealer who has taken four different franchises to the World Series. 

“People s— all over him,” one MLB executive said. “Didn’t go to an Ivy League school, blah, blah, blah. But it’s like that old Winston Churchill quote: ‘However beautiful the strategy, you should occasionally look at the results.’”

The Philadelphia 76ers were a divisive topic, with some NBA voters praising team president Daryl Morey’s creativity and drive and others dismissing his approach to team-building.

“Daryl has balls, but he’s trading stocks from a desk,” one NBA executive said. “I don’t think what he does can win at the highest levels.”

There have been a few folks in the general manager chair over the past decade for the Edmonton Oilers, and it’s Stan Bowman’s spot for now. With Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl rightly eating up a big chunk of cap space, the Oilers’ job is a challenge for anyone to try to fit good pieces around two of the game’s biggest stars. 

“You can’t ignore the success they’ve had, even with some turnover in the front office,” one NHL scouting director said.

60-69

Winnipeg Jets general manager Kevin Cheveldayoff’s 13-year tenure has produced a pretty decent team, given the factors — including requested changes of scenery — that have gone against the Jets since they moved from Atlanta. 

“They draft well, develop their players,” one NHL assistant general manager said. “They’ve taken strides in being more proactive in trades because that had been a roadblock. They probably don’t want to admit it, but it’s a tough place to attract players, and they’ve continued to win.”

Seattle Mariners president of baseball operations Jerry Dipoto is famed for his affinity for trades, but the Mariners found franchise cornerstone Julio Rodríguez on the international amateur market while drafting rotation mainstays Logan Gilbert, George Kirby and Bryce Miller.

Under Milwaukee Bucks general manager Jon Horst, the 2021 champions have kept the main thing the main thing, twice extending star Giannis Antetokounmpo while maintaining a core group around him with Khris Middleton, Brook Lopez, Bobby Portis and Pat Connaughton. An opportunistic foray to swap Jrue Holiday for Damian Lillard has been the one recent major swing, although the 2020 trade that netted Holiday in the first place played a massive role in their championship. And while Lillard has played much better in Year 2 with the Bucks, that deal — so far, anyway — has hardly worked out as they’d hoped.

T70

One executive described a fifth-place vote for the New York Mets as “purely a vote of confidence for David Stearns,” who in his first year as the team’s president of baseball operations led the Mets to the playoffs.

Under president of basketball operations Lawrence Frank, the Los Angeles Clippers have seemed to do their best when things look bleakest, such as scratching out a 48-win playoff season the year before Kawhi Leonard and George showed up, or this year’s solid start with George gone and Leonard injured.

Owner Steve Ballmer has also invested heavily in the front office. Said the NBA’s lone Clippers voter: “This is going to be controversial because it didn’t work (with Leonard), but those guys are really good.”

Not much love for the Toronto Maple Leafs, who haven’t produced enough wins to go with all the attention around their core and their status in Canada’s biggest market. GM Brad Treliving has a big Mitch Marner decision looming, so we’ll see where the Leafs go from here.

(Top graphic:

 

How Magnus Carlsen’s jeans sparked a chess controversy

The world’s No 1 chess player Magnus Carlsen will return to the World Rapid and Blitz Chess Championships in New York after initially withdrawing as he refused to change out of a pair of jeans.

The 34-year-old pulled out from the World Rapid Championship on Friday after breaching the dress code and opting not to change his attire.

However, the International Chess Federation (FIDE) announced on Sunday Carlsen would return for the World Blitz Championship. The organisation’s president Arkady Dvorkovich confirmed that while the official dress code would remain in place, it would be relaxed to accommodate “elegant minor deviations”.

A post on Carlsen’s X account read: “Oh, I am definitely playing in jeans tomorrow”.

“I am playing at least one more day here in New York and, if I do well, another day after that,” the Norwegian said, speaking to Take, Take, Take.

Why did Carlsen withdraw?

FIDE deemed Carlsen had broken the dress code for the World Rapid and Blitz Chess Championships by wearing jeans on Friday.

He was initially fined $200 and asked to change but he refused to and was subsequently not paired for round 9 of the World Rapid Championships.

Carlsen claimed he had worn jeans for a meeting and “didn’t even think” about swapping into different trousers for the tournament. He said he offered to change for the following day but this was not accepted.

“I had a nice lunch meeting before I came here, I barely had time to go to the room and change so I just put on a shirt and jacket, I didn’t even think about the jeans — I even changed my shoes,” he told Take, Take, Take.

“I got a warning that I would not be paired if I did not change my clothes. They said I could do it after the third round today. I said I’ll change tomorrow if that’s OK. They said you have to change now. At that point, it became a bit of a matter of principle for me.”


Carlsen (Henry Nicholls/AFP via Getty Images)

He then said he did not intend to return to defend his title in the World Blitz Championship, which begins on Monday.

“I’ll probably head off somewhere where the weather is a bit nicer than here,” he added. “I don’t know what would have to change for that to happen, but no (I won’t be playing in the Blitz).”

Carlsen continued: “They can enforce their rules, that’s fine by me. My response is that’s fine, I’m out, f*** you.”

Carlson was the defending rapid champion but had trailed the leaders at the time of his withdrawal.

Russian grandmaster Volodar Murzin, 18, ultimately won the tournament to become the second youngest world rapid champion in history.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Indian teenager, 18, becomes youngest chess world champion in history

Why does chess have dress code regulations?

FIDE states its regulations for the tournament, including the dress code, “are designed to ensure professionalism and fairness for all participants”.

The FIDA regulations for the 2024 Rapid and Blitz Championships state: “No players with t-shirts, jeans, shorts, sneakers, baseball caps or inappropriate dress are allowed in the playing area. Any requests to wear national or traditional dress shall be approved by FIDE Supervisor.”

Players are permitted to wear: “Dark-coloured pants, long-sleeved light-coloured (white, light blue, beige, brown, etc.), blue or black shirt, in any case unicoloured. Dark-coloured jacket, waistcoat or cardigan with buttons: black, navy, grey, beige, brown, in any case unicoloured. Jacket, waistcoat or cardigan may be taken off during play. Tie is not mandatory.”

Participating players and FIDE staff, officials and representatives all have to adhere to the dress code policy.

A first infringement of the regulations results in a fine, with the sanctioned player permitted to play the current round, before a second infringement leads to not being included in a pairing for the following round.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

The 18-year-old phenomenon aiming to make chess history

Did anyone else break the dress code regulations?

Russian grandmaster Ian Nepomniachtchi was also fined on Friday for a dress code breach after wearing sports shoes. However, he changed into “approved attire” and continued in the tournament.

How was the Carlsen situation resolved?

Carlsen said on Sunday “fruitful discussions” had taken place with FIDE president Dvorkovich.

“I love playing blitz,” he told Take, Take, Take. “I want to give the fans an opportunity to see this… For now, I’m here, and there have been, I think, some slight alterations to the rules. As a matter of principle, I’m definitely playing in jeans tomorrow.”

A statement from Dvorkovich read: “I sincerely regret that this situation escalated without a resolution being found by both sides in time to prevent Magnus’s withdrawal.”

He added that Carlsen’s concerns “highlight the need for further discussion about how to modernize the current approach, to ensure that our rules and their application reflect the evolving nature of chess”.

Dvorkovich explained a flexible approach to the dress code would be taken for the World Blitz Championships.

“I took the decision to trial an approach to provide more flexibility to FIDE officials in judgements regarding the suitability of the attire,” he continued. “Special assistants will be requested to help in those judgements and make final conclusions, shall any doubts arise.

“The principle is simple: it is still required to follow the official dress-code, but elegant minor deviations (that may, in particular, include appropriate jeans matching the jacket) are allowed. In the end, it is New Year time, and I sincerely hope that nobody would try to undermine the festive mood, including by abusing this additional flexibility.”

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Why Guardiola, Maresca and Salah love chess: Space, patterns and ‘controlling the centre’

(Dibyangshu Sarkar/AFP via Getty Images)

Pace, swerve, angle – the art of the ‘olimpico’, football’s (usually) rare phenomenon

Oscar Wilde once famously wrote that “to concede one goal direct from a corner is a misfortune, to concede two in eight days looks like carelessness.”

The thoughts of Oscar, noted corner-kick scholar, may have been rushing through the heads of anyone associated with Manchester United recently after they allowed not one but two ‘olimpicos’ — which, if you’re not familiar with the term, means scoring directly from a corner — in just over a week, in two different competitions.

The first came from Son Heung-min in that madcap Carabao Cup quarter-final against Tottenham, his corner sailing over second-choice keeper Altay Bayindir and into the net. The second saw Matheus Cunha flummox Andre Onana, with the help of some judiciously positioned Wolves defenders, in the Premier League on Boxing Day.

The olimpico is a relatively rare phenomenon. You tend not to get more than one a season, if that, so United managing to let two in over such a short period of time is fairly extraordinary. Although given their problems with defending set pieces and their general existential crisis, if you were going to predict which team this would happen to, it would probably be them.

The instinct is to write these goals off as flukes, misdirected crosses that rely on goalkeeping errors to go in, not genuine attempts to score by the corner taker. How can the attacker possibly mean it when they can’t see the goal?

That’s certainly true of some. However, many of them exist in a sort of grey area, where there’s intent from the corner taker and the attacking team, and the aim is ultimately reached, if perhaps not through entirely conventional means.

Former Blackburn Rovers winger Morten Gamst Pedersen, still playing aged 43 back in his native Norway, has made scoring olimpicos something of a signature move in the latter days of his career. He scored three of them in one season a few years ago, and claims he once scored five in one game, in his youth.


Pedersen celebrates a Premier League goal for Blackburn in 2005 (Paul Mcfegan/Sportsphoto/Allstar via Getty Images)

His contention is that even if the taker isn’t always ‘shooting’ per se, a goal is the ultimate conclusion of a well-struck corner anyway.

“If the ball can go straight in, it’s like a perfect free kick,” he tells The Athletic. “You’re aiming for the far corner, and loads of things can happen, the goalkeeper can get distracted. If it would go in anyway with nobody there, it’s a good corner.

“You see with what Arsenal have been doing this season: loads of the corners they’ve been scoring from, if nobody touched it, the ball would have gone straight in anyway.

“It’s about creating those situations as close to the goal line as possible. Anything can happen.”

This is a sentiment echoed by another olimpico specialist, the former Wycombe Wanderers full-back Joe Jacobson. He scored two in one game (as part of a hat-trick of set pieces) against Lincoln in 2019, and a number of others over his career.

“I don’t think I ever set out thinking, ‘I’m gonna hit it in the top corner’,” Jacobson says, “but there’d be plenty of times when the coach would tell me, ‘Get it on target, as if it’s a shot’, so that if someone gets a nick or anything it can go in.

“I think inswinging corners went out of fashion for a while — there were a lot of studies showing that if you do outswingers, then defensive headers don’t go as far. Now all of a sudden Arsenal have kind of made inswingers popular again.”

On some occasions though, the taker is definitely trying to shoot.

Megan Rapinoe famously scored directly from a corner at the Tokyo Olympics in 2021, having done so nine years earlier in London. The first instance might not have been entirely intentional, but the second was. According to her, at least.

“I meant this one,” she told the media after that game against Australia in Tokyo. “I actually said it to Vlatko (Andonovski) and our assistant coach Laura Harvey yesterday. They were saying ‘Put it here, this is where we want to go, this is kind of the game plan,’ and I was like ‘Well, I might just shoot it.’”

Pedersen’s became so frequent and clear that his colleagues adjusted their movements accordingly.

“At one stage one my team-mate, who played centre-half, asked me before I took the corner, ‘Morten, are you going to shoot?’ I said yes, so he just stayed back on the halfway line.”

Pedersen would practise corners as if he was trying to score, even if most of the time someone would intervene before it got to the net. “When I played for Tromso at the beginning of my career, I would put a basketball hoop and board in front of the goal, and aim for that,” he says.

From a layman’s perspective, it seems that the secret to a dangerous inswinging corner is to get as much swerve on the ball as possible, so the taker must adjust the way they strike the ball accordingly. But Jacobson suggests that, while swerve is a factor, pace and delivery angle is much more important.

“You see loads of times where it’s a nice curly ball into the box and the keeper just plucks it out of the air. But when there’s pace on the ball and it doesn’t get too high, it doesn’t go too far above his eyeline, then I think it’s really difficult for the keeper to come and claim anything.”

Jacobson instead relied on the angle of his run-up to create just the right amount of curl, thus allowing him to concentrate on striking the ball as cleanly and as powerfully as possible.

“As with free kicks, I’d always stand at a right angle to where I wanted to hit the ball and where I wanted it to end up. I tried to hit over the top of the ball, a bit like topspin in tennis, and so it wouldn’t curl miles out and then curl back in.

“I’d over hit a lot and I’d under hit a lot, but when I got them right, the angle meant that I wouldn’t worry about where the ball would end up directionally. I knew that if I ran up at that right angle, the ball would end up in an area where I’d want it to end up.”

From a goalkeeper’s perspective, it’s pretty embarrassing for one of these to go in. But sometimes, when the penalty area is crowded and the taker gets the kick just right, there isn’t a huge amount you can do.

“They’re tricky because you have a lot of guys around you,” says Matt Pyzdrowski, the former goalkeeper and The Athletic’s resident expert. “The tendency for goalkeepers is to first go forward — your instinct tells you that you want to go forward to attack the ball, and get it at its highest point, so you get it before any of the attackers.


Bayindir initially moves forward… (Sky Sports)


… before trying to retreat and getting caught under the ball (Sky Sports)

“As a goalkeeper you want to resist that tendency to be a little bit more patient and I think the goal that Tottenham scored (against United), it’s very clear that the keeper bites very early. There’s a player who runs in front of him and he’s almost more concerned about the player in front of him. He takes a couple of steps forward and then realises the ball’s going over his head.

“Any time the ball goes over your head as a goalkeeper, it’s quite tough to retreat. I think it takes his attention away from the ball enough that he just misses it entirely.”

In Onana’s case, for the goal Cunha scored, the United keeper had attackers in front and behind him, making it extremely difficult for him to move anywhere. In that case, the finger of blame arguably points more at his defenders.

“Each goalkeeper is different,” says Pzydrowski, “but when I played I wanted the defender to be on the outside of the attacker so they can push the player into the goal, so it takes away that space. In this case, the defender (Manuel Ugarte) just doesn’t do a good enough job and he basically pushes the attacker into Onana.”


Onana, surrounded by Wolves players, is also beaten from a corner (Jack Thomas – WWFC/Wolves via Getty Images)

Teams train for these scenarios, but like anything, it’s difficult to recreate the unpredictability and intensity. Might these goals partly be the result of when teams practise corners? Pyzdrowski thinks it could be a factor.

“It was always the day before a game (that we would practise corners) where the intensity is lower. And any time that the intensity is lower in training, there’s just a natural tendency for the player to relax a little bit too much.”

When you watch any olimpico, the instinct is to assume that the ones that go in at the far post are intentional, and the ones that sneak in at the near post are lucky. But the truth might be exactly the opposite.

A perfect example is the game when Jacobson scored directly from two corners. The first snuck in at the near post, the second curled higher into the far.

“The second one obviously looks a lot nicer, but it was probably a bit too high for the near post, and it flew in,” he says.

“Wycombe’s assistant manager Richard Dobson, who was in charge of set pieces, always said try and whip it in the near post head high, because an attacker will get there, and if he doesn’t he’ll cause some chaos behind. It’s really difficult for a keeper to read it if there are players running across the ball.”

Pyzdrowski confirms that. “Where I always felt insecure was when I knew teams were trying to whip the ball in towards the near post,” he says. “Because you want to go forward and attack it, other players might get in the way and that’s where you’re a little bit more vulnerable.”

With more and more teams following Arsenal’s lead and whipping those vicious inswinging corners into the six-yard box, it may not be the last time this season that we see an olimpico.

And while they might look like flukes, there is often a little more to them than that.

(Photos: Getty Images; design: Will Tullos)

Luka Dončić ‘doing fine’ after Mavericks star’s home burglarized, coach Jason Kidd says

Dallas Mavericks coach Jason Kidd said Luka Dončić is “doing fine” after the 25-year-old star’s home was burglarized Friday in what was the latest occurrence in a string of break-ins into professional athletes’ homes in the past few months.

“I reached out, texted him,” Kidd said Saturday. “He’s doing fine (after) going through that incident. Glad no one got hurt. I talked to him today.”

No one was home at the time of the break-in and an investigation into the incident is ongoing, Dončić business manager, Lara Beth Seager, told multiple outlets. Jewelry valued at around $30,000 was taken from the home, according to The Dallas Morning News, which obtained an internal police report.

It’s unclear who burglarized Dončić’s home.

Since September, the homes of at least six professional athletes have been burglarized, including Dončić’s. Minnesota Timberwolves guard Mike Conley’s home was broken into on Sept. 15. Milwaukee Bucks forward Bobby Portis had his home burglarized on Nov. 2.

On Oct. 6, there was a break-in at Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes’ residence in Missouri; Mahomes called the incident “frustrating” and “disappointing.” Travis Kelce, Mahomes’ teammate, also had his home broken into in October. Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow’s home in Ohio was broken into on Dec. 9.

The NFL and NBA issued memos in November about the threat of burglary groups targeting the homes of professional athletes.

The NBA’s memo indicated that the FBI had identified “transnational South American Theft Groups” that are “reportedly well-organized, sophisticated rings that incorporate advanced techniques and technologies, including pre-surveillance, drones, and signal jamming devices.”

Dončić sustained a left calf strain in the Mavericks’ Dec. 25 game against the Minnesota Timberwolves. He is expected to be sidelined for at least one month.

The Mavericks began a four-game road trip Friday with a win against the Phoenix Suns.

Required reading

(Photo: Ron Jenkins / Getty Images)

The top NFL media stories of 2024: Tom Brady debuts, Netflix steps in and more

If you want some long-term relationship advice, I offer you this: Find someone who loves you as much as news outlets love end-of-the-year content.

The New Yorker did a piece 11 years ago on why our brains love lists, and it holds up today. Among other reasons: It spatially organizes information and promises a story that’s finite.

The NFL story will, of course, continue in 2025 and beyond, but in the space below, we offer eight NFL media stories that captured our interest in 2024.


1. Tom Brady begins his NFL broadcasting journey

Fox has the broadcast rights to the Super Bowl this year, which means Brady will call the league’s most important game in his rookie season as a TV analyst. He is 15 games into a 10-year, $375 million deal with Fox, a journey that has prompted plenty of commentary on his performance, including multiple pieces from this author.

Brady’s broadcasting work has improved during the season — not to the point of being an elite TV analyst, but the progress is noticeable. Still, the long-term prediction here is that Brady’s juggling act as Las Vegas Raiders owner and TV analyst, and the restrictions that come with that, feels unsustainable for Fox and Brady.


Tom Brady has improved as a game broadcaster, but February’s Super Bowl looms as the ultimate test of his progress. (Mitchell Leff / Getty Images)

2. Netflix lands an NFL package of games

Netflix and the NFL announced in May a three-season deal for Christmas Day games through 2026. That deal becomes even more magnified given Netflix securing the exclusive broadcast rights in the United States for the 2027 and 2031 editions of the Women’s World Cup. These are significant signals to the marketplace (along with its WWE rights deal, given its live element) that Netflix has shifted from being interested in sports-adjacent properties to being a legitimate sports rights holder.

The streaming giant aired the Kansas City Chiefs–Pittsburgh Steelers and Baltimore Ravens–Houston Texans games on Christmas Day and largely succeeded in avoiding a glitch-filled rerun of its Jake Paul-Mike Tyson fight event.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

‘Watch what Netflix does’: Unwrapping the NFL’s Christmas Day experiment

3. Peacock airs a regular-season game from São Paulo

The Philadelphia Eagles–Green Bay Packers game on Sept. 6 was the NFL’s first-ever regular-season game in South America and aired exclusively on Peacock, the streaming network’s third exclusive NFL game following the Buffalo Bills–Los Angeles Chargers regular-season game in December 2023 and the Miami Dolphins-Chiefs AFC wild-card playoff game last January.

The result was a significant viewership win for the league and the streamer. Peacock delivered 14.2 million viewers for Eagles-Packers, well above the 7.3 million for Bills-Chargers and Peacock’s second-best NFL streaming audience ever only behind the Chiefs-Dolphins game (23 million viewers). The numbers include figures from the over-the-air markets in which the games ran.

The NFL will play eight international games in 2025, including in Madrid, as Spain will be the sixth country to host an NFL regular-season game. NFL commissioner Roger Goodell and Chiefs owner Clark Hunt have talked openly about playing 16 games overseas annually in the near term, per this report from SBJ’s Ben Fischer. It’s clear we will soon see a Sunday morning window with a new international media-rights package.

4. Super Bowl LVIII sets TV ratings record

We live in an apples-to-pomegranates world when it comes to comparing the sports viewership of today versus yesteryear, due to factors including new out-of-home viewership data and cord-cutters and cord-nevers. Using today’s metrics, via Nielsen and Adobe Analytics, the Chiefs’ 25-22 overtime victory over the San Francisco 49ers in February’s Super Bowl averaged 123.7 million viewers across television and streaming platforms. That makes it the most-viewed program in history, shattering the previous mark of 115.1 million for Kansas City’s last-minute win over Philadelphia in the previous Super Bowl.

Super Bowl LVIII


Fans watch Super Bowl LVIII outside Chase Center in San Francisco. The game was the highest-rated program in television history. (Loren Elliott / Getty Images)

5. The rise of alt-broadcasts

The alternate broadcasts of NFL games launched into a new stratosphere in 2024 with a “Simpsons” animated alt-cast of “Monday Night Football” airing on ESPN+ and Disney+, and NBC Sports making its NFL alternate broadcast debut on Peacock with last week’s Texans-Chiefs game. It follows alt-broadcasts on Nickelodeon and ESPN’s now long-standing Manning Brothers broadcasts and one using “Toy Story.”

6. The ‘New Heights’ podcast blows up

The popular podcast — hosted by brothers Jason Kelce, the Eagles’ center from 2011-2023, and Travis Kelce, the current Chiefs tight end — inked a deal with Amazon’s podcast network, Wondery, in 2024 to be the program’s new home.

The show has found itself on measurement lists of the biggest podcasts in the United States and has nearly 2.5 million subscribers on YouTube. One of the interesting notes in the deal is Wondery’s plans to translate the podcast to different languages to increase its global audience, including in NFL-strong markets such as the United Kingdom and Mexico. That’s a blank space for NFL fans.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

The Kelce brothers and the ‘Heights’ of podcast popularity

7. New broadcast rules for increased access

It was not an accident that you saw more in-game interviews during NFL games this season. Last May, the NFL broadcasting department outlined access changes for the NFL’s television partners after a review between the league and its media rights holders. The shared goal? To enhance the game content that we see as NFL viewers. The new rules included in-game coach interviews for all games, pregame player interviews for all games, network pregame locker room coverage, preseason player interviews, and coaches’ booth network cameras. Look for it to continue.

8. NFL ordered to pay $4.7 billion in “Sunday Ticket” antitrust trial … only to see it overturned

In August, the U.S. District Court in Los Angeles overturned a $4.7 billion verdict against the NFL for colluding to raise prices for its “NFL Sunday Ticket” television package. The judge disqualified expert testimony used by the jury to determine damages. (The jury’s verdict had threatened to upend the league’s strategy of selling exclusive television packages to broadcasters.) Next up: The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Per Sportico’s legal writer and sports law professor, Michael McMann, a decision is likely many months, if not longer, away.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Imagining NFL on TV in the year 2030: Tom Brady out, Travis Kelce in?

(Top photo of a Netflix “Christmas Gameday” banner at Wednesday’s Chiefs-Steelers game: Mark Alberti / Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

NHL trade matchmaker: Predicting where top targets go by the deadline, part 2

We are now exactly 10 weeks away from the NHL’s March 7 trade deadline.

That leaves enough runway for the needs of buyers and sellers to shift before the biggest decisions are made — or for buyers and sellers to switch places. But in a season where there’s already been plenty of trade action, it’s not too soon to try to find some fits between teams and players available on our latest NHL trade big board.

With that in mind, here’s part two of trade-board matchmaker.

GO DEEPER

NHL trade matchmaker: LeBrun and Johnston predict where top targets go by the deadline, part 1

Team: San Jose Sharks
Position:
F
Shoots: L
Age: 32
Contract term: 2025 UFA
AAV: $5 million

LeBrun: Vegas Golden Knights

The 32-year-old Granlund leads the Sharks in scoring and is on pace for a career high in points. He’s meant a lot to San Jose off the ice, too, as far as his leadership and influence around the youngsters. He also likes it there. All of which is to say, it’s not a slam dunk he gets dealt before the deadline just because he’s a pending unrestricted free agent. The expectation is that Granlund’s agents, Todd Diamond and Mark Gandler, will have a discussion in the new year with Sharks general manager Mike Grier. But the team will need to balance any potential extension with the kind of offers it’ll get on the trade market, and there will certainly be some. Granlund’s versatility of being able to play all three forward positions with comfort will appeal to contenders. He may also augment his trade value depending on his performance under the spotlight playing for Finland in the 4 Nations Face-Off in February. Looking into my matchmaker crystal ball, let’s make him a Vegas Golden Knight. The Sharks and Knights got together on a trade deadline deal a year ago involving Tomas Hertl. Keeping in mind Granlund’s versatility and the unfortunate reality of always being concerned about Mark Stone’s health, I like the idea for Vegas of adding this kind of depth.

Johnston: Minnesota Wild

A lot of water has passed under the bridge since Granlund was a first-round pick by the Wild who spent seven seasons playing for the organization. Still, wouldn’t it be a nice homecoming story? Minnesota could really use a forward who can toggle between center and wing while chipping in with some offense. Granlund ticks all of those boxes and should come with an added level of comfort given his familiarity with the organization. The cap aspect will need to be worked out since San Jose doesn’t have any retention spots still open and Minnesota has some added challenges while operating in long-term injured reserve, but those aren’t big enough hurdles to keep this from happening.

Team: Philadelphia Flyers
Position:
D
Shoots: R
Age: 30
Contract term: 2027 UFA
AAV: $5.1 million

LeBrun: Winnipeg Jets

It wasn’t too long ago that Ristolainen’s contract scared teams, but it’s funny what happens with a 20-minute-a-night, top-four defenseman finds his game more consistently, as he has this season. Suddenly, with the salary cap going up, a $5.1 million cap hit for the next two and a half years isn’t so bad at all. That’s why league sources say the Flyers have indeed received calls this season asking if they would be willing to move Ristolainen. The answer from the Flyers is yes — if there’s a certain price met. They would want a good prospect or young player in return or a combination of a prospect and a pick. And while trading for a player with term on his contract isn’t your typical deadline deal since most contenders prefer rentals, I can see it appealing to a few teams. For example, the Jets. I’d like to see the Jets add the kind of size on the right side of their defense that Ristolainen would bring. And after giving up a first-round pick last season for rental Sean Monahan only to see him leave July 1, and keeping in mind how difficult it is for the Jets to attract free agents to Winnipeg, I like the idea of acquiring a player under contract. So there you have it, I’ve got the Cup-contending Jets taking on Ristolainen.


Could Rasmus Ristolainen end up in the Central Division? (Emilee Chinn / Getty Images)

Johnston: Dallas Stars

The Stars made a big splash by acquiring Chris Tanev ahead of last year’s deadline but were unable to retain him in free agency over the summer. They haven’t yet filled that hole on the right side of their blue line. The term remaining on Ristolainen’s contract fits in with the Stars’ win-now window, and the improvements in his game should hold appeal given how few defensive stoppers are expected to be available in the marketplace. Depth is essential for any team gearing up for a long spring, and Dallas is all in on trying to win the Stanley Cup.

Team: Chicago Blackhawks
Position:
F
Shoots: L
Age: 33
Contract term: 2025 UFA
AAV: $6 million

LeBrun: Utah HC

The Blackhawks actually haven’t committed yet to trading Hall, although given where they are in the standings, one would imagine that’s the most logical course of action for the veteran pending unrestricted free agent. It hasn’t been the best of seasons for the 33-year-old winger, but something tells me that a move to a Cup contender might ignite a little flash from the former Hart Trophy winner. He’s always been one of the smartest players in the league. The hockey IQ hasn’t dulled even if the skating has slowed down a little. If the Hawks are willing to eat some of Hall’s $6 million cap hit, there’s no question in my mind there will be a market for him. Hall has a modified no-trade clause, so his agent, Darren Ferris, could have a role in helping the Hawks find a suitor. So hear me out here: Utah HC as a buyer! This is only realistic in a world in which Utah stays in the race in the second half. They could use a little more offense. Hall has some brand-name cache that would be fun to bring into the NHL’s newest market, and Utah has plenty of cap room, plus a strong desire to stay in the playoff chase.

Johnston: Colorado Avalanche

The Avs are one of the few top teams who could make room for Hall in their top six, which is likely where a player with his skill set needs to play in order to be most effective. The continued uncertainty around Colorado captain Gabriel Landeskog, who has gone more than two and a half years without playing while recovering from a cartilage transplant in his right knee, makes the need for another left winger more pronounced. Hall may not skate at the same level as earlier in his career, but he’s still faster than average and could hold his own alongside Nathan MacKinnon in top-line duty if needed. At minimum, he would give the Avalanche more lineup flexibility than they enjoy now. The acquisition cost also shouldn’t be too significant for a veteran player unlikely to be part of the long-term solution for the rebuilding Blackhawks.

Team: New York Rangers
Position:
D
Shoots: R
Age: 28
Contract term: 2025 UFA
AAV: $2.7 million

LeBrun: Florida Panthers

The Rangers just acquired Borgen, but he’s a pending unrestricted free agent and unless New York can somehow stop the bleeding and turn around its season, the Blueshirts will be sellers and open to flipping him. The 6-foot-3, 204-pound Borgen would fit nicely in South Florida. I think in many ways, pending unrestricted free agent David Savard is a more obvious fit for the Panthers given his past relationship in Columbus with Panthers general manager Bill Zito, and it wouldn’t surprise me if Florida tried for Savard if it’s looking for a rental, right-shot D with some physicality who won’t break the bank. But Borgen would be the more under-the-radar move if indeed the Rangers decide to make him available.


Will Borgen, right, has only played three games for the Rangers, but he could be on the move again. (Wendell Cruz / Imagn Images)

Johnston: Vancouver Canucks

The Canucks have struggled since losing Filip Hronek to a significant lower-body injury earlier this month, and they’re not expecting him to play again before February. That’s exposed a gaping need on the right side of the blue line that management has aggressively been trying to address. Enter Borgen, who excels in the less-celebrated parts of the game like penalty killing, which Vancouver can certainly use. The stay-at-home defender is a good skater who should be able to step into a second pairing on a team and brings the kind of size teams view as an added plus come playoff time. Borgen will have plenty of suitors ahead of the deadline, but there may not be anyone more motivated to pursue him than Vancouver.

Team: Seattle Kraken
Position:
F
Shoots: L
Age: 32
Contract term: 2025 UFA
AAV: $3.5 million

LeBrun: New Jersey Devils

All signs point to the pending unrestricted free agent winger getting dealt ahead of the deadline if the Kraken aren’t in the playoff chase, which seems rather likely as of now. My understanding is there are several contenders waiting to see if/when Tanev is on the market because they want a crack at him. He brings the kind of grindy game most playoff teams are looking for. He’s an excellent penalty killer who leads Seattle in shorthanded ice time. He won’t back down from anyone. I like the Devils as a fit. They’re looking for a bottom-six boost, and I can picture Tanev finding a nice spot in that Cup-contending lineup that has no shortage of offensive talent but could use a little more sandpaper.

Johnston: Vegas Golden Knights

Vegas went into the NHL’s holiday break with the league’s best points percentage, and there’s a strong expectation it’ll be looking to beef up before the deadline yet again. In fact, it wouldn’t be a surprise to see the Golden Knights pursue two forwards – one with more offensive ability, and a bottom-sixer to round out other elements of the team. Tanev falls into the latter category and may end up being the strongest player with that skill set available. A high-end skater who plays the game hard, it’s not difficult to imagine him fitting in with a team accustomed to using all four lines to win.

(Photo of Mikael Granlund and Brandon Tanev: Eric Hartline / USA Today and Alika Jenner / Getty Images)

Manchester City and a refused pass that laid bare their myriad problems

Manchester City attempted 683 passes in their 1-1 draw with Everton, but it was one that Nathan Ake refused that revealed the tensions that are gnawing at them. 

It came just as another flurry from Pep Guardiola’s side was beginning to settle down. A familiar sense of exasperation was already brewing in the stands — fans reflecting on Iliman Ndiaye’s sensational equaliser, that came from Everton’s first touch in the City box — but after a strong start to the second half, including a rare Erling Haaland penalty miss, adrenaline and indignation was beginning to take hold. 

There was a roar as City regained possession deep in their own half, fans urging the team on as Ake ambled forward while Josko Gvardiol careered down the left flank. But as the Dutchman turned back to find Bernardo Silva in midfield, to a collective groan from home fans, Guardiola burst to the edge of his technical area and appealed for calm.

Everton scrambled back into their shape — Guardiola still pleading with his supporters — as a slower attacking move through the middle eventually fizzled out down the opposite side

It could have become the kind of sweeping move that City have struggled to contain throughout their growing winless run — no team have conceded more than their 5.3 expected goals (xG) from fast breaks in the Premier League this season — but it only underlined their aversion to exploiting such situations themselves.

Gvardiol had rushed past Jack Harrison, and clearly had the forward momentum to skip by 36-year-old Seamus Coleman at full-back, but on this occasion, Guardiola’s insistence on controlled build-up prevailed over common sense. City had sufficient numbers back to deal with any loss of possession and a counter-attack the opposite way, and given their current issues controlling such situations even when they are in their desired defensive shape, surely they should have just taken the chance.

It was, of course, just one individual decision in a game of millions. But as City once again looked more threatening when they picked up the pace and were more aggressive in their movement, it poses the question as to whether Guardiola’s side should embrace the disorganisation of a direct forward run that little bit more.


Despite long periods of safe attacking play, City were not completely risk-averse in their approach. Particularly in the opening 15 minutes, they seemed desperate to score the first goal, aware that their opponents had ground out consecutive clean sheets against Arsenal and Chelsea, and were capable of turning this into a 90-minute slog.

City usually bring one of their full-backs into midfield to help with their build-up, but it was noticeable how they pushed both Rico Lewis and Gvardiol high and wide as they came flying out of the blocks, looking to overload Everton’s back four and stretch them across the pitch.

As we can see from the grab below, with Lewis cut from the shot in the bottom right, the approach was practically a 3-0-7 as City piled on the pressure in the early stages.

After Silva nicked the opening goal, however, Lewis was quickly restored to his more central role to offer more control in the build-up and make City more compact should they lose the ball.

Here he is three minutes after the goal, close to Mateo Kovacic in midfield.

It was a conscious decision by Guardiola to take the sting out of the game and revert to a more settled shape, and he may have been vindicated had Ndiaye not produced a moment of brilliance on the break. But with City so susceptible to sucker punches right now, it felt a missed opportunity to see them take their foot off the gas so soon.


One of the side effects of Lewis dropping back into midfield is that his winger — Savinho yesterday — loses support out on the flank. The Brazilian took 15 touches in the quarter of an hour leading up to City’s goal, but only 16 throughout the rest of the half.

Data from SkillCorner helps to paint the picture further: City are the team in Europe’s big five leagues who make fewest overlapping runs per 30 minutes in possession. They have also attempted the fewest passes to find a runner in-behind relative to their possession, taking up around 46 per cent of their opportunities to find those runs when they are made. Unsurprisingly, that’s the lowest such proportion in the Premier League this season.

There are several factors that influence those numbers — the fact that City tend to face teams who sit deep and deny them space in behind being one — but the lack of movement from forward players while the team inches forward has become increasingly apparent in recent weeks. It makes things predictable, as it did for Aston Villa, and only increases the difficulty of finding players in congested central areas, mostly static and with their back to goal.

There was an encouraging example of a positional rotation in their 3-0 win over Nottingham Forest at the start of the month, as Jack Grealish dragged a defender into midfield to allow Gvardiol to steam through for a shot on goal, but City seem reluctant to make such disruptive strides forward as often as they could.

A gloomy way of looking at things is that dropped points don’t matter so much now that City are so far away from the summit. The damage — from a title-chasing perspective, if not perhaps Champions League qualification — has already been done.

But starting a run of three winnable games with another setback feels like a missed opportunity for the team to rebuild confidence in front of goal. Had City been more ruthless in their approach, and gone for the kind of passes that Ake turned down, their firepower might have overridden some of the bad luck.

(Top photo: Carl Recine/Getty Images)

Ashton Jeanty didn’t win the Heisman, but he’s still chasing history at Boise State

Ashton Jeanty was into basketball more than football as a kid. So before he grew up to be a 5-foot-9 battering ram in cleats, his favorite athlete was LeBron James. Jeanty, who bounced around the globe as the son of a Naval officer, spent a chunk of his childhood in Florida when James was on the Miami Heat.

“Seeing (LeBron) beat all the odds,” said Jeanty, “I feel like I’ve been doing that same thing in my career.”

It’s why the Boise State running back will forever be the answer to that same question — Who’s your favorite athlete? — for a generation of Broncos fans.

Jeanty didn’t win the Heisman Trophy, finishing second to Colorado’s Travis Hunter. But he did collect the most points by a Heisman runner-up and forced the narrowest margin of defeat since 2009. He also took home the Maxwell Award (player of the year), Doak Walker Award (best running back) and unanimous All-American honors. And Jeanty has another major milestone in his sights.

He enters the College Football Playoff at 2,497 rushing yards this season, just 131 yards shy of college football’s official single-season record, set by Oklahoma State’s Barry Sanders in 1988. Considering Jeanty has averaged 192.1 rushing yards per game this season, there’s at least a decent chance he rewrites that record in the quarterfinals of the College Football Playoff against Penn State on Dec. 31.

But Jeanty is more than just a Heisman runner-up and future first-round NFL running back who is on the verge of a record-breaking statistical accomplishment. At a Boise State program with a reputation for giant slaying and a rich history of running backs, he has managed to stand above the rest.

“Ashton Jeanty is phenomenal for college football, and he’s going to be phenomenal for the NFL,” said Boise State coach Spencer Danielson. “Not only from his play on the field but also the culture he brings with him.”

GO DEEPER

Can Penn State stop Ashton Jeanty? ‘He just doesn’t go down’

There is some nuance to Sanders’ record. He rushed for 2,628 yards in only 11 games on his way to the Heisman in 1988; Jeanty has already played 13 games. And Sanders’ unofficial record is 2,850 yards if you add in the 222 yards he racked up in the Holiday Bowl, before bowl game stats were officially counted.

There will be those who discount Jeanty’s record if he does set it, but Sanders won’t be among them, sending a tweet ahead of Boise’s victory in the Mountain West championship wishing Jeanty luck.

“My fans can gripe, but records are made to be broken & I am rooting for you,” Sanders wrote.

Asked about Sanders’ mark, Jeanty said it would be “like the cherry on top, to break a record that’s been around for decades,” especially after he came up just short in the Heisman race. But as Boise State enters the inaugural 12-team Playoff as a No. 3-seed from the Group of 5, the record — attained or not, contested or not — doesn’t change what Jeanty has achieved.

The stats are staggering, like if Paul Bunyan played high school football. Nearly 2,500 rushing yards, an FBS-leading 30 total touchdowns, 7.3 yards per carry and six games with 200-plus rushing yards. His season low was 127 yards against Portland State, and he got pulled at halftime. Jeanty outrushed 115 FBS teams this season all by himself. The next closest player to him in terms of rushing yards is North Carolina running back Omarion Hampton with 1,660. That’s less than the 1,889 yards Jeanty has gained after contact. He’s the first back to eclipse 2,000 yards rushing since 2019.

“I love watching Ashton play — the mix of physicality, speed and control,” said Alexander Mattison, a former Boise State running back now in the NFL with the Las Vegas Raiders. “But I’ve been able to get to know him, not just as a football player but a genuine person. It’s fun to see him get everything that he deserves. He loves the game, and if you love the game, it will love you back.”

There is an impressive pedigree of running backs at Boise State, with Jeanty set to become next in a long line of Broncos bell cows who have gone on to play in the NFL. Jeanty surpassed Cedric Minter as the program’s all-time leading rusher this season and broke a number of other records Minter has held since at least 1980. But the string of modern-day tailbacks stretches to Ian Johnson, who famously won the 2007 Fiesta Bowl on the Statue of Liberty handoff, followed by Jeremy Avery, Doug Martin, D.J Harper, Jay Ajayi (the former single-season record holder), Jeremy McNichols, Mattison and George Holani.

It’s quite a list, and that’s just the running backs. Former quarterback Kellen Moore is the winningest QB in FBS history (50) and the program’s only other Heisman finalist (he finished fourth in 2010). He remains a Boise State icon. Yet after this season, no one compares to what Jeanty has produced on the field or what he embodies off it.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Boise State and Ashton Jeanty: The Cinderella in a steel-toe boot

“He’s a unanimous captain, part of our leadership council,” said Danielson, who added that he meets one-on-one with Jeanty each week after those council meetings.

“Every single time we have those meetings, it is nothing about Ashton. He’s asking about the team, a player, asking how he can help lead better, have more of an impact,” said Danielson. “That is uncommon. He’s different in all facets.”

Jeanty does care about the awards and accolades. He hasn’t shied from that, whether rattling off the individual goals he had for himself this season or lamenting his Heisman finish by stating: “I really felt like I should’ve walked away with the award.” It’s part of why he returned to Boise State this season, believing he could achieve everything he wanted right where he was.

But Jeanty also cares about the legacy he will leave behind. It’s why he embraced being a team captain and leader and de facto spokesperson. It’s why he spurned more lucrative name, image and likeness (NIL) offers to transfer elsewhere last offseason. It’s why he established the Ashton Jeanty Endowed Scholarship for Football — in October, even before he broke all the records and became a Heisman finalist and carried the Broncos to a Mountain West title and first-round bye in the CFP. The scholarship has raised more than $180,000 toward its $200,000 goal, which will support future Boise State athletes.

“He’s like a movie star here,” said athletic director Jeramiah Dickey. “We had to finally get him security so we could cut off the autograph and photo lines. It was our responsibility to help him because he’s such a good kid, he didn’t want to say no to anyone.”

Jeanty is already the most decorated player in program history and has put Boise State in position to compete for a top-flight national championship for the first time. He has a chance to set a single-season rushing record that could stand for decades.

And none of it will outlast what he has meant to Boise State football and the community that surrounds it.

“Culture is about the people who are here — just bringing back what Boise State’s been, having a positive influence over everybody,” said Jeanty. “People won’t remember the stats, they’re not going to remember the games. But they’re going to remember how I treated people, how I carried myself throughout my time here and the impact that had.”

The Athletic’s Vic Tafur contributed reporting

 (Photo: Loren Orr / Getty Images)

Those who never doubted Cameron Skattebo share validation: ‘No one understood what we were looking at’

Arizona State was picked to finish last in the 16-team Big 12. The Sun Devils are now meeting Texas in the Peach Bowl in the College Football Playoff quarterfinals. The player who sparked that incredible run also epitomizes it. 

Cameron Skattebo — 1,568 rushing yards, 19 rushing touchdowns, 506 receiving yards and three receiving touchdowns — went from high school graduate with no FBS offers to fifth-place finisher in the 2024 Heisman Trophy voting. The running back has gone from cult hero to folk hero, displaying an uncanny knack for breaking tackles and for blowing people’s minds. 

Leo Skattebo III (Cam’s father): Before he turned 3, we got him a bike for Christmas.

Becky Skattebo (Cam’s mother): He (Cam) argued with my dad (Cam’s grandfather) to take the training wheels off. “I don’t want em! I don’t want em!” wouldn’t take no for an answer. My dad popped them off. “Welp, he’ll eat dirt a couple of times and then he’ll figure it out.”

Leo Skattebo IV (older brother): They took him out on the bike. He goes down the street, and within two minutes, he’s full speed pedaling back and goes, “Watch this!” And he stands up on the seat of the bike coming down the street.

Becky: He’s going, “I don’t have to hold the handlebars!” The neighbors just stood outside hysterically laughing.

Leo III: I think that’s when I knew he was gonna be different.

Becky: At about 18 months, we were sitting at the dinner table and a neighbor knocked on the door. She’s standing there with Cam in a diaper. He had climbed over the fence and dropped over the other side to play with her kids.

The scariest thing he ever did was when he was 2. We were watching his dad play softball. He had been standing next to me and we were watching his dad at bat. It seemed like a split-second but when I turned and looked. He was gone. I started to panic. Everybody was yelling his name. His brother ran to the bathroom and was calling his name. People are looking under the bleachers. Then, the umpire says, “Well, there, he is!”

We looked straight up above us. He had crawled all the way up the chain-link backstop and was looking down on his dad that was at bat. It was like 14 or 16 feet up on those rounded backstops. One of the guys started to climb the fence and Cameron turned around but instead of backing down like a normal person, he came down head first, like a little Spiderman. He’s been doing things that are inexplainable from pretty much Day 1.

Leo III: Yeah, he did a lot of weird things.

Leo IV: All he ever cared about was winning. It didn’t matter if we were playing a video game, or wrestling on the trampoline. He wanted to beat me.

Becky: We had many holes in the sheetrock from the boys wrestling, slinging each other around the house. They never took it easy on him. They tossed him around pretty good, and he’s just always been able to handle it.

Leo IV: I was six years older than him and he wanted to beat me in everything. I didn’t take it easy on him.

Becky: He’d always competed with older kids, whether that was wrestling in the front yard or on the field. When he says he can do something, it’s real hard not to believe that he can do it.

Jack Garceau (Rio Linda (Calif.) High School coach, Skattebo’s coach from 2017-19): I’ve known Cam since he was a little boy, because I coached his older brother, so we’ve always heard about Cam coming up in our youth program. We’d go watch him. He was just a little ball of muscle. He had that little mohawk and it just always fit his image.

I became the head coach when he was a sophomore. It was the first day of spring ball. It was a blocking drill. No pads and he just was not going to lose. If he got beat in any one-on-one drill, he was going again. I came home and told my wife, “This guy is way different than anybody we’ve ever had.”

GO DEEPER

Who’s the best player in the College Football Playoff at each position?

In 2018, Rio Linda won its first section title in 14 years, led by Skattebo. The junior running back scored seven touchdowns and ran for 313 yards in a 63-12 win over Casa Roble.

Chris Horner (Casa Roble (CA) High School head coach): After that game, I saw him by the bus. I remember dapping him up. I said, “Bro, you were so fun to watch. I’ve never seen anything like that. Good luck. I’m a huge Rio Linda Knights fan from here on out.”


Skattebo had a prolific high school season but struggled to gain traction with major FBS programs. (Photo: Aaron M. Sprecher / Getty Images)

A few weeks later, on Rio Linda’s opening series of the CIF State Division 5-AA Title Game against San Gorgonio, Skattebo had a 67-yard touchdown run where he broke 11 tackles. He finished with 396 yards and three touchdowns on 29 carries in a 38-35 win. He was doing it all through his parents’ divorce. 

Leo IV: My mom and dad had been together for about 20 years. That was hard. It was hard on Cameron. I was away at college. I lived in Ohio, had a son. I wasn’t there to be the big brother for him. And at the most formative moment for him — he’s 16 and everything around him is falling apart. Somehow on Friday nights, he was able to tune out all that emotional distress, when he was falling apart on the inside, and still be the best player in the state. A lot of kids can’t handle that. That showed me this kid has something different than other kids have mentally.

It’s very easy to let that affect you, and start lashing out at other people around you. He just didn’t do that. He continued to be a leader.

Becky: When we split up, his coach was really instrumental in keeping him focused and letting him vent, giving him room when he needed. I don’t think we’ll ever really know if it fueled him or if it almost derailed him.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Hines Ward at Arizona State: How the NFL star turned WRs coach is fitting in

That same year, Skattebo led the Knights to the California 5-A state title by rushing for 3,550 yards and 42 touchdowns. He averaged almost 12 yards per carry but he was still a zero-star recruit who had no scholarship offers.

Garceau: Bigger schools did come. We had UCLA, USC. Utah, Air Force but they just passed on him. It made us all kind of doubt ourselves.

Cam Skattebo: I went to UCLA right after my junior year. They told me that I wasn’t good enough for this level. I can’t remember who I was sitting with at the time. It was (Bruins running backs coach Deshaun) Foster’s assistant. Bjian (Robinson) was at the facility and that was their focus. They spelled my name wrong on my name tag. It was just an unofficial visit there. I was just sitting in the back, hanging out. Me and my father. It was a humbling experience.

Troy Taylor (Stanford head coach, former Sacramento State head coach 2019-22): We were evaluating players. I couldn’t really find anybody who said we should go on the kid. I put on the tape. You could see the anger when he ran and the determination. I was five or six clips in and I said, “We’re taking this guy!”

I remember specifically that run (where he broke 11 tackles in the state title game). I just couldn’t believe that no one else would go on the kid. I’m not always right but I decided on the spot.  We were his only offer. Everybody missed on that one.

Cam Skattebo: I wasn’t too worried because I knew at some point in my life I was gonna take that next step even if I had to go the juco route. I knew I was gonna make it. But I definitely sat around a lot of days hoping for a text from somebody, which never happened. I finally got Sacramento State, and I was the happiest kid in the world.

Taylor: Then he came to our camp and he was kind of a prick when he competed. It was one-on-ones against the linebackers. He would win the rep and then get up and cut in line and take another rep. He just had that attitude that you don’t want to compete against this kid. I just fell in love with him.

Malcolm Agnew (Sacramento State running back coach, 2021-22): In 2021, he was unbelievable in spring ball because of how physical he was, and because of how competitive he is. It was practice No. 6. This kid touched the ball probably around 10 times that practice, and he scored every time. And we had a pretty good defense.

My favorite play was when we ran this middle screen with him. It was a poor throw, but the dude caught it with his left hand like down towards where his knees are — and he played baseball so he’s really good at tracking the ball — and had the ability to make a guy miss as he was turning and catching it. Then, he made another guy miss and scored. I said to our head coach, “That is one of the best plays I’ve ever seen.”

Taylor: His first game, it looked like he was playing with younger people who didn’t belong on the field with him.

Jason Eck (New Mexico head coach; then-Idaho head coach): He killed us (Idaho) in 2022. He reminds me of Jim Brown highlights.

Agnew: I’ve seen this kid hit standing backflips. I’ve seen this kid broad-jump almost 11 feet. He did a 10-7. I’ve seen him throw a baseball 95 miles an hour to the point where the Sac State baseball coach asked him if he wanted to play in the offseason. We didn’t let him.


Skattebo is the heart and soul of Arizona State’s turnaround. (Photo: William Purnell / Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

In Skattebo’s first season at Sacramento State, he ran for 520 yards, averaging over 9 yards per carry, scoring six touchdowns. In his second year, he had almost 1,900 all-purpose yards and was named Big Sky Conference Offensive Player of the Year, helping the Hornets go 11-0 in the regular season. But after Taylor left to become Stanford’s head coach, Skattebo opted to enter the transfer portal.

Taylor: (Then-Arizona State offensive coordinator) Beau Baldwin called me: “We’re trying to figure out whether to go on Skatt. What do you think?” I said, “Beau, he’s an incredible player. You guys would be crazy not to take him.” Beau pulled the trigger.

The Sun Devils were in the midst of a massive rebuild. They finished 3-9 in 2022 and subsequently hired 32-year-old Kenny Dillingham, an ASU graduate, to lead the program. They were an undermanned team in 2023, but Skattebo emerged as the backbone of the overhaul. He did almost everything for the Sun Devils. He was a finalist for the Paul Hornung Award, given to the nation’s most versatile player. He’d run for 788 yards, but also played some quarterback, completing six passes on 15 attempts for 150 yards and a touchdown. He averaged over 42 yards per punt. He lined up at receiver for another 100-plus snaps.

This year, the Sun Devils were seeded fourth and got a bye in the first iteration of the 12-team College Football Playoff. They will play 5-seed Texas in the Peach Bowl on Jan. 1 for a spot in the Playoff semifinals. 

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

The CFP quarterfinals are set. Here’s a reason to be excited for each matchup

Marcus Arroyo (ASU offensive coordinator): I think (former USC analyst Kliff) Kingsbury was the first guy who told me about him (Cam). Kliff’s like, “Dude, they got a back down there that is bananas. This little sawed-off White guy.”

Joe Connolly (ASU strength coach): Last season, we saw a lot of flashes of unbelievable balance, unbelievable body awareness. He was our starting quarterback at one point, our starting punter, our starting running back, often playing wide receiver. One of the biggest things we did this offseason was tightening the nutrition, the consistency. He was north of 230 pounds and now he’s around 218. He’s increased his speed and his quickness. All those things really showed this year. He never has to come off the field. He is absolutely relentless.

Cam: I think my top speed was the high 19s (miles per hour on the GPS) last year. Right before training camp this year, I almost hit 21.

Arroyo: The guy can really run. He’s hitting 20 MPH on his GPS in the game. It’s crazy where he doesn’t look like he’s moving that fast sometime. When you see guys go up against real guys, and you’re like, “OK, let’s see what this looks like?” And every time, he takes the torch. God-dang, these guys just can’t even tackle this guy. Against Utah, those guys are really big and fast and talented, and he ran over those guys. He was absolutely insane against Iowa State.

Morgan Scalley (Utah defensive coordinator): For as much punishment as he dishes out, and as much as he takes, he is so durable. His shirt get ripped and all the crap he takes, and he just keeps coming back. He’s like Rocky.

Taylor: I always said he was like a Viking. A couple of hundreds years ago, he’d have been at the front of the boat with horns on his helmet, ready to jump onto the other boat to take it over.

Horner: Our coaches (at Casa Roble) had a text chain while we were watching what he was doing to Iowa State (in the Big 12 title game). It was another level. When we lose to a guy like this doing what he’s doing to a college team, it should make us feel a lot better about that drubbing that he put on us in his junior year of high school. Yeah, we lost to Cameron Skattebo, but so did everybody else!

Taylor: He’s been doubted at every single level, and they’ll doubt him again for the NFL, but watch, he’ll end up being an NFL player — and a good one.

Leo III: Whoever drafts him or wherever he ends up, if he just plays in the preseason, he’ll earn his spot on the team. But if they get him on the field and give him the opportunity, he’s going to make somebody very smart.

Garceau: Now, we all feel validated. We knew exactly what we were looking at and nobody else understood. We would hear everything from he’s too small, he’s too short, he’s not fast enough. There was the stigma of the White running back; the fact that we weren’t a giant school. There was just always that one little thing. I am just glad he got the opportunity to show everybody what he can do. But if you change that, and he maybe he gets a big ride out of high school, maybe we’re not here today.

(Photo: Sam Hodde / Getty Images)

The tennis stories of 2024, from doping bans and Grand Slam titles to a bee invasion

Happy holidays, and prepare for the greatest gift: tennis returns tomorrow, December 27.

In the spirit of looking back on the previous season and remembering all the moments big and small that defined it, here is a compendium of tennis stories of all kinds from The Athletic’s tennis writers, Matt Futterman and Charlie Eccleshare, with a few guest appearances. This is not a “best of,” but rather a “remember when?” and a “did that really happen?” as well as an opportunity to revisit the stories you may have missed.

Matt will hold up the front end of the year given Charlie’s joining for the full launch of tennis coverage in May. See you next season, or rather, tomorrow.  — James Hansen


“There is nothing quite like a comeback in tennis, a game that essentially punishes players for time away.

Ranking points disappear. There is no job protection the way there might be for an athlete in a team sport, with an organization committed to managing a rehabilitation, if only to salvage value from a contract. There are no practice starts without consequences in the minor leagues to ease the transition back to top-tier competition.

For older players, the game, the practice sessions, the matches, they all hurt more.”

Matt Futterman

“Mirra Andreeva showed up to tennis in the middle of last season, like the new kid at school whose mother or father has just been transferred into the local branch office.

One day, no one had ever heard of her, the next, she’s all anyone is talking about: 16 years old, three days into the online version of her junior year in high school, complaining about the homework and taking over this Australian Open.”

Matt Futterman

“There was Andy Murray (or was it an actor named Fraser McKnight?) looking very serious, sitting for a tell-all interview.

“The players, the matches, it’s all just made up,” he said. “Let’s face it, people are stupid, so they’ll buy anything.”

There was Novak Djokovic coming clean about his true identity as the actor Bert Critchley, practising ripping his shirt in front of a bathroom mirror and discussing his process of getting into character.

“I want to bring truth to Novak,” he said. “What is he thinking, what is he feeling, what would motivate him, if he was a real person?””

Matt Futterman

“Maybe one day his name will become household. Or maybe not. Tennis is a difficult business; only a tiny sample size of its athletes achieve enough to become part of the vernacular. But what Top Nidunjianzan already has done is extraordinary. In the 50 years since the ATP Tour started its singles ranking system, not a single player from Tibet had earned a single ranking point. Nidunjianzan has 20 of them and ranks 869th in the world.”

Dana O’Neil


Fnu (Top) Nidunjianzan in Tibet. (Courtesy of Princeton Athletics)

“For several minutes, Alcaraz stood in the center of the court in his warm-up jacket, conveying his fears to Davis and a tournament supervisor. They assured him the random flying bee he might still see was harmless.

“If I see the bee, I cannot concentrate on the ball,” he told them.

Both are yellow after all.

Matt Futterman

“No one will ever know whether tennis would have experienced a surge in popularity had more of the best players let in the cameras the way some of the biggest stars in F1 and golf have in recent years for Drive to Survive and Full Swing, the golf equivalent. Still, in many ways, the failure of Break Point revealed some of the long-running fractures and countervailing interests throughout tennis, especially at a time when the best players treat access to their lives as their intellectual property.”

Matt Futterman

“We do compete in many countries that certainly reflect different cultures and value systems,” said Steve Simon, the chief executive of the WTA Tour. “We certainly understand and respect that Saudi is something that provokes some very strong views.”

Matt Futterman

Challengers, Tashi and the film’s director Luca Guadagnino have plenty to say about that metaphysical quandary. They have plenty to say about the aggression-filled flow state two players enter when they are in the middle of a high-octane match, rhythmically pounding and pattering a ball back and forth across a net.

Challengers may not really be a tennis movie — but it has plenty to say about the quintessence of the sport.

Matt Futterman

“One normal day of Corentin Moutet, that’s all we ask. It will never happen.”

James Hansen

“Initially, it was thought that the bottle might have been thrown deliberately because footage of the incident obscured where the bottle had come from. However, video shows the bottle slipping out of a spectactor’s backpack as they bend over to attempt to get the attention of the 24-time Grand Slam champion.”

Charlie Eccleshare

“The knee-jerk reaction is that women don’t bring in as much money as the men and if they did, they wouldn’t be second-class citizens. Yet consider a counter-narrative: during the 55-year history of the sport’s modern era, if women had received the same exposure and investment as men and didn’t have to confront countless barriers and aggressions, maybe they would be bringing in the same amount of money.”

Matt Futterman

“The dominance becomes self-fulfilling once she wins a few games and she and her opponent both feel like they know what’s coming next, so the starts and ends of points become more inevitable; what happens in between is less important.”

Charlie Eccleshare

“The world of invention is full of products and gadgets intended for one purpose that found their groove with another.

Bubble wrap was supposed to be three-dimensional wallpaper. Viagra was a new blood pressure medication. The slinky was a surefire way to secure naval instruments in rough seas.

Umpire-Head-Camera, welcome to the ranks of unintended consequences.”

Matt Futterman


Corentin Moutet was just one of the players to fall victim. (Eurosport)

“The weeks before the French Open had been filled with doubts. He had barely been able to practice. It seemed like what he had experienced during the previous year, and even for some months before that, was coming for him all over again.

Back then, Alcaraz was starting to gain a reputation as a beautiful but possibly brittle player. His young body, so fast and so strong, way beyond the level of most 20/21-year-olds, somehow kept betraying him.”

Matt Futterman

“All the pent-up emotion that Murray must have been feeling for days, weeks, months, even the seven years since he limped off this court with a hip injury against Sam Querrey and was never the same again, could pour out.”

Charlie Eccleshare

“For the second time in five weeks, Paolini, the diminutive Italian, has forced everyone in the sport to forget everything they thought they knew about the modern version of tennis. She has reminded them of one of the things, maybe even the thing, that makes tennis special.”

Matt Futterman

“After Krejcikova left the court, she saw her name next to Novotna’s on the board that lists the champions on a wall inside the All England Club. Emotion overcame her then.

Afterwards, she said she had been dreaming of Novotna lately. In the dreams, they are talking. She didn’t want to say about what.

“It’s a little personal,” she said.”

Matt Futterman


Barbora Krejcikova’s Wimbledon title stretched back into her tennis youth. (Clive Brunskill / Getty Images)

“Andy Murray made you care.

That was his superpower. There were better players in his era; there were more stylish ones. But none possessed the ability to make you invest emotionally in their matches as much as Murray did.”

Charlie Eccleshare

“I have no cartilage in my knees,” Bopanna repeated several times during a recent interview, emphasizing the absurdity of what he has accomplished despite all that. He shook his head. He shrugged his shoulders. Then he recalled asking a relative, a yoga teacher, if she could help.

At the time, it was not a particularly serious question. The answer ended up changing his life.

Matt Futterman

Aged seven, Zheng went to Wuhan with her father to play in front of a coach. She impressed so much that she would stay there to train — alone.

“Now I can tell him I made history,” she said, beaming with the brightest of smiles.

Matt Futterman

“Djokovic went to the center of the court and knelt in prayer, crossing his chest, his closed eyes looking skyward with his arms raised in the air. He crouched on the clay, crying more, his hands trembling.”

Matt Futterman

“All of these processes follow the Tennis Anti-Doping Program (TADP) regulations. But that hasn’t stopped the fury from Sinner’s fellow players.”

Charlie Eccleshare

“Gauff knows this isn’t about just about her. During her lifetime, Black Americans have become some of the biggest stars in tennis and in some cases have transcended the sport, especially in the U.S.”

Matt Futterman

“Most people can envisage dating someone who does the same job or works for the same company. But most people’s jobs don’t involve travelling the world to play a very selfish sport in front of thousands of people, sometimes with — or even against — your partner.”

Charlie Eccleshare


It was a summer of love in tennis in 2024. (Getty Images; design: Meech Robinson)

“How did that chirpy teenager suddenly get to this middle-age existence, wife and kids and in-law dinners, wearing the status of millennial tennis wise man?

Where does life, his and ours, go?”

Matt Futterman

“Muchova has come from a place that no tennis player wants to go. After that surgery in February, on the area of the body tennis players most dread becoming damaged, Muchova worried she might not play the sport again.”

Charlie Eccleshare

“Something about the human backboard nature of her play, the hard (but not too hard), flat power of ball after ball after ball opposing off her racket. The beauty of her game, her economic and elegant movement, and the subtle scything of her forehand almost go unnoticed.

She is plenty steady, sure, but that doesn’t begin to describe her. Stealthy is more like it.”

Matt Futterman

“Sabalenka can be funny and bubbly off the court but has a temper to match her athletic gifts on it, and an obduracy that follows her out of the tramlines too. When the stress ramped up, she would get so hot she could barely breathe or function, let alone serve.

That is when it helps to have someone with a background in martial arts: a discipline in controlling your breathing and your emotions when you are facing someone beating the crap out of you.”

Matt Futterman

“Both are so quick that they look like they could be Olympic sprinters, and where Alcaraz lunges and bends like his limbs are putty, Sinner dives and twirls like a superhero escaping from a burning building.”

Charlie Eccleshare

“Forlan expected to spend much of his retirement honing his golf game, but instead has found himself drawn back to tennis. Nothing else gives him the same satisfaction as the sport that, along with football, he excelled at in his youth.”


Diego Forlan’s professional debut was one of the less likely stories of the year. (Kevin Santamaria / Tenis al Maximo)

“When the WTA go to Saudi, I would say they should adopt a political prisoner’s case and take it on and say ‘OK, we’re going, but we are also advocating for them. And Manahel al-Otaibi (the jailed fitness instructor) is the closest case you could have to sports. Say, ‘We are happy to be in Saudi. We’re happy that Saudi women are to now play tennis. But what about Manahel al-Otaibi?’”

Charlie Eccleshare

“Jannik Sinner is trying to speak, but his own name is resounding too loudly across the Inalpi Arena in Turin. Lit up on billboards, written on placards, chanted across the aisles. Sinner, the first Italian to achieve the men’s world No. 1 ranking, isn’t just the featured attraction of the ATP Tour Finals tournament in his home country: He is the tournament, on the court and off it.”

Matt Futterman

“Instead of letting her serve become a complete albatross, Errani has used her ground skills, tactical nous and the shock factor of a serve that regularly registers around 60mph (96.5kph) on the speed gun to reach the very top of tennis in singles and doubles.”

Charlie Eccleshare

“For two decades, whatever outrageous fortune controls tennis injuries kept slinging arrows at Rafael Nadal.

When the Spaniard finally raised his white flag last month, he admitted defeat to an opponent he had vanquished not just in his later years but for two decades, until he couldn’t win the battle any more.”

Matt Futterman


Rafael Nadal’s retirement was one of many that defined the year. (Julian Finney / Getty Images)

“Both Swiatek’s one-month suspension and the decision not to ban Jannik Sinner for his two positive tests for clostebol, an anabolic steroid, have been conducted according to ITIA protocol. Both cases have also revealed deep wells of mistrust and anger within tennis from fans and players alike, confused at players being allowed to play while under investigation. Everything has been done by the book. The book appears in need of a rewrite.”

Matt Futterman

“I wasn’t alone,” she said. “It wasn’t something wrong with me.”

Matt Futterman

“I was like, ‘Oh my god, it’s my boyfriend’s birthday. Like happy birthday. I love you.’ And then, boom!

“It was so normal for me that I didn’t think about it.”

Charlie Eccleshare and Matt Futterman

(Top photo: Mark J. Terrill / Associated Press)

‘I don’t digest food properly now’: The all-consuming pressure of managing a football club

Pep Guardiola’s list of symptoms is long and unsettling. He has trouble sleeping. He can only take light meals in the evening. On some days, he does not eat at all. He finds it difficult to read because his mind keeps wandering. He feels, at times, intensely lonely. Things can get so bad that they begin to take on a physical form: bouts of back pain, breakouts on his skin. 

They are not isolated to moments like the one in which the Manchester City manager finds himself trapped, when his team are locked in a tailspin he has spent the better part of two months trying and failing to halt. By his own admission, he is always like that. Guardiola cannot sleep, or eat, or relax even when things are going well at work.

Manel Estiarte, perhaps Guardiola’s most trusted confidant, used to call it the “Law of 32 minutes”. Estiarte had spent enough time with Guardiola to calculate precisely how long his friend might last talking about another subject — literally any other subject — before his mind wandered back to football. 

That image has long since been folded into Guardiola’s mythology. He is the obsessional genius, his brain forever fizzing and whirring, a synapse permanently set to fire. His teams at Barcelona, Bayern Munich and then City represent his ideas made flesh, given perfect form. His brilliance has been constrained only by the limits of his imagination.

The cost of that dedication, though, has been laid bare over the last couple of months. As City’s form has slumped, Guardiola has given at least two unusually bleak interviews: first to the Spanish chef Dani Garcia, and then to his former team-mate, and longstanding friend, Luca Toni on Prime Video Sport. He told the former of the “loneliness of the football manager”, and how he found that — in defeat — there is “no consolation” once “you close that bedroom door and turn off the light”. 

To Toni, meanwhile, he detailed the impact on his health: the skin problem he has been dealing with for “two (or) three years”, the problems with sleeping and eating. “I don’t digest food properly now,” he said, as if the metabolic shift is permanent. Sometimes, he said, he “loses his mind”.


Guardiola during Manchester City’s 2-2 draw against Crystal Palace this month (Ryan Pierse/Getty Images)

That he was so matter-of-fact about it — that he could insist he was “fine” just a few days later — may well be because none of it is new, not really. He struggled to sleep in his final year at Barcelona. In 2019, when City beat Liverpool to the Premier League title, he had long since stopped eating on matchdays. He said in 2018 while speaking at the University of Liverpool that he could not read books to relax because “I start reading and before I know it I am reading about Jurgen Klopp”. 

It may also, though, be because it has become the standard reality of those in his profession. Management has always been stressful. Many of Guardiola’s most famous antecedents — Bill Shankly, Arrigo Sacchi — either resigned or retired because of the strain the job placed on them. The man he identified as the greatest opponent he had faced, Klopp, stepped away from Liverpool for similar reasons.

It has, too, always been a vocation largely reserved for the single-minded, the pathological, the fanatical. And yet even those who choose to do it, again and again, would acknowledge that it appears to be extremely bad for you.

Richie Wellens, the Leyton Orient manager, told The Athletic this year that he can no longer grow a beard because of the stress of the job; Nathan Jones, once of Stoke City and Southampton, used to bite his nails so feverishly that he drew blood. As far back as 2002, (vaguely unscientific) experiments showed that some managers were under such stress during games that they suffered irregular heartbeats.

“I definitely didn’t feel healthy at the end of my time at Chelsea,” Emma Hayes, now in charge of the United States’ women’s team, said last month. “I don’t want to say it’s pressure. I just think it’s the stress, the toll it took on me.” 

It is tempting to say that is inevitable, given the scale of the football industry, the money at stake, the unwavering scrutiny of the media. And yet, in some senses, management should be less, rather than more, stressful now. 


Hayes walks away after an altercation with the then-Arsenal Women manager Jonas Eidevall in March (Marc Atkins/Getty Images)

Most clubs have stripped back the burden of the post: technical or sporting directors take care of recruitment; chief executives handle contract negotiations; whole departments exist to analyse games and coordinate scouting. Shankly could not call on a psychologist, a specialist set-piece coach, or a nutritionist.

Yet it appears to have made little effect; management has not become more manageable. Ange Postecoglou, the Tottenham Hotspur manager, might have been exaggerating a touch when he suggested it was the “hardest job in any walk of life”, but it was not difficult to follow his reasoning.

“You can say politics, but this is harder,” he said. “The tenure and longevity of this role now means you go into it and very few are going to come out without any scars.” Asked to compare it to being the prime minister of an actual country, he said: “How many times does he have an election? I have one every weekend, mate. We have an election and we either get voted in or out.”

In part, that can be attributed to the fact that while football has delegated responsibility behind the scenes, it has not done so in front of the cameras. The manager, particularly in England, more often than not remains the only public face of the club. 

“They have to comment on everything,” Michael Caulfield, a sports psychologist who works with Brentford, among other clubs, told BBC Radio 5 Live last week. “From Covid to Brexit to anything you care to mention: potholes, traffic, the price of hamburgers. Football is not good at sharing that workload. It is too much for one person.” 


Brighton head coach Fabian Hurzeler at his unveiling in July (Steven Paston/PA Images via Getty Images)

That anachronism has practical benefits — as an executive at one club has noted, privately, it makes life easier if certain questions are asked of a manager who can legitimately say they do not know the answer — but it creates the impression that the absolute responsibility for the wellbeing of a club rests on one person’s shoulders.

But far more significant is the fact that football, essentially, actively discourages managers to switch off. Guardiola might be seen as an exception, but he is also presented as a model; the obsessiveness that has been central to his legend for the last decade and a half has created a blueprint for how a manager is supposed to be. 

It is telling, for example, that Fabian Hurzeler — the 31-year-old head coach at Brighton — does not watch television or movies but does read books about “mindset”.

“What is the mindset from high-performance people? People like Elon Musk, Steve Jobs, Mark Zuckerberg. I like to understand how they behave, how they get so successful,” he said this season. Fabian Hurzeler’s reading materials are his own business, but this does not sound like switching off.

Indeed, most Premier League managers struggle to describe how they relax. Many exercise, of course — a notable percentage are very fond of padel, with Hurzeler one of several lobbying his club to build a court at their training facility — but genuine outside interests appear to be scarce.

Nuno Espirito Santo likes to “go to the window and look at the River Trent”. The night before he was summarily dismissed by Wolves, Gary O’Neil had allotted time to finish watching the film Wonka with his children. He knew it was “important to switch the brain off”. But he also knew exactly how long he had left. “I will try to switch off for an hour and six minutes,” he said.


The River Trent running by Forest’s ground. Their manager Nuno finds solace in watching the river (Michael Regan/Getty Images)

Caulfield described Thomas Frank, his head coach at Brentford, as being unusually well-balanced for a manager — he plays padel (obviously), he skis, he spends time at his house in Spain, he has friends who have nothing to do with football — but even he has admitted his “brain is thinking about the next game” in almost every waking moment during the season.

He sometimes, he said, watches interior design programs on television with his wife. But only because she “forces” him to do it. Roberto Martinez, now managing Portugal, told The Telegraph in 2015 that he had designed his living room so it could contain one sofa and two televisions: one for his wife to watch normal television, and the other for him to watch football matches.

None of this, of course, is healthy. The League Managers Association, the umbrella body that lobbies on behalf of both current and former managers in England, has published a handbook to encourage its members to find some form of work-life balance; it is at pains to point out that they cannot function to their utmost if they are drained and fatigued.

“That is the biggest problem,” said Caulfield. “Football is exhausting. That culture of ‘be there seven days a week’ has to stop at some point. Managers have to manage their own energy as much as their players. We are not designed to work seven days a week, 24 hours a day, under that pressure and scrutiny.” 

Guardiola would, it seems, be proof of that. The symptoms of what it is to be a manager are worse now, of course. He always suffers more after defeats. But it is not so different when things are good; he has been dealing with them for years. “I think stopping would do me good,” he told Garcia, the chef, in one of those stark interviews.

He knows that, and yet he will not. He will, like so many of his peers, keep coming back for more.

(Top photos: Getty Images)

A guide to Christmas-themed trading cards: From Santa Claus to Clark Griswold

Sports stars, celebrities, and even cryptocurrency all have rookie cards… but does Santa Claus? It’s a question you may ask yourself after consuming a little too much nutmeg. And since the season of giving is officially here, I want to spread some holiday cheer by highlighting Christmas-themed trading cards, which is a bigger niche than you may realize.

So let’s dive into a fun corner of the trading card world, one dominated by the GOAT of gift giving himself: Old St. Nick.

A brief history of Santa Claus trading cards


An 1891 Woolson Spice card. (Photo: eBay)

There isn’t a concrete origin story of Santa Claus trading cards, but some of the first examples in the United States date back to the late 1800s. Ohio-based company Woolson Spice created several artistic Christmas trading cards featuring Santa sitting around the tree with children or on his sleigh. Woolson Spice used the back of the cards to advertise its products, such as Lion Coffee.

There technically isn’t a card from the 19th century that’s coined as Santa’s “true” rookie card among the collecting community, but one of his most known from the time can be found in the 1890 Duke Holidays set. The popular tobacco company produced a 50-card set featuring three Christmas cards, but only the U.S. variation included Santa Claus. According to Professional Sports Authenticators’ (PSA) graded population report, the company has authenticated less than 15 copies. An example of the card is even in the Metropolitan Museum of Art’s collection.


1890 Duke Holidays Christmas, U.S. card. (Photo: Metropolitan Museum of Art)

It’s fascinating to see Santa Claus’ evolution from how he was depicted back then compared to today. Many early picture cards showed a thinner-looking version, sometimes dressed in a green or brown suit. It was Coca-Cola’s advertisements starting in the early 1930s that cemented the image of Santa Claus that we have today (although it was political cartoonist Thomas Nast who originated it in the 1860s). And yes, there are trading cards featuring those old Coke ads that were made in the 1990s.

In the late 1980s, the sports card industry exploded in popularity and began producing more and more sets. One of the first Santa Claus cards that caught the attention of modern collectors is the iconic 1989 Pro Set Football card. The promotional card was given to card shop owners and dealers during the holidays and could not be pulled out of packs, which heightened demand for it.


1989 Pro Set promo card. (Photo: eBay)

The front of the card lists Santa Claus as a “player-coach” and depicts him wearing a baseball cap bearing his own name and a red satin jacket emblazoned with the NFL logo. Inexplicably, he is holding up the very same trading card that he is on, creating a mind-bending card-ception loop. Behind Santa Claus, through a snow-covered window are two Pro Set executives dressed as elves (Leaf remade this card in 2021 with a selection of notable figures ranging from Donald Trump to Pele there instead, which can complicate searches for the more valuable original). The back of the card features Santa Claus’ vital info and a scouting report.

It was such a hit that Pro Set began putting Santa Claus cards into its sets starting in 1990. All of those were printed in far higher quantities, making them easy to obtain today, but the ‘89 card is still highly sought after, with “gem mint” PSA 10 graded copies selling for around $500 to $750.

As the sports card industry continued to innovate in the 1990s, it opened up new opportunities to celebrate the holidays through autograph and memorabilia cards. One of the first autographed cards of Santa Claus can be found in 1991’s Pro Line Portraits with the rarest version limited to 200 copies.

In 1998, Upper Deck produced an oversized Kris Kringle promo card featuring a velvety red piece of “holiday-worn jersey” that was exclusive to the company’s Collector’s Club members. The card can be found on eBay for around $20.

In 2007, Topps created the most comprehensive offering yet, with a special Santa Claus Holiday Set that contains 18 cards, all featuring versions of Santa Claus on Topps’ most popular designs of all time, including a Kris Kringle relic card, an autograph card, and a rookie card that pays homage to Mickey Mantle’s famous 1952 Topps card. Instead of being a “Topps Certified Autograph,” the signed card in this set is a “Topps Santafied Autograph,” with the back of the card insisting, “Santa himself signed this card with the very pen he uses to make his list of all the naughty and nice children around the world.” The back of the relic card, bearing a piece of Santa’s suit, says, “Topps acquired this suit from Santa himself, who requested it be spread as far and as wide as possible so everyone could have a piece of his holiday spirit to cherish and revisit whenever they wish.”


2007 Topps Holiday Set. (Photo: eBay)

In recent years, Topps has produced more Santa Claus autograph and relic cards for its holiday baseball sets (more on those in a minute), but the disclosures have gotten decidedly less whimsical. “The relic on this card is not from anything at all,” says the back of a 2019 offering.

Over the last decade or so, the hobby’s annual holiday set releases have produced more Santa Claus trading cards than ever before. In the most recent Topps Holiday set releases, collectors can pull rare chase cards of other classic North Pole characters such as Mrs. Claus, Frosty the Snowman, the Gingerbread Man, and more.

Holiday-themed sports sets

The sports card industry offers a few holiday-themed sets that bring a seasonal vibe to collecting with unique player-worn holiday sweater cards and festive super short print variations.

The main baseball card release centered around this festive time of the year is Topps Holiday. First produced in 2016, the set has holiday-inspired designs of the MLB’s rookies and stars where you can find hidden elves, snowflakes, and Christmas lights on cards. Collectors can pull autograph cards, player-worn Christmas hat relics, and those aforementioned rare relic/auto cards of Santa Claus. Topps Holiday sets are retail exclusives that can be found online and in stores like Target and Walmart.


2024 Topps Holiday Bobby Witt, Jr. image variation. (Photo: eBay)

A few years after the first Topps Holiday release, Panini, which produces NFL and NBA licensed trading cards, began offering Hoops Basketball and Donruss Football holiday-themed sets that have also become popular with collectors. In 2022 Donruss Football, Panini released a visually stunning Santa Claus Downtown insert. The ultra-rare case hit (there has traditionally been only one Downtown insert per every couple hundred packs) is still in massive demand, with PSA 10 copies selling for more than $1,500. The one-of-a-kind Clearly Donruss Holo parallel of this card sold for $3,234.71 in June of this year — a record high for a Santa Claus card, according to CardLadder’s database, which tracks card sales across major online marketplaces.

I would consider these products to be more collector-focused, with less monetary value on average than many other sets, but they offer plenty of chase cards and autograph relics of top rookies and stars that can still fetch hundreds of dollars. PSA 10 Topps Holiday base rookie cards of superstars like Aaron Judge and Shohei Ohtani sell for north of $100.

Classic holiday movie trading cards


This Peter Billingsley autographed A Christmas Story card sold for $750. (Photo: eBay)

One of my favorite holiday traditions is to sit back with a glass of eggnog and watch Christmas movies — a genre that is also making its way into trading card forms now. This year, actor Chevy Chase released a Christmas Vacation 35th Anniversary Box Set that offers signed cards of the Griswold family and personally used Chevy Chase relic cards. The limited edition release of 300 boxes quickly sold out, but a few have made it to eBay.

Cryptozoic Entertainment and Marquee Trading Cards recently put out a similar set based on the beloved holiday movie “A Christmas Story” to celebrate the 40th anniversary of the film’s release. Collectors have the chance to pull single and dual autograph cards signed by the cast, hand-drawn sketch cards, and serial-numbered chase cards. Sealed boxes are available on eBay for around $130 and a 1/1 Peter Billingsley (Ralphie) autograph card inscribed “I want a Red Ryder!” has already been pulled from a pack and sold for a penny shy of $1,000.

Billingsley also signed cards for Leaf, some with an “Oh fudge” inscription that are being sold for $99 each — exactly what someone might say after their loved ones find out they spent $99 on a Ralphie autographed card.

The Athletic maintains full editorial independence in all our coverage. When you click or make purchases through our links, we may earn a commission.

(Top photo: Stephen Pond/Getty Images)

‘Nearly flawless’ Michael Penix Jr. helps re-energize Falcons’ playoff push

ATLANTA — Michael Penix Jr. looked like an NFL veteran in his first professional start but not as much as he sounded like one when he took the podium after the game.

The Atlanta Falcons quarterback was at a local Costco shopping Tuesday night when head coach Raheem Morris informed him he would be making his first NFL start. After leading the Falcons to a 34-7 win over the New York Giants in that start, Penix was asked if he’d be celebrating the win at Costco on Sunday night.

“No, hopefully, something fancier,” Penix said. “Costco is great, though. Costco, hit me up.”

If the Falcons (8-7) keep playing like they did Sunday, Penix may get a sponsorship offer from the company, which would mean he replaced Kirk Cousins to become Atlanta’s Kirkland quarterback and pitch Costco’s signature line of products.

“Could not be more pleased with how the team responded, really rallied behind a young man,” Morris said. “He went out and played nearly flawless football and helped us get a win.”

GO DEEPER

NFL Week 16 takeaways: Should Niners still pay Purdy? Did Jayden Daniels clinch Rookie of the Year?

Tampa Bay’s loss to Dallas on Sunday night put the Falcons back in the driver’s seat in the NFC South. If they win their final two games, at Washington and home against Carolina, they will host a playoff game.

The Falcons’ 27-point margin of victory was their second largest since the 2016 Super Bowl season, and they have now topped seven wins in a season for the first time since the 10-win 2017 season. The Giants (2-13) lost their 10th straight, the longest losing streak in franchise history.

“You do feel (nerves), but once I hit the field it goes away,” Penix said. “It’s the game I’ve been playing since I was 5 years old. It’s at a higher level, but it’s the same game.”

The Falcons drafted Penix eighth in April intending to let him understudy behind Cousins for a year or longer, but Cousins’ most recent five games convinced them to accelerate that timeline.

“The plan came a little bit sooner, but the kid was ready,” Morris said. “We had a lot of time to develop him, and the kid did a great job himself of getting ready where the moment wasn’t too big.”

Cousins swallowed the sting of being benched less than a year after signing a four-year, $180 million contract to mentor Penix throughout the week, Penix said. In the tunnel before the pair jogged out for warmups, Cousins said his weekly prayer and patted Penix on the back, gently pushing him to jog out in front of him.

“Kirk has been great all week, just being there for me and anything I need help with. He’s a great leader, great teammate,” Penix said. “Coming off the sidelines, he was asking me what I saw, and he continued to encourage me throughout the whole game.”

Penix finished 18-for-27 for 202 yards and one interception on a ball that bounced out of the hands of tight end Kyle Pitts near the goal line. The quarterback was victimized by three drops, including on his first throw of the game. Drops of his passes weren’t rare during his early practices because of his strong arm, but Penix has made big strides in throwing a more catchable ball, said wide receiver Darnell Mooney, who led the Falcons with five catches for 82 yards and then told reporters they might not want to stand too close to him in the locker room because he was feeling under the weather.

“When he first got here, he was (too excited) to throw the ball and everybody was dropping the ball everywhere,” Mooney said. “Now he’s just chilling, and he’s got some touch to him.”

Sunday’s drops didn’t rattle Penix, running back Bijan Robinson said.

“After the Kyle play, he was like, ‘We’re good,’” Robinson said. “A lot of guys would have put their heads down, but he was like, ‘We’re good, we’ll get it right back the next drive,’ and that’s what he did.”

Robinson carried the ball 22 times for 94 yards and is fourth in the league in rushing (1,196 yards). He ran for two touchdowns but was upset he didn’t get a receiving score because he was tripped up short of the goal line on a swing pass. Robinson returned to the huddle and apologized to Penix for not getting him his first NFL passing touchdown.

“I told him, ‘It’s all good, man. We won the football game,’” Penix said. “That just shows the person he is, not just him but everybody on this team, the character. He talked about getting me my first touchdown, but it’ll come. The biggest thing we want to do each and every week is win. We did that.”

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

What Michael Penix Jr.’s college film reveals about his chances as Atlanta’s QB

Atlanta’s defense had nothing to apologize for after returning two interceptions for touchdowns in the same game for the first time since 1983. Jessie Bates III jumped in front of a Drew Lock pass and returned it 55 yards in the second quarter, and then celebrated with Deion Sanders’ “Prime Time” dance. He said his inspiration was the throwback red helmets Atlanta wore Sunday.

“Something about these red helmets,” Bates said.

In the third quarter, defensive lineman Matthew Judon recorded the first interception and first touchdown of his nine-year career when he found himself holding a pass batted by Zach Harrison and rumbled 27 yards into the end zone.

“I just looked up and it fell right there. All glory to God,” said Judon, who became the first Falcon since Kroy Biermann in 2011 to have a pick six and a sack in the same game. “I am really grateful. I kept thanking Zach the whole time in (the locker room) until he left.”

The Falcons also recorded three sacks, one of which resulted in a fumble recovered by Arnold Ebiketie.

Penix, though, was the story of the day. Simply by providing a stabilizing element at the position, he gave the Falcons hope for their playoff push. His coaches and teammates said they never really doubted that the 24-year-old would.

The Falcons reorganized the “Mamba” periods they have used in practice this year where the starters from each side face off in competitive situations to give Penix some looks he hadn’t seen enough of, but other than that didn’t change their routine at all, Morris said.

“I think the guy is just a grown adult that came in with a high level of football experience,” the coach said. “I couldn’t be more proud of the young man. It was fun to watch.”

(Photo: Kevin C. Cox / Getty Images)

Max Purcell admits doping violation: U.S. Open doubles champion enters provisional suspension

2024 U.S. Open men’s doubles champion Max Purcell has admitted breaking anti-doping rules and has been provisionally suspended from tennis while under investigation.

Purcell has been suspended since December 12, having made the admission and requested to be provisionally suspended December 10. The International Tennis Integrity Agency (ITIA) confirmed the suspension December 23, saying that the Australian, 26, breached rules relating to the use of a “prohibited method,” rather than any positive test for a banned substance.

Purcell said in a statement on Instagram: “I have voluntarily accepted a provisional suspension since I unknowingly received an IV infusion of vitamins above the allowable limit of 100ml. Until last week when I received medical records from a clinic showing that the amount of an IV I received was above 100ml, I was fully convinced I had done everything to ensure that I had followed the WADA regulations and methods.

“But the records show that the IV was over the 100ml limit, even though I told the clinic that I was a professional athlete and needed the IV to be under 100ml.”

According to the World Anti-Doping Authority (WADA), “infusions or injections of 100 ml or less within a 12-hour period are permitted unless the infused/injected substance is on the Prohibited List.”

A “prohibited method” comes under three possible definitions in the WADA code: blood manipulation, widely referred to as blood doping; chemical and physical manipulation, which extends to all forms of tampering or doctoring either blood or urine samples and also covers intravenous infusions; and gene and cell doping. Purcell’s violation falls under chemical and physical manipulation.

The ITIA has not yet commented on the specifics of Purcell’s violation.

As the suspension is provisional, it is unclear how much tennis Purcell will miss but that time will be credited against any ultimate sanction when the investigation into his case concludes. He was absent from the Australian Open’s list of singles wildcards despite being ranked world No. 105, just outside the cut-off for entries to the main draw.

Doubles entry lists have not yet been released, but Purcell, who won the U.S. Open title in September with compatriot Jordan Thompson and is ranked world No. 12 in doubles was in line to enter his home major. Purcell also won the Wimbledon men’s title with Matt Ebden, another Australian, in 2022.

Purcell is the third major champion in 2024 to be charged with an anti-doping violation. Defending Australian Open champion and world No. 1 Jannik Sinner, who twice tested positive for the banned substance clostebol in March, was found not to be at fault by three independent tribunals convened by the ITIA. Sinner, who also won the U.S. Open title, is awaiting the result of a WADA appeal to the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS), which could see him banned for up to two years.

French Open champion Iga Swiatek, who tested positive for trimetazidine (TMZ) in August, served a one-month ban. 22 days of that ban were covered by her provisional suspension, which saw her miss three tournaments. Swiatek was deemed not to be at significant fault.

GO DEEPER

Jannik Sinner’s doping case explained: What WADA appeal means and what is at stake for tennis

(Clive Brunskill / Getty Images)

Why USC’s win over UConn is so significant: ‘This is what basketball excellence was’

HARTFORD, Conn. — As USC’s bench emptied onto the XL Center floor, with the No. 7 Trojans having defeated the No. 4 UConn Huskies 72-70, JuJu Watkins’ hands shot to the sky. Basking in her 25-point performance that lifted USC past UConn for the first time in school history, Watkins turned to the small section of supporters decked out in red and yellow inside the sold-out arena and acknowledged their support.

“It hit a little different knowing the history from last year and how they sent us home,” Watkins said.

The stakes were different this time. In April, in the Elite Eight, the Huskies knocked the top-seeded Trojans out of the NCAA Tournament. But Saturday night’s 2-point victory was meaningful nevertheless. Not only for Watkins and USC senior transfer Kiki Iriafen, but for their coach, Lindsay Gottlieb, who has long admired the program UConn coach Geno Auriemma has built.

“This is a really significant win, and it’s a really significant win because of the stature of UConn’s program and what Geno Auriemma has done for our sport,” Gottlieb said. “For my entire high school (career) on, this is what basketball excellence was. This is what we saw, and it’s challenged all of us to want to be better, to find players who want to be better and be that elite. And I don’t think that’s gone away.”

Gottlieb is in her fourth season with the Trojans, and she aspires to build a sustained program similar to the Huskies. A season ago, USC won its second Pac-12 tournament title in program history and made consecutive NCAA Tournament appearances for the first time in nearly two decades. Over her brief tenure, she has reminded onlookers not only of USC’s history of success — two national titles and three Final Four appearances in the 1980s, Hall of Fame players such as Lisa Leslie, Cynthia Cooper, Cheryl Miller and Tina Thompson — but of what it can be in the present. Watkins, last year’s national freshman of the year and a first-team All-American, is at the center of the latest chapter. Victories like Saturday’s help make lofty aspirations feel more attainable.


USC coach Lindsay Gottlieb wants to emulate what Geno Auriemma has built in Connecticut. (David Butler II / Imagn Images)

Gottlieb grew up just outside New York City, but she wasn’t recruited by Auriemma in high school. Nevertheless, when she was 15 or 16, she accompanied one of her friends to one of his camps. UConn was always the local draw, and following Saturday’s win, she recalled a trip she made during her senior year at Brown University, in nearby Providence, Rhode Island, when she and her father drove to Storrs to see UConn take on Tennessee.

“It was sold out,” Gottlieb said, “and I was in that building and saw this atmosphere.”

Saturday was raucous, too. And Watkins, USC’s star guard, said it might have been the largest crowd she has played in front of. Nearly 16,000 people packed inside XL Center, almost all of whom wore navy and white.

Still, Watkins added, “just to see my family here, all the SC fans, it meant the world.”

If anyone needed reminding, the Trojans’ victory reinforced their status as one of this season’s national title contenders. At 11-1, their lone defeat came at home to Notre Dame by 13 points. It would have been easy, Gottlieb said, for those inside the program to blame each other after that November loss — for the Trojans to fracture.

“As long as we stick together, this can make us better,” she said she told them afterward. “And (the loss) has in every way.”

Entering Saturday’s victory, the Trojans sported the country’s third-best defense and No. 15 offense. They convert in transition (nearly 20 percent of their points come in transition) and off turnovers (averaging 28.7 points per game), important measurables that could serve them well in the future. Their victory over the Huskies reinforced that they could come on the road, in one of the most-anticipated games of the season, and punch first. It proved they could surrender a 13-point halftime lead, trail by a point with just under five minutes to play and still recover.

“No one got off the treadmill,” Gottlieb said.

Of course, having a transcendent star like Watkins helps calm any nerves. Not only did she lead the game in scoring, she added six rebounds, five assists and three blocks, including one just before halftime on UConn star Paige Bueckers. Bueckers was prolific in the second half and finished with 22 points, but she also guarded Watkins as the USC star got off to a fast start in the first quarter.

“Every scouting report that you put together or every film that you watch, it’s very evident that one player can’t guard (Watkins),” Auriemma said. “When she gets into a little bit of a rhythm, you have to hope she misses.”

With the score within one possession with only 4:30 to play, Watkins recorded 6 of USC’s 8 points and assisted forward Rayah Marshall on the lone basket she didn’t score.

“A lot of the things she does is super hard, but she makes it look so easy,” Iriafen said. “We all know she is a superstar, so playing with her definitely relieves pressure on everybody else.”

Any remnants of pressure dissipated even further in the postgame locker room. Players doused Gottlieb with water as she entered. They leaped together in celebration.

“For me now to bring a team here, to know we could do it, and then to actually do it is incredibly meaningful,” Gottlieb said. “Really proud of the big win.”

(Top photo of JuJu Watkins driving between Paige Bueckers, left, and Kaitlyn Chen: Joe Buglewicz / Getty Images)

Penn State, Louisville volleyball will make history in NCAA championship. Their coaches are why

LOUISVILLE, Ky.  — What’s remarkable is not that two women are coaching for the national championship and one will win a title for the first time in the 44 years of NCAA women’s volleyball. It’s remarkable that these women, Katie Schumacher-Cawley and Dani Busboom Kelly, are the two doing it.

Because they are the ideal representatives.

In this historic moment, as Schumacher-Cawley at Penn State and Louisville’s Busboom Kelly match wits before a sold-out KFC Yum! Center and a national ABC audience on Sunday at 3 p.m., they are the embodiment of what it takes to get to the top in an industry dominated by men.

Eighteen of the 20 winningest coaches in Division I women’s volleyball history are men.

“It’s going to be awesome for the sport to get this monkey off its back and move on from this, where it’s not historic that a woman wins,” said Busboom Kelly, 39, in her eighth season and making a second trip to the national championship match with the Cardinals. “It’s just a regular thing.”

Penn State (34-2) and Louisville (30-5) reflect their coaches’ drive and resilience. They won national semifinal matches on Thursday against Nebraska and Pittsburgh, respectively, in dramatic fashion.

Schumacher-Cawley and Busboom Kelly both coached with a steady hand. They fostered confidence from the sideline as their squads’ manufactured comebacks against opponents considered to rank first and second nationally in talent, depth and championship-level experience.

GO DEEPER

Penn State, Louisville set to meet for women’s volleyball national title

The Nittany Lions pulled a five-set reverse sweep, fighting off two match points for Nebraska in the fourth set.

At the start of the decisive fifth set, junior libero Gillian Grimes heard a voice of reassurance in the Penn State huddle: “We’re made for this.” The phrase didn’t come from Schumacher-Cawley. But she is why it was spoken.

Louisville players faced pressure all season to earn a spot in the Final Four at home. As stress rose when Pitt won the opening set and took the lead in the second, Busboom Kelly implored the Cardinals to keep their composure.

“This is going to start to work,” she said.

Without star attacker Anna DeBeer, the senior was injured two points into the fourth set, they swarmed Pitt after turning back three set points for the Panthers in the third.

In short, Penn State and Louisville refused to go away. They kept taking huge swings. They played to win.

“We’re not talking about losing ever,” Penn State outside hitter Jess Mruzik. “We’re never counting ourselves out, no matter how big of a deficit we’re facing.”

In matches played in front of an NCAA-postseason record crowd of 21,726, Penn State and Louisville were the tougher teams.

Is it any surprise, considering the coaches?

“Women are tough,” said Nebraska coach John Cook, who’s won four national championships. “And those two are really tough. Look at them as players. They both won national championships, so this isn’t a fluke. These guys are winners. They’re great competitors. And their teams play like it.”


Schumacher-Cawley, 44, is a Chicago brand of tough. She grew up in the city and starred in multiple sports at Mother McAuley High. She played at Penn State, earned two All-America honors and won a national championship, the school’s first in women’s volleyball, in 1999 for coach Russ Rose.

Rose won six more titles. He’s the all-time leader in championships and wins among Division I coaches. In 2008, Schumacher-Cawley was inducted into the Chicagoland Hall of Fame in a class alongside Dick Butkus, Gale Sayers and Andre Dawson.

She ran the program at Illinois-Chicago for eight seasons and returned to Penn State to work for Rose in 2018 — four years after the Nittany Lions’ most recent Final Four appearance until last week.

Schumacher Cawley took over when Rose retired in 2022.

“Following Russ Rose, to take the team back to the Final Four in just three years,” Busboom Kelly said, “take being a man or woman out of it, that’s an amazing accomplishment.”

Early in her third season this fall, Schumacher-Cawley revealed a Stage 2 breast cancer diagnosis and she began chemotherapy. She lost her hair but did not miss a practice with her team.

“We’re obviously wanting to do this for her because she’s been so amazing throughout this season,” said Mruzik, who hammered a match-best 26 kills against Nebraska. “So that gritty five-set win helped put another brick into the piece that we’re trying to build this season.”

Schumacher-Cawley deflects questions about her health and the gender issue in coaching.

“I’m just really excited to represent Penn State,” she said.

Maybe it’ll sink in, she said, the magnitude of two women on the bench, both in charge with a trophy on the court, when they step out under the lights Sunday.

“I’m proud of this team,” Schumacher-Cauley said. “I think I’ve said that every day. I’m proud of their fight.”

The fight transcends volleyball.



Louisville coach Dani Busboom Kelly was the 2021 AVCA national coach of the year. (Sam Upshaw Jr. / Courier Journal / USA Today via Imagn Images)

When Busboom Kelly took over at Louisville in 2017, she doubled the Cardinals’ win total, from 12 to 24, in one season.

In 2019, Louisville advanced to the round of eight for the first time. In 2021, Busboom Kelly was named the national coach of the year as the Cardinals went undefeated until the Final Four, losing in five sets against Wisconsin. A year later, Texas beat Louisville for the national championship.

“She’s led one of the great turnarounds in any college volleyball program,” Cook said.

Busboom Kelly played for Cook at Nebraska from 2003 to 2006. He recruited her off a farm near Cortland Neb. She was a multi-sport star at tiny Adams Freeman High School.

In college, she moved from setter to libero and helped spark the Huskers, alongside future Olympians Jordan Larson and Sarah Pavan, to a national championship in 2006. She won another title with Cook and the Huskers as an assistant coach in 2015.

A year later, she took over at Louisville.

“I hope people appreciate what she’s done here,” Cook said.

Louisville fans appreciate Busboom Kelly, based on the reception Thursday that she and the Cardinals received.

“I think the last time I was on the mic talking about Dani, I called her a badass,” Louisville middle blocker Phekran Kong said Friday at the news conference to preview the championship. “So I’m going to double down on that one. Because she’s legit.”

In the fourth set on Thursday, after DeBeer left with the injury that could keep the senior All-American out of the championship match, middle blocker Cara Cresse promised Busboom Kelly that she would deliver two blocks.

Cresse produced. Momentum flipped. The Panthers fell apart late in the match. Even sophomore opposite hitter Olivia Babcock, crowned Friday as the national player of the year, felt the pressure. The Cardinals embraced it.

“This is for all the people who doubted us,” Louisville outside hitter Charitie Luper said.

Her coach looked on and smiled.

More than to shatter a glass ceiling on Sunday, Busbom Kelly said, she’s excited that a woman will coach her team to the national championship so that athletic directors and future players who might go into coaching understand that it can be done.

“It’s more just being really proud that we can be role models,” she said, “and hopefully blazing new trails.”

(Top photo of Schumacher-Cawley: Dan Rainville / USA Today via Imagn Images

‘A long road. A big mountain to climb’: Inside Matt Murray’s emotional journey back to the NHL

BUFFALO, N.Y. — Matt Murray looked up to the scoreboard above him, counted down the seconds as they disappeared and finally pumped his fist.

It had been 638 days since Murray last felt the feeling washing over him.

Bilateral hip surgery forced the Toronto Maple Leafs goalie out of the entire 2023-24 season, the final of a four-year contract. There was no guarantee the oft-injured Murray would play in the NHL again. A one-year contract offered him a lifeline to continue grinding far out of the spotlight in the AHL, with only one goal.

And over a year and a half later, Murray was back to where he had fought to be: in the NHL win column after stopping 24 shots in a 6-3 win over the Buffalo Sabres.

“A long road. A big mountain to climb. But I kept this moment in the front of my mind on the days it felt tough,” Murray said.

The 30-year-old’s eyes grew more red with every word he spoke after the game. His voice quivered.

“A big release,” he said, struggling to find the words to put nearly two years away from the NHL into perspective. “A rush of emotions.”

The typical goalie hugs with teammates after the win were tighter, longer. In a physical game where a player’s career can turn on a dime, Murray’s return resonated far more heavily than the 2 points the Leafs also added on the day.

“It’s good to see (Murray) smiling,” Steven Lorentz said, “because you know he’s back doing what he loves.”

In the dressing room, Max Domi immediately handed Murray the team’s WWE-style wrestling belt as player of the game. Murray’s up-and-down performance was secondary.

“He was getting that thing, 100 percent, he deserved it,” Domi said. “The ability to stick with it mentally, out of all those days that I’m sure he had a lot of doubt, it’s a long road to recovery. We’re all super proud of him.”

It’s easy to quantify just how long Murray’s road back to the NHL was in days: 628 of them between his last two appearances.

It’s far more difficult to accurately describe just how arduous that road is.

Injuries have dogged Murray throughout his career after winning back-to-back Stanley Cup titles in his first two seasons in the NHL with the Pittsburgh Penguins. His games played tapered off every season from 2018 to 2022. After he was traded to the Leafs in summer 2022, he struggled through his first season. It was fair to wonder whether hip surgery would be the final dagger in his NHL career.

But Murray would still hang around teammates at the Leafs’ practice facility during his rehabilitation last season, feeling so close but so far away from the league he once conquered.

“The fact that he’s just on his way back here says a lot about his character, his dedication to the game,” Lorentz said.

Murray kept a stall full of his gear at that facility that was never used. An important and humane gesture from the Leafs organization, but still a reminder that Murray was not playing NHL games.

Even after re-signing with the Leafs on a one-year, $875,000 deal, he felt like the organization’s No. 4 goalie. When the Leafs needed a netminder to replace the injured Anthony Stolarz, they called up Dennis Hildeby. The lanky Hildeby is seven years’ Murray’s junior.

How could Murray not wonder whether his NHL return would ever come?

“There were definitely times when it felt really difficult,” Murray said. “But whenever I felt like that, I had a great group of people around me. That’s the only reason why I’m here.”

All Murray could do was work his tail off, far away from public sight, quietly hoping for the return that finally came Friday night.

“The emotions were high today,” Murray said.

Those emotions perhaps ran highest before the game. The typically stoic Murray allowed himself to stop and appreciate how far he’s come.

“I was able to take a moment in warmups and during the anthem and look around and appreciate the long journey that it’s been and think of all the people who helped me get here,” Murray said.

It was the kind of game that reminded onlookers of the fragility of an NHL career. Just a few short years separated Murray from being a Stanley Cup winner to being largely written off from the NHL, all essentially before the age of 30.

“You feel for a guy like that because he works so hard and he wants it so bad,” Lorentz said. “We’re all rooting for him.”


Matt Murray saved 24 shots in a 6-3 win over the Sabres, earning his first NHL win in 638 days. (Timothy T. Ludwig / Imagn Images)

Murray moved well enough in his return. He swallowed most of the 27 shots the Sabres threw at him, looking every bit the veteran he is. Murray had two goals against called back upon video review. His sprawling save on Sabres forward Alex Tuch was a reminder of the athleticism he can provide now that he’s fully healthy, too.

They’re all qualities Leafs fans might have forgotten. But they’re qualities that are still front of mind for Murray’s Leafs teammates.

“It hasn’t been forgotten in my mind what he’s accomplished in this league in his career,” Leafs forward Max Pacioretty said, himself no stranger to debilitating injuries that threaten a career. “It’s hard to almost remember what you’ve done, what you’ve accomplished because it seems like all the noise is always in the moment, whether it’s the injury or what has happened lately.”

Perhaps the Leafs win could have been predicted ahead of time. Sure, they were playing a reeling Sabres team that has now sputtered through 12 losses in a row. And they were buoyed by an upstart, white-hot line of Max Domi, Bobby McMann and Nick Robertson. They’re the third line in name only: The trio combined for three goals and 6 points against the Sabres.

But the opponent shouldn’t denigrate what was front of mind not just for Murray but also for the Leafs in Buffalo. They wanted to do right by a player who has done everything in his power to return to the NHL. You didn’t have to squint to see a defenceman like Jake McCabe throwing Sabres out of Murray’s crease with a little extra gusto.

“It gives you some incentive to go the extra mile because you know (Murray) has gone that extra mile just to get back to this position to where he’s at right,” Lorentz said. “It’s not like he half-assed it to get back to this point and he expected to be here. Surgeries and injuries like that, that he went through, that can stunt your career for a long time. You might never be able to recover to your old form.”

But Murray is working on getting back to the Matt Murray of old. And the Leafs’ need for Murray won’t end when they head north on the QEW back to Toronto.

The earliest Stolarz will likely return from a knee injury will be mid-to-late January. Hildeby doesn’t exactly have the full confidence of the Leafs organization right now after allowing a few soft goals during a recent call-up against the Sabres at home, combined with a less-than-stellar AHL season so far. He’s likely going to be an NHL player down the road, but there’s room for him to grow and develop more confidence in his game.

But Murray has what no other goalie in the Leafs organization has: experience. And that matters to Brad Treliving and Craig Berube: Both value games played and would rather lean on veterans whenever possible.

They’ll lean on Murray because of everything he’s done, and gone through, in his career.

After Friday night, that career looks drastically different.

“In reality, you’ve got to take each day as it comes and you never know when it’s going to be all over,” Pacioretty said. “So you don’t want to take days for granted.”

After Murray had dried his eyes and slowly taken off the pounds of goalie gear heavy with sweat, he sat on his own in the dressing room. The Leafs equipment staff all stopped unloading bags from the dressing room to give him a quiet pat on the back.

Murray looked up to see a note written on a whiteboard in the dressing room. The Leafs bus would be leaving in 20 minutes. There was another NHL game on the horizon.

He could smile once again knowing it certainly won’t be 628 days between being able to do what he loved.

(Top photo: Timothy T. Ludwig / Imagn Images)

How Merseyside became America’s 51st state

Beyond the dust of Liverpool’s dock road and the huge lorries rolling in and out of the city’s port, the glass panels of Everton’s new home at the Bramley-Moore Dock sparkle impressively, radiating ambition.

The site, expected to open next year, is a feat of engineering considering the narrow dimensions of the fresh land below it, where old waters have been drained to create a 52,888-capacity arena that has been earmarked to host matches at the 2028 European Championship.

The Everton Stadium, as it is currently known, has been nearly 30 years in the making and nothing about its construction has been straightforward. There were three other proposed sites — including one outside Liverpool’s city boundaries, in Kirkby — which never materialised; a sponsorship deal collapsing due to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine; three owners, Peter Johnson, Bill Kenwright and Farhad Moshiri, departing; and several flirtations with relegation. 

Ultimately, Dan Friedkin, a Texan-based billionaire, will have the honour of being in post when it is inaugurated after his group’s long-awaited takeover was completed on Thursday.


Everton’s new waterfront home (Paul Ellis/AFP via Getty Images)

It has been a momentous week for Everton, and for the region as a whole. The Friedkin Group’s takeover means both of Merseyside’s Premier League clubs are now controlled by Americans. Meanwhile, a third, League Two side Tranmere Rovers, could join them if the English Football League (EFL) ratifies a takeover by a consortium led by Donald Trump’s former lawyer Joe Tacopina.

In football terms, Liverpool is on the verge of becoming the USA’s 51st state — the name of the 2001 movie starring Samuel L Jackson and Robert Carlyle, which was filmed in the city and used Anfield, the home of Liverpool FC, as a backdrop.

It is a huge cultural shift from the days — back when that film was released — when Liverpool and Everton had local owners and an American takeover of the city’s most celebrated sporting organisations seemed unthinkable. 

And for all the excitement that Everton and Tranmere’s takeovers have generated, there remains an underlying caution — born of years of fear and frustration over the direction their clubs have taken — over what U.S. ownership will mean.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Inside Everton’s Friedkin takeover: From the precipice to fresh hope thanks to new U.S. owner


Everton is a club of contrasts. 

Much of their mainly local support comes from some of the United Kingdom’s most economically challenged districts in the north end of Liverpool, near Walton where Goodison Park is located, and the ‘People’s Club’ — as former manager David Moyes christened them — has long taken pride in not being connected to big business, particularly in comparison to their near-neighbours Liverpool.

“One Evertonian is worth twenty Liverpudlians,” said former local captain Brian Labone, who led the team he supported as a boy in the 1960s.

Yet it hasn’t always been this way. At that time, it was Everton — not Liverpool — who were the city’s big spenders under their chairman John Moores, the founder of Littlewoods Pools. Then, their nickname was the ‘Mersey Millionaires’ and the club’s modus operandi was unapologetically ruthless: one manager, Johnny Carey, was sacked in the back of a taxi.

Moores would detail several innovations that would grow the sport, making it more attractive to business. They included the creation of a European Super League (sound familiar?), the rise of television, as well as the removal of the maximum wage, leaving a free market in which the best players would go to the richest clubs.

When Liverpool started to dominate English football and Goodison Park experienced a dip in gates, Moores tried to raise more cash. One of his solutions was to bring corporate hospitality to Goodison, as well as more advertising boards around the pitch but the move experienced pushback.

“Fans didn’t like it,” says Gavin Buckland, who recently published a book entitled The End, which looks at some of the longer-term causes of Everton’s struggles. “They felt the boards intruded on their match day routine — an in-your-face commercialism.”

Attitudes haven’t changed much since, in part because successive Everton owners haven’t been able to expand Goodison which is hemmed into Walton’s warren of terraced streets. Under Kenwright, Everton played on that reputation of the plucky underdog punching above its weight; it was only when Moshiri, a Monaco-based British-Iranian steel magnate, arrived as co-owner in 2016 that the waters were muddied. 


Goodison Park – with Anfield visible at the top of the picture – is sandwiched into terraced streets (Michael Regan/Getty Images)

Under Moshiri, Everton became two clubs in one. Like Kenwright, Moshiri operated from London but unlike the theatre impresario, he had no natural connection with Merseyside. While Moshiri aimed for the stars, spending big on players and managers, Kenwright — who remained chairman and still had influence until his death last year — had a more corner-shop mentality. There was a lack of clarity over decision-making.

Enter Friedkin. Perversely, Everton’s fallen state is a major reason they represent such an attractive proposition to the San Diego-born businessman, who identified them as one of, if not the last, purchasable English football club where there is room for significant growth.

On Merseyside, there is some concern about what this might mean: Americans have tended to develop dubious reputations as owners of English football clubs due to their appetite for driving non-football revenues and seeing their investments as content providers. 

Will the new stadium, for example, become a shopping mall experience, complete with hiked-up ticket prices? Buckland speaks of a “cliff edge”, where Everton are moving into a new home, necessitating new routines for matchgoing fans, while a new foreign owner with a reputation for keeping his distance gets his feet under the table. For some, all of this at once might be too much.

Given that Friedkin cannot claim to have played a leading role in the stadium move, he is likely to be judged quickly on the team that he delivers. Any new revenue-driving schemes will only float if fortunes improve on the pitch, otherwise his priorities will be questioned.

For proof, simply look across Stanley Park. In 2016, thousands of Liverpool fans walked out of Anfield in the 77th minute of a Premier League game against Sunderland after FSG announced that some ticket prices in the stadium’s new Main Stand would be priced at £77. 

Liverpool had won just one trophy in six years of FSG ownership at that point and local fans, especially, felt like their loyalty was being exploited, given the organisation’s policy of investing its own money in infrastructure but not the team. The protest led to an embarrassing climbdown.

Liverpool was once described by the Guardian newspaper as the “Bermuda Triangle of capitalism”. It has since been framed absolutely as a left-wing city even though voting patterns suggest it should be described as a dissenting one. Its football supporters, whether blue or red, tend to confront perceived injustices, especially if it involves outsiders making money at the expense of locals, and even more so if they are not delivering on the pitch.


Liverpool have retained their working-class feel (Simon Hughes/The Athletic)

FSG were only able to buy Liverpool at a knockdown price, which its former American owner Tom Hicks described as an “epic swindle”, due to the response of the supporters who unionised themselves in an attempt to drive both Hicks and his partner George Gillett out following a series of broken promises, as the club veered dangerously towards deep financial problems from 2008.

“The missteps of Hicks and Gillett put power in the hands of the fans,” reminds Gareth Roberts from Spirit of Shankly, the fans group which is still active 16 years after its formation and which now has members on the club’s official supporters board. The latter became enshrined in Liverpool’s articles of association after FSG apologised for its leading role in the attempt to create a European Super League in 2021. 

This came after several other high-profile PR blunders that eroded trust. It remains to be seen whether figures like John W. Henry, FSG and Liverpool’s principle owner, will listen to the board rather than pay lip service and carry on regardless with his own plans. Roberts says the ongoing challenge is “getting them to understand the culture”, and it does not help the relationship when Henry’s business partner, Tom Werner (Liverpool’s chairman), speaks so enthusiastically about taking Premier League fixtures away from Anfield and potentially hosting them in other parts of the world.

There was a time when either Everton or Liverpool’s local owner not showing at a match would dominate conversations in pubs and get reported in the local paper. Now, that only happens if they actually turn up.

Leading FSG figures usually fly in from Boston, Massachusetts, attending a couple of games a season — Werner was at Liverpool’s recent game against Real Madrid, while Henry was in the stands for the first home game of the season against Brentford. They appoint executives and dispatch them to Merseyside, or London, where the club has long had an office, to run the business on their behalf. Such individuals are under pressure to drive revenues as far as they can, in theory improving the economic possibilities of the team.


John W. Henry visits Anfield for the Brentford game in August (Michael Regan/Getty Images)

Roberts says ticketing is an especially thorny issue at Liverpool due to the popularity of the club. It feels like locals are under attack: that there is a race to get the richest person’s bum onto a seat.

As far as Roberts is concerned, a club that markets its image from the energy that Anfield occasionally creates is treading on dangerous ground. “The Kop still has power,” he insists. “But if you squeeze the fans and they drop off, there is a risk that the place gets filled with spectators rather than supporters and with that, you kill the golden goose.”

This, he adds, should act as a warning to Evertonians as they embark on their own American adventure. 

Like Roberts, Liverpool metro mayor Steve Rotheram is a season ticket holder at Anfield and he understands such anxieties. In October, he spent a fortnight in North America exploring trade opportunities and the experience made him realise how powerful a brand Liverpool has abroad due to its connections with football and music, as well as its central role as a port in the movement of the Irish diaspora that spread across the Atlantic in the 19th century.

He says such history helps start conversations with American businesses from sectors like bioscience and digital innovation, which are now interested in investing in Merseyside due to the availability of land near the waterfront on both sides of the Mersey river, a hangover from the harsh economic measures of the 1980s and the decline that followed. 

Rotheram says football, especially, plays a significant role in the visitor economy to the region, which in 2018 was worth £6.2billion. A thriving Everton playing at a stadium that does a lot more than host football matches every fortnight has the potential to add to that pot. The site at Bramley-Moore promises to regenerate the area around it and, currently, there are small signs of that change. Now Everton’s immediate financial concerns have gone away, perhaps businesses hoping to move in can proceed with more confidence.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

How Liverpool 2.01 was built – and FSG abandoned any plans to sell


To reach the third professional football club on Merseyside attracting American investment, you have to cross the river.

If Rotheram gets his way, a walkable bridge will connect Liverpool to Wirral, the home of Tranmere Rovers, and potentially boost the peninsula’s economy. But for the time being, there are just two transport options: a tunnel under the Mersey or, more pleasurably, a ferry which takes less than seven minutes to sail from the Pier Head, beneath the famous Liver Buildings, to Seacombe.

In the middle of this journey, as the ferry juts north, there is a different view of Everton’s new stadium, positioned between a scrapyard and a wind farm, both of which are in the shadow of a brooding tobacco warehouse that is the biggest brick building in the world. Everton’s new home is much closer to the city and might seem enormous from the land, glistening from whichever angle you look at it, but it does not dominate the skyline from the brown, scudding channels of the Mersey.


Everton’s new stadium, as viewed from Birkenhead across the Mersey (Christopher Furlong/Getty Images)

When the novelist Nathaniel Hawthorne sailed across the same stretch of water in 1854, he recalled a scene that he thought neatly captured the personality of the Liverpudlians he’d encountered over the previous six months, having been sent to the city as American consul.

There, on the ferry, was a labourer eating oysters using a jack knife taken from his pocket, tossing shell after shell overboard. Once satisfied, the labourer pulled out a clay pipe and started puffing away contentedly. 

According to Hawthorne, the labourer’s “perfect coolness and independence” was mirrored by some of the other passengers. “Here,” Hawthorne wrote, “a man does not seem to consider what other people will think of his conduct but whether it suits his convenience to do so.”

Hawthorne did not specify whether the labourer was from Liverpool or the piece of land to the west now known as Wirral. To any outsider, the places and their residents tend to be viewed as one of the same.

On Merseyside, however, distinctions are made: Liverpudlians tend to identify themselves as tougher and sharper, while those from “over the water”, tend to have softer accents and are once removed from the struggles of the city.

In truth, both areas suffered in the late 1970s and 80s when unemployment ripped through its docks and shipyards. Whereas Liverpool’s city centre has been transformed in the decades since, the Wirral’s waterfront feels less promising. Whereas Liverpool has the Albert Dock, museums and a business district punctuated by glassy high rises, Wirral has very few distinguishable features from the river beyond its scaly, grey sea wall.

Three miles or so from the terminal in Seacombe lies Prenton, the home of Tranmere, a football club that returned to the Football League in 2018, having fallen on hard times since the early 1990s when it threatened to reach the Premier League.


Tranmere’s homely but ageing Prenton Park ground (Simon Hughes/The Athletic)

That history is one of the reasons why an American consortium led by Tacopina has an application with the EFL to try and buy the club from former player, Mark Palios, who later acted as the chief executive of the English Football Association.

The Athletic reported in September that Tacopina was attempting to “harness the power of his celebrity contacts” to try to propel Tranmere up the divisions from League Two. In a report the following month, it was revealed on these pages that rapper A$AP Rocky and Las Vegas Raiders defensive end Maxx Crosby were two of the investors.

According to a source involved in the deal, who would like to remain anonymous to protect working relationships, there is a belief the takeover will be completed in early 2025. While the source suggests it has taken longer than expected to reach this point after an unnamed investor dropped out, The Athletic has been told separately that an unnamed investor’s application was rejected by the EFL. This led to the buying group trying to source a replacement. The EFL declined to comment.

Tacopina has been involved in Italian football for a decade, with mixed success. He knows Tranmere is not a sexy name but neither was Wrexham before they were taken over by the Hollywood actors Ryan Reynolds and Rob McElhenney in 2021. While Tranmere has a fight this season to retain its Football League status, Tacopina would be taking on a club that more or less breaks even. 

Palios is naturally cautious. For years, he’s wanted to find a minority partner but interested parties have tended to find there isn’t much up-side for such investment. Palios has since been able to convince Tacopina that Tranmere has significant potential with a full takeover, that the club has geography on its side and could become the region’s third wheel.


Joe Tacopina, sat next to former U.S. President Donald Trump, wants to buy Tranmere (Andrew Kelly-Pool/Getty Images)

More than 500,000 people live on the Wirral but the majority cannot get tickets for Liverpool or Everton. There is an interest in Tranmere but many Wirral residents are only would-be fans. That would surely change with an upwardly mobile team, as Tranmere were in the 1990s when it tried to reach the top flight and a packed Prenton Park witnessed a series of exciting cup runs.

Tranmere is worth around £20million in assets. Even if the club reached the Championship, the gateway to the Premier League, the value would increase significantly, potentially leaving Tacopina with a profit if he decided to sell. Importantly, the stadium is owned by the club and Tacopina would be inheriting that. Tacopina takes confidence from the stories of clubs like Bournemouth and Brentford, who are now established in the Premier League despite playing in similar-sized stadiums to Prenton Park (Bournemouth’s is actually considerably smaller) and with little history of success at the top level. 

Prenton Park, however, does not have the facilities to generate much revenue outside of matchdays. In the boom of the early 90s, the venue was rebuilt on three sides but that did not include the main stand, which remains a relic of corrugated iron and brick. Lorraine Rogers, the chairperson before Palios, suggested the stand was costing Tranmere £500,000 a year to maintain. In 2021, a League Two game with Stevenage was postponed after a part of the roof flew off during a storm.

Palios has explored other stadium options. From the Mersey, the West float slipway leads to Bidston, where a site has been discussed but diehard fans are not enthusiastic about a move three miles away which would take the club away from its roots and potentially position it next to a waste plant, and where there are few pubs and transport links are limited.

Last summer, Palios suggested the zone was ripe for redevelopment in an interview with Liverpool Business News. “I advise my children, if ever they invest in property, invest in the south bank of the river,” he said. “As sure as apples fall from trees, this place is going to get developed.”

Any relocation, however, would need assistance from Wirral Waters as well as a council that for a decade has carefully been trying to manage its budgets due to cuts from central government. At the start of December, the Liverpool Echo reported that the council will be asking the government for a £20million bailout to prevent it from having to declare bankruptcy. 


Tranmere’s ground rises out of the streets in Birkenhead (Lewis Storey/Getty Images)

While it is generally accepted the Palios era is near an end and Tranmere needs to find a way to move forward, there is a wariness and some Tranmere supporters are questioning whether they want someone who has represented Trump in a rape trial running their club. 

Matt Jones, the presenter of the Trip to the Moon podcast, speaks of “excitement, curiosity and fear”. Two years ago, he tracked down Bruce Osterman, Tranmere’s previous American owner (and the first in English football), to San Francisco.

Osterman told Jones that in 1984, he was able to complete a takeover because Tranmere were “days away from shutting its doors”. Yet Osterman was humble enough to admit that he was ill-prepared for the challenges that followed, despite investing £500,000 in cash. “I didn’t know what the hell I was doing,” he admitted. “I had no experience in this area. I was a trial lawyer… I had no understanding of the history, or where we were going.”

Osterman says that if he had his time again, he “would probably have paid more attention to the team’s relationship with the community”. Over the next three and a half years, Tranmere’s financial position became bleaker and he ended up selling the club at a loss to Palios’ predecessor Peter Johnson, the son of a butcher who became a millionaire businessman in the food industry.

Johnson ended up buying Everton where he was much less popular. His story is a reminder that it is not just American owners who move around clubs, as Friedkin has. Johnson grew up a Liverpool fan, an inconvenient factoid which put him on the back foot at Goodison, where he encountered suspicious minds and hardened attitudes.


Cynicism is deeply embedded among Everton fans, who might wonder how long it will take for their club to see the benefits of being at a new stadium and under new ownership.

Yet Friedkin’s arrival potentially draws a line under much of the uncertainty. Simon Hart, a journalist and author who has written extensively about the club, speaks about the last few years being battered by “existential concerns relating to the club’s future to the extent you are largely numb, hoping just to survive. The impression that Friedkin seems reasonably sensible and hasn’t destroyed Roma is something to grasp and be grateful for.

“At the moment, the thing that needs answering is whether Everton can go into the new stadium as a Premier League club that is secure. There is a sense that anything that keeps the club alive is acceptable.”

Excitement is not the right word but relief might be. Hart thinks Goodison is irreplaceable, a venue where the terraces hang over the pitch and some of the timberwork dates back to the Victorian era. It is as much a part of the club’s identity as the Liver Buildings are to Liverpool. A departure inspires mixed emotions that swirl around the freezing reality that Everton has not won a trophy of any kind since 1995. 

As the years pass and the record extends, it becomes harder to escape. Hart describes Goodison as his “special place”, but it feels like “disappointment is soaked into every brick now”. He attended the 0-0 draw with Brentford in November when the visiting team were down to 10 men and it felt as though Goodison was weighed down by negative emotion.

Perhaps their new home allows the club to embrace a fresh start and, as he puts it, “allow Evertonians to look forward rather than back.”

(Top image: Getty Images/Design: Eamonn Dalton)

Woody Johnson’s Jets: ‘Madden’ ratings, a lost season and ‘the most dysfunctional place imaginable’

By Zack Rosenblatt, Dianna Russini and Michael Silver

Woody Johnson decided to do his own research.

The New York Jets’ owner was at his house in Palm Beach, Fla., last February, discussing potential offseason acquisitions with team decision-makers as they watched game tape. Wide receiver Jerry Jeudy, a former Denver Broncos first-round pick, flashed on the screen. Jets general manager Joe Douglas expressed interest, according to someone familiar with the meeting. Johnson took out his phone and started typing.

A few weeks later, Douglas and his Broncos counterpart, George Paton, were deep in negotiations for a trade that would have sent Jeudy to the Jets and given future Hall of Fame quarterback Aaron Rodgers another potential playmaker. The Broncos felt a deal was near. Then, abruptly, it all fell apart. In Denver’s executive offices, they couldn’t believe the reason why.

Douglas told the Broncos that Johnson didn’t want to make the trade because the owner felt Jeudy’s player rating in “Madden NFL,” the popular video game, wasn’t high enough, according to multiple league sources. The Broncos ultimately traded the receiver to the Cleveland Browns. Last Sunday, Jeudy crossed the 1,000-yard receiving mark for the first time in his career.

Coming into this season, the Jets had hopes of ending the franchise’s 13-year playoff drought — the longest in the four major men’s North American sports — and quieting years of talk about the franchise’s dysfunction. Instead, this season has only cemented the Jets’ reputation.

Head coach Robert Saleh was fired five games into the campaign. Douglas was fired six weeks later. Johnson suggested benching Rodgers due to poor performance — a Jets spokesperson said the owner was “being provocative. He made the statement in jest to see how it would be handled.” A week later, the Jets traded for Davante Adams, the All-Pro wideout and Rodgers’ close friend and former teammate in Green Bay. New York has stumbled to a 4-10 record and will miss the postseason for the 14th straight season.

Another offseason of turnover awaits, and at the root of the franchise’s problems is Johnson, who was characterized as an over-involved, impulsive owner in conversations with more than 20 people in and around the Jets organization — current and former players, coaches and team executives — who were granted anonymity in order to speak openly without fear of reprisal.

“They keep on doing the same thing over and over: they change the football people. The football people are not the issue,” one former executive said. “It’s, ‘Hey, I have brain cancer.’ And, ‘Well, just cut off your foot.’”

Johnson, who declined The Athletic’s request for comment, soured on his franchise quarterback less than a year after betting big on him, denigrated his own players in the locker room and seemed to follow decision-making advice from his teenage sons, according to various team and league sources. And the proposed Jeudy trade wasn’t the only time Johnson cited “Madden” ratings when evaluating players.

“There are organizations where it is all set up for you to win,” said a player with the team in 2023. “It feels completely different (with the Jets). It’s the most dysfunctional place imaginable.”


Ahead of the Jets-Giants preseason finale at MetLife Stadium in 2019, an administrative assistant popped into the team’s coaching offices to make an announcement to then-head coach Adam Gase and his staff. Woody Johnson, then serving as U.S. ambassador to the United Kingdom in the Trump administration, was temporarily returning from London. The assistant said everyone should refer to Johnson as “Mr. Ambassador.”

That has held true long after Johnson left government and returned to his role as Jets chairman in January 2021, striking a discordant tone among those who believe the organization has long been plagued by mismanagement.

“I guess that’s what you’d call him,” one assistant coach said. “I’d never been around royalty before.”

Johnson is an heir to the Johnson & Johnson pharmaceutical fortune, but he spends most of his working days at the Jets facility in Florham Park, N.J., and often meets with the head coach and general manager. When he bought the team in 2000, Johnson thought he was inheriting Bill Belichick as coach — hand-picked by Bill Parcells to take over before Parcells resigned. Belichick lasted only one day, scribbling “I resign as HC of the NYJ” on a napkin at his introductory news conference before bolting for the New England Patriots.

The legendary coach has spent much of the past two decades torturing the Jets franchise, on the field and off of it. While out of coaching this fall, Belichick mocked Johnson in various media appearances (Belichick’s camp also reached out to the Jets about their head-coaching vacancy). In an appearance on ESPN’s “ManningCast” during a Monday night game between the Jets and Bills on Oct. 14 — New York’s first game since firing Saleh — Belichick described the owner’s approach to running the organization as “ready, fire, aim.”

Many who have been part of the Jets organization during Johnson’s tenure heard that comment and agreed. Others pointed to the owner’s words on Oct. 15, the day the Jets acquired Adams, when Johnson said, “Thinking is overrated.”

“Woody is just acting on instinct,” said a current Jets executive. “With Woody, it’s like, ‘I’m right — prove me wrong.’ You just don’t know what to expect … He’s been right enough, just with his random opinions, that (a bad decision) doesn’t dissuade him. And when he’s wrong, who’s gonna hold him accountable?”

During the annual NFL Draft, Johnson is known to keep to himself while decisions are being made, according to one former executive, then exit the room and retreat to a nearby snack bar with confidants to make “smart-ass lines” about the front office’s decisions. Team decision-makers didn’t appreciate Johnson’s after-the-fact critiques, but the owner was occasionally proven correct: The executive remembers Johnson being especially vocal when former general manager Mike Maccagnan drafted quarterback Christian Hackenberg out of Penn State in the second round of the 2016 Draft. Hackenberg never played a regular-season snap for the Jets.

Some inside the organization believe Johnson is consumed with the public perception of his franchise, sometimes at the expense of on-the-field success. When the Jets traded quarterback Zach Wilson to the Broncos last April, Denver asked Douglas to include the final pick of the draft (257th overall). According to a source familiar with the negotiations, Johnson instructed Douglas to instead trade the 256th pick — which the Jets also owned — so New York could select “Mr. Irrelevant,” the final pick of the draft who is annually celebrated upon his selection.

“Can you believe that?” the source said. “He thought he needed the Mr. Irrelevant pick to get a Brock Purdy (the final pick of the 2022 draft who has emerged as a franchise quarterback in San Francisco). I don’t think that’s ever happened in the history of the NFL: A team wanted a worse pick.”

The Broncos used pick No. 256 to take offensive guard Nick Gargiulo, who is now on the Broncos’ active roster. The Jets used the “Mr. Irrelevant” pick on Alabama safety Jaylen Key, who didn’t survive the final roster cutdown and is no longer on their practice squad.

Johnson weighs in on matters throughout the organization, from lineup decisions (he forced interim head coach Jeff Ulbrich to bench starting safety Tony Adams in November) to the team schedule (he wanted the Jets to practice during their bye week, much to the chagrin of team leaders). “He’s like most team owners,” the team spokesperson said. “He asks questions of his staff to better understand what their plans are.”

“Your job becomes managing Woody,” a current team executive said. “That’s not unique for an NFL GM — the difference here is that not only are you managing Woody, but you have to manage all the people who influence him. That could be family, that could be media, that could be people in the building.”


An heir to the Johnson & Johnson pharmaceutical fortune, Woody Johnson purchased the Jets for $635 million in January 2000. (Sean M. Haffey / Getty Images)

When Johnson left for the U.K. in 2017, his sons, Brick and Jack, were 11 and 9, respectively. When he returned, they were teenagers. Last year, Johnson started including his sons in some meetings at the team facility. For some Jets employees, the sons’ increasing involvement clarified their father’s propensity for sharing posts from X and articles from various outlets, including a blog called “Jets X-Factor,” with the organization’s top decision-makers.

“When we’re discussing things, you’ll hear Woody cite something that Brick or Jack read online that’s being weighed equally against whatever opinion someone else in the department has,” said one Jets executive.

“I answer to a teenager,” Douglas quipped to people close to him before the season in an acknowledgment of the perceived power dynamic.

Johnson’s reference to Jeudy’s “Madden” rating was, to some in the Jets’ organization, a sign of Brick and Jack’s influence. Another example came when Johnson pushed back on signing free-agent guard John Simpson due to a lackluster “awareness” rating in Madden. The Jets signed Simpson anyway, and he has had a solid season: Pro Football Focus currently has him graded as the eighth-best guard in the NFL.

The Jets spokesperson disputed the idea that Brick and Jack’s observations impact the organization’s decision-making process. “It is used as a reference point; it is not determinative,” the spokesperson said. “It’s really sad that an adult would use a misleading anecdote about teenagers to make their father look bad. It’s ridiculous, quite honestly, the idea that this was used to influence the opinion of experienced executives.

“(The sons) have no roles in the organization. It’s completely ridiculous to suggest that any outside info is intended to replace the opinions of (Woody Johnson’s) staff.”

The Johnson family’s behavior inside the Jets locker room has also become an issue, according to team and league sources. NFL locker rooms are restricted-access spaces typically limited to players, coaches, team personnel and media members. But Brick and Jack have brought friends — male and female — into the locker room, and current and former players and coaches told The Athletic that Woody Johnson, his wife, Suzanne Ircha Johnson, and his sons criticized players inside the locker room.

In 2022, quarterback Mike White played through broken ribs in a late-season game against the Seahawks with postseason hopes on the line. White played poorly; the Jets lost and were eliminated from playoff contention. After the game, with the quarterback in the showers after throwing his helmet to the locker room floor, multiple Jets players said they heard Woody Johnson say, “You should throw your helmet, you f—ing suck.” The statement got back to White. The team spokesperson said Johnson apologized to the quarterback, who declined to comment for this story.

In the postgame locker room after last year’s Week 17 loss to the Cleveland Browns, multiple players said they heard Johnson’s sons loudly disparaging certain Jets players.

This year, on Halloween night, the Jets registered their first victory since Saleh’s firing four weeks earlier. It was a significant moment for a struggling team. Rodgers walked into an energized locker room with a game ball in hand, and it was expected that he’d give the ball to Ulbrich, a customary gesture when a coach gets his first NFL win.

But before Rodgers could speak, Brick Johnson took another game ball and awarded it to wide receiver Garrett Wilson in a profanity-laced exclamation, which the owner’s son later posted to Instagram. Woody Johnson then gave Ulbrich the ball Rodgers had been holding. Multiple players said the energy felt drained out of the room.

“It was the most awkward, cringe-worthy, brutal experience,” one player said.


The high point of the Johnson-Rodgers marriage came at Rodgers’ introductory news conference, when he spoke of the Jets’ lone Super Bowl trophy — won in 1969 — looking a little “lonely.” New York entered the 2023 season as one of the league’s buzziest teams — and potentially Super Bowl contenders — and the Jets were selected to appear on HBO’s “Hard Knocks” during training camp. Johnson wore a custom-made chain featuring 80 carats of emeralds and diamonds spelling out “Woody,” a gift from star cornerback Sauce Gardner.

Then Rodgers tore his Achilles on the fourth play of the season, and everything changed. Following surgery, Rodgers rehabbed with the goal of potentially returning at the end of the season, but only if the Jets were still in playoff contention.

In Week 14, New York was mathematically eliminated with a 30-0 loss to the Dolphins. Rodgers preferred to rehab on his own in Los Angeles with an eye toward the 2024 season, but Johnson, according to team sources, insisted that Rodgers practice with the team, so the quarterback reluctantly returned to New York. When Rodgers was activated off injured reserve five days before Christmas, which resulted in the release of fullback Nick Bawden, Rodgers said on “The Pat McAfee Show” that the move wasn’t his idea.

“There was a conversation: ‘Do you want to practice?’ And I said, ‘Not at the expense of somebody getting cut.’ I know how this works,” Rodgers said. “I didn’t feel like I needed to practice to continue my rehab. I could do on-the-field stuff on the side. But obviously I got overruled there.”

Several Jets players and coaches — Garrett Wilson and running back Breece Hall, in particular — were unhappy with offensive coordinator Nathaniel Hackett throughout the 2023 campaign. There were rumblings that Johnson wanted to fire Hackett, so Rodgers, who considers the coach a close friend, brought it up with the owner at the end of the season. The conversation “didn’t go over well” with Johnson, according to a current Jets executive.

Johnson ultimately didn’t force Saleh to fire Hackett, as he had with Mike LaFleur after the 2022 season. In the offseason, Saleh tried to hire a veteran offensive coach to join the Jets staff and potentially reduce Hackett’s role, speaking with Arthur Smith, Kliff Kingsbury, Luke Getsy and Eric Bieniemy. Rodgers got on the phone in an attempt to recruit, but each coach took jobs with offensive coordinator titles elsewhere.

Before this season, according to a team source, Johnson demanded that Saleh’s signature phrase — “All Gas, No Brakes” — be stripped off the walls around the facility. “Another completely out-of-context and false narrative,” the team spokesperson said. “That was removed as part of the entire organizational rebrand.” Saleh later introduced a new team motto: “Love and Regard,” which was not displayed on the facility’s walls.

Rodgers and Johnson spoke on Oct. 7, just after the Jets lost to the Vikings in London to drop to 2-3, a game behind the Bills in the AFC East with Buffalo coming to MetLife Stadium the following Monday night. According to a team source, Rodgers implored Johnson to remain patient.

The following morning, Saleh called Rodgers to let him know he was demoting Hackett and installing passing game coordinator Todd Downing as the new play caller. Rodgers made it clear to Saleh that he did not agree with the decision — so much so that Saleh told his staff to get backup Tyrod Taylor ready to play in case a banged-up, disgruntled Rodgers wouldn’t, according to a team source.

Shortly afterward, around 10 a.m. ET, Woody and Christopher Johnson, Woody’s brother and the Jets’ vice chairman, walked into Saleh’s office. Woody told Saleh he was fired. Saleh asked why. Woody told him he didn’t think Saleh could turn the season around and that the team needed a spark. Then the Johnsons walked out of the room.

Ulbrich, installed as the interim coach, went forward with Saleh’s plan to demote Hackett and managed to calm the waters with Rodgers, who hadn’t been in favor of firing Saleh, according to multiple team sources.

On the Dec. 3 episode of McAfee’s show, Rodgers, in reference to the 12-2 Detroit Lions, talked about how much of a difference it makes when owners back their coaches and general managers both privately and publicly. The next day, he was asked by members of the media if he felt that Jets ownership operates in that way.

“Is that a rhetorical question?” Rodgers said. “I cited an example I’ve seen. There were other examples in Green Bay, both for and maybe not, as for whoever was in charge. But I think it’s an important part of ownership to hire the right guys, set the vision and support them when the outside world is trying to tear them down.”

On follow-up, he was asked again whether he believes that’s been done in New York. “I’d have to look,” he replied. “I’ll ask you guys, has there been a lot of public comments? Supportive comments?”

The response from reporters that day? Not really, there have been firings.

“Yeah, there’s your answer,” Rodgers replied.

The Jets kept the exchange out of the transcript of Rodgers’ news conference.


In addition to firing the head coach and general manager and suggesting the benching of the star quarterback, Johnson has pursued cuts across the Jets organization.

This offseason, he forced Saleh to fire five coaches and wouldn’t allow Douglas to replace former assistant GM Rex Hogan (who Johnson forced Douglas to fire in January). “The open role was used to re-organize the staff,” the team spokesperson said. “The notion that he didn’t want that position replaced is untrue. The responsibilities were filled by employees who deserved promotions.”

The Jets didn’t hire officials for training camp, a standard practice in the NFL, after being the most penalized team in the league in 2023 (they are the third-most penalized team in 2024). They did have officials for two joint practices with the New York Giants and Washington Commanders, respectively.

Several men from Johnson’s investment group have been attending free agent, draft and other football operations meetings at Johnson’s behest over the last year, according to a current Jets executive. They’ve also interviewed Jets employees from across the organization about their roles and ways they feel the Jets can improve. “It was a positive initiative that identified real gaps in process and communication and collaboration,” the Jets spokesperson said. “(Woody Johnson) values the independent feedback. It’s a way to avoid groupthink. We learned a lot from it.”

Multiple Jets employees refer to the group of men as “The Bobs,” a nod to the condescending corporate efficiency consultants from the film “Office Space.” The arrival of “The Bobs” has only heightened a sense of dread around the building, where some employees don’t feel like they can speak freely.

“There’s no nice way to say what we need to say, which is: Unless we drastically alter our culture and the way we do things from the top down, we have no chance,” one executive said. “There’s not a comfortable environment where you can speak your mind and try to address things that could improve the situation. You have to tiptoe around it.”

The Jets spokesperson disputed that characterization. “That’s just a false premise,” the spokesperson said. “(Woody Johnson) really just seeks out and welcomes feedback and debate. We wouldn’t have been named one of the best places to work in New Jersey if people thought that way … there’s never been a complaint.”


Whether or not Aaron Rodgers will return for a third season in New York is one of the key questions facing the Jets this offseason. (Mike Ehrmann / Getty Images)

As recently as three-and-a-half years ago, there was a different atmosphere at Florham Park. Woody Johnson’s absence during the first Trump presidential term meant that Christopher was running the show.

Like Woody, Christopher Johnson was influenced perhaps too heavily by media coverage — one team source said he was known to lean on prominent media members for advice during his head coach and GM searches in 2019 — but the impression he gave to many in the building was that he wanted to give the keys to the people he hired and let them take the wheel.

“Chris was really, really laid back,” said a former Jets coach. “He’s not a person with any type of ego. When he would talk with you, he was really a regular dude. He never, ever acted like he was the owner or he was in charge; he was just basically trying to get along.”

When Christopher Johnson hired Douglas (in 2019) and Saleh (in 2021), both were under the impression that, when he returned, Woody Johnson would take a similarly hands-off approach. They quickly learned how wrong that assumption was as Woody took control and Chris stepped back.

“It’s not like he just disappeared, but you wouldn’t know if Chris was in the building or even in the room with you,” a former Jets executive said. “He’s just so quiet and reserved. And that’s not a bad thing.”

Some Jets employees hoped Woody might retake his ambassadorship in the U.K. after Donald Trump was elected president in November, which would once again put Christopher in charge. But on Dec. 2, Trump nominated billionaire Arkansas investment banker Warren Stephens to the post. According to team sources, the decision came as a surprise to the Jets owner.

As the Jets close the 2024 season, they’ll enter an offseason promising wholesale change, familiar territory for an organization that hasn’t found much stability since Johnson bought the franchise from the estate of Leon Hess in 2000. In 25 years, the Jets have employed eight interim or full-time head coaches (nine if you count Belichick) and seven general managers. They’ll need another new head coach and general manager and must decide if they want to bring Rodgers back for what would be his 21st NFL season — if he wants to return.

Those decisions remain Woody Johnson’s to make.

(Illustration: Demetrius Robinson / The Athletic; photos: Chris Coduto, Matthew Stockman, Cooper Neil, Perry Knotts / Getty Images)

Joao Fonseca: Brazilian tennis starlet who plays beyond his years but still gets homesick

What’s the right moment to hitch your hopes to an up-and-coming tennis player?

People were having visions of Carlos Alcaraz’s future when he was 10, the age at which Babolat and the other big racket companies sometimes start handing out equipment and swag. At France’s Les Petit As, the premier tournament for juniors 14-and-under, any prospects racking up games, sets and matches will already have an agent in their parents’ ear, if not a signed contract.

By those measures, having faith in Joao Fonseca, the easy-going Brazilian teenager with the wavy light hair who can already hit serves at 140mph (225kmh), seems like a pretty conservative bet.

Some more numbers. At 18, he’s the youngest player to make the field for the ATP Next Gen Finals in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, a competition for the top-ranked men’s players who are 20 or younger. And at 6-foot-1 (185cm), Fonseca is in the Goldilocks zone — not too tall, not too short — of players who have won most of the Grand Slams the past decade.

Fonseca grew up worshipping Roger Federer, which is part of the reason his lead sponsor is On, the Swiss sports manufacturer that Federer has a significant stake in. On signed Fonseca, who hails from Rio de Janeiro, two years ago when he was just 16.

“They said it was going to be me, Iga (Swiatek) and Ben Shelton,” Fonseca recalled during an interview last month. “Of course I said yes.”

Perhaps Fonseca’s business acumen is as precocious as his tennis talent. On’s stock price was $17.36 two years ago. It’s around $55 now. His contract lets him travel with a physiotherapist full time; it’s also gotten him onto the practice court with Shelton, 22, when they have landed at the same tournaments.

The first time they met, at the 2023 Mallorca Championships, Shelton figured out Fonseca was the new guy in the On team and suggested they practice the next day.

“I was like, ‘I am nothing and you want to practice with me?’,” Fonseca said.

GO DEEPER

Ben Shelton: ‘I didn’t want to be one of 50 Nike guys’

He wasn’t nothing then and he certainly isn’t now. He won the U.S. Open junior title in September 2023, the season he became the first player from Brazil to top the junior rankings. In February, he smashed Arthur Fils in the first round of the Rio Open, 6-0, 6-4. At the time, the loss appeared to be a major setback for Fils, who is now ranked top 20 in the world and was the favorite for the Next Gen tournament, which began December 18.

They played each other in the last match of the first day. Fonseca beat Fils again, in five best-of-four game sets, breaking on a sudden-death deuce in the final set before serving out like a veteran. Then he hammered Tien, dominating but for a one-game blip in the third set. He is into the semifinals with a group match going spare.

That first loss in Brazil has become more palatable for Fils ever since it happened. Fonseca started the year ranked world No. 727. He’s up to No. 145 now and he came within a couple of games of his first Grand Slam main draw in New York this August, losing to Eliot Spizzirri — four years his senior — in three sets in the last round of qualifying.


Joao Fonseca in full flight in Rio de Janeiro. (Wang Tiancong / Xinhua via Getty Images)

The obvious comparison to a top player is world No. 1 Jannik Sinner, given Fonseca’s big serve, easy baseline power and shy demeanor on the court and off it. Fonseca hums along like a flywheel, ready to whip his opponent off their axis when he leans into a forehand, or perhaps a two-handed backhand down the line. He can also change gear.

At the Madrid Open, Fonseca went a set down to Alex Michelsen, an American who is another rival in the 20-and-under bracket. Outplayed in cross-court forehand rallies, Fonseca started marmalizing balls straight down the middle and asking Michelsen to generate angles, pinging anything short to the corners. Michelsen couldn’t pass the exam: Fonseca served him a 6-0 bagel to level the match and prevailed in the third set.

“He is a player who can play his best under big pressure, and he has the ability to adapt fast to different situations,” his coach Guilherme Teixeira wrote over email. Teixeira has been working with his charge since he was 11; Fonseca’s mother, Roberta, has watched him play for much longer than that.

Roberta, who also answered questions over email, said she has never seen her son get nervous before a tennis match. She remembers him losing when he was eight or nine because he kept volleying balls that were heading out back into play. He was seriously upset leaving the court, but as soon as he saw his mother he started begging her to sign him up for another tournament.


None of this, including qualifying for the Next Gen Finals, guarantees anything. Alcaraz and Sinner both won it on their climb up the tennis mountain, but the tournament has also featured younger versions of Alexander Zverev, Stefanos Tsitsipas, Daniil Medvedev, Taylor Fritz, and Casper Ruud — all of them Grand Slam finalists but just one of them, to date, a winner. Medvedev won the U.S. Open in 2021. Many of the fabled eight at the end of each season have never gotten close.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Daniil Medvedev is the fly-swatting enigma of men’s tennis – and he’s taking a moment

Fonseca is in this year’s lineup alongside Fils and Luca Van Assche of France; Michelsen, Learner Tien and Nishesh Basavareddy of the U.S.; Jakub Mensik of the Czech Republic and Shang Juncheng of China, who also goes by his Americanized name, Jerry Shang.

It’s hard to say whether there are any Grand Slam finalists in that group, especially in tennis. The kids with the swag and the spots at Les Petits As may be alright, but wariness in the face of teenage hype is the far safer posture. Brazil hasn’t produced a top men’s tennis player since Gustavo ‘Guga’ Kuerten, the three-time French Open champion and former world No. 1 who helped revolutionize tennis with his early adoption of polyester strings.

For decades, players from the country and the rest of South America have had to overcome their rearing almost exclusively on red clay. It’s a far greater challenge for them than for players from other red clay hubs like Spain because of the distance that South Americans have to travel to find different playing surfaces and opponents. There is no wonder that young people tend to gravitate to the far more accessible game of soccer instead, before getting to talk about the influence of World Cup trophies, Ronaldo Nazario and Neymar. To play tennis in Brazil, you mostly have to be a member of a private club.


Joao Fonseca has already represented Brazil at the Davis Cup. (Emmanuele Ciancaglini / Getty Images for ITF)

Fonseca remembers traveling to Europe to compete for the first time when he was about 13. He played on a public court in Germany with a picturesque view. Tennis balls appeared free and unlimited.

“In Europe, you have so much more help,” he said.

He was lucky enough to be born into a family of means with sports-mad parents. His mother flirted with professional volleyball. She and her husband, who competed in junior tennis in Brazil as a teenager, have run half-marathons and competed in road and mountain cycling and adventure races.

“Sport runs through our veins,” Roberta said.

Joao played just about anything they offered to him, including soccer, volleyball, swimming, judo, skateboarding, surfing, and skiing, plus tennis. His mother said he excelled at all of them.

At six, he would score all the goals at soccer tournaments for his academy while also chasing back on defense. He could swim all four strokes from an early age, and his swim club bumped him to the competitive team. He achieved his purple belt in judo at 10.

Teixeira spotted his tennis potential when he first saw him at 11. The quality of his shots, his pure contact with the ball, was far ahead of other kids his age and older, but there was something else he noticed. Wins didn’t excite him all that much and losses didn’t make him all that sad.

“On tour, you need to compete and practice week after week and be able to manage your emotions,” Teixeira said. “He just resets his mind and starts again.”

In the last year, Fonseca’s first as a full-fledged professional, Teixeira has seen him dial up that dedication. He is treating tennis as his career for the first time, engaging in practices and gym sessions with what Teixeira describes as a new level of seriousness.

This is a typical training day schedule for him, which begins with tests on his muscles to determine how hard he can go that day:

  • 8:30 a.m.: Tests
  • 9 a.m.: Physiotherapy and warm-up
  • 10 a.m.: Gym
  • 11 a.m.: Practice on court
  • 1 p.m.: Lunch and rest
  • 3 p.m.: On court
  • 4:30 p.m.: Gym
  • 5:30pm: Physiotherapy, if needed

Teixeira said Fonseca is also paying more attention to his rest and what he eats. He is diligent with breathing exercises that can help him stay calm during matches. Improving his footwork is high on the agenda for 2025.

Fonseca is still a teenager, though. He can only manage a month or so away from home before fatigue and homesickness set in. This season, he tried to play tournaments for four or five weeks, before returning home for a couple weeks of training and seeing his friends and family.


Joao Fonseca reacts to winning the U.S. Open boys’ singles title in 2023. (Sarah Stier / Getty Images)

He’s still a teenage tennis player too. His biggest challenge is consistency: figuring out how to win when he isn’t playing his best. In junior tennis, the better player — the one with the best technique and the best shots — usually wins the tournament. That’s not how it shakes out during the serious stuff.

“In the pro tour, there’s a lot of players that can find the solutions, and the ones that find more solutions during the tournaments, during the weeks, they have better results,” Fonseca said. He went 7-7 in ATP matches this year; not bad for an 18-year-old. Sinner was 11-10 in 2019, the year he turned 18.

Fonseca has time, but for some things he is impatient, especially shaking that assumed allegiance to red clay and slow courts. Instead, he wants grass to be his best surface one day

“I love Wimbledon,” he said. “I want to be like Sinner or (Novak) Djokovic. Those guys that play good on any surface.”

(Top photo: On)

Mykhailo Mudryk doping test ‘a dagger to the heart of Ukrainian football’

It was only six months into Russia’s invasion of Ukraine when, on a balmy September evening in eastern Germany, I came across Mykhailo Mudryk shortly after midnight.

This was September 2022 and Mudryk was by then an emerging talent for the Ukrainian champions, Shakhtar Donetsk. He scored and was the team’s major attacking threat in a shock 4-1 victory for Shakhtar in the opening match of their Champions League campaign against German team RB Leipzig.

For Mudryk and his team-mates, the Champions League offered respite from the horrors of home. When Russian bombs landed in Ukraine in February 2022, many of Shakhtar’s foreign players took emergency refuge in a windowless room of a Kyiv hotel, before interventions from multiple national embassies, football federations and UEFA, the European football governing body, hatched an escape plan.

Shakhtar had, at that time, more than a dozen Brazilian players on their books, but many left for safer climes when the Ukrainian season ceased and did not return. Football did resume in Ukraine for the 2022-23 season and Shakhtar, who were first uprooted from their home in Donetsk in 2014 following Russian-backed incursions, were playing home matches in the relatively safer city of Lviv, in Ukraine’s west — though games were still frequently paused by air raid sirens.

Shakhtar’s squad was a shell of its former self, including only one player bought for more than £2million ($2.51m at current rates). This squad was largely comprised of young and inexperienced men. When they played against Real Madrid the following month, their starting team included 10 Ukrainian players, eight who had been produced by the club’s youth system and seven were aged 23 or below.

Mudryk, only 21, all of a sudden became the poster boy of a team whose indomitable spirit and improbable resistance appeared to encapsulate the Ukrainian struggle.

On that evening in Germany, The Athletic was embedded with the Ukrainian side to produce a documentary about their attempts to play on in the midst of war. I briefly spoke to Mudryk and his midfield team-mate and best friend Georgiy Sudakov as they headed out of their hotel in Leipzig in the early hours of the morning. Their heads were spinning after an unlikely victory, the adrenalin coursing through their veins. But, they explained, they also wanted to walk freely in the night, in a place where there were no shelters, no screams, no air raid sirens to force them rapidly underground, to remind themselves of normal life. For half an hour, they did that, before returning to their rooms.

At that point, Mudryk’s star was only just beginning to shine. He was raw, in the extreme, and had it not been for the untimely exodus of Brazilian players, it is unlikely he would have become risen to prominence so rapidly.

This was a player who only debuted for his national team in June 2022 yet by January 2023, following a handful of impressive performances in the Champions League, including against Real Madrid, Mudryk became the most expensive Ukrainian footballer in history. He signed for Premier League side Chelsea, who committed an initial £62m, plus £26.5m in potential additional payments dependent on his and Chelsea’s success.

This week’s news that Mudryk has tested positive for the banned substance meldonium is a dagger to the heart of Ukrainian football and leaves the player in a fight to salvage his career. The extent of the damage will hinge on the result of Mudryk’s ‘B’ sample, which is yet to be revealed, as the adverse finding relates to his ‘A’ sample, but he has been provisionally suspended by the English Football Association.


Ukraine’s Euro 2024 campaign turned into an emotional symbol of national pride (Andrzej Iwanczuk / NurPhoto via Getty Images) 

Chelsea’s commitment to acquiring the player was significant, tying him to a seven-and-a-half-year contract, with the option of another year. Even in the middle of the invasion, Shakhtar managed to attract a bidding war, such was the interest. He had previously been pursued by Germany’s Bayer Leverkusen, as well as Newcastle United, Brentford and Everton in the Premier League, but it came down to a fight between Arsenal and Chelsea.

At the time, Shakhtar’s director of football Dario Srna told The Athletic: “If somebody wants to buy Mudryk, they must pay huge, huge, huge money. Otherwise the president of the club (Rinat Akhmetov) will not sell him. All the clubs must respect the president, respect Shakhtar and in the end they must respect Mykhaylo Mudryk, who is one of the best players I saw. The price is so big.”

Srna said he rated Mudryk as being only behind Kylian Mbappe and Vinicius Junior in his wide forward position and insisted big money would be required, considering Manchester United signed Antony from Ajax in a £86m deal and Jadon Sancho from Borussia Dortmund £73m, while Manchester City bought Jack Grealish for £100m.

Shakhtar, conscious of the power of sport in steering the narrative around the war, also announced upon completion of the transfer that their own owner, Rinat Akhmetov, would donate $25m to the war effort, to support in particular the defence of Mariupol and the families of those who have lost loved ones. The agreement with Chelsea also included a clause that said Shakhtar would play a future friendly against Chelsea in Donetsk, when and if that area of Ukraine is no longer occupied by Russian forces.

“It is written into the contract,” Sergei Palkin, the Shakhtar chief executive, told The Athletic in January 2023. “But actually, we did not even need to read it in the contract because Behdad Eghbali (the Chelsea co-owner) spoke with our president. Behdad supports Ukraine a lot because he is American and it is an English club, so this is a positive triangle. When you say England and Ukraine, it is important for our war support.

“It was Behdad who proposed (the friendly), because he said he wanted to help Ukraine, to help Ukrainian refugees and to support Ukrainian people. This match (in Donetsk) would be like a miracle (having not played in their home city since 2014). We would have this match every weekend if we could.”

When Mudryk was unveiled at Stamford Bridge, he did so wrapped in a flag of Ukraine. The player was born and raised in the city of Krasnohrad, close to Kharkiv, one of the most brutally hit areas of the country. “Since the the beginning of the full-scale war, my city has been bombarded with missiles day and night,” Mudryk said, speaking in a powerful video of 13 Ukrainian players talking about the impact of the war on their hometowns, released by the Ukrainian Football Association before the European Championship in the summer of 2024.


Mudryk (left) competes with Arsenal’s Martin Odegaard last month (Ryan Pierse / Getty Images)

He is a more reserved figure than his Ukrainian compatriot Oleksandr Zinchenko, who has been at the forefront of media initiatives to promote solidarity with Ukraine. He appears to be a devoutly religious figure, a follower of the orthodox Christian faith, who carries religious icons with him to games. On his chest, he has a tattoo that reads: “Dear god — if today I lose my hope, please remind me that your plans are better than my dreams”.

For his national team, the speaking has more often been done on the field, most notably when he scored the winner in a victory over Iceland to take his country to Euro 2024. Ukraine exited that tournament at the group stage and Mudryk did not score, although his nation went out only on goal difference with all four teams in Group E tied on four points after three games.

For club and country, he is yet to fulfil his potential. He has scored only five goals and recorded four assists in 53 Premier League appearances for Chelsea. This week’s sample revelation cast doubt on his ability to play at all, meldonium being a drug that previously saw the tennis star Maria Sharapova barred from competing.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Explaining Mudryk’s drugs ban: What is meldonium – and possible punishments

The adverse test was reported during a routine urine test, according to a Chelsea statement. The club added that Mudryk “has confirmed categorically that he has never knowingly used any banned substances”.

Writing on Instagram, Mudryk said the result “has come as a complete shock as I have never knowingly used any banned substances or broken any rules”.

He added: “I am working closely with my team to investigate how this could have happened.

“I know that I have not done anything wrong and remain hopeful that I will be back on the pitch soon. I cannot say any more now due to the confidentiality of the process, but I will as soon as I can.”

The English Football Association’s (FA) anti-doping regulations state that any breaches will be dealt with as strict liability violations. For example, a player will be found guilty of a violation if a prohibited substance is found in that player’s body. It is not necessary to demonstrate intent. A player’s alleged lack of intent or knowledge is not a valid defence to a charge.

A violation of the FA’s anti-doping regulations carries a maximum penalty of a four-year suspension, although mitigating factors can reduce that from anywhere from two years to just a month. The B sample will be key.


Shakhtar’s Georgiy Sudakov voiced support for his friend Mudryk (Christof Koepsel / Getty Images)

As Mudryk’s career hangs in the balance, the Ukrainian football establishment appears to be rallying behind him. Multiple sources in Ukraine, who remain anonymous because they did not have permission to speak, have indicated to The Athletic that the player suspects he may have been sabotaged while he was away with his country’s national team this season — a claim we have seen no evidence to support — but which is being taken seriously in his own country.

On Instagram, the Shakhtar midfielder Sudakov posted a message of support, urging his friend to “stay strong”.

The Shakhtar CEO Palkin, meanwhile, wrote that Mudryk is a “high-profile professional athlete”, adding that he has complete trust that the player “did not use any banned substance”.

Palkin said: “I am confident that he will prove his innocence.” Time will tell whether their faith is warranted.

(Top photo: Etsuo Hara/Getty Images; design: Dan Goldfarb)

Hater’s guide to the College Football Playoff: Dabo turns SEC tears into holy water

Of the many things worth hating about college football, most of them are at least tacitly associated with the most hated people in sports: television executives.

They fix games that hurt your team. They don’t fix games that should be fixed to help your team. They find a way to keep those games at four hours. They won’t let their employees say “two-minute warning” even though we all know it’s A TWO-MINUTE WARNING. They’re giving us 18-team leagues with teams that are 18-hour drives apart, and so much stiff Nick Saban acting. They say “harumph” under their breath a lot, when they aren’t breathlessly debating the 36 teams that will make up NFL Campus North and NFL Campus South.

They are, per previous reporting from The Athletic’s Grant Brisbee, “chuzzlewits and pecksniffs.” And by the way, add that World Series Hater’s Guide to the list of targets of this Hater’s Guide, because that one was much funnier. This one, however, does have a curveball in its repertoire: some love for the TV execs. Before getting into the 12 teams of the College Football Playoff and why each is uniquely worthy of deep resentment and scorn, let’s celebrate the one that isn’t here.

Thank you, media rights overlords, for not forcing Alabama into our living rooms when the Crimson Tide didn’t deserve it, even though so many were sure you would. We all know you can buzz into the selection committee deliberation room with a direct order, and I imagine it’s delivered at booming levels by an enormous hologram that gives off a scary “Wizard of Oz” vibe except with the visage of Lou Holtz. You held off this time, and maybe it’s because oil people are scarier than TV people, but whatever. Thank you.

Moreover, thank you for existing and making the resulting SEC administrator/coach/public relations — er, media — weeping such a hoot. Oh, you’re going to stop scheduling competitive nonleague games? Going Mercer-McNeese State-Maine-Murray State and keeping it at eight SEC games if that’s how they’re going to treat you? Here, let us reintroduce you to the people who run the sport.

Greg Sankey may tweet about schedule strength and have a humorous-yet-somewhat-tender anecdote for every coach he introduces at SEC media days, but check out his necktie collection and understand he’ll always side with team “harumph.” So good luck with that.

And good luck, Alabama, in the Spoon Makes Annoying Clinking Sound Against My Cereal Bowl. On to the games that mean more.

Tennessee at Ohio State, winner gets Oregon: Ducks, Bucks and Pilot Flying J welcomes trucks

Apparently, because Ohio State fans are spoiled brats who would rather fire their 66-10 coach and imprison Connor Stalions than win a national championship, more Vols fans are going to gather Saturday at Ohio Stadium than did on Nov. 26, 2017, in Knoxville. That’s the day a bunch of them got together to falsely accuse Ohio State’s defensive coordinator of heinous crimes because they didn’t want him to be their football coach.

Schiano shaming joins mattress burning, butt chugging and mustard bottle chucking in a tapestry of Tennessee embarrassments over the past two decades, but things are much better now thanks to Josh Heupel and his football team. These people are thrilled to be in the Playoff — the Vols are usually fighting for something like the How Much More Would You Trust Raiders Owner Mark Davis If His Haircut Wasn’t A Bowl — and they’re acting like it.

In an elite “X” matchup of fans who post awful things that no one should ever say to other humans, Vols fans have apparently duped Buckeyes fans into selling them their tickets. I’d say I’m surprised, but Ohio State fans also seem to think Knoxville is a tropical paradise in the winter and that temps in the high 20s will make the Vols turtle the way the Buckeyes do every time they see winged helmets.

Just understand, Vols: In Ohio, they actually have elected officials who make up crimes, and felonies at that. If you win, walk quietly to the locker room with your eyes down. If you so much as touch a flag, the punishment will be harsher than the things that Buckeyes Boosters members will be screaming at Ryan Day when he leads his team onto the field Saturday.

Team we’d most hate to reach semifinals: Ohio State. Oregon and its fans can’t really hang. Too many goofy uniform combinations? Too much caffeine in Dan Lanning’s bloodstream? Sure. Phil Knight and Nike’s sordid history? Yes, and Tennessee’s got “Big” Jim Haslam and Pilot Company. But did you see the signs and tailgate props of Browns fans, most of whom are Buckeyes fans, when Deshaun Watson — signed by Jimmy Haslam to the worst contract in sports history — started his tenure? Those people deserve another decade at least of sports misery.

Indiana at Notre Dame, winner gets Georgia: Jimmy Chitwood and Rudy in a slap fight

Has anyone ever worn a visor and not looked like a dolt? Let’s do an online poll, write-in candidates only because I can’t for the life of me come up with a name: The person in human history who has looked coolest wearing a visor is ______.

On an unrelated note, say two things for Georgia coach Kirby Smart: He wins a lot of football games and he convinces his players no one thinks they can win any football games.

His next challenge is to find a way to turn these Bulldogs into underdogs against the winner of the state football championship of a state known for its basketball.

What tradition though, right? Indiana men’s basketball, with all of one Final Four in the past 32 years, having last won it all in 1987, a few months after “Hoosiers” introduced Jimmy Chitwood to movie audiences.

Goodness, the last time IU hoops got as close to a natty as the final 12 teams was in 2002, when Notre Dame coach Marcus Freeman was a 16-year-old star linebacker, getting recruited hard by Notre Dame and realizing he’d prefer a program that could sell recent championships (Ohio State) over 1920s newsreels.

But coaching Notre Dame football? It’s a sweet deal — witness Freeman’s contract extension for following up a loss to Northern Illinois with a bunch of wins over teams not quite that bad. He’ll be hailed far and wide if he can beat the Fighting Curt Cignettis. Notre Dame’s last natty was in 1988, a few years before “Rudy” hit theaters. It keeps coming back to the late 1980s, which is fitting because much of that state seems to wish we still lived in the late 1980s.

Team we’d most hate to reach semifinals: Georgia. Sorry, but Sankey sort of Darth Vaders up the whole enterprise. Notre Dame is right there, though. At least 99.99 percent of unaffiliated fans would pick Indiana, which is about as likely as an Indiana Jones sequel in which Indy searches for Knute Rockne’s 1924 practice whistle and trades in his leather fedora for a visor.

SMU at Penn State, winner gets Boise State: Blue field, gold Trans Am, white out

One of the big things they’re watching in this 12-team Playoff is the logistics involved in the four programs that are hosting games. Does everything go smoothly? How does the hotel situation work out? Who do the bowl reps have to pay off to make sure this doesn’t happen again?

It’s especially daunting at Penn State, and not just because the nearest hotel room with a color TV is in Altoona, 44 miles away. Penn State representatives are working hard to fool James Franklin and his team into thinking this is actually a pre-conference game against an FCS opponent. Right down to signs at the local bookstores that read, “Beat Southwest Montana University.”

This means an extensive labyrinth of heaters in the stands, so fans can take part in the traditional “White Out,” but in shorts and T-shirts. No expense is being spared, because we all know how James Franklin and his team react to the words “big game.” If you get into big games against Ryan Day and lose those games, you might have a problem in big games.

Now, Penn State fans sometimes go overboard on the Franklin criticism. I saw one after the Ohio State loss who posted that Franklin is “literally taking a blowtorch to this program,” and I had so many questions. Literally? How big of a blowtorch? More of a flamethrower? To the exterior of the football building, the weight room, the footballs themselves? I need more information, including on how the media got away with the cover-up.

Then again, Franklin is incredibly elusive with media, pretending to put on a Harry Potter invisibility cloak and slipping out when he gets tough questions. Big games, schmig schmames. Put my money on Franklin when it’s a big presser and you need a coach who says absolutely nothing.

Team we’d most hate to reach the semifinals: Penn State. It’s almost not worth mentioning. I mean, sure, Boise State has a blue field, which is the sort of thing you’d expect from a team with a postseason ceiling of the Need A Sharper Knife To Scrape The Resin Out Of This Bowl. But it also has Ashton Jeanty. Some of the SMU people are terrifying, but let’s give them some grace — they were missing their football program for a few years.

Speaking of not being able to get out of the late 1980s, we need some new joke fodder for the Mustangs if they’re actually going to be good now — Eric Dickerson’s gold Trans Am and the death penalty have jumped the shark. Figuratively.

Clemson at Texas, winner gets Arizona State: Oh God, You Sun Devil

Did Clemson coach Dabo Swinney already give away the result of the College Football Playoff? Gamblers, pay attention. Here’s what he said to ABC’s Molly McGrath in the moments after his three-loss Tigers beat SMU to claim the ACC title and automatic bid: “We all thought the door was closed on us. But this was God’s plan for us. That’s all I can tell you. God just opened the door and they fought their butts off.”

You know, another person with the same beliefs in the same situation might have kept it to his or her own personal faith and how much strength it has provided, or even how important God has been to certain individuals on the team. A person in that situation might have considered that not all people who root for Clemson have the exact same religious beliefs and that the other team probably has a lot of folks who do, which would make it difficult for God to pick one side or the other in a football game. Some with deep religious beliefs might even have a problem with the idea that God would care about the result of a football game.

But not Dabo! No sirree! Apparently that Clemson fire zone blitz is so good it’s holy, especially when deployed against heathenly opponents. Perhaps then it is written, and not just on Clemson message boards, that Dabo, armed with favor from above, having forgiven the transfer portal, is due for a natty and the resulting bonuses to take that salary higher than $12 million.

Team we’d most hate to reach the semifinals: Clemson. You’ve made Texas a sentimental choice and unworthy of being insulted in this piece, Dabo. For shame. The winner plays Arizona State, a great story, but also a team that might be best off in the Underrated Date In Which You Don’t Have To Spend Or Talk Much Is To Go Bowl.

(Photo of Dabo Swinney: Bob Donnan / Imagn Images)

Falcons bench QB Kirk Cousins for rookie Michael Penix Jr. amid struggles

The Atlanta Falcons are making the move they clearly did not want to make – replacing veteran quarterback Kirk Cousins with rookie Michael Penix Jr. starting immediately.

Falcons head coach Raheem Morris announced the decision Tuesday night in a statement released by the team.

“After review we have made the decision Michael Penix Jr. will be the Atlanta Falcons starting quarterback moving forward,” the statement read. “This was a football decision and we are fully focused on preparing the team for Sunday’s game against the New York Giants.”

That statement came less than four hours after Morris had hinted at the move during a regularly scheduled news conference the day after the Falcons improved to 7-7 by beating the Raiders 15-9 in Las Vegas.

“We didn’t play particularly well at the quarterback position,” Morris said. “That’s the thing that’s got to be addressed.”

Penix was drafted eighth by the Falcons in April. It was a surprise move at the time considering the organization had signed Cousins to a four-year free-agency deal the previous month that guaranteed the 13-year veteran $90 million in salary the first two seasons and had a total potential worth of $180 million.

The plan at the time was to sit Penix behind Cousins for at least a year, and Morris had been holding out hope as recently as last week that he could stick with that plan. The head coach, who was hired in January, repeatedly referred to Penix as “the future” and said the Falcons were committed to their “plan” at the position.

“You can look at organizations that have put young guys out there too early, and it’s gone terrible and I don’t want to be that guy,” Morris said last week. “I do know the plan that I have and what I want to do for that young man.”

However, Cousins’ last five games convinced the Falcons they could no longer stick to the plan. He threw nine interceptions and one touchdown in that span and ranked 33rd in the league in expected points added per dropback (minus-.14). When the quarterback was told Monday night that Morris said he needed to play better, Cousins replied, “It’s stating the obvious.”

“I don’t think that’s a mystery,” he said after passing for 112 yards. “Every week you go through your process and plan to go out there and play the very best you can. This week will be no different.”

Morris said Tuesday that he didn’t notice any physical issues with Cousins that “jump off the page.” The 36-year-old returned this season from a ruptured Achilles tendon that ended his 2023 season after eight games.

“Some of it is natural progress of erosion through a football season,” Morris said of Cousins’ appearance in the pocket.

The start to Cousins’ season made it look like Atlanta’s long-term plan was going to work. He was fourth in the league in passing yards (2,328) and touchdowns (17) and seventh in EPA per dropback (.15) through Week 9, and the Falcons raced to a two-game lead in the NFC South.

From there, though, Atlanta lost four straight and fell behind Tampa Bay (8-6) in the division as Cousins floundered. According to The Athletic’s projections, the Falcons now have a 23 percent chance to win the division and a 31 percent chance to make the playoffs.

“Kirk got us into a point of contention,” Morris said last week. “You have to have the resolve to stay steady-handed with a guy you believe in. I don’t want to be like some organizations that make harsh decisions on your people when they make their mistakes. It’s our job and my job to back him at the highest level of certainty to get him to get out there and play better. He’s going to come out of this thing, and he’s going to go on a run here.”

He didn’t, though, and now the Falcons are turning to Penix, the former University of Washington quarterback who led the Huskies to the national title game last season and twice was a Heisman Trophy finalist. How the Falcons handle Cousins from here is an open question. It would cost them $65 million in dead money if they released him after this season, according to Over the Cap. If they hold on to him through the 2025 season either in a return to the starting role or as a backup, they could cut him after that season and incur only a $25 million dead cap hit.

The Falcons could also attempt to trade Cousins this offseason. The Raiders, Titans and Giants are expected to draft a quarterback but might also be interested in bringing in a veteran to help the transition. The Saints, Panthers, and Jets could also make changes.

Cousins’ track record of success will give him some value on the trade market despite this season, in which he stands 17th in EPA per dropback (minus-.05). However, his time ends in Atlanta, this is not how anyone envisioned it.

Required reading

(Photo: Kevin Sabitus / Getty Images)

Why is the NBA All-Star Game format changing again? To boost competition — and intrigue

LAS VEGAS — As expected, the upcoming NBA All-Star Game in San Francisco will be a mini-tournament of three teams composed of the top 24 players in the league and the team that wins the Rising Stars Challenge.

Yes, the idea behind the change — this will be the league’s third different All-Star format since 2020 — is to try and make the game more competitive. But also, or instead, or at minimum, to make it more interesting to watch on TV.

“I think we’ve come to terms that modern All-Stars are in part about competition, but ultimately, they’re about entertaining the fans and creating a strong experience for them,” NBA commissioner Adam Silver said Tuesday in an interview with The Athletic and other national media outlets.

“As you guys know, I was wrong about last year,” Silver said. “I thought in Indiana that given the sort of fact it was sort of viewed as the heartland of basketball and a strong presence from some legends there, that the guys would roll the clock back a bit and play a traditional game and it wasn’t meant to be.

“And so we went back to the drawing board with the players association, again, talking directly to players and said, ‘Let’s come up with a format that we think has a better chance of creating a game, or in this case, a series of competitions that will be of interest to the fans.’”

The new format, announced jointly Tuesday by the NBA and National Basketball Players Association, will include three games — two semifinals and the championship — in which the winner is the team to reach 40 or more points first. There is a prize money pool of $1.8 million, with the champion team earning $125,000 per player.

The selection of the league’s top stars will not change. Twelve players from each conference will be named All-Stars, with fans, media and players voting on the five “starters” and the seven reserves from each conference decided by coaches.

Those players will then go into a pool for picking by TNT’s three analysts — Charles Barkley, Kenny Smith and Shaquille O’Neal — who are serving as honorary general managers for the three All-Star teams. They will divide the teams into three groups of eight All-Stars on Feb. 6 before TNT’s weekly doubleheader.

Honorary general manager for the Rising Stars team is another Turner Sports analyst, Candace Parker. The Rising Stars Challenge takes place on the Friday of All-Star weekend; the All-Star tournament is on Feb. 16 at Chase Center.

The coaches for the All-Star Game will come from the staff of the first-place team in each conference as of Feb. 2. The head coach from each first-place team will coach an All-Star team, an assistant from one of the staffs will coach the Rising Stars champion and another assistant will coach the remaining All-Star team.

In November, The Athletic reported that Silver’s office was consulting with players, including the Golden State Warriors star Stephen Curry, on changing the All-Star Game again in another attempt to make the event more competitive. Silver credited players’ association executive director Andre Iguodala with leading the discussion on the players’ side with Silver’s office.

As Silver referenced, last year’s All-Star Game in Indianapolis set a new record for points scored — and that wasn’t a good thing, as players on both teams simply didn’t play with any effort whatsoever on defense.

“With the elephant in the room being us competing, them trying to shake things up is expected and makes sense,” said Oklahoma City star Shai Gilgeous-Alexander, who is a two-time All-Star. “But at the end of the day, it’s going to come down to whether the players want to go at it, and I would love to see that. Love to be a part of that for sure, and hopefully it happens.”

Fan voting for All-Stars will begin on Dec. 19. There were no changes announced to All-Star Saturday programming, but it is expected Curry and WNBA star Sabrina Ionescu, who is from the Bay Area, will engage in a shooting competition for the second consecutive All-Star Saturday.

Silver said the league has worked with the players association to decrease the All-Star Game pregame introductions and national anthem productions so the players could have a more normal warm-up routine before playing.

GO DEEPER

Steph Curry consults with NBA to change All-Star format for San Francisco game

“When I was a kid growing up and watching All Stars, it was one of the only opportunities you had as a fan to see many of these players,” Silver said. “It was one of the only time that these players came together. It’s just such a different world now. They’re together all the time. They’re together in the summer. They’re together on national teams.

“For us, it’s a recognition that it’s a different time,” Silver continued. “And, you know, we’ll see. I’m encouraged with this new format that we can create some real excitement there.”

Required reading

(Photo: Kyle Terada / USA Today)

Was Emi Martinez’s save against Nottingham Forest the best of the Premier League era?

Emi Martinez’s save from Nottingham Forest’s Nicolas Dominguez was arguably the best we have seen in the Premier League this season.

Alan Smith, commentating for Sky Sports, dubbed it “miraculous”, which does a slight disservice to changing water into wine, but you get what he’s saying.

Jamie Redknapp said he couldn’t think “of a better Premier League save in my life”, although those last three words felt a little unnecessary.

Anyway, it’s cued up on the video below and, you’ll likely agree, it was great.

But how did it compare with other great saves in the Premier League era?

Saves are much harder to remember than goals, so let The Athletic jog your memory.


The Premier League congratulated itself for existing in 2012 when it ran the Premier League 20 Seasons Awards.

There was a bit of recency bias among the winners, what with Wayne Rooney winning best goal for his shinned overhead kick for Manchester United a year earlier, while 2011-12 was named best season and Nemanja Vidic was voted into the all-star 20-year team.

Gordon’s save against Bolton was fresh in the memory too, but it’s hard to argue against it winning the 2012 award and it stands up very well today.

Zat Knight is only a couple of yards out when he forcefully prods the ball goalwards.

Gordon sticks out an arm…

And claws it over the bar. Points off because it was only from Zat Knight, but still, tremendous save.

Everton’s 1-0 win over Chelsea in May 2022 was iconic in a number of ways: Richarlison celebrated his winning goal with a blue flare, Everton’s victory at a feral Goodison Park went some way to keeping them in the Premier League, and Pickford produced a memorable diving save from Cesar Azpilicueta.

After Mason Mount’s shot hit the post, a sprawling Pickford was outside of the width of his posts as the ball headed to Azpilicueta…

Pickford immediately recognised the danger and curved his sprint behind the goalline to give himself extra room to make the impending save…

… and he has to adjust his body to dive to his right after running slightly past the angle.

“I’ve had worse,” he said after. Oh Jordan, you joker.

The most cat-like save on our list. James is caught short, sorting out Portmouth’s wall, on the opposite side of his goal when referee Uriah Rennie tells Gareth Barry he can take a quick free kick.

James sprints across his goal and dives at full stretch to tip the ball around the post.

Peter Schmeichel, Manchester United vs Liverpool, 1993

Pure reflexology from the OG PL GK (original gangster Premier League goalkeeper).

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

‘Take me back to the 2000s’: Premier League nostalgia and the perils of comparing different eras

It’s a story as old as time; attacker versus goalkeeper, one-v-one, powerful shot, strong save. And there is no better example in Premier League history.

Schmeichel’s left wrist is stronger than steel, forged from working as a cleaner in an old people’s home in his youth.

Don Hutchison shouts “f***” and puts his head in his hands. It’s an appropriate reaction.

There are two good indicators that a special save has just happened:

1) Fans make a goal celebration noise but then just cut to stunned silence; or

2) Players put their head in their hands.

Four Swansea players do this after Joe Hart’s save from Federico Fernandez in 2015.

What preceded their reaction was an acrobatic save of the very highest quality. Fernandez’s header is directed towards the corner…

But Hart fingertips it over the bar.

Miguel Almiron absolutely harrumphs this volley like his life depends on it…

But Alisson unleashes his inner Gandalf and almost screams, “You shall not pass!” with a save that almost defies gravity and physics.

Cudicini let in four goals in this game, a humdinger of a 4-4 thriller at the old White Hart Lane, but he also produced one of the finest saves of the Premier League era.

Tottenham’s Dimitar Berbatov, with a free shot from 12 yards, should obviously score, but when he lines up his attempt Cudicini’s weight is heading left…

… but he adjusts his body and sticks out an almighty right paw to somehow block it.

Probably the save with the quickest reaction time on our list.

Arsenal’s Leno had just blocked from Christian Eriksen, but the ball was headed out to Moussa Sissoko who thwacked it full pelt from the edge of the box.

With two players in the way, Leno can only see the ball at the last millisecond…

But sticks out a hand to divert it over.

Ian Wright tweeted the word ‘Leno’ with several clapping emojis. Can’t say fairer than that.

Right, please leave your “I can’t believe X save was included, I could have saved that” and “Why isn’t X save on the list, I’m unsubscribing” comments below. Cheers.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Emiliano Martinez: Hated by opponents, loved by Argentina, endlessly entertaining

(Top photo: Martinez’s save against Forest; by Shaun Botterill via Getty Images)

Mets went wild for Juan Soto: Why a measured approach might come next

After signing Juan Soto to the richest contract in sports history, people familiar with the New York Mets’ thinking about filling roster holes said the club plans to act “aggressively yet smart.”

Such phrasing suggests the Mets will take their shots with some of the talent available on the market but may want to avoid being tied to another long contract. So it would seem their preference, even in some cases with large annual average values, would be to go short-term.

That might mean the Mets prefer homegrown star Pete Alonso to return on a shorter deal rather than conceding entirely if Alonso’s desired figures run on the long end. That might mean a reluctance to go five years, possibly even four years, for Sean Manaea, a pitcher they’d like to re-sign. And it might mean wanting Walker Buehler, someone who’d fit in well with them, for something like a one-year deal with an option rather than a straight multiyear pact.

The Mets inked Soto last week at 15 years and $765 million, underscoring in big bold lettering owner Steve Cohen’s willingness to spend for what he wants.

What Cohen desires most, though, is a perennial winner, not a team prone to big ups and downs.

So while a team’s winter is always difficult to predict because opportunities sometimes arise unexpectedly, it wouldn’t be surprising if the rest of the Mets’ offseason reflected a more measured approach.


Steve Cohen (left) made a splash by paying up for Juan Soto, but expect upcoming moves by David Stearns to be more understated. (Al Bello / Getty Images)

In Soto, the Mets saw a generational player and viewed splurging on him as a rare opportunity. He’s 26 years old and one of the game’s most prolific hitters. They’ll continue looking for ways to supplement a roster that includes star Francisco Lindor, veteran Brandon Nimmo and breakout player Mark Vientos. But just because they committed so much to Soto, doesn’t necessarily mean they’ll fill other holes by any means necessary.

The Mets splurged multiple times a few years ago with mixed results at best. One year, they experienced success. The next year, they needed to pivot. That is why Cohen hired David Stearns as president of baseball operations, to run things with an emphasis on viability.

Sensible trade options exist for the Mets, particularly if they don’t match with free agents such as Manaea, Buehler, Nick Pivetta or someone similar. There is no guarantee the San Diego Padres’ Dylan Cease or the Houston Astros’ Framber Valdez will be traded, but both pitchers seem to work under the Mets’ plan. They’re both set to be free agents after the season. Thus, they both would be motivated to have big seasons. In either, the Mets could see an opportunity.

Other opportunities to upgrade the pitching staff may involve starters under club control. Garrett Crochet, 25, stood out as an example. The Mets engaged with the White Sox about Crochet before Chicago dealt him to the Red Sox, which indicated a willingness to part with high-end talent from the farm system. But talks between the Mets and White Sox went only so far because the Mets didn’t want to part with what the White Sox wanted and ultimately received (multiple top prospects). The process served as a data point in learning how Stearns operates with the Mets.

After reaching the NLCS in his second year leading the Mets, Stearns doled out his three largest contracts with the club: Soto, obviously, plus Frankie Montas (two years, $34 million) and Clay Holmes (three years, $38 million). In the case of Holmes, Stearns used money to beat out other teams interested in converting the All-Star reliever into a starter. Still, that’s not exactly akin to going an extra year on someone like Alex Bregman. It’s more taking a shot on someone based on processes and acting with conviction within guided parameters. Veteran agents often compliment Stearns for his ability to collect information, read the market and then make a decision. He is not easily susceptible to being on the wrong end of a bad contract.

While the Soto deal highlights Cohen’s capabilities, what comes next figures to feature Stearns and his front office’s track record.

(Top photo of Juan Soto and David Stearns: David Dee Delgado / Getty Images)

Joao Lucas Reis da Silva, the first out gay active professional male tennis player, was just posting a selfie

Saturday, December 7, Joao Lucas Reis da Silva, a 24-year-old professional tennis player, did about the most normal thing anyone does these days. He posted a couple selfie on Instagram.

It was his partner’s birthday, so he posted a sweet carousel of them posing by the water in Rio de Janeiro. “I love you so much,” he wrote. The post made him a trailblazer — the first out gay active professional male tennis player — but he was just wishing his partner a happy birthday.

“I didn’t think about it… I just wanted to post a picture with him,” Reis da Silva told The Athletic Sunday from São Paolo, in his first international interview since he inadvertently made himself a part of tennis history.

About an hour earlier, he had won a tournament for the first time in four years, defeating Daniel Dutra da Silva 7-5, 1-6, 6-4 to lift the Procopio Cup and earn a spot in the qualifying at the Rio Open, the ATP 500 event he has played the past two years. Not a bad few days for the world No. 367.

“It’s been a crazy week but in the end it was perfect,” he said. After two long injury layoffs, the 24-year-old said he has played the best tennis of his life of late, reaching the semifinals of a tournament in Chile before this run to the title in São Paulo. Even as he felt the tennis world watching him in a way it never had before.

“I didn’t feel pressure,” he said. “I was happy. I had my boyfriend here with me. He was supporting me. My whole team was here.”


The women’s tennis tour has had numerous out gay players, including all-time greats Billie Jean King and Martina Navratilova, who won 98 Grand Slam titles between them across singles and doubles.

Men’s tennis has not been this way. Bill Tilden, the American star who dominated tennis in the 1920s, never publicly discussed his sexuality outside of his 1948 book, “My Story: A Champion’s Memoirs.” Brian Vahaly, who played in the 2000s and reached a career-high of world No. 57, and Bobby Blair, on tour in the 1980s, came out after they had retired from professional tennis.

Reis da Silva said Sunday that he told his family and friends that he was gay five years ago. “Before that, it was tough,” he explained.

“I couldn’t say too much about myself to my coaches, to my friends. When I tried to love myself, that was something different. It changed my life, changed everything, the relationship with my parents, with my coaches.”

Over a year ago, Reis da Silva fell in love with Gui Sampaio Ricardo, a Brazilian actor and model. Then Ricardo’s birthday rolled around for 2024, and Reis da Silva did what 24-year-olds do.

“I was like, ‘Oh my god, it’s my boyfriend’s birthday. Like happy birthday. I love you.’ And then, boom!

“It was so normal for me that I didn’t think about it.”

Messages and support from big names inside and outside the tennis world began to roll in. Lulu Santos, a massive music star in Brazil, sent him a message. Thiago Monteiro, Brazil’s current No. 1, added heart emojis to the post. He got a like from Diego Hypolito, a gay Brazilian gymnast who won a silver medal at the Rio Olympics in 2016.

Just like that, this largely unknown player from Recife, a coastal city in Brazil’s northeast corner, had become a sports and cultural icon. He said he expected to receive some negative reactions, but the responses have been “99.9 percent positive.”

“I’m really happy that people respect me, that people look at me, admire me maybe,” he said.


Joao Lucas Reis da Silva on his way to winning the Procopio Cup in São Paolo, Brazil. (Joao Pires / Photojump)

Speaking in an interview with The Telegraph in 2018, Vahaly said that he heard homophobic comments from other players in the locker room, describing it as “part of the culture.” He added that he hoped for a time when “we can say, ‘Congratulations,’ and then quickly move on. For people to be defined by their sexuality is what we need to get past.”

Reis da Silva, who said he was aware of Vahaly being honored by the U.S. Open (he will be USTA president beginning in 2025), remembers being 18 and hearing someone saying something offensive in the gym.

“In the locker rooms and at tournaments I used to hear some things that kind of bothered me,” he said.

“But when I started to tell everyone that I’m gay and these people knew about it, they stopped saying these things. It’s like when they have someone close to them that is gay, they respect them more. They stop doing sh**** comments,” Reis da Silva said.

“Maybe that’s a big thing to stop it — if people see someone in the top that is gay, things can change. People might stop saying things they shouldn’t that hurt people.”

Alison Van Uytvanck, the recently retired former world No. 37 who is married to physio Emilie Vermeiren, said that she never received any negative comments in the locker room. In an interview earlier this year, Van Uytvanck told The Athletic that “it is kind of surprising“ that the ATP Tour was yet to have an out, active male player.

“If only one player, like a top 100 player, would be open about it, it would be easier for others to open up.”

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

‘Now I can breathe a bit more’: Alison Van Uytvanck on life after tennis and Grand Slam anxiety

Reis da Silva said seeing a role model in the sport would have made a huge difference to him.

“When I was 16, 15, I had problems accepting myself.

“Maybe if I had had someone playing saying, ‘I’m gay, I’m here, I’m competing for the big tournaments,’ it would have been easier for me to accept myself and to love myself. People have told me that. People told me that they admire me. That I inspire people. So it’s a big deal for me and them.

“I don’t have a problem with being remembered as the great gay tennis player,” he said, “but I don’t want to talk about that every time, you know?

“I know there will be a lot of attention on me.”


Born into a tennis-playing family, Reis da Silva said he began hitting balls when he was three. He followed in the footsteps of his brother, who is six years older and who competed at the junior level. As a little boy, Reis da Silva was so obsessed with tennis that he would cry when his father told him it was time to go home.

He began to compete nationally at 10, leaving home at 13 for São Paulo, where he lived and trained for seven years before he moved to Rio de Janeiro. Reis da Silva prefers to battle from the baseline, rather than rush the net, and he rates his service return and his backhand as his biggest weapons.

“I love to break serves,” he said. “I like to stay there in the point and be aggressive in my forehand and play big rallies.”

He has competed throughout the U.S., Europe and Australia in addition to South America, playing the Grand Slams as a junior. After the win in São Paulo, he plans to take a week off, including a few days of holiday with his boyfriend in Porto de Galinhas, the beach town known for its natural pools and white sand. He will then spend Christmas with his boyfriend’s family in Goiania, a small city in the center of the country near the capital, Brasilia.


Joao Lucas Reis da Silva hitting his favorite shot during the Wimbledon boys’ singles in 2018. (Michael Steele / Getty Images)

After that, he will return to Rio to begin preparations for some Challenger tournaments (one rung below the ATP Tour) that lead into the South American ATP Tour swing in February and the Rio Open. His big goal for 2025 is to play in the qualifying tournament for Roland Garros — and to build the tennis life he wants.

“It’s an individual sport, so you can be whatever you want,” he said hopefully. “Everybody will accept you.”

(Top photo: Joao Pires / Photojump)

‘I can’t believe it came to this’: His Lions fandom is his identity. He almost lost it

NORTHVILLE, Mich. — Fahad Yousif is two days removed from receiving something called a Certificate of Completion from the National Football League. It is dated Dec. 12. It is signed by Ari Novick, Ph.D., a licensed psychotherapist with a private practice in Laguna Beach, Calif. It is numbered “Cert #216932,” meaning 216,931 others presumably have received such an honor. It cost $250 — the fee Yousif paid for a four-hour course covering about eight or nine chapters of fan behavior expectations in NFL stadiums. 

He holds up his phone to show me. 

“I can’t believe it came to this,” he says. 

This is what happens when it all goes too far. Yousif is the Detroit Lions fan who decided to chirp at the Green Bay Packers sideline during pregame festivities at Ford Field last weekend. Some choice words (no swearing, he makes clear) were followed by drawing his thumb across his neck, making a slashing motion. That, it turns out, was a terrible, terrible idea. Because to some, notably Packers coach Matt LaFleur, what started as some mouthy fan talking trash had crossed over to a raving madman making a threat. LaFleur fired back at Yousif. Yousif, smiling wildly, yelled back at LaFleur. Security got involved. 

Yousif was on the field as a perk of his ticket package. Allowed to choose one add-on bonus for the 2024 season, he opted to be one of those fans who pull a giant American flag taut across the field during the pregame national anthem. Instead, security escorted him off the field before the anthem ever began.

The dust-up went viral. Yousif, after returning to his seat, was ejected from Ford Field before halftime. Then LaFleur spoke about the incident in the postgame news conference, saying Detroit’s pregame activities should’ve been policed better. On Wednesday, the Lions revoked Yousif’s season tickets. Then he was banned from attending NFL games. Every day brought new waves of coworkers and old friends texting, “Did I see you on TV?” and media requests. Yousif took each opportunity to acknowledge he was in the wrong and apologize. Everyone, including Yousif, more or less agreed that he went too far out there. 

Near the end of the week, the Lions and the league offered a path forward. The stadium ban would be lifted, Yousif was told, if he completed the code of conduct class and wrote a formal apology. 

Now, here we are. It’s Saturday afternoon, nearly a week removed from the incident, and nearly 24 hours until the Lions host the Buffalo Bills in the NFL’s marquee game this weekend. Yousif accepted an invitation to meet at a Starbucks in Metro Detroit. 

Maybe this could be about life in the blast radius of a viral moment. 

Or it could be about nearly missing out on what might end up as the greatest season in Lions history. 

Or about contrition. 

Or second chances.

But then Yousif is asked about what he nearly lost. 

“Oh, man, everything,” he says. “This is who I am, and, you know, I almost lost that. I don’t dismiss any of the criticism I’ve gotten. None of it. I agree with most of it.

“I was blessed with an honor to hold the flag of a country I love. I crossed the line and it shouldn’t have happened. I get where people are coming from. I can’t believe this happened.”

Yousif is a lot of things. He’s a product of Metro Detroit’s vast Chaldean community — a first-generation American born to a father from Iraq and a mother from Kuwait. He’s an older sibling to two brothers. He’s a Wayne State University graduate. He’s a sales associate for a Midwest automotive tools company. He’s a husband to wife Gabby.

What he most identifies as, though, is as a Lions fan. 

Yousif grew up speaking only Arabic at home. He tried everything to fit in at school and came to feel most comfortable talking about football. He says that, growing up attending Farmington Hills public schools, he’d introduce himself by saying, “Hi, I’m Fahad. I’m a big Lions fan.” 

Yousif ignored pleas from his father, Saad, to play soccer. He instead lined up at defensive end and linebacker through middle school and into high school. He scored tickets to his first game at Ford Field in 2013. He and an older cousin began attending four or five games a year. 

“It was so natural,” Yousif says. “It was like, this is where we’re from, this is who we root for. Root for the Lions, no matter what.”

Yousif grew to learn and understand the game more and more, but, like so many others, fell into the same trap that’s befallen generations of Lions fans. He believed. 

“Oh, the Matt Patricia era, bro,” he says now, fighting through a laugh, “I totally bought the hype.” 

But like all those generations of Lions fans, something came from that belief. Shared experience. Yousif convinced his father to start rooting for the Lions. He sold the dream. “This is the year.” Soon, Yousif stopped attending games, choosing instead to watch them at his dad’s house. Two chairs. Big-screen TV. Standing appointment. 

“Every year, he got more and more into it,” Yousif says. “He finally got it, and it kinda changed our whole relationship. Those years weren’t very good for the Lions, but, you know, they were good for us.” 

The Dan Campbell era in Detroit began in 2021 with the franchise trading star quarterback Matthew Stafford for Jared Goff. Yousif called his father the minute the news broke. It was mid-March. Saad, at 65, was newly retired and ready to get aboard his next ride as a Lions fan.  

Six weeks later, Yousif got word that his father was feeling sick. He entered the hospital. He was placed on a ventilator.

“It was so quick,“ Yousif says. “Within 10 days, he was dead.” 

Yousif hasn’t mentioned any of this through his numerous media appearances this week. Viral moments don’t afford time. That, and his story doesn’t excuse what happened last week. 

“It still shouldn’t have happened,” he says. “I was also a big pro wrestling fan growing up and I think I’ve got some of that in my personality. I root for the heel.” 

That personality, you can be certain, is big. Yousif is the loudest person in the coffee shop by a wide margin. He speaks like he’s drinking jet fuel. One customer has closed his laptop and moved to a far table. But Yousif can’t really seem to help it. He seems to only operate with excitement and emotion and in equal proportions. 

Until he talks about these last few Lions seasons. After his father’s death, Yousif wasn’t sure he could watch the Lions anymore. Every game was tied to loss, no matter the outcome. Saying this, he gets caught, and pauses, jaw clenched, cheeks trembling. 

The 2021 season came and went. He watched games in 2022 at home with an empty seat for his dad. Before 2023, he decided to make the big move. Season tickets. Lower bowl. Section 141, 33 rows up. 

He watched his team go 12-5 and win the NFC North last season. 

“I know it sounds crazy — really, I do — but it’s felt like Dad being like, yo, it’s OK, I got you,” he says. “I’ve been telling people these last few years that he’s got his hands all over this. I found a lot of comfort in that. I think he heard me say I didn’t want to watch the Lions anymore. He wanted to make it easier.” 

Now Yousif is rooting for football’s unlikeliest juggernaut. The Lions are 12-1 and current favorites to do it — something so unthinkable that we won’t even say it.

Neither he nor anyone else can quite wrap their heads around what is all playing out. Yousif says he admits his mistake, and accepts the punishment, but also believes LaFleur overreacted and perhaps this all never needed to escalate so much. He’s hoping for another Lions-Packers matchup in the playoffs. 

He plans to be there for it. Just as he plans to be in the stands for Lions-Bills. A massive group of longtime season ticket holders who operate a tailgate out of Eastern Market invited him to Sunday’s tailgate. There might be an available ticket for him.  

While his season tickets are gone, apparently forever, Yousif can still go see his team. 

So he’ll go be a fan.

He doesn’t know how to be anything else. 

(Illustration: Meech Robinson / The Athletic; photos: Nic Antaya / Getty Images; Courtesy of Fahed Yousif)

This 49ers season is effectively over — and Kyle Shanahan bears plenty of responsibility

SANTA CLARA, Calif. — And in the end, after another postseason heartbreak, after an emotionally exhausting offseason, after the drama-filled holdouts and the gnarly wave of injuries and the personal tragedies, after a star player’s lash-out and, with a team’s hopes hanging in the balance, an infuriating and surreal tap-out, the San Francisco 49ers’ 2024 season finally collapsed under its own weight.

Buried under the wreckage, barely able to speak at an audible volume, was Kyle Shanahan — the man who had the most to do with the 49ers’ failings, and the biggest culprit behind a last-gasp attempt to extend an era that seemed doomed from its inception last February.

Shanahan, the Niners’ eighth-year coach, was standing at a lectern after the defeat that all but mathematically eliminated the defending NFC champions from playoff contention, one that came courtesy of his fiercest professional rival. With a 12-6 victory at Levi’s Stadium on Thursday night, Sean McVay’s Los Angeles Rams (8-6) boosted their playoff hopes while exposing the 49ers (6-8) as a team that lacked the purpose, precision and unity to play beyond the first weekend in January.

In the end, with desperation in the rain-filled Northern California air, Shanahan’s offense couldn’t produce a single touchdown, San Francisco’s special teams were typically sloppy and an uncharacteristically strong defensive effort was marred by veteran linebacker De’Vondre Campbell Sr.’s stunning refusal to enter the game when summoned in the third quarter.

All of that falls on Shanahan — that’s why he sits in the big chair — and he made no attempt to run from it.

“Not good enough,” Shanahan said of the offensive effort he coordinated Thursday, though the words applied to everything about this defeat and to this challenging season.

Those words also served as an epitaph to a six-season stretch in which the 49ers suffered two excruciating Super Bowl defeats to the Kansas City Chiefs, lost a pair of wrenching NFC Championship Games (including one to McVay’s Rams) and assembled a loaded roster stacked with some of the league’s most talented and resilient players.

Together, they built a formidable foundation, won a lot of big games and at times felt indomitable.

What we witnessed Thursday night was the NFL’s equivalent of rubble — and the group charged with cleaning it up, and rising from it, will look much, much different in 2025 and beyond.

GO DEEPER

A tale of two 49ers linebackers: Dre Greenlaw enters, De’Vondre Campbell exits — abruptly

“There’s been a dark cloud over us all season,” veteran cornerback Charvarius Ward told me after the game. “This will be a good offseason for this team to regroup, refocus and try to rekindle the spark.”

Ward, a second-team All-Pro in 2023, is headed for unrestricted free agency next March and is one of the many marquee 49ers who might not be on next year’s roster.

“I don’t know if I’m gonna be back,” Ward continued, “but I know this team is still gonna be great, with or without me.”

That remains to be seen, because Thursday’s faceplant — and, really, this entire season — has underscored how different this 49ers team is from its immediate predecessors.

Once again: Not good enough. Realistically, not even close.

The NFL is a production business, and Shanahan — who along with general manager John Lynch assembled this group, and was charged with coaching it up — will have to wear the stain of his team’s consistently substandard performances. The Niners have just two victories over opponents with winning records (the Seattle Seahawks and Tampa Bay Buccaneers) and suffered three brutal defeats to division foes after squandering late leads.

On Thursday, with a chance to stay in the NFC West race, they fell woefully short, and produced a lowlight reel in the process.

Wide receiver Deebo Samuel Sr., who complained on social media earlier in the week that he wasn’t getting the ball enough, had a brutal drop that likely cost him a chance to reach the end zone for a game-changing score. The 49ers were penalized for two illegal formation penalties on punts. Shanahan, after Brock Purdy connected with tight end George Kittle on a 33-yard pass early in the game — against a defense that had given up 42 points to the Buffalo Bills four days earlier — got weirdly conservative, calling three consecutive runs in Rams territory and settling for a 53-yard field goal by Jake Moody. And Purdy, coming off his best game of the season, struggled in the rain (a recurring theme) and later threw a brutal end-zone interception with 5:20 remaining and the 49ers in range for a game-tying field goal, essentially killing their chances.


Deebo Samuel had a chance to make a game-changing play for the 49ers. Instead, he dropped the ball. (Thearon W. Henderson / Getty Images)

And, amazingly, none of those gaffes came close to being the night’s most ignominious moment. That belonged to Campbell, a veteran linebacker signed in March as a placeholder for Dre Greenlaw — the passionate playmaker who tore his Achilles while running onto the field after a punt during the second quarter of Super Bowl LVIII, and who finally worked his way back Thursday night to try to help save San Francisco’s season.

He almost did, before his body betrayed him. The 27-year-old enforcer, one of the sport’s most criminally underappreciated stars, picked up where he left off in last February’s Super Bowl, before the farfetched injury that helped doom the Niners to defeat.

Had Greenlaw been rusty against the Rams, it would have made plenty of sense.

He wasn’t. Rather, he was the best player on the field.

Greenlaw had eight tackles, many of them prolific and sudden and violent, before leaving the game midway through the third quarter with knee tightness. At that point, Campbell was the next man up.

Campbell, however, did not exactly man up.

Apparently upset over losing his job to Greenlaw — hardly a shocking development to anyone in the 49ers’ locker room, or outside of it — Campbell, according to Shanahan and numerous players, declined to enter the game.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

49ers’ De’Vondre Campbell refuses to play, quits TNF game in third quarter

“He said he didn’t want to play today,” Shanahan said. Campbell, who eventually was sent off the field and into the locker room — almost certainly never to return — was described as “selfish” by Ward and Kittle during postgame interviews.

“That was his plan,” Ward told me. “He had his mind made up. I mean, it’s crazy. He’s not a better player than Dre. You saw that today — (Greenlaw)’s the engine of our defense, the guy who starts everything for us. But you could see (Campbell’s decision not to play) coming for a while.”

The juxtaposition of Campbell quitting on his teammates with the resilience of players like Ward and rookie wide receiver Ricky Pearsall was staggering.

Pearsall, shot through the chest during a robbery attempt shortly before the start of the season, missed six games before returning and making his NFL debut. Ward missed three games after his daughter, Amani Joy, died in October, shortly before her second birthday. (Amani Joy was born with Down syndrome and a heart defect that required surgery.)

After Thursday’s game, Ward opened up to me about the trauma he and his family have endured, doing his best to affirm his commitment to his teammates while acknowledging that football isn’t the preeminent force in his life right now.

“It’s been hard for me personally to go to work every day, every game — even to practice or go to meetings,” he admitted. “I almost left a couple of times. S—, I know fans probably hate me (for saying that), but f— it, it’s real life. It’s bigger than football. This is the hardest time of my life for sure.”

In that context, a football team’s lost season pales in comparison. Yet falling short still hurts. Players and coaches channel an extreme amount of energy, intensity and devotion for the cause, and when they don’t reach their goals, they grieve. And that’s especially true for the head coach.

In the coming weeks and months, Shanahan will have to be real with himself as he reckons with how it all went wrong, and how he and Lynch can try to make it right in 2025, and in the years that follow.

In the meantime, there are three games to play, none of which will likely matter. While noting that the 49ers are technically still in playoff contention, reaching the postseason would require a series of hugely improbable outcomes, and Shanahan acknowledged that the dream of finally winning a championship with this incarnation of his team is basically over. “They say mathematically we still have a chance,” he said. “I’m not too concerned with that right now. … I want to come back and play better football and challenge the character of our team.”

Clearly shaken, Shanahan almost looked as though he had seen a ghost — which, metaphorically, was kind of true. Across the sideline Thursday night was the coach’s former franchise quarterback, Jimmy Garoppolo, now a backup to the Rams’ Matthew Stafford. And, of course, there was McVay, a former Shanahan assistant who has since challenged him for coaching supremacy, capturing the Lombardi Trophy that has eluded Shanahan and, after bottoming out in 2022, deftly reshaping the Rams on the fly in each of the past two seasons.

Last Sunday, McVay schemed up an offensive outburst that fueled a 44-42 upset victory over the Bills and kept the Rams in hot pursuit of the Seahawks (8-5) in the division race. On Thursday, after L.A. cornerback Darious Williams picked off Purdy’s overthrown deep ball for Jauan Jennings in the end zone with 5:20 remaining, McVay and his players became the closers that Shanahan and his 49ers have struggled all season to be.

When the Rams took over at their own 20-yard line up 9-6 with 5:20 remaining, McVay had no intention of giving the ball back.

“That’s the responsibility I felt,” he said as he walked from the visitors’ locker room to the team bus late Thursday night. “Now, (the 49ers) have a say in that, too.”

Soon, the Rams silenced them. Thirteen plays, 69 yards and only two third downs later, Joshua Karty kicked his fourth field goal to make it a six-point game. Only 20 seconds remained, and the 49ers’ last, desperate gasp ended when Purdy was sacked by Christian Rozeboom at his own 44-yard line with no time remaining — in the game or, for all intents and purposes, the season. Or the era.

“This wasn’t an easy win,” McVay said. “Their defense was really, really good; they were flying around all night. And the elements made it really tough, especially in the first half. But this is a mentally tough team. I like our resilience. I like that we can win in different ways. I like what we’re made of.”

Those used to be sentiments that Shanahan, in all sincerity, could express about his team. In 2024, if he’s being honest, they no longer apply. Shanahan’s players and assistant coaches bear plenty of responsibility, but most of all, it’s on him.

In 2024, the 49ers weren’t good enough, and neither was he.

(Top photo: Kelley L Cox / Imagn Images)

With World Cup in her backyard, Mikaela Shiffrin and Aleksander Kilde — skiing’s golden couple — focus on recovery

This wasn’t the way alpine skiing aficionados drew it up when they scheduled men’s and women’s speed races on the famed Birds of Prey course in Beaver Creek, Colo., on back-to-back weekends this month.

They figured the events held major potential for a celebration of the sport’s golden couple: American Mikaela Shiffrin, who might be closing in on her record 100th World Cup win, and her fiancé, Aleksander Aamodt Kilde of Norway, arguably the best speed skier in the world, both making the podium just a few miles from Shiffrin’s home down the road in Edwards.

That was Plan A. Not happening as Kilde announced in October he’d miss the entire World Cup season due to injuries sustained in a January crash.

On the bright side, Shiffrin is up on her feet and walking again after a crash of her own over Thanksgiving weekend in a World Cup giant slalom race in Vermont that left her banged and cut up and with a significant puncture wound in her abdomen. She is sidelined indefinitely, though she expects to be back before too long. Last weekend, she shot a video while walking carefully outside her home.

“I got my trusty little wound vacuum, we got it put in yesterday,” she said, showing off the gadget that can accelerate healing by decreasing air pressure over a wound, pulling out fluid and dead tissue and reducing swelling. “This is where I’m at,” she added with a look of reluctant acceptance as she stepped gingerly on an icy mountain street.

Shiffrin’s latest injury also killed Plan B, which was for Kilde, who has spent nearly a year recovering from the major crash 11 months ago in Switzerland, to help coach Shiffrin this weekend on Beaver Creek’s Birds of Prey track — where he won three years ago and where she had never competed. Instead, he’s been coaching her in the art of patience and recovery.

Kilde has had to become an expert in that, unfortunately. The January crash wrecked his left shoulder, ripping muscles from the joint. It also left a deep gash in his right calf, courtesy of one of his skis. Then, in July, out of nowhere, an infection raged through his surgically repaired shoulder. He was on the edge of sepsis, a potentially life-threatening condition that occurs when the body’s immune system overreacts to an infection, damaging the body’s tissues and organs.

His heart racing, his shoulder swelling, his fever spiking, he went to the emergency room during a visit with Shiffrin in Colorado. Doctors took one look at him and told him he wasn’t going anywhere for a while.

There are few sports that test an athlete’s ability to manage injuries the way alpine skiing does. It has basically a 100 percent injury rate. So many of its top performers have missed full seasons or more to recover from ghastly bone breaks, torn ligaments, ruptured joints, concussions and everything else that can happen during high-speed crashes on ice while clamped into long, sharp-edged carbon boards. Skiers are good at doing the thumbs-up Instagram post from their hospital bed, but recovery and rehabilitation is anything but a happy process.

Shiffrin, 29, has been pretty lucky so far during her storied career, though last season she missed six weeks while recovering from damage to her knee ligaments that she suffered during a downhill race on the Olympia delle Tofane course in Cortina d’Ampezzo, Italy, where the 2026 women’s Olympic competition will take place. She returned in time to capture another season slalom title, but the experience taxed her brain as much as her body.

“When you’re injured, whether it’s for nine months or eight weeks, you’re watching the world carry on without you being in a space where you are supposed to be, and that’s frustrating,” she said during an interview this fall before the start of the season. “There are so many moments of doubt when you feel pain or weakness, when it’s like, ‘I don’t know that I can do that.’”


Mikaela Shiffrin was seeking her 100th World Cup event win in Killington, Vermont, when she crashed and suffered an injury. (Sarah Stier / Getty Images)

That’s basically been Kilde’s life since his January crash.

The damage to both his shoulder and his leg left him wheelchair-bound for weeks, since he couldn’t use crutches. Kilde has been called “the Arnold Schwarzenegger of skiing” for his strength. His being too weak to get out of a wheelchair is a difficult image to conjure.

The gash in his calf severed nerves. For months, he could not make his foot and toes move the way he wanted them to. Sometimes his toes would just hang like appendages. Only in late spring did he begin to think that his foot would eventually work properly again, though he still hasn’t regained much feeling in the toes.

For months he felt like he had no purpose in his life.

“You lose your job and you’re injured, you can’t even do anything,” he said. “I can’t work on my shoulder which needed to be worked on. I can’t work on my leg which needed to be worked on. I can’t even be in the sun because of antibiotics. I had to be indoors. Just a really, really boring life, honestly.”

A few weeks in, he realized he needed to find a reason to get out of bed in the morning, especially since this recovery was going to take a while. So he looked into finding some way to stimulate his mind.

Kilde may be a two-time Olympic medalist with 48 World Cup podiums, but by some measures he is the black sheep of his very educated family. His father is an engineer. His mother is a nurse. His brother is a finance executive. He has a high school education, and for the last couple of years, he has largely focused on being outdoors and his athletic career. It had been a long time since he had to study. And even longer since he was interested in studying.

Aleksander Kilde and Mikaela Shiffrin


Aleksander Kilde gets evacuated by helicopter after a crash at a World Cup event in Wengen, Switzerland, in January. He’s still recovering. (Marco Bertorello / AFP via Getty Images)

He does have an interest in real estate, though. So he signed up for an eight-week online course in real estate and finance through the London School of Economics. There were a series of modules to complete each week, plus assignments and tasks, a final project and a certificate at the end.

The course description said the work would take up roughly 10 hours each week. He said it took him at least 20. He hadn’t worked with mathematical formulas in 15 years.

He said he learned plenty about his investments, but more than that, he learned something about himself.

“Reading and learning is really something that can give you a lot of energy,” he said. “I never thought of it like that before. I felt like I didn’t need it. But I think now, just always strive to learn. It’s really something that is good for you. Not only for your mental capacity but also for your mental health. It’s very nice to know things.”

It will be nice to ski again, too. He’s been cleared to get back on snow, but just for free skiing. He can’t go fast. He can’t crash. He needs another operation on his shoulder since doctors had to remove a lot of the work that had been done when they were trying to rid his body of the infection.

The next surgery will be the one that will make a comeback possible. For now, he can basically live a normal life. He just can’t ski race. To set himself up for that, he’s been paying close attention to his diet, cutting out alcohol and most sugar, making sure to eat quality meats and other proteins, biding his time for the opportunity to be able to do the thing that he has dedicated most of his life to. And if he needs his speed rush, he’s got a nice Audi that can go from zero to 60 pretty fast.

“And that’s fine,” he said.

His fiancée still has to work on her patience as she manages through her latest injury. She can be a little less zen than him at times, especially when she is on the sidelines, waiting to be healthy enough to get back into the starting hut at the top of the hill.

Then again, this one’s a little different.

“I’ve been impaled,” she announced in a video she posted on social media days after her crash.

You don’t get to say that every day. Not even when you’re an alpine skier.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Lindsey Vonn, at 40, returns to competitive skiing, earns World Cup eligibility

(Top photo of Aleksander Kilde and Mikaela Shiffrin: Alain Grosclaude / Agence Zoom / Getty Images)

How CT scanners are being used on trading cards: The ethical and legal issues it presents

NORTON SHORES, Mich. — There is nothing outside that suggests the machines sitting inside this gray, nondescript building in an industrial office center could disrupt the trading card industry.

Sign your name on the clipboard just past the entrance. Walk by a long table with pizza boxes next to a refrigerator and it all feels pretty normal. It’s not until you turn the corner and see millions of dollars worth of machinery in an open space flanked by a giant American flag on the wall that it starts to feel different. When you’re asked not to take certain pictures or video because of the required privacy of inventory nearby, yeah, that’s when everything changes.

There could be airplane parts. Pieces of a satellite. Rocketry. Military ballistics. And on a recent Friday afternoon, an unopened Mega Box of 2023 Donruss Optic Football cards with Anthony Richardson and Brock Purdy on the front, bought at a Detroit-area Meijer for $60.

The goal? To use the technology at Industrial Inspection and Consulting to see what’s inside without breaking the plastic wrapping that traditionally indicates an unsealed, untouched and unexamined package of cards.

For most of its history, buying and selling packs and boxes of trading cards was a game of chance with neither the buyer nor the seller knowing the results.

“The product is designed to be a mystery,” said Keith Irwin, the general manager of Industrial Inspection and Consulting.

And if it wants to stay that way?

“They’ll need to find new packaging solutions,” he said.


IIC went from a company focusing primarily on industrial X-rays and CT scans within the medical and aerospace fields to potentially taking the cover off the trading card industry without taking the cover off any product at all. And in the process, they say, their company — with no prior connections to the trading card industry — has earned thousands of satisfied customers in the collectibles space. All electing for a sneak peek at their cards before tearing the packs or boxes open, circumventing the mystery that has long been a central element of these products.

The service caters to high-end products manufactured by Topps, Panini and Upper Deck, with the technology best suited to reveal cards in densely packed configurations. Take a 2023 Panini Flawless Football First Off The Line case for instance. Each case comes with two boxes. Each box comes with one pack of 10 cards. At $15,000 a case, it certainly makes economic sense that collectors are willing to pay IIC the going rate of $650 per case of that product to get a CT scan and see whether there’s something inside that they want, or to keep the package sealed and sell it on to someone else.

The economics are easy. But the ethical dilemma isn’t for this group of non-collectors in western Michigan whose industrial scanning start-up has received a financial windfall from those in the hobby willing to pay for a preview.

“We’ve had to wrestle with that as a team and some of us think differently about it,” Irwin said. “So some of us say ‘It is what it is. We can do it (scan products).’ And others say, ‘This feels like we’re participating in something that is very much in a gray area.’ And we still wrestle with it. I think where we land is that we are data people and we’re very good at what we do. And if we’re not doing it, then somebody else will.”

Nick Andrews, co-host of the Sports Card Madness podcast, has been one of the more prevalent online commentators addressing the practice of CT scanning since IIC opened its doors to the trading card industry in late July. He’s been loudly expressing how this could be a significant concern within the hobby.

“I think ultimately they took the stance of Napster in a way, like they’re not committing fraud,” Andrews said. “What these people do with these CT scan(ned) cards is not their problem. You know, they’re not the shepherds or steward of the hobby.”

IIC’s website states, “Pandora’s box is open,” which is an interesting choice of words considering the controversial practice involves not opening the sports card box at all.

“I think that you can probably draw a lot of correlations to different industries that have been negatively impacted by a group or a large number of groups that figure out a way to get an edge,” said Zach Stanley, CEO of WeTheHobby, one of more prominent online card dealers and box breakers (the practice of opening boxes of cards in larger quantities after customers buy the rights to all the cards of specific teams, players, etc. that may come out of them) within the industry. “I also think my hope is that it is something that can be combated from a technological standpoint, but we’re obviously a ways off from that now.”

And with the CT scanning technology comes the increased possibility for questionable resale practices at best and fraud at worst.

“I’d strongly encourage collectors to buy from established shops they trust,” said Eric Doty, CEO of Loupe, a live streaming platform for online vendors. “The short-term gain you’d make from scanning is not worth the risk of losing your entire business due to breaching that trust.”

Stanley said WeTheHobby has been approached by other contacts within the industry to explore or be helped to explore CT scanning technology. He immediately followed up saying, “Obviously we rejected (the offer) quickly.” But not every seller stands on equal ground, or possesses an equal moral compass.

“When people get desperate they do desperate things,” Stanley said.


A 2000 Bowman Chrome Tom Brady rookie card as seen through the CT scanner. (Image provided by Industrial Inspection and Consulting)

It all began over lunch and a search for Charizard. The start-up industrial scanning company was looking for ways to market its capabilities and a brainstorming session led to the idea of scanning packs of Pokemon cards. Compared to airplane parts, scanning packs of cards was child’s play.

“It was like a revelation of ‘Holy cow! Not only did this work, but it’s extremely obvious,’” Irwin said. “That was really the extent of what we thought. So hey, let’s throw it up as a case study.”

Irwin said he posted the imagery and results on his LinkedIn page in late June, where it received “140 or 150 likes and tons of comments.” The company had no idea what it stumbled upon.

“Immediately we were like well nobody’s gonna be paying for our labor to be able to do this,” Irwin said. “But I think that that was a naive thought because we didn’t understand the true value of these cards.”

The values of sports and Pokemon cards have grown exponentially in recent years, with regular sales in the six-figure range and some going well into the millions (the highest sale to date for a Pokemon card was nearly $5.3 million in 2022 and the highest sale for a sports card was $12.6 million, also in 2022).

Irwin said the company began receiving emails from parties interested in having products scanned following the post on social media. He estimated it only took a week and a half from there to turn it into a “full flooded service.”

“We laugh that you have rocket components sitting on one shelf and then cards on the other shelf,” Irwin said. “It’s just odd.”

Irwin estimated the volume of product IIC has scanned since starting in July to be “in the thousands.” Though that’s still just a drop in the bucket for an industry that produces millions of packages of cards each year.

Now months into what’s gone from lunch room chatter to a sizable portion of Industrial Inspection’s income, what’s the biggest technical challenge for scanning thick paper and cardboard?

“How do we go fast enough to make it worth it for people to pay,” said Irwin, who told The Athletic on Wednesday the company has hired additional full-time staff to help with the card demand.

And what’s become the biggest non-technical challenge entering an unfamiliar niche space?

“It’s a moral dilemma,” Irwin said.

There have been threats. A window near the front of their building is covered. They’ve taken steps to protect themselves from those in the collectibles business who believe what they’re doing is morally wrong and a serious threat to a billion dollar industry.

“I think it’s certainly a disruption (in the industry). … First of all, for boxes that were produced before today, I think as a potential buyer of those boxes you have to be very cautious,” Professional Sports Authentication (PSA) CEO Nat Turner said in a recent interview on the Sports Card Madness podcast. “Basically you have to assume the box has been scanned. So I think you can see a price correction in boxes that are thrown up on eBay, for example, perhaps. But I think manufacturers I think are going to have to respond.”


The CT scanner loaded up with a box of football cards. (Photo: Craig Custance)

There’s been rampant speculation within the hobby long before IIC existed around card vendors using CT scanners to view inside card packs and boxes. Many times online accusations occur when box breakers unveil what some within the hobby would deem a disproportionate amount of “hits” from sealed products with a break.

Irwin said the company has seen verified proof that “many sources” are already scanning products and have been doing so without being public about it. (No proof was offered to The Athletic for this story.) IIC was the first one openly offering the service for certain price points, which is part of its moral defense. It believes it’s being very transparent about all of this. Its price list is on the website. So are pictures of the scans. IIC invited The Athletic in to see how it all works in person, an invitation that was accepted.

The company specifically quotes prices for high-end products (boxes priced around $1,000 or more, generally) manufactured by Topps, Panini, Upper Deck and Pokemon on its website, whose homepage essentially doesn’t promote the service at all other than an initial announcement near the bottom of the page. There’s a focus on cards from the last 25 years or so containing foil, raised portions, imprinted numbering and patches or relics (cards containing pieces of jerseys or other memorabilia) since those elements are the most defined on the scans.

Pricing varies per product. For example, IIC charges $75 for one box of Topps Dynasty, which is one of Topps’ premier products containing only one autographed patch card encased in a plastic holder and carries a retail price anywhere from $900 to $1,200, depending on the sport or year.

“Dynasty is our favorite, I’ll say that,” Irwin said. “It’s probably the easiest to detect, I’m guessing. It’s a single (package), it’s one to two cards, typically one card. It’s just a dream, and those are very expensive products. We sent out a quote to somebody with a Dynasty box, and they’re like, ‘God, this is a no brainer, I’m sending it over.’”

A patch autographed card numbered to 10 of Formula 1 star Max Verstappen from 2022 Topps Dynasty (image below) serves as one of IIC’s prime scanning discoveries. The card displayed by IIC last sold on eBay for nearly $2,200 on Aug. 3 according to CardLadder, which tracks sales across major online marketplaces.

When asked if card manufacturers like Topps and Panini have reached out to discuss the company’s scanning practices, Irwin said, “Any conversations like that are under non-disclosure, but we have spoken with a variety of interested parties that are leading the market. So I’m not just talking manufacturers — auction houses, authentication houses, third-party services that are like couriers, you name it. Pretty much anybody that is interested has either spoken to us or spoken to people that know us.”

Fanatics Collectibles, the owner of Topps, declined an interview for the story. But people inside Fanatics Collectibles told The Athletic: “While we believe that CT scanners aren’t currently being widely utilized, we take any issue that potentially harms collectors very seriously. As such, we are working on innovations and solutions to address the issue.”

Panini declined to be interviewed for this story. Upper Deck said it would look into the possibility, but never agreed to an interview. Goldin Auctions and parent company eBay declined an interview for the story, deferring the issue to individual sellers. The Athletic also reached out to four other prominent online vendors who never responded to interview requests.

When asked if the conversations with other parties involved a request to discontinue scanning products, having products scanned or ways to hinder the ability to reveal the contents of a product through scanning, Irwin said, “All of the above.”

“That’s an interesting question because it seems like publicly everybody wants us to stop,” Irwin said. “In private, nobody wants us to stop because everybody that you can imagine has reached out to us.”

There’s also no way to know whether a pack or box has been scanned without the person or company divulging that. There’s no database kept by IIC for what’s been scanned, nor is there an indicator placed on the product to show it’s been scanned by IIC.

Additionally, the company doesn’t know the true identity of everyone sending in products to be scanned.

“We’re not verifying our clients,” Irwin said. “A lot of them we assume are using fake emails. And so we don’t know who they are. Fake emails, fake names, and then we use Square for credit card processing. So we don’t know who any of these people are, honestly.”

Irwin said the company hasn’t looked into any instances of nefarious practices by individuals, box breakers, hobby shops or anyone else using IIC’s services once a scanned product leaves its hands.

“Our objective position is one of scientific ability and data-driven results,” according to IIC’s website. “It is not our responsibility to determine the ethical positions and choices of others and we do not accept responsibility for their actions. Our quotes require clients to disclose to their potential buyers if they have CT scanned their sealed products.”

The consequences from IIC for a customer failing to disclose to a potential buyer that a product was scanned is unclear. Legally speaking, that’s a different story.

Paul Lesko, a Missouri-based attorney known for being “The Hobby Lawyer,” said while scanning packs and boxes may be legal, consumer fraud charges could result for the owner of scanned products if resold without disclosure.

“Consumer fraud claims require a knowingly false representation about a product made with the intent for buyers to rely on that misrepresentation,” Lesko said. “So, if a seller scans a pack/box and determines it does not have a hit (industry parlance for a desirable/valuable card), but when selling states it ‘could contain an auto(graph) or patch’ or really just recites that the boxes ‘may contain an auto or relic’ or just shows a picture of the box with that representation from the manufacturer, that’s a false representation made by the seller in the hopes of duping the buyer.

“Best case scenario, after scanning a pack/box, if you’re going to resell it, disclose you scanned it.”

Irwin posed the question that anyone in the hobby would ask, though.

“Are people going to do that? I have no idea,” Irwin said.


Irwin was handed the box of 2023 Donruss Optic football cards, our attempt to see just how effective his technology was and the first thing he did was turn to YouTube. He wanted to learn more about a product in which he was unfamiliar since most people weren’t spending $75 to scan a $60 box of cards.

He landed on a video of a breaker sorting through each card individually. Immediately, he was able to determine that his machines wouldn’t be able to pick up the names of each player on the cards because of the design. But he was confident in the ability to pick up the outline of the players along with any uniform numbers, important indicators when searching for specific hits. He also expressed confidence in the ability to identify numbered cards and patches.

So we moved on to the next step.

A few feet away, a giant XTH 320 X-ray machine sat, waiting to reveal what was inside this box of football cards. Irwin placed the box in the middle of the machine on a round table on top of a piece of styrofoam. A large sliding door closed slowly, sealing itself next to a red emergency stop button and a caution sticker. Within minutes, the contents of the box of cards showed up on a monitor near the machine, each card a blurry gray rectangular shape that revealed little, until the outline of a patch on one of the cards became clear.

About 20 minutes later, the CT scan was complete. Irwin was able to rotate the scan in every direction. He was able to zoom in on specific cards. It was abundantly clear that the bottom pack contained the patch card, which he was then able to rotate and zoom in on to identify more characteristics of the card.

If we knew the specifics of a card we were trying to get, at that point we would have been able to identify it. But in the case of this patch card, we only could make out vague details. There was some writing on the front. It appeared to be a wide receiver with a number in the 80s. Just as important was identifying what wasn’t in the box. There didn’t appear to be any numbered cards. If we wanted to spend the time, we likely would have been able to determine there wasn’t a C.J. Stroud.

Once opened, the patch card turned out to be Raiders tight end Michael Mayer. A 10-minute scan of the contents was enough to conclude this wasn’t a particularly valuable box, which ended up being confirmed when it was later opened the old-fashioned way. By a 13-year-old ripping through foil.


The Michael Mayer patch card detected by the scan. (Photo: Craig Custance)

It wasn’t a fast process. There was a lot of card rotating and data reading. To truly benefit, there needs to be a target card in which the person doing the scanning can be on the lookout for. It’s tedious work on expensive equipment, one reason Irwin isn’t convinced the work is going to spread throughout the industry.

“You saw me scrolling through this data, it’s annoying, right?” Irwin said. “We were a startup hungry for work. We’re all workaholics without enough work. So we stumble upon this thing that nobody’s done before and all of a sudden we have… clients in a brand new territory.”

It’s transformed his business. Whether it alters another just might depend on what happens next.


There is a train that runs past the industrial complex where these scans are taking place, blaring its horn each morning while crossing a nearby road. It’s close enough that the shaking it produces in the building can disrupt scans that rely on complete stability for pinpoint accuracy.

The slightest vibration can get in the way of an accurate scan and that realization has helped this same group design a solution. IIC has patented a process that would make the scanning much more challenging.

“All (new packaging) has to do is introduce a slight vibration to the cards and it makes it very challenging for us to read it,” Irwin said.

The company hopes its solution would either be licensed or outright purchased by a card company.

“It would be strange to both want to be the fixer and then also the breaker,” Irwin said. “But in the conversations we’ve had, we’ve been compared to say Google wanting to hire the hacker to go through their systems, find loopholes, find ways in.”

But that still leaves every unopened product in the world made up to that point unprotected.

Geoff Wilson, a prominent YouTuber and owner of Cards HQ in Georgia, said in a video posted last week that he believes the CT scanning topic is an overblown issue for most collectors. He immediately followed up, though, saying certain types of collectors and investors should be “terrified.”

Wilson pointed to high-end sealed wax boxes that people have held onto for years as being an issue. He went so far to say he’s in the process of selling off older sealed boxes he’ s collected because “people will forever be concerned that this box was CT scanned” and the concern will only grow over time.

“I mean because of the moral gray, I think the best thing to do would be to eventually find a way to stop this, move out of it,” Irwin said. “What does that do for the last 25 years of product that is prime for CT scanning? I don’t know.”

So there lies the dilemma for the industry. The biggest problem isn’t that this is happening on a small scale. It’s that it’s creating distrust amongst consumers on a potentially larger one.

“Once you sow that distrust with the consumer, you’ve got bigger problems,” Stanley said. “I think that right now, educating the consumers on the fact that this is happening is going to enable them to be educated and prioritize who they are buying from. I think the resale market right now for sealed wax is going to become increasingly problematic.”

Follow The Athletic’s regular, in-depth sports memorabilia and collectibles coverage here.

The Athletic maintains full editorial independence in all our coverage. When you click or make purchases through our links, we may earn a commission.

(Top image: Industrial Inspection and Consulting, Craig Custance, Bruce Bennett/Getty Images, Mark Cunningham/MLB Photos via Getty Images; Design: Meech Robinson)

At 38, Calais Campbell is still wrecking games: ‘I might just do this until the wheels fall off’

MIAMI GARDENS, Fla. — During quiet moments on the sideline, Calais Campbell can still hear his father’s voice.

Truth is, it never left him. The words were stored away, hardened into his psyche. Charles Campbell saw his son’s path before his son ever could. Twenty years later, the lessons have lasted.

Like the time Calais — long, lean and consumed by football from the minute he first slipped on a helmet — bragged about two first-quarter sacks on the way home from a high school game. He felt on top of the world. Wait until his older brothers heard …

“What’d you do the rest of the game?” Charles asked, quieting the car. “You got satisfied.”

Or the time Calais climbed the steps of the high dive at the local pool, then froze once he got there, too terrified to jump. This ain’t gonna work, he told himself. He tried to beg his way back down, but dad wouldn’t hear it. “Once you start something,” Charles told his son, “then you finish it.” So Calais gritted his teeth and tiptoed toward the edge.

“Belly-flopped,” he says now, laughing. “Hurt so bad. But after that I jumped in 25 times.”

GO DEEPER

Dolphins, Bills sell stakes in team to private equity firms

Charles had been gone four years by the time his son entered the 2008 NFL Draft. Calais left the University of Miami a year early, showed up to the scouting combine out of shape and figured he’d coast on his God-given ability. He was wrong. He bombed.

Teams wrote him off.

So he sat there that afternoon and seethed, watching helplessly as he tumbled out of the first round. He knew what his father would tell him: “You let everybody pat you on the back, and you didn’t put in the work. It’s always about the work.”

Calais had to wait 50 picks to hear his name called. He’s never forgotten.

“You know how many defensive linemen went ahead of me?” he asks. “Ten.”

Most of them didn’t last five seasons. He’s in Year 17.

He’s been playing so long that he once shared a high school field with his head coach.

It was 2001. Mike McDaniel was a scrawny wide receiver at Smoky Hill High School, just outside of Denver, on his way to Yale. Campbell was the best player in the state of Colorado, a 6-foot-8 game-wrecker with offers from every top program in the country.

“I still have a ribcage, so he didn’t tackle me,” McDaniel joked last month. “I stayed away from him. I was trying to coach here 20 years later. I couldn’t do that if I was dead.”

A month ago, Campbell’s agent called. The trade deadline was nearing. Six teams had reached out to the Dolphins, wanting to deal for the veteran defensive tackle. Among them was Baltimore, where Campbell played from 2020-22. The offer was a fifth-round pick. Another team — Campbell won’t say who — offered a fourth as long as a late-rounder was going back to them.

“A fourth?” Campbell says, flattered. “I’m 38 years old!”

But the Ravens made the most sense. Campbell was going to get another shot at a ring — maybe his last shot. The trade was all but agreed to. Then his phone buzzed.

“I can’t do it,” McDaniel told him. “You’re too valuable to us.” The Dolphins coach had nixed the deal. Campbell would stay.

At that point, the season looked lost. Miami was 2-6, tied for the second-worst record in the league. A gilded career would sputter to a forgettable finish.

A few nights later, standing on the sideline before kickoff of a “Monday Night Football” game against the Rams, Campbell heard his father speak to him.

Once you start something

“That’s when I decided I was gonna do everything in my power to get this thing going,” he says.

Miami is 4-1 since.


Campbell’s 109.5 career sacks place him third among active players, behind only Von Miller and Cam Jordan. (Ronald Martinez / Getty Images)

McDaniel refers to Campbell as “the Tom Brady of defensive linemen.” Dolphins tight end Jonnu Smith calls him “the LeBron James of the NFL” because of the respect he garners around the league.

“One of my favorite teammates I’ve had on any team on any level,” Smith says.

Defensive end Zach Sieler admits there’s a running joke inside the position room: with Campbell on the roster, the unit’s average age is 33; without him, it dips to 27. “I’m so grateful I get to come to work every day with that guy,” Sieler says. “I’m always asking him, ‘What’s the secret? How are you still doing this?’”

Campbell never wanted to do anything else. He’s bounced from Arizona to Jacksonville to Baltimore to Atlanta to Miami. He’s played every position along the defensive line. He’ll step in on special teams and block for field goal attempts.

“He’ll do anything,” says one of his former coaches, Bruce Arians. “He’s more than just a run-stopper. He’s so rushable. He’ll blow up plays in the backfield. And the best thing he does is use those long arms to bat balls down and tip passes. We got so many interceptions off that.”

Campbell’s missed fewer games (15) than seasons played (17). He’s one of four defensive linemen in league history to make 250 career starts. He’s two years older than every defensive player in the league. Heck, he’s two years older than his own position coach.

He’s wrestled with retirement each of the last few years, dreading the prospect of getting his body ready for another season. It’s the first two weeks he hates the most. “Do I really wanna go through that torture?” he’ll ask himself.

But he hasn’t been able to convince himself to walk away. Not yet.

“The man could be at home sipping his Piña Coladas with his gold jacket on. Instead he’s putting everything he’s got into this team,” Smith says, shaking his head. “And you know the crazy part? He’s still one of the best players in the league at his position.”

Smith’s right. Campbell’s 27 solo tackles are fifth-most in the league among defensive tackles. His five batted passes are second-most. He’s second on the Dolphins in both sacks and tackles for loss, trailing only Sieler.

Consider for a moment how long Campbell has been at this: He was a rookie on the Cardinals team that made it to Super Bowl XLIII in February 2009. Kurt Warner was Arizona’s quarterback. He’s been retired for 15 years.

Campbell can still remember Adrian Wilson pulling him aside before kickoff that night in Tampa, begging him to soak in the moment. “Don’t take this for granted,” the veteran safety told him. “Getting here is hard.”

Campbell’s never made it back. “My No. 1 motivation,” he calls it.

Each spring, while he weighs his future, friends and family throw out an obvious question: “Why don’t you just sign with the Chiefs?” Campbell bristles at the idea. To him, it feels like a shortcut. He doesn’t want a free ride to a championship. He wants to be a reason his team hoists the trophy.

That drive was first fueled by doubt, from a father who taught him to run from complacency and from a high school basketball coach who told him he was picking the wrong sport. “You’re too skinny!” Campbell remembers hearing. “You could make it to the NBA!”

And from Arians, his second coach in Arizona, who once said something in a news conference that Campbell never forgot. “For a guy as talented as he is,” Arians told reporters, “Calais disappears too much.”

The comment made its way back to him. Family members figured he’d fume. “Aren’t you pissed?” they kept asking. Campbell shook his head, then stored the words away.

“From that day on I decided I was gonna show up in every ball game. Every … single … one,” he says, pounding the table in front of him. “B.A. knew how to motivate. B.A. made me a better player.”


Campbell spent the first nine years of his career in Arizona, where he earned Pro Bowl and All-Pro honors from 2014-16. (Christian Petersen / Getty Images)

Arians’ words lit a fire, and as Campbell’s career took off, so did his ambitions. At one point he decided to Google “Hall of Fame defensive linemen.” He spent hours poring over their careers, watching highlights, studying stats. He pictured his own path to Canton. What would it take? How long would he have to play?

Between 13 and 17 seasons, he decided. Fifteen seemed like a good number. He wrote it down. “Then eight years in, I told myself no way,” he admits.

More research. More conversations. Campbell picked the brain of Dwight Freeney, who played until he was 37. Then James Harrison, who played until 39. Then Bruce Smith, who lasted until 40. He started seeing the chiropractor every week. He added acupuncture and massages to his routine. He spent nearly $30,000 on his own hyperbaric chamber.

He fought off Father Time.

He was 10 years into his career but started to feel like he was in his 20s again.

“I might just do this until the wheels fall off,” he told himself.


Campbell leans back in his chair, letting the silence linger for a few moments.

He’s a mountain of a man, with the voice of a preacher and a smile that warms the room. It’s late November. He’s sitting inside the Dolphins practice facility, weighing the most trying moments of his adolescence against the Hall of Fame-worthy career that followed.

Does one happen without the other?

He’s thinking.

He grew up one of eight, too busy trying to keep up with his older brothers to notice the hard times sneaking up on them. At one point, when Calais was in junior high, the family was forced to spend six months in a homeless shelter, crammed into a room with metal bunk beds pushed against the wall. The boys would take multiple city buses just to get to school each morning.

For years Campbell bottled up the experience, never mentioning it in interviews. He wanted to keep the pain private. But it was always there, same as the words his father left him.

Liver cancer stole Charles Campbell away at age 61, five months before Calais’ high school graduation. His father never saw him suit up at the U. Never saw him play a down in the NFL.

“To tell you the truth, I don’t think my career’s the same without everything I been though,” Campbell says. “We’re all a product of our environment, right? I know I am. I had an incredible father who saw something in me. He pushed me, he motivated me, and all those situations helped build up this callus, this toughness in me. He’s still pushing me.

“That’s such an important part of my story.”

The story since: 17 NFL seasons, six Pro Bowls, a spot on the 2010s All-Decades team and the 2019 Walter Payton Man of the Year award. The foundation Campbell was honored for, the one he started way back in 2013, is called CRC. It’s named after Charles Campbell, whose son is now one of the most revered players in the sport.


Campbell won the NFL’s Walter Payton Man of the Year award in 2020 for a mixture of on-field performance and community service. (Tom Pennington / Getty Images)

Even so, after he arrived in Miami, Dolphins coaches weren’t sure how much he had left. Campbell didn’t sign with the team until June. He wasn’t there for a single offseason workout.

Then, a week into training camp, they put the pads on, and No. 93 started blowing plays up.

Austin Clark, Miami’s defensive line coach, began to envision Campbell lining up next to Sieler, a 29-year-old coming off his first 10-sack season. “Oh man,” Clark told himself, “we got a shot here.”

Five weeks after his first practice Campbell was voted team captain. One snap into the season he had his first sack. In the months since he’s transformed the unit, the defense and the building. After workouts, he stays on the field and tutors the Dolphins’ young pass rushers. In film sessions, he points out their mental mistakes.

“You can’t go through the motions around him,” McDaniel says. “First of all, he’ll call you out. Second of all, you’ll feel too guilty.”

On Saturday nights, the coach asks Campbell to address the entire team. “When Calais speaks, it’s just different,” Smith says.

Arians says it started in Arizona. Younger players would gravitate toward Campbell. He’d mentor. He’d motivate. He’d counsel. “A special player and a special leader,” Arians says. “One of the most positive guys I’ve ever been around in all my years coaching.”

It carried over to Jacksonville, then Baltimore. In 2022, Ravens defensive tackle Nnamdi Madubuike was two years into his career and fed up: he had just three sacks in 25 games. He was frustrated and losing faith. “Come visit me in Arizona this spring,” Campbell told him. So Madubuike did.

“I believed in my heart that I could be a guy who could really be a problem in this league and Calais was giving me insight that, ‘You are,’” Madubuike says. “When we don’t get the results we want in any field, you can automatically get discouraged. He always told (me) just to stay up, just stay focused, stay working and eventually you’re going to break through.”

Madubuike had 18.5 sacks over the next two seasons, made his first Pro Bowl and signed a four-year, $98 million extension with the Ravens last spring.

“I’m telling you, wherever I’m coaching the rest of my career, (Campbell) is gonna be around,” Clark adds. “If he doesn’t wanna coach, then I’m begging him to come by the building at least once a week. He has that big of an influence on guys.”

Campbell’s approach then is his approach now: “No. 1, be authentic with everyone,” he says. “No. 2, be the best version of myself. No. 3, love on people.

“If I do all of that, we’re gonna be all right. I believe that.”

The Dolphins are two games back of the final AFC playoff spot with four to go. Campbell’s pep talk to himself before the Rams game sparked something — starting that night, Miami ripped off three straight wins. Then on Sunday, they rallied to beat the Jets in overtime. A season that looked lost in early November suddenly has new life.

“We need nine wins,” Campbell keeps telling himself. “We get to nine wins, we got a shot.”

In the back of his mind, he knows this might be his last stand, the final chapter of a career born of drive and draft-day disappointment. If it is, it’ll end the way it started, with his father’s words ringing in his ears.

Once you start something

(Illustration: Demetrius Robinson / The Athletic; photos: Todd Rosenberg, Andy Lyons / Getty Images)

Wimbledon tennis expansion could be set for judicial review after challenge to planning permission

Plans to expand Wimbledon are set to go before the U.K. High Court.

The All England Club (AELTC), host of the third Grand Slam tournament of the tennis season, wants to add a third stadium court and 38 further courts to its footprint, tripling its size in works expected to cost over £200million ($254.8million).

The Greater London Authority (GLA) granted planning permission in September, but campaign group Save Wimbledon Park (SWP) has now instructed lawyers to challenge the decision, which could ultimately lead to a judicial review in the High Court.

It has “sent a lengthy formal letter setting out our case to the GLA, copied to both Merton and Wandsworth Councils and to the AELTC,” according to a spokesperson’s statement seen by The Athletic Wednesday December 11.

The letter is required as part of the “pre-action protocol” for a judicial review. In it, SWP’s law firm, Russell Cooke, invites the GLA to confirm it will reconsider the planning permission. This would involve quashing the grant. The firm requests a “substantive reply” by December 16; the letter is dated December 6.

A spokesperson for Sadiq Khan, the Mayor of London, said: “The Mayor believes this scheme will bring a significant range of benefits including economic, social and cultural benefits to the local area, the wider capital and the UK economy, creating new jobs and cementing Wimbledon’s reputation as the greatest tennis competition in the world.

“City Hall will respond to Save Wimbledon Park’s letter in due course.”

Separately, the AELTC confirmed December 1 that it will challenge a key tenet of SWP and other residents’ groups objections to the plans in the High Court. SWP argues that when AELTC bought the freehold to the Wimbledon site and the adjacent park in 1993, it fell under a statutory trust which requires that land to be kept free for public recreation.

GO DEEPER

All England Club granted planning permission for huge Wimbledon tennis expansion

The AELTC argues that “there is not, nor has there ever been, a statutory trust affecting the former Wimbledon Park Golf Course land”. It will now take this argument to the High Court in a bid to prove itself right.

The AELTC bought the golf course — whose lease was set to expire in 2041 — for £65million (now $87.1m) in 2018. This led to each member receiving £85,000, and the AELTC argues that it being a private club voids the concept of a statutory trust.

“We have been pointing out for a considerable time that the statutory public recreation trust on which the AELTC hold the heritage golf course land is a fundamental block on the proposed AELTC development,” an SWP spokesperson said.

“We are glad to hear that the AELTC now recognise our point of view and note that they wish to take this to litigation rather than engage in any discussion.”

The AELTC believes its plans will ensure that Wimbledon does not fall behind the Australian, French, and U.S. Opens in terms of prestige.

One of the 39 new courts will be an 8,000-seater stadium, and the other 38 will allow the AELTC to bring the qualifying event on-site. That event is held the week before the main tournament starts, and Wimbledon is the only Grand Slam of the four not to already have its qualifying event on-site. Wimbledon’s third show court, No. 2 Court, is the smallest of the third courts across the majors.

Planning permission for the expansion went to the GLA after Merton and Wandsworth councils failed to agree on them. Merton granted permission in October 2023, before Wandsworth refused it a month later. There is no expected timeline for the AELTC’s case, nor for the judicial review proposed by SWP. AELTC chair Deborah Jevans has said that it wants the new courts in play by the early 2030s.

(Julian Finney / Getty Images)

‘What a shot’: The stories behind some of hockey’s most iconic photos from the man who took them

OLD BETHPAGE, New York — Bruce Bennett may have been to more NHL games than anyone in history, and the 69-year-old’s house offers glimpses into the career that’s put him rinkside so many times over more than five decades.

Signed jerseys, sticks and photos of Wayne Gretzky line the living room walls, many inscribed with notes thanking Bennett for his friendship and work. There’s a model Stanley Cup. And a closet full of camera lenses, wires and other equipment.

Bennett has a lofted office over the living room. A few of his photographs hang framed on its walls. There’s a bookshelf full of hockey and photography books, as well as a plastic rat that hit him on the head when the Florida Panthers were celebrating their 2024 Stanley Cup Final win. On the bottom shelf, there’s a shot of John Tavares’ first NHL goal.

“What a shot!” the former New York Islanders captain inscribed on the photo.

Scotty Bowman coached 2,141 NHL games. Patrick Marleau played 1,779. David Poile spent 3,075 games as a general manager, though executives don’t always attend every game. Lou Lamoriello is closing in on that record with 2,868.

Bennett has photographed more than 5,000.

“I could do a game every other day through an entire season, but I’m too greedy,” Bennett says. “So if there’s four games in four nights, chances are I’m going to take all four. Don’t want to leave anything on the table.”

As of July 2, when Bennett most recently updated his statistics, he had been to 5,240 NHL games between the regular season and playoffs. Of those, 44 have been Stanley Cup deciders. If you include preseason, he’s been to 328 more. If you count all hockey games — international, PHWL, junior, exhibitions, etc. — he was up to 6,142 over the summer.

The Islanders presented him with a customized No. 5000 jersey when he reached that mark. It’s framed right above a shelf of toys for his grandchildren.

Now the director of hockey photography at Getty Images, Bennett was born in Brooklyn and grew up on Long Island. When he was in elementary school, he borrowed his father’s Kodak Instamatic to snap pictures on school field trips. “Horrible photos,” he calls them, but they sparked a passion.

He first shot a hockey game as a 17- or 18-year-old at Madison Square Garden. He didn’t have a press credential, so he took pictures from the balcony. Around the same time, he snuck into the Islanders photo box and shot the game. He mailed a few of his pictures to the Hockey News and asked if they’d be interested in using his work. The publication said yes, which got Bennett a photography credential and kicked off what has become a legendary career — one that has given Bennett a front-row seat to some of the biggest moments in hockey history.

Whether they know it or not, sports fans’ lasting memories of those seminal hockey moments are often seen through Bennett’s lens.

How does he capture them, and what are the ones that mean the most to him?

To give a sense of it, he walked The Athletic through 10 of his favorite photos, his process of creating the shots and why he values them.


Varlamov from above


Islanders goalie Semyon Varlamov as seen from above in 2023.

To get a shot from above, Bennett has to walk along the arena catwalk and attach a remote camera into the rafters. Then, while shooting a game from ice-level, he presses a button on a remote that will trigger the rafter camera to snap pictures.

Walking above the rink is not for the faint of heart, but don’t get fooled by the fact that Bennett does it. “I am scared s—less of heights,” he says.

Getty Images likes its photographers to be creative, and Bennett had the idea to set one camera above the net with a slower shutter speed. That way, if a goalie was on top of the puck during a net-front scramble, he’d appear still with a blur of action all around him. Bennett got his wish with this photo of New York Islanders goalie Semyon Varlamov.

Yzerman in the box


Red Wings Hall of Famer Steve Yzerman leans on the boards in 1984.

The old photo boxes at Nassau Coliseum were positioned right between the penalty boxes, which allowed Bennett to capture a photo of the Detroit Red Wings’ young Steve Yzerman in 1984. It was an ideal position in many ways: He was close enough to smell the liniment on players’ skin and hear them trash talk.

There were drawbacks, too. Bennett got hit by plenty of pucks flung by players trying to get out of their defensive zone. Nowadays he shoots from the corner of rinks, where there are 4-by-5-inch holes for camera lenses.

Richter and Vanbiesbrouck’s shared jersey


Rangers goalies Mike Richter and John Vanbiesbrouck pose together in 1991.

The Hockey News assigned Bennett to take a photo of New York Rangers goalies Mike Richter and John Vanbiesbrouck, who shared the net in the early 1990s. Ahead of the shoot, Bennett purchased the biggest Rangers jersey possible and cut the back of it so both could squeeze into it. He remembers feeling weird destroying an expensive jersey.

“I hope this works,” he thought to himself while making the cut.

Fortunately, both goalies were into the idea and happily posed for the photo. Afterward, Bennett didn’t know what to do with the jersey, so he had Richter and Vanbiesbrouck sign it. Now it’s in a frame in his living room, matted over a copy of the shot for which it was used.


Penguins forward Patric Hornqvist and Devils goalie Cory Schneider watch the puck enter the net in 2017.

Bennett sometimes puts a camera into the base of the net. He secures it inside a polycarbonate box, then can snap photos remotely with the same type of clicker he uses for his rafter shots. He likes this photo, which shows the Pittsburgh Penguins’ Patric Hornqvist scoring on Cory Schneider, because you can see the New Jersey Devils’ logo on the puck, as well as the symmetry of the players and the scoreboard showing New Jersey was on the penalty kill.

“It’s such a great angle,” he says. “To me, it’s a little cliched at this point. … But when you get a good one, it’s a good one.”

Crosby’s golden goal


Sidney Crosby celebrates an overtime goal on Ryan Miller in 2010.

Before the end of Olympic gold medal and Stanley Cup-clinching games, Bennett has to line up at the Zamboni corner, where he’ll get let onto the ice for the postgame presentation. He hates it.

“Horrible,” he says. “You’re standing there and you’re looking at the scoreboard. You can’t shoot.”

Bennett had a camera set up in the rafters during the 2010 Olympic gold medal game between the U.S. and Canada. During overtime, he got on his knees so he could look up at the scoreboard. As Crosby received a pass from Jarome Iginla, Bennett held down his remote button, hoping the scoreboard monitor was synchronized with real-time action. Thankfully for him, it was. He got the shot he was looking for.

“It’s the moment that Canada sighed (its) relief,” he says.

Gainey with the Cup


Bob Gainey lifts the Stanley Cup in 1979.

Bennett found himself in a predicament after the Montreal Canadiens beat the Rangers to win the 1979 Stanley Cup in five games. He couldn’t find his way onto the ice and didn’t know French, so he ran both ways around the rink trying to figure out how to get close to the celebration. Eventually, he gave up trying to get on the ice and made his way to the stands. He stood on a chair and snapped photos as best he could.

“A couple fans, instead of clapping for their hometown, were holding me up so I could take pictures, which was really nice for the Anglophone, stupid American,” he says.

He got lucky with a photo of Hall of Famer Bob Gainey. It’s a symbol, Bennett says, of the glory of winning the Stanley Cup.

Young Gretzky


Wayne Gretzky stands in the Oilers locker room in 1979.

This photo of Wayne Gretzky is the cover for the English edition of Bennett’s book, “Hockey’s Greatest Photos.” It’s from Gretzky’s final WHA game with the Edmonton Oilers. Back then, photographers were allowed in the locker room after games, which is how Bennett got this shot.

“High school shoulder pads,” Bennett says. “Skinny, scrawny guy.”

It was the first famous photo he took of Gretzky, who wrote the foreword to “Hockey’s Greatest Photos.” Bennett took the lasting image of Gretzky scoring his 77th goal of the 1981-82 season, breaking Phil Esposito’s record. He doesn’t view that photo as anything special artistically, but it captured a moment in history. A signed copy hangs in Bennett’s living room.

Bennett’s relationship with Gretzky has spanned decades now. Gretzky brought him along as the official photographer of the Ninety Nine All Stars tour, which took place during the 1994-95 lockout, and Bennett shot Gretzky’s fantasy camps, too. That’s the source of some of the memorabilia on his wall.

Bossy’s burning stick


The Islanders’ Mike Bossy poses for a portrait in 1980.

Bennett staged this picture for the Hockey News in the locker room at Nassau Coliseum. Look closely and you’ll notice Bossy is still wearing a towel from the showers. To create the image, Bennett put kerosene on the base of the stick and then lit it on fire.

“We had a bucket of water there, but it eventually burnt up the cotton and then dissipated on its own,” he says.

Bossy was part of the Islanders four-peat from 1980 to ’83. That era of hockey came at a good time for Bennett.

“I think it was a moment that helped turn my career a bit,” he says. “Not only that you had a dynasty growing on Long Island, but the fact that I was smart enough or able enough to turn off the fan switch in my head and focus on the task of doing the job.”

Potvin hits Lafleur


The Islanders’ Denis Potvin upends the Canadiens’ Guy Lafleur in the early 1980s.

This photo of Denis Potvin hitting Guy Lafleur is one of Bennett’s early-career favorites.

“It was one of the first best shots that I had,” he says.

He says he would have considered using it as the cover photo for his book, had it worked horizontally. It’s similar to a photo he took in the 2024 playoffs of Carolina’s Dmitry Orlov hitting the Rangers’ Jonny Brodzinski and leaving him in a similar position as Lafleur. But, he says, “Slight difference in Hall of Fame status. No offense to Jonny.”

Martinez’s Cup-winning goal


The Kings celebrate Alec Martinez’s Cup-winning goal in 2014.

When Bennett lectures on sports photography, he stresses the power of capturing celebration and dejection in the same frame. That’s exactly what he got when Alec Martinez scored on Henrik Lundqvist to win the 2014 Stanley Cup Final.

“It’s gold,” Bennett says. “Lundqvist was a guy who, his emotions, even with a mask and everything, you could just tell by body language.”

The Kings celebrating so close to him added to the impact of the image, which he took with a remote camera positioned in the rafters.

“I’m getting ready to be pushed out on the ice, so I’m just blindly holding that button,” he says.


More than two hours before the Rangers game Nov. 30 against Montreal, Bennett is crouched in the bowels of Madison Square Garden, attaching his camera into place at the base of the game net. His plan is to shoot the 1 p.m. Rangers game, then take a train to UBS Arena to take photos of Islanders-Buffalo Sabres in the evening.

Bennett’s proximity to multiple teams in the New York area has always allowed him to shoot lots of games, and the passion that carried him as an 18-year-old doesn’t seem to be going anywhere.

“It’s hard to walk away,” he says. “It’s like a professional athlete.”

Bennett starts his work days in his office looking at the photos Getty shooters took the night before. He’ll send out emails, some complimentary, some constructive and some sarcastic. He watches NHL Network and will download media notes for the next game he’s shooting. He’ll note which players are coming up on milestones so he’s prepared to catch the big moments.

During hockey’s summer hiatus, Bennett keeps himself busy with … photography. He enjoys going on day trips around Long Island and shooting pictures of wildlife. He has one of his favorites, an eagle in Centerpoint catching a fish, blown up and framed in his office.

Then, when the season starts up, he’s always ready to go.

“The expression a golfer would say — one great shot brings you back the next day — that’s how I feel about a hockey game,” he says. “If you’re not there, you’re not getting it.”

(Illustration: Dan Goldfarb / The Athletic. Photos: Peter Baugh / The Athletic; Bruce Bennett / Getty Images)

Brad Pitt’s F1 movie: Producers talk wrapping filming in Abu Dhabi, Hamilton’s role

To finish fifth and still stand on the Formula One podium made for an unusual end to George Russell’s Abu Dhabi Grand Prix.

On the other side of the rostrum was Charles Leclerc, the Ferrari driver who had already been on the podium on Sunday evening after recovering from 19th on the grid to finish third behind Lando Norris and Carlos Sainz.

In between Russell and Leclerc in his white and black race suit was Sonny Hayes, the veteran racer from APXGP.

Hayes is the fictional character played by Brad Pitt in “F1,” the movie produced by Warner Bros. and Apple that has embedded itself within the F1 world for the past two seasons. APXGP, Pitt’s fictional team owned by Javier Bardem’s character, has received a full garage setup at races and lined its Mercedes-designed cars up on the starting grid, so committed has the sport been to making this the most realistic racing film ever.

On Sunday after the race in Abu Dhabi, a second podium ceremony was staged to capture some scenes, all in front of fans who had been told to stay in their seats after the race for a chance to be caught in the movie.

Abu Dhabi marked the end of on-site filming for “F1.” Due for release on June 27 in North America and June 25 in the rest of the world next year, the project is steadily nearing completion.

“We’ll stay here for the rest of the week doing pick-ups, and then we’re in the editing room,” Jerry Bruckheimer, the producer of “F1,” said on Sunday in a select media roundtable including The Athletic.About two-thirds of the movie is already cut. This will be the last race that we have (to) cut this together, and we’ll take a look at it.”

The immersion within the F1 world has given Bruckheimer and director Joe Kosinski, who worked together on “Top Gun: Maverick,” the perfect opportunity to make it as close to real life as possible. A teaser trailer debuted ahead of the British Grand Prix in July, featuring a number of the current drivers and team principals and giving a taste of what the in-car footage might look like. Similar to the fighter jets in “Top Gun: Maverick,” a lot of the footage in “F1” tries to give the audience as close an experience as possible to driving an F1 car.


Brad Pitt’s character speaks with Lewis Hamilton at the Abu Dhabi GP. (Pro Shots/Sipa USA)

Input from the drivers — particularly Lewis Hamilton, who is a producer on the film — was crucial, said Bruckheimer.

“They were very open about their experiences, what they went through getting to F1, (even their) superstitions,” Bruckheimer explained. “We took little things that one driver did about this superstition, and Brad has that in his character.

“Lewis keeps us honest. Lewis looks at every race and goes, ‘You wouldn’t be in second gear in this turn, you would be in first.’ He comes in there, and he can hear the engine and the shifting and everything like that.”

“One of the big things that we’re doing as part of this is that we wanted the racing to be real,” added Eddy Cue, Apple’s Senior Vice President of Services. “Lewis has helped tremendously. It’s always about the story because that’s what it is, but we wanted the racing scenes to really be legit and be the real thing, and I think that’s what we’ve captured. Lewis has been great about that.”

Pitt and Damson Idris, who plays Hayes’ young teammate Joshua Pearce, went through extensive training and testing to pilot the APXGP cars used in the movie, which are bulked-up versions of F2 cars. Pitt and Idris were on-site in Abu Dhabi for the last round of at-race filming and even photobombed some of the teams’ end-of-year photos in the pit lane on Thursday. The paddock has embraced the project of filming within a living, breathing sporting environment.

One consequence of operating during a grand prix weekend, particularly in front of fans, is that clips of filming taking place have inevitably made their way online. Scenes such as the podium in Abu Dhabi or Pitt’s celebrations with the Mexican flag in front of the Foro Sol stadium section in Mexico have already surfaced. But both Bruckheimer and Cue were comfortable that nothing had emerged that would give away details central to the plot.

“If you’re on the set of a movie, and you get a clip of it, you would have no idea what the hell is going on,” Cue said. “It’s not like it’s shot in sequence, right? These little things… I saw this thing on YouTube of Brad fainting in Vegas or whatever, but you have no idea what the context of that is or before. I actually think all of it helps.”

The nature of that scene in particular, where Pitt ‘fainted’ onto a crash mat on the main straight in Las Vegas last month, was not something Cue felt had pushed the dramatic element of the movie too far.

“I saw a guy walk out of a fire in real Formula One,” he said, referring to Romain Grosjean’s 2020 crash in Bahrain. “I think passing out is pretty real.” Be it for crash sequences or even the on-track scenes, the producers said everything in “F1” took inspiration or reference from moments through the sport’s history.

“A lot of the incidents in the movie are taken from real events,” Bruckheimer said. “Everything that Brad does on the track, the little tricks that he does, drivers have done through the decades in various races. Because he doesn’t have the fastest car and he’s not the fastest driver. He has to use clever tactics to stay up with these other drivers.”


Brad Pitt, playing Sonny Hayes, greets Damson Idris, playing Joshua Pearce, after the Abu Dhabi GP. (Sipa USA)

The conclusion of on-site filming in Abu Dhabi was later than planned after last year’s actors and writers’ strike in Hollywood put things on hold. But Bruckheimer said there was never a moment when the project looked to be in jeopardy.

“We’re very fortunate because we had a whole section of the second unit photography that we hired, the second unit director,” he said. “So when both strikes hit, we didn’t need the writers. We didn’t need the actors. Joe Kosinski, who is our director, shot all of the second unit during the strike. So when we came back, we just had to shoot the actors. We were very fortunate that it worked out this way.”

Cue said that while it “delayed things a little bit,” there was “never any question about this,” even feeling the added time had been beneficial. “You can make an argument that having more time always helps,” Cue said. “We were able to come here twice, as an example, and we were able to film more than we would have.”

Much as Netflix’s “Drive to Survive” docuseries helped F1 reach a younger, more mainstream audience upon its debut in 2019, the sport hopes that “F1” will have the same impact. Bruckheimer thought that desire from the paddock and wider sport had led to such a collaborative effort in the past two years.

“The fans have been phenomenal, they really have,” Bruckheimer said. “They’ve embraced us and been really gracious to Brad and to the movie itself, the stuff that they’ve tweeted about the movie. They’ve realized the impact that a movie can have on a sport.

“The drivers haven’t been exposed to certain markets. I mean, these guys are rockstars, let’s face it, they’re the 20 best drivers in the world. And they’ll be exposed to not just the ‘Drive to Survive’ audience, but everybody.”

Watching the Premier League from LA’s futuristic sports bar – and a restricted-view seat

You may have seen the clips going viral on social media. The fans watching sporting events indoors, on a huge screen that makes them feel as though they are in the stadium of their choice. It’s a venue that has been frequented by the likes of Hollywood actor Danny DeVito and has transformed the way top-level European football can be consumed in the United States.

So, how does Cosm, as the new concept is known, compare to the real thing? The Athletic found out. We sent Pablo Maurer to Cosm Los Angeles to take in Fulham vs Arsenal yesterday, while Caoimhe O’Neill watched the action in person from the crowd at Fulham’s Craven Cottage stadium.


Maybe more than any other city in the United States, Los Angeles is a monument to American scale, dotted with outsized landmarks: the famed hillside Hollywood sign, a spaceship-sized football stadium and a host of other monuments to outsized kitsch.

Cosm Los Angeles, then, fits right in. It is ostensibly a sports bar but feels a bit more like a theme park, featuring an 87ft (26.5m) wide video screen that completely and totally immerses you. Cosm takes the American obsession with making nearly every sporting event a “premium” experience to the extreme, plopping you down on a couch, essentially, in what appears to be the middle of a stadium on another continent.

Just hours after I finished covering Major League Soccer’s championship match elsewhere in the city on Saturday night — among the most authentic footballing experiences you can have in the United States — I hopped in my car at 5am to watch Fulham take on Arsenal from 5,000 miles (nearly 9,000km) away in Cosm. I nursed my hangover with a $15 (almost £12) bloody mary and a $17 slice of avocado toast, alongside Americans who’ve shunned MLS in favour of the real version of the sport, as they sometimes say.

Clips taken inside Cosm have gone a bit viral on social media and the surrounding narrative is that it’s the closest you can get to a true matchday experience without the trouble of attending the match itself. In America, it’s an easy sell to Premier League supporters, many of whom rarely, if ever get a chance to visit their chosen club’s home ground.


Remnants of Storm Darragh batter Fulham fans as they make their way down the steps at Putney Bridge station.

They are met by calls of “Get your matchday scarves” and others trying to offload spare match tickets. It is 35 minutes until the 2pm kick-off but nobody seems in any great rush, even in the rain, as the last few Arsenal supporters finish their pints of beer and leave The Eight Bells pub.


Fans walk from Putney Bridge station to Fulham’s ground (Caoimhe O’Neill/The Athletic)

As throngs of fans make their way over the River Thames, via Putney Bridge itself, and towards Craven Cottage there is one man going against the crowd, awkwardly carrying a Christmas tree. In Bishops Park, the green railings that overlook the fast-moving river guide us towards the stadium.

Among those making that muddy walk are Charles Singer and his daughter Kirsty. The 72-year-old Scotsman is an Arsenal fan but became a member at Fulham after finding it difficult to get tickets to Arsenal games at the Emirates Stadium. They will be sitting in the new Riverside Stand — which incredibly includes a sky deck, rooftop terrace and a swimming pool. “I hope Emile Smith Rowe (formerly of Arsenal) scores for Fulham today but my heart wants an Arsenal win as much as I love watching Fulham,” says Charles, who has made the 93-mile (150km) journey from Bath, in the west of England.

Craven Cottage is a sight to behold. It is (parts of it anyway) the oldest football stadium in London and also one of the most aesthetically pleasing. The Johnny Haynes Stand — which is cornered by the actual cottage to which the ground bears its name — has slim turnstile entrances built into the surrounding brickwork. With 15 minutes until kick-off, fans bundled up against the winter weather are queuing up to squeeze through these slight openings in a wall which bears classic Fulham crests.

“Everyone knows Pam Wilson,” one Fulham fan says as he buys a matchday programme.

Pam, another Scot, has been selling programmes from the same spot on Stevenage Road for 26 years. The Athletic finds her as she is giving dog treats to a ginger labrador. “I bring treats for the dogs and sweets for the kids. You have to give back to the community,” the 51-year-old says. “I have loved Fulham ever since I first came here in 1997.

“I sell programmes outside Stamford Bridge before Chelsea games too (the two stadiums are only a couple of miles apart in west London) but I’m Fulham 100 per cent. I get regular customers who have been buying programmes from me for years. People are superstitious. When they buy a programme here and Fulham don’t win I get moaned at, but then if I’m not here one week they moan and groan. I love the banter.”


Let’s get this out of the way: there is no way, really, to convey the scale of the screen at Cosm.

You are essentially sitting inside of it, so to speak, as it cycles through four different camera angles beamed directly from, in this case, Craven Cottage. The Cosm space is split into three levels and my ticket has placed me on the second one, just to the left of the centerline.

The place is far from full, this is a 6am local time start on a Sunday, but there are still quite a few fans in attendance, and most of them are supporting Arsenal. Fulham, though, have always had a special place in the hearts of the American soccer fan, from the days of Brian McBride, Carlos Bocanegra and Clint Dempsey to Tim Ream, Antonee Robinson and owner Shahid Khan more recently, and today, the Los Angeles chapter of their American fan club is in attendance. All six or so of them.

When Raul Jimenez gets the opener for Fulham about 10 minutes in, they explode, drawing groans from the Arsenal fans in attendance.


The scale of the screen at Cosm is incredible (Pablo Maurer/The Athletic)

“Atmosphere is atmosphere,” says Todd Petty, who sits alongside his father Mark, also a Fulham supporter. They have been to Craven Cottage many times. “If we were sitting in the Putney End or the Hammersmith End or the Riverside, it would be different. But for us to be sitting here in the crowd, and to hear the chants and the cheering, to join in, it does give you a bit of that experience.”

Moments later, that tiny bit of magic disappears when an issue with the feed from across the Atlantic causes the picture to drop out completely for about five minutes. It’s a bit of a reality check.


After managing to get into the ground with two minutes to spare before kick-off, we’re hearing referee Chris Kavanagh being called “useless” by one Fulham fan within a minute of the opening whistle being blown. The stand we’re in is old and the view, despite our ticket costing £81 ($103), is so restricted I have to watch the action through and around a metal pillar when Arsenal are on the attack, which is for the majority of the first half — until I move into an empty seat further along the row.

When Mexico international Jimenez scores with Fulham’s first shot from their initial attack, his country’s flag is unfurled by fans in the Riverside Stand behind the two dugouts. A little boy in a Fulham shirt jumps into his mother’s arms to celebrate as Jimenez dances in front of the Arsenal fans — much to their frustration.

Arsenal forward Bukayo Saka is jeered and told to “f*** off” when he volleys a shot into the Hammersmith End as rain swirls into all four stands.

The visitors from across London remain 1-0 down as their fans in the away end chant, “You only came to see the Arsenal play.” One Fulham supporter enjoys (even if the Arsenal contingent can’t directly hear him) pointing out, “We came to see Fulham!” When Smith Rowe takes a heavy touch, he is reminded by another in the home crowd that he doesn’t play for Arsenal anymore — as though he has somehow forgotten.


The service at Cosm was great, albeit a little slow. The staff were friendly and attentive, in keeping with the luxury experience the place is seeking to provide. Top-level pro sports in the United States long ago became a product for the wealthy, and Cosm fits that mold quite well.

To the general public, my seat on level two of the place would cost nearly $90 (£70), about twice what you’d pay for a cheap ticket to an LAFC match in MLS at their stadium down the street. Cheaper options are available if you’re willing to stand or mill about the overflow areas.

I have a coffee, a bloody mary and a piece of avocado toast. The food and drink, frankly, were excellent but again, the items would set me back nearly $40. I cannot think of a single sports team I would pay a combined $150 (£117) to support in a single regular-season game, even in person, though maybe that’s just a personal problem.

As halftime approaches, I stroll outside, to the venue’s deck, which provides an absolutely, positively spectacular view of the surrounding hills. Cosm overlooks SoFi Stadium, home of the NFL’s Rams and Chargers, and the streets below are already dotted with Rams fans who’ve queued up for their game against the Buffalo Bills, which kicks off in five or six hours.

The dude next to me takes a hit off of a weed pen. It’s a little early for that, in my view, but Arsenal have indeed been tough to watch today.


On 43 minutes, some fans head to the concourse to beat the half-time rush for £7.20 ($9) pints and £7 ($8.92) chicken and sage pies.

When the rest of us head down into the cramped space beneath the old wooden seats shortly afterwards, it takes the majority of the 15-minute break to get served. Most opt for pre-poured pints of Camden Hells lager. Others munch £9.50 ($12) jumbo hot dogs. Back-to-back hot chocolate orders mean one server disappears to the end of the bar for long waits at the hot water station. There are also a lot of requests for Bovril, a beef-flavoured drink that’s a staple of English football winters, to tend to.


Fans queue for food and drink at half-time at Craven Cottage (Caoimhe O’Neill/The Athletic)

Those in the seats closest to the pitch are paying for it today with damp coats and jackets. The head steward hands plastic rain ponchos to those colleagues whose stations mean they are not under shelter. Being closer to the pitch does mean you can more crisply hear the ball being kicked and see small clumps of turf stick up into the air as Martin Odegaard sprays a pass through the rain.


Technical problems plague the feed again in the second half at Cosm, leading the small crop of Fulham supporters to break into a “What’s the WiFi password?” chant, drawing laughter and groans from the Arsenal fans in attendance.

When the feed works, it is truly spectacular.

For years, I’ve watched matches from the press box, and I’ve always appreciated the high angle from there, the way it allows you to see the match holistically. Oftentimes your eyes will wander and you’ll see plays develop off the ball, something so frequently lacking from the broadcast feed. At Cosm, other curious bits add to the viewing experience: fans who appear on the screen are larger than life and you can sometimes see them using their phone or chatting with each other.


The feed from Craven Cottage goes down at Cosm (Pablo Maurer/The Athletic)

The four-camera setup is managed by Cosm staff and one of those views comes from directly behind the goal, which proved to be my favourite. You can study players at the near post as they relay defensive tactics and watch the goalkeeper position his defenders. Arsenal score their second goal (later disallowed) on a corner kick, and my view of the action could not have been closer:


There is a lot more rain and plenty more expletives in the second half from the home fans — especially after William Saliba levels the scores. Arsenal midfielder Jorginho’s shouts of “Stay there” to forward Gabriel Martinelli are audible from across the ground. His advice works, seemingly, as Martinelli cuts in from the right to provide the cross for Saka’s would-be winning goal, though it turns out the Brazilian was offside in the build-up.

Before they knew that, the Arsenal fans wildly celebrated. Some even used the rain-soaked plastic partition that kept them separated from the Fulham fans in the Putney End as a water slide to get closer to the pitch. Saka was mobbed by his team-mates. Some Fulham fans couldn’t sit through the pain of it and got up to leave.

When the video assistant referee reviewed the goal and chalked it off, some of them — but not all — returned to their seats to watch the final few minutes of the game.


A restricted view at Craven Cottage (Caoimhe O’Neill/The Athletic)

The Arsenal supporters tried to put the disappointment behind them as their team put together some late attacks but it was the Fulham ones who banged their feet to create a rumbling sound as the visitors’ Declan Rice stood over a free kick on the left side of the pitch. They seemed pleased with themselves when the ball curled into the away end behind the goal and Rice covered his face with his hands.


Cosm, quite simply, isn’t much like being at a sporting event in person. The people who run the place, though, will often tell you that it isn’t supposed to be. It is something else entirely, feeling a bit more like a 3D movie than going to a game. Elements of the matchday experience are there, of course — the supporters, the food and drink, all that — but at the end of the day it’s still a very sterile environment, not quite as, um, seasoned as the surroundings at Craven Cottage.

Still, if you’re the type of person who likes lighting money on fire, it’s worth checking out. The technology is undeniably crazy and is absolutely Cosm’s selling point.

In the end, it feels a lot less like Anfield, Old Trafford or any other stadium and more like something plucked out of 2001: A Space Odyssey. I’ll stick to attending matches in person when I can.


Heading back through Bishops Park, the mud is even worse than it was pre-match as fans disperse in the direction of Putney Bridge and the station it gives its name to. Drizzly rain is ever-present as both sets of supporters rejoice and lament. Groups of Arsenal fans argue among themselves about whether or not they are in or out of the title race after failing to win today.

The sellers of half-and-half scarves have an urgency in their voice knowing the time to shift remaining Fulham vs Arsenal merchandise is fleeting.

Those same Arsenal fans head to The Eight Bells to continue their debrief. Fulham fans heading onto the Tube with mud-covered shoes seem pretty happy with the point.

(Top photos: Craven Cottage’s restricted views and Cosm Los Angeles: Caoimhe O’Neill and Pablo Maurer/The Athletic)

Conor Niland’s book ‘The Racket’ documents fear and loathing on the tennis tour

When Conor Niland picked up £30,000 for winning the William Hill Sports Book of the Year Award three weeks ago, it was double his biggest payday throughout a seven-year professional tennis career.

This neatly encompasses what Niland’s award-winning book, “The Racket”, is all about — the reality of being a tennis player outside the elite. For players like Niland, who reached a career high of world No. 129 and never went further than the first round at a major, Grand Slam glamour gives way to the grind of the second-tier (Challenger) and third-tier (ITF) tours, crisscrossing the world on cheap flights — and one hair-raising drive through the Uzbekistan countryside without a seatbelt.

The Racket covers a side of tennis often overshadowed by bigger events and more famous names, which is part of the reason it has captured the imagination not just of the sport’s own fans but of the wider sporting public. “It’s very accessible to people who don’t follow tennis, but it isn’t watered-down in any way for those who do know and understand the sport,” Niland says in a Zoom interview at the start of December.

Part of what makes the Ireland Davis Cup captain’s book so fascinating is his discussion of the mental challenges of tennis, which are varied and intense. Niland sees the book as a counterweight to “Open”, eight-time Grand Slam champion Andre Agassi’s searingly honest 2009 autobiography which deals with similar themes but focuses on the top of tennis. It also has kinship with “Challengers”, the Zendaya tennis movie centered on a top pro tennis player trying to return to glory on the Challenger circuit.

“You’re in your head a lot, that’s for sure,” Niland says, explaining that musicians and actors who are hoping to ‘make it’ have reached out after feeling kinship with his story. “You’re on your own. And you’ve got an awful lot of time to reflect … Tennis asks so much of you.”

GO DEEPER

60 minutes and 14 years: A Manhattan drive out of the tennis wilderness with Andre Agassi


Niland, 43, turned pro in 2005.

He qualified for two Grand Slams but lost in the first round of both. He blew a 4-1 final set lead against Frenchman Adrian Mannarino at Wimbledon in 2011; had he won, he would have played Roger Federer in the next round. He then had to retire with food poisoning while trailing Novak Djokovic 6-0, 5-1 on Arthur Ashe Stadium at that year’s U.S. Open. Those two defeats were his biggest career payouts, ahead of winning the Israel Open Challenger event in 2010 — until last month’s William Hill award.

Niland, as a promising 12-year-old from a country with negligible tennis pedigree, beat Federer in a friendly at the Winter Cup youth tournament in 1994. He trained at the Nick Bollettieri academy in Florida with Serena Williams, before competing on the U.S. college tennis circuit for the University of California, Berkeley, where he studied English literature and language.

He retired, aged 30, in 2012 because of a persistent hip injury but didn’t start writing his book for another eight years. Niland started jotting down some thoughts during the Covid-19 lockdown and found that they were gushing out of him; a few weeks later, he had a book proposal from publisher Penguin. Irish sportswriter Gavin Cooney was a ghostwriter on the project, but much of the writing is Niland’s own.

He feels tennis is a misunderstood sport: a profession in which around 100 men and women can make a decent living each year while thousands of others play for little reward. “It’s not good enough that there aren’t 300, 400 people in the world, men and women, who can make a very decent income,” Niland says, pointing to golf as an example of a sport with a better remuneration structure. Ultimately, only 128 men and women can be in any Grand Slam event’s draw, which makes getting those bigger paydays harder.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

How the fight to improve the tennis calendar risks destroying its soul

This creates a brutal hierarchy, which is at the heart of The Racket. Niland paints a vivid picture of tennis’ haves and have-nots, documenting a training session with idol Pete Sampras among portraits of the myriad characters all the way down the sport’s rungs. Niland’s peers crave support and success, while the likes of Agassi and Sampras occupy another universe; he recalls Agassi surrounded at a tournament by so many hangers-on that he accepts a glass of water he doesn’t really want, just to give them something to do.

What Niland also captures is that players, even greats such as Sampras and Agassi, don’t breathe that rarefied air from the start; he uses current world No. 10 Grigor Dimitrov as an example of how the tennis hierarchy moves. He recalls getting on well with Dimitrov when the Bulgarian was a wide-eyed teenager who proudly declared that “(Maria) Sharapova likes me, man”, before explaining that Dimitrov became more distant as he rose up the food chain. “By the time he had cracked the top 20, he was ignoring me completely,” he writes.

There is scarcely more friendliness among players of the same level, though, especially on the Challenger and ITF Tours where people are fighting for their livelihoods as well as their ranking points. “Locker rooms on the lesser tours are full of strangers with bad tattoos,” Niland writes. “Everyone is just polite enough not to call one another out for being an a**hole, but selfishness is rewarded. Everyone is in competition with one another and on the lookout for a weakness in everybody else.”


Conor Niland’s only main-draw match at Wimbledon ended in heartbreak as he lost in five sets (Clive Mason / Getty Images)

These are power structures that people who have never gone near tennis can relate to, whether on the corporate ladder or in social groups. In tennis, as in all fields of life, “you’re constantly self-analyzing,” Niland says.

The tensions intrinsic to these hierarchies have boiled over in the past few months in the wake of high-profile doping cases involving men’s world No. 1 Jannik Sinner and women’s world No. 2 Iga Swiatek. Tennis players and fans largely accept that it is a tiered sport: the top players aren’t just paid more on and off the court, but receive preferential treatment in terms of court allocations and appearance fees.

Low-level players who do make it into bigger tournaments won’t get picked for show courts equipped with roofs for when it rains; they are less likely to make deep runs and so rarely know when their matches will be scheduled or how long they’ll be at a tournament for. An early defeat can mean a panic to change flights and an unexpected series of wins can mean scrambling for a new hotel room. The Challenger and ITF or ‘Futures’ circuits are played at small venues with modest facilities and few spectators.

The Racket sees Niland recount Federer summoning the British player Dan Evans to his base in Dubai for a few weeks of off-season workouts, insisting that every practice match be at 7 p.m. local time. Federer knew he would play the first match of his next tournament three weeks before the tournament even started.

Players accept these kinds of privileges. Things get heated when people perceive the accepted double standards in other realms.

Several of Sinner’s peers vented their frustration in August when he was not banned after twice testing positive for the banned substance clostebol, even though the International Tennis Integrity Agency (ITIA) followed due process throughout an investigation that led to a “no fault or negligence” verdict. Sinner received a provisional suspension for each positive test, but quickly and successfully appealed on both occasions, meaning he could keep playing without the bans being made public until the conclusion of the ITIA’s investigation.

‘One rule for them, another for us’ was the essential complaint. In November, Swiatek’s positive test for trimetazidine (TMZ) from contaminated melatonin (sleeping tablets) medication led to a month’s ban. Swiatek also quickly and successfully appealed her provisional suspension, which the ITIA issued in September.

On this occasion, lower-ranked players emphasized that only elite players like Sinner and Swiatek can afford the swift legal and medical advice and testing required to appeal their provisional suspensions. Players only have a 10-day window and ITIA chief executive Karen Moorhouse accepted that players with more resources are better positioned to deal with incidents like this.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

What players’ reaction to Sinner’s doping case says about their trust in their sport

Niland feels the segregation of the Challenger and ITF Tours “downgrades” tennis outside of the rankings’ top 100s and “makes it seem like we’re not legitimate professionals,” describing the Swiatek case as a “perfect example” of why tennis is perceived to be a two-tier sport.

“The fact that they’re able to announce to the world on their terms on their own Instagram page … Tennis has a bad habit of thinking the very best players in the sport are the sport and that they’re bigger than the sport. It’s the way these things are managed and the feeling that it’s the haves and the have-nots,” he says.

Niland never directly witnessed doping but was once approached to fix a match by an anonymous caller. He hung up the phone.


Unable to afford the entourage and support teams of the best players, Niland describes the “crushing” loneliness and isolation of being a lower-ranked tennis player.

“I made virtually no lasting friendships on tour through my seven years, despite coming across hundreds of players my own age living the same life as my own,” he writes. Players who do strike up bonds, such as Dane Sweeny and Calum Puttergill, two Australians who document their seasons on YouTube, spend time figuring out if they can afford to lose a match or not.

Niland also recalls the unhealthy obsession with one’s ranking — the digits that measure a player’s sense of self-worth. He says he still gets a “flash of adrenaline” when he sees the number 129, say on a digital clock, remembering the constant fretting about losing points won the previous year.

“By September, you’re already thinking about the points you might lose in February,” he says.

“You’re dealing with losing constantly and constantly trying to get better and comparing yourself with the very best in the world,” he says, explaining that the intertwining of results with self-esteem was the worst part of the job.

And the best? “It was great to wake up with a dream every day — mine was to play at the Grand Slams. The fact I actually got to do it was great, even though it was bittersweet.”

Niland hopes The Racket humanizes the players below the sport’s top 100, explaining that one of the biggest misconceptions about tennis is the perceived gulf in talent between the elite and those just below them. It’s a much smaller gap than people think, he says, and very small margins can determine a player’s career trajectory.

Nowadays, Niland is the Irish Davis Cup captain, but his main job is with a commercial real estate company.

He lives in Dublin with his wife and kids (Emma, eight, and six-year-old Tom), all of whom play tennis, something he very rarely does anymore. Full-time coaching doesn’t appeal, but he would love to keep writing, with the work on this book helping him to process his gruelling first career: “I think some of the ‘failures’ in the book are what makes it more compelling and the fact that there isn’t necessarily a happy ending for me in the tennis context. I guess the happy ending is this book.

“Tennis can offer you something — you might get bits and pieces out of it, but it’s not necessarily going to save you.”

(Top photos: Getty Images; design: Dan Goldfarb)

Giants’ record-setting Willy Adames deal shows Buster Posey means business

Buster Posey held the San Francisco Giants’ record for the largest contract in franchise history. In Posey’s first major move as the club’s president of baseball operations, he did not hesitate to smash it.

The Giants agreed to terms with free-agent shortstop Willy Adames on a seven-year, $182 million contract on Saturday, reshaping the left side of their infield for the remainder of the decade and signaling their resolve to remain aggressive as they seek to reestablish their relevance in the National League West. The agreement with Adames is pending a physical — more than a trifling detail given the medical issues that scuttled Carlos Correa’s $350 million contract following the 2022 season — and its guaranteed money would soar past Posey’s own nine-year, $167 million contract that he signed after winning the NL MVP Award in 2012.

With Adames and third baseman Matt Chapman, who signed a six-year, $150 million extension in September, the Giants have committed a third of a billion dollars to establish a solid offensive and defensive presence on the left side of their infield. Viewed together, those investments are not so different from the megadeals that the Texas Rangers gave to shortstop Corey Seager and second baseman Marcus Semien after the 2021 season — a $500 million bet that paid off when the Rangers won the first World Series title in franchise history two years later.

Adames, 29, earned 4.8 fWAR last season when he finished fourth in the majors with 112 RBIs, set career highs in home runs (32) and stolen bases (21), and led the Milwaukee Brewers to the NL Central title. Likely just as significant to Posey and the Giants, Adames was a respected leader in Milwaukee, praised for his durability and his ability to produce in the clutch. He was among the league’s best defenders at shortstop in 2023, and although several of his advanced metrics declined this past season, there’s little doubt that he represents an upgrade with the glove over the Giants’ internal options at the position.

Perhaps the most revealing aspect of the Giants’ stunning agreement, which came on the eve of baseball’s Winter Meetings in Dallas, is how it reflects on Posey, who had been something of a cipher in his brief tenure as a first-time baseball executive, filling out front-office positions and adding advisory voices but otherwise providing few specifics on how aggressive he would be at improving a team that finished 80-82 in 2024 while missing the postseason for the seventh time in eight seasons.

But Posey had been clear on one point: He identified acquiring a shortstop as the club’s top priority. And the Giants just agreed to sign the top shortstop on the free-agent market.


As a player, Buster Posey was a problem solver. (G Fiume / Getty Images)

Posey had a talent for cutting through the noise during his career behind the plate, tackling problems head-on, carving a direct path and avoiding the trap of overthinking. If his first major move as the Giants’ chief baseball architect is any indication, he will lean on those same attributes and impulses while seeking to close the sizable gap between his team and the Los Angeles Dodgers, San Diego Padres and Arizona Diamondbacks.

Identify problem. Fix problem.

Posey wasn’t sufficiently deterred by the fact that signing Adames, who had been extended a qualifying offer by the Brewers, will force the Giants to sacrifice their second- and fifth-round picks along with $1 million in international bonus money from their 2026 pool. Those are no small considerations for a franchise that also punted its second- and third-round picks in this past draft after signing Chapman and left-hander Blake Snell the previous offseason. The Giants wouldn’t have lost draft picks if they had pivoted from Adames to shortstop Ha-Seong Kim, a favorite of Giants manager Bob Melvin from their time together in San Diego but who will be continuing to rehab from offseason shoulder surgery on Opening Day.

But Adames was clearly the best shortstop on the market. And Posey kept it as simple as that.

“Ultimately, it’s a boring answer, but you just want complete baseball players,” Posey said at the GM Meetings in November. “You want guys who can do some of everything.”

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Top 45 MLB free agents for 2024-25 with contract predictions, team fits: Will Soto get $600M+?

Interestingly, Posey’s first major free-agent signing is a fellow CAA client. The Giants recently announced the hiring of Jeff Berry, Posey’s former agent and the former head of CAA’s baseball division, as a special advisor.

ESPN was the first to report the agreement. The Giants aren’t expected to announce it until late Sunday or Monday.

The addition of Adames would push Tyler Fitzgerald into a competition at second base with Casey Schmitt, Brett Wisely and potentially Marco Luciano if the organization’s former top prospect isn’t traded or moved to the outfield.

The biggest question becomes how aggressive the Giants will be to address their second major need: a pitching presence for a rotation that threw the fewest innings in the National League despite the fact that their opening-day ace, Logan Webb, threw the most on an individual basis. Several reports have linked the Giants to former Cy Young Award winner Corbin Burnes, a Bakersfield-area native who competed at Saint Mary’s College in Moraga and would give the Giants one of the best 1-2 punches in the league.

Before last season with the Baltimore Orioles, Burnes had spent his entire major-league career with the Brewers so the addition of Adames might be a selling point in any Giants’ attempt at a pursuit. Both players are very well known to Zack Minasian, the Giants’ newly elevated GM, who had been the scouting director in Milwaukee during his 14 seasons with the organization. Minasian had been one of the strongest voices to champion Burnes when the right-hander showed promise in the minor leagues, advising then-Brewers GM Doug Melvin to make the former fourth-round pick practically untouchable in trade discussions.

On a cash basis, the Giants spent $206 million on player salaries last season, exceeded the luxury tax threshold ($237 million) for the first time since 2018 and sustained operating losses that caused some discomfort among members of the ownership group. Their placeholder budget numbers for 2025 had called for a reduction in player payroll, which might still be achieved even if the club can win the bidding for Burnes — a market that is expected to exceed $200 million — as well as Adames.

Adding Adames’ $26 million average annual value would put the Giants’ estimated cash-basis payroll at roughly $170 million. If the Giants seek to trim in other areas, they could trade one or more of their arbitration-eligible players (LaMonte Wade Jr. and Camilo Doval among them). Or they could sign one of several second-tier starting pitchers who won’t come cheap — witness Luis Severino’s three-year, $67 million contract with the A’s — but would require a fraction of what it would take to land Burnes, who notably left CAA for the Boras Corporation in 2023 and whose potential signing also would cost the Giants their third- and sixth-round draft picks.

Or Posey could do what he demonstrated so often over his playing career: cut through the noise, go after the best player, and convince ownership to spend.

“I know we’ll be very diligent in our decision-making,” Posey said last month. “But something I’ve tried to inject with the group is for us not to be hamstrung from that potential fear of failure. It’s knowing that, ‘Hey, sometimes we’re going to have to risk media members saying this was a bad decision or a bad move.’ But if we feel convicted in it, then you have to be OK with it.”

(Top photo of Adames: Lachlan Cunningham / Getty Images)

NFL Week 14 roundtable: Should Pittsburgh be on upset alert? Time for Michael Penix Jr.?

The Jameis Winston experience reached heights never seen before with the Cleveland Browns’ loss to the Denver Broncos on Monday night. The Browns aren’t your typical 3-9 team, which the Pittsburgh Steelers already know well.

Should the first-place Steelers be on upset alert again in Week 14? Our writers Mike Sando, Zak Keefer and Jeff Howe address the question in The Athletic’s roundtable previewing Week 14’s remaining slate.

Our writers also ponder if it’s too late in the season for a team amid a playoff push to throw a rookie quarterback in the fire. It’s the talk in Atlanta as the Falcons and Kirk Cousins (at Vikings) continue to fall with the rival Tampa Bay Buccaneers (vs. Raiders) rising.

Read more below for what else is on our writers’ minds this week.


As Monday night showed, you never know what you’ll get out of the Jameis Winston experience. Should Pittsburgh be on upset alert vs. the Browns on Sunday?

Keefer: Absolutely. For starters, they lost to this same Browns team in Week 12, and it’s no secret across the league that Cleveland’s offense is much more potent with Winston under center than Deshaun Watson. Maybe Winston’s prayer to rid himself of the pick-sixes will work, because without those killer mistakes, he’s unlocked something in the Browns’ passing game. For starters, look at what Jerry Jeudy’s doing (he’s eighth in the league in EPA per reception). Also, with Winston at QB, the Browns have had their three most productive days on offense this season.

Howe: The Steelers would need to have short-term amnesia if they aren’t on upset alert because the Browns beat them two weeks ago in one of the funnest games of the season. The Browns are playing much better on offense with Winston, similar to the way the move to Joe Flacco sparked the offense in 2023. You can tell the Browns are playing hard for their coach and quarterback, and they’d love nothing more than to sweep their rivals during an otherwise lost season. The Browns may not be able to predict what they’ll get out of Winston each game, but the results were far more predictable and a whole lot less successful earlier this season when they could foresee the results.

Sando: Yes, because it’s a divisional game and Pittsburgh already lost to the Browns recently. The Mike Tomlin-era Steelers are 19-4 against the Browns when Cleveland had a losing record entering the game. The record is 4-2 since 2019 and 0-1 this season.

The Jaguars meet the Titans without Trevor Lawrence, who, while sliding, suffered a concussion on a hit by Texans linebacker Azeez Al-Shaair last week. There has been some debate over whether Lawrence started his slide too late. Is there any merit to that notion? Could you envision the league ever addressing “fake” QB slides in the future?

Keefer: I’m not buying that. Lawrence started to slide when he saw the defender approaching, giving himself up on the play. Al-Shaair leveled the quarterback with a forearm to the upper part of Lawrence’s shoulder pad and his neck. It was late. It was dirty. It was unnecessary. And it’s not the first time this season Shaair’s been criticized for a late hit on a QB. I do think, if quarterbacks start faking slides to keep the play alive, the league will step in. But this was not that.

Howe: Lawrence slid later than critics may have liked in order to maximize his opportunity to get a first down, but that doesn’t come with an open invitation for a defender to launch himself with a leading elbow to the head area. Later slides generally come with some level of contact from the defense, and the officials tend to do a decent job of determining which of those hits are incidental and which others rise to the level of a penalty. If quarterbacks start a tendency of doing the fake slide, a la Kenny Pickett at Pitt, the league should absolutely put an end to it. The closest thing we’ve seen to that, at least in terms of any semblance of regularity, would be the QBs who take advantage of a few extra yards near the boundary, but I’m not sure how that could be objectively enforced.

Sando: The first coach I spoke with regarding the Lawrence hit pointed out right away that he thought Lawrence slid late. There is merit to the notion. Texans GM Nick Caserio speaking out so forcefully in defense of Al-Shaair does raise the possibility some in the NFL could push for clarifications/changes. But because the league would rather have critics complaining about too many protections for quarterbacks than not enough protections for them, I think it’ll take examples more blatant than the one involving Lawrence for the league to address “fake” slides.

The Bears and 49ers meet on Sunday. Who might be the best fit as the next Bears head coach? What should be at the top of the 49ers’ offseason to-do list, should they miss the playoffs?

Keefer: Can they get Ben Johnson? If Kevin Warren is right — and this is the best job of the NFL’s impending hiring cycle — then this franchise needs to do everything it can to lure the Lions’ offensive coordinator down to Chicago. Nothing is more paramount than Caleb Williams’ development, and the rookie’s shown enough promise this season, despite the recent chaos surrounding the organization, that with the right coach he can become a star in this league. The old Chicago regimes would get this wrong. Maybe this year they actually get it right.

As for the 49ers, despite what some pundits are saying, I don’t think a full-on rebuild is necessary. There’s too much talent. Brock Purdy is young. Christian McCaffrey will be back next season. This year was plagued by a ridiculous stream of injuries, and probably the lingering effects of last year’s gutting Super Bowl loss. The roster needs some tweaks, and needs some youth, but there are too many sound building blocks to move on from.

Howe: They should prioritize offensive consistency for Williams, so there should be apprehension over a defensive-minded coach who could lose his offensive coordinator every couple years. Thomas Brown will deserve a serious look if the Bears play better down the stretch, and the Bears should also bring in Ben Johnson, Zac Robinson and Liam Coen for interviews. With the Niners, it’s been a few years running now where rival executives marvel at the top-end talent but remain wary over their depth, which is why they run into these issues when their stars go down. They aren’t giving out bad contracts to their stars, but there’s an injury risk involved that’s been coming to a head. Same with the Trey Lance pick. Sure, they ultimately figured it out at quarterback, but they’d be in a much better spot right now if they hit on the trio of first-round picks that it cost to draft Lance. This would be a logical time to move on from veterans who are on the back nine and reinforce depth through the draft.

GO DEEPER

Thomas Brown’s chances to stay? Trade for a coach? Bears mailbag, plus Week 14 picks

Sando: How fun would it be if the Bears made a run at Deion Sanders? I’m thinking outside the box with an eye toward the other coaches in this division. Dan Campbell is one of a kind, an outsized personality. Kevin O’Connell and Matt LaFleur are more conventional and both are flourishing. Coach Prime would instantly make the Bears relevant. And while most high-profile coaches would want more personnel/organizational control than Chicago appears willing to grant, Sanders might not. He could bring in some veteran NFL coaches and shake up the division. Is anyone with me?


Would Colorado Buffaloes head coach Deion Sanders be a fit for the Chicago Bears? (Ron Chenoy / Imagn Images)

The Bucs (vs. Raiders), Cardinals (vs. Seahawks) and Rams (vs. Bills) are all 6-6 and probably need to win their respective divisions to make the playoffs. Which team should be feeling most confident right now?

Keefer: I like Tampa Bay’s chances in the NFC South simply because the Falcons feel like frauds. Atlanta’s been so wildly inconsistent this season, and Kirk Cousins is amid one of the worst slumps of his career. The Bucs, meanwhile, won’t see a team with a winning record the rest of the regular season.

Howe: If the Bucs take care of business, they should win four of their last five games and take the NFC South. Their defensive inconsistencies are concerning because it’s tough to rip off a winning streak like that, but their schedule is the most accommodating compared to the Seahawks and Cardinals. The NFC West is completely unpredictable and has been pretty much all season. The only thing I feel confident about is the Niners won’t win the division, so you might as well print their championship T-shirts now.

Sando: Tampa Bay is the team for me as well. It’s amazing to me the Bucs lost twice to the Falcons, but they did, and that’s why they’re in this position. The Athletic’s model puts the Bucs’ playoff chances at 54 percent, compared to 35 percent for Arizona and 26 percent for the Rams. That feels about right to me.


Our writers trust Baker Mayfield and the Tampa Bay Buccaneers to end up on top in the NFC South with the Atlanta Falcons struggling. (Elsa / Getty Images)

The Falcons are on the road vs. the Vikings. Throwing a rookie QB into the fire against a Brian Flores defense seems ill-advised. But should the Falcons consider starting Michael Penix Jr. over Kirk Cousins at some point this season if things get worse?

Keefer: Yes. If Cousins continues to struggle — his third interception Sunday against the Chargers was one of the worst ones I’ve seen a starter throw all year — the Falcons need to consider giving Penix a chance. The division is still within reach, and if you stick with a starter who’s killing drives and costing the team games, you’re doing a disservice to the locker room. Players know. Players pay attention. They simply want the guy who’ll give them the best chance to win on Sundays. Penix played a lot of games in college; it’s entirely possible he could step in and give this offense a spark.

Howe: I’ve been told Penix has been lighting it up in practice, so a switch would be justified if they felt like making the move. Under no circumstances would I start Penix against the Vikings, but the remaining games against the Raiders, Giants, Commanders and Panthers would be appealing. But this decision wouldn’t be made in a vacuum. If the Falcons go with Penix while they’re still in contention and he plays decently enough, I don’t see how they could keep Cousins in 2025. And it’s fair to believe Cousins will be better next season once he’s fully healed from the torn Achilles. But if the Falcons switch to Penix once they’re out of contention and he plays OK, even if it’s only for the regular-season finale, Cousins won’t have any room for error with the fan base in 2025. The safer play is to stick with Cousins. But if the Falcons believe moving to Penix would spark the locker room and accelerate his chances to start in Week 1 next season, such an aggressive move would be the correct play.

Sando: The Falcons should play Penix for the final four games if Cousins plays poorly and/or the team loses at Minnesota. They’ll have an extra day to get Penix ready because they follow their game at Minnesota with a Monday night visit to Las Vegas in Week 15. Atlanta then finishes with the Giants, Commanders and Panthers. Getting some experience for Penix in the absence of great expectations seems like a good idea. Getting Cousins to the offseason without another injury also has value.

(Photo: Brooke Sutton / Getty Images)

NHL 2024-25 bold predictions: Revisiting our preseason prognostications

Utah will be one of the NHL’s highest-scoring teams? The Stars Stanley Cup winners? Dylan Larkin — and many others — 40-goal scorers?

Heading into the 2024-25 NHL season, The Athletic asked its hockey staff for bold predictions, and two months later, some are holding up well while others look to have been a bit too bold.

Here’s a progress report on each prediction, from the writers ready to take a victory lap to the many who need a mulligan.


Preseason bold prediction: Trevor Zegras will not be traded this season

Outlook: Still in play

It feels like there have been two factions at work here: those who feel like a Zegras trade is inevitable and those (i.e., Zegras/Ducks fans) who are beyond tired of seeing his name in trade-related/hypothesized/predicted stories. Mind you, it’s hard to peg what his value is or could be. He had been healthy until he got injured this week and his return date is uncertain. Those who’ve watched him closely can see he is playing a more responsible 200-foot game under Greg Cronin. But he’s also on a 34-point pace. Zegras might be a distressed asset, but GM Pat Verbeek isn’t going to move a highly skilled 23-year-old forward for another team’s throwaways. — Eric Stephens


Jeremy Swayman struggled early for the Bruins, but is better as of late. (Michael Reaves / Getty Images)

Preseason bold prediction: Jeremy Swayman will struggle early

Outlook: Lock it in

This one was easy. It wasn’t just that Swayman missed all of training camp before signing his contract. He had to adjust to the physical and mental strain of being the go-to goalie following the trade of Linus Ullmark. On top of that, most of his teammates struggled out of the gate. It’s no wonder Swayman wasn’t himself. — Fluto Shinzawa

Preseason bold prediction: Owen Power will double his previous high-goal total

Outlook: Still in play

Power is already almost halfway to a career high in points 26 games into the season and has three goals. He needs nine more in the final 66 games to get to my preseason bold prediction. Given that he plays 22 minutes a night and has a role on the power play, 12 goals is still a number that’s in play, but it’s not quite a lock. — Matthew Fairburn

Preseason bold prediction: Jonathan Huberdeau will crack the 80-point plateau

Outlook: So far, not so good. But there’s time …

While Huberdeau’s goal totals look more promising compared to last year (he had one point in all of December 2023), we kind of figured his assists would be up. However, he isn’t trending toward an 80-point season, per Hockey Reference. But if he goes on some kind of scoring run between now and the end of the season, maybe that changes. — Julian McKenzie

Preseason bold prediction: Seth Jarvis will get a shot at center

Outlook: So far, not so good. But there’s time …

The Hurricanes still haven’t figured out who will be their second-line center, but so far it hasn’t been Jarvis. Coach Rod Brind’Amour has bounced between using Jesperi Kotkaniemi and Jack Drury in a more featured role, while Jarvis has remained on the wing. Jarvis has also not been used much on faceoffs — a key for any Brind’Amour center — since returning from an upper-body injury. — Cory Lavalette

Preseason bold prediction: The Blackhawks will finish 25 points better than last season

Outlook: It’s a long shot

This season hasn’t gone as expected for the Blackhawks, which was apparent with Luke Richardson’s firing on Thursday. They’re more competitive than a season ago — they’ve led, been tied or within a goal in the third period in 25 of 26 games — but their record is even worse. Does a new coach change that? We’ll see. But they have to win a lot to meet the bold prediction. — Scott Powers

Preseason bold prediction: Cale Makar will have 100 points

Outlook: Still in play

This prediction is looking solid through the first two months of the season. Makar leads all defensemen with 34 points, which ranks 13th amongst all players. He’s on an 82-game pace of 103 points, so he’s right on track. As expected, Makar is getting a lot of his production done on the power play, where he’s tied for fourth in the NHL with 14 points. — Jesse Granger


Yegor Chinakhov has had an impressive start to the season with the Blue Jackets. (Jason Mowry / Getty Images)

Preseason bold prediction: Yegor Chinakhov will bloom as a goal scorer

Outlook: Still in play

Chinakhov threatened to make this prediction look like pure genius with three goals and seven points in the Blue Jackets’ first five games. He’s since cooled off and is currently out of the lineup day to day with an upper-body injury. But once he returns, the 23-year-old Russian will get a top-six role on a club that’s been surprisingly productive. He has seven goals in 21 games, meaning our prediction of 25-plus is still in play. Our prediction of increased ice time? He’s gone from 15:10 last season to 17:01 under coach Dean Evason. — Aaron Portzline

Preseason bold prediction: The Stars will win the Stanley Cup

Outlook: Still in play

Top 10 in goals per game, top five in goals-against per game, top five in penalty kill and a top-10 goalie in Jake Oettinger. The Stars are right where we expected them to be, among the league’s best teams, and they’re doing it with an underperforming power play and relatively slow starts from Jason Robertson and Wyatt Johnston, all of which likely will positively regress to the mean. Even with Tyler Seguin’s potential season-ending surgery (something which likely will make the Stars more aggressive in the trade market), Dallas remains a leading contender for the Stanley Cup. — Mark Lazerus

Preseason bold prediction: Dylan Larkin will score 40 goals

Outlook: Still in play

This season hasn’t gone how the Red Wings would have hoped, but Larkin is indeed close to being on pace to threaten 40 goals. There’s a lot of season left, of course, but he’s been a force, particularly on the power play. Detroit could really use some more offense from down the lineup, but their top players (Larkin, Lucas Raymond and Alex DeBrincat) have been scoring to begin the year. — Max Bultman

Preseason bold prediction: Stuart Skinner will finish top five in Vezina voting

Outlook: Not happening

Skinner went from perhaps the presumptive starter for Team Canada at the 4 Nations tourney entering the offseason to not making the team because of his subpar start. Skinner sports an .889 save percentage in 17 appearances. He’s also surrendered 5.26 more goals than expected in all situations, per Natural Stat Trick. His last start before rosters were due was one of his best, but it was too little too late. — Daniel Nugent-Bowman

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Stuart Skinner’s last audition for a Team Canada job is as good as it gets

Preseason bold prediction: Adam Boqvist will break out

Outlook: It’s a long shot

It’s not that Boqvist has been horrendous — an expected goal rate of around 50 percent for a cheap, third-pair defenseman could be worse — but he hasn’t come close to a breakout, either, and actually played his way out of the lineup for most of November. He’s back, though, and scored in consecutive games through Thursday. More than anything, that prediction was based on Boqvist getting a whole bunch of power-play time, and that’s once again Aaron Ekblad’s job to lose. Probably not happening. — Sean Gentille

Preseason bold prediction: Quinton Byfield will become the Kings’ best player

Outlook: Not happening

Can I say I was kidding? No? Hey, I bought into the idea of Byfield building on his breakout season. Seeing him with just three goals and 11 points nearly a third of the way into the season is a bit baffling. He’s back at his natural position but the transition from playing on wing with Anze Kopitar and Adrian Kempe to centering his own line hasn’t been seamless. It’s not that he’s hurting their lineup but the Kings becoming a real threat in the Western Conference will look more realistic if he starts to look more like a leading player on their roster like Kopitar and Kempe are. — Eric Stephens

Preseason bold prediction: Matt Boldy will score 40 goals and 40 assists

Outlook: Still in play

This felt like a lock in mid-November when he had 10 goals in his first 16 games, but Boldy has gone six games without a goal and has one in his past nine. Still, he was on pace for 36 goals and 43 assists for a 79-point total through Thursday, which would establish career highs. This is a guy who has a tendency to get white hot, especially because he is a high-volume shooter (93 in 25 games this season, 3.7 per game). — Michael Russo

Preseason bold prediction: Juraj Slafkovský will hit 70 points

Outlook: So far, not so good. But there’s time …

Slafkovský has 14 points in 23 games and has 56 games left to get 56 points. Doesn’t seem ideal. But last season at this point, Slafkovský had 7 points in 25 games and finished with 43 points in his final 57 games. Putting up a point per game from here on out is a high bar, but Slafkovský has not yet reached the level we saw from him last season. There is a lot of room for him to grow. I’m not willing to write off this prediction just yet, though it’s not looking great so far. — Arpon Basu

Preseason bold prediction: Juuse Saros will win the Vezina Trophy

Outlook: Not happening

Saros is the absolute least of the Preds’ concerns. He’s having a fine season — you might even call it an extraordinary season, given the utter lack of help he’s getting. But he isn’t standing on his head enough to deliver wins for the league’s worst offensive team. Or is this just the worst team, period? Team failure to this extent repels individual awards. — Joe Rexrode

Preseason bold prediction: The Devils will finish with the East’s best record

Outlook: Still in play

The Devils’ offseason overhaul has led to a successful start to 2024-25. Their position in the East standings is a bit inflated by games they have in hand, but they were still fourth in points percentage through Thursday. One hot streak and they could be right in the mix with the leaders. — Peter Baugh

Preseason bold prediction: Noah Dobson will score 70 points again — and get a big extension

Outlook: It’s a long shot

The 70-point thing is a pipe dream with Dobson sitting on 12 points through 27 games. And the eight-year $8-million-or-so extension might be a pipe dream too. Dobson is still just 24, but he’s hit a plateau this season for the middling Islanders. Whoops. — Arthur Staple

Preseason bold prediction: Igor Shesterkin will win the Vezina Trophy

Outlook: Still in play

The Rangers are in a bit of a rut, but Shesterkin has had a good year. His 8-9-1 record isn’t overly impressive, but he has taken most of the Rangers games against playoff teams and had a .908 save percentage through Thursday with better underlying numbers. He’s not among the Vezina front-runners at this point, but him winning the award isn’t impossible. He also now doesn’t have any contract talk hanging over him. He agreed to a record-setting eight-year extension Friday. — Peter Baugh

Preseason bold prediction: Travis Green will win the Jack Adams Award

Outlook: It’s a long shot

If the Senators reverse their fortunes after a less-than-ideal start, Green’s case for the Jack Adams could be made. When Ottawa plays at its best, it looks like a playoff team. The issue is consistency. That’s on Green to help instill in his own group. But right now, we don’t think Green will end up on many ballots for coach of the year honors. — Julian McKenzie

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Who has disappointed the most so far? Senators fan survey results

Preseason bold prediction: The Flyers will have a top-15 power play

Outlook: It’s a long shot

It looked so promising early. The Flyers converted on eight of their first 31 power-play chances through eight games, good for eighth in the NHL. Since then it’s resumed its place at the bottom of the league. Since Oct. 27, only the Bruins have a worse power play than the Flyers’ 10.4 percent success rate. At some point, perhaps soon, the Flyers may be forced to make a decision on assistant coach Rocky Thompson, who just can’t seem to get this part of the Flyers’ game going. — Kevin Kurz


Marcus Pettersson could be a big target for teams at the trade deadline. (Patrick Smith / Getty Images)

Preseason bold prediction: Marcus Pettersson will become a trade-deadline commodity

Outlook: Lock it in

Pettersson was No. 2 on our big board and would-be UFAs that high on a trade list don’t usually end up staying with their teams. The Penguins won four consecutive games before Friday, their best run of the season. They’re within striking distance of a playoff spot — and it’s possible that means they hold on to Pettersson. But a case can be made for striking while the iron is hot. There are no indications a long-term extension is on the table here in Pittsburgh. The Penguins are in the mushy middle but closer to the bottom than the top. Keeping a player like Pettersson doesn’t make much sense. — Rob Rossi

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Penguins Today: A Pettersson dilemma and a convergence of Pittsburgh’s Stanley Cup GMs

Preseason bold prediction: William Eklund will lead the team in scoring

Outlook: So far, not so good. But there’s time …

With his 18 assists and 23 points, Eklund is second in those categories to Mikael Granlund so the possibility does exist of the 22-year-old overtaking the veteran. The chances of that will greatly increase if the Sharks were to move Granlund before the trade deadline. Eklund can build up his goal total as he has only five in 28 games, and he may have to hold off a hard-charging Macklin Celebrini who’s nearly at a point per game since returning from injury. But the left wing in his third full season has become the front-line core player the Sharks imagined when taking him at No. 7 in the 2021 draft. — Eric Stephens


Matty Beniers is struggling to produce in his third full season with the Kraken. (Steph Chambers / Getty Images)

Preseason bold prediction: Matty Beniers will score 30 goals

Outlook: Not happening

I’m ready to capitulate early on this prediction. After what appeared to be a snake bit, sophomore slump campaign for the 2023 Calder winner, the gifted Kraken center has somehow remained in shooing-percentage hell this season. Through 27 games before Friday, Beniers had scored just four times on 51 shots and is carrying a 7.8 percent shooting clip that’s less than half of the conversion rate he managed in his electric rookie season. Beniers would have to score at a 44-goals per 82-game pace over the balance to hit 30, which is a massive stretch for a player that has scored just 19 goals in his most recent 104 games played through Thursday. — Thomas Drance

Preseason bold prediction: Philip Broberg and Dylan Holloway’s success will lead to more offer sheets

Outlook: Lock it in

I’m more confident about this now than I was at the start of the season. Broberg missed 12 games with an injury, but when in the lineup, he’s been arguably the Blues’ best defenseman. Likewise, Holloway has perhaps been their most versatile productive forward. There may not be an identical situation where two talented players are available on a team — in this case the Oilers — that can’t afford to match an offer sheet. But with the way Broberg and Holloway are playing, the vultures will be out. — Jeremy Rutherford

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

How this summer’s stunning offer-sheet saga has worked out for Oilers and Blues

Preseason bold prediction: Andrei Vasilevskiy will be a Vezina Trophy finalist

Outlook: It’s a long shot

Vasilevskiy may have more two-way support this season, but he isn’t in the Vezina Trophy race right now. That’s a conversation led by the likes of Connor Hellebuyck, Lukas Dostal and Filip Gustavsson. Vasilevskiy is having a fine season so far — he has saved 3.97 goals above expected through 20 games while earning a .909 save percentage — but those numbers aren’t sparkling like some of the league’s best or even his peak years. The season isn’t over yet and he tends to heat up as the pressure rises, but he has a lot of ground to make up. — Shayna Goldman

Preseason bold prediction: Mitch Marner will score 40 goals

Outlook: Still in play

Marner had one goal in October. Then, a heater shooting the puck in November. He had eight goals in 12 games. Marner is still off the 40-goal pace though. He appears headed more for his third 30-goal season than his first 40-goal campaign. If head coach Craig Berube gets his way though and Marner starts shooting the puck more aggressively, there’s still a chance Marner comes close to or even hits 40 goals. During the back half of the 2021-22 season, Marner shot the puck more aggressively than ever and punched in 29 goals during a 46-game stretch. That’s what he’ll need the rest of the way to hit 40. — Jonas Siegel

Utah Hockey Club

Preseason bold prediction: Utah will finish as one of the NHL’s highest-scoring teams

Outlook: Not happening

Did anyone here whiff as much as this prediction? Other than an early flurry to start the season, Utah has struggled mightily to score this season, sitting 23rd in goals per game and 24th on the power play through Thursday. A lot of the Hockey Clubbers’ young talent has failed to break through, with Logan Cooley on pace for fewer than 20 goals and a lot of their 20-goal producers from last season coming up well short of those projections in the early going. Connor Ingram’s struggles in goal and injuries on defense have hurt their record, but regressing offensively to this extent is the bigger surprise given the cast up front. — James Mirtle

Preseason bold prediction: Elias Pettersson will bounce back and lead the team in scoring

Outlook: Still in play

It certainly hasn’t been an out-of-the-gate, no-doubt-about-it, he’s-back-like-John-Wick level bounce back for Pettersson this season, but the star Canucks center has found his form of late. He’s back to controlling play and still has a chance to lead all Vancouver players in scoring. Through Thursday, he ranked first in points and points per game among Canucks forwards, but what I didn’t expect was Quinn Hughes to hit even another level of preposterous form this season. Through Thursday, Hughes was holding a six-point lead over Pettersson in the point production department this season, so Pettersson still has some catching up to do. — Thomas Drance

Preseason bold prediction: Pavel Dorofeyev will finish second on the team in goals

Outlook: Still in play

The hope with this prediction was that Dorofeyev would take advantage of a bigger opportunity than he’s had to this point in his career, and that’s exactly what has happened through two months. Through Thursday, Dorofeyev was second on the Golden Knights with 12 goals, only one behind team leader Ivan Barbashev. He has contributed both at even strength and on the top power-play unit, and has been an integral part of Vegas’ seventh-ranked offense. — Jesse Granger

Preseason bold prediction: The Pierre-Luc Dubois deal will pay off

Outlook: Still in play

There’s plenty of road left before I can do a victory lap, but I feel good about predicting good things for Dubois. Is he playing to a 70-point pace, as I said he would? Not quite. Has he been a major catalyst for the Caps’ early-season success? Absolutely. He’s crushing most of his minutes as the 2C, which allowed Washington to set up favorable matchups for Alex Ovechkin’s line, and has helped Connor McMichael get off to a scorching start. So far, so good. — Sean Gentille

Preseason bold prediction: Nikolaj Ehlers will play out the season and then walk as a UFA

Outlook: Still in play

Ehlers is a point-per-game player now, mostly because he’s been every bit as good on the top power play as advertised: helpful on entries, good in the high slot, creative with options in the zone. He’s also hurt, nursing a lower-body injury suffered against Vegas on Nov. 29. It’s difficult to say what any of this means for his future, though. I believe the “self-rental” option is still on the table for Winnipeg. If recent call-up Brad Lambert bursts offensively, Ehlers could become a trade chip. (For the right return, it might not take that Lambert burst.) An extension does not appear to be a front-burner, midseason option, but must also be considered a possibility. — Murat Ates

(Top photo of Red Wings center Dylan Larkin celebrating after scoring a goal: Brian Bradshaw Sevald / Imagn Images)

Lewis Hamilton’s final F1 lap with Mercedes: A year of challenges, a decade of triumphs

ABU DHABI, United Arab Emirates — Atop the Mercedes hospitality unit at the Yas Marina Circuit in Abu Dhabi, cooled by nearby fans working hard in the midday heat, Lewis Hamilton sat at a table with his race engineer, Peter Bonnington, for some pre-race weekend planning.

It was a routine they’d been through plenty of times before — 245 times, in fact — but the 246th time carried a little more emotion. After 12 years, 84 race wins and six world championships, marking it the most successful driver-team partnership in F1 history, this was the last race weekend for Hamilton as a Mercedes driver.

Hamilton’s conversations with Bonnington, affectionately known as ‘Bono’ and someone Hamilton has likened to a brother, remained as professional as ever. They knew there was a job to do. But speaking a few hours later, the seven-time world champion admitted these chats involved an extra degree of emotion.

“You’re sitting there, and you’re realizing these are the last moments with the team, which is … it’s hard to describe the feeling,” Hamilton said. “It’s not the greatest, of course, but I think mostly I’m just really proud of what we’ve achieved.”

The ‘last dance’ for Lewis Hamilton and Mercedes has been ten months in the making. On Feb. 1, Hamilton announced he would move to Ferrari for 2025, securing the 39-year-old a last blast in F1’s iconic red cars to end his glittering career. Abu Dhabi was always going to be a significant grand prix.

But at the end of a taxing year on the track, filled with the highs of victory at Silverstone and Spa to the late-season lows, both Hamilton and Mercedes are committed to ending with a celebration.

“It’s a really beautiful journey you go on together,” Hamilton said. “And being that it was so long, the emotions run so deep.”


Toto Wolff, the Mercedes team principal, had an inkling of what was coming when Hamilton arrived at his Oxfordshire home for their pre-season catch-up.

Fred Vasseur, Ferrari’s F1 chief and a close friend of Wolff’s, hadn’t replied to a text asking if he was “taking our driver,” and the father of Carlos Sainz, who Hamilton would replace, had tipped off the Mercedes boss that something might be happening.

Looking back on Thursday, Hamilton admitted to it being an “awkward” meeting with Wolff to break the news that their partnership would end. Only eight months earlier, they’d agreed on a contract extension that appeared to reaffirm their commitment, one Hamilton had previously envisaged lasting long beyond his time racing in F1 was over. Their joint work on campaigns to assist long overdue change concerning diversity and equality in F1 is a legacy that means more to Hamilton than his racing achievements.

It also made for a year he admitted that he “massively underestimated” from an emotional point of view. “It was straining on the relationship very early on; (it) took time for people to get past it,” Hamilton admitted. “And then just for my own self, it’s been a very emotional year for me. And I think I’ve not been at my best in handling and dealing with those emotions.”


Lewis Hamilton and Toto Wolff talk on the grid at Lusail International Circuit on Nov. 30, 2024. (James Sutton – Formula 1/Formula 1 via Getty Images)

Hamilton has always worn his heart on his sleeve, evidenced by the tears that flowed after ending his two-and-a-half-year win drought at Silverstone. The intimacy of his relationship with Mercedes permits a brutal honesty that has survived significant disappointments — like his 2016 title loss to teammate Nico Rosberg or, more controversially, what happened in Abu Dhabi three years ago when he missed out on a record eighth world title.

Wolff has always liked to prod at any open wounds, knowing that is often the only way to understand how to make a situation better. He felt that Hamilton and Mercedes had “done a good job” handling the emotions of this year.

“When he took the decision at the beginning of the season to go, we knew it could be a bumpy year ahead,” Wolff said in Qatar. “He knows he’s going to go somewhere else. We know our future lies with Kimi (Antonelli). To go through the ups and downs and still keep it together between us, that is something we have achieved.”

go-deeper

“I’m just slow.”

For these words to be uttered by a seven-time world champion might seem fanciful. But there was a degree of resignation as Hamilton digested a difficult Friday of practice for the Qatar Grand Prix, where he couldn’t feel the car giving him back the kind of performance he needed. It continued a season-long trend.

For much of the year, the Mercedes W15 car hadn’t gelled to his driving style or allowed him to extract the kind of pace that he’d needed, particularly over a single lap. Through 23 races this season, Hamilton trails George Russell 18-5 in their qualifying head-to-head and is 24 points behind in the drivers’ standings.

The day after Hamilton made that comment, when he’d qualified sixth in Qatar while Russell was P2 and almost half a second quicker, he was asked to expand on it. Did he really mean that he’s lost the edge? Is this a sign of the decline most elite drivers and sports stars encounter as they near their forties?

“I know I’ve still got it,” Hamilton said. “(It’s) just the car won’t go a bit faster. I definitely know I’ve got it still. It’s not a question in my mind. (I’m) looking forward to the end.”


Lewis Hamilton enters his final race with Mercedes seventh in the drivers’ championship. (Mark Thompson/Getty Images)

It wasn’t the first time Hamilton had given such a bleak outlook. After the race in Brazil, where he’d lagged to 10th in rainy conditions while Russell had been in the mix for victory prior to the red flag, he admitted he “could happily go and take a holiday” instead of doing the final triple-header. In Las Vegas, when the W15 came alive in the cold and allowed Mercedes to sweep to a 1-2, Hamilton seemed downbeat that he’d not been the one to lead it home after qualifying down in P10 while Russell was on pole.

“These last races, maybe even the whole season, was clearly not what we expected,” Wolff said in Qatar. “That car is a handful to drive on its worst days.”

But how much of that has hurt Hamilton in a way that it has not for Russell? Wolff put part of it down to Hamilton’s driving style. “One of his strengths is how he’s always able to brake late and attack the corner, and the car can’t take it,” he said, adding that when the grip kicks in the slow-speed corners, the problem worsens. “Then if the car slides more and it lacks grip, that contributes to (him) probably suffering more than George.”

In Qatar, Vasseur said he was “not at all” concerned by the form of his incoming star signee. “Have a look on the 50 laps that he did in Vegas, starting P10 (and) finishing on the gearbox of Russell,” Vasseur said. “I’m not worried at all.”

The progress made by Ferrari this year, recovering from its mid-season slump to put up a late fight to McLaren for the constructors’ title, will also encourage Hamilton that he can rekindle more of his old form. He stressed on Thursday that while his focus remains on Mercedes for his final weekend, there was a natural excitement building about the next chapter.

“It really sparks motivation,” Hamilton said, “and it’s a dream scenario for any driver to have an opportunity like this. I don’t take that for granted.”

go-deeper

Whenever Hamilton hangs up his helmet and calls time on his enormously successful career, this period with Mercedes will be the lasting, most definitive part of his racing legacy.

When he decided in 2012 to make a shock move away from McLaren, then consistently one of F1’s leading teams, it was scoffed at as a mistake: a step into the midfield, away from the team that had brought Hamilton up to F1, and into the unknown.

It proved to be the right move at the right time. McLaren was about to start a decade-long decline, while Mercedes was on the verge of starting a record-breaking F1 dynasty with Hamilton as the centerpiece.

The move also allowed Hamilton to become himself. His evolution from a 27-year-old one-time champion into one of F1’s elder statesmen, on the cusp of his 40th birthday with seven world titles to his name, with interests and a celebrity status stretching far beyond this paddock, has been impressive.


Mercedes’ British driver Lewis Hamilton sits on his car, posing for a group photo with his team ahead of the Abu Dhabi GP. (Andrej ISAKOVIC / AFP)

On the entrance to Mercedes’ garage for this weekend at the Yas Marina Circuit are two large pictures of Hamilton, one from Hungary 2013 — his first win for Mercedes — and the second from Silverstone this year, arguably the most emotional of his record 104 victories. Across it reads the message: “Every dream needs a team.”

Even the challenges of this year and the difficulty of a year-long goodbye will not diminish what Hamilton and Mercedes built together.

“Nothing is going to take away 12 incredible years with eight constructors’ and six drivers’ championships,” Wolff said. “That is what will be the memory, and after next Sunday, we’re going to look back on this great period of time rather than a season or races that were particularly bad.

“We will stay with the good memories.”

Good memories. Historic memories. So heavy in emotion that, when the checkered flag drops for Hamilton on Sunday night and he hoists himself out of a Mercedes F1 car for the final time, they will surely come flooding back.

go-deeper

Top photo: Chris Graythen/Getty Images, Clive Rose/Getty Images; Design: Meech Robinson/The Athletic

QB future for all 32 NFL teams: Russell Wilson, Aaron Rodgers and other intriguing questions

Russell Wilson playing for a new contract with the Pittsburgh Steelers ranks among the top quarterback storylines heading into the 2024 NFL season’s final weeks. There are many others of interest, which makes this a good time to check in on all 32 quarterback situations.

As I usually do this time of year, I’ve grouped all 32 quarterbacks into buckets based on how their teams should feel about them, from “Committed Without Reservation” at one end to “We’re Looking For A Way Out” at the other.

The New York Giants’ current starter (Drew Lock) is not listed, but their former one (Daniel Jones) does appear. I’ve included contract duration and salary rank, along with where each ranks in EPA per pass play among the 40 quarterbacks with at least 100 pass attempts this season.

1. Committed Without Reservation

We have top-five QBs in their primes, signed to long-term contracts.

Patrick Mahomes, Kansas City Chiefs

Signed thru: 2031 | APY Rank: 12 | QB EPA Rank: 10/40

There’s been an interesting statistical tradeoff for Mahomes in recent weeks. After tossing eight touchdown passes with nine interceptions in the first seven games, the TD-INT ratio has flipped to 11-2 in five subsequent games. His sack rate has also jumped from 5.1 percent to 9.0 percent, while his rate of passes gaining more than 15 yards has dropped. Not that any of these things affect how the Chiefs feel about their quarterback, who leads the league in fourth-quarter comebacks (four) and game-winning drives (six), per Pro Football Reference.

Josh Allen, Buffalo Bills

Signed thru: 2028 | APY Rank: 14 | QB EPA Rank: 4/40

Allen has become the betting favorite for MVP honors in recent weeks and is everything the Bills hoped they were getting when they traded up to draft him in 2018. His sack rate has fallen and his explosive pass rate has risen across all three offensive coordinators during his seven seasons.

GO DEEPER

Josh Allen, Saquon Barkley, Lamar Jackson and a sizzling MVP race: Sando’s Pick Six

Lamar Jackson, Baltimore Ravens

Signed thru: 2027 | APY Rank: 8 | QB EPA Rank: 1/40

The Ravens are winning the big bet they made on Jackson when they signed him to an extension before the 2023 season. Jackson’s production, in decline before he signed the deal, has reached new highs. He has 41 more total touchdowns than turnovers since signing the deal, tied with Allen for the best differential in the league. Jackson ranked 21st (+13) across the 2021-22 seasons.

Joe Burrow, Cincinnati Bengals

Signed thru: 2029 | APY Rank: 4 | QB EPA Rank: 6/40

Burrow passed for 820 yards with nine touchdowns and one interception in 41-38 and 35-34 defeats to Baltimore this season, capturing the essence of this Bengals season. Cincinnati ranks fifth in offensive EPA per play but only 30th on the defensive side. That is the largest differential between offensive and defensive rankings through Week 13. The other teams with similar disparities include the 8-5 Ravens (-24), 8-5 Commanders (-24) and 6-6 Buccaneers (-23).

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

QB Betrayal Index: Lamar Jackson acing his toughest test; Justin Herbert finally gets a break

Justin Herbert, Los Angeles Chargers

Signed thru: 2029 | APY Rank: 7 | QB EPA Rank: 21/40

Herbert was fifth in Quarterback Tiers voting before the 2023 and 2024 seasons despite slipping from Tier 1 to Tier 2 entering 2024. He’s throwing fewer passes and taking more sacks for a team that is winning on defense. It’s difficult to imagine coach Jim Harbaugh straying too far from his run-heavy philosophy.

2. Committed And Hoping The Sky Is The Limit

We think our young QBs can become stars (and there’s some evidence to prove we are right).

Jordan Love, Green Bay Packers

Signed thru: 2028 | APY Rank: 3 | QB EPA Rank: 13/40

Comparing Love to predecessor Aaron Rodgers would seem unfair if Love weren’t starting his career with similar production.

Rodgers through 27 starts: 64 percent completions, 7.8 yards per attempt, 50 touchdown passes, 18 interceptions

Love through 27 starts: 63 percent completions, 7.4 yards per attempt, 51 touchdown passes, 23 interceptions

The main differences: Rodgers added more EPA on scrambles and lost more EPA on sacks, while Love has lost more on interceptions.

C.J. Stroud, Houston Texans

Signed thru: 2026 (not counting fifth-year option) | APY Rank: 26 | QB EPA Rank: 25/40

To what degree does Stroud’s decline in production from his rookie season reflect a weakened offensive line and injuries at receiver?

That will be a key question heading into next season for the 2023 Offensive Rookie of the Year.

3. Committed And Content

We have veteran quarterbacks signed for the long term and are happy with the situation.

Jared Goff, Detroit Lions

Signed thru: 2028 | APY Rank: 6 | QB EPA Rank: 3/40

Goff is proving to be a great good-team quarterback.

Now in his fourth season with Detroit, Goff is replicating his 2018 Super Bowl season with the Rams through 12 games, except he’s throwing the ball less frequently and throwing it shorter, which means a higher completion rate and fewer explosive gains.

Everything else is about the same: the won-lost record (11-1 both years), the passer rating (109.9 then, 109.0 now) and the elevated yards per attempt (9.1 then, 8.8 now).

Jalen Hurts, Philadelphia Eagles

Signed thru: 2028 | APY Rank: 9 | QB EPA Rank: 12/40

The Eagles are 31-4 through the first 12 games of the past three seasons with Hurts in the lineup. The big difference this season is how much more Philadelphia is leaning on its defense and ground game, led by Saquon Barkley.

Hurts, in his first season with offensive coordinator Kellen Moore, has attempted 304 passes during the 10-2 start this season, down from 403 during the team’s 10-2 start last season. That’s a drop from 33.5 attempts per game to 25.3 per game.

Kyler Murray, Arizona Cardinals

Signed thru: 2028 | APY Rank: 10 | QB EPA Rank: 14/40

Murray seems to have matured and is no longer defined by the “homework clause” Arizona put into (and later removed from) the contract extension he signed in July 2022.

After missing parts of the past two seasons with a torn ACL, he has started the first 12 games of a season for the first time since 2020, his second year in the league.

One big difference from then to now: He averaged a career-high 7.6 rushes and scrambles per game then, compared to a career-low 3.9 this season. While he leads the league in ESPN’s Total QBR metric, teams are blitzing Murray much more effectively than in recent seasons.

Dak Prescott, Dallas Cowboys

Signed thru: 2028 | APY Rank: 1 | QB EPA Rank: 28/40

The Cowboys have had a winning record six times in seven seasons when Prescott started at least half the games and never had a losing season (they were 8-8 in 2019). But the team fell off in 2024, Prescott suffered a season-ending hamstring injury and his new contract is set to count $89 million against the cap in 2025 — his age-32 season — making the future look murkier.

Baker Mayfield, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Signed thru: 2026 | APY Rank: 18 | QB EPA Rank: 11/40

Mayfield has found a home in Tampa and is providing a solid return on the Buccaneers’ three-year, $100 million investment in him. Since joining Tampa Bay last season, he ranks 10th in EPA per pass play and is tied with the Ravens’ Jackson for the league lead in touchdown passes (53).

The Buccaneers have a mediocre record this season (6-6) because the defense ranks 29th in EPA per play. Mayfield has posted career-high totals through 12 games for passing yards (3,034), passing touchdowns (25), passer rating (101.3) and EPA per pass play (0.11). He’s done it for an offense that ranks fifth in points per game (27.2) and sixth in EPA per play.

4. Committed And Content, With No Guarantees

We like our QBs and have them signed beyond this season to deals containing little or no more guaranteed money. This gives us more flexibility to consider our options.

Matthew Stafford, Los Angeles Rams

Signed thru: 2026 | APY Rank: 15 | QB EPA Rank: 17/40

When Stafford sought a new contract last offseason, the Rams gave him $40 million fully guaranteed, with only $4 million in guarantees after this season. That gives the team greater flexibility to move on from Stafford if some combination of age/injury/performance leads the Rams to consider other options. Stafford remains the best option now. His three game-winning drives are his most since having four in 2021.

Geno Smith, Seattle Seahawks

Signed thru: 2025 | APY Rank: 19 | QB EPA Rank: 23/40

The way this Seahawks season has played out under new offensive coordinator Ryan Grubb, with the team skewing heavily toward the pass and Kenneth Walker III ranking 30th among running backs in rush yards, the focus could fall more on the overall approach than it falls on the person taking snaps from center.

Whatever the case, Smith remains under contract for 2025 under terms favorable to the team, as his $24.8 million in compensation is not guaranteed. That gives the Seahawks flexibility if they decide to consider other options.

Smith had 30 touchdown passes with 11 interceptions in his first season as the Seahawks’ starter (2022). He has 13 and 12, respectively, for an offense that has struggled to find consistency so far this season.

5. Committed With Concerns

We signed our QB to an expensive long-term extension but can’t feel great about it, for different reasons.

Tua Tagovailoa, Miami Dolphins

Signed thru: 2028 | APY Rank: 5 | QB EPA Rank: 2/40

The Dolphins struggled to function when Tagovailoa was not available to them, pushing back against perceptions that the quarterback was mostly a product of coach Mike McDaniel’s scheme and the team’s elite weaponry.

The team has averaged 0.09 EPA per play on offense with Tagovailoa, compared with -0.32 per play without him. That is the difference between being a top-five offense this season and being more than twice as bad as the last-ranked one (Cleveland at -0.15).

Tagovailoa and the Dolphins paid a heavy price for learning more about the quarterback’s value. The concussion he suffered against Buffalo in Week 2 spurred another round of questions about his long-term health and viability as a quarterback.

Trevor Lawrence, Jacksonville Jaguars

Signed thru: 2030 | APY Rank: 2 | QB EPA Rank: 27/40

There’s little evidence Lawrence can overcome tough situations, or that the Jaguars can help him enough to ensure success, but the team still entered into a $275 million extension with him before the season, when there was no looming deadline to do so.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

The Jaguars overestimated themselves. Did they overestimate Trevor Lawrence, too?

Here’s where Lawrence ranks in EPA per pass play: 25th since 2021, 20th since 2022, 25th since 2023 and 24th this season. He’ll likely remain among the top five in average annual salary for years to come. Can he close the gap?

6. Committed Until No Longer Committed

Our veteran starters could be on the way out, for different reasons.

Derek Carr, New Orleans Saints

Signed thru: 2026 | APY Rank: 16 | QB EPA Rank: 9/40

The Saints’ next coach will likely help decide what course the team follows at quarterback after this season. Releasing Carr could be difficult given the team’s salary-cap situation, but all options would seem to be on the table as the club sets a new course. Designating him a post-June 1 release would make the most sense if the Saints decide to cut ties.

Kirk Cousins, Atlanta Falcons

Signed thru: 2027 | APY Rank: 13 | QB EPA Rank: 16/40

Cousins could be running out of chances to reverse a recent slide in production. How long before first-round rookie Michael Penix Jr. becomes the best option? It seems fitting that this career crossroads has Cousins returning to Minnesota against his former team in Week 14. Here’s hoping Vikings coach Kevin O’Connell is miked up during pregame, at least.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Falcons sticking with, and standing up for, Kirk Cousins after ugly day in Atlanta


How long before Penix takes over from Cousins as the Falcons’ starter? (Kevin Sabitus / Associated Press)

Aaron Rodgers, New York Jets

Signed thru: 2025 | APY Rank: 17 | QB EPA Rank: 29/40

Rodgers’ contract has a $35 million option for 2025. It’s difficult to see the Jets exercising it when a franchise refresh seems appropriate and Rodgers, who just turned 41, has lost athleticism.

As disappointing as this Jets season has been from a quarterback standpoint, this might be worse: The team’s 88.2 passer rating is its second-best through 12 games since 2008.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Jets owner Johnson suggested benching Aaron Rodgers in September: Sources

7. Committed, But At What Value?

Our QB has earned an extension, but recent events have raised questions about the price.

Brock Purdy, San Francisco 49ers

Signed thru: 2025 | APY Rank: 84 | QB EPA Rank: 7/40

Purdy, with less than $3 million in career earnings, has a $1.1 million salary in 2024. He’s been the NFL’s biggest bargain over the past two-plus seasons and should be in line for a big raise, but how big?

Six weeks ago, the conversation revolved around whether Purdy might cash in for $60 million per year. But as the season slips away and some of Purdy’s physical limitations surface, could the 49ers decide to wait? Could they pursue more of a compromise deal, in the spirit of what Green Bay did with Love in 2023? There’s time to figure out something.

8. Lots to Play For Down The Stretch With Contract Talks Ahead

The veteran we signed on the cheap will command an extension if this keeps up.

Russell Wilson, Pittsburgh Steelers

Signed thru: 2024 | APY Rank: 63 | QB EPA Rank: 8/40

The one-year, $1.2 million deal Wilson signed with the Steelers (while still collecting $37.8 million from Denver on his previous deal) ranks as the biggest bargain in the league this season.

Wilson’s passing production in six starts projects to 4,706 yards with 28 touchdowns and nine interceptions over a 17-game schedule. The final five games deliver some difficult defenses, but with the Steelers all but assured a playoff berth, Wilson has a great opportunity to make Pittsburgh his longer-term home.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Russell Wilson and the Steelers offense’s sensational day (and the immense implications)

9. Evaluating: Long Runways

Our first-round rookies are just getting started.

Jayden Daniels, Washington Commanders

Signed thru: 2027 (not counting fifth-year option) | APY Rank: 24 | QB EPA Rank: 5/40

This season has showcased Daniels’ dual-threat prowess along with some preexisting durability concerns, but Washington must be very happy with its selection of Daniels overall. His EPA per pass play ranks fifth through 13 starts among all rookies since 2000, per TruMedia. Matt Ryan, Robert Griffin III, Ben Roethlisberger and Prescott rank higher. Wilson, Herbert and Stroud rank sixth through eighth, respectively. That is good company for Daniels.

Caleb Williams, Chicago Bears

Signed thru: 2027 (not counting fifth-year option) | APY Rank: 22 | QB EPA Rank: 30/40

Williams has gone from ranking among the bottom 10 in EPA per pass play under former coordinator Shane Waldron to ranking among the top 10 after three games with Thomas Brown in the role. Whether that is sustainable, the uptick has been encouraging for the No. 1 pick in the 2024 draft. Who will be coaching Williams for the long term?

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

The Bears need to hire the right head coach this time. 5 tips for their search

Bo Nix, Denver Broncos

Signed thru: 2027 (not counting fifth-year option) | APY Rank: 39 | QB EPA Rank: 26/40

Nix has feasted on the AFC West and NFC South, combining for 15 touchdown passes with one interception in eight games, including six Denver victories. He ranks among the top 10 in a range of passing categories, including EPA per pass play, since Week 8.

Drake Maye, New England Patriots

Signed thru: 2027 (not counting fifth-year option) | APY Rank: 25 | QB EPA Rank: 22/40

Maye has less around him than the other first-round rookie quarterbacks, one reason the Patriots were reluctant to start him right away. He has arguably outperformed expectations given that context, shifting the focus away from him and onto what New England must do to help him in the coming offseason.

10. Evaluating: Clock Is Ticking

We haven’t given up on the 2023 first-round picks we benched, but there’s some urgency.

Bryce Young, Carolina Panthers

Benched after only two games this season, Young has played well enough in five games since his return to renew hope for his future. The Panthers are 2-3 and averaging 21.4 offensive points per game since Young’s return. They had a 2-16 record while averaging 11.2 points per game on offense in his previous 18 starts.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

NFL QB stock report, Week 14: Insight into Bryce Young’s revival; Kirk Cousins still Falcons’ QB1?

Signed thru: 2026 (not counting fifth-year option) | APY Rank: 23 | QB EPA Rank: 34/40

Anthony Richardson, Indianapolis Colts

Signed thru: 2026 (not counting fifth-year option) | APY Rank: 29 | QB EPA Rank: 31/40

The Colts were much worse on offense during the two games Joe Flacco started than they were previously or since Richardson returned to the lineup for the past three games. Richardson remains a low-percentage passer capable of the spectacular but is still seeking consistency. How patient will the Colts be in developing him?

11. Evaluating: Need An Alternative

Our young QB could play his way into a future with us, but it’s looking like we’ll be in the market for an upgrade.

Will Levis, Tennessee Titans

Signed thru: 2026 | APY Rank: 53 | QB EPA Rank: 35/40

The Titans’ current coaching staff inherited Levis and could keep him but presumably would not want to bet its future on him, given the returns so far. Can Levis finish strong?

Aidan O’Connell, Las Vegas Raiders

Signed thru: 2026 | APY Rank: 71 | QB EPA Rank: 15/40

The Raiders had O’Connell on their roster entering this season and preferred signing Gardner Minshew for $12.5 million per year. Can O’Connell play his way into their future plans over the remaining five games? His 340-yard game at Kansas City was a start.

12. Thank You For Your Service (And The Future Comp Pick)

We’re grateful for our QB but committed to a different one.

Sam Darnold, Minnesota Vikings

Signed thru: 2024 | APY Rank: 21 | QB EPA Rank: 19/40

The assumption here is that Darnold has played well enough to earn an opportunity greater than what the Vikings can promise him in 2025, when first-round pick J.J. McCarthy returns from knee surgery to presumably claim the starting job.

13. Likely Headed to Free Agency as a Bridge Starter/Backup

There will be a market for these veterans, but not necessarily as the undisputed starter.

Jameis Winston, Cleveland Browns

Signed thru: 2024 | APY Rank: 42 | QB EPA Rank: 20/40

The Browns are averaging 21.8 offensive points per game when Winston starts after averaging 13.4 when Deshaun Watson was in the lineup earlier in the season. Their rate of explosive pass plays has more than doubled from 8.4 percent with Watson to 17.8 percent with Winston.

It’s possible the Browns or another team will project Winston as a starter next season. The two pick sixes Winston threw against Denver on Monday night tempered some of the recent enthusiasm.

Daniel Jones, Minnesota Vikings

Signed thru: 2024 | APY Rank: 90 | QB EPA Rank: 32/40

Jones could fill the Darnold role for the Vikings next season if Darnold finds a better opportunity elsewhere. He could also test the market, although additional time with O’Connell in Minnesota could be good for his career longer term.

14. We’re Looking For A Way Out

Help! Our quarterback could not start for any team, but we owe him more than $90 million over the next two seasons.

Deshaun Watson, Cleveland Browns

Signed thru: 2026 | APY Rank: 11 | QB EPA Rank: 40/40

The worst contract in NFL history isn’t getting better soon enough for the Browns. Watson, out for the season with a torn Achilles tendon, is scheduled to count $72.9 million against the cap in each of the next two seasons. Those figures could be manipulated in various ways, but Watson is getting his money regardless, unless he violates the contract in some way.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Deshaun Watson and a Browns escape plan (once they finally admit it’s over): Sando’s Pick Six

(Top photo of Russell Wilson, left, and Aaron Rodgers: Joe Sargent / Getty Images)

The Football 100

The Football 100

The story of the greatest players in NFL history. In 100 riveting profiles, top football writers justify their selections and uncover the history of the NFL in the process.

The story of the greatest players in NFL history.

BuyBuy The Football 100

Club World Cup team guide: Inter to Chelsea to Auckland City, all 32 profiled

The 2025 Club World Cup will feature 32 clubs from across the globe who will go through group stages and then knockout rounds. This differs from the previous format, which saw one team each from six continental confederations and the league champions from the host nation fight it out.

There have been concerns over the tournament elongating the football calendar and controversy over qualification criteria. Inter Miami, for example, are in after winning the 2024 MLS Supporters’ Shield, but having lost in the subsequent MLS play-offs, Lionel Messi’s side are not MLS champions.

Several high-profile teams, including Liverpool, Arsenal, Barcelona, and Bayer Leverkusen will not be there, but the likes of Manchester City, Inter and Real Madrid will be. A full explanation of the qualification criteria and how to watch the draw can be found here. The draw takes place in Miami today at 1pm ET (6pm GMT).

Below, The Athletic profiles each of the 32 teams, ranked by their position in the Opta Global Power Rankings (all data in this piece is correct as of December 3, 2024). You can find a table with the 32 clubs and their world rankings at the bottom of this article.

GO DEEPER

Club World Cup 2025: Who is competing and how to watch the draw


Inter

Country: Italy

Confederation: UEFA

Global Power Ranking: 2

Opta Serie A Ranking: 1

How they qualified: UEFA Ranking between 2021 and 2024

Inter’s only Club World Cup appearance came in 2011. They beat TP Mazembe 3-0 in the final. They got there after achieving the treble in 2010 under Jose Mourinho, winning Serie A, the Coppa Italia and the Champions League. They also achieved another treble back in 1965, lifting the now-defunct Intercontinental Cup, league title and European Cup.

Key Player: Lautaro Martinez

Since joining from Racing Club in 2018, Martinez has scored 135 times in 298 matches, leading Inter to seven domestic trophies and winning the 2023-24 Serie A golden boot.


Inter are Serie A champions (Gabriel Bouys/AFP via Getty Images)

Manchester City

Country: England

Confederation: UEFA

Global Power Ranking: 3

Opta Premier League Ranking: 2

How they qualified: 2022-23 Champions League winners

City won the 2023 Club World Cup by defeating Fluminense 4-0 in their tournament debut. The Premier League’s defending champions have been one of the world’s best teams over the past 15 years. They were the first English team to win a domestic and European cup in the same season back in 1970 when they lifted the European Cup Winners’ Cup and League Cup.

Key Player: Erling Haaland

City evidently struggle without Rodri, but with him injured, Haaland is their key player. The Norway international has 107 goals in 117 appearances for the club. Even in what has been a difficult 2024-25 season, he has 17 strikes in 19 games.

Real Madrid

Country: Spain

Confederation: UEFA

Global Power Ranking: 5

Opta La Liga Ranking: 1

How they qualified: 2023-24 Champions League winners

Real Madrid have won the most Club World Cup titles (five). In addition to being the only team to have won the Champions League thrice in a row two times, Madrid are also the only Spanish team to have played their own academy team in a cup final, doing so in the 1980 Copa del Rey.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

When Real Madrid played their own reserve team in the Copa del Rey final

Key Player: Vinicius Junior

Since the start of the 2021-22 season, Vinicius Jr has recorded 81 goals and 60 assists in 154 matches, averaging 0.9 goal contributions per game.


Vinicius Junior, left, celebrates with Brahim Diaz (Gonzalo Arroyo Moreno/Getty Images)

Country: Germany

Confederation: UEFA

Global Power Ranking: 8

Opta Bundesliga Ranking: 1

How they qualified: UEFA Ranking between 2021 and 2024

Bayern have won two Club World Cups, both of which followed treble-winning campaigns in 2012-13 and 2019-20 — a feat matched only by Barcelona. The connection between the two teams is extensive. In addition to meeting 16 times in European competitions, they were founded just 91 days apart — Barcelona on November 28, 1899, and Bayern on February 27, 1900.

Key Player: Harry Kane

In November, Kane became the fastest player to reach 50 Bundesliga goals, taking just 43 matches. Overall, his record at Bayern stands at 64 goals and 21 assists in 64 matches.

Paris Saint-Germain

Country: France

Confederation: UEFA

Global Power Ranking: 9

Opta Ligue 1 Ranking: 1

How they qualified: UEFA Ranking between 2021 and 2024

Next summer will mark PSG’s first appearance in the Club World Cup. PSG have played in three finals on the European stage (1996-97 Cup Winners’ Cup and Super Cup, and 2019-20 Champions League), but have lost them all. Among the UEFA clubs in the 2025 edition, PSG are the youngest, having been founded in 1970.

Key Player: Bradley Barcola

Barcola has more than doubled his Ligue 1 goal tally from last season (four) in just 13 matches, scoring 10 times. No PSG forward has played more minutes than his 1,301 across competitions this season.


Barcola has impressed for PSG this season (Franck Fife/AFP via Getty Images)

Country: England

Confederation: UEFA

Global Power Ranking: 10

Opta Premier League Ranking: 4

How they qualified: 2020-21 Champions League winners

Chelsea won the 2021 Club World Cup after beating Palmeiras 2-1 after extra time. However, among the European teams set to feature in the 2025 edition, they are one of only two teams to have lost a Club World Cup final (Real Madrid being the other), after losing 1-0 to Corinthians in 2012. Chelsea are the only team to have won the Champions League, Europa League, Super Cup, and the now-defunct Cup Winners’ Cup twice.

Key Player: Cole Palmer

Palmer has contributed to 54 goals in 60 matches across all competitions for Chelsea and is currently on a contract until 2033.

Country: Italy

Confederation: UEFA

Global Power Ranking: 13

Opta Serie A Ranking: 3

How they qualified: UEFA Ranking between 2021 and 2024

Juventus have never participated in the Club World Cup, though they have lifted the Champions League twice and Europa League/UEFA Cup three times. They also enjoyed success in the Cup Winners’ Cup (1983-84) and Intercontinental Cup (twice). Juventus were the first club to add a star to their jersey back in 1958 to commemorate their 10th Serie A title. They now boast three stars and are just four away from being eligible to add a fourth.

Key Player: Andrea Cambiaso

Cambiaso has played all of Juventus’ first 19 games this season, racking up the most minutes with 1,567 across competitions. He has contributed two goals and two assists.

Atletico Madrid

Country: Spain

Confederation: UEFA

Global Power Ranking: 14

Opta La Liga Ranking: 3

How they qualified: UEFA Ranking between 2021 and 2024

Atletico Madrid will be competing in the Club World Cup for the first time, having never won the Champions League. They are among the five teams to have won the Europa League/UEFA Cup three or more times, though. While rivals of Real Madrid, Atletico were formed in 1903 as a Madrid branch of Athletic Club by three students from the Basque region, which is why both teams wear red and white stripes.

Key Player: Antoine Griezmann

Griezmann was not at Atletico when they won their two most recent La Liga titles, but he is their all-time top scorer with 188 goals in 410 matches across three spells (2014-19, 2021-23 on loan, and 2023-present).


Griezmann is Atletico’s all-time top scorer (Octavio Passos/Getty Images)

Country: Germany

Confederation: UEFA

Global Power Ranking: 20

Opta Bundesliga Ranking: 3

How they qualified: UEFA Ranking between 2021 and 2024

This will be Dortmund’s first appearance at the Club World Cup, but they won the Intercontinental Cup in 1997 following their Champions League triumph earlier that year. Before that, Dortmund were the first German team to win a European trophy after lifting the Cup Winners’ Cup in 1966.

Key Player: Karim Adeyemi

Adeyemi has struggled to stay fit, but his five goals and five assists in eight matches across competitions have come in just 510 minutes of action. He is on track to eclipse his best season at Dortmund (nine goals, six assists in 32 matches in 2022-23).

Benfica

Country: Portugal

Confederation: UEFA

Global Power Ranking: 21

Opta Primeira Liga Ranking: 2

How they qualified: UEFA Ranking between 2021 and 2024

Benfica won successive European Cups in 1961 and 1962 and this will be their first Club World Cup. They also hold the distinction of going an entire league season unbeaten and not winning the title in 1977-78, with 21 wins and nine draws from 30 matches. Benfica finished level on points with Porto but lost the title as Porto scored 81 goals to their 56.

Key Player: Kerem Akturkoglu

In his first season at Benfica, Akturkoglu has recorded nine goals and four assists in just 14 matches. Two of his five league goals have been match-winners, too.

Porto

Country: Portugal

Confederation: UEFA

Global Power Ranking: 23

Opta Primeira Liga Ranking: 3

How they qualified: UEFA Ranking between 2021 and 2024

Porto have won the Champions League and Europa League/UEFA Cup twice, leading to two Intercontinental Cup wins in 1987 and 2004 before the Club World Cup was formed. Domestically, Porto have won the league 30 times and are the only Portuguese team to have won five league titles in a row (between 1994 and 1999).

Key Player: Samu Aghehowa (formerly Omorodion)

Aghehowa joined Porto last summer from Atletico Madrid after missing out on a move to Chelsea and has scored 13 times in 14 games across the league and Europa League, averaging a goal every 83 minutes.

Al Hilal

Country: Saudi Arabia

Confederation: AFC

Global Power Ranking: 30

Opta Saudi Pro League Ranking: 1

How they qualified: 2021 AFC Champions League winners

Al Hilal have competed in the Club World Cup three times, even making the final of the 2022 edition, where they lost 5-3 to Real Madrid. They went the 2023-24 league season unbeaten, winning 31 of their 34 games with 101 goals scored, 23 conceded and 96 points.

Key Player: Aleksandar Mitrovic

Signed in August 2023, Mitrovic scored 40 goals in 44 matches last season and has 19 goals in 21 games in 2024-25, including 12 in 12 league outings.


Former Fulham striker Mitrovic is on a good goalscoring streak (Yasser Bakhsh/Getty Images)

Botafogo

Country: Brazil

Confederation: CONMEBOL

Global Power Ranking: 55

Opta Brazilian Serie A Ranking: 1

How they qualified: 2024 Copa Libertadores winners

Botafogo will make their Club World Cup debut next summer on the back of beating Atletico Mineiro 3-1 in the Copa Libertadores final last month. They hold the record for the longest unbeaten run in the Brazilian top flight, going 42 matches without a loss between 1977 and 1978. They did not win the title in either year, though.

Key Player: Jefferson Savarino

Savarino recorded 12 goals and 13 assists in 52 matches during the 2023-24 season, including three goals in the knockout rounds of the Copa Libertadores.

Palmeiras

Country: Brazil

Confederation: CONMEBOL

Global Power Ranking: 58

Opta Brazilian Serie A Ranking: 2

How they qualified: 2021 Copa Libertadores winners

Palmeiras have featured twice in the Club World Cup, notably taking Chelsea to extra time before losing 2-1 in late 2021. The Brazilian club won one of the first club tournaments involving teams from different continents. The Copa Rio, in 1951, included Austria Vienna, Sporting CP, Juventus and Red Star (Crvena Zvezda). In a two-game final, Palmeiras beat Juventus in one and drew the other to win the title.

Key Player: Estevao Willian

The 17-year-old, who is set to join Chelsea next summer, racked up 18 goals and 12 assists during the 2023-24 season, averaging a goal contribution every 98.6 minutes.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Estevao Willian: Chelsea’s €34m signing who shrugged off ‘Little Messi’ nickname to star in Brazil


Estevao Willian is on his way to Chelsea (Heuler Andrey/Getty Images)

Flamengo

Country: Brazil

Confederation: CONMEBOL

Global Power Ranking: 67

Opta Brazilian Serie A Ranking: 3

How they qualified: 2022 Copa Libertadores winners

One of the most successful South American clubs, Flamengo have made two previous Club World Cup appearances, losing the 2019 final to Liverpool (1-0 after extra time) and finishing third by beating Al Ahly 4-2 in 2023. Flamengo’s full name is Clube de Regatas do Flamengo, meaning “Flamengo Rowing Club,” with the club originally being formed in 1895 as a rowing club and not playing their first football match until 1912.

Key Player: Pedro

Pedro scored 30 times in 43 matches for Flamengo during the 2024 season, guiding them to the Copa do Brasil. He won the golden boot at the 2023 Club World Cup with four goals.

River Plate

Country: Argentina

Confederation: CONMEBOL

Global Power Ranking: 99

Opta Liga Profesional Ranking: 2

How they qualified: CONMEBOL ranking between 2021 and 2024

River Plate have competed twice at the Club World Cup. They made the 2015 final, losing 3-0 to Barcelona, before finishing third in the 2018 edition by beating Kashima Antlers 4-0. They are among the most successful South American clubs with 56 trophies, including 37 league titles.

Key Player: Pablo Solari

Solari, 23, will be one to watch next summer after recording eight goals and five assists in just 27 starts for his club in 2024.

Al Ahly

Country: Egypt

Confederation: CAF

Global Power Ranking: 104

Opta Egyptian Premier League Ranking: 1

How they qualified: 2020-21, 2022-23 and 2023-24 CAF Champions League winners

Al Ahly have enjoyed reasonable success in the Club World Cup, making it to six third-place playoffs (four wins) in nine appearances. They ended last December’s edition in third by beating Urawa Reds 4-2. In the last 18 completed top-flight seasons, Al Ahly have won 15 league titles, with the other three going to their rivals, Zamalek.

Key Player: Wessam Abou Ali

Striker Abou Ali recorded 20 goals and six assists last season and has started this campaign with four goals in seven appearances.

Inter Miami

Country: USA

Confederation: CONCACAF

Global Power Ranking: 114

Opta Major League Soccer Ranking: 3

How they qualified: 2024 MLS Supporters’ Shield winners

On the back of their first league shield, Inter Miami will compete in their first Club World Cup next summer. Founded only in 2018, Miami will be the youngest club at the tournament. In fact, they are about the same age as the youngest of marquee star Lionel Messi’s children, Ciro, born in 2018.

Key Player: Lionel Messi

Messi recorded 20 goals and 10 assists in the 2024 MLS regular season despite playing just 19 matches, averaging a goal contribution every 49.5 minutes. Miami lost only one of those games compared to three of the 15 he missed.


(Chris Arjoon/AFP via Getty Images)

Country: USA

Confederation: CONCACAF

Global Power Ranking: 143

Opta Major League Soccer Ranking: 5

How they qualified: 2022 CONCACAF Champions League winner

This will be Seattle’s second appearance at the Club World Cup, having lost 1-0 to Al Ahly in the 2023 edition. The Sounders are the only MLS club to have ever featured at the Club World Cup.

Key Player: Stefan Frei

Seattle captain Frei has kept 30 clean sheets in MLS over the last two seasons — including the playoffs — more than any other goalkeeper in this period.

Monterrey

Country: Mexico

Confederation: CONCACAF

Global Power Ranking: 144

Opta Liga MX Ranking: 3

How they qualified: 2021 CONCACAF Champions League winners

Monterrey have featured five times in the Club World Cup, finishing third twice (2012 and 2019).

Key Player: Sergio Canales

Former Real Betis stalwart Canales has been Monterrey’s best player since joining in July 2023, recording 22 goals and seven assists in 57 matches.


(Azael Rodriguez/Getty Images)

Red Bull Salzburg

Country: Austria

Confederation: UEFA

Global Power Ranking: 151

Opta Austrian Bundesliga Ranking: 2

How they qualified: UEFA ranking from 2021 to 2024

Red Bull Salzburg have never participated in the Club World Cup. Their best result in Europe over the past decade has been reaching the round of 16 of the Champions League in 2021-22. Domestically, Salzburg won 10 league titles in a row between 2013-14 and 2022-23 but lost out to Sturm Graz last season.

Key Player: Kamil Piatkowski

Salzburg have struggled with injuries this season, but Piatkowski has been ever-present at centre-back and is the only player to have featured in all 25 of their matches across competitions.

Boca Juniors

Country: Argentina

Confederation: CONMEBOL

Global Power Ranking: 155

Opta Liga Profesional Ranking: 5

How they qualified: CONMEBOL ranking between 2021 and 2024

Boca have played in one Club World Cup previously, making the 2008 final, which they lost 4-2 to AC Milan.

They have won the Copa Libertadores on six occasions and remain the only team to have won the tournament without a single loss, having done so in 1978.

Key Player: Edinson Cavani

Former PSG and Manchester United striker Cavani scored 20 times in 38 matches last season, his first at Boca, aged 37.


(Daniel Jayo/Getty Images)

Fluminense

Country: Brazil

Confederation: CONMEBOL

Global Power Ranking: 166

Opta Brazilian Serie A Ranking: 8

How they qualified: 2023 Copa Libertadores winners

Fluminense’s only Club World Cup appearance came last December as they lost 4-0 to Manchester City in the final. The club’s first president was an Englishman, Oscar Cox, who played a part in founding the club in July 1902. Cox remained in the role until December 1904.

Key Player: Ganso

The former Sevilla midfielder was Fluminense’s chief playmaker in 2024, recording 10 assists and four goals in 51 matches.


(Wagner Meier/Getty Images)

Mamelodi Sundowns

Country: South Africa

Confederation: CAF

Global Power Ranking: 218

Opta South African Premiership Ranking: 1

How they qualified: CAF ranking between 2021 and 2024

The Sundowns have featured once in the Club World Cup, losing the 2016 fifth-place playoff 4-1 to Jeonbuk Hyundai. The team also holds the record for the most South African league titles with 17, four ahead of the Kaizer Chiefs in second.

Key Player: Lucas Ribeiro

Ribeiro, 26, has managed seven goals and five assists in under 1,200 minutes of action this season, contributing to more goals than any other Sundowns player.

Esperance de Tunis

Country: Tunisia

Confederation: CAF

Global Power Ranking: 325

Opta Tunisian Ligue Ranking: 1

How they qualified: CAF ranking between 2021 and 2024

Esperance have featured in three Club World Cups, playing in the fifth-place playoff on all three occasions and winning twice. They have the third-most CAF Champions League trophies with four, behind Al Ahly (12), TP Mazembe and Zamalek (five each).

Key Player: Youcef Belaili

The Algerian winger has had a fantastic start to the 2024-25 season, with seven goals and eight assists in 11 matches after joining from MC Alger.

Ulsan HD

Country: South Korea

Confederation: AFC

Global Power Ranking: 360

Opta K League 1 Ranking: 2

How they qualified: AFC ranking between 2021 and 2024

Ulsan have competed in two Club World Cups, losing the fifth-place match on both occasions. Since their most recent appearance in the competition, they have won each of the last three K League 1 titles with at least a five-point buffer over the team in second place.

Key Player: Ataru Esaka

Esaka featured in 43 matches for Ulsan last season, scoring seven times and assisting five more from midfield.

Pachuca

Country: Mexico

Confederation: CONCACAF

Global Power Ranking: 376

Opta Liga MX Ranking: 9

How they qualified: 2024 CONCACAF Champions Cup winners

Pachuca will make their fifth Club World Cup appearance next summer and first since 2017 when they finished third — their best showing in the competition — by beating Al Jazira 4-1. The club were originally known as Pachuca Athletic Club.

Key Player: Salomon Rondon

The former Newcastle United and Everton striker joined Pachuca in January and has scored 25 times in 44 matches.


(Agustin Cuevas/Getty Images)

Urawa Red Diamonds

Country: Japan

Confederation: AFC

Global Power Ranking: 392

Opta J1 League Ranking: 9

How they qualified: 2022 AFC Champions League winners

The Red Diamonds have featured in three Club World Cups, including the 2023 edition when they lost to Al Ahly 4-2 in the third-place playoff. They did finish third in 2007, though, by defeating ES Sahel on penalties. They have won the J1 League just once in 2006 but have lifted the AFC Champions League title on three occasions (2007, 2017 and 2022).

Key Player: Ryoma Watanabe

The 28-year-old winger was the only Urawa player to start all 37 league games in 2024. Watanabe contributed six goals and five assists as well.

Leon

Country: Mexico

Confederation: CONCACAF

Global Power Ranking: 405

Opta Liga MX Ranking: 11

How they qualified: 2023 CONCACAF Champions League winners

Leon featured at the 2023 Club World Cup, losing to Urawa Red Diamonds in the second round. One of the oldest clubs in Mexico, Leon were the first to be conferred the “campeonismo” title awarded to teams that win the league and cup in the same season, doing so in 1949.

Key Player: Stiven Mendoza

Mendoza has provided goals from the left wing, scoring four times in 12 matches since joining from Adana Demirspor in July.

Wydad Casablanca

Country: Morocco

Confederation: CAF

Global Power Ranking: 565

Opta Botola Pro Ranking: 4

How they qualified: 2021-22 CAF Champions League winners

Wydad played in the 2017 and 2022 Club World Cups, losing to Urawa Red Diamonds and Al Hilal in the fifth-place play-off and second round respectively. They have won the Moroccan league a record 22 times, seven more than Union Sportive Marocaine in second, and won three CAF Champions League titles.

Key Player: Pedrinho

The 20-year-old Brazilian has received only 297 minutes of action so far this season but has shown serious potential, scoring once.

Al Ain

Country: United Arab Emirates

Confederation: AFC

Global Power Ranking: 679

Opta UAE Pro League Ranking: 5

How they qualified: 2023-24 AFC Champions League winners

Al Ain will be playing their second Club World Cup next summer, having made the 2018 final, which they lost 4-1 to Real Madrid. They remain the only team from the UAE to win the AFC Champions League, having lifted the title in 2003 and lost in two finals (2005 and 2016) before their success in 2024.

Key Player: Soufiane Rahimi

Rahimi, who has 10 goals in 25 caps for Morocco, was crucial to Al Ain’s latest AFC Champions League success. The 27-year-old scored 13 goals and assisted six more in 13 matches in that tournament.

Auckland City

Country: New Zealand

Confederation: OFC

Global Power Ranking: 4083

Opta New Zealand National League Ranking: 1

How they qualified: Best-ranked OFC Champions League winner between 2021 and 2024

Auckland City are the lowest-ranked team at next year’s Club World Cup, more than 3,000 spots lower than the next-lowest club. They have, however, made more appearances at the tournament than any other team with 11, with their best finish coming in 2014 when they beat Cruz Azul on penalties to finish third.

Key Player: Stipe Ukich

How many of Auckland City’s players will return for next season remains to be seen, but Ukich, who turns 18 next month, impressed, scoring 10 times in 38 matches in all competitions last season.

The 32 teams in the Club World Cup 2025

Team Global Power Ranking

Inter

2

Man City

3

Real Madrid

5

Bayern Munich

8

PSG

9

Chelsea

10

Juventus

13

Atletico Madrid

14

Dortmund

20

Benfica

21

Porto

23

Al Hilal

30

Botafogo

55

Palmeiras

58

Flamengo

67

River Plate

99

Al Ahly

104

Inter Miami

114

Seattle

143

Monterrey

144

Red Bull Salzburg

151

Boca Juniors

155

Fluminense

166

Sundowns

218

Esperance

325

Ulsan HD

360

Pachuca

376

Urawa

392

Leon

405

Wydad

565

Al Ain

679

Auckland

4083

(Top photos: Getty Images)

UCF inquires about USC coach Lincoln Riley: Sources

By Bruce Feldman, Antonio Morales and Ralph Russo

UCF has inquired about the availability of USC coach Lincoln Riley as it searches for a replacement for Gus Malzahn, three people who have been privy to those conversations told The Athletic on Wednesday.

There has been no indication Riley is interested in making the move, the people said. He is three seasons into a reported 10-year contract that pays him about $10 million per year.

The people spoke to The Athletic on condition of anonymity because all the discussions were private and UCF was not publicly revealing details of its coaching search.

Riley’s contract is not publicly available because USC is a private school, but extracting him from Southern California — if he wanted to leave — would likely cost tens of millions of dollars for either the Trojans or the school looking to hire him away.

Representatives from UCF reached out to Riley’s representatives last weekend to inquire about his interest in making a move across the country, one source said. Any discussions about adjusting the terms of Riley’s contract would be between him and USC, sources said.

The first source added that UCF has not received any word from Riley’s camp that he is interested in leaving USC, and the school is still looking at multiple candidates to fill its head coaching vacancy.

Firing Riley, whose win total with the Trojans has decreased in each of his three seasons, would cost USC about $90 million, according to one of the sources. If Riley were to leave for another school, he would owe USC nothing. But UCF is not in position to replicate the deal Riley has at USC. Malzahn made $4 million in 2024 at UCF.

Two sources said even if Riley had an interest in making the move, it would require some payout of his current deal with USC to make up for what he would be giving up in the transition — like a professional sports trade where one team pays a chunk of a player’s remaining salary on a large contract and the receiving team picks up the rest.

Riley was hired at USC by former athletic director Mike Bohn, who resigned amid controversy in the spring of 2023. University president Carol Folt oversaw the hire as well and will retire this summer, which means two of the main parties involved in bringing Riley to USC will be gone.

Jen Cohen, the former Washington athletic director, was hired in August 2023 to lead the athletic department. She inherited Riley and his contract.

She’s in the unenviable position of having an underperforming football program but a coach who is too expensive to move on from. In the spring, Cohen navigated a delicate situation with men’s basketball coach Andy Enfield, whose tenure had run its course but his track record was too good to justify a firing. He eventually took the SMU job, and Cohen hired Eric Musselman from Arkansas to replace him.

Even with a suitor for Riley, getting out from under his deal looks more difficult.

Malzahn left UCF after four seasons as head coach to become offensive coordinator at Florida State. The Knights have gone 10-15 overall and 5-13 in league play in their first two seasons in the Big 12 after making the move from the American Athletic Conference. UCF received only a partial share of Big 12 revenue last year, about $18 million, and is scheduled to receive about $19 million for the 2024-25 fiscal year.

The number jumps to a full share in 2025-26, which should be about double those figures.

Riley is 25-14 at USC since being lured to Los Angeles from Oklahoma after the 2021 regular season. It was a seismic move for the Trojans, swiping away a coach who had a 55-10 record in Norman and two Heisman Trophy winners in Baker Mayfield and Kyler Murray.

The Trojans went 11-3 in Riley’s first season with another Heisman winner in Caleb Williams, the star quarterback who followed the coach from Oklahoma to USC. But the results have been trending in the wrong direction since.

USC went 8-5 in 2023, its final season in the Pac-12, and wrapped up its first regular season in the Big Ten with a 6-6 overall record (4-5 in league play).

After the 2023 season, Riley told The Athletic that he “didn’t come here (USC) for some short-term thing and as long as SC continues to give us the support and the things we need to continue to build this, this was not a two-year rebuild.”

Recruiting hasn’t lived up to the high expectations that came with Riley’s hire. USC continues to regress on the field each season, and the program doesn’t appear to have much direction moving forward, making the outlook for Riley look hazy at best.

(Photo: Sean M. Haffey / Getty Images)

Miami AD, ACC commissioner sound off on Canes’ exclusion from CFP field in favor of Alabama

University of Miami athletic director Dan Radakovich did not hold back his disappointment upon learning that his Hurricanes were ranked No. 12 in Tuesday’s latest College Football Playoff rankings, and thus out of the 12-team field in favor of No. 11 Alabama, who earned the last at-large bid in this iteration.

Michigan AD Warde Manuel, the chair of the College Football Playoff selection committee, explained the reason Alabama was ranked ahead of Miami: The Tide are 3-1 against current Top 25 teams and Miami is 0-1. Warde also noted that Alabama is 6-1 against teams above .500 and Miami is 4-2.

“Really ??” Radakovich said on X on Tuesday. “What put Bama over the top of Miami for the last spot in is that Miami went 1-2 in their last 3 games (by an average of 4.5 pts, to a ranked Syracuse and (Georgia Tech) team that just took (Georgia) to 8OT). Bama went 2-1 (to 5-7 Auburn, destroyed by (Oklahoma), and beat FCS Mercer).”

Radakovich and football coach Mario Cristobal both pitched for the Canes’ inclusion in the 12-team field earlier Tuesday.

GO DEEPER

College Football Playoff guide: 12-team format, important dates, game locations

ACC commissioner Jim Phillips also came to Miami’s defense: “We are certainly pleased that SMU moved up in the rankings and that the Committee continued to recognize the Mustangs’ incredible season, which should unequivocally earn them a Playoff spot, regardless of this weekend’s outcome. With that said, we are also incredibly shocked and disappointed that Miami dropped six spots to No. 12.

“Miami has more wins and fewer losses than the team directly ahead of them and a dominant victory over an SEC team whose late-season surge includes a win over No. 13 Ole Miss. Moreover, with two losses by a combined nine points — to a ranked Syracuse team and a Georgia Tech team that just took No. 5 Georgia to eight overtimes. Miami absolutely deserves better from the Committee.

“As we look ahead to the final rankings, we hope the Committee will reconsider and put a deserving Miami in the field. We will continue to look forward to this weekend, when Clemson and SMU have an opportunity to earn an ACC championship and represent the conference in the CFP.”

Miami is now projected to play against BYU in the Pop-Tarts Bowl on Dec. 28. According to The Athletic’s latest projections, the Hurricanes have only an eight percent chance to make the Playoff. The field will be finalized Sunday, Dec. 8 after the FBS conference championship games.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

College football bowl projections: SEC gets all the love for the Playoff field

The case for Miami

Miami had a strong case to finish ahead of the Crimson Tide. Where Manuel and the selection committee missed the boat is by dismissing the fact that Miami’s two losses were to quality opponents. Georgia Tech finished 7-5 but took Georgia, a Playoff team and SEC finalist, to eight overtimes. Syracuse is 9-3 and No. 22 in the CFP rankings.

Two of Alabama’s three losses were to Vanderbilt (6-6) and Oklahoma (6-6). The loss to the Sooners happened just two weeks ago and was by 21 points. — Manny Navarro, Miami beat writer

The case against Miami

Miami being eliminated from CFP contention came off as a pleasant surprise after several weeks of overrating the Canes, and after Manuel seemed to telegraph that the relative weakness of Miami’s profile would not count against it.

“Teams can only play the (conference) schedule that’s in front of them,” Manuel said after last week’s rankings. “They can only play the opponents that they have. So we take the stance that we’re going to really look at these games, we’re going to look at the stats, we’re going to look at the strength of schedule, but we’re also going to look at how teams are performing against the competition that they have. From our perspective, if it was just about strength of schedule, we wouldn’t be needed.”

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Ding dong, Miami’s dead, but did Ole Miss deserve the CFP rankings nod over Alabama?

In penalizing Miami, the committee thought beyond the simplicity of counting loss totals, valued good wins over “good losses” and ejected a team with a poor strength of schedule and no ranked wins. It’s not Miami’s fault that it didn’t play Clemson and SMU this season, but it’s not to Miami’s credit, either. — Joe Rexrode, college sports columnist

(Photo: Al Diaz / Miami Herald / Tribune News Service via Getty Images)

The Transfer Radar 2025: The Athletic’s ultimate guide to players who could be on the move

Florian Wirtz is a jewel of German football and was central to Bayer Leverkusen’s unbeaten domestic double last season, winning the Bundesliga’s player of the year award. Alongside Bayern Munich’s Jamal Musiala, he has become the great hope of Julian Nagelsmann’s national team, too, and will be fundamental to Germany’s challenge at the 2026 World Cup.

His contract runs until 2027, so there is no obligation to sell but considering his close relationship with in-demand head coach Xabi Alonso, there will come a point when Wirtz, who joined Leverkusen from Koln in 2020, may also look elsewhere.

He belongs at the top of the game but his path depends on which club is willing to meet Leverkusen’s €150million (£125m; $159m) asking price. They will not get that, but the figure represents how highly Wirtz is valued.

Fernando Carro, the club’s CEO, believes he might stay beyond this season.

Seb Stafford-Bloor

What else do I need to know about him?

There’s an enigmatic quiet to him. He is understandably laconic, given the attention he receives in the German media, but is also extremely popular within the Leverkusen dressing room and fashion-conscious off the pitch, too, looking like someone on the way back from a Stone Roses gig.

Wirtz has been a star for a long time. In his early teens, there were stories of a tiny boy at Koln who might be the country’s finest talent in years. The hype was justified. What happened next, however, created acrimony that lasts to this day.

When he was progressing through Koln’s youth teams, a gentlemen’s agreement existed between several clubs in the area — Koln, Leverkusen, Borussia Monchengladbach and Fortuna Dusseldorf among them — stipulating that, for the betterment of the region, they would not poach each other’s youth players.

After he turned 17, Wirtz’s youth contract at Koln expired. The player’s parents wanted him to finish his schooling and stay close to home, so he joined Leverkusen for €300,000. His new club felt he was fair game — a senior, rather than a youth player. Koln believed differently, claiming their local rivals had violated the agreement.

Max Eberl, Gladbach’s sporting director at the time (and now Bayern’s board member for sport), was critical of Leverkusen’s conduct but Carro, who remains Leverkusen’s CEO, defended his club.

Old news, perhaps, but among Bayern’s transfer targets is — inevitably — Wirtz, which would involve a prickly negotiation.

Will he go there? Most likely not. Musiala’s contract extension is Bayern’s priority. Given the strength of his relationship with Alonso and how good his form has been under him, the smart money might be on them taking their next steps together.

Seb Stafford-Bloor

Tell me about how he plays…

On the pitch, his control, dribbling ability and creative prowess make him one of the world’s most exciting players. He can weave his way past defenders but also find team-mates with one-twos, precise passes and through balls while his off-the-ball movement and positioning regularly put him in areas to score and create.

Across his short senior career, he has featured across the front line and as a No 10. This versatility allowed Nagelsmann to successfully play him and Musiala together at Euro 2024.

Under Alonso, Wirtz’s defensive work has improved too, and he has been willing to put the hard yards in to lead Leverkusen’s press. Wirtz has lifted the floor for playing behind the striker but arguably has not reached his ceiling — that, more than anything, is a frightening prospect.

Anantaajith Raghuraman

Paige Bueckers becomes first NIL athlete to launch Nike player edition sneaker

UConn star Paige Bueckers continues to make history.

On Monday, Nike named Bueckers as the first name, image and likeness athlete to design and launch a player edition sneaker, with the brand debuting Bueckers’ Nike G.T. Hustle 3 on Saturday.

“It’s definitely motivating to wear your own shoe,” Bueckers said in a statement. “I grew up wearing Nikes — all the signature shoes — so it’s surreal to have this player edition model. I just want to show out in it.”

The sneaker features details personal to the 2021 Naismith Player of the Year. The area codes for Storrs, Conn., and Bueckers’ hometown in Minnesota intersect on the left tongue, and a text bubble with the phrase “Be You, Be Great” is printed on the left heel as a nod to the message she receives from her father before every game. “Bueckers” is printed on the right heel.

Bueckers first signed an NIL deal with Nike in September 2023, adding the apparel company to a lengthy list of deals with companies such as Gatorade, Dunkin’, Bose and Chegg.

In August, Bueckers also signed an NIL deal with Unrivaled, the new winter 3×3 professional league co-founded by Breanna Stewart and Napheesa Collier. She became the first NCAA athlete to receive ownership equity in a league. She is expected to play in the league next year.

Bueckers’ playing future has been a recent topic of conversation following the 2025 WNBA Draft Lottery in mid-November. The Dallas Wings won the lottery, allowing them to select Bueckers No. 1 if the Huskies star declares for April’s draft.

Bueckers is a redshirt senior, though she still could return to UConn for an additional season after receiving an extra year of eligibility because of the COVID-19 pandemic. However, Bueckers told The Athletic this summer that she planned for this college season to be her last, and she later shared in a social media post that she was taking part in her last UConn media day this fall.

She joins a growing group of women’s basketball players to have design input on Nike sneakers. Jewell Loyd and Jonquel Jones are among WNBA players who unveiled Nike player-exclusive sneakers this past season, while Sabrina Ionescuhas a popular signature sneaker and A’ja Wilson’s will be on the market by the 2025 WNBA season. Caitlin Clark also debuted several player-exclusive sneakers, and she reportedly will receive a Nike signature sneaker in the future as part of an endorsement deal she signed last spring.

Through six games this season, Bueckers, a two-time first-team All-American, is averaging 22 points, 4.5 rebounds and 4.5 assists per game. UConn is undefeated and hosts Holy Cross on Tuesday before playing Louisville in the Women’s Champions Classic at Barclays Center on Saturday.

Required reading

(Photos courtesy of Nike)

Holiday gift guide 2024: What to get the sports fan who already has everything

Shopping for sports fans can be harder than one might think. Chances are the fan in your life already has a variety of hats, jerseys and who knows what else to rep their favorite teams and players. But there’s a massive array of sports related items out there that the person on your list may not even know about. So to help you find that perfect gift, we’ve enlisted help from around The Athletic’s newsroom to put together a list of ideas and recommendations to consider. Happy holidays!

—Brooks Peck and David Betancourt, The Athletic’s memorabilia and collectibles editors 

(Updated 11/28 with additional items.)

Starting small

Riddell mini football helmets 

Riddell has an extensive selection of mini helmets of both NFL and NCAA teams (the University of Colorado section alone is pretty impressive). There are current looks, alternative styles (such as the Washington Commanders’ Hail Mary Black helmets) and throwbacks (the Tampa Bay Buccaneers’ creamsicle helmets are always a good look). 

Other minis: Rawlings MLB mini batting helmets, Franklin NHL mini goalie helmets, PWHL mini sticks, NBA mini retro basketballs

Sports art


Landing Pond by Jacob Trouba

Jacob Trouba’s hockey art

There’s beauty in the physicality of hockey. New York Rangers defenseman and captain Jacob Trouba knows that more than most. Trouba, known for his hard hits, is also an artist. But he doesn’t use a paint brush. Instead, he slathers paint all over himself — in his hockey equipment — and charges toward a canvas. The collision results in paintings that portray power and dynamic movement. A small print of some of Trouba’s works can be purchased directly from his website for $150. Larger, signed prints go for $1,000 apiece. —Alex Iniguez, NHL Senior Editor

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

How Jacob Trouba, one of the NHL’s most vicious open-ice hitters, found his artistic side

Other sports art: John Battalgazi’s circular athletes, The Golden Hexagon: Where basketball meets geography, Literally Balling: Very fancy basketball, Shelton Art Company, Triple Play Design Company’s retro prints and more

Sports books

The Basketball 100

A comprehensive look at the greatest players, past and present, in NBA history. From a surprising choice at No. 100 to a sprint to the finish at the top of the list by LeBron James and Michael Jordan, “The Basketball 100” features 100 full-length profiles of the game’s greats. Written by David Aldridge and John Hollinger with The Athletic’s NBA staff and a foreword by Charles Barkley, “The Basketball 100” is “guaaar-uuunnn-teeeed!” to satisfy the basketball fan in your life this holiday season. —Rob Peterson, NBA Deputy Managing Editor

The Basketball 100

The Basketball 100

The story of the greatest players in NBA history. In 100 riveting profiles, top basketball writers justify their selections and uncover the history of the NBA in the process.

The story of the greatest plays in NBA history.

BuyBuy The Basketball 100

Other sports books from The Athletic and its writers: The Football 100 by Mike Sando, Dan Pompei and The NFL Staff; Undeniable: The Kansas City Chiefs’ remarkable 2023 championship season; Garden Party: Inside the Boston Celtics’ run to the 2023-24 NBA Championship; Caitlin Clark: Raising the Game; Extra Time Beckons, Penalties Loom by Adam Hurrey; Who Owns Football? by Nick Miller; The Franchise: The Business of Building Winning Teams by Craig Custance

Throwbacks

Homage x Starter jackets

The satin bombers represents ’80s sideline sophistication while the pullovers were the coolest thing on the playground in the ’90s. Nostalgia never goes out of style, right?

Other throwbacks: Ebbets Field Flannels, Mitchell and Ness, Classic Football Shirts

Lionel Messi Inter Miami Archive Jersey

On any given day in any given elementary school there are seemingly dozens of kids wearing the pink and black of Inter Miami with Messi’s name and No. 10 on the back. There is no doubt Messi’s move to MLS has an outsized impact on youth fashion, but the next level look is the minty retro third kit that dropped midway through this season. (The only thing more ubiquitous among kids these days might be Stanley cups, and they have a new Messi “Goat” Collection releasing Dec. 3 — complete with mate mug)

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Five MLS clubs get retro third kits for the remainder of 2024

 

 

San Diego Wave Home Jersey

It was the most popular NWSL jersey in the U.S. this year and it’s a design that will still be talked about for years to come.

Other gifts for kids: Shohei Ohtani T-shirt, Little People NFL sets, Lego Formula 1 sets, Future Fans — teach kids about sports in a creative new way

Gifts for WNBA fans

Wilson x Caitlin Clark basketballs

The WNBA surged in popularity this year, bringing in a slew of new fans who are likely still getting up to speed in the gear department. Wilson has had a hard time keeping Caitlin Clark’s signature basketball collection in stock, but if you can snag one it would make a good gift for anyone looking to emulate the WNBA Rookie of the Year.

Other gifts for WNBA fans: Reebok Angel Reese Collection, Kate Martin socks, Playa Society x WNBA

Sports…scents?

For the tennis obsessive in your life — or even the friend who can’t stop talking about Challengers — this is a luxury candle that even the pickiest person will fall in love with. Vacation’s Ball Boy candle combines the sweet smells of uncanned tennis balls with sunscreen and cotton sweatbands. And Otherland’s Matchpoint candle takes you straight to Wimbledon with cut grass and cucumber scents. —Jordan Cohen, Executive Director of External Communications

Cool baseball gear

Victus Pencil Bats

The Pencil Bat became a sensation last year when the Philadelphia Phillies’ Bryson Stott used it in an MLB game and remains a wildly popular twist on the standard baseball bat (it’s available in a variety of sizes for different levels of play). But if that’s not colorful enough, Victus also has a collection of Crayon Bats too.

ARiA Sliding Mitts

Sliding mitts have become a regular part of baseball equipment at this point, and Absolutely Ridiculous has turned something that was frankly rather silly looking into an item on the cutting edge of baseball creativity. Their imaginative designs are enough to make you want to lean into a fastball just so you can get on base and put one on.

For sports/movie fans

Grays Sports Almanac prop replic

OK, so Back to the Future Part II isn’t exactly a sports movie, but the Grays Sports Almanac is an iconic cinematic sports items. This prop replica is filled with actual scores and stats from 1950-2000 (which, sadly, is now the distant past) and comes with a futuristic receipt and shopping bag, just like the one Marty McFly pulled it out of after making his purchase in 2015. It even has the dust jacket!

Other sports movie gifts: Penfold Golf: James Bond’s ball of choice in Goldfinger, The Sandlot Babe Ruth Replica Autograph Baseball (after Hercules got to it)

Home decor

25-layer StadiumView lighted end table 

Available for a variety of college and processional stadiums and arenas, these end tables provide a unique way to bring home a favorite team’s home. The tables cost several hundred dollars, but there are also five-layer wall art and 3D coasters available from the same company (YouTheFan) at lower price points.

Other home decor gifts: Golf pencil display cases, NASCAR car hood wall signs

Pickup by Gameflo

If you like Marvel Snap, you will like this. Basketball strategy and chance, as you look to win matchups against your opponent’s weaknesses.

Philters

Non-alcoholic liquor, which we used for cooking, but I’m sure others can find tons of uses for, even just to enjoy alcohol free mixed drinks.

Zora’s Best

Slow-roasted and freeze-dried dog treats. Barkley goes crazy for them, and they’re super nutritious and healthy.

A Very Kelce Christmas

A Philly Special Christmas

Hugely popular among fans of the Philadelphia Eagles, Kansas City Chiefs, Taylor Swift, the New Heights podcast, television commercials, breakfast cereal and a dizzying array of other things, the Kelce brothers are everywhere. Perhaps their most endearing endeavor has been Jason’s series of holiday albums that benefit a variety of Philadelphia charities and includes a surprising mix of notable musicians alongside his former Eagles teammates, Lane Johnson and Jordan Mailata. This year’s edition is the third and supposedly final one they’ll produce and it includes a Jason Kelce and Stevie Nicks duet!

Other Kelce related gifts: McFarlane Toys Super Bowl LVII Kelce brothers figures, Garage Beer Employee of the Month shirtless Jason Kelce chugging T-shirt

eBay insights

The four athletes who were among the 10 most searched on eBay every month so far this year:

So gifts relating to those four should be decent bets.

Other athletes who saw big jumps in searches this year:

  • Anthony Edwards card” had a 1,850 percent increase in searches in May compared to the start of that NBA season as he led the Minnesota Timberwolves to the Western Conference Finals.
  • Paul Skenes searches increased 620 percent in July, when he was named an MLB All-Star Game starter, compared to when he was called up in April. He remains a hot commodity after being named NL Rookie of the Year and with the Pittsburgh Pirates offering a unique bounty for his Topps Debut Patch card.
  • Searches for Freddie Freeman increased almost 1,500 percent the day after his walk-off grand slam to win Game 1 of the World Series for the LA Dodgers on his way to becoming series MVP.

Also, “PSA 10” searches increased 30 percent in October compared to the same time last year, perhaps showing a growing focus for trading card collectors on cards deemed to be in gem-mint condition by the industry largest grading company.

Offbeat sports gifts: 


A patron holds a Masters Gnome during the first round of the 2024 Masters Tournament. (Photo: Andrew Redington/Getty Images)

Interest in The Masters annual garden gnome continues to grow — the only item in the official Masters gift shop to carry a purchase limit. The only place to buy them at their retail price of $50 is on site at the tournament each year, but on eBay the full-size 2024 edition is selling for around $250-$300.

Searches for vintage NFL gear spiked after Taylor Swift wore an old Chiefs jacket that was bought on eBay to a game in early November.

The Dodgers’ Shohei Ohtani and Decoy bobblehead giveaway was arguably one of the most coveted (and cutest) sports-related items of the year — the day after the giveaway eBay users searched for “Shohei Ohtani bobblehead” at a rate of more than 1,750 times per hour. There’s even a rare gold variation.

The Athletic maintains full editorial independence in all our coverage. When you click or make purchases through our links, we may earn a commission.

Follow our sports memorabilia and collectibles coverage for more gift ideas (even if they’re gifts for yourself). 

(Top photo: Thomas Shea-Imagn Images)

Arizona State will play for Big 12 championship, and its overlooked star deserves Heisman consideration

TUCSON, Ariz. — The Arizona State Sun Devils gathered at midfield, an enormous mass of maroon and gold celebrating Saturday’s 49-7 win against rival Arizona at Arizona Stadium. Suddenly, Cam Skattebo broke from the pack, lifting the Territorial Cup in his right hand and charging for the stands where Arizona State fans awaited.

Skattebo had just rushed for 177 yards and three touchdowns, lifting No. 16 Arizona State to its 10th win and a place in the Big 12 Championship Game, an improbable tale for both the bruising running back and the program he represents.

Heisman Trophy ballots are sent out on Monday. Like his team, Skattebo began the season as an incredible long shot. Also, like his team, Skattebo has shown he belongs.

“He has to be one of the best backs in yards from scrimmage in all of Power 4 football,’’ Arizona State coach Kenny Dillingham said outside the locker room. “How are there many players more impactful than him and what he’s done for this program, picked dead last to playing potentially in the conference championship?”

Colorado two-way star Travis Hunter is the favorite for this season’s Heisman, given to college football’s top player. Boise State running back Ashton Jeanty, Miami quarterback Cam Ward and Oregon quarterback Dillon Gabriel are strong contenders. The top four finalists travel to New York for the Dec. 14 Heisman ceremony.

Skattebo has never been to the Big Apple. Has it entered his mind?

“I never thought I would be (in this position),” he said.

Does he think he deserves to go?

“Potentially,’’ Skattebo said. “We got more work to do. But, yeah.”

As Skattebo held up the Territorial Cup, the oldest rivalry trophy in the sport, his teammates gathered around him in the corner of Arizona Stadium. Dillingham told officials to get the players already in the locker room to return to the field. Once they did, Dillingham and the Sun Devils sang the school fight song. After the last word, they took the celebration inside.

Skattebo stayed on the field.

He looked down the length of the field and noticed Arizona State fans lined the entire way, from one end zone to the other. Skattebo started making his way down, signing autographs, posing for photos and living in the moment. In the locker room, his coaches and teammates celebrated. Skattebo wasn’t concerned.

“I see those guys every day,’’ he said. “We’ll have our fun later.”

Elite players in college football enter the sport in high regard. Hunter was a five-star high school prospect, the top player in his class. Jeanty was a four-star running back. Coming out of Rio Linda High School in California, Skattebo barely registered, a running back who played like a linebacker.

Skattebo signed with Sacramento State, the only school that offered him a full scholarship. After two seasons, he transferred to Arizona State. In his first season with the Sun Devils, he rushed for 783 yards and nine touchdowns behind a banged-up line. This season, slimmed down and determined, he’s been among the country’s most improved players, the only back who entered Saturday with 1,000-plus rushing yards and 350-plus receiving yards.

“It’s funny because those of us who have watched him grow up — and I talked to his brother last week about it, too — it looks exactly the same,” Skattebo’s high school coach, Jack Garceau, said by phone during Saturday’s game. “It was this way in high school. This way at Sac State. And now it looks this way at ASU. Nothing’s changed. He’s just gotten better and better and better.”

Near the stands, Skattebo grabbed a maroon hat and scribbled “Skatt” in black ink. He shuffled to his left, slapping fives, stopping at a blonde-haired boy who asked him to sign his maroon jersey. Skattebo shifted the boy to the side so he could use his shoulder for support. A security guard informed co-workers that Skattebo was still on the field. A photographer informed the running back that his family waited not far down the line.

Arizona State achieved bowl eligibility after a Nov. 2 win at Oklahoma State. After that game, Dillingham said the Sun Devils (10-2, 7-2 Big 12) were playing with house money. Quarterback Sam Leavitt said that’s when the expanded College Football Playoff first popped into his mind.

“Why not us?” he thought.

Arizona State hasn’t lost since, winners of five in a row, each win bigger than the last, the most memorable march this program has experienced since the Sun Devils went 11-1 during the 1996 season. Leavitt has developed quicker than expected. The offensive line has stayed healthy. The defense has made plays.

“They still surprise me,” Dillingham said. “They’re just a unique, goofy group of misfits that somehow came together and are accomplishing things that are special.”

Skattebo has been the engine. Earlier on ESPN’s “College GameDay,” Nick Saban called him his favorite player in college football.

“This guy, he’s rugged,” the former Alabama coach said. “Tough. I just love a great competitor. He’s all that.”

Skattebo grabbed a cell phone. He held it out as far as his right arm could extend, making sure the fans behind him were in the frame and smiled. He posed in the middle of nine Arizona State cheerleaders. Twenty minutes after the game, Skattebo hugged his family. After a brief conversation, he turned and jogged to the locker room. Fans serenaded him along the way.

“Skatt for Heis-man!”

“Skatt for Heis-man!”

(Photo of Cam Skattebo (left) and Kenny Dillingham: Christopher Hook / Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

FIFA ‘has a responsibility’ to compensate Qatar World Cup workers, report finds

A report commissioned by FIFA has concluded football’s governing body “has a responsibility” to compensate workers who suffered during the hosting of the 2022 Qatar World Cup.

The long-awaited report from FIFA’s sub-committee on human rights and social responsibility — finally published on Friday at midnight Central European Time — says the governing body “took a number of steps to seek to meet its responsibility to respect human rights” as part of the delivery of the tournament two years ago.

However, FIFA failed to meet one of the report’s primary recommendations of using the Qatar Legacy Fund to remedy workers impacted by human rights abuses, instead announcing they would donate the money to several other programmes which will not directly compensate workers in Qatar.

FIFA insisted the study was not “a legal assessment of the obligation to remedy”.

The independent study, commissioned by the sub-committee and developed by the business and human rights advisory firm ‘Human Level’, notes that “a number of severe human rights impacts did ultimately occur in Qatar from 2010 through 2022” for a number of workers connected to the tournament.

This included “deaths, injuries and illnesses; wages not being paid for months on end; and significant debt faced by workers and their families reimbursing the fees they paid to obtain jobs in Qatar.”

While acknowledging that “the main responsibility to rectify such shortcomings lies with the direct employers of these workers as well as with the Qatari government” the sub-committee “endorses the view expressed in the Human Level Study that FIFA too has a responsibility to take additional measures to contribute to the provision of remedy to these workers.”

World Cup organizers have put the number of deaths directly linked to the delivery of the tournament at 40. Human rights groups have long estimated that thousands of workers died.

GO DEEPER

Explained: Why it is so hard to provide a death toll for Qatar’s migrant workers

A FIFA spokesperson said: “All reports and recommendations were considered during a comprehensive review by the FIFA administration and relevant bodies. While all recommendations could not be met, practical and impactful elements were retained.

“It should be noted that the study did not specifically constitute a legal assessment of the obligation to remedy.”

The report recommends that FIFA should use its Qatar Legacy Fund to remedy workers impacted or, for those who died, their family members.

The sub-committee advises them to “act upon the intention, as indicated by FIFA in a press release of 19 November 2022, to dedicate the FIFA World Cup 2022 Legacy Fund in full or in part to further strengthen the competition’s legacy for migrant workers.”

However, two days before the report’s publication FIFA announced the $50million fund would instead be used on a series of social programmes globally in collaboration with Qatar and three organisations, the World Health Organization (WHO), the World Trade Organization (WTO) and UNHCR, the UN Refugee Agency, instead.

A FIFA spokesperson said: “The creation of the FIFA World Cup 2022 Legacy Fund was unanimously endorsed by the FIFA Council following a proposal made by the FIFA governance, audit and compliance committee.

“A Workers’ Support and Insurance Fund was established in Qatar in 2018 and FIFA believes the new Legacy Fund, endorsed by recognised international agencies, is a pragmatic and transparent initiative that will encompass social programmes to help people most in need across the world.”

Following the award of the World Cup to Qatar, FIFA has added human rights as a consideration as part of its bidding process for tournaments.

On Friday FIFA’s evaluation report for Saudi Arabia’s 2034 World Cup bid declared the risk assessment for human rights to be “medium”.

A vote on the hosts for the tournament — where the Saudi bid has no rival — will take place at the FIFA Congress on December 11.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

World Cup 2022 migrant worker diaries, one year on: Death, regret, joy and trying to return

(Anne-Christine Poujoulat/AFP via Getty Images)

FIFA report: Saudi 2034 World Cup bid has ‘medium’ human rights risk

FIFA, the world governing body for football, released on Friday night its evaluation report for Saudi Arabia’s bid to host the men’s World Cup in 2034, awarding the nation a higher score for bidding requirements than it granted the successful Canadian, American and Mexican joint bid for the 2026 edition, while declaring the risk assessment for human rights to be “medium”.

FIFA also claim in their report that there is “good potential” for the competition to act as a “catalyst” for reforms within Saudi Arabia, saying it will “contribute to positive human rights outcomes”. Amnesty International described FIFA’s observations as “an astonishing whitewash” of Saudi Arabia’s human rights record.

The bid report also declared the bid by oil-rich Saudi to have demonstrated a “good commitment to sustainability” while FIFA acknowledges that the Saudi bid presents an “elevated risk” in terms of timing due to the climate of the country.

FIFA, which ordinarily holds men’s World Cups in June and July, says the bidder did not stipulate a proposed window for the tournament but pledged to collaborate to “ensure the tournament’s success”, implying we may see a repeat of the 2022 edition in Qatar which was shifted to the winter months to allow for the safety of participants and supporters.

FIFA ranks its World Cup bids out of five and awarded the Saudi bid a score of 4.2, higher than the so-called United bid for 2026, which was rated 4.0. For the Women’s World Cup in 2027, Brazil’s successful bid was ranked 4.0, while the defeated joint bid of Belgium, the Netherlands and Germany was given a score of 3.7.

FIFA released its report in an email to media at 12.33am Central European Time on Saturday morning. Almost immediately, reports emerged in Middle Eastern English-speaking outlets such as the Saudi Gazette, declaring that the Saudi bid had received the highest ever score from FIFA when bidding for a World Cup.

The Saudi bid for the 2034 World Cup had already been considered a nigh-on inevitability because it was the only bidder for the tournament. This outcome developed after FIFA announced a mega-edition bid for the 2030 World Cup, which would be hosted across three continents (Africa, Europe and South America) and six countries (Morocco, Spain, Portugal, Argentina, Uruguay and Paraguay).

This ruled those three continents out of bidding for the following World Cup in 2034, while the joint U.S., Canada and Mexico event for 2026 ruled out a return to North America due to FIFA’s principle of confederation rotation.

This left the Saudis with a clear run in the absence of a rival from elsewhere in Asia or Oceania, subject to a vote of member nations at the FIFA Congress on December 11, which was widely seen as a formality.

FIFA’s report say their evaluation “consulted various sources, including the bidder’s human rights strategy, the mandated context assessment, as well as direct commitments from the host country and host cities, together with all contractual hosting documents, all of which notably contain provisions relating to respecting human rights in connection with the competition”.


Tennis stars Ons Jabeur (far left) and Aryna Sabalenka tour the Saudi 2034 bid exhibition in October (Katelyn Mulcahy/Getty Images for WTA)

However, The Athletic revealed last month how 11 organisations — including Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, a Saudi Arabian diaspora organisation and human rights groups specialising in the Gulf region — raised major concerns about the credibility of a report for FIFA entitled “Independent Context Assessment Prepared for the Saudi Arabian Football Federation in relation to the FIFA World Cup 2034”.

The independent context assessment, produced by the Saudi arm of global law firm Clifford Chance, excluded a large number of internationally recognised human rights from its assessment, saying this was because “either Saudi Arabia has not ratified the relevant treaties or because the Saudi Football Federation did not recognise them as ‘applying’ to the assessment”.

This meant it avoided delving into matters many would consider pertinent to Saudi, notably relating to freedom of expression, association and assembly, as well as LGBTQI+ discrimination, the prohibition of trade unions, the right to freedom of religion and forced evictions.

The report said that the scope of its assessment was “determined by the Saudi Arabian Football Federation in agreement with FIFA”, suggesting that FIFA itself approved the omissions. Both the Saudi Football Association and FIFA did not respond when approached by The Athletic at the time.

In a press release by the rights groups, they claimed that “Saudi Arabia’s already dire human rights record has deteriorated under the de facto rule of Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman” and cited a “soaring number of mass executions, torture, enforced disappearance, severe restrictions on free expression, repression of women’s rights under the male guardianship system, LGBTI+ discrimination, and the killing of hundreds of migrants at the Saudi Arabia-Yemen border”.

“As expected, FIFA’s evaluation of Saudi Arabia’s World Cup bid is an astonishing whitewash of the country’s atrocious human rights record,” added Steve Cockburn, Amnesty International’s head of labour rights and sport. “There are no meaningful commitments that will prevent workers from being exploited, residents from being evicted or activists from being arrested.

“By ignoring the clear evidence of severe human rights risks, FIFA is likely to bear much responsibility for the violations and abuses that will take place over the coming decade. Fundamental human rights reforms are urgently required in Saudi Arabia, or the 2034 World Cup will be inevitably tarnished by exploitation, discrimination and repression.”

The FIFA bid evaluation, published on Saturday morning, leans heavily on the Clifford Chance report. It does not make any references to the terms “LGBTQI+”, “sexuality” or “sexual orientation”, while the only mention of women’s rights within Saudi Arabia can be found with references to the growth of the women’s game and women’s participation in football within Saudi.

The bid evaluation says that Saudi “has made significant strides in developing interest and grassroots participation for women and girls, and at the elite level”.


A model of Jeddah Central Development at the Saudi 2034 World Cup exhibition in Riyadh (Fayez Nureldine/AFP via Getty Images)

The bid, which ranks by low, medium or high, also gives a medium level of risk to stadiums, transport and accommodation, as well as the previously explained “event timing”. Stadiums are awarded a 4.1 rating out of five, despite eight of the proposed 15 stadiums for the tournament being new-builds. FIFA said this presented a “slightly elevated” risk profile.

The bid evaluation says the Saudi bid submitted commitments from the government to “respect, protect and fulfil internationally recognised human rights in connection with the competition, including in the areas of safety and security, labour rights (in particular fundamental labour rights and those of migrant workers), rights of children, gender equality and non-discrimination, as well as freedom of expression (including press freedom)”.

FIFA says the Saudis have committed to “equitable wages”, as well as “decent working and living conditions for all individuals involved in the preparation and delivery of the FIFA World Cup, including through the establishment of a workers’ welfare system to monitor compliance with labour rights standards for tournament-related workers”.

They also say the Saudis will “engage with the International Labour Organisation (ILO) in relation to its commitment to upholding international labour standards in all activities associated with the competition.” The treatment and rights of migrant workers were among the biggest talking points before and during the 2022 World Cup, staged in neighbouring Qatar.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

World Cup 2022 migrant worker diaries, one year on: Death, regret, joy and trying to return

FIFA simultaneously released its report for the sole bid for the 2030 World Cup, which will be held in Spain, Portugal, Morocco, Uruguay, Argentina and Paraguay. The 2030 bid, which does not have a rival, will also be voted on by the member nations on December 11. It also received a rating of 4.2 out of 5, with the only medium risk factors judged to be stadiums, accommodation, transport, and the legal framework of the tournament.

The “sustainable event management” and “environmental protection” of a competition held across three continents was judged to be a “low” risk.

The report says that the “environmental impact assessment and initial carbon footprint assessment by the bidder, together with the commitments, objectives and mitigation actions outlined, provide a good foundation for the development of effective strategies towards managing the negative impacts of the tournament on the planet and protecting the environment”.

(Top photo: Christopher Pike/Bloomberg via Getty Images)

Barcelona’s 125th anniversary: When their star striker was kidnapped for 23 days

Friday, November 29, 2024, marks the 125-year anniversary of the formation of FC Barcelona.

To mark the occasion, The Athletic is running a series of pieces, celebrating the people and the moments who have helped make the club what it is today.

We have told you about the story of Joan Gamper, the man who founded the club, and run through some of the most significant numbers in Barca’s history. Now, we look at the scarcely believable story of when their star striker, Quini, was kidnapped in 1981…


“Quini’s wife called me at four o’clock in the morning. She told me he hadn’t come home that night and that she hadn’t heard anything from him.”

Former Barcelona president Joan Gaspart is talking to The Athletic about one of the most unusual incidents in the club’s history.

It was Sunday, March 1, 1981, and Gaspart was vice-president. Barca had beaten Hercules 6-0 at the Camp Nou and La Liga’s top scorer Quini had provided two goals. Barca looked on course for the Spanish title — something that had not happened since 1973-74, in Johan Cruyff’s playing days and when Quini was scoring goals for Sporting Gijon instead.

There was a sense of euphoria in the city and among the players, who decided to go for dinner at a restaurant near the ground.

It was the restaurant Can Fuste, a 15-minute walk from Camp Nou. Everyone was waiting for the then 31-year-old star striker Quini, full name Enrique Castro Gonzalez — but he never arrived.

“There were seven or eight of us,” Carles Rexach — one of the players in the squad tells The Athletic. “(Barca centre-back and Quini’s close friend Jose Ramon) Alexanko met us and said he didn’t know where he was or where he had gone.”


Quini was one of Spanish football’s most famous players in the 1980s (FC Barcelona)

The last anyone had heard from Quini was a TV interview in which he spoke about their upcoming game against Atletico Madrid. Atletico were in first place, two points ahead of Barca and the game was crucial.

Mari Nieves, Quini’s wife, had flown back from Gijon that afternoon with her two children, as she did on many weekends. After the match, her husband stopped by the house to pick up his things before getting in his Ford Granada to head to Barcelona airport to pick her up.

“His wife (when he did not appear at the airport) had called several hospitals, police stations or any place where they might know something,” Gaspart says. “He didn’t show up. Nobody knew anything. We went to his house at five or six o’clock in the morning thinking, ‘Where could he be?’”

Gaspart, then-Barca president Josep Lluis Nunez and Alexanko spent the night at Nieves’ house and immediately called the police.

The next day, the report of Quini’s disappearance became official. The three men stayed with Nieves until she received a call that began to give her answers.

The case caused a stir across the country. It was reported in all the major media outlets and rumours began to spread about whether the Basque separatist group ETA had been involved after terrorising Spain with a number of attacks.

Nieves received the first of 21 calls from her husband’s kidnappers. It was not ETA but three people with no criminal record and no jobs who had tried to solve their financial problems by kidnapping one of the country’s biggest football stars and demanding a large ransom.

“The news spread like wildfire all over Barcelona,” Josep Maria Minguella, a former agent and a figure who has been closely linked to the club over the years, tells The Athletic.

“There was a lot of consternation. With ETA active, there were a lot of kidnappings at the time, but it had never happened to a player. It was reminiscent of what had happened to (Real Madrid legend Alfredo) Di Stefano a few years earlier (when he was kidnapped by Venezuelan guerrillas in 1963).”

As Rexach puts it 43 years later, “At first we thought it was a joke because it was unimaginable.”

On his way home from the airport, Quini had stopped to fill up his car when the three men suddenly assaulted him and forced him into the vehicle at gunpoint. They later abandoned the car and put Quini in a hood and wooden crate in a van and drove to Zaragoza, around a four-hour drive to the west of Barcelona.

There they transferred him to a hideout, where he spent 23 days locked up.

Quini had been top scorer five times in La Liga and had scored 73 goals across four seasons with Barcelona.

“He was one of the best players in Spain and was constantly in the media spotlight,” Rexach says. “They knew kidnapping him was going to have a big impact.”

“He was such a charismatic man and he was good to people,” Juan Carlos Perez Rojo, a player who was in the ‘B’ team but trained with Barca’s senior side, tells The Athletic. “They knew everyone was going to step up and give him the money he needed.” Rojo and Quini became friends some time after the kidnapping and he is into his 46th year at Barca, where he works as a scout.

“As a person he was very simple, a good person, kind,” says Minguella, who helped sign Quini from Sporting Gijon. “He didn’t deserve all the things that happened to him and his family. It’s one of those moments when you realise that life can be unfair.”


Quini with Nieves on the day of his release (Xavier Bonilla/NurPhoto via Getty Images)

It later emerged the kidnappers’ main target had been the then-Barcelona coach Helenio Herrera. When they found out he had a cold, they changed their plans as they feared he might die during the kidnapping.

In the days that followed, the police worked in secrecy.

“There was a lot of upheaval,” says Minguella. “The police controlled the situation and didn’t want too many people to intervene.”

“The police didn’t want people to get in the way, even if they wanted to help,” adds Rexach. “So they just let Alexanko be the one to help.”

Barcelona asked La Liga to postpone the match against Atletico that weekend. The Spanish top flight denied that request, Barca played and lost 1-0 at the Vicente Calderon, Atletico’s former home. The German midfielder Bernd Schuster, who threatened not to play, blamed Nunez and Herrera for the match going ahead.

“There were people who didn’t want to play until they found him and there was a bit of a struggle because the coach thought we had to play even if he wasn’t there,” says Rexach. “It was complicated.”

Barca played two more games with Quini still missing, losing 2-1 to Salamanca and drawing 0-0 with Real Zaragoza. They would finish four points behind champions Real Sociedad in fifth place.

“That year we didn’t win La Liga because we spent those three weeks just thinking about Quini,” Rexach says.

Meanwhile, the police continued to do their job. As calls from the kidnappers were made from phone boxes, they asked Telefonica, Spain’s leading telecoms company which owned them, to cooperate.

“The kidnappers went completely unnoticed,” Juan Martinez Ruiz, one of the 20 officers in charge of the case, later told Spanish magazine Libero. “That was the main reason it took so long to locate them. They had never broken a dish, they had no previous convictions, they were not related to criminals… They were absolutely normal.”

The police issued a statement appealing for the public to help and had to deal with an avalanche of false leads. Telefonica had trouble identifying the origin of the calls.

In one of their calls, the kidnappers told Nieves they were nervous because of how much Quini ate, given they no longer had enough money to buy sandwiches. They were demanding 100 million pesetas for his ransom (worth around €600,000 today), a figure that had risen from the original 70 million pesetas.

In one of the attempts to pay the kidnappers, the police asked Alexanko to go to La Jonquera, a Catalan town close to the French border, with a briefcase full of banknotes. The kidnappers asked him to cross the border, but the police refused because the French authorities would have arrested him on the spot.

On March 20, the three men asked the money to be paid into a Credit Suisse bank account.

“Barca were looking for solutions because the kidnappers were very absent-minded,” Minguella says. “Those who kidnapped him did not have very clear ideas about what ransom they wanted to ask for and were changing their strategy.

“Nunez’s secretary called me to find out if I had any way of getting money in Switzerland, where the kidnappers asked for the money to be deposited. I was doing business in Luxembourg and Switzerland and I had money there. I said yes and agreed to help with the payment.”

The bank account was in the name of one of the kidnappers, Victor Miguel Diaz Esteban. The Swiss police worked closely with their Spanish counterparts to track him down. Diaz Esteban went to Switzerland to withdraw one million pesetas in U.S. dollars on March 24; within 18 hours, the police had arrested him after finding the hotel where he was staying and following his steps when he left for the airport to catch a plane to Paris. He was interrogated and confessed to holding Quini in a basement in Zaragoza.

In less than a day, the police released him and arrested a second kidnapper.

Quini later told friends this was when he was most afraid because he heard a lot of noise and thought the kidnappers would kill him. But on the night of March 25, radios across Spain announced he had been freed.

When he arrived in Barcelona, a huge crowd was waiting for him at the police station — Quini had to go out to greet them.


The striker prepares to give a press conference after his release (FC Barcelona)

“When he came out he was in a very bad state, you could see it,” Rexach says. “All I know is that I gave him a hug. He was hidden in a place with no light for 23 days. It’s something you wouldn’t wish on your worst enemy.”

“He wanted to play and get back to normal as soon as possible,” Rojo says. “They gave him psychological support, I heard about it from team-mates some time later.”

Quini returned for the last four games of the La Liga season, playing again barely a week after his release, and was received with full honours at every ground he played at. He played 90 minutes in each of his first three league games after his return — scoring twice in a 5-2 win against Almeria — and still finished as La Liga’s top scorer with 20 goals. He also scored in both legs of the Copa del Rey semi-final and twice in the final against his boyhood side Sporting Gijon in the final as Barca lifted Spain’s national cup.

“On every pitch, when they said Quini’s name, there was five minutes of applause,” Rojo says. “He had a spectacular reception.”

The three kidnappers were sentenced to 10 years in prison and given a five million peseta fine.

“They were simple people, without great possibilities,” Quini told a press conference after his release. “They fed me with sandwiches because they couldn’t afford any more.”

“There were team-mates who made jokes after that,” Rojo says. “Sometimes, when we were in hotels after dinner when you go to the room, there were team-mates who would go into his wardrobe to scare him when he arrived.”

Quini spent three more seasons at Barcelona, finishing with 73 goals in 141 appearances for the Catalans. He then returned to Sporting Gijon in 1984, where he spent the last three years of his playing career. He worked as a coach, team delegate and director of institutional relations for them.

The kidnapping had a very real impact on Quini, who died of a heart attack aged 68 in 2018. He was given an emotional tribute by the Camp Nou, with a huge tifo unfurled that read ‘Quini, sempre recordat’ — Quini, always remembered.


The Camp Nou tribute to Quini after his death (Xavier Bonilla/NurPhoto via Getty Images)

“This affected him a lot throughout his life,” Rexach says. “He spent many days locked underground in a very small cell. He didn’t want to talk about it because every time he did, he relived the trauma.

“He did tell me that when he was fed by the kidnappers he sometimes kept (the food) to himself. He thought that if they hunted them down and killed them, it would be impossible for anyone to find him there and he would starve to death.

“He had those 23 days in his head until the day he died. People think he forgot it quickly, but he didn’t. When someone would ask him a question (about it), you’d see him change the subject very quickly.

“It’s the most unbelievable thing that has happened to Barca in its history.”

(Top photos: Getty Images; design: Eamonn Dalton)

When brain cancer struck a baseball family, a ‘wonderful’ village sheltered them

Ten months ago when the nights were longest, Ned Rice emailed total strangers to share his family’s unthinkable dilemma. These were doctors across the country who had not met and did not treat his 3-year-old daughter. Wynnie had brain cancer. This was how Rice, a Phillies assistant general manager, coped.

He had to gather as much information as he could.

“I have still to this day never googled medulloblastoma,” said Cary Rice, his wife. “Because I can’t handle it. And I’m an analytical thinker, too. But if it’s too emotional, I can’t do it.”

Everything about this felt impossible. Wynnie had lost her balance a few times — and now her parents faced a sudden and critical decision. Doctors at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia (CHOP) told the Rices they could not treat Wynnie with radiation; she was too young. The neurocognitive damage from radiation would prevent her from having an independent adult life. But her chances of survival were better with radiation.

Ned Rice sought a second opinion from another leading children’s hospital. They told him it would be reckless not to use the treatment known to be the best — radiation — no matter the long-term effects. Rice had negotiated player contracts worth hundreds of millions — a high-stakes process that blends objective valuations with a subjective hand. But this was so different.

It was a parent’s worst nightmare.

Then Rice saw an email. A neuro-oncologist at Cincinnati Children’s Hospital named Richard Graham sent a lengthy reply to one of Rice’s cold calls. “I was really panicking,” Rice said. “He doesn’t even know who I am. He has his own patients and his own life.” Graham shared his advice. He became a frequent resource for Rice.

These small, thoughtful moments accumulated.

An unexpected gift at the doorstep. A video from Wynnie’s classmates. More responses from out-of-town doctors who would never meet Wynnie. Family members and friends who dropped everything to care for her two siblings. More gifts. Nurses who did not just look after Wynnie — but her parents, too.

“It hits you over and over again,” Rice said. “There’s so many people that want to help. Everybody does it in their own way.”

Rice called his former boss. These weren’t like the late-night talks Matt Klentak and he often had while they ran baseball operations for the Phillies. But it felt normal, even though Klentak worked for the Milwaukee Brewers and Rice was on leave from the Phillies.

The phone calls were cathartic. They could dive right into whatever was on Rice’s mind because Klentak knew the latest on Wynnie through an Instagram account the Rices created to chronicle her fight against cancer. It’s grown to more than 700 followers. Friends of friends of friends now reply to posts with, “Go Wynnie go!” The account is a raw look into life with pediatric cancer. It’s become a way for Ned and Cary to express complicated feelings.

More than anything, it’s opened a door. “Caregiver burnout is a common phenomenon,” said Jane Minturn, Wynnie’s neuro-oncologist at CHOP, “and (Ned and Cary) have worked together to limit this.” Wynnie knows she is sick, but she does not understand what brain cancer is. The burden is shared by everyone around her.

It is immense. Klentak could sense it, at times, during those late-night conversations. It is isolating. But Rice started to carry the goodness of those who had entered Wynnie’s universe.

“I couldn’t really relate to what he was going through,” Klentak said. “And I think very few people could. But that doesn’t stop people from wanting to help.”


The first sign of distress wasn’t alarming. Wynnie was a happy and healthy 3-year-old learning to move faster. That meant an occasional stumble. But Ned and Cary noticed their daughter’s balance wasn’t improving; it looked a fraction worse every week. They scheduled an appointment last December with their pediatrician.

He threw cotton balls across the room to Wynnie, who was content to play the game. She had to bend over and fetch them. She wobbled. The pediatrician agreed something seemed off. He wanted her to see a neurologist at CHOP. The next appointment wasn’t for five months. He suggested the Rices go to the CHOP emergency room — not because it was urgent, but to assuage any immediate concerns.

They took Wynnie on Dec. 21, 2023.

“Sure enough,” Rice said, “we had five neurologists in our room in a few minutes.”

Wynnie didn’t have any other symptoms. The doctors scheduled an MRI in three weeks. It could be a muscular disease. Maybe it was vertigo. The Rices visited family for Christmas and Wynnie vomited twice. CHOP rescheduled the MRI for Dec. 29 and, that morning, Wynnie threw up again. She stumbled a few more times.

A doctor summoned Ned and Cary during the MRI. He pointed to a screen. There was a large tumor in Wynnie’s brain. Wynnie was sedated for the MRI. The doctors wanted to do immediate surgery to remove the tumor. It was 4 p.m. on the Friday of a holiday weekend. The procedure lasted four hours; it would take a week to know whether the tumor was cancerous.

Everything had spiraled so fast.

“It’s a long process, but that was definitely a low point,” Rice said. “Those first few days — you took a mostly happy, healthy, sweet girl in for an outpatient MRI. She wakes up and you’re just like, ‘Will we ever see that girl again?’ That was really hard.”

Then Wynnie was diagnosed with medulloblastoma.


Cary lies with Wynnie in the CHOP ICU four days after her brain surgery. Wynnie still could not move or talk. (Courtesy of the Rice family)

During that first trip to the E.R., before everything escalated, Rice was on the phone with Dave Dombrowski. Yoshinobu Yamamoto’s camp had instructed teams to make their last and best offers for the star free agent. Dombrowski communicated the number to Rice, who relayed it to Joel Wolfe, Yamamoto’s agent. Yamamoto signed with the Los Angeles Dodgers that night.

Rice did not mention where he was.

The day Wynnie underwent surgery, Rice called Phillies general manager Sam Fuld. He told him what was happening. Dombrowski was out of the country for a rare vacation; Rice talked to the Phillies’ president of baseball operations soon after New Year’s.

“We’ll see you when it’s over,” Dombrowski told him. “Take everything you need. We’ll completely cover it. Don’t worry about anything.”

John Middleton called a few hours later. The Phillies’ principal owner offered to connect the family with doctors. Cary is a lawyer and her firm, Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller, told her to take as much time as she needed. The Rices were fortunate; they had the means to pay for treatment and ample time to direct attention toward Wynnie. Acquaintances offered to help with whatever the family needed, but what they needed was a cure for cancer.

All they wanted was normal. It was an uncomfortable situation that didn’t always have to be uncomfortable.

“We just have this wonderful sort of village that kept showing up,” Cary said. “Kept calling. Kept texting. Even when I couldn’t respond. We’re just really grateful for that because we are still the same people. We still want to talk about things and do things that have nothing to do with cancer. We want to feel normal. We want to have hope for a normal future. The worst thing you can do or say is nothing.”


Wynnie sits on a bed at CHOP between cycles of her treatment. (Courtesy of the Rice family)

Wynnie lived on the third floor at CHOP for almost eight months. The Rices opted against radiation. But her treatment — alternating cycles of chemotherapy and autologous stem cell transplants — was so grueling that most of it was inpatient. Ned and Cary would take 24-hour shifts with Wynnie. They were ships passing in the night without much interaction.

They found a community inside the hospital.

“These nurses, I mean, they’re not just nurses,” Cary said. “They’re therapists. They’re friends. They’re cheerleaders.”

Heidi Turner, one of Wynnie’s nurses, worked only overnights. That meant a lot of late-night bonding. Wynnie was discharged Aug. 23. The last night at CHOP, Turner handed Cary a letter to Wynnie.

“I’m going to miss you so much,” Cary said to Turner. “We’ll stop by and hopefully I’ll see you.”

She stared at Cary. The nurse replied she hoped to never see them again.

“And,” Cary said, “it just stuck with me because it’s such a weird feeling to have.”


Rice, who has been with the Phillies since 2016, stayed in contact with player agents and rival team executives last offseason but no longer served as the team’s main point of contact. The Phillies had started negotiating Zack Wheeler’s three-year, $126 million extension with B.B. Abbott, Wheeler’s agent at Wasserman. By January, Rice and Abbott had regular talks that started with 30 minutes about Wynnie and progressed to Wheeler’s contract.

“You’re never what you want to be for these families that are trying to talk about this,” Abbott said. “Because you just can’t be. It’s so all-consuming when you think, ‘My 3-year-old daughter has to go through this.’ It’s hard for parents and families to get their heads around exactly what’s getting ready to happen. The days and nights and hospitals. Watching their little girl lose her hair and be sick. All of this stuff that I knew was getting ready to come.”

For years, Abbott has raised awareness for pediatric cancer research through the Rally Foundation and the National Pediatric Cancer Foundation. “I just wanted to be more of a sounding board for him,” Abbott said. The Rices weren’t keeping Wynnie’s illness hidden; it was more of an open secret. Abbott decided to help subtly.

He asked Wheeler if he’d lend his name to a fundraiser for the National Pediatric Cancer Foundation near the end of spring training at the Phillies’ complex in Clearwater, Fla. Everyone knew it was for Wynnie, but no one had to say it. Word spread to the team’s front office and support staff. Dozens of Phillies employees had their heads shaved or orange streaks painted in their hair. Players made donations to the foundation.

Reliever Matt Strahm’s wife, Megan, organized a present from the Phillies’ wives and girlfriends. “An unbelievable, huge, outrageous gift wagon for Wynnie,” Rice said. He had not met Strahm’s wife until later that summer at the team’s family day.

“You’re amazing,” Rice said to her.

With Wynnie in the hospital, Rice watched from afar this year as the Phillies sprinted to first place. “The Banatic!” Wynnie said to her dad whenever the furry green mascot appeared on the screen. There are certain rhythms to the baseball season. It is monotonous but contains specific checkpoints. The Rices had none of that with Wynnie. There were no regular updates on her prognosis. They will not know how successful her treatments were until a scan sometime in December.

Their focus was singular. Get through today.

“Wynnie, she’s something,” Cary said. “She has this tiny little voice and she’s so sweet and gentle with everything she does. We always kind of considered her this little delicate flower. But she’s a beast.”



Wynnie at her 4th birthday party. (Ashley Blair Photography)

Two weeks ago, Wynnie had a birthday party. The Rices held it outdoors, at a playground by the Schuylkill River Park, because Wynnie’s immune system remains at risk. They had bagels and coffee and a face painter. Cary handed every kid a stuffed fox as a party favor. “Mr. Fox” was Wynnie’s constant companion in the hospital; Cary had so many at the house because people kept sending them when Wynnie would throw up on hers.

This was a celebration of Wynnie and the village that formed around her.

“We were surrounded,” Cary said, “by about 85 of the friends who have been there for us in so many different ways this year.”

Wynnie’s hair has started to grow back, although she wore a purple knit cap that covered her head at her party. Everyone could see the three purple flowers painted on her forehead.

But Wynnie felt sick near the end of the party. She went to the emergency room with croup. Another challenge. But she was 4 and she was here.

She wore her face paint to the E.R.

(Top image: Dan Goldfarb / The Athletic. Photos: Ashley Blair Photography) 

College Football Playoff at-large contenders: Cases for, against and fatal flaws

As the season approaches its final two weeks, jostling for at-large bids continues for teams in the upper echelon of College Football Playoff competition.

At this point, there are teams with CFP hopes both as a conference champion and as an at-large. There are others, such as Big 12 contenders BYU and Colorado, which need to win their conference to reach the Playoff. The same scenario exists for Group of 5 squads Boise State and Tulane.

For the teams strictly in at-large contention, what are the cases for their inclusion and what are the flaws that could keep them from the 12-team tournament? Below we examine 16 teams with at-large hopes — not just the 16 highest-ranked teams — and examine why they are worthy of at-large consideration while breaking down their flaws.

No. 1 Oregon (11-0)

By the numbers – Sagarin SOS (strength of schedule): 52; Record vs. FBS winning teams: 4-0; Record vs. FBS non-winning teams: 6-0; Points for: 33.9; Points against: 15.7.

Case for: The Ducks are the nation’s only unbeaten team, have ranked wins against Ohio State, Boise State and Illinois and compete in a coast-to-coast conference. At this stage, Oregon deserves the No. 1 ranking without debate.

Fatal flaw: This is more of a concern moving forward. Had Ohio State quarterback Will Howard slid a second earlier and called a timeout against Oregon, the Buckeyes might have kicked a game-winning field goal in Eugene. The teams are likely to meet in Indianapolis for the Big Ten championship. Should Oregon fall, the Ducks could face Boise State again in the CFP, and they won that game on a last-second field goal. Rematches against motivated opponents could pose challenges.

No. 2 Ohio State (10-1)

By the numbers – Sagarin SOS: 58; Record vs. FBS winning teams: 5-1; Record vs. FBS non-winning teams: 5-0; Points for: 37.8; Points against: 10.7.

Case for: The Buckeyes have the talent at every position to compete with any team in the country. They boast two NFL-caliber running backs and the nation’s top defense. Howard has completed 80 percent of his passes in six different games, and receivers Emeka Egbuka, Jeremiah Smith and Carnell Tate are an electrifying trio. On a neutral field, this team could win it all.

Fatal flaw: There are times the Buckeyes look ordinary, like in a 21-17 home win against Nebraska. Injuries to Ohio State’s top two offensive linemen could have consequences against a physical, athletic front. Howard has competed at a high level this year, but can he make the game-winning plays in a close contest against similar talent?

GO DEEPER

Predicting College Football Playoff rankings after Week 13: How far will Indiana fall?

No. 3 Texas (10-1)

By the numbers – Sagarin SOS: 39; Record vs. FBS winning teams: 7-1; Record vs. FBS non-winning teams: 3-0; Points for: 37.8; Points against: 12.1.

Case for: Texas can match up with anyone player-for-player. The Longhorns have the SEC’s top scoring defense and rank second nationally in total defense. They have an experienced quarterback in Quinn Ewers, elite players at every position and showed their grit by losing only one game so far in their first SEC season.

Fatal flaw: The Longhorns don’t own a victory over a current Top 25 team. They avoided Alabama, Ole Miss, Tennessee and South Carolina and they lost decisively to Georgia. That doesn’t take away their intent; the Longhorns traveled to defending national champion Michigan and won 31-19. But questions persist about how Texas will perform against fellow elite programs because they haven’t faced more than one entering this week’s showdown against Texas A&M.

By the numbers – Sagarin SOS: 37; Record vs. FBS winning teams: 6-1; Record vs. FBS non-winning teams: 4-0; Points for: 32.4; Points against: 14.6.

Case for: The Nittany Lions have handled their business in fine fashion. They survived at tough road venues like USC, Minnesota, Wisconsin and West Virginia with big plays in critical moments. Penn State has an underrated quarterback in Drew Allar, the nation’s best tight end in Tyler Warren and a top-five NFL Draft pick in edge rusher Abdul Carter. The Nittany Lions can adapt to different styles and weather won’t be a factor.

Fatal flaw: There are two big questions facing Penn State. One, can their wide receivers gain enough separation against an equally talented opponent? Two, can coach James Franklin string together multiple wins against top-10 competition? In Franklin’s 11 years, the Nittany Lions are 3-17 against top-10 opponents with only one victory in the last eight seasons.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

‘On our terms’: Inside Penn State’s season-saving drive with 3 fourth-down conversions

By the numbers – Sagarin SOS: 65; Record vs. FBS winning teams: 6-1; Record vs. FBS non-winning teams: 4-0; Points for: 39.0; Points against: 11.6.

Case for: Few, if any, teams have looked more impressive than Notre Dame in the last two months. Only once have the Irish allowed more than 16 points in a game, and they’ve scored at least 31 points in each of their last seven games. Quarterback Riley Leonard has become an elite playmaker and Notre Dame’s line of scrimmage play can hang with any opponent.

Fatal flaw: The Irish have ranked wins against Texas A&M and Army away from home, but their overall schedule was light. Notre Dame’s 16-14 loss to Northern Illinois has served as a lightning rod for criticism. For the Irish the scenario is simple: beat USC and pick up a home CFP game. Lose to the Trojans and probably fall from CFP consideration.

No. 6 Miami (10-1)

By the numbers – Sagarin SOS: 61; Record vs. FBS winning teams: 5-1; Record vs. FBS non-winning teams: 4-0; Points for: 44.7; Points against: 22.3.

Case for: The Hurricanes average more points than any team in CFP contention. With quarterback Cam Ward, Miami can fill it up. In five different games, the Hurricanes have scored at least 50 points.

Fatal flaw: No at-large contender allows more points per game than Miami at 22.3. The Hurricanes frequently have been involved in one-score games against unranked opponents and have needed late rallies to win. Miami has yet to play a Top 25 team, let alone beat one.


Miami will finish the regular season on the road against Syracuse on Saturday. (Sam Navarro / Imagn Images)

By the numbers – Sagarin SOS: 4; Record vs. FBS winning teams: 4-2; Record vs. FBS non-winning teams: 4-0; Points for: 33.2; Points against: 14.6.

Case for: Nobody has more quality wins than Georgia, which beat CFP contenders Clemson, Texas and Tennessee. When operating at a high level, the Bulldogs look like an eventual champion. They have a veteran quarterback and talent that jumps off the roster. Despite a loss at Alabama, their furious comeback attempt will scare any future opponent.

Fatal flaw: Which version of Carson Beck will take the field in the CFP? He’s thrown 12 interceptions and three picks in three different games, including in a loss to Alabama and a win against Texas. In a game between equally matched opponents, how Beck performs could enhance – or harm – Georgia’s performance.

No. 8 Tennessee (9-2)

By the numbers – Sagarin SOS: 57; Record vs. FBS winning teams: 3-2; Record vs. FBS non-winning teams: 5-0; Points for: 37.4; Points against: 13.1.

Case for: The Vols can play any style of football and compete. They rank second in the SEC in both points scored and points allowed. Running back Dylan Sampson is one of the nation’s three best running backs and sophomore quarterback Nico Iamaleava displays some dynamic qualities.

Fatal flaw: Outside of beating Alabama, the Vols have an ordinary resume. None of their nonconference opponents are bowl eligible, and they lost to 6-5 Arkansas in Fayetteville. It’s why Tennessee hovered outside the CFP before Ole Miss and Alabama suffered losses last weekend.

No. 9 SMU (10-1)

By the numbers – Sagarin SOS: 59; Record vs. FBS winning teams: 5-1; Record vs. FBS non-winning teams: 4-0; Points for: 39.3; Points against: 21.0.

Case for: SMU’s ACC debut has been flawless with nary a loss despite a reduced revenue share. The Mustangs are one victory shy of running the table and advancing to the ACC title game. All-everything running back Brashard Smith was critical in wins against Duke and Pittsburgh.

Fatal flaw: An early loss to BYU lingers but not in the way most people expected back in September. With SEC teams slipping after their third loss, heightened scrutiny awaits SMU this weekend against Cal and in a potential ACC title game. It’s worth watching SMU’s defense, which has allowed at least 25 points to every bowl-eligible opponent since its BYU loss.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

How SMU has developed the nastiest defense in the ACC

By the numbers – Sagarin SOS: 68; Record vs. FBS winning teams: 3-1; Record vs. FBS non-winning teams: 6-0; Points for: 41.3; Points against: 16.0.

Case for: The eye test and statistics favor Indiana. The Hoosiers have an electrifying offense led by quarterback Kurtis Rourke and five receivers with at least 24 catches, 280 yards and three touchdowns. Indiana also plays high-level defense, which is unusual for a portal-based team.

Fatal flaw: As of today, Indiana has beaten three FBS teams with winning records but that could fall to zero by Saturday. Its strength of schedule is by far the lowest of any power conference team vying for an at-large bid. In the Hoosiers’ only game against a ranked opponent, they lost 38-15 to Ohio State.

No. 12 Clemson (9-2)

By the numbers – Sagarin SOS: 62; Record vs. FBS winning teams: 1-2; Record vs. FBS non-winning teams: 7-0; Points for: 37.6; Points against: 22.0.

Case for: In all but one of its victories, Clemson won by double figures. It has a potent offense guided by quarterback Cade Klubnik, who has 29 touchdowns and four interceptions. The Tigers are third in the ACC in both scoring offense and scoring defense.

Fatal flaw: Clemson has the most pedestrian resume of any potential at-large squad. It has played just three FBS teams with winning records and won just once, and that was last week against 7-4 Pittsburgh. The Tigers give up nearly 23 points a game, the second-most of any team in the CFP Top 25.

No. 13 Alabama (8-3)

By the numbers – Sagarin SOS: 7; Record vs. FBS winning teams: 6-3; Record vs. FBS non-winning teams: 1-0; Points for: 36.2; Points against: 17.5.

Case for: In the first half against Georgia or throughout its victories against LSU and Missouri, Alabama looked like not only a CFP team but a title contender. Nine of its 11 FBS opponents have winning records, including seven of eight SEC opponents.

Fatal flaw: It really starts and ends with the win-loss record. Losing three games would end CFP hopes for nearly every other program save for Alabama. The Tide dropped games to Vanderbilt and Oklahoma, both of which are 6-5. It’s not impossible to build a case for Alabama’s inclusion, but it involves losses by multiple teams this weekend rather than for the Tide to simply beat Auburn.

No. 14 Ole Miss (8-3)

By the numbers – Sagarin SOS: 31; Record vs. FBS winning teams: 5-2; Record vs. FBS non-winning teams: 2-1; Points for: 38.5; Points against: 13.9.

Case for: Just watch the Rebels in action. It’s a potent offense led by Jaxson Dart and Tre Harris, capable of putting up points on everyone. Ole Miss crushed Georgia 28-10 and scored 63 points on Arkansas, which held Tennessee to 14. The defense has NFL-caliber performers, especially along the line.

Fatal flaw: Not only do Mississippi’s three losses make it difficult to climb into the CFP, but it’s also who beat the Rebels. None of the three teams are ranked by the committee with LSU (7-4) posting the best record. Losing at home to Kentucky (4-7) is probably the kill shot.


Ole Miss’ loss to Florida last week dropped the Rebels’ Playoff chances to 9 percent, per The Athletic’s model. (Matt Pendleton / Imagn Images)

No. 15 South Carolina (8-3)

By the numbers – Sagarin SOS: 18; Record vs. FBS winning teams: 4-3; Record vs. non-winning FBS teams: 3-0; Points for: 32.9; Points against: 18.2.

Case for: Of the 8-3 teams hovering in the SEC’s second tier, the Gamecocks won the important head-to-head battles against Texas A&M and Missouri. South Carolina has one of college football’s most dominant defensive lines with 39 sacks. Its offensive efficiency is impressive.

Fatal flaw: This is the season of “almosts” for South Carolina. Two touchdowns were called back against LSU because of penalties and a failed two-point conversion cost the Gamecocks an overtime opportunity against Alabama. Barring a chaotic scenario rivaling 2007, South Carolina “almost” will get into the CFP.

By the numbers – Sagarin SOS: 33; Record vs. winning teams: 3-1; Record vs. non-winning teams: 6-1; Points for: 30.5; Points against: 22.8.

Case for: Arizona State has posted its two most impressive wins in the last two weeks, beating Kansas State 24-14 on the road before toppling BYU 28-23 at home. The Sun Devils, who are led by versatile running back Cam Skattebo, have churned out five wins by a touchdown or less.

Fatal flaw: The Sun Devils have a 7.7-point differential, which is by far the lowest of any potential at-large team. Their losses came against 7-4 Texas Tech and 5-6 Cincinnati, and they’ve played only four teams with winning records.

By the numbers – Sagarin SOS: 40; Record vs. winning teams: 4-1; Record vs. non-winning teams: 4-1; Points for: 31.4; Points against: 19.5.

Case for: The Cyclones are resilient, as demonstrated by three come-from-behind victories in the closing seconds. Iowa State has the Big 12’s best pass defense, which ranks third overall. Their receiving combination of Jayden Higgins and Jaylin Noel has compiled nearly 2,000 yards and 13 touchdowns.

Fatal flaw: Iowa State steadily climbed the rankings until losing two straight to Texas Tech and Kansas (5-6). The Cyclones don’t own any Top 25 wins, and their depleted defense has given up more than 230 rushing yards in three of their last five games.

(Top photo: Johnnie Izquierdo / Getty Images))

The PWHL pulled off its inaugural season. Year 2 will decide the future of women’s pro hockey

Marie-Philip Poulin stood on the blue line at the Bell Centre, fighting back tears.

She had just been introduced to a world record crowd in Montreal and the fans were giving her a deafening ovation. Poulin, the best women’s hockey player in the world for almost a decade, typically gets the loudest pregame cheer, especially in her home province of Quebec. But this applause — over 20 seconds long and delivered by 21,105 people — was different.

“Honestly, I didn’t know what to do, how to react, the emotions were so high,” Poulin said. “Having the Bell Centre packed for women’s hockey … it (felt like) we finally made it.”

That April 20 game broke the all-time attendance record for women’s hockey, one of many milestones for the inaugural Professional Women’s Hockey League season. Since its launch in January 2024, the long-awaited six-team league featuring the world’s best players has largely been heralded as a success. Millions of viewers tuned in for games; attendance records were repeatedly set and broken; and demand for tickets in some markets was so high that teams have already moved into bigger venues. Just last month, the league announced that it was preparing for expansion as soon as the 2025-26 season — sooner than anticipated.

But there were bumps along the way, and with the arrival of the PWHL’s second season, which begins on Saturday, big-picture questions loom. Now that the league is no longer sparkling brand new, can it maintain positive momentum? And what needs to happen to set the PWHL up for long-term success?


Five days into the PWHL’s inaugural season, Stan Kasten had seen enough.

Kasten was on a tour around the league, making stops at most teams’ home openers during the first week of the season. He visited Toronto for the first PWHL game on Jan. 1, attended a sell-out in Ottawa the next day, and watched games in New York and Boston.

Then Kasten got to Minnesota for the team’s home opener, which set a women’s pro hockey attendance record with over 13,000 fans at the Xcel Energy Center.

“That was the day I knew this was going to work,” Kasten said.

The longtime sports executive and president of the Los Angeles Dodgers became a central figure in women’s hockey after Dodgers majority owner Mark Walter and his wife, Kimbra, agreed to bankroll a new professional women’s hockey league.

The PWHL came together in a six-month sprint. Six markets and venues were chosen. A 72-game schedule was assembled. General managers and coaches and league staff were hired; players were signed and drafted. With so little time, teams played without traditional names, logos or jerseys.

“I will look back in amazement that we did it,” Kasten said. “We set the six months as our goal. … I was too dumb to know it wasn’t possible.”

The inaugural game on Jan. 1, between Toronto and New York, was sold out, albeit at Toronto’s 2,600-seat venue. Tennis legend Billie Jean King — who sits on the league’s advisory board — dropped the ceremonial puck alongside PWHL senior vice president of hockey operations Jayna Hefford. The game reached over 3 million views on Canadian television networks and the league’s YouTube stream.

“It was that moment where you’re like, ‘my childhood dream is coming true,’” said Toronto defender Jocelyne Larocque. “I had tears in my eyes because as a kid, my dream was to play pro hockey. And then, as you get a bit older, you think because I’m a woman, this isn’t going to happen for me.”

The next day, the league broke an attendance record for a women’s professional hockey game in Ottawa with over 8,000 fans at TD Place Arena. That was the record Minnesota smashed only four days later.


Fans packed the Tsongas Center in Lowell, Mass., for a Minnesota-Boston PWHL game during the first week of the league’s inaugural season. (Maddie Meyer / Getty Images)

The honeymoon phase didn’t end after the first few weeks of the season either. The league set a world record for attendance in Toronto (19,285) in February at Scotiabank Arena, which was broken two months later at the Bell Centre when Poulin received the ovation.

Overall, the league beat its own modest attendance projections for the inaugural year. According to Kasten, the internal projection was around 1,000 fans per game. The actual figure — over 5,000 — is a major accomplishment considering that previous women’s hockey leagues mostly struggled at the gate.

“Going into this season, no one really knew what to expect. We knew that we had a product that was worth watching and that we were going to do the best we could to showcase women’s hockey,” said Toronto goalie Kristen Campbell. “The fan support (exceeded) my expectations.”

Games throughout the season were uptempo, highly skilled and surprisingly physical. They were also easy to watch, since every game was available on YouTube for free — with high-quality broadcast production paid for by the league.

“I just don’t think a lot of people understood the skill level and the athleticism of these players,” said Ottawa GM Mike Hirshfeld. “And I think once they saw that, it became really attractive.”

The league landed several partnerships with major brands — such as Air Canada, Scotiabank, Bauer and Barbie — and worked with the NHL, going to All-Star Weekend and playing two neutral-site games at NHL venues in Pittsburgh and Detroit.

But the inaugural season was far from perfect.

PWHL merchandise flew off the shelves despite a lack of team names or logos, but the rollout was criticized because of supply issues and the limited size ranges.

The New York franchise played in three different rinks and struggled to draw fans, finishing with the worst attendance in the league. One game in Bridgeport, Conn., had only 728 fans — the league’s only game with fewer than 1,000 all season.

And just nine days after Minnesota won the first-ever Walter Cup, the league announced it was parting ways with the team’s general manager, Natalie Darwitz, “effective immediately.”

Some reports suggested there was a rift between Darwitz — a legend of Minnesota hockey and now a Hockey Hall of Fame inductee — and head coach Ken Klee, with some influential players siding with Klee. However, the league maintained the decision came after a review of the team’s operations that found “there wasn’t a path forward with the current personnel in place.”

Still, when the PWHL hosted the 2024 draft and awards in St. Paul, Minn., four days after Darwitz departed, fans were dispirited. Klee, who was responsible for the team’s draft picks, was booed at points during the night. He was also heavily criticized for selecting Britta Curl, who stirred controversy in the weeks leading up to the draft for her social media activity.

When asked about Darwitz’s departure this month, Minnesota captain Kendall Coyne Schofield said it was a league decision. Klee, meanwhile, said the team was focused on moving on.

“It’s pro hockey. Things happen,” he said. “We’re excited to get the season going.”


Kendall Coyne Schofield raised the Walter Cup after Minnesota won the PWHL’s inaugural league championship. (Troy Parla / Getty Images)

If the PWHL’s first season was about celebrating the league’s existence, its sophomore year, just days away, will focus on maintaining momentum while remaining in startup mode.

“We are far from a finished product,” said Kasten.

The league has taken several positive steps in its first real offseason.

In September, it unveiled team names and logos; jerseys were released earlier this month. The coinciding merchandise offerings have included more design options and size ranges.

New York has moved into a single primary venue — the Prudential Center in Newark, N.J., where the team played in front of its biggest crowd (5,132) last season — while Toronto and Montreal have moved into bigger venues full-time.

“We always hoped and planned to be in bigger buildings, but I don’t think we expected it so quickly,” said Hefford. “But that demand was real and it wasn’t just a blip. It wasn’t just inaugural-year excitement. And we’re seeing that in the response from fans this year in terms of ticket sales and memberships.”

Even with an 8,150 capacity at Coca-Cola Coliseum, Toronto’s season-ticket memberships sold out for a second year in a row. And Kasten said the league expects average attendance to increase.

The PWHL will also play nine neutral-site games, mostly in NHL buildings including Seattle, Vancouver, Denver and St. Louis.

“It’s a reinforcement of what we perceive as widespread and growing interest around our sport,” he said of the neutral-site games. “I can’t say it enough times, these women, these world-class athletes who have been overlooked for so long, are finally seeing the recognition they should have been receiving for years and years.”

Perhaps the biggest development of the offseason is that the league is already looking to add up to two teams as soon as 2025-26. Last season, league leadership often tried to head off questions about expansion but Kasten said the success of Year 1 convinced league leaders to start the process sooner.

“I don’t know if we do it,” he said. “But we’re looking at it because the interest is really there.”

The league has sent out over 20 requests for proposals to interested potential expansion partners, said Amy Scheer, the PWHL’s senior vice president of business operations.

A major driver of PWHL expansion is the influx of international players. In June, over a dozen international players — from Finland, Sweden, Russia, Czechia and more — were drafted, alongside dozens more players from the NCAA. That so many players have decided to make the jump to North America is an encouraging sign. Most top players elected to stay in Europe last season and track the new league’s progress from afar.

“It became more clear what the league is going to look like and so now, I feel like everybody is trying to get a spot here,” said Team Germany forward Laura Kluge, who was invited to Toronto’s training camp after going undrafted in June. “The goal is to come here and play because (it’s) the most professional league out there.”

One of the major critiques of the PWHL last season was that — with the seven-team Premier Hockey Federation shutting down in June 2023 — the ecosystem for women’s hockey in North America became too small, with very few roster spots and development opportunities. Expansion would fix that without diluting the product, given how much talent should be coming from Europe and the NCAA over the next two years.

How expansion might work still remains to be seen. All six current PWHL teams, as well as the league itself, are owned by the Walters.

The single-entity ownership model was critical, Kasten said, to the league getting up and running as quickly as it did. But the question remains: Will the business eventually outgrow unilateral control?

Women’s hockey has attempted individual ownership in the past. The original National Women’s Hockey League folded, in part, because owners stopped seeing the value in investing. The PHF sold some teams, but the league’s main financial backers — John and Johanna Boynton — still owned four of the league’s seven teams.

“I love how it has worked for us so far. I don’t know when that model stops being the most efficient, if ever,” Kasten said. “Could that change in the future? I suppose it could, but we don’t have any plans to change it now.”

For all the progress made during this offseason, there are some longer-term benchmarks left.

The PWHL does not have the kind of media rights deals that are traditional in men’s pro sports, and those more recently signed in women’s professional basketball and soccer.

“Let’s face it, until we get a mature media plan and media revenue we won’t really be a full-fledged league,” said Kasten.

Last season, every game was broadcast on the league’s YouTube channel. This season, however, Canadian audiences won’t have access to the PWHL’s YouTube stream. Those streaming rights are now exclusive to the league’s Canadian broadcast partners, which include TSN, CBC and Amazon Prime. U.S. broadcast rights have not been announced. Pulling games off YouTube in Canadian markets is a hit to access and visibility, but the league is expected to make more money from an increase in rights fees.

“The change is positive for the league because it helps us grow in terms of stability,” Scheer said. “It helps us grow to ensure that the league is on the path to long term health and that women’s hockey will be here for good.”

The biggest challenge for the league is going to be the wage gap that exists between top players and those who make up the majority of each team’s roster, due to how the collective-bargaining agreement set player compensation and roster construction.

In Year 1, the top six players on each team were required to make at least $80,000 on guaranteed three-year contracts, per the CBA. Meanwhile, the league minimum was set at $35,000, which will increase by 3 percent to $36,050 in 2024-25. Many players’ salaries are closer to league minimum on non-guaranteed contracts. And given how much of the salary cap has already been allotted to top players, incoming players — or free agents deserving of raises — will be feeling the squeeze until those contracts expire after the 2025-26 season.

It’s a trickier problem to fix with the CBA locked in until July 31, 2031. But it’s something the league will inevitably be judged on if the business continues to grow.

Despite all these questions, perhaps the biggest change in Year 2 will be a focus not so much on milestones and records but more on the game itself.

“There were a lot of firsts last year and a lot of emotional moments — moments that were bigger than hockey,” said Poulin. “This year is about making it normal that we play in bigger buildings that sell out, that people are excited (to be there). And now we’re just going to play hockey because that’s our job.”

(Illustration: Meech Robinson / The Athletic. Photos: Mark Blinch, Minas Panagiotakis, Bruce Bennett / Getty Images; Kevin Sousa / NHLI via Getty Images; M. Anthony Nesmith / Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

How tennis players and tennis coaches choose each other: ‘The most important thing is trust’

How does one of the best male players in tennis history choose a new coach?

Pick somebody who has been there with you — and who you beat to get there. Novak Djokovic’s decision to hire Andy Murray for at least the Australian Open has renewed interest in one of the most interesting psychological relationships in sport: The tennis player and their coach.

Djokovic has always sought out a coach who has scaled the mountain he chose, hiring Boris Becker, Andre Agassi and Goran Ivanisevic throughout his career, all of them, like Murray, former Wimbledon champions and multiple major winners, Ivanisevic apart. He needs the voice of someone who he respects and who is happy to have it out with him mid-match — until they aren’t. A few months after Djokovic and Ivanisevic parted ways in March this year, six seasons and 12 major titles in the bank, Ivanisevic explained that they simply ran out of patience with each other.

Djokovic’s decision comes on the back of a reshuffle at the top of the WTA Tour, with world No. 2 Iga Swiatek, world No. 3 Coco Gauff, world No. 6 Elena Rybakina and four-time Grand Slam champion Naomi Osaka all firing and then hiring in the wake of the U.S. Open in a bid to renew their games, work on technique, strengthen relationships, gain an edge — or rather, a mix of all these things that is unique to each player’s priorities and each coach’s way of working. That mix can win titles and inspire careers, but it had better work, with players and their teams on the road together and working at close quarters for practically the entire year.

“I imagine that if I had a family and kids, I would not be here at all,” world No. 18 Marta Kostyuk’s coach Sandra Zaniewska said in an interview with The Athletic earlier this year.

A technical master or a sideline hype master? A proven champion or a developing prospect? Players and coaches alike have myriad decisions to make in choosing each other.

GO DEEPER

Murray named Djokovic’s coach for Australian Open


There are all sorts of factors that go into choosing a coach. Sometimes players want to work on something technical, whether a shot or a surface. Three-time Grand Slam champion Stan Wawrinka brought in former Wimbledon champion Richard Kraijeck in 2016 to improve his grass-court tennis; Roger Federer and Murray did the same thing for clay with Jose Higueras and Alex Corretja respectively.

Djokovic hired Ivanisevic — who is now with Rybakina — in part to improve his serve, increasing its fluency and turning Djokovic into one of the most feared and precise servers in the sport in the early 2020s. In search of a better net game, Djokovic employed Australian player Mark Woodforde, who won 11 Grand Slam doubles titles with fellow ‘Woody’ Mark Woodbridge; he hired former U.S. Open finalist Todd Martin to work on his serve earlier in his career with less successful results.

Technical changes were the main motivation behind Gauff’s decision to split with Brad Gilbert, with whom she won the U.S. Open in 2023. Gilbert coached Gauff to deflect the vulnerabilities in her serve and forehand by turning matches into battles of defense and attrition; he would tell her to hit her forehand with a slow, looping arc to neutralize attacks. When opponents figured this out — and her serve kept letting her down — it was time for a change, not just in her game but in the type of coaching that would help her progress.

“I wanted someone to help me with what I wanted to see progress in, especially on the serve,” Gauff said in a news conference at the WTA Tour Finals in Saudi Arabia, which she won in an early boost to her relationship with Matt Daly, a specialist on both footwork and grip technique who co-created a training device to help players improve their grip, and Jean-Christophe Faurel.

“JC” has worked with Gauff previously and players often return to coaches they know and trust. Djokovic went back to long-time coach Marian Vajda in 2018 before they split for a second time four years later. Murray did likewise, bringing Ivan Lendl back in 2016 after the latter had stepped down two years earlier, and then again for a third spell in 2022. As when football clubs sack and hire managers, availability is the intangible that remains out of players’ control and choosing a familiar face can be easier than going into the unknown, especially in the case of Djokovic, 37, who does not have much time left in his career to take a punt on something new.


Gauff switched from a tactical to a technical focus in her coaching team (Artur Widak / NurPhoto via Getty Images)

Emma Raducanu is another player focused on improving a specific shot — often the serve or forehand. If she doesn’t feel it’s working, she is quick to move on. Torben Beltz, who was brought in to improve Raducanu’s forehand in November 2021, was sacked five months later when it was felt that insufficient progress was being made. Raducanu doesn’t want a hype man or woman, but technical expertise.

One of the most successful examples of technical focus in recent times comes from women’s world No. 1 Aryna Sabalenka, who transformed her serve with the support of biomechanics specialist Gavin MacMillan after it completely broke down in 2022.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

How tears and a telephone in Toronto changed Aryna Sabalenka’s tennis life

It’s something Swiatek, who Sabalenka dethroned as world No. 1 in October, is looking for from her new relationship with Wim Fissette. Fissette, who has had Grand Slam-winning success with Kim Clijsters, Angelique Kerber and Naomi Osaka, is one of the most prominent coaches on the WTA Tour. Their uniting offered a window into the mutual considerations that players and coaches undertake when beginning a relationship, which representatives from both have explained over the last few weeks.

Swiatek, by her own admission an overthinker, spoke to Fissette by phone before meeting in person in Warsaw to discuss “the specifics of the technicalities and what he wanted to change in my game”. At a news conference at the WTA Finals earlier this month, Swiatek said that Fissette “added some extra stuff that I haven’t thought of” as well as aligning with her own ideas for improvement.

On a personal level, Swiatek appreciated Fissette’s listening skills, which players and friends said is one of his defining characteristics as a coach in interviews with The Athletic last month.

“The communication was kind of smooth. He also let me talk a lot and he was able to listen to me and this was pretty fun,” Swiatek said. Fissette told Eurosport last month that he wanted to work with Swiatek after splitting with former world No. 1 Osaka, who switched to working with Serena Williams’ former coach Patrick Mouratoglou in September.

“Not only because she is No. 1 in the world but also because of her personality, which is a role model for other tennis players,” Fissette said.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Emotional intelligence, data, and tough love: Who is Wim Fissette the coach?


Personality is the other deciding factor in player-coach relationships: Not just whether they work or not, but how long they might last. While players are typically the more ruthless party in ending partnerships despite the now de rigueur mutually gushy Instagram announcements, coaches can sometimes take the decision.

Fissette was working with world No. 5 Zheng Qinwen when he decided to rejoin Osaka’s team last year, a decision which left Zheng blindsided and heartbroken. Zheng has since reunited with Pere Riba, who helped her to an Olympic gold medal and a first Grand Slam final in 2024. They have a quirky dynamic whereby during practice sessions at a tournament, Zheng dictates the sessions, but Riba calls the shots in training; they figured out the compromise after learning each other’s personalities, a necessary process in every relationship.

Jessica Pegula, who reached the U.S. Open final in September after splitting with David Witt and bringing on Mark Knowles and Mark Merklein, discussed the importance of retaining identity in a news conference at the WTA Tour Finals. “I think you can see a coaching situation doesn’t work out because they try to change the player too much,” she said.

“You obviously have to get along with the person. You have to be able to respond well to them.”

American world No. 18 Frances Tiafoe was next to hire Witt and he reached the U.S. Open semifinals with the American in his box. “Someone needs to push me and hold me accountable, but also make it fun for me,” Tiafoe said in a news conference at the tournament.

“If you come at me with a drill-sergeant-type mentality, I’m going to go the other way.”

Patrick McEnroe, who has been guiding players since retiring in 1998, worked with Tiafoe at the Laver Cup exhibition event. “He brings a certain energy to everyone around him, so obviously you’ve got to understand that coming in.”

Mouratoglou, who coached Simona Halep and Holger Rune between Williams and Osaka, described the need to be a “chameleon” in a recent Zoom interview ahead of his arrival in London for Ultimate Tennis Showdown, his main pursuit outside of coaching.


Mouratoglou with Osaka in Beijing earlier this year (Robert Prange / Getty Images)

“My job is to understand I cannot be the same every time,” he said.

“Serena needed to feel that she was in control of everything. If you don’t win the title, it’s nothing. It’s No. 1 or nothing.

“Simona was the opposite, she wanted me to be in control of everything.” After Halep had a panic attack at the 2022 French Open, Mouratoglou realized he had to back off the intensity that had worked with Williams.

“She felt the pressure of having to deliver was hurting her. I completely changed the way I was interacting with her.” Halep then reached the Wimbledon semifinals before being provisionally suspended in October 2022 after testing positive for roxadustat. Tennis integrity authorities suspended her for four years in 2023 before the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) reduced the ban to nine months on appeal in March this year after accepting that the positive test came from a contaminated supplement. Mouratoglou said he felt “responsible” for Halep’s case in an Instagram video in 2023.

Now working with Osaka, Mouratoglou said the former world No. 1 is “a very interesting personality” but “not easy to understand because she’s very secretive and keeps a lot inside.”

“I think in terms of game and work to do, we are really on the same page. But there is this piece that is very important, which is understanding the person that she is. That will take more time.”


In the sea of recent changes, world No. 1 Sabalenka has been an oasis of calm. She prioritizes coaches who can understand her unique personality and has built a relationship with her long-time coaches Jason Stacy and Anton Dubrov over time after some “really bad experiences” that left her “betrayed”.

“I was (never) looking for big names because sometimes big names are just big names,” she added at a news conference at the WTA Tour Finals earlier this month. “I was looking for someone smart and someone who is always looking for something.

“I was looking for someone who can understand that even if I go crazy on court, it’s nothing personal.”

“Anton, I knew him, since I don’t know 15, because he was in the academy when I was practising.

“With Jason, it took us two years to open up and trust him fully and to understand him as a person and I’m really glad I didn’t kick him out.”


Sabalenka has found success in stability after remodelling her serve with a specialist (Robert Prange / Getty Images)

Former U.S. Open champion Daniil Medvedev also treasures stability, working with main coach Gilles Cervara for more than seven years before bringing on former world No. 6 Gilles Simon, which is more similar to Djokovic’s decision to bring on Murray. “I am not someone who wants to constantly change and look for something new,” he said in a news conference at the Laver Cup in September.

Argentina’s world No. 30 Francisco Cerundolo echoed the benefits of having multiple coaches at a news conference a couple of months ago, but America’s Danielle Collins meanwhile said in an interview earlier this month that she prefers not to have much of a team around her: She likes working things out herself and isn’t always convinced of the value that coaches can bring.

That value can be hard to quantify. In Djokovic’s case, the rarefied level at which he operates means it’ll likely come down to whether Murray can provide the right sort of energy to help him get over the line for an 11th time at the Australian Open. Murray’s ability to absorb and defuse the frustration that comes his way from Djokovic, just like his coaches had to try to do when he was hurling invective their way during his own career, may be his biggest asset as the rivals turned partners establish the most important element of any relationship.

“The main thing is to trust them,” world No. 4 Jasmine Paolini told The Athletic in Riyadh.

(Top photos: Getty Images; design: Kelsea Pietersen)

Brian Kelly left Notre Dame for LSU to win a title. Why is he further away from that than ever?

The low point of Brian Kelly’s 38 games as head coach at LSU came in Gainesville two weeks ago, with a third consecutive loss and two heated sideline exchanges with his players.

The first sideline interaction looked familiar: Kelly got in the face of wide receiver Chris Hilton with a stern lecture that featured a couple of expletives. The second was different: Kyren Lacy, the team’s leading receiver, seemingly startled Kelly when he yelled at his coach after another failed LSU possession.

The loss to Florida snapped Kelly’s string of seven straight seasons with at least 10 wins, dating back to his time with Notre Dame, and feels indicative of larger issues at LSU. It’s difficult to look toward 2025 and project a significant turnaround for the Tigers — especially after five-star quarterback Bryce Underwood flipped his verbal commitment from LSU to Michigan late last week.

GO DEEPER

Bryce Underwood’s meetings with Tom Brady helped flip QB to Michigan

Kelly’s first season included an SEC West title and win over Alabama, and his second featured a Heisman Trophy winner and 10 victories. But the Tigers (7-4) head into their regular-season finale against Oklahoma playing out the string on a disappointing year.

“It’s just not up to the standard. It’s been patchwork,” a person long affiliated with LSU football said.

Almost three full seasons after Kelly made the audacious decision to leave Notre Dame to chase a national championship at one of the SEC’s most volatile superpowers, it remains to be seen whether he fits the job and can effectively recruit and coach the players the Tigers need to reach that goal.

The Athletic spoke with more than a half-dozen people who have ties to LSU and Kelly for this story. Most were granted anonymity to speak candidly about how Kelly’s tenure at LSU has gone and whether the marriage can be successful.

LSU’s last three coaches — Nick Saban, Les Miles and Ed Orgeron — had all won national championships by the end of their fourth seasons in Baton Rouge. Kelly ran toward, not away from, that standard upon his arrival.

“I want to be in an environment where I have the resources to win a national championship,” Kelly said in the spring of 2022. “And I came down here because I want to be in the American League East,” a reference to the hyper-competitive Major League Baseball division that features the Red Sox and Yankees.

Instead, Kelly will enter Year 4 still searching for the right combination of assistant coaches and with a roster that looks more like the early stages of a rebuild than one ready to contend in the toughest conference in the country.

From the moment LSU athletic director Scott Woodward made the surprising move to pull Kelly from Notre Dame on Dec. 1, 2021, with a 10-year, $95 million contract, the biggest question was: How would the Massachusetts native fit at the SEC school?

While some pointed to Kelly’s career spent coaching in the North and an awkward foray into a Southern accent — “my FAM-i-lee” — at an introductory appearance as signs that his long track record of success might not be transferrable to LSU, those familiar with the program and the coach say his hands-off and at times detached management style has not matched what’s needed at LSU.

“Brian Kelly’s trying to be the same guy he was at Notre Dame at LSU, and it ain’t working,” a former assistant said.

Last week on the SEC coaches’ teleconference, Kelly was asked by The Athletic to what extent he was still learning what works best at LSU. “I don’t know that it’s as much about me as much as it’s about us, and how we continue to build our program consistently,” Kelly said.

Cleaning house

With the full backing of Woodward, who felt the program lacked structure under Orgeron, Kelly cleaned house when he arrived at LSU. It was an unusually deep cleaning for a power-conference program just two years removed from a national championship. But Orgeron was seen by Woodward as running too loose a ship, and the volatility made it difficult to sustain success. The idea was to start anew and implement a more buttoned-up approach.

About 50 people were replaced, from assistant coaches to support staff, including longtime strength and conditioning coach Tommy Moffitt, now at Texas A&M.

“I think just that first (coaching) staff was not what the staff needed to be, and it probably was trying to be too clean of a break,” a former staffer said.

That appears to have been an overcorrection.

“You lose your way a little bit,” the source long affiliated with LSU said.

After pivoting hard away from Coach O’s regime, Kelly, again with input from Woodward, pivoted back after the 2023 season to try to fix an abysmal defense that undercut Heisman winner Jayden Daniels and a spectacular offense, and to fortify credibility on the recruiting trail close to home after Kelly’s first full signing class had only 10 in-state players.

Corey Raymond, a former LSU player who was part of the 2019 national champion staff, was brought back to coach the secondary. Raymond helped establish LSU’s reputation for elite defensive back play. Bo Davis, another former player who was part of the 2003 national title staff under Saban, returned as defensive line coach.

“I think to recruit Louisiana, you have to have Louisiana guys,” the former staffer said.

In addition, Blake Baker — who had a brief stint as linebackers coach at LSU in 2021, Orgeron’s final season — was brought back from Missouri as defensive coordinator at $2.5 million per year. The defense is better than last year’s version, which was maybe the worst in school history, but it still ranks near the bottom of the SEC.

It was expected for the offense to regress some from the best in the country with the departure of Daniels and two first-round NFL Draft pick receivers in Malik Nabers and Brian Thomas. Instead, the drop-off has been drastic for what appears to be LSU’s more talented side of the ball, led by two offensive tackles with first-round potential and quarterback Garrett Nussmeier.

The offensive coordinator transition from Mike Denbrock, who left LSU after last season to return to Notre Dame, to Joe Sloan, who was promoted from quarterbacks coach to replace Denbrock, has not gone well. The Tigers are ninth in the SEC in yards per play (6.11) and 11th in points per game (28.6).

“Scott Woodward and Brian Kelly made a personnel gamble when they decided to let Mike Denbrock out the door because they felt like Joe Sloan was the answer,” the former assistant said. “The data right now would tell you that that’s not the case.”

Woodward declined a request to be interviewed for this story through an LSU spokesman.

Kelly could very well be heading back into the market for an offensive coordinator after this season.

The BK Way

Kelly has always taken something of a 30,000-foot approach to running a program, and the results show he knows what he’s doing. Kelly has a .725 winning percentage over 21 years coaching in the FBS, which doesn’t include 118 victories in 13 seasons leading Division II Grand Valley State.

But even at Notre Dame, particularly after going 4-8 in 2016, Kelly conceded he needed to be more present for his players, acknowledging they wanted him to be more available and connected to the team.

Changes were made and the Fighting Irish took off on the best run the program had since its glory run under Lou Holtz, bulldozing to five consecutive double-digit win seasons and two College Football Playoff appearances.

“When Brian Kelly’s at Notre Dame, he can be his CEO self. He’s often surrounded by excellent staff members and business just goes on as usual,” the former assistant said.

Thirty years of being one of the most successful coaches in college football has made Kelly confident in his ability to build a winning program. At LSU, he seems to have underestimated the need to adjust.

Kelly brought with him from Notre Dame an accountability system for the players, which rewards and penalizes things such as timeliness, dress code, health and wellness check-ins and taking nutritional supplements. Players are either above the line or below the line, and being below can result in a loss of playing time.

“You can’t be late for meetings. You’ve got to take your vitamins every day. You have to do a wellness check-in app on your phone every day, and for (some of) these guys it’s a foreign language to them,” the former staffer said. “… Installing culture is a great idea, but now the way you’re installing culture is actually creating a culture problem.”

Charles Turner, who arrived at LSU in 2019 for the Tigers national title team and was the team’s starting center in 2022 and ‘23, said he had hardly any personal interactions in two seasons playing for Kelly.

Turner said players had to schedule appointments to visit Kelly, which was much different than Orgeron’s open-door policy.

“For Coach Kelly, I think this is a different dynamic for him. … When I was playing for Kelly the last two years, I didn’t talk to him. I started every game for him. Just, ‘Hey, hi. How you doing?’ And that was really it. We never talked Xs and Os. I never sat in his office and got personal with him. He really never got to know me.”

Turner said he hopes Kelly can get it turned around but added he “might not be the best fit” for LSU.

“He’s definitely a good coach, but as far as championships and all that other stuff, you gotta come a different way with your players,” Turner said. “You have to let your players know that you really got ’em.”

A second former assistant echoed Turner: “If you don’t really know the players, if you don’t know how to come at them, don’t know how to talk to them, don’t know how to build relationships with them — if you’re not involved with them, it’s not gonna work.”

Another source said Kelly makes an effort to try to connect with his players, though it doesn’t always seem to come naturally to the coach.

“I think the (players) that believe in him, believe in him,” the source long affiliated with LSU said. “He’s had to find his way when he first got here because it is a different animal.”

Of the two sideline dust-ups at Florida, Kelly chewing out Hilton drew the most attention.

“I do think he is held to a little bit of an unfair (standard) because people want to see him fail,” the former assistant said.

Kelly alluded to this during an interview with Paul Finebaum on the SEC Network last week.

“I find it kind of interesting that I am the only coach in the country that has conversations with their players on the sideline. But be that as it may, we were having a coaching moment with one of my wide receivers, you know, who is desperately wanting to make big plays for us,” Kelly said.

Lacy initiating an exchange with Kelly was more notable. Whether it was a red flag signaling deeper problems or an isolated incident, it was something not seen much at the college level between head coach and player. Kelly said during the interview he had no issue with Lacy expressing his frustration.

“Unfortunately sometimes the camera’s in our office where we’re working, and that comes with being the head coach at a high-profile institution like LSU,” he said.

Recruiting misses

It was one of the first questions Kelly faced after the move: Would he be able to recruit in the SEC against the likes of Georgia’s Kirby Smart and Alabama’s Nick Saban? Kelly and his initial staff were short on recruiting ties and institutional knowledge of a talent-rich state where battles can be fierce.

New Orleans native and longtime SEC assistant Frank Wilson was the one notable addition to the first staff to build those Louisiana connections, but Kelly put Brian Polian, who had been a key member of his staff at Notre Dame, in charge of recruiting.

Kelly himself has never been as hands-on and immersed in the recruiting process as might be necessary to compete with SEC machines, where a top-10 national class might rank closer to the middle of the conference than the top.

“You sit down with these parents and these guardians and these people that are around these kids, and a big part of their decision making is, ‘Who do I trust? Who gives off this vibe that, you know, I want my kid to be with?’ And I think BK probably struggles there a little bit. I think they bring him in as the closer, and I don’t know that that’s his specialty,” the former staff member said.

LSU’s recruiting classes under Kelly haven’t been poorly rated. The 2022 class he mostly inherited was ranked 12th in the country by 247Sports’ composite rankings, because it only had 15 players. The stars were offensive tackles Will Campbell and Emery Jones, tight end Mason Taylor and linebacker Harold Perkins Jr., all juniors who could jump to the NFL after this season.

Almost half that class, seven players, has already transferred out.

LSU’s first full recruiting class under Kelly in 2023 ranked sixth in the country in the 247Sports Composite. Only 10 of the 26 signees were from Louisiana high schools. Only 15 members of the class are still with the team. Most notably, five-star offensive lineman Lance Heard from Bonita, La., transferred to Tennessee, where he starts.

The class that should be the backbone of next year’s LSU team has so far produced four significant contributors, led by linebacker Whit Weeks. Instead, there is a glaring hole in the roster.

“We didn’t need to go to all those other places (outside LSU’s traditional footprint) to get guys. We’ve got guys right here. I think you had arrogance, and that’s what happened. It set us back. There’s no doubt,” the source long affiliated with the program said. “(Polian) was still recruiting like he had at Notre Dame.”

Of course high school recruiting isn’t the only way to improve a roster these days. LSU found a Heisman winner in Daniels in the transfer portal in 2022. Two of the team’s best players this season, edge rusher Bradyn Swinson and receiver Aaron Anderson, were portal additions in 2023. Still, LSU under Kelly has not shown the capacity to transform the roster through transfers the way SEC rival Ole Miss has done under Lane Kiffin. Though Kelly’s biggest win this season came against the Rebels, who have shown portaling to the championship can be a perilous path.

There are also questions about how well LSU is keeping up with the competition when it comes to name, image and likeness compensation for players.

“Some of it has been the misperception that this place is rolling in dough, when the reality of it is they are losing recruits because they’re simply being outbid,” one of the former assistants said.

That appears to be the case for what might turn out to be a bigger loss than anything that has happened on the field this season. Late last week, Underwood — who was primarily recruited by Sloan — decommitted from LSU after 10 months. Underwood is reportedly set to receive an NIL deal worth millions over multiple years for going to Michigan.

Back in May, Kelly lamented LSU coming up short when portal shopping: “We were in the market, in the transfer portal, looking for defensive linemen. It hasn’t fared very well, quite frankly, because we are selling something a little bit differently. And that is, we want to recruit. We want to engage, build relationships. We want to develop, retain, and have success. We’re not in the market of buying players. … And unfortunately, right now, that’s what some guys are looking for. They want to be bought. … We’re not going to go out and buy players.”

With revenue-sharing with players on the horizon, and possibly less emphasis on booster-funded NIL deals, the system might be moving in Kelly’s favor.

What’s next?

Despite dissatisfaction at LSU — there were some “Fire Kelly” chants coming from the student section early in Saturday’s 24-17 home victory against Vanderbilt — Kelly will not be ousted anytime soon.

“Nothing happens without him being the head coach because it is an economic problem that they cannot solve,” a second former LSU staffer said.

Woodward gave Kelly a 10-year guaranteed contract, and the buyout currently sits at $64.5 million. That goes down by $9.5 million annually.

It’s easy to look at the declining results and apparent trajectory of LSU football and conclude Kelly will enter Year 4 on a hot seat, with a roster unable to compete for a Playoff spot. Economics might force patience, and not everybody believes this situation is irreversible.

“I think where LSU’s in a good spot is BK is Scott’s guy. Scott is BK’s guy, they’re gonna work together. (LSU) President (William) Tate’s supportive. They do actually have the pieces in place right now, they just don’t have the roster in place,” the former staffer said.

A victory over the Commodores is no cause for celebration at LSU — more of a temporary respite after three weeks of mostly bad news and a little something to back up the signs of progress Kelly insists he sees.

“Based upon the feedback that I’m getting from (weekly meetings with) our leadership council here, we’re right on where we need to be in terms of building the foundation of our program,” Kelly said last week. “We have to continue to recruit. Our players are playing hard. They’re playing with the right kind of attitude. But this is the SEC. And the talent is real.”

(Top photo: Meech Robinson/ The Athletic; Photo: James Gilbert / Getty Images)

Gukesh Dommaraju, 18, has made history. Can the prodigy become the youngest chess world champion?

Dr. Rajinikanth and his wife Dr. Padma would regularly play chess together for fun at their family home in India. Always at their side, watching wide-eyed, observing intensely as each piece was strategically moved on the board, was their son, Gukesh. The young boy was captivated by the calculated black and white dance before him.

“He would become fascinated with how the pieces worked,” Rajini tells The Athletic.

Over the next few weeks, Gukesh, still fresh into adulthood, could become the youngest-ever chess world champion. By qualifying for this month’s 2024 World Chess Championship in Singapore, the 18-year-old is already the youngest challenger to compete for the world title.

It has been a meteoric and surprising rise for a player who, until the summer of 2022, was still solely ranked as a junior. “It just happened by accident,” says Rajini, a surgeon. His son’s success wasn’t preordained, he says. Neither he nor his spouse, who is a microbiologist, had planned for or dreamed of their son becoming a phenomenon in the sport. “We never realized he was a special talent,” he explains. “It was the schools, teachers, and coaches who started to tell us, ‘This kid is talented, you should pursue more’.”

Starting on Monday, Gukesh will play titleholder Ding Liren, 32, of China in the best-of-14 classical games match that could last until December 13. For the first time in 138 years, two players from Asia will contest the final.

Gukesh, from the city of Chennai on the Indian south coast, a hotbed for chess talent, won the eight-player 2024 Candidates tournament in Toronto to set up the chance to become the first teenager to win the world title. Aged 17, in his first appearance at what is essentially the final round of World Championship qualifying, he overcame the odds and got the better of five more celebrated players — all with higher rankings — earning his title shot with five wins, one loss, and eight draws to finish with a score of nine out of 14 (one point for a win, half a point for a draw, and zero for a loss). Should he triumph in Singapore, he will become India’s second world chess champion after Viswanathan Anand.


Ding competes against Gukesh during the Tata Steel Chess Tournament in the Netherlands in January 2023. (Photo by Sylvia Lederer/Xinhua via Getty Images)

Perhaps such success shouldn’t have been surprising given the records he broke as a child. Still young enough to be included in the International Chess Federation’s (FIDE) junior world rankings, he is the world’s top-ranked junior male player in classical chess, the longest format of the sport.

That he could beat the defending champion isn’t in the realm of fantasy, either. Gukesh, ranked fifth in the world in this month’s classical rankings, is the in-form player. Ding, currently 23rd, has had a difficult reign as world champion, taking a nine-month break from the sport last year for mental health reasons. He hasn’t won a classical game since January and has only played 44 classical games since becoming world champion.

“I am worried about losing very badly. Hopefully it won’t happen,” Ding said to chess app TakeTakeTake in September. At this week’s press conference, Ding said he wasn’t at his peak but said he was at “peace” and would review his previous best performances for inspiration.

Ding does, however, hold the better record in the pair’s head-to-head classical meetings, winning two and drawing once, and his peak FIDE rating of 2,816 is higher than Gukesh’s (2,794, reached in October).

But Magnus Carlsen, the five-time world champion who opted not to defend his world crown in 2023 but is still ranked as the world’s best classical player, has backed Gukesh to win, and urged the importance of Ding making a fast start.

“Ding cannot lose the first game… from what we’ve seen from Ding for the last one-and-a-half years, I don’t think he’ll come back from losing the first game, so I agree, hesitantly, that he’s going to be the first person to win a game, but I’m very uncertain,” he told chess.com. The Norwegian added: “The only way there’s going to be a low number of decisive games is that Ding gets chances and keeps missing them. We could see a bloodbath.”


‘Gukesh D’ as he is known, started playing chess at the age of seven, winning various junior tournaments before becoming, at the time, the second-youngest grandmaster, aged 12 years, seven months and 17 days. Grandmaster, awarded to players by governing body FIDE for life, is the highest title outside of world champion; today there are more than 1,850.

This year, he became the third-youngest to reach a FIDE rating of 2,700 after claiming two gold medals at the Chess Olympiad — a biennial international tournament that was held in Budapest, Hungary, and he is the youngest player to achieve a rating of 2,750.

Gukesh said his youth could be viewed as a negative and a positive heading into the final, but at this week’s press conference Ding said his opponent played with maturity “in many aspects”. Known for being an aggressive player, Gukesh, who recently revealed he was a fan of the sitcom Friends, is one of a number of young players making a name for himself in the sport. Ding recently decribed the new generation of players as fearless. “There are a lot born after 2000, they play fearlessly and are willing to try different strategies that the previous generation might not have,” he said, according to The Straits Times.


Gukesh is welcomed at Chennai International Airport after winning two gold medals at the FIDE Chess Olympiad (Photo by R. Satish Babu/AFP via Getty)

One of the coaches who told Gukesh’s parents about their son’s special ability and helped his development was Indian grandmaster Vishnu Prasanna, who coached the prodigy from 2017 to 2023.

They first met after Vishnu hosted a small training camp for students from Gukesh’s school, Velammal Vidyalaya, which has a great reputation for producing chess talents. Developing a strong mentality was a big focus point for Vishnu. “We discussed a lot of non-chess stuff about mindsets and how people in extreme sports behave,” Vishnu tells The Athletic. 

“We talked a lot about Alex Honnold (the American free solo climber) and many extreme athletes and what kind of mindsets they try to keep. I always emphasized that chess techniques come and go and can be played around with, so there is no one right technique. But there can be a right mindset that promises performance, and that is the difference between players rather than the chess itself.”

His parents never involved themselves in training, instead making sure life outside of the sport was settled. But, with the approval of Gukesh’s parents, Vishnu, experimenting with his approaches, resisted the use of computer or chess engine assistance until Gukesh was a grandmaster, the aim being to encourage Gukesh to think on his own.

Chess had a deeper impact, too, on the teenager. “He used to be very naughty,” says Rajini.

“He was the only child so whatever he wanted he had to get it sometimes. He used to have all these tantrums but once he started chess he became very observant, how he is now. He started becoming more calm, patient, and observant. Chess has changed him.”


Playing chess can cause mental fatigue because of the concentration required. Yet, Gukesh’s appetite for the game once saw him play 276 games in 30 tournaments across 13 countries over 16 months while squeezing in 10am-5pm sessions with Vishnu in between competitions.

The longest game at a World Chess Championship was in 2021 between Carlsen and Ian Nepomniachtchi, taking seven hours and 45 minutes. Such mental focus can take its toll. After the ‘Moscow Marathon’, a World Championship contest between Anatoly Karpov and Garry Kasparov that lasted five months and 48 games, Karpov told a Russian magazine he had lost 10kg (22lb) in weight.


Gukesh could become the first Indian world champion since Viswanathan Anand (Photo by Marcus Brandt/picture alliance via Getty Images)

In Singapore, each classical game will follow the time control of 120 minutes for the first 40 moves, followed by 30 minutes for the rest of the game. From move 41, a 30-second increment will start. Players must remain poised, balanced and consider their moves deeply. A score of 7.5 points or more will win the world title. If the players are level after 14 classical games, a tie-break will be played on December 13. The right mindset is paramount, says Vishnu.

“It’s probably the biggest stage that anyone would get to, it’s all about nerves when you get there,” he says.

“He has been thriving under pressure. So far, he has always delivered in moments where he has a lot to lose and when things are hanging by a thread.”

History is on the line, and so too is a lot of money. The total prize pot for the World Championship is $2.5million, with each player earning $200,000 for each game they win. The remaining prize money will be split equally between the players. This is a significant hike from the €48,000 ($50,489 at current currency conversion) Gukesh banked from winning the Challenger tournament.

Even if Gukesh remains calm under the Singapore spotlight, his parents will not be relaxed. Padma does not watch her son’s matches because the experience is too stressful. Instead, she will wait for the results to come in.

“I also want to do that, because it is too stressful for us, but it is too difficult to stay away so it’s like a hide-and-seek. So I just watch once every half an hour or hour and just see what position he is in,” says Rajini.

Tournaments have taken Gukesh, accompanied by his father, all over the world. There have been sacrifices, but the family have few regrets.

“Two-thirds of the year we were travelling for tournaments — his mother got very little time to spend with us. That is one thing we regret. Otherwise, we are very happy with how things turned out and we are very fortunate,” says Rajini.

Coach Vishnu saw the pursuit of greatness first-hand. “There is no clear path to recreate what he has done,” he says. “A certain hyper-focus and sacrifice of a regular childhood, a regular school life, and a regular social life of a teenager, you give up all that and focus on the main thing and that is to get better at chess.”

There are increasingly more chess prodigies, but Gukesh has worked persistently to fulfil his potential. “I had no doubt he was going to do well but, still, he exceeded expectations,” says Vishnu.

Gukesh is following in the footsteps of a great: five-time world champion Anand, now the deputy president of FIDE and also from Chennai. Fittingly, Gukesh overtook him in the chess rankings last year to knock him off the top spot as India’s highest-ranked player, a position he had held for 37 years (although Arjun Erigaisi, in fourth place, currently holds that honour).

Anand dominated an era, including winning four consecutive World Championships between 2007 and 2012.

“Playing the world championship and winning the Candidates is trying to fill Anand’s shoes, which is something my generation tried but failed to do,” says Vishnu, 35.

“So it is very inspiring that Gukesh is close to putting India back on top of world chess, looking back and thinking, ‘That was the kid who was coming and training with me’.”

(Top image: Andrzej Iwanczuk/NurPhoto via Getty Images; design Eamonn Dalton)

The rise of football’s ‘arrival fits’, putting player fashion in the spotlight

Tom Marchitelli worked as an accountant for a hedge fund for eight years before setting up a side hustle that soon became his full-time business.

Marchitelli started a custom menswear clothing business called Gentleman’s Playbook a decade ago. Since then, he has accrued approximately 500 clients, the majority of whom are professional athletes in the NFL, NBA, NHL and MLB, and on the PGA Tour.

When The Athletic spoke with Marchitelli, he was heading to an airport in Dallas after a meeting with a baseball player.

In his role as personal designer, stylist and tailor, Marchitelli handpicks entire wardrobes for a clientele which includes Kansas City Chiefs tight end Travis Kelce. During the different pre-seasons across the United States’ various leagues, Marchitelli is rarely in one city for long. As well as working on a lookbook of outfits for specific events, the majority of his work centres around personalising entire collections of tunnel fits for the athletes he works with.

“Tunnel fits” is the phrase used to describe what sportsmen and women wear when they turn up at venues for games (‘fits’ being short for ‘outfits’).

Usually, athletes arrive in the tunnel beneath the arena wearing their best outfits, which is where the name derives from. Think of it as a pre-game runway, where players across sports in North America showcase their personalities through what they wear.

The most fashion-conscious athletes, such as Houston Texans’ Stefon Diggs or Oklahoma City Thunder’s Shai Gilgeous-Alexander, will go big, but others prefer to keep it simple.


Stefon Diggs arrives for an NFL game in January this year (Perry Knotts/Getty Images)

Kyle Kuzma was in the former camp, and is now the latter. The Washington Wizards forward recently announced his ‘retirement’ from the tunnel walk after taking the game to heights with choices including an incredibly oversized pink Raf Simons jumper and a black Rick Owens puffer jacket.

“I don’t want to be a part of that type of community where you have to put on a ’fit. I’m really taking a backseat to all of that,” Kuzma told Vogue in October.

While Kuzma has checked out and traded in a palate of high fashion for plain-tasting sweatsuits, in Europe, footballers are only just checking into the world of tunnel fits.

“It is a sport within sports (in the U.S.),” Marchitelli says. “Social media plays a huge role, because all major sports teams have media people who are in charge of photographing the players as they enter.

“That’s only been around, I would say maybe eight years, because when I first started, that (posting images of players arriving to games on social media) wasn’t a thing. And then it started becoming so visible.


Kyle Kuzma, pictured in 2022 (left) and 2021, has ‘retired’ from deliberate tunnel fits (Getty Images)

“You’re getting a close and personal look at what athletes look like when they’re not in their uniforms (team kit), and how they are choosing to express themselves. And, over time, players have taken more pride in how they show up for work.

“Another big factor that drives it is competition among players. These guys are trying to outdress guys on their team, guys on other teams across their sport, and even crossing over into other sports.

“When they show up to the arena, they’re given the uniform that they’re forced to wear, so they don’t have any real choices of self-expression other than their shoes, cleats (boots), maybe a wristband accessory or a headband. But the outfit that they wear to show up to the game, they’re able to express how they feel and how they want to look.”

Marchitelli could field a team in each men’s major sports league with the number of clients he has, but not a single one is a professional footballer despite MLS and NWSL teams having both dabbled in this subcultural movement.

In European football, tunnel fits are almost nonexistent. France international Jules Kounde led the way for Barcelona in recent seasons with his ensembled looks which blend vintage finds with high fashion. This season though, Barca players are no longer been allowed to arrive for games in their own clothes. This has led Kounde, a face now as recognisable in fashion quarters as much as football, capturing his fits to share with his followers on social media after matches instead.

Most teams have a strict club-tracksuits-only policy applied to matchday and this is one of the main reasons why pre-game tunnel fits have not yet taken off in football.

So where is the individuality? The answer to that does not yet reside in the underbelly of stadiums but in the car parks of the sport’s training grounds. Heading into training for your club or national team has slowly evolved into a time when players across the men’s and women’s games can showcase their style in the form of arrival fits.

Showing up for international duty, in particular, has become a moment for players to demonstrate their fashion prowess.

Last month, Liverpool defender Ibrahima Konate arrived at France’s training ground wearing a neon green hood zipped over his face while his international team-mate Marcus Thuram, often bedecked in Balenciaga and Chrome Hearts, is among those also paving the way.


Konate arrives for international duty with France in October (Franck Fife/AFP via Getty Images)

Players of Argentina, Belgium and Portugal are three other standouts who consistently show up. Meanwhile, England — whose players include Louis Vuitton brand ambassador Jude Bellingham — are still strutting around in team-supplied Nike tracksuits, proving the trend has not completely caught fire everywhere.

“It was probably 2022 when that (arrival fits) wave really began,” Jordan Clarke, founder of Footballer Fits, a platform which celebrates footballer fashion, says.

Clarke noticed that Premier League team Crystal Palace had started putting pictures on Instagram of their players arriving at their south London training ground wearing their own clothes. After starting a conversation with the club, Footballer Fits and Palace have been collaborating on Instagram posts to showcase what players are wearing ever since.

“Now we’ve done it with Chelsea, Nottingham Forest, Anderlecht in Belgium, we’ve done it with Brentford a lot, we’ve done it with Crystal Palace Women, Chelsea Women — there are so many,” says Clarke, who hopes that arrival fits are a precursor to tunnel fits becoming a regular sight in football.

“I don’t want to leave anyone out, but we’ve done it with so many clubs and now you’re seeing Liverpool, Newcastle United and Manchester City maybe not doing it in collaboration with us, but they’re doing it (themselves) now, and that’s amazing to see.

“With training, there is a lot less pressure. They (clubs) can release photos midweek and whatever happens on the weekend, unless you’re a super-negative person, I don’t think people are going to link back to what the players wore to training as the reason why they lost.”

Siobhan Wilson is one of the players who has featured on Footballer Fits’ Instagram page in collaboration with her club, Birmingham City Women, and she would welcome an escape from the traditional pre-match tracksuit.

“It actually annoys me, you know — especially when you see what they are doing in the WNBA,” says the 30-year-old Jamaica international with a laugh. “I wish we did stuff like that here. They just want us to all look like clones of each other, but it’s fine.”

Wilson used to deliver mail while playing part-time for Palace. She now combines a full-time playing career at Birmingham, who are top of the second-tier Championship, with being a fitness influencer to 1.3million followers on TikTok.

“It’s nice for the fans to see players express themselves through what they’re wearing and their style,” she says. “You get to see people’s personalities by doing that, so it would be something that I would love to see more of.

“For me, I feel like if you’ve got like a nice ’fit on, and a good pair of shoes on, you just feel good. But I get the other side (players arriving in uniform tracksuits) too. It is a team game. You’re there to play as a team, so I get it from that standpoint, but wearing your own clothes and feeling comfortable in what you’re wearing: it allows you to be yourself a bit more.”


Martin Odegaard and Arsenal arriving in team gear to play Chelsea this month (Stuart MacFarlane/Arsenal FC via Getty Images)

Algen Hamilton is a designer and stylist from south London.

His break in the fashion industry arrived when he started styling looks for footballer friend Reiss Nelson, the Fulham winger (on loan from Arsenal) who he met at primary school aged four. Hamilton’s client list includes Trevoh Chalobah (Crystal Palace, on loan from Chelsea), Kai Havertz (Arsenal), Joe Willock (Newcastle), Ben Chilwell (Chelsea) and Mateo Kovacic (Manchester City).

“I’ll work with them constantly throughout the season, whenever they want to — when they have an event coming up or they have an awards ceremony or they’re going to a premiere,” Hamilton, 24, explains. “When it comes to arrival fits, those looks normally come from the wardrobe I create and I’ll update it multiple times in a year.

“I speak to them first about what they want to wear and what the vibe is that we are going for, if it’s different to before, where they are travelling to et cetera. Then I’ll go off, make the outfits and send them a message. They will tell me which outfits they love.

“So, for example, I’m working with Trevoh right now. We made a whole bunch of outfits, which he picked, and then there are brands who want to gift some stuff for winter.”


Amadou Onana, left, checks in for Belgium duty in 2023 (Nico Vereecken/Photo News via Getty Images)

Having worked with Chalobah on a full-time basis since 2021, Hamilton has watched the progression of football and fashion’s relationship firsthand.

“When I first started, players weren’t really going out there dressing up like they do now, and it wasn’t just the Premier League — we are talking La Liga (its Spanish equivalent) and the Bundesliga (the top division in Germany),” he says.

“Also, brands weren’t really opening up partnerships to football players either. As time has gone by, the popularity has grown and supporters are tapping into the player outside of the training ground and off the pitch. I feel like now, those opportunities are happening more. Players are more open with their fits and want to show them off.

“We have watched the game change bit by bit and it is only a matter of time for it to get to that stage where it’s like the sports are in America. But let’s not mix a step forward with progress, because it can be a step forward seeing teams do that (post-arrival fits on social media) but it doesn’t mean it’s actual progression for the teams to change their minds.

“The Premier League is very traditional. They’ll probably be the last league that will change how things are.

“It would be nice for the progress to be meaningful; for it (wearing an arrival outfit) not to be looked at as a distraction or as a moment where players aren’t focused on what the team objectives are, but to see it as an opportunity where players are expressing themselves.”

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Footballers, modelling and the power of expression

(Top photos: Getty Images; design: Kelsea Peterson)